Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind The Stack

Behind The Stack artwork

Harrison Hill, The Oracle's Daughter

Nov 10, 202637 minAudio

Brett sits down with author Harrison Hill to discuss his debut non fiction book, "The Oracle's Daughter", about a woman's escape from a cult her mother was the leader of. They talk how he got the idea, research and legality, religious fundamentalism, and the frightening challenge of getting out. Harrison's website: https://www.harrisonhill.me/ Harrison's Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/1harrisonhill/ If you like what you're hearing on this podcast please subscribe so you never miss an episode! Watch Behind the Stack on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@brettsbookstack Bookshop.org page: https://www.bookshop.org/shop/brettsbookstack Brett's instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bretts.book.stack Behind the Stack email: brettsbookstack@gmail.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Brett BennerHey everybody, it's Brett Benner, and welcome back to another episode of Behind the Stack. So I first heard about today's guest and his book from Tracy at the Stacks podcast. She had read this and mentioned it, and I was completely intrigued by it. So I listened to it when I was driving down recently from Pacific Northwest to Southern California, and I was completely caught up in the whole thing. The book is about a cult, and I am somebody who is obsessed with cults, the whole kind of mystique around them, everything to do with them.

Brett BennerThey both terrify me and yet I find them completely intriguing. This book by author Harrison Hill, his debut novel, The Oracle's Daughter: The Rise and Fall of an American Cult, follows three women and the daughter of one of the women when she escapes from this cult. But it's also a bigger examination of cults in general in the United States. And when I finished, I thought,"I have to sit down with Harrison Hill." So a little bit about Harrison. He grew up in Charlottesville, Virginia. He received his MFA in nonfiction from Columbia University, where he also taught undergraduate writing.

Brett BennerHis journalism and essays have appeared in The Cut, GQ, Vogue, Travel Leisure, The Guardian, and the London Times literary supplement. The Oracle's Daughter is his first novel, and he lives in Brooklyn, New York. So I hope you enjoy this episode of Behind the Stack. I'm so happy to be sitting down with Harrison Hill today for his... It is fantastic, but also, I have to say, it's a little terrifying.

Brett BennerThe Oracle's Daughter: The Rise and Fall of an American Cult. Thank you so much for being here, Harrison.

Harrison HillSo much fun to be here, Brett. I'm a big fan of the podcast. I'm thrilled to speak with you.

Brett BennerAs I told you, I had got this book because Traci from the Stacks podcast had spoken about it. Oh, cool. And so I am one of those people that are kind of obsessed with cults, about shows about cults- any of that kind of thing, like I think so many people are. And so I was like,"I have to get this." So I bought the book, and then I was driving down from the Pacific Northwest to Southern California. I thought,"This is, this could be a great thing to listen to." And you narrated it as well, which I really appreciated. and I also thought this could be a subject that my husband would listen to on a book on tape, who wouldn't be like, I don't wanna listen to this." And he was.

Brett BennerHe was totally in so thank you for being a- So glad to hear it. Thank you for also being a compelling narrator.

Harrison HillOh, I appreciate it. Yeah. I- I was thrilled that I got to record it. It was so much fun, though it was actually surprisingly exhausting. It took, like, five days over three weeks. It was, it was a lot. And it's funny, you know, the, the, the folks at Simon Schuster who, who directed the audiobook, they have a whole kind of catalog of things to drink while you're recording it that, that'll help you get through it. They have something called a, the Broadway Brew, which is like tea mixed with a throat lozenge, which I, which I thought worked quite effectively. Um, but yeah, it was, it was a lot of fun.

Brett BennerSo you grew up in Virginia. Where'd you get your BFA?

Harrison HillYeah. I got my undergraduate degree at NYU, and then I studied writing. I got my MFA up at Columbia.

Brett BennerWhat was your bachelor's in?

Harrison HillUh, theater. I studied theater.

Brett BennerOh, oh, you did. You wanted to be an actor.

Harrison HillI did. I did, yeah.

Brett BennerOkay,

Harrison Hillso- Acting on the page now, I guess.

Brett BennerYeah. So what... See, so then it makes sense w- why you did such a great job reading. What made the change for you?

Harrison HillIt was a couple things. I mean, writing and theater were always the two things that I loved to do. And so yeah, I went to NYU and I studied, I studied theater and was doing small shows for maybe, uh, you know, two years or so after graduating and also, like, teaching swimming and working. I had a job handing out flyers in Times Square, like advertising Broadway shows and things like that, which was, which was a wild experience. Maybe I should write about that one day, honestly. and then I did a tour of a children's musical called If You Give a Mouse a Cookie, which I don't know if you know that- Yeah.

