Send us Fan Mail Step right up! Test your knowledge about farming in LaCrosse, Wisconsin! Whoever can answer all the questions will immediately be sent all remaining Beyond Artless Season 1 overstock t-shirts. Shipping not included. Our guest Angela Klinkner is an authority on dairy farming, but is also a superstar sixth year teacher in Holmen, WI. Her years of middle school band teaching in Houston, Texas helped her develop a strong approach to teaching fundamentals to young musicians. She might win the award for most organized teacher ever. Peter, Phil and Chris win the collective award for aimless banter. Holmen High School Band Uniform Fundraiser Holmen High School Band Website Uniform Fundraiser Article SHOW CREDITS Servant of Peace (Dorothy Gates) performed by Teddy Van Winkle - recorded on March 7th, 2022, in the University of North Texas Voertman Concert Hall. Accompanied by Dr. Joshua Vigran, piano. https://youtu.be/tcUfcwZ31Qw?si=Rntj8gVsFe9_4p6A REGISTER NOW: 2027 BEYOND THE NOTE FESTIVALS - A few spots remain!! https://www.btnmusicfestival.com/festivals/ensembles/kalahari-1 COMMISSION POSSIBLE 2028 W/ OMAR THOMAS https://www.btnmusicfestival.com/education/commission Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_04On the exterior, I look pretty relaxed. On the interior, it's a seething wreck of attention.
SPEAKER_06God, he's a better hero than we are. I might actually buy a book just for black power dispute. Look, we all have our problems. You're baloney. You're full blowing.
SPEAKER_04I gotta walk away, I'm gonna punch you in the face. So at times you must um have um tr had um not struggled, but um he'll get there. He'll get there.
SPEAKER_05We have pre-banter banter and we have post-banter banter. And uh we're gonna start today by mentioning how amazing that uh recital was, Philip Ostrander. Holy crap, man. Philip Ostrander. That was my hot a little bit. Yeah, and your mic's loved too. Um yeah, it was my my mic or Peter's mic? No, Peter's mic. Uh yeah, excellent. Beautiful, great lit, great balance, just but that first piece, I love that first, the first work.
SPEAKER_04It's a nice piece. Second movement, man.
SPEAKER_05Purdy. Beautiful. Yeah. Control, finesse. Yeah, it was beauty, man.
SPEAKER_04Great piece. Yeah, I pretty uh well, you gotta get you get into it and it's repetitive, and you play and play and play, and then you gotta like uh let it rip on a high D. Yeah. I think I felt different parts of my lip both tear and sort of bleed all at the same time on that high D. This this might affect the rest of the recital. Yeah. That could that could do something.
SPEAKER_04Actually, the high note the high notes don't bother me anymore. It's that's good. It's the notes after the high notes that are the ones that I'm worried about. Those are the ones I get worried about. Commuter go find Can they find it anywhere? No, it's not. You missed it. Um I've buried it. It'll never be accessible to anyone ever again. Got it. No. What I neglected to mention, because I didn't have a microphone, and nobody can hear online. And it was so I sort of had to abridge all my verbal commentary. But my my son and my wife came to the recital, and that was really nice of them too.
SPEAKER_04Oh, that's nice. And so did Adam Beaver.
SPEAKER_03But you better save room for my fist because I got a picture.
SPEAKER_04And Julie Beaver came to the recital. You got Julie Beaver too. Nice. I did. I did. Super special. Mr. Hudson was there as well. So and there were others, but not in particular, those folks.
SPEAKER_05That's cool. That's cool. Yeah, it was great, man. Well done.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Okay. Next. Um, Peter, what are you good for? I'm in my office on a Sunday night. Um I am good for it's because I do something called Haberman time with my students, where I don't get to see my students one-on-one, especially my non-majors, except in my classes. So in my ensembles, they come in and I get to meet them and ask a bunch of open-ended ended questions and get them thinking and learn a lot about them, and it's a deal.
SPEAKER_06And there's a lot of them are students teaching and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_04I know this sounds like something a thoughtful, caring teacher would do, but I know you're not really like that. So strange. Uh probably this is I don't know. I get blackmail.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, that's right. Gr Grandma Julie said, How many other people do this with their students? And I said, Do they all bring you anything like a cookie or a big good seltzer? Or it's so it's so great though. Like I've I've got this non-major, new uh clarinettis non-major, always looks at me scared. She is one of the funniest humans I have ever met, and I had no idea until she came in. And for 10 minutes I was just laughing as she like told me about her family or what she considers home, or oh my god.
SPEAKER_06I was I was on the floor. I was like, look at this one. Who knew? Who knew? It's it's a really good experience.
SPEAKER_04And it's a it's a good idea that we can dispense with all that humor and and enjoyment now.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Get this serious enough silver. And uh your office looks clean. What's going on with your clean office? I did clean.
SPEAKER_05I did. I did. Uh it might have been like a half inch of dust uh causing me to sneeze a lot, and uh the rocks complained, and so I uh cleaned up the office. Uh a radon check. Can I get a radon check? A radon check? No, but I'm gonna give you a deep thought tonight. And the deep thought is this have you ever noticed how many towns are named after their water tower? It's just not. Here's my other deep thought. This was great. The Packers finished the game today, right? And literally two minutes later, all of a sudden I hear lawn mowers.
SPEAKER_05And I look outside, and like four of the neighbors are out mowing lawn all at the same time because they finished the game and they're like, and this is what we do. And I'm like, I love Green Bay. I love it, because it's like you could go out during that game and nothing. Quiet.
SPEAKER_06It's not even Green Bay. It was that way in Eau Claire. It was it was psychotic. We're 68 miles from the border with Minnesota, and they were it was the most crazy fan base ever.
SPEAKER_04Love it. That would explain why it's for us. No one was outside while I was mowing the lawn today uh between 12 and 2. That's it. That's it, man.
SPEAKER_06I was the only one mowing. And they were thinking, who is that idiot out there bothering my football game?
SPEAKER_04Uh Chris, what's on deck this week? Anything good or nothing?
SPEAKER_05Uh let's see. Uh what's going on? Bunch of meetings, uh, bunch of oh, hey, state of education address. This is cool. So each year, the state superintendent in Wisconsin goes to the Rotunda, the state capital, and there's the governor, and there's legislators, and there's all these administrators and so on, and gives our state of the state as far as education goes. Now, music has always played a crucial, vital role in this. We've had performances, but this year, this year, we are we are celebrating every art form.
SPEAKER_05I was able to convince them, because we only get 60 minutes. I was able to convince them to give me more time, and we will have an elementary dance group from Lincoln Elementary in Madison, Wisconsin. Cute little kids dancing. We are gonna have two students doing Shakespeare from Oakla or Appleton North. We are gonna have uh an amazing vocalist singing Lift Every Voice and Sing Black National Anthem from Madison, Wisconsin. We've got a flute choir from Wannakkee playing the stars and stars or the Star Spingle Banner. I mean, like it's a full and then visual art.
SPEAKER_05We got all these kids that did visual art that's gonna be on display.
