Brett sits down with author Will Maclean to discuss his American debut, 'Solace House'. They talk about reading snobbery, his past writing in comedy, horror narratives, writing sympathetic characters in the genre, The Fairy Feller's Master-Stroke, the artist Richard Dadd, visual writing and Stephen King. Will's instagram: https://www.instagram.com/willmacwriting/?hl=en The Fairy Feller's Master-Stroke: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fairy_Feller%27s_Master-Stroke If you like what you're hearing on this podcast please subscribe so you never miss an episode! Watch Behind the Stack on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@brettsbookstack Bookshop.org page: https://www.bookshop.org/shop/brettsbookstack Brett's instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bretts.book.stack Behind the Stack email: brettsbookstack@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Brett BennerHey everybody, it's Brett Benner, and welcome back to Behind the Stack. Today's author that I'm sitting down with, Will McLean Has written... Well, they've called it a puzzle box, and it certainly is that. This thing split my head open. As I was saying to Will, I got to the end of it and kind of discovered something in the book right at the very end, which kind of blew me away. There are no spoilers in this episode. It would be very unfair to do that to anybody,'cause part of the fun of this book is letting it wash over you and discovering it all for yourself, but it is truly the perfect book for spooky season.
Brett BennerA little bit about Will. He's a screenwriter who has worked with people as varied as Peter Serafinowicz, Miranda Hart, Al Murray, and Tracey Ullman. His first novel, The Apparition Phase, was shortlisted for the McKitterick Prize. Solace House is his American debut. He lives in London with his wife and daughter. So I hope you enjoy this episode of Behind the Stack I'm so thrilled to be sitting down today with author Will McLean for his Solace House, which is so good and so trippy and truly broke my brain.
Brett BennerSo thank you for being here.
Will MacleanNot at all. Thank you for having me.
Brett BennerOne of the descriptions of the book, they said The Secret History meets The Haunting of Hill House, but I actually thought it was more The Haunting of Hill House meets Ari Aster.
Will MacleanThat, that certainly. I think it's the narcotic element of things, but, uh, yes, that originated with me, by the way. You know, your publisher goes,"What books do you like that are similar?" And you go,"I don't know. The Haunting of Hill House. I like that book. Uh, the, The House That Leaves" and then that, that's everywhere. That's then the thing.
Brett BennerYes, and then they run with
Will Macleanit. That's everywhere. Yeah. But- Which is fine. What you don't want to go is,"It's every bit as good as those." They're asking for these comparisons, and then you have to sort of go,"Well, you know, they're in the same area." So yeah.
Brett BennerJustify it. Yes.
Will MacleanYes, exactly.
Brett Benneryou grew up, you grew up in Merseyside, which is in Liverpool, or I should say b- near Liverpool. Well,
Will Macleanyou know, you say that, but it's just outside Liverpool. There's a... If you go across the Mersey, we're in where I'm from, which is the Wirral, uh, which is a peninsula. I'm from... You wouldn't have heard of where I'm from. It's where the ferry across the Mersey goes. It either goes to Birkenhead or it goes to where I'm from, which is Seacombe, which is like not a remarkable place. But I found out about 15 years ago that there's another writer from there. It was Olaf Stapledon, the science fiction writer, comes from literally exactly where I'm from, and I, I, I grew up being completely ignorant of him and I only heard of him about 20 years ago and I found out he was from where I'm from, which is a mind-blowing thing to discover and he's an amazing writer that no one knows about.
Will MacleanYeah, but so I'm... That's where I'm from. And people in Merseyside are very concerned with micro-geography. So if you're from somewhere, you're from there. You're not from two miles down the road. You're definitely from there. So look, my, my wife came up, um, last year. We came up for something and she was chatting to a guy in the hotel and went, uh,"Oh, my husband's from around here." The guy behind the bar went,"Where's he from?" And then she went,"Oh, he's from, uh, Seacombe." He went,"Well, he's not from around here, is he?" And it's like, it's just sort of like So that's very much like, yeah, you are from where you're, where you're from.
Will MacleanUh, so that's where I'm from.
Brett BennerThat sounds very much, that sounds very much like how the French approach Canadian French.
Will MacleanYeah. Yeah, yeah, that's it. And, you know, you're not properly from Liverpool, but you're also not You know, it's a, it's a very f- funny place to be from.
Brett BennerWere you a big reader as a kid?
Will MacleanI was, yeah. There's a public library in Seacombe, and that's, it's still there amazingly, which is enormously influential on me as a, as a kid, because I just read a lot, and I read sort of everything that came my way, uh, sort of indiscriminately, which you, you later learn is the wrong approach. And then, you sort of, your habits become a bit more formalized. But I did always just read anything that came my way. There was a lot of stuff- Wait I really just loved as a kid.
Brett BennerNo, but I'm so curious about this. When you say is, is the wrong approach towards in regards to what?
Will MacleanWell, I went to university and, and, and you're told that it's sort of like you've been doing it wrong. If you were reading for pleasure, you've been doing it incorrectly. And, and it's the first time because I'm first generation of my family to go to university, so it's like there's a lot of things I was unaware of. Like the, I'd not heard the term canon of English literature before. so, you know, the, the sort of books you are expected to have read if you study English literature. And it was not a thing that I, I'd experienced before. So I had this kind of ramshackle knowledge of a lot of things, but not... You know, there are massive gaps in my, in my reading, I think, and there still are, which I try to plug every year by reading something I should have read ages ago.