Harrison HillYeah, I know that.

Brett BennerOf

Harrison Hillcourse admissible title. I'm sure your- Yes your, your listeners do as well. Uh, there is a little one-hour musical version of that, and I did a tour of that for, for a couple months, and I came back to New York, and I didn't have another gig lined up, and I just felt like I needed a proper job. I mean, both for, like, money and for my brain. And so- Mm-hmm I got a job working at a theater advertising agency as a copywriter. And I worked there for a number of years through my 20s, and that was this interesting sort of bridge because, you know, I- I'd studied theater and then, uh, and I was writing, but I wasn't writing, you know, books or articles or anything.

Harrison HillI was writing taglines and, uh, TV commercials and radio spots and things like that. And so I did that for a couple years, and then I did a, a, a writing workshop in, in Greece with Cheryl Strayed, which was this extraordinary experience and, I mean, honestly, like, you know, quite life-changing'cause I came out of that feeling like I really wanna write more seriously. I mean, all through those years I was writing on my own, and I, I had a blog, and I love journal writing a lot, and I think that that's actually the best, some of the best writing education that I got is just being with- Mm-hmm myself on the page for all those years.

Harrison HillAnd so then I went to Columbia from there, and then in the years since then have been, you know, writing professionally. And what's funny is that I work freelance for the ad agency where I started back in my 20s. So it's, it's funny. It's like I can't, I can't get away, and I don't want to. It's a great gig to have because I can write through the morning, and then I get in the subway and I go up to Times Square and I go to the office and start writing ads for The Book of Mormon.

Brett BennerThat's really cool. So when you went to school, your MFA, it said for nonfiction. Now specifically- Right I'm trying to figure out how to phrase the question. Is it specifically like a journalism type writing, or how does that work for nonfiction? Or I don't understand how that works.

Harrison HillYeah, yeah. It's very, it's very interesting, and frankly, I didn't know that these kind of programs existed until I took that, uh, workshop in Greece that I mentioned earlier. A writer who also was teaching there, Rachel DeWoskin, this major- amazing writer, she, she told me about these programs and, and actually wrote me a recommendation. But yes, it was not a journalism program, and it was not a fiction writing program, obviously. It was maybe what you could call, like, literary nonfiction. It was a lot of, it was a lot of people Because I, I never wanted to be, like, a newspaper reporter.

Harrison HillThat wasn't the kind of writing I enjoyed doing. I didn't wanna, like, show up at city hall and kind of hound criminals for quotes. Though frankly- Yeah that's actually what I d- I did a little bit of that for this book, now that I mention it. I wanted to do more sort of beat journalism, and so I did the program, and a lot of the people in that program, myself included, write a lot of first-person personal essay, memoir, that kind of stuff. And I certainly did that as well, and I really enjoyed that and was learning a great deal. And then I took a research class with the writer Brenda Wineapple, incredible writer, and it just really keyed me into the possibilities of a kind of writing that I, I honestly didn't really even know existed in a funny way, which is I guess you could say New Yorker style, you know, long form journalism, long form narrative literary journalism.

Harrison HillI mean, I sort of don't like using the word literary because it sort of suggests that sort of more straightforward journalism doesn't have kind of literary, uh, cred, which I don't think is necessarily the case at all. But that class really opened things up for me, and I started working on a, a project That became my thesis for graduate school, which was a completely reported project and had no first person in it whatsoever. And that led me to actually taking a class in the journalism school with a professor named Sam Freedman, who teaches this book proposal writing class every year.

Harrison HillAnd it was an amazing experience, and I wrote a book proposal for that, and I just learned the rigmarole, uh, uh, of how all that works. And it was amazing because, again, I, I do like writing from the first person, but the world is certainly infinite in terms of what, like, I can write for myself. But what's interesting to write for other people, I, I think is a little bit more limited. But the world, the volume of stuff out there is, of course, entirely infinite. And so I got really excited about that. And also, frankly, you know, there's just so many more opportunities for publishing and the possibility of having a career if you're writing outside of the personal.

Harrison HillI mean, obviously this is probably pretty obvious to your listeners, but I didn't just wanna write personal essays or even, you know, a memoir or something. I wanted to write books for the rest of my life. And so-

Brett BennerYeah

Harrison HillI'm really glad- Yeah that it kinda happened that way.

Brett BennerOkay, so I wanna get into the book. Do you have, for our, our listeners or viewers, an elevator pitch of it?

