Send us Fan Mail What does it take to be a great leader? On this episode of Beyond ArtLess, Tobin Stewart, Symphony Orchestra Director and Assistant Professor of Music at Montana State University, joins us to talk about leadership, musicianship, and lifelong learning. Drawing from his book Leading as a Conductor, Tobin shares insights on building ensemble culture, developing student leaders, finding your own leadership style, and knowing when to lead, delegate, or simply get out of the way. We also explore the connections between music and athletics, the value of singing in instrumental ensembles, and how a mountain biking accident changed the way he conducts. Then it’s off to Montana for a speed round featuring cold smoke, skijoring, and a few questionable attempts at humor. Commuters, there’s plenty to learn - and a few reasons to shake your head - along the way! Learn More About Tobin: https://www.montana.edu/music/directory/1524642/tobin-stewart https://www.tobinstewart.com/ https://giamusic.com/artists/tobin-stewart https://www.nmeanebraska.org/2026-all-state-orchestra REGISTER NOW: 2027 BEYOND THE NOTE FESTIVALS - A few spots remain!! https://www.btnmusicfestival.com/festivals/ensembles/kalahari-1 COMMISSION POSSIBLE 2028 W/ OMAR THOMAS https://www.btnmusicfestival.com/education/commission Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_04I am a huge fan because you guys are like the brothers I didn't even want. I'm like, oh my god, what? But nobody could say anything bad about Phil. I mean, even though your dad, you know, got all of the sound bites. You guys familiar with a stopwatch? That's not true. I'm leaving, but anyway. What happens now?
SPEAKER_02What?
SPEAKER_00Elkis.
SPEAKER_07Let me ask this question. When the conductor asks you to stand up to acknowledge you for doing a solo, do you A stand up and smile? Or B, do you try to get the rest of the trombone section to stand up with you? What do you do, Phil?
SPEAKER_04I I felt that the piece featured the whole trombone section. So did you get to the concert? Well, we got a solo bow at the end, but she uh the other two gentlemen uh made me stand up first alone. I didn't want to do it. I did I did have an extended solo just to myself. It wasn't just a section feature, but I felt like I we should stand up together and how'd that go? I heard you were absolutely amazing on the Simon.
SPEAKER_06Uh people were being overly generous or forgiving or lying. I think all that might have been true, but I still think it's pretty amazing because the person that told me would not have lied. They said you sounded like a million bucks, and they were like, wow, that was very funny. So nice work.
SPEAKER_04The solo did, I mean, it was basically like mostly um bellowing uh sort of why Cliff Gordon meets uh wind ensemble.
SPEAKER_06Oh well, that's that's your strength, just making bellowy sounds like that.
SPEAKER_04Pretty much in sort of uh 10 years of college. There you go.
SPEAKER_06Indeed. Bellow, baby. It's this box you got back there.
SPEAKER_07Uh I it's a box. It's uh it's another desk. Why do you need a third desk? Um uh I muted you guest. Uh I I need more desk space, so I'm got another desk to put more crap. Hey.
SPEAKER_06How many screens in that room? How many screens in that room?
SPEAKER_07One, two, three, four, five, six.
SPEAKER_06Um how many cameras?
SPEAKER_04It was great. I just important information. I have I'm I know that our one commuter is very interested in talking about Chris's office. What? Um uh there was a Miles Gleason and Jerry Young double double sighting uh yesterday uh in downtown St. Paul at the Oktubafest featuring uh Marty Erickson. It's great. Wow. I got a I got hugs from all of those people and more. Oh that's good. Peter, what are you doing today? What's what's happening?
SPEAKER_06I'm sitting here listening. I'm gonna talk about how great you sounded. And you don't like that. Oh god, it's wonderful. Uh we had a big weekend at Concordia, otherwise I would have been down for the concert, of course. But um we had a big uh band retreat weekend up here.
SPEAKER_07So wait a second. Wait a second. I'm getting a premonition. I see Peter Hobberman walking through a hallway with a grill. Is that pot? Did you do that, Peter?
SPEAKER_06So true. We had a we had an all-bands picnic for all the bands, pet bands. We were grilling out. I was wearing a bad Hawaiian shirt. I got like in the early 2000s. Traditions that uh should go away are still strong here. That's just how that works.
SPEAKER_07Yeah.
SPEAKER_06And yeah, it was on Facebook. And then uh on all the socials. Yeah, anyway, so we had a great weekend and it was raining, so nobody wanted to be anywhere else, so that was good too. Um, how about you, Christopher, besides getting a new desk? What else uh you got going on this big weekend?
SPEAKER_07Yeah, I moved like a metric ton of rock. That was fun back. I saw that hurts a little bit.
SPEAKER_06Can I ask a question? Did you move it like out, but then get too much and have to move the extra over so you could use your driveway?
SPEAKER_07Oh, yeah. No, I I ordered entirely too much. So I I did all the rock moving Friday afternoon. Beautiful day, beautiful day. That was fun. Um, so uh, but back up Thursday, went and saw the governor. That was cool. We did our state of education event. We got to go hang with gov for uh that's right. Yeah, at the residence.
SPEAKER_04And uh did all did all your superstar students were they there and then did they perform?
SPEAKER_07So good. Oh, they were so good. The little kids, the elementary kids were dancing. We had some you know, Shakespeare going on for the first time. The choir was great, the vocalist was great, the flute choir from Wanakkee was great. So, I mean, yeah, that was all fun. It was fun, it was good. And then uh ordered too much rock, move the rock, regretted that, and then I had a lot rock left over. I went on Facebook Marketplace, and these two nice gentlemen came uh this morning and they loaded it up into their uh Honda uh SUV, which was fascinating to see people put rock into an SUV, but it was fine.
SPEAKER_06They made it Oh my god, pulled up without a just like rubbing on the wheels as they drove away.
SPEAKER_07Just rubbing on the wheels. So they took one load and then came back for a whole nother load. And so um and then they went straight to get new tires. It's straight uh suspension, all of it. I was like they didn't bring a truck or a trailer. I'm like, oh, this is gonna be good. Okay. No trailer needed, no trailer needed, so just manpower.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, you can own that good stuff. And then I offer like Home Depot in Menarans for like 20 bucks an hour. It's worth it.
SPEAKER_04Did you did you offer like a free free tuba with the extra rock? I did not. Was that part of the deal?
SPEAKER_07Hey, have you guys seen this? This is good. This is worth a few extra minutes. We'll go fast. This is uh I doubt it. No, I doubt it. Do we have to narrate it? Are our guests gonna be able to know what the No, your guests will love this. Your guests is gonna love this. Have you seen this? Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_08Jesse McGuire has been the Arizona Diamondbacks' good luck charm for decades. This trumpet playing the team to their first and only World Series win 25 years ago. So naturally, as the team honored its 2001 championship squad, Maguire was there. But in the middle of the anthem, suddenly silenced. The trumpet failing. In 40 years of playing, I've never missed that high note.
SPEAKER_08But this show must go on. With a different instrument. Like the pros he plays for, Maguire has always been cool under pressure.
