All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: 2026 Midterms Polling Update The French Student Uprising Breadfruit! Fear of a Nuclear January 6th Executive Disorder: ICE Shooting in NYC, Russian Diesel and Ukraine, Protests Around the World You can now listen to all Cool Zone Media shows, 100% ad-free through the Cooler Zone Media subscription, available exclusively on Apple Podcasts. So, open your Apple Podcasts app, search for “Cooler Zone Media” and subscribe today! Sources/Links: 2026 Midterms Polling Update https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/irans-revolutionary-guards-call-trump-big-liar-2026-09-29/ https://img9.irna.ir/d/r2/2026/09/29/0/173138753.pdf?ts=1790679102019 https://maristpoll.marist.edu/polls/midterm-elections-in-maine-october-2026/ https://mainebeacon.com/new-polling-jackson-narrowly-leads-collins-mainers-want-affordable-childcare/ https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/maine-senate-democratic-party-troy-jackson-graham-platner-susan-collins.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/north-carolina-us-senate-election-polls-2026.html https://www.semafor.com/article/10/02/2026/republicans-pull-ad-spending-from-north-carolina https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/6131462-sabatos-crystal-ball-shifts-alaska/ https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/alaska-us-senate-election-polls-2026.html https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-poll-its-lone-star-senate-showdown-between-talarico-paxton https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/texas-us-senate-election-polls-2026.html https://x.com/AdImpact_Pol/status/2106409529512808548?s=20 https://x.com/MediumBuying/status/2108208307550752820?s=20 https://floridapolitics.com/archives/820643-poll-ashley-moody-45-angie-nixon-45-and-florida-now-has-two-toss-ups-at-the-top-of-the-ticket/ https://www.miamiherald.com/news/article317496818.html https://d3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net/documents/ttw_fl_20260921_lv.pdf https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/michigan-us-senate-election-polls-2026.html https://www.cbsnews.com/detroit/news/michigan-voter-poll-abdul-el-sayed-mike-rogers/ https://www.kff.org/public-opinion/kff-health-tracking-poll-health-care-issues-in-the-lead-up-to-the-2026-midterm-election/ https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2026-elections/midterms https://gsas.harvard.edu/news/how-much-will-gerrymandering-impact-2026-midterms https://www.npr.org/2026/10/06/nx-s1-5989694/midterm-elections-control-congress https://news.gallup.com/interactives/507569/presidential-job-approval-center.aspx https://www.cookpolitical.com/analysis/house/house-overview/gop-track-lose-house-majority-15-race-ratings-shift-towards-dems Breadfruit! https://es.mongabay.com/2023/08/arbol-del-pan-conservacion-crisis-climatica/ https://www.wired.com/story/breadfruit-caribbean-pacific-climate-change-super-food/ https://journals.plos.org/climate/article?id=10.1371/journal.pclm.0000062 https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/is-breadfruit-the-climate-change-proof-foo d-of-the-future-180980665/ https://thestoryexchange.org/shes-brought-a-climate-resilient-superfood-to-the-worlds-att ention/ https://ntbg.org/breadfruit/about-breadfruit/ https://www.civilbeat.org/2026/09/supply-and-demand-concerns-breadfruit/ https://www.civilbeat.org/2026/09/ulu-on-the-up-hawaii-breadfruit-production-keeps-boo ming/ https://www.civilbeat.org/2026/09/supply-and-demand-concerns-breadfruit/ https://www.9millones.com/story/como-los-puertorriquenos-disenan-su-recuperacion-just a-colectivamente https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/06/18/climate-change-impact-on-food-everyone- giving-up-breakfast/ https://news.northwestern.edu/stories/2022/08/climate-resilient-breadfruit-might-be-the-f ood-of-the-future https://www.plateapr.com/que-hacer/origen-festival-de-la-pana-humacao https://www.eater.com/23664880/what-is-breadfruit-hawaii-how-to-cook https://edition.cnn.com/2025/11/12/climate/3-degrees-warming-reports-iea-united-nations https://bittmanproject.com/breadfruit-is-delicious-and-versatile-but-it-shouldnt-have-to-sa ve-the-world/ https://www3.ctahr.hawaii.edu/oc/freepubs/pdf/FN-68.pdf https://estadisticas.pr/Agricultura https://ishs.org/ishs-article/1128_8/ Breadfruit: Three Global Journeys of a Bountiful Tree by Russell Fielding Recetario de Pana Edición 2014 by Asociación Recreativa y Educativa Comunal del Bo. Mariana, Inc (ARECMA), edited by Luz A. Vega Rodríguez https://treesthatfeed.org/programs/planting-trees/ https://treesthatfeed.org/programs/school-feeding-programs/ https://treesthatfeed.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/AR_2026_.3.6MB.pdf Executive Disorder: ICE Shooting in NYC, Russian Diesel and Ukraine, Protests Around the World NYC Immigration Resources: Immigration Legal Support Hotline: 800-354-0365, or dial 311 and say "Immigration Legal." “Free, confidential, funded by the City. Interpretation in 200+ languages. Immigration status does not matter,” - Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs. https://www.nyc.gov/site/immigrants/legal-resources/moia-immigration-legal-support-centers.page Intake form for help from the Rapid Response Legal Collaborative: http://nyc.gov/RRLC Know Your Rights booklets, multiple languages: https://www.nyc.gov/site/immigrants/legal-resources/know-your-rights.page “What to do if ICE agents approach you / what to do if a friend or family member is detained / Sanctuary City laws in NYC.” https://x.com/David_J_Bier/status/2108722293967073459?s=20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHE6Zfi-vUs https://x.com/hollypret/status/2108343537309990968?s=20 https://x.com/StatusCoup/status/2108344393958617221?s=20 https://www.dhs.gov/news/2026/10/09/dhs-debunks-new-york-sanctuary-politicians-lies-about-ice-shooting-illegal-alien https://www.amny.com/news/ice-shooting-detainee-bullet-neck-10122026/ https://x.com/DarializaforNY/status/2108564402756595758 https://x.com/nycDSA/status/2108539679452942837?s=20 https://www.nytimes.com/live/2026/10/09/nyregion/ice-shooting-bronx-nyc https://www.thecityreporter.nyc/2026/10/08/federal-officers-shoot-man-in-the-bronx-nypd-says/utm_content=buffer39205&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter&utm_campaign=buffer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQA_BiDZH-0 https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/10/mayor-mamdani-directs-first-comprehensive-review-of-nypd-use-of- https://x.com/IlhanMN/status/2109675562344087792 https://x.com/PeteHegseth/status/2108344900165263476?s=20 https://x.com/PalmerLuckey/status/2109454084961137040?s=20 https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/crx23qlnj27qo https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article317572876.html https://prospect.org/2026/10/13/militants-victory-uaw-shawn-fain/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96ogPwN9ykM https://nypost.com/2026/09/22/tech/seniors-struggling-worse-than-teens-with-screens-ai-and-algorithms/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2026/06/17/how-opinions-and-use-of-ai-differ-by-age/ https://brendonbeebe.substack.com/p/did-bot-traffic-drop-after-the-yandex https://www.msn.com/en-us/technology/tech-companies/russia-s-yandex-bot-traffic-plunges-after-ukraine-drone-strikes-cripple-russia-google-data-centers/ar-AA2e0IjN https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c9y7l0pm8jkko https://archive.is/2RtqI#selection-1999.0-1999.257 https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2026-10-10/russian-attacks-kill-20-in-ukraine-after-trump-strikes-diesel-deal-with-putin https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/Russian-Strikes-Cut-Power-to-600000-Ukrainians-Days-After-US-Diesel-Deal.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/india-shuts-down-iconic-delhi-024043716.html https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/france-student-protests-spread-scroller-9.7379099 https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/belgium-9-minors-arrested-clashes-055545941.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/spain-madrid-protesters-mourn-evicted-123225186.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/india-cockroach-leaders-jailed-protest-140533064.html
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Call zone media.
Speaker 2Hey, everybody.
Speaker 3Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode of the week that just happened is here in one convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to listen to in a long stretch if you want. If you've been listening to the episodes every day this week, there's going to be nothing new here for you, but you can make your own decisions.
Speaker 2Welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Garrison Davis, joined by Robert Evans.
Speaker 1Hello.
Speaker 2Hello, Garrison Davis. How are you doing today? I'm doing okay. I'm really, I'm getting prepared to vote. I'm psyching myself up.
Speaker 3Just like the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps told you to do, huh?
Speaker 2I think that's what we want to start with. In general, this episode will be kind of going over the midterm polls as they are. in early October, kind of what we can get a sense of the election about a month out, now that we're just a few weeks away from the election. But a few weeks ago, the IRGC, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps... Prince of the Pod.
Speaker 4Sure.
Speaker 2At this point, man... One bad day, full Stalinist, full Maoist. I mean, that's more, it's a slightly different-ist. A few weeks ago, the IRGC released a 26-page letter, not short. Not strong on brevity, the IRGC. Addressed to the American people, a spokesperson from the IRGC told Reuters, quote, the American
Speaker 2people are not knowledgeable about many developments. We believe if they knew more, they would think differently and take other decisions, unquote.
Speaker 3You guys might have more faith in the American people than I do at this point.
Speaker 2The start of the letter and how it's addressed reads, to the honorable people of the United States of America, the scholars, the students, and the members of the media. I think that last part is important because at least some of them know that The American people are not reading a 26-page letter. This is going to be mostly read by journalists. This is going to be read by nerds on Twitter. And blue sky, I guess. And nerds on Twitter.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Now, I actually was able to get a short video. The IRGC also released a short video kind of summarizing the letter. And I will play that here for Robert. So that's, yeah, that's the special, that's the special video. Yeah, that really is. That's something else. So there's a few sections before. The bulk of the letter is arguing why
Speaker 2Iran is the victor in the war, concrete evidence of Iran's victory. They have a section on the meaning of, quote, death to America. Yeah. Which reads, quote, Death to America does not in any way express any ill will toward the American people who have themselves suffered through the same oppression. Death to America is a prayer for the eradication of the diabolical ruling elite whose seat of power is in the White House. And the letter goes on to say that the RGC and the people of Iran have no feeling of hostility toward the American people. And then they ask,
Speaker 2how can the U.S. be saved? And this is what leads to the bulk of the letter saying, which is essentially trying to get Americans to vote harder. Oh, which... You're finished, fascism.
Speaker 3Oh, man.
Speaker 2But there's also a few other interesting kind of like name drops here. Quote, God will come to the aid of the American people if they decide to change course. Thankfully, Americans are waking up to the truth. Over the past two years, Americans have participated in numerous demonstrations in cities across the U.S. to express their outrage at Israel's genocidal actions in Gaza.
Speaker 5Moreover.
Speaker 2The No Kings rallies that swept across the U.S. last year were a nation- Okay, IRGC. Were a nation, right? Repudiation of the burgeoning autocratic tendencies within the American government. These powerful manifestations of collective action are evidence of a national awakening spreading through the U.S. Polls show that the majority of Americans, especially younger Americans, no longer wish to be complicit in their government's crimes against other nations, unquote. Part of what makes this so funny to me is
Speaker 2how diametrically opposed it is to the messaging coming out of like, you know, U.S. based like Maoists or like anti-imperialists, you know? Oh yeah, like the U.S. far left. Absolutely.
Speaker 3They're so much, so much more generous to the American people.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's something that's really, that's really funny to me. As for the vote harder section, let's read one paragraph here. Your response may be that you do not accept these atrocious actions, but are powerless to do anything about them. This answer, however, is not acceptable. You are the ones who empower with your votes. The government had allowed to do what it wants. Although American politicians often win your votes through deception of false promises, as Trump did, you can change the makeup of the government if you apply the criteria for good leadership in choosing the people you
Speaker 2vote into office.
Speaker 3See, guys, I gotta tell you, it's not that easy. First off, I've voted every time I've gotten the chance, pretty much. I don't think I've ever empowered anyone with my votes.
Speaker 2You know, it's one of those kind of Adam Curtis moments. Yeah. We have the IRGC advocating the ideal of electoral politics, something that does not exist really in Iran either.
Speaker 3It's consistent with there's that one famous interview with an Iranian cleric where he's like, as Alexander de Tocqueville, who I'm sure all Americans have read once said, he's like, guys, you are way overestimating us.
Speaker 2So, yeah, if you have any sort of anti-imperialist impulses as per as per the IRGC, get your voter registration up to date.
Speaker 3Get your voter registration card and get out there.
Speaker 2If you're in line, stay in line. That's right. So part of why this letter was released is because it is just a few weeks away from the midterms. We are less than a month away from the 2026 midterm elections. And so I thought we should do a little update on polling and take a look at some of the close races.
Speaker 6Sure.
Speaker 2And let's start by talking about the current makeup of Congress. Right now in the House, 218 seats are held by Republicans, 214 by Democrats, and there's one independent who caucuses with the Republicans. 218 seats are what's needed for a majority. This has been a very small majority that the Republicans have been able to hold onto in the House these past few years. The Cook Political Report is forecasting that the Dems will pick up around five to 15 seats
Speaker 2in the midterms, likely putting them in charge of the House with anywhere between 220 to 230 seats. And this lead in polling and their projected victory has only grown these past few weeks. It's not becoming a closer race for the Republicans.
Speaker 3No, things don't look good for them because gasoline costs all of the money in your pocket now.
Speaker 2That is a huge factor. That's a big part of the reason. I'll go over some of the kind of main issues driving the election person polling and gas prices is like number one or number two.
Speaker 3Yeah, I have trouble imagining anything other than other cost of living stuff being like a larger impact on voters.
Speaker 2Something that is interesting, the redistricting across Alabama, California, Florida, Louisiana, North Carolina, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, and Utah is will likely have a minimal impact in the results, like in total. There's obviously for the people actually impacted, the people whose votes are being diluted, especially.
Speaker 3Not that this is not bad or a problem. It's just they have fucked up enough that it's not going to benefit them to the extent.
Speaker 2That's what it.
Speaker 3Seemed like to me, that they're not going to benefit the way that they were.
Speaker 2No. So I don't want to discount the impact of the erosion of the Voting Rights Act by any means, or the just larger structural issues of partisan gerrymandering. But an analysis by Harvard estimated a net gain of only two seats for Republicans in these midterms, though other estimates give them a few more seats, anywhere between five to nine. So we're looking at somewhere between a couple seats. I think nine is probably a bit optimistic. Yeah, for the Republicans. Around two to five seats they could net because of
Speaker 2the redistricting measures. Could, might, yeah. coming years, going into 2028, when Virginia is able to push forward its redistricting again, which they tried to do earlier, but because of a procedural error, it was shot down. So that will also net Democrats a few more seats that will start to kind of even things out. And then we had this whole little fun redistricting for nothing.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's a real, just a marker of how badly they have botched their starting position going into this administration. Just kind of a catastrophic series of political decisions. We'll see if any of that matters, but it really does highlight how pissed off people are.
Speaker 2Now, obviously, the Senate is kind of the big question here.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 2Will Democrats be able to actually take the Senate? Will they be able to control all of Congress, not just the House? Yeah. Currently, the Republicans have a 53-seat majority, plus a Fetterman.
Speaker 7Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2And the vice president who can vote. So that kind of really throws a wrench in all these numbers, the Fetterman factor and the Vance factor. Democrats just have 45 seats plus two independents who caucus with the Democrats, like Bernie Sanders. So essentially, things actually sit at like 54 to 46, adjusting for independents and Fetterman. So Democrats really need a net gain of like four to five seats to be able to have the Senate be more of
Speaker 2a competitive voting arena, also considering J.D. Vance. There are 35 Senate seats on the ballot next month. So Democrats will need to flip around four to five seats, like I said, and one of the seats Democrats have wanted to flip for a long time, and especially this year, is Maine, with Susan Collins. One of our worst lawmakers.
Speaker 8Yes.
Speaker 2And ProPublica, as I reported on ED a few weeks ago, ProPublica did that great investigation into military contracting corruption and bribery involving Susan Collins. So union logger Troy Jackson is trying to unseat Collins. Right now, this race leans D or is a toss up. Morrist has Jackson up four points ahead of Collins among registered voters, but with a
Speaker 2margin of error of 3.8%. So that's essentially still almost within the margin of error. This is going to be a very close race, right? A margin of error like that. This is still basically a toss up. Other polling shows roughly the same results. Jackson up a few points, but within the margin of error. Per Morrist, among the Maine electorate, 57% think Collins will win. That's not saying 57% want Collins to win, but they think that will happen, right? That's what they think is more likely. A survey from the
Speaker 2Maine People's Resource Center found Jackson ahead among independent voters, 58% to 33% for Collins. The Maine People's Resource Center is a progressive-leaning institution. Obviously, this race in Maine has been a big shit show, to say the least. And since Jackson has taken over as the nominee, Democratic Party establishment consultants have really swooped into Maine and have been trying to keep Jackson on a tight leash. Jackson's campaign has
Speaker 2not replicated the Platner-style intensive town hall strategy.
Speaker 3I think that would be a bad idea. Like, it would be really obvious if he just tried to be Graham Platner without the scandal, right?
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, let's try to be Graham Plattner, but I think it is, the style of campaigning is very different. Jackson's not as accessible to the electorate. Consultants have tried to keep him from doing Q & As at the events that he does end up doing. They've been dissuading him from talking about ICE and Israel and Palestine.
Speaker 8Great.
Speaker 2So they really have been trying to keep him on a pretty tight leash. There's a story in New York Magazine a few weeks ago that kind of details how Democratic establishment consultants have been trying to lead the Jackson campaign that if people are interested in that specific topic, I recommend they check out. So this is one of the races that Democrats really do need to flip if they have a chance of winning the Senate. And it is, you know, theoretically possible, you know, he may be slightly
Speaker 2ahead in the polls, but only very slightly. But I think, yeah, this is this is essentially a toss up. especially looking back at 2020 when the Democrat in that race also was, you know, a little bit ahead and Collins still ended up walking away with it.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think they're I mean, they're they're both trying to avoid having another platner who gets like out of control of them and is saying shit that the DNC does not want to have to stand by. And I think they are also hoping that that Plattner's campaign at least did enough damage to Collins that she isn't going to be able to like pull out a win this time. And maybe that'll be the case, you know, that might wind up being a play that works.
Speaker 2Definitely.
Speaker 3It's not a great position to have someone who is doing as well as Plattner had been doing get dropped out with a scandal that fucked up. Like that's a, that's a, that's not easy to handle.
Speaker 8Yes.
Speaker 2Especially mobilizing that many people who were already kind of disillusioned with politics, giving them that sort of hope and then having that hope be ripped away And then those people who maybe, some of them who even still want to be politically engaged, the Jackson campaign is not letting them touch the campaign with a 10-foot pole, which you could maybe understand their reasons for. But there's a lot of grassroots, very working-class-oriented activists who want to be involved in some way that are not being tapped.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And as strong as Plattner's campaign was, it was because it was built on the work that they were doing.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Not just him as a person. Yeah. So those are sort of complicating factors in this race.
Speaker 3And you know what's a complicating factor in this podcast episode, Garrison?
Speaker 2The fact that we have to pivot to ads in order to pay the bills. We have to pivot to ads right now.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. That is a complicating factor in our lives. And we're back.
Speaker 3How do you feel about North Carolina, Robert? Of the Carolinas, definitely my favorite.
Speaker 2That's so true, actually.
Speaker 3Easily the best of the Carolinas. Top 50% Carolina. Sorry to everyone in South Carolina. I'm not apologizing. I did not apologize, South Carolina. You need to know that.
Speaker 2Well, North Carolina could also be one of the states that flip for the Dems. Former Democratic Governor Roy Cooper is facing former RNC Chair Michael Watley. What a name. Who is running to replace Republican Senator Tom Tillis.
Speaker 3Those are both silly names. Have some self-respect.
Speaker 2God damn it. This race is leaning Democrat. This is not a toss-up.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Polls from late September have Cooper ahead 5 to 13 points. Yeah, that's pretty good. And last week, a Republican super PAC pulled $ 30 million of ad money out of the state to use in other races. So... That's a sign that at least even among some Republicans, they're kind of giving up on this. Roy Cooper is a pretty strong candidate for this state. I should say, as we're going through all of these sort of candidates, this is not, it could happen here, endorsing any candidate just because they belong
Speaker 2to one party or another. Not our thing. I'm just talking about this in terms of what the Democrats want in order to take back power and the sort of how these candidates relate to each state. Roy Cooper... is a relatively liked figure in North Carolina. That is reflected in the polling for this. His campaign is also helped by the fact he's not going up against an incumbent. He's not going up against someone who voters already are familiar with, already like, who they just want to keep in power. He's going up against a new guy, a former RNC chair. So this is one of those states
Speaker 2where the Democrats will probably flip. You can kind of count this on the four to five states needed to flip. This is the most kind of certain one. There'd be a massive polling error if it goes the other way or some sort of fuckery. And just a total misread of the situation on the ground. Now, one of the more interesting kind of surprises is Alaska, which could also flip for Democrats. The former Democratic congressman, Mary Peltola, is going up against sitting Senator Dan Sullivan. Paltola is definitely
Speaker 2running more as, like, a centrist. Very pro-fossil fuels. You're in Alaska.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2Pro-gun, too. Pro-gun. Her campaign slogan is Fish Family Freedom.
Speaker 7Yep.
Speaker 2That makes sense.
Speaker 3Not a terrible slogan for running in Alaska.
Speaker 2Not bad for Alaska. And rather than attacking Republicans, a lot of her campaign messaging is focused on taking on, quote, D.C., You know, it's very much like Alaska versus D.C. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3Corruption is a massive issue for the whole electorate. So that makes sense. Like that's, yeah, kind of the obvious play.
Speaker 2And really prioritizing Alaska as like its own special interest because it's so different from every other state. Part of Feltola's strategy is trying to, you know, is trying to attract certain Republicans. So she's not really going hard against Republicans per se, but attacking the sort of like D.C. swamp establishment. That's that's that's her main strategy here. New York Times-Siena poll from late September to early October has Peltola up seven points.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's a pretty solid lead. Alaska's been wavering the last couple of elections between blue and red. So this is not like a sea change, right? This is kind of an incremental change in some of the And obviously, the disaster that is this administration has pushed things further along than I think it otherwise would be. But this is it's been moving in this direction a while.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2And like Alaska hasn't had a Democratic senator in like almost 20 years. this would be a significant event if this happened. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. I didn't mean to say it wouldn't.
Speaker 3I've just been like this, this pattern has been occurring since before like Trump too.
Speaker 9Right.
Speaker 2And obviously there's this general pattern of in the midterms, usually, especially the house, but sometimes the Senate as well, shifts to the opposition party. You know, this is like politics 101. This is a very basic pattern. And what we're looking at is this, this could be even stronger this year than some years previously, probably not as strong as 2018, but, But taking back the Senate and the House would be huge, especially because of how far they have to go in the Senate in order to retake it. Yeah. Now, the race in Alaska, this definitely used to lean Republican, right?
Speaker 2This was not seen to be a very competitive race. But recently, this went to a toss-up, right? And now, some models even have it leaning Democrat. So this is one race where there's been a lot of movement. And J.D. Vance was dropped into Alaska to campaign for Sullivan last week. something that they may not have needed to do or thought they needed to do a few months ago. But now now this is competitive enough that they're sending in the vice president. Will J.D. Vance actually help Republicans win the state? That's that's certainly debatable. But I don't know
Speaker 2if I would be putting J.D. in as my pen. That's the thing, right? I don't like it. Like, I don't know who.
Speaker 3I put in as my pen shitter right now in the Republican bench, but it would not advance would be the bottom of my list.