Harrison HillSo the book is called The Oracle's Daughter: The Rise and Fall of an American Cult. It tells the true story of a woman-led cult called the Aggressive Christianity Missions Training Corps, which began in Sacramento, California in the 1980s and collapsed in remote New Mexico in 2017. So the book tells the story of this group. It, it tells this, that story through the eyes of a woman named Sarah Green, whose mother founded the group. Through Sarah's eyes, we follow the growth of the group, and we also follow Sarah's escape from it and her journey to start a new life on the outside.

Harrison HillThe book is also an examination of American religious history and extremism more broadly. I wanted to think about the ways that this one particular group could say something bigger, something broader, something more universal. And so to that end, yes, there's a lot of history, and there's also just information about cults. You know, who joins? Why do they join? How do they get out? All that kind of stuff. So my hope is that it's working at a couple different altitudes, which is, that would be the, the language that my editor used sh- with me, which was always really, really helpful.

Brett BennerStephen King said,"It's terrifying, gripping, all true. I couldn't put it down, and it would make one hell of a movie," which is what I kept thinking through this whole thing. I kept thinking it was a Netflix s-series or something or, or an Apple series. Really cool, yeah. The Kirkus Review praised it as compelling and thoughtful. Book List in a star review described the book as,"A deeply compelling experience," and Publishers Weekly said,"It isn't easy to shake. Readers will be haunted," which was totally so much of what my experience was with the book as well. I think this kind of fascination with cults- Mm-hmm and then kind of having a veil lifted and seeing behind something that's so specific.

Brett BennerIt's what you expect and worse than you expect in some ways. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And that's what's so crazy about it. I know you took five years kind of investigating this and researching this world, but can you tell everybody the story of how this kind of came to you?

Harrison HillYeah, it was sort of miraculous and out of nowhere. So back in 2018, my younger brother and his wife moved to a ground floor apartment in Brooklyn, which is where I myself live. And one day, a pipe in their apartment burst and the, and the apartment flooded. Their next door neighbor saw that they were in distress, and she came on by and she helped them clean up. And so in the weeks and months that followed, they all became friendly. And eventually, this woman started opening up about herself, and she revealed that she had grown up in a cult that was run by her mother. My brother and his wife were both obviously quite interested in that and learned a little bit more.

Harrison HillAnd then my brother came to me and he said,"You know, I met this woman. She has this remarkable story. I think you-- You know, are you interested? Do you wanna meet her? I, you know, you-- Perhaps you wanna write about her." And I, and I said,"Absolutely. Of course." And so in late 2019, I got a beer with Sarah Green, the titular oracle's daughter. Her face is really big on the cover of this book. Um, I got a beer with her and, you know, those kind of meetings are always kind of like a first date. You know, you're saying, you're seeing, okay, what is your vibe? D-do, do I feel like I match with your vibe?

Harrison HillDo you feel like you match with me? Do we feel like we could have a kind of reportorial relationship, which is an extraordinarily intimate relationship? You know, she gave me a quick overview of her first story, and immediately I was like,"Oh, I'm gonna have to, I have to write about this." And so, I mean, I've said this before, but I, you know, leaving that bar, walking down Washington Avenue carrying like a little delicate egg, and I was like,"I just need to not drop this." You know, it-- Like writing about this stuff will be obviously quite difficult, but If I can get out of the way of the story enough, I think it'll work.

Harrison HillAnd so from there, I actually, I wrote an article about Sarah for The Cut, and that piece came out in 2021. And already by that point, I th- I thought, you know, this has to be a book. There's just so much more material here. And I proposed the idea to Sarah, and, and she was on board. But the book is obviously about much, much more than Sarah. So she and I continued with the interviews that I, that we'd begun years earlier, and then I sold a proposal for the book in the summer of 2022, and it came out this past spring.

Brett BennerWow. So was she instrumental then in connecting you with people like Maura, who was one of the other real integral parts of the book, one of the other, the, the three women that you kind of follow, in kind of connecting dots for you?

Harrison HillSure, yeah. So the book is basically the story of three women. It's the story of Sarah, the daughter of the cult leader and founder. It's the story of Deborah, the founder and leader. And it's the story of Maura, the first member. Um, yeah, Sarah was very helpful in introducing me to Maura and then Maura introducing me to other people, and other people in turn introducing me to others. I mean, that's the wonderful thing about having sources who are, who are open to writing about them and enthusiastic about it. You know, there's also a lot of just cold emailing, writing, calling, sending letters.

Harrison HillYou know, some people who were really helpful, sources who, who led me to some really important information are, are quite old. There's a woman in her 90s who was just hugely helpful, and I just wrote her a letter. You know, I mailed her a letter out, and I printed out a copy of the article that I'd written for The Cut, and I said,"You know, I'm working on this book and I think you may have some information that could be really helpful that I would love to hear." And so eventually one day she j- she just called me. And so I'm, I'm very much a believer in, like, you know, try all the avenues of reaching out to people, not just, not just email.

