Behind the Bastards

Behind the Bastards artwork

It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

3 hr 56 minAudio

All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG You can now listen to all Cool Zone Media shows, 100% ad-free through the Cooler Zone Media subscription, available exclusively on Apple Podcasts. So, open your Apple Podcasts app, search for “Cooler Zone Media” and subscribe today! Sources/Links: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom David’s book: https://orbooks.com/catalog/the-myth-of-red-texas/ Biden and the War on Gaza Akbar Shahid Ahmed’s book: https://wwnorton.com/books/9781324118190 Repression in Iran https://hengaw.org/ https://www.theamargi.com/ Executive Disorder: Everything Breaks, Rohingya Genocide, Mamdani Disbands SRG https://thehill.com/the-120/6227485-sanders-supports-van-hollen-challenge/ https://newsguild.org/unionized-journalists-at-reuters-overwhelmingly-authorize-strike/ https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/11/mayor-mamdani-wins-90-day-extension-to-protect-small-retailers-n https://media.defense.gov/2026/Nov/09/2004025139/-1/-1/1/REFORMING-PROFESSIONAL-MILITARY-EDUCATION-TO-FORGE-WARFIGHTERS-AND-SECURE-VICTORY.PDF https://x.com/syriahr/status/2122313987802927545?a=gbJltRTGzuFRwwoJYx8&s=20 https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/seeking-info/drone-in-restricted-airspace https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/new-zealand-mayor-says-democracy-has-had-its-day-after-china-visit/ar-AA2hFUqM https://x.com/Microsoft/status/2121282013600907325?a=xFkPi44OjVY9wQTc7Xc&s=20 https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/12/business/live-news/microsoft-global-outage-intl-hnk https://x.com/clamanna/status/2122209697226948729 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/11/microsoft-details-how-three-problems-combined-for-a-global-outage/ https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/17/technology/apple-down-outage-issues.html https://www.snopes.com/news/2026/11/16/duffy-son-in-law-company-faa/ https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/the-single-router-in-southern-arkansas-that-ground-air-travel-to-a-halt/ar-AA2hs7wV https://www.business-standard.com/world-news/us-aviation-shutdown-explained-what-caused-the-faa-nationwide-ground-stop-126111601147_1.html https://mashable.com/tech/faa-nationwide-ground-stop-why https://x.com/Chase/status/2122433813955379268 https://thehill.com/business/6226179-chase-outage-software-bug/amp/ https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/17/politics/highly-classified-national-security-communications-network-goes-down https://blog.giovanh.com/blog/2025/10/14/a-hack-is-not-enough/ https://icj-cij.org/case/178 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/18/us-sanctions-icj-judges-myanmar-genocide-ruling-israel-gaza-court https://x.com/USAmbUN/status/2113246764228616559 https://www.state.gov/icc-sanctions/ https://icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/case-related/178/178-20261119-pre-01-00-en.pdf https://x.com/NYCMayor/status/2122298477816504328?s=20 https://legalaidnyc.org/news/mayor-first-steps-protest-policing-reform/ https://x.com/CB_Cotton/status/2122312337986130314?a=L4ZoV5sccOabw3-EE5o&s=20 https://x.com/CB_Cotton/status/2122356466849841254?s=20 https://www.nyclu.org/resources/policy/one-pagers/curb-act-protect-the-right-to-protest-in-nyc https://x.com/avitale/status/2122373841296978008?a=ZUzk_Z8gim94ItUtgOY&s=20 https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/11/mayor-mamdani_and-police-commissionertischdisbandnypd-s-strategi

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Call zone media.

Speaker 2Hey, everybody.

Speaker 3Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode of the week that just happened is here in one convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to listen to in a long stretch if you want. If you've been listening to the episodes every day this week, there's going to be nothing new here for you, but you can make your own decisions.

Speaker 4Welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Garrison Davis. We are talking Blexus, or maybe Red Texas, Red in one of two ways. Red, both Republican Texas, and maybe the other kind of Red Texas as well. And to help with that, I'm joined by David Griscom, host of Left Reckoning and The Jacobin Show, but for our purposes today, also the author of the book, The Myth of Red Texas, Cowboys, Populism, and Class War in the Radical South. which came out

Speaker 4earlier this year. Thank you for coming on, David.

Speaker 1I'm so happy to be here. It's been a hell of a couple of weeks.

Speaker 4I've just blazed through the book in the past two days. Really clear, really clear writing. It's super concise. People should read it. We'll probably plug it.

Speaker 5Again at the end.

Speaker 4Reading this after the election is super interesting because... It's both a reflection on the history of Texas as well as being kind of prophetic. Did you kind of see this coming when you were writing the book?

Speaker 1I mean, I've been involved in kind of Texas politics for a while now. I've seen a lot of potential here. And, you know, I guess it's kind of like if you're watching football on TV and you're yelling, like, they need to run the ball, they need to run the ball, and then they run it 80 yards for a touchdown, right? It's like, all right, they took the advice and, like, it went even better than I had expected.

Speaker 4In the conclusion, you write that there's a path out of GOP control of Texas, but that would require a commitment to economic populism and bottom-up organizing and going outside of corporate PAC spreadsheets. And the way in which that was essentially the playbook that specifically Tallarico did in Texas is super stunning.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, for sure, with Tallarico, for sure, and also with our governor-elect, Gina Hinojosa, I don't have the numbers in front of me, but I was reading recently that I think she spent like $ 5 for every vote that she got and Greg Abbott spent $ 26. So really just like talking about, you know, a very serious kind of bottom-up campaign in the sense that like it wasn't kind of run from DC. It wasn't run by these kind of big consulting agencies. It really was a kind of a homegrown operation and a lot of people doubted

Speaker 1it because of that.

Speaker 4One of like the frustrating things that, we've seen in the weeks after the election is D.C. Democrats trying to claim this whole election as a win for moderates, trying to backpedal the economic populism that is what just won the election. If you look at Tallarico's campaign platform and rhetoric, it's much closer to 2016 Bernie Sanders than Hillary Clinton. And I guess some people might be, I guess, confused

Speaker 4initially of like, how is that rhetoric able to win in Texas? Because they might not be aware of, as is explained in your book, like how rooted in Texas this type of politics is. But why do you think the D.C. Democrats are trying to kind of pull back so much, even though this is the thing that just kind of undid 30 years of precedent?

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think because what happened here was a major threat to the kind of politics that they've been advocating. If you are a Texan or if you follow politics at all, you've probably heard of these kind of phrases like demographics as destiny. And that was the real Democrat strategy in Texas for a long time, that as Anglos kind of declined as the majority population, and particularly the Hispanic population grew, the Democrats would just automatically start winning. We saw that theory just completely blow up in Democrats' faces over not just 2024 is the big one.

Speaker 12024 is when you start to see these like huge swings to the Republican Party. But you actually start to see that in 2020 and 2022. So this idea that like Hispanic voters are automatically going to go to the Democrats because of, I don't know, some kind of identity reasons, that was proven completely false. But what was proven true was that, you know, if you appeal to people on their economic interest, you can actually create a winning coalition across the state. You know, it's funny in politics today, like talking about the economy is coded as quote unquote moderate,

Speaker 1which to me, you know, I'm just putting my cards on the table. Like I'm a socialist. I think about the economy all the time. That's actually kind of fundamental to my politics.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1And, you know, I think it's a left-wing perspective. And, you know, another thing too is like, you know, the Bernie Sanders campaign, you know, the kind of identity politics that dominated the Democratic Party afterwards, that was kind of utilized by the Hillary Clinton campaign. If everyone remembers the famous line, like, what will breaking up the banks do to solve racism? So why is it like our burden, that kind of losing politics on the left? And look, I will just say this, and I'm not trying to be glib. If moderate Democrats and people in positions of power want to start saying that, like, hey, we're going

Speaker 1to start talking about working class issues and economic populism, and that's the new moderation.

Speaker 5Hell, I'll take it.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 4That has also been my reaction is like, if this type of economic populism is the new moderate, then that's like a win for the left, man. That is moving the Overton window on real material politics.

Speaker 1I think it absolutely is. And you look at James Tallarico, and you look at Gina Hinojosa, and both of them kind of grew into this version of politics. You know, Gina was a particularly like liberal member of the ledge here. And obviously everyone's seen the videos of James Tallarico that were beamed across the nation talking about gender. Both of these folks were very much talking about kind of culture war issues and social issues like that. And you saw that they really kind of leaned into the economic populism in this cycle.

Speaker 4Yeah, and that's something that Gina has been very open about, is that this political moment requires us to fully tackle cost of living and economic populism. And she's still pointed to her voting record for her stance on those other social issues. But we are at a very crucial tipping point in America right now. Things are not going good for working people. And if Republicans keep holding on to power, that's just going to keep getting worse. And I think the way that she's outlined why she is just fully

Speaker 4focusing in on this now is really illuminating. And you have someone like Tallarico talking about the 1%, billionaires, trillionaires, buying elections, banning gerrymandering, passing the PRO Act, which would be huge for labor, huge for working people, as well as talking about universal health care, which isn't to say that Democrats like Tallarico.

Speaker 5have all of my.

Speaker 4Preferred policy standpoints isn't really plugged into like a working class organization the way some other candidates across the country are.

Speaker 5And we could talk about that more later.

Speaker 4But the big like difference that I see and you kind of this, your book helps kind of illuminate this is like the difference from like the Beto strategy or God forbid Colin Allred. They're not doing this demographics as destiny idea, right? It's not that you just need to wait for the demographics of the state to change and then activate this new base of naturally democratic voters, whether that's, you know, the growing Hispanic population or suburbs liberalizing, right? It's not that the voters have to change. Rather, the

Speaker 4Democrats have to offer a different kind of politics.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1And I mean, I think, you know, the demographics is destiny. I mean, we could get into it if folks need me to. But like, You know, really, it's just a kind of lazy political idea at the end of the day. It's just saying like, hey, this is a group of people that will just support us no matter what. We don't have to worry about it. And if their numbers grow, we win. Total failed strategy, you know, really disastrous. The other one was Texas is not a red state. It's a non-voting state. And, you know, that also, while very true, like Texas voting has a lot of like restrictions on voting and things like that. You know, you see this

Speaker 1when you look at the polling and especially a lot of non-voters in Texas. They didn't actually tend to be particularly, they weren't necessarily reactionary or right-wing necessarily, but they weren't this kind of like socially liberal Democrat voter and waiting that a lot of folks believed. What they tended to be actually were kind of moderate on many social issues and very much economically populist. And neither party was speaking to those folks. What you see with, you know, Host's campaign and Tallarico's campaign was really actually saying, we're going to convince people, not who we believe are already Democrats

Speaker 1that just need to be kind of activated and motivated to go to the poll, but actually people who might disagree with this or that and actually kind of reach out to them. And, you know, I think in addition to like whether or not that like moved the needle in the final sense, it's also motivating. I think one thing I noted a lot with Tallarico and like his kind of reclamation of Christianity was, you know, It's an open question about how much that actually ends up moving evangelical voters in this election. It certainly moved some of them. You know, it really gave a lot of people a tremendous amount of confidence because it's like, okay, we're fighting,

Speaker 1we're promoting an idea. And like, there's something that we can believe in where a lot of the Democratic, I mean, Chuck Schumer walking around trying to claim victory for this massive, you know, for this massive flip in Texas and all across the country is totally ludicrous because, you know, what is Chuck Schumer's politics? None of those things were motivating folks. When Tallarico is talking about dealing with the billionaires, dealing with affordability, protecting education, you know, same thing, flock cameras, affordability, and I could go down the list. Like there was something that people were actually positively voting for there in

Speaker 1addition to just being against the Republicans.

Speaker 4The Christianity element also relates to big parts of the book and the history of Christianity with radical socialism, which you don't see as much anymore. But that is a significant thing in the South. I think people are more familiar with liberation theology in general. But some of the speeches that you have excerpts of in the book is really stunning. And not all that dissimilar from some of Tallarico's campaign speeches in some ways. There's this kind of

Speaker 4sermon style of giving populist speeches that ties in tenets of Christianity and morals and ethics with populism and socialism and how these things actually go together in a real way.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think that a major mistake that the left has made has been to try to basically give over Christianity to the right. There's a great book that came out for people who are interested about it just on Texas by a person named Joseph Locke called One State Under God. And it's the history of Christianity, of religion more broadly, but largely Christianity in Texas. And it's really fascinating to kind of see like in the 30s and 40s, this kind of concerted effort by the right to control the churches, to have influence over the churches. And this was like an active process From them, because

Speaker 1as you're noting in my book, The Myth of Red Texas, Christianity was a massive part of both the populist and the socialist movement. I mean, one of my favorite characters is this person, G.G. Hamilton, who actually was brought in to debate against socialists, to debate against socialism. And he very quickly becomes converted to socialism, and he famously kind of converts on stage. And he has this great line, it's like, you know, will socialists make— I' m paraphrasing, but like, will socialists make mistakes— Of course, they're only human, but I would rather be with the masses than with the masters.

Speaker 1And there's this congruence between a particular version of Christianity, actually, in fact, like an evangelical Christianity.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1Which most people don't associate with the left. But back in the day, I mean, you know, one of the socialist candidates in Texas was somebody who was the president of Baylor University.

Speaker 6Okay.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 1So this is like, this is deeply rooted within the movement. Eugene Debs cites Christianity a lot.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1And these things are very much neglected at our own peril on the left today.

Speaker 4I grew up pretty evangelical and I'm actually Texan on my dad's side.

Speaker 7Sweet.

Speaker 4And I do wonder, I mean, how much of growing up in that environment with, although a much more kind of a right-wing version of evangelicalism, but there's certain things that you absorb as a child. that just kind of impact your kind of like moral worldview in a certain way that even when you decouple from the more like reactionary and bad parts, you know, as you grow up, as you're a teenager, I have, I found myself kind of returning to, to some of those sorts of like core, like moral aspects and reading more about this kind of stuff. And like liberation theology has, has kind of helped me

Speaker 4like reconcile these kind of two parts of like myself, my sort of like upbringing with like my radicalization as a teenager.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1No, for sure. I mean, I'll just, you know, just a little on a personal level, like, as I was writing and researching, particularly this Christianity aspect, I was one kind of, I don't know, revelation away from, you know, returning in a big way to the church. Like, these writings that I cite in the book, they're extremely, extremely powerful, extremely moving. And yeah, I mean, if I could add another thing, too, that I think is really notable about the history of Texas socialism is Texas populism. is like

Speaker 1there's an optimism there as well. When you read a lot of these speeches, like you just, you know, your heart breaks a little bit because you know what's going to happen. But you do have this sense, it's like, man, I really feel like this is about to, this is about to, you know, they're about to win. Like they're about to take over the state. Like there's this kind of immediacy in the language and optimism and boasting and things like that. I think on the left, you know, we're very pessimistic. We're very kind of rational. Like there is something to be learned from the way that these folks spoke and wrote back a hundred years ago.

Speaker 4And there's also this like utility of using like Christian metaphor to relay certain things that if you just go full into, you know, DOS capital language might not be as immediately like absorbable by the population, which isn't, isn't to say you have to like, you know, lie or trick them into becoming a socialist. That's a horrible strategy.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4But this is, this is finding real ways to like communicate with people about things that they already kind of have a, have like an understanding about and you can like connect these ideas.

Speaker 6For sure.

Speaker 1And I mean, I will add that like when it comes to these movements, I think your assumptions about like the literacy rates of these folks is correct. But they had things like we would call like front porch readings where somebody in the community, somebody in the town who was literate or in the family would sit on the front porch and they would read these socialist newspapers like the rebel. They would read these populist papers in the generation before them. And that also kind of created a community around these ideas, too, because right now we're in such an isolated world. world where like you listen to podcasts, you know, I do it too. So, you know, no

Speaker 1shade to anybody, but like, you know, we listen to podcasts, we read online. We're kind of a lot of that work, a lot of that political education as a solo activity where for folks back in the day, back in the Texas, the height of populism and the height of Texas socialism, this was very much like a communal activity. So like you're using Christianity in many ways to kind of introduce ideas. But, you know, they also don't like water things down either too much. Like it's very accessible.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 1There's been a lot of, I think, bad history of this movement where they say like, oh, because they're citing the gospel, they're not really Marxist. Or, oh, they're not really socialist. They were just using that because it was a strong word. No, if you read the papers, The Rebel, if you read the debates that are happening, they're like, frankly, sometimes more sophisticated than things we see on the left today.

Speaker 5Way more sophisticated.

Speaker 4And like, as much as, you know, religion can be this like obscuring mechanism, the writing in The Rebel... about labor and capital is so clear.

Speaker 5It's clarifying. It gets right to it, right?

Speaker 4Yes, they're talking about how the international socialist commonwealth is God's kingdom, but there's also very clear and solid economic analysis.

Speaker 1Yeah, 100%. I mean, and it was truly fascinating for me when I was doing the research for this because I had come and kind of heard that many times before I had really got into it myself. But yeah, yeah, you know, it's like, oh, they were just using this because it was a hard word. No, these folks were very much socialists. So, I mean, it's rich. I mean, and the history is so deep. So they would do these things called encampments where they would have thousands of people show up in the summer. They would teach people to read. They would learn about socialism. Folks like Eugene Debs and Mother Jones, they would come down to Texas

Speaker 1and give these kind of incredible speeches. And these were not isolated. You can go, like, if you have roots in any town, go and look it up and type in encampment. in that town, and you're very likely to find one of these. I found them all over the state. And it's a fascinating thing to think. There's a whole generation of Texans, working class Texans, who probably learned to read at a socialist encampment or learned all these techniques or history or science because they were very broad. Education was a major part of the movement. In addition to doing things like having a good barbecue and a dance

Speaker 1and a Ferris wheel and all this other kind of stuff. I mean, it really is just such a fascinating and vibrant part of our history.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 4Let's get into some more of that kind of history. And it's maybe like go back a few years. I mean, I'm sure listeners would really like to hear about the cowboys on strike, the fence cutters. I think that that's very much kind of up their alley. But I think they should read the book because I've actually, I got way more interested in.

Speaker 5The Farmers Alliance, right?