Speaker 2Like, honestly, send in Fetterman. No, legitimately, yes. He'll do better for you in this instance. Sending Fetterman to campaign for the Republicans would be, I think, probably a smarter move. Yeah, you could convince him to do it. What a nightmare.
Speaker 3What a horrible situation. It's it's things are really bad, buddy. Things are really bad. I know when like we were getting shot at by federal agents in Portland, things were bad, but things are a lot darker.
Speaker 2Yeah, well, I'm about to get maybe shot at by federal agents in like 20 minutes. So, yeah, because they just shot a dude with an actual gun in New York.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 2Time is a spiral.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Let's talk about Texas.
Speaker 1Sure.
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm excited to talk about Texas because this is the first time I get to be like a little optimistic about more than like two Texas elections, actually.
Speaker 2So, yeah, I'm I'm excited. Let's talk about Talafrico. Talafrico. In terms of the big, big question is Texas with James Talarico going up against Kenny Pax, Ken Paxton. K-Pax, as I like to call him. You probably didn't see that movie, Garrison. It's not good. No, no. I did just see Out of Sight, the Steven Soderbergh movie. I don't know if I've seen that one. From like the 90s. It's like the proto Ocean's Eleven. Okay. It's the hottest I've ever seen George Clooney. Oh, Cloon Tang. Okay. He
Speaker 2plays like a serial bank robber. That's a good role for him. Who keeps going to jail, prison, then he breaks out. And then it kind of cuts between a few different timelines as he gets into a sort of doomed romance with a federal marshal played by Jennifer Lopez.
Speaker 3Okay, I was going to say I've seen this movie and then... Well, no, I have seen this movie with J-Lo. Yeah, yeah, I have seen this movie. It's hard to tell because like the first half of that description is like 18 different George Clooney movies.
Speaker 2Exactly. He's like a bank robber. He keeps going to prison. No, especially like the late 90s, early 2000s. This is like his role. He had this like on lock. Yeah. The hottest bank robber you've ever seen. Yeah, people love a criminal. Speaking of, Ken Paxton, not doing great in the polls. Yeah. Marist and New York Times have Tallarico up six points as of late September, with a recent Fox News poll
Speaker 2showing Tallarico at 51% to Paxton's 49%. Not good for old Kay Pax. No. There's also this big enthusiasm gap that the Fox News poll really focused on. Among MAGA Republicans, 64% say they're extremely interested in the midterms. But for non-MAGA Republicans, only 50% is extremely interested in the midterms. So that's almost like a 15% gap among Republicans for Republicans. how
Speaker 2much they're invested in these midterms. And this difference does not exist on the Democratic side. The Fox News polling has Democrats broken down into two categories, similar to MAGA or non-MAGA. They have DSA Democrats and non-DSA Democrats. Which is funny on its face. DSA Democrats are at 68%, non-DSA is at 67%. So basically no gap.
Speaker 10Jeez.
Speaker 3And I think this has less to do with Tallarico's specific characteristics as a candidate and everything to do with the fact that Ken Paxton is the literal Christian devil.
Speaker 2Yes, he is Satan. And people want to see him beaten.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2But I mean, these numbers are not just interesting because of the gap between MAGA and non-MAGA Republicans, but also MAGA Republicans are at 64% for enthusiasm versus Democrats are at 67, 68. So that's a few points ahead just for enthusiasm. against the mega kind of hardcore. And the other really worrying part of this for Republicans is that out of the percent that say that they will vote, mega is at 76%, non-mega is at 65%. That's an 11% gap. And similarly, this gap does not exist for the Democrats, DSA or otherwise. That is really interesting.
Speaker 3And it says a lot about MAGA Republicans that they have just completely given up any kind of like moral.
Speaker 2Standards for their candidates. Do not care. Does not matter at all.
Speaker 3In a lot of the country, Republicans and MAGA Republicans are synonyms, but that's not the case in a lot of Texas. Like Texas has a lot of Bush Republicans still. Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, like those people still likely are going to vote for Trump in the presidential election. Absolutely. But oversimplifying their, like all of their politics to MAGA is, I think it's a sort of theoretical mistake. It's a mistake.
Speaker 3Those people are not, some of them are, because there's a chunk of Republicans that look like they're going to Tallarico, but.
Speaker 2It's not a huge chunk.
Speaker 3It's more that some of them just aren't going to vote or are going to put in like a protest candidate. You know, I've read some interviews to that stance with like Republican voters who are on sort of the Bush Republican side of things being like, I'm just going to put in a protest vote or something, which in this instance is just as good as voting for Tallarico in terms of stopping Paxton from winning again, because the Republicans who have some degree of moral fiber left are also disgusted with Ken Paxton.
Speaker 2He's gross. On that topic. I don't know if you saw this. Ken Paxton's ex-wife. who is a Texas state senator, was tapped for an election ad where she does not even say her ex-husband's name, but just begs people to vote for the quote Republican ticket to stay on the team. I want to play the ad.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2God, this is great.
Speaker 11I'm Texas Senator Angela Paxton.
Speaker 2People have asked my thoughts about.
Speaker 12This election and turns out I have some. Let's talk about the elephant.
Speaker 10In the room.
Speaker 11In a general election, it's not as much about the individual players on the team.
Speaker 12It's about getting the whole team across the finish line.
Speaker 11Either we hold every Republican seat or we hand the future of Texas to the other team. That's why I'm voting for the Republican ticket on November 3rd. Let's hold the line together.
Speaker 2Texas PAC is responsible for the content of this advertising. Rousing.
Speaker 3Won't even say his name. Crazy stuff.
Speaker 2Wow. Wild stuff. Hold your nose and vote for my shitty ex, the psychopath. Especially because she starts by saying, let's address the elephant in the room. And then doesn't. Does not at all. Does not address the elephant.
Speaker 3Can't bring herself to say his name.
Speaker 2Oh my God, that's amazing. It's one of the most incredible political ads I've ever seen. Almost as good as, we may as well play this one. This is technically a House ad. Unfortunately, we're going to drop it here in the Senate section. But in terms of talking about political ads. This is an ad running in Ohio in response to a series of anti-trans ads that the Republicans have been blasting in the airwaves.
Speaker 8Seen these ads?
Speaker 2They're a complete lie.
Speaker 8Records show not only is this woman actually from Texas, she didn't have any surgery as He protected men who abused young girls by voting in the Senate to block the release of the Epstein files. Maybe that's because Husted took one hundred and sixteen thousand dollars from associates of Jeffrey Epstein. Ten times more than any other senator. John Husted should be ashamed.
Speaker 13I'm sure Brown and I approve this message.
Speaker 2It's that easy. It's that easy, folks. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2The ads made for you, really. If the Republicans want to make, quote unquote, protecting young girls the center of their politics.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2They fucking handed you the silver platter. The Epstein's right there. Yeah.
Speaker 3It's frustrating because Tallarico has fucking recently made some kind of bows to the anti-trans kids in sports panic shit, which was very wishy-washy.
Speaker 2Wishy-washy, flippy-floppy, not standing firmly where he should be, certainly.
Speaker 3No, and I don't think that's helping him. Honestly, I think the primary thing helping him is that Ken Paxton is an abominable monster.
Speaker 2He's awful. He's the devil. Like.
Speaker 3And to run against the devil, you simply have to not be the devil.
Speaker 2I guess it's harder than that. Trump won.
Speaker 3And also offer people real things as well. I think I'm not being fair to the campaign. Like he has run a much better campaign than that.
Speaker 2Well, I'm also just saying like in general, I think the sort of running as just not Trump. Yes. That's not one as a strategy. That's not enough.
Speaker 3Tallarico has worked hard to portray himself as, other than being a Democrat, like a Texas Christian that Texans can find respectable, right?
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 2We'll talk a little bit more about Texas, but first, here are some ads.
Speaker 3And we're back. I did want to mention one more thing about the KPAX campaign. Paxton's Senate campaign recently put out a series of missing posters demanding proof of life for James Tallarico. Oh, yeah. A little less than two weeks ago, he took sick with the flu. He got diagnosed on September 30th. And after that, he had to like attend. He attended like a Hispanic Business Council meeting via video that had been scheduled to attend in person.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3He told attendees, I'm running a fever and I'm at my most contagious right now. And I guess I've been shaking too many hands on the campaign trail. So I want to keep everybody safe. He stated that if he passed his illness to somebody's grandmother or baby, he couldn't live with himself. Totally reasonable thing. But Paxton's campaign put out this like old West looking like wanted poster of him demanding proof of life because he's been absent 12 days from the campaign trail.
Speaker 3He's been making statements. He's just not. He's sick.
Speaker 2That happens.
Speaker 3He's booked for a CNN town hall on October 14th. There's been a pretty bad illness going around. I think there's probably a few.
Speaker 2There is a cold. There is a COVID strain.
Speaker 3And he's young for politics, but he's also at the age in which flus and shit hit yard.
Speaker 2He's not a baby. I did see a clip from the president in the past few days talking about this. And he said that Paxton's hiding because he's been forced to eat meat when running. And so he's been vomiting up meat all the time. And that's why he's not... What? Non-visible. Donald, what? What the fuck? Because Trump just learned what veganism is. Yeah. And he says it really funny. And it's been like the main thing he's been attacking Talafrico with is that the fact that he's like.
Speaker 3Alleged vegan, right? Because he's not a vegan.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3No, even if you were a vegan, if you wanted to win a major election in Texas, you would lie about that.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 3That's almost more of a disqualifying factor in Texas politics than being a Democrat.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 2But yeah, that's been the main thing Trump's been trying to attack Talifrico for is this alleged vegan status and the idea that Talifrico is having to fake being a meat eater and has gotten sick from eating meat and is thus vomiting. And that's why he's out of the spotlight. Yeah, of course. That's definitely it. Simple, basic stuff. Politics 101.
Speaker 3Yeah, politics something or other. The gubernatorial election is also going to be this year for Texas. And this is like the first time in a while that it's looked actually kind of competitive. Gina Hinojosa is running against Greg Abbott, who is. right up there with Ken Paxton in terms of being an evil scumbag. Like he is just a monster, although a much more popular monster than Ken Paxton is with voters. But even so, Hinojosa is giving him a
Speaker 3run for his money. Right now, the real clear politics average trend has Abbott at 48.1 and Hinojosa at 46.4. But there are several polls that have Hinojosa ahead, including YouGov and The New York Times Siena poll has her up by three. Marist has her up by three. Recon MR at Siena has her up by four. Now, obviously, there are some like Telemundo has Abbott up by seven. Fox has Abbott up by five. And there are definitely more polls that have Abbott ahead. But this looks close
Speaker 3enough that like it's being considered by a lot of people to be a.
Speaker 2Toss up or close to a toss up. It's competitive. It's competitive.
Speaker 3Like she really could pull it off. I'm not saying I think that's the likeliest. thing to happen here because this is still Texas. And I just can't be that optimistic about the gubernatorial race. But I would love it if Gina could unseat Greg Abbott because he is just a fucking monster.
Speaker 2And yeah, she's running a really good campaign.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 3She's currently in the House of Representatives representing the 49th District.
Speaker 2The Texas House or the federal? In the Texas House. She's a state legislator. The Texas House.
Speaker 9Okay.
Speaker 2Got it. Yeah.
Speaker 3And she worked for the AFL prior to that. She's been a lawyer for quite some time. She was part of the legal team that sued Tom DeLay. The Hinojos are like a prominent North Texas family. I went to school with one of her, I don't know if it was her kid or like a cousin or something, but like the Hino Yoses are like a prominent wealthy family in, in North Texas.
Speaker 14Hmm.
Speaker 3So, It's very interesting that she's and I haven't enough of a deep dive. I think a lot of what's helping her is just the general unpopularity of the Republican Party right now. And I do kind of suspect that Greg Abbott is being dragged down a little bit by Ken Paxton, too, like that, just the general the overall trend. And also, like, I think he knows is probably benefiting from some of the enthusiasm that Tallarico's campaign has helped to generate, too.
Speaker 9Right.
Speaker 3Obviously, she's also made a lot of really good moves on her own that have increased enthusiasm. But in general, I think because Texas looks competitive in a way it really hasn't, it's benefiting probably both candidates a lot. Just that that is bringing more people out to volunteer. It's bringing more people out to donate. Just creating this impression that like this might be a winnable fight has done a lot.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3So that's one to keep watch on. Again, I would say a gun to my head. Abbott's still probably going to eke out a victory, but I can't say definitely.
Speaker 2Right. Yeah, he does have that sort of incumbent advantage. And that's another factor with the Tallarico-Paxton thing. Paxton does not have that incumbent advantage. I think Corbyn would be a much harder candidate for Tallarico to beat.
Speaker 3This wouldn't be an election if Corbyn had won the primary.
Speaker 2That's why we were sort of softly excited when Paxton won. Because as dangerous as it is for Paxton to potentially be in the Senate... He has a much bigger attack radius or attack surface than Cornyn does. Another one of these kind of long shots, actually, I would say the biggest long shot for a flip is in Florida with progressive Democrat Angie Nixon running against Ashley Moody, who took Rubio's seat. The best poll for Nixon as of a
Speaker 2few days ago is by Florida Politics, and according to them, the race is at a tie, 45%. But a recent poll from Stetson University has Moody leading 51 to 40, so 11 points. A YouGov poll from late September to early October has Moody five points ahead, with 5% of likely voters still undecided. Though, actually, as of just a few hours ago, as of recording, we're recording this on Thursday night, Florida Politics did another poll, which shows Moody
Speaker 2at 47% and Angie Nixon at 45% within margin of error. So a slight difference from the last poll that had them tied. This is one of those races that the Democrats, as the DNC, is not actually expecting Nixon to win. They're not really pumping much money in, or really any money in. They're not helping. All of this is the result of just Nixon being a really good politician. The fact that the race is this close. And the Nixons
Speaker 2are sort of like sleeper candidates. I was not familiar with Nixon until the primary. Since then, I've watched videos of her working in the state house. from these past few years and then campaign appearances, she is great. She is really good. A really clear communicator of working class issues, issues of impacting the black community in Florida, right? This Florida is a state we often like reduced to kind of the worst of the worst people, but there's a lot of like good people in Florida as well. They
Speaker 2just haven't been represented in, in politics for almost, almost as long as I've been alive. Yeah.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, it gets forgotten, but there's like a reason why the 2000 election hinged on Florida. And it was because it was really close.
Speaker 2And I'm really interested to see what the results of this race is, because this will indicate kind of how much Trump is hurting the Republicans. If it's like a really, really close race, if the results are really close. And it will also point to Nixon's strength as a candidate. And I'm interested to watch what she does after this election, whether or not she wins. Now, of course, there's the other close race, which is in Michigan, which currently leans Democrat with Abdul El-Sayed on average, polling about 3% ahead of former Republican Congressman Mike Rogers. A Mars poll from
Speaker 2late September has El-Sayed at 51 to Rogers 44, a seven point lead. That's El-Sayed's most favorable poll. A New York Times Siena poll from mid-September shows El-Sayed up five points. A Fox poll has him up one point. If Abdul wins, Dems could hold on to this seat, strengthening their chances of controlling the Senate. But this would not be a flip. So this is something that they really need to hold on to in order to have a chance. But this will not go towards the sort of four to five seats they need in order to flip. Before we close,
Speaker 2I do want to just mention a few of the sort of underlying factors that could be influencing this election. One of the big ones just is Trump and how much everyone hates him. He has a 36% approval rating. which is the lowest pre-midterm approval rating in 50 years. Yeah, that makes sense. Not good. Not great for the Republicans. Not what you'd want, yeah. Not what you would want. And remember when I was talking about the enthusiasm gap that the Fox poll was showing? The latest KFF health
Speaker 2tracking poll, it's from the organization formerly known as Kaiser Family Foundation. They found a very large enthusiasm gap between parties in their last poll with Democratic voters... Much more likely than Republican voters to say they're, quote, more motivated to vote this year. Way more than usual. It's 63% to 38%. That's a huge gap. The cost of healthcare and gas tie as voters' top affordability worries. A quarter
Speaker 2of respondents said that they are very worried about affording each ahead of food, utilities, and housing. So 25% said they were very worried about affording health care. 25% said they're very worried about affording gas. So that's the tie. It's 50% of the concern. It's those two. The Democratic Party has a clear edge over the Republican Party on who voters trust to handle many top issues in the election, including cost of health care. 42% of respondents trust the Democrats more on these issues. For cost of living, 39%
Speaker 2of respondents trust Democrats more, going to 25% for the Republicans. And the cost of living was the top issue for both Democrat and independent voters, while Republican voters wanted candidates to discuss, quote, fraud. That's the big issue for Republicans right now. This is, you know, J.D. Vance's task force, the post kind of doge thing, is they're really obsessed with this idea of fraud, and not really the type of fraud that Robert or I would talk about. You know,
Speaker 2I think Everyone's pretty familiar with how much we're all being ripped off all the time. Scam culture is huge. Corporate fraud. The only culture. It's everything, right? And that's not what Republicans are interested in. They are wanting to kick people off public benefits, right? That's the type of fraud that they are mostly interested in. To close, the most interesting part about this KFF poll, though, is the numbers around Medicare for all. Quote, two thirds of the public, 66%,
Speaker 2said they favor Medicare for All, the highest share KFF has recorded since it began polling the idea in 2016. And, this is the really crazy part, quote, about half, 52%, said they would favor Medicare for All if it eliminated private health insurance companies, while 47% oppose. That is a huge change from like five years ago. This has been the biggest kind of protest against Medicare for All is the idea that it would take away your private health care.
Speaker 2When respondents get told this in polling, historically, we've seen support for Medicare for All take a big dip. This is the first time a majority of respondents have said they would still support Medicare for All if it took away private health care. To quote KFF, quote, This marks a departure from when KFF last asked this question in October 2020, when the prospect of eliminating private health insurance companies led to lower support for Medicare for All at just 37%. So this is a huge thing. And I
Speaker 2would be remiss to mention, you know, most of these candidates we're talking about in the Senate, the Democratic ones, you know, Troy Jackson, Angie Nixon, Abdul, Al-Said, they are running on Medicare for all. This has become a big resurgent topic, this election. The cost of healthcare is a big topic in these midterms. And rather than doing this sort of Pete Buttigieg style, Medicare for all who want it, you know, just kind of vaguely talking about having a public option, right? These candidates are being a bit more
Speaker 2strict about Medicare for all as like an actual policy and as a policy guarantee. I think Abdul's policy has some slight differences where it does not completely eliminate private health care, but it says that private health care should become redundant and still has a focus on a universal single payer system, which is much closer to the Bernie Sanders version than the sort of like half-assed versions that we've seen from other progressive candidates, you know, running for president like six years ago. So something that, you know,
Speaker 2maybe two or three years ago, I felt like is kind of like a political, you know, bygone. This is focused on like Medicare for all is definitely coming back in a big way. And people are not nearly as scared of the prospect of them not having private insurance because private insurance sucks. Yeah, it's gotten even worse. Like we're what, like two years after the Mangione assassination, things still suck. Everyone still hates health care companies.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 2Only hate them more as time goes on. So, yeah, that is the kind of rough overview of the issues affecting the midterms and where the polling stands now just a few weeks away from November. I want to say third. Let's see if I'm right. I am right.
Speaker 7Boom.
Speaker 2We'll probably do a few more polling updates on executive disorder as we get closer to to Election Day. Absolutely. But yeah, that's that's all for me here. Yeah.
Speaker 3Remember, guys, do what the IRGC would want you to do. Register to vote. We're not telling you to vote.
Speaker 2The IRGC is. No, the Iranian government is. We're not. Good stuff.
Speaker 9Welcome to It Could Happen Here, a podcast where the here is France and the it is it.
Speaker 2I am your host, Mia Wong.
Speaker 9And today we are going to be talking about the enormous and incredibly militant student protests in France.
Speaker 2And with me to talk about this is Faiza, who is a political analyst and feminist theorist in France. And Faiza, welcome to the show.
Speaker 1Thank you for having me, Mia.
Speaker 2Hello, everybody. Yeah, I'm really excited to talk with you about this because there has been so much unbelievably wild stuff happening both good and bad and like oh my.
Speaker 4God it's like hundreds of thousands of people in the streets most of whom are like 15 16 like oh my.
Speaker 1God it is so exciting to watch I mean, I've wanted to see such an uprising for so long. And it's finally starting to happen.
Speaker 12Yeah.
Speaker 1It was a slow build up this past couple of years. But I feel like something is maybe happening. And not just in France. Like the whole Gen Z worldwide is really tired of this shit. And is hitting the streets. And I love it. And I'm here for it.
Speaker 2It's amazing.
Speaker 5It is.
Speaker 9And yeah, we're going to be getting more into every other country that's also.
Speaker 2Going on right now because it's, you know, it's like.
Speaker 9It's like India and Spain and Chile.
Speaker 2We've seen a whole bunch of other countries in the past.
Speaker 1Yes, we have.
Speaker 2Six months go up. But I guess I want to start with going a bit in to sort of the background of this and going into what, what the political situation has been in France that's sort of been leading up to this and what kinds of conditions have been sort of producing this?
Speaker 1Well, have you heard of neoliberalism? No, like seriously, like that.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, well, we've had Macron, which is our very dear president. No, I'm kidding. We fucking hate the guy. The guy is rotten to his very core. So, yeah, he's been president for almost 10 years now.
Speaker 2Jesus Christ.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1And the utter and complete destruction of anything public, like public education, public health and everything, didn't start with him. But let's just say that he put the final nail on the proverbial coffin. And he's been like dismantling public education ever since he arrived in And took his job as president. And if you want an analogy or something
Speaker 1in comparison with what's happening in the U.S. with respect to your public education. Well, when I saw, like, 10 years ago, Betsy DeVos arrived as the Secretary of Education. Yeah. Well, you remember her? She basically destroyed anything public education-wise. Like she wanted to funnel all the money to private schools and charter schools. And that's basically what has been happening in France too, like in these past 10 years. All
Speaker 1the money has been funneled in public. More or less legal ways to private schools. Yes, I see more or less legal ways because there are a lot of loopholes. And Macron and his government are experts at using those loopholes. Basically, they can look at you in the eye and tell you that what they're doing is legal, technically.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1You know what I mean. And they will say that to your face while... destroying everything you hold near and dear at the same time. So these past 10 years, the money allocated to education has decreased. The number of teachers has tremendously decreased, like dramatically decreased.
Speaker 2Jesus.
Speaker 1The number of students by class has increased. The way this project started is, well, A school year in France started in September. It's basically from September to June, July. And, well, in the poorest areas of France, high schoolers arrived in their high schools and found basically not enough desks, not enough chairs, no teachers, holes everywhere. In the roof, water
Speaker 1leaking in the classrooms.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1No AC, like that goes without saying, like we don't have AC, like this is not the standard thing in France. So you could have like a hundred degrees Fahrenheit in, you know, and with no AC, like people, like high schoolers were cooking in their schools during the winter.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1Some of these schools, the poorest schools, also don't have heat.
Speaker 2Oh, Jesus. Yeah.
Speaker 1So it's freezing.
Speaker 2Oh, exactly.
Speaker 1I'll let you imagine how you can, how can you... learn anything in school while freezing by, I don't know, 50 degrees in your school.
Speaker 2Yeah. Like, you know, like, I remember thinking back to my high school, and it's like, well, like, we occasionally had drowned rafts falling out of the ceiling, but, like, at least we had heat in the winter. Like, we would have all died.