Brett BennerYeah,'cause my canon when I was young would've been strictly Stephen King and maybe, um, V.C. Andrews' smattered in, so
Will MacleanWell, exactly, and it's sort of like, you know, like I was one of those kids, if I liked one book by someone, I'd read everything they read, which I think is a very... So when I went for an interview at university, like,"What have you been reading?" They went, I said,"Kurt Vonnegut." They said,"Well, which one?" I was like,"Literally all of them," because that's what I read for six months. You know, it's one of those things. But I, I don't like people using books as a kind of intimidatory thing that like, you know,"You're doing it wrong." Uh, s- I was lucky enough to have really good tutors at university, and they sort of, flew the flag for the value of the things that they taught.
Will MacleanBut I don't like that thing where people are kind of snobbish about what people are reading. I think reading is reading. And if you're reading something you enjoy, then that's clearly, there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. So.
Brett BennerOh, 100%. Yeah. I find it even now, even with Instagram or social media, just even right now watching all the discourse about the Booker Prize and, um, everybody talking about it, and seeing some people dig in on, you know,"This is such serious literature, and this is why." And sometimes I'll read some of these things and be like,"I don't even know what the hell I'm reading- Yeah or getting out of this," and I'm like,"Uh, am I just stupid? Am I just failing?" I will say even with your book, I went through it and there were moments that I was, like, digging for what am I missing here, or what am I a- anticipating or trying to get ahead of it to try to figure out, you know, this has been called a puzzle box at times.
Brett BennerYeah. And I, I will say, like, when I was putting my thoughts together for this interview, there was something towards... It was the very last paragraph of the book, which we're not gonna give spoilers away, but- I realized because I was coming out with another question for you, what just tied in, and I know you'll know what I'm, you know what I'm talking about. Yeah. And literally my head exploded and my son had come in to my room and I was like, I made him sit down and I was like,"You don't understand.
Brett BennerI, I, I just figured something out and I don't even know if people are gonna figure this out and I need to talk about this with people." And, um, so it is one of these moments like I went a little off track of where we were just going, but it made me think of this'cause at first I was like, God, this ending can I... And then this ending and I was like, holy shit. So anyway, we'll get into all that in a second.
Will MacleanBut it's, it's sort of that's reflective of what I like and value in books or reading as an experience. I think you've got a responsibility as a, as a writer to hold a reader's attention and, and not talk down to them. I think a lot of literature does sort of talk down to people and it, it makes what I think is, is the cardinal sin which is assuming that the audience is less bright than they are, which I hate. I really-
Brett BennerYeah
Will Macleandislike that enormously when I read that. You know, when you're being like... Especially with things where you have to put a sort of twist in. It's like, often an astute reader will guess a twist really early doors and then you've got, you know, 200 pages of, of a thing that you've already worked out, uh, which is incredibly frustrating to read. It's interesting you mentioned the Booker Prize'cause M. John Harrison's on it this year, who I absolutely love Um, and I, I really like The End of Everything. I think, to be fair,'cause I'm such a massive fan of his, I think he's written better books, but I, I, I did love The End of Everything. I thought it was great.
Will MacleanBut it's, it's interesting to me as a sort of writer who's neither one thing nor the other,'cause like I'm from, for want of a better term, I'm from a working class background, but I sound middle class and always have because I didn't go out a lot. Didn't leave the house. But w- I don't like that, that box that, that writers are often put in. If you're from a certain background, you have to write a certain kind of fiction, and I think the Booker Prize carries on over to that where they kind of all, they're... I'm glad they're letting science fiction in, I guess is what I'm saying. I'm glad they're letting genre in, uh, like when they put Fever Dream by Samanta Schweblin, which I just, is a brilliant book.
Will MacleanBut it's sort of like I, I don't like snobbishness towards genre. I think, and I don't like this idea that if you're a certain kind of writer, if you're a gay writer, you must write books about the gay experience. It's incredibly limiting for, I think, writers to just write about a little box they might be in. I mean, it's handy to have that.
Brett BennerIt's interesting, though, you're saying that'cause I find so many parallels between w- writers and actors. Well, obviously creatives, but just to what you're saying and how the same way, uh, uh, actors get boxed into, you're able to play this or you're able to be this.
Will MacleanThink, I think a lot is changing. I think people's, you know, public perce- There was the, you know, my mom always used to say,"Poor Anthony Perkins, you know? He's, he's only ever gonna be Norman Bates." And I think that from a couple of generations ago was, was true, that you were, if you did one thing, that was who you were, and you could never escape that for good or-
Brett BennerAnd to be fair, he was a little, uh, pigeonholed himself anyway.
Will MacleanYeah,
Brett Bennerhe, he was. He, he, he is
Will Macleansuperb as Norman Bates.
Brett BennerYes. There is no- Yes
Will MacleanUh, but it is a thing I think now people are just a bit more forgiving of. You know, there's a thing that I think, uh, people are less hung up on genre than they used to be. When I grew up, there was a lot of snobbishness, I think, in Britain towards Stephen King. I think he was viewed as sort of pulp-y. And I think people have just caught up with the idea it's just generally quite hard to write a book, you know? So-
Brett BennerYeah
Will Macleanuh, so you know, you write what you can, and that's what you've written. And yeah.
Brett BennerNo, I, I agree. You've written for some of the best comedians, including Tracey Ullman and Peter Serafinowicz and Miranda Hart. How was that experience?