Speaker 4It's this sort of thing where it's like, yeah, I go in, I'm like, I'm excited to read about cowboys on strike. And that chapter is really exciting. But man, the Farmers Alliance is crazy.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's a fascinating moment. So the Farmers Alliance starts in Lampasas, Texas. Not to get too into weeds of like con production text or anything like back then, but it was basically a system that was totally rigged against the producers, against the people who actually grow on the con. You see this massive debt crisis that actually like kicks thousands of people off of land that their family once owned. So the humiliating situation where you are now a tenant on land that like your family may have settled. And it was because of basically a system of debt called the crop lien system where you can't get ahead. So

Speaker 1people start getting together and they start asking themselves this great question, which is why is it that those who work most get leased and why is it that those who work least get most? And they come together and they found this organization in Lampasas, Texas, where our agricultural commissioner Clayton Tucker is actually from. And it creates this mass movement that's not only big in Texas. My book really focuses on Texas for obvious reasons. But the Southern Farmers Alliance spreads across the entire U.S. South. And it's this movement that at first is just kind of like looking at like the economic needs of farmers. They're maybe saying, oh,

Speaker 1we could use new techniques. We can use different strategies for growing, you know, more efficiently. But they realize, no, the economy is rigged against us. So we're going to need to create political power to do things like cooperatives. They wanted to start having cooperative stores, also like basically pooling con together to sell it collectively. And just to be really clear with the listeners here, too. I know like, oh, you hear con farming. It's like, oh, that's interesting. This is like what economic production is. Like if you were a normal person in Texas back then, like you were a con farmer, it was like pretty much like it was like one of the other, unless you were like

Speaker 1working for the railroad, this was what most people were doing. In just a few short years, it becomes this massive political movement that then leads into the People's Party, which is an independent political party in Texas that completely shakes and upends the political system here in just a matter of a few years. They spread through, you know, if you're Methodist, you'll know they thread through basically like the equivalent of, you know, traveling ministers. But they would go from town to town and they would kind of preach the ideas of the Farmers Alliance. This spreads wildly across

Speaker 1the state. People organize themselves. across Texas and across the South and the county level. And very quickly, now you have this incredible organization of people, incredible communication apparatus. And at the same time, they're dealing with the problem of the merchant class and the railroad class. And as this is going on, there's this massive strike in Texas. And the farmers actually show up for the railroad workers, the industrial workers, and they actually provide them food while they're on strike. They're showing up at the picket lines. They're showing up with them. And this makes a lot of sense.

Speaker 1But if you know anything about the history of kind of labor organizing in Europe and even in the US, oftentimes like farmers and industrial workers do not see eye to eye and they're in conflict with one another. And that's, I think, one of the most unique things about the history of populism and Texas socialism is that from the very get-go, there was actually this alliance between industry, industrial workers, people working the railroads, people working in heavy industry and farmers, which is really, really rare. And I think that's why populism and even Texas socialism were such a powerful force

Speaker 1in Texas even compared to other states and certainly states in the Northeast.

Speaker 4The book kind of lays out how people in the alliance, William Lamb, I think, right, had made the case for solidarity. And some of his letters and the later documents from the alliance, you call some of the founding documents of populism and just labor solidarity in the United States. Could you explain kind of what what you mean by that? Like what how how some of these these these early documents like I think it's called the Cleburne demands.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4How these things kind of laid laid the groundwork for the populist and socialist movement that would flourish in these next few decades.

Speaker 1So I don't focus on this on the book so much because, you know, I wanted to kind of like get into the story. But there were other agricultural organizations at the time. And the Farmers Alliance basically is the successful one. And the reason they're successful is because of what we're talking about here, the Cleburne demands. Again, as I noted, like there was all this kind of talk back in the day. It's like, oh, we need to just become better, more moral men. You know, like we just need to like be more deserving people and then like good things will come to us. Or like let's use new scientific advances in farming and like everything will

Speaker 1be fine. What's different about the Farmers Alliance and the Cleburne demands is they immediately start to speak of themselves as members of the working class. That's why I call this one of like the founding documents. of both populism and labor solidarity in the U S they immediately see themselves as, as members of the working class and extend that solidarity to the industrial workers. So there, this is like, sorry to use like Marxist terms or whatever, but like, this is literally class consciousness, like, like explicitly developing amongst this farmer's class. And the fact that these are demands, these are demands against the rich. These are demands against

Speaker 1the government. And, and you look at them and you see a lot of kind of progressive demands around, you know, um, democracy. around the economy, all these things that are very, very forward-looking. And one thing that's really notable about the populist movement is that you will start to see these things, they end up happening to a certain extent within the FDR administration. These demands really are cooked up in the 1880s and more broadly in the 1890s. And they come into being, you know, just a few decades later, you know, later

Speaker 1for sure. But like these kind of enter into the American consciousness. And William Lamb is also just a fascinating character, if I will just say, because he really had this long view of what the Farmers Alliance could be. He's brought in pretty early. And within the Farmers Alliance, there's like a conservative and a more left-wing portion of the membership. The conservative membership tended to be like well-off farmers, like They were still being screwed, but they were a little bit more comfortable. They kind of had more to lose. They wanted to stay close to the Democratic Party. And William Lamb, from the get-go, is like, we need to have an independent party. We need to have an independent

Speaker 1political movement. And, you know, he ends up getting it. And he's kind of a tragic figure in some ways. He's totally right. He's totally vindicated. They found the party, but he gets destroyed by a libel lawsuit and actually has to be pulled out of the movement, which is just the kind of tragedies like He is in many ways the kind of like the intellectual architect of this movement, but he doesn't get to kind of participate in its heyday.

Speaker 4Could you go over a little bit of like what happened to this moment? Because we have the People's Party, which grows pretty significantly, right? It becomes the second largest party in the state. It rivals the Democrats for power. Then, you know, the Socialist Party a few years later also becomes the second largest party in the state, right?

Speaker 5There was.

Speaker 4There was people voting for these in pretty decent numbers, right? And they had this whole culture around them with the encampments, with political education, this network of newspapers. Why isn't Texas a socialist utopia?

Speaker 1Well, you know, yeah, I'll take you all through this in kind of broad strokes here. The Populist Party really rises out of nowhere and it completely changes Texas politics and not just in the fact that it existed, but it forces the Democrats to put forward a lot of major reforms, things like the Railroad Commission. Texas has a lot of kind of progressive laws, let's call them, or I guess more accurately, we could call them populist laws and kind of structures, and that's all because of this movement. It grows immensely, and in 1896, I argue, and it's not just me as a leftist, a lot of other scholars argue that the Democrats basically just rigged the election.

Speaker 1They stuffed ballot boxes, they did racial terror, and they didn't count votes. And very likely that the populace won the governor election, and it was just kind of denied to them. Immediately after that is when you see the restriction on the right to vote for Black people in Texas. Actually, not just Black people, poor folks as well. So people might not know this, but Texas actually was one of the later states in the South to kind of really restrict the franchise. And the justification for it was that these folks are voting for these crazy populace who are

Speaker 1like a big threat to us. I don't want to overly paint the populist movement as like this kind of like ideal unity between white and black folks. There's a lot of ugliness there, but I will actually stand up for it in a big way because it was the only kind of political movement at the time that was serious and had capacities to actually create a better world for black Texans. I mean, it actually was fighting for both the votes of black and white Texans. So an imperfect movement, but that was really the path out.

Speaker 4That's something I really actually appreciate about the book. And it's not like a revisionist or whitewashed history of Texas, but it illuminates this like long forgotten part of that history, including, including some of the racial tensions and then the way racism hurt workers' ability to organize. But also when at times certain like populists or socialists like saw through how racial hatred was being weaponized and tried to organize a multiracial working class. There's, there's some really, really good quotes, kind of both, both about them doing this well, like

Speaker 4establishing multicultural unionism, but also socialists reflecting on their failures to overcome racial prejudice. And I think those chapters are still very relevant.

Speaker 1I really appreciate that. I just think it's an important thing to kind of note, because I think a lot of times on the left, we see these kind of imperfect movements And we're quick to kind of write them off because of that. But like, this is actually was what the path out. It's like, yeah, the reason that there was, you know, people saying certain things that, you know, we wouldn't want to repeat today was because there's actually like a connection happening. Like there's actually like political organized, like they had, they had, they had people on the, on the state leadership who were black at the very beginning of, of the populist revolution.

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 1That's, that's, that's incredible. I write about in Grimes County as how I kind of closed the chapter on populism, the county that went overwhelmingly for Trump, this incredible story of a white popular sheriff and his black deputies as they kind of take down and they fight in this prolonged shootout with this white supremacist organization, the White Man's Union, that was trying to kind of throw them out of the county, right? These are the things that are happening and they're populist. And I think that it's important to understand But this was the force that was actually fighting

Speaker 1against racism and the coming Jim Crow. This is where it changes, though. You basically have all, you know, basically like the black vote is taken away after this kind of coup effectively in 1896.

Speaker 9And.

Speaker 1You also see a significant reduction in the ability of working class whites to be able to vote as well because they have things like the poll tax and the literacy test and all these kind of things. Those things were brought. They certainly were set up to disenfranchise black people, but they also kept a lot of poor whites from voting in the first place. The Socialist Party, I think, is really interesting because it is operating in this situation where it can't actually rebuild the old coalitions of the populist movement. And it's also living in this period of like,

Speaker 1you know, like in a non-democracy because the right to vote has been severely restricted. And yet they're able to build this massive political party. This is going to surprise folks, but Texas was the second largest socialist party in the country. And they're not as electorally successful as the populace, but they're certainly getting folks elected on the county and the local level across the state. And they're also overtaking the Republicans at this period of time in like a pure number. as the only kind of real opposition to the Democrats. But where they're really effective is with labor organizing. They're

Speaker 1organizing people into new kind of unions of tenant farmers. And my favorite part of the book is the story of the Brotherhood of the Timber Workers, which is this incredible interracial union in East Texas and in kind of Western Louisiana. And it was an explicitly anti-segregation organization. It was an integrated union, which was against the law, right? And it's like, you know, again, these things like people really suffered for those having those principles back then. It was also fascinating on gender as well, because they extend membership to the wives and girlfriends and partners of all

Speaker 1of these timber workers. And somebody asks, why should these non-workers have a right to vote? And Big Bill Haywood, who's an incredible leader of the labor movement at this time, he says, well, will she not go hungry if you can't afford food? Will she not suffer if they kind of crack down on these movements? They have just as much a right to a vote as you do. And what's really fascinating about this is that it ended up also being a very great discipline tool for the labor movement. Because if a man was going to kind of, you know,

Speaker 1turn his back on the union and maybe scab, their wife would very famously say like, well, I'll go get with a real union man. Which is a very, very effective. And then, I mean, like there's so much obviously in the book. There's also this incredible kind of relationship with the Mexican Revolution.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1That is really fascinating. And this is really what starts to scare the ruling class in Texas, in addition to the opposition to World War I. So in Texas, this is when a lot of the kind of repression starts. This is when a lot of the spying starts. And the rebel, the Texas Socialist paper, was the first paper that was shut down over the Espionage Act. And this was set up because of their opposition to World War I. Obviously, people know Eugene Debs is famously imprisoned for his opposition to World War I. And it's a tragic ending in a lot of ways to the socialist movement in Texas.

Speaker 1Because The Rebel was why the party was able to grow so quickly. Because you could have a chapter in Lubbock. You could have a chapter in East Texas. You could have a chapter in South Texas. And the way that people communicated was largely through the mail, it was through The Rebel. And once they lost that organ, which allowed them to kind of really grow all across the state, it really led to a kind of sustained collapse of the movement in Texas.

Speaker 4It was so sad because the book builds up this incredible momentum. And then you get this sort of like first version of the Red Scare, all of like this international solidarity gets like almost like weaponized against the movement. You have like 50 socialists arrested in Texas. Eugene Debs arrested a year later. It's like the walls are closing in.

Speaker 1And I would just add just like, again, with both populism and socialism in Texas, like this is one of the large, I mean, obviously the history is important. The history is interesting to me, as I'm sure it is to many folks. But also like the point that I really wanted to get into with the book is there's all these ideas that like, oh, this kind of politics is not Texan, right? Oh, socialism is not Texan. It's like, no, in a lot of ways, it's more homegrown than a lot of the kind of modern conservative movements that we have today. And none of these movements are beat because they're unpopular, right? What they were met with was violence

Speaker 1and like state oppression and like the restriction of democracy. So that's why I kind of argue that like these are traditions to reclaim today. It's not like, Oh, this was interesting, but it failed. It's like these things were just straight up shut down through state terror. And like, you know, I mean, I don't know, you know, don't want to be naive. These things can always happen again. But I'm hoping that we live in a different country today where, you know, those kind of things aren't possible.

Speaker 4To close, let's try to touch on, I guess, how some of this relates to our current political moment, right? It's this sort of bittersweet thing of these movements established such an inspiring tradition, but most of the people and movements you cover in the book lost in their own time. So how do you see their legacy continuing? And what can our contemporary political organizations learn the most from these past examples?

Speaker 1Well, I'll be a little glib here at first. You know, there's nothing in Texas that we love more than people who stand up and fight for the principles and lose. I mean, the Alamo is central to our understanding of ourselves as Texans. But on a more serious level, look, I mean, populism, at least as a label, is back. I mean, and, you know, Gina Hinojosa in particular, I think, has really embraced it. She's regularly calling herself a populist. And to the listeners, I mean, she's not just using that in the kind of contemporary way. She was on the New York Times on my birthday, actually felt like a very nice gift. And she actually starts talking about

Speaker 1the Farmers' Alliance.

Speaker 5Wow.

Speaker 1Explicitly about the Farmers' Alliance, which to me was shocking because, you know, populism now has like this other kind of meaning, I think, for a lot of folks. But she was very much saying like, this is our history in Texas. Like these are our texts and traditions. We're reclaiming them. And as a person who wrote a book about why we need to do that, I mean, it was a very exciting, exciting moment. And I think these questions are very pertinent today for the same reasons. Like, we're still fighting these economic fights. And a lot of ways, like, where the left is, is in the same kind of moment as maybe the Farmers' Alliance was, or the early

Speaker 1populist moment, where it's like, okay, we see there's a problem, and we're starting to get people to organize together to come up with solutions to it. And we can actually learn from these earlier chapters of, like, how did they build a movement that was so powerful in Texas in just a few years, right? You know, what can we learn from them today? And all the questions. You look at the Socialist Party, for example. Like, if you're in the DSA, you'll engage in these debates. Like, should we be a third party? Should we be an independent party? All of these things are just, like, alive in this moment. And there's just, I think, a lot of insight that

Speaker 1we can learn from this history.

Speaker 4No, it's interesting how many of, like, the debates that I'm seeing now among the DSA and, like, the left more broadly are being clearly articulated and debated, like, at these encampments, in these, like, letters. dueling newspaper articles, right? There's an element of kind of time is a flat circle.

Speaker 5But there's also, I guess, a lot of differences.

Speaker 1For sure.

Speaker 4What's some of the differences between something like the Farmers' Alliance, the People's Party, the Socialist Party of this era, and something like the DSA, or even more broadly, the difference between this moment in the late 19th century and sort of like democratic politicians now who are running on economic populism but aren't even tied to a mass member organization like the DSA.

Speaker 1Yeah, well, I mean, I'll take the last one first. I mean, I think that this is the one thing that we should be extremely excited, and I've been kind of noting that this is an incredible opportunity for our movement here in Texas. You know, having somebody who's calling themselves a populist, having this kind of politics open up, getting the Republicans out of power, I mean, it's just massive. Like, the door's wide open for a different kind of politics.

Speaker 9Totally.

Speaker 1But I think as you're noting, and I kind of lay it on the book, like, That lack of connection to the mass movement, you know, is something that we need to build. We need to take advantage of this opportunity. I wrote a piece on my sub stack and I said, like, you know, we have populist rhetoric, but not a populist movement. So we need to build up that populist movement. I think those connections can happen. Jeannie Hinojosa, one of her first deployments, one of the co-chairs of her transition team, is like a longtime labor leader here in the Austin area.

Speaker 3Somebody who's deeply involved in these things. So like these things are being built up.

Speaker 1On the other question, let's talk about DSA and the Socialist Party and DSA and the Populist Party. I'll tell you what the biggest difference is, the open primary. This is a massive change from what it was back in the day. Back in the day, if you wanted to be on the ballot, there was just no opportunity to kind of jump into a primary and win elections in the same way that Zoran Amdani did in New York. Those were appointed by party bosses. They were closed party systems. We have a very different system here today. And I

Speaker 1think that if you just look at the recent history, it's abundantly clear what strategy has been working for the left. And I do think that there's a very different party system. At the same time, I think that you can look at these political organizations, if you are a member of the DSA, and say those are the kind of what they call in the DSA, they call a party surrogate like build up those same kind of organizations, those same kind of connections. But the ballot question, I think, is very different between then and now, just because we do have the capacity to go in and win the ballot

Speaker 1line on Democratic Party ballot line and basically open up a big lane for political victory.

Speaker 4No, this is a good article in a catalyst from last month that people should check out if they can.

Speaker 1Yeah, by Paul Heidemann, who also wrote an incredible book on the history of the Republican Party, if I could shout that out as well.

Speaker 5Ditto on that.

Speaker 4I guess the last thing I just want to ask about kind of in this vein, something that was very clarifying for me, is the difference between class-focused and class-rooted.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4There's something you kind of get to towards the end of the book in talking about how these movements in Texas maybe differ from some of our sorts of, like, you know, working-class organizations today.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think that this is really the kind of fundamental challenge of, like, of our time politically. Like, This is the best time, certainly in my lifetime, and I'll, you know, when I talk to some of my older friends on the left, certainly in their lifetime in many ways to be doing this kind of politics. But this transition between class-focused and class-oriented politics is really important. So what do I mean by that? Class-focused politics is like you're talking about the class, right? So it's like, that's an incredible improvement from a lot of the previous politics. You're thinking about class, you know, this is very important. But,

Speaker 1you know, a lot of times these are kind of like self-appointed spokespeople. I mean, A very clear example is like think about like the NGO left, right? Think about all the NGOs who might say like, okay, we're an anti-poverty organization. So great, we have anti-poverty organizations. But if these organizations aren't actually coming out of the working class in the sense that they're made up of people, membership of the working class, people who are actually living that life, then you have the tendency to kind of put your own hopes, your own aspirations, your own dreams, your own ideas, and then try to impose them on the working class.

Speaker 4It's not a movement of the working class itself.

Speaker 1Exactly. And this has been one of the tensions between the progressive movement and the like actually existing working class in this country. Progressives, I think like in their heart of hearts, like they do care about working people, but the class position of many of the progressive organizations isn't coming out of the working class. I'll just say like, here's a great example of this. What do I mean by like a class focused versus class rooted organization? So the socials back in the day in Texas, they would organize these unions of tenant farmers, right? And somebody would

Speaker 1come in And they were just a socialist organizer, but they weren't a tenant farmer, but they organized the union and everybody shows up and then they create this structure and everyone loves this new person. So they might even appoint them as president. And they had a principle of stepping down and having somebody else from the actual tenant farmers lead the organization instead of having them as socialists running it. That's something that I think a lot of organizers struggle with. You don't want to, quote, organize yourself out of the job. But socialists back in the day,

Speaker 1they saw that as a victory, right? We're creating organizations, like we are guiding, right? We are giving our perspective and our influence for sure, but we're actually handing over the keys to working people. That's really, I think, the kind of thing that we need to start seeing. That's what I mean between the difference between class-focused and class-rooted.

