In his 100th episode, Brett sits down with Bonnie Garmus to discuss her new book, 'Peck & Peck'. They have a 'Lessons in Chemistry' check in, they talk poets as oracles, the downside to AI, the need for artists, and an unlikely friend in Essex. Bonnie's website: https://www.bonniegarmus.com/ Bonnie Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bonnie_garmus_author/ If you like what you're hearing on this podcast please subscribe so you never miss an episode! Watch Behind the Stack on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@brettsbookstack Bookshop.org page: https://www.bookshop.org/shop/brettsbookstack Brett's instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bretts.book.stack Behind the Stack email: brettsbookstack@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Brett BennerHey, everybody, it's Brett Benner and welcome back to another episode of Behind the Stack. Today's guest I was really excited to talk with because her debut novel was one of my favorite books the year it came out. I know it was for so many of you. It was made into an Apple TV series as well. She is back with a new book set in the publishing world, specifically of poetry. She, of course, is Bonnie Garmus. The book I was talking about was Lessons in Chemistry, and her new book is called Peck Peck.
Brett BennerA little bit about Bonnie. She is a coffee-dependent American novelist. Hey, everybody, it's Bret Benner and welcome back to Behind the Stack. Today is a special episode for me, not just because of the author, but also because today is the hundredth episode of Behind the Stack. I am so thrilled to have gotten this far. I never thought when I started this thing that I would have reached a hundred episodes. So first of all, I just want to thank all of the publicists, all of the marketing executives, and all of the authors who have agreed to come on the show.
Brett BennerBut most of all, I want to thank all of you listeners and viewers for continuing to show up and for telling your friends and continuing to help this podcast grow. I so appreciate it. Now, on to today's guest. I loved this author's first book so much, as I know so many of you did. It was one of my favorites the year it came out, so I am so thrilled to be sitting down with her for her second book. She is, of course, Bonnie Garmus. The book was Lessons in Chemistry, and her new book is called Peck Peck.
Brett BennerA little bit about Bonnie. She is a coffee-dependent American novelist. Best opening ever. Her debut novel, Lessons in Chemistry, was a Good Morning America Book Club pick, a Goodreads Best Book of the Year, and a Barnes Noble Book of the Year. It spent nearly two years on The New York Times bestseller list, nearly three years on Der Spiegel, was selected as one of the top one hundred books in the twenty-first century by readers of The New York Times, and was voted number five of Australia's ABC Radio Top one hundred Books of the Twenty-first Century.
Brett BennerSelected by Queen Camilla for the Queen's Reading Room, it has been honored with sixteen other international literary awards. Translated into more than forty languages, it was made into an Apple TV limited series. Peck Peck is her second novel. So I hope you enjoy this one-hundredth episode of Behind the Stack And I, um, I am thrilled to be sitting down today with Bonnie Garmus for her wonderful new book, Peck Peck.
Brett BennerIt is, it is just so delightful to have you here. Also because I did not have this podcast during your first book, and Lessons in Chemistry was such an amazing book. I loved it so, so, so, so much. And so- Thank you the fact that have something else and I can sit down with you today is just so exciting for me. So thank you so much for being here.
Bonnie GarmusOh, thank you. I was so great- I was so happy to get the invitation.
Brett BennerI'm so curious before we dive into Peck Peck, you know, kind of post Lessons in Chemistry, I just am so curious, like the, the show business person in me. Yeah. How was the whole adaption process for you with it, you know, the Apple TV series?
Bonnie GarmusOh, you know, the people were so great, honestly, at Apple and at Aggregate Films. And for me, I, I didn't write the series. I wasn't really involved. Right. And I think that's probably a healthy position- for a novelist to be in, because you know, and I was warned of course, but you also know because you've seen so many books adapted, that they're gonna change things. And it's your- Yeah child, and so you don't really want your child to change, but you have to embrace that there will be changes. And so I just thought everybody was really wonderful.
Bonnie GarmusThey were really great to me, and I feel incredibly lucky that my book got made into a series. And I will say that I remember a bunch of people saying,"Oh, you know, but it'll never get made," or,"If it does get made, it'll take, it'll be 10 years from now." Boy, they just, they just did it. So. Yeah,
Brett Bennerthey really did.
Bonnie GarmusYeah. I was very lucky.
Brett BennerI did think you had an incredible cast. And honestly, I think that was one of the first times I'd ever seen Lewis Pullman, and I thought he was so wonderful. Yeah. And, uh, and so it's been fun to kind of watch his trajectory. And I- Yeah thought he was so great in, uh, Remarkably Great Creatures as well. But yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I thought she was wonderful, too. I, I really- Oh,
Bonnie Garmusabsolutely I,
Brett BennerI really thought... I thought it was a great cast.
Bonnie GarmusYeah. Yeah, I did too. Thank you.