SPEAKER_08Teams across the sports world for years turning to Maguire for his Star-Spangled tribute. In demand not just for his performances, but his points, proven again this weekend. Because this musician always finds a way to end on a high note.
SPEAKER_06Great work. That is great.
SPEAKER_04That you know what else is great? Oh, it's good. At least he he he showed up for the gig. Showed up for the gig.
SPEAKER_06That's all it's got. It's totally true. Thanks for that. Um you know who else is you know who else is great? Our guest. Our guest, their first musical experience was with the bagpipes. And they still made it. Uh, dad's a bagpipe player, Billing's symphony board member. This uh this guest fell asleep a lot to concerts around Montana as a child. Um that bagpipe experience and that uh little uh pipe and drum core made made them want to be a percussionist, so they wanted to be a drummer.
SPEAKER_06And when dad brought home a concert snare instead of a Kevlar marching snare, they said, nope, that's not the right sound for me. So they dumped that and decided to be a trumpet player instead. Um, also a national track. You know who this is? No? Anyway, uh also uh in eighth grade, they uh the athlete amongst us, Phil, watch out, basketball player, also made the national track meet in eighth grade, went out to Pennsylvania for that. And they're actually liked by people, unlike us.
SPEAKER_06They were the student body president in high school, right? So talented, athletic, smart, athletic, popular. Us not so much. Um, this person has a love for music and music education that started with their time in Montana growing up. I attended the Red Lodge Music Festival that Dr. Hopman now works at. They love the mountains hiking, biking, skiing. They uh went off to school and became a member of the Luther Mafia. They went to St. Olive uh for their undergrad and then graduate degrees at the University of Nebraska, Lincoln.
SPEAKER_06Over 25 years of experience. Get this. They've taught choir, they've taught band, they've taught orchestra, they've taught middle school, they've taught high school, they've taught in the collegiate setting all over the country, Florida, Nebraska, Montana, Minnesota. Once they broke their right arm while biking in the mountains the night before classes started so badly that they had to conduct the entire semester left-handed. That's commitment. Oh Phil, you have commitment like that? Would you play children left-handed?
SPEAKER_06No? No. Okay. A passion for developing and empowering leadership in their students, facilitating leadership workshops. How many of you have done a leadership workshop? Guest conductor for all middle schools, high schools, collegiate professional groups, uh, regular presenting at regional and national conferences and both conducting in music ed. College orchestras have performed at regional and national conferences. They've conducted professionally and three continent on three continents, devoted father and husband, author of a book titled Leading as a Conductor.
SPEAKER_06Currently, they are the Symphony Orchestra Director and Assistant Professor of Music at Montana State University, where they lead the orchestra program and teach conducting and music education courses. Please help me welcome Tobin Stewart.
SPEAKER_07Oh, there you go. Okay. Yeah. Welcome. That is awesome. That's great. I don't know. Thank you. No, you're unmuted.
SPEAKER_06Thank you. Glad to be here. Chris, did you have a chance to meet Tobin when we were in uh Montana together?
SPEAKER_07Yeah. I re yeah, absolutely.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_07I mean, he's I know he was because he came up to me and he said, Why is Hobberman still here? And I said, I don't know. We could get rid of him. Yeah, it was a good moment. No, it's good to see you again, sir. Yeah, likewise. Wow, you have better things to do than this. But that's fine. It's great to have you. Glad to be here. It's good. Honored. Okay. Well, check this out. I have questions that I'm ready to ask, but I want to tee this up for Peter. Peter, this is your guest. Let's see what you come out of the gate with. First question. Here we go. This is going to be great.
SPEAKER_07Wait, I'm supposed to ask a question?
SPEAKER_06Yes. You. Okay. Yeah. We want to see what you come up with. Here we go. Um, let's see. Tobin, what should we talk about first? Let's talk about let's talk about the bagpipes.
SPEAKER_02There we go.
SPEAKER_06Um I knew we'd get there. Just take a little while. Uh I I like Tobin do his. Well, I'll give the easy questions to you all. Tobin, um this book, Leading as a Conductor, is one of my favorite books to use. I use it with all my conducting certificate students. Would you tell us a little bit about why you wrote this book and how you got all these. I mean, your resources in here are amazing. So obviously, you've been reading about this a long time, and I'd love to hear more about that passion for yours.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so I've been teaching conducting for a bit, and um as I was getting into it a ways, I realized that in my own experience and as I observed conducting classes, um, there's so much about technique and score study, um, but not much about leadership and realize that that's all of what we do. I mean, we lead people all the time, and yes, we need the skills, we need to be proficient with our gestures and our ears and all that stuff. We need to read a score, but uh you could be phenomenal at both of those things, and if you don't know how to lead a person, you're probably not gonna be successful.
SPEAKER_05And so I decided in my conducting classes that I wanted to start giving some time to leadership, and so we would I have a three-day class, and so we would give a portion of at least one of those classes every week to discussing different tops of of leadership. And so at first I would just pull in a variety of resources and materials um that I had been reading and um from all kind of areas of leadership and just pulling them in and saying, like, how does this connect?
SPEAKER_05And after doing that for a while, I was you know always having to kind of help draw the connections. And so it at one point I was like, you know, I should just start compiling some of these things into one. Um and so that's where it started. And so there were a couple early drafts that were just kind of things for my class only, and then um at one point somebody's like, You should you should write your own book. You're you're on your way, you've started. And so um that's kind of where it went.
SPEAKER_05And basically what it is is I took one word, every chapter is one word of uh a characteristic that I think leaders have. And um then we talk about in the chapter what does that mean for a conductor specifically.
SPEAKER_06So great. I just read the integrity chapter again today for a lesson this week, and um it was really good, Chris.
SPEAKER_07Wow. I'm looking at well one, your website's amazing. People go check out this website. It's clean, it's nice. Oh, you yep, good good design. It'll be in the show notes. It's gonna be in the show notes, along with the praise for leading as a conductor. I mean, the folks that have hopped on this to to say pretty amazing. It is good stuff. So congratulations. That's really awesome. So as you go out and start working with folks, like I see you have uh speaking arrangements and so on.
SPEAKER_07Like, what do you what do you find is one of the main topics that folks want to hear about and learn from you about?
SPEAKER_05Um you know, a lot of times it's just creating a culture. I think that's probably one of the biggest. What what is the culture in the group and how do we kind of foster the culture that they want to have? That's that's a biggie. Um sometimes vision, I think, is often um up there. Like what do people want, you know, and and they tie together. Like I think you've got to have the right vision of what kind of culture you want to make that clear to make it happen. Um but it to me that all starts with all the leaders and not just one at the top, everybody helping craft that culture together.
SPEAKER_04Tolbin, do you feel do you feel like this um passion for working with people in regards to leadership is a result of you uh along the way working with great leaders or poor ones?
SPEAKER_05Totally both. Um I can see definite examples in my past where um when there's a a void of it, um, it drives me nuts. And so um I'm not personally one that uh typically steps into leadership roles. I wouldn't say that's my personality. I'm not I'm not just that you know dominant leader or that charismatic leader. Uh, but I've often been thrown into leadership roles, or when I'm uncomfortable enough and frustrated at the lack of leadership, then I'll step up because I want I want it to be different.