Speaker 4No, and that also helps against the sort of like drift to the right and the reformism that you can see, especially in something like the Democratic Party and politicians who are not rooted in an actual like, organization of working people. I mean, that's something that comes up with Governor Hogg in your book, right? And frankly, the way some of these sorts of demands from the populace and the socialists then got moved into the New Deal era, and some of those things are good policies, but it also did

Speaker 4weaken the power of the Socialist Party as an independent force, among a lot of other things.

Speaker 1Everybody wants like quick and simple answers, but I think history shows us that like, like, especially like on questions of like theory, it's like, you know, it was really beneficial that like some of those populists got stuff done within around and in some of them in the democratic party. Right. It's just like, yeah, it's way better than this movement advocating, advocating, advocating outside of the state and then collapsing and they're not getting any of these kinds of victories. But as you know, yeah, it, it also created like a weakness for populists that allowed things to be co-opted. I mean, the socialists had this, too, that they were never really like as much of an electoral threat in a general sense.

Speaker 1Paul Ferguson, who's a very, very famous Texas governor, I mean, he straight up lifted a lot of the demands from the socialist movement on protecting tenant farmers. Of course, extremely watered down. And in fact, he passed them and then the Supreme Court struck them down and he didn't really fight over it. But still, I mean, these are socialists, kind of maybe a political minority. Who knows how much really they're representative in Texas at the time. But they're still able to influence politics, right? There's just like this idea that like there is just like one correct strategy necessarily.

Speaker 1I think like history doesn't really bear that out. What we see is like things that like we see the pitfalls of certain strategies and we see the opportunity. And really like, you know, this is why like studying and understanding the moment that you're in is going to be really, really critical, right? You can't just take a textbook from the past or a guidebook from the past and bring it into the present moment.

Speaker 4That said, I was shocked when reading your book, how relevant it felt to the current moment, like from the border and fence cutters from company towns and Elon Musk. It's like, there's so many of these echoes. I think people can learn a lot from it. And I don't often talk about books on this show, frankly. So that should be a testament to, I think, how good this book is, is that people should read this. It is harder... to find, I guess. You have had, after the election,

Speaker 4the book is sold out in many places, but not everywhere.

Speaker 1Yeah, you can get it directly from OR, and I think on Amazon is the big one right now, but I think they'll be getting a shipment in the next couple of days. So rest easy, though, but you can always get it directly from OR Books, and that does help out support the independent publishing world, too. So I do suggest getting it from there if you can.

Speaker 4I will put the link to that below. Where else can people find you or your work online?

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I'm doing too much these days. I'm on The Jacobin Show, which is on YouTube. I do Love Reckoning as well. You can find both of those on the podcast as well, but they're primarily YouTube shows. I have a sub stack called The Rattler, and I write for Jacobin, Texas Observer, and a few other magazines. So I'm easy to find at David Griscom everywhere.

Speaker 4Thank you so much, David.

Speaker 1Thank you.

Speaker 11Hello, everyone, and welcome to It Could Happen Here.

Speaker 12My name is Dana Al-Kurd. I'm a researcher and analyst of Arab and Palestinian politics. Today I have with me on the podcast Akbar Sheikh Ahmed, who is the author of the new book, Crossing the Red Line, Biden, His Advisors, and Israel's War in Gaza. This book basically outlines the ways in which Biden administration officials fueled atrocities in Gaza. Akbar himself is a very well-established foreign policy journalist. He currently works as the diplomatic correspondent at The Washington Sun.

Speaker 11And for his coverage of the war on Gaza, he's received a Writers Guild Award and a New York Press Club Award, and has twice been named a finalist for the Livingston Award. He's based in Washington, D.C., and previously covered foreign policy at the Huffington Post for 12 years. So we get into the main argument of his book in this discussion. And he provides a lot of details from his book about how the Biden administration officials covered up for Israel, facilitated Israel's destruction, and really bear the burden of what happened in Gaza and what continues to

Speaker 11happen today. So without further ado, this is Akbar Sheheda.

Speaker 13Thank you so much for being on the podcast.

Speaker 7Thanks for having me, Donna.

Speaker 13Let's start with the big, broad question for listeners who haven't picked up your book yet. What is crossing the red line? And why are you writing about the Biden administration now?

Speaker 9Crossing the Red Line is my documenting, based on about 175 interviews of State Department officials, White House officials, diplomatic officials, people close to them, of how and why the Biden administration fueled atrocities in Gaza, why their response to October 7, 2023, so often stale to meet their own stated goals, of... bringing home hostages from October 7th, of bringing more aid to Palestinians, of trying to move, they claim, towards Israeli-Palestinian peace,

Speaker 9I felt it was really important to make a historical record of this tremendous policy and moral failure, given its cost, I mean, given its human cost, given its strategic cost, but also because I feel that so many of the patterns that were entrenched by Biden administration officials are fueling worse outcomes under the Trump presidency. So, so much of what we continue to see in Palestine, for instance, the unprecedented blockade of aid, all of those patterns were set

Speaker 9under the Biden era. They've just been deepened. And even some more risks, so for instance, the war in Iran, the sense of American impunity for Israeli policy choices, that again, I felt was really sped up and escalated because of decisions by Biden era officials. And then I thought it was important for us to have this historical market on it because, yes, we are now in the Trump presidency, but we are looking towards 2029. We're looking towards elections in which Democrats are trying to retake power. And having

Speaker 9covered the U.S. foreign policy establishment repeatedly, you know, Barack Obama into Trump, into Biden into Trump, I've seen how easy it is for officials and politicians to essentially forget their past policy mistakes and horrors. And I didn't want to let that be possible over Gaza.

Speaker 13Yeah, I mean, especially, I think, because we're seeing so much of this kind of attempted rewriting, you know, attempted rewriting of what happened. And establishment Democrats love to focus on Trump. But as you said, a lot of these policies began under Biden, or at least were exacerbated under Biden. So let's kind of drill into that for a bit. So you describe policy.

Speaker 14Around Gaza being run by Biden and like a small group of men, Sullivan, McGurk, Blinken, how was their handling of Gaza different from how they handled like Ukraine or Sudan?

Speaker 15Who was cut out.

Speaker 7Of the process? Yeah.

Speaker 9And this is what I really hope Crossing the Red Line will do is equip people with that understanding that while we think on paper, you know, the Secretary of State was in and the Secretary of Defense is here and here's where legal experts are. In the case of Gaza in particular, what I was told by officials was, Jake Sullivan, the National Security Advisor, Brett McGurk, the Middle East Coordinator, Tony Blinken, the Secretary of State, and to some degree, a couple of other advisors, John Feiner, the Deputy to Sullivan, and Addis Huxley, the former IDF soldier,

Speaker 9who was Biden's Lebanon envoy, but had a kind of.

Speaker 7Broader remit too.

Speaker 9It was these four or five men around Biden, and it's important to remember they are all men.

Speaker 7They're all specifically white men of a certain age group, really.

Speaker 9They're all around They're all Ivy League educated for the most part. Relative to Biden, of course, much older than them, a self-professed Zionist for many years. But there's not a relationship of peers or equals. It's this kind of staffer relationship. What I was told by people... inside the Biden administration was even relative to Ukraine, relative to Sudan, Jake Sullivan organized far fewer meetings of the National Security Council, of the Principals Committee. Very often, it was hard for officials

Speaker 9to even get intelligence. On Gaza, a higher threshold was was established by the Director for National Intelligence, Avril Haines, who is now running the Carnegie Tablet for International Peace, essentially saying if you don't have okay from a cabinet member, we're not going to let you see what the US government itself knows about Gaza, which of course, if you're an official mid-level further down the chain, makes it that much harder internally to say, I think there are war crimes occurring. I think there are violations of our interests occurring. That was not the case when it came to Ukraine

Speaker 9and Sudan. add to your point too about who was cut out. I will say the Biden administration humored dissent. It didn't punish dissent in the way we've seen occur in the Trump era so often. However, the costs of dissent were also clear in more subtle ways, right? So Samantha Power and Linda Thomas-Greenfield at the cabinet level, the USA chief and the US ambassador to UN in particular, did express some concerns about the policy, about what the

Speaker 9US was enabling Israel to do with American weapons. Essentially, I was told that meant that Sullivan cut them out. They were not invited to meetings or meetings were restricted to a much smaller setting. And then if you look at another internal critic like John Feiner, relative internal critic, he was so conscious of the risk that if he pushed too hard in questioning Biden's embrace of Israel, or in questioning Sullivan and McGurk's choices, he would be cut out too. So that also created an incentive structure in

Speaker 9which how much actual critique was occurring. And we simply don't know because there was this abnormal process around Gaza that Sullivan, Blinken, McGurk still haven't told us very much about in terms of their one-on-one dealings with Biden.

Speaker 13I mean, it's really jarring to hear how much internal shenanigans were happening to hide information from parts of the U.S. government, essentially. And by the way, these people, I want the listeners to understand, like they really, I mean, some of them have claimed, you know, I called them war crimes and I no longer, you know, I couldn't do that then or whatever. But like somebody like Amos Hochstein, for example, like is still talking about Saudi Israeli normalization. Like they haven't learned any lessons whatsoever. So your source is, told

Speaker 13you that Sullivan and McGurk, for example, told colleagues they didn't believe Palestinians were starving because they didn't, like, look thin in photos.

Speaker 5So what, those kinds of remarks, like, what.

Speaker 13Did they do to, like, everybody under them, all the officials who, like, have to manage policy around aid, weapons.

Speaker 7Et cetera?

Speaker 9Yes, there was a culture of a denial of reality, especially when it came to Palestinian and then Lebanese suffering. Those statements by Sullivan and McGurk, for instance, from what I was told by officials, essentially made it clear further down the chain, the White House isn't taking this seriously. And remember, this is occurring in February and March of 2024. This is six months after October 7th, by which point all the red lights are flashing, right?

Speaker 7The U.S.

Speaker 9Government itself says in the beginning of April 2024 that famine is occurring in northern Gaza. So for the highest level officials, Solomon McGurk, to doubt that, to push these spurious claims is really disheartening to officials who are trying to tell the truth inside the process, right? The sense of the perversion of the process is really endemic. And I should say, you know, Salza and McGurk deny making these comments. Sullivan's defenders would argue that this is what

Speaker 9the Israelis were saying, so he was gathering fuel to push back against Netanyahu's claims. But Again, because of the provision of the process, that was never made clear. What was made clear to other officials was the second most powerful man in the U.S. government is saying Palestinians don't look skinny. It was not, this is a tactic, here's our strategy, here's how we're going to pressure Netanyahu. And of course, given the public statements that were repeatedly rushing more weapons to Israel, repeatedly validating Netanyahu's narrative about the

Speaker 9Israelis do need to go into Rafah, the Israelis do need to continue this offensive, even while it's clear that Hamas is not getting degraded. That was sort of the effect. There was also a lot of concern among lawyers. Some of the people who were hardest to get to talk to me were those lawyers. They are very wary of journalists. They're cautious by trade. They're non-partisan career experts. But a lot of the government lawyers, particularly at the State Department, who I talked to, described discussions of horrific U.S.-backed Israeli

Speaker 9actions as.

Speaker 7just being surreal, right?

Speaker 9For instance, they would say, we would spend hours upon hours dissecting the evidence of, is this a war crime? Is this strike on a hospital? This killing of a child? This assault on a journalist?

Speaker 2A war crime.

Speaker 9And very often the consensus view in the room would end up being, yes, almost certainly it is, or we should go ahead and say it is. And then what the government would write, or what Sullivan's closest advisors, figures like Josh Geltzer, would write was a one-sentence summary saying, We discussed the issue and did not reach a firm conclusion. And this gets to something you were saying with the lack of reflection. Among these officials who want to take future jobs, a John Finer, for instance, has come out and said, I wish the lawyers had given us firm conclusions.

Speaker 9Then we might have said it was a war crime. We might have said international law was violated. But as lawyers told me, the environment was such that it seemed clear the White House did not want those conclusions. And I actually document also at the State Department that an advisor to Tony Blinken, her name is Azra Zaya, she runs a group called Human Rights First, essentially discouraged officials from pushing up to Blinken formal dissents, so-called split memos, that would force him to acknowledge serious professional doubts about

Speaker 9the U.S.-Israeli policy.

Speaker 13And they discouraged that kind of information?

Speaker 9From going up, because it would create a paper trail linked directly to Blinken. And so if you just tell people, express your concerns orally, or let's have a meeting about it, there's not a paper chain saying, formally, you know, one or two or four offices at the State Department rejected this weapons sale, blink and overrule them. And so that kind of plausible deniability, in fact, what one official described to me as herd impunity, is what is so concerning to a lot of people who did talk to me

Speaker 9because of their deep alarm.

Speaker 13So I want to get back to that term, but just very... briefly, can we outline what does the law actually require of the United States on arms transfers? And we know that they were sidestepped, but like, what does the law actually say about those things?

Speaker 7Yeah, let's take it through three quick routes.

Speaker 9Two are statutory and one is a Biden-era policy. So the statutory ones are the Leahy Laws.

Speaker 7Some people might be familiar.

Speaker 9These are laws introduced in the 1990s by Senator Patrick Leahy.

Speaker 7Essentially saying the U.S.

Speaker 9Cannot provide support or training to a foreign military unit if it has faced credible accusations of grave violations of human rights. Note that it's just credible accusation. You don't have to prove it. And if there are those credible accusations, the U.S. government is meant to cut off the support to that unit, the training to that unit. This has never been applied to Israel in the 30 years this law has been on the books. There's also a law that became very relevant in this period called Section 620I

Speaker 9of the Foreign Assistance Act, which says the U.S. government will not provide weaponry to any country that is blocking U.S.-provided humanitarian aid. So again, in this instance, U.S. government experts very often said Israel was blocking U.S. government-funded aid through the World Food Program or other organizations, but there were no consequences. Then there's the Biden administration's own policy. And this is part of why I wanted to write this book and dissect this policy, because Democrats so often

Speaker 9are the party that tells us we're making progress, we're acknowledging human rights violations, we're acknowledging the brutality of American policies. The Biden administration introduced a conventional arms transfer policy, saying if it is more likely than not that American weapons will be used in major violations of international law, we simply won't send them. So these were the three policies that were very relevant in this era. The Biden administration then also willingly, in this period, post-October 7th, agreed to

Speaker 9write reports on Israel's conduct, and in fact heightened the standard to say it was U.S.-backed humanitarian aid. If that was blocked, they wouldn't send weapons. And of course, we saw that they never found Israel culpable on any of those four benchmarks.

Speaker 13Yeah, you describe a system of denial, like, In all the months of the administration, they never concluded that there was a war crime. They never concluded that these red lines had been crossed. And you mentioned the term herd impunity. Is this, do you think, a Gaza-specific phenomenon, or is it basically a template that every administration can use moving forward?

Speaker 9It's It's made possible by the very particular degree of US government blindness towards Palestinians, right? I was told, for instance, by a senior State Department official, look, there's fewer than five people in the U.S. government who regularly ever talk to a Palestinian. Relative to, throughout the entire U.S. government system, there are hundreds, if not thousands of people talking to Israeli counterparts, right, every single day. And in this period, Israeli hostage families were being brought into the White House once or twice a month. They got to know Jake

Speaker 9Sullivan and Brett McGurk on a first-name basis. That was never an option for Palestinian Americans, Lebanese Americans, or Syrian Americans once Israel also moved into Syria in December 2024. So there's a particular blindness in this instance, right? But I do think, to your point about a template, this is where I named the book about red lines, and I'm sure we'll get to Biden's red line over Rafa, but what the U.S.

Speaker 7Government and what Democrats in particular.

Speaker 9Believe allowed to occur, enabled, often helped cover up in Gaza. So for instance, justifying the raid on the Shifa hospital in November 2023, justifying the blurry of the red line, assaults on journalists, assaults on aid workers, saying, oh, well, giving credence to Israeli talking points. That does degrade international standards to a new degree than we've ever seen. International law experts tell us that. And it makes it more risky in future conflicts. I also document in the book that in some of these discussions of findings of war crimes,

Speaker 9of should the U.S. cut off weapons, Pentagon lawyers notably were saying, if we find that Israel has violated international law or the law of armed conflict in this setting, does that restrain us in the future? Will we as the United States then be held culpable to that standard? So you can see how it's a symbiotic impunity as well. That is looking forward to future conflicts. And that is not, by the way, those patch card lawyers are not, as you are supposed to do, judging the particular incident based

Speaker 9on the specifics, the discrimination, the proportion, the actual way you're supposed to judge a war crime.

Speaker 7The question is, should we give the U.S.

Speaker 9Government leeway for its own potential future violence, which is really alarming.

Speaker 6That is extremely alarming. Thank you. Yeah, so take us through Rafah.

Speaker 15So Biden publicly set a red line.

Speaker 13Israel crossed it.

Speaker 15Weapons kept flying.

Speaker 13What happened around that? What happened inside the room when that line was crossed?

Speaker 9Yeah, it's really important to note, to highlight Rafah. I mean, the humanitarian toll of it, again, really sets the stage for what we see now with 2 million Palestinians still being on 35% of the land. And that's shrinking in Gaza as Israeli control expands. Rafa's at the stage for 1.4 million Palestinians who are sheltering in that southernmost town of Gaza to be pushed out, mostly pushed into Mawassi, a tiny coastal strip. And this idea that even seven months into tremendous data coming into the U.S.

Speaker 7Government, the U.S.

Speaker 9Government developing its own intelligence capabilities in Gaza, by the way, because after October 7th, they felt they couldn't trust the Israeli intelligence so much, the U.S.

Speaker 7Government still wasn't willing to change its policy.

Speaker 9And I highlight that moment because there was a real belief in March and April of 2024 that Biden might finally use his leverage, perhaps to save Palestinian lives, or at the very least for other interests, whether it was domestic political interests, by this point the backlash inside the US to the policy had already grown, or just because of his stated goals of ending the fighting, not looking like he is overseeing these massive atrocities. I also highlight

Speaker 9in a run-up to Rafa why this becomes so important, the killing of the World Central Kitchen aid workers in April 2024, after which Biden actually makes specific humanitarian demands of the Israelis.

Speaker 7That they meet.

Speaker 9So it's a moment that's important to note because to so many of the officials I talked to, it proved the appetite was there to use American leverage. And the April 2024 moment, post-World Central Kitchen killings, showed opportunity. American leverage could be effectively used. It could change Israeli behavior. So then we got to May 2024, where the Israelis do test Biden's red line. His red line had two components. You have to have a plan for the civilians in Rafah, and you have to not bomb it, destroy it, the

Speaker 9way you have Khan Yunus, Gaza City, other parts of the Strip. The Israelis begin to advance on Rafah. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are fleeing. And the Biden administration says, begins to, in the words of Dan Rhodes, former deputy national.