Brett BennerYeah. And what's Crazy to me about it is I think, perhaps you have an assistant, but I don't know, maybe you're working so much of this by yourself, right? And so just the sheer volume of that, even looking at your notes and sources in the back, I'm like, there's so much. I don't know how you didn't get completely overwhelmed at times.

Harrison HillI mean, I did, to be clear. Hmm. Yeah. I mean, the, the, the volume of, of reporting and research was, was quite substantial, and in some ways it was really Beginning with the article was really helpful in that sense because I knew, I was like,"Okay, I'm writing a 7,000-word magazine piece. I know how to do that. I can do that." The, the kind of reporting required for that is, is something, uh, that feels approachable. And so by the time I began working on a book proposal, I had, you know, a year and a half, two years or something like, I'm forgetting what exactly. I had a lot of reporting. I had already put that into the bucket, you know?

Harrison HillAnd so I wasn't starting from zero, and so it wasn't quite so intimidating. But yes, it was extraordinarily intimidating to just think like,"Oh, okay, I'm writing this book about this group which had dozens of members and, like, gazillion crimes, and oh, by the way, it's also a story about the history of American religion,"

Brett Benneryou know? Which is quite a large topic, and just, like, extremism.

Harrison HillI will say the thing that was actually the most intimidating, it wasn't so much the travel or the interpersonal interviews or even the reading for the history. It was the legal stuff. Just to back up a little bit, the, the climax of the book i- is a, is a trial, and I mean, I don't think that's giving too much away because the subtitle is The Rise and Fall of an American Cult. So there, so the, the legal cases, frankly, were extraordinarily complicated, and there were, like, tens upon tens of thousands of pages of legal documents I both got from, from sources, from, from public records, et cetera, all that kind of stuff.

Harrison HillAnd so just kind of making sense of that, just finding a way in, finding the necessary material without getting bogged down and spending five years or whatever flipping through these pages, that was quite hard. You know, I'm not a lawyer. I don't have a legal background. And so it was also just trying to figure out what is the vocabulary of The system, you know, how does it all kind of work? And the other thing I, uh, related to that I should mention is that I, I think that there were a lot of problems and errors in how this, this group was pursued by the law. And so you have to come to a certain level of fluency to be able to actually criticize something, you know what I mean?

Harrison HillInteresting. You can't just be like,"That's bad." You know, you have to really know the material. And so I spent a great deal of time in the material. Related to that, actually, I was saying this just to someone the other day, I think that there's a world where someone writing this kind of book might today take all those legal documents and just, like, dump them into ChatGPT and be like,"Summarize this for me." And I suppose that someone could find that useful. For me, that's just not I, I think that actually being in the documents and s- doing the slog, you actually get a sense of the texture and the, the surprise and just the, the humanity and life of the material that I just don't think you could.

Harrison HillI mean, I was hearing someone talk about this the other day, that they just, like, dumped a bunch of material on ChatGPT to help them summarize, and I thought,"Okay, I guess that could be helpful." But again, I don't think that that would serve a, a project like this. The other thing was just sort of questions of liability. Yeah. You know, because there are some really horrific crimes that are committed in this book, and I'm stating that really publicly. Yeah, and I, I tried to be really careful about it because I, I don't wanna say things that are untrue about people o- in print. And so the book was very thoroughly fact-checked.

Harrison HillThat took place over a couple months. An extraordinary fact-checker named Julie Tate, who I hired, who was just the best. She went through everything and gave it a really thorough fact check. And then the lawyer at Scribner and Simon Schuster, he was amazing, and, and just we spent two days on the phone, if I'm remembering correctly, just walking through all this material and just sort of talking about,"Where did you get this? How did y- how can you back it up?" And all those kinda things like that. And that was really interesting. It was a little nerve-wracking. You know, am I, am I covered in all these ways?

Harrison HillAnd of course, I certainly was. But the other part of it that was, that was quite, quite interesting was that, you know, the book came out in the UK as well. Wow. And their laws around free speech are, are quite different than ours are. Oh, wow. And so we actually had to cut some material for the UK version because of certain laws about what you're about to say about victims of certain crimes. And you know, these are not meaningful cuts, but they, they, they did happen.

Brett BennerIn your own life, were you somebody who was interested in cults? Is that something that fascinated you? Is it something you ever thought about?

Harrison HillNo.