SPEAKER_06So I'm excited. I feel like um they've got a good mentor guiding the arts. Who is that? I don't know. Um we got a retreat next weekend, our fall retreat for the band. So we get together with some social time and extra music making and senior recital to figure out who our soloist is gonna be on tour. It's very exciting. That's my big week.
SPEAKER_04And hopefully, how come what why have Chris and I never been invited to the retreat?
SPEAKER_06I'm curious. It's a retreat. I'm trying to get away from other things and just focus on my students. And you are not my students. Yeah, it's the focus part.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Do you take this week off now, Phil? What's the recital?
SPEAKER_04You played an ID.
SPEAKER_06He needs a week.
SPEAKER_04He needs a week. I take the week off before and the week off after. Oh, got it. Got it. That's in the contract. You're welcome. That's in the contract. Uh oh. Uh speaking of not taking a week off, uh, we're gonna introduce our guest uh right now. Our guest was raised on a dairy farm. Uh they had their first job when they were a little kid doing chores, milking cows before and after school every day. So obviously, our guest went to uh school in a very small rural community.
SPEAKER_04Um our guest has run four half marathons very slowly. Uh our guest was um her high school's FFA president uh for two years and competed in the soil and land judging competition. Uh and their team qualified for nationals in Oklahoma, her senior year. Uh let's see. Our guest moved across the country to Houston, Texas, uh, after college to student teach and ended up loving it and stayed there.
SPEAKER_04Taught high school band for a year, and then uh the school that uh she was student teaching at created another band director uh position and kept her there uh as a middle school band director for three years. This is where our guest developed a love for teaching beginners and middle schoolers. Uh the schools in Houston were massive, had diverse populations, and she learned from incredible colleagues and mentors. Uh our guest moved back to Wisconsin in 2025 when an opportunity allowed me to teach closer to family, including 11 nieces and nephews.
SPEAKER_04Our guest uh started year six of teaching this year, and year two is a high school band director in their current position, uh and is halfway through completing their master's in uh music education uh at Texas Tech University. Our guest is a Clarin Edison, lacrosse symphony, lacrosse wind symphony. Done. Done. All right, Chris Chris Gleason, introduce our guest, Angela Klinkner.
SPEAKER_05Well done. Yeah, there you go.
SPEAKER_01Good to see you guys.
SPEAKER_05Yep, see. Gary Farm, that helped. And then I'm like six years, yeah, back to Wisconsin. Yeah, yeah, I got you. That's good. Angela, great to see you.
SPEAKER_01Good to see you.
SPEAKER_05Hi, Angela. Good to see you.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me. Yeah, it's good to see you.
SPEAKER_05It's good stuff, yeah. And this is all not due to Phil. I will just say, like anything good is mostly due to Sharon Haroldson, I would say, at this point. You know, we owe a lot to Oh yes.
SPEAKER_02Sharon's awesome. Yep.
SPEAKER_05Sharon got you on the right place.
SPEAKER_04Angela, maybe you can maybe can explain why you know Sharon. Because I didn't do that in the intro.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So towards the end of my time at Eau Claire before I moved over to Houston, I got to um do a little practicum teaching with Chris and Sharon, mostly Sharon, of course, um, through my block placement. And it was, we made it work. Um, it was during the time of coming out of COVID. So most of it was virtual. Um doing those virtual band rehearsals. And you were so grateful to let me uh gracious to have some of those lessons with your kids virtually, which was a learning experience for sure.
SPEAKER_02And then you let me come down towards the end of the school year and got to do some teaching with the kids in person and got to play on your concert with you that time. And um, it was a fun experience. And we made the most of it during that very confusing time of COVID.
SPEAKER_05That's right. We had you play because none of the kids could play. So it was really nice to have a clarinet section.
SPEAKER_02I remember we played Union March, and I remember you had a little kid conducting uh, you know, the kid in a Superman costume that came up and conducted cute kid. It was good.
SPEAKER_05We're all outside because it had to be like 20 feet apart.
SPEAKER_02You have the tent with like the cameras mounted in this tent because I remember like logging into your class.
SPEAKER_05That's right. Yeah, man, those were great days.
SPEAKER_06When I look back, I just remember all that time with fondness. So much energy was put into teaching. Yeah, it was great. So cold.
SPEAKER_05It was so cold.
SPEAKER_06So, Angela, um, worst experience with Dr. Ostrander that you can share as a funny story.
SPEAKER_03Coming up strong.
SPEAKER_02Um there was a time I remember in brass techniques, which was also, I think I took it this semester right after COVID was happening. We were outside. We were playing trombone out in the wild lawn. It was all frosted. We were out there at 8 a.m. And low brass is my weakest playing section by far. And so I was really struggling in that class. And um, I remember I had submitted some videos of me playing some trombone excerpts, and you commented on one of them and said, It is so awesome to see you fail at something.
SPEAKER_02And that has stuck with me.
SPEAKER_04Love it. That's it.
SPEAKER_07Yeah.
SPEAKER_04A commuter, that's not fair. Because Angela was a uh that's not fair. She feels a lot of things. No, that's actually the treatment. It's quite completely the opposite. Angela was a teaching assistant uh for the band area um while she was a student. And the I I would say there's a strong likelihood that Angela was more organized than one of the band faculty members.
SPEAKER_06That was you, because Johnstree was pretty organized.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, he is.
SPEAKER_06And uh one one more, Angela. Uh you worked with Chris. Oh, I mean, you worked with Chris's teaching partner, but uh any uh stories about Chris in the classroom besides his uh uh GoPro on the pool on COVID?
SPEAKER_02I feel like some of the things I remember or I've taken from watching you teach, especially during that time, was tr always trying to find something positive to say. Because sometimes you really had to find something, even if it was you're you showed up today. I'm so happy for you. And I remember you would always find something positive. And there was a couple times where you had sent me in to do like a virtual lesson with some kids, and I think I was doing a lesson with a tuba player, no camera on, and I don't know if they could hear me at all.
SPEAKER_02They were just playing the most aggressive whale noises for like five minutes straight. I would try and give feedback and they just kept on playing. And I was like, okay, what would Chris say in this situation? And I was just trying to come up with something positive, like, you're doing great, keep it up. And it was just, you know, those times of trying to find something productive and meaningful in a moment that's you know, confusing.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, chaotic. Yeah, no, you did you did so well, and I would echo everything that Phil said. I mean, your organization, your curiosity, even in that weird, chaotic time, it just was apparent immediately. I'm just like, oh my gosh, you know, she's gonna be great no matter where she is. I'm just glad that you came back to Wisconsin. So how's it been? How's that transition been coming back from from?
SPEAKER_02I think because I grew up in this area, it was a lot easier coming back because I knew what to expect. I knew what the band culture was like. I had a network of family and friends already here. So it was much more um much smoother than when I did the opposite and I left the Midwest and traveled to Houston by myself. That that was difficult. But coming back, I mean it's it's different, but it I mean, it's good. I've got a good network of people to be surrounded by.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. How did you how did you make that choice to go to how did you think of the I don't know her, I want to know all the cool stories. Okay, fine. How did you get to Houston? Did was that a choice of yours? Did you go to a job fair?