SPEAKER_05Um so I would say, but I've also had some phenomenal leaders, so I say it definitely comes from both sides.
SPEAKER_04You know, do you feel when you've been thrust Well, I'll I'll I'll shut up with this question. But those times where you were thrust into that role unexpectedly, have those ended up being rewarding experiences over time or also dependent?
SPEAKER_05Um I think very dependent. If uh it definitely is taxing and just time and energy and thought. And so sometimes, you know, that's can be very draining um at certain points, but it's also I think more rewarding when you see the fruits of positive and and leadership that's moving in a positive direction. There's there's definitely benefit from that.
SPEAKER_07Aaron Powell Tobin, what do you think is most under un uh misunderstood about leadership? That it is um a title.
SPEAKER_05Um and it's to me it's not a title at all. It's uh it's a role, um, and it's a servant role, um, which I think especially immature leaders and especially a lot of young folks, they think of leadership as I've I've gotten this position and this title, and now I have authority, um, instead of realizing that no, that the best leaders are actually servants and they're serving the people they're leading. And when you're a leader, you all of a sudden have to step up and do a whole lot more work, and um and it's a lot of hard work and a lot of at times grunt work and servant work, and um so it's not about just I earn this title.
SPEAKER_07That's yeah, uh that's awesome. So how do you balance having a clear vision versus being adaptable? Like there's a friction point in there. Like what how do you navigate that?
SPEAKER_05That's a uh that's a great question. Um I think you gotta have a you gotta listen a lot and listen to those around you. Um because if it's if it's only you that's trying to cast that one vision um but it doesn't fit the whole group, then it's it's not gonna work if you just try to ramrod it through. And the more you can listen to to specific needs of your specific group that you're leading in front of you, um and then being willing to accept the changes that they present that might be slightly different than your own vision.
SPEAKER_05Um go ahead.
SPEAKER_04Oh, that's all right. That's okay. Peter can shut up. I don't mind cutting him off, but I certainly don't want to cut you off.
SPEAKER_06Uh like so I just usually they usually they I must have a delay. There's something going. Usually they don't speak for a long time, so this is exciting. I can't even get in, so keep going, keep going.
SPEAKER_05Well, like, you know, I might have had a an incredible experience in one setting and want to take that to a different different location, but you can't necessarily replicate the same thing in a different place because it's different people, different environment. And so I think that's a great place where you've got to take the good things that you can, but also be adaptable to what is this current situation and how am I going to make it work here? Sure. I like that. I like that.
SPEAKER_07Go ahead.
SPEAKER_04I mean, Chris Chris and I um both know that um one of the chapters of your notebook is all is dedicated to basically the flaws in the Hoberman leadership style. So I was wondering if, you know, as a result of this chapter, maybe you can share some with the commuter about, you know, things that Peter is working on improving and uh maybe, you know, some of the apparently he's had some success. I'm not sure what it is, but uh I guess it's it's out you know on uh on social media somewhere. Luck of the dice. Just rolling the dice. He roll them enough times.
SPEAKER_05Maybe as he needs to talk less and and use his hands more, and that's why the miming uh semester.
SPEAKER_07Oh yeah. That's good.
SPEAKER_04See, he's on to this. Yeah. What please talk about? Talk more about the miming. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_06I'll let Peter take that. Uh okay. Okay, so I want to ask a question, right? Uh I met Hoban through Music Ed and Montana and Orchestra and his reputation and all that. And then I found out you've done choir, band, and orchestra. How did that happen? Because you know, my students, they don't, or people are like, oh no, I just want to do I'm just a band director. Like, how how did you find did you want to do that?
SPEAKER_05It's a great question. So I went to St. Olaf primarily with instrumental um experience. I, you know, maybe sang in you know some little choirs as a kid, but did not sing, you know, in middle school or high school in choir at all. Um I had piano experience, trumpet experience, so I went to St. Olaf thinking I'm gonna be a band director. Uh, but then you can't go to St. Olaf and and not listen to choirs and be like, that's incredible. So I did join a choir um part of my time there, and I also thought, well, I I should I should work on this.
SPEAKER_05Um at St. Olive, you're either instrumental or vocal when you get your certificate, but I tried to do both, didn't quite finish them both, but I did a bunch of the choral conducting and you know, tried to get as many choir classes as I could um before I finished. And then it was quite interesting. I I still thought I was gonna be a band director leaving, but um I taught in the ninth semester, so I taught in the fall and then was done and figured I'm just gonna stut or or be a substitute in the spring until jobs open up for the fall.
SPEAKER_05But um I'd moved to Omaha at the time. Um Where my soon-to-be wife was already teaching. And so I just threw out my application everywhere in the Omaha metro area. And uh I was actually home at Christmas break and got um a phone call from OPS, Omaha Public Schools, saying, We've got we want to interview you. We have a couple positions we're interested in. And the first one was a band position, so I was like, great. Uh, but it was clear they wanted a marching band person. And at the time, I I didn't know I have a clue about marching band.
SPEAKER_05Um, and so I went through that interview and they said, Yeah, you're you're not the guy, but um, we like you, so will you come back tomorrow and interview for the choir job? And I was like, sure. Um, so I showed up. And um, and the the position I walked into, the teacher um walked out of class in the middle of the day in like December 12th or something and said, I quit, I'm done, I've I've had it. And so that's what I, you know, that's why there was an opening at this point. And so I'm I'm home in Billings on Christmas break, uh, got hired and had, I don't know, a week and a half or something to move and figure out how to jump in to be a choir director.
SPEAKER_05So my first job was a full-time choir position. Um his four by four, strict four by four block, which has its own challenges, and it was there were some victories and some great things about it, and also some real struggles. Um and then my second job, I moved actually to the district where my wife was, so I got to do choir and band. Um, my third job had an orchestra, and so I moved into that world and just really started to love the strings and the string repertoire, and so eventually I moved fully that direction.
SPEAKER_05But I I actually loved my choir time and for for several years thought maybe that's what I'll do. Um loved conducting the choirs and working with them. So I'm so thankful that I had had experience in in all three areas.
SPEAKER_06Okay, uh, I'll go on. So tell me what uh a lot of young teachers go out and they don't feel prepared for certain parts of the job, the general music part of the job, or they've only worked with high school and now they also do middle school. What's the common thread through all of that? And if you could um give any suggestions to young teachers that are maybe out of their what they would consider their wheelhouse, how can they get through that or uh encourage them to take a position with Oak Group?
SPEAKER_05Um be just a sponge to learn everything you possibly can. Uh, find the people that are going to be your resources to help you. I was so thankful in that first job, and thankfully the Omaha Public Schools um provided for me uh a mentor, and it was a choir director that had been retired for a couple of years, but she came back, and so I think maybe once a week she came in and worked with me, and I just soaked up everything I could uh and learned everything, and I just I went to people to ask about repertoire suggestions, and I I was just asking every question I could.
