Behind the Bastards

Behind the Bastards artwork

It Could Happen Here Weekly 258

4 hr 13 minAudio

All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount Merger A Tale of Two Assassinations with Andrew Executive Disorder: Hegseth Impeachment Vote, Jensen Huang’s Spy Scandal, Salvadoran Operations in Haiti You can now listen to all Cool Zone Media shows, 100% ad-free through the Cooler Zone Media subscription, available exclusively on Apple Podcasts. So, open your Apple Podcasts app, search for “Cooler Zone Media” and subscribe today! Sources/Links: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/us-declares-drought-disaster-parts-puerto-rico-dry-conditions-persist-rcna594653 https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/locales/notas/el-embalse-la-plata-se-acerca-al-nivel-de-control-como-estan-sus-condiciones/ https://www.esmental.com/agua-impacto-sequia-salud-mental-ansiedad/ https://www.neefusa.org/story/water/home-water-use-united-states#Puerto%20Rico https://docs.pr.gov/files/Estado/OrdenesEjecutivas/2026/OE-2026-035.pdf https://www.prfaa.pr.gov/recent-press-releases/governor-announces-usda-approval-of-drought disaster-declaration-for-puerto-rico https://periodismoinvestigativo.com/2026/09/aaa-contratos-millonarios-perdida-agua/ https://periodismoinvestigativo.com/2026/09/aaa-fondos-reparar-tuberias-perdida-agua/ https://wapa.tv/noticias/locales/una-semana-sin-agua-y-190-mil-abonados-afectados-por-rotura-en-el-superacueducto/articleb4a05276-f542-4d3b-a21e-6b154eee5d16.htmlref_=heavyweather.media https://www.metro.pr/noticias/2026/06/07/utilizaran-camiones-de-leche-para-distribuir-agua-en-comunidades-afectadas-por-averia-de-la-aaa/?ref=heavyweather.media https://www.youtube.com/watchv=Mtu_y1nBj1M&sourceve_path=NzY3NTg&embeds_referring_euri=https%3A%2F%2Fheavyweather.media%2F https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/gobierno-politica/notas/averia-en-el-superacueductos-dejara-mas-de-100-mil-abonados-sin-agua/?ref=heavyweather.media https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/locales/notas/yo-voy-a-cobrarles-todo-lo-que-pueda-presidente-de-la-aaa-advierte-que-buscara-que-luma-pague-por-reparacion-en-carraizo/?ref=heavyweather.media https://elpais.com/us/2026-08-01/mas-de-100-dias-sin-agua-la-crisis-que-golpea-a-miles-en-puerto-rico-ademas-de-los-apagones.html https://www.periodicolaperla.com/actualidad/nuevo-estudio-advierte-que-la-sequia-en-puerto-rico-seguira-y-aumentara/ https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2026/sep/10/puerto-rico-water-access https://www.wired.com/story/puerto-rico-is-rationing-water-it-could-avoid-it-by-harvesting-rainwater/ https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/locales/videos/carl-axel-soderberg-acueductos-pierde-el-60-del-agua-que-produce-294132/ https://es.euronews.com/2026/08/08/puerto-rico-raciona-el-agua-a-500000-personas-por-la-peor-sequia-desde-2015 https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/puerto-rico/notas/falta-de-dragados-y-mala-planificacion-estudio-confirma-lo-que-esta-limitando-nuestros-embalses/ https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/us-declares-drought-disaster-parts-puerto-rico-dry-conditions-persist-rcna594653 https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/locales/notas/mas-de-la-mitad-de-puerto-rico-sigue-bajo-sequia-o-sequedad-pese-a-lluvias/ https://www.cdc.gov/global-water-sanitation-hygiene/about/about-global-hygiene.html https://apnews.com/article/puerto-rico-esencia-cabo-rojo-developers-44d13fdafa22d9ec3 94ff222426db331 https://noticel.com/ultima-hora/20260811/puerto-rico-tiene-desde-el-2024-una-ley-que-obliga-a-las-agencias-recolectar-agua-de-lluvia/ https://bvirtualogp.pr.gov/ogp/Bvirtual/leyesreferencia/PDF/91-2024.pdf https://periodismoinvestigativo.com/2026/09/agua-no-da-proyecto-esencia/ https://www.senado.pr.gov/aaa-aee-y-turismo-se-oponen-al-proyecto-esencia-en-cabo-rojo-durante-los-trabajos-de-investigacin-del-senado-de-puerto-rico https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/gobierno-politica/notas/culmina-el-dragado-del-embalse-carraizo/ https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/legislatura/notas/carlos-johnny-mendez-promete-accion-sobre-el-plan-de-mitigacion-al-cambio-climatico-pero-dice-falta-un-proyecto-de-ley/ https://periodismoinvestigativo.com/2026/08/nuevo-estudio-advierte-sequia-aumentara/ https://planclimaticopr.com/visor.html?tomo=1&pagina=1 https://www.elnuevodia.com/noticias/legislatura/notas/legislatura-apunta-a-aprobar-version-reducida-del-plan-para-enfrentar-el-cambio-climatico/?templateId=OT3HWJU9FRSI& templateVariantId=OTB2HAZL1TSY&experienceID=EX029JWEG3W3 https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/63354869/108/1/maldonado-gonzalez-v-puerto-rico-aqueduct-and-sewer-authority/?ref=heavyweather.media https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/dd80d863-6a63-11ef-a8ba-01aa75ed71a1/language-en https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/who-was-puerto-ricos-water-system-really-built-for/id1553089886?i=1000799569550 Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene https://ashevilleblade.com/?p=5399 Press Freedom and the Paramount Merger https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/sustainable-finance-reporting/warner-bros-signs-110-billion-deal-with-paramount-its-executive-discloses-2026-02-27/ https://www.skydance.com/news/press/paramount-completes-acquisition-of-warner-bros-discovery-creating-a-new-global-entertainment-leader-skydance https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/12-states-challenge-paramounts-takeover-of-warner-say-merger-would-extinguish-competition https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/paramount-pledges-release-30-films-year-how-will-that-add-up-2026-09-23/ https://fortune.com/2026/10/15/skydance-warner-media-consolidation-trust-gallup/ https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/18/paramount-bonta-in-talks-to-settle-antitrust-litigation-01085072 https://variety.com/2026/tv/news/trump-praises-paramount-warner-bros-skydance-merger-terrific-people-1236903643/ https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/free-press-founder-bari-weiss-named-editor-cbs-news-after-deal-with-paramount-2025-10-06/ https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/new-cbs-news-chief-draws-backlash-by-pulling-60-minutes-story-on-el-salvador-prison https://www.nilc.org/resources/tracking-the-cecot-disappearances/ https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/new-cnn-cbs-news-editorial-indepedence-board-who-what-why-1236707168/ https://www.cnbc.com/2026/03/11/oracle-tiktok-us-stake-outages.html https://apnews.com/article/trump-tiktok-china-d5d8a1d56b5185778536874d7fc1ee62 https://csmapnyu.org/impact/news/was-there-censorship-on-tiktok-after-the-u-s-takeover A Tale of Two Assassinations with Andrew https://abcnews.com/US/luigi-mangione-charged-murder https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2024/12/10/luigi-mangione-life-school-family-back/ https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/aug/14/luigi-mangione-guilty-plea-brian-thompson-killing America's Forgotten Terrorists: The Rise and Fall of the Galleanists by Jeffrey D. Simon Assassins against the Old Order: Italian Anarchist Violence in Fin de Siecle Europe by Nunzio Pernicone, Fraser Ottanelli The Anarchist Assassin and Italian History, 1870s to 1930s by Carl Levy The Monza Tragedy by Errico Malatesta - https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/errico-malatesta-the-monza-tragedy Executive Disorder: Hegseth Impeachment Vote, Jensen Huang’s Spy Scandal, Salvadoran Operations in Haiti https://x.com/AvAkifAkin/status/2119530275541811504?a=P678NnFDDQ_gCEpTZ5Y&s=20 https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ICS_U.S._Mission_to_Burma_20260831-Public.pdf https://www.state.gov/releases/office-of-the-spokesman/2026/11/disrupting-irans-pursuit-of-man-portable-air-defense-systems-fact-sheet https://www.portsmouth.co.uk/news/politics/portsmouth-grants-rnli-highest-civic-honour-following-threats-to-crew-9342509 https://www.axios.com/2026/11/08/scoop-mamdanis-bid-for-2028-kingmaker https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/11/09/congress/union-sours-on-schumer-01157983 https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/11/10/congress/sanders-dings-schumer-01159546 https://www.newsnationnow.com/politics/no-idea-hegseth-strategy-iran-james-comer/ https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mzvwv2cxl32x https://clerk.house.gov/Votes/2026317 https://x.com/Rep_Stansbury/status/2120312483697091008 https://www.washingtonsun.com/congress/house-democrats-traffic-key-hegseth-impeachment-vote https://thehill.com/homenews/house/6206617-jeffries-supports-hegseth-impeachment/ https://x.com/riley_rogerson/status/2120299241348202952 https://x.com/LEBassett/status/2120307288754065812?a=q397I_gDFM3huIgD_to&s=20 https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1119-natural-causes-340763248/episode/urgent-the-bipartisan-effort-to-quietly-erode-environmental-and-tribal-protections-349745030/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2aC8lAOQbg https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2118778661243634138a=9rxD6GnZblVeCArqCvo&s=20 https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2118794656154550533a=qjnnQBn295o28uObEuM&s=20 https://x.com/bennyjohnson/status/2118805228153864465a=UMBw8NvHgD9qVhvwTbY&s=20 https://massie.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=395863 https://massie.house.gov/uploadedfiles/hegseth_articles_of_impeachment.pdf https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pete-hegseth-impeachment-vote-house-thomas-massie/ https://drive.google.com/file/d/1T_Ui8f1k6jYbISwuK2TJWdFmumkR24jM/view https://www.wawd.uscourts.gov/sites/wawd/files/General%20Order%200826%20re%20Immigration%20Habeas%20Petitions.pdf https://apnews.com/article/immigration-bond-policy-trump-washington-judges-976cd214de879948f324988a60a96d4b https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/bukele-says-salvadoran-troops-destroyed-195938494.html https://x.com/nayibbukele/status/2120182485015474372?a=Dgw1vfEEOAu9XXLcnqY&s=20 https://x.com/nayibbukele/status/2118798429434343447?a=-NEIMF6zQ-lBZ4jXr5A&s=20 https://apnews.com/article/nayib-bukele-el-salvador-haiti-elections-war-on-gangs-un-rubio-democracy https://edition.cnn.com/2026/10/17/americas/haiti-erik-prince-drones https://www.hrw.org/news/2026/03/10/haiti-drone-strikes-put-residents-at-risk https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/documentary/the-deal-trump-bukele-gangs-el-salvador/ https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/world/americas/haiti/article317973147.html https://www.axios.com/2026/11/10/el-salvador-state-department-haiti-gangs https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/analysis/2026/11/11/haiti-depth-what-bukeles-intervention-means-security-crisis https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/a-message-to-our-company https://www.ft.com/content/a55a2a22-4479-4f93-a445-6147a5c6d790?syn-25a6b1a6=1 https://techcrunch.com/2026/11/09/jensen-huangs-affair-with-alleged-chinese-spy-puts-nvidias-china-ambitions-under-scrutiny/ https://archive.is/4MK0d#selection-473.0-477.231 https://archive.is/DitAN https://archive.is/20261029091025/https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/us/politics/nvidia-china-jensen-huang-trump.html https://www.wired.com/story/nvidia-ceo-jensen-huang-hired-a-pr-firm-known-for-handling-sex-scandals-last-year/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Call zone media.

Speaker 2Hey, everybody.

Speaker 3Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode of the week that just happened is here in one convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to listen to in a long stretch if you want. If you've been listening to the episodes every day this week, there's going to be nothing new here for you, but you can make your own decisions.

Speaker 2Hello, you're listening to It Could Happen Here, a podcast about things falling apart and how to put them back together again. Today's here is Puerto Rico and the it is the water crisis. My name is Carlos and I'll be your host for today. Over the past year and a half, Puerto Rico has been experiencing a pretty bad water crisis where at its peak, about a half a million people didn't have adequate access to running water. This was mainly in the metro area, which consists of the capital city of San Juan and surrounding municipalities. The problem

Speaker 2was originally caused by the archipelago's water infrastructure breaking down because of years of mismanagement and failure to provide adequate maintenance. Then, the lack of water in some areas was compounded by a pretty intense drought throughout the middle of this year. July was the driest month on record in San Juan in more than 120 years. And in August, more than 60% of the archipelago was experiencing either extreme or severe drought. While the glut of the water problems have now subsided,

Speaker 2the government has done little to deal with the underlying infrastructure problems that caused the crisis in the first place. Instead, when the drought began earlier this year, the government, with a little help from friendly media, was able to shift the blame for their fuck-ups onto the drought and the dry conditions caused by El Niño. Then when it started to rain in mid-September and reservoir levels started to go up while the amount of areas affected by drought started going down, they were able to skate by almost entirely

Speaker 2without any consequences with very little mention of actually fixing the problems. This water crisis is built on top of many other societal problems that Puerto Ricans face daily, like crumbling electrical and healthcare systems, corrupt local politicians, continued colonialism by the U.S., and a whole host of other things. All these problems intermingle and coalesce into the much bigger crisis that's bubbling under the surface, but the water issue is really emblematic of the problems we have as an archipelago,

Speaker 2because the pro-statehood new progressive party government's solution has been to metaphorically hold everything together with duct tape and hope people forget the problem ever existed, only for it to come back to bite us in the ass while politicians talk about remaining calm and blame anything but themselves. Much of the archipelago has been lulled into a false sense of security with the water crisis because it's currently raining a lot and most reservoirs are close enough to full that water is flowing freely. However, just because things are

Speaker 2doesn't mean that they always will be. And as we approach the end of the rainy season, as the year ends and a new year begins, it's entirely possible that some part of the archipelago could face water rationing in the near future. In fact, at time of recording, one of the reservoirs managed by the public water utility, the Puerto Rico Aqueduct and Sewer Authority, is slowly approaching the quote-unquote control level, at which historically Praça has instituted water rationing to prevent a reservoir from going out of service,

Speaker 2according to El Nuevo Dia. However, Praça told Endy that they are not currently considering rationing, although that might change by the time you're listening to this episode. So, to lay some groundwork before I talk about when the crisis was at its worst over the summer, I have to start in July of 2025, when several neighborhoods in San Juan, like Isla Verde and Machuchal, started losing running water or having it severely limited. The experiences these communities face would prove prophetic for what awaited many of us the following year.

Speaker 2At the start of October, I spoke to Dara Rivera, co-founder of La Colisión Exigimos Agua, we demand water coalition, which demands reliable water services for all, for water leaks to be fixed, and government transparency. But what her neighborhood had been experiencing for more than a year, although the water situation had more or less stabilized by the time we talked, the memories and exhaustion were still fresh. As a quick note, Dara and I spoke in Spanish, but Abu from the Cool Zone team is reading a translation

Speaker 2of the interview here and throughout the episode.

Speaker 4It changed my life completely because.

Speaker 5It completely changed our lives, because you never knew if you were going to wake up with water or without it. On occasion, they would cut off the water for the whole day, and they'd turn it back on in the dead of night, and they'd cut it at 6 in the morning the next day. And then, they wouldn't even warn you. They wouldn't even let you know. They wouldn't say, look, you're not going to have water, get ready. No, the government's communication was extremely inefficient. They weren't honest with the community.

Speaker 5That was one of their main problems, that they wouldn't tell you when you'd have water and when you wouldn't have water so you could prepare. And definitely, that changed many people's routines, emotionally, physically, and mentally.

Speaker 2This feeling of not knowing if you were going to have water coming out of the faucet when you woke up or got home, as well as having to drop everything when water returns because you didn't know when it would be back or for how long you'd have it, bore is positively Kafkaesque. This sense of uncertainty and anxiety came to define a lot of that time that I explained. It's a pervasive feeling that many people I've interviewed about the water crisis have told me about. Dara said that sometimes Praza would say her area was going to have

Speaker 2water only for her to turn on the faucet and for nothing to come out, which added to the mental stress that they were living with at the time. She explained that not having running water disrupted everyone's routine. She'd get home from work and wasn't able to cook, so she had to buy food only to find that some restaurants weren't open at all or had severely limited menus. Of course, being without water is expensive because you have to buy water as well as prepared food, but I'll talk a little bit more about that in a bit.

Speaker 2Because she doesn't have a cistern, Dara said she kept about 30 gallon jugs in her house that her family would use for everything from cleaning to flushing toilets. Whenever they had water, she made sure to fill them up as quickly as possible because that was the only water they would have for days. Access to water is a basic human necessity. If you don't have any, it can lead to a bunch of negative physical and mental effects. As one clinical psychologist told me for an article I wrote for Es Mental about the mental effects of the

Speaker 2lack of water, the feeling of uncertainty can infect everything from your sleep to your relationships. Meanwhile, when it comes to physical health effects, that could be another podcast in and of itself. But basically not being able to bathe yourself or clean your hands could lead to the spread of diarrheal and respiratory diseases because there is no way to keep yourself clean. To illustrate that picture for you, imagine pooping, not being able to flush the toilet, then not being able to clean your hands afterwards. Now, imagine that for multiple days or weeks. It's not a great

Speaker 2situation at all, really. Sometimes, lack of running water could lead people to get water from non-potable sources, which can lead to the spread of bacteria and viruses that could put you in the hospital, or even worse, water is imperative to good health in all aspects. The year following Dara's neighborhood losing water would see the crisis expand significantly, in part because of the quote-unquote super aqueduct, the 26-year-old 72-inch tube that supplies water to much of the metro area,

Speaker 2breaking down due to lack of maintenance over the last two decades, more than once, and because of pumps and other parts of reservoirs falling into disrepair for the same reason. These ruptures and breakdowns came in batches, leaving hundreds of thousands of people with very limited water coming for their pipes or no water at all. The latter was the case for me. I'm not going to dox myself, but I live on the edges of the metro area, which means we usually aren't as affected by any water problems. But one of these ruptures left us without any water

Speaker 2flowing into our neighborhood for roughly 10 days. And let me tell you, that was not a fun time at all. Like a lot of houses in Puerto Rico and much of Latin America, we have a cistern on our roof. But the thing you quickly find out when you have no running water is that people use a lot of water per day. Like way more than you would think. The average person here uses roughly 62 gallons per day, according to the National Environmental Education Foundation. And our cistern, for a family of four, holds 600 or so gallons.

Speaker 2So if you do some quick maths, our average daily consumption was roughly equivalent to three days' worth of our cistern's capacity. We were rationing water, so we were probably only using between a quarter to half of what we usually use. And even then, my dad still had to pay several hundreds of dollars for a water truck to come fill it up twice during that 10-day period. While 10 days might seem like a lot to go without running water, it's really nothing compared to what other people were experiencing, especially in communities like the poor areas of

Speaker 2San Juan that were more or less left to fend for themselves for months while the government was protecting them. like there wasn't a water crisis. However, when the super aqueduct broke for the second time, heavily affecting the tourism and business sectors, the government sprung into action, dispatching water trucks to certain zones so people could fill up their gallon jugs, using sanitized milk trucks to deliver water, and even activating the National Guard to aid in those deliveries. Per a survey by the Restaurants Association, some restaurants were

Speaker 2spending between $ 2, 000 to $ 3, 500 per week on water to be able to open with limited services. One coffee shop near the beach started counting the days they spent without water by plastering that number on their window with highly visible red tape. Last I checked, they were at about 120 some days or a little bit more this year without water. This was very disruptive to people's routines. Instead of being in school, at work, or at home, people

Speaker 2had to wait in lines in the hot sun, sometimes for hours, waiting to fill up whatever containers they could carry And if they could swing it, they had to spend a bunch of money at a time when the economy was and continues to be bad to fill up their cistern. If they were lucky, they only had to go through these cycles a couple of times before access to water was restored. About a third of Puerto Rico lives below the poverty line, and we pay some of the highest rates in the U.S. for electricity. So for a lot of people, it felt like they were getting

Speaker 2squeezed from all ends. Oh, did I mention people were also paying their water bills this whole time, even when they didn't have water? Some places got credits for up to 50% on their water bills for a few months, but even then it was not nearly enough to make up for all the stress people experienced. As Dada told me, she only got the credit for three months. Meanwhile, some in a neighborhood close to hers got seven months worth, even though they'd both experienced 14 months worth of water troubles.

Speaker 2When the drought really hit, the water rationing spread from these few communities throughout the major metropolitan area and some surrounding municipalities. Isati Sintrong, a climate scientist and founder of the NGO Climate Trace PR, which focuses on climate justice and empowering communities to lead climate action in the archipelago, told me that we have to think of the drought as a multifaceted problem, not just an environmental issue.

Speaker 6The drought is not simply, I guess we know, an environmental problem. This is a public health problem. It's a cascading crisis that affects water security, food production, public health, economic stability, and climate resilience. I mean, you can ask anyone in Puerto Rico how much have they spent over the past few months trying to get drinking water or making sure that they have water to daily use. Prolonged

Speaker 6drought reduces river flows, reservoir storage, and groundwater availability. And this can lead to this water rationing, but the interruptions are just, they go beyond water services and higher household costs.

Speaker 2Governor Jennifer Gonzalez-Colón declared a national state of emergency on July 31st, and the U.S. Department of Agriculture later approved a disaster declaration for drought in late August for 26 of Puerto Rico's 78 municipalities. Hundreds of thousands went without water for two or three days at a time. It was honestly a shitshow, in part because of how truly bad Praça and the central government were at communicating. They essentially did almost everything you don't want an authority to

Speaker 2do during a disaster, which requires clear and precise information that's actionable. Instead, government communications were often messy and confusing. The metro area was separated into zones that would get water a couple zones at a time, but then you would have people randomly having water when they weren't supposed to and not having water when they were supposed to. For many people, it felt like being in the aftermath of Hurricane Maria, which totally destroyed Puerto Rico in 2017.

Speaker 5All over again.

Speaker 2While the causes were different, the devastating effects and lack of government accountability was much the same. In part, that's why Dara and her neighbors formed Exigimos Agua, because they knew that the only people they could count on were each other. This became particularly clear when it came down to helping the elderly, who make up about a quarter of Puerto Rico's population and who can't mobilize to gather water or spend hours in the hot sun waiting in line.

Speaker 4What we went through was really awful. Really intense.

Speaker 5And honestly, people were calling me in tears because you just can't take it anymore. I mean, it's exhausting. It's really exhausting. I'm still young. I can carry a bucket of water. I can handle it. But there are older people who live on the second, third, or fourth floors, and they live alone. The population of San Juan is mostly older adults. About 30-something percent are older adults here in San Juan. Just imagine.

Speaker 2They live alone.

Speaker 5They don't have anyone. Well, those are the people we need to take care of. Honestly, just like we did for Maria. The ones who are united here are the neighbors, the communities, and the ones who are moving things forward are us, working hand in hand, pushing the country forward. And we don't depend on the government. We can't depend on it.

Speaker 2And while the water situation has stabilized from being at critical levels, Dara still keeps her 30-gallon jugs filled because the problems haven't actually been fixed. But at least people can rest a little before the next crisis.

Speaker 5Right now, we have water pressure that we haven't had, wow, in a really long time. And we're honestly taking a breather because it was more than a year going through this bad experience. But we know, or at least in my case, I know, that at any moment we could find ourselves in the same situation with a water shortage.

Speaker 2While the PR government would come to blame the drought almost entirely for the lack of water, many of the aforementioned ruptures and equipment failures happened way before the drought. So while you could blame it for escalating the situation, it did not cause it in its entirety. And I'm repeating myself here because we as an archipelago moved on way too quickly from the government's role in our continued water crisis. I'll be right back to talk about two of the biggest things that impact our use of water

Speaker 2here in Puerto Rico. Welcome back to It Could Happen Here. I'm Carlos, and there's two things that we should focus on when it comes to our uses of water here. The first is our degraded and unmaintained water infrastructure. And the second is the fact that we treat water as an infinite resource when human-caused climate change is proving that

Speaker 2it is quite the opposite. Before the major ruptures, our water system lost and currently loses 60% of the water that runs through our pipes. It's been like that since at least 2004, according to reporting from El Centro de Periodismo Investigativo. The lowest amount we've lost since 2004 has been 55% in 2015 and the highest amount was 69% in 2022. even though Praça set a goal of reducing

Speaker 2that water loss amount to 25% in 2011. Per El Centro's reporting, this is caused by leakages, overflowing tanks, excessive pressure, aging subterranean infrastructure, outdated or inexact water meters, billing errors, and theft, although the leaking pipes are the biggest cause of lost water. To visualize this for you, If I wanted to fill up a gallon jug to have water stored for future rationing, filling each one would lead to

Speaker 2a loss of 2.5 gallons somewhere along the pipes. So imagine if after I filled that gallon jug, I just dumped 2.5 gallons worth of water on the floor afterwards, and you get a sense of just how much water we lose.

Speaker 7El supertubo that is causing problems. We have Old leaky pipes, old infrastructure all across the islands. Agencies like the EPA, for example, and global agencies like the World Bank, they state that the best system, the best public water system should lose less than 15% of the water it produces.

Speaker 7The EPA, for example, states that 25% of losses, that requires urgent investigation and urgent repairs because it's a huge loss of the resources and we lose more than half.

Speaker 2That's Amira Odeh, a geographer and hydrologist that I spoke with in October. She lives in Carolina and while she didn't experience water rationing, the reservoir that feeds her area is the one that's currently hovering above the control level.

Speaker 7The lack of water in the San Juan communities and in many other parts of the country is just an example of how bad our infrastructure is. And that tends to get mixed up with the issue relating to the drought. But it is true that they do not have water. They've had water shut off for months now just because of bad management. And obviously, the government would say, like,

Speaker 7there's no funding to fix that. But when you're losing more than half of the water that you produce, obviously, you won't have funding for that. And it is unfair on the consumer also because we are not receiving the best quality product because of this all bad infrastructure. And we're also... paying for energy, materials, chemicals, all these things needed to produce the water, just to have it literally

Speaker 7thrown in the ground because less than half is what gets to our homes.