SPEAKER_02It was a choice. Um She was in trouble with the law.
SPEAKER_06She had to get them.
SPEAKER_02Run really quick. Um UW O'Claire has a partnership with a school district in Houston, Alding ISD. And so they send several educators who apply for this program down to student teach in Aldine for you know an experience. It's almost like a domestic study abroad, I guess you could say. Yeah. Um, just because it's a such different world and much of just a such a different culture and diverse area. Yeah, it is. And so there was a cohort of us that went down. I was the only band teacher at the time that I went down, but there was like an English major that went and a few others that were placed at other schools.
SPEAKER_02And so it was through UW O'Claire. Um, so I actually went down kind of expecting it to be a four to five month experience. I drove down in my little Nissan Versa car with hardly anything in it and bought some furniture when I got there and made the most of it. And then I got sucked in for a little bit and loved every second that I was there. But it is good to be back.
SPEAKER_06And you were there how many years?
SPEAKER_02I taught there for four total school years.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, great. Uh okay, it's it's different there, but uh, what are some things you took from your time there that you bring back with you to make you a better teacher in Wisconsin?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. It is a lot of things. It was a very, I mean, those were my first years of teaching, so it was very molding, very like shaping of who I was as a teacher. Um there's a huge stress down there of like instrument pedagogy and really strong fundamentals of playing. And that was something that I was really thankful to get that education on because I grew up in a really small town. I did the best I could. And I went to Eau Claire and I learned a lot more. Uh, Dr.
SPEAKER_02Kaprowski, the clarinet professor at Eau Claire, she whipped me into shape real fast and taught me all the things I didn't know. Yeah. And then, you know, going down to Texas, I was like, wow, there's still so much more that I haven't been exposed to. And so learning how to really teach those um specific instrument skills was a huge benefit. I mean, they've got a different structure in place with their schools where kids, when they join band in sixth grade, they're in a homogeneous classroom where they're just with their clarinets uh members for a full year, developing those skills before they join a full band the following year.
SPEAKER_02So that alone, you know, those kids can really accelerate and get really found, really sound foundations on their instrument. So learning all the instrument pedagogy was awesome. I went to a several day-long um bassoon and oboe camp, which was amazing. And it really um allowed me to fall in love with teaching bassoon because that was something that I was absolutely terrified in my first middle school job down there, actually, because when I um I wanted to teach middle school to get that experience and everyone was encouraging me to do it, I was terrified to teach the double read class.
SPEAKER_02And that was going to be one of my assignments was to be in charge of all the beginner double reads. And I'm like, oh God, I don't know what I'm doing. Uh I barely played bassoon in my life, but going to that camp was awesome, and I feel so much more confident. And I really fell in love with how to navigate that and how to scaffold that kind of instrument and those skills with young little musicians who don't know, you know, how to wake up and shower in the morning, you know, getting them to play a bassoon was so cool. So yeah, the instrument pedagogy was a big thing.
SPEAKER_06Um and how how do how have you incorporated that in your program now? I mean, I I really ascribe to that. I think we should spend a lot more time in like instrument groups in the Midwest than we do.
SPEAKER_02Um I think now I feel a lot more confident in like able to diagnose kids who are struggling with this skill. I can find those solutions a lot quicker than I could a few years ago. And part of that just comes with experience. I mean, every year that you teach, you you get a little bit better with that. But I think that it was really accelerated when I was teaching in Texas, of like I had constant clinicians and mentors with me that would give me advice and tools to use. So my toolbox got bigger, and now I feel like I can incorporate that with my current students because I oh, you should try this.
SPEAKER_02Oh, we we should use a mirror and do this. We should try this technique to fix this issue that you're having. And I feel like I am able to help those kids feel a lot more successful and enjoy playing their instruments more, which has been a huge benefit.
SPEAKER_06Phil, she's a great guest. Uh I'll shut up now. I I got it. I got it. That was really good. I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Sometimes it becomes a word jumble.
SPEAKER_04No, it doesn't at all. Uh I wanted to backtrack because that's usually what I do because I'm slow, I can process things, you know, that we were talking about six minutes ago and I'm finally caught up. Um you are clearly a a super organized teacher. And I'm wondering if you could sort of uh place that in comparison to, you know, as band directors, sometimes we get completely caught up in the organizational side and we forget that there's a whole music side that really requires our attention in an equal way uh uh in at times.
SPEAKER_04And I'm wondering how do you manage to keep that in balance?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there are definitely times where I have to remind myself that my job is to teach music, not to create a spreadsheet and send an email. Like the root of my job is working with the kids and being present with them and giving them what they need. So I definitely have to remind myself of that because the administrative tasks, that stuff is all really easy for me. I don't know where it came from. I think it was just from how I was raised and my time in high school. All of those skills that I developed have made it so the the paperwork side of the being a band director, that stuff doesn't bother me at all.
SPEAKER_02I really try to prioritize my time into you know the music side of things and the teaching side and making sure I'm giving the kids what they need.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, making it sound easy and it's not for everybody. It's not.
SPEAKER_02And I I do have to say, my current coworker, Andrew, he's awesome. He is really good at like focusing on the music side of things and reminding us like about what kind of rehearsal structures we're having. So we're a good balance and a good team of um the administration of Tasks, but also the teaching side of things. So he helps keep me, you know, centered and grounded and moving forward in the right way.
SPEAKER_05Does George Von Arks or Jeff Croklus give you any trouble?
SPEAKER_02Um No, I wouldn't say they give me any trouble.
SPEAKER_05Okay. All right. You like to do that.
SPEAKER_02Jeff likes to show up and stop in and be a surprise guest in our band room every once in a while. He dropped off some music for me last week. And I see George every Monday. We teach private lessons at a studio, so I get to see him and um Yeah.
SPEAKER_05These are old Quintet friends from the uh the Lampha, the Lampha days over lacrosse. That is uh old stomping grounds. So, question for you, knowing that these are the stomping grounds, you have the Oktoberfest parade coming up. So being a program that has a fall marching component, how do you balance this out with like your long-term goals and making sure that you're uh still representing Holman, which does a guys look great, but like how do you balance all of that?
SPEAKER_02Uh, you is your question like, how do I balance it as a teacher, or how do I balance it in my classroom?
SPEAKER_05He doesn't really know. What would which one would you rather answer?
SPEAKER_02Choose your own adventure. Is that what I'm hearing?
SPEAKER_03That's the way I work.
SPEAKER_02Um Yeah, I mean, I guess our program is similar to a lot of band programs in the fall with the marching component. I mean, we do the summer band camp, getting them ready for Cornfest Parade, Oktoberfest Parade. And we're not a competitive like field show band. We do field shows for football games, but uh, we do parade is our main focus. So I mean, we spend a lot of time on that, and that's our main, main um vision for the fall. But once we everything that we're doing music-wise, especially in the fall, even though we're preparing them for the marching side of things, we're still trying to teach them those skills that will translate to concert band seasons.