Speaker 1Even if the heat is out of the window, like, there's nothing left in some high schools. Like, really nothing. And The egregious thing is that you can have a very poor area with the poorest high schoolers, with the most destroyed high school you can see. And in the town nearby, you will find the best high schools with the richest population, like, For instance, in Paris, like you
Speaker 1have Paris, the capital, and you have Parisian suburbs. Some are extremely rich and some are basically the poorest ones in the whole country. So what has happened is that we don't have states. We basically have regions and departments and stuff like that, like the way France is cut. The map is cut like that. And so the president of, it's called the Île-de-France. Basically, Paris is part of a region.
Speaker 1The president of this region is a right-winger, pretty much far right, but officially she's only right-winger. And her specialty is to funnel money, public money, to private schools, private Catholic schools.
Speaker 2Jesus Christ.
Speaker 1Of course.
Speaker 2Many, many such cases.
Speaker 1I know, right? Amazing. You see the similarities with Betsy DeVos?
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's basically, those two women are the same picture. Let's just say it like that. So that president has been putting a lot of public money in private schools in Paris and in the Paris suburb. Rich ones. But where is she taking that money?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, instead of distributing this money equally across the whole territory that she's leading, she's only distributing that money to private schools, Catholic schools, and schools that are in the richest suburbs and in the richest area.
Speaker 2That makes sense.
Speaker 1So that's how you find yourself when you're poor, when you're a poor kid. growing up in a poor suburb that's how you find yourself going in a high school that has holes basically everywhere that doesn't have enough teachers that doesn't have enough desks enough chairs that is lacking basically everything that has rats running in in the hallways and yeah yeah so came last september like a month ago high schoolers went back to they found their school
Speaker 1being just as bad as it was just before when they went for the summer holidays and stuff like that. And so they came back and they found no teacher. They found no desk, no chair, no nothing. And yeah, they were mad and they were right. And so they started to protest to ask for teachers, money for... desks for chairs I mean it's the most basic things like
Speaker 1they're not asking for they're not asking for the the latest uh I don't know iPhone or iPad or whatever you know whatever the fuck no no they're asking for like the most basic necessities.
Speaker 2Yeah like we're asking for to be a school like exactly desk plus teacher is like the most basic school like what what are we doing.
Speaker 1Here And they're asking for a chance at life.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1You know what I mean? Like, we have a system. It's a system that has been in place since 2018. It started, so, under Macron, again. And it's a very, very opaque system. It's a system that is designed... It's an algorithm, basically, that is designed to... Think for you what you're going to do next. Basically, when you're in 10th grade, so I was telling you that before we started taping, but high school in France only has three
Speaker 1years in it, like 10th to 12th grade. So when you get in 10th grade, you have to choose in 10th grade what you're going to do in college or university.
Speaker 2Which is ridiculous.
Speaker 1It is utterly ridiculous.
Speaker 2Like, granted.
Speaker 4Awful.
Speaker 1Why? You're... You're 15. You're 15. And people are asking 15 years old to pick with high accuracy what they're going to do as adults for the rest of their lives. That is stressful. The level of stress these kids are facing is humongous. Ridiculous. Yeah.
Speaker 2It is ridiculous.
Speaker 1And the level of attempted suicide among high schoolers. has increased in a way that you cannot comprehend. Like, the numbers are terrifying. Also, that algorithm is a very racist one. It's a very classist one.
Speaker 9Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1It basically is a black box. Like people, we, the public, we don't know what's in the algorithm. Like we do not have access to it. The only thing that we know is the result. And the result is poor kids coming from poor areas have basically zero chance at getting access to a proper university or a university at all.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1Like you could end in a queue, but like the 5,000 kids in a queue to access a public university. I'm not talking about private schools. I'm talking about public schools.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1It's something that is deeply unfair. It's a system of, that when I was in high school didn't exist. When I was in high school, like it was 20, 25 years ago, I'm old. But yeah, when I was in high school, basically the only thing you had to do, you had an exam at the end of high school. And if you pass that exam, you could go to university. And that was it. And then the only thing that matters is was your grades in university. That's it.
Speaker 2Which is also still like a stressful system, but it's like, we've made it worse.
Speaker 1Exactly. It was a stressful system, but it made some sense.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 9There's a one-to-one correlation.
Speaker 1Exactly. There was some logic behind it. The logic now is cruelty. It is violence. It is class violence. It is race violence. It is ableism, obviously, also. And kids, well, they arrive in high school and they already know that their life is screwed. That's what's happening. And the government, the state, doesn't give a fuck. Which is basically why
Speaker 1you're seeing the footage you've been seeing for the last weeks. This is why the cops have been beating the shit out of high schoolers. because they don't give a fuck yeah and also they know that they don't have a choice what they're going to.
Speaker 9Do yeah it reminds me so much of the protest in india where it's like yeah you're facing the same thing of like this i guess is one of the one of the things of neoliberalism was like on the one hand education was supposed to be like your ticket out right it was supposed to be like if you you know, like meritocratic, if you were like good enough, you could get into a like elite university and that was your like ticket out of poverty. And then simultaneously, we're going to make that impossible. And yeah, I mean, just like thinking about like, yeah, like this, the stories
Speaker 9of these kids were forced into this like unbelievably intense, like competitive pressure and are just getting screwed out of the ability to fight their way out of the poverty that they've been born into and just.
Speaker 2Being like, fuck this. If they're going to rig the system, we're like, the only thing we can go do is fight them.
Speaker 1Exactly. And, you know, you were talking about like meritocracy, like I'm putting it in between quotes for people who can see me.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well, I mean, it was, that, that term was originally a joke. It was originally a joke. It was invented as a joke.
Speaker 9Like, and it's, it's the same thing with like the like pulling yourself up by your bootstraps the whole point of that is that you can't it was a joke but no we've like we decided this is a thing that exists in the world even though it doesn't god uh makes me insane all the time you can not.
Speaker 1Create a parody out of this reality. Like the, it's the level of like a comedy of dramedy is, is got here.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, talking about that, like a few days ago, um, we on my stream were watching a clip from the news. I don't remember which news outlet it was, but they were basically talking about a high school, a very famous one, uh, which is called Henri Quatre, Henry the fourth. And this high school is inside of Paris and it is well known for being like a very bourgeois high school. Like this is like basically as bourgeois as you can do,
Speaker 1as you can get. Yeah, it's a rich kid one. The anchor, the news anchor, introduced this high school by telling that it was basically poster child for meritocracy. And I choked. I choked on my saliva. I was like, no, no, you mean it's bourgeoisie. You used a word instead of another word. That's not meritocracy. That's bourgeoisie. But basically, that's the same thing. And thank you for saying it out loud. I was like, thank you.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 9And it's so funny because it's like it is in the original sense, which is that it was a joke about how it was just rich kids who got into college. But like it's not in the sense you're trying to use it.
Speaker 2Like, come on.
Speaker 1Yeah, neoliberalism saw the joke and was like, yeah, you know what I can do about it? I can rip the joke out of it. And I can just keep the word and make it something real. How about it?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 9It's like, what if all of the metaphors became literal now? And that's like the world that we live in.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1That's the fucking world we live in. Absolutely. The kids have no prospects. I mean, they don't have any in the US. Like Gen Z won't be able to buy a house. That's the same thing in France. Like that's the same thing in Spain. That's the same thing in Chile. That's the same thing in every country. capitalist capitalistic based society basically so yeah what we're seeing worldwide what we were seeing in france right now is the product of
Speaker 1what you're seeing in the u.s it's product of what you're seeing in spain it's yeah the neoliberal order it's white supremacy and of course i mean to be honest it's the least surprising thing ever like It's basically one plus one equals two. That's what we're seeing. It's a logical product of our society. So yeah, the kids are mad. They have the right to be, and I'm fully supportive.
Speaker 9Like, really.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 9So we're going to take an ad break because, yeah, we too are subject to the horrifying violence and whimsy of neoliberal capitalism.
Speaker 1I hear you.
Speaker 14I hear you.
Speaker 9And we are back. So let's talk about what the students have been up to.
Speaker 1You mean on the streets or do you mean on social media?
Speaker 9Yeah, let's get into, I guess, the streets first. What have the students been doing? What kinds of tactics have they been using?
Speaker 1So they've been using blockades, a lot of them. Which is basically a French tradition. We're very good at that. Like whenever there's a protest, especially high school protests and student protests, we build blockades. So we go for a disruption. So the purpose is to disrupt high schools, is to disrupt universities, and to push the adults, basically. to listen to the kids and what they want. So that's what
Speaker 1has been happening, except that our dear government basically says, fuck, we don't care, and sent the fuzz. So the cops have been answering to the protest by mutilating kids.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1And mutilating adults, basically. That's been this government's response to any protest since 2017, since Macron arrived in the Élysée, which is our White House, basically. So this time around, even news anchors have been taken aback by the violence coming from the cops.
Speaker 2Yeah, because it's like actual children. It is.
Speaker 1It's children... But on the other side, you have an authoritarian regime. Yeah. And what is evidently behaving as a police state. I mean, come on.
Speaker 2Yeah, like you're blowing kids' hands off.
Speaker 1You know who they've been getting their inspiration from?
Speaker 2The US?
Speaker 10ICE.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1Our government, when they saw ICE, when they saw... how, quote unquote, effective ICE is at handling the public and handling protests.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1They didn't even hide that it was their wood dreams. What we're seeing is the logical evolution of policing in a neoliberal society.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1Like the kids are asking for the most basic stuff and the most basic stuff could lead to a semblance of equality. And they cannot have that. So let's just send the cops. Let's just bit the shit out of the kids and terrorize the fuck out of adults. And let's teach everybody, the whole population, what protest looks like. It looks like blood. It looks like amputation. It looks
Speaker 1like losing an eye. The purpose is very clear. It's to put the fear of God in the population. Once the population is scared shitless, the said population will stop protesting and start complaining. Yeah.
Speaker 2Which, I will say, the kind of upside of drawing from the American ICE anti-protest model is that that didn't work. Doing that stuff in the US just pissed everyone off, and it was only when they stopped doing that kind of confrontation and, like, move to this like quiet ethnic cleansing model i guess where they didn't do comfort mass confrontation that like everything kind of i don't know that they were like really effectively able to carry out the ethnic cleansing which is bleak in its own right but
Speaker 2like it did it did backfire on them like sort of spectacularly yeah.
Speaker 1But it was a polite ethnic cleansing like What is scaring me, and it's not surprising, but it's still scary as fuck, is that you can do the most violent things with a polite tone and people just.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1Stop look at it and just keep living their lives as long as it's polite as long as it doesn't make a lot of noise as long as it's not disruptive yeah and our government really understands that but yours also.
Speaker 9Does sort of i feel like they're they're kind of like like our government's like because our entire government is like designed to produce content it took them a while to figure out that this is the way that you should actually do it because their initial instinct was just to like do these giant confrontations to produce content out of, and then eventually they realize, like, if you just do it quietly, then you can actually do the thing.
Speaker 10But.
Speaker 1Yeah, because if you do it quietly, then you get the liberals behind you. Because liberals, at the end of the day... They're not disruptive. Like, they want to keep on living their lives.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1They want to keep on, like, being able to consume. They want to be able to go to the movies and go on vacation. And, like, they need that kind of scope. They need that sense of normalcy to keep on going and protest, like, disrupt that sense of normalcy.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1So once you get back to a semblance of normalcy, you... Get liberals on your side, basically. Or at least you stop having liberals against you. Yeah. And yeah, that's what has been happening in the US. That's how our government has been rolling for the past almost 10 years now. What has been happening, though, with this protest is that liberals have been watching their own kids being beaten up.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1They've been watching their own kids losing eyes, like being arrested.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 1Put up in jail and stuff like that. And that is way too disruptive. This doesn't fly. So they're going to find another way to do things. I mean, I know how they're going to do stuff. They're just going to point their fingers at black and brown folks and say that these kids are the bad ones. And they deserve everything that's happening to them and that they are like manipulating the good white kids and stuff like that, like through social media, through So what our government also
Speaker 1has been doing these past almost 10 years is vilifying anything remotely left-wing. Like, I don't know if you know Jean-Luc Mélenchon.
Speaker 9Yeah, he's the kind of... The media used to describe him as like Francis Birdie, but he's like, Actually.
Speaker 1That's not so far-fetched. I would say that he's not as left-leaning as Bernie.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 9It's very funny because, like, when you read about him in the press, he gets described as, like, the hard left guy.
Speaker 2And he's like, no, he's not. This guy's, like, to the right of, like, the PCF, who were, like.
Speaker 1Oh, no, no. His political party, France Unabashed, La France Insoumise, has been categorized as far-left. It's social democracy.
Speaker 2Social democracy, yeah. It's like, what are we doing here? They're not revolutionary at all.
Speaker 1They're not anti-capitalist.
Speaker 2They're trying to save capitalism from you. And you're like, no, you're communist. It's like, no.
Speaker 1No, they're not even socialist. They're not a less harmful capitalism. It's really social democracy. It's Bernie core democracy. basically. But they might be a little bit more radical than Bernie here and there. Bernie can be more radical in some stances, but you know, none of them, neither Bernie nor Mélenchon are far, far left. Like they're not, they're just not. But when you have such reactionary politics in power, anything
Speaker 1remotely left-leaning seems far left. So This is how they've been presenting our opposition. And so coming back to what I was telling you, they are linking the protest to the France Unabashed Party, saying that it was created.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1It originated from France Unabashed and that this political party is instrumentalizing the protest and is basically, it's a big puppeteer.
Speaker 9The youth yeah this is like exactly the same shit they did in india except for india there was like i guess well actually i i don't know if if the french government has pulled the islamist card yet but like that was the other one oh it already has yeah yeah they're all the same like.
Speaker 1Scott islamophobia transphobia those two things are at the very core of our reactionary figures political figures and as they are as yours and and my like this is white supremacy basically like they're defending what they see as whiteness and white femininity and islam to them is a danger to white women and so is the existence of trans
Speaker 1folks so yeah yeah they're coming they're trying left-leaning to trans folks islam uh hamas obviously of course and yeah the muslim brotherhood jesus.
Speaker 9Christ at least well okay i'm not gonna say at least but like that that was the the one thing in the u.s to be at least kind of moved past was like we at least kind of stopped accusing everything of being the Muslim Brotherhood because a bunch of people started taking money from the UAE.
Speaker 2And then it was like, okay, we're going to quiet it down a little bit.
Speaker 1It's the same thing in France. The UAE have a lot of financial interest in France. But they're the good ones.
Speaker 2But they still do the loss of brotherhood.
Speaker 1Yeah, but they're the good Muslims because, you know, they invest a lot of money. Yeah, yeah. So that's okay. We can do business with them. So if we want to do business with them, we have to be able to say that they're the good ones. So the good ones.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Algeria.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1Palestine and other Muslim countries. Not so much. Not so much.
Speaker 9I feel like we kind of moved from like, it used to be everything was the Muslim Brotherhood and then that changed into everything is Hamas. But it's like, at least we moved from one to the other. But it's like, no, no, we're still doing the Muslim Brotherhood thing. God damn it.
Speaker 1Islamophobia is so... Raw.
Speaker 2Like, so raw.
Speaker 1They don't even think about, like, are they Shiite? Are they Sunni? Are they, like... No.
Speaker 8No.
Speaker 1Not at all. No, that's like.
Speaker 2They're just Muslim.
Speaker 1The problem is Islam. The problem is brown and black people. Yeah. And the problem is the left... which is defending Hamas, which is defending the Muslim Brotherhood, which is defending trans folks. When you look at the arguments, that's basically what they're saying. And I'm not even exaggerating. I wish I were, but I'm not. And it's like, they're not even trying. It's so obvious. But it's the same argument that has been
Speaker 1fed to the population through our media platforms. for years now. So yeah, people like just eat it up.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 9And I guess that leads into this question of like, how has the rest of French society been reacting to this? Have other sort of like movements been mobilizing?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, I was going to say apathy, which is kind of true. If you look at people on the center and on the right, it's apathy. It is, They just want to be able to wear their heads in the sand and keep on going, just like doing business as usual. Left-leaning people, some of them are scared. Some of them are in disbelief. Like they want to believe that if things were as bad as Gen Z is saying it is,
Speaker 1they would have somehow managed to see it.
Speaker 15Yeah.
Speaker 1The majority of people still believe that the media are a honest actor, which they are not. They haven't been for years. And as long as, basically, as long as people keep believing what the media, like mainstream media, traditional media feeds them, then they're not going to be able to see the problem.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 1And it's the same thing in the US. I mean, if people keep watching CNN and MSNBC and stuff like that, how can they possibly know how bad things are on the ground? They cannot. They cannot. So that's where we are. And it's scary, but it's the truth.
Speaker 9There's this quote from the sociologist Raul Zebechi about how Basically, one of the things that social movements do is like in these moments of rupture, they act like bolts of lightning across the sky, like illuminating the darkness. And that's what social movements do to the actual fundamental nature of reality. They reveal the structures of like power and domination in the world that are otherwise hidden by the sort of darkness. And that's what you're trying. But part of what you're trying to do with these protests is to like make
Speaker 9the actual function of society visible. clear for a moment where i don't know if there is a more clear expression of what neoliberalism is than we took all the money from the schools and gave it to the cops.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah a lot of signs during the protest like down the streets explicitly say that yeah like the kids know where the money is yeah it is funneled to the very rich through state subsidies and stuff like that and it is funneled to the cops and to the military complex, defense complex, and contractors and stuff like that. They know where it's going. So they know there is money. Even when our presidents say that there is no money
Speaker 1left for anything. Like, no, there's always money for the rich, somehow.
Speaker 12Go figure.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2There's always money for the police, too.
Speaker 1Exactly, there's always more money for the police, there's always more budget for the military, there's always more budget for the cops, there's always less budget for hospitals, there's always less budget for teachers and schools and stuff like that. So, people are not stupid. So they kind of, like, can put two and two together. But, People knowing what's happening and people acting on what they know, that's two entirely different things.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1And that's where the issue is, is what people know, people feel the problem like every end of the month when they realize that they don't have any money left in the bank for food and for anything. Yeah. But they don't act on it. Like, it feels impossible to get out of this way of life for the majority of people.
Speaker 16Yeah.
Speaker 1Call that the liberal mindset also? Like, do you know Thought Slime? Like, do you know the YouTuber Thought Slime?
Speaker 2Vaguely familiar.
Speaker 1They made a wonderful video about the way liberals think inside of a box and how even the most revolutionary thoughts are still imprisoned within that scope of thought for liberals. Like that scope of thought basically is what makes Bernie or Mélenchon far left to them.
Speaker 13Yeah.
Speaker 1Because it is so out of their deep possibilities to them that it feels revolutionary, even though it is absolutely not revolutionary.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1And that's why people stay in that apathetic state. Like, it feels impossible to them to ask for the most basic stuff. And that's what keeps... people in that loop of work, waking up, going to work, going back home, wondering how you're going to pay the bills, going to sleep and going back to work the next morning. So I don't think that people don't know what the issue is. But I think the issue is that people feel like
Speaker 1they have no leverage on their own lives and on their own governments. And if we stay in a liberal mindset, I think they're right. Which is why we have to get out of that liberal mindset. Which is how we have to throw away the liberal playbook. Because if we keep on playing by those rules, we're fucked.
Speaker 9Yeah, you either get more Macron or you get the inheritors. You either get the indirect inheritors of the SS or you get the direct inheritors of the SS.
Speaker 1Exactly, exactly. And they're all defending the same thing. They're defending capitalism. Yeah. They're defending the very rich. And we already know who the very rich are. We saw that about 100 years ago. So we know who they're rolling for. They're rolling for fascism.
Speaker 13Yeah.
Speaker 1That's all there is. So as long as we keep trying to adapt and keep on trying to save liberalism, We're not going to save us, ourselves. Like, we're not going to save the population. We're just going to save capitalism. It drives me crazy.
Speaker 9Speaking of doing things, of, like, finding alternatives to saving liberalism, like, this is all happening... At the same time as the giant sort of mass movement in Spain has kicked off.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 9Which is about, for people unfamiliar, I guess the short and incredibly bleak version is that basically Spanish authorities evicted a.
Speaker 2I think it was like an 80, 90-year-old woman.
Speaker 1She was 87, I think. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, 87.
Speaker 9And she fucking died because of it. And this has set off a massive, massive, series of protests I think they put like a couple days ago so we're recording this on like Friday October 9th I think like I think on like the 8th they put a hundred thousand people like in the streets of Barcelona over this there's been a you know they've been reoccupying some of like the core sort of places where Like the year the 2011 protests were born and like that sort of the thing, the thing that became Occupy, like the movement of the squares.
Speaker 1There still is a massive protest in Madrid. And yeah, it is.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1It is beautiful to see the solidarity around that woman and around her situation, how she's been evicted from the place she was living for over seven decades.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1It resonated with so many people.
Speaker 9I mean, it's social murder, but it's like normally social murder happens at like one more degree of remove than that. And this is like, no, actually, yeah, she was just murdered by the state and the landlords.
Speaker 1Exactly. Exactly.
Speaker 2So directly. And yeah.
Speaker 1And for everybody to see.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 9And so I guess I guess my question is like, how are you and how are also like people in the streets kind of like are people looking at this in the context of like the other movements that are happening at the same time? Or are we kind of still in that? what I would call the 2018-2019 mode of isolation, where it's hard for people to see themselves as part of a broader thing?
Speaker 1That's a very good question, and I think it's the latter. I think that people are so depoliticized that it is hard for them to link the most obvious linkable stuff together.
Speaker 2Yeah, or it's like you and the kids in India.
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 2I believe in us.
Speaker 1That's manufactured. The depoliticization of your population, mine, it's not random. To be able to keep us doing the 9 to 5 and complying and everything, they need a depoliticized population to keep on going forward. So I think that social media managed to get through Gen Z. So they managed to see that what's happening, what has been happening in France has also been happening in other countries. And they
Speaker 1managed to put two and two together. And they managed to see that, yeah, the issue is capitalism. The issue is white supremacy. The issue is patriarchy and imperialism. But when you start looking at millennials, Gen Xers....
Speaker 9That's... Which is also like, hey, if you're a millennial, we've literally, you've done this twice already.
Speaker 2I know!
Speaker 9We did 2011, we did 2020. I believe in us. I believe we can figure this out.
Speaker 2I know we can do this.
Speaker 1There's a part of me that believes in us, but there's also a part of me that knows how effective the capitalistic propaganda is. So the moment you start owning stuff... like a house, you know, an apartment and stuff like that, you start wanting to keep that stuff for yourself. Like, you deserve it. Like, suddenly, meritocracy seems real. And that's where the danger's at.
Speaker 14Yeah.
Speaker 1And that's where the danger's at. So, I mean, I see people living their lives and having zero realization.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Like, with respect to what's happening in the streets. Like, it doesn't hit them at all. Like, they keep on going... doing their stuff, and they just don't see how it affects them. Or worse than that, they see how it affects them, but they seem to have accepted, like.
Speaker 2Yeah, nothing can be done about it.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's like, I've suffered, you're going to suffer.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1That's how shit works. And to me, this is the scariest thing. This is the scariest thing. I don't have an answer to how I have to deal with that. I just know that, again, liberal mindset, and we have to get rid of that. I don't think that we're going to be able to convince the majority of people that what we are doing is the right thing. But then again, a hundred years ago, when we were fighting against fascism and Nazism, the majority of people So we
Speaker 1don't need a majority of people.
Speaker 9Yeah, this is the actual lesson of the storming of the Winter Palace. The actual lesson of the October Revolution is that You don't need everyone on your side. You just need your enemies to stay home.
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 2Then you can knock off Kerensky.