Brett BennerI don't know if you're a writer who visualizes as you're writing, like if you're creating a character, I'm curious now, a- as I'm saying this. If there's an essence of someone that you have in your head, or, or you're really, as you're creating someone, it is- It is not, you don't see an actor per se, it's just a, uh, a character you're creating.
Bonnie GarmusIt, it is just a character I'm creating. I, it was, just getting back to Lessons in Chemistry for a moment, I, they actually asked me if I had anybody in mind to play certain roles, and it had never occurred to me to think of an actor for the roles, which I realize maybe puts me in the minority. But, uh, when I did give them my list of people I thought would be great, they just went,"Uh-huh," and then I think threw it away. Anyway, you know, they, they, they chose very well, so I have no problem with that. No, I don't, I don't envision an actor in any of these roles, although I do mention one actor.
Bonnie GarmusBut it, it's, it's really just that I see the person in my head. I see what they're wearing, I see what their habits are, I see what they're trying to hide from me. And yeah, I just see them as an individual, completely different from anyone I've met. Well, not completely different obviously, but I just see them so clearly in my head, and then I just write it down.
Brett BennerI love that.
Bonnie GarmusAnd then I rewrite it a thousand times.
Brett BennerBut now h- how about as a reader? When you're reading things, do you visualize people? 'Cause sometimes I read and I just see a vague, I don't really s- sometimes I don't see a person necessarily. I get an essence of the person without seeing them. Do you ever read and think,"Oh, this person would be amazing as this"?
Bonnie GarmusNo. I mean, isn't this terrible? I, I, it's- No,
Brett BennerI don't. I think it's gonna- And
Bonnie GarmusI, I, well, I love, you know, I love movies, film, uh, TV, things like that. But n- you know, when I read a book, part o- I don't listen very often to audiobooks because I like to do all the voices in my head. Yeah. And, uh, and I like to imagine this person. So for me, um, giving that away is part of the fun. I like to, I like to hear it all in my head.
Brett BennerI love that. I love that. Yeah, it's very rare. It's, it's, like I said, I, I'll read and it's, it's almost like the face is kind of blanked out. It's almost after the fact, and I don't really a- almost wanna read something if it's already been adapted because then I'm gonna be stuck with that person kind of in my consciousness.
Bonnie GarmusSo. That's it. I know, me too. I'm the same way, so I, I always try to read the book first.
Brett BennerI'm so curious. Uh, now, n- like, with your second book, obviously,'cause,'cause Lessons was so huge, how does this feel for you? You're on the precipice of the second book come out, and obviously, this is coming with so much expectation and a very different initial publicity rollout, right? Yeah. How are you feeling?
Bonnie GarmusWell, it's so funny because I, I must be, I think, the most naive person in the world. I never considered that there'd be any expectation. I just, um, I think part of that is age. You just sort of give up on that and, and you just go,"No, I'm just gonna do what I feel is right." You know, I have a lot of experience, so I'm just gonna write what I wanna write and what I feel is really important to say right now. And so it's funny because in the book, I talk about the weight of expectation- Mm-hmm and how that can actually ruin people. And, you know, you, you decide who someone is or what they're going to do based on your expectation of what they should do.
Bonnie GarmusAnd I kind of ignored that for myself, and now I'm realizing people are going,"Uh, no, we had expectations that you were writing the sequel to Lessons in Chemistry." Sorry. Surprise. Um, but- Yeah but I couldn't do that because this novel is all about originality, creativity, inventing new things, and, uh, and that's what I really wanted to accomplish. So it's, for me, it's been great and, um, the publicity and everything, it's been wonderful. Uh, and it is different because there, people do know about Lessons in Chemistry, so- Yeah it's great to see people coming to the book and going,"Oh."
Brett BennerYeah. Yeah. No, I'm sure. It... Did the idea for the book start to germinate soon after you'd finished Lessons in Chemistry, or when did it start for you?
Bonnie GarmusAnd it started in 2009. Wow,
Brett Bennerokay. I had a...
Bonnie GarmusYeah, I was-- Well, I was actually here in Seattle. I was working for a lot of technology companies as a consultant. I was a copywriter, creative director consultant. And so I just remember at that time, I was beginning to feel kind of discouraged about the way technology was going. It seemed like what had once been really fresh and innovative and interesting and, and meant for the common good was slowly turning into,"How much money can we make from this?" It was turning into greed. Instead of don't be evil, it was more like, you know,"Be evil,'cause we're gonna make a lot of money that way." And I was really struggling with that.
Bonnie GarmusUm, and so I had an idea. I was driving home one day, and I, I was listening to NPR, and I heard a Nikki Giovanni poem read on the radio, and it's called"The Laws of, of Logic." And it really struck me,'cause I hadn't heard that poem since I was 14. I'm not a big- Mm poetry person. I am kinda now, but I wasn't then. And when I heard that piece, I j- I j- just went,"Oh, wait a minute." And it sorta brought this whole idea of what is substance? What is value in our lives? What really matters?