SPEAKER_02So everything that we're doing now, we want it to be transferable and not just this is an isolated version of band, and then concert band is a whole different thing. You have to relearn how to do that. We want everything to kind of blend together as far as the skills that they need in both settings. Um, so yeah, especially when we're having music rehearsals, I'm always thinking about like what do these kids need to be able to do for the field show on Friday, but also for our winter concert coming up in December, and also for, you know, solo ensemble season coming up and chamber music. So trying to teach transferable skills, I guess.
SPEAKER_05And now a message from our sponsors. Grand Tours Incorporated is a trusted leader in designing custom international group concert tours for student and adult music ensembles, setting the standard for traveling with purpose.
SPEAKER_06I know because we use them at Concordia all the time, and when I was a high school teacher as well. Because they provide authentic music performance opportunities at distinctive venues, and they engage local musicians, conductors, and composers.
SPEAKER_04Grand Tours. They aim to inspire artistic growth and enable transformative cultural connections through music while creating a sense of family throughout the journey.
SPEAKER_06Visit Grand Tours online at Grand Tours Inc.com. That's Grand ToursInc.com. To learn more about their services and request an international tour design specifically for your ensemble.
SPEAKER_05Anyone can sell you an instrument. A true music partner helps you build something bigger. At Hyde Music, they support the educators, families, performers, and advocates who keep music thriving. For nearly 80 years, their family-owned, musician-operated team has provided instruments, rentals, repairs, educational resources, and creative solutions with personal service every step of the way. Expect more than a transaction.
SPEAKER_05Expect a partner. Learn more at hidmusic.com or visit Hide Music in Appleton, Green Bay, Madison, Oshkosh, and Stevens Point.
SPEAKER_06Can't get enough of me? Not sick of me yet? Complete your master's degree in music education with me at Concordia College in Moorhead, Minnesota. We offer a hybrid degree plan so you can keep teaching and getting paid and still have an in-person cohort in the summers to enrich your experience and learn a lot from others as well. Already have your masters. Ship those beautiful children off to Moorhead. We want your music majors, your non-majors, good kids, bad kids, smart kids, and everything in between. Music scholarships here are available for all students with an annual deadline of February 1st.
SPEAKER_06Info about all these options and more can be found at concordiacollege.edu slash music. That's Concordiacollege.edu slash music. Or just contact me and I'll take care of it.
SPEAKER_04Uh we we talked about Texas, we talked about a like a clear a little bit about what you're doing at Holman, which is r awesome. But we skipped over all the good stuff, which is like uh the fact that you probably should still be uh on a dairy farm uh in the middle of nowhere, uh, but somehow you ended up a music music teacher, I guess.
SPEAKER_06Music teacher.
SPEAKER_04How did uh how in the world did you get from, you know, basically for all intents and purposes, being a dairy farmer as a teenager to what you're doing now? Uh did you your parents must have encouraged you in some way, shape, or form?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I am super fortunate that you know my mom is more of a musician than my dad is. My dad loves music, but my mom was in band in high school and she's always been a lover of music. She sings at church and uh we perform together at weddings. So she's always been a huge part of my musical upbringing. Um, the biggest thing that I think got me into being in a band director was taking piano lessons. They signed me up for lessons when I was five, and I had a really amazing piano lesson teacher for 12 or 13 years, uh, Mrs.
SPEAKER_02Jothan. And um, unfortunately, she's passed away now, but she was she's a big part of where I got my inspiration to study music. And she was always just a joy to spend every Sunday evening with. And I definitely spent way too much time at her house. Like my lessons were an hour, we were there for hours on end, and she she never once made me feel like I didn't belong there. So she was a really big part of my inspiration to become a band teacher. And then I think it was in seventh grade, it was either seventh or sixth grade. Um, in band rehearsal, I remember the distinct moment I decided I was gonna become a band rector.
SPEAKER_02We were playing a Star Wars medley, and I was being that really annoying clarinet player that took everything up an octave for fun. So I was playing everything up the octave, and in that moment, I remember looking up and being like, I'm gonna do this. This is what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna be a band rector. And that has always stuck with me. It never changed. Everyone told me in high school, they're like, No, you're gonna do something else. You're you don't you don't really want to do that. You should do this instead. And I was like, Nope, I'm gonna do that. That's what I said I'm gonna do. And I've always been super passionate about it. Um, I was in the FFA band with Monty Dunham, so he was a big part of that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I got really close with him, and so he was a big inspiration for me and um kind of guided me into the next steps after high school into college.
SPEAKER_04So what made those people great mentors, like Amonti and others?
SPEAKER_02They cared more about the connection they had with me than about if I was playing the right notes in in our rehearsals, you know, that I always felt like they were someone a role model, you know, everything we talk about with good teachers, they it was the way they made me feel. So I will always remember sitting in those rehearsals or in those private piano lessons and just feeling a sense of comfort and enjoyment for the music.
SPEAKER_04And this this is great because Peter is really working on trying to connect with students and struggle with it. And so he's picking up a lot of good information tonight.
SPEAKER_02Happy to help.
SPEAKER_05So what's an unrealized goal that you have? I mean, you're still at the front edge of your career and so on, but what's what's what's out there that you're you're reaching for?
SPEAKER_02Hmm, that's a good question because I sometimes go back and forth. I know that I am strong with organization and admin skills, like we talked about. That that's something I've always enjoyed doing. So everyone's always been like, you're gonna be a principal someday, you're gonna be an admin someday. I really don't think that that's what I'm wanting to do at this point. I think my place is in music, um, even though I've kind of gone back and forth with that idea. Um, as of now, I really just want to get better at being a teacher. I just I'm so I feel like I'm on this path of like every day and every year I get better and more confident in my skills and abilities to, you know, connect with kids and teach the kids.
SPEAKER_02Um and I especially love getting kids to feel successful at their instruments, particularly beginners. That's like a huge passion of mine since I've, you know, gained those skills in Texas. So I mean, eventually I would love to just continue teaching and maybe even get back into the middle school world if possible. But long term, when hopefully I've been more established and I maybe know what I'm doing slightly or feel more confident in what I'm doing, I could see myself helping new teachers, like undergrads, becoming more confident in their um teaching skills, kind of like Dr.
SPEAKER_02Dunbar. She was always someone I'm like, I could, I could see myself really enjoying a position like what she has, kind of being a music education type professor. But I don't even want to get close to that idea until I feel like I've been in the public schools long enough to, you know, have some of those experiences.
SPEAKER_06So I wasn't adding them up. How many years of teaching is this for you now, minus your master's degree time?
SPEAKER_02Yep. So I'm still a baby teacher. I'm in year six right now.
SPEAKER_06Oh, that's good.
SPEAKER_05That's yeah, but it's like dog years. It's like really 15. You know, you just double it, add three more hours.
SPEAKER_06Every year is like seven years of your life. Yeah. God.
SPEAKER_05No, I mean, look at Phil. He's only really been teaching for 10 years, but look at the gray hair and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_04Well, when you teach every other week, I mean, this is the way it works. It's exhausting. It's exhausting.