Speaker 9All you need is for them to stay home. Your enemies to stay home and enough of your allies to come out.
Speaker 2And you can do this.
Speaker 1You can see this liberal mindset is so hell-bent on trying to convince the majority of people. Like, No, we're not going to make it. It's not going to happen. This is why the very rich are owning all the media.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1Because they know. They know what you want to do. And they see what you want to do. And they have already put their chess pieces in place to disrupt that. So you have to do stuff differently. We have to organize differently.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 9Speaking of doing something differently, I want to close on... So, okay, I think people in France kind of understand logistically what it means when you're doing a blockade of a school. But for people, for example, in the US, we're like, I guess I have seen schools... I have seen colleges blockaded, but I've never been involved in a high school blockade. What does that actually just look like on a practical level?
Speaker 2Is it like.
Speaker 9We're, like, blockading the street leading up to the school? Is it like we're barring the entrance? What does that actually, like, physically look like?
Speaker 1Well, basically, physically, you are barring the entrance... Borrowing the street is complicated because for a lot of legal reasons and logistical reasons, it can be really difficult to block a whole street.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 1But yeah, you can block the entry of the school. You can put in front of the school whatever you want, like trash bins, barriers. Whatever. You can take desks from the inside, put them outside, pile them up. Yeah. Like anything.
Speaker 9Classic French revolutionary tradition. Stack all the desks.
Speaker 1You know, it surprised me when you asked me that because I was like, what? People don't know that? You take shit and you put that in front of the door and that's it.
Speaker 2Yeah. We have less of a tradition of that.
Speaker 1Exactly. Just like burning trash cans and stuff like that. It's a tradition. We do that all the time. That's protest shit. Like, of course, we're going to burn the trash.
Speaker 12Like, it's normal.
Speaker 1It's normal. But yeah, it's really, it's that simple. The purpose is to disrupt. So you do everything in your power to stop people from getting in the school.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1Because you don't want them to be able to get into school because you want them to ask for the same thing as you do so that they can go back to school.
Speaker 17Yeah.
Speaker 1So yeah, you forbid them from getting into school and you push them to support you. That's the whole blockade mindset.
Speaker 2Makes sense.
Speaker 1That's how strikes work, basically, also.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 9Which I guess is the other angle of like... Something I've been thinking about a lot, talking to you, because one of the things that struck me about these protests is the extent to which when you like read over the student grievances, it's like, oh, this is like exactly the same grievances you would have for a teacher strike.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 9Like it's the same things. It's like, oh, wow, class size too big. Don't have teachers.
Speaker 1That's very good that you talk about that because our teachers are not really supportive.
Speaker 2Of Yeah, which is like, what is wrong with you? Like, you gotta go now.
Speaker 9Like, if you want your conditions to suck less, you need to move right now.
Speaker 2Like, this is the best you're gonna get.
Speaker 1Well, in France, like, a few decades ago, teachers used to be seen as left-leaning, left-wing. They're no longer left-wing. I'm sure they're really, like, right-wingers. Like, they want to be paid more, which they deserve to be paid more. Like, really, they're not paid enough.
Speaker 2But.
Speaker 1they're not asking for it like in a disruptive manner and basically they're not getting paid more. Oh, shocking. I know. But so yeah, the, the teachers are not really supportive of the, their students, which shows you everything you need to know about the state of affairs basically. Yeah.
Speaker 9Which like that has been like one of the things that's been heartening in the U S is seeing a lot of kind of like, like students coming out to support teacher strikes and like, things like that, where, like, teachers are sometimes, like, are supporting, like, student walkouts and stuff.
Speaker 2And that's really sad.
Speaker 9Because, like, I don't know, like, if you were a teacher, like, the thing that you have the responsibility to do is to care for your students. And if you're not doing that, then, like, yeah, I mean, I guess you are just the kind of, like, you're doing education in the Napoleonic sense, if, like, yeah, we're cranking you out so you can, like, be cannon fodder for, like, the French Imperial Army.
Speaker 7Like.
Speaker 1Exactly. No, that's what's happening.
Speaker 2Like.
Speaker 1Again, neoliberalism is a deeply individualistic way of life. And you can see that in the way teachers are not supporting their students who are asking for stuff that teachers are also asking for. So logically, you should see teachers support students. But when you look at reality, they are not. They're not. So, yeah, because they only think about what's in it for me. And we've been molded into only
Speaker 1thinking about what's good for me, what's in it for me. And we've stopped thinking us as a society, but just as a set of individuals. And that's one of the biggest issues we're facing, politically speaking.
Speaker 2Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Yeah, do you have anything else that you want to make sure people know before we wrap things up?
Speaker 1Yeah, I really want to stress the fact that what's happening in France and the problem is at its root. It's the same problem that is happening in the US. It's the same one that is happening in Spain, in the UK, in Germany, and basically the whole West and even more like in Japan, in South Korea.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1In India, just like what we're talking about, that is neoliberalism, that is capitalism, that is imperialism, that is white supremacy, that is patriarchy. And we need to come together. I don't think that fighting within our borders is going to lead to anything, but we cannot change stuff by just fighting for our countries individually.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1Like we have to fight together because, well, capital doesn't know borders. Yeah. We share the same enemy. We share the same enemy and we have to coalesce and organize worldwide in order to fight back and have a chance of fighting back properly.
Speaker 18Yeah.
Speaker 1So yeah, organize internationally. Talk to your French folks, to your British folks, Spanish.
Speaker 12Folks, etc.
Speaker 1And yeah, teach what you know and learn from them. And I think that's the only way out of that shit hole.
Speaker 2Hell yeah.
Speaker 9Faiza, thank you so much. Thank you so much for coming on. Where can people find your work?
Speaker 1Thank you for having me, Mia. People can find me on Twitch. at a phaser so f-a-y-z-a underscore underscore and also on instagram and blue sky and sometimes on tiktok.
Speaker 9Cool yeah we will have links to that in the show notes yeah thank you so much for coming on and i don't know i hope i hope y'all fucking win.
Speaker 1Thank you i also hope that much thank you thank you thank you and thank you again for having me Yeah, it's been great.
Speaker 2Hi, everyone.
Speaker 19You're listening to It Could Happen Here. My name is Carlos Berrios Polanco. And today I'm going to be talking about breadfruit, the climate change resistant crop that also works as a tool for emergency preparedness. But before I get into that, let me tell you why I started thinking about breadfruit in the first place. If you're anything like me, the effects of human-caused climate change on the food that we eat and grow have been on your mind lately. Maybe you've been thinking about it because you saw a
Speaker 19scary-looking graph that shows the global temperature shooting up over the last few years and only increasing over the next couple of decades. When this type of graph comes up in an article about food, It's usually accompanied by a rice or cornfield so dry that the ground is cracked to show how bad it's gotten and how much worse it can get. Or maybe you're thinking about it because the price of foods that have become staples in your diet, like rice, chicken, and coffee, have gone up significantly year
Speaker 19over year because of a mixture of different climate-related causes has caused crop losses all over the world, and for the very process of planting and harvesting to become more expensive, a process known as quote-unquote climateflation. And in the case of more specialty foods, like Florida oranges, for example, maybe they're not even available at the grocery store anymore because of how hard crops have been hit by extreme weather events and illness. To be clear, climate change isn't the only reason that food prices have gone up lately. The
Speaker 19closure of the Strait of Hormuz because of the U.S. 's war on Iran has also certainly led to prices going up for everything across the board. But climate change is the main thing that has been and will continue to affect the way that we consume food into the future, especially as resources become scarcer and we as a planet start realizing that what once worked to feed us isn't going to be viable forever. A study by the Climate Impact Lab found that every additional degree Celsius of global
Speaker 19warming will lead to global production of six stable crops, corn, soybean, rice, wheat, cassava, and sorghum, to decrease by 4.4%, which is roughly equivalent to a loss of 120 calories per person per day. As Solomon Sheehan, one of the senior authors of this study and a professor of environmental sciences at Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability, told the UK Telegraph, quote, if climate
Speaker 19warms by three degrees, that's basically like everyone on the planet giving up breakfast, end quote. This is pretty bad already, but it's going to affect the people already suffering from food insecurity the worst. And that's not to say that we're not growing enough food, just that it's not being distributed to the people who need it most. Three degrees of warming would also cause cataclysmic ecological effects for millions of people around the world, to include cities submerged by
Speaker 19rising sea levels, months-long deadly heat waves, and turn people into refugees by the millions. The regions most affected by climate change right now, like Africa, Southern Asia, and the Caribbean are would be the most affected by this. So I've really been thinking a lot about that lately, and I did what I always do whenever I start to think about collapse and cataclysm like that. I look for the ways that people around me are trying to deal with the effects of climate change in the best way
Speaker 19that they can.
Speaker 12That's why.
Speaker 19On a recent Friday morning, I found myself about an hour away from my hometown of Caguas in a tiny little neighborhood called Mariana that's nestled into the mountains of the municipal borderline between Yabucoa and Umacao. As I made my way through the labyrinth-like roads up to the mountain that definitely were not made to fit two cars side by side, I knew that I was getting close because I started seeing nearly 100-foot-tall breadfruit trees reach towards the heavens. I was there in late September right at the tail end of the breadfruit's harvest season. So the bright yellow-green
Speaker 19football-sized fruits weren't as plentiful as they would be if I had come earlier in the month. If you've never seen a breadfruit or never tasted one, you should probably fix that as soon as you can.
Speaker 12It's delicious.
Speaker 19Breadfruit trees can grow up to 100 feet tall and are covered in large green leaves. The fruit itself can grow to be almost 15 pounds, but usually tops out at about 6 to 10 pounds. Per the Breadfruit Institute in Hawaii, it's an energy-rich food and a good source of complex carbs, fiber, and minerals like potassium and calcium as well as vitamin.
Speaker 2B and others.
Speaker 19Although some varieties grow with seeds, in my experience, the majority don't. Therefore, about 90% of the time, you're more likely to see breadfruit propagated through root cuttings or tissue cultures or something like that, rather than from seed. Breadfruit trees grow extremely quickly, like up to four feet per year, and will begin producing fruit in about three years. And it produces a lot of fruit, like between 100 or 200 individual fruits per tree, although some trees could blow
Speaker 19past that. Harvest season depends on where these trees are grown, but it's generally late summer to fall, usually. The tree itself doesn't need too much care or perfect growing conditions. Far from it, actually. As long as you can provide it with medium amounts of water and deep, fertile, and well-draining soils, it'll grow for you. And even then, some varieties grow in atolls that are shallow and sandy, according to the Breadfruit Institute. And it'll also grow on hillsides.
Speaker 19That's why it's often touted as a quote-unquote climate-resilient tree, because it'll grow in a bunch of different conditions. It's really the goat of trees. As to what the fruit tastes like, well, it's in the name. When cooked, it tastes like bread, although I've read some people can describe it as kind of like a starchy and nutty potato. It can be used in a million different recipes and used in all states of ripeness, from completely raw to overripe. Personally, my favorite way to eat it is cooked into tostones,
Speaker 19which are these kind of twice-fried flattened fritters that are usually made from plantain, but I prefer when they're made out of breadfruit. I've been to Mariana before, about three years ago, to work on a story about how communities affected by the destruction caused by Hurricane Maria in 2017 and Hurricane Fiona in 2022 were designing their just recovery through bottom-up methods, like a community aqueduct to help ail the neighborhood's decades-long water issues, as well as a community census to know who is the most vulnerable in case
Speaker 19of an emergency and make sure they got help first. And in a sense, I was back there to cover essentially the same thing, except that this time it was community preparedness through a breadfruit farm that they've planted at La Loma de la Niña Mariana, a kind of community park slash rec space. It's a really serene space. especially when it's empty. It's surrounded by breadfruit and other trees, so there's a lot of green, and the breeze is a welcoming reprieve from the near triple-digit temperatures we've been
Speaker 19having lately. Mariana is the neighborhood that grows the most breadfruit in Humacao, Rosalina Abreu tells me. She's a community leader who's part of the neighborhood's non-profit organization, Arecma, which is in charge of community participation and development. As a quick note, I interviewed Rosalina in our native Spanish, but Mia from the Cool Zone team was gracious enough to read a translation of that interview here and in following sections.
Speaker 2It's a tree with a strong root. It's resistant to hurricanes and any environmental changes. And a mature tree can yield a harvest of between 100 and 300 to 400 breadfruits.
Speaker 13Therefore....
Speaker 2The harvest is fruitful and abundant.
Speaker 19Breadfruit has a long history here. Rosalina tells me that her family has always had a breadfruit tree or a couple growing near them going back generations because of how much food it produces and because when you preserve it, it can last months with proper refrigeration. In Puerto Rico, it was originally used as sustenance for pigs and other livestock, but little by little, people started paying attention to how good the fruit was, how many nutrients it provided, and people started using it for everything. Mariana has been hosting
Speaker 19a breadfruit festival between the end of August and the start of September amid the peak breadfruit harvest for 38 years. The community has also created a breadfruit recipe book that I'm flipping through as I read this script, and it has dozens and dozens of different things you make with it from fritters to flan and even juice. When Hurricane Maria, a Category 4 hurricane, tore through Puerto Rico in 2017, leaving thousands of people dead and causing more than $ 91
Speaker 19billion in damages, Mariana was left more or less incommunicated from the rest of the world. Rosalina told me years ago that it was like a bomb had been dropped in their neighborhood. But knowing that the government wasn't coming to help their small rural community, they knew that the only people they could count on or themselves. So they got to work and opened a food distribution center at La Loma where they were feeding members of the community with whatever food they had on hand and whatever food
Speaker 19they could gather from the hundreds of breadfruit trees and others in the neighborhood.
Speaker 2We've seen that when the need arises, people come here to look for breadfruit. And not only that, But the environment is full of trees that keep us cool, that provide a natural space for growth. And eventually we know that we are going to be one of the neighborhoods best prepared for any situation that involves a food shortage. We're going to have breadfruit to share and to use. In fact, we have a kitchen here, a semi-industrial kitchen that opens to feed the neighborhood. During the time of Maria, we served 400 people daily that came looking for food here.
Speaker 2We already have the kitchen, we have the trees planted. So we're already a step ahead for the survival of our people if an event occurs.
Speaker 19Neighbors in Mariana have planted about 80 breadfruit trees throughout La Loma as a kind of disaster insurance policy. There is probably not a fruit tree that can really withstand a hurricane or severe flooding or something like that. But if a breadfruit tree goes down, it'll likely start to spring back up from the roots. Of the four people that I interviewed for this episode, all of them told me something similar. And if a breadfruit tree gets stripped of its leaves and its fruits by a storm, it'll probably start sprouting leaves a few weeks after and will
Speaker 19probably produce breadfruit next harvest season. Something similar, although to a lower degree, happened when Hurricane Fiona hit in 2022. Rosalina explained to me that in the 1920s and.
Speaker 101930s, the U.S.
Speaker 19Government tried to take down breadfruit trees to grow potatoes, but they didn't take away the roots, so it just sprang back up again. She also says that Puerto Rico's farmers took the tree up into the mountains. It usually grows closer to the beach and other places where it has thrived ever since.
Speaker 2It looks like a Christmas tree with its bulbs because each branch has two or three bread fruits. And when they're ripe, when it's harvest time, you look at it, and it's really miraculous. Plus, it provides food, provides shade, it's resistant to the soil, meaning you can plant it in areas prone to landslides, and it will preserve the terrain so there's no collapses or landslides. So, for many.
Speaker 20Reasons, it's a tree we could consider miraculous.
Speaker 19Breadfruit is one of the first crops to grow back in Puerto Rico after an extreme weather event. It also grows pretty much everywhere throughout the archipelago. And this is super important because Puerto Rico is one of the countries most affected by climate change, ranking sixth on German Watch's Climate Risk Index. which looks at how countries are affected by extreme weather events and how they cause loss of life and how it impacts their GDP. Puerto Rico has experienced several disasters caused by extreme weather over the years,
Speaker 19the biggest of which were Hurricanes Irma and Maria and Fiona. Maria caused a loss of around 80% of the archipelago's crops, or about $ 800 million worth of food, according to the New York Times. Meanwhile, Fiona caused about $ 159 million in losses for the agricultural industry per the AP.
Speaker 21Breadfruit has proven to be drought resistant. It's wind resistant. After Hurricane Maria, we were eating breadfruit first than we were eating local bananas and local plantains. Because they were highly affected by the winds, but they would come back. So it's very interesting how... Even if the fruits are smaller, it will bear fruit, especially in a drought season.
Speaker 19That's Marisol Villalobos, a co-founder of Amazar, a company that sells breadfruit flour that's shelf-stable and can last years with no problems. Their farm's in Hayuya, and in 2017, her and her husband, who's also a co-founder, had planted about two acres of their farm worldwide. breadfruit, but the saplings were little tiny sticks when Maria hid, and only one survived. Marisol now calls it the quote-unquote matriarch tree. Nearly 10 years after that, their farm now has 500 breadfruit trees
Speaker 19that are producing hundreds and hundreds of pounds of breadfruit that they turn into flour every year. They're one of the first farms in Puerto Rico to grow breadfruit and cocoa at the same time. The breadfruit trees provide the necessary shade for cocoa to grow. They've also planted several other native trees throughout their farms. If you wanted to produce breadfruit at an industrial scale, this probably isn't the best way to go. Most industrial agriculture has one singular crop planted over large swaths of land to maximize production,
Speaker 19ease of gathering, and resources. This is called monoculture. However, there's serious downsides to it, like needing to pump tons of fertilizer and compost into the soil to keep it growing the same thing over and over again, as well as increasing the risk that a pest or illness will wreak havoc throughout the crop. The way Marisol grows breadfruit isn't ideal if they wanted to maximize production, but Marisol isn't really bothered by it. Instead, she thinks it's better
Speaker 19that way because of its positive effects on the soil and on the plants.
Speaker 21Some people say, no, it might not be the best synergy. I see it in a way, you know, I'm enriching my model of agroforestry. And what we produce is what we produce. But if I have a more secure crop in terms of resilience and protection from sicknesses, illnesses in place, I'm very happy with that.
Speaker 19Puerto Rico grows very little of its own food, about 10-15% depending on the source that you look at. While breadfruit has been part of Puerto Ricans' diets for centuries, production of it has been going down over the last few years as Puerto Rico becomes even more reliant on imports. Per data from the Archipelago's Department of Agriculture, production of breadfruit has gone down from 1991 to 2019, the last year for which public data is available, by about 771,000 pounds.
Speaker 19Only about 650,000 pounds of breadfruit were produced in Puerto Rico in 2019, according to the data. Meanwhile, imports have risen rapidly from 2015 to 2019, reaching about 830,000 pounds of breadfruit imported in 2019. So people are still eating breadfruit. They're eating more of it, but we just can't grow it fast enough.
Speaker 21So we definitely have a great opportunity in Puerto Rico to increase local production and local consumption with a crop like breadfruit and especially incorporating other crops with it. Beans, vegetables, a lot of farinacios, taro.
Speaker 1Plantains, all that. Yeah.
Speaker 21And even animals, you know, nice farms that have both things, silver pasture with trees and with the animals. And then we have a little bit more protein there too.
Speaker 1So yeah.
Speaker 19When we get back from the ad break, we're going to be talking about the history of breadfruit's voyage from the Pacific to the Caribbean and the rest of the world and how breadfruit is being distributed to help combat hunger crises everywhere. And we're back. You're listening to It Could Happen Here. I'm Carlos, your host for today's episode. And while breadfruit has become a staple in the Caribbean
Speaker 19because of how easily it grows and its ability to be turned into a gazillion different things, it's not native here. Instead, it's originally from the western Pacific, specifically from New Guinea and the Indo-Malay region. Thousands of years ago, it was spread by the indigenous Polynesians who were the literal first people to travel across the region. They would travel on double-hulled canoes that are nothing like what we know of as canoes today. Instead, each hull could reach up to 100 feet in length, they had a sail, and they
Speaker 19could fit entire families as well as the food and resources they needed to settle on the islands they were traveling to. And one of the things they carried were breadfruit saplings because of how much fruit it would produce when planted.
Speaker 20In the case of breadfruit, it was usually the little saplings that shoot up from the roots. They would cut them and pack them in a ball of earth and leaves and keep them moist so that they could plant them on the new island and have the same familiar foods that they were used to wherever they were coming from.
Speaker 19That's Russell Fielding, an associate professor at Coastal Carolina University in South Carolina who researches geography and environmental justice and who wrote the book Red Fruit, Free Global Journeys of a Bountiful Tree. He explained, that one of the Pacific people's earliest uses for breadfruit was roasting it in an earth oven, which is when you create a pit, put burning coals in there, then the fruit, then more coals on top, and then you cover it all with stones and soil. This type of cooking is common to a
Speaker 19bunch of indigenous cultures across the world, and it produces delicious food. Another way that the people of the Pacific used breadfruit that Russell's never seen outside of the region is putting it into a dark pit, making sure there's no airflow, and then letting it ferment. This turns it into a sort of paste that can be stored for a long time. It tastes kind of tart, almost like citrus, Russell told me. Its name depends on which Pacific island you're on, but the people of the Marquesas call it ma.
Speaker 20And so this fermented breadfruit was used as kind of an insurance against times of scarcity, where, you know, if you get a big crop of breadfruit, like you said, A single tree in a single season produces lots of fruit. So if it's more than you need for the time being, you can ferment some of it to store it away for later. And then maybe there's a drought or a famine at some point and you have to dip into your reserves.
Speaker 19This shows that the history of breadfruit as an emergency preparedness tool goes back millennia. People and the breadfruit they carried continued spreading across the Pacific. When the Europeans colonized the region, they essentially forced the people to switch from breadfruit to imports from the globalized market. Crops like coffee, pineapples, and sugar overtook the breadfruit groves in taro patches, while rice became a staple of the Pacific diet, according to Russell's book. It's a story anyone familiar with colonization or
Speaker 19who's been a victim of it knows all too well. However, breadfruit has seen a resurgence in recent times. In Hawaii, According to an article in Civil Beat, breadfruit production is booming, but similar to Puerto Rico, farmers can't keep up with demand. We'll get back to the modern-day breadfruit situation in a second. But before that, let's talk about how breadfruit made its way all the way from the Pacific to the Caribbean.
Speaker 20It wasn't until the very end of the 18th century that breadfruit made its jump to the Caribbean. And this was intentional. This was directed by the European colonialists. It was the British that eventually succeeded first, but they weren't the only ones trying. The French had also made efforts to bring breadfruit to the Caribbean. And there's some hypothesis that the Spanish were also moving breadfruit around the same time. But the British did it first.
Speaker 19You might have heard this story before. The story of the mutiny on the bounty. Every time I mentioned to someone that I was working on this breadfruit project, They would mention the original 1945 movie, The Muni on the Bounty, or the 1962 remake with Marlon Brando to me. And I would be like, yeah, for sure. But let me be honest with you, dear listener. I did not know that these movies existed up until a couple of weeks before recording this episode.
Speaker 2And to be honest, they're pretty good.
Speaker 193.5 stars on Letterboxd. Anyway, as European colonization wrecked terror and death throughout the Caribbean... The British came up with a plan to transport breadfruit from their Pacific colonies to their Caribbean colonies, all of which had more or less the same climate, to feed the enslaved people that they had kidnapped from Africa and forced to work on sugar plantations. So, the British assigned William Bly to the HMS Bounty, and they traveled to Tahiti to load upon breadfruit. Bly, as
Speaker 19authoritarians commonly do, was quick to anger and routinely verbally berated and physically assaulted his crew, who eventually mutinied and sent Bly in his loyalist packing. However, Bly eventually made his way back to England, where he would once again make his way back to Tahiti and eventually reach his original goal of bringing breadfruit to the Caribbean. He first stopped in St. Vincent in 1793, then Jamaica shortly after. Then breadfruit was all over the Caribbean in a few
Speaker 19short years, even reaching the state of Florida a few decades later, where it's still really the only place in the continental U.S. where it can grow outside without too much trouble. Although it really only mostly grows in the Keys and the warmest parts of South Florida because it's super susceptible to a cold snap.