Speaker 7Security advisor, fold like a tent.

Speaker 9So they start to actually provide cover to the Israeli narrative that the red line is not being crossed. Rather than saying these strikes, this humanitarian situation we are seeing is blatantly clear, they're saying, well, it does seem the Israelis are changing their tactics. And you mentioned Saudi-Israel normalization. Jake Sullivan goes to Saudi Arabia in this period. and says, well, we're going to move towards peace. It's all coming together. It's just staggeringly dishonest, frankly, in that moment. And you

Speaker 9see this moment is also when Biden has, for one period, limited one weapons shipment, as they say, in the room, based on really emotion, not on a legal or deliberative process, but on Biden's temper, Jake Sullivan's calculus in that moment, the sense of, okay, this is our pressure point on Israel. We withhold this one shipment of weapons.

Speaker 7And then in.

Speaker 9Addition to providing cover for the Israeli violation of Biden's red line, the Biden administration effectively apologizes for withholding some weapons in May and June of 2024. You see Israeli defense minister Yoav Galant invited to the Pentagon, promises of rushing more bombs, rushing more ammunition. So it's a moment that's so hollow in so many ways and to me encapsulates the sense of missed opportunity willful blindness, and a lot of callousness and dishonesty from these officials.

Speaker 6Yeah, callousness for sure.

Speaker 13Let's talk about Biden's mental decline. I think, you know, it was a talking point, you know, near the end of his administration. But how much do you think his condition shaped Gaza policy? Or, like, did it allow for others to kind of step in as.

Speaker 15He lost the plot?

Speaker 4So.

Speaker 9As one official put it to me, Biden was the potato, Jake Sullivan was the president. And whether or not this was fully true, it was certainly an impression among many inside the administration. So what does that do? That says that your careerist instincts are, how do I not anger Jake Sullivan or Brett McGurk or John.

Speaker 7Feiner, who, unlike Biden, are going to be around. They're going to be in public life for the next 20, 30 years. This is where I'm.

Speaker 9McGurk, for instance, having that really hard line as a pro-Israel defender inside the administration, I was told a lot of officials were effectively trying to stay on his good side, right? Or not be overrun by him, as one humanitarian official put it, to be McGurked. Sullivan himself, while more open to maybe a less hard-line embrace of Israel, consistently wasn't willing to break with Biden's policy. And I think officials

Speaker 9were really, really dedicated to this idea of Jake is just a.

Speaker 7Smart guy in a tough spot, right?

Speaker 9Rather than interrogating what it means for that national security advisor to be in this position. And then Biden's own willingness, I mean, my reporting says, my reporting found that.

Speaker 7He was making the key decisions himself.

Speaker 9It's not the case that his advisors were, you know, bypassing or sidelining him. But What we don't know is when Sullivan tells us, for instance, I presented cutting off weapons to Biden as an option. What was that discussion like? Sullivan still hasn't told us. Was it a serious option? Was there a serious discussion? How did emotion play into Biden's thinking?

Speaker 13So you did more than 150 interviews and many of your sources wouldn't go on record. I mean, it says something, I think, about the fact that all these people are afraid of kidding on McGurk and Sullivan's bad side, you know, that that are now being kind of celebrated and positioning for future jobs. But what does that say about our entire kind of foreign policy establishment?

Speaker 9Yeah, the extent of fear of being seen as a critic of a deeply pro-Israel foreign policy is really deep. And even in a period where we're having bigger questioning, mostly on the left, but now also on the right of the U.S.-Israel relationship, of the relationship to Palestinian rights, that hasn't hugely changed. The sense of it could be a career killer among professionals is very deep, but it's especially deep, I should note, among people who very often

Speaker 9never thought they could be international security establishments. So younger people, people who are already more marginalized, people of color, women, who might be more open to a progressive view, but also have joined this machine and now are trying to figure out how to be part of it.

Speaker 7But also the sense of retribution is very deep.

Speaker 9I was struck by even people in positions of power not wanting to critique their colleagues. So for instance, Samantha Power spoke with me on the record, was one of the few high-level people to do that on record, and I give her kudos for that. However, she said to me, I will not criticize specific actions by my fellow colleagues.

Speaker 7And I just... don't understand.

Speaker 9It's not a personal attack to say, I strongly disagree with your decision while I respect your judgment. But the culture remains one of, to some degree, deference. And it's a factor, too, of kind of the ongoing battle inside the Democratic Party that we're watching now and I'm actually reporting on live now, which is the battle about whether the scrutiny over Israel policy and the backlash over Gaza was a blip or will actually be significant to the

Speaker 9DNA of the U.S. foreign policy conversation going forward. And there's a lot of people, a lot of donors, and not just, you know, AIPAC donors or ardently pro-Israel donors, also kind of old school, just establishment, don't rock the boat Democratic donors. maybe a good way to describe them is even Clinton-esque or Bidenite, right? Who are saying, we like these people, we've had them in positions before, bring them back. And so for people who I think didn't

Speaker 9go on the record, for people who are still being very cautious in their critiques of fellow officials, that awareness of that donor class is very deep. I thought you saw it in an interesting way recently with Brett McGurk's book tour. His book is out as of October 6th. And Phil Gorton, Kamala Harris's advisor, came out publicly and said McGurk's portrayal of this policy was inaccurate and that it missed Netanyahu's blame, put too much on Hamas. What he didn't do in that instance was describe the deep

Speaker 9disagreements that he and many others had and the fights he had with McGurk.

Speaker 7So there's still a shielding.

Speaker 9Of the personal, and it's very easy, as we referenced earlier, with the bogeyman of Trump of Netanyahu, of Hamas, to always find someone else to blame for the policy than your own colleagues.

Speaker 13Yeah, and speaks to, you know, this is a job, I guess, and they're very far removed from the consequences, but like, obviously, you know, the fact that they have a rotating door in and out of D.C., like, shouldn't be norm for people who have such disastrous policies. But you end on a kind of hope that this is a pattern that can be broken down. What would breaking it actually look like? Like, what should our listeners watch for from maybe less establishment Democrats who are positioning for 2028?

Speaker 9When I think about the signs of hope, I think the hope comes from people empowering themselves with the actual details of this policy. What so often happens, especially on Israel-Palestine as a file, is the sense of, let the experts deal with it. This is too complicated. You couldn't possibly get into it. And that's what I want Crossing the Red Line to do, is equip people with understanding that it's hundreds of decisions, hundreds of officials whose salaries we pay, and that we can demand better or ask

Speaker 9for things differently. small signs of hope, I will note literally on the day we are recording this, and I was shocked by this, but the Harvard Kennedy School, which is where Jake Sullivan and Samantha Bauer now work, had faced some pressure from internal faculty to invite me for a talk to discuss this, and it was really up in the air, and They just confirmed today that they're going to do it. And I thought that was interesting, you know, that even these most elite of institutions, which,

Speaker 9of course, have welcomed these people, want to have this discussion. And, you know, I'm quite clear that I'm not going to pull my punches in that discussion or anywhere else.

Speaker 7So I found that interesting.

Speaker 9I also think that when you look at, you look at a Senator Chris Van Hollen, of course, not a newer candidate, someone who's been in politics for decades, but the real anger that that he has a real deep awareness of this issue and the sense of betrayal by the Biden administration, that's not going away. That's among a lot of lawmakers, given how these Biden era officials treated them and treated people in the Democratic Party tent, treated organizers, treated other candidates.

Speaker 7And I think that is an interesting sign of.

Speaker 9Where a return to the status quo simply will not be possible unless There's also, you know, there's interest on the right among Republicans, particularly around Trump's Iran war of questioning, dissecting the U.S.-Israel relationship in new ways. We haven't seen that manifest into a policy agenda at all. I mean, it's really been once or twice around Paul, maybe voting against particular giveaways for Israel. If some kind of conservative policy agenda around Israel-Palestine that is new and different, maybe

Speaker 9even rooted in factors like Christian solidarity for the suppression of Palestinian Christians That, I think, is also a possible factor in this policy shift.

Speaker 7But I do think that just the awareness is.

Speaker 9Really, really, really hard to put back in the bottle, as much as people in D.C. would like that to be the case.

Speaker 13Yeah, it's still popping up and haunting them. Do you think Sullivan is going to come to your talk?

Speaker 9I have really wondered this question. I guess we'll touch base on Friday.

Speaker 6Yeah, let me know, let me know.

Speaker 14All right.

Speaker 6Thank you so much, Akbar.

Speaker 12We really appreciate you coming on.

Speaker 7Thank you, Tyler. It was really great.

Speaker 6Thank you.

Speaker 5Welcome to It Could Happen Here, a podcast where the it is many things. You know, I had a whole introduction planned out, and the moment I started talking, it immediately evaporated. But you know what? The it is the resurgence of the international struggle, and the happening and the here are both in the U.S. and in a whole bunch of other places where things are kicking off in various ways. I am your host, Mio Wong. And one of the things that I think, as we've been covering

Speaker 5more of the sort of uprisings that are happening around the world, I think there's a tendency to look at these things as, you know, they're just like things that happen kind of out of nowhere, right? And, you know, there's obviously an extent to which like, yeah, like one day there were people in the street and like the day before there wasn't. But the foundation for all of this stuff is that in all of the places where these movements are happening, there have been events like things going on for ages. And one of the ways that

Speaker 5these sort of massive movements like happen is, you know, I keep going back to this quote from someone from the Egyptian revolution in 2011, talking about how like you, you, you have these protests and like you do this for a decade. And like, if like 50 people show up, you're depressed. And if 500 people show up, you're really happy. And one day a hundred thousand people show up and you like kind of forgot that that could happen. Um, But in order to have the 500,000 people showing up, you have to start with the like thing that doesn't

Speaker 5look like the uprising, but eventually becomes it. And in order to talk about some of the stuff that is happening here and in other places and how the kind of networks, you know, to talk about sort of the kinds of things that eventually become the big thing, but don't look like it until until it happens. is Brady, who's from the Greater Chicago IWW. I guess it's GMP IWW. Yeah, and Lindsay from the Pittsburgh IWW and 100 million projects, therefore, in. Sorry,

Speaker 5I have a very lengthy introduction. Both of you two, welcome to the show.

Speaker 10Thank you so much.

Speaker 6For having us.

Speaker 15Excited to be here.

Speaker 5Yeah, and I thought, you know, originally I was going to start with one of the least mea things imaginable, even though I did technically grow up next to a cornfield, which was agriculture and agricultural organizing. But I have caught the whiff of internationalism. And I kind of want to start there with Lindsay, I know you've been kind of off gallivanting, seeing a bunch of very interesting kind of

Speaker 5Storm before the storm is not the right word, but that's what's appearing in my mind right now.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8Lots of cool stuff, both like getting prepared to happen and now happening.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 15And I can tie it into agriculture workers as well.

Speaker 8So I am a member of the IWW, Industrial Workers of the World Association. International Committee, and I just had the honor of being a delegate for NARA, so the North American Regional Administration, so that's Canada, U.S., Mexico, at the International Confederation of Labor Congress with our sibling unions from all over the world. There were folks from Cyprus

Speaker 8and Argentina and We welcome new folks from Myanmar. And so when I learned that was happening in like Northern Italy, a place with like higher union density and higher cooperative.

Speaker 15Density, I was like, oh, I got to figure out how to stick around.

Speaker 8Yeah. And so I was like, hey, ICL, can I like come maybe a week early and like stay around after?

Speaker 15And so- I got to meet actually agriculture workers as well before and after the gathering. So it was so cool.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 5So can we can we talk a little bit about like what the icl is and like what yeah like what what what kinds of stuff people are up to because it's it's cool.

Speaker 8Yeah, so the IWW is part of the ICL, International Confederation of Labor, which includes folks from like CNT Spain, CNT France. Flora in Argentina we just welcomed in folks from Myanmar and Brazil and basically there are like working groups so the Latin American working group Asia working group like you know different regions so that's been really exciting

Speaker 8and I'm relatively new to that committee but you know Have a lot of IWW experience, but it was now excited to level up and talk to other international union folks about it.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5So what have our comrades from a whole bunch of different unions sort of been up to? And what were, I don't know, what were kind of the common things that people were encountering.

Speaker 8And- So we had a vote on supporting some of our Palestinian comrades and had, like, presentation and heard from folks from unions in the Palestinian workers' rights movement and voted to, like, as the International Confederation to work on supporting those efforts.

Speaker 15There were proposals around, like.

Speaker 8Working together more, just like the ICL is a relatively like newer confederation that only formed about a decade ago. And one of the things that we were discussing was like, instead of meeting every five years, what if we met.

Speaker 15Every three years?

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8Uh, those were some really exciting topics. Um, kind of just also comparing notes, especially like the last day I got to talk about, uh, and share, uh, about like some folks from the Minnesota 15, uh, which folks were curious about. And, uh, one of our fellow workers, Emmett Doyle is a member of the Minnesota 15. Uh, and then literally like right after that, the folks from Spain like got up and were like, yeah, things have been bubbling up. but we're looking at our phones right now

Speaker 8and it looks like we're going back to a general strike.

Speaker 15That was a really fun thing. And like the folks from France were like, yeah, things seem to be bubbling up here too.

Speaker 8So, um, Yeah, those are some of the things. And just like, yeah, how we can facilitate more discussions. One of the things I was really excited about and why I spent more time is like, I'd like to do more like delegations, like not just me go, but like other folks from Agriculture Worker Organizing Committee or the IWW Co-op Council to meet like other cooperative folks. Like there's, I think in the US we have kind of a

Speaker 8crisis of imagination. And like creativity that like things could be different or what does that even look like? And so getting some of that exposure to like, well, what are organizing methods going on in like Argentina?

Speaker 15What are they like going on in Mexico? And actually just.

Speaker 8Like hear from other workers instead of just like, you know, maybe filtered through social media was like really special.

Speaker 15And I hope to build more of it.

Speaker 5What was your favorite thing that you heard people talking about? You heard someone from Argentina or.

Speaker 8I mean, it was really cool when the Spain folks were like, I think we're going back to a general strike. Yeah. I think one of the things that was really cool is I actually also came a week early and stayed at this place called CSA Veranda.

Speaker 15And I learned about.

Speaker 8Like basically these are self-managed community social centers that are like a cross between like a union hall and a venue space and a people's gym. And some of them are squats and have been for decades. But like learning about some of that to be able to share with like some of the co-op council folks. And oh my gosh, like a lot of the Italians I think.

Speaker 15Had better education.

Speaker 8Knowledge of US politics than a lot of the people I run into in the US.

Speaker 5Yeah. God, if I remember right, there used to be an old joke about how everyone in France knows the name of the American political prisoners and no one in the US does.

Speaker 15Yep.

Speaker 5Which I guess, to some extent, is a legacy of periods where the movements were significantly more interconnected than they have been now, which, I don't know, I think it's interesting that I guess, kind of a coincidence that it's happening at like exactly like this meeting is happening at like exactly this moment where suddenly everything is kicking off again. And it's like, oh, we do kind of need to rediscover our internationalism because suddenly it's happening everywhere again.

Speaker 8Yeah, I mean, this one was actually technically an extraordinary Congress. So it was called before that like five year period. It was part of the reason we were like, maybe three instead of five. Um, cause like, yeah, we do need to be building these connections. Uh, cause like, it's been really helpful, like actually like hearing from like folks, like, like getting texts from people from Argentina, like, Oh, what's going on? Um, so I'm like getting those ideas. And I,

Speaker 8I spent a week up in Germany with our comrades in the FAU and they took me from like, worker cooperative farm worker cooperative farm to meet like union members in agriculture that they're like a couple of years ahead of where you know we've talked about where we want to be and like exploring some of the same things and so like being able to crib notes is from them is really helpful. And then also like there's from that,

Speaker 8like an international agriculture workers chat.

Speaker 15And so we just heard.

Speaker 8About like IWW, like Zimbabwe, like tobacco farmers have started organizing. So the regional organizing committee in Zimbabwe just dropped. So like it's building some of those connections and like, Oh, what are you doing over there? What are you doing over there?

Speaker 15And building that creativity that we really want to create.

Speaker 6FAU is.

Speaker 2Oh.

Speaker 15My gosh, it's like a German name.

Speaker 5Oh God.

Speaker 15It's like Free Workers Union, but.

Speaker 5Yeah, so the FAUs are very, very old. It is very funny. Listening to you list the unions, it's like, oh, it's FORA. Yeah, that's like the Argentinian syndicalist union that did the uprisings in 1919. And the FAU, if I'm remembering right, is the other, is like the old German syndicalist union that was huge in the 1920s and did a whole bunch of anti-Nazi street fighting and shit.

Speaker 15That tracks.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 15That tracks with what I saw.

Speaker 7Yeah, I think.

Speaker 5They were also the people who were doing free abortion stuff, if I'm remembering this correctly. Oh, that's sick.

Speaker 8I need to ask them about that. We also connected over labor choir stuff. I got to hang out with the Dresden Labor Choir, because I'm a member of the Pittsburgh Labor Choir. And as a thank you, I made a little songbook that I brought with me. I was like, how could I ever repay your kindness? Not through money. Here's some songs... from my union and community. And so like, also a lot of people were really into like the, the union music or labor like music.

Speaker 7It was cool. It was really cool.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5Speaking of people being into stuff, I wanted to circle back around a little bit of talking about the, like the talking about cooperatives and the sort of like self, the cooperative farms and sort of the self-management and thing because I think that's a I don't know what it is specifically about the US that we don't have like

Speaker 5the same kind of tradition I mean like we obviously like have a long cooperative movement but it's it's like a different thing kind of than like my understanding of this is like kind of a different thing than something like Italy something like Argentina or Germany it's like the kind of like self-management thing is a lot more ingrained as like a strategic thing there. And I wonder if you talk about like, yeah, like what it was like being in those spaces and like what, yeah, like, I

Speaker 5don't know what you kind of came away from with it.

Speaker 8So something that was really interesting that I noticed about CSA Baranda, because I interviewed some of them, was like, well, do you pay for this, like, third space through, like, membership dues or, like, how do you make decisions? What does your bookkeeping look like? Because I'm a nerd. But, like, for example, they were like, no, we, like, want to make this, like, an accessible space. Like, the main way we make our, like, money to keep the lights on and stuff is, like, holding events that the community comes

Speaker 8to and, like, venue space and stuff like that. Which, like, was really cool. I know like a couple of those CSAs like maybe just had a conference, which is exciting because it sounds like I just like scratched the surface on that.

Speaker 5Can you explain what a CSA is for people who are not familiar and what they're like in Germany versus like the US?

Speaker 15So, okay.