Speaker 2According to El Centro's reporting, Praza has paid $ 50 million to private companies to fix the water issues over the past two decades, only for it to get worse. Over the last five years, the percentage of Brasa's budget dedicated to repairing and replacing old infrastructure hasn't increased, and in 2026, they only dedicated 4% of its budget to these repairs. This has been happening while the agency's funding has gone up, and it's actually forecasted to decrease to 2% in 2027

Speaker 2and 2028, then increase to 5% in 2029, according to El Centro's reporting. there's also a big issue of reservoirs not being dredged properly. If they were, it would allow them to hold way more water than they currently do. Per a study published by the Department of Geography and the Environment at the University of Texas at Austin and the Department of Geology at the University of Puerto Rico at Mayagüez, approximately a quarter of the archipelago's reservoir capacity

Speaker 2isn't usable because of accumulated sediment in these reservoirs. When the lack of water storage capacity mixes with how much water we waste daily, it's really a recipe for disaster, as we've experienced. Part of the reason that the government continues to be okay with losing so much water all the time is because we're used to having it in abundance. The Caribbean as a whole has only contributed less than 1% to global greenhouse gas emissions, yet we're one of the

Speaker 2areas most affected by human-caused climate change. If we keep treating water like it'll always be there, it'll be our doom.

Speaker 7Compared to our neighboring islands, we have an immense privilege of having a bunch of rivers, water bodies. We have so much rain. And we've never had to sit back and think twice about the water that comes out of our faucet because we are so privileged to be in a place that has enough water and safe water that you can drink. But that is not the reality anymore.

Speaker 7As we face the climate crisis, we are already seeing it, how droughts are getting harder. And it is expected and studied that in the next decades, it's going to get worse. and the government is acting like if we were going to have infinite amounts of water forever, and they keep talking about building everywhere, deforesting, watersheds are not being protected,

Speaker 7and that privilege that we have is not going to last forever, so we can't sit back and pretend that every time... there's going to be a drought. It's just going to be a couple of weeks and it's over because it's going to get worse. And it could get to a point where instead of rationing for a month or two, it can be rationing up to six months because that is what is expected from what is happening

Speaker 7with the climate crisis.

Speaker 2Ameda's mention of our neighboring islands is particularly important when considering Puerto Rico and the rest of the greater Antilles. future water scarcity, because we don't collect rainwater like we should in a lot of cases. In comparison, the Lesser Antilles, the small series of Caribbean archipelagos to the east of the Caribbean, have a culture of and systems for rainwater harvesting because some do not have large natural rivers and lakes that function as reservoirs. Here's Amedda explaining what she's

Speaker 2seen in other Caribbean countries.

Speaker 7In Dominica... They are very rich in water resources, but still they capture water from their rooftops at homes. And most recently in the British Virgin Islands, something that caught my eye was this little ferry terminal, very small. It was just like an office and a toilet. And they captured water in the roof. They don't miss an opportunity.

Speaker 7Every single place captures water in the rooftop. And we don't have to reinvent the wheel. Decades ago, our houses would have aljibes. They would capture water in this concrete block or abasement. Many old houses, then they reconstructed the basement to do something else once the aqueduct system was

Speaker 7a thing. But we used to do that. And I believe that every single home should have that again.

Speaker 2Some houses and buildings in Puerto Rico have installed these rainwater collection systems, but they're few and far between. in part because they're costly to install, and well, Puerto Ricans simply don't have much money to spare. Some small non-profits have installed them in places of great necessity, but that's still a big economic burden that few people can meet without going into ginormous debt. And I want to be really clear about this. It's good that people and organizations

Speaker 2are investing in preparedness through cisterns, solar panels, and other things. But this is all born out of a government that refuses to actually care for its people and instead has shifted the burden of surviving onto them. Essentially creating an individualist mode of survival where the rich are able to have water and electricity while the poor are left in turmoil without much, if any, help. While community resilience is absolutely of the utmost importance if we want to reach a better world, governments should have a responsibility to people

Speaker 2and we can't let them off the hook for not providing for us as they should be. In fact, to point out how bad the Puerto Rican government isn't actually doing things that could help us, there's a 2024 law that requires all government buildings to install water collection systems. Yet, per a Noticel report from August, Seemingly, nothing's been done to actually do that. However, what the government has pushed is rampant overdevelopment in construction of luxury hotel megaprojects, as

Speaker 2well as attempting to gut the permit laws that offer a modicum of protection to land that is important for ecological diversity. The biggest and most visible of these projects is Esencia in Cabo Rojo, which has garnered widespread protests from people because of how much water it will use if it's built and the ecological impact it could have. While the developers say that it'll get water independently from the public water system through desalinization and aquifer on the land and reuse of wastewater, experts have reiterated time and

Speaker 2time again that this will have an outsized impact on Cabo Rojo, which is already one of the driest areas of Puerto Rico. Per reporting from El Centro, the daily water use of Esencia will likely be 3.78 million gallons, while the entire municipality consumes 4.46 million gallons. The people of Cabo Rojo already suffer from lack of water whenever there's large amounts of tourism, so their fear is that their water problems will be much worse if Esencia gets built.

Speaker 2In fact, in late August, Praza said they were opposed to the project and that they did not have the capacity to supply it with water. Other agencies, municipalities and legislators have said similar things.

Speaker 6They are constructing a city and that requires a lot of water to make sure fulfill the necessities of the guests that are billionaires, right, like the upper class in there. But also that they have a lot of golf courses and golf courses are particularly known to utilize a lot of water, like I think between one or two millions of gallons of water a day. And that is just

Speaker 6to keep the grass green. So while Puerto Ricans do not have water to drink, We are approving and speeding up projects that will just keep the water running just to keep the grass green so it looks great for people to go play golf.

Speaker 2The Puerto Rican government has already greenlit the construction of Essentia and other similar projects, and I'll be talking about these types of projects in a future episode, but I wanted to drop some words here about them because they're relevant to the water conversation we're having. It's also worth noting that while San Juan and the surrounding metro area has received most of the attention in this episode, and indeed in national and international media, because it's where the largest amount of people live, other regions like the aforementioned Cabo Rojo have been experiencing water issues for decades without

Speaker 2government assistance. In fact, the small town of Morobis in the center of the archipelago had to sue Praça in federal court a few years ago because it continuously failed to deliver running water Dumorovic's communities, which violated the municipality's constitutional rights, they argued in their lawsuit. The lawsuit was eventually settled in 2026 on the condition that Brasa complete several water infrastructure projects by January 2028. I'll be right back after these ads to talk more about how Puerto

Speaker 2Rico is not ready for another water crisis. Hi, welcome back to It Could Happen Here. And to cap off this episode, I want to talk about the right-leaning conservative government's continued lack of willingness to approve our climate adaptation plan. A group of experts created this climate change plan years

Speaker 2ago that calls for more than 150 measures that need to be taken to prepare the archipelago for climate change adaptation, mitigation, and resilience. Some of these tasks include reducing water loss from 60% to 17%, reaching 100% reuse of treated wastewater by 2050, combating widespread deforestation by planting half a million trees in the next 10 years, not authorizing new construction in terrain that is at risk of flooding because of

Speaker 2sea level rise or storm surges, and many others.

Speaker 6We have a fundamental problem of the vision of where Puerto Rico should be. Because currently, it's not only that they're not acting on it, they're acting... actively against it. What we're seeing is a weakening of environmental laws and everything that could provide some kind of infrastructure or some kind of adaptative capacity to Puerto Ricans. What we're seeing is a vision in which the only priority is to

Speaker 6bring external capital into the island, not having any regards to what that means for the well-being of Puerto Ricans or having in mind future threats, right? Like it's kind of short-sighted how Puerto Rico is being governed by now, to say the very least.

Speaker 2All of these measures would go a long way towards making sure that Puerto Rico is prepared to deal with a world on fire. However, this plan has been stuck in the legislature forever. for years, with seemingly no path forward for it to be approved or implemented. This has become a trend with any projects or initiatives that would allow the archipelago to be better prepared for future crises. When it comes to water, it would radically reduce the ruptures and failures that caused the start of the water crisis and being able to better respond whenever there's a drought,

Speaker 2which we know will increase in intensity and occurrence because of human-caused climate change. There's a mix of reasons why this plan hasn't been passed, mainly a lack of political will by the ruling political party, corporate capture of public institutions, and the U.S. Fiscal Control Board, which has squeezed PR's economy nearly to the brink. The excuse is that it would cost hundreds of millions of dollars or maybe even billions. But we've already lost more than that to the effects

Speaker 2of climate change, and things are only going to get worse if we don't prepare.

Speaker 7We only talk about water when there's rationing, not even when there's drought. We talk about water when there's rationing. And for us to be able to manage this, and be ready for the impacts of the climate crisis. We need to educate about this every day, how to take care of our watersheds, our water, how to protect it, how to ensure the best quality and quantity of the limited water that we have.

Speaker 2It's important that Puerto Rico is focused on these issues at all times, not just when we're facing water rationing and drought, because that's how we create the conditions for change. For Dara, she agrees wholeheartedly, saying that if you want to change a country, you have to educate it about what it means to conserve water, to prepare for climate change, and to take care of one another.

Speaker 5I believe that is one of the coalition's duties, to educate the country, at least regarding water, the protection of natural resources, and safeguarding of our coasts. In short, everything related to how climate change affects the country. So that we can leave something behind for future generations. Otherwise, we'll essentially be left with no country at all.

Speaker 2Although we've seemingly passed the peak of the water crisis, I know that many people here are keeping their water reserves in cisterns full because we never know when the next time will be when we open the faucet and nothing comes out. Thanks for listening to It Could Happen Here. You can find me online everywhere at Vaquero2XL. Remember to keep your reserves full, just in case there's a disaster soon.

Speaker 8Welcome to It Could Happen Here, a podcast where I guess the it is hurricanes and the happening is Asheville and many other places along the path of the Hurricane Colleen, which the hurricane itself has passed. The effects have not. I am your host, Mia Wong, and with me today to talk about. I don't know if I can reasonably call it the second hurricane, but the second disaster. Yeah, we've been calling

Speaker 8it locally the crisis after the crisis.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8In Asheville, in the wake of Hurricane Helene, is David Forbes, who is a friend of the show, Asheville Blade journalist and editor, also writes for the Trans News Network. And yeah, David, welcome to the show.

Speaker 9Good to be back.

Speaker 8Yeah, it's good to talk to you again. It's I say this a lot, it sucks that the only times I get to talk to people are when bad things are happening.

Speaker 9Yeah, but we.

Speaker 8Wanted to have you on to talk about what has been going on in the aftermath of Helene in a sort of long-term sense, after the sort of cameras have gone away and after the government has declared a back to normal. I guess the place I want to start is something that becomes very clear when you are living in disaster areas, when you are covering disasters, when you're looking at the history of these things. There are sort

Speaker 8of two different imperatives that people are driven by in the wake of a disaster. You have, on the one hand, you get these massive upswellings of solidarity, what I guess gets called everyone coming together But is in reality, you know, massive expressions of incredibly selfless mutual aid and a bunch of sort of everyday heroism and all of the efforts to, you know, like a bunch of people dragging like generators

Speaker 8halfway across the state and like people from like halfway across the country showing up with food. So you have that on the one hand. On the second hand, you have the shock doctrine. which I had the unfortunate realization that I am now old enough that I don't know if everyone knows what the shock doctrine is anymore. So can you explain what the shock doctrine is before we get to talking about sort of the Asheville version of it? So the term the shock doctrine was popularized by the Canadian leftist writer Naomi Klein, and it is basically the

Speaker 8tendency of capitalists, and I would use the term gentry power structures, to use the aftermath of the disaster to consolidate resources and prop up their own power at the expense of everyone else. Yeah, and a lot of times it also allows them to ram through structural changes they would never have been able to ram through.

Speaker 9That too.

Speaker 8In normal times. I mean, I think this is another I am slightly feeling my age one because we were talking about this before the podcast. I had this horrifying realization that I was like, oh, I can explain the shock doctrine with Hurricane Katrina. And then I was like, oh, my God, kids who were born in 2006 are 20. It's good for him to hear history. I'm always a fan of you youngins need to hear some history. It's a considerable part of what I do for a living.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Katrina was one of the very famous examples of the shock doctrine. Like Pinochet's coup in Chile was like another one. But like, you know, with Katrina, you can see this sort of twin imperatives thing where on the one hand, you know, you have this absolutely horrifying hurricane. You have like basically right wing death squads. of white dudes going around shooting people. You have Blackwater deployments, which I think people have really forgotten about. Blackwater was deployed to New

Speaker 8Orleans in the wake of Katrina. And then you also have Common Grounds and a whole bunch of other associated efforts around it. This unbelievably powerful social movement and mutual aid efforts That was built around it. And then also, at the same time this is happening, the government in New Orleans is eliminating the public school system.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8Which is like the shock doctor part of it of like, oh my God. Like, Jesus Christ. Yeah, I guess that's the thing I want to talk about in the context of Asheville. Yeah, can you talk a bit about what the city government has been doing in the wake of of this, and I say like the kind of long wake, I don't know, like the two year aftermath, the aftermath.

Speaker 9Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 8So, and I spell a lot of this out in the recent piece for the blade called two years after Helene, we are still two cities. So I think it's worth knowing going in that if people think of Asheville as this like progressive Haven, blue dot Mecca, whatever term that we often get described as, That's just flat out untrue. There are really interesting, vibrant, amazing cultures here. That's why even folks who've done disaster relief work around the world were honestly shocked by the level of, I used the

Speaker 8term as a compliment, of course, anarchic, on-the-ground ability of people to gather together and help each other out, even when the government was nowhere to be seen. That is a common thing in disaster zones. We did have a particularly well-connected and powerful example here. And honestly, I kind of got to both report on that and see some of that because I was also out doing mutual aid stuff and double duty as a journalist trying to inform folks when the storm hit. Yep. So that was very real.

Speaker 8And that reflects like these entrenched kind of community spirit you have seen in this town. It's why a lot of us like love the city and like living here despite the hardships. This also was for a long time, may still be, sometimes ranked as like the most unaffordable city in the entire country.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Because of a combination of really high housing costs, often inflicted by this like very runaway gentrification. And the tourism industry fueled a lot of that. And also just like ridiculously low wages and anti-labor stuff, especially from progressive businesses often. Because like you want to see any of them become like Sam Walton conservatives. You mentioned their workers unionizing in Asheville. And all of a sudden they will just like become the most right-wing figures imaginable. So you had all that. There's a huge poverty problem heading into Helene Hitting. There's

Speaker 8a lot of neglect of seriously like vital infrastructure. The river is overdeveloped. These wall and all still are problems, but they will they all made the impact feeling a lot worse than it had to be. And the city government was at the heart of a lot of this. It's not the only government and county government, certainly its own share. And as I'll mention a little later, federal and state governments like this is a multi-government problem. But City Hall is the is the government with the most day to day power over the lives of people living here. Yeah,

Speaker 8they are the head of the Voltron of shit composed of the state federal governments. Yeah, basically, if one wants to use that analogy, yeah. Yeah, but by our powers combined, we can make everyone's lives worse. They are the on-the-ground-like problem. They are where the evils of the state and the gentry really hit the ground.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 8So a fact that I think kind of sums things up that a lot of people don't know was that evictions here in Asheville restarted before the water was back on. Which is just, like, Jesus Christ.

Speaker 10Yeah. Like.

Speaker 8Yeah, that's... And that was not just city government, because evictions were carried out by the county in North Carolina.

Speaker 10But, like.

Speaker 8city government could have said, hey, please don't do this. And because they're all run by, you know, overlapping Democratic Party clicks, there probably would have been like some hesitation from the county figures that would have backed off some. The governor might have declared a, who was also a Democrat at the time, still is actually, might have declared like an eviction moratorium. And there were considerable local efforts to press for these. But no, no, I went to the courthouse while they were still holding eviction hearings, At the same time, they had signs saying, hey, you can't use the restrooms because we don't have a reliable water supply. Yeah.

Speaker 8It's such a stark demonstration of, like, water? Not essential.

Speaker 5Landlords getting paid? Absolutely essential.

Speaker 10Yes.

Speaker 8And that wave of evictions, while people have done a lot to organize against it and, you know, keep people housed, it has been truly devastating. And irony of ironies now, state and local governments, as of, like, A month ago, we're starting to say, oh, maybe we need some relief plan. We're literally running out of workers.

Speaker 5It's like, wow, damn, social reproduction. Who could possibly have guessed? You do need to reproduce the worker.

Speaker 12Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8They're like, wow, businesses aren't getting as much money anymore because locals got driven out left and right.

Speaker 5Tourists aren't going to work in your shops. You kind of have to. Oh, no.

Speaker 8Why is my local economy failing? One billion dollars for cops. Pretty much. And it's an interesting example of kind of this magical thinking. And again, this is everywhere in the country, but it's Asheville distills a lot of like social evils in America, frankly, with the lack of affordability, with how openly liberals here on the side of like downright genocidal capitalism exist. with it being a tourist hub, there's a lot of like attempts to appease gentry from elsewhere as well.

Speaker 8And with just how blatantly in the, this is, this is kind of where he'll improve the apocalypse. Like the old says the word, like a ripping off of the veil is that, They see Asheville as an asset. This is something to be pumped for as much cash as possible. The first major city contract backed by federal relief dollars after Helene started to kind of like had kind of cleared out was to repair the golf course.

Speaker 5Jesus Christ.

Speaker 8It's just, oh my God. One reason I did this like kind of two year anniversary column, because I realize a lot of folks, especially outside Asheville, didn't know exactly, like just listing out the drumbeat of actions and lack of action in case of local local government did. You know, they bragged recently on putting 15 and a half million into subsidizing businesses.

Speaker 9Mm hmm.

Speaker 8Locals pled for action. any sort of amount, that level of amount of rental aid. I think there's like, reluctantly, they parted with a few hundred thousand dollars, which given the scale of the crisis, didn't really do a damn thing. And locals are pushing for far, far more. I feel like that's just such a mask off, like let them drink rainwater.

Speaker 5We have golf to play. Yeah.

Speaker 8Occasionally, I've heard folks wonder why, like, of all the kind of, you know, leftist strains of thought, anarchism is really strong in Asheville. And this is a great example of why, because of just, like, even by government standards, how openly hostile the state is to your barriers.

Speaker 5Yeah, they just hate you.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8Yeah, they just straight up hate you. The mayor, Mayor Sturmanheimer, who may or may not be the mayor in about like a month or two, she's faced a pretty serious re-election challenge. In classic Ashford Court fashion, I don't think a huge amount will change, but she got so angry about locals giving her shit at meetings. that she started to read the entire rules of decorum before every meeting. Jesus Christ.

Speaker 5That's the most I'm not mad.

Speaker 8Like that's her priority is like no one can make me feel uncomfortable. She's also kind of famous for banning clapping.

Speaker 9What?

Speaker 8But not for everyone. And this is actually one thing where I've like talked to legal experts about this kind of thing. Yes, technically legal in Nashville, you know, and most cities in North Carolina. a government can ban clapping, but ask me for everything. Like you can't clap for good news to the city, bad news to the city. It's one or the other for first amendment reasons.

Speaker 9No, no.

Speaker 8She just decides arbitrarily to ban clapping. If it's people like wanting a ceasefire resolution, uh, two years ago for like the rights of Palestinians or like anyone criticizing city government in any way, as you straight up said one time, like, no, y'all can clap now. We're like the city manager, horrible city managers retiring because like, that's good news for us. So go ahead and clap. And it's just like, openly blatant petty cruelty, but like that's been her priority. So about a month after the storm in October 2024, the

Speaker 8Blade put out a piece in our Patreon. which is where we do a lot of our like shorter kind of quick hit stuff, no paywall. But it was entitled We Are Two Cities. And this had certainly been a reality well before the storm. The storm really brought it into sharp relief. And on one end, you had like these amazing efforts of communal care and people really helping each other out. and a stunning amount of organization going on. And then on the other end, you had, you know, how did, how did we put it? Like, uh, the place of $ 5, 000 rents and 5,000 Airbnbs.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8You know, it's, there was like a line of cops outside, uh, like abandoned Ingalls grocery store just to make sure people couldn't reach anything inside to help themselves out.

Speaker 5It's great.

Speaker 8Let, let the food rot. We cannot allow a single. Yeah. Literally they would, they would not, not even just the food, but like people want like diapers wise because again, the water wasn't, wasn't running. Yeah. Things like that.

Speaker 9No.

Speaker 8Ingalls, which is the kind of almost like de facto grocery store monopoly locally, has a lot of power protecting their bottom line. Like their ability just to write off a little bit more.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Was literally what the police are being deployed for. It's one of the most kind of searing things I've ever seen as far as like what the cops are actually for. It's probably a good time to mention that. Covering Asheville's local government, which I've done for over 20 years at this point, which is probably unhealthy at some deep levels, is one of the things that made me an anarchist. Because after a while, I'm like, this just shouldn't exist. And nothing like it has a right to exist.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Especially after repeated changes of government, things just kept largely proceeding in worse and worse directions, whatever people promised. But so that dynamics never really went away. And if anything, I think it kind of got exaggerated over time. A small example, but a really telling one. there was this really, she made national news for how callous she was. Monique Pierre, who was the head of the public housing agency in Asheville, and notoriously the state of the public housing towers, which are also a site of a ton of segregation, were really, really bad after the storm. The housing authority just neglected

Speaker 8everyone there, just left them to basically nearly die in a lot of cases. No supplies, no help whatsoever. And she publicly said, interviewed the local NPR station. Well, I had to make sure landlords got paid, and they did.

Speaker 2Well, it's just like.

Speaker 8That was so egregious that even the housing authority board, like, removed her for it.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And in response, the city, which the mayor appoints, like, housing board members, and with council approval, can remove them. And everyone voted for this, pretty much, including the, like, dissident who, quote-unquote, who's running against the current mayor, Esther Manheimer, right now. But they all voted to purge the Housing Authority Board to punish them for doing any consequences whatsoever, even if it's a figure that egregious. So, like, even the usual gentry thing of, like, she was a little too blatant and too openly evil. Like, we're going to

Speaker 8be fine with, like, throwing her overboard to make the rest of us look better. They wouldn't even do that. It's like, that's how open the, like, abuse of power is.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8So, that's continued. And... They've really actually emphasized a lot of collaboration with the federal government since Trump retook office.

Speaker 6Which.

Speaker 8The first thing they announced about the federal government was that they'd gotten approval from his FAA to do more drone surveillance of the public.

Speaker 5Doing drone surveillance? Like, drone surveillance of what? Like, the houses you didn't rebuild?

Speaker 9Like, what.

Speaker 8Well, and they got a ton of money from the federal government, and until there was a massive public backlash about it, initially that overwhelmingly was just going to go to capital projects, which is like city speak for big infrastructure, and specifically stuff that they felt could get tourists back. A month after the storm, again, still not, we didn't have running water.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8The tourism board was always like, it's time for everyone to come back to Asheville and spend money. And, you know, the tourism bubble was a problem, again, long before Helene. It kind of exacerbated and showed how big these issues were. And Helene, for justifiable reasons, like for understandable reasons, smashed it with a hammer.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8If anything, the effects from that haven't been all bad because like rental rates while still horrible here, especially if like people don't have income, finally stopped rising meteorically. We finally stopped having some of the highest COVID infection rates in the Southeast here. And so it showed, I think, along with the extremities they've gone to try to bring it back, how much that was always an extractive industry. Yeah. And to some degree, this fits in a longer history in Appalachia, which, you know, Asheville just seen as, oh,

Speaker 8this kind of progressive fun tourist town. But we're in the middle of Appalachia. There is a long history here of the purpose of governments, local and otherwise, just to be the place you run, the people in it are a site for extraction.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8Originally, that was taking land from indigenous folks, and then it was timber, then it was coal. And I think in a lot of ways, the little quieter about it, tourism is like a similarly extractive industry. Yeah, well, it has now gone back to being land a second time.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 5It's the thing that's being extracted.

Speaker 8Well, yeah, partly, but also, like, I mean, I know areas that used to have streets before the storm that used to have, you know, neighborhoods on them, and now they're mostly vacant because it all got turned into Airbnbs. Yep. Well, and where did a lot of those folks go? Well, they went to older, in worse disrepair, more flood-prone housing near the rivers. Some of them died there. Yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8This kind of all came together, actually, at the last city council meeting in September. It was a few days for the storm anniversary. And they showed this glossy video about how Asheville is making opportunity out of tragedy. And it's like business owners talk about how much money they'd gotten from City Hall.

Speaker 7Jesus Christ.

Speaker 2Christ.

Speaker 8And then the open public comment period hits where, you know, locals can just rant for a few minutes about whatever's in their mind, but also is one of the only, like, not tightly controlled areas of the meeting, probably because they legally have to have it.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8And this retired teacher from this neighborhood in East Asheville, which got hit really hard by the storm, which is, you know, that's mostly, like, retired educators, said, look, like, it's telling that we hear how Asheville's revived, but none of the footage is from our neighborhood. We have a, like, crumbling cliff we have been warning you about since the storm jesus christ and the response we've largely gotten is well if it falls apart we'll help you clean it up incredible stuff like it just yeah like i can't

Speaker 8make this up if i were writing this as like a post-disaster late capitalism novel the editor would tell me to stop being so heavy-handed yeah it's like It would be comic if, like, my life and the lives of a lot of people I care about weren't attached to this. And the shock doctrine part definitely plays a key role in it because there was this really unpopular thing called the Business Improvement District.

Speaker 9Oh, my God.

Speaker 8Which basically are privatized mini-governments. I think y'all have talked about them in other episodes before. And Asheville– Locals put up a pretty fierce resistance to this one, and to get it through, City Hall had made some concessions, in paper at least, there would be more limits, they wouldn't use private security, things like that. And in the wake of the storm, they revoked all of that and shoved it through anyway.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 8Which, related to this, if you ever hear anyone talking in any form about something called a TIF, kill it with hammers.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8Hammers. Like, it must die immediately. You are about to get fucked. Myself and everyone else who lives downtown, which, you know, despite supposedly being this ultra-strange area, it still includes, like, a lot of elders and Section 8 housing and even some, like, you know, bits of working class housing here and there, all of us now have to pay a tax to a front group controlled by the Chamber of Commerce to basically, like, look at us weird when we walk down the street,

Speaker 8you know? So it's charging our, like, cars, among other things, you know? Yeah, like, it's one of these things when you talk about extraction, right? And a lot of that is at least slightly indirect, or it's like people are being forced out of their homes by like what are nominally market forces. But sometimes no, they're just like, Hey, yeah, we're going to use the state and you're just going to pay us all money.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 8And like, it's, it's this real sort of like robber baron in the most literal sense of like, we are using the coercive apparatus of the state to get you to hand business money. It very much is. And as a matter of fact, It's another thing they did was so City Hall, like a lot of local governments, has like various citizen boards and commissions. And these are not, you know, super fervent sites of like direct democracy or anything. They're largely, you know, older, mostly white kind of centrist

Speaker 8or even conservative leaning people. Often retirees get appointed to them. But occasionally some of these boards would say obvious things like, hey, maybe we shouldn't just build hotels everywhere. or if the cops keep like brutally kicking out every homeless person they see, we're going to get sued a lot. And that was too much. So earlier during the height of the pandemic, City Hall had previously tried dismantle all of them, just like shut them down basically entirely, replacing the few like tiny little rubber stamp commissions because it was, you know,

Speaker 8taking up too much of their time. That was the literal excuse. Jesus Christ. But after the storm, they just shut the commissions down and never reopened them.