Bonnie GarmusWhat are we leaving behind when we leave this earth? And- Mm and that's when the idea for Peck Peck came in. It's, it's, uh, it's not obviously based in technology, but it is about originality. It is about preserving substance. It is about value, and so it is very, very much anti-AI.
Brett BennerSo did this start for you in terms of germinating before Lessons in Chemistry?
Bonnie GarmusYeah, before Lessons in Chemistry, and then I put it aside because I was so taken, uh, by A Bad Day at Work that I wrote Lessons in Chemistry instead, and I put this idea aside. And then, you know, it's really interesting because I was on a plane going to an event for Lessons in Chemistry, and all of a sudden, I thought, I was reading this thing a ex-colleague of mine had written about where some technology was going, was heading, and it all came flooding back to me about how much I thought that was the wrong direction.
Bonnie GarmusAnd I started writing Peck Peck then on the plane.
Brett BennerWow. That's crazy, but really cool. It's
Bonnie Garmusa little weird, yeah.
Brett BennerHave you always been a writer, like even when you were young?
Bonnie GarmusYeah, I, I, um, I'm really proud to say that I wrote my first book when I was five. I illustrated it. It's a page long. No publisher wants to read it. I also wrote another book when I was 12, and it was over 200 pages, and, uh, my librarian bound it and put it in the school library, and no one ever checked it out. And, um, and then I wrote another book, and that was rejected 98 times. And then I wrote Lessons in Chemistry, and now I've written Peck Peck.
Brett BennerWow. All right, so for our viewers and our listeners, do you have an elevator pitch for Peck Peck?
Bonnie GarmusFor Peck Peck? Boy, you know, I've been trying to come up-
Brett BennerOh, you're gonna be doing this so much.
Bonnie GarmusI... Well, you know, I'm so bad at elevator pitches, and that's bad, right? Because I'm from advertising. But I would just say Peck Peck is about a young man who doesn't quite know who he is and is a little ashamed of the talent that he has, which is an ear for poetry. That is a skill absolutely no employer cares about or wants. But he does find one employer who's interested in that, and when he takes a job there, the adventure begins.
Brett BennerOkay, so the big question is, and you started to interestingly talk about it for a moment, but why poetry? Like, what is it? Especially'cause I just said, I, my first thought was,"Oh, clearly she's a huge poetry fan."
Bonnie GarmusI know. I'm sorry, poets everywhere, but I wasn't. I'm not. I, um, I, it's, you know, let's face it, a lot of people don't like poetry. I was one of them. I, I completely understand that, and that's why I wanna reassure readers that this book isn't littered with poetry. What it's trying to do is just teach you about an art that is so undervalued, but is so, so important in our lives. You know, when we attend funerals or weddings or inaugurations or graduations, we hear poetry, and there's a reason for that.
Bonnie GarmusAnd I think when we discover that we turn to the poets during our most tragic and most vulnerable times, our happiest times, that says something. So what is it that these people provide us? I wanted to really get into that. But really, the book, besides poetry, is exploring these underfunded, overlooked art forms, including-
Brett BennerHmm
Bonnie Garmustypography. None of which we can live without, all of which continue to exist without our help. In other words, they don't go extinct, no matter how much we don't seem to use them. And the fact is, they do hold the key, I think, to our very humanity. And so I really wanted to bring that out in a fun way in a book.
Brett BennerDid you know that there was actually a hosiery shop called Peck Peck? Yes.
Bonnie GarmusDid
Brett Benneryou see this?
Bonnie GarmusI know. Yes, yes. A woman said,"Oh, I'm so glad you've written about this department store," and I went,"What department store?"
Brett BennerYeah. And I love that it said, it expanded to a 78-store chain, um, and it was known for women's wear that defined traditional WASP fashion.
Bonnie GarmusPerfect. There's the
Brett Bennerbook. Which I was like- Yeah what is WASP fashion? You don't talk about it? You know what I mean? Like- Oh, right if, like, if it's uncomfortable, you don't say anything.
Bonnie GarmusYeah, right. Right. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. But you look very neat and put together.
Brett BennerTh- that's exactly right. One of the two brothers,'cause there's this kind of r- recurring motif of twins in the book. Mm-hmm. Batter, who's our protagonist, had a twin who died at birth, which kind of haunts him, and then going into Peck and Peck, these twins are the head of it. One of them, who's kind of the businessman- Mm-hmm is at the head. But I think it's Declonius. Did I pronounce his name correctly?
Bonnie GarmusYes. Yeah.
Brett BennerYes. And Declonius is kind of more the more, the more creative side of the two brothers. Yeah. And he says at one point that he thinks great poets are oracles, and it really affirms for him that the idea of wisdom still exists. Mm-hmm. Do you think that? Do you feel that?