Speaker 8So CSA is, was like a specifically an Italian thing because the Germans and Americans, like we had the same understanding of a CSA as like a community supported agriculture program, which is where like you cut out the grocery store by like giving your money directly to the farm. And actually- Booker T. Whitley, who is, like, a Black agriculturalist, helped, like, kind of pioneer some of that for, like, survivalism, you know.

Speaker 15Like, in Reconstruction time.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 15And, like, how do we get free from, like, sharecropping? Like, it's really interesting. Check out the book Freedom Farmers.

Speaker 8But, yeah, CSA in Germany was, like, community-supported agriculture. Something I noticed that was really interesting is, like, especially I was with the agriculture workers is like, they were basing a lot of it in the history of like peasant rebellion too. And like, like, you know, we have a long history of like, you know, land workers also trying to like, you know, there's a history of like Martin Luther who like basically was just co-opted there basically was just like, Hey, rich people are cool. And also like

Speaker 8fuck the Catholic church and stuff. But, was also used to put down peasant rebellions at the time. And so something I would see at some of these worker cooperative farms in Germany was more of fighting peasantry type of stuff, which was really interesting and cool. And it was also interesting to see how they were talking about land access is a really big problem both here.

Speaker 15In the US and also in Germany.

Speaker 8And how they were starting to pool funds in both the community-supported agriculture network and cooperative network so that worker cooperative farms could actually operate and access land. Because I'd love to see something like that built here.

Speaker 6Yeah, that's really cool.

Speaker 5So my brain is immediately distracted by you're talking about Martin Luther and the kind of revolution against the peasants and like, The fact that he wrote a pamphlet called Against the Murderers, Thieving Hordes of Peasants after he like accidentally kind of set off like the second wave of the peasant revolution. It's just like, oh, no, I meant religious freedom for princes, not for peasants.

Speaker 6That's the thing, right?

Speaker 10Martin Luther, famously a guy that was right about one thing and wrong about basically everything else, like the whole like church accepting donations to absolve your sins thing.

Speaker 5Yeah, good job.

Speaker 10Probably a bad thing. Everything else has opinions on, like, literally, like, women, peasants, the Jews. A lot of opinions on that.

Speaker 5His plan was, our, like, new religious doctors, we're going to try to outflank the, like, 1500s Catholic church on antisemitism by being more antisemitic than them? It's like, Jesus Christ!

Speaker 7Like, ugh!

Speaker 15Bro, even how?

Speaker 5Astonishing stuff. I, yeah, I don't know. But I get angry about this because I was, like, raised Lutheran, and then, like, you'd find out later all of the shit they didn't tell you about this guy, and it's like, oh, no! Okay, digressions aside, as we're... I guess it is kind.

Speaker 2Of accurate, but.

Speaker 5given the arc of industrialization in Germany to say we're still fighting the same people because their old Ancien Regime just kind of, like, was fused into the sort of, like, Prussian bourgeoisie. So in terms of all of us still kind of fighting a version of the same fight that, like, I don't know, a bunch of peasants were fighting in, like, 1530. Yeah, do you want to talk a little bit about What

Speaker 5kinds of agricultural worker organizing has been happening here?

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 8So we founded the Agriculture Worker Organizing Committee in 2025 after a sustainable agriculture conference where folks were coming together. There was discussion from... the National Farmers.

Speaker 15Union on the agenda.

Speaker 8And they had a really interesting framing of what a union is and or not. But there were other groups like Not Our Farms leading all worker discussions and stuff like that. And so it was a really good space to talk to other fellow workers. And I finally had been able to bring other IWW folks with me.

Speaker 16And so.

Speaker 8we kind of looked at like, okay, well, you know, we want to move. We view this like as a long-term thing where we're like planting a tree and this has got to grow. And so like some of the first things we're doing is like mapping the industry of like which farms are unsafe for women to work at, which farms are unsafe for like LGBTQ folks, which places have somewhere where you can wash your hands and, and have access to a bathroom. So some stuff like that

Speaker 8and just basically getting to know other folks who, you know, we talk a lot about land sustainability in certain parts of the agriculture community, but a lot more folks are interested in starting to have the discussion about labor sustainability because people go into that because they care about you know, feeding their communities or the environment and trying to like small business owner your way into it and like fit

Speaker 8yourself into that like sucks.

Speaker 15It's terrible.

Speaker 5No one likes it.

Speaker 8And so like even locally you see like a good thing is like a farm and an increasing number of like, you know, smaller places like that, like considering like, oh, how do we, transition actually to like a worker cooperative. Uh, and, uh, how do we like, you know, start, how do we start to do that? And so as agriculture workers, you know, we were also really inspired by, uh, the history of

Speaker 8black cooperativism in the U S I recommend everybody go check out collective courage, uh, history of African-American, uh, Cooperative Theory and Practice by Jessica Gordon-Dempart because she talks about how the history of Black cooperative organizing in the U.S. is also the history of Black labor, agriculture, and domestic labor organizing because they were left out of the NLRB.

Speaker 8And so there's a lot of different... phases of cooperative development. And so we're pulling inspiration both from that history and, uh, like, you know, some.

Speaker 15Other parts of the world.

Speaker 8Like I said, FAU has been playing around with some of this a little bit longer, started more so like agriculture worker organizing a couple of years ago, but yeah, we're exploring, uh, also like what does it look like to eventually like maybe do like, uh, like investigate like some healthcare stuff. Like what does it look like to do like hosted like skin cancer screenings or something for fellow agriculture workers? Or like, that's something I'd like to

Speaker 8really see build too. But yeah, right now we're, we've more than doubled our committee and are kind of just like comparing notes and educating ourselves on the industry, doing some mapping, moving at the space of our capacity as we grow this tree and sustainable land.

Speaker 15Food forest. There's a metaphor somewhere.

Speaker 10Quick interjection. Lindsay, you talked about how certain farms do not have a place to wash your hands and use the restroom a little bit ago. Do you want to explain to people what that means in terms of when you see a recall on produce, how that's actually more of a labor story than it is a health story?

Speaker 15I mean, it's both. Labor issues is a health issues.

Speaker 8And so far, like, you know, yeah, you might have someone who doesn't have access to like clean hand washing stations, like pick lettuce or something like that. But then it gets sucked into a machine that then becomes like a super spreader, which is, you know, some of, for example, the summer of diarrhea we had.

Speaker 15So it's a health issue.

Speaker 8Like not our farms taught a workshop that was like farm health and safety is also community care.

Speaker 15And like, that's a case in point example.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5So what if my, I am like notoriously city pilled after growing up in like places that were like, had like the last remnants of like farming-ness like paved over. God, I hate that shit too. But one of the things that I sort of, you know, one of the things that you pick up even as kind of like the urban girl who was, you know, but growing up around this is like how slippery the category of farmer is. Because,

Speaker 5you know, it's my understanding of this is like, When you're talking about like farmers, that's a category that includes both like agricultural labor and the farm owners, which is like I guess I'm used to seeing this in terms of like, you know, the list of like the most dangerous jobs. And it's like, you know, like farmer is really high up the list, but it's like. Actually, it's way more dangerous than that because there's a bunch of people whose, like, job it is to own the farm who, like, are being counted in with people who are, like, you know,

Speaker 5getting sucked into the 7,000 kinds of horrific grain silo disasters that haunt my dreams. Don't go in after the person sinking into the grain silo. You'll just die, too. Yeah, so, like, let's... On a sort of more serious note, yeah, so, like, can we talk a little bit about, like, what's going on with, like, the American conception of Farber.

Speaker 15Wow. I feel like I could talk about this subject for like five hours.

Speaker 8But so I think there's like a couple of camps here. There is like the yeah, the like a farmer is farm owner. And then I've like read books like I really like Farming While Black by the folks at Soul Fire Farms. And they talk about how, like, you know, farmer as person, yeah, who also includes, like, agriculture worker. And, like, yeah,

Speaker 8I sometimes will, like, call myself a farmer, sometimes, like, agriculture worker. But, like, I don't own the farm I work on.

Speaker 15No. Yeah.

Speaker 5And.

Speaker 15It's definitely an interesting thing to navigate.

Speaker 8Uh, I know I've had interactions, like for example, like talking to like the national farmers union, they'll be the first ones to be like, but you know, we're not a real union, right?

Speaker 15And it's like, bros take that out of your name.

Speaker 5Yeah. Um, but can you, can you describe what you mean by that?

Speaker 8Like, uh, like sometimes it'll be, they'll say like, Oh, we're not a real union. Uh, we, uh, represent the bosses, uh, Or they'll say, like, we're not a real union. We're a 501c5 agricultural organization. Because unions are also 501c5s.

Speaker 15But it's like, bro, I, like.

Speaker 8Yeah, it's really interesting. It also depends on, like, are you in agriculture co-op spaces?

Speaker 15What type?

Speaker 8Because there's also, like, a bunch of different types of agricultural co-op. A bunch of different types of co-op.

Speaker 15But... I think that also.

Speaker 8There is this idea of like what a farmer is that often centers around like the patriarchal family and how like land is.

Speaker 15Owned and controlled and.

Speaker 8Like, That also is, like, tied up in there. Like I said, I could talk about this for, like, five hours, but.

Speaker 5Yeah, and, like, it's also just, like, the giant, sort of, dew of Damocles settler colonialism hanging over all of it. Which is also true of cities, by the way. It's my media shout-out that, like, cities also settler colonial. Like, it's not actually more settler colonial.

Speaker 6They're both.

Speaker 5But, yeah.

Speaker 15But, yeah, I think it really is.

Speaker 8An interesting area that we've been exploring, especially what does worker cooperativism look like?

Speaker 15Because there are a lot.

Speaker 8Of failings of the labor status quo that was set up under the National Labor Relations Act that we largely operate under today in the U.S., where the idea was like, the deal of part of that New Deal was like, we'll keep capitalism and the state will be the quote unquote neutral mediator between bosses and labor. And part of that deal package, I guess you could call it, was

Speaker 8a deal with Southern segregationists that left out especially like black and brown folks, especially like those in agriculture and domestic labor. Like those industries are like, nope, not that.

Speaker 15Like, yeah.

Speaker 8Whereas like, for example, in Italy, they were like, yeah, like, of course we have people like in union who are like also in agriculture. Like that's partly where our union movement comes from. So that was like a super interesting thing as well.

Speaker 5So I want to kind of focus in for a second on the specifics of this, which is, I guess, like, the thing about that compromise, the thing about the National Labor Relations Act is that, like, you know, if you're under the National Labor Relations Act, you're getting screwed. The only way to get screwed even worse than being under the National Labor Relations Act is to not be under the National Labor Relations Act, where you get even more fucked. Like, if you're one of the industry that's specifically not, so, like, rail workers, for example, are regulated by, like, a different

Speaker 5regulation thing that's like somehow even worse. And yeah, my understanding is that agricultural workers are like one of the other big categories that don't get the normal... They don't get any of the benefits you're supposed to get from the National Labor Relations Act that like let you form unions. So, I mean, you're right, but also.

Speaker 10And this is a thing that we've ceded to the bosses and stuff like that, which is that unions existed before the current administrative framework, whether that's the Railroad Act or the NLRA or various state-level versions of that. They're going to exist long after. You do not need to have an administrative framework to unionize.

Speaker 5You don't.

Speaker 10And that's kind of like the IW– go ahead.

Speaker 5Yeah, I should be clear about that. When I say the only thing worse is not being under the National Relations Act, what I mean is if they wrote you a separate set of regulations, those ones are going to be somehow even worse, which is where it's like the NLRA was like the best deal you could get, kind of the best deal you could get from the state, which means you're still getting fucked. But like if you didn't get included in that deal, they carved out like an even shittier one. And so it's like either you're like under those even shittier ones or... You're operating outside it in a way that's, like, we're going back to

Speaker 5the fucking negotiating table, by which I mean we're, like, telling all the regulatory frameworks to fuck off.

Speaker 10No, yeah, you're absolutely right, and I apologize for the miscommunication.

Speaker 5No, you're all good. I was explaining that badly.

Speaker 10Well, it's complicated. It's complicated.

Speaker 15I also think the, like.

Speaker 8the conditions of organizing in the U S labor movement, like even 10 years ago, like maybe the NLRB for those who could get it made more sense, but the NLRB, you know, one of the arguments we've made in IWW is like, you know, it's never been super great, but now it's even more hardcore failing. And so Brady, I think like some of the stuff you were talking about with moving post NLRB world, maybe.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah, I mean, the NLRA, it really was just a compromise in order to protect capital and the labor piece in the wake of World War II. There was enough money to go around due to the fact that most of the rest of the world had all of their factories destroyed and created kind of an aristocracy of labor in the United States. We no longer live in that world. And because of that, we need to... be going back to, uh,

Speaker 10we don't necessarily need to, but it's probably for the best that we start going back to the stuff that worked before the current labor piece. Um, we, uh, like labor did not used to need an administrative framework. You didn't used to have to go to a labor board, uh, to, uh, march on your boss and demand better conditions. Uh, that is a, um, like it's a construct, uh, What matters on the ground is being able to actually show your

Speaker 10ability as a worker to stop working and stop producing profit for your boss.

Speaker 8I mean, I think one of the distinctions I often talk about with folks of like, What differentiates the IWW from like other unions and the AFL-CIO? There's a number of things, but a lot of it is the like capitalism, yes, no, like question, right? So, you know, the deal of the New Deal was like, yeah, we'll keep capitalism around and we'll keep this really top-down system around if it means

Speaker 8that some workers got treats, right? Or like, you know, some workers got like a little bit better than others. But, you know, one of the things that I think is also like really important is, you know, we have to take the step of like, okay, well, that didn't work out for the labor movement.

Speaker 15That didn't work out for us. You know, what does it look like to having.

Speaker 8A strategy that goes beyond that. And also one that is like internationalist right like we talked a little bit about the importance and like why the international organizing i think an internationalist labor perspective is really important because like i grew up in the rust belt um I grew up in Michigan, live in Pittsburgh, and this was an area with a really strong background. Even today, people are like, Pittsburgh's a union town.

Speaker 7And it is.

Speaker 8And we've had a lot of folks unionize in the past few years. But if we take a nationalist view of America first or whatever, made in America, then that's They'll do what they did in 2008. They'll do what they did with fast fashion where they'll just keep cutting and running and to wherever they can exploit. And so that's why we need to connect with workers everywhere and not be afraid of connecting with workers everywhere because we can't–

Speaker 8like rich people get to cross borders. Like why not us? Why not like actually– you know, connect with our fellow workers and just make it better everywhere. And so they can't cut and run and leave devastation in their wake.

Speaker 10And that's a huge part of the reason why the IWW focuses on organizing industrially, because it's very easy, even from just a U.S.-centric perspective, it's very easy to close down a factory in the Rust Belt and then open it up down south or open it up in like Mexico or Canada due to like NAFTA reasons. But when you are organized industrially, you can't be played off like that in the same ways. And that's one of the reasons why it was like one of the primary reasons

Speaker 10that the IWW was formed in the first place. It was a fundamental disagreement between the AFL and a bunch of leftists, anarchists, socialists, communists, radical trade unionists that didn't want to see workers competing against each other.

Speaker 5When you say industrial in this context, that means?

Speaker 6Oh, yeah.

Speaker 10So industrially, what that means is within an industry. So not necessarily like when people think industry, they think, oh, like a factory or whatever. But what we mean when we say industry is like the agricultural sector, and then you can maybe subdivide it a little bit. But fundamentally- If you are working in schools, that is the education industry. If you are working in a manufacturing plant, that is the manufacturing industry. Rather than the more typical, more commonplace

Speaker 10type of organizing, which is shop by shop, I'm organizing this specific factory, I'm organizing this specific school.

Speaker 5And so the goal there is to get everyone into one instead of having a bunch of different, every shop having a different union and like competing against each other. It's to put everyone in one thing.

Speaker 10Yes, one big union, you might say.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5One of the things that I'm interested in, you know, in terms of the IWW project, broadly as we've been talking a lot about kind of you know like the like what what what were the conditions that made labor peace possible but i think one of the the insights that the iww has that i've been seeing a lot from it is that like even if you want to try to maintain that compromise it's being torn up from the other side and yeah i wanted to hear sort of your thoughts on I guess what I've seen a

Speaker 5lot and what I've heard from a lot of people in unions, which is that like, yeah, we're going to have to learn how to do this because they're tearing up the National Labor Relations Act from the Capitol side.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 8And I mean, and I think that's why like a lot of our– tactics, like in our organizing trainings, 101, 102, the focus is like, how do we keep the battle here on the shop floor, pushing on the shop floor and not just like put it into like, the legal system of like delay, delay, delay that bosses and bureaucrats tend to use, you know, in our one-on-ones we teach about like, well, what does it look like to actually

Speaker 8collectively make a demand from your boss? What does it actually look like to start to work together as a committee? And like, you know, anyone looking to get involved with like the IWW, one of the first things I recommend is checking out an OT 101 and Because, for example, rather you're building a union or you're trying to start a worker co-op or something like that, you need to build a committee and figure out how to work together with people to do a thing. Even if there are

Speaker 8people that you maybe don't agree with on every single thing.

Speaker 5Yeah, this is an organizer training 101, which I've been to one of these. It was very useful.

Speaker 8And they're also kind of fun because... You can travel to a different part of the country, meet other workers, especially I'm on the gender equity committee. One of the things that all of our members have access to is, you know, if you're a person of color, you can access the Fletcher funds. And if you're a woman or gender nonconforming, the Sato funds. If you're not either of those things, I recommend maybe... need to ask for financial

Speaker 8help you could reach out to the organizing department but the GEC especially has those funds to make sure that anyone from those groups are able to access funds for travel for housing to be able to access that organizing education hell yeah.

Speaker 5So I guess like other than sort of like do you want to OT 101 like join join the class struggle from one of five thousand five thousand is such a there's 100 billion different points from which you can join this.

Speaker 7Um, yeah.

Speaker 5What else do you all want people to know?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8So if you are trying to join the IWW, uh, you can do so by going to IWW.org and then join, uh, And I can also include a link in the show notes. Once you join the union, you become an at-large member until you affiliate with a local branch. This is because sometimes, like, maybe your job– you're in a remote job and most of your coworkers are in a different place, like in– Pittsburgh,

Speaker 8we have Keystone Development Center, which most of the folks are remote, but they help develop cooperatives. And a lot of the folks that are remote, maybe not in Pittsburgh, but they're affiliated with the Pittsburgh branch. We also work on like agriculture stuff. So, you know, if you're interested in co-ops or IWW co-op council, you or Agriculture Worker Organizing Committee, I'd reach out to Pittsburgh at iww.org or the Ypsilanti Michigan branch or Baltimore DC branch are good

Speaker 8for also agriculture, food systems stuff. You know, once you become a member, you start getting general organizing bulletins in those. They list where you can take organizing trainings, 101, 102s, things like that. But yeah, reach out to some of the branches in your area, see what is the culture like, especially if you're in a more rural area. You can pick where you want to affiliate.