Speaker 5Ah, shock doctrine.

Speaker 8Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, because even that occasional tepid dissent was too much for them. The first budget after the storm, and for anyone who has had the misfortune or just the necessity of having to fight local governments, the budgets were a lot of the worst stuff goes down because they can just put it all in one package.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8And no one looks at it. Not enough people do. Interestingly, folks have been pretty alert to them here since.

Speaker 5The storm, especially.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8So one, they did a massive tax hike. And while that is property tax, Obviously, landlords pass it on to renters.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And in this area specifically, there's a long history of black working class neighborhoods, especially getting highly overvalued property value wise. But then like wealthy white enclaves get highly get massively underrated. They have to pay way less tax. So this is this is, you know, pretty extractive. And I think some people would have been OK with a tax increase if it's like, OK, this is all going towards rebuilding. Like we're going to improve the infrastructure, you know, like or like get some aid for locals who are struggling. Like

Speaker 8there could have at least been a case made.

Speaker 9No, no, no.

Speaker 8It went to more cops, massive raises for city hall higher ups. The city manager of Asheville makes more than the mayor of New York City. Jesus Christ. Which, if you've heard, is a little larger than Asheville.

Speaker 4Good Lord.

Speaker 8Yeah. Now, it's not a huge amount more, but it is, you know, like $ 275, 000 before her, like, bonuses and vehicle allowance and clothing allowance kicks in. This is the person telling you do not become addicted to water.

Speaker 9Like, yeah.

Speaker 8I'm going to vote for my own pay raise. Yeah, it definitely is. Well, yeah, she draws the budget, not surprisingly. Every year, the higher-ups get massive pay hikes. So it went to that. It went to more cops. And it went to actually putting money back in the Rainy Day Fund, which you'd think after a massive storm, you're spending money from the Rainy Day Fund. But no, wealthy investors wanted to see Asheville have more money in reserve just sitting there because it made them feel more comfortable. This happens in various cities. Like Chicago famously just had a big

Speaker 8back and forth with these kind of investors in municipal bonds and pushed back against them some. Asheville didn't even try. They were like, oh, well, we just want to do their bidding in advance. When you are being out-progressive by the mayor who fucking deployed SWAT teams against an art student encampment. Like, what are we doing? Like, Jesus Christ. You know, Asheville has a highly conservative government with progressive marketing. And the kicker in that budget, too, was there was

Speaker 8like a one-time larger pay hike that some city staff got to supposedly address some of the post-Aline desperation issues.

Speaker 4Uh-huh.

Speaker 8But they excluded one major group from this, a group that has struggled for ages with some of the worst pay, like, in the region for the profession. And that's Asheville's firefighters.

Speaker 9It's just like.

Speaker 8They specifically excluded the firefighters, the heroes of Helene, who they waxed or something. And to be clear, like, nurses, firefighters, public works folks, they did do real heroic work on the ground. They did, like, repair stuff under horrible conditions, you know. The most anarchist of locals is not going to talk shit about them. If anything, it's like, why are they being paid better? But the city manager who is actually county city manager complained that people were asking for water too quickly. She literally did the do not become addicted thing in the aftermath of the storm. Jesus Christ.

Speaker 8And Asheville had had a crumbling water system for ages. We had a huge outage a few years before Helene hit just due to like disrepair. Because we have a setup that the more water a business pumps, the less they have to pay for it.

Speaker 9What?

Speaker 8Which is straight up like, yeah, it's straight up a corrupt giveaway. Even most of their places in North Carolina don't do this. They have like just a flat rate for, you know, whatever amount of water.

Speaker 5That's insane. Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8So and this was specifically meant to give like HCA, the HCA run hospital and all the big breweries that came in, all the big manufacturing. They actually had to pay less the more water they use. which meant that the system, which was already crumbling and neglected, got worse and worse and worse. Yeah, because you're incentivizing overdraw on it. That's... Yeah, it's funny. When I tell folks, even other folks who dealt with local governments, they're not good anywhere. They are corrupted evil everywhere. How bad Asheville is, I get reactions like this because it sounds like something from, like, cyberpunk fiction. Yeah,

Speaker 8this is like the shit... Unfortunately, I can't tell... Many of the stories of the city council that I grew up with, which was like a notoriously corrupt city council by the standards of Illinois governments.

Speaker 5But it's like that shit.

Speaker 8That level of we are personally, physically targeting journalists we don't like.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 5Kind of shit.

Speaker 8It's like, oh, the blades journalists as y'all covered on this for did get arrested.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 5Yeah. That's why I was like, yeah, I was like, oh, no, we've reached that.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8We've reached like city council water fuckery.

Speaker 6Like, yeah.

Speaker 5Jesus Christ.

Speaker 8Yeah, so when the pipes burst, when we had a particularly cold winter, which they didn't prepare for, you know, because cold winters are utterly unheard of in the Appalachian Mountains. What's on top of the mountain? The sun. Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 5Not anything else.

Speaker 8So a few years before Helene hit, we had this extended outage that covered, I think, like two-thirds of the city and a fair amount of the county at one point. And it occurred then the city had no water distribution plan for this kind of outage. And Helene rolls around, and they still hadn't developed a water distribution plan if there was a serious shock to the system. And in one of the first interviews she gave post, Helene, the mayor, said, well, that's not our job. That's the county's job. Now, the county did have a water supply, but they put it across the Swano River, which was even days before the storm,

Speaker 8like the National Weather Service was like, hey, we're going to have historic flooding. on this river, like start moving stuff away from it. They're just like, it'll be fine. They're like, our water supply got cut off. Why are y'all asking for water? Stop annoying us. Yeah, so that's what we've been dealing with. And there's probably some stuff I'm forgetting. Oh, a bunch of people end up homeless after Helene for obvious reasons. So one of their big priorities has not been aid for the homeless, other than like a few token amounts here or there. It was to even further criminalize people asking for food and money. Yeah,

Speaker 8the most recent, and this ties in with all this, because they already had the drone surveillance, which the FAA under Trump gave them more power to use on the public. And they have used drone surveillance just to hunt homeless people before. And so not only did they escalate camp sweeps, they also teamed up with the now not running for re-election Chuck Edwards due to even the Republican Party getting him for sexual harassment. Like, that's how bad it was. That's not good.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 8Don't worry, the Democrat, Republican running to replace him are both transphobes who support ICE. So, you know.

Speaker 9Great, great.

Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8It's quite a time here. But so he secured money for them to do the other big priority, which is to massively expand their camera and surveillance systems across the city. So that's the kind of like official city. That's the city of the gentry that we're dealing with here today. And in the propaganda they put out, like, Asheville is recovered and is welcoming back tourists, and you won't see any of the filthy poors. Why are we also having a worker shortage? And literally every dollar they can get a hold of, unless there is some sort of public backlash,

Speaker 8they are putting towards the worst possible things. And firefighters still can't afford the rent. I think a lot about a thing that people in the prison abolitionist movement say a lot, which is that it's cheaper to send someone to Harvard than it is to put them in prison.

Speaker 9It is.

Speaker 8And it's like, okay, your problem with... There are a bunch of out-of-house people, right? A lot of whom's homes were destroyed by the hurricane. You could just fix the houses and then you would have workers. But neoliberalism is a regime of extraction based on take money from literally everything else and give it to police. So that's just their, like, fuck it, we're gonna build, like, a.

Speaker 8What would you even call it? Like a multi-airspace level surveillance system instead of fixed house? There's also another element to this. It's not just the homeless. That's absolutely part of it. They are terrified of protests and dissent.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Because Asheville had a pretty powerful action in 2020. A lot of stuff continued after that. There was a major public backlash to the surveillance plan. And occasionally, when they started to dump a bunch of storm debris in a historically Black neighborhood... the neighborhood started to get very angry and militant about it. And they actually moved the debris.

Speaker 9Hell yeah.

Speaker 8You know, that's kind of the other Asheville, the one where most of us live, which is a lot of poverty and desperation, but also like, The solidarity that stems from the storm has not entirely gone away. And some of that's been more informal organizations that have continued. Some of that's been more formal ones. Swannanoa, an area that got utterly devastated by the storm, has seen a lot of community organizing that's kind of on the more formal side because the needs there are still really dire. But there's also attempts to basically bulldoze and gentrify that whole area, which is historically fairly working class.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8These are things also come to collision like twice in the past two years. Asheville police have just set up outside Banks Avenue, Lex Avenue are two areas known for like mostly multiracial crowds of like queer party goers kind of thing coming out of the bars after your last call. And just started pelting people with pepper balls.

Speaker 2Jesus Christ.

Speaker 5So and their excuse.

Speaker 8When asked about this isn't even like they don't even try to claim, oh, there was some like immediate problem going on. There was some like, you know, giant knife fight or something. They don't even bother those excuses. They're just like, oh, we've had crime in this area before.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Like over the years, there's occasionally been crime in this area. So we have a right to help anyone with chemical weapons. The police commander that honed this strategy is now the chief.

Speaker 9Oh, God.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 8Well, look, look, in order to maintain the respectability of the city, you must, in fact, use chemical weapons on the queers.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Unfortunately, one of Trotsky's two good lines is, One of them is combined uneven development, which is sort of useful, though not in the way that.

Speaker 5He used it.

Speaker 8And the second one was in the in the in the heart of every small business owner, like every petite bourgeois is is is a particle of Hitler. And this is the like the Hitler particle level is escalating.

Speaker 5We're back.

Speaker 8We're back up to chemical weapons against the queers like we got it.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8And that was the justification. And openly. they didn't even try to hide it. It was just like, oh, there's crime in that area. We felt the crowds were too rowdy and too much of a threat. Yeah, which, you know, I'm drawing Chicago examples. It's like, girl from Chicago draws examples of Chicago. But it's like, yeah, no, like, Chicago does this. Anytime there's just, like, a crowd. I mean, obviously, they beat up poor people, too. But, like, every time there's just, there's, like, a continuous, like, for, like, a decade now, I mean, probably longer than that. There's just been, like, this running panic over, like, oh, my God, a bunch

Speaker 8of black kids are, like, gather together outside.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And we're going to deploy the police against them for literally no reason. And it's just like, yeah, like you get this thing of like, oh, my God, are like subjugated underclass is gathering for like, you know, just to like hang out.

Speaker 2But fuck it. It's time.

Speaker 8It's time to like shoot them with riot munitions. There was a really telling scene. phrase that I heard, some really telling words I heard from a local when they had to move for the third time since the storm.

Speaker 5And it is.

Speaker 8We feel like we're, I feel like we're being punished for surviving. And that is like what a lot of us are grappling with. I will say. Because this is an excuse City Hall uses, and there is a grain of truth to it, but not the way they portray it. Funding has been lacking from the state and federal governments. You mentioned Katrina earlier, and as devastating a shock doctrine as that was, they did cover 75% of the various governments' costs. Now, those governments turned around and also put the funds they got towards some pretty bad purposes, which is what we're

Speaker 8seeing in Asheville too. Asheville's gotten like 17. Jesus Christ. Might be up to 20% now.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8So, like, there is a real issue with state and federal governments just not sending money here.

Speaker 5But the money they get.

Speaker 8They're putting towards things like the golf course, you know, surveillance, and a big one, rebuilding the river district exactly as it was. Oh, great.

Speaker 5Building the floodplain again.

Speaker 8This is going to go great. It's going to go great for you. Yeah, so this is... So they bought in the urban landscape, which is, for those who may not be aware, is like, the epitome of like a neoliberal gentrification planning think tank. They are as establishment as it gets. But the city brought them in to, you know, advise them on how to redevelop the city, you know, obviously prime for like, you know, more tourism and more gentrification. And even the Urban Land Institute was like, you massively overdubbed the river. That made the flooding way worse. It

Speaker 8destroyed a bunch of stuff. Your only option is to move a bunch of stuff away from the river. Like, you have to move it back. It is too flood-prone. And the city literally put out a statement at the urging, specifically of the, like, river district gentry, of just like, we're just not going to listen to this.

Speaker 5Well, and it's one of these things.

Speaker 8Where it's like, you can see in, like, five years when the next hurricane hits, because that's just the world that we're living in. Like they're going to do the same thing again. They're going to learn no lessons. And the people who are going to have to suffer for it are like people like you and people like me. It's easy to look at all this and get pretty doom and gloom. I don't want to be, that's not,

Speaker 8there's certainly a lot of like, you know, precarity and depression. I mean, I am still from just the months afterwards doing double-duty journalism and intense mutual aid stuff. And, yeah, that is somewhat continued. Like, I still have to arrange supply drops for folks occasionally who are still kind of facing, like, insecurity stuff from the long aftermath of this. But, like, there is and remains a lot of solidarity among people on the ground. And, honestly, like, to the degree that any research has been directed towards things that aren't horrible, it's been grudgingly because people got really angry at them. Yeah,

Speaker 8the state is fightable. And they will do concessions because... They're scared. The state is absolutely fightable. And ironically, I think they've weakened themselves by how openly vicious they are in this because they dropped all pretense after the storm and just went for the openly most extractive policies they could.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8But in doing so, I think for a lot of folks, they just open up their alley like these aren't your friends.

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 8This is not a legitimate place for your public decision making that occasionally makes bad decisions. They just hate you and everyone in your neighborhood.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 8Any point where they can't, you know, completely just extract money. I still feel the burnout. I'm still struggling with it. I have probably never, I don't mean just as high mode experience, just because this is incredibly common.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Among those of us who are like working class and we're on the ground in Asheville, you still haven't really had the time to like sit down and recover from the like months long burnout that we incurred from doing that because there's just still so much to fight. And we have to also pay written bills and work for a living.

Speaker 11Yep.

Speaker 8So that is a real problem. But also like, I think locals are even more willing to organize and even willing to organize outside of like governments, the nonprofit complex. Um, Ashford is one of the largest per capita nonprofit complexes in the country. Uh, well, that seems to be working great.

Speaker 5Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 8And that's the thing. Previously, they have functioned as a very effective way of, to channel dissent into official channels where it never goes anywhere and to the least effective strategies possible. But a lot, there are a handful of exceptions that did actually like, you know, credit where due, put money towards real aid that has really like benefited folks. But in general, especially the larger, more established ones, utterly failed after the storm. So the one reason they were supposed to exist was, you know, I mean, the actual reason was to repress the scent and put it into,

Speaker 8you know, like this kind of very gentrified structure. But the reason on paper this was exist was, you know, to help with exactly this kind of thing and channel philanthropic dollars.

Speaker 5And a lot of them just didn't.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Or the amounts were so minimal that they didn't really get much done.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8It's like you're being outdone by the local bookstores. Like, it's just like.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 8Yeah yeah shout out to fire yeah uh like firestorm co-op bookstore in in west ashville did a lot of great organizing uh and he's worth supporting yeah good good good people good stuff but it's also like it says something when the when like the the giant ngos with all the money are getting out organized for the bookstore yeah like it's it says like who actually cares about this stuff and who well and even among the non-profits it was like be loved which is like a liberation theology, like, you know, homeless support group and a homeless support organization. Um,

Speaker 8and then a handful of more left-leaning Presbyterian churches are the ones who've been actually like directing serious funds, like to rental aid and things like that. So like, that's kind of been, been the, the, you know, brighter spots in this as it were. And, There were weird exceptions, like, credit where due, the Register of Deeds office.

Speaker 9What?

Speaker 8Yeah, like, organized a substantial amount of, like, coordination for, like, flush brigades and stuff like that. It was famously, like, one of the only government offices to actually put resources and attention into, like, meeting some of the needs of the public. Yeah, I mean, I guess it is that, like, occasionally you get these situations where it's, like... I have a friend who says this about, like, sometimes you get managers in union shops like this where it's like they're, like, a worker who had a bad idea. So they got into management, but they're not, like, shitty people and will, like, sometimes help you with stuff. And sometimes with this, it's like, yeah.

Speaker 8And I guess this is true of, like, you know, this is, like, part of how the state as an institution functions. But, like, yeah, every once in a while, you do get someone... In a like, you know, kind of random bureaucratic position who is like a good, normal person and has not had their soul like devoured by the maw of capital.

Speaker 5And it's just like, oh, yeah, fuck it. I don't know. I wrote the.

Speaker 2Office of Deeds.

Speaker 8Like, fuck it. I work in the Office of Deeds. We're going to go help people.

Speaker 2And it's like, yeah.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 8But it's interesting because it's kind of the exception that proves the rule.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 9Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 5Because, like, the rest of the thing could be doing the soup, but they're not.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8They have way more resources. Yeah. But the stuff they gave was generally grudging and was outdone, like, by other stuff. For example, like, okay, well, we're going to eventually set up water stations and, you know, food supplies. Oh, but also your eviction case is going forward.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8You know? One reason I wrote, I think I mentioned earlier, I wrote the piece was just because Focus kind of went away from Asheville after Helene. Like, it tends to in disaster areas. Yeah. But we're still in crisis. It still feels like we're digging our way out of the rubble. And that's literal in some cases. You will turn off a less public road and still just see a line of destroyed houses. Less so than you would have a year, even a year and a half, definitely a year and a half ago. But they're definitely still there. There's one I see while driving, eat groceries occasionally. So that's literally

Speaker 8still happening in some places. But because of how badly both the storm itself and its aftermath been handled and all the prioritization of just like extracting as much money from locals as possible and restoring this already highly unsteady my capitalism standards like tourist city previous status quo.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 8It's still very much present. Like Asheville is still defined by Helene in a lot of ways. And what does give me hope is the number of people who know each other, know their neighbors, can kind of work together on stuff. We've seen more tennis union stuff since the storm.

Speaker 9Hell yeah.

Speaker 8You know, we've seen more labor organizing since the storm. And honestly, like, and I say this for the efforts I'm involved in as well as all of others, like, we had some really good mutual aid stuff before, which is one reason, like, the networks didn't come from nowhere. Some of those people were, and they were just, like, cobbling stuff together in the ground. But a lot of cases, they did grow out of folks who were already engaged in some form of that work in Asheville beforehand. But I definitely say, like, we've all kind of leveled up some because we have a much clearer idea of what does and doesn't go down, you know, when a storm

Speaker 8hits and what areas are more vulnerable. And it was interesting because despite all the money they're pouring the police department, all the surveillance, the new police chief, like the like two or three before her, is still complaining they can't find enough cops. Even though I mentioned the first budget they passed, the second one last year, which was a lot more contested and like only passed by a single vote. They cut more services like community center hours and much of, you know, things like that. They also still gave the

Speaker 8city manager another massive raise.

Speaker 4Jesus Christ.

Speaker 8But they were like, oh, we're in a $ 30 million budget crunch. But if you look at the actual numbers, a lot of that was they tried to hire 24 more cops. Yeah, and it's just like every single city government is like, oh no, my budget's unbalanced. And you look at it, it's like 60% police. And it's like, hey, what if we paid less? What if we had less of the guys whose jobs it is to intermittently switch between standing around playing Candy Crush and beating up queer people?

Speaker 5We can do this.

Speaker 8I believe in us. Yeah, it's that is it's for about 20 years escalating more in the past decade or so. That's literally been kind of the, you know, where the budget and the increases from it always go. And Asheville's not alone in this, but it raises to higher ups, more cops, more surveillance, more policing of various sorts.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8And then, you know, maybe some consultants, tourism friendly stuff. You know, I don't know, putting money back in an account where you normally spend it from because the gentry want it. Another interesting example, and God, I feel like I'm just kind of going by like, but these all form a picture together.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Biltmore Village, which is notoriously this hyper-expensive tourist trap area, but built in the floodplain, got basically annihilated during the storm. Uh-huh. And... When, unlike the folks from the, you know, the retired educators were like, hey, we're close about to collapse. And the city was like, well, you know, if it collapses, whatever. The more village folks went and went, hey, our businesses aren't making profits anymore. You should subsidize us. You should buy stuff from us so we can make money again. And it's not clear exactly how that's, how that's sorted out.

Speaker 8Because getting records from City of Ash is like pulling teeth. But the response from the dais was, oh yeah, we'll get right on that.

Speaker 5Jesus Christ.

Speaker 8Like, Yeah, I think sometimes because they have less PR and less polish, local governments are much more open about exactly what they're there for. There's less pretense about, yeah, we're here to do the bidding of the wealthy and the rest of y'all are not just kind of expendable, but actively despised for wanting anything else. It's pretty illuminating, but, like, Asheville is, for one disaster or another, with both, you know, this is where government's head really happens. I think we're

Speaker 8just kind of ahead of the curve here because of just, like, how openly, comically, almost evil the gentry are in Asheville.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8But, you know, some sort of disaster, whether it's wildfires... you know, hurricanes, flooding of some sort, what have you. It's coming to a down near you if it hasn't already. And when the chips are down, the government's probably not going to react that dissimilarly.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8So I do hope folks learn from that, but also from... The power is, in fact, in your hands, like you and your neighbors can immediately organize and start responding to things. And often you can do a way more effective job than the people whose job that supposedly is, than your local government. Yeah, they can be fought and they can be replaced. Yeah, exactly. And not replaced like the ways we're told they can be replaced, like the ballot box, because there is a crop of candidates running to replace the current city council. they all have exactly the same

Speaker 8views as the current city council. One of them thinks they should put even more attention and resources into reconstructing the river district exactly as it was before the storm.

Speaker 9Jesus Christ. Yeah.

Speaker 8That's what passes for, like, dissent among, like, the ranks of political candidates. Yeah, no, but replacing the sense of... I'm constantly haunted by this question from an anthropologist at the beginning of what ends up being a quite good book about the Zapatistas.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8That I'll link in the description. But she goes in, and one of the things about the Zapatistas is that they refuse to take money from the Mexican government, which they call the bad government, because it is a systemic organization of death squads that murders indigenous people and steals their land in order to build their fucking megaprojects on it. And this anthropologist comes in. This is something I've seen a lot in a specific kind of like a specific kind of like nominal leftist resistance to neoliberalism where they

Speaker 8see someone like, you know, like literally building their own infrastructure, right? In the way the Zapatistas did where, you know, like they, okay. So like they've built their own self-governing communes and they refuse to, and they provide their own services and refuse to use the services of, of the like, you know, of the like hideously corrupt murder state. And the anthropologist goes in and, like, starts asking Zapatistas, like, is that neoliberalism? Because you're replacing the goods of the state. And every single person looks at her and is like, what the fuck are you talking about? Yeah, seriously. Like, literally, what

Speaker 8are you talking about? Like, you know, and this is also, like, running, I don't know, like, there's so many angles you can comment this from, from the perspective of, like, it is, in fact, extremely different when, like, workers and indigenous people and you know all all of the people who would be like put together into the category of the wretched of the earth come together and do things outside of the state and do do the original version of of the sort of democratic like procurement of like aid for

Speaker 8the community and do the things that the state absorbed specifically as a counterinsurgency thing People then see that, like doing the original socialism as like neoliberalism because you're doing it outside the state and you're doing it instead of the state-sponsored ones that are designed to capture you in the upper half of the state. And they see that and they go, oh, you're doing neoliberalism. And like, no, no, no, no, no, no. Well, it's not corporate in nature. It's not capitalist in nature. Yeah. And this is a good point because... there's things, you know,

Speaker 8like police, for example, upper level managers that can be dismissed with entirely. But there's a reason the anarchists don't go abolish the fire department.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8Abolish the libraries. Those are things that governments generally just kind of took over and glommed onto.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And folded under. But like, People want to do those things.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And that's the thing where it's like all of the work in the world is done by workers.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8The postaline stuff is an example I point to and folks go, well, how would anarchism work? I'm like that.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8Like that. You know, basically that like it worked far better for those of us in the ground than the pittance in like resources and aid for a long time that we were getting from local state and federal governments.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 8And, you know, and this is not to be, like, too much to just send it to, like, quote-unquote prepper territory, but preparation is highly important. I encourage folks who are VR, like, think about where your water comes from. Think about where your food comes from. Think about putting some reserves of that aside. Unlike certain governments, you should probably have, like, different locations among different folks because some folks get cut off by, like, fallen trees or whatever.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 8Wherever you are, I guarantee there is some form of a Helene-like disaster you're probably going to face at some point. Yeah. And it's good to start thinking of what that is, preparing for it with some folks you trust now. And a little bit of that can go a very long way. And this has real practical impacts. When Asheville was faced with some torrential rains recently, which brings a lot of trauma for a bunch of us.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8But I realized other than like charging a few backup batteries and, you know, stuff for devices, I didn't really have to do anything. Yeah, I actually had it already. I already had the preparation stuff in place. So I just focused like checking on some of my neighbors and helping folks out, which was a really good feeling. And that was like a legacy of the organizing after Helene.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8I think like, you know, like one of the fundamental conflicts here, other than just sort of the general class war that's been happening in Helene is like, Which of these two visions of a post-disaster society is going to take root? Is it going to be the one where the shock doctrine sends cops with riot batons and crowd control munitions to just beat the shit out of people? Or is it going to be the one where you bring your people food?

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And honestly, this is why I keep coming back. to We Are Two Cities. Which one do you want?

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 8Eventually, it's going to be one or the other.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And that doesn't just apply in Ashford. Yeah, that is the stark choice of the world that is to come.

Speaker 6Indeed.

Speaker 8I kind of feel like this should be a dispatch from a place where it already happened to some degree.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 8Yeah. But also like it shows that there's a world after that, too, that it's not all hopeless.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And interestingly, like recently, though, they're still trying to up the Axon contract. City Hall went back against the wishes of the police department and canceled the flock contract. Now they still want to keep a door open to resume it. You know, there's a lot of weasel stuff on it. But they didn't want to do that themselves.