Bonnie GarmusAbsolutely. Absolutely. You know, I subscribe to get a poem a day from the Poetry Foundation. It's the best thing I ever did. I read just one poem a day. Well, sometimes two. I cannot believe how much I learn from the poets in the nine years I've been doing that, and it, it's given me a lot of hope. It's also given me a lot of anger and passion. You know, like, we can do a lot better, and the poets come from thousands of years ago or, or two years ago or whatever. They're still writing really powerful work, and the great thing about poetry is that it's, it's economical.
Bonnie GarmusIt's really small. You can read something and get fed, have your soul fed and your brain piqued within, you know, five minutes. I'm a little jealous about that as a novelist because they are so much more economical than I am. But yeah, I think that they're really important.
Brett BennerI've never been a poetry person either, but I'm finding out, I almost said at this point in my life, it's something I'm discovering more. Like, I used to say, like,"I don't like poetry. I'm not really a short story fan." Right. And yet I find myself coming back to both of those kind of styles of writing. And both of them, like you said, in terms of economy, that's so much of what they're doing with both formats. But I'm also someone, and I don't know about you, I love poets who then move to prose and write a prose book. I find myself always saying,"Oh my God, it's so beautiful, and what they can do with words, it's so incredible," in, in a way that I, you know, y- I just don't always see.
Brett BennerAnd so at al- I'm always saying to myself,"I really should be going back and reading more," because poetry's changed as well in terms of- Yeah even narratively what people- Yeah are doing with poetry. It's so fascinating.
Bonnie GarmusYeah, it's, it's one of the very few arts that really evolves a lot, a lot. It's not afraid to change. And I think it's a great lesson for us in poetry, actually. This is an art form that continues to exist even though a lot of people don't like it. When people actually discover what it is,'cause I had a lot of preconceived notions, when they actually start reading just little bits of it, I think they'll be shocked. I was personally stunned by how much I didn't know. And, you know, in terms of poetry, there's a theme that kinda runs through the book of, uh, couplets, which are the twins.
Bonnie GarmusWe always expect couplets to rhyme. That's the weight of expectation. We always think that things should be harmonious, and that twins should always get along. But just the opposite is true. And I wanted to have this kind of theme of expectation versus reality throughout the book, lies versus the truth. We live in a very divisive time, and I kinda wanted to bring that out in terms of the two brothers and what's important to them and what's important to the world at large. But also what we can all do about moving our society forward and our culture forward.
Bonnie GarmusBecause the arts are our culture. That's the beauty in the world, and it needs protection right now. It needs a lot of protection.
Brett BennerYeah. It's not lost on me that we're sitting here talking about this today, which is Banned Books Week. Yeah. And, um, and, and thinking about the amount of books that continue to grow that, that a very small group of people are dictating-
Bonnie GarmusYes
Brett Benneryou can't see this or why you should see this. And we know for a fact now, especially when you're getting into young people, how much words save them, and how much words and books help people to be seen and understood in ways that they possibly wouldn't be.
Bonnie GarmusThat's exactly it
Brett BennerI also like the idea with the duality of the twins, the capitalism- Yes versus creativity that really starts- Yeah to exist. You have these two brothers, Declonius, who I've quoted before, and then Sultan-
Bonnie GarmusMm-hmm
Brett BennerPeck, who's almost frankly Trumpian in- Yes. um, in, in the way that he manages his staff, the way that he talks to people. Yeah. Everything about him. And I also love that you've assembled this group, the, sort of the 39 editors who are, are working under him. They're from all over the world. Mm-hmm. It's almost like you've assembled this UN of-
Bonnie GarmusExactly.
Brett BennerYes. Of, of editors from everywhere who are coming at this with all different kind of ideas.
Bonnie GarmusYeah.
Brett BennerAnd okay, now this is me stretching.
Bonnie GarmusOkay, good. Stretch
Brett Benneraway. But, but I did feel like when I was, when I-'cause you know, y- another thing you talked about really briefly in the beginning that I wanted to talk about was typefacing.
Bonnie GarmusMm-hmm.
Brett BennerAnd typefaces, and you, when you get into typefaces and what we know as, like, Helvetica or whatever, but then there's also all these various fonts that fall underneath individual headings. And to me, it's almost as if these various editors were different fonts that have been created in, under these typefaces. That's how I kind of view it. Oh my
Bonnie GarmusGod, you're brilliant. I love that. Oh, that's great. Uh, I think that's a fantastic way to look at it. The truth about typography is that every typeface is a family. It's called a family. It's a family for a reason. All the letters have to work together, um, and, and they have to be kerned correctly together to work together. Um, there's some infighting sometimes within families. Like, you usually have to kern a K to sit correctly on a headline, for instance, because it, you know, it, it's, it's its own little force.