Speaker 6Awesome.

Speaker 10And this is especially true if you are in an industry that perhaps has less union density than the already abysmal union density in the United States. So we kind of touched on it a little bit, but If you're in one of the NLRA-exempt categories, independent contractor, domestic worker, agriculture workers, technically not exempt, but if you or someone you know is an incarcerated worker, we have a program for you, the Incarcerated Worker Organizing Committee. It does a

Speaker 10lot of work with prison strikes and that sort of thing. Reach out. Like the IWW, there's a place for everyone. If you work for a wage, whether that's salary or hourly, you're welcome here. One final thing is that I am running for general secretary treasurer of the IWW right now. If you are a member, well, if you're not a member,

Speaker 10consider joining.

Speaker 7Google us.

Speaker 10We're really cool. If you are a member, I would encourage you to reach out to me, and I'm going to put my email address listed here, and also hopefully it'll be in the show notes. It is bb4gst at gmail.com. That's B as in boy, B as in boy, the number four, gulf, solidarity, trans rights. So that is bb4gst at gmail.com. I'd love to talk to you.

Speaker 8Yeah, I'm running for gender equity committee and international committee. I'm not super concerned about getting reelected. I think people like what I'm doing. But I would like to actually recommend a write-in, fellow worker Malcolm Gay from Mexico. If you're in the IWW, please write him in. He helps out with a lot of our translation. stuff and would really like to see him on the international committee again but yeah if you are not in the union and

Speaker 8want to join check us out yeah IWW.org oh.

Speaker 2Yeah Hi everyone and welcome to the podcast. It's me, James. Today I'm very lucky to be joined again by Gordain, a journalist who also works with Hengau, documenting human rights abuses in Iran. How are you doing today?

Speaker 6Well, hello James. Thank you very much for inviting me again. It's been a long time and I'm really happy to be here again to talk about the latest situations in Iran and also in Kurdistan.

Speaker 9Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2It's been a while and I think like a Unfortunately, the situation of people in Iran has kind of faded from the headlines in the United States and specifically the situation of people in Kurdistan. We had this flurry of very strange headlines in the first month of the war where it was like, oh, the Iranian opposition is going to do like a land war. Then it was like the Kurdish groups are going to do a land war.

Speaker 2And then it was like a baffle. Talabani is going to lead the conquering army into Iran, which seemed very unlikely. And then Donald Trump started shit talking Kurdish people for a time and accusing them of stealing weapons that he tried to send.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 2And then people stopped paying attention.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 8Like, and yeah.

Speaker 6When I think about that time, it feels like it was a million years ago. There was this huge media fight between, I don't know, Trump and Kurdish parties. And the Kurdish parties were denying that there is no such thing. There was no such plan. And Trump was just accusing Kurdish people of stealing the weapons and these kind of things. And At the end, I think the Kurdish parties were also clear about that, that we don't want to engage

Speaker 6in a war with a country like Iran that is extremely powerful and extremely dangerous. Because this argument has been going on for years, even like a few weeks after Gina Amini in 2021. Two, there was the same question that why the Kurdish parties are not going back and fight the Iranian forces in Kurdistan and things like that. But the Kurdish politicians came out and said that if we enter the Kurdish cities or villages, the Iranian regime

Speaker 6will destroy everything and kill tens of thousands of people. We're talking about a regime that has absolutely no morals, no values, and no respect for Let's not talk about human rights, just human lives. They don't care about anything. And this is the thing that happened. And it was the same argument during this year's war. because a lot of people were talking about it, but then Trump came

Speaker 6out and said that, yeah, we want to do it. But then the Kurdish parties also said that we will not enter this war without a guarantee. We just don't want to be some proxies that go there and get ourselves killed and then gain nothing, because there should be a guarantee for us that, okay, we're going to go fight, and when the regime falls... What's going to happen to us? What are we going to get? What's going to happen to the Kurdish people? And also to other people like

Speaker 6Baluchis and many other different ethnic groups across Iran. So this was the thing. And this argument just went on for months. And then Trump started this hate campaign against our people, which also caused a lot of, I mean, it added to the already existing racism against the Kurdish people from the Persian region. groups and oppositions and they were just accusing Kurdish people of being thieves and these kind of things and it caused more problems for our

Speaker 6people and yeah and then after some months it kind of just turned off I don't know why maybe it was just that the media stopped talking about it but At the same time, which I think we're going to talk about this more today, that a lot of people thought that, okay, this was the war, the regime got damaged in some ways, which is true. But at the same time, when we look at the whole situation and

Speaker 6the way that the regime is dealing with the people, with the civilians, it feels like, it seems like that this regime, there is no change because... The repression, the oppression, the brutality of the regime is still there, and it's even worse. And this war basically didn't change anything for the people, for the civilians. And it's led to a

Speaker 6huge security crisis. And it's also, I would call it, a complete economic collapse. and a lot of damage to the environment and any kind of social problem that you could think of. We are even seeing... This is just one example. We are seeing a... a surge in femicides. And we know that femicides in a country like Iran or Afghanistan, they are not simply a social issue. Femicide

Speaker 6is a global issue. But in countries like Iran, the state and the laws are also helping this to happen. And since the war, I would say since the past two years, This has intensified. And just in the last two weeks, over 12 women have been killed. And when you look at it, you see that the laws or the Sharia laws that the Iranian regime uses, they are also making this happen. And they are basically protecting the

Speaker 6criminals who are committing these crimes.

Speaker 2Yeah, fuck. That's terrible.

Speaker 6This is just one example that I'm saying. And this war has made things worse in all aspects of people's lives. And at the same time, you know, like before the war, there was this massacre and this mass protest that we still don't know really how many people were killed. Maybe 30,000. Maybe nobody knows the exact numbers. But there was also another surge in the. In executions and mass arrests, I would just refer to

Speaker 6some numbers that, for example, last year, there was a short time of conflicts also last year. Only last year, according to the statistics from Hangout, Organization for Human Rights, I'm just looking at the notes here. 1,858 people were executed only in 2025. You know, this is like one of the highest numbers in the past 10 years. And only, I mean, during the first six months of 2026, 689 people have been executed. And only in October, 85 people were executed. Jeez. So these numbers are really getting worse

Speaker 6and worse every year, and especially since the war, because there is this security atmosphere and everything is, or every city is somehow militarized. I mean, in Kurdistan, it's been militarized since the past 100 years. But like, according to what I'm seeing or what the people are talking about, and also you can see that how they're arresting people, it's got worse. This is what was happening in the prisons.

Speaker 6And we all know that these executions are not simply a number and they are not just targeting, I don't know, some drug dealers or something, because most of the times these people who are accused of, I don't know, some non-political crimes they actually are innocent because the Iranian judiciary is extremely corrupt and it's not independent so it's not really clear that what these people have done that they are getting executed for and this is also like what's

Speaker 6happening and I will just refer to some more numbers to give the audience an overview of the situation in Iran. According to Hangar's statistics, since the protests, over 10,000 Kurdish civilians have been arrested.

Speaker 2That's the January protest?

Speaker 6Yeah, since the January protest, like over 10,000 people have been arrested and only around 900 of them have been um identified like you know their identities having verified because there has been this wave of mass arrests since january and they just arrest everyone for no clear reason and this is also what's what's happening and at the same time um When we are talking about the prisons and

Speaker 6their situation, we are talking about, you know, I think this is also like a global thing that all the prisons are horrible places that they are built for people to suffer. And the prisons in Iran are horrible. They are in the worst conditions that you can ever imagine. Most of the times there are no medical assistance. There is no food. There is nothing. You know, it's just a building full of people. And many people die in these prisons. There has been several cases of people who

Speaker 6died in these prisons. Some of them also die under torture. There has been at least, I think, around eight cases this year that people died in prisons. They either were tortured or they just died because there was no medical support. I don't know, the conditions are really horrible there and people die. And at the same time, there is another issue for women who are in prisons. And many of

Speaker 6these women have children, they have babies. And in some cases, these babies, they are also in prisons with their mothers. And there was a case where There was a woman that was arrested some years ago. I'm sorry, I'm not really good with the dates and numbers when I don't have the notes in front of me. But this Kurdish woman from the city of Piran Shah, she was arrested a few years ago, accused of collaborating with some Kurdish parties.

Speaker 6And she had a baby in prison. I think she was pregnant during her arrest. And her baby was basically born there. And this baby had a lot of health issues. Her eyes had problems. And this baby was in the prison with her mom. And her mom was also really sick and nobody was helping her. Fortunately, she was released on bail last year or maybe this year. I'm not sure about the exact date, but it's very recent. They

Speaker 6fled to South Kurdistan or the Iraqi Kurdistan region. And I think they are safe there now. So this is just one case. And there are... tens of thousands of these cases. And this is how it's going on. And I also like, I have heard from the people who are in the prisons for a short time that sometimes they would, I don't know, 20 people, 30 people in a very small room that basically there is no space for you to even sit down. So you have to

Speaker 6stand up for hours in a room with people Tens of people. So they are basically doing this to torture people. Jeez. Yeah, this is the overall situation. And the whole torture of the Iranian prisons is also nothing new. It's been going on for decades. And besides physical and mental abuse and torture, they also sexually assault prisoners. There are many, many cases

Speaker 6that some of them talk about it and some of them don't. I can give you one example. There is a Kurdish human rights activist from a Kurdish human rights organization, not our organization, another organization that He was also sexually assaulted in the prison and he didn't talk about it for years until last year he posted some stories and he talked about it. So this is also something that's happening in prisons and it's especially really horrible for women

Speaker 6because there's always this thing that everybody talks about it that if you're a woman and if you're sentenced to death. And if you are, quote unquote, a virgin, somebody needs to take your virginity and then, I mean, they can execute you. Like, this is also something that a lot of people talk about it. And this is what they do to people in prisons. There's another thing that I

Speaker 6want to talk about because there's also some sort of resistance in prisons. The prisoners, especially political prisoners, they have been doing it for... almost three years. It's called No Execution Tuesdays. So it's basically a movement from the inside of the prisoners that started in, I think it was in around January 2024. And it started in Qasr al-Hassar prison.

Speaker 6It's near Tehran in Karaj. It's basically one of the worst prisons in Iran to be in. And so the prisoners started this movement and it's basically a movement that they protest against executions and they want the regime to stop executions and hold all the sentences. And so far, until today that I checked, there are 67 prisons that

Speaker 6are doing this weekly strike, if I want to call it.

Speaker 2Right, the collective action.

Speaker 6Yeah, and this has been going on for almost three years now. And they want to... held all the executions. They want to also cancel all the death penalties for political activists. And they want to have access to lawyers. They want to end the torture and also these forced confessions, which is also, I just remembered that it's important to

Speaker 6talk about the forced confessions So one of the things that the Iranian regime also has been doing for years is that they force prisoners to confess a crime that they haven't because they torture these people, they threaten their families. They do the worst things to them. So they have no other choice to come in front of the camera and confess a crime that they haven't done. And usually this happens for quote-unquote crimes against the national security and

Speaker 6collaborating with Israel or America or these kind of things. And they force these people to come in front of the camera and talk. And then they broadcast it on national TV and social media. And then they actually use that as an evidence to simply execute them.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 6And this is also what's happening. And at the same time, they also threaten the families, these prisoners. Or they kind of threaten the prisoners that we're going to do this and that to your family if you don't do this and that. Right. while the prisoners are suffering in prison, their families also suffer. So it's like, you know, I think North Korea also does that. It's like a collective punishment of the whole family line that goes on. And

Speaker 6this is also one of the things that's been going on. And it's very important because these No to Execution Tuesdays, they have been... in very, very small things, a little bit like they've been successful a little bit. I remember there was a time that they demanded better food, which actually it got better, but like, you know, it's not, it's never good, but it's improved a little bit.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2They made a gain.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 6Like people talked about it. And I also remember there was a thing that I think they wanted to execute 20 people in one night. Something like this was going on in one of these prisons and the prisoners started protesting and they kind of postponed it, which was also considered as a small success for the movement.

Speaker 7Sure.

Speaker 2Like it's still, it's still, they've extracted something, right? And I can see how it would be easy to feel like very hopeless in the situation of being a political prisoner in Iran. So like having any, being able to extract any concessions, any victories is still important. It doesn't mean everything's fixed. It just means it's still a thing that people have been able to gain. I wonder, there's this really troubling trend in the United States, right? Because

Speaker 2a lot of us understand that the war against Iran is bad. because well we're killing people we're not like the only shit that's ever getting liberated is is oil right like like the goal of this campaign is not to liberate the Iranian people from an oppressive regime it's either to manufacture domestic success for Donald Trump to like you know have an enemy like we have in 1984 or maybe to try and do what they did in Venezuela and they haven't stuck the landing on that right like But the response on a lot of the left

Speaker 2in the United States has been solidarity with the Iranian state rather than solidarity with the people oppressed by the Iranian state.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 2And it's in part i think because our reporting on the conflict with iran has been like straightforward moves this straightforward moves that right like iran shot a tanker us stopped a tanker blah blah blah like our reporting hasn't looked at people inside the Iranian state as it is right now, but like the U S has done terrible things, right? The U S bombed a school and killed children.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2And it's, it's killed more children. I think they bombed a Baluchi wedding. There's some really horrible photos, like little children's shoes, but like the Iranian regime, as far as I can tell in its capacity to oppress the detain and kill its own people, and especially people who are not Persian, there's been no damage, right? Like aside from the first few weeks where like the Iranian like soldiers were like hiding in mosques and schools and shit to

Speaker 2try and not get bombed.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 2There's been no change, right? Or even like an uptick in the tempo of detentions and executions since February.

Speaker 6Yeah. I mean, the same argument went on last year during this 12 day war where Yeah. That people thought that, yeah, oh my God, so the regime is getting bombed everywhere, but the repression didn't stop. In fact, it got worse. So the thing is that the regime, like this is what I believe, and I think many experts would also agree with me that this regime is not going to change simply with bombing. It's more than that. It needs

Speaker 6to change now. from the within. And it's extremely hard to do this because this regime is not evolving around just one leadership or one personality. It's a whole network of different mechanisms, different organizations, different groups, different ideologies that all work together And what the regime is scared of the most is not America or Israel, it's the people. And they have created this system, which I also want

Speaker 6to mention that the system of repression is not what the Mullahs created. It was built on a system of repression that was created during the Pahlav, especially the prison systems and the whole intelligence service. So the regime is very protective of itself when it comes to that. And they have been creating these systems, these networks to simply keep people as silent as possible, or just keep them

Speaker 6in the gray area so that they wouldn't do anything, they wouldn't take any moves. And the war, in the beginning, it was a big motivation because when the war started, the regime had done a horrible massacre. against the people and the people saw that war as a revenge and that's why they celebrated and i would say that majority of the people still celebrate that war and they want the regime to be bombed all the time but at

Speaker 6the same time they also know that this regime is not going to change simply by being bombed it needs something more than that and That's why I think a lot of people who talk about the war in Iran, they completely forget about what the people, I mean, the ordinary people are dealing with on their daily basis, lives, you know?

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 6Just now that I'm talking, because of the war, And the situation that's been created, the regime is taking all the measures to keep people inside, keep people in a state of mind to be worried about everything, to be worried about food, I don't know, supplies, everything. So right now that I'm talking, I was talking to my brother today. And he was telling me that now it's really hard to get like gas for the car because there is

Speaker 6a limit and it's not enough for like a month. I didn't quite understand it, but like apparently they have created this new system that you cannot get gas more than a specific limit. And it's expensive. And like basically most businesses that are dependent on like transport, they are not able to perform and basically it's affecting the whole society there right now. And so this is going on

Speaker 6and it's just making things really hard for people. And I think we have talked about this before and I have always talked about it, that at the same time, this war also made the inflation worse and access to some resources even harder. There is a shortage in food and especially in medicine and medical supplies. Many people who are dealing with specific diseases or illnesses, they are not able to get the medicine that they need. It's not

Speaker 6available because some of them are made in other countries or imported. So it's really hard for ordinary people. But As I said before, it seems like the repression machine of the regime has not moved at all. It's just got stronger and it's just doing its work even better than before.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 2And they have this new thing to accuse people of, right? Collaborating with the, I mean, they always accuse people of collaborating with the Americans, but I suppose they can point to something now.

Speaker 6Exactly. So basically, there is also another thing that you just mentioned, accusing the people who are arrested of collaborating with Israel and America. There is this fear that we always talk about it in the political spaces, that there are thousands of people, young people, in prisons, that their cases are still not clear. And we are afraid that Many of these people might be simply accused of collaborating

Speaker 6with the enemies of the regime and they might face death. And it's not clear that how this is going to happen and how these people can get out. So it's just really horrible. And today, as we're talking, I want to give a little bit of background. A few days ago, there was a bus accident and 13 Kurdish workers died. And it's in the province of Elam. It's one of

Speaker 6the poorest provinces in Iran, but it has the biggest gas resources in Iran as well. But, you know, colonialism, and I don't want to talk about this right now, but basically 13 of these people died and They're from a small town called Abdanan, which was one of the most active cities during this year's protests in January. And today the people came to the streets and they were protesting against the situation that the roads are horrible, the workers'

Speaker 6situation must be improved, and these kind of things. And then, of course, they chanted lots of anti-regime slogans. And I just read in the news that the regime, the regime forces started arresting people on the streets, which is, I mean, it's not normal, but like it's typical of the regime. But at the same time, they also arrested a number of the people who were arrested during the January protests and they were released on bail. Like they had these ankle GPS devices.

Speaker 2Okay. Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 6So they arrested these people and they wanted to like kind of frame something new that, yeah, you were in the process again. Jeez.

Speaker 2But they just went to their houses and grabbed them because they already knew where they were, wherever they were.

Speaker 6Yeah. But I just saw like an hour ago that some of them were released, but there are still some people. So this is how the regime is operating right now. And they are monitoring people on social media and I mean, it's worse than before. And there's a lot of propaganda also going on. I think this is the same case about Afghanistan, for example. A lot of foreign YouTubers, bloggers, they are kind of invited in Iran to Iran and

Speaker 6they are going to some fancy places in a fancy restaurant or something in Tehran and other cities. And they are showing the world that, wow, look how great it is. Wow, look, I went to this restaurant and I spent only $ 10. on this amount of food, but they don't talk about that $ 10 is like the amount of money that a person earns in, I don't know, a week, you know?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 9Or.

Speaker 6few days and this is also something that's happening and a lot of people from inside Kurdistan and Iran talk about it and like as I said my brother was even talking about it that this bloggers come here and they try to show the world that this is such a great place yeah it's beautiful the nature and everything but it's hard everything's expensive we cannot afford basic stuff you know the people are literally living in a famine so this is also really annoying to see that's happening sure.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah and i think the iranian state has that it's been smart with this external propaganda right like not just in terms of again getting like influences or whatever but also in terms of like just doing very clever sort of propaganda towards American people that I think they have had success.