Brett BennerWow,

Harrison Hillokay. To be totally honest, no, not at all. I think to some extent that was actually helpful to me as a writer because I was coming in like a reader, like a general reader might come in. Yeah. And so I knew I had a sense of what are the bigger questions someone like that might have. But of course, this book is about a cult. That's the central story. You'll laugh, but I never really thought of it that way. I always thought of it as a story about a really intense, remarkable, kind of insane family. The cult began as just four people, which is to say the husband and wife that, that began it, and the daughter and the son who were part of it from the very beginning.

Harrison HillI felt like by looking at this family, a, a family that just, uh, their, their dynamics were just at the most extreme version of what something like this could be, that that extremity might help reveal something more universal about families that are not so extreme, not so nutty, not so criminal in behavior. I will say, though, I'm quite interested in religion, and that's been an important part of my life in many different ways. And so I think I came at it The, the kind of historical and, and religious and, and cultish material.

Harrison HillI came at, I came at it from that side rather than from the kind of, like, true crime, potentially exploitative, sensationalist perspective. Part of the work of the book that I was trying to do was to so- sort of show that, yes, there's a lot that's crazy about these kind of groups, but it's not entirely crazy and that there is this real actual connection to and continuity with more mainstream religious practice. And I don't say that to, to malign or denigrate mainstream religious practice at all, only to say that the division between those two can be quite porous. And so when I say I wasn't interested in cults going into this project, there's an element of that that, that, that's true.

Harrison HillYou know, I'd never read about Jim Jones or whatever. But I very much was interested in faith and belief and belonging and all these things that are, that are central to, to religion. And so that is an interest in cults. You know, those are the things that are going on in cults as well.

Brett BennerIt's funny'cause I was thinking, first of all, It was so kind of cool driving down from the Pacific Northwest to Southern California In the midst of all this, where all of these things were taking place, like Sacramento and all these places that were being talked about, just the proliferation of cults in California alone.

Harrison HillBut- Yeah. Cultifornia, as some people

Brett Bennercall it. Cultifornia, yeah. But I grew up in that time of which a lot of this gets addressed in the book, I'm talking about it. You know, I remember being a little kid and the Charles Manson murders happening and not knowing anything about it except Helter Skelter, the book coming out. But I remember the Satanic panic you talk about in the book, which was this time period, and the McMartin trials, all of that kind of stuff. I remember growing up, and there was this sense of doom out there that this could happen to you.

Brett BennerAnd it wasn't just necessarily or only that you could get pulled into a cult, but I think as a young person, it was more that something would happen to you if you didn't kind of follow the straight and narrow. I think it just rooted for me, and I think for a lot of people, it, it started this fascination of what goes on here. And also I'm so curious your thoughts on this, about what is it that you think really draws people to them? Because Reading your research of the book and seeing that there isn't one kind of central thing that puts people in it, I, I'm so curious, what is it you think that pulls them in?

Harrison HillThat's interesting to people, that pulls in sort of consumers of culture, you mean? Yes. Or, or people into-

Brett BennerI, I, I, and both sides of it, I guess.

Harrison HillBoth, yeah. I mean, I'll start with the culture side of it because I find that especially, uh, interesting. I, I mean, I think that there's a real appeal in being close to something kind of dangerous, but not actually giving into it. I mean, I think about, like, going on a rollercoaster or something. The fun there is in this danger in the midst of safety. I think that that is, is, like, exciting. You know, if you go to a movie theater and it's a horror film, film, and you scream, you know, that's, that's fun because you're scared, but you're also safe. And so literature would do the same thing.

Harrison HillI also think that there can be a kind of comfort in reading about people who are doing something that's, like, really wild and, um, like, a little bit, you know, dangerous and criminal or whatever. There's this comfort of feeling like,"Oh, well, that's not me," you know. Like, at least, you know, my life might be a little bit wild, but it's not as wild as that. Though I will say part of what I was trying to communicate in this book is that there is more overlap than maybe we would like to think, so maybe that's not, that's not an entirely warranted comfort. I also think there's a real kind of-- Cults often have a real narrative component to them.

Harrison HillThere's-- I think they really suit themselves to books or movies or podcasts or whatever because there c- there's a very clear beginning, there's often a clear middle, and h- you know, hopefully, there's a clear ending. And the characters are great, you know. They're, they're wild. They want something desperately. You know, I think that good art is about people who are-- want something really badly and fight really hard to get it. In the case of this book, you know, Deborah Green, the leader of this cult, she believed herself to be a prophet, and she wanted to usher in, you know, an era of righteousness on the face of the Earth through, through God.