SPEAKER_05Um and the same thing was true when I finally got to do orchestra, and I was thrilled and excited about it, but again, I'm a trumpet player, and I'm primarily working, you know, in the school I was in was just a string orchestra. We didn't really have full orchestra at the time, and so I had to learn a ton about strings, and so I found every string person I could and asked every question I could, and I found a friend that was my go-to for literature, um, and just like okay, what do I what do I program for this group and what do I do with this group?
SPEAKER_05And how do I teach this concept? And um I started uh in grad school, I took viola lessons intentionally to start learning a little bit more of the string world, and so I think just you know learning everything you possibly can and being willing to say, I I don't know what I'm doing. Will you come in and help me uh with what I'm doing? And the other thing that I think was probably my favorite, um, I would invite in some guests, like a string quartet, um, and have them play, but also like clinic my ensemble.
SPEAKER_05And that's great for the students, but I was taking the most notes in the back, and then the next day I was a better teacher because I was like, well, how did how did they do that when they worked with my group and when they clinicked, and then I would steal that and go use it.
SPEAKER_07See, I think the brilliance in that is that you had the courage to ask those questions and reach out. What I worry about now is with Chat GPT and all this stuff, you know, like people just will go online or watch a YouTube video, and again, it's a resource. It doesn't mean it's it's necessarily bad, but I think it is different than asking for help personally. What can you say about that specifically? Why is that still a really important strategy?
SPEAKER_05I mean, first of all, I just think human connection is way better um at any level than just interacting with, you know, the internet. Um and it's it's more lasting too to have some of those. And it also is more um, it's more accurate. It's a funny side story. There have been times when I've tried to use AI for things, um, and it's completely wrong. And I'm like, uh, you don't have it right. But um sometimes if people don't realize that, they're gonna get wrong information. So, you know, a real person is gonna be better suited to say, okay, this is my situation, here's my struggle, here's what I'm not figuring out, and they can really then tailor their information a little better to what what you're actually talking about.
SPEAKER_05I love it.
SPEAKER_06Uh one other quick question about your background. I know your dad was a bagpiper, you said, which is cool. Um, I bet that was loud. Uh, did he practice in the garage or in your room? And then also, um, who were some other early influences musically for you that inspired you to take your path, either to St. Olaf or just to choose to be a music teacher?
SPEAKER_05Uh I think the biggest, um, because my dad was president of the community concert in in our in Billings uh for a number of years, and so they would bring in often like smaller chambered things. And so I had the experience of hearing the Canadian brass, the Empire Brass, the Dallas Brass, um, as a kid. And um I you know that those were the things that just made made me get excited. Um, no offense against some of the other instruments. I think each person, there's pun intended here, there's certain instruments that resonate with them more than other instruments.
SPEAKER_05And so me having the chance to hear, you know, some of those quality brass quintets as a little kid, I was just like, that's what I want to do. Um I actually wanted to play the trombone, but my older brother brother played the trombone and he said no, you have to pick a different instrument. So good choices. Good choices. If I could, yeah. If I could do it again, I'd be a horn player instead. But I I wasn't that smart when I first picked the instrument in fifth grade. That's all right.
SPEAKER_07I guess so Peter's glossed over a great so on your I muted him. Um on the you have this blog that uh I've been reading a little bit while Peter's been talking, and you're talking about this person named Pete who came to work with your choir. And at first I was worried because I thought it was Peter, but then I realized that you know this had a lot of positive influence in you. Uh what are some of those takeaways?
SPEAKER_07You know, like from that specific, it looks like you said here, oh, that Pete came leadership and worked uh with your choir that morning. So what are the big takeaways that you had from that exchange?
SPEAKER_05So, first of all, I should I should call out um if anybody knows, it's John Peterson, um, choir director of Nebraska, um, and he went by Pete for short. Um but he um it was it was super eye-opening for me. So at this point, I'm the assistant choir director, assistant band director at a high school in Nebraska. And uh he'd come in to work with our groups that day, and um there was just a major difference. I mean, I'd gotten up and conducted a piece, you know, warmed them up a little bit and conducted the choir through a piece and did my thing.
SPEAKER_05And then he walks in and just in moments has got them like in the palm of his hand. Um, like they're focused, they're there, they're they're like everything. And he's shaping them, he's fixing things, he's adjusting things, and um, they're inspired. And I, and it was just for me, I I sat there and was like, what what is it different about him that's got my students sounding so much better than what I've been doing for three or four weeks. Uh, and so that was really a huge moment for me just to be like, I gotta figure this out.
SPEAKER_05I I gotta figure out what is it that he's got that I don't seem to have yet. That's really great story. It began this journey of like, I gotta figure out some of the intangibles of this whole conducting thing.
SPEAKER_06And now a message from our sponsors.
SPEAKER_07Grand Tours Incorporated is a trusted leader in designing custom international group concert tours for student and adult music ensembles, setting the standard for traveling with purpose.
SPEAKER_06I know because we use them at Concordia all the time, and when I was a high school teacher as well, because they provide authentic music performance opportunities at distinctive venues, and they engage local musicians, conductors, and composers.
SPEAKER_04Grand Tours! They aim to inspire artistic growth and enable transformative cultural connections through music while creating a sense of family throughout the journey.
SPEAKER_06Visit Grand Tours Online at Grandtours Inc.com. That's Grand ToursInc.com. To learn more of other services and request an international tour design specifically for your ensemble.
SPEAKER_07Anyone can sell you an instrument. A true music partner helps you build something bigger. At Hyde Music, they support the educators, families, performers, and advocates who keep music thriving. For nearly 80 years, their family-owned, musician-operated team has provided instruments, rentals, repairs, educational resources, and creative solutions with personal service every step of the way. Expect more than a transaction.
SPEAKER_07Expect a partner. Learn more at hidemusic.com or visit Hide Music in Appleton, Green Bay, Madison, Oshkosh, and Stevens Point.
SPEAKER_06Can't get enough of me? Not sick of me yet? Come get your master's degree in music education with me at Concordia College in Moorhead, Minnesota. We offer a hybrid degree plan so you can keep teaching and getting paid and still have an in-person cohort in the summers to enrich your experience and learn a lot from others as well. Already have your masters? Prank your less educated colleagues by sending them my way. You got students? Ship those beautiful children off to Moorhead. We want your music majors, your non-majors, good kids, bad kids, smart kids, and everything in between. Music scholarships here are available for all students with an annual deadline of February 1st.
SPEAKER_06Info about all these options and more can be found at Concordiacollege.edu slash music. That's Concordiacollege.edu slash music. Or just contact me and I'll take care of it.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_06Did you mute Phil or did Phil mute himself and not notice that he mailed the government? No, I did.
SPEAKER_04But uh is it my turn? Do I get to talk?
SPEAKER_02Oh my god.
SPEAKER_06It's like we're at the bar. This is hilarious. You two cannot stop being low brass players for one minute.
SPEAKER_04Uh so you're you're a lot of your uh learning style, I think, has developed from uh being fearless about asking questions. And I'm wondering how have you found have you found a way or are you finding a way to get your students to learn the same way? Or can you inspire them or to do that do to to learn in that way?