Bonnie GarmusUm, there are lots of letters like that. Every typeface, every family expresses an emotion, every single one. And so it directly influences what you're reading. So you might think,"Oh yeah, you know, I'm reading this and, you know, it's very academic." Well, a lot of that comes from the typeface. Mm. And we don't really realize that. We're still using typefaces that were created 2,000 years ago. I love that, and I think it's really important. It's one of... It's sort of like poetry. It's an overlooked art. I did go to art school, and I studied typography, which is why it's in the book.
Bonnie GarmusI had to write about one thing I knew about. And that was typography. But I think it's, it's one of the most beautiful arts that we have, and people are still creating typefaces toda- today, and they're fantastic, the kind of emotion those deliver.
Brett BennerIt's really, really cool. And I never, and again, frankly before this, I never thought about it. I was just like,"Oh, typefaces." And you do have, I find if I'm writing something, and I'm sure other people do, you have, I find, an inclination towards,"Oh, this makes me feel good," or,"I wanna write with this particular thing." Uh-huh. Like, I had a very brief point in my life when I was putting things in Comic Sans, just'cause I was like,"Wow." I
Bonnie Garmushope it was brief.
Brett BennerYes, it's... I know. Right. Right. Like a little bit of whimsy. Many people don't admit
Bonnie Garmusthat.
Brett BennerRight. It's a little bit of whimsy, and then I'm like,"Grow up." But yeah. I also love the character of Batter. I love his idealism. I also love that you created a character who goes into this world of poetry, who doesn't believe or doesn't feel that he's not a writer of poetry. He's cognizant of that, but he really recognizes the beauty of it.
Bonnie GarmusWell, I think, you know, a lot of editors are not writers. I think one part of the editorial responsibility that is constantly overlooked and is actually what they, they do, what they excel at, is finding the work that should be read. Now- Mm I do think we need more editors out there, because sometimes it can get way too narrow. Um, that's why I have my United Nations of, of editors. That's why Peck Peck has 39, not 3. It takes a lot to identify new voices.
Bonnie GarmusIt takes a lot of education, enormous amount of reading, a lot of ideas, and you're looking for a fresh voice. And so I really wanted to kind of celebrate that part of editorial, that the responsibility these people have, they're determining what the rest of the world reads. Yeah. And that, to me, is enormous responsibility, and I think we should be quite serious about making sure that there are as many voices that get heard as possible by these editors.
Bonnie GarmusAnd, and that's how we get more culture into our culture, more diversity, more interest. That's how we become a better world, I think, because we listen to each other.
Brett BennerYeah. What's startling to me as I was going back through the book, and you alluded to it earlier in terms of your job, in terms of what you kind of were seeing on the horizon, but that you really started writing this book, which is a kind of manifesto against AI- Yeah in a lot of ways. Mm-hmm. And, and what's coming down, and the kind of demise of creativity. Mm-hmm. And I think it's pretty cool that you even, that you could see it so far ahead when so many of us couldn't.
Bonnie GarmusWell, they, you know, AI has been around forever, and way back in the early 2000s, I was sitting in meetings where they were debating whether or not to move forward. And you know what? Cooler heads presided, and everyone said,"No. No. It's uncontrollable. It's dangerous." That was smart. You know, and, and even back then people were saying,"If you go down that road, it has to be regulated." That's another area where we need all hands on deck. You know? Not just the United States, not just a few people in Silicon Valley.
Bonnie GarmusWe need people all over the world whose voices need to be on this because it's that powerful and that dangerous. It's also not very well-written right now. It's the, the ChatGPTs and Clods, they're cloddish. They're, it's bad code, and, you know, I'm, I'm gonna defend that statement to my death because it is absolutely bad code. And they know it. And that's what I really don't like. I think, um, it was really important then when I saw it coming to think,"Well, luckily there's so many people who know that this is a dangerous thing.
Bonnie GarmusThese people won't let it go forward." And it did. And I'm as shocked as anyone else. Um, but yeah, I did see it coming, but it wasn't just because I was somehow prescient. It was because we talked about it.
Brett BennerYeah. It's just so frightening to me. Uh, and also because the way the progress moves, especially in regards to technology, and it's almost a, this kind of unharnessed, like wild stable of horses. Mm-hmm. It starts to run, and then something like this, where does it reach the point where it gets ahead of all of us, and- Mm-hmm and no one could stop it? Right. And if the people who aren't... You know, even I was watching Bill Gates the other day was in an interview talking about all this, and kind of, again, sounding the alarm on it and saying, and his wasn't even about a kind of annihilation due to, say, starting a war, but it was more about kind of creating, you know, pathogens that could wipe us all out.
Brett BennerYeah. But then thinking about those, watching these books that were being acquired and destroyed and fed- Yeah into these systems-
Bonnie GarmusYeah
Brett Bennerjust to give more information to I don't know. It's just this, it's, it's, it's, it's pushing us all towards this kind of age of stupidity is the way I look at it, because- It is like we're all... I look at that movie WALL-E, the Disney- Yeah the Pixar film from years ago. Yeah. Of a bunch of people just sitting around being fed food and ingesting information without having to actually think- Right or be creative.