Harrison HillI mean, that kind of objective or desire doesn't get any bigger than that. And so I think that's part of what makes these stories work in a narrative sense. And then in terms of why do people just join cults, it's for many reasons that I won't, I won't list them all because they're, they're all in the book. But obviously, there's stuff about belonging. People want, people want a place to have community, to have a kind of shared common purpose. People want religious fulfillment. They want to have some spiritual foundation to their lives. There's also real material things that are, that draw people into cults, you know If you don't have a job, if you don't have a lot of money, joining a cult can give you a job.

Harrison HillIt can give you clothing and food and childcare and, you know, in a country like the US that doesn't have an especially strong social safety net, some people sort of theorize that it is that lack of a social safety net that can help explain at least some part of the proliferation of these kind of groups in the US. I think there's more going on there, but that's a little bit part of it.

Brett BennerI find it so fascinating with so many of these cults in the whole kind of movement, if we call it a movement, the kind of arc of them all seems to start with such a kind of pure intentions at the beginning of it. Mm-hmm. They really do. For sure. And how quickly they descend. Bridging of religion and sex, that's one of the things that how those intersect so quickly and how, uh, kind of a moral structure kind of goes out the window and what gets accepted and is thought just to be acceptable I don't know, and I know this was part of what you were getting at as we get through the book, but talking about not only the rise of Christian fundamentalism, but certainly what we've witnessed over the past ten years with kind of Trumpism.

Brett BennerMm-hmm. And I thought about this book a lot on election night. Mm. Because I think for a lot of people, feeling like this moment could be the start of collectively breaking out of what we've all kind of been in. But for a lot of people to kind of see the light, I guess.

Harrison HillMm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. That's interesting. I, I'm so glad, I guess, that, that, that the book, uh, came to you on election night.

Brett BennerBut I do think, you know, you're talking about this whole rise of Christian fundamentalism that has been going on, and I'm so curious about your thoughts because one of the statistics that kind of blew me away that, that you say in the 1990s, the number of private militia groups, gun cults really, exploded with an estimated nine hundred groups with more than forty thousand followers. Mm-hmm. And I wonder what those numbers are now in light of the fact- Yeah how social media connects us in ways that it never did before.

Harrison HillFor sure. Yeah. And there's, there's a lot-- I mean, yeah, I, I would wonder what that number is too. And the question of the internet and social media, that really complicates the, this idea of, like, what is a cult in some sort of interesting ways. Because traditionally, a cult would be defined by a, a number of, of qualifiers, one of which, to me at least, has always been a kind of confined physical space. People are in each other's spaces. The internet, though, complicates that because, of course, people are not in the same space. They're connected digitally. Does that mean that somebody who is being drawn into a certain kind of extremism that we might recognize as something that's kind of cultish, does that mean that it isn't a cult?

Harrison HillOr does it mean that it is and we have to just find a new definition of cult to be more elastic, or do we need a new word? Um, yeah, it's all kind of interesting.

Brett BennerIs there anything that surprised you when you were investigating all this?

Harrison HillOh, gosh. I can't think of anything off the top of my head, except-- Here's what I'll say. You know, this isn't a kind of fact, but I think something that surprised me creatively working on this was how much I enjoyed it. Um- Again, I think you maybe had in mind, like, you know, how many cults were in New Mexico or whatever. But the real, yeah, the real s- not surprise, but the sort of delight, the wonderful thing that I found, you know, as I got into it, as I continue, is that the, the creative work of it was just really satisfying and there were very difficult parts, but I was able to really take a great amount of pleasure in the process and that was key to me actually.

Harrison HillI had a kind of realization when I was midway through the book, when I was sort of stuck at a certain part of it, that I should just write towards my own pleasure. I should write the parts of the book that I think would be fun to write and that in so doing that I could create a project that would be fun and interesting to the reader as well.

Brett BennerIs there anyone, any of the kind of players in the book that you wish that you could have sat down with that you didn't get to?

Harrison HillYeah. I mean, I wish I'd been able to speak with Jim and Deborah Green, the two founders of the cult and the mother and father of Sarah Green, the Oracle's daughter, the woman whose face is on the cover of the book. I corresponded by mail with Jim for a little while. We sort of had tentative plans to speak. He ultimately decided not to speak with me. And I communicated with Deborah's lawyers a little bit in twenty twenty-one prior to the publication of the article that I wrote about the group for The Cut. And subsequent to that, they did not speak with me.