Speaker 5Yeah, they're scared.

Speaker 8They only did it because they were terrified of how many people are getting mobilized.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8Often through networks that got kind of cemented during Helene. They'd be just getting to know each other. Against the surveillance state in Asheville because, like, flock cameras were starting to get vandalized.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8And so even despite their intense evil... They're still weak. They're still vulnerable. And if that's what they concede to what we're going right now, like what would happen if that escalated even further, if the public outrage and mobilization escalated even more on even more fronts?

Speaker 9Yeah. So, yeah.

Speaker 8Well, David, thank you. Thank you so much for coming on the show and talking about this. Do you have anything else that you want to say before we go to plugs? You know, prepare, get to know some people around you. I think people should realize that they're stronger than they know. Where are the many places people can find your great work? So they can find the work of the Asheville Blade, which is our local journalism co-op, at ashevilleblade.com, and some of our shorter, quick-hit coverage at patreon.com slash avlblade. If they want to read me ranting

Speaker 8in similar veins about, and a lot of other great trans journalists as well, about kind of trans-specific stuff on a national, even international level, transnewsnetwork at transnews.network.

Speaker 9So, yeah, all that.

Speaker 8And I do think it's somewhat inspiring. There are like more on the ground co-op media and a lot of us being done by trans people. So, hell yeah. And you too can support trans journalism. You can become a trans journalist. It's never too late for either part, whether you want to become a journalist or transition, you know?

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 8If you're asking the question, the answer is yes.

Speaker 3Yes.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 12Paramount Pictures, CNN, CBS, HBO, Discovery, Warner Bros., even reality TV darling HGTV, and many more are now under one roof run by billionaire fail-son David Ellison, the child of Larry Ellison, the CEO of the tech firm Oracle. I'm Kevin Foster, this is It Could Happen Here, and today we're talking about the largest antitrust lawsuit and debacle in recent memory, the Paramount-Warner Bros.

Speaker 9Merger.

Speaker 12This episode involves a couple of interviews I did and goes in a few different directions, from the consequences of the merger on labor, press freedom, and archival history, as well as some of the surrounding antitrust law. But before that, let's do a quick rundown of what happened. On October 6th, 2026, the Paramount Skydance Corporation, which was its own antitrust mess, acquired Warner Bros. for $ 110 billion, forming a new company called Skydance Corporation. Per the Skydance press release on the acquisition,

Speaker 12they are combining entertainment giants into a quote, single creative powerhouse. Before the deal went through, however, there were many legal challenges because this is one of the largest media consolidations in history. A coalition of 12 states sued to block Paramount's takeover with California's Attorney General Rob Bonta at the helm. Bonta said at a press conference, quote, Just a few months later, though, Bonta conceded, settling the lawsuit for limited promises. Per Reuters, Skydance pledged to release 156 films over five years, or about 30 films per year. which would be an

Speaker 12increase from the combined total of the formerly separate entities. However, Paramount will have discretion over production spending, albeit with a few limitations, which has led analysts to say the terms of the settlement do not address the structural issues that raised antitrust concerns. One of the obvious concerns is that this is only a five-year agreement. Who knows what they do after that? Skydance already plans to cut $ 6 billion within three years, which could easily have ripple effects on theaters and entertainment industry workers at a time when the

Speaker 12industry is already struggling. To talk about that struggle, I interviewed Jake Hart, a screenwriter who had been organizing protests against the merger for months.

Speaker 13I've been a Writers Guild East member since 2003. My dad's a screenwriter, my sister's a screenwriter. I feel like I've, for pretty much my entire life, either been getting ready to go on strike, on strike, or recovering from a strike. The studio system, they've been trying to crush the unions since we formed the unions. The fight, it's the exact same fight. It's just who's the face of the bad guys today and how big can the merger get? Like the Skydance Paramount merger last year seemed like as terrifying

Speaker 13as it could get sort of in the current political landscape. I mean, that's the thing about these mergers is the ripple effect, the snowball effect. We know what it is generally. We call this an industry town for a reason. When the unions suffer, small businesses and restaurants suffer. And it's the union members who, as always, the working class, the industry, who get hit with the brunt of this speaking as a writer. That's always been hard. I've, you know, half my life I've been competing with a lot of people for a very small amount of opportunities.

Speaker 4And, you know, we go on strike.

Speaker 13And we get these meager victories that we celebrate because the unions will never be able to outlast the studios.

Speaker 5We consider them.

Speaker 13Wins and then we keep going and we know we're going to have to strike again to ask for more pennies on the dollar. And I will just say after the SAG WGA strikes 2023, which were, you know, again, successful, quote unquote, the studios just said, you know what?

Speaker 5We're going to hire.

Speaker 13Fewer of you, so fewer of you get to enjoy those mega victories you're celebrating. Production dropped. The amount of writers' rooms dropped. The amount of shows that were being bought dropped. So even when we think we're doing well, they're going to find ways to make sure that we don't think that for long. And this is only going to make that worse. The media consolidation always leads to fewer opportunities. Wages go down as prices go up. And the worst, I mean, sort of as far as social impact, it's

Speaker 13also undeniable that the diversity of voices in media goes down. The government can't keep up with corporations as far as throwing money at legal cases like this.

Speaker 9They can't.

Speaker 5It's small business and big business.

Speaker 13It's just government and corporations.

Speaker 5They know they can't compete.

Speaker 9We know that.

Speaker 13Rob Bonta was talking tough in a way that we all believed. And I don't envy him for having to be in those rooms negotiating with these monsters.

Speaker 5But ultimately, it.

Speaker 13Seems like they got scared by, well, we're going to move Paramount out of the state. And they're like, well, that's going to kill a lot of jobs. And you say, well, it's already going to kill a lot of jobs. So why bend a knee to that shit?

Speaker 12California Governor Gavin Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass seem to have played a role in the settlement, encouraging it for weeks, according to Politico. A major sticking point was Paramount threatening to leave California. All of that said, the entertainment industry is not the only thing at risk here. Trump has close ties to the Ellisons and praised the merger, saying, quote, they're terrific people and it's going to be a great company, unquote. Many are concerned about editorial independence at CNN and CBS,

Speaker 12especially after David Ellison appointed Barry Weiss as CBS's editor-in-chief, leading to massive editorial scandals, such as the polling of the 60 Minutes episode on Seacott, the maximum security prison notorious for torture and human rights violations in El Salvador, where the Trump administration sent over 280 immigrants. Now with CNN as well, Ellison controls the largest TV news organization on the planet. To discuss the merger and its impacts on the press, I spoke with Adam Rose, the Deputy

Speaker 12Director of Advocacy for Freedom of the Press Foundation. This interview will span pretty much the rest of the episode, but before that, here's some ads. I just want to start broad. You know, what does this merger and maybe even the previous merger mean for press freedom in the United States?

Speaker 1Well, there's a really easy way to think about the litmus test of who has resources to put into major journalism. And it's not the merger itself. It's the White House press ban. Trump recently banned MSNOW, CNN, and Politico from the White House, lost that in court in terms of the hard passes, but he's still been able to exclude CNN from the pool. Well, the pool, when we talk about that, it means that there's only so much space. If you've got someone on Air Force One or the Oval Office, you can't fit 1,000 people from the White House press corps. And so there'll be one or two

Speaker 1main lead TV cameras and the lead TV networks that do this rotation and document the president who help us understand, is he falling asleep at his desk in the middle of meeting with international dignitaries, right? I mean, important stuff about the fitness of the president to serve. When he kept CNN out, as is continuing to happen, That's 20% of the pool. One out of the five major TV cameras not able to cover the president on certain days because they're sharing and rotating through these positions. And the other ones as part of a solidarity movement are not willing to backfill. So that's 20% of the White House

Speaker 1TV pool gone. Well, now 40% is owned by David Ellison because he owns CNN now and he owned CBS before. So that leaves ABC, NBC, and Fox. And say what you will about any of those, anything is possible, but it's corporate consolidation at its worst. So 40% of the White House TV pool now is under the control of David Ellison. Think about major historical events, the assassination of JFK. What would our collective memory look like if we didn't

Speaker 1have film from that? Who knows what the next major event like that will be? We can think about George W. Bush on 9-11 and being informed at a school of what was happening in Those are images we still see circulating on the internet all the time. Well, that was captured because of the pool. And what might not be captured either if the pool isn't there or if someone who wants to be favorable to a certain administration decides that they're going to curry that favor by withholding information. That would be a profound violation of trust that this

Speaker 1pool has established amongst itself. But when you have fewer and fewer members of that pool and fewer and fewer corporate entities controlling them, it's a lot easier to manipulate and control narratives. So that is profoundly concerning to me.

Speaker 12Yeah, and I think there's this serious issue of the Ellisons being aligned with the Trump administration on many different things. And, you know, it's going to be sort of complicated to see what happens with CNN in the coming months as, you know, they're taken over there and what the dynamic is and how it changes with the Trump administration. But, you know, it's not necessarily... directly state media. But at a certain point, it's like, OK, if your corporate oligarchs are working with the Trump administration, they have aligned interests.

Speaker 12There's maybe some level of quid pro quo there. You know, we can't necessarily say for certain, but it's certainly the.

Speaker 4Vibe at times.

Speaker 12And it erodes faith in the media and creates a worse situation for all of us. And I think you mentioned earlier about archiving and the issue there. And I have a buddy that I'll talk to about, you know, journalism is like archiving history in real time in a way. And I think, you know, losing those cameras, like this is a longer term consequence than just, oh, CNN is not going to be the same anymore. It's like this actually, you know, this consolidation has the ability to change how

Speaker 12history is represented. And yeah, I mean, I guess, On that note of archiving, what do you feel like people aren't talking about enough around this merger?

Speaker 1There is an incredibly powerful line from George Orwell in 1984, which is, who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past. And there are variations of that, including by Rage Against the Machine, that have been put even more eloquently, including who controls the present now. being added to that. Our history, our collective memory influences a lot about who we are and where we're going.

Speaker 1There are only so many news archives out there. One of the few organizations that has the institutional focus to really bring up these issues over and over is a wonderful group called the Archival Producers Alliance. They have been bringing attention to this for The last several months in particular around this merger and the idea that fewer and fewer corporate oligarchs will control access to those archives and can dictate where and when different things appear. They had noted that one of the archives recently had laid off

Speaker 1its entire licensing department. So when you're putting together a documentary or a news story, whatever it may be, you could go there and you could ask them for some footage that they might own the rights to and you cannot get otherwise. But no one was going to be there to pick up the phone. In other cases, there was an archive in the last couple of years where they had, at one point, it was one of the major networks, had said that they would only license their material to themselves effectively. And that drew a major outcry. And archives are not in great shape institutionally, financially. Wonderful

Speaker 1people working there trying to preserve our history, but the resources are pretty thin. And Even just in the last few days, Getty was taken private. It will now be controlled by the Getty family and the Koch family, which if you think about the Kochs and the Ellisons all teaming up to control all of our archives, well, who controls the past controls the future.

Speaker 9Oh, God.

Speaker 1And that should be really concerning to all of us. You think about where conspiracy theories come from and what can launch them or stamp them out. Well, a lot of that's our archives. And to rewrite history and ideas like, hey, what about reparations? What about the way that our country has mistreated certain groups over the course of many, many generations? Well, we have historical footage of people trying to integrate schools and things like that, which show how difficult it was. We have oral history and testimonies in particular. And this

Speaker 1is a space I've worked in before in preserving a Holocaust testimony, for example. And so whatever anyone's modern-day politics might be with the Middle East, there's certainly no denying the Holocaust, you'd hope. But the reality is, of course, that some people do, right? Ahmadinejad, when he was running Iran, said, yeah, the Holocaust is basically a conspiracy theory, right? Well, how do we never forget if we don't have the people in their video testimonies to remind us of why certain things mattered so much? And so when there's a vow

Speaker 1for never again, as there was with the Holocaust... And as some would very, I think, well articulate that maybe we are seeing something happening again in Gaza that is profoundly tragic and ironic. It's important that these survivors who are no longer with us still be able to tell their stories through what we have captured on film. And that is really terrifying to me that as a community, in any sense, we would lose our history. we can't hold on to everything from history, but we need to

Speaker 1hold on to the most important parts. And it's hard to imagine who would control more of television history than a combination of CBS and CNN, not to mention Warner Brothers, not to mention Paramount Films, not to mention so much of Hollywood history. And Think about now when you're just trying to surf online and figure out what to watch off of Netflix or Amazon or whatever subscription service you may have. And you can be really frustrated trying to

Speaker 1find certain older films where you're like, how does no one have this online? Well, what if they decided suddenly to take whole chunks of film away from our collective memory?

Speaker 5They can't.

Speaker 1And they have the rights and the lawyers to enforce that.

Speaker 12This is bleak, man.

Speaker 9I mean.

Speaker 12This is going to be kind of a stupid question, I feel like. But is this even legal? Like, what should have happened? I know you said you're not a lawyer, but. Yeah, there's a lot to unpack there. And many of us would argue that it is not legal. And many, in fact, of the best attorneys in this country have said that this particular merger is not legal because of antitrust laws. Let me pause on that really quickly just to touch on a couple more historical notes I think are important as we talk about this context and the bleakness of it, because I don't want that to go.

Speaker 1Unremarked upon, because I think you're right. It is extraordinarily bleak. I would not say that I am hopeless. I think that there is an amazing community out there and an amazingly globally aware community, especially as the internet provides So many capabilities for people to connect, for the ability for people to record with their own phone in their pockets and share that around the world. And it doesn't, I'm not being Pollyanna about it either. I'm just saying two things can be true at the same time. It can simultaneously be bleak and I can simultaneously have hope. So I hope people hold on to that.

Speaker 12I don't know how all this works exactly, but when the AI bubble pops, we're going to have a lot of capacity to store data.

Speaker 5Plenty of data centers, right?

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 10Yep.

Speaker 1And they'll all be cooled off as we are heating. But I also wanted to really underscore something you brought up about fascism and the historical implications here. Our technologies have evolved a lot since the 1930s, of course. But I mentioned before that I've been involved in archival projects of Holocaust testimony and really an amazing organization called the USC Shoah Foundation, which is based here where I am in Southern California. And they've collected tens of thousands of testimonials from not only Holocaust survivors, but genocides and atrocities

Speaker 1around the globe.

Speaker 5Guatemala, Rohingya, all kinds. And they're trying to preserve.

Speaker 1That history and doing a fantastic job of it. And I went into those archives and I had some staff access. So I was able to kind of poke around at one point and get a sense of the technologies that were discussed by Holocaust survivors in the 1930s. And what was striking to me is how in watching, you know, maybe a couple dozen of these survivors, that they would describe the day that the Nazis came in or came to power or, stormed in with their tanks. And every

Speaker 1single one of them who talked about what was taken from them, the first thing they mentioned was that the Nazis came in, and if you were Jewish, they took your radio. And if they found you with a radio and you didn't give it up by the deadline, they shot you and killed you on the spot. they mentioned the radios. They go, oh yeah, and by the way, they also took all our diamonds and our jewels and our furs and our expensive things. But the very first thing, 100% of these survivors, the very first thing that they remember

Speaker 1and that they talk about being taken from them were the radios. Because the radios were how they were hearing what was actually happening. Because radio signals can travel a long way. So they weren't just getting Nazi propaganda. They were hearing from resistance movements. They were hearing from other countries. They were hearing a more global perspective. And so control over the media ecosystem is literally day one, page one of the Nazi playbook. Now, I'm not saying that's exactly what's happening here, but I'm saying you need to pay attention to this because of how significant... knowledge and information is.

Speaker 1At that same time, now that we talk about all these different people having the ability to film and record from their own pockets, I always think about George Floyd and his murder being captured by a young lady, Darnella Frazier, who was given a Pulitzer Prize. She's not a journalist, right? But she was given a special citation by the Pulitzer Committee. because she committed a sacred act of journalism. And, you know, the initial narrative that came out from his murder was a press release by the local police department saying the man died from a drug overdose. It was Darnella's video

Speaker 1that she took of the murder that proved otherwise. And bring that all the way to today where we think about these protests that are going on out in the street where, you know, often the narrative is, oh, a protester tried to hit us with a car or protesters were being violent. And the video shows regularly disproves the federal DHS narrative that they try and spread about violence against them. And what's really twisted, what's really downright Orwellian is I have sat in courtrooms where I've worked on

Speaker 1cases where we got federal injunctions against DHS and LAPD and different agencies to stop their violence against journalists and protesters alike. And I have sat there as these lawyers for DHS have tried to, it was then Kristi Noem was the head of DHS, have tried to bring forth her argument into the courtroom that filming their officers is violence.

Speaker 11Yep.

Speaker 5I've talked about that a good bit.

Speaker 1It's pure doublespeak, man. Really, really disgusting stuff. And I'm sitting there going, how do these guys sleep at night?

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 5I mean, that's just gross stuff.

Speaker 1So, you know, we can shift back into the idea of legality of this merger.

Speaker 5But, you know, that you.

Speaker 1Just cannot understate the significance of control of information and freedom of information and what they mean in a democratic society. So I always like to preface this.

Speaker 5I'm not a lawyer.

Speaker 1I am often the guy that lawyers call when they need help for sorting this out and figuring out how rubber hits pavement here in the real world. And so I sort of serve as an interpreter between legalese and the street journalism that's happening out there. So when it comes to the particular merger that we're talking about with Paramount and Warner Brothers Discovery, there are what they would call different markets in antitrust law. And so antitrust lawyers who have looked at this said, wait a minute, this would create an unfair amount of competition in these particular markets.

Speaker 1And again, they identified multiple different ones. And I'm forgetting off the top of my head, but it could be stuff like broadcast, could be stuff like movie production. It could be different things like that. News, certainly an obvious concern here. But from a legal standpoint, they identified a number of these different markets. And so at the time that this was being proposed and was not a done deal yet, there were a number of different people who filed suits for any number of different reasons.

Speaker 8For example.

Speaker 1there was a consumer lawsuit that was filed saying that this would drive up prices for consumers of streaming and movie media of all types. And so that one didn't win in the end. Unions filed lawsuits saying that it would be something that we would call monopsony. Many of us know the word monopoly, but there's also an important term here called monopsony, which is when you're trying to sell something and you've only got one buyer out there. And so the market is constricted. So whether you're selling your talent as an actor or a writer or whatever it may be, you know, producer, Or let's say you put together a whole film and you're selling that film.

Speaker 1There's fewer distributors to take it. So there are those kinds of markets as well. There are also shareholder concerns here that this was not in the best interest of shareholders. And so, in fact, my organization, Freedom of the Press Foundation, was behind a shareholder lawsuit with that first merger that happened. The big one, though, the big lawsuit here was the one that was led by California Attorney General Rob Bonta. And he was one of a dozen state attorneys general who teamed up to fight the merger and to try

Speaker 1and take a stand identifying, I think it was three discrete specific markets that were potentially antitrust violations. Now, normally, in a more functional United States of America, this is the kind of investigation that would be handled by the federal government. And indeed, the reports were pretty widely spread that the U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division had started to prepare an investigation into and that the career lawyers were planning on recommending that it become an official, not only investigation, but lawsuit. Those are career lawyers. They have a job to do. They're very good at it, and

Speaker 1they know what they're doing. Political appointees, chosen, of course, by Donald Trump, then got involved and unconditionally approved the merger at a federal level. So that left it to the states. But now let's think about what it costs to do an anti-merger investigation. there are obviously the lawyers, there are the court fees, there are the expert witnesses who, as I understand it, are very expensive. I have heard from people who are far more knowledgeable than me that it can cost for a major federal antitrust investigation up

Speaker 1to $ 40 million. Now, $ 40 million is the drop in the bucket for our federal government when you think about it in the grand scheme of things. If you think about Connecticut, Rhode Island, Maryland, that's doing some real damage to a budget. So when these 12 states came together and all these attorneys general came together, I mean, look, $ 40 million is a lot for California, right? And that's the fourth largest economy in the world. But with California's resources behind it, they had a fighting chance. And obviously

Speaker 1other states would chip in as well. And you got a dozen states kicking in time and money. And it was wonderful, right? And it was really, really heartening to see. Eventually, as this case dragged on, I don't know that it was necessarily resolved in a way that was legal. What we do know is that Rob Bonta in California backed out under a lot of political pressure. And when they backed out, other state attorneys general spoke out and said, well, there's certain things that we're really unhappy with in this. But they wound up, every single one of them signed the piece of paper saying they would agree to what's

Speaker 1called a consent agreement. So the deal went through. And in the media afterward, those state attorneys general would say, oh, we wish they'd done this. We wanted it to be this.

Speaker 5But you know what?

Speaker 1I don't think, you know, Connecticut or wherever the heck it was, they don't have 40 million bucks to throw into an antitrust investigation. So that's really what happened here. You know, the law exists in two very different places. You know, it exists in the courtroom and it exists in the street. And these are not equal places. So in the street, the billionaires won.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 1And they were going to be able to spend indefinitely. When you think about what I mentioned before with the DOJ putting their finger on the scale here with the earlier merger as well, when this is the one where Trump was effectively, I mean, this is an accusation that would have to be proven if there were a way to legally prove it, but it sure as heck felt like a bribe when he was paid off in terms of the 60 Minutes story. This is part of CBS then rolling into Paramount in the first go around with these mergers. And when that happened, That money was paid first, technically,

Speaker 1to his library, of course. But, you know, it's all kind of wink-wink. And so big check gets cut to Donald Trump in his personal civil life. And then all of a sudden, the deal is approved in the federal government, which he controls. And so our problem, from Freeman Press Foundation's point of view, is not that there's private ownership in media.

Speaker 9Because guess what?

Speaker 1There's always been that. Literally since day one of this country, right? Ben Franklin owned the Pennsylvania Gazette. We're not upset about that. Thomas Paine wrote his own pamphlets. It was basically privately done. That's cool, right? No problems with private ownership of some media. And the problem becomes when it's the government and political power picking and choosing winners. And the problem also becomes when there's so much consolidation that it is harmful for our information ecosystem. And I think that's exactly what we're seeing. So whatever the lawyers might argue, and there's a lot

Speaker 1there that I described on a high level that can be argued. The end result and the impact for all of us is that it is damaging to our collective knowledge. It is damaging to an informed public, an informed electorate, and therefore damaging to a functioning democracy. So yeah, that's a little bleak. And I don't think it's legal, but the law wasn't what prevailed here.

Speaker 8It was the billions.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 12Something that I talked about in my other interview was just the sort of depressing reality around it. Like, OK, maybe we would have lost these things in the lawsuit or they were threatening this and taking Paramount out of California. And there was this backward pressure in that way. But it's now with the consolidation, it's like, OK, we're going to lose jobs now. Either way, it's not a bluff anymore. 4,500 expected just in Los Angeles.

Speaker 10God.

Speaker 12It's just it's like, OK, we've now signed the check for our fate on that. And it's who knows what would have happened. But I mean, I think about the concessions, the quote unquote concessions that we got in this settlement. I think one of the ones I want to talk about a little bit is, you know, there's this idea of an independent oversight board for CNN and CBS. My understanding is that That board can essentially be selected by like executives and the Ellisons. I don't know if that's exact. I was reading like a Hollywood reporter article on this.

Speaker 5You're 100 percent right.

Speaker 12If you want to dive into that a little bit more and how bullshit I think that could be helpful for people.

Speaker 1And that is actually I'm not a lawyer, but I think bullshit is the legal term for this whole thing. And actually, I've heard a number of lawyers use that term about this deal. So actually from a real legal perspective, what has been explained to me by some of the best antitrust lawyers in the country is that when there is an antitrust investigation, typically they do settle, right? Typically it doesn't go to court. And what they do is they extract different kinds of remedies. That's the term for it. And these remedies tend to take one of two different forms. There's what they call behavioral remedies and what they call

Speaker 1structural remedies. So behavioral remedy is an example that came from the settlement is Paramount commits to producing 30 films a year. or this combined company, whatever it is. So take our word for it. We're going to do this.

Speaker 5Trust us.

Speaker 10Wink, wink.

Speaker 5We're going to be good.

Speaker 1A structural remedy is something that actually has some teeth and forces real change. Like you have to sell CNN before you can complete the merger, right? And that would protect the independence of one of those five major TV pool networks.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1So when this was initially being fought over very publicly with Rob Bonta and everyone else, Rob Bonta was explicit that he would not allow this deal to go through without structural remedies. Lo and behold, they settled for only behavioral remedies.

Speaker 5Oh, God damn it.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 12I didn't know that.

Speaker 1One of those behavioral remedies being an independent editorial oversight board or whatever the exact terminology was, which is sort of meaningless anyway.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 5Let me tell you how absurd this is.

Speaker 1I understand that everyone's welcome to their own opinion and there is no such thing as a view from nowhere and many people in many newsrooms are members of a political party or whatnot. But it shows what a warped perspective it is that when they put together this board, some of the only requirements were things like, oh, well, two of the members have to be from the Republicans and two of the members have to be from the Democrats. Why does party matter? That's never supposed to be a thing in the first.

Speaker 8Place, right?

Speaker 1Nonpartisanship is supposed to be the way this goes. So to anyone who's an actual journalist, that just immediately blew our heads. The thing that you said, though, really striking is, okay, well, who gets to appoint that editorial board? Well, it's the controlling interest of Skydance. Who is the controlling interest of Skydance? It's David Ellison, right? So he gets to handpick whoever the heck he wants. Now let's say that they aren't doing their job, right? And their job is whatever he wants it to be. But then who's going to enforce it if they're not actually doing a good job in

Speaker 1a vacuum, right? Let's say we actually had some faith in them, which no one really does.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, then the only one who can enforce this, at least for a few years, would be the state attorneys general who are political creatures, right?

Speaker 5So I don't care.