Speaker 20It was specifically intended to feed people that were enslaved on sugar plantations and or otherwise impoverished. I know that not every island was practicing slavery at the time that breadfruit was imported to that island, but breadfruit was never really intended as a food for everyone. It was for the poor and the enslaved. And unfortunately, that gave breadfruit something of a stigma or a negative reputation in a lot of places throughout the Caribbean. And you can even still find traces of that today, where it's referred to
Speaker 20as you know, poor man's food or comida y barro, where it's still got that association today with poverty.
Speaker 19Russell explained that while slavery was still going on, people that were able to eat something else absolutely refused to eat breadfruit. That's how hated it was, and who could really blame them? This reputation as a food for enslaved people or something that only people in poverty ate stuck around for decades, and one could make the argument that some of that sentiment still lingers today. Even if breadfruit's reputation has started to turn around, so much of that evil history of colonialism and slavery is inescapable. Even now,
Speaker 19as I read this script, I think about how the communities where this fruit grows the most are some of the ones most affected by human-caused climate change, which they contribute the least to. The Caribbean historically accounts for less than 1% of the world's global greenhouse gas emissions, according to the Emissions Database for Global Atmospheric Research. Theoretically, there could come a day when breadfruit is not as bountiful as it once was because of the heat or even refuse to grow altogether. Even though breadfruit is certainly climate
Speaker 19resilient and it can take a lot, it can't survive without soil and water. both of which are becoming harder and harder to come by day by day. The global south, a lot of which relies on breadfruit as part of their diet, will no longer be able to grow this bountiful tree if we reach certain levels of warming. As the hottest year on record morphs into the hottest year so far, the global north will likely get to experience breadfruit for the first time as areas that were once
Speaker 19hostile to breadfruit become its new home. This seems to already be happening in the Marshall Islands, another place that is very, very, very affected by climate change, as in they're literally disappearing before our eyes. Their breadfruit, which they call ulu, similar to other places in the Pacific, has seen better days. They're growing smaller and less bountiful, according to one farmer the Civil Beat interviewed. He thinks it's salt getting into the soil or the aquifer. While breadfruit
Speaker 19can resist some salt, the constant presence is killer. Per a study published in PLOS Climate about how breadfruit can contribute to climate-resilient food systems in areas near the equator, the area suitable for breadfruit cultivation in the tropics and subtropics is projected to decrease by 4.4% in a scenario where we stabilize emissions. aka where emission levels go down but do not reach net zero by the year 2100, and they'll decrease by about 4.5% in a high-emission scenario,
Speaker 19which essentially means if we burn even more fossil fuels by 2100. In these scenarios, the areas most affected will be Latin America and the Caribbean. where a suitable range for breadfruit growth will decrease by 10.1% if we stabilize emissions and 11.5% in a high-emission scenario. Meanwhile, in Southeast Asia and the Pacific, yield quality and consistency show minimal decreases under a high-emission scenario, while the land where you
Speaker 19can plant breadfruit will likely go up. In all regions, a high-emission scenario will lead to reduced consistency and quality of breadfruit harvests. The narrative of the study ends by saying that breadfruit may play a role in alleviating current and future food insecurity, particularly in equatorial Africa. When instituted with an agroforestry model, as Marisol is doing, it could be a potent climate adaptation strategy. This study also mentions that its role can be expanded in countries that already
Speaker 19produce it to become even more of a staple and help address growing climate-related issues there.
Speaker 13Ironically, tropical regions are where you do find some of the world's underserved people, people with hunger and malnutrition as part of their risks of daily living. So the kinds of tree that we plant and the need are very well matched.
Speaker 19That was Mike McLaughlin, co-founder and secretary of the Trees That Feed Foundation. a Chicago-based nonprofit whose mission is to feed people, create jobs, and benefit the environment. Mike and his wife, Mary, who's president of Trees That Feed, grew up in Jamaica, where breadfruit is incredibly common. However, they didn't think of planting it until years later when they realized how badly climate change was affecting the environment as well as the problems it was causing around the world.
Speaker 19And then they started thinking about what they could do about it.
Speaker 15And the reason we wanted to plant fruit trees, it was kind of an easier sell. There were, and there still are, climate change skeptics, people that don't think anything is happening. They're not worried about super El Nino. They're not doing anything to reduce our fossil fuel use, our carbon footprint. And so because of the skeptics, we said if we lead our effort with with climate change and
Speaker 15solving that problem, we kind of have to do more explaining. We're going to be more skeptics. But if we say we're planting trees to feed people, everybody understands that.
Speaker 13They know that.
Speaker 19Trees that feed gives breadfruit and other trees to farmers in more than 20 countries, then teaches them how to take care of them, harvest the breadfruit and process it so that it can be sold and used to feed their families. Part of the reason they have this emphasis with farmers is that it reduces reliance on imported food, which means that more money circulates in the local economy instead of going elsewhere. The organization also buys breadfruit flour
Speaker 19and other breadfruit-based products from processors and bakeries, then donates them to schools as part of their school feeding programs. which serves more than 20 schools and orphanages in Haiti, which is the second country that they started working with, Mike explained. 5.8 million Haitians, a little more than half of the country's total population, face crisis levels of food insecurity or worse, according to the United Nations World Food Programme. More than 250,000 children aged 6 to 59 months are
Speaker 19projected to suffer from acute malnutrition between June 2026 and May 2027, per a UN analysis. Some people in Haiti are forced to eat mud cookies, which are exactly what they sound like, a little bit of earth, salt, and oil that's meant to curb hunger pangs. It's the saddest thing Mike's ever heard of, he told me. Trees that feed Foundation have tried to substitute that where they can, with con pared, a type of bread that's dense like cake or a breadfruit porridge. These recipes were co-produced with
Speaker 19bakers in Haiti and North America, according to the organization's website. Part of the trouble of growing so much breadfruit is that it ripens really quickly, like within a couple of days, it might start rotting if you don't refrigerate it. So to combat that, Mike helped create a solar dehydrator that can dehydrate breadfruit so that it can be stored without refrigeration without affecting the nutritional benefits of the food. This means that it can be stored for up to several years and still maintain the same nutritional value. What Trees
Speaker 19That Feed is doing, using breadfruit as a tool for sustainable development, is part of its history all along, Russell, who's also a board member of the organization, told me during our interview. When indigenous communities were carrying it across the Pacific, they were hoping to feed themselves wherever they settled. Although it was a weapon in service of the evils of slavery, the British brought breadfruit to the Caribbean to provide food when it became scarce, in large part because of their own actions planting monoculture sugar plantations everywhere, to
Speaker 19be clear. Meanwhile, in modern times, it continues spreading across the world as an attempt to feed people suffering through hunger because of climate change and other crises. It's time to throw the ads, but when we come back, We'll wrap this episode up by talking about how the real power of breadfruit might have been the friends that we made along the way. You're listening to It Could Happen Here.
Speaker 19I'm your host for today, Carlos. And one thing I haven't mentioned yet is about what we call breadfruit in Spanish. It has a bunch of names depending on where you are. Panapeng, frutipang, masapang, buempang.
Speaker 1You get the idea.
Speaker 2They're all bread related.
Speaker 19However, what I and millions of other Puerto Ricans call it is pana, which is exactly the same way that we refer to a close friend. A direct translation would be something like buddy or homie. So every breadfruit is a friend. This fruit that grows quickly and produces hundreds of pounds of food from a single tree that has accompanied people into the unknown and been turned from a weapon that sustained humanity's greatest evil into a food that
Speaker 19now helps sustain millions and millions of people every day that has started sprouting weeks after disaster raised every other crop, that will grow tall and wild without much help, and almost always has something to give, is literally named Friend. That's the kind of beautiful and surreal that only real life could ever be? Marisol from Amazar has a theory about why it's called Pana that I think is worth sharing.
Speaker 21We in Amazar have a theory that it has to do that. We have a very strong relationship in Puerto Rico with our godfathers. And comadre and compadre is that relationship of the parents of the godchild with the godfather and godmother of that child. So if I were to visit in the 1800s, and we were very, very, very poor, extremely poor, and a lot of malnutrition, if I were to visit a friend, I would bring a pana. with
Speaker 21me and here's your pana, here's your pana, a pana. So it was kind of like that connotation of I'm giving you something to help nurture your family. So that's something very special. So if you're really my pana, you're dear to me, I will protect you. I will take care of you and I will, I will have your back.
Speaker 19I want to end this episode by returning back to La Loma de la Niña Mariana. After my interview with Rosalina, when I was on my way out, I stopped to take a photo of a mosaic made with hundreds of little pieces of colorful tiles. It depicts about a dozen hands together in a circle, like they're about to go three, two, one, go team.
Speaker 2There's a breadfruit at.
Speaker 19The center of the circle, almost as if it's the thing they've put their whole faith in. But the inscription under the mosaic, glory to the hands that work, makes it clear that even though breadfruit might be at the center of this art and one of the most important things in this community, The real greatest thing that this neighborhood has are its people, the ones that are putting in the work when it's needed, the ones that are making sure to help their neighbors when they need help, the ones that are using all this breadfruit and have used it to cook for years and years whenever there's
Speaker 19a crisis. It can't happen without them. Breadfruit might grow super quickly. It might be incredibly abundant as a source of food, but it can't be used to feed people without the community putting in the work to gather it, cook it, store it, and then bring it back out when it's needed.
Speaker 9Because to us, if we've done anything, it's that we've seeded solidarity. I mean, whenever a situation happens here, people show up and immediately ask, how can I help? What can I do? Where can I pitch in? People get here hauling water with whatever they have at home. Cans of beans, rice. Look, I have this, you can start cooking. People say, I can get to such and such place because I have the right equipment. What can I do? We have that in abundance. This community's greatest resource is
Speaker 9its people. We've always said so. We might not have the vast financial resources, but we do have the people.
Speaker 2And that is.
Speaker 9The primary resource we work with, and the people to whom we owe everything we have here.
Speaker 19I've been thinking about that mosaic pretty much every day since I was at La Loma. While breadfruit is at the center, it's the people that are putting in the work who are actually able to help one another by using breadfruit. It's a powerful reminder that the only way out of a crisis is through, that the only way through is together. Thanks for listening.
Speaker 3Welcome back to It Could Happen Here, a show about things falling apart. I'm Robert Evans. We all know what happened at the U.S. Capitol on January 6th, 2021. Those events were so consequential and infamous that I fear people have forgotten how they felt about the possibility of an attack on the Capitol by a mob of citizens on January 5th. That's not something I can forget. as I spent my first days of January that year digging through thousands of comments on social media and MAGA-focused message boards.
Speaker 3I came away from my research convinced an attack on the Capitol was possible, and I tried to warn people. I was not the only researcher who wrote about the possibility of an attack on the Capitol before January 6th. None of our warnings were heeded, in part because the authorities, like most people, considered the odds of a mob successfully occupying the Capitol to be right around 0%. The United States is the most powerful nation in history, the argument went, and the Capitol building and nearby government facilities are some of the most hardened targets on Earth. There's no way
Speaker 3a mob of mostly unarmed protesters could just storm them like the Winter Palace and put lawmakers' lives at risk.
Speaker 2Your fears are a fantasy.
Speaker 3You're just trying to scare people.
Speaker 1Shut up.
Speaker 3Well, we were correct about January 6th, and over the last few years, I've begun to worry about something new. The name I've given this fear is Nuclear January 6th. Now, I'm not talking about an all-out nuclear war here, and I'm certainly not talking about a nuclear strike on the U.S. Capitol, although that's one possible way this could occur. You're all readily familiar with the possibility and consequences of Atomic Holocaust, and I'm not using that term for the possibility of a terrorist organization or their non-state actor acquiring a nuke or dirty bomb, which remains possible, but let's say unlikely.
Speaker 3A nuclear January 6th would be a lot like its namesake, a catastrophic event that would have seemed impossible, even laughably so, before it occurred and involves the use of a nuclear weapon. A nuclear January 6th, then, would be a fuck-up, either a disastrous nuclear error caused by incompetence or a limited nuclear deployment inspired by incompetence. Either way, the scenario I'm envisioning doesn't mean the end of the world, It means one or at most a small number of warheads are detonated for a very stupid reason, and we're all left
Speaker 3to move forward in a world that is now permanently less safe. In 1989, American political scientist Robert Jervis published a book titled The Meaning of the Nuclear Revolution, Statecraft and the Prospect of Armageddon. Looking out at the international situation at the tail end of the Cold War, Jervis argued that war between nuclear powers was now unthinkable. Within the context of that conflict, he was correct.
Speaker 2Both the U.S.
Speaker 3And the USSR, despite their separate battalions of war hawks and substantial doses of paranoia, avoided stepping over the nuclear brink. The men who ran both nations clearly considered nuclear war unthinkable. In the decades since the Cold War's end, the nations of the world have continued to avoid nuking us all into Cormac McCarthy's The Road. But there is an unfortunate amount of evidence that some of the people in charge of the great powers of our time no longer find deploying a nuke to be unthinkable, even against other nuclear powers.
Speaker 3The clearest example of this comes from the Russian Federation and its activities in Ukraine. Back in January, The Bell, an independent Russian news site, reported on building support in the Kremlin for the battlefield use of a tactical nuclear weapon. This was thought to most likely occur over Crimea.
Speaker 5A 2022 U.S.
Speaker 3Intel assessment independently estimated 50% odds that Putin would order a nuclear strike if the defenses around Crimea began to fail. Russian nuclear doctrine today supports the use of atomic weapons against an existential threat. And as Kieran Monks writes in a piece for iNews, Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Rybakov said this morning this meant encroachments on Russia or its territorial integrity by aggressors, including those who may possess such weapons, could prompt us to use these weapons in the worst-case scenario.
Speaker 3The loss of Crimea, which Putin calls an inseparable part of Russia, could technically reach that threshold, said Dr. Pavel Podvig, a senior researcher and specialist on Russia's nuclear forces at the UN Institute for Disarmament Research. Now, my understanding of the situation in Ukraine is that Crimea is not under imminent danger of being retaken by Ukrainian forces, somewhat unfortunately. However, the vagueness of Russia's nuclear line being an existential threat means that they might well decide one day that diesel refining facilities count, given the centrality of oil exports to
Speaker 3their economy. Sergei Karaganov, head of a defense industry think tank in Moscow and former advisor to Putin, is among Russia's largest nuclear hawks. He has recently argued for limited nuclear strikes on Ukraine's European allies. I bring this up not because that's a scenario I'm discussing today. If Russia nuked a NATO country, that would be a de facto strike on a nuclear power and would likely end up being much worse than my nuclear January 6th theory. I bring this up because comments like this from Russia have contributed to an unfortunate trend in U.S.
Speaker 2Defense circles.
Speaker 3Serious discussion about the need for expanded low-yield tactical nuclear options. And folks, remember, when we're saying low-yield nuclear weapons, we're still often talking about stuff at least on par with the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs, if not still considerably more powerful. Those count as low-yield weapons today. For most of our lifetimes, The U.S. has focused its nuclear research and buildup on what we might call big civilization-ending doomsday nukes. I'm using a little hyperbole there, but not much. Most of our standing nuclear weapons are strategic.
Speaker 2In nature.
Speaker 3That means they're very big, and they're meant to deter an enemy from launching a full-scale nuclear attack on us. The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists estimates that about 94% of all actively deployed U.S. warheads are long-range strategic weapons. As Gabriel Honrada noted in an article for Asia Times, this makes tactical nukes a, quote, small, specialized component of overall U.S.
Speaker 2Nuclear posture.
Speaker 3You and I might consider that a good thing because any nuke small enough to use safely is likelier to get used. However, when defense planners hear the U.S. has very few tactical nukes alongside news articles about Russia threatening to use small tactical nukes, a funny thing happens. They begin to worry about a gap between our capability and that of an adversary. Fears of that gap have been further exacerbated by recent significant modernization of China's nuclear arsenal. In the last few years, the Chinese military has massively increased the quality of their nuclear weapons and the related equipment,
Speaker 3the delivery devices and such. I'm not going to go into a nerdy, fear-mongery deep dive about the exact capabilities of these new tools. That doesn't really matter today. What does matter is that in August of 2026, U.S. Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby initiated a policy review of the nation's nuclear posture. The stated goal of this review is, per coverage by Breaking Defense, quote, focused on providing more options for the White House. Undersecretary Colby expressed the need for what he called rational nuclear options to
Speaker 3deal with the changing threats from China and Russia. And, as Honrada wrote in his article, The policy review comes amid longstanding U.S. DOD concerns over foreign deployments in low-yield warheads, which risk leaving the U.S. without proportional non-strategic responses. An expansion in the number of, and potentially the in-theater deployment of, low-yield nuclear weapons does not guarantee their use. Low-yield nukes have been deployed to hot zones or potential hot zones before, albeit decades ago during the height of the Cold War. But I have trouble looking at this current administration in
Speaker 3the U.S. and so much of the bombastic, kill-obsessed rhetoric that comes out of the Department of War these days and believing that the terms low-yield and tactical won't be interpreted as safe to use. In fact, there's a real chance that just by accepting the need for more of these weapons and deploying some near-conflict regions, we'll start a countdown whereby some of our current defense thinkers convince themselves there's a ticking clock. and they need to find a target for a low-yield nuclear strike to prove we've got the guts to use this thing. If that sounds far-fetched,
Speaker 3I want you to think back to April of 2017, when the U.S. conducted an airstrike in Afghanistan using the largest non-nuclear weapon we've got, the MOAB. There were some logical reasons for such a strike. ISIS fighters were using a tunnel network, and the MOAB is meant to penetrate and take out such underground targets. That said, there's no evidence this facility or the 36-ish ISIS fighters killed in the blasts represented a threat to U.S. interests in the region, necessitating such a dramatic response. Many pundits suspected the real reason we dropped this big bomb had more to do
Speaker 3with Trump's campaign promise to bomb the shit out of ISIS. Faisal Pervez, an analyst for the military intelligence forum Stratfor, told Vice his suspicions. We drop a bomb that weighs 21,000 pounds.
Speaker 2That's so big.
Speaker 3I think a part of it, or some part of it, is the messaging and the symbolic significance that the U.S. is sending out to countries such as Russia. that we are the premier military in the world. We are the biggest power. We have the tools and weapons to show you that this is the case. Well, the same man who dropped that bomb is back in power now. We are fighting a losing war with Iran that has endangered his power. Back in April of 2026, President Trump threatened Iran by saying, a whole civilization will die tonight if the Strait of Hormuz was not reopened. More recently, he's
Speaker 3mused that Iran might take out Los Angeles or San Diego with a nuclear weapon someday. which he viewed as a small price to pay for the permission that would give the U.S. to annihilate Iran in return. We'll keep talking about this, but first, here's some ads.
Speaker 2We're back.
Speaker 3If more low-yield nuclear weapons are built and deployed, they will become in startlingly short time just another option on the menu for military planners. We might expect decade-standing traditions against using such weapons to count for something, but as you're aware, Pete Hegseth has purged a huge number of veteran leaders from the Department of Defense. Similar brain drains have occurred across all of our primary national security institutions.
Speaker 2There are fewer cooler heads to prevail.
Speaker 3Hegseth has also made lethality and kill count into our military's primary measure of operational success. More to my point, today, the entire Trump administration runs on social media. Truth social, Twitter, and TikTok aren't just organs the regime uses to disseminate propaganda. They are where Donald Trump and his advisors go for information and to take the pulse of the nation. Let's consider one possible chain of events. Some months from now, Trump orders a tactical nuke deployed with our forces attacking Iran. The plan isn't to use it, but to threaten the
Speaker 3enemy and generate a groundswell of rage among Trump's domestic enemies, which is always something he thinks about. Soon after the weapon arrives, Iranian forces score a major hit. Maybe one of their ballistic missile strikes and damages a naval vessel killing soldiers. Maybe they hit a base and cause an unprecedented loss of lives and materiel. Such a strike is not impossible. It could happen tomorrow, and it would not need to debilitate or cripple our military forces long term to provoke Donald Trump into a nuclear response. All it would need to do is embarrass him. At his footage
Speaker 3spreads of fire raging atop an aircraft carrier or a burning frigate listing at sea or wounded and dying U.S. soldiers near a base, Trump's followers begin howling for blood on social media. One cry sounds out louder than all the others.
Speaker 2Nuke the bastards. Trump might.
Speaker 3Such a strike would be unlikely to cause an immediate apocalyptic cascade into nuclear war. There would be international outrage, but not outright retaliation. Even so, in a stroke, Trump would have dissolved any remaining stigma against the use of nuclear weapons in war. This would make Russia much likelier to use a tactical nuke in Ukraine. It might change Chinese calculations, RE Taiwan, but what it would inarguably do is make nuclear weapons a normal, conceivable, usable tool of
Speaker 3conventional war. I don't know how long it would take the breaking of that taboo to generate a larger nuclear war, But I believe after this point, such a future would become almost inevitable. It is still quite possible, even likelier, that Russia would be the first nation-state to break the taboo and use a tactical nuke for the reasons I've just outlined. This might lead to a similar outcome worldwide, although I'm less certain of that. Russia is considered an international pariah to many in ways that the United States still isn't quite. That said, I have no doubt that
Speaker 3the ultimate chain of events leading to such a deployment would be just as stupid as they would be in the United States. China feels less likely to be the direct cause of such a deployment. Their nuclear policy originated from Mao Zedong. He did not love nuclear weapons, calling them a paper tiger and talking shit on the US and the USSR for building so many of the damn things. When China became a nuclear state in 1964, Mao stated the only use for this thing, his term for the bomb, was to deter other nuclear-armed countries. As a result, China
Speaker 3has always had an official no-first-use policy with their nuclear arsenal. This differs from the U.S. and Russia, who operate by launch on warn. In other words, if we think you're going to nuke us, we will nuke you. China's official policy is minimum deterrence. That's generally translated to mean we keep our arsenal at the minimum level necessary to deter our adversaries. However, in an article on the evolution of China's nuclear posture, the website DEFCON Warning System notes, This declaratory posture also embodies China's strategic ambiguity. For one, minimum
Speaker 3deterrence remains undefined. Chinese officials have never quantified what a minimum nuclear capability means in practice. Is it a few dozen warheads able to strike back?
Speaker 2A few hundred?
Speaker 3As China's arsenal grows, the goalposts appear to shift. Similarly, what constitutes an arms race is left vague. Beijing's current buildup, by far its largest and fastest ever, ostensibly does not violate its pledge to avoid arms racing, at least in its own view. Crucially, China's nuclear doctrine has begun to stress achieving strategic counterbalance with other powers. Though not officially defined, this phrase suggests Beijing sees its nuclear forces as vital to shaping the global power equilibrium. It implies a more assertive role for nukes, not merely to deter an attack
Speaker 3on China, but to offset the overall military might of rivals, particularly the United States. This nuanced shift in language contributes to uncertainty. Does counterbalance mean China seeks nuclear parity with the U.S. or simply a survivable second strike? The lack of clarity keeps observers guessing. Now, I don't bring any of this up with the interest of fear-mongering over China, but because the questions and ambiguities outlined in that segment are a real cause for concern to the defense analysts who study China, not just for the U.S.