Will MacleanThat's great. Uh, I really enjoyed it. It's the early part of my career. I, um, me and a friend wrote a script ages and ages ago, and it was like 2004, I think we wrote it. Um, it got picked up by Asha Taylor, who'd then just done The Office. And the script didn't go anywhere, but as a result of that, I got an agent and, and, you know, we, we wrote sketches for a lot of people. Um, and then the, the credit crunch happened, and there was less comedy than ever before. Don't know why. Uh, so I kind of sidestepped into kids TV.
Will MacleanAnd both of them, I have to say, I always say this, they were, they were a really good apprenticeship. Comedy's terrifying because you have to be funny. Um, it's instant success or failure. but and also like when you go into co-comedy, like you're, you're overthinking it when you start off and you're... And also, like, for me, it was never a reliable gift. I, I found it. I did two days on Tracey Ullman Show, and the first day I hadn't written for ages. I think it was like six months where I hadn't written any gags, and I went in, and I absolutely sucked on the first day.
Will MacleanLike I, I was so bad, I almost apologized to her at the end. She was not only one of the... People always go like,"People in show business, they're really nice." Uh, but she was genuinely one of the nicest people I think I've ever met. She was just incredible. She was genuinely interested in who you were and like, you know, what, where you were coming from. And the second day, because I had absolutely nothing to lose, you know, and, and-
Brett BennerYeah
Will MacleanI was relaxed and therefore was a lot better, you know? And I just sort of killed it on the second day. You know, like it, it both were horrible and nerve-wracking because you're like, I'm literally, flying by the seats of my pants on both of these things, and this is not a reliable way to make a living. And it's often, I found that a lot with comedy. Certain people are really good at understanding the maths behind it and sort of, you know,'cause there are certain approaches you can make. And I worked with a bunch of people on impression shows, and they were just like gag, gag, gag, gag, which is not a, a way that I would normally approach things.
Will MacleanI'd normally go character, and who's this person and what do they want? But often you don't have time for that. It's a, it's a very unforgiving apprenticeship.
Brett BennerTruly. Meanwhile, were you still, uh, you were writing, writing, like you started writing books during all this? I,
Will MacleanI've always written books for good or ill, and I found one recently that I wrote when I was 23 And it's obviously awful. Uh, but it was nice to see it again. It's nice to know that progress has been made. Uh, but it was It's, it's not good. I thought, and I thought recently, I thought,"Yeah, I'll do a William Burroughs and cut it up and try and make it,"'cause I was unwilling to burn it or get rid of it. And I thought,"I'll do some cut up." And it cut up, it's all, it's even worse. I've, I've cut the text up and now I've just got this bag of texts where it's just like, you know, awful.
Will MacleanSo it's like, I think I may have to get rid of it, but I've always written, and I've always liked writing prose. It took me a long time to get to a point where I mean, I'm 53 now, so I'm, you know, like I'm, I'm Write- writing wise, I'm a sort of dashing young blade, but in terms of TV comedy, like I, I don't think I have anything more to sort of give in that sense. The idea of you know, pitching ideas and making them compete with other people's ideas just sort of leaves me cold. Whereas prose is infinite.
Will MacleanIt's that sense of possibility you get when you open the page for the first time. It, I just love it. So yeah, and that never goes, I think.
Brett BennerWell, your first book, uh, that was published in 2020, The Apparition Phase, I will tell you, on a side note, I saw on Amazon the hardback is on sale for$389.50. So-
Will MacleanYeah. You know what? There's, there's literally 10 copies in my loft if you want one. Uh, they're lit- they're over there. I can pick them up. Um, I, I am also a huge fan of books as objects. I spend a lot of time in secondhand bookshops looking for treasure and obscure things, and I think there's a lot of writers who do that, I think. But I like that as an item it has value It's become a desirable thing, especially in an era where, you know, everything is available. Scarcity is gone, and everything is available all the time.
Will MacleanI quite like that idea.
Brett BennerThe only other thing I wanna talk about before we get into the book is The Broken Veil, which is this podcast, that you created with Joel Morris. And y- you talked about, I think, and maybe this was on social media, could've been on Instagram, that, uh, because the podcast explores stories where in certain conditions, the veil of reality breaks, and you said that, uh, I think-
Will MacleanThat's a brilliant description, which we probably should've u- used in promotional materials. That's really good. We might actually just have to steal that from
Brett Benneryou.
Will MacleanIt's very concise, so.
Brett BennerBut I think you say in the introduction to the podcast, you talk about, Solace House, and you say the people that, that like this podcast would probably find something similar to like in the book. Yeah. So I'm wondering, with that said, let's launch into the book a little bit,'cause my questions started to stem out of that. But for our listeners and for our viewers, do you, do you have a elevator pitch for Solace House?
Will MacleanUh, I would say, a student, a lonely student, is left alone during the massive gap between his first and second year of university over summer, and through a piece of good fortune, he joins a bunch of other students clearing out a hospital and then subsequently a large house, which have been both acquired by the university with a view to turning them into halls of residence. As it's a fundamentally, it has the bones of a horror story. Things do not go well. Uh, things do not go according to plan.
Will MacleanAnd it's partly an exercise on my part, seeing how wrong that could go.
Brett BennerSo what I started to, to ask you before when I was in relation to the podcast, had this story began to germinate before that, or was your work on the podcast, did that bleed into this as well? Or where did it all begin for you?
Will MacleanThey're really kind of two separate things, I think. The podcast is its own thing,'cause I write that with Joel. But the book, um, I'd always wanted to write something about... 'Cause I, for various reasons, I couldn't go home At summer term. And I was, I was like Alex in the book, just left there.