Speaker 1Again, it shouldn't matter what partisanship is involved here, but that means in California, most likely it's going to be a Democrat. I don't want a Democrat or a Republican to be the one deciding what editorial independence looks like for CNN and now CBS as well. They actually made this worse because CBS didn't have an editorial oversight board before this. But not that things were going well at CBS, given Barry Weiss and given the quote-unquote ombudsperson who they hired, who's just a Republican Party operative who actually appears to have done nothing since the day he was hired. It's just sort of a farce to have this sort of

Speaker 1a board. So when we see these sorts of so-called behavioral remedies, we don't have much hope that it's going to do anything. Another thing to flag in this deal as part of this consent decree that it was, you know, the final agreement to make it go through is they have something called force majeure, which I'm probably mispronouncing. My French is terrible. But it means a major force, an act of God, something that makes this unenforceable because you couldn't have predicted it, right? You know, a nuclear war

Speaker 1is the kind of thing you think about with a rental car agreement. Sorry, I couldn't return my rental car. There was a nuclear war, right? Okay, a very reasonable thing. So they included a force majeure clause in this consent decree with things that were like economic downturn, labor unrest, right? You can look through it. I don't have the language in front of me, but it was like trivial to trigger this clause, at which point they don't have to produce 30 films a year. They don't have to have an editorial oversight. They can throw everything out. But, you know,

Speaker 1there is no real legal concept as force majeure. But that's kind of what it is, or horse manure, as it more feels like. But that is actually in, you know, you can ask a lawyer, and I've had lawyers who are part of fighting this who've looked at it and just were pulling their hair out, saying none of this agreement is even enforceable and binding on Skydance because they're just going to say, oh, yeah, the economy is not good. And then all of a sudden, because that's not defined in any of this, what it means that there's an economic downturn or something like that. It's not like there's a 10% drop in GDP that they could peg it to. No,

Speaker 1this is just like, if they invoke it, they invoke it.

Speaker 5And guess what?

Speaker 1The Ellison family has not been afraid to invoke those things before. In fact, I believe that Oracle just did it a few weeks ago. And so to give people, most people listening by this point in... what you're producing here will probably have heard this context, but you know, the billions that are bankrolling this originally are Larry Ellison's money. Larry Ellison's money is from Oracle. And that's what bankrolled David all the way through literally from creating, you know, sky dances and early companies so that he could be an actor on fly boys and his acting career did not pan out. So then he became a media mogul

Speaker 1because his dad was bankrolling everything. And many one was sky dance, the original flavor. And now all of a sudden, he controls 40% of the White House press TV pool, and two of the last major standing Hollywood studios, and two of the major streaming services, and on and on and on. So this is all Ellison family money. And I don't know what the will says for Larry Ellison. I think he's in his 80s, but it's probably going to be controlled all by David when all is said and done, right?

Speaker 9So.

Speaker 1You know, this is oligarchy at its most pure, right? Where it's a rich person passes the billions on to their kid who takes control of empires. And not only is that force majeure issue notable with Oracle historically and now with Skydance, but also let's think about bringing all of this together with one neat little bow. And think about what Oracle as a company is actually selling. What is their product?

Speaker 2It's you.

Speaker 4It's me.

Speaker 1It's data about us. Oracle knows when people stop at a certain place in the supermarket aisle and linger staring at certain products. That's the sort of data that Oracle specializes in. Oracle's own executives, I think former executive now, have used the word scary on a conference stage to describe how much they know about us and how their technology works. They're a surveillance company at heart, right? They're a computing powerhouse and they always have been. And they've done some amazing technological things. And you can sit there

Speaker 1and be in awe of some of the computer and technology work that they've done. But at the end of the day, they're a surveillance company.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1And we think about where we are in an age of surveillance and license plate readers and flock cameras and all these things. And now CBS News and CNN and Warner Brothers, by the way, I should point out, also owns HBO and all these really important documentaries that HBO points out.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 1So now you've got one of the strongest media empires in the country ready to tell us how scary and terrible everything is and how crime is up when it's really down and how we all need to be terrified and we need to support the police with more big budgets and more spending and more military spending. And oh, by the way, who's going to benefit from that?

Speaker 13Oracle.

Speaker 1Because they're selling our data and also, by the way, our defense contractor for billions and billions of dollars. And they have some huge controversy with the VA as well right now. and problems delivering on medical record software for the VA. Oracle knows so much about us. And so now they've got a propaganda arm that's as big as any propaganda arm in history.

Speaker 12Jesus, dude, I'm like sick to my stomach. This is bad.

Speaker 5So I don't think that should be legal.

Speaker 9No, no.

Speaker 12And I mean, TikTok is wrapped up in this too, right?

Speaker 7Oh, yeah.

Speaker 12It goes beyond traditional media. And like, I think that that to me is, you know, the broadening of the ecosystem of control is it creates such a multifaceted threat. And like you said, then you can start to be able to manipulate narratives. And even if you don't have the power of even like, let's say we did get a Democrat into office who's maybe not as closely aligned, God willing, I guess, away from the Ellison family. But it's like, you know, they have so much control over

Speaker 12this narrative. We've already seen this in many ways with social media, but it feels like an uphill battle to be fending this off. Hey everyone, I'm breaking up the interview to just provide some details related to TikTok. Per CNBC, Oracle owns a 15% stake worth about $ 2 billion in the TikTok-USDS joint venture, which has housed the US operations of TikTok since January 2026 due to the US government mandated sell-off. Oracle also holds TikTok's user data and leads

Speaker 12oversight of the algorithm. There have been widespread accusations of censorship on the platform since the change in ownership, though so far these are difficult to prove with absolute certainty. But that's all I had. Back to the interview.

Speaker 1Speaking of investors and speaking of our oligarchs, you know, this deal, by the way, on paper, the Paramount and Warner merger financially made zero sense. And by the way, I say that as someone who actually owns still a little bit of Paramount stock or whatever the heck is Skydance. I guess it is now it's rolled over so many dang times. I happen to be a very, very small shareholder in this. So I follow that a little bit. And it's, you know, the whole deal is catastrophic, right? There's a reason Netflix, with all their deep pockets, backed away from the acquisition of Warner Brothers. And so on paper,

Speaker 1I mean, like literally, this will obviously rebound, there'll be all kinds of things going on. But in like 24 hours, the market capitalization of Skydance fell by like 50% this week. It's just, anyone who's putting money into this, besides those who are really controlling it, knows how rotten this is. And so it's really like, there's so much debt that they have taken on because they didn't want to pay for it themselves, the Ellisons, even though they've got a lot of money. But even for a family as rich as the Ellisons.

Speaker 9It's tough.

Speaker 1So first of all, they got special approval from the federal government because Trump is able to put his finger on the scale, which allows them to have, I think it's like a 49% foreign ownership stake. So we're talking about major oil companies, you know, countries where journalists have, you know, they're will have their citizenships revoked or be butchered with a bone saw. These are not free press loving regimes, right? And to say nothing about the people there, who I know many lovely, amazing, warm-hearted, wonderful people. But the people who control the governments and countries there are

Speaker 1not fans of the free press. And so those types of countries are the ones that are investing heavily in this. And while we're talking about these oligarchs, guess who else they've been looking at to invest very heavily in this new Skydance company because of the debt load? None other than Elon Musk.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 1So the guy who controls X and the folks who have a major stake in TikTok are also the people controlling CBS, CNN, HBO documentaries, all kinds of film, all kinds of television. We're talking a lot about free press, but also fictional narratives have a really impactful role here on the zeitgeist and on popular opinions. So Yeah, it comes back to who controls the past now controls the future, who controls the present now controls the past, who controls the past now controls the future, who controls the present now.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 4Hello and welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Andrew Siege, Andrewism, on YouTube, and.

Speaker 5I'm here with Garrison Davis, greetings.

Speaker 4Greetings and salutations. Have you witnessed any assassinations recently?

Speaker 5It's been a minute, actually.

Speaker 11There was that streak for a while, but it has been.

Speaker 9I guess.

Speaker 11A year since the last kind of major political assassination that I can recall. I'm sure there's been some, you know, incidents since then.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5But I think that.

Speaker 11That sort of wave that we had around like the final Biden years to the first Trump year, it may have subsided.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 4I mean, assassinations were having their moment. And they haven't had a moment like that, it felt like, since the 20th century.

Speaker 5Oh, yeah, definitely.

Speaker 4And so today I actually wanted to look at two different assassinations. One was carried out by an American of Italian descent, a certain Luigi Mangione, against the CEO of United Healthcare, Brian Thompson, back in the ancient times of 2024. And the other assassination was carried out by an Italian, Gaetano Breschi, against the King of Italy, Umberto I, in the year 1900. So we're talking about... a private citizen

Speaker 4killing a corporate executive in one instance, an anarchist immigrant killing a monarch, separated by a century and change, but both deliberate attacks on highly symbolic individuals, almost as stand-ins for harmful institutions. And so I really wanted to look at their causes and consequences for the sake of analysis and put forward a critique of such actions as a tactic. To be clear, I, and it could happen here, do

Speaker 4not endorse assassinations. Just putting that disclaimer out there.

Speaker 5Let the record state.

Speaker 4Let the record state. So, I mean, I think a lot of people are familiar with Mangione. Have you heard much or anything about Gitano Berski?

Speaker 11I think I've heard this mentioned as a part of this wave of assassinations, which was a bit longer than the sort of wave that we were talking about of the past few years. But in like the early 20th century... You know, there's this big way from the start to, you know, the 1920s and then, you know, more in the 60s and 70s. So I think I've heard this referenced, especially in terms of like anarchist folklore, but it is not one that I'm like as familiar with.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4So looking into him, he had a very interesting story. Whenever I look into an anarchist in the past, I'm always reminded that, you know, people in the past were really just like us for real. This is Gaetano Breschi. He was born in a peasant family in Tuscany in 1869. His parents owned a small farm where they grew grain, olives and grapes. But falling crop prices and competition from cheaper American grain pushed the family into poverty during the 1880s. So Bresci had to begin working as a factory apprentice

Speaker 4at 11 years old to help support his family. By 15 years old, Bresci was a qualified silk weaver and had gotten involved in an anarchist group in Prato. And his experience of poverty and factory exploitation shaped his opposition to Italy's social order. He ended up being imprisoned for 15 days in 1892, so at the age of 23 years old, for contempt and insubordination toward the police, after which authorities labelled him a dangerous anarchist.

Speaker 5Time is a flat circle.

Speaker 9Indeed.

Speaker 4And then in 1895, at the age of 26, he was sentenced to domicilio quarto, or forced residence, on an island prison. for helping organize a textile worker's strike. He was released the following year under a royal amnesty, and was, of course, more radicalized than ever.

Speaker 11Yeah, I guess that is something that is maybe slightly different. I guess I have not heard of a union organizer getting sent to an island prison in the recent past in developed countries. I'm sure there's obviously other obstacles towards that. towards organizing textile workers in many parts of the world.

Speaker 4Yeah, and I mean, the island prison, the Tomicilio Quarto thing, that was like a big go-to move in Italian history. I remember reading about Luigi Galliani. He also spent a lot of time on island prisons. So that was like a thing that the Italian government was doing back then, just like send off all the inconvenient people to these islands off the coast of the mainland.

Speaker 11See, it would be interesting if Luigi Mangione was on the island prison of Rikers as a parallel, but he is actually not. He is in the Metropolitan Attention Center in Brooklyn, which I guess is still on a island, if you're going to count Long Island, I suppose.

Speaker 4Sure, sure, sure. I think there's a degree of difference between Brooklyn and.

Speaker 5There is a degree of difference.

Speaker 4A sparsely populated Italian island.

Speaker 8Yes, yes.

Speaker 4So Breschi, you know, after he got out of prison, he remained in Italy for a few more years before eventually emigrating to the US, where he arrived in 1898. And very quickly became involved in the Italian-American anarchist milieu in Paterson, New Jersey, which I had no idea Paterson, New Jersey was like that, but it was very much popping in the Italian anarchist scene. So he helped establish and support La Questione Sociale, which is an Italian language anarchist newspaper. Unlike Angioni, he was not someone who became

Speaker 4politically radical in isolation. You know, Bresci was participating in a very socially vibrant political movement, which when I look at the differences between the assassinations of now versus the assassinations of then, that's something that I notice. You know, assassins of the past were very much integrated in social networks of a radical tradition. Whereas now they tend to be online atomized lone wolf.

Speaker 11And we just don't even have the sort of living, you know, in-person social, that scale of member organizations and like actual connections between people to channel political process or to channel their politics through in the same way. I mean, just in terms of like scale, you know, it's it's a totally it's totally different yeah as much as you have your like affinity groups or you have your various kind of socialist organizations like proportional to the population it's it's still it's nowhere close.

Speaker 4Yeah yeah and i think well what helped in the italian case was just the fact that it was a wave of these people who had that shared experience of being in a foreign land in the u.s and you know experiencing intimately the same workplace abuses and also being connected to radical political traditions back at home and bringing those ideas over. And, you know, so Brzezinski would have been involved in newspapers. We've been attending meetings. He would have,

Speaker 4you know, in part of their social events, he was reportedly a very chill guy. He kept his domestic life and his political life separate. He apparently got married to an Irish-American woman. And he had his own hobbies. You know, like I say, these people in the past, they're just like us for real. He really was into photography. So he used to spend his free time taking pictures. And you can imagine the camera just came out. And he's curating his skill. He was also very into fashion. If

Speaker 4you remember, he... worked in silk and he worked in textile in textile industry yeah yeah yeah so he actually would spend his spare change like saving for expensive clothes and in fact in one of the books that i was looking into in research for this episode i can't remember which one i have them all linked to the show notes his comrades were like kind of suspicious of the fact that like yo you're like An anarchist revolutionary. Why do you like those bourgeois high fashion clothes? But you know, the guy had his interests and he was

Speaker 4very much himself. While he had strong opinions, he would also be almost like a quiet storm in meetings. Like apparently he wouldn't say much. He would just be there. And then all of a sudden, as an issue would be raised or something would come up, he would speak very eloquently to make his point, to argue his piece. And at one point, also in his history, he saved Malatesta's life. There was an attempt on Errico Malatesta's life, the Italian anarchist, probably the most famous of them, where

Speaker 4during a meeting, another anarchist basically came at him with a knife. I can't remember if it was a knife or a gun. One of the two. And Bresci was the one who basically helped disarm the guy and saved Malatesta from a potentially fatal wound. And so Bresci... was going along, taking his pictures, raising his family. Also, apparently, I don't want to get too much into his personal life, but he was a bit of a ladies' man. But he had taken care of his family and doing all these things, attending these meetings, being part of his political agitation.

Speaker 4Then he finds out about this event, which is the Bava Beccaris Massacre. So in 1898, Italy experienced a lot of unrest over food prices and economic conditions. And in Milan... Troops under General Fiorenzo Bava Beccaris violently suppressed demonstrations, killing at least 118 people and wounding hundreds more. King Umberto I not only approved of the crackdown, but awarded Bava Beccaris Italy's highest decoration, praising him for his service to, quote,

Speaker 4our institutions and to civilization. And so while living in Paterson, New Jersey, Bresci read about the massacre and was enraged by the king's praise for those responsible. Actually, he later testified that this is what convinced him that Umberto I deserved to die.

Speaker 5He's still in the States at this point?

Speaker 9Yes.

Speaker 4Huh. And then on the other hand, we have Luigi Mangione. I'll give a very brief biography here. He was born in Maryland, 1998, apparently to a fairly wealthy, prominent, privileged Baltimore family. Like I went on his Wikipedia page and he had relatives that had blue links. And that's when you know, like, okay, you're kind of big in the dance.

Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 4He had an elite education. He graduated from Gilman School and the University of Pennsylvania. He studied computer engineering and later worked in technology and data engineering and did not appear to have a very politically radical personal background, but due to his longstanding problems with severe back pain, he underwent spinal surgery and his online activity increasingly included a lot of criticism of American society and the healthcare system in particular. He also expressed interest in the writings of

Speaker 4Ted Kaczynski, Which, you know, if you came up around the time that he came up on the internet and stuff, that's not too surprising. Ted K has kind of been one of those like internet figures that everybody kind of cares about, whether it be a video essay or a TikTok or whatever. So he stumbled upon his stuff and expressed interest in it. And the available evidence does establish that his grievances with the health insurance system basically were at the heart of his frustration of his thinking. I

Speaker 4think he connected his experience to a lot of the issues in the broader American zeitgeist related to medical debt and denied claims and the bureaucracy of it all, the high healthcare costs. And his writings shared a lot of frustration with the industry. And so he decided to select Brian Thompson as a representative of United Healthcare and almost to treat him as an embodiment of the system and of his as an individual, but I suppose also as

Speaker 4a society, the wrath towards the healthcare system. And so Bresci, on the other hand, viewed the Milan massacre as something that Roberto I was politically responsible for, because he produced the regime that rewarded that violence. So by attacking Roberto I, Bresci would be attacking both an individual that he considered personally culpable for and also the political office of the kingship of the monarchy, the head of state of Italy.

Speaker 4Brian Thompson was the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. He was a corporate executive. And UnitedHealthcare is itself part of UnitedHealth group. So he was like a big cheese, you know, he had a very powerful position, but he wasn't the sovereign authority of the American healthcare system. And he could be replaced. Of course, in Berthoud I, after he was killed, he was also replaced by Victor Emmanuel III. Brian Thompson After he died, he got replaced by another executive. So in both cases, we see that the office and the institution

Speaker 4attached to that office survived. The unaligned social relations survived. But consequences were felt in other ways, which we'll get to. On the day of the assassinations, in both cases, so in Bresci's case, it was the 29th of July, 1900. He returned from the US, specifically intending to assassinate Umberto. He reached Monza, where Umberto was attending a public event. He approached him, fired several shots, and Umberto died shortly after. And Bresci was immediately captured. The crowd basically seized him,

Speaker 4and he was taken into custody. He didn't get caught at the McDonald's.

Speaker 9No, he did not.

Speaker 4He was not at the McDonald's. Mangione, on the other hand, he traveled to New York. This was on the 4th of December, 2024. He researched Thompson, got information on the Investor Conference, positioned himself outside the hotel, waited for him. plow shot fled scene was at large for a while. If you were on the internet, when this happened, there was a lot of celebration. There were condemnations as well, but there was a lot of a sense of like catharsis about the action that he took.

Speaker 11Across like the right and the left, right. The most, like the combination came from like what you could call like the elite class.

Speaker 9Right.

Speaker 11But yeah, a lot of people who might have, you know, just kind of baseline, like moral scruples against murder. can see something like this happen and be like yeah i mean it it's a health insurance ceo.

Speaker 4Yeah so it's not even necessarily endorse it or co-sign it but it is that they're just like yeah i get.

Speaker 11It no it's more so it's understanding that the conditions of our society made this almost inevitable in a certain sense yeah and to see that sort of structural analysis from both the left and the right in the sort of days and weeks following the assassination was a very interesting moment this big, big like transition point in American politics going from, it's like right in Biden's like lame duck period, going right into Trump. And you had this, this sort of like unfocused, like populist energy. It was, you know, very, very bubbled.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4And so in that period, you know, when Manjuni is on the run, eventually he's recognized and arrested in Pennsylvania. But in the conversation, both before his capture and after, you know, The difference between this assassination and Bresci's assassination of Umberto was that the internet was existent. And so it was able to spark and stimulate a lot of conversations, sympathy, discussion of the health insurance system, arguments about violence.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 4Even treating them as like a folk hero kind of figure, memes. You know, this is a kind of a landscape that did not exist in the time of those early 20th century assassinations. I'm sure people would have had their own opinions and thoughts and jokes and perspectives that they would have published or shared person to person verbally in the times of all those assassinations. But the speed at which information just goes around the world nowadays is something that

Speaker 4we take for granted. Just how much it has changed the whole human zeitgeist. So what happened in terms of the outcomes for both assassins? Mangione was arrested five days after the killing. As I said, he was prosecuted federally and by New York State. The federal murder charge that could have carried the death penalty was later dismissed. And on the 14th of August, 2026, Mangione pleaded guilty to death. Two federal stalking charges resulting in death. He explicitly admitted

Speaker 4in court that he shot Thompson and federal prosecutors are seeking a life sentence. Sentencing is scheduled for December 18th, 2026. Meanwhile, his separate New York State prosecution is unresolved. because his lawyers are arguing that the federal conviction bars a fuller prosecution under double jeopardy protections. But the state is disputing that argument. Now, as I said, Bresci was captured immediately. He was tried and sentenced to life imprisonment. And there

Speaker 4was suspicions of a plot during his trial. They thought that he collaborated with other people. But whenever they brought witnesses to the stand, first of all, his wife had no idea what he was going to do. In fact, she's on the stand and she's like, when he told me he was an anarchist, I didn't really know what that meant. You know, I thought he was an anarchist, like, you know, somebody's like a Catholic, you know? So it's kind of interesting to me that he really didn't share.

Speaker 11You mentioned he had like a sort of separation.

Speaker 4Yeah, of his domestic life and his politics. He really did not let his wife in, in that way, which is such a stark contrast to some other notable anarchists. who, you know, sometimes the husband-wife pairing were both equally passionate anarchists. I think of Parsons, the Parsons, for example.

Speaker 11Yeah, there's this sort of like anarchist family unit with like Emma Goldman even as well, this sort of like extended network where you like social and political ties.

Speaker 4Exactly, exactly. So, and then his comrades, they were brought to the stand as well. They're like, yeah, we had no idea he was going to do this. Nobody suspected. But he would have done it. And so because they couldn't find any evidence of a plot, they sentenced him alone. He was moved through several prisons before being transferred to the remote island prison of Santo Stefano in January of 1901. And they chose that island prison because they were afraid that his anarchist buddies would try to free him. So

Speaker 4he was kept on this island prison and then further in the island prison is kept in an isolated cell under constant guard. He spent basically 23 hours a day in solitary confinement with only an hour of exercise in a corridor. He couldn't receive visitors or letters, newspapers, books. The guards were instructed not to speak to him. His diet was of soup and bread and occasionally meat and his cell didn't have much in the way of furnishings

Speaker 4at all. And despite those conditions... The prison officials reported that he was mentally coherent and in good spirits. And then tragically, on the 22nd of May, 1901, the prison authorities announced that Bresci had committed suicide by hanging himself from his cell window. To this day, people are questioning this official account. Okay. Because for one, prisoners were not supposed to have towels in the first place. So how could he have hung himself with a towel? Also, He

Speaker 4was under round the clock surveillance, right? You know, like how could he have hung himself for that long if he's constantly being watched by guards? You know, he had wine and cheese in his cell that was untouched and soup as well, which doesn't make sense if you're thinking that, oh, I'm going to die today. You're probably going to eat your last meal.

Speaker 9And he didn't do that.

Speaker 4And on top of that, on top of those circumstances, he also had a pending appeal So it's like, why would he take his own life before he found out the outcome of that appeal? He has a wife and children to think about. And an autopsy found that while he did die by strangulation, his body was a lot more decomposed than it would have been if he had died less than 48 hours earlier. So it's possible he had died days before they claimed that he died. But

Speaker 4that discrepancy was literally... Never investigated. They did not care to investigate it. He was buried very swiftly on the 26th of May with his few possessions and the nearly 100 letters from his wife that the prison authorities never allowed him to read. So imagine he got inside jail in January. He's there until May. Nearly 100 letters and he never got to read any of them.

Speaker 5Yeah, it's almost like one letter a day.

Speaker 4So then you look at what happened. other than to the individuals in question, you look at the reverberations, the consequences. Well, after Umberto was killed, obviously there was shock throughout Italy, but the state continued. The assassination just intensified the existing fears surrounding anarchist violence and anarchists across Europe and North America who were already being subjected to surveillance and repression. It basically wrapped up the fervor of that suppression. There

Speaker 4was a kind of an anarchist terror panic of the period. And so that assassination and other incidents kind of served as political justification for further repression. In Mangione's case, what has actually changed? You know, the corporation still is in operation. The business model hasn't changed. The structure of capital insurance is still the same. And yet there was public discourse. We got a sense of the pulse of the populace, how they felt about about this issue, it was like

Speaker 4a kind of a lightning rod for dissatisfaction.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 4But I think most people have moved on. Mangione's in jail right now, probably going to spend the rest of his life there. And the public has moved on.

Speaker 11I think the sort of optimistic future facing read is that the incident demonstrates the sort of urgency of this issue. which could be channeled into various other forms to dramatically change the way the healthcare system works in the US, getting rid of private insurance as a necessity or just getting rid of it altogether. But yeah, in terms of immediate effects, there was a debate on certain kind of

Speaker 11minor policy changes in the weeks following the assassination, but those did not turn into kind of lasting effects. The only really lasting effect was on the sort of company side is that executives now pay more money for tighter security.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4And I mean, the lasting effect on the individual side is life imprisonment.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 4I mean, and that's one of the issues I have, right? With this tactic, it is, I mean, obviously we could talk about the more obvious issues, but I think one of the issues that I have with this tactic is the assassin is taking themselves out of the equation, basically, you know, all that they could contribute in terms of building networks, building organization, building the momentum of a movement or a prefigurative alternative, any kind of resistance, all that

Speaker 4is basically silenced. And of course, in any struggle, there will be martyrs, there will be people who are taken out by the state, abducted, imprisoned. But An action like this, I think the outcome is with the consequence in terms of like taking such an impassioned individual off the board of what they could contribute.

Speaker 11It kind of goes back to the sort of death of mass politics and how mass politics was like extinguished in the 20th century. the fact that so many people feel like they have to turn to these sorts of like individualized forms, this lone wolf aspect. I mean, and if you take like a deeper look into Mangione's like own politics, sort of like libertarian, like tech aspects of it, you know, his proximity to like what you would call like gray tribe or like post-rationalism, right? This sort of like individualist look at the problems of the modern world

Speaker 11and thinking how you can solve this through like technological solutions, or in some cases, just like focusing one's willpower to accomplish actions that normal people would consider being like impossible, just as such as going to just kill the CEO of a healthcare company, right? A sort of quote unquote normal, well-adjusted person would just not consider that as like a legitimate option. But if you can weaponize your like mind in a certain way to like go and achieve things,

Speaker 11do things that just seem like impossible that aren't like real options. Maybe that could have some sort of, butterfly effect outcome. But all this exists totally outside of actual mass politics and engagement. I think you can see the affinity for something like Ted Kaczynski is very evident here.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think there are parallels more to Kaczynski than to Raskin in this case. In terms of the isolation of the assassin in question, Bresley was at that point integrated in an actual movement and network, whereas both Kaczynski and Gianni seemed to have been carrying things out as lone actors.

Speaker 11And that's, you know, very similar to the other kind of politician assassinations that we've seen from Shinzo Abe, which had a very deep, personal motivation.

Speaker 5Something like you.

Speaker 11Know, the attempted assassination of Trump and Butler, where you had this much more kind of, you know, school shooter type like mindset motivating that rather than like political beliefs. And then the Charlie Kirk assassination, I think similar to the Luigi one, very kind of like personal frustration taking the form of like a very like political act, even if it wasn't, you know, tied in with a sort of larger political framework.