Harrison HillI mean, I, I communicated with the lawyers and ultimately they said no, Deborah would not speak with me. And then when I started writing the book, I reached out again, and I reached out many, many times in the years that followed, but she never replied, which is certainly her right, but it would've been really amazing to hear her s- perspective as well. That said, you know, this is a woman who I know to be just inveterate liar, just somebody who really is manipulative and- Perilous to the truth. Yeah, and does not, does-- is not, is not best friends with the truth. And so I think it would've been quite interesting and perhaps revealing in some ways, but I think I would have to be very credulous in kind of thinking about and using what she said.

Harrison HillYou know, she had a lot of writings that she published online. This is a really wonderful thing about writing about a cult because they have to evangelize, they have to get their message out and so this group has like hundreds of sermons online, thousands of pages of evangelizing materials, many of which have biographical content in them. So I was able to get a lot of material there. But yeah, I wish I'd, I wish I'd gotten to speak with Deborah. I'm especially interested to speak with her now because of some developments that have taken place legally over the past year.

Brett BennerAnd see, I'm one of those people that was poring through the internet because I wanted a visual of all these people. Deborah in particular, it's fascinating because you see the young picture of her.

Harrison HillRight.

Brett BennerAnd that evolution is startling. Um-

Harrison HillRight.

Brett BennerAnd kind of how very handsome he was, Jim was. I mean, they were this very, like, attractive couple and,

Harrison Hillum- Very physically attractive. Yeah, that was part of their appeal. Yeah. It really was. Just you mentioned, the way that sex plays a part in this story, and I actually think that this, what you're talking about here, the, the physical appeal of these people. Again, you know, Sara would always tell me that a lot of men joined because they found Deborah to be just incredibly beautiful, and she was quite beautiful.

Brett BennerIt is one of these books and one of these stories that at times you're so frustrated and angry for some of the people in the book, including Sara, including Maura, but also asking yourself,"What would I do in that situation?" And of course, I think many people would feel like,"Well, I'd get out of it. I don't understand why they just didn't walk away," without really understanding. You know, easier said than done, right? And I think of so much of Maura's story in particular and the relationships she had with Deborah and with Jim previous to this exploding into what it was and the closeness that they felt.

Brett BennerIt's a little bit like the lobster in the pot who just doesn't- Right feel the heat turning up, and then it's too late. Absolutely.

Harrison HillYeah, I mean, they always say nobody joins a cult. They join what they think is, like, a kind of especially devoted religious group, and it's only by gradually becoming more and more enmeshed in the group that the level of abuse or intimidation or something really reveals itself. And by that point, you've maybe abandoned so much of your life on the outside world that it becomes much harder to think about returning to the life that you once had. I mean, maybe you, you cut off your family, maybe you, you quit your job, maybe you gave all your money to the leaders of the group.

Harrison HillMaybe you don't have a place to live anymore. Your entire identity at this point is pinned to this, to this group. And so it becomes that much more difficult to not only actually leave, but to even imagine what it would be like to leave. If you can't think about, you know,"Where would I go the first night that I leave?" If you don't really have an answer for that, that, that's, it's quite intimidating.

Brett BennerYeah, and that part of the book- resonated with me so much and what it means for so many people reestablishing themselves in life. Yeah. What people are eating and what people are doing and what people are talking about and, and what any of it means, and to be in a place where you are so cut off from everyone except for the people around you disseminating the information to you. I don't know, my mind is kind of blown by that whole thing. And I think people reading this will-- I think it should make you question, what would I do in that situation? Would I get pulled into that situation? Mm-hmm. How would I cope in that situation?

Harrison HillThe epigraph for the book is this William James quote from his book, The Varieties of Religious Experience, which is an extraordinary book. But the quote is,"The sanest and best of us are of one clay with lunatics and prison inmates." This idea that we're, we're basically made of the same stuff. And so I hope that the book helps people kind of feel the, what it i-- what the, what it is that the characters who were enmeshed in this cult felt, which is to say they felt like they couldn't leave in many cases.

Harrison HillUm, hopefully, the book mimics a version of that, so you, you kind of understand that. I think that there are particular challenges for parents, and more specifically mothers who are in these kind of groups, because it's not just a question of them leaving, it's also a question of Okay, my two, three, four, whatever children, uh, h-how would, how am I gonna, what am I gonna do about them? Am I gonna bring them with me? Am I gonna leave them here? How am I physically gonna get off of this location without alerting the leaders of, of a group?

Harrison HillUh, you know, that, that I, that I'm leaving with, like, four children in tow, children who might be making noise. And then there's just all these, like, practical challenges as well. You know, it's hard enough to start a new life in the world as one person. It's certainly much harder to begin if you have a caravan of children with you. This is a conundrum that Sarah faced in this book, which is in some ways sort of the central conundrum. At the beginning of the book, the very, very beginning, and I'm not giving anything away because this is literally in the first four pages of the book. The beginning i- is in nineteen ninety-nine when twenty-six-year-old Sarah decides she has to get out of this group, which at this point is based way, way, way in the rural New Mexico desert.