Brett BennerAnd
Will Macleanin, at university and so- You know, and it is empty. It just empties out. And I always thought that was a promising precinct in which to set a story because it is an unusual time. It's that sort of left behindness of it. Uh, the movie The Holdovers came out when I was writing this, which I still haven't seen and probably never will because it came out while I was writing this. But it's a similar kind of premise that, you know... But I understand The Holdovers is set at Christmas, which from my experience, Christmas is, is a different proposition. It's short. There's a tradition of taking people into Christmas.
Will MacleanWhereas summer it's like it's three months, you know, you're on your own. Nobody really wants to have you around for three months.
Brett BennerYeah. Yeah.
Will MacleanUh, so it is that thing of just emptiness and it's sort of, you know, it's supposed to be the, the sort of halcyonic time of your life, and yet you're stuck on your own. And you know, I felt that that was a, an interesting place to start a story. And then obviously I started work on this during the pandemic, so I needed a ready-made arena that I knew well emotionally'cause the research time was compromised. So I took that and I took the early'90s when I was a student as, as the setting because I just was... I, I was just compromised on the time I had to do research.
Will MacleanOriginally it was gonna be set in 1980, but I decided that was thematically not, not good. I find 1980 a really interesting year and I've always wanted to set something in it because it's not the'80s as we understand it. It's not the'70s. It's very much its own little island of time. But I found also that 1993 for me was a similar kind of thing. It's like not the'90s as we popularly remember it quite yet, but neither is it the'80s. It sort of hasn't decided what it's gonna be yet. And I find that if you're gonna set a story in the past, it has to feel really as unresolved as the present moment does.
Will MacleanAnd I f- I like, so I like those eras where history hasn't quite jumped one way, waiting to resolve itself.
Brett BennerIt's also, it's a time where it's a, a, a tad bit isolating because we didn't have the connectivity that we have now, right? So like I was just thinking when you were talking about it, I was like,"God, when did those first cell phones, when did we start to get those first cell phones?" And, um I, I don't, you know, I don't think it was until the-
Will MacleanI think it's the late'90s when people are finally, you know-
Brett BennerYeah, yeah. But there isn't, there is like a, a sense of isolation about the whole thing.
Will MacleanUm- There's also a question I always like to ask people is, when did you first go on the internet, if they're, if they're of my age. And mine was 1994 or late'93 in the student house I was in. One of the people in my house managed to go online, you know, through a dial-up modem, and it took forever. Yeah. And, and it was text. It was like all text. And you were like,"This is terrible. This will never catch on." And it was, it was so primitive back then, and it's almost impossible now to imagine.
Brett BennerTo think about it, and how fast. Yeah. I still remember sitting in my apartment dialing into AOL and that forever, like that,"You've got mail." Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Will MacleanOh, that's a really good impression. Well done. Thank
Brett Benneryou. Just waiting and waiting and like,"Ugh," and then, you know, busy right now. I also remember I was in the desert with friends and opening the New York Times book section, and there was a picture of the Amazon River, and it said,"Amazon is coming." And I was like,"What does that mean?" And, uh, and it was like the world's biggest bookstore. I was like,"I don't even understand that."
Will MacleanYeah.
Brett BennerSo who would have known? Yeah. And here we are.
Will MacleanYeah, exactly. But I have written two novels now, one of which is set in the early'70s, one set in the early'90s, and I find that the landscape post-internet is, is a thing that I haven't yet grappled with. And I should, you know, I should get on that, but it is a different kind of, of horror to write, I think. Especially if you're writing horror. It's like a lot of horror... There's a great super cut someone put on YouTube of, People in horror films saying that their cell phone doesn't work. And it's- Yeah. you know, like, and it's every conceivable excuse from, like, it's been eaten to, like, there's no coverage or, like, there's, you know.
Will MacleanAnd a lot of horror films simply collapse if, uh, if-
Brett BennerRight
Will Macleanif, you know, tr- traditional horror narratives collapse if you can just look stuff up.
Brett BennerUh- Truly
Will Macleanincluding Solace- including Solace House, you know? It'd be very, it'd be a very different proposition if you could simply Google everything you found.
Brett BennerYeah, yeah, yeah.
Will MacleanMm-hmm. Uh, so there's an element of traditional storytelling that falls by the wayside, and I think, um, certain people have really engaged with that technology. And, you know, there are stories that are really, really good at doing that., Black Mirror obviously is exactly that, but I think there's an unwillingness to let go of the old tropes, and I kind of like that. I kind of like both approaches. I don't really think either is correct, you know, but it, it is a, it is a line in the sand where it's like, you know, you either choose to engage with this or you don't.
Brett BennerRight. Right.
Will MacleanJ- even Jane Schoenbrun's book, which I read recently, Public Access Afterworld, which I really liked, a lot of it is VHS tapes, and it sort of revolves around these kids who are into They're retro kids who are watching VHS tapes. Because of the physicality of that media, that's what's that's, that's the thing that everyone likes, and it's sort of that's gone.
Brett BennerBut I think this all lends itself to the book too because these kids have to be connected. You're forced to interact with each other because you don't have the distraction of something else to pull you out of it, right? I mean, yes, they discover as they're doing this job these books that they come across, but generally speaking, it's almost like Survivor, right? They're all sitting around so much of the time talking, having dinner, just interacting with each other, and then in relation to the house, and then things start to go very bad. Was it always a first-person narrative?