Speaker 4Yeah. And I don't really like to say that you know, an action worked or didn't work or succeeded or failed. Cause it really depends on what your metric is for those things. You know, you're going to see like released frustration and yeah, it worked, you know, killed someone.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4It definitely killed someone, you know, get people talking.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4Got people talking or even saying something like, Oh, like my goal was to punish this person. I didn't really care what the outcome or anything else.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4You could even look at it from a propaganda angle and say, oh, like this is a symbolic message about like, you know, that these people are not untouchable and unreachable. But that kind of brings me to the whole like raising awareness conversation, which is like, to what end, you know? Yeah, you could raise awareness, but what if there's no meaningful awareness left to raise?

Speaker 11Yeah. I mean, in terms of propaganda of the deed, everyone already hates health insurance. Yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 11There is public support for universal healthcare, but the sort of institutional blockages that are preventing that from happening in this country, I don't know if those can be moved through propaganda of the deed itself.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4And to be precise, propaganda of the deed is not exclusive to assassinations. It has become kind of synonymous with it as a euphemism. But yeah, I get what you're saying. The powers that be responsible for The current state affairs are not going to be moved by you taking out a CEO.

Speaker 11No, but they can spend more money on security. And one of the parallels between these two things that you were talking about is the way that there is this sort of crackdown on radicals, anarchists, Antifa, if you will. despite Luigi Mangione not being a leftist, despite the Trump assassination definitely not being a leftist, and the specific political motivations of the Charlie Kirk assassination being somewhat unclear, having

Speaker 11it be seemingly more related to personal motivation based on the shooter's romantic partner, rather than connected to a larger political framework. Despite all that, despite these things not really having the same kind of political connection that assassinations in the 60s, 70s, or in this early 20th century had, these assassinations still have been used by the administration to do a very significant crackdown on the left more broadly, whether that's in nonprofits, whether that's union organizing, or that's

Speaker 11just people protesting. You see that through the Antifa terrorism executive order, taking down the Noblogs sites, MSPM7, terrorism charges against protestors. it has had those sorts of like similar kind of broad effects.

Speaker 9Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 4And so I get why political violence happens, but if we want to make a structural change, I think we have to address the structure.

Speaker 10Yes.

Speaker 4It's an ontology, but you know.

Speaker 8Well, it's true though.

Speaker 11I mean, it's the fact that that needs to be said in a certain way kind of shows the gravity of the situation. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 4Like, You have to address the root motivation of the violence in the first place and not just condemn the violence or direct the violence. So carry on the violence, you know, and reducing structural political problems into an individual or, you know, carrying out an action that will lead to consequences that go beyond yourself. You know, it's not just that Bresci was imprisoned and likely killed in prison. It's

Speaker 4not just that Ban Joon-hee has been imprisoned. It's that what it leads to, what it emboldens. And I hate this kind of way of framing it because the state doesn't necessarily need an excuse to suppress, to oppress, right? So that's not what I was saying, but.

Speaker 12Totally.

Speaker 5I'm not saying that, yeah, 100%.

Speaker 4You know, it adds to the rhetorical ammunition for policing, for surveillance, for censorship. for restrictions on organizing, for deportations, for greater cooperation among international police forces and things of that nature. And so in closing, I did want to share some of Malatesta's thoughts on the incident, seeing as Malatesta was, you know, involved the guy. They weren't friends. I mean, he did save his life, but there's no

Speaker 4evidence that they were particularly close. But he did write an article in response to the Monza tragedy, as he calls it. So he had said that every time that capitalists and governments perpetrate some extraordinarily criminal act, every time that innocents are tortured, every time the savagery of the powerful erupts into bloodshed, we deplore that act on account of the legacy of hatred it leaves in its wake and the seed of vengeance that plants in the minds of the oppressed. And then he says, when the pent-up anger of protracted tortures bursts into a storm, raises an

Speaker 4avenging arm and strikes what he reckons is the cause of the war, that the guilty parties, the ones responsible, are us. I think many of the words that he says in this article can really easily be applied to the present because he refuses to romanticize the assassination. He says that a king has been killed and since a king is for all that still a man, that fact is to be deplored. But he does ask why such an outpouring of sentimentality over one particular misfortune. when thousands

Speaker 4and millions of human beings are perishing. And importantly, nevertheless, the sufferings of royals are human suffering too, and to be deployed. But lamentations are pointless if one does not look into the root causes and try to eliminate them. So he does place responsibility for the Monza tragedy in the king's hands, you know? Even if he didn't do it directly, he failed to prevent it.

Speaker 5Yeah, 100%.

Speaker 4And even if he could not prevent it, he allowed it to be done in his name, you know? But Maltester still rejects punishment. revenge you know he says we're not believers in the right to punish we repudiate revenge as a barbaric notion we do not mean to be either executioners or avengers and then the calling of liberators and peacemakers strikes us as a holier nobler more productive calling is me in charge and really the one i want to drill here and kind of end on is that we know that such singular acts of violence in the absence of sufficient preparation by the people remain futile,

Speaker 4and indeed, by triggering backlashes against which one cannot stand, they generate incalculable injury to the very cause they were intended to serve. The essential, incontrovertible, purposeful act lies not in the physical killing of a king, but in killing all kings. from courts, parliaments, and factories, in the hearts and minds of people, meaning the eradication of belief in the authority principle worshipped by so many other people. And so before deploying the ultimate argument to the oppressed, before,

Speaker 4you know, engaging in any kind of action that would involve a kind of extremity of violence, a movement must strive to acquire the moral and material strength that is needed to minimize the violence needed to bring down the system of violence to which humanity is presently subjected.

Speaker 5I think that's as good a place as any to end.

Speaker 4Yeah. To be clear, again, to kind of sandwich the disclaimer, I am not a fan of assassinations. I do not advise it or encourage it. While I recognize that for some it can be a source of catharsis and it could certainly spark a lot of public conversations, it is a far cry from the action necessary for change, you know, prefiguration and actions which set up alternatives certainly beats that singular heroic, in quotes, act. I think you are better

Speaker 4served directing your energy and passion toward service to the living rather than sacrificing your life to death or life imprisonment. In a time like this, I think we need all hands on deck. And with that... All powers to all the people. Peace.

Speaker 8Peace.

Speaker 11This is It Could Happen Here, Executive Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening in the White House, the crumbling world, and what this means for you. I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm joined by James Stout and special correspondent Carlos Berrios Blanco with a special segment later on by Robert Evans. This episode, we are covering the week of November 4th to November 11th. James Stout.

Speaker 1Yeah, you want to talk about some little things? I've got quite a few today. I guess I'll start with Turkey. Turkiye, I think they want you to call it now. They don't want it to sound the same as the bird at this time of year.

Speaker 5Woke 3 is crazy, man.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1In Turkey, there's been a fallout between Ahmed Spor and Galatasaray.

Speaker 5People aren't familiar.

Speaker 1Ahmed Spor is the biggest Kurdish team. The Galatasaray team's shop posted a picture, which they claim was a promotional image for a special jersey. It looked a lot like the yellow bags that have very painful associations for Kurdish people due to their use as body bags during the conflict between Turkey The Turkish state and the PKK, but it's really blown up in terms of this very unresolved conflict. Turkey's in this peace process with the PKK, which is dissolving itself, but it's revealed these very deep wounds that

Speaker 1have been there for a very long time. Obviously, people will always say it's just sport, it's just football, but very clearly it's more than that. Moving on to Myanmar, in recent weeks, the Trump administration has been moving closer and closer to Min Aung Hlaing's coup regime in Naypyidaw. Trump kind of implicitly recognized this regime when he sent that tariff letter. Certainly, that was what the junta went for. He sent them a letter about tariffs, and they were like, look, he recognizes us. Very kind of pathetic. But they conducted

Speaker 1direct government-to-government meetings in Japan this year, which is a first since the regime overthrew the government right after the election. A recently released document entitled the, quote, Integral Country Strategy for Burma, the US still calls it Burma, right? It never went with Myanmar, outlines four different goals for US engagement. Stopping visa overstays, stopping scam compounds, selling United States goods, and pushing back against Chinese influence. And it's aiming for

Speaker 1peace in the region by 2030. So it doesn't mention democracy. Literally, I control F to the word democracy in the document. It doesn't mention civilian deaths. It doesn't mention political prisoners, right? They openly say in this document their goals are mostly extractive. Quote, the mission will facilitate at least three multi-stakeholder forums that produce concrete agreements or policy proposals advancing fiscal federalism and territorial demarcation in Burma, which will create opportunities to access Burma's bountiful rare earth resources and combat scam centers. The

Speaker 1scam centers are a big deal. Like when you get one of those, I think they call it spear phishing. I guess it's cat phishing, but it's not directly directed at you. But when you get those texts that are like, hey, we're meeting up tonight, right? And it's from an unknown number, very high chance that those people are held against their will in scam centers, often in Miaowili or one of these areas, one of these zones along the borderlands of Myanmar. and the FBI has been going really hard against those for the last few months. Rather than engaging with the resistance,

Speaker 1they have chosen to engage with the coup regime to do that. The State Department has also sanctioned three people, as did this last week, for trying to help Iran work around sanctions to obtain manpads. I'm always kind of interested in the illicit market for surface-to-air missiles, right? A manpad is a man-portable air defense system. People think of like a stinger or something like that, right? Because this is still the one area where the states of the world kind of have this on lock, right? Like the

Speaker 1proliferation of manpads has not been as great as proliferation of drones, of small arms, even artillery, mortars, stuff like that. So these people, it seems, were acting as middlemen to help Iran procure Chinese and Russian manpads. At least in one instance, they were creating fake end-user certificates in Nigeria for them. And then allegedly moving them to the Iranians. We know the Iranians had some advanced Chinese manpads, right? They shot down that US aircraft or a couple of US aircraft. Portsmouth has granted the local RNLI crew, the

Speaker 1lifeboat crew, the freedom of the city, which is the highest civic honor a city can give. I'm sure there's another Portsmouth somewhere in the East Coast. They just love to name stuff after British towns. But I'm talking about Portsmouth, England here. In the process, the council heard of abuse directed at lifeboat crews and of their children being bullied at school, which is fucking mad to me.

Speaker 11This is based on the idea that these lifeboat crews are helping migrants who are in trouble in the water.

Speaker 1Yeah, they're not even helping. They're not allowing migrants to drown. They are helping anyone who's in peril on the sea, which is what they've always done.

Speaker 9I cannot.

Speaker 1overstate the extent to which these were a non-partisan. These were our Dolly Parton. No one hated the lifeboats when I was a kid. Everyone put money in the little lifeboat money box. Notably, all the Reform UK council members abstained from this vote because they are both bigots and cowards. Finally, a general strike today in Spain. Shout out to my people. Some of my friends are recording. I saw they were playing the International outside the Ministry of Culture on violins right before we started recording. It seems great. It is,

Speaker 1of course, the 90th anniversary of the beginning of the Battle of Madrid this week. I was just looking at pictures of the Graphic Arts Battalion and the Hairdressers Battalion who held off Franco's army 90 years ago today. So it's kind of a nice anniversary to be out on strike again. But we'll have something about that for you next week. Yeah, you had some stuff.

Speaker 11Yes, and actually in some breaking news, which is breaking for us right now, would probably be old news by the time this comes out tomorrow. Scott Colom of Mississippi is projected by CNN to become the senator of Mississippi. The first black person elected to statewide office in Mississippi since Reconstruction.

Speaker 8Jesus wept.

Speaker 11Beating Republican Sidney Hyde-Smith by just about 4,000 votes.

Speaker 1Geez. Wow.

Speaker 5Pretty tight.

Speaker 11CNN, I think, is the first outlet to call this. We'll come in these next few hours.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 5How are things going in Alaska?

Speaker 8They're still counting, man. It's going to be a little while.

Speaker 5That's going to be a while. That still might go to instant runoff.

Speaker 1Last I saw, Peltola had more votes than both Dan Sullivans combined, which is a good thing, I guess.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 11There's another third party candidate in there, which kind of throws a wrench in.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 5I think he's another Republican, right?

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5We'll get a closer idea of what's going on there in the next week, hopefully.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 2Is Mississippi the one that doesn't have recount, right? He wins?

Speaker 8Correct.

Speaker 10Yes.

Speaker 11Mississippi does not have a recount rule in their state election law. And because election laws are largely determined by states, not federal authorities, yes, it does not appear like there will be a recount rule.

Speaker 5In this race.

Speaker 11But Colombe's lead has only grown this past week and a half. Now up point, like four or five percentage points.

Speaker 5So there you go.

Speaker 9Moving on.

Speaker 11Amid uncertainty whether AOC will or will not run for president in 2028, Zoran Mamdani has been meeting with labor leaders to try to consolidate support for a left labor candidate, someone that can become the standard bearer for the into the next election with the backing of unions to oppose the swath of corporate devs who will inevitably attempt to take the reins and moderate the populist policies that just won Democrats the election. According to a report from Axios,

Speaker 11Zoran is, quote, arguing that progressives can't afford to squander their midterm momentum. Citing sources that have spoken with the mayor, Mamdani, quote, wants the progressive ecosystem to mobilize quickly, strategically, and efficiently in if a moderate candidate is clearly on the rise, unquote. So Zoran has been asking unions which candidates they might like, what their endorsement process is, and if certain labor leaders themselves would be open to running for office. In the

Speaker 11past months, Zoran has met with Jimmy Williams Jr., president of the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, Sarah Nelson, president of the Association of Flight Attendants, CWA, and on Wednesday, he met with Sean Fain, president of the UAW, who is probably the frontrunner for everyone who's not considered a frontrunner in this race. In terms of the unexpected, unlikely candidates, Fain's name has been thrown around a lot as a labor reformer, as someone who has acted very strategically the past few years, and has really, really led the UAW

Speaker 11to some pretty big victories. So it'll be interesting to see what comes of these meetings these next few weeks as people already start preparing for the next election because that's how America works. Speaking of election results, so after the Republicans' historic defeat, Speaker Mike Johnson announced that he would not be seeking to maintain his leadership position going forward, letting his term expire at the start of next year. So this week, Republicans held a closed-door secret ballot vote

Speaker 11to decide who will become the minority leader. Now you might think, after their historic defeat, they might, you know, and evaluate why they're so off-putting to voters, maybe moderate themselves on certain things, maybe pick someone that people find.

Speaker 5More likable or agreeable.

Speaker 8No, not at all.

Speaker 11They elected co-founder of the far-right House Freedom Caucus, Jim Jordan, to be the new House Minority Leader for the Republicans starting in 2027. So there will be a lot of interesting stuff to watch there as the House Freedom Caucus really becomes more and more dominant.

Speaker 2Yeah, actually, I'm... I don't think y'all know this about me, but I graduated from Ohio State in 2021, which is where Jim Jordan was wrestling coach, if I remember correctly. Where he systematically, well, reportedly... knew about and ignored the sexual assault of over a hundred wrestlers.

Speaker 7I don't know.

Speaker 2Bad guy to have in charge.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 5Not the kind of freedom we're looking for.

Speaker 2No, absolutely not.

Speaker 10No.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 11We could definitely do a whole episode in the future about Jim Jordan.

Speaker 10Yes.

Speaker 11Not as much of like a kind of, you know, like an unknown figure the way that Mike Johnson was when he, when he secured house speaker position.

Speaker 5A few years ago.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 11This is like a very, very known quantity, you know, someone that already has a sort of like national reputation.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 11And this signifies that they are not going to, you know, back down in any kind of sense or kind of, they are going to be putting up a fight in the House against the Democrats. Speaking of leadership, though it's expected that Hakeem Jeffries will become House Speaker, there is growing resistance to Chuck Schumer, assuming the role of Senate Majority Leader. New Senators-elect Abdul El-Sayed, Adam Hamilton, Annie Andrews, Troy Jackson, Peggy Flanagan, Chris Pappas, and Julianna Stratton have said that they will not support Schumer becoming majority leader.

Speaker 11On Monday, the 600,000-member Machinist Union, the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, sent to Schumer and the full Senate Democratic Caucus a letter urging Schumer to quote, not seek another term, stating... This week's elections sent a clear message. Working people are demanding change. We believe that this is the right moment for a new generation to lead Senate Democrats. Adding that this moment, quote, will require fresh ideas, new energy, and a new generation of leadership. This letter also urged

Speaker 11Democrats to pass the PRO Act, which would strengthen workers' rights and ability to organize to a massive extent. I'm putting together an episode on that for the next month or so. Union President Brian Bryant, that's a cool name, told Politico, quote, the IAM union is through with any member of leadership in any political party who stops one iota short of being a ferocious, unyielding, and unbending champion

Speaker 11of working people. On Tuesday in a joint press conference, Bernie Sanders and CIA's Michigan Senator Alyssa Slotkin Both signaled opposition to Schumer. Bernie said, quote, And Slotkin announced that she wouldn't support any candidate until a 100-day priority agenda is established. Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen has indicated he's open to challenging Schumer. On Tuesday, Schumer said he's, quote,

Speaker 11And that, quote, We have great unity in our caucus, and I'll be proud to lead it as majority leader.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 11So that's the state of the Schumer fiasco. Hopefully we'll get even more pressure against him in these next few weeks.

Speaker 5Do we want to move on to other shitty Dem events? It's an endless.

Speaker 8It's a.

Speaker 5Rich source of content for the pod, yeah. We'll be here for a minute. Don't worry, guys.

Speaker 1We're not going to run out of shit to do when Blue January comes. Let's talk about impeaching Pete Hegseth, or not impeaching Pete Hegseth, as it turns out. So, impeachment articles for Pete Hegseth were introduced this week by Thomas Massey. Massey is a Republican who lost his primary, so he won't be returning to the House in January. He was in Kentucky's 4th District, and his primary was the most expensive House primary in history. Talked a bit about some of the absolutely bonkers AI attack ads. Maybe those succeeded. Maybe those are what took the balance. Unfortunately,

Speaker 1he didn't win. Trump backed his opponent because Massey had opposed the so-called Big Beautiful Bill and aid to Israel.

Speaker 5Massey's not a good person.

Speaker 1He has lots of absolutely reprehensible views, but at least he's not a coward, which really distinguishes him from, I think, a lot of the Republican caucus these days, like, you know, all the guys who talk shit on Donald Trump and then fell in line.

Speaker 8Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1Like, Massey believes in his things and he believes in them and I don't agree with any of them. Well, apart from this one, I guess. But, Yeah, at least he's going down fighting. He introduced eight articles. Three of the articles deal with alleged violations of the War Powers Act and continuing the war in Iran without congressional approval. So I think Hegseth and Rubio, they thought they could make an end run around this by giving it a different name every few weeks and claiming each bombing salvo, each few weeks of bombing was a separate mission.

Speaker 5Each bomb was a new war.

Speaker 6Yes.

Speaker 5Completely different, not requiring congressional approval.

Speaker 1Massey also alleges Hegsworth ignored laws that minimise civilian casualties, extra-judicially killed at least 243 people in drone strikes on boats. Kidnapped a sovereign foreign leader in the operation against Maduro, and suppressed free speech by attacking Senator Mark Kelly and threatening to weaponize the military justice system against him, as well as conducted an unlawful war in Yemen.

Speaker 5All things that are pretty easily proven.

Speaker 1Yes, all things that we have much of evidence for, much of which was shared on the Department of War's X account.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1He's been trying to do this since September, but House leaders recessed the chamber early. He was able to force a vote yesterday. At a press conference, he made the case for Republicans doing this now. Quote, what is an impeachment? An impeachment is just firing someone, really. You don't go to prison. You don't go to jail. You don't pay a fine, he said. But the Democrats are going to have hearings. They won't just have eight articles of impeachment. The Democrats are going to bring people in here who have served under him and with him, give them protection. So he's suggesting that it'll be worse for Hegseth if they do this later. Initially, it seemed like some Republicans

Speaker 1got behind this argument. And it could be a way for Republicans to distance themselves from this completely failed war in Iran, right? Here's James Comer, a Republican from Kentucky, talking to News Nation. What do you want to see done with Pete Hegseth, sir? There's a lot of talk about, you know, could Democrats bring forth articles of impeachment against him as soon as next week?

Speaker 5Do you want to see somebody new in that spot?

Speaker 14Well, that's going to be a decision that President Trump's going to have to make. But I can tell you with a high level of confidence that.

Speaker 9There's a lot of.

Speaker 2Questions about headsets.

Speaker 14We have no idea what the strategy is moving forward in Iran.

Speaker 8No one's happy about Iran.

Speaker 14And I think the Republican voters are more upset about what's going on in Iran.

Speaker 2Than the Democrat voters.

Speaker 14And that's all I heard from Republican voters, people that have been MAGA for years. The last 12 years, they had MAGA flags in their yard, wore MAGA caps. I mean, they are mad that we're in this situation in Iran.

Speaker 2They're mad over gas prices.

Speaker 5And a lot of them stayed home. I do not think, at.

Speaker 14Least in Kentucky, I don't think that these upset MAGA people voted Democrat.

Speaker 9They just didn't vote.

Speaker 1I thought it was really interesting to see him being kind of a bit more candid on that. Of course, he voted to send this to committee, which effectively killed it, right?

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1Decided not to continue with the impeachment. Should we play Donald Trump's take where he says, what about impeaching the generals who did Vietnam?

Speaker 2Why not?

Speaker 5Let's hear from the president.

Speaker 10And he certainly, I think he's won the war in Iran, but he's certainly winning the war.

Speaker 9Iran would love to make a deal.

Speaker 10And they've been obliterated, their Navy, their Air Force.

Speaker 9So he won the war. in two places, two big places, very important, very impactful. And they were one. They're not like Vietnam, where nothing.

Speaker 10Was won, or Afghanistan, or Iraq, or any of these wars, where nothing was won. There was nothing won. Just lots of death, and then let's leave. In one case, they're not going to have a nuclear weapon. In the other, we're making hundreds of billions of dollars for this country. So I say this. Pete Hexseth won two wars. Oh, let's impeach him. What about impeaching the gentleman from Biden, his person that disappeared for two weeks and nobody had

Speaker 10any idea where he was? What about impeaching the people that ran the Vietnam War? What about impeaching that ran Iraq and Afghanistan and all of these other wars where thousands of lives have been?

Speaker 9You know, we lost 18 people. people, 18.

Speaker 10They lost 65,000 in Vietnam. We're in there for seven months. They're in there for 21 years. What about impeaching those people? What about impeaching the leaders of these stupid wars that were done when nothing was gained?

Speaker 5Some actually very compelling points from the president here.

Speaker 2Yeah. Impeach every president. Something we can get behind.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1None of these people are in office to be impeached. Nonetheless, fascinating take from the president. I think his chance that they'd won the war is not the consensus opinion. This vote for impeachment was very close, 204 to 205. vote sent it to committee, right, which effectively kills it. 11 Dems, no showed. Seven Republicans, also no showed. Interestingly, at least two of those Republicans did vote on other measures yesterday, just in some cases, just a few minutes before, right?

Speaker 1So it seems like that was an active abstention choice in their part of the 11 Democrats, including Nancy Pelosi.

Speaker 5And I should say, Israel comes to me in my dreams, Haley Stevens.

Speaker 1Yes, not surprising that Haley Stevens didn't vote.

Speaker 5I think no one's seen her for a minute.

Speaker 1Four Democratic legislators have blamed a traffic jam in the Capitol for their failure to do their jobs. When I was 14 and I washed dishes at a caravan park, if I had said, sorry, I didn't show up today, there was a traffic jam, people would have laughed at me and then I would not have got paid or asked back. But I guess that's fine if you're a representative.

Speaker 5It's embarrassing.

Speaker 11And this also highlights Hakeem Jeffries' inability to actually lead the caucus. If you can't whip these people into being their for this vote.

Speaker 5Well, he didn't whip the vote. Yes, exactly.

Speaker 1He made a choice. He made a choice. I'm going to get onto Hakeem in a second here. I want to point out that I'm not certain why these people weren't in the House. It does seem to coincide with a PAC event for the elect Democratic women PAC at a restaurant nearby. And it seems like they went somewhere out of the House. and then weren't able to get back in time because of traffic. Some reporters have reported that other legislators were able to get back in time either by walking or getting dropped off on the Senate side. I should note that Lou Correa, who's a Democrat from California,

Speaker 1had said beforehand that he was having a medical procedure and he would miss a vote. Pelosi, it seems, this is fucking remarkable. I love this, sir. She was on her way to a Veterans Day event where she was being honored. Which is just remarkable for her contributions to veterans. Now, we need to be fair and balanced here. Nancy Pelosi has ensured that there are a shit ton of veterans in this country by spending her whole life doing fuck all about America's Forever Awards.

Speaker 5Yeah, that's really, that's chef's kiss.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 5That shit's so on the nose.

Speaker 8Yeah, right.

Speaker 1In an interview less than a week ago with ABC, Hakeem Jeffries had said he was a, quote, hard yes on impeaching Hegseth. But on Tuesday, he told a Politico reporter, quote, I haven't had a conversation with anyone on the floor team about what may or may not have happened in terms of the Hegseth resolution. But this is not the end of it. It's just the beginning. According to Laura Bassett, she's editor-in-chief at Jezebel, Jeffries didn't whip the vote and he told people to, quote, vote their conscience.

Speaker 5Embarrassing.

Speaker 1Great stuff, man. Not even a fucking week. And you've already failed miserably, right? Like you have all this momentum and you take it and just belly flop. Dems got to be Dems, I guess. Just talking of bipartisanship in the Senate this time, I want to talk briefly about Baja, B-A-A-J-A. Some people call it Baja, but it's got an extra A. I made a Natural Causes episode about this yesterday, which we'll link in the show notes, which will go into much more detail. But the long and the short of

Speaker 1it is that Mike Lee and his friends are on their bullshit again. This time, it is with a bipartisan bill which normally speeds up permitting, but in practice makes much, massive concessions in treaty rights for indigenous people. It waives cornerstone environmental endangered species laws, stops the judiciary having power to slow down or stop projects which violate things like the Endangered Species Act, the National Register of Historic Places, NEPA, all these absolutely cornerstone pieces of legislation which protect the

Speaker 1land and animals and indigenous people. It is couched in language about green energy and but it could equally well be used for data centers and pipelines. And you know, that's what it's going to end up being used for, right? This is a really bad piece of legislation, and it passed with three quarters of the vote in the Senate. Yeah, listen to my other episode for more on how bad it is and what you can do to oppose it.