SPEAKER_05That's uh I should think about that more actually. I asked I asked them a lot of questions. Um and I guess I hope from that that they might learn to be good good folks to ask questions. But I I think I should probably push them to to to be better at this. Um I find more and more that some we have to sometimes push them to do these things. They're not just gonna intuitively pick them up.
SPEAKER_04Um I've noticed that in in my classes that it's oh, I'm here now, I'm gonna sponge up all the information from you, and then class is over. Right. But that leaves you empty and it doesn't really refill anything.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So I I think I'm gonna think about that a little bit more and how I can uh incorporate that.
SPEAKER_04No, but it's something you figured out at a really early age that this is the key if you want to make the fastest progress um is figuring out the right question to ask when and and ask a lot of them if you've got a well to plumb.
SPEAKER_06Do you think you can teach that, or is that just something is that like a personality trait of yours, or do you think that was just out of like sheer panic of taking a quiet job and not knowing what to do?
SPEAKER_05Or or I think I do think there's a lot about just kind of who I am. I mean, I notice in my own students there there are some that are just apt to like figure stuff out and and and just be curious, and there are others that are okay to just be like, I'm good until I'm pushed. Uh so I do think it has a lot to do with just kind of your personality and your inner drive.
SPEAKER_06Uh you you teach a lot of future teachers. Okay, so I I just want to um I just need to uh talk about Tobin. So I've met him a couple times in Montana, but um every time I meet him, I learned more information. There'll be a question coming. Hold on. You guys gotta know more about Tobin, why I chose him for this. Um he's amazing, and everything he touches turns to gold, right? So he just picks up a choir and does the thing, and everybody who's met him or knows him um speaks so highly of him.
SPEAKER_06I keep and you keep you just keep track. Yeah, that's right. Um so last year when we were on tour, I love to do some professional development things, and um I just I called him and I said, I want you to work with the band for a couple hours on tour. And he came to the concert the night before, he came to a dress rehearsal, he got to meet the students because he doesn't just show up, and then he worked with us, and the students could not stop talking about our two hours together, and his patience, which is something I don't have, and how he drew them into the experience, asked questions, let them grow.
SPEAKER_06It was amazing. It was an amazing tutorial on how to be a teacher and a conductor and to listen and build relationships and be a leader. So here's the question he does this every week, he's almost done, he gets tired eventually. Okay. So here's here's my question, Tovin. Um, those are all learned skills in your 25 years of teaching, of course. But um the worst. If you could if you could get to yourself earlier to guide yourself to where you're at now with the pet rock, what what would you tell yourself earlier so that 25 years ago you could have done more of what you did with my group last year?
SPEAKER_05I would say probably first of all, loosen up. Um relax. It doesn't have to be perfect. Uh, in meaning like your your rehearsal plan doesn't have to be perfect. Uh be willing to to deviate more, be a little bit more curious to take tangents. Um and I think also the biggest lesson I've really had to learn is stop trying to be somebody else and figure out who you are and how to do who you are the best you can.
SPEAKER_05Uh, because I think early on, uh too often I was trying to be somebody else. And there's there's a difference, you know, I've had to learn there's a difference between seeing somebody else that's really good at what they do and being inspired to grow in certain skills. Because we all have skills that need to get better. Like my ears can always get better, I can always improve in certain things. But there's a difference between being inspired to get better and like me wanting to be that person. Um, for example, I'm I'm not I'm a pretty serious person and I'm not like super charismatic, I'm not super humorous or funny.
SPEAKER_05Uh, and so if I tried to be that on the podium, it's gonna flop. And and my students are gonna see right through it that that's not who I am and how I do it. And so I've had to figure out um how to be the best version of me instead of trying to be somebody else. And that's taking a lot of time. Wonderful. It totally stuck there.
SPEAKER_04Wonderful answer to a question that took only 20 minutes to ask. Um, Tobin, can you talk a little bit about reflection?
SPEAKER_05I am a huge fan of reflection. Um and I think it's it's um what we need to put a lot of things into place. So one of the reasons I I try to ask a lot of questions is because I want people to, in their own time of reflection, come up with their own answers. Um especially even when I like a lot of times when I do presentations, I try to ask more questions than I even give answers so that they can walk away and hopefully then in their reflection just spend time wrestling with things because I think that's when we when we come to answers is when we have to really wrestle through and and figure out how am I gonna take this and and apply this?
SPEAKER_05Uh I can't just you know quickly do things. It's not gonna work out that way unless I've reflected on how to best do that.
SPEAKER_06Okay, I have a funny question. A serious question. Nope. Funny question first. When you had to conduct left-handed for an entire semester, did that make you a better, like independent conductor later, or did you just like start mirroring all the time once you could use both arms? I think he broke his arm doing the bagpiping. I'm almost positive.
SPEAKER_04I agree.
SPEAKER_05I think that's probably true. While biking. It made me a better conductor actually because it made me do less. And I find that when I do less, I'm actually better. And and yet I still haven't fully learned that lesson because even now that I have both arms again, I often try to do way too much. And so it's better. I should I should probably put my arm in a sling again.
SPEAKER_06God, I like that. Uh okay, now here's a serious question. Um we're kind of have a little advocacy advocacy bent this year, and um you've done a lot, you've taught in a lot of places, Nebraska, Montana, all the Florida, all this stuff. Um when it comes to advocacy, and let me actually switch us from the sports world. You spend a lot of time as a younger uh man in athletic events and team sports. How can we advocate with people that don't know music but have been on the athletic side of the teamwork concept about the importance of music and like connections or how it's different so that they can understand?
SPEAKER_06Like, what's a way we could go outside of our comfort zone to people that don't know about music and advocacy?
SPEAKER_05I don't know if I can answer the question about the sports, how do we how do we draw the sports piece in very well? Partially because I see right now that that's a a major competitor and major struggle. Um, and especially in the specialization of everything right now, um, and especially in sports that's super specialized, super intense, a lot of time. Um and it's really too bad because you know, when I was growing up, you could do a bunch of different sports and you could be on the student council and you could be in the band, and you could be in, you know, you could do all this stuff and and it it was possible.
SPEAKER_05And I was even in a really big school, so it wasn't like I was in, you know, small rural school where you have to do it all. Um, but now it's like if you if you want to play on the varsity team, then you you better commit, you know, everything you've got to that. And and so it's forcing kids, I think, into one area. And so the the struggle is like how how do we make this um you know something where they can they don't have to give their whole life to just band or their whole life to just basketball or the whole life to just whatever the the the activity is and and get back to can we create some balance?
SPEAKER_05So, you know, in in one sense, I think part of it is I remember, you know, as a high school teacher having this having students that did both, and sometimes, you know, I could as a teacher or the coach could just force like, nope, you're either in my thing or you're not. Or like um, there's a s a book, a story in the book I shared. I at one point I was up against this. I was um able to go to state basketball, or I was able to go to All Northwest uh honor band.
SPEAKER_05And I was told by the coach that if you choose the honor band, then you're gonna be benched for state and you're not gonna play. Um that doesn't make it work for students, and so I think that the more we can say, no, we're gonna figure out how to let you do both, um, and can we work with the other coaches and the other activity leaders to say, let's let's work this out together instead of fight for them for the whole time? Can we let the student be more well-rounded and do all of it? Um and and and I don't want to just pick on the sports because you know there are some music programs that demand just as much or more time, you know, in the music world, and like, well, if you can't commit to this, then you're not in the top group.