SPEAKER_05A couple years off.
SPEAKER_06So, Angela, um, I know you're early in your career, but we have a lot of young teachers that listen in. So uh uh you say that you're still growing, but you remember your first year in your second year. And uh, did you feel successful? Uh why did you go back? If you could tell yourself something even in those first two years, or if you could talk to another teacher who's getting ready to start, how would you guide them with the perseverance and the rigor it takes to push through some of those early year difficulties?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, those first few years are brutal. They they're tough, and uh you make a lot of mistakes. You're making money. I'm supposed to encourage these kids. Um, stick with it. Um, I think the real reason that I survived was in Texas, there's so many band teachers, it's a huge network. I would not have survived the way I did without people. So asking for help, reaching out to mentors, uh reaching out to a band director from a school next door, doing anything you can to get help.
SPEAKER_02I I mean, I'm notorious for being the question person. So I I really relied on my colleagues and um my district had some assigned band mentors that were some retired teachers that would come in every so often and provide feedback. And they they really helped me get through those first few years and feel more confident in my my skills.
SPEAKER_06Excellent. What was the biggest thing that you grew in as a first-year teacher?
SPEAKER_02It's tough because I was a first-year teacher teaching in a place where I was very different from my students. I was in a whole new cultural environment. So I had to not only learn like podium presence and like how to run a rehearsal, but how to do it with those specific kids. So classroom management and getting to know the students and how to speak to them, which is very different than how I speak to my current students because it's just a different world. It was it was like doing two things at once, getting acquainted with my new environment and also learning how to teach them.
SPEAKER_05You know, you benefited from this concept of learning from others. What if you could, where would you go in this world if you were to go somewhere else to go learn?
SPEAKER_02Ooh, go learn anything or banned?
SPEAKER_05Doesn't matter. I'd say anything.
SPEAKER_04Again, you can answer the questions however you want. You could answer a completely different question if you wish. You could.
SPEAKER_02Um I spent a little bit of time right after high school before my first year at UW Eau Claire in Peru through a mission trip. And I wish I would have spent more time there, um, being immersed in that environment. I think I would go back to to Peru. Um there was a lot to learn about just life in general, I felt felt like down there and learning about what's important in perspectives.
SPEAKER_06Anytime. Good question. Here we go. Ready?
SPEAKER_04Relax, Haberman. Um of the things that we're asking many of our guests uh this season is about advocacy. And I'm uh you know, I know you'll have a great answer, but I'm wondering if the way you advocated for programs when you were teaching in Texas is different than the way you have to advocate here. Yeah. That is a good question.
SPEAKER_02That that is really good. Um in the places that I was at in Texas, and I shouldn't speak for the whole state because it's massive and it's different in different pockets. I mean, even one side of Houston is different from the other side of Houston. Um I didn't have to advocate as much when I was there because band was very rooted into the school culture. It was very well respected by our admin. We I had time with the kids, I had a lot of time with the kids. I saw them every day, some of the kids several hours a day. And as far as like budgets, you know, the budget was just more than enough for what we needed in our program.
SPEAKER_02So I didn't have to worry as much about the advocacy part as I maybe do now here in the Midwest, where the scene is a little bit different. Um I think the biggest thing with advocacy is focus more on what you're doing in your classroom and let that speak for itself. If you continue to do great things with your kids and you can show the product and the benefit of what your kids are learning and doing, a lot of times that can speak for itself, or at least at what I've seen. It speaks for itself and people will notice that and your admin will see that, and your community will recognize that.
SPEAKER_02Even in uh my current position in Holman, the community sees how involved we are. We go to all the local parades, we perform at all the sporting events, and just that alone, they then even not even considering the quality, just us being there speaks value, and our community really appreciates that and and respects that.
SPEAKER_05So, Angela, you are uh a fantastic planner. So let's talk about some music literature. What are you excited about performing this year? What's on the list?
SPEAKER_02Ooh. Um, we are actually having Willie Owens come visit our school in November. He's our guest conductor for the Western Wisconsin honor band. So um I'm excited to see some of his pieces and possibly program those with my ensemble. Um, I'm also the reading band coordinator. Ooh, yes.
SPEAKER_06Blue Tango. They all love it.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. That's a good one.
SPEAKER_06Maybe Ostrand will come down and play a solo for you. He won't. He'll charge you. It's fine. Has to take that week ahead and week off. There's a week to do that.
SPEAKER_04It takes me a full week to even read the notes to Blue Tango. Sorry I interrupted. Keep going.
SPEAKER_02No, it's okay. Um I coordinate the reading band session for the Wisconsin Concert Band Association. I'm in my second year of doing that. And it basically entails just reaching out to composers and publishers to get music that they'd like to donate for the session. And then there's a people bring their instruments, we sit down, play them, and then the pieces are um put into a drawing and people can go home with the music. So I've had a lot of fun researching composers that even I've never heard of, and I've never heard their music, and trying to bring those to light and bring those to the session and sent home into some band rooms to be played by kids all around the state.
SPEAKER_02So that's been kind of a fun project, too.
SPEAKER_05Excellent. I remember that reading bandwell. Perfect. Next question. Lovely.
SPEAKER_04Uh okay. Funniest dairy farm story. We're ready. Oh no. Yeah. This is good now. We're getting into it.
SPEAKER_05Here we go. Commuters are very interested. They are interested. Oh man. Was it Blair? Where is the hometown? Was it Blair?
SPEAKER_07Cash.
SPEAKER_05Cash. Okay.
SPEAKER_02Oh goodness.
SPEAKER_04Thriving metropolis. Tons of thousands of people. Look it up. Google it.
SPEAKER_02Oh man, there's lots of memories. Most of them aren't fun when they initially come. They're fun to think back on, but in the moment they weren't fun. Um the ones that I think about most are waking up in the middle of the night to just stampeding, mooing cows in the yard because they escaped because someone forgot to close the fence or they got out some other way. And we'd be all running around in our pajamas with boots on, trying to get the cows back into the area they need to be. And of course those moments are stressful, but looking back now, it's like those are kind of funny, imagining like a bunch of people running around in the middle of the night.
SPEAKER_02I'd have to think on some other memories.
SPEAKER_04I mean, you must have had a network of friends that grew up similarly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. A really um large percentage of my graduating class, which is a very small number of people, but a large percentage of the class were grew up on farms or at least in the country in like a hobby farm type of situation.
SPEAKER_05How big was your class in school?
SPEAKER_02I'd have to look it up, but I think it was 38 people.
SPEAKER_06That's close enough. We we can be off by one, we'll be okay. Um 38 people. What what skills growing up on a farm or even in a rural environment have you found to help you be successful as a teacher?
SPEAKER_02Work ethic I think is probably the most obvious. I most days in high school and in college and even now teaching, I'm like, you know, this is still better than having to go out in the fields and pick rocks, or this is still better than some of the stuff I had to do on the farm. So it really made me be able to yeah, just have a really strong work ethic. And I think the rural part of my upbringing is really special because now that I've lived in both a really tiny community and I've also lived in the fourth largest city in the country, seeing like both sides of the spectrum as far as like the population, it really makes me appreciate the small town and how I feel like I knew more people in my small community than I did in Houston.