Speaker 11Let's go on an ad break and then return for some more news. We are back. Let's let's stick on the Trump Washington, D.C. train here and talk about Trump's 60 Minutes interview. The first sit down interview since the election with New York Times conservative columnist Ross Douthat, who

Speaker 11was added to the 60 Minutes roster by the Weiss Brain Trust earlier this year. He did not a terrible job, frankly. I think because he comes from this notable conservative background, he was able to kind of have more leeway with Trump than some other interviewers. You know, under no circumstances do you got to hand it to Ross. But this was not a terrible piece of interview journalism, I suppose. Right off the bat, Trump blames the Republicans' midterm defeat on the fact that he was not on the ballot,

Speaker 11as he has been saying continually. Though Trump did list a few other reasons for their loss, including that voters, quote, didn't like the candidates, didn't like the war, and didn't like the fact that gasoline went up, unquote. Some stunning analysis there from the president. Early on and throughout the interview, Trump boasted about how good the economy actually is, claiming that we have, quote, historically good numbers and lamented Republicans, quote, bad messaging around the economy.

Speaker 10The numbers that we have are historically good numbers. I think it was bad messaging, maybe by me, but I would talk about it all the time.

Speaker 9So I don't know how much can I talk about it?

Speaker 10Look, the press doesn't cover positive news for Republicans.

Speaker 11He has been talking about it all the time. And that's part of the issue. Voters have heard from Trump and other Republicans. They have heard their message about how great the economy is. But that message has not resonated with working people. Previously, Trump has called affordability concerns a hoax. And Jim Jordan, the upcoming Republican minority leader, responded to rising gas prices by saying, that's life.

Speaker 5Great stuff.

Speaker 11But in this 60 Minutes interview, Trump complains that his administration and Republican candidates just, quote, couldn't get the word across about the, quote, highest stock market in history.

Speaker 5Jesus Christ.

Speaker 10We have created wealth at a level that our country has never seen before.

Speaker 15Including for yourself. There's a Forbes story that said that your net worth... maybe it's changed with the stock market recently, but your net worth went up by $ 3 billion.

Speaker 5Since you returned.

Speaker 9Okay, you ready?

Speaker 15My net worth did not go up by $ 3 billion.

Speaker 10Well, you should have had stock.

Speaker 5I should have had stock.

Speaker 9Excuse me.

Speaker 15How did it go up by $ 3 billion?

Speaker 9Well, let me explain. I devote almost no time to my net worth. I don't care.

Speaker 10I have a lot of money and far more than I ever thought I'd have. And I guess it's gone up.

Speaker 9I don't even know. Incredible.

Speaker 8Incredible.

Speaker 2Incredible.

Speaker 5That's why they lost the election, man.

Speaker 8Like among other things, but like.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5Shitting on people for being poor.

Speaker 11Should have had stock losers. Like, yeah, this is this exact same mistake that Biden, Harris and the Democrats made during the era of like Joe Flation.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 11With with these tone deaf statements about how Bidenomics is working.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 11This is the problem with like like the so-called K-shaped economy. Yeah, if you have money, the economy is doing fine. If you don't, if you don't have assets, you are completely fucked.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1Like no one really fucking cares what the stock market's doing if they can't afford to fill up their gas tank.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 11I find it really interesting that Trump comes at this from the point of like, man, I don't know what went wrong. I've been talking about this all the time. How could this not have worked? And like, yeah, it's because you have been talking about it. It's because you're bragging about having an extra $ 3 billion.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 11It's one of the more stunning points of the interview. Now, in terms of the other reasons for why Republicans maybe did not do very well in the midterms, Trump remarked that there, quote, seems to be an incredible dislike for Israel. And on that note, Trump was asked about Vice President Vance's post-election analysis and specifically whether the Iran war was worth losing the midterms.

Speaker 10The only thing I wish he would have said there, if he felt it, and you'd have to ask him about that, But if you had it to do again, would you do it? You know, it's part of a decision making process. And my answer is an emphatic yes, because you can't let Iran have a nuclear weapon. I think historically, this will be a very good decision. Is it a good decision for today and tomorrow?

Speaker 9Maybe not.

Speaker 5Maybe not.

Speaker 11So Trump somewhat signals he somewhat agreed with Vance's post-election screed that we reported on last week, except for this sort of question of like, even if that's all true, is the decision to go to war with Iran, is that still worth it?

Speaker 5And Trump emphatically says, yes.

Speaker 11In an interview later on, I think from this past week, Trump remarked, quote, a lot of people didn't like his, being Vance's, comments. But throughout this 60 Minutes interview, Trump said that he's not looking to escalate the war, claiming that we have, quote, won the war with Iran, and that Iran is, quote, withering away as a country.

Speaker 5Also noting that we.

Speaker 11Were, quote, close to making a deal before the election, insinuating that the election disrupted a deal to officially end the war with Iraq. But in particular, Trump defended his war on Iran on the basis of saving Israel.

Speaker 15Tell me about it.

Speaker 10Israel would not exist except for Donald Trump, because we went in with those beautiful B-2 bombers more than a year ago, And we hit the three sites at the time. You know, I call it nuclear dust. They were loaded up with nuclear dust. They were two weeks away from having a nuclear weapon.

Speaker 2Two weeks.

Speaker 10Fuck.

Speaker 8Two weeks away.

Speaker 2Always are.

Speaker 5Yeah, the perpetual two weeks.

Speaker 1Must really suck if you're an Iranian scientist who has spent your entire career just stuck at that fortnight period.

Speaker 11You're always doing the ultimate mythos of his story of you're so close to the top of the hill and the U.S. comes in, rolls the boulder back down. I'm going to skip ahead like 40 seconds to the next thing Trump says.

Speaker 10We decapitated their nuclear arsenal. If I didn't do that, there would be no Israel right now. Israel would be gone.

Speaker 5Great stuff.

Speaker 11There he was specifically defending the choice to do the decapitation strikes in that section. Trump reiterated one of these things that we've always heard, that Iran would use a nuclear weapon in 24 hours after they have one. Quote, just like the Democrats will terminate the filibuster once they take power. It's his equivocation there. One of the more interesting moments towards the end of the interview is something that I think Trump was alluding to in that earlier clip that we played. Trump claimed that we haven't lost

Speaker 11a single soldier yet. in six months.

Speaker 9You know, when you call it a war, it's not a war.

Speaker 10If you look at what's happened with Iran in the last six months, five months, six months, we haven't lost one soldier.

Speaker 9You know, I wrote one thing down.

Speaker 5Wait, can we just give you a second?

Speaker 1Because you just pulled out, for those of you listening at home, a piece of paper.

Speaker 5What's he got written down, Garrison? This is a paper with.

Speaker 11The list of fatalities from our previous wars in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan. That was what he was talking about in that press conference that we played earlier. I can show you guys here.

Speaker 10So we've been in Iran seven months, maybe eight months. There have been 18 people, and that includes Venezuela.

Speaker 11He's talking about 18 deaths, and those 18 deaths are from the first wave of engagement from February to July, in which 18 U.S. service members died. Last month, the DoD updated their defense casualty analysis system. raising the official Iran War U.S. Service Number-related death toll to 23 people since February 2026, with at least eight overseas casualties since July 7th.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 11So Trump's statement about not having a single soldier dying... in the past six months.

Speaker 5Including four KIA, right?

Speaker 11I believe, I mean, I don't have that in the doc, so I wouldn't say, but if you're looking. I'm looking at DCATS right now.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1That's Overseas Operational KFC starting July 7th. And like, just before anyone comes in and goes, what if there are Marines, four Army, and I think one Navy, which is non-hostile death pending. Two Air Force non-hostile deaths.

Speaker 11It's kind of nitpicky, but I thought this is such like a specific claim that Trump kind of had the entire last five minutes of the interview kind of based on, it's just not true. It's just not a true statement. That was kind of his big closing argument. And then you see him echoing that in that press conference that James played earlier this episode. Yeah. He also adds in the quote-unquote war with Venezuela in these numbers.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 5Being like, no one died in our war with Venezuela.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1And DCAS breaks it down by operation. So you can see like Operation Epic Fury versus overseas operations. But like not necessarily everyone deployed all around the world, like even in that region since February will be under Epic Fury, right?

Speaker 5Well, it's a sort of thing.

Speaker 11It's like they want to have their cake and eat it too if it's a totally different war. So, you know, this one specific war that you claimed is only in this certain time period.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Well, there were three wars. Three wars that they've done since February, I think.

Speaker 5Yeah, see.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 9Mm-hmm. Anyway.

Speaker 5Yeah. Still very silly semantics.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1And imagine, like, if you had lost a family member, and he's like, yeah, there's only 18 of them. Like, it's a fucking insane thing to say.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 11Yeah, or the eight others who are confirmed to have died since July, which Trump is just not counting. Yeah. On the topic of war, Trump reiterated that we are very close to a deal in Ukraine that and claimed that he didn't know who slowed Ukraine's Starlink speeds, noting that they have been restored. One of the things Trump was most proud of in this interview was winning the, quote, less than one hour war with Venezuela, and said that since winning, the U.S. has taken out billions.

Speaker 10Billions and billions and billions of dollars already, and we will be taking out many billions of dollars and get along very well.

Speaker 9And you could call it a territory, you could call it whatever you want.

Speaker 11You could call it a territory. You could call it whatever you want. So insinuating that Venezuela is effectively a U.S.

Speaker 5Territory now.

Speaker 2They're just like me for real.

Speaker 5Unfortunately, it seems so. Yeah, really, really quickly there.

Speaker 2I want to highlight that earlier this week, NYT released the report stating that quote, the U.S. government received more than $ 12 billion in revenue from Venezuela's natural resource exports in the first nine months of this year, end quote, and that the vast majority of funds were distributed back to Venezuela soon after they were received. But it is unclear if the money stayed in the country or who the ultimate recipients were.

Speaker 11Yeah, I mean, he certainly has not stopped bragging about the amount of oil that they're taking out. Not a great situation in general, and the territory comment is really... Everyone's sick of headlines about a crazy thing Trump said, but he did just call a sovereign country a U.S.

Speaker 4Territory.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 2I talked with James about this in the episodes we did, but it's like he just wants to make it a vassal state without like, well, I guess he now is, he's close enough to calling it a vassal state, but he just doesn't want to, or I guess the U.S. government as a whole doesn't actually want to put that out there. But if Trump says it, since everyone thinks everything he says is an exaggeration, they're okay with with saying it, but it's like, it's essentially what he's doing to Venezuela and trying to do in several other places as well.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5Bonkers.

Speaker 1That like, this is the president just being like, yep, got new territory over here.

Speaker 5Expanding, expanding the empire.

Speaker 8You can call whatever you want.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 11Now, Trump claimed that success in Venezuela had nothing to do with his decision to do decapitation strikes in Iran months later and defended Hegseth against calls for him to be impeached. Near the end of the interview, Trump, Trump said that he expects to issue, quote, tremendous numbers of pardons before leaving office, and that he might pardon himself. He did also indicate that there will be White House personnel changes following the midterm defeat, and that he'll be firing some of the people on his team.

Speaker 15After a big midterm defeat like this, do you expect to fire anyone from your team?

Speaker 11I do.

Speaker 9A little bit.

Speaker 5A little bit?

Speaker 9I love my cabinet. I think they're good. But I'll be doing maybe a few changes.

Speaker 11So this 60 Minutes interview was filmed Friday, and that afternoon, Trump announced that Stephen Miller would be promoted to chief of staff, with former chief of staff Susie Willis being moved over to Trump's political operation. Miller assumed his new position on Monday. Trump told reporters, quote, I wanted to make a change. I think Susie has done a very good job, but I just wanted to make it. Stephen's been great, and we gotta make moves. Sometimes in life, you have to make moves. Later that day, Trump admin-aligned

Speaker 11influencer Benny Johnson tweeted, Everyone in the White House keeps texting me. It's Miller time, with excited anticipation. It's like the dogs have been let off the chain. Good people on the inside are hyped.

Speaker 4Unquote.

Speaker 5It's not a good look. Go ahead, Carlos.

Speaker 2I mean, yeah, I agree with James. It's not a good look at all. It's pretty bad stuff, but I think this might mean that He's going to be let off the hook with whatever the U.S. does internationally, right? We just saw Trump call Venezuela territory of the U.S., you know?

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2And the U.S. is supporting a lot of bad stuff in a bunch of countries in Latin America. And I think that Miller only wants to do more of that. And being chief of staff will only... help him in doing that.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 1Like it, it also signals that like, like a lot of people have left the administration in the week since we last recorded, right. Especially at the DOJ and like the direction that they are moving to fill those gaps is doubling down on the worst things that they've done so far, at least with Miller, right? Like Miller has been behind many of the most egregious policies of Trump 1.0 and 2.0. And he's just been kind of slowly climbing that ladder. And seeing him have all this control,

Speaker 1some stuff that I've heard about him exercising very direct control in relatively minor policy areas, it's concerning for sure.

Speaker 11Yeah, I mean, he already was, I think, deputy chief of staff. He's a very, very high up advisor to the Department of Homeland Security and many other policy areas.

Speaker 1Yeah, he had this kind of floater mandate for a while where he was very clearly running a lot of shows. Like Miller is credited with Title 42, for example, right?

Speaker 11Yeah, he's been very obsessed with finding these sorts of like old kind of niche legal justifications for extreme uses of executive power.

Speaker 1Yeah i think of it like um like reddit law almost you know where people are like oh well if there's a fringe on the flag it's actually the admiralty flag so you're being tried under like it's like that but he's uh He's repeatedly struck the landing on it.

Speaker 11Obviously, Susie Willis's politics aren't great either, but she is somewhat more of kind of like an adult in the room type person in the cabinet. And moving Miller up to her position is further centralizing Miller's influence over the entirety of the Trump administration. And it's something that I'm sure we will be keeping an eye on these next two years. And this Miller news is especially interesting to me, considering what I would consider to be the most interesting

Speaker 11part of this 60 Minutes interview, where Trump discusses working with Democrats on immigration and somewhat admitted that his immigration enforcement these past two years has been, quote, too tough.

Speaker 5This is a longer clip.

Speaker 11I'll probably split up into two sections, but I think this is the most useful thing to take out of this whole interview. And for the record, I'll be playing the on-air version of this interview, which edits down this exchange a little bit. from the full extended version, which I've been pulling the other clips from.

Speaker 15You came out after the midterms. You congratulated the Democrats. You said that you were open to working with them.

Speaker 9True.

Speaker 15What is one thing you would like to work with a Democratic majority on?

Speaker 9I'd love to do something on immigration.

Speaker 3What?

Speaker 9Because, well.

Speaker 15Do you think immigration hurt you in the midterm? Do you think the crackdown hurt you?

Speaker 5I think it both.

Speaker 9Helped and hurt.

Speaker 10I think I got an A-plus for closing up the border. I get very high marks for getting the bad ones out. But I get hurt because we also took people that had good jobs that created one violation or breaking of the law, and that was that they came into the country illegally. Now, there is a large part of the country that think that they should be put out. And there's a large part of the country that think that they should be allowed to stay if they're good people working in a landscaping company or working in a hotel

Speaker 10or doing something, right? And in some cases paying taxes. And there's a large group of people think that they should be allowed to stay.

Speaker 5He went straight to landscaping as a migrant business, right? Mm-hmm.

Speaker 1It's a lot of tropes here, but it is interesting to see. I read somewhere that his wife had had some friends deported.

Speaker 5Yes, I guess I've also seen that.

Speaker 1And perhaps that's been the whispering in his ear. It interests me more from the perspective of his information diet.

Speaker 9Totally.

Speaker 1That he's heard this and that he's thinking this.

Speaker 11I shared this clip with our Cool Zone chat a few days ago. And yeah, I think Mia pointed out that he often seems to have this sort of last person in the room syndrome.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 11If he just kind of believes or parrots whatever the last thing someone told him is. And I'm sure after the election, he's being told a lot of things. Miller's still in his ear and in his ear more now that he's, you know, chief of staff. But the way he's talking in this interview seems to be to almost counter some of the things that you often hear Miller say. And Miller gets alluded to in the second half of this clip, which I'll play now.

Speaker 15So you think your deportation policy went too far?

Speaker 5It was too tough.

Speaker 9I think it might be too tough, yeah.

Speaker 5What would happen? What does the deal look like with the Democrats?

Speaker 10I think ultimately that hurt me. Well, the deal would be we would work something out. And I think that's something that's actually doable.

Speaker 15Doable to create some kind of legal status for the landscapers?

Speaker 10When you go into a hotel and you have a woman that's worked there as a maid, as a cleaner, as a this, as a that, as a waitress, a lot of good things, great jobs. And all of a sudden, they're being taken out of the country.

Speaker 9It's tough. It's a tough thing.

Speaker 10But there's a group of people that I would say on the sort of pretty far right, that would like everybody taken out.

Speaker 15Do any of those people work in your administration? Are they in the building with us right now?

Speaker 9No, no. Well, there are a lot of those people.

Speaker 10Then there's also people that are more modified on that. In other words, get the killers out, get all the rough ones out, get the drug dealers out, but let the people that are here, and in some cases here for 10 and 15 years, work a deal for them.

Speaker 15You think the Democratic Party right now has people in it Who would be interested in this kind of deal?

Speaker 10I think so, yeah. People have already called me.

Speaker 1The way that both of them engage with migrants through these tropes is super telling, right? The landscapers and the maids. It's just such a stereotype that that's how they understand migration. That these are people who come to the menial jobs that Americans don't want to do. And to be fair, a lot of liberals do too, right? You'll see this a lot from libs. Like, oh, do you want to pick your own strawberries?

Speaker 8Fuck you.

Speaker 1Like, but, I don't know, Reagan did a fucking, you know, like Reagan did an amnesty.

Speaker 11Yeah, I mean, and it seems that's kind of what they're alluding to somewhat. The 47 rapid response Twitter account rebuffed the use of the term, like, amnesty in discussing this specific exchange on Twitter.

Speaker 5I don't know who's running that account. I'm sure someone does.

Speaker 11But, I mean, it seems like effectively that Ross is proposing some sort of amnesty deal with the Democrats, which Trump seems, or said that he is... is interested in pursuing. It's a really interesting clip. He's talking about how there's people on the quote, pretty far right in his administration who believe that just everyone, everyone should be taken out. And then talks about this more like moderate approach, which he might pursue with the Democrats. It makes me, you know, question how much Trump is like a popularist, which is not just like a populist, but, just chases what he

Speaker 11thinks is popular.

Speaker 5Yeah, is he following or leading?

Speaker 9Mm-hmm.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 1This dude's political career launched, right, with him riding sideways down an escalator shit-talking Mexican people.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1This has been the one through line of his politics, more or less, right? He's completely pivoted, including wars, right? But he has always found electoral success through bigotry. and through shit talking migrants. So like, it would be a huge challenge to his base if he went ahead and did that. At the same time, like I think Garrison, like you have a really good point that like, he also likes to be associated with winning. We saw that

Speaker 1when he was like hanging out with SoRan, right? Like, and if he thinks he can go out being the guy who did a mass legalization and fucking bask in that forever, Is anything if not unpredictable, you know, like maybe I've done double negative there.

Speaker 11This is the argument that Sanders has been making to people just assuming that if the Senate passes any sort of progressive legislation or populist legislation, Trump will veto it. And And Sanders has been saying, well, if he does, fine. The Senate should still pass that legislation. That shouldn't prevent us from doing anything. But also kind of push on this idea of Trump likes things that are popular. And if this legislation has popular support, people might be surprised at what things he allows to pass or signs on to even. And the idea that, you know, some of

Speaker 11Trump's image might get rehabilitated in the last two years by signing on to, you know, economic populist proposals. That's like a whole other issue that we'll have to deal with.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 11But it is an interesting question. And I think the last two years of the second Trump term might end up looking quite different in the first two years because of the way the balance in Washington has shifted.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's really worth highlighting what y'all said earlier that He really just kind of parrots whatever the last person to talk to him was, because on the 9th, which was Monday, I believe, he said that there won't be amnesty to reporters at the White House. So I really think it really is just the last person who talked to him. But I do agree that if somebody spins it to him continuously as something that will make him go out as a winner, as somebody who's celebrated because of the amnesty, it's something that He won't throw

Speaker 2off the table. Someone just needs to like repeat it for him again and again and again.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 11Or like how much of it's like based on this word amnesty versus a policy that is effectively similar.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5You know, this will be also that we need to fight over.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 11He talks about doing this for people who've been here like 10 or 15 years. It should not be limited to people who've been here 10 years. This is still something we'll have to fight over. And you're going to deal with the fact that, let's say you put that on the table, right?

Speaker 1And you are Donald Trump. And you say, come to assure us you've been here for 10 to 15 years and we'll legalize it.

Speaker 5People are fucking... People aren't going out to get their groceries.

Speaker 1My friends are buying groceries and taking people's kids to school. The ability of his government to do that is very.

Speaker 5Limited right now.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 5Which I think he probably is not being told by his little... Talking heads.

Speaker 7No.

Speaker 11I don't think that's something he is aware of or would necessarily care about, right? He doesn't think about buying groceries.

Speaker 1Every time he talks about buying groceries, it's great. It's a fucking insight into another world. But I'll play this last clip. Ross kind of grills Trump on his ability to actually work with Democrats. Asking Trump if he himself thinks he'll be able to work with Democrats. And it has the overall vibe of talking to your child about name-calling. I think this also shows, I think, Ross's limited view of what politics is and kind of puts him on his ass to a certain extent.

Speaker 5But it is, you know what, it is funny.

Speaker 15In the course of the campaign, you did occasionally call him Talafrico.

Speaker 9Yeah, I did.

Speaker 15Do you think you could work with it? Democrats without insulting them consistently?

Speaker 9Yeah, I could.

Speaker 5You think so?

Speaker 9I also call many of them Democrats.

Speaker 5You did that just the other day.

Speaker 15If it took six months of not insulting the Democrats to get a deal done, do you think you could do it?

Speaker 9Very easily. Okay.

Speaker 5Oh, Ross is coming in with the fucking dad talk. It's a little wild.

Speaker 1No fucking allowance for Donald Trump for six months if he calls him Califrico.

Speaker 11We will never pass any bill that helps working people if you use a bad word.

Speaker 5No name calling or else everyone's fucked.

Speaker 1Have you guys seen the TikTok rapper with the Talafrico rap song?

Speaker 9Oh, yes.

Speaker 2It is amazing. It's such an earworm.

Speaker 5Yeah, it's outstanding.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 11But the second half of this clip actually gets into something a little bit more, I think, deeper, a bit more of an interesting question of will Trump be able to actually work with Democrats again? as Democrats are investigating his administration, right? Doing this sort of like accountability stuff that we discussed last week.

Speaker 5That'll be interesting to watch. I'm here to help the country.

Speaker 15Do you think you could do it if they're investigating you? If they're running investigations into your administration, can you work with them?

Speaker 10Well, I did it for four years. You know, what they did with me was there's never been weaponization. They impeached me twice. And there are those that say that worked out to my advantage. Do you think they'll impeach you again?

Speaker 9I can't imagine it.

Speaker 5What have I done?

Speaker 11So that is the bulk of that interview. There's a lot more funny moments, but if you can check those out yourself. Ross asks him about corruption allegations, world liberty financial, his cryptocurrency, which Trump says he doesn't know anything about the operations of. despite foreign leaders buying his cryptocurrency ostensibly to get favor with the president. Trump talks about the superintelligence race with China, how an AI executive was threatened by the DOJ.

Speaker 1He's going to drop in superintelligence like it's a real fucking thing.

Speaker 11That was a whole five-minute exchange between Ross and Trump was AI versus superintelligence. Trump said that he would, quote, probably but not necessarily endorse someone for president in 2028. in terms of succession, besides Vance, Trump named Rubio, and mentioned some, quote, excellent senators. But overall, he seemed genuinely uncertain of how involved he'll get in selecting the next Republican presidential nominee. Quote, maybe I'm better off not getting involved. And then for some reason, because Ross is still a doofus,

Speaker 11the interview ended by asking Trump about UFOs, which Trump said he's not that much of a believer, and grilled Trump about what he thinks heaven is and if if going to heaven meant forgiving Nancy Pelosi, could he do it?

Speaker 5And Trump said, no. If you have fucking one hour.

Speaker 1With the president of the United States, Russ is talking out the wrong fucking hole for 10 minutes.

Speaker 2That's such an amazing question. Do you think he'll go to heaven?

Speaker 9Not really.

Speaker 11Yeah, there was a big chunk talking about the afterlife and Russ insinuated that Trump will actually be in purgatory near the end of the interview.

Speaker 5So, you know, give him props for that, I guess. It's so long trying to be a journalist, man.

Speaker 1I've been so fucking poor for my entire fucking adult life.

Speaker 11So that's why, you know, couch this by saying as good as Ross did in some sections under no circumstances, do you have to hand it to him?

Speaker 5Yeah, I won't be. All right.

Speaker 1We're going to talk now about habeas. Can we talk a little bit about the DOJ, right?

Speaker 5People leaving.

Speaker 1In a rather wild turn of events, the acting United States Attorney in the Western District of Washington State has folded under the weight of these habeas petitions. Citing a general order in the Western District of Washington which streamlined the process for case assignments and scheduling for writs of habeas corpus filed by people in immigration detention, the acting United States Attorney wrote a letter to his Chief District Judge saying, quote, Since the general order was first issued, However, the influx of immigration petitions has continued to increase. The large volumes of petitions that are being filed, often copying

Speaker 1from other petitions, has severely impacted the government's ability to respond to specific petitions that require appreciable attorney time from the U.S. Attorney's Office to investigate and analyze. It has also negatively impacted the government's ability to respond to other civil litigation filed against the government in the district. So what it's essentially saying there is this volume of petitions has made his office grind to a halt, right?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Going to continue reading the u.s attorney's office unfortunately does not have the available resources at this juncture to continue entering assistant usa attorney appearances in every one of the dozens of immigration petitions filed each week thus going forward in order to conserve resources there will be many habeas cases in which the usa attorney's office will no longer assume responsibility for providing a defense on behalf of the respondents on the other hand for the time being the at The U.S. Attorney's Office will continue to review petitions and scheduling orders as they are filed, will transmit the

Speaker 1scheduling order to the appropriate persons at ICE, and will enter a U.S.A. appearances and far returns to specific petitions as the office determines appropriate.