SPEAKER_05And you know, so um is our goal to have the the best top performance we can, or is our goal to have well rounded? Educated individuals that can do a variety of activities. Um but it's a struggle because in the other pieces uh for so many students, the the trophies and the winning and the that side of sports is it draws them a lot. So it's appealing.
SPEAKER_07Here, here. Yep. That's great answers. So speaking of sports, we started tonight with uh Dr. Jesse McGuire, who was playing trumpet for a Major League Baseball game and his trumpet stopped working, so he just started singing, right? And I believe that all great musicians sing, like we have to find the inner voice. The instrument is just trying to replicate that which is perfect. So, how has teaching and training vocalists and so on informed your conducting and teaching wind band?
SPEAKER_05So, first of all, I became a huge believer in Soulfeg when I started teaching choir for a variety of reasons. And I can't even explain why, but um I can say in my undergrad, we always sang on numbers in my oral skills. Um and, you know, I wasn't the strongest when I went to oral skills, albeit, you know, it was a struggle for me. I'd taken a bunch of piano lessons and theory came really easy, but then all of a sudden I had to site sing and I was like, I I don't I don't know how to use this instrument. Um and so then when I first started teaching, I was under a phenomenal teacher and she did everything in Soulfeg.
SPEAKER_05And those students, and and as I started learning Soulfeg with them as a teacher, I just realized like, wow, my ears are getting better, and wow, the sight singing is getting easier. And it was phenomenal. And so um I make my group sing on Soulfeg. And there's a learning curve for a lot of the instrumentalists early on to figure out that, uh, because they've not been haven't haven't necessarily grown up with that. Uh, but it it's it reaps huge benefits um to stop and you know, like we have a chord out of tune, and if we stop and be like everybody sing the root, and we sing it on doe and we add soul and we add me, and um it it helps.
SPEAKER_05And so I think just getting your groups to sing in any way you can is huge.
SPEAKER_06And then again, I'm a huge believer in soulfegge, so you even have a sight singing book out, isn't that correct? I did uh teacher.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I taught uh oral skills for a number of years, and I I really loved that part of my job, partially because I was like I said, I wasn't great at it in undergrad, and I had to struggle my way through it, and so I think that's why I love to teach it because I could relate to most people that struggled through it. Um I I think that some of the teachers that are you know have amazing ears and really good oral skills are not always the best oral skills teachers. Um, and so I loved teaching that class, even though most students hated it.
SPEAKER_05Um and I got that book because it I was just, you know, for where we were at and the students we were with, I I just wanted something that was moving at the right pace. And so I just wrote all my kind of drills that fit our needs at the time. So I wrote a lot of very simple melodies that were just all stepwise and then jumps of a third and then jumps in the triad, and kind of the way I wanted it to work.
SPEAKER_07Um see hop on his website. It's a great website. And then let's say you're teaching a middle school band and you're you're a little insecure yourself about teaching vocal techniques because you're like probably saying sixth graders can't sing, they just and they shouldn't sing, you know. What would you say to help maybe give one or two strategies to get that process going?
SPEAKER_05First of all, um I'm not comfortable, I'm not super comfortable with my own voice. And that was one of the reasons that made me least comfortable as a choir director, is I just didn't feel like I was super strong myself, never being, you know, having a lot of training or experience in that area. Um so some of it is just being willing to get out there and and not be perfect and not sound wonderful. And um, I think it's also a great place for students to say, look, you don't have to be amazing. I don't feel like I'm amazing at this either, but we we all have a voice and we can all use it and we can all sing, whether you think it's beautiful or not, whether you're super comfortable with it or not.
SPEAKER_05Um and then I I would say just doing a lot of vocalizing, vocalese exercises where you're doing sirens and things where everybody gets to be goofy and you're being goofy with them, um, and you're all just using your voice can break that ice. And especially with middle schoolers, a lot of them might be tentative to sing early on and and their voices are changing and all that. So just getting them using it a lot and doing a whole lot of different things that they're not feeling um exposed, they're not feeling out there as a soloist, they're all doing the weird sounds together.
SPEAKER_05Um, and I've found they're often really shy, but as soon as you get them actually doing it, pretty soon they're like, this is pretty cool. Um and it's amazing how often they can sound really good.
SPEAKER_06Is that why you chose to work with the vocal piece with my group last year?
SPEAKER_05It probably was. I don't remember for sure, but it could have been. I love it.
SPEAKER_06I've got them singing in this year already. I took the La Bar Grace Before Sleep, and I'm combining the two pieces into a vocal instrumental combo thing. So nice. I'll make them listen to this.
SPEAKER_04Tobin, I wanted to go back to um what you led off with, which was about um the servant aspect of leadership. And um certainly hard work is embedded in that as you described. And I'm wondering if um you can talk a little bit about delegation as it relates to that.
SPEAKER_05How to delegate work. Yeah, I'm not great at this. So um yeah, I need to learn. Me either.
SPEAKER_06That's why I'm asking you. He's a trombone player. He's trying to learn how to delegate so he doesn't have to go into work on Wednesdays. That's what he's really trying to do. Well, yes.
SPEAKER_05Well, and the the the trouble, part of why I'm not great at this, is because I'm also a perfectionist. And so um, you know, sometimes when it's delegated and not done like I want to do it, then I feel like I have to redo it. But uh at the same time, I think where we need to grow in this is to realize that um students are gonna have that opportunity to step up and lead in certain ways if we don't give them an opportunity to do that. And so if we can delegate some things, even if it's not gonna be done as well, um it gives them a chance to try it and to learn.
SPEAKER_05And um and so we've got to give them opportunity. One of my pet peeves that I often share, you know, with uh band directors and clinics and things is if if there's nothing for them to do, then don't give them a title. For example, I find so often there are band programs that will have a band president and a band vice president and a band secretary and a band treasurer. And it's like, if they don't have a role, like some of these people don't even have money to deal with. So what does a treasurer do it?
SPEAKER_05Like, why are you giving them a title if they're not doing anything? Um, and if does the band president do anything or is it just a popularity vote? And if that's what it is, then don't even do it. But I believe strongly in student leadership. And so give them a role where they can actually lead. And then are you letting them lead? So if you name a section leader, do you give them an opportunity to lead in some capacity? Are they doing something, you know, on the marching field, or are they leading a musical sectional in some way, or like are they doing something?
SPEAKER_05Because if not, you're you're just perpetuating that idea that leadership is just a title instead of something that you do. Excellent.
SPEAKER_04I really like that answer. All of your answers have been great, but I really like that one.
SPEAKER_06The problem is Tobin's better than us at all the things that we do. I know. He's not great for anything, but just really resonated with me. We could have him back as a second guest. You could have him as a surprise guest. We wouldn't know who's coming because he's got all the skills. But we're gonna end tonight with speed round. It's fine with me. About I just gotta give me up on the mine. You just relax so much about it. Let's we're gonna see how well he does on this mine.