Harrison HillAnd so she pulls herself out of her sleeping bag, grabs a backpack, and runs away with another member. She decides to leave her three children behind, and that was a really difficult and agonizing decision for her, and one that she ultimately chose because she felt like, you know,"I can't begin in the outside world with these three children. I have to get settled. I have to get established. I'll come back for them later, and, you know, in the meantime, I'll just figure things out on my own." Of course, reality was a little bit different. I won't say more about that, but the fact of the children was, was enormously complicating.

Harrison HillAnd it was also in some ways actually motivating for her because she wanted to have a better life for those children. It was by seeing how they were mistreated that she was in some ways able to see how she and other members were mistreated. That's something that's consistent with other people's experiences in cults, specifically mothers, that it is by witnessing what their children go-- are going through that they can recognize,"Oh, maybe what I'm going through is not so great either." You know, the people can be okay with their own suffering, but they're not suff-- they're not okay with the suffering of their children. And so they have what's called an escape hatch relationship with those kids.

Harrison HillThose kids provide something that is not oriented exclusively around the leader or the doctrine of the cult. It gives them a little window out, and they are able to get out. That's a term I should give credit to this, um, writer, Alexandra Stein, who has an extraordinary book called Terror, Love and Brainwashing that, that gets into all this stuff

Brett BennerThe story's fascinating. I don't really wanna get too much into more of it because I don't-

Harrison HillYeah, no, for sure

Brett BennerI don't wanna ruin. There's a whole sequence with Sarah that is so incredible where she goes overseas that I don't wanna talk about at all, but I do wanna talk about. Yeah. But I don't wanna talk about because people really need to experience that and the reasons why and what ultimately becomes of that, which is just unbelievable. The book is fantastic. It's amazing. I can't say enough good things about it. Um, al- also it's not lost on me that this is Nonfiction November in the book world, so if you are looking for- Oh, is it? If this is nonfiction- I didn't know

Harrison Hillsuch a thing existed. Well, happy Nonfiction

Brett BennerNovember. Yeah, maybe that's only in the Bookstagram world, but for, for everybody out there, yeah, Nonfiction November they call it. So if anyone's looking for a fantastic nonfiction book, please, please, please check this out and buy independent if you can. But Harrison, um, it's such a pleasure. I'm so excited to see what your next subject is going to be.

Harrison HillYeah, yeah. Nothing to do with cults. No more cults.

Brett BennerYeah, exactly. That's all I'll say. You're culted out for the moment.

Harrison HillI've said everything I have to say about them.

Brett BennerWell, thank you so much for being here. I really appreciate it.

Harrison HillThank you so much, Brett. A real treat.

Brett BennerThank you again, Harrison. If you've liked this conversation or other conversations that you've heard on Behind the Stack, please consider liking and subscribing so that you never miss an episode. And if you have the time, what would be really helpful to me is if you can give this show five stars on your podcast platform of choice I will be back next week with another episode, and until then, you can always find me on Instagram, Substack, and YouTube at Brett's Book Stack. And as always, thanks for listening

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Lucy Tan, Tiger's Mouth

    Nov 17, 202632 minAudio

    Brett sits down with Lucy Tan to discuss her sophomore novel, 'Tiger's Mouth'. They talk indie bookstores, writing male protagonists, class and privilege, her approach to writing at the start of a book, some book seller...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Chad Harbach, The Brightness

    Nov 3, 202630 minAudio

    Brett sits down with Chad Harbach to discuss his sophomore novel, 'The Brightness'. They talk revisiting characters from, 'The Art Of Fielding' and why go back, writing a book about female friendship and feminism, a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Mary Beth Keane, Whale Harbor

    Oct 27, 202630 minAudio

    Brett sits down with Mary Beth Keane to discuss her latest novel and Good Morning America Book Club Pick, 'Whale Harbor" They talk all things Irish: extended large families, including her own, the rural setting,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Will Maclean, Solace House

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Brett sits down with author Will Maclean to discuss his American debut, 'Solace House'. They talk about reading snobbery, his past writing in comedy, horror narratives, writing sympathetic characters in the genre, The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Bonnie Garmus, Peck & Peck

    Oct 13, 202639 minAudio

    In his 100th episode, Brett sits down with Bonnie Garmus to discuss her new book, 'Peck & Peck'. They have a 'Lessons in Chemistry' check in, they talk poets as oracles, the downside to AI, the need for artists, and an...

    Credit the people on this episode