Will MacleanYeah. I, I Uh, as well, that was a, a matter of convenience. I just, just removes, for me, an element of distance between the reader and the narrator. It's very efficient to go like this is, you know And I did toy with doing it third person. It didn't work. So it, it just straight up didn't work. It was good to have that experience of going, right, that I know now which approach I should take because these are very fundamental questions if you're writing. So I like, with horror, I like that kind of thing where it just kind of straps you in, and it's, um It's interesting'cause Stephen King obviously is, is obviously the best at this and v- very seldom uses first person, I think.
Will MacleanBut he has that thing of it's like someone telling you a story. The narrator is almost a character in his books. I think if you're going to do horror, it kind of has to be, like, as if it belongs to a very old storytelling tradition. So you kind of have to, to enga- an engaging voice as a narrator, or because time was a factor, I, I just did it first person. Um, also as well because, like I said, Al- Alex is not me, but he had a lot of similar experiences, um, so it just proved easier to do that.
Brett BennerI'm so curious, and again, this is all tricky'cause I don't wanna get into any spoiler territory'cause I think part of the joy and the appeal of the book is kind of the discovery, and it's also why I feel like this is a great book for a book club because it evokes a lot of questions, and asking questions, and what people think, and the perception of what do you think is happening versus what is happening, which is kind of what is happening to Alex as it's going through, yes?
Will MacleanYeah. But i find that such a kind of fundamental thing of, of lived experience that, you know, you... It's just, everything's just a best guess, you know? Everything that happens to you today is like, you know, you'll never understand one-tenth of it. You know, everything that's come your way is like, you see, you, you make your best of the information that comes your way, and you assemble some kind of narrative about it, but it's definitely not really what's happening. And I find that a kind of fundamental state of human being, really, like, which is obviously taken to the extreme in this book, but I find it comforting that we don't know as much as we think we do, and so that's in the book, definitely, I think.
Brett BennerI'm so curious when you begin to put all this together in terms of your outlining and then you creating this cast of characters. Talk about that experience for a moment, because you have this, this group of kids who are so varied, and it... They never feel like... Sometimes you'll feel like people are plotted in as a device, right? To, to- Yeah kind of execute something. Yeah. And it doesn't feel like that in here. But I'm so curious about how you started to evolve these different characters or how you approached it.
Will Macleanknow, they, they just... And then they start talking to each other, and you, you're just an observer who listens. But having said that, there is an element of where you kind of set them off, and they do A- another thing is that,'cause it's-- I don't wanna say it's out and out horror because it isn't. If you go into this expecting Texas Chain Saw Massacre, you will be disappointed because it's, it's a bit more slow burn than that. But one of the rules of horror which is very helpful is you pick a situation. Once you have your situation, the people you then throw at it must be the worst possible people to be in that situation.
Will MacleanSo it's like, you know, so Jack Torrance is the worst person to look after the Overlook Hotel. He should not be within 100 miles of that hotel, and that's horror. The people in that story, they're, they are, they're all, you know, uh, Ty is the older post-grad, he's older than they are, but the rest of them are all teenagers, and they're late teenagers, and they are so kind of... They've got no concept of risk. They've got no concept of... Their drug and alcohol intake is enormous, which is a very kinda early'90s thing as well, I think. So they are in, in many ways the wrong people to be in that, you know, which in narrative terms they all have...
Will MacleanBut I also like, you know, you said about assembling the characters. One of the things I had in the back of my mind that,'cause it is a book, this is slightly spoiler-ish territory. It's a book about madness to some degree, which is kind of the, the sort of core of it really. And, you know, people go mad in very, very personal ways. You know, the people become unbalanced in very ways unique to them, and I just felt that that was important for the characters, that if they started to fracture, that they would fracture along highly specific lines. And that was helpful in building who they were It's funny because, uh, I love Obviously, you, you can't help but look at reviews.
Will MacleanYou tell yourself you're not going to, but you sort of look at Goodreads or whatever. But what I love is that people either really like those characters or they absolutely hate them There's no ambivalence towards those characters. People are just kind of like,"Well, they're, um, yeah, I, I- they're all jerks, and I hate them." They're I just You know, I like spending time with these characters. It's interesting to me that, that they b- should be so polarized.
Brett BennerWell, it's also the kind of thing if you're going into something that has this element of, you know, as the horror starts to build, you're thinking,"Well, people are gonna probably go down." And there is a kind of a schadenfreude of like, okay, who's getting it first, or how is it going to happen? Right. But it is also funny when you're putting a character, like there's a character of Helen, who's this very, you know, kind of uptight, very conservative religious student-
Will MacleanMm
Brett Bennerpoised against someone like Clive or even Ruth, who's this goth girl. You already know. Again, it's like watching the Big Brother house or something. It's, yeah. You know, watching these people come together.
Will MacleanI love Ruth. Ruth is my absolute favorite. She was a joy to write. And again, that thing of like she was just You know, you don't wanna go down to that pretentious road of again saying that characters become their own people, but she would always be surprising in whenever'Cause she had that sort of, you know,'cause it's the'90s, there's a lot of cynicism and a lot of sarcasm, often, like, almost aggressively so. But she's just hilarious I think every time she turns up. I just really like her. Um, Helen is interesting because there are a lot of people you meet at university when you're young, and they're like,"Why are you young?" Mm.
Will Maclean"What are you... Why are you squandering this gift being middle-aged?" There are quite a lot of people like that, and I think that you, you sort of forget that. There's a, there's a sort of- TV image of young people sort of being massively hedonistic and sort of these party animals. And yet there are people you meet at university who are very serious and very buttoned down, and in many ways kind of like, you know, they're, they're in their 40s already, and it's like I did want to want a character like that. So w- they weren't all, uh, sort of hedonistic cliches really.