Bonnie GarmusScientists, you know, at MIT and other big universities have, have proven it's making us stupid. You know, students' test scores are rock bottom now. Do you really want someone, uh, to operate on you- That's right who spent 15 minutes in cardiology? You know, I can't believe that we even have to explain this to people, but that is also kind of the byproduct of this, is that they're selling you ease and efficiency. It's anything but. They're selling you conformity and control and fascism.
Bonnie GarmusThat's right. It is far easier to control stupid people, and we don't- Yes wanna turn into a world of stupid people. But that is the goal. I am positive that is the goal
Brett BennerNo, I agree with you 100%. It's conformity, and it's making sure that these very few people at the top who are building their bunkers and doing all the things- Yeah you know, even watching an interview the other day with Peter Thiel, and they asked him about something about the end of, you know, humanity, about the so- so many of these things moving towards that. And he had to pause- Yeah literally to think about the question for a second, like how bad would it be for the race to be effectively annihilated.
Brett BennerBecause in his mind, I'm sure he, he believes that he'll survive. Yeah. Um, you know, it's just everybody else. And so there'll be these select people that are left over. And it now makes me so mad, to be perfectly honest, when I see people posting on, say, Instagram, like,"This is me in my'80s uniform."
Bonnie GarmusOh, I know.
Brett BennerLike-
Bonnie GarmusI know
Brett Bennerbecause I'm like-
Bonnie GarmusYou're not gonna make the'80s, by the way.
Brett BennerNo, no. And, and you know, we were kids that grew up and you were sent out of the house on a summer day. Your mother pushed you out of the house. Yeah. You would come back maybe at lunchtime, and then you weren't home again till dinner. Right. And your whole day was creativity. You were playing- Yeah and making things up. And I start- Yeah to think, like, how do we continually manifest it? How do we... And, and you know, and I guess maybe that's the Batter Gray in me. I don't know.
Bonnie GarmusNo, it's great. It's great that there's a Batter Gray in you because that is what he's fighting for. He's the most average person, you know, in the world. Um, he doesn't expect to become anything important. But all of us are ordinary in that way. We only become extraordinary when we stand up to these big- Yes forces and when we speak out. And a lot of people are still afraid to speak out, but now's the time because now your life is being threatened. It's not just your income, which is also being threatened, or your job. Well, those are, are, those are going away.
Bonnie GarmusBut your very soul, your, your life, your children's life.
Brett BennerThat's it. That's it. And that's the thing that comes back to me the whole time, too, is these people who are in these positions, their children, their grandchildren, how are you expecting- Yeah to continue a life for them and what it all- Right means. And that's-
Bonnie GarmusRight
Brett Bennerbig part of it. I do love that Batter stands up. He is this ordinary guy. And I feel like so much of who he is and his kind of backbone and the, and the way that he was raised is his mom. Yes. And I loved her, Rainey. And I think the way that she approaches him and the way that she just talks about how to be is such a cool thing. So I read somewhere, and I don't necessarily disagree with this, that they said Rainey and her parenting style is a little bit like what Elizabeth Zott would've been if we saw her raise a kid.
Brett BennerAnd I kind of agree- Yeah with that.
Bonnie GarmusYeah. I mean, I like, I like Rainey. I mean, she's different in one way from Elizabeth Zott. Elizabeth Zott was so logical and nonsensica- Yeah I mean, and, and, and I think Rainey sounds Sounds nonsensical. She sounds a little bit off, you know? Whereas Elizabeth Zott was never a little bit off. She was just determined and like,"This is it. This is what we're doing." Um, but I love writing Rainie because she does have these apocryphal stories that she tells about her dog, and she's trying to teach her son how to grow and be a, a person through these dog stories that sound completely made up.
Bonnie GarmusAnd she explores all of these different facets of human psychology from anxiety to narcissism to, you know, uh, self-esteem, low self-esteem, depression. She goes through it all, and she just picks it apart and goes,"Look This is all coming at you. You've gotta understand how this is gonna work, and you've gotta understand how to get past it, and here's what my dog did. And I love it how she always just shoves it on the dog,"And here's what the dog did." Um, but yeah, no, for me, she was one of my favorite characters to write, and of course, she had to be the topographer.
Brett BennerYeah, that's, I know, that's brilliant. We should also tell our listeners and our viewers that Batter got his name from the dog. Like, that- Yeah was the dog's name. Yeah. And that's what, that's what she named him after. Yeah. You have quite an affinity for the canines, which I love. I
Bonnie Garmusknow.
Brett BennerUh.
Bonnie GarmusI know,
Brett BennerI
Bonnie Garmusknow. I- Because you've- Yeah
Brett Benneryou've written two books with great dogs in them. I mean, both of them. Do, do you still have, you have a, you had a greyhound, yes?