Speaker 2Government, but over in New Delhi.
Speaker 3The Indian state is locked in a continuous low-level border conflict with China, alongside their border conflict with Pakistan, also a nuclear-armed state. Both China and India have been extremely careful to avoid bringing nuclear threats to the table. But that only underlines how much leaders in both nations fear the possibility. And over on their border with Pakistan, nuclear threats have come up recently. 2025 saw a large skirmish between India and Pakistan that included crossfire.
Speaker 2Aerial raids.
Speaker 3After several days of this, Pakistan's foreign secretary issued a statement on May 28th. We will not hesitate to use any weapon in our arsenal to defend our territorial integrity. This was interpreted as a nuclear threat and caused a massive international ruckus. which prompted a spokesman for Pakistan's government to clarify that that was not the intent. We all lucked out that the May 2025 conflict did not occur at the same time as another uptick in hostility between Beijing and New Delhi, but it's easy to imagine something like that might occur. In the event of such a conflict,
Speaker 3Pakistan would rely heavily on their naval forces, armed with nuclear weapons, to complete the third leg of their nuclear triad. Having a nuclear triad, which means having separate land, sea, and air-based weapon systems that can deploy nuclear weapons, is considered the gold standard for nuclear deterrence. Most nations that have one fulfill the third leg of the triad with nuclear-armed attack submarines. The most advanced of these are, inarguably, the deadliest weapon systems ever devised by man. Pakistan is
Speaker 3generally considered to be the nuclear power with the least reliable protections for their arsenal. These have long inspired fear that Pakistan might lose control of a weapon or that rogue elements of their security services might give one to a terrorist group. That's not my concern here. One of my sources for these episodes was an article in the Defense and Security Analysis Journal. Its authors point out that in recent years, Pakistan has done a decent job of sealing some of the former security holes in their nuclear weapons systems. However, as one researcher noted in 2014, Parts
Speaker 3of Pakistan's nuclear management system, like its command element, have been reasonably transparent. Other parts, like the physical security and surety human reliability elements, have been at best translucent.
Speaker 2In many areas, there are only.
Speaker 3Bald assertions that programs and methods have been put into place with very few details provided. One of the parts of their management system we know least about is the rules under which shipboard nuclear weapons operate. In theory, any nuclear weapons used by Pakistani forces would have to be authorized by a special 10-man committee. It's believed, but not known, that some systems require both a civilian and military key to be provided in order for the weapons to become operable. This is because Pakistan's military has a long history of
Speaker 3outright running the shop. Today, civilian leadership is meant to have much more oversight. One example of this is the fact that all air and land-based nuclear weapons in Pakistan are stored separate from their delivery systems. This makes them harder to steal and makes it more complex for, say, rogue military leaders to get a hold of a piece of the arsenal. But we already know that Pakistan's naval nukes do not work exactly the same way. Per that journal article, quote, Little information is available for the naval leg of Pakistan's deterrent, currently based on the Babur III
Speaker 3submarine-launched cruise missile. First test-fired in 2017 and described by Pakistan's Inter-Services Public Relations as a second-strike capability because of its naval requirements, the Babur III is assumed to be pre-mated and contained within a vertical launch system or similar canisterized device. Procedures meant to inhibit the use of nuclear weapons outside authorized uses are called negative controls. We do not know what negative controls Pakistan has for their naval weapons. it is entirely possible the military remains in total control
Speaker 3here and justifies that as necessary for guaranteeing their ability to launch retaliatory strikes against India. I want you to think right now about a fun new development in technology that we've all witnessed, the growth of generative AI tools that can convincingly mimic both human posters on social media and create believable fake videos, including fake news videos. These and similar tools make it possible to flood any region with targeted disinformation and make it seem legitimate, at least for a short span of time. Earlier this year, in
Speaker 3March of 2026, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists published a theoretical article by Herbert Lin. He's a Stanford fellow and expert on cyber warfare operations who in 2016 worked for the Obama administration. Back in the 1980s, he was a staff scientist for the House Armed Services Committee, so he's a guy with some knowledge of this area. The article he put together envisions several scenarios in which AI tools might help cause or exacerbate a nuclear conflict. None of his scenarios involved anything like Skynet. The dangers he foresees from AI come not from its intelligence so much
Speaker 3as its ability to automate the production of targeted bullshit and influence the decisions of political leaders. And speaking of targeted bullshit, here's some ads.
Speaker 2We're back.
Speaker 3And I was talking about an article for the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists written by Herbert Lin. One of his scenarios envisioned a blockade of Taiwan in which the Chinese military deployed an army of AI chatbots to lie about military maneuvers in order to create the impression of high military readiness to deter U.S. intervention. I don't consider this specific scenario very likely, but I do think he's on to something with passages like this. The accounts adopt personas of professionals or students isolated by the crisis and connect with foreigners through the full suite of channels described above.
Speaker 3These spaces attract not only their regular users, but also journalists, analysts, and even mid-level Pentagon staffers looking for unfiltered intelligence. In one instance, a bot mimicking a 28-year-old engineer named Li Wei claims, I saw convoys with TELs heading east. DF-26 is probably, referring to mobile transporter erector launches used to launch ballistic missiles and land-based dual-capable DF-26 intermediate-range ballistic missiles. Before adding, sirens everywhere, evacuation starting. Then screenshots start flooding the social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, amplified
Speaker 3by coordinated sock puppets. The bots adapt seamlessly to queries, cross-referencing real-time U.S. open-source chatter for added plausibility. A user of Tinder, a dating app in Washington, D.C., matched with Wang Mei, a fabricated nurse in Ximen, who relays her alleged eyewitness panic about explosions near the port and prepping of hypersonic weapons, which aligns with the partial satellite imagery glitches caused by Chinese jamming and begins to see doubt in U.S. intelligence assessments. State media subtly echoes these stories, framing them as grassroots outrage at U.S.
Speaker 2Provocation.
Speaker 3In the United States, some of this material migrates into expert discourse. Open-source intelligence analysts, journalists, and think tank experts incorporate screenshots and chat logs into maps, timelines, and situation reports, and present them on cable news and in policy briefs as independent confirmations of missile movements. Congressional staffers and allied governments cite these products in their own assessments, generating a feedback loop in which fabricated chats appear as triangulated, multi-source evidence. I think the only weakness of Lin's article is his focus on scenarios that lead to mass nuclear exchange and
Speaker 3in his insistence on considering nation states as the only relevant actors in most of these escalation cycles. But the basic process he outlined there, a bad actor flooding regional social media with disinformation designed to look like OSINT that suggests an imminent attack, that's entirely possible and you wouldn't need a nation state level actor to pull it off. Let's say you have a well-funded non-state group of ideological hardliners. Let's imagine them as partisans of India or Pakistan, right? You could also imagine they're just trolls, eager to add
Speaker 3confusion for the lulz. Or more insidiously, you could imagine them as motivated to pull off a massive score gambling on world events by betting on a limited nuclear attack and then making one happen. Returning to our hypothetical border conflict between India and Pakistan, let's imagine another outbreak of actual shooting like May of 2025. Imagine whichever of those hypothetical non-state groups you like to pick floods the region with reports of Indian nuclear forces mobilizing or even weapons inbound.
Speaker 3This would occur alongside the already nightmarish disruption of communication and command and control that will occur during such times of conflict. Is it so crazy to imagine that one of those Pakistani ships chooses to fire its payload? There's a very good reason why most nuclear-armed nations do not give military leaders direct control over how and when to fire these weapons. We don't know how Pakistan governs the use of their naval nukes, not really, and that means we cannot discount such a possibility. The kind of decisions made in nuclear war planning tend to come with a
Speaker 3timer of less than a half hour. New weapon systems like hypersonic missiles have shortened that even further. This means any decision about when to deploy nuclear weapons is likely going to be made on a very short time frame by frightened people. Another equally terrifying vision of that scenario could lead China, Pakistan, and India to each conclude, based on a mix of real movements by neighboring forces and a flood of AI disinformation, to activate and position their nuclear arsenals just in case. Once you have nuclear weapons assembled, deployed,
Speaker 3and aimed properly, the odds rise exponentially that something might go wrong, even if no one chooses to fire them. And the same sort of concerted digital disinformation attack, executed by a state or non-state actor, could happen today, during literally any tense international situation with a potential for nuclear escalation. As I said, my interest here is not in an apocalypse narrative, but in the possibility of a limited nuclear fuck-up. Let me propose another that might occur in this situation.
Speaker 3In the U.S., all nuclear weapons are built to be what's called one-point safe. This means the weapon has a probability of less than one in a million of causing a nuclear detonation if the weapon explodes unintentionally. We have had nuclear weapons destroyed in plane crashes, and so far they have never detonated in a proper nuclear explosion on accident. Because they're one point safe Other nations do not necessarily abide by the same safety rules in their nuclear weapons And we simply do not know if Pakistan's nukes are
Speaker 3safe in the same way Imagine then, as the border conflict heats up Pakistan's military assembles their arsenal and begins flying it in theater A plane crashes or gets shot down, and the weapon inside detonates in a proper nuclear fireball. Every one of my nuclear fuck-up scenarios relies on terrible decision-making. Clear-thinking civilian and military leaders do not take the kind of risks that would lead to a nuclear January 6th. Alas, clear-thinking civilian and military leaders are thin on the ground
Speaker 3these days, especially where I live. As I noted earlier, the decision makers in any of these situations, regardless of national identity, might have only minutes to make their decisions. They'll be frightened and probably sleep-deprived. And what do frightened, sleep-deprived people turn to these days when they need to get work done?
Speaker 2That's right, AI.
Speaker 3In a CNN article from earlier this year, Katie Lillis and Zachary Cohen write, Across the US military and the intelligence community, officials are pushing to weave AI into nearly every facet of their work, from analyzing the huge volumes of raw intelligence the US collects and selecting targets for strikes, to more mundane applications like managing budgeting, logistics, and supply chains. Just a few months ago, back in the spring of 2026, one member of the intel community, an analyst, asked one of these chatbots to analyze intelligence around a Chinese vessel sailing to the Middle East. The bot was likely an
Speaker 3internal tool, but as one senior U.S. official told CNN, the internal tools are mostly just copies of the commercial stuff wearing lipstick. Said bot did what bots do best. It mixed a bunch of different sources together to create a product for its user. This analysis, based on a mix of OSINT and secret intel, concluded that the Chinese ship was carrying components used in the production of nuclear weaponry. The analyst asked his AI tool to take its finding and produce an intelligence report, which was sent up the chain of command. Since the vessel was headed in the general direction of Iran, and since China does sell conventional
Speaker 3weapons to Iran, this sparked a panic. Heard that CNN article?
Speaker 2The U.S.
Speaker 3Military swung into action with plans to intercept the vessel, according to four sources familiar.
Speaker 2With the episode.
Speaker 3According to two of the sources, armed members of the U.S. military were preparing to board the ship. Military planes were in the air, one of these sources and another source familiar with the incident said. There was only one issue. The AI chatbot that Analyst used had hallucinated. Every piece of that report was wrong. China was not sending nuclear weapons equipment to Iran or anywhere else because of fucking course they weren't. But we came calamitously close to attacking a Chinese ship with military force due to that hallucination. In January, Pete Hegseth gave a speech outlining our Department
Speaker 3of Defense's new AI strategy. He insisted, we will unleash experimentation, eliminate bureaucratic barriers, focus our investments, and demonstrate the execution approach needed to ensure we lead in military AI. All that says to me is that these tools will only become more critical to the production of intelligence products than ever before, and we know they'll continue to hallucinate too. This change isn't just happening in the United States. It's occurring in governments and militaries all across the world, and it's happening at the same time as some nuclear-armed nations seek to expand their low-yield stockpiles. Simultaneously, the U.S. war
Speaker 3against Iran and the ongoing war in Ukraine have made it clear to every nation-state actor that the only real guarantee of national sovereignty is a nuclear arsenal. More nations will work to acquire nukes in the near future. This means more nuclear weapons and more conflicts where they might get used, alongside an even wider proliferation of tools like the ones I just described.
Speaker 2I'm not trying to be.
Speaker 3Apocalyptic here, because again, that's.
Speaker 2Not really the immediate worry.
Speaker 3The worry is that a mix of increasing acceptance that it's okay to use small nukes, and increasing reliance on these AI tools, alongside the conflicts that we have always had between nations, will lead to a situation in which a very limited nuclear fuck-up not only is disastrous to people on the ground or wherever it occurs, but changes the very nature and all of the decision-making calculus in the world that we live in. I hope it doesn't happen, but that's what I'm thinking about these days.
Speaker 2That's everything for today. We'll be back tomorrow. This is It Could Happen Here, Executive Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening in the White House, the crumbling world, and what this means for you. I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm joined by Mia Wong, Robert Evans, and Sophie Lichterman. Not allegedly. Yeah, no,
Speaker 2that's definitely Sophie, but you can't prove it's me. I can prove it's you.
Speaker 3Sophie, you have no idea where I am, Sophie, or what I'm doing.
Speaker 5I know exactly where you are, and I know exactly.
Speaker 2What you're doing. This is the first episode where we're testing AI Robert.
Speaker 1Oh, no.
Speaker 2We're not testing, there's no AI Robert. Don't yell at me, I'm Blue Sky.
Speaker 3It'd be shit. You'll know there's no AI Robert because they would have trained an AI Robert on like the subreddit and all of the different jokes that I can no longer do because people have taken it too seriously. Like if I start talking about a child hunting island, like you'll know it's the AI me.
Speaker 2It'll pull like a bagel throwing reference from like nine years ago.
Speaker 5Yeah, all of a sudden you start talking about Doritos like you did 10 years ago.
Speaker 3Yeah, talking about Doritos like 10 years ago or talking about the Jamie Loftus murder thing, which I don't do anymore because now there's a real serial killer in the area that people were making comments about.
Speaker 2And being like, what is it, Jamie? I'm like, guys, there's really people dead. We don't keep the bit up at this point. All right.
Speaker 1Here.
Speaker 2This episode, we're covering the week of October 7th to October 14th. And we're actually going to jump straight to our first main story. Last Thursday afternoon, October 8th, ICE shot a 28-year-old man named Oscar Belgal in the New York City neighborhood of Marble Hill, which is physically located in the Bronx, but technically in the borough of Manhattan. Oscar was in a car with his five-year-old son. Per video released by the NYPD, around 4 p.m., just in
Speaker 2the middle of the day, masked plainclothes agents, some wearing yellow construction vests, ran up to a parked car with guns already drawn. The driver, Oscar, started backing away, and then an agent began hitting the car windows with the butt of his gun. Oscar then pulls into the street and drives off screen, as agents point their guns at the windshield. The actual shooting itself is not captured on this video, but I'll play it here for us to reference.
Speaker 2This is security camera footage.
Speaker 5Yeah, one of the things that was, like, noticeably unsettling besides all of it was the fact that, like, these guys were dressed like crossing guards.
Speaker 2Construction workers, crossing guards.
Speaker 12They had, like, on normal clothes and then.
Speaker 10Just, like, a.
Speaker 2High-vis vest.
Speaker 12Yeah, which, you know, somebody in a high-vis vest and a... Machine gun comes towards me. That's scary.
Speaker 2They look like, like, especially the guy with the long gun. He looks like a mass shooter. They look like.
Speaker 3Fucking mass shooters. Like, I would not assume those were police officers. And I might take steps to defend myself in that situation because they just look like fucking mass shooters.
Speaker 12Correct.
Speaker 2Mayor Zora Mamdani said, quote, There was no reasonable way to identify them as ICE agents. School had just gotten out. The street was crowded with families and children.
Speaker 7Unquote.
Speaker 2According to the NYPD, at least one agent fired seven shots. We do not have footage of the actual shooting. As I said, Oscar's five-year-old son was in the backseat of the car. Thank God he is physically unharmed. But, of course, he still had to watch masked men with guns run up, shoot his dad in the neck, and drag his body away. Jesus Christ. DHS Secretary Mullen said that agents were not aware a kid was in the car. Uh-huh, because they
Speaker 2didn't care. Air check.
Speaker 12Shoot first, ask questions later.
Speaker 2The child's mother told Governor Hochul that her son is traumatized and won't talk. Quote, the child is not speaking.
Speaker 12That's terrible.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean.
Speaker 2Sure, of course.
Speaker 4Jesus.
Speaker 12That's horrible, you guys.
Speaker 3I mean, I can't really think of anything worse that could happen to a child than to watch their parent shot in the neck at random when, like, in a normally safe situation like that.
Speaker 2Jesus Christ. ICE has still not released body cam footage of the shooting. DHS has said that they were conducting a, quote, targeted enforcement operation and that Oscar, quote, weaponized his vehicle. This is the thing they always say when something like this happens.
Speaker 12Spoiler plate ass statement.
Speaker 2DHS also claimed that after Ice shot and arrested Oscar, agents, quote, rendered first aid and then took him to the hospital. This is a lie. This did not happen. This is a plain-faced lie from DHS. Body camera footage released by NYPD from when they first got to the scene, when the cops got to the scene, Show Oscar just sitting in the street, bleeding out, with his hands handcuffed behind his back, surrounded by ICE agents who are just standing in a circle around him, offering no assistance.
Speaker 9Yeah, and they do this all the fucking time when they shoot someone.
Speaker 2Because they just, like, stand there and handcuff them. The NYPD rushes over in this footage, picks up and carries Oscar, who now appears to be going unconscious. They take Oscar into a squad car, they render aid, put pressure on the wound, and drive him to the hospital down the street.
Speaker 9Do you know how hard it is to have less concern for human life than the New York Police Department?
Speaker 3My God, that's astonishing. That's that's that takes some work. Jesus Christ. We're reaching average Los Angeles sheriff's deputy levels of empathy here.
Speaker 2Like it's shocking.
Speaker 9It's like it's like the CPD detectives they brought in to do torture after 9-11.
Speaker 2Like that kind of shit. We don't really know what would have happened if NYPD did not get to the scene as quick as they did. In the body camera footage of them carrying Oscar, his body is fully limp. He's out of it.
Speaker 3He looks like he's been shot in the neck.
Speaker 2NYPD had no involvement in the federal operation prior to this point, prior to the shooting.
Speaker 3Quite frankly, this kind of shit isn't what they do. They do other bad things, but they don't just like, shoot and like charge people's cars with guns when they're like driving away from school with it. Like that's just that that's this is so much of an escalation of like our normal police bullshit is what I'm saying.
Speaker 2DHS has tried to justify their targeting of Oscar, calling him a, quote, criminal illegal alien from the Dominican Republic.
Speaker 5Great.
Speaker 2And pointed to prior arrests and a criminal conviction for grand larceny and claim Oscar's, quote, associated crimes. With a gang. That's the word they keep using. Associated or association. They won't even say he's like a member. They'll say he's associated with a gang.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2I'll play a short clip here from the mayor's press conference later that evening, just down the street from this side of the shooting.
Speaker 10There is no explanation for federal officers firing this many rounds into a car that has a five-year-old in the car. there is no explanation we are standing here so close to the site of where this actually took place and look at how many people live right here this is a residential neighborhood we are right here by a subway And the pretext of ICE is, in their words, to keep this country safe. How is it keeping anyone safe to have, as you just heard from the police commissioner,
Speaker 10individuals wearing construction vests and masks with long guns?
Speaker 16Residents have no idea if these are law enforcement agents or if they are simply attacking someone on the street. And when it comes to ICE, it begs the question, what's the difference? There is no explanation for this.
Speaker 2After the shooting, soon-to-be DSA Congresswoman Daria-Liza Avila-Chavier quickly went up to the Bronx and saw that federal agents were going door-to-door, quote-unquote, collecting evidence and trying to question residents about the shooting, writing down people's names and numbers. So Daria-Liza followed behind these HSI agents, informing residents that they did not need to speak to or answer questions from these federal agents. Meanwhile, soon-to-be former congressman Adriano Espaillat And Oscar's own family weren't allowed to see Oscar at the hospital.
Speaker 1Jesus.
Speaker 2Now, outside the hospital where Oscar is being treated, a few hundred New Yorkers gathered to protest ICE and the shooting of one of their neighbors. Earlier in the evening, ICE vehicles were driving through protesters. But pretty quickly, NYPD arrived to do crowd control and clear the street for vehicles to enter and exit the hospital. This led to violent shoving matches over metal fence barricades that NYPD was trying to set up around the street. Daria Liza moved to this protest, and she was trying to de-escalate conflict.
Speaker 2But NYPD got very aggressive, and Daria Liza was shoved to the ground by a community affairs officer. The NYPD blue shirts. The ones that are, you know, supposed to de-escalate conflict at protests.
Speaker 9Yeah, average example of community affairs is shoving a congressperson.
Speaker 2To the ground. I arrived at the hospital just after this first big clash over police barricades, during which NYPD arrested five protesters. After that, things seemed to settle down for a little bit. The crowd got smaller. And about like a little over an hour later, just before 11 p.m., police rapidly cleared the street again, pushing protesters onto the sidewalk as a small caravan of feds departed the hospital at dangerously high speeds. They were zooming by.
Speaker 14Ice just pulled away.
Speaker 7The crowd chased him a little bit. It's 10.40 p.m. We've got a group of NYPD now leaving the area and the crowd is falling behind, yelling.
Speaker 2At them as well. Again, NYPD is putting off into two directions. Oscar was in one of these vehicles leaving the hospital. After the feds left the hospital, the crowd continued to dwindle to about 40 people who then marched forward. up over the bridge to protest in front of Zoran's press conference. At the press conference, Zoran said that for the past two hours, he had been on the phone negotiating with President Trump and Secretary Mullen for Oscar's release,
Speaker 2but that those negotiations were unsuccessful. I think it is worth noting here that earlier this year, Trump did release someone from ICE custody following a request by Mayor Mamdani. With the cries of protesters heard in the background, The mayor reiterated calls for ICE to be abolished, saying, quote, ICE is rotten to its core, operates with impunity, sows chaos and terror across our country, and they have killed far more of our neighbors than they could have ever
Speaker 2claimed to save.
Speaker 16I stand here not just as the mayor of our city, but as someone who is proud to be an immigrant in our city. And I know that these kinds of raids, this kind of terrorizing of this city, leaves the three million immigrants of this city asking if they are safe here, if they belong here, if this too can be their home here. We will not normalize ICE's viciousness. We will not accept its cruelty. We know, and I have said this directly, whether to the president or to the public,
Speaker 16ICE undermines public safety.
Speaker 2It makes us less safe.
Speaker 16New York City will not stand by while ICE agents shoot New Yorkers. And we will not back down from the demand that so many, including myself, have put forward time and again. This is an agency that must be abolished.
Speaker 2Commissioner Jessica Tisch then gave some more details about the shooting, some of which I've already echoed, but also read off Oscar's NYPD rap sheet. Average Commissioner Tisch move. Including two prior arrests. one for robbery, which he pleaded guilty to and received probation, and another for drug possession. When Zoran got the microphone back, he again undermined ICE's legitimacy and said that while negotiating with the president and Secretary Mullen, he requested ICE agents leave the scene entirely and demanded
Speaker 2that ICE stop its enforcement actions in the city.
Speaker 16There is no justification for what we have seen today and we know. That what we have seen today is but a microcosm of what ICE does on a daily basis across this country. How can that be how we describe public safety?
Speaker 8It can't be.
Speaker 16And I've shared that with the president. I've shared that with the secretary. This city wants ICE out. We want ICE out of our city, ICE out of our schools, ICE out of our hospitals, ICE out of our streets, ICE away from our kids. We want that because we want to keep the city safe. We do not need them to do so. All they do is terrorize the city.