SPEAKER_02It's better.
SPEAKER_06All right, here we go. It's a speed round. These are all questions about Montana, um, hiking or skiing, or other things I knew nothing about until I uh asked AI a bunch of questions. So here we go. Are you ready, Tobin?
SPEAKER_05Accurate.
SPEAKER_06Yep. If you go mountain biking in western Montana, what non-human right-of-way hazard are you most likely to wait on a trail crossing for? A horse. I'll take it. Horse, elk, or stubborn moose. But don't want to get too close to any of that. True.
SPEAKER_05I did almost uh run into a small bear at one time. Did you? I left that one off. Tell me about that. Grizzly or black bear? Yeah, it's it was a black bear, thankfully. And uh I was biking by myself, and uh this is near Butte. I was between my daughter's softball game, so I took my bike and I went went up and went biking and uh didn't have my bear spray, which is a mistake that day. But I was biking along and I saw something ahead dart real fast, and I thought it was somebody's dog. Uh, and then I looked a little closer and it was a bear cub.
SPEAKER_05And so at that point I ended my ride and turned around and headed back.
SPEAKER_06Smart man. Smart man. So even biking, you carry bear spray, not just hiking. You even biking, you carry a bear spray. Sometimes I do, yeah. Yeah, good, smart. Okay, here we go. Skiing. What ultra-light, feathery, soft snow condition in Bozeman's Bridger Bowl ski area, what is the what is it famous for? What's that snow called? Cold smoke. It is ding cold smoke. Nice work. Nice work. Okay. This one I had no idea about, so if I get it wrong, it's AI's fault.
SPEAKER_06What winter activity in Montana involves being towed on skis behind a horse at high speeds over jumps? Ski jorring. That is totally true. Have you done this? No. Have you seen people do this? I should have looked it up.
SPEAKER_05Nope. No, but as a kid, we had a uh a sled dog um when I was growing up, and I really tried to get him to pull me on skis, but he was smart enough that whenever I'd put the harness on, he'd just lay down.
SPEAKER_07I love it. I love it. That's good. That's great.
SPEAKER_06Okay, I think uh this one goes well. Just two left. Um first one's kind of funny. The second one is not funny at all. Uh Big Sky Resort boasts over 5,800 acres of skiable terrain. What is the most common phrase heard at the bottom of its famous Lone Peak Tram? Or your answer to the question, Are you glad you've been on this podcast? I have no idea the answer to the what's at the bottom of the tram. Uh uh the answer they say is, I think I made a terrible mistake.
SPEAKER_06All right. Which is also what our guests say. Okay. And if you fall off your mountain bike and end up with a spiral fracture in your upper arm, why is it medically impossible to find the situation funny? Because you broke your humerus. Yes. Yes. Huh? Oh. Just had to get it. Wow.
SPEAKER_04What a ending the speed round with a resounding thump. Yes.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, that's a that's gonna need a lot of sound effects to save that.
SPEAKER_06Maybe even an ed edit out. You you could be you could edit that one out. You could maybe the the scheduring is pretty cool, though. I had no idea.
SPEAKER_07I think I will. I think that's a good one.
SPEAKER_06Scojuring is pretty cool. I I'll I'll go with that. All right. Well, Tobin, thanks for coming on. I uh love how much you're a lifelong learner. Every time I've been in Montana doing anything, I see you there with all of the teachers learning, growing, asking questions. Uh love your musicianship and leadership in the state and uh honored to sh help share your story and the greatness that you provide our profession. And uh don't stop. Keep going. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Tobin, thanks for for coming on coming on this and and uh just uh talking about really important things for the three or four people that uh are commuting while listening to this. Uh very, very important information. Thank you.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, we're actually down to two in a bear, and that's about all we got left. Uh Tobin, great to see you again. Yeah, you're awesome. You're amazing. People go check out his website, get his book, and read that book because uh this guy's smart.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, thank you much. Pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_04Nice job, Peter. That is a very thoughtful person. I didn't compliment him enough when we were done, but he takes a minute. That that split second that he takes to answer whatever the question it is, there are so many synapses and like firing going on.
SPEAKER_06There's like literally the first time I met him, Chris and I were doing our sessions in Montana, and there's this guy sitting there, and I'm like, that's not a normal teacher. And it wasn't like he was looking at us like he was judging, he was just fully invested in what we were saying and talking about. And then he came up afterwards and introduced himself and started asking more questions. And I'm like, dude, I know who you are. And like the last thing you need to do is be asking me questions. Uh, and then the next year, when I went back with Dr.
SPEAKER_06Hawkinson, um, he gave me his book and we started catching up, and I'm just like, this guy's got a lot to give the world, and I'm just late to the game. And plus, he's a good Luther Mafia, you know, brother, so we gotta invest in that. So anyway, I just really love what he's doing.
SPEAKER_07Yep. Brilliant, brilliant. Uh speaking of brilliant, you know what time it is? We have a band bustler. Here we go. The first edition from Paul Kyle is inside. Exciting.
SPEAKER_04This is I just saw Payle yesterday and the day before, and the day before, and it was great to see him. He's wonderful. Band Bustler.
SPEAKER_01Hello, Erudite listeners. Despite the urgings of many of you, I'm back. And like an ankle weight on the leg of a swimmer in last place, I'm not sure if I'm much help, but I'm happy to be along for the ride. To kick off season five of the Band Buzzler, let's start with a semi-quicentennial celebration of our good old United States while also honoring the heritage of bands. That's right, folks, it's a march.
SPEAKER_01This toe tapper is great for teaching cut time, octave lipslers and single-tonguing in the brass, scalar runs in the woodwinds, and historical tunes like America's unofficial national anthem. Enjoy this season five opener.
SPEAKER_07There you go.
SPEAKER_06We've never played that piece before.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, that's nice. It's nice. I think Ives wrote that, didn't he?
SPEAKER_06No, not unless he wrote in three keys at the same time.
SPEAKER_07There we go. First Bam Buzzler in. This is exciting. A whole other season. I don't know if Paul was excited when I asked him. I think he was. Either way.
SPEAKER_04I it was it was it was a it was an excitement that seemed guarded to me. Yes, guarded. I'd be guarded in a C2, also.
SPEAKER_07Okay, that's it. Any guesses? You want to go on the limb here? Come on. Take gotta take a stab. It's a march.
SPEAKER_06Okay, good. Military march. Yep. Incorporating uh folk tune from the United States. Okay, Phil. I heard snare drum and bass drum and cymbals. I heard a lot of trombone. There's maybe too much trombone for me.
SPEAKER_07Uh okay. That's uh that's really good. Um hey, let's bring in the coach.
SPEAKER_06Coach. There's got a hat. He's got a hat. It says Beyond Artless Coach. It's a nice gift. Did you have to pay the uh shipping need when that arrived? I had to pay for the hat.
SPEAKER_03I love it. I actually paid for that hat. Well, maybe I didn't. I don't know. I have to pay to wear the hat, actually. He makes me send him$5 on Venmo every time I wear the hat.