Bonnie GarmusYeah, she passed away unfortunately. We're,
Brett Bennerum-
Bonnie GarmusOh, I'm sorry. Yeah, no, it's okay. She was, she was, um, she was old and, uh, she was ready to go. But what a, what a gift she was in our lives. I mean, we're so lucky to have her, you know. I wish dogs could last forever, but they don't. But yeah, I admire animals so much, beyond our own species. I have a lot of admiration for a lot of different species and, and dogs are just one of them. Birds are another. Actually, I don't think I don't admire any other sp- I admire all of them because they all have these gifts that w- we kind of don't take seriously, but if we could smell like a dog or hear like a dog, you know, we'd be a kind of a superhero in our neighborhood, if not our nation or the world.
Bonnie GarmusAnd we take it for granted that a dog can smell cancer and diabetes. I mean, that's, that's amazing, isn't it?
Brett BennerYeah.
Bonnie GarmusUm, so there are all these things about dogs that, uh, that I love. I, I keep thinking it, when I write another book, should I switch animals? I'm not sure. That's why I have birds in, bird eggs in this one.
Brett BennerI know. I was like, what, what, what animal would you think you would go to? Would it be a bird?
Bonnie GarmusI don't know. You know, I, I, I'm kind of into birds. I'm not a birder, either, but I, I do, out where I live in, in Essex, we get to see so many bird species out in the country, and I've become fascinated by them. And I've set up a feeder and, you know, I've gotten to know some of the birds. But we actually, I kind of, I know this sounds weird, maybe wishful thinking, but I've made friends with a dove, and the dove laid her eggs in our hedge. Um, but she would come out and sit with me on the steps, you know, about five feet away from me, um, when I would sit out there and work.
Bonnie GarmusAnd she just became sort of a friend. And I know you hear crows that leave people gifts. She started leaving me things'cause I would put some food out for her, and then she would leave me things. Like, she'd put a little flower on the step or a little pebble for me somewhere, um, on, on the step leading into our house. And, uh, yeah, I'm, now that I'm in the United States, I'm all worried she wonders where I am.
Brett BennerI get that completely, and I feel that, like, you know- Uh, when I walk,'cause, uh, you know, we were talking earlier about Bainbridge Island, and there's something about being connected to nature, which is- Yeah I find so magical that h- having lived in a city for so long, despite the fact that it was a neighborhood-
Bonnie GarmusYeah
Brett Bennerit's still removed from everything. And- Yeah we go f- take the dogs for a walk, and so many nights there's this owl who just sits there on the telephone wire. And the first time it happened, like, I'd heard the owls, never had seen them.
Bonnie GarmusOh.
Brett BennerAnd it's been so... They're such magical creatures.
Bonnie GarmusYeah.
Brett BennerAnd of course, I completely turn into this, you know, dithering idiot, and I'm standing there- with the owl looking down at me. I'm like,"Hello, Mr. Owl- Oh my God or Mrs. Owl. How are..." You know what I mean? I, and I'm- I do I'm waiting for this, like, moment of the o- I don't know what the owl is going to say to me or what it's gonna do. Yeah. And it turns its head, and it's watching the dogs and-
Bonnie GarmusYeah
Brett Bennerbut yeah. But I find birds really amazing. But just the whole nature thing, even to see the coyotes and the deer. I know. Just the deer, they're so- I know majestic.
Bonnie GarmusI know.
Brett BennerAll of it, it's a really, it's a really cool thing. In light of all this, because y- uh, the, the, the book is very positive. I'm just so curious, um, and it is really, uh, like, you know, it becomes a struggle of, of creativity versus capitalism. Mm-hmm. But do you feel, is there a part of you that feels positive despite, you know, everything we've been talking about in terms of the progress of AI? How do you settle this for yourself, or do you?
Bonnie GarmusOh, I do. You know, yeah, I believe that people can, will, will stop this, can change this. I believe, uh, very much so. You know, all over the world, and, you know, I live in the UK, but all over the world you can see people going,"No, I'm not doing this." In the UK there are laws about this. I mean, there are things that the United States does that the UK and other nations don't allow. That includes, um, collection of your private information There, there are already laws that have been in effect there.
Bonnie GarmusSo other countries operate on a different level, and I think it would be really wonderful if Americans understood that they don't have to put up with this. Other countries have long ago said,"No. Absolutely not." You know, I think it was, uh, the UK has gotten rid of part of, uh, I think it's Google Search. They refuse to participate in this mass gathering of information, especially because now we know that it's mostly misinformation. And so I think I have a lot of hope that, you know, as the Trump term wanes and the midterms are coming- Yeah I think that there will be a resurgence of common sense.