Speaker 5Can we pause here and just translate that last section into English? Yeah, for sure.

Speaker 1He's saying that because they are so swamped with these things, they will not always be showing up to court.

Speaker 11So they will not be providing the government's argument. Yes, they will not be there on behalf of ICE to say, here is our response. They can't keep showing up like that. They are going to look at them when they come in, but they're not going to show up for all of them. They next say, if the office does not file a notice of appearance in a case within seven court days of the issuance of a standard scheduling order, The court may assume that the USAO will not be filing a response to the petition, and the court may proceed to

Speaker 11rule on the merits of the petition based on the papers filed by the petitioner. So then they're just going to look at the petition, right, and be like, shall we do this or not?

Speaker 1Got it. So they're saying they will take no responsibility for facilitating the processing of this case, nor will it serve as a conduit for communications between the district court and respondents in this case. That would be the detaining party, right? So it would be ICE. The acting US attorney in this case is Charles Neil Floyd. He seems to be referred to in the press by both names. He signs stuff certainly with one name. He's often referred to as Neil Floyd. He was a former immigration judge. People have

Speaker 1referred to him as a former judge, but I think it's relatively pertinent that he was a former immigration judge because in his time doing that, he was way ahead of the Trump administration in denying bonds for people in immigration detention.

Speaker 5So that means they can't get out, right?

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1And he was with a group of four judges in Tacoma who did this. They'd been doing this for like a decade. He essentially... is part of the origination point of that argument that people are applying for admission and that the legal phrase applicant for admission included anybody, not just people entering at the border. This is a justification that we spoke about last summer when we saw court challenges to the Trump administration's mandatory detention, where they're saying we have to detain all of you because everyone is

Speaker 1applying for admission who's an asylee or who's asking for asylum. Let's say you come in on a visa and then ask for asylum. His argument at the time when he started doing this was that people who cross into the United States across the physical border and ask for asylum are detained, so everyone should be. This is the argument that the Trump administration went with, and it bucked decades of precedent. he did that, then he left his job to go work with the FBI for a bit and consult with them on immigration stuff before coming back as

Speaker 1acting USA attorney. So it is notable then to see him caving on this, right?

Speaker 9Sure.

Speaker 1To see him basically saying, when they bring these habeas petitions, which have been the tool, really, right? This has been the wedge that immigration attorneys, that groups have been able to drive to stop not all of the ICE detention by any means, right? There are a shit ton of people in immigration detention who shouldn't be. Well, everyone in immigration detention shouldn't be. But this has been the tool that has succeeded, right?

Speaker 5If you remember.

Speaker 1A few months ago, we talked about the US Attorney's Office in Minnesota, where the attorney asked the judge to hold her in contempt so she could sleep for two hours. This has been happening all over the country. I think we'll probably hear some interesting reporting on how this was organized, how lawyers organized to do this, to respond to a government agency which has effectively an unlimited budget. Somehow, people have been able to flood. I'm not talking about ICE here. ICE has been able to detain so many people. And

Speaker 1people have been able to file enough habeas petitions that it has effectively ground this US attorney's office to a halt. And in order to do anything, it has to stop responding to these. So this is a really interesting move. I mean, the timing coming after the election is somewhat interesting, but I think it's just overall fascinating to see that all across the US, these offices are struggling to deal with the amount of habeas, rates of habeas that are being filed.

Speaker 11Let's go on one more ad break and then return for a special segment by Robert Evans.

Speaker 3Hey everybody, Robert here. On November 8th, 2026, NVIDIA released a unique sort of press release. This one didn't tout a new product line or investment deal or partnership. Instead, titled A Message to Our Company, it contains CEO Jensen Huang's admission of infidelity. He also included apologies to his

Speaker 3colleagues at NVIDIA. as well as the board and shareholders. Only at the bottom of the announcement did he acknowledge the national security concerns raised in news reports and promise that the board was launching an independent investigation into his actions. The specific news reports he referenced are articles from the Financial Times and the New York Times, both published November 6th.

Speaker 3The Financial Times article was titled, U.S. Believes NVIDIA's Huang Had Romantic Relationship With Alleged Chinese Spy. The article revealed that earlier this.

Speaker 9Year, U.S.

Speaker 3Officials wrote a memo based on intel we'd received that Huang had started a romantic liaison with Alice Huang, no relation, an executive at Megaspeed who had previously probably been a TV journalist in China, although that's a little unclear. Alice worked in China's financial sector before taking a job as managing director of Megaspeed.

Speaker 9The U.S.

Speaker 3Intelligence community suspects Alice Huang was recruited as a spy by the Chinese Ministry of State Security. She'd initially drawn spook attention because her Singapore-based data center company, that's Megaspeed, was suspected of moving banned NVIDIA chips to China. Alice was put under surveillance, which is when the Intel people realized Jensen was involved. For their part, the New York Times got onto the story after a 2024 photo from a party Jensen and Alice both attended. There was a clip from that video, and in a CNN interview, Times

Speaker 3reporter Trip Mickel explained that this is what got the ball rolling. Basically, the clip revealed that Alice had the ability to pretty much summon Jensen Huang, one of the most wealthy and powerful men in the world, at a moment, and they thought that was worth looking into. NVIDIA initially declined to comment on the reports, but Chris Coons, a Delaware Democrat senator who will chair the Foreign Relations Committee in January, promised to open an investigation into, in his words, the insane relationship between the Trump administration, Chinese spies, and AI billionaires. According to the New York Times, Trump was

Speaker 3briefed on all of this, that is, the suspicions about Jensen and Alice, a year ago, and shows not to do anything with the information, per the Times.

Speaker 8Quote, Mr.

Speaker 3Trump has been wary of disrupting NVIDIA's chip sales, which are helping to drive the economy and the stock market. It's possible Trump even gave Jensen a warning that the Feds were on to him. Now, this is speculation on my part, But on Monday, Wired published an article revealing that Huang had hired a crisis PR firm, Heller, in October of last year. Per Wired, Risa Heller, the firm's founder, has built a reputation as a fixer for powerful men facing allegations of sexual misconduct and other personal controversies. Her past clients include people like Anthony Weiner, chef Mario Batali,

Speaker 3and writer Jeffrey Toobin. Further New York Times reporting has revealed that the U.S. investigation into Megaspeed started as a Commerce Department inquiry. Tim Teeter, NVIDIA's general counsel, reached out to Commerce Undersecretary Jeffrey Kessler, a Trump appointee, to ask about the investigation in the summer of 2025, that is a few months before Jensen hired a crisis PR firm. And, per Bloomberg, specifically, Teeter wanted to know whether Kessler's Bureau of Industry and Security was involved in the Singapore government's recent detention of Alice Wong, a Megaspeed executive. Singapore police

Speaker 3had brought Alice in for questioning and restricted her from leaving the country. Now, it turns out Kessler's people were completely uninvolved, and because he's a helpful guy, Kessler apparently gave NVIDIA permission to reach out directly about the case to the Commerce Department agents investigating it. Times reporting describes these agents as having been alarmed that NVIDIA lawyers had dropped their boss's name. Bloomberg described the investigation as being muzzled in the weeks after this with, quote, a mandate that they route all requests of NVIDIA through Kessler or

Speaker 3seek his approval for outreach, a highly unusual step that remains unique to the chipmaker, the people said. The investigation was ultimately transferred out of commerce and to the Justice Department. Now, this is obviously rank corruption of the highest order. I guess we're all pretty used to that from this administration at this point. My suspicion is they didn't think it would ever come up. Now, before we go further, I should address the obvious question some of you might have right now. Why does the Chinese government want to spy on and influence Jensen Huang so badly? Well, it all

Speaker 3comes down to the fact that China wants NVIDIA's advanced AI chips, and the US government won't let NVIDIA sell those chips in China. For a write-up in TechCrunch, Historically, China has been a big market for the company. It has shrunk in recent years due to strict US export controls and an aggressive push by Beijing for domestic alternatives. In the three months ending on July 26th, NVIDIA recorded $ 7. 9 billion in revenue from customers headquartered in China, roughly 8% of total revenue. Wang has repeatedly lobbied the U.S. government to expand access to China, and some of his persuasion

Speaker 3tactics have been successful. Wang met repeatedly with President Donald Trump and administration officials last year. Afterward, the government reversed restrictions on NVIDIA's H20 chips and allowed exports of its more powerful H200 processors. So Jensen is on the record calling U.S. export controls to China a failure and unwise. He's warned that if NVIDIA can't sell chips to China, the country will simply develop its own AI chips and challenge NVIDIA's international dominance. I don't really think you need to have foreign influence to explain why Jensen wants to sell his products more widely to a massive market, but

Speaker 3it also makes it very clear why he's the kind of guy China would devote resources to influencing. In the immediate wake of the announcement, Jensen pulled out of several speaking engagements. Journalists at The Information followed the money and found that Alice Wong's family own a network of Chinese companies that buy NVIDIA chips, including banned ones. Shanghai Century Letong, one of these companies, is an NVIDIA preferred cloud partner who purchased some $ 7. 5 billion worth of NVIDIA chips. Per TechCrunch, NVIDIA's head lawyer, Tim Teeter, intervened in a 2025 U.S.

Speaker 3government probe surrounding the suspected smuggling of AI chips by Megaspeed International. In early 2025, Alice Huang and a business partner sought China-based investors for an Asian data center, promising they had no problem in securing GPUs, the Financial Times reported. Trump responded to this whole blow-up by calling Jensen a fine person and adding, but you never know what's going on. Still, he expressed a belief that Huang should remain CEO of NVIDIA.

Speaker 2However, U.S.

Speaker 3Officials aren't just worried that Huang helped China get access to forbidden AI chips. For the New York Times, the revelation that she was feeding information directly to Beijing raised more troubling possibilities, including that Mr. Huang had insights into Mr. Trump's thinking on an issue of vital importance to both nations, one likely to come up when the president visits China next month. And it left questions about whether she could be gleaning information about NVIDIA, which, as much as any company, accounts for the lead the United States has maintained in developing cutting-edge AI models. Now, the New York Times reporting

Speaker 3also confirms that Huang never received what's called a defensive briefing. These are warnings given to Americans being targeted by foreign or likely to be targeted by foreign intelligence services. And the fact that he didn't get one of these is weird and maybe suggests that the U.S. government was well aware of this relationship. At least people in Trump's part.

Speaker 4Of the U.S.

Speaker 3Government were well aware of this relationship.

Speaker 4On Tuesday.

Speaker 3NVIDIA announced that they'd hired former acting U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, June Kim, to conduct their independent investigation into Huang's activities. Kim had joined the Wachtel Lipton law firm just last month. His prior career highlights include the prosecution of rapper DMX over tax evasion charges and the investigation into sexual harassment allegations made against Andrew Cuomo. Megaspeed, for their part, have denied any wrongdoing and insist Mrs. Huang has largely been removed from the company since the start of the investigation. The Chinese embassy

Speaker 3calls any claims of spying groundless smears and slanders. Nvidia's stock price fell sharply after Huang's little press release, dropping by around 4%, although I should note it's down some 22% over all in the last month. That's around $ 1. 7 trillion in value, and it's down around 5% over the course of the year. This whole blowup cost Jensen about $ 13 billion in speculative net worth just in its first day or so. By Tuesday, Nvidia's stock continued to plunge, down almost 10%, which made Huang's loss in net worth around

Speaker 3$ 17 billion after two news days of trading. This has all caused some analysts and pundits to wonder, is the Huang Huang affair serious enough to pop the AI bubble? Could this be the most expensive affair of all time? And so far, I mean, no. It still costs less real money, not stock value, real money, than the Jeff Bezos infidelity that led to his breakup with McKinsey or Bill Gates' Epstein-inspired divorce. But the point is a valid one. Huang is, more than anyone, the poster boy for the AI boom. While every frontier company continues to lose billions

Speaker 3of dollars every year, NVIDIA has made an incomprehensible fortune. Per an article in The New Yorker, In Silicon Valley and on Wall Street, many people associate NVIDIA and its success almost entirely with Huang, who founded the company in 1993 and who hasn't made any succession plans. In many ways, Jensen is NVIDIA's Steve Jobs, Daniel Newman, the CEO of Futurum Group, a tech advisory firm, told the Wall Street Journal. Given Huang's importance to his company, it is perhaps surprising that NVIDIA's stock didn't fall by even more. When the rival chipmaker Intel issued weak earnings guidance last month, its

Speaker 3shares plunged by about 30%. The AI industry seems to be rallying around Jensen, or at least initially seemed to be rallying around Jensen. Venture capitalist and MAGA weirdo Sean McGuire called him irreplaceable for America's AI leadership. But it's worth noting that on Monday, as Nvidia's stock plunged, the overall AI market rallied and the NASDAQ closed up by 2.75%. Now, I'd be remiss if I didn't include some of Ed Zitron's reporting on this. You can read it on where'syoured.at, or you can listen to Better Offline. But his recent article,

Speaker 3Jensen's Bizarre Adventure, includes some important notes, among them the fact that Megaspeed is NVIDIA's largest Southeast Asian customer. Earlier this year, Coper Research took a short position on NVIDIA, arguing that their indirect sales to mainland China were a major part of NVIDIA's revenue. How major? Around $ 43 billion this year, although NVIDIA officially claims their revenue for these kinds of sales to China is zero. As Ed notes, this means 20% of the largest company on the stock market's revenue comes from illicit sales to China.

Speaker 5This is all a really.

Speaker 3Big deal, and since I finished writing this on Tuesday over the course of just like Today, Wednesday, when I recorded it, it came out that Jensen's had another affair. The Wall Street Journal was able to get five Nvidia employees on the record talking about this other affair with an Nvidia employee, a subordinate of his. And now things have moved. There's been some articles saying that the board's looking to remove him. Things are not looking good for Jensen right now. This is much bigger. I really need to emphasize much bigger than infidelity. The real story here

Speaker 3is the massive amount of chips that NVIDIA has been illegally selling to China, almost certainly with Jensen's explicit guidance and almost certainly with at least the tacit acceptance of the White House. Now, why would Trump do this? One possibility is that he's getting kickbacks, right? We have to at least look into the possibility when we're talking about Donald Trump. But I could see him supporting this and supporting Jensen breaking the law just because NVIDIA is so fucking.

Speaker 9Crucial to the U.S.

Speaker 3Economy right now and Trump wants number go up. We don't know exactly what the fallout from this is going to be, but this is looking like it could be one of the larger scandals of our lifetime. And this is certainly something that it could happen here. We'll continue to cover. I also, again, would recommend checking in with Ed Zitron's Better Offline. But yeah, something to keep an eye on.

Speaker 5Thank you, Robert. Thoughts and prayers with Jensen.

Speaker 11Hey, Garrison here with a quick update because on Thursday morning, Jensen Huang officially resigned as CEO and president of NVIDIA. And then later that day, Reuters reported that Huang had another affair with a second subordinate at NVIDIA. The stonk market is not taking the news well. Carlos, do you want to close us out with your reporting?

Speaker 2Yes, absolutely. So I'm going to be talking about what El Salvador is doing in Haiti. I'm compressing a lot of stuff here, but here's the basics. At the tail end of October, El Salvador's President Nayib Bukele deployed more than 2,000 soldiers to Haiti to ostensibly find four Salvadoran soldiers from the United Nations Gang Suppression Force, or GSF, that were reportedly kidnapped by Haitian gangs while returning from a market in Croix de Bouquet, which is near the

Speaker 2Haitian capital of Port-au-Prince. This 2000 is a massive escalation of the 100 special forces troops that were deployed a couple days after the four soldiers were kidnapped on October 18th. In total, per the AP, there's roughly 2,500 Salvadoran soldiers in Haiti currently. However, there's very little transparency or oversight on these troops, which has led many people to question who these troops answer to and what they're actually meant to do there. Per the Miami Herald, speaking with the

Speaker 2UN spokesperson Stéphane Dujarric, only about 200 of the Salvadoran soldiers deployed to Haiti fall under the GSF's mandate. Bukele reportedly sent these troops into Haiti without signing an agreement with the Haitian government, although Haitian Prime Minister Alix Didier Filzami has come to back the Salvadoran deployment because of its, quote, commitment of the Salvadoran forces in the fight against gangs, end quote. This praise came after Salvadoran troops bombed the headquarters of the 400 Mawoso, one of Haiti's most powerful gangs,

Speaker 2as well as the house of its leader, Wilson Joseph, which is on the same compound. However, per the AFB, Joseph was not present at the time of the strike. What's particularly interesting, and I guess incredibly gruesome about the whole thing, is that the idea to strike the compound appears to have happened because a Twitter account asked Bukele to hit it. On November 5th, an account posted a picture of Joseph's house with a caption in Haitian Creole saying that it was built in front of people's faces by a, quote, gang leader involved in kidnappings and assassinations,

Speaker 2end quote. A day later, Bukele, quote, tweeted the post asking, in Haitian Creole, quote, where is that house located? Give us the exact address and we'll destroy it, end quote. After that, several accounts commented the coordinates. Then, on November 10th, Bukele posted a video of Salvadoran troops firing missiles at the house and striking the structure with the caption, quote, we fulfilled our promise, end quote. It's worth noting that per the Miami Herald, the attack was a joint operation

Speaker 2between the Haitian National Police's drone task force and the Salvadoran troops. Two of the helicopters that participated in the attack were operated by the task force and the other two were operated by the Salvadoran soldiers. It's notable that the video that Bucala posted shows presumably a Salvadoran soldier aboard a small helicopter.

Speaker 5Yeah, it's a weird helicopter choice. I don't know what helicopters they have available to them.

Speaker 2Yeah, no, it's, it's extremely little. There's, there's not took a little bit that much reporting on if this is a Salvadoran helicopter, but that seems to be the case.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 2The tactic place while task force soldiers were deployed on the ground, a source told the Miami Herald, at least 20 people were reportedly killed by the strikes. So before I go on to talk about Salvadoran troops, I really want to quickly mention that the task force works directly under the office of the prime minister, and it's supported by the private security firm Vectis Global, which was founded by Eric Prince, who also founded Blackwater, which is now part of Constellus Group. If people aren't familiar with Blackwater,

Speaker 2they're the PMC that killed 17 Iraqi civilians in Baghdad's Nisr Square in 2007. Prince and his group have been in Haiti since at least March of 2025. because they were hired by Haiti's interim government to work on the drone task force, which has executed over 2,000 strikes. Per data from the Human Rights Watch, at least 1,243 people have been killed by the strikes between March 2025 and January 2026, including at least 43 civilian adults and 17 children.

Speaker 2So if you're keeping track at home, there's at least five separate security forces currently operating on the ground in Haiti. The Haitian police and the Haitian military, the gang suppression force, formerly known as the Multinational Security Support Mission, Vectis Global, and the newly deployed Salvadoran forces. I'm going to work on a longer episode about this at some point, but for the rest of my segment, I want to focus on the Salvadoran troops and what Bukele actually wants them to do there. Per Axios and their bullet points, Bukele, who is a longtime ally of Trump, has received the U.S.

Speaker 2president's full support for the deployment. Trump said, quote, you have to do what you have to do. However, the State Department and El Salvador have reportedly hit a rough patch after a gang attack on a Salvadoran convoy led to the U.S. embassy in Haiti being struck by gunfire. David Howell, the U.S. charge d'affaires, which is basically a diplomat in charge of an embassy when the ambassador is absent, reportedly texted Haitian Prime Minister Didier Fils-Aimé, quote, they, as

Speaker 2in the Salvadoran forces, took at least three casualties. They don't have a medical plan. They nearly killed GSF troops, end quote, and asked them to stop operations as soon as possible, ellipses, until they coordinate. They are going to kill GSF troops or civilians and or get themselves killed. Since then, there appear to be some pretty petty back-and-forth messages going on behind the scenes between the State Department and El Salvador. Bukele denies his troops hit the embassy

Speaker 2and that any of his troops were injured, although Axis' reporter claims he saw a picture of an injured Salvadoran soldier. Bukele also said that he's been coordinating air assets with the GSF and the Haitian government since the tail end of October. which appears to line up with the details we know of the attack on the 400 Mawoso headquarters. I should mention that, per Joseph, the four missing Salvadoran soldiers were killed, quote-unquote, in error by another gang, and four charred bodies were handed over to the GSF, but

Speaker 2there's been no independent confirmation to see if they are or aren't the same soldiers. For his part, Bukele claims they aren't. To get a sense of what Bukele is trying to accomplish in Haiti, It seems clear to me that he has really little care for what happened to these four soldiers, but is very much using their kidnapping as an excuse to portray himself and El Salvador as a regional military power that is able to quote-unquote solve gang problems like no other country can. If people aren't familiar,

Speaker 2Bukele reign in El Salvador has been defined by him suspending the constitution and detaining more than 1% of the country's total population, according to the AP. Per reporting by El Faro, which is a group of journalists that have since been exiled from the country because of their reporting, Bukele and his government negotiated extensively with the gangs including reportedly offering gang leaders in prison privileges for reducing the amount of killings and support for his party in gang-controlled areas. He's been praised extensively by right-wing politicians, including Trump, of course.

Speaker 2Bukele is a public relations guy through and through, that's his background, which is why he's trying to present himself as this liberator type who can deploy his manadura politics anywhere he wants, which is why he's responding to people on Twitter and in Haitian Creole and talking about hitting the gangs harder than anyone ever has before. But the truth is that the Haitian gangs appear to be far more organized and entrenched than El Salvador's, so he won't be easily able to do the same thing as he did there, which will likely mean a lot of violence being meted out against anybody perceived as supporting the gangs

Speaker 2or being a gang member. We can't forget that Trump sent more than 200 immigrants to Secot, which is a violent prison in El Salvador.

Speaker 1I got to look at the video again. They are their helicopters. There's a Salvador flag right on the tail. It looks like MD-500s, which it had for a while. That's their Civil War, Salvador Civil War era helicopter. They show them right at the very start in profile. He also today ratioed Amnesty International on his Twitter account.

Speaker 5That's how you know that you're on the good side of history. Yeah.

Speaker 1Quote retweeted them with the word ratioed.

Speaker 2Is this after the post they said asking to make sure that civilians and other people were safe from gang attacks?

Speaker 10Yes.

Speaker 4Oh, my God.

Speaker 5Let me just read it out.

Speaker 1The Prime Minister of Haiti, Alex Didier-Phil Zermier, and the President of El Salvador, Nayib Bukele, must ensure that all operations conducted by Salvadoran forces in Haiti continue. comply with international human rights law he quote retweeted this with the word ratioed jeez cool the people of fucking haiti have suffered so much for colonial bullshit for centuries yeah this just fucking sucks.

Speaker 2I mean even in this century this is the second un sponsored mission that has uh entrenched itself in haiti.

Speaker 1Yeah i mean since since the earthquake where the uh like the people responding brought infectious disease right like Yeah. It's just like a nonstop parade of suffering for the Haitian. It's such a beautiful country. These lovely people, like, yeah, it really fucking sucks.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2I don't know. To me, it really seems, and I will expand on this somewhere else, but to me, it really seems like Haiti is being used as a testing ground by these kind of, I guess not necessarily smaller powers, but like by El Salvador, it's definitely being used as a testing ground for them to show the world. what they can do. And, like, it's clear that he's mimicking Trump and what he's trying to do in Iran and, I guess, did in Venezuela.

Speaker 1Yeah, he's trying to project himself as, like, Trump's Western Hemisphere enforcer for deniable war crimes, right?

Speaker 2Absolutely.

Speaker 1At the same time, like, Eric Prince is very clearly testing this, like, rent-a-state strategy there. Like, if your state lacks the ability to enforce its rule of law by violence, we will be the violence part.

Speaker 10Like.

Speaker 1It's not a new method for PMCs, right? Like Wagner, Africa Corps have been effectively doing this in Africa for a while. And of course, Margaret Thatcher's kid did it. But it's interesting to see Prince going that route, right? Before it was like, I'll use all my connections in America to make money off doing stuff the US government doesn't want to do with its own troops. But he's clearly moved on from that to like, I'll make money by being your state violence capacity if you don't have one or enough of one in this case.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely. Very well said. And I don't know, I think it's sadly, there doesn't seem to be a clear endpoint for what any of these groups are trying to do in Haiti, other than like the amorphous idea of ending the gang control over Haiti. But, you know, they're very entrenched in the system, both politically and region wise. And there doesn't seem to be a super concrete plan as to how that can actually end. And I guess

Speaker 2the big thing that I've seen Haitians talk about is them not being able to participate in these processes, right? Because a big part of this is supposed to be holding elections again in Haiti, but that seems extremely far off, even though they're planned for next year.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1It's crazy to see El Salvador, like almost acting as like a, like a full service PMC, like complete with carceral capacity, right? Like it, In the same way as a PMC, they don't see it as their role to have a peace plan, right?

Speaker 5Unfortunately, no one seems to, the Haitian people. Or not no one, but all of the people with guns.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 5Carlos, where can people find more of your work online?

Speaker 2You can find me everywhere online at Vaquero2XL, V-A-Q-U-E-R-O 2XL.

Speaker 5And on It Could Happen Here.

Speaker 2That is true. I forgot this the last time as well. Find me on It Can Happen Here on the occasional podcast episode. Thanks for having me on, y'all.

Speaker 5Yeah, you're welcome. If you want to email us, can do. I've been blocking heavily.

Speaker 1I'm returning, actually, to my threat of reading out the email addresses of the next marketing people who continue to spam me. So maybe that'll be a little Thanksgiving treat for you all. But you can email us on coolzontipsatproton.me.

Speaker 5We reported the news.

Speaker 2We reported the news.

Speaker 3Hey, we'll be back Monday with more episodes every week from now until the heat death of the universe.

Speaker 16It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions.

Speaker 5Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    3 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Part Two: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    1 hr 8 minAudio

    Robert concludes the story of Pastor Mackenzie's starvation apocalypse church with a really shocking mass murder.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    1 hr 3 minAudio

    This week Robert takes us to Kenya, and the deadliest cult since the days of Jonestown. Prepare to meet Pastor Paul Mackenzi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Part Two: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    1 hr 25 minAudio

    Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Part One: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    1 hr 10 minAudio

    In this week's harrowing episode, Robert and Soren Bowie explore the life and times of Don Simpson: the man who produced Top Gun and most of the other big hits of the 1980s while being a coked-up devil behind the scenes.

    Credit the people on this episode