SPEAKER_02It's just so much more connected. People are friendly, people work together, they help each other. And I'm not saying that doesn't exist in a bigger city, but it's it's different. And coming back now, I have a way stronger appreciation for that, and I definitely took it for granted before I left.
SPEAKER_05I might write that down. Have you ever been to the ski jump?
SPEAKER_02The Westby ski jump?
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh yes, definitely.
SPEAKER_05That's that's fun. Okay, that's awful.
SPEAKER_02I don't ski though, so nope.
SPEAKER_04All right, I'm just checking. All right, Phil? Uh uh you dislodged me. I I I uh I wasn't quite expecting the ski jump story. Uh biggest challenge or barrier facing your current students right now. Wow, he thought about that one. That was prepared.
SPEAKER_02Current students, I would say it's two things. Um, first thing is just time. We are really lucky that we have extremely talented students that are very involved in sports and other activities, which unfortunately inhibits their time in band. So it's really difficult for us to schedule rehearsals that are, you know, where a lot of people could come to that's outside of our our class time. And we're on a block schedule, so we really only have two large blocks of time with them a week and then one mini section of time.
SPEAKER_02So just time, I think seeing the kids and being in front of them is an obstacle that we're facing. And they they work hard when they're there. And we're it's really about the quality of the rehearsal over the quantity of rehearsals, but I mean, it still is nice. We would love to see them a little bit more frequently. And then this is something that I think is out of the control of the kids, but a big project we're currently working on is getting new marching band uniforms. They're wearing 23 plus-year-old uniforms in our performances right now, and they're just um, yep, they're at a point where they're unrepairable.
SPEAKER_02So my coworker and I, we've been working really hard on this project. And we have this is the thing I love about this community that our band booster organization and parents are like all in, and they're helping us out so much with this fundraising campaign to get all the money that we need to purchase new uniforms, hopefully to receive them by next school year is our goal. So we are at the day that we're recording this um podcast, I think we're at about 82,000 of our$105,000 goal. And that's just people in our community wanting to support us.
SPEAKER_02And so we're really grateful for that. But the kids have been working really hard on that too with us. And it's not necessarily an obstacle that's because of them, or you know, they're kind of roped into it because it's the time that we need to replace them. But we're trying to really emphasize that we're paying it forward to future generations of marchers, just like people did in the past for our current students. So those are the two big things that we're experiencing right now.
SPEAKER_05Our uh commuters are a very generous bunch. They continue to send 20s in the mail and they write for fill on the top, and I just send it back. But if folks wanted to contribute to your uh to this cause, how could they do so?
SPEAKER_02I certainly didn't mean to put in a plug for this on your podcast because I know everyone probably has situations and fundraising needs. But uh you can check us out on the Holman Band Facebook page. We have an online method of donating, and we have an event coming up on October 12th, a marching review concert that we're doing at dinner and raffles and stuff. So if people want to come to that, we'd love the support. But no, the kids in our community have been working really hard and we're we're confident. And hopeful that we will be able to hit our goal so that these kids can get nice new uniforms that they'll feel really prideful in.
SPEAKER_05I I would like to suggest to the commuter that instead of buying our shirts, which which you've done in in multitudes, that you just shift those funds right to Homan.
SPEAKER_06Peter? Uh the way we don't have to make them pay for the shipping. Um Okay. Well uh I did start with the funny stories about Phil and Chris, but I think they're amazing humans and educators. And so I'd like to end by asking what are some of the stories you can share about the amazingness of Dr. Ostrander and Chris as teachers and mentors of you. And don't let them interrupt. Holy letter talk.
SPEAKER_02We'll have to mute them. Um, I mean, there's a lot of moments that I can think on where I was able to steal an idea or to watch a way that they do something. I'm like, oh, that's something that I I want to be able to portray. I think with Dr. O, especially like watching him conduct Symphony Band. And then the semester that I was in Symphony Band with you, your demeanor and your presence in front of us, I think was always something that we all respected. We I felt like, at least when I was at Eau Claire, I really enjoyed seeing how calm you were and how that reflected into the musicians.
SPEAKER_02And we were able to like make true music together because we were all there and we all wanted to listen to what you had to say. So that was something that you know I want to be able to do with my students too. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I mean, it's a fine line between calm and sleepy. And I I seem to walk those lines between calm and sleepy very, very well. It's a it's a narrow pathway, but I've got to do that.
SPEAKER_02Well, you do a good job of making it seem like you're not falling asleep.
SPEAKER_06So it's two o'clock, you know, he's getting tired. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And then with Chris. Um I think I mentioned it at the beginning. You're the enthusiasm and the ability to make every kid feel valued in the rehearsal and the pot always finding something positive and something to celebrate with every kid. That's something that I still think about and try to apply in my teaching. Um you had the ability to connect with every kid, even if it was in the full band setting. And yeah, they all felt like they had a place to belong when I was watching you teach and being a part of your rehearsals.
SPEAKER_05Especially when we played Among Us, because that's what we did during COVID. It's like, yeah, good times, good times.
SPEAKER_04Well, uh the tonight we give an award to whoever can guess the uh topic uh for the speed round. Oh, it's gonna be about dairy farm. Yep, cows. It's too easy. That's right. It's questions about farming in lacrosse, Wisconsin.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I get ready. This will be embarrassing if I don't know the answers.
SPEAKER_04Really okay. Um we don't really know the answers. We're sort of guessing. So much like Chris's questions. Uh you can name any one of the top five crops in lacrosse county. Corn.
SPEAKER_02Top five crops, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Chris Chris is right beans. That is not one of them.
SPEAKER_02Is it alfalfa?
SPEAKER_04Wait, what kind of farm did you grow up on?
SPEAKER_02Dairy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's number one.
SPEAKER_02Oh. What was the question? Top crop?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah. Milk.
SPEAKER_02Oh. Oh.
SPEAKER_05Crop milk.
SPEAKER_02I wouldn't have guessed that.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I don't. I hear it. He's not logical. That's why he's he's he never was on a farm. That's right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, thank you, Peter. Milk, grain, cattle, hay, and hogs. Question number two. Um, what percentage of farms are family owned? Oh.
SPEAKER_02I think it's declining now, but uh over 50, I would want to say.
SPEAKER_05Chris? Uh I I'm I'm worried. I think it's like 41. Peter? 30. 98%.
SPEAKER_04Holy crap.
SPEAKER_05That's great. Take care.
SPEAKER_04If that's declining, that's that's how many people does agriculture employ in La Crosse County?
SPEAKER_02Lacrosse County. Several thousand.
SPEAKER_04Like not another percentage, but a real number of people. Yeah, a real number. I'll give you some choices here. Uh 4,000, 6,000, or 9,000.