Bonnie GarmusI really hope so. And you know what? I am so inspired by younger generations. I was at a university and I asked 1,500 kids how they felt about AI. The entire audience booed. That's young people who are supposedly writing all their papers using AI. Well, not all of them are. A lot of them are demanding that they be educated now. They, they're demanding that this nonsense stop. And I, I was talking with a group of 14-year-old Muslim girls in, in the UK, and I remember this one young woman, she said,"You know, we're not waiting around for you guys to change how this is gonna go down.
Bonnie GarmusWe're gonna do it, and we're gonna do it now." And I thought,"Wow!"
Brett BennerYeah.
Bonnie GarmusCan you be President of the United States?" Yes. I- I mean, she was so impressive. She was 14. So there are activists out there. But I'm, I'm kinda proud of what I'm hearing from younger generations about this. You know, they're putting their foot down.
Brett BennerAnd I do think, you know, I look at it with both of my kids. Yeah. The way that they approach things and each other- Yeah are very different. Yeah. Even though there's times where some of it's maddening to me- Yeah the majority of it I'm like, they're living different. They're demanding- Yeah different things. Yeah. And they see the kind of fruits of these previous generations', labor- Yeah or not labor, and what's become of it, so.
Bonnie GarmusWell, and especially, you know, their job market's being wiped out. Um-
Brett BennerThat's right
Bonnie Garmusand so they are going to recreate this job market. They're, I, I'm, I'm really impressed by what I've heard so far and, you know, I, I was in, uh, this one university, this one kid yelled out, and he goes,"So does this mean I don't have to major in computer science anymore?" And I said-"Absolutely not. Be a poet. Be a writer. Be an actor. Be a musician. But fight this." And you know, the whole audience, they were just cheering. It was like- Yeah giving permission to be creative again.
Brett BennerWell, and I also love that it's something that Batter faces in the beginning too, like telling- Yeah his parents.
Bonnie GarmusYeah.
Brett BennerI think I wanna go into this." Yeah. And it's that age-old argument that everybody that enters the arts has with their parents, like,"Do something practical. Be a doctor- or be a lawyer." And it's always the same four different things. You know what I mean? I
Bonnie Garmusknow. I know. It has. It always is. And I have to say, you know, as a mom, if my kid came home and said,"Mom, I've decided to be a poet," and I'd go,"Well, oh. Well, great."
Brett BennerI
Bonnie Garmusknow. "Yeah. Oh, fun, but what else are you really gonna do?" Um-
Brett BennerThat's exactly, yeah.
Bonnie GarmusYeah, yeah. And so, you know, I, I completely understand the parental, uh, part of this, but the fact is, right now, we need more creative people more than ever. We need smart, well-read people more than ever, and we need editors, we need writers, we need actors. We need all these people. We need musicians. We don't need AI music and AI actors and AI translators and everything else. We need people.
Brett BennerI agree. I agree. Well, Bonnie, the book is wonderful. Thank you. I'm so excited for you. Yeah. Everybody, please go out and get it, and buy independent if you're able to buy independent. But go out and get it. Your tour will be up, will it be up on your website?
Bonnie GarmusYeah, it's on my website, and, uh- Okay,
Brett Bennerwhich I'll link
Bonnie Garmusbelow
Brett Bennerin
Bonnie Garmusthe notes I'm coming to, yeah, a lot of American cities, so, so buy your tickets now.
Brett BennerYes. Look for her, and, uh, and please get the book. But thank you so much for being here. This has just been a joy talking
Bonnie GarmusOh, thank you. It was really fun, Brett. Thank you.
Brett BennerThank you again, Bonnie. If you liked today's episode or other episodes of Behind the Stack, please consider liking and subscribing so that you never miss an episode. Also, what would be really helpful to me is if you can give the show five stars on your podcast platform of choice, and if you have the time, what would be really helpful is to write a review. All these things are incredibly helpful so I can continue to bring you conversations like this one. I will be back next week with a new episode. Until then, you can find me on Instagram, YouTube, and Substack@BrettsBookStack.
Brett sits down with Lucy Tan to discuss her sophomore novel, 'Tiger's Mouth'. They talk indie bookstores, writing male protagonists, class and privilege, her approach to writing at the start of a book, some book seller...
Brett sits down with author Harrison Hill to discuss his debut non fiction book, "The Oracle's Daughter", about a woman's escape from a cult her mother was the leader of. They talk how he got the idea, research and...
Brett sits down with Chad Harbach to discuss his sophomore novel, 'The Brightness'. They talk revisiting characters from, 'The Art Of Fielding' and why go back, writing a book about female friendship and feminism, a...
Brett sits down with Mary Beth Keane to discuss her latest novel and Good Morning America Book Club Pick, 'Whale Harbor" They talk all things Irish: extended large families, including her own, the rural setting,...
Brett sits down with author Will Maclean to discuss his American debut, 'Solace House'. They talk about reading snobbery, his past writing in comedy, horror narratives, writing sympathetic characters in the genre, The...