Speaker 6Exactly.

Speaker 2There are a lot of people who really don't, I think, grasp that this is a regime which routinely murders its own people, which like uses sexual assault as a weapon against against people asking for like basic human rights and freedom. And like those people are between a rock and a hard place. Like they have an oppressive regime that doesn't allow them the freedoms that they want. And then they have the United States using that oppressive regime as a way to manufacture consent for its own attempt to steal

Speaker 2those same resources that you were talking about.

Speaker 1Like, right.

Speaker 2Like the, the reason the alarm province is, is, core is not because it doesn't have things, it's because those things have been taken from the people who live there.

Speaker 6Exactly.

Speaker 2And that's the model that the US is proposing to. Liberation for those people is not going to come from Tehran and it's not going to come from Washington either, unfortunately.

Speaker 6This argument that a lot of people who are against Trump, I mean, I think majority of the world hates Trump. It's clear, but.

Speaker 2Yes, and Americans judging by the most recent election.

Speaker 6Yeah, I mean, even here in Germany, I am very involved in these activities and I have a lot of friends that always talk about it. And I think what I see is that, I wouldn't say all of them, but many of these people who are kind of pro-Iran and they are feeling bad for the Iranian regime is that they just kind of project their own hatred or I don't know how to explain it, but like they

Speaker 6kind of, because they hate Trump so much, they think that whoever is against Trump is good. It doesn't matter what they do. It doesn't matter if they are killing their own people, if they are raping people, if they are murdering women, it doesn't matter. As long as they're against Trump, that's okay for us. And I see the same thing here among some circles that in Germany, they even take Iranian flags on the streets.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 6Alongside Palestinian flags and other flags. There was even a demonstration last year that they even brought Taliban and ISIS flags in the middle of Berlin. So I think sometimes this feeling of being pro-Iran is very selfish because it's not black and white. How do I explain it? It's really hard because Trump is bad, but Iran is also bad. You know, people don't have to take sides. And when

Speaker 6we were talking about this, a lot of people also say, oh, yeah, we need to talk about collective freedom and these kind of things. But I always tell them that I grew up in Kurdistan and I'm just one person who experienced that colonialism, that repression. And everything that we're talking about right now, I experienced all of that. And I'm very young. My family too. And basically every person there has been

Speaker 6experiencing all of these things. So it's not really something that you can come and tell me that, yeah, Trump is bad. We hate Trump. So as long as the Iranian regime is fighting America, they are good.

Speaker 5No, it's not.

Speaker 6Because for us, Both of them are bad because on one side, the Iranian regime is killing us on a daily basis. That's clear. But on the other side, America is also one of the roots of the problem that typical people are suffering from. Like, for example, the sanctions, you know.

Speaker 2Yeah, they hurt regular people.

Speaker 1Yeah, and.

Speaker 6America is one of the main reasons that the sanctions exist. So it's from both sides. And on the other side, if I want to go further, America is also one of the reasons that, I mean, from a Kurdish point of view, America is also one of the reasons that my people in other parts of Kurdistan are suffering because... For America, these things don't matter as long as there is money, there is oil, so they don't care about people's lives. They would do anything. And it's the same for the Iranian regime because America is a colonial state

Speaker 6that's taking everything from most countries around the world. But Iran is doing the same with fewer countries. They were doing that in Yemen, in Afghanistan, in Iraq. I mean, they were doing that in Syria. They destroyed Syria. And they've been doing... the same type of colonialism and theft, if I want to call it, in Kurdistan, in Balochistan, into the Turkmen region of Iran, or as they call it, Turkmen Sarah, and other regions. You know, we talked about Ilan,

Speaker 6we talked about Kurdistan, with all these resources, and the people are basically. Starving there while their cities their farms are basically located on some of the biggest gas or oil resources in the world so this is what's happening both sides are evil and both sides are massacring people in different ways They're killing people, but they're just using different methods.

Speaker 2Right, and different justifications.

Speaker 6And I think it's very unfair. I mean, I always tell people that if you claim that you are for human rights, especially for women's rights, and you show any little amount of sympathy for a regime like the Iranian state, You know, I wouldn't consider you as a human rights activist or a humanist or whatever you call yourself. I wouldn't call you that because, you know, there is a red line and you should not cross that because these

Speaker 6regimes like the Iranian regime have absolutely no respect for human rights, for freedom, for anything.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's just a it's a pretty transactional thing for them. Like they'll use the language of human rights when they think they can get a win from it. But it's not like an ethical principle that they adhere to. I wonder, like, to close up, if people maybe like haven't thought of this this way or they haven't been aware of this. And I understand that.

Speaker 9Right.

Speaker 2Because, again, a coverage of the situation for people in around this country in the media has been poor. And when it has been covered, it has been more or less to just manufacture consent for bombing them. If people want to help, like there's Hangout, there's other organizations monitoring human rights. How can people, if they want to do more than saying that they are in solidarity, angry posting on the internet, what can they do to advocate for people, especially in these, like Balochistan, Kurdistan, these areas where just

Speaker 2by being born, by being from there, you're automatically subject to repression? Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 6I think the first step would be educating yourself on the situation there and to look more into the statistics, the numbers, the stories from these regions and the history of these regions and the people who are being killed on a daily basis. Because there are so many people that are dying that we really lose, you know, we lose count. So sometimes somebody dies and we find out

Speaker 6a year later, this has happened many times. So I think it's important to understand clearly that what's happening there. And that's the first step. And I think at the same time, it's also important to connect with the diaspora communities from regions like Kurdistan, Balochistan, or other, regions and simply talk to people and support these communities outside of

Speaker 6their homeland. Because I'm not sure about the U.S., but I think it's pretty similar because here in Germany, I'm Kurdish. I have Baluchi friends. Even here, we face the same, I mean, it's not the same level, but we still face racism and and fascism from both pro-regime and anti-regime groups. So I think it's important to connect with diaspora communities and also support them more often. And if I want

Speaker 6to say that, oh yeah, it's possible to financially support Kurdistan or Balochistan or something, this is very hard. It's possible, but there is no... easy way like you can't just do a gofundme or something like that it has to be done through a network which i have done it several times and i plan to do it probably in january or something so like what we do is that we collect money through our network and then we send

Speaker 6it back home yeah to trusted people and in small amounts like we wouldn't send i don't know ten thousand dollars or euros We would do it in small amounts because it's safer for the people who are there. And there is not much that you can do, actually. But these are just a few things that our community in Germany has been doing. And I think these are really important. And I think at the same time, it's important for the audience and also for other organizations. or other groups

Speaker 6to connect with the human rights organizations like Hangout, Kurdistan Human Rights Network and many other organizations that are documenting these crimes in their own networks. I think it's important to connect with them and I'm sure that there are people who are in academia and universities and I don't know, institutions that can use this data, this information to make the situation more understandable and more clear for others and

Speaker 6also to somehow bring more attention to that. And I think this is really important. Yeah, this is what I can think of it right now that can be done. to help a little bit because it's a really, um, hard situation now.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 2I think that it's important for people to realize that like, you can't just send money. What you can do, like you said, is support like migrants from that diaspora in your community, because those people are probably sending money home. They're probably supporting their family at home. And like, it's important that those people, like we've seen people deported to Iran. I've reported a lot on, on, like the access that the Iranian regime has to people in immigration detention. So like where there are people, you know, where be they below G Kurdish Persian who are afraid of being returned

Speaker 2to the Iranian state and the danger they would immediately be in as soon as they got off that plane, like it's good to support migrant communities.

Speaker 6Exactly.

Speaker 2Where can people find your work if they want to follow along?

Speaker 6Well, honestly, I haven't been so active recently because I'm dealing with a lot of personal stuff. You know, life in Germany for a refugee is not easy, but they can always follow Hengau Organization for Human Rights. I'm not really that active anymore there either, but I'm still there. We post and publish daily reports on the things that are happening.

Speaker 3And.

Speaker 6This is one of the best sources that I can also recommend and also the Kurdistan Human Rights Network. I would also advocate for another Kurdish media. I think you probably know them. They are called the Amargi. They're also based in Germany.

Speaker 2Yeah, they've been doing really good work.

Speaker 6Yeah, and I published something there like a few months ago as well. And they're my friends.

Speaker 17I know them.

Speaker 6And they also post and publish a lot of really, really good articles about the whole situation in Kurdistan and also in the Middle East. So they're not Kurdish focused, but they're really international. And there are many experts there that are publishing really, really good stuff, which I highly recommend for everyone to follow that up.

Speaker 2Yeah, you've reminded me that I agreed to write something for them and I have forgotten to do so. So I need to email them. Yeah, thank you very much for your time today. Thank you very much for sharing all that stuff. And yeah, hopefully we'll have something more positive to follow up on soon.

Speaker 4This is It Could Happen Here, Executive Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening in the White House, the crumbling world, and what this means for you. I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm joined by Mia Wong, James Stout, and Robert Evans. This episode we are covering the week of November 11th to November 18th. Senator Chris Van Hollen has officially announced his bid to become Senate Majority Leader, challenging current Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. On Sunday, Holland said he has the backing of 15 senators. Meanwhile, Schumer has insisted he has

Speaker 4enough votes to become leader. Nearly 300 journalists and media workers at Reuters, represented by the News Guild of New York, have voted to authorize a strike after more than a year of bargaining.

Speaker 5Good for them. We'll see how that shakes out.

Speaker 4Also in New York, Mayor Mamdani has negotiated with Trump a 90-day extension for bodegas and other small businesses. to comply with new SNAP authorization rules on stocking standards. Basically, rules mandating a certain number of ingredients or varieties of types of ingredients have to be in stock in order for these businesses to have SNAP be a valid method of payment. This 90-day delayed implementation of these new SNAP requirements will apply to bodegas and small retailers all across

Speaker 4the country, not just here in New York.

Speaker 2All right, let's start off with a friend of the Cool Zone Media Network, School of the Americas. A Defense Department memo, which mostly deals with the service colleges, and it's mostly the usual Hegseth shit, right? Like it uses warriors, it uses warfighters.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2Probably uses lethality a lot.

Speaker 1They love those words.

Speaker 2Yeah, you can imagine him like judo chopping like a two by four in his office right after writing this memo. It also talks a lot about AI, another thing they love, right? It includes a rather menacing bullet point towards the end that reads, quote, develop options to align the America's counter cartel coalition with the Inter-American Defense College to create joint learning opportunities with alliance partners on strategies to target, disrupt and eradicate transnational drug cartels and narco-terrorist networks from the Western Hemisphere.

Speaker 6God.

Speaker 2It sounds a lot like School of the Americas 2.0, right? At some point, we will do an episode on these CIA guys who died in Mexico, I'm sure.

Speaker 1RIP.

Speaker 2Yeah, pouring one out for those guys. The stuff they were doing was wild. The way they were operating without knowledge of the Mexican federal government was pretty bonkers. Shocking they died.

Speaker 7Wow.

Speaker 2Who could have imagined?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2In a car crash.

Speaker 4Wow.

Speaker 2The US is doing a lot of stuff in the Western Hemisphere right now, especially with regard to targeting what it sees as cartels or organized crime. And I think this points towards a tendency that it has to try and do these deniable operations in the Western Hemisphere right now. Let's move on to Kurdistan. Protests about Kurdish language education were ongoing in Kamishlo. When I wrote this, it's still out this week, students sort of blockaded a Syrian government delegation and demanded that the University of Rojava not be

Speaker 2incorporated into the University of Euphrates and that they be given access to education in Kurdish. This is an ongoing issue that has been an issue for months now that the Syrian transitional government has not given students access to education in Kurdish, both at K-12 level and the higher education level. Let's move on. The FBI is asking for help. They need some mutual aid. They're looking for people who flew a drone near Ronald Reagan Airport in restricted airspace. It's kind of wild to me that they have very

Speaker 2clear pictures of these people. Really clear.

Speaker 3You'd think anyone who recognized them could spot it, but maybe they've just.

Speaker 2All got good friends. Yeah, and you know what made them even clearer? What? is asking Grok to enhance them on X.com.

Speaker 13Oh, good.

Speaker 2We're doing that still. Several brain geniuses have done, yeah. But it's kind of remarkable that these guys are flying a device which is paired to a controller in D.C., right, at the Reagan Airport, or maybe just outside D.C., and the FBI has very clear pictures of them, and they can't find them. They will occasionally post these, like, bolos or whatever, but it can't not be linked to the fact that the federal government has fired a bunch of people and the podcaster is in charge of the FBI now.

Speaker 4I can't believe having fun with your friends is illegal now.

Speaker 3Because of woke.

Speaker 2Yeah, woke 3.0 is crazy.

Speaker 5Finally, the mayor of Auckland, New Zealand, a man named Wayne Brown, said in a recent interview, quote, democracy's had its day. It's time for something else, really. And quote, what's working? China's working. You know, in terms of economic growth and prosperity, this is, again, the mayor of the largest city of New Zealand. This is part of several major trends, including a continual push-pull between different political factions in the Pacific over economic integration with the CCP. Another

Speaker 5trend of dudes going to Shenzhen or Guangzhou, running into a normal city instead of whatever racist fantasy they'd imagined, and immediately convincing themselves that China is the greatest country on Earth. Wayne Brown watched the election in new zealand from a hotel in guangzhou oh wow and obviously of course this is this is part of the emerging trend of the historical unity of the bourgeoisie manifesting itself in increasingly overt dictatorships of the bourgeoisie we will keep you updated if if wayne brown is able to successfully bring

Speaker 5the formal bourgeois party state apparatus to the people of new zealand any day now i'm sure it's coming it's coming godspeed wayne For our first kind.

Speaker 4Of main story or collection of main stories, let's go back a week. Last Thursday, November 12th, millions of people wake up, get dressed, go to work, turn on their computer, boot up Outlook and are met with a huge sigh of relief. Thank God I don't need to use Microsoft 365 today. Who knows how many workers were freed from having to use the worst email service ever.

Speaker 3So many people got to avoid Outlook. Really, Microsoft should get an award for breaking their own product.

Speaker 4Not to mention Microsoft Teams, right? Which feels like it was designed by.

Speaker 15One of those. The devil.

Speaker 2The devil himself.

Speaker 4Specifically one of those energy vampires from what we do in the Shadows TV show, which kind of sucked. the life force out of you through bureaucratic nonsense.

Speaker 1Yeah, I can see that.

Speaker 5It was great. We had this day of peace.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 4Almost the entire Microsoft 365 suite was down late last week for 24 hours. So really it should be called Microsoft 364.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 4The Anderson Economic Group, a think tank, estimated the lost productivity stemming from the Microsoft outage could cost at least $ 7 billion, and they think that's an undercount.

Speaker 2But can you put a price on joy?

Speaker 5Apparently $ 7 billion.

Speaker 2It's worth it. I think it was worth it, yeah.

Speaker 4Police departments in the UK told people to report crimes via telephone rather than online through their website.

Speaker 9Love it.

Speaker 5Incredible.

Speaker 4So that means Gen Z is not going to be reporting any crime because they're too scared to use the phone. And as fun as it is to make fun of Microsoft, Outlook, and their other cloud software, these services do provide essential services and support critical infrastructure. And last week's outage didn't just impact big businesses. It also affected schools, universities, hospitals, pharmacies, local governments, banks, courts, and it disrupted stuff like bond payments, and people being released from prison. An outage of this

Speaker 4scale immediately led people to wonder if this was some kind of cyber attack or the result of what I'll term AI bullshit. According to Microsoft, no. The outage was a, quote, technical issue not related to cyber or AI slash agents. Now, it did take them a while to figure out what exactly went wrong. Microsoft has credited three compounding factors, a months-old latent bug, shifting data traffic and server capacity issues, which worked together to just totally.

Speaker 5Break Microsoft's cloud apps.

Speaker 4Microsoft 365 has two networking gateways, basically data paths. So if one has issues, traffic can be routed to the other. About 15 hours before the outage, Microsoft Teams data was redirected from the alternate to the primary gateway. And at the same time, server capacity was diminished due to unrelated issues from the previous day. So the new traffic patterns created a data traffic jam, which overwhelmed the servers and

Speaker 4exposed this latent bug from an update like last July. Charles Lamina, the executive vice president of co-pilot agents and platform at Microsoft, wrote on X, quote, taken together, the increased load and the reduced server capacity caused the network gateway to encounter the latent bug from July. This caused requests to build up until servers ultimately stopped working. This occurred during the peak window of traffic in the United States, unquote.

Speaker 5It sure did.

Speaker 4Now, ordinarily in isolation, reduced server capacity and increased gateway traffic could kind of be pretty easily resolved by themselves. These aren't huge issues. But together with the latent bug, This triggered, quote-unquote, cascading failure, which froze more than 80% of Microsoft's networking gateway servers. The automatic data rerouting that Microsoft does to avoid service disruptions, in this case, just spread the problem across their whole system.

Speaker 6Incredible.

Speaker 4To quote Charles from Microsoft, quote, this caused a cascading failure from server to server as the same amount of load was spread across fewer systems. In less than two hours, the previously unknown defect was encountered across our fleet and rendered them unresponsive. He added, recovery took longer than usual because as servers returned to service, they were immediately overwhelmed by waiting traffic and became unresponsive again. Our normally automated

Speaker 4recovery processes were not designed to restore service from this broad unresponsive state. Additionally, since the main code defect was a latent bug from several months previous, our normal rollback, flighting, and feature flags were unable to quickly revert the change. So they couldn't just set their system back a few days to whatever the previously working version was because that version still had the bug inside it. So it made it pretty hard to fix this problem. Within 24 to 36 hours, Microsoft was back online and they patched the bug.

Speaker 4Then five days later, iCloud and Apple Pay also went down for some users after a, quote, internal update caused some outages on Tuesday, according to Apple. But it's not just Microsoft and Apple that ran into issues this week.

Speaker 5Robert, do you want to talk about the airplanes?

Speaker 3Yeah, I feel like I should probably talk about the airplanes. This is something everyone's going to be very aware of. But on November 10th, the FAA posted a press release announcing its new SMART system. That's an acronym, so it belongs in all caps. The SMART system is an AI-powered communication system built to advise and coordinate between air traffic controllers. And it was rolled out on a national basis after having previously undergone a trial period in the D.C. area. This is not going where you think it's going to go, but I do need to start with this. About three days later, on November 13th, starting at 3.30 p.m. Eastern

Speaker 3Standard Time, our collective air travel telecommunications network got its shit fucked up. I'll talk about what probably happened, really, a little later. But at first, all anyone knew was that everything was, like, down, right? The network that supported communication and radar systems that was used by our air traffic controllers was no longer functional in 17 of the FAA's 22 air route traffic control centers, or ARTCCs.