SPEAKER_02I want to be optimistic and say 9,000.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I agree. I agree. That's right. 6,000. Good job. Um Cash. Um in La Crosse County, what was the cash crop in the 1850s? Corn. Again, editing is a powerful tool.
SPEAKER_02I was gonna say tobacco. I was gonna say tobacco farming, maybe.
SPEAKER_04I'll take well, it's a different crop in the 1860s. Uh so in the 1850s it was uh wheat, and in the 1860s, potatoes.
SPEAKER_07Yeah.
SPEAKER_04We're doing really well. I would say we've gotten no questions right. Uh La Crosse County School of Agriculture and Domestic Science opened in On Alaska in what year?
SPEAKER_02Ooh. Are there is it multiple choice?
SPEAKER_04Yes, 1880, 1909, or 1917.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna go 1909.
SPEAKER_04Winter. Uh 1939. Uh the Tri-State Ice Cream Corporation became what very famous dairy company in lacrosse?
SPEAKER_02Dairy company.
SPEAKER_04What's the name?
SPEAKER_02I know I was thinking the Pearl too. I'm like ice cream.
SPEAKER_04What's Pearl's good? It's uh it's still a company that is around, but it's now not as associated with the dairy uh so much anymore.
SPEAKER_07I'm not sure.
SPEAKER_04Uh let's see. That's right. Dolly Madison Dairy. The Dolly Madison Dairy. Yeah. There you go. Okay. And uh final there's no wrong answer to this question. Best ice cream in lacrosse.
SPEAKER_02The Pearl. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Chris? Ice cream. Following? Second place? What's second place?
SPEAKER_05Second place. Uh what's on the north side? What's the north sider thing called? Hang on. Orange side ice cream. Important. Just just it's fine. Just hang with me. It's called. It might be closed by now because it was like forever ago. Oh, this is stunning.
SPEAKER_06Stunning journalism. Stunning.
SPEAKER_05Excellent podcasting right here. It's it. That's it. You go to Pearl.
SPEAKER_04Go to the Pearl, or you're wrong. All right. Great. Okay. Okay. A quick trip. Some quick trip.
SPEAKER_07Quick trip.
SPEAKER_04That's it. Angela, you're the big winner of the speed round tonight. Chris and Peter consistently lose.
SPEAKER_06I think our audience is all losers because of having to go through that speed round. That's all right. It's good. Just living through it to win. Angela, I'm going to start because I don't know you until now. We've met, I think, at the Kalahari way back, way back when. But wonderful to see you taking so many opportunities to expand and learn and grow. And you say you're you're a baby teacher, but you're just like going and getting it.
SPEAKER_06And a lot of people are already like starting to downshift and relax into something, and you're pushing forward, which is a beautiful thing. And I can tell that's why you're amazing. And uh thanks for being with us. I'm so sorry that you know these other Yahoos on the screen so well. Well, thank you.
SPEAKER_02I appreciate that. And thanks for bringing some sanity to this podcast.
SPEAKER_06You are so welcome. You are so welcome.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's what he's known for. Yeah, no, integrity and humility and humility. Humility, yeah, that's one of the things. Uh no, I'm so I'm grateful that you came back to Wisconsin. We are better off because of you. And uh I'm uh honestly honored to know you, and I'm thankful that I I know you.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_04That seemed very heartfelt. I don't know if he's telling the truth. It could just be a bunch of hogwash, pretty much. Um a lot of teachers um uh struggle with the organizational part of what they're doing. Uh you you make that look effortless. Um, and uh it's really remarkable. It is not necessarily a strength of mine. I can do it um uh when called upon to, but uh I what it does is it it makes it possible to have like great lightning bolt teaching moments during the school day.
SPEAKER_04If you're not organized, the percentage just goes down. And and and the likelihood that you can create it just sort of goes away. Um and I think it um not that it's everything to be to to the construct of a great classroom, but it is super, super important. Um and uh it you've always had that skill, and I just am uh amazed and and somewhat envious of how you're able to do it uh as easily as you are. Um and you you seem to have this insatiable thirst uh to want to get better at it, teaching in general.
SPEAKER_04And uh man, I want to be in your classroom. Um I wish my kids could be part of that. So it's fantastic. And uh just great to be observing all the success that you're having. So way to go.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Am I able to ask you guys a quick question?
SPEAKER_06Oh god. I mean, yes.
SPEAKER_02It's like it's a real question. It's not like a silly question.
SPEAKER_04Um what we'll treat it silly.
SPEAKER_02What is something you wish you saw, young teachers, let's say like 10 or less years of teaching experience, what do you wish you saw us teachers doing more of in our classrooms or in general?
SPEAKER_04Failing. Like just experimenting wildly, um throwing something against the wall, hoping it works, and when it doesn't, just picking yourself back up and trying another tack to get through to whatever it is that you need to get.
SPEAKER_06Uh I'd say that but uh a little differently. W there's been a lot of work in the last 20 years in neuroscience to learn how we learn. Um and I we've had a couple of other guests on recently about this, but none of us were taught that way. And it's much safer to teach in the way you were taught, even though that may not be the best way to teach the idiom of music or how to read music, or should we be reading when should we start reading music?
SPEAKER_06And um not that you have to fail, but be willing to listen to some new science about how we could do this better, and then be willing to take the confidence leap to go try something um that that works for students. And I think I mean there's a lot of things that uh are happening down in Texas and other places with that they're doing that we should try to bring around the country. Yes, it takes a lot more FTE, but there's ways to incorporate stuff like that.
SPEAKER_06So I wish I saw young teachers take more risks in teaching the way we should be teaching rather than maybe the way we were taught.
SPEAKER_04That sounded like the grown-up version of my my answer. Good job. Yeah, that's about right. Uh remain curious.
SPEAKER_05See how that was that was short.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's easy. Look at that. Uh Angela, thanks for doing this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Great dad. Thank you for having me. It's out of my comfort zone a bit, but I think that's also important to do those things. So I appreciate that.
SPEAKER_04At no point in time did this uh seem to be uh out of your comfort zone, like at all. Phil hasn't been comfortable doing this for years.
SPEAKER_05Oh my god, it's just wildly uncomfortable every single time. Hey what passes nicely done, Peter. Well done. I'm very proud of you for recapping this. Yep, no problem. Oh, and Phil, great guest.
SPEAKER_04Really good guest.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, she's amazing.
SPEAKER_04Regardless of the quality of the guest, um, I stumble over the questions. Good guest. Yeah, I mean you didn't even ask any for a while. It was good.
SPEAKER_05No, but you you've been excited about your guest list this year, and I know I see why. Like you that's another winner. She is amazing. Yep.
SPEAKER_04Uh I like most of the people that I ask turn me down initially, and then I come back and ask them again.
SPEAKER_06That's right. Smart. Uh one of my favorite things is um she's not insecure, but she doesn't think she's figured it out yet. So she's still scratching and growing. Um she had that conversation, but well, my first year was different in Houston, but like then she mentioned all the things that young teachers deal with building relationships with students, learning the culture of the school. Uh it was really nice, and classroom management, of course. And uh that's that's it's just all right there.