Speaker 2Now, the people chanting outside the press conference weren't just protesting ICE, but also the NYPD and Zoran himself, with chants of, quote, Mamdani is complicit. most of the ire directed at Mayor Mamdani was due to NYPD facilitating ICE's exit by clearing protesters in front of the hospital off the street before the agents sped off. After leaving the hospital, DHS moved Oscar to New Jersey and then back to
Speaker 2New York, where he's currently in federal custody at the Metropolitan Detention Center. On Monday, Oscar's lawyers released a statement, quote, Mr. Belgal is living through an unimaginable nightmare. While he is currently in solitary confinement, a bullet remains lodged in his neck. The left side of his face is numb and he can barely hear out of his left ear. Doctors have told him he urgently needs surgery, unquote. Awful. A federal
Speaker 2judge has also temporarily blocked Oscar's deportation. The day after the shooting, Daria Liza called for NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to step down in a statement, quote, Last night, the NYPD and Commissioner Tisch violated the spirit, if not the letter, of our sanctuary city policies and fueled the Trump administration's attempts to demonize our communities. The NYPD's Strategic Response Group, or the SRG, must be disbanded as quickly as possible, and Commissioner Tisch must step down. New York City DSA
Speaker 2also released a statement, of which I'll quote a small portion of. ICE's devastating shooting of a New Yorker in front of his child cannot stand. Neither can the NYPD's attack on New Yorkers who stood up for their neighbors. ICE is a terrorist agency that must be expelled from New York City and abolished. Jessica Tisch must get ICE out of New York and end NYPD complicity with these terrorists. If the commissioner can't put a stop to these injustices, she must be fired. Unquote. Now, initial reports claim that SRG,
Speaker 2the strategic response group, was deployed to handle this protest at the hospital. And this is notable because Zoran ran on disbanding the SRG. And right now, any SRG deployment must get approval from City Hall, according to reporting from Politico. So the idea that Mamdani personally sent the SRG to crack skulls of anti-ice protesters fueled a lot of the anger coming from protesters that night. The SRG, or the Strategic Response Group, is a specialized unit within the NYPD,
Speaker 2which focuses on counterterrorism, but also policing protests. They're sort of the city's de facto riot cops. The unit has been long criticized for violently suppressing political protest. The SRG did not respond to that protest, though. Instead, NYPD sent officers from community affairs, as mentioned, and the transit bureau's, quote, anti-terrorism unit, which doesn't need City Hall's direct sign-off. So
Speaker 2while Zoran did not personally send the SRG to crack down on this protest, the violence from NYPD demonstrates that this issue is bigger than just one specific unit. But there is this larger question of like crowd control at these protests. And I think this question demonstrates the diverging interests on the part of protesters and city hall. Some protesters want no NYPD crowd control. People want to directly
Speaker 2fight ICE and they're willing to put their body on the line. Yeah. Even if that means they might get hurt. As we've seen in other cities, physical confrontations against ICE could result in DHS sending more troops to New York and possibly triggering a political crisis, which some on the left also desire. There is a sort of like accelerationist bent towards some of these protests. They kind of want this political crisis and they want to directly fight and oppose ICE. On the other hand, for someone in Zoran's position, there's a desire to prevent ICE agents from hurting more people, whether by running people over or shooting more New Yorkers.
Speaker 2I think all of these questions definitely exist in the shadow of Minneapolis. And furthermore, the mayor wants to limit the amount of DHS and ICE agents deployed to the city. So to that end, NYPD may end up doing some level of crowd control to limit protesters' interactions with ICE to avoid provoking a larger deployment. So even if protesters and Zoran have similar ultimate goals vis-a-vis ICE, their respective positions lead them to contradictory impulses. Zorn has said that
Speaker 2he will not justify the use of force against protesters on Thursday night and told MSNOW he'll be conducting a review of the entire 24-hour period, quote, from the ICE shooting to the NYPD response to the incident and the ensuing protests to ICE's use of a privately owned parking lot as a staging location to every tool that we have at our disposal to keep New Yorkers safe, unquote. And on one of those last parts, AOC has also mentioned this, that ICE has been using the rooftop parking lot of a Target in the Bronx to stage before
Speaker 2going out to do arrests. And that's something that electeds are looking to crack down on if they can. But Zoran has said that there are no plans to replace Commissioner Tisch, pointing to her history of uprooting NYPD corruption and the later Adams administration and the record low number of murders, shootings and shooting victims. But Zoran has reiterated multiple times this week his intention to disband the SRG and said he will provide an update on that timeline in the coming months. Also to the dismay of the
Speaker 2police union, the mayor announced this week that his administration will be conducting the first comprehensive review of NYPD use of force policies and practices for the first time in a decade and will crack down on officers getting out of misconduct proceedings by retiring before disciplinary action can take place after this was announced yesterday. There was a very angry statement from the police union about this. And because New York has already ended qualified immunity, the biggest thing City Hall could do to undermine police power is to
Speaker 2move certain public safety and administrative roles outside of the NYPD, which Zorn wants to do with the Department of Community Safety, but that has faced budgetary constraints, especially following the discovery of the $ 12 billion deficit left over by Mayor Adams. Now, 10 months into his administration, Zoran has not been eager to spend political capital taking on the NYPD. Where he has been spending political capital, it's mostly been to strengthen labor, investing in the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, creating and enforcing a new click-to-cancel rule to crack down on
Speaker 2impossible-to-end subscriptions, winning hundreds of millions of dollars for delivery workers, fighting to pass the Delivery Protection Act to strengthen Amazon workers' right to unionize, and partnering with labor unions to modernize the process of applying for city jobs and launching the mayor's office of worker power. And this is in addition to universal child care and the rent freeze, which just went into effect earlier this month. But after attending protests this week, my general sense is that when it comes to NYPD and ICE, protesters want more than just well-worded
Speaker 2statements and these reviews. They want to see more actionable change. whether that's using his position as mayor as a sort of bully pulpit to rally the masses against ICE, or employ more direct measures to protect New Yorkers from ICE. What those measures may be is not entirely clear. And if the left wants to be effective in agitating for larger social change, beyond making just general demands of electeds, it may be worth closely considering why an elected is
Speaker 2taking certain actions, the constraints of their power and the contradictions inherent to holding office, so that those not in office can apply targeted outside pressure to counteract the pressure coming from the federal and state level, and just the pressures of governing itself. Though firing Tisch may please some of Zoran's left-wing base, more broadly it is politically risky and could damage Zoran as he tries to enact his economic agenda while contending with a centrist governor and a very hostile federal administration. From City Hall's perspective, choosing to
Speaker 2go to war with the NYPD right now could undermine Zoran's ability to protect New York from ICE, whether by limiting... the scale of ICE operations, or ideally keeping ICE out of the city entirely. Of course, none of this means that people should stop protesting. Protesting is the crucial thing that could apply pressure here. But it's also going to have to be more than 400 of New York's most left-wing protesters. It's going to have to require mass engagement. But the thing I wanted to emphasize here at the end is that a socialist elected to an executive position
Speaker 2and a protester and an organizer outside of government are very different kinds of political actors whose positions strongly influence the actions they take or may be inclined to take. Protests supply an important pressure on city leaders to pursue certain aims, but our political analysis must take account of the balance of forces within the state. Does anyone else have any thoughts on this? I'm sure Mia does.
Speaker 9Yeah, well, I think part of what's happening here on a broader scale is that, like, One of the reasons that ICE has been successful over the last, call it like three or four months, in significant escalations of raids, and we've talked about this a little bit on this show, but there have been huge escalations in raids in Texas and raids in Florida. And there's also been kind of beneath the notice of people who aren't there, a really
Speaker 9significant escalation in places like Minneapolis and But they're doing it quietly.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 9Like, they're not fighting with protesters. They're going in, they're grabbing people, and they're leaving. And I think this is one of the things the protesters are thinking about to some extent, which is part of why their calculus is different in the mayor's office, because, you know, one of the things that's been allowing all of this to happen is that ICE has been able to do this smoothly.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 9The fact that they'll do it smoothly, quietly, and without disturbing, like, the broader public order.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 9Is a big part of how they've been able to really ramp up rates without the kind of mass resistance that we saw.
Speaker 13Earlier in the year.
Speaker 9But this leads you to a structural problem with the position of someone holding office, which is that, A, holding office in the U.S. does not give you a monopoly on violence because the police are effectively a semi-independent force. And you can do oversight on them to some extent, but as long as you're sending them there, even if you tell them, hey, don't beat up protesters, they're going to go beat up Congress people. And then you have
Speaker 9a secondary problem, which is that if you're running the government of New York, your job is to maintain public order. And the way that you defeat ICE is through breaking public order. And this puts you inherently in tension. with the state itself in a position where Mondani ends up being aligned structurally with the police trying to do protest control. And this is just sort of like the structural limits of what kind of power you actually hold in the
Speaker 9United States when you are elected. Because, yeah, I was like, no, we're keeping on fucking Adams-era police commissioner because if you want to try to have the body that's nominally enforcing your legitimacy on violence, you have to go to war with people who can fight you. And that's just a huge structural problem with power in the American government. Yeah, and Tisch was also retained. essentially following requests from hokal
Speaker 9as a sort of like yeah sign to hokal that like zorn will still be like a competent administrator essentially it was it was it was it was assigned to her to kind of get her on board during the general election yeah and then also you know extract economic wins and revenue from the state so that mom donnie can have the funding for things like universal child care and it's that was one of the calculations that was made and and he did like announce his intention to retain her during, during the campaign. So this wasn't, is it, this isn't necessarily one of his campaign promises, the way abolishing SRG is.
Speaker 2Yeah. And which he seems to be still trying to work on and you can apply, but as we see from, you know, NYC DSA, Zoran's political home, a pressure can still be applied on both of these things. Yeah. And, and, and should be in that pressure is necessary. Even if that means you're going to be going against someone who is like, you know, an economic ally, right. In terms of, in terms of, yeah. how he's trying to run the city. But there are going to be these contradictions that part of the left winning power in these places means we have to deal with those contradictions. You have to go
Speaker 2through them, not just avoid them. You can't just avoid conflict here. You have to pursue it with focus and determination. I think sometimes, at least in conversations in New York over the NYPD aspect, I definitely do not want to distract from the ice angle here as there is a man With a bullet still literally in his neck.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2And I hope that that gets some more focus in these next few days. Yeah. Because that situation has not resolved itself. In the episode description, I will link New York City's immigration resources, the Immigration Legal Support Hotline, the
Speaker 2intake form for the Rapid Response Legal Collaborative for people facing the threat of detention or deportation, as well as the Know Your Rights booklets that the city offers in multiple languages. It's time for us to go on an ad break, and then we will return for more news, because it has been a busy week. We are back.
Speaker 2Let's now go through some of our small things here. Mia, do you want to start us off?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 9So speaking of the filmed shooting of people in America, Pete Hegseth has announced that he is planning to live stream the execution by firing squad of the 2009 Fort Hood shooter. He announced this by email. Quote tweeting a CBS News tweet about the Pentagon's plan with a quote tweet that says, quote, correct. And that's that's how it was announced by the U.S. government that we were going
Speaker 9to execute a man by firing squad. A thing that the military hasn't executed someone in 65 years. And live streamed. The live streaming part specifically is that is 30s lynching shit. That's crazy.
Speaker 3Like, to be honest, I don't support the death penalty for the military. Like, the state shouldn't be doing that, in my opinion. But among death penalty options, I don't care about, like, a firing squad. Like, I actually think that's more ethical than the fucking lethal injections they're doing.
Speaker 2But live streaming? It's depraved. It's sick shit.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2That also just more so points to the brutality of lethal injection, despite it being this.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Thing that's marketed as peaceful and civil. Yes, I'm not saying it's nice to shoot people. Yeah, it's also horrible. It's much worse than shooting them. Yeah, the fact that lethal injection is by all accounts actually a more horrific way to die than a literal firing squad is itself crazy. If you know what you're doing, a bullet's quick. But I mean, the live streaming thing is insane.
Speaker 9Yeah, it's horrible. Like, obviously, there's been widespread condemnation of this. The people who have been really in support of this have been a bunch of the worst Silicon Valley fascists. There was a quote from Palmer Luckey, who is one of the founders of Andriel, which is a Silicon Valley weapons manufacturer we've talked about.
Speaker 2They make drones. They make a bunch of other shit.
Speaker 9Who said, quote, and then there are those who suggest any revel in the death of those who truly deserve it is an indicator of a broken or diseased mind. To the contrary, it is normal, good, and aligned with our natural order that it has not been done here in 60 years as an indictment in and of itself. And the thing I would say about this is to everyone who wants to do this, like, are you sure you want to live in the world where you've opened this door?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Like, are you sure you want what follows?
Speaker 3Do you want us to talk about live streaming executions? Because I will tell you, I don't think a lot of Americans want to watch this execution live stream, but there are some executions I can imagine a lot of Americans would want to watch on a live stream.
Speaker 9Read up on your Chochescu is all I'm saying about this.
Speaker 3Look at your poll numbers and read about Chochescu.
Speaker 2Yeah. You can't help but think of like, When our term comes, we shall make no excuse for the terror. Like, I'm there, baby. I've never understood those words so much as I do now.
Speaker 9I would prefer that that door remained shut because I don't think you should be publicly executing people. I don't think you should be publicly executing people on livestream. But like, you're opening this fucking door. If that's what we're doing, it's like.
Speaker 3I can I can agree. Perhaps the country would be better if everyone couldn't buy an AR-15. But you opened the door. So I have like six. Right.
Speaker 2It's also it has been reported that Trump is debating canceling the live stream only after he learned that the shooter was paralyzed, which is very interesting.
Speaker 3Every now and then, you get a little insight into the fact that Trump does have some kind of moral schema in his head, and it's always baffling when you get a hint of how it really looks.
Speaker 2It's always just completely unhinged. I mean, that just might be an optics thing, too. Yeah, that is an optics thing, but it's showing his awareness of the moral component and the optics.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. It's just nuts. It's just like, that was your line, huh? Maybe. Like, okay. Oh, God.
Speaker 8All right.
Speaker 2Quick update here. On Thursday, President Trump did, in fact, cancel the planned live stream of the Fort Hood shooter's execution. Moving on. On Monday, DHS and HSI Homeland Security Investigations raided the D.C. home of Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar. This follows confirmation at the midterm RNC from Secretary Mullen that there is an investigation into the allegations of immigration fraud
Speaker 2made against Omar based on a years old racist conspiracy theory. After the raid on Monday, Ilhan made a statement, quote, I'm OK. Make no mistake. This is an attempt to target political enemies and weaponize federal law enforcement. 10 years, Trump has targeted me with baseless lies and smear campaigns. This is just the latest escalation in his campaign of political intimidation. I will not be silenced, unquote.
Speaker 9It's also worth noting, like, we're coming up on the elections, and this is the shit that's happening right now.
Speaker 2Quick update here. Shortly after recording, the Wall Street Journal reported that the Trump administration's investigations into Representative Omar's is specifically aimed at building a case to strip her of her U.S. citizenship and ultimately deport her. We will likely talk about this more next week.
Speaker 3I do want to take us a little bit further from the United States to the Democratic Republic of the Congo. There's a long ongoing conflict there between the Congolese government and the rebel group M23, which is backed by the Rwandan state. Eric Prince and his mercenary corporation, Vectus, have been contracted by the Congolese government to fight against M23. What I'm talking about actually happened on September 17th, but we just found out about it within the last couple of days. During intense fighting in the Menemwe highlands, a
Speaker 3group of Prince's mercenaries were ambushed and roughly 20 of them were killed or injured. This came after a clash earlier in September in which several Colombian contractors were killed. During this most recent ambush, a New Zealand military veteran was killed and an American named Tim Kennedy, who was a former Green Beret, and then after being a Green Beret, a former UFC fighter. fighter, was badly injured. I think he got shot three times in the leg. Sounds like there's a good chance he'll lose a leg, but I don't really know for certain. And was evac'd and wound
Speaker 3up eventually at a U.S. military hospital in Germany. So there's a couple of things about this. First off, I've seen people being like, why is the U.S.
Speaker 2Military.
Speaker 3Yeah, paying for the health care of a mercenary because he's a veteran. It's not weird that he went to a military hospital, right? He's entitled to that, to health care of that kind. The bigger issue is that Eric Prince has a mercenary corporation that's active in the Congo. Things do not seem to be going well for Prince or for Vectis in the Congo. Although, again, we don't know that. We just know 20 injured and killed. I don't know how many killed. I don't know what their nationalities were. They're not a real military, so they don't have to tell anybody that shit, right?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 3Once James is back, I'm sure we'll put together an episode. covering in more detail, like what's happening in the Congo, because that's important. And it's not really a topic we've covered a lot on this show. As a little bit of a fun note, because this really pissed off a lot of people on X, the everything app, like a lot of right wingers who are angry that turns out US Special Forces guys aren't nearly as badass without air support.
Speaker 2Yeah, they can just get killed in the jungle like anybody else.
Speaker 3Bullets don't discriminate on how much training or whatever you have, how cool you look in pictures. So this started a discourse that ended ultimately with a poll and a week long discussion as to whether or not all of Europe in 1939 could conquer modern 2026 Africa. 78% of X voted they believe 1939 Europe. Let me tell you something, folks. This is objectively true. Anyone who knows anything about modern 20th century warfare will tell you it wouldn't take all of Africa. Egypt alone could wipe out 1939 Europe. to
Speaker 3the man militarily without a single soldier landing in Africa. They have Rafale fighters. They have 1,100 Abrams tanks. Even if you were to take somehow and magically transport all of the tanks in Europe in 1939. And remember, in 1939, none of the cool shit from World War II existed yet, by the way. The German army, I mean, it ended the war horse-based, but it was really horse-based in 1939, right? If you were to take all of the tanks, every armored vehicle, and put them against just Egypt's Abrams tanks, and by the way, there's 600 T-90 tanks or something
Speaker 3like that in Algeria. I don't know how many Abrams tanks fucking Morocco has, but it's a lot. But if you take just Egypt's Abrams tanks, there was not a single man or vehicle portable weapon on the planet that could pierce Chobham armor in 1939. The battle would be over in seconds.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Anyway, one of the more amusing pieces of derangement online lately. Oh, God, I just love it when people are crazy. That's what I got.
Speaker 2One of the other things that James, I assume James will want to talk more once he gets back, is early this week, J.D. Vance, as part of his fraud task force, announced big crackdowns on H-1B visas at Microsoft and J-1 visas at universities. Hmm. So this is something that does deserve more dedicated focus in a future episode. Netflix this week has laid off about 1,000 employees. That's roughly 6% of their workforce.
Speaker 20Oh, it sucks.
Speaker 2Before Paramount acquired Warner Brothers, Netflix was trying to acquire Warner Brothers. In election news, but an even cooler kind, Sean Fain and his left-wing slate at United UAW Just swept the United Auto Worker elections. We are the incumbents now.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, yes.
Speaker 2Just totally demolished.
Speaker 3And look, do some of us find it entertaining that his name sounds a lot like the Irish political party Sinn Féin?
Speaker 2Of course. That's all I have to say.
Speaker 12How much did he win by, Ger?
Speaker 2Sion Féin won with 67.98%. To runner up Rich Boyer's 14%. Nice work, Rich. I'll glitter it. Nailed it. You really hit the zeitgeist there, my man.
Speaker 9You think that like regular politicians have incumbency advantage? You have never seen a union election.
Speaker 2Oh, my God. Especially a union election for a guy who like made things better in the union. Like, damn. Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, there's just a Catholic school in Oregon that fired their football coach because he won by too much.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3He was scoring points when it was just kind of mean. I feel that way about Sean. It's like, okay, man, did you really need 67% of the vote?
Speaker 9For details, by the way, that guy ran an onside kick before halftime up 57.
Speaker 2So that's some sicko shit. But also, I did not know Sean had game like that.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2Starting this week, the White House has a new press secretary, Katie Zachariah. And I'll be the first to say she's doing great. She's amazing work. You know, no notes. I think we can move on, right?
Speaker 17I adore my family.
Speaker 2I love them.
Speaker 17They are my priority. I love being with my kids. The idea of not spending evenings with my kids is completely unacceptable. So my president, excuse me, my husband, that's a good one. My husband is out here.
Speaker 2Incredible. Oh, my God. Incredible slip. Oh, my God. Incredible slip. Oh, my God. Is she the one that was, like, claiming to be a lawyer?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2Yes, in China. In China. She passed the bar in China? Let me be clear. No, she didn't.
Speaker 9Like, I would bet my life she did not pass the bar in China.
Speaker 2Like, I am that certain.
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 9Like, I am as certain of that as I am certain that 90% of people who write about Taiwanese politics can't name three Taiwanese cities.
Speaker 2I don't know, Mia. She seems to have a pretty solid grasp of foreign policy. Let's see her Mandarin. Here's her talking about Venezuela.
Speaker 17He had a historic one-day war, and now we have a booming economy and a great relationship with Venezuela.
Speaker 2Incredible.
Speaker 5I'm looking forward to covering her. I don't know what you're talking about. This is going to be great.
Speaker 9By the way, for people who can't see this clip, the amazing part is she, when she stops before she says Venezuela, she is looking down at the page.
Speaker 2She looks down at her notes.
Speaker 9To remember what country she's talking about. Incredible stuff.
Speaker 2We could do a whole episode about this first press conference. There's some great clips going around if you want to have fun.
Speaker 1God.
Speaker 2Less fun, on the afternoon of October 7th in Sacramento, a day after the county began mailing out ballots, an SUV pulled up to a USPS mail truck. A masked man got out of the SUV and stole trays of mail from the truck. Residents have reported their mail-in ballots are now missing. Great stuff happening here. Love this country. A few days later, the National Guard were videoed standing in front of... Ballot drop boxes in D.C. They claimed
Speaker 2that they were not legally guarding the boxes because that's illegal. But they were meandering in front of ballot drop boxes.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2God. Not great stuff just a few weeks before the election. Lastly, while addressing a MAGA crowd in Tennessee... Trump made this very accurate comment. No, it's true.
Speaker 6No, there's such love. It's like, like, I mean, it's amazing. When you stand up here, it's just like the love. I could say the stupidest things and you're clapping, oh, I love you so much.
Speaker 2That's true.
Speaker 6But we don't say the stupidest things. We say things of common sense.
Speaker 5There's so much clapping to that.
Speaker 2He knows his fans. What can you say?
Speaker 12He certainly does.
Speaker 5And speaking of fans, I have a segment here for us.
Speaker 12It is sports season for me.
Speaker 5With the WNBA and MLB playoffs going on and the NBA season starting, it's exciting.
Speaker 2I have not approved this message. Fuck off.
Speaker 12It's exciting for.
Speaker 5Me, but it also means I'm exposed to television commercial advertisements.
Speaker 9Oh, my God.
Speaker 12It's so bad.
Speaker 5Besides the alarming number of sports betting ads, a new trend I'm upset about is AI ads targeting seniors.
Speaker 12Let's take a listen.
Speaker 21Can you go to my calendar and find me a half an hour tomorrow so I can mail some of these cookies to my grandson?
Speaker 1I've added a post office trip at town.
Speaker 13All right, Esther, we're ready.
Speaker 17ChatGPT boys.
Speaker 9ChatGPT boys got a whole lot more useful.
Speaker 1It's no longer just answering questions. It's better at getting things done.
Speaker 5Don't do me.
Speaker 8Oh, honey.
Speaker 2Let me show you an example.
Speaker 9Can you go into my finances and let me know if you see any duplicate charges?
Speaker 2Jesus. Sure.