Brett BennerNo, it's hilarious. I mean, she very much is like, you know, which one of these is not like the other. Um, but- Yeah. I, I
Will Macleanlike Helen as well. I just sort of, you know, she's, she's not wrong 100% of the time'cause that would be insufferable. A lot of the time she is the voice of sense. It's just that she's quite-
Brett BennerThat's it
Will Macleanso yeah. She's the one who says,"Let's not do any of this," and they all kind of laugh it off, and it's sort of like,"I just should listen to her."
Brett BennerYeah, also the whole idea of youth anyway, that you feel invincible. There's no fear of death. There's no fear of anything. Like, when you're that young, life is your oyster, especially at university'cause I think, you know... I look at it with my own kids. You're in a space where everything is being paid for and covered. You have a house. You have living arrangements. You have food. You have everything you need. So it is that kind of period where you're on top of the world, and it's c- it's, it's like pseudo-adulting. Like, you're not quite- Yeah there yet, but you can pretend that like,"Oh, we can make these decisions, and we're, you know, we're in control of everything," when you're really not.
Brett BennerAnd so for all of them to be in this situation, especially when things begin to get crazy, and how they all start to interact with each other, it's great.
Will MacleanThey're much more sort of honest though. There, there, there's the bit at the beginning where Alex is watching all his friends leave for summer, and he re- he, he says they sort of shed their university personas. And the people you meet who are the core cast of the book don't do that. They're very much who they are, which I kind of wanted to build in because I felt that they were more I don't know. There has to be a sort of Again, it's horror. It's like, all right, if something bad is gonna happen to those characters, you have to feel it. And in order for that to happen, you have to feel some kind of sympathy with those characters. In the first book I wrote, there's a, there's a very I, I can't really spoiler that, but a key character, something terrible happens to them.
Will MacleanUh, and a lot of people said,"Oh, that was my favorite character." It's like, you have to miss them. If other characters in this book are gonna miss them too, you as a reader have to miss them. And so you have to feel that there's something at stake here because otherwise it's just a bunch of, you know, to use the Star Trek term, it's just red shirts who are sort of people you, you've never met, you know, where terrible things are happening to them. It's It makes more sense to have much more rounded characters who, who you miss.
Brett BennerOkay, so I want to talk about The Fairy Feller's Masterstroke. Yes. The painting, um, by Richard Dadd because- Yeah it gets referenced early on by Ella, who's one of the students and who kind of piques Alex's interest. But talk about this painting for a second and, um Because first of all, I have to tell you, like, one of the things I love about books or love about a book, and this is one of them, is when something's referenced, when should I immediately look up and say,"Is he making this up or is this a real thing?" Yeah. And so to see it as a real thing was kind of incredible. And then also, I know you've talked about it on, on social media before and what the painting means to you.
Will MacleanYeah. It's always been in my life, that painting. I saw it first when I was a kid, I think, and it's not an image you forget. It's, um For those who don't know, it's a, it's an insanely detailed depiction of a thing that's alluded to in Romeo and Juliet where, um, a hazelnut is being split. Richard Dadd as an artist was in an asylum when he painted this painting. He was in Bethlem Asylum because he killed his father. He had a, what we would now know as a schizophrenic breakdown during a tour of the Middle East, and he killed his father and then attempted to kill someone else and then ended up in the Bethlem Asylum.
Will MacleanSo when you see it, I mean, you often see it. I think I must have seen it in a children's book or a book that the, the children were expected to read. I think it may have been one of the Reader's Digest books of folklore or something like that. Um, but you see it, and it, it doesn't have an eeriness to it because it's, it's not an eerie painting. It's weirdly kind of a happy painting. Mm-hmm. There is such an intensity to it, um, which is... It's on display at the moment in the, the Royal Academy in London, so I went to s- I went to see it literally last week. Um, I've seen it, you know, various exhibitions, but it is... I went with a friend, and she went,"It's tiny," the minute we saw it'cause she is familiar through it in a book.
Will MacleanShe went,"It's absolutely tiny."
Brett BennerI thought the same thing. I s-'cause I saw the picture of you on Instagram with it. Yeah. And I was like,"Wow."
Will MacleanYeah, you expect it to cover one wall. It's like- Yes and he worked on this painting for about eight, nine, 10 years, and it, it is, it looks like it's been worked on for about 10 years, um, because it, it absolutely swarms with detail. It's almost like something under a, a, a slide under a microscope. There's just so much going on in it, and it's just full of stuff. You know? It's like there are little stories in there and allusions and, and you know, and it's a, it has been an inspiration to quite a lot of artists. You know, the Queen song about it is in the book.
Will MacleanAlan Moore talks about it in one of the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen volumes. And you know, it, it's... Dadd's tragedy is sort of separate to that picture even though it's inextricably bound up with it, and I find it... I don't know. I just, I just really like it. I d- I really like art. I'm a, a fan of art. I wanted to be an artist as a teenager and then, thank God, had a realization that I was never gonna be good enough. You know, I mean, that saved me a lot of time. But I have always had an appreciation of art, and I really like it.
Will MacleanAgain, there's a thing where I think it, a lot of people feel excluded from it. There's a lot of snobbishness about it, but I think what I really like is when something, you have a visceral reaction to, and that painting is something I think everyone has a visceral reaction to. You know, it, it's, it's charming and almost overbearingly so, and it's full of hints. It, it seems to hint at a story that's not quite finished, and I just, I just love it.