SPEAKER_06It's all right there.
SPEAKER_05But notice what she said, which was one of the most substantial things that she learned down there, is the fundamentals of the instrument. You have to be able to teach the very basic concepts so that kids can access the art form. Because if you don't have that, then everything else just crumbles under that weak foundation.
SPEAKER_06And so every day, every day you have your students sound, time, tonguing, you know, fingers. It's just you you have to and then the tuba players can actually play because they're part of it too, and you're not just playing whole notes with the tuba players while the flutes are playing six tuplets. It's just yeah, we we really need to keep that in mind. It's good, good stuff. Man, you guys are lucky to have her in Wisconsin. I got we got to get down there.
SPEAKER_06Phil. Um, I have a question for you. Okay.
SPEAKER_07Here we go.
SPEAKER_05Nope. This is a bambuzzler. Okay, I got another bambuzzler. Why? Because Paul wants more time to prepare the bamboozler. Yeah. Oh, wait, I flipped it. This is a bamboozler. Bamboozler. Bamboozler. He's working on the bambuzzler.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, so why don't you ask that question there, uh Skippy? This is riveting to the way this is developing. It's good. Here we go. Thank God AI cleans this up.
SPEAKER_05I pulled this out of uh the interwebs here. I like to go on the Facebook and I like to look at the middle school band director's uh page because there's oftentimes some interesting questions. This is an interesting one. Are papers acceptable replacement assignments for missing a concert? Oh, this got some this got some interesting responses. I'm just curious what you what you fellas think about that kind of question.
SPEAKER_06There's no way to make up a concert. But there are lots of reasons to not be at a concert that are totally valid. And I just don't think making them write a paper as a punishment because their grandparent died or something like that is really what we need to do. I'd rather have them watch the concert and fill out a form of feedback and listen and be actively musical about something. Um but I don't know. I don't have my kids do anything.
SPEAKER_06You go next, Chris. You answer that.
SPEAKER_05My answer changed over my course of and I of course Well, and it should, right? I mean, just like Angela said, you kind of learn. And I would do the carrot and stick thing and I would punish them and and have them write or do uh something, you know what I mean? And at the end of my time in the classroom, uh I did nothing. And I know that it's gonna shock people because I figured at that point you did nothing. I did nothing. Like if a student didn't come, this is a middle school band, right?
SPEAKER_05And we had a hundred and some kids and some, and not saying that to like throw a number up, but I'm just saying it was a lot of students. And invariably I would have some students that wouldn't come to the concert. Okay. So then the question is, you know, how do you approach that situation? And to me, it is I need to find out more about the situation itself. And because there's always a reason. And what we learned, and again, I you know talked about Sharon a little bit tonight, but my work spouse Sharon, we we came to the conclusion that we didn't know enough about it, and we found out, oh, yeah, that some of our kids didn't have parents who could get them to the concert or didn't value the concert, and that the kid actually valued the concert, but their parents didn't, and they had to take care of their younger sibling or something like that.
SPEAKER_05So we actually got a school van and went to go pick up the children to bring them to the concert if they couldn't make it there themselves. But that again, we have to make sure that we always come to this question, this thing, with a lot of compassion and our eyes wide open because we we tend to think in bias that my dad would, of course, destroyed me if I didn't go to the concert. But not all families are like that. We have to make sure that again, we're treating that with care and understanding first and then work with the child.
SPEAKER_06Love that. Way more articulate than my response. And I love that you had another response that you found a way to break down that barrier and make it easier and uh a way for kids to get there. Um yeah. And I also think it's not really a consequence to do something, but if you value the concert or not, if there's something musical to be done, let's do something musical to explore rather than make them write a paper or something that feels much more like a punishment. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06You know. And uh yeah, and uh I think uh I talk to my students a lot about the you know, poverty is uh hidden. It's hidden, right? They just don't raise their hand, they don't elect to be part of band. You've got to go searching about why and and uh then make a choice to go do something that's gonna help. Good for you, Chris. I don't care what Phil says, I like you. Phil, what do you think?
SPEAKER_04My perspective on concert attendance changed when I had my own children. I think, you know, as a young, whatever I was, like twenty-seven-year-old teacher or something, by the time I finally was able to get through college. I you know, I was like, how could anybody possibly you know, I create it was a I had a good classroom environment and and and I knew P my students wanted to be there. I knew they loved it. But I I you know, I I I try for some reason, some stupid reason, I took it personally when somebody like, you know, bull I gu I guess blew it off or something came up, I'm not, you know, or whatever.
SPEAKER_04And then I had my own child who was, you know, like it's just they're you know, really busy. Uh they have a million different things they're trying to do. You know, your your students are working jobs, they're volunteering, they're trying to do really well in their coursework, they're dealing with at times really challenging home environments. You need to find out in a professional way what's going on with your students so that um you can invest in them properly, not punish them.
SPEAKER_04That's stupid. Uh whether that's a paper or a a grade or something like that. Like it doesn't there's no lasting relationship with music or learning um when it's uh when it's about punishment.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Goes back to Angela. She actually said it. Uh teachers are people will forget what you did, people will forget what you said, but they'll never forget the way that you made them feel. Right.
SPEAKER_06Why were they good mentors? I don't know. They just cared about me and made me feel good.
SPEAKER_04I think you'll be at work tomorrow morning. I have to stay until about 10 p.m., so I'm going in a little bit later tomorrow. Got it.
SPEAKER_05Uh I will be up, uh let's see, I'll be logged in at 7 a.m. Nice. But when will you actually start working? 7 a.m. Good job. I log in, I'm in, man. Then I'm in. Door closes, I go. Yeah. I work for the state.
SPEAKER_06I do work later on Mondays. Not a trombone called the code. What are you logging into exactly? It's a deep state of the deep state depression and anxiety.
SPEAKER_05Beyond Artless is sponsored by Beyond the Notes Music Festival. Our mission is to create and provide profound learning and social experiences through music that go beyond the notes. Visit BTN Music Festival.com to learn more.
Send us Fan Mail Commuters, buckle up. Phil celebrates Chris and Peter, which is awkward for everyone involved. Chris reveals the dangers of painting music stands without putting anything underneath them. Peter...
Send us Fan Mail Commuter has weighed in and feels that middle school band instrument repair stories are far and away the best. Greg Beckwith has worked at Minnesota State SE Technical - Instrument Repair in Red Wing,...
Send us Fan Mail Becca Arons has contracted ensembles for countless major musical stars - from the Eagles, the Who, Ed Sheeran, Snoop Dog, Cory Wong and Aerosmith to Andrea Bocelli, Stevie Wonder, Weird Al Yankovich,...
Send us Fan Mail What does it take to be a great leader? On this episode of Beyond ArtLess, Tobin Stewart, Symphony Orchestra Director and Assistant Professor of Music at Montana State University, joins us to talk about...
Send us Fan Mail What happens when deep commitment to music education, trailblazing pedagogy, and the pursuit of artistry come together in one remarkable career? You get Randy Swiggum, nationally recognized conductor,...