Speaker 1Checking your accounts.
Speaker 7Okay.
Speaker 9It looks like you're paying twice for a magazine called Sound and Stereo.
Speaker 2Well, that's odd. Can you cancel the duplicate and send an e-refund?
Speaker 18Of course.
Speaker 3So you're just giving it access to your bank details as an old person. That doesn't seem like it'll lead you to getting scammed anymore.
Speaker 12Yeah, I was pretty angry when I first saw that.
Speaker 5I thought I was being irrationally angry, but now I think I'm just rational and that it sucks.
Speaker 3I can't think of any way in which a chatbot that pulls for its answers from places like Reddit and the social Internet would spread like bad advice on what old people should do with their money once it has access to their bank accounts. I can't imagine that causing a problem. So I don't see what your issue is, Sophie.
Speaker 12From the New York Post quote, it's very concerning, says Dr.
Speaker 5Stacey Wood, clinical neuropsychologist and professor at Scripps College. Older people are maybe less aware of the algorithm's power, like how they work. It's really hard for them to discern what's credible and what's not. Older people are also taking up AI en masse. Hugh Data from February found that a full 23% of senior citizens use chatbots and 42% of those aged 50 to 64 are the same. And, you know, like keeping up with tech is not necessarily a bad thing.
Speaker 12But Dr. Stacey Wood says it's a slippery slope.
Speaker 5As people age, Wood noted, they also tend to be more likely to believe something is true because it is simply repeated to them over and over. And they're generally more susceptible to sensationalized and highly partisan content.
Speaker 2I can say the dumbest things and you people would clap for me.
Speaker 12Yeah.
Speaker 3One of the issues, as you stated, Sophie, is that like it's actually more important, I think, for the elderly to be aware of what AI is capable of than a lot of other groups because they're being targeted so relentlessly by different kind of AI based scams. Unfortunately, that usually gets translated into you should be using AI, which is going to make a lot of these people more vulnerable to scams.
Speaker 5Yeah, I mean, like, I don't like that there's this like trend that AI can can replace like human to human contact for our seniors. You guys, Garen, Robert, you saw a number of products at this year's CES that were targeting seniors in that way.
Speaker 3We saw one or two reasonable ones and a lot of bad ones.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 12And, you know, I guess slippery slope.
Speaker 5But this commercial comes on a lot with different versions of seniors, almost always seniors that are women doing things and, you know. the chat GPT or whatever AI helping them. I just don't see a reason why chat GPT should have access to these people's calendars, finances, that kind of a thing. I don't see this ending well for so many folks. It lacks security and I'm angry about it and I wish it wasn't a trend that I see increasing, but that seems to be the path we're going on.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 5That's all I had on that. I just felt it was worth mentioning because it was On my mind.
Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3Another story that's come out this week is that a bunch of anthropic researchers are now, or at least there's been stories in San Francisco. And you should always take this stuff with a grain of salt, but this is consistent with a lot of internal conversations that a lot of them have been taking up smoking because they're like, AI will cure cancer, right? And this has been occurring alongside, like there was just an interview with an AI researcher on the Delphi podcast for Anthropic who said he's enjoying his last six months. Part of the issue here is that if you try to engage with what these people are saying, then you wind up sounding to a lot
Speaker 3of folks like you're just like ignoring the potential of AI and the things that it is actually capable of doing. But you have to engage with what the people making it are saying. And everything that the company is making this stuff is saying it's nuts.
Speaker 2It's bullshit. It's lies. And it's insane.
Speaker 3And that doesn't mean that these are not incredibly powerful and very dangerous tools.
Speaker 9They are.
Speaker 3They are extraordinarily dangerous because, among other things, they have automated the ability of small groups of nation states of non-state actors. to carry out massive digital attacks with a level of penetration and speed that was not possible before. And that's a huge problem. These things are very capable tools. It's just that everything being said by the people making them is insane bullshit, and it makes it very hard to have reasonable conversations about what should be done.
Speaker 2Anyway. That's a really good point. Fuck these guys. Yeah. Let's go to ads real quick. Enjoy these hopefully non-AI products.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2And we're back.
Speaker 3And I think it's time for us to head south of the border that is south of the Polish border to talk about Ukraine. I don't know why I decided to lead in that way, but I did.
Speaker 5Baffling.
Speaker 3Things have unfortunately been very spicy in Ukraine over this last week. Last Friday, President Donald Trump announced that his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin, and he had made a deal to release 300,000 tons of Russian diesel fuel to, quote, the American and global marketplace immediately. This came as a massive surprise to everyone because last month, Trump signed a massive sanctions law to stop Russia from making money selling oil and gas to fuel their war against Ukraine.
Speaker 2The midterms crunch is really hurting.
Speaker 3It's really making strange, not strange, but I guess normal bedfellows. All of this seems to be in response to continuing disastrous polling numbers of Republicans in the midterms. An APNORC poll published on October 1st showed that most Americans disapprove of Trump's war with Iran and blame him personally for higher gas prices because he's why we have higher gas prices.
Speaker 9He has destroyed a generation of work. So trying to tell people the president does not control gas prices by finding the only possible way to actually.
Speaker 2Increase gas prices. He really did.
Speaker 3He definitely did. This is the first time that's been true. This is like the first time we've been in what is effectively a recession. You can say, no, it's directly as responsive to current policies, like literally direct. Like, I mean, obviously the 2008 crash, a lot, Bush did a lot to do with it, but most of that didn't hit until anyway.
Speaker 2You know what I'm saying, right? Yeah. I did that.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 3So Trump's goal was to make a deal with Putin to lower diesel prices in particular, as diesel prices have been debilitating to American farmers who tend to support Trump. And I think also just a lot of the ads that have been running with farmers being like Trump fucked me are really bad for Donald and for MAGA. in addition to the immediate 300,000 tons of diesel promised to be released, another 500,000 tons of Russian diesel were to be released by Russia in November, and 1 million more tons were to be released immediately hereafter. It's not actually clear if this is any kind of formal deal or
Speaker 3if any of this is actually promised anywhere, what these numbers are based on. A lot of what Trump says is just nonsensical. So he says that in November, we'll get another half million, and then another million immediately hereafter, and then 3 million more tons within a short period of time. That's not what we what are you at? How much fuel is supposed to be released? This might be market manipulation. Genuinely, this might just be market manipulation. It's entirely possible as that probably leads you to believe there are serious doubts as to whether anything like what
Speaker 3Trump has promised is possible to get out of Russia right now. And I will talk about the ethical and like Ukraine stuff. But I'm just talking about like, can they do this right? Like, do they even have the ability to get this fuel on the marketplace?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Per an article in the LA Times, quote, Now, while he says half of Russia's refining capacity has been damaged, that doesn't necessarily mean that, like, they're down by 50%. The IEA, the International Energy Association, said, Estimates that Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries have cut Russia's diesel output by
Speaker 330 percent or so. That also could mean that they're like gas fuel output is by more than averages to 50. I don't fully know. I don't know anyone has other than the Russian government exact numbers on how much Russia's refining capacity has been damaged. Russia's deputy prime minister has tried to repost claims like what the Polish deputy minister said yesterday. Our foreign minister said, arguing that Russian exports would rise in November and December as previously damaged refineries return from maintenance. And obviously, I don't doubt that the Russian state is actively repairing and refurbishing damaged facilities and
Speaker 3that some of them will come back online periodically. But they also will continue to face targeting from Ukrainian drone strikes.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3This current phase of the war is largely focused on deep ranging drone strikes into Russian territory with retaliatory drone swarms and missile attacks from Russia into Ukraine as the front remains locked in a relatively stable position. Ukraine's hitting 1500 miles beyond the line of contact now with drones, which is nuts. Like that's air power levels, right?
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 3There's a lot of kvetching about like, oh, it's going to change warfare. We've already seen the biggest change in warfare that I think will occur in my lifetime. lifetime, maybe I'm wrong, but it's drones. Careful what you wish for. Yeah, I may be biased because a drone tried to kill me once, but I have trouble imagining something altering the experience of the regular soldier on the ground more than drones have.
Speaker 2Robert, I'm so excited for the plague weapons. We'll see.
Speaker 3Obviously, I'm not counting the possibility of currently illegal weapons like biologicals or nuclear weapons becoming.
Speaker 2Regularly deployed, right?
Speaker 3Immediately after Trump announced this deal, Ukrainian President Zelensky issued a furious statement on his nation's behalf. In Kiev, a protest gathered at the Memorial to Fallen Soldiers in the Maidan to express their anger. Within a matter of hours after Trump's announcement, Ukraine hit the loading terminal to Russia's Novoshakhtynsk oil refinery, causing a massive fire. For weeks prior, Trump had begged Zelensky to halt strikes on Russian energy infrastructure, even as Russia has continued to hit Ukraine's energy infrastructure. When news broke of this new Ukrainian strike, Trump reacted
Speaker 3with fury, telling Ukraine that it needed a new president and blaming Zelensky for losing 30 percent of your country. people had been killed in a war that never should have been started.
Speaker 2I agree. Putin shouldn't have started the war.
Speaker 3Trump has repeatedly stated his belief that it wouldn't have occurred if he'd been president when Biden was.
Speaker 2I think that's nonsense. By the way, his number is also wrong.
Speaker 3Russia currently controls about 20% of Ukraine's territory, not 30%. We don't have official death tolls for this war. We know Russia has lost at least about 500,000 soldiers killed. So it's reasonable to assume Ukrainian civilian and military fatalities would be somewhere in that ballpark. I should also note that Trump made this announcement, you know, complaining about Ukraine hitting Russian energy infrastructure and promising to buy Russian diesel directly after 20 civilians in Ukraine were killed by Russian strikes, including three children. Russia has continued to devote significant effort
Speaker 3to striking Ukrainian civilian property and infrastructure. On October 13th and 14th, Russian strikes cut power to more than 600,000 Ukrainians. This came just four days after Trump licensed imports of Russian diesel. It also came after an energy ceasefire that Trump unilaterally announced during the weekend in response to Ukraine's strike on that binary. Trump was like, there's an energy ceasefire now. Nobody's striking. And then there were strikes. He was like, well, nobody's striking diesel. And then there were more strikes, right? And Zelensky pointed out on Monday that Russia had already violated the ceasefire. Since his announcement, Trump
Speaker 3has escalated his efforts to defray blame for the high cost of gas. And his current strategy is blaming high diesel prices in the states on Ukrainian resistance.
Speaker 2He is in speeches.
Speaker 3He is saying, like, Ukraine is why your diesel is so expensive, which it's not. And again, they've been fighting in Ukraine for years. Diesel prices didn't skyrocket until Trump decided to fuck with Iran. On October 11th, Ukraine also struck a facility belonging to Yandex, which I would casually describe as Russian Google. This facility hosted a massive supercomputer, two massive supercomputers actually, used to train neural networks. It also part of like the Yandex facility there was like a military research facility. By any term, this is a
Speaker 3valid target in war, by the way, just I wanted to make that clear. The strikes caused massive disruption to Yandex services across Russia. Yandex is an interesting company. The founder, Arkady Voloz, was not willing to fall in line and support Putin after the expanded invasion of Ukraine. He went so far as to condemn the war. This forced his exit from working in Russia, and a deal was arranged in 2024 to put Yandex under Kremlin control. This is why Arkady wins my least problematic Russian billionaire award. The strike on that Yandex hub was Ukraine's third major hit on Russian tech infrastructure in four days. It cut access
Speaker 3to huge numbers of services for Russians and people, not just Russians, right? A number of countries that border Russia, including countries that are worried about getting invaded by Russia. Yandex is still like an important service for them. And this was not just like they lost access to Google. They lost access to like ride sharing apps and like AI, like all their AI apps. Like it did a bunch of damage to just like people being able to use the Internet the way that most people do. people are used to in the 21st century, not just in Russia, but in bordering countries. This has caused confusion online. In the immediate wake of the strikes, reports began to spread
Speaker 3that Yandex going down had cut bot traffic to huge portions of the Internet. That is objectively true. What bot traffic means is often misinterpreted. Specific claims were made that traffic had plunged for off day, the German far right party that like their people commenting and like pro off day boards and stuff had like fallen off a cliff. and that the conservative subreddit was also down, that there were no more Magabots online, that the Russian bots had declined. And evidence for these claims was posted in the form of cloud flare graphs that purported to show plunging bot activity.
Speaker 2And again.
Speaker 3some of those graphs were real, some of them weren't. There is plunging bot activity. The problem is that, and I made a joking comment about like, this is why we should keep airstriking data centers and then tried to follow it up by claiming like, look guys, no one has to abide by the truth in politics anymore.
Speaker 2Like, why should we, right?
Speaker 3But the reality of the situation is that bot traffic did drop precipitously as a result of this attack. Cloudflare reported that Yandex bot traffic is like 0.4% of the max number of HTTP requests that had been reported over the prior two weeks. But that doesn't mean there are fewer Russian bot accounts on the internet, right? I'll refer to an analysis by Brandon Beeb that he put together on his Substack that does a good job of explaining the disconnect in many people's understandings. The bots that dropped are mostly Yandex's own search engine crawler. They aren't troll accounts.
Speaker 3No primary data shows that Russian social media bots went offline. None shows that Engagement Reform UK, The Off Day, or MAGA accounts fell because of the strikes.
Speaker 2Here's what matters.
Speaker 3In Cloudflare's language, a bot is any automated web request. Nearly all automated traffic from Yandex's network is Yandex bot. It's search crawler, which is Russia's version of Google bot.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 3So that's what has declined. Now, while the people who are saying like, no, it's wrong that like Russian bot. you know, influence operations collapse as a result of these strikes. That's also led some people to say, like, there's been no impact in Russia's influence operations as a result of these strikes. I can't imagine that's true. It's just not true in the way people online assumed it is, right? Like, they lost a massive access to a massive supercomputer center that the military used, right? This has certainly done some damage of damage. It certainly frustrated some to some degree,
Speaker 3some of the shit that the Russian government does online. It just hasn't gotten rid of all of the bot accounts because that's just like not how any of this works.
Speaker 9No, like there's not like a Death Star you can blow up that like make Russian influence operation go away.
Speaker 8Like, no, no.
Speaker 2It's bad for Russia that these got struck, right? They prefer that not happen.
Speaker 3And that will presumably have impacts that are broader ranging and that are probably kind of obscure to us on a number of their operations. But it's not as simple as all of the bots went away. That's just not what happened.
Speaker 2Interesting. Interesting and informative.
Speaker 9So let's close with a segment I am calling Dispatches from a World in Revolt with the starting claim that, yeah, we're kind of back, by which I mean we're kind of back in what appears to be at least the beginning of another global era of mass protests along the lines of sort of 2011 or 2019, 2020. We have talked about some of these protests on the show. We're going to be going through a few areas that have seen large protests here. Today, we are mostly going to be focusing on India. Now, previously on the show, we've
Speaker 9talked about the massive wave of student protests in India under the banner of the meme Cockroach Janta Party, which is named after a Supreme Court justice calling unemployed youths their cockroaches. So it's a play on the BJP. It's like the BJP, but it's the CJP because it's cockroaches. Okay, with that out of the way, Those original protests from a few months ago have sort of won. The CJP declared victory recently after forcing the resignation of the Minister of Education, after government officials leaked the answers to standardized tests. But, comma,
Speaker 9Protests in India have continued, and they have continued over the BJP's attempt to remove 130 million people from the voting rolls.
Speaker 3Now, Mia, I've never done a number before. Is that a lot of people?
Speaker 9That would be the 12th largest country on Earth. That is larger than the population of Japan. It is slightly, slightly less than the population of Mexico that they are trying to strip from the voting rolls. The rhetoric coming out of the BJP is in a lot of ways, very similar to the rhetoric you see from fascist parties around the world. They're screaming about like illegal Muslim aliens casting fake votes. And so like, basically they're doing on the scale of 130 million people, a thing that like you see in the U S where they go through the voting rolls and like purge everyone with a nonwhite name.
Speaker 9And here it's like, yeah, they're purging people with Muslim names at the scale of the 12th largest country on earth. So yeah, In response to this, India's, I would call them largely feckless opposition parties, actually finally did something and they deployed their... So Congress, which is like the main INC, are India's main opposition party. They are the party that is like the party that did Indian independence. And they have connected their legacy to Gandhi. And so they deployed
Speaker 9their one strategy, which is throwing Gandhi's at the problem. So they staged a protest outside of the Electoral Commission.
Speaker 3That's not honestly an enjoyable mental image. I'm just savoring that.
Speaker 2For a second. Literally, physically, it is what they're doing. They threw Raul Gandhi. How many Gandhis we got? A lot. They have a lot of Gandhi descendants. They got a lot of his family tree down there. Pick on the ground the Gandhis are these days. That's good to know.
Speaker 9Yeah, so Rahul Gandhi and his sister, who's also in the party and is like a high ranking party official, Rahul Gandhi is like the opposition leader. They went and were nominally they were trying to like they went to the Electoral Commission. We're trying to talk to the guy who's in charge of the Electoral Commission. And they got arrested like multiple times. There's a bunch of scenes of like Rahul Gandhi trying to like crawl out of a bus that he was being held. This is like this was like a week ago Wednesday.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 9Yeah, on October 7th, or maybe it was October 6th or 7th. Basically, it was last week from when we were recording this. And this has led to a bunch more protests, including the CJP, like the cockroach party, like going out against these electoral purges. But it's also led to a sort of astonishing level of repression in India, and particularly in the capital of New Delhi. that has turned it over over the last weekend into effectively a
Speaker 9fairly overt police state. On Saturday, Indian police arrested the founder of the cockroach party as an attempt to try to stop the protest. There was a huge militarized police deployment in New Delhi itself trying to stop anyone from being able to assemble and form protests in the first place. They've also shut down the mile long road to Junter Munter, which is basically there's a road there that has been a massive site of protests since like the 90s. Basically, whenever someone's doing a protest in the Capitol, you show up here and you do a protest on the street
Speaker 9and you like occupy the street for a while. And this was also a huge hub of of the car crash movement was a giant sit in here. And like the entire street has been declared like not a valid site of protest by the police and the police have been trying to funnel protesters into other sites around the city that are like significantly further from the center of the city, man.
Speaker 3Sometimes the just international like reflexive solidarity between police officers is just really beautiful.
Speaker 2You know, it's always the same the same move. No, no, no. You can't do it there, though. Can't do it there. Sorry. This is just free speech zones. Sorry.
Speaker 8Sorry.
Speaker 2This is not a free speech zone. Yeah, it's a free speech zone. Yeah, they always do this like, oh, but there. No, it's fine what you're doing, but not there.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 9Like over the weekend, there were these massive attempts to stop the protests, and that did kind of cut down on numbers. But on Monday the 12th, the Congress party, the terminology is mildly confusing to Americans. But yeah, like a lot of like Congress political leaders and a bunch of protesters were able to take the streets again on Monday. On Tuesday, cockroach protest leaders like tried to retake that street and a bunch of their leaders got arrested after trying to take the main square again. The protests do not seem to be slowing down as of now. Congress
Speaker 9has been trying to turn this into a sort of sustained attempt to challenge Modi's rule. I think even as he's trying to purge 130 million people from the voting rolls, which would be the end of anything even remotely democratic in the Indian system, this is a real moment of weakness for him. And the escalation of these protests has been very damaging for the regime, even after they were kind of able to like slow down and stop the original cockroach protests. Now that's been reignited and Congress has
Speaker 9been throwing their base into it. So we're going to continue to fill you in on what's going on there.
Speaker 2Do they have any specific demands when it comes to the voter roll purchase?
Speaker 9Yeah, the main one, obviously, they want everyone put back in and they want the chief of the electoral commission to resign.
Speaker 2Okay. Those are the demands that everyone seems to agree to, basically.
Speaker 9Congress and the cockroach protesters aren't... one-to-one overlapping political bases, right? So, you know, it's a bit complicated there. But yeah, those are the main demands that we've seen so far. I want to turn to Europe, where we've also seen continuations of, well, both the protests in France and Spain, there were large French student protests over the weekend. I've seen numbers that suggest it was down to about 160,000, down from like 300,000 the week before. You know, and obviously the police
Speaker 9have continued to attack student protesters. Things are still really bleak. There's like a horrifying picture of like a kid getting crushed by a gate that a bunch of like a giant metal gate that a bunch of cops are pushing. Yeah, so they're still doing absolutely horrific stuff there. We did a larger episode about this earlier this week. Now, the student protests have also begun to spread, although kind of in small forms as of this week. We've seen versions of them break out in Greece, Albania and Belgium. Greek protesters,
Speaker 9student protesters put up tents in Stigmata Square, which is another historic protest site that was, I mean, it's been the core of a hundred million protests, but it's notably was one of the places that was the core of the protest in 2011, which, you know, I think links back in a lot of ways to the ways that the protests in Spain have been reoccupying a lot of the like 2011 historic protest sites. The Albanian ones, I think, have been pretty small so far. of multiple fairly large
Speaker 9protests going on. There was a student protest on Monday, but then also earlier in like last week, there was a giant anti-austerity protest. There's about like 10,000, well, it's about like 10,000 people. Pretty large, much smaller than the sort of full-scale stuff in France and Spain, but also, yeah, similar cops have been attacking them fairly significantly. The cops arrested 10 people, like nine of whom are minors. So the student protests have a very similar sort of composition of like, it's like these high school students going into revolt that you see in France. Meanwhile, in Spain, there
Speaker 9was like another massive round of the giant protest they've been having. A bunch of the occupations are still going. We're probably going to talk to James next week a bit more in detail about what's been happening there. I think it's also fairly notable that there's been a pretty significant attempt to by the... Okay, so this is where we have to make a distinction between socialist party and socialist. The socialist party government of Pedro Sanchez, with the caveat that in Spain, the socialist party has been kind of
Speaker 9the equivalent of the Democrats for many, many, many years now. The socialist party was one of the two parties that the protests in 2011 were against, which led to the formation of Podemos.
Speaker 2That's a whole other story.
Speaker 9But Pedro Sanchez has been trying to use these protests to save his government, even though it has also been his government that has been presiding over the housing crisis and these evictions. He's been attempting to co-opt the protests in order to save his flagging electoral things, which obviously, yeah, it would be worse if the far right took power, and that's kind of what things have been looking towards. Yeah, because the far right killed two pro-tenant bills in parliament like earlier this month yeah and then he's kind of
Speaker 9used that and the protests yep to call for an election yeah and but this has also been paired with attempts to sort of like directly co-opt the protests themselves which there's been a whole bunch of stuff around that there that we can get into more detail with later but that's a dynamic that we're going to see frequently here i mean you don't often get one as blatant as the like hey this is the government that did this that's like now trying to use your movement to do something but Yeah, this is a very common dynamic in protests like this. And yeah, we're going to be
Speaker 9seeing it more and more as protests continue. And we will let you know what other places start having mass protests. I'm just going to briefly note there were some also education protests a little bit before this in Chile. There's been anti-Bolsonaro protests happening all over Brazil. But yeah, we will keep you updated as we get more really large protest waves.
Speaker 2Yeah. All right. That does it for us here at It Could Happen Here. If you want to send James a marketing email, you can do so at coolzontips at proton.me. He will kill you.
Speaker 9He will hunt you down with predator vision. Do not send marketing emails to him.
Speaker 2That email is actually for news-related tips and information. Put a trans girl on your couch. We reported the news.
Speaker 13We reported the news.
Speaker 3Hey, we'll be back Monday with more episodes every week from now until the heat death of the universe.
Speaker 18It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever.
Speaker 12You listen to podcasts.
Speaker 18You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions.
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...
Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.