Brett BennerI find it fascinating with this particular painting the way it's used but also his story and kind of this schizophrenic break In relation again to the book, the stuff that's mined here, that again, like as I finished the book and I was like,"Holy shit, I..." It's one of those things where I had to go back,'cause again, I, I'm not gonna give anything away, but I found it was almost by happenstance because I marked that earlier, uh, early passage in the book that led me to the end, and I was all of a sudden like,"Oh my God. Oh my God." Um-
Will MacleanSee, see I love stuff like this in stories myself. I lo- I really like it when you have those rabbit holes that you can go down. Oh. Obviously I've, this is clearly what I've done here. But, um, the long poem that's in Solace House that runs all the way through-
Brett BennerYes, I was gonna ask you about that. Yeah
Will Macleanthe section, that is based on the very long doggerel poem that Dad wrote about... It's called Elimination of a Picture. It's actually got a longer title than that, but I can't remember off the top of my head. But Dad obviously like, you know, like there wasn't enough detail in The Fairy Feller's Masterstroke, and so he decided to write a poem alongside it. And in that, that poem, which is couplets, he names all of the characters in the canvas and what they're doing and all their relationships to, as if to sort of like reinforce their meaning, as if like rendering them in this almost, you know, th- th- this maddening detail was somehow not enough.
Will MacleanUm, and I find that, that as a piece of Victoriana is fascinating. And it was, it's also based on that and In Memoriam by Tennyson, which I think is in quatrains. I haven't looked at it for a while. But yeah, so I had this idea of writing this very long poem that you could take or leave, by the way. That's the main thing. It's like if there's a literary device in a book You should be able to, like, take or leave it. Get the general idea and move on. If it's, if it's bumming you out reading the poetry, you should just be able to move on. Um, hopefully that won't happen, but it is in there. I... As a...
Will MacleanWhen I decided that that's what I was gonna be doing, I went away and reread Pale Fire by Nabokov, which is a book I really like. 'Cause I, I just thought how much poetry will people tolerate in a book? And, uh, that's got way more poetry than mine. It begins with a thousand-line poem or a 999-line poem, which you are expected to go through before you've read the manuscript. So, you know, I felt kind of justified in doing what I'd done in there.
Brett BennerThat feels like that should be one of the books on the literary canon that you had to have when you went into university.
Will MacleanYeah. Yes. I discovered that years afterwards. It's always the way that, like, a lot of the books that I absolutely love, I didn't... Like, I mentioned Olaf Stapledon earlier. Uh, things like The Third Policeman, which is a book I absolutely adore by Flann O'Brien. Have you read that?
Brett BennerNo. No.
Will MacleanOh, you should do.
Brett BennerOkay.
Will MacleanAnd it's, it's probably the darkest subject matter available written in a kind of humorous, whimsical Irish way. And I love that, and I think that's the, the, the bit that came out of Solace House was if you're gonna have all this highfalutin, pretentious architecture in there, um, about the last living Victorian and his battle with sanity, the people against that have to be kind of not interested in it to a degree. So they're just, you know, they, they, they swear a lot. They drink a lot. They make jokes about it.
Will MacleanThey're inappropriate. And they are the... Again, they're the wrong people to be investigating this. They do not take it seriously until it's far too late.
Brett BennerDid you know when you went in where this was gonna end up, or did some of it just reveal itself as you went through?
Will MacleanI always knew where it's going because I always do. I think you have a responsibility. If you're doing a complicated story, you must know where it ends, and you must be able to answer every single question put to you about the architecture of that book because I... It is... I don't like things where it, it feels like people are wasting your time, where they haven't worked it out themselves. I find it very insulting to the reader to do that. So yes, I did know where it was going, but I do like to have the material surprise me. So the idea of the characters being portrayed to some extent within The Fairy Feller's Master-Stroke, which is not a spoiler, but it's there.
Will MacleanUm, but that came from just scrutinizing the painting again, looking at it, thinking the, the cast of this book is actually in this painting. Um, and so stuff like that, you want it to surprise you, you know. And I find that those connections come if you, if you have your obsessions within your, your field of what you're focusing on, that those connections will start to become apparent.
Brett BennerIt's like almost like the reverse peel of an onion, right? You have the center that you know what holds, and then you can layer it, right? You can put, like, the, the poetry on top of it. You can add this layer to it and this layer to it. That's what I imagine-
Will MacleanIt's interesting working with Joel because he's a, you know, like he's way more successful as a comedy writer than I ever was. I mean, he, he's written a book about comedy where he refers to this thing called the bucket. You know, whereas if you have like in Spinal Tap, it's a mock documentary, you know? And that-
Brett BennerYeah
Will MacleanThree, Three Idiots, and that's a really solid bucket for putting all the comedy inside. And I find it's the same with writing. If you've got a character like Leo who's an archeologist on his own terms, then you can talk about deep time, you can talk about civilization, you can talk about stone circles, you can talk about all of these things which are germane to the book because that character is interested in them, and that is the lens through which he'll see those things. He's a very good bucket to put those concerns in. You, again, you have to like your characters. I, I really like Leo.
Will MacleanI like all of them, but um, it's, it's hard in horror because you have to make them suffer.