SPEAKER_04You've been paying for many years. That's good. Before you even knew it. That hat is a surefire method to avoid dating in general.
unknownThat's good.
SPEAKER_06Well, just I don't have a brother. And because of this podcast, I realize I'm probably in a good place about that. Like I've always thought maybe I needed a brother, but now with you three on the screen, I feel like I'm okay. Coach, what'd you think tonight?
SPEAKER_04Paul Kyle's got a vocabulary that is endless. Yes. Yeah, Ariodite and semi-sesquentennial. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Wow. And then his analogies. The uh swimmer with the cement. Yeah, well. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Ankle weights and coming in last place.
SPEAKER_03It's just it's worth the intro. Just listening to that intro. You know, it's worth it. Great guest. Another another wonderful person, very intelligent. I again, I wish there was a website where we could collect all of these wonderful books and places. You're on the website. Can we have a dedicated? You know you're on the website now. Can can we talk about any can we talk about it? How many times have you been to the show notes of any podcast that you've listened to?
SPEAKER_03That's uh you know.
SPEAKER_04A couple times. Um I have Coach has been taking handwritten notes from uh each of our episodes over the last four years. We're gonna um I would send those out to everybody, full photocopy.
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
SPEAKER_06I'd be happy to upload those too. I will I will tell you, I have gone to the show notes a couple times. Look at this. Um I also listen to like thousands of podcasts in my life, so it's like less than 0.2% of podcasts that I've listened to if I gotten to the show notes.
SPEAKER_03Hey, in in kind of in the spirit of tonight's guest, I have an idea for you. Two ideas, actually. Ready? That's way above my like I'm only I'm only paid for the first idea. So the second idea you're getting for free tonight.
SPEAKER_04So I I think we're paying for all of them.
SPEAKER_03Here's the here's the first idea. David Epstein. Do you know the name? No, so David Epstein, I believe, was a writer for Sports Illustrated. And for those young listeners, Sports Illustrated used to be a magazine. Um I think I think it's turned into now more of a a website and a place where people um visit online. I'm not sure they sell many copies of their actual magazine anymore. Uh Epstein wrote a book about the generalist.
SPEAKER_03So it was about the power of the generalist. I have heard about him on a podcast. Taking over or or being so important in a now more than ever specialized world. And I think back, I hearken back to last year when one of your better episodes was from an author. Yeah, and I thought I'm thinking two of you have, you know, jobs that require much of your life, there's one of you that I think would have the ability to um getting a hold of Mr.
SPEAKER_03Epstein to uh to join you on a podcast that I think would be wonderful. So Christopher, I know I was a little harsh the last time I was on. What? But if there's if there's a person on this screen right now that has the power to cold call David Epstein and get him to come to you to this show, it's you.
SPEAKER_04I see the coach seems to be quite adept at offering homework assignments to Chris. I think that's I really like the way this has gone. Yeah, it's uh that's you got a homework assignment for Peter?
SPEAKER_07Yeah, give him one. That's good. I'll work on that. Coach. Peter.
SPEAKER_06I like the coach. Before he gives me an assignment, I just gotta say, he has said some of the best things on our podcast to make it better. And he is almost never wrong. So what were you gonna say? Oh wow.
SPEAKER_03That's the nicest things anybody's ever said about me.
SPEAKER_07Almost never.
SPEAKER_03Uh almost never. Peter basically. The last uh the portion of this podcast that I've listened to, I think you'll need to continue to work on your mental toughness because the other two individuals on this podcast are unrelenting on their critiques of you.
SPEAKER_06Well, first of all, they did I deserved it at the end. My speed run was trying to get some dad humor in there, and I'm not good at that. And I also, yeah, I kind of deserved it tonight. I was not on my A, I was on my A game, but I was trying to get too you know, when you're trying to get too much in?
SPEAKER_04You got set back on your heels immediately when Chris and I wouldn't ask a single question. I would just sit there watching you flounder. Oh God, it's beautiful.
SPEAKER_03Just beautiful, just exploded into nothing. Stay tough, Peter. Stay tough.
SPEAKER_06It is fine. If I come out and ask questions right away, they always interrupt me. So then I sit there now and then like, why don't you ask a question?
SPEAKER_03I'm like, tell me it's great. Here's the other for free idea. I I love the advocacy movement that we're uh that we're currently on. Here's my here's my question and idea kind of put together. What what would happen if you brought somebody in that necessarily wasn't part of the advocate group? You know, would would our listeners and our commuters grab some interest from somebody or something that is outside the realm of what we do every day?
SPEAKER_03That's my question to you. That I just want you to ponder. I love it. You see, I told you he says things that are almost always smart. Because part of the brilliance of Sam was the fact that he could look at it with different eyes than necessarily musician eyes. He could look at it from an uh the from a from an outsider and say, I will help you tell your story, but you need to do that better as well.
SPEAKER_04My stories are too long. Peter's pretty high up in the whole mime advocacy uh, you know, lead leadership circle. So we're gonna get we're gonna get that operation in here next time.
SPEAKER_06Well, the reason I am is I'm the only one that talks in that room. They all just look at me weird. Chris, you're writing a book.
SPEAKER_04Hey Chris, hey Chris, how are you coming on that repository, that webpage for all the information?
SPEAKER_06He writes a lot of notes during these things, but they don't really apply to much.
SPEAKER_07Yeah, I've got my I've got my to-do list here. It's fine.
SPEAKER_06Chris does a great job on the show notes, I will have to say. And they are thorough and they've got lots of links and a lot of helpful information. It's just that it's hard for my phone to get to them sometimes, and so I don't go to them very often. So, in that sense, breaking that barrier down, the coach is not wrong.
SPEAKER_04Okay. He's still going. See how it got better? It just got a lot better. I think that's the new exit ticket. Is we'll let here and go for a while and then just mystery mute him. We've finally found it. Ending for the podcast. We've done it. Thank you, coach.
SPEAKER_07Beyond Artless is sponsored by Beyond the Notes Music Festival. Our mission is to create and provide profound learning and social experiences through music that go beyond the notes. Visit BTN MusicFestival dot com to learn more.
Send us Fan Mail Commuters, buckle up. Phil celebrates Chris and Peter, which is awkward for everyone involved. Chris reveals the dangers of painting music stands without putting anything underneath them. Peter...
Send us Fan Mail Commuter has weighed in and feels that middle school band instrument repair stories are far and away the best. Greg Beckwith has worked at Minnesota State SE Technical - Instrument Repair in Red Wing,...
Send us Fan Mail Becca Arons has contracted ensembles for countless major musical stars - from the Eagles, the Who, Ed Sheeran, Snoop Dog, Cory Wong and Aerosmith to Andrea Bocelli, Stevie Wonder, Weird Al Yankovich,...
Send us Fan Mail Step right up! Test your knowledge about farming in LaCrosse, Wisconsin! Whoever can answer all the questions will immediately be sent all remaining Beyond Artless Season 1 overstock t-shirts. Shipping...
Send us Fan Mail What happens when deep commitment to music education, trailblazing pedagogy, and the pursuit of artistry come together in one remarkable career? You get Randy Swiggum, nationally recognized conductor,...