Brett BennerYeah. I was just thinking, and maybe this is also because of your background, but it's, it's very cinematic, and I think that's the other reason I thought about the Ari Aster thing because I was thinking of just his, the visuals of some of his things that he does, and there's a sequence, and this is not, I'm not giving anything away, but there's a kind of a tableau of three characters at a table. It just ha- felt very much like something that would be in that world to me. And um, so it was so evocative and haunting and-
Will MacleanThat's, that's really lovely to hear because it, it is a lot of work. It's a lot of hard work putting those things in. And I really, I like- Visual writing. I like to have a, you know, I, again, Stephen King, it's like he's really good at having a shorthand visual by which that story will be known. You know, if I go, there's a, there's a, a red classic car, you know which book I'm talking about.
Brett BennerRight.
Will MacleanA, a, a young girl at a prom covered in pig's blood. There you go. It's a massively There's a hotel.
Brett BennerA rabid dog, right?
Will MacleanYeah, exactly. You know, even if the book itself may not be the best, you know which book I'm talking about because he has a very strong sense of, you know, visual imagery, and it's really, it's shorthand for that story. So you should have like that and, and the detail of things. I, I really do-
Brett BennerI think I'm gonna write in the notes of this episode, um, answer what those four Stephen King books were for all the, uh
Will MacleanThere are loads of them. I mean, yeah, but you can now think of all of the Yeah. It's, I But I like to have a strong With The Apparition House, I also like to boil down the stories in one word, which I think you should try and do. Uh, so for The Apparition House, it was haunted. I just think-
Brett BennerFor this?
Will MacleanWhat's it like? No, no, for the first one. Um-
Brett BennerOkay, so what would your, what would your word be for Solace House?
Will MacleanIt was madness. I just- Yes what's it like to be mad? But, um, I, I wanted to write something that was not flippant about those concerns,'cause if, I think if you are writing about those concerns, again, like with the story of Richard Dadd, I just feel terribly bad for him. I just feel really bad. You know, that he was in the grip of something that was far stronger than he was. The delusions that beset him were just awful for him. I mean, I, you know, I know that he killed his father. It's a horrible story all round, and from that he managed to wrest this beautiful image, and I think that's, you know So you want to sort of, you don't want to disrespect those people and your own knowledge of these things.
Brett BennerWell, Will, the book, it's so good. Please go out and get the book. Buy independent if you can. Um, but it's really fantastic. Also, I have to say they did such an incredible job in the inside boards. They're just beautiful. Um-
Will MacleanThis is the people at Atlantic, and this is Holly Battle who designed the cover, which is I love the cover so much. I'm just gonna tell you that the seed of-- I always keep a notebook for visual images. There we go. The, if you go back to the endpapers, the, uh, the, the, that image there- Yes um, that's from- Ah,
Brett Bennerthat's yours.
Will MacleanThat is my daughter and I in the first few months of lockdown We painted over that just, you know, she was three and a half, almost four at that point, and we painted over that and then it was just like a stupid thing to do because it was in a magazine. And then I remember thinking,"Who, who is that? And why, why would they pa-" And then it just, it just exploded from there, that end of things, because I needed, I knew that there would be somebody who'd been an inhabitant of this house, and I just... That was the key that unlocked it really was having this. So it's like the sort of serendipity of, of that chaotic time of that first lockdown.
Will MacleanWow. Yeah. And it was just literally looking and going,"Who would paint over every, not just one picture, but every picture of themselves? What would cause someone to do that?" And that was, that was obviously, like, very helpful to-
Brett BennerAnd Richard Fayne was born.
Will MacleanYeah. Exactly.
Brett BennerYeah, yeah.
Will MacleanThere he is. Yes, there he is.
Brett BennerUm- Well, it's fantastic. Congratulations. And I'm going back to your first book now because I, I... like I said, I love this so much that, uh, I can't wait to read the first.
Will MacleanPlease do. Yeah, yeah. So honestly, I'd love, love to hear what you think about that. Yeah. So yeah.
Brett BennerNo. All right. Well, thank you so much. Thank you so much
Will Macleanfor... No, I... the pleasure was all mine. And, uh, uh, thank you.
Brett BennerThank you again, Will. If you liked today's episode or other episodes of Behind the Stack, please consider liking and subscribing so that you never miss an episode. Also, it's my weekly ask to say if you have the time, what would be really helpful is if you can give the show five stars, and if you're so inclined, please write a review as well. All of these things are incredibly helpful to bring the podcast in front of more people so that I can continue to bring you conversations like this one. I'll be back next week with another episode, and until then, you can always find me on Instagram, YouTube, and Substack at Brett's Book Stack.
Brett sits down with Lucy Tan to discuss her sophomore novel, 'Tiger's Mouth'. They talk indie bookstores, writing male protagonists, class and privilege, her approach to writing at the start of a book, some book seller...
Brett sits down with author Harrison Hill to discuss his debut non fiction book, "The Oracle's Daughter", about a woman's escape from a cult her mother was the leader of. They talk how he got the idea, research and...
Brett sits down with Chad Harbach to discuss his sophomore novel, 'The Brightness'. They talk revisiting characters from, 'The Art Of Fielding' and why go back, writing a book about female friendship and feminism, a...
Brett sits down with Mary Beth Keane to discuss her latest novel and Good Morning America Book Club Pick, 'Whale Harbor" They talk all things Irish: extended large families, including her own, the rural setting,...
In his 100th episode, Brett sits down with Bonnie Garmus to discuss her new book, 'Peck & Peck'. They have a 'Lessons in Chemistry' check in, they talk poets as oracles, the downside to AI, the need for artists, and an...