Speaker 7So.

Speaker 3The FAA issued a national ground stop and halted all departures at airports across the United States. This is only the third time that this has ever happened. The first was obviously 9-11, and you can be forgiven if, like me, your first reaction upon hearing that there had been a total ground stop was to ask, who's got eyes.

Speaker 2On George W.

Speaker 9Bush?

Speaker 2Has he been up to anything yet, you know?

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 3Obviously, it was not another 9-11. He's too busy painting. But once that was clear, everyone online pivoted to assuming that this had something to do with AI. Now, this was not an ignorant or unreasonable assumption. The FAA had just started the nationwide rollout of an AI flight control planning system days earlier. So it's not weird that people connected those two things. And before I go into more detail, I need to say up front, this probably was not caused by AI, at least not directly. There's not really good evidence of that.

Speaker 6First.

Speaker 3Let's look at what actually happened to cause all this based on the documentation we have currently. Earlier in the afternoon of the 13th, sometime before 3.30 p.m. EST, the FAA started noticing glitches in its communications, specifically at their center in Indianapolis that monitors high-altitude flights over the middle of the country. Within minutes, the errors spread, disrupting comms between pilots and air traffic control. At first, the disruptions were, per the Wall Street Journal, just static and interruptions. FAA employees tried to figure out what the issue was, and

Speaker 3they isolated the source of the problem to two locations. One was a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and the other was an FAA radio center in El Dorado, Arkansas. Per MSN, quote, network gear at the Arkansas site, and possibly the one in Texas, overloaded the communication system that thousands of air traffic controllers used to guide pilots through the nation's airspace. We saw two places that were actually pinging our network at a very high rate, a thousand connections over every four to five seconds, Rebecca Guy, the FAA's technology chief, said at a Saturday press conference. These

Speaker 3pings traversed a tangle of copper wires and fiber optic cables that feed into the FAA telecommunications infrastructure, or FTI. The decades-old system is outdated and undergoing a multi-billion dollar upgrade to move into the fiber optic age. And this is actually basically what caused the second ever, I mean, not this literal thing, but the fact that the system is outdated is what caused our second ever nationwide flight grounding, which hit in January of 2023. This happened before and it happened very recently and it happened for a similar reason, which is that like our shit's really outdated and we

Speaker 3actually genuinely do need to fix.

Speaker 5This system, right?

Speaker 3And update it to the modern era. Unfortunately, the people we have making that happen right now include former reality show contestant, Sean Duffy, who has been overseeing the upgrading process for some time. although the work was done by a defense contractor known as L3Harris. Most upgrades are done in the evening to minimize the impact on travelers, but sometimes mistakes happen, and that's very likely what occurred this time. The probable cause of everything getting fucked up is that several days before this went down, L3Harris installed a new

Speaker 3router at the FAA's Arkansas facility. The router, made by Juniper Networks, started spitting out a crazy amount of data, way more than the system could handle. This cascaded, and that's what fucked your shit up if you happen to be traveling on the 13th. Data from the Arkansas router and one other router overwhelmed the system. Per FAA Administrator Brian Bedford, who walked the Wall Street Journal through the process, was it a faulty installation?

Speaker 2Was it a faulty configuration?

Speaker 3Or was it just a bad piece of router technology that we put into this system that propagated these errors? They don't really know right now. They've taken at least one of the routers into custody, and they're, I think, trying to figure out exactly what caused the issue. Now, I know there's been a lot of doubt and some conspiracizing around this. Oh, they're trying to protect the AI company, et cetera, by blaming it on this router. But believing that means that L3 Harris, a major defense contractor, must have agreed to take the blame for fucking up everybody's flights to protect an AI. Like, why would they do that? Like,

Speaker 3what does that benefit L3 Harris, right? Now, it's still possible, I should say, that AI played a role in this. But if so, it would be like an indirect role. Something like the people who installed these routers checked in with AI when they were installing them, and the AI gave them bad info, and.

Speaker 2That caused it. That's not impossible, right?

Speaker 3We really have no way of knowing at this point what went wrong. But it was probably either something, either the Juniper device itself was fucked up, but it seems more likely somebody made a mistake while installing these things, right? I don't really need or expect more of an explanation than that for my own self. I should note that there's been a viral claim since this all happened, basically pointing out that Sean Duffy's son-in-law, U.S. Representative-elect Michael Alfonso, has a stake in Airspace Intelligence's which is the AI

Speaker 3company that built that AI powered smart traffic management tool.

Speaker 2For the FAA.

Speaker 5Of course.

Speaker 4Oh my gosh.

Speaker 3So people are claiming this fuck up is tied to them and they're covering it up. And like, look, first off, Snopes has looked into this. They pointed out that ASI did donate money to Alfonso's election pack, but it was like $ 2, 500, not $ 12, 500.

Speaker 1As some people claim.

Speaker 3And that's still not enough to get L3 Harris to pretend that this was them when it wasn't, right?

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 3Snopes also reported that neither Alfonso or Duffy has a direct stake in ASI. I don't know how much I trust that. There's ways to obfuscate that shit. Now, considering they donated to Alfonso's campaign and won an almost $ 900 million FAA contract, I understand why people are suspicious. And I would agree that the relationship between these people and that company is suggestive of corruption of some kind. It just doesn't mean that it's what caused this, right? Now, do I think that Sean Duffy's being generally incompetent and not fit for this job had something to.

Speaker 13Do with this?

Speaker 2That's a problem.

Speaker 3I think that's a reasonable thing to.

Speaker 7Say, right? Yeah.

Speaker 3But that doesn't mean that this is like an AI cover up or whatever. And again, I guess my best piece of evidence as to why I don't think this has to be an AI cover up is that we had a very similar outage in 2023 and it was due to outdated equipment fucking up.

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 3Like it's just not I don't need this to be people protecting some AI, both for it to make sense and also for it to still be a story of like, well, the Trump administration is fucking bad at everything.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 5So there was also another set of outages over the weekend. There was a decently significant disruption of banking services stemming from an outage at JPMorgan Chase Bank, which caused a ripple effect as other banks attempting to interact with JPMorgan Chase were unable to do so. Unlike the other outages, we know almost nothing about this outage other than this. Chase posted on Twitter saying, quote, now the only other

Speaker 5information that we have about this whatever this internal software issue was is a statement per the hill that the fbi gave that this was a software issue and not any kind of cyber attack this is almost certainly true i think the largest conspiracy about this has been there's been some kind of cover-up of an iranian cyber attack and no just no um A, because they would have claimed responsibility because that's the thing that running back groups, when they do any kind of like, we took down

Speaker 5a website, you get 7,000 people going, hey, we did this. But then also, as we've mentioned earlier with these other kinds of outages, there have been outages like this in the past few years. There was one, I think there was one earlier this year, but they get less press attention because they're not happening at the same time as everything else. This is something that is kind of in a similar way to that period where everyone was really into fires at food processing plants.

Speaker 4Yes, or airplane runway collisions or something.

Speaker 5Yeah, a bunch of things happened at the same time, and they are, to some extent, signs of, yeah, our software infrastructure and our physical infrastructure in this country are bad, and they are underfunded, and they are not maintained very well, but multiple things went wrong at the same time. and not there was a giant conspiracy of a covered up Iranian cyber attack. So yeah, but we still know nothing about what the actual bug was other than they said there was a bug in the physical hardware.

Speaker 3Yeah, I think one thing that also people need to keep in mind around this time of year is that the weeks before Black Friday are when a lot of shit gets like, fixes get rolled up out. And sometimes that means stuff gets fucked up, especially when security teams have been thinned out and are all using ai too.

Speaker 4Yeah yeah i mean as much as these these sorts of things may not be directly ai related i think the reason why part of why they're being reported on so much is because of just the scale of the outlook and the faa issues which yeah then cause news reports to find other instances of of similar events happening But also, I think there's also been other reporting in the past few weeks about AI systems like discovering vulnerabilities in various websites that then require quick patches. And sometimes those patches can then run into issues, which then takes the service down. It's kind of funny that people are

Speaker 4jumping to like AI as this explanation, even when we don't have like a clear idea. It's like if this was a cyber attack, if this was like an AI agent doing an attack. Because as AI tools get integrated into more kind of software and cloud software, there is problems that AI discovers that then do require fixes.

Speaker 2Yeah, and I think that building what you just said, Garrison, is most likely what happened to the NSA, which is the final computer meltdown of the week so far. I guess it's Wednesday. So the NSA net, NSA net is like an internal secure communications network used by the National Security Agency, went down. according to CNN. Like what we're saying, what they have said is this was a result of a patch applied to address the massive security issue that Robert spoke about earlier this month with PHP. And when

Speaker 2those security flaws were made public, everyone scrambled to fix their website or their program or whatever, right? In this case, they scrambled to fix NSAnet. And according to Director of National Intelligence, Jay Clayton, that was what caused NSAnet to go down. For a time... They did issue a code yellow.

Speaker 5Oh, okay.

Speaker 2Which is like the second tier of their security system, right? They staggered employee arrivals that day. So they had emergency employees come in and then other employees come in like in a staggered fashion. I'm guessing just because their systems weren't working, right? And I'm guessing it's probably a fairly involved process of checking in when you get to the NSA. It's not like you walk through the revolving door and pick up the secret documents.

Speaker 5Yes, that makes sense.

Speaker 2They were back at a code green by Tuesday evening. So yeah, NSA back. But yeah, yet another system that capitulated under the load this week. That might be affecting a lot fewer people than the others. So talking of capitulating, it's time for us to capitulate to the demands of our advertisers, I think. Here's one for Microsoft Teams.

Speaker 5I hope not. We are back. Robert.

Speaker 3All right. So I wanted to talk about something that just kind of worried me a little bit this week or gave me, I should say, gave me a deep sense of foreboding. I came across a post by a user, imgeovanh on Blue Sky, who was working on some project using several cloud bots and saw them start canceling work requests and killing processes because it decided that some of the stuff he was asking them to do violated their policies. If I'm understanding properly, It was like a copyright thing. He was doing some like game cobbling or something. Now, again,

Speaker 3we're not talking about like he was planning a mass shooting or something. You know, as best I can tell, again, Claude was worried that he was like violating some rule that the company Anthropic had set around like copyright.

Speaker 7Which.

Speaker 5Yeah, I know, guys.

Speaker 6I know.

Speaker 5Sorry, I can't not.

Speaker 3I don't use any of these chatbots or agents. I'm going to guess most of our listeners don't unless it's something that's literally required in whatever company you work for. But this actually is something you should find concerning, even if you've taken a strong line on not using this stuff, because like it or not, a lot of people do use these services, and it's entirely possible they will become the only way most people can do a number of things with computers and online that we used to handle in a, let's say, an analog fashion, right? Stuff like coding small-scale video game projects or editing images. So why

Speaker 3should it bother you? Why should this bother you if you don't use AI? Well, I looked into that user, and he's got a blog. He calls it GeoCities, like G-I-O, cities. It's a little joke, right? And he writes on that, and I think this is prescient. There is a tendency, especially among technically competent people, to use the ability to work around a requirement as an excuse to avoid dealing with it. When there is a political push to enforce a certain pattern of behavior, discourage or ban something, or to make something socially unacceptable, there is an instinct for clever people with workarounds to respond with, you can just

Speaker 3use my.

Speaker 1Workaround, right?

Speaker 3And this hit me because that is like, I'm that kind of guy. When I want to watch the BBC, I use a VPN or I pirate media, right? But the point this person is making is that you can't always count on the existence of a workaround on a way to, oh, I'm pissed off that there's these, Microsoft has fucking, they've got an AI watching what you put into Word and you can't write some stuff. So I'll just crack my own version of Word or something like that. Or I'll use like a different like version of the, like a different kind of like word processing software, right? You can't always count on stuff like that. You can't always count on the ability to jailbreak your phone or

Speaker 3to use a browser extension to let you right click on a site that's disabled that possibility, right? You know, that's the kind of thing that right now a lot of these work, but a lot of these workarounds are based on on holes, right? On holes in the way systems work that a number of these AI programs are better at finding and are better at closing than before, right? I can tell you I'll find a way around it has been like my watchword for every limitation ever placed in my digital path for as long as I've been online. But one thing Gio points out is that, quote, relying on hacks and workarounds is a kind of normalization of deviance,

Speaker 3a reliance on an unrecommended or unsafe practice that becomes standard operating procedure. The deviation here isn't the workaround, it's the reliance on the workaround. Trusting in the ability to hack around a requirement introduces risk, the potential for the workaround to be prevented without any alternative. When we succeed in avoiding trouble, we feel prideful and superior instead of understanding that we're still in constant danger. It's true that you shouldn't have to fight a forever war against corporations orders of magnitude more powerful than you are just to maintain your way of life. But even if you wanted to, you can't. As hard and narrow as the path may be,

Speaker 3there's nothing keeping it from being completely destroyed. And what worries me is that the expansion of AI is going to come for everything we do on the computer. At the moment, I can disable Copilot or Google Gemini. And even though I do, I like find my phone constantly opening Gemini because I like press the wrong button. I don't even know what button it is, but it'll like try to send me there or fucking one of the annoying things. Google is now hiding their like AI search results and making it look like it's an article. And so sometimes like I wake up in the morning, I'll click on what I think is a headline and it'll take me to their AI.

Speaker 2And I'm like, I don't want this fucking shit, Google.

Speaker 3How much longer are they going to let me have even the fractious degree of control that I have currently? Many of the workarounds I enjoy work because of flaws in code or holes in systems that AI will allow developers to patch and block with greater speed than ever. Geo brings up the fact that game preservation relies heavily on piracy because game companies have zero interest in preserving culture and actually work around the clock to make it illegal and impossible to preserve culture.

Speaker 4And.

Speaker 3one of the things he points out is that this assumption that we'll always have piracy, that it will always exist and always be possible, that's not a guarantee. You actually can't say that to a point of certainty. And as he points out, there are no technical limitations that prevent any system from being secured to block whatever workarounds you rely on. And that's just kind of the thing I want to highlight here in terms of the stuff that we have to be concerned about. It's not just People are trying to make you use this stuff. It's not just that these are taking away jobs from certain people.

Speaker 3It's not just that they're creating more slop. It's that they are enabling a greater degree of control over how we compute and use computers and the internet. And we can't guarantee that just because we say no to this stuff and don't want to use any of these AI tools, that we will continue to have the ability to use our tools as we are right now, right? That that will remain possible into the foreseeable future. And- I think it's a reason, number one, why as much as I hate a lot of this stuff, I do pay attention

Speaker 3to what people are doing with it. I pay attention to what it's functional at. I pay attention to what it's bad at. And I pay attention to how stuff is evolving because I do feel like it's a threat to my way of life. And the better way to deal with that threat is to keep an eye on it rather than to just be like, well, this is AI shit and I don't use any of that. So I'm not paying attention to it. You do kind of have to pay attention to it to a degree because- It's coming for the stuff that you do and for the things that you rely on, whether you want it to or not.

Speaker 5I think there's an important part of this that you mentioned, which is the extent to which this is about control over computing itself. There's a Sam Altman quote where he's complaining about everyday people having RAM in their computers rather than data centers. That got clowned on a lot, but part of what's happening here is that these companies want to make it so that they are the people who control the world's computing power. And that if you want to do, if you want to actually use a computer

Speaker 5to do something, you have to work through their services so that they can control them and they can set the rules, you know, dating back to the sort of arguments, but like the Apple walled garden and stuff that like Microsoft has been doing for a long time.

Speaker 3Or even, even what happened with social media, right? The term that people use before Facebook ate, the old internet was a splinter net that like these splintered internets, the social media companies were creating would become the internet and and it would permanently reduce people's freedom.

Speaker 5And it has. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And the kind of decentralization that the old internet required is fundamentally not good for capital, and it's not good for these, you know, sort of tech fascist ability to control all of society.

Speaker 2And that's Yeah.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 15Yeah.

Speaker 3Hostile computers that users fundamentally do not control and which act against the wishes of users are more profitable to the industries that control the design and sale of those computers. The incentive to design computers as double agents to trap and control users slash customers is extreme and warrants significant vigilance to prevent. And I guess that's the thing I would like our listeners thinking about and aware of, because it's going to continue to be a fight to have any freedom to do anything at all on the computer other than whatever Sam Altman or whoever is the tech

Speaker 3oligarch of the day decides you should be able to do.

Speaker 10All right.

Speaker 2Yeah, talking of things that are shit, let's talk about genocide. So on the 19th of this month, that'll be the day, if you hear this today, it comes out the day before you hear it. That's the day after we're recording it. I will drop in a pickup to tell you the result. We will hear a verdict on the case brought in the ICJ in 2019 of the Gambia versus Myanmar case. It's going to be a little difficult to refer to this case because I don't want to call it the Gambia case because obviously there's like a double definite article there. But the Gambia bought the case in 2019 because it's

Speaker 2a signatory to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Myanmar has also ratified most of that, including Article 9. And it's Article 9 that allows one signatory to bring a case against another signatory, right? And that is what the Gambia is doing here. It has been supported by a number of other states. It, of course, is bringing this case because it was a genocide that began in 2017 against the Rohingya people in Rakhine state by the Burmese military and the Burmese state.

Speaker 2We've covered that in scripted episodes Robert and I have done about Myanmar. It's also covered in a chapter of my book. Since the Gambia brought this case, a number of other states, including Ireland, the UK, the DRC, France, Germany, and Canada, have filed declarations of intervention in the case, evidently to support the case against Myanmar. This will be the court's first decision in a genocide case since 2015. And thus far in its history, the court has not found a state to have violated the convention because of

Speaker 2the way the court understands intent. The intent is very important, not just the actions. If they are satisfied with the intent in this case, it will pave the way for doing the same in the case of South Africa, regarding Israel's genocide in Gaza. I guess I want to take a moment to say that it upsets me a great deal when people are only interested in this because it reflects on Gaza. I've seen way too much of that. Like, do Rohingya people's lives not matter? Is what happened to them not important? Is there only one type of person

Speaker 2who you want to be upset if they're genocided? It's a very pure way of understanding the world. So it seems very likely that the court would rule against Myanmar in this case. What happens then is that's a final and binding judgment. So it's not like Myanmar can just go and be like, hey, we're repealing, right? If they fail to comply... The Gambia can go to the United Nations Security Council, which can suggest order measures be taken. States can also intervene without waiting for the United Nations

Speaker 2Security Council. Obviously, when we talk about a security council in Myanmar, we've got the issue of a potential Russia or Chinese veto, right? But in 22, after the coup, they abstained. They didn't veto. Now, China has been a supporter of the junta, but also like, has supported some of the larger rebel groups which are aligned more with the PRC. And it seems to be like in a period of being a bit less supportive of the junta than other periods where it's been a bit more supportive.

Speaker 2Russia has increased its support quite significantly, right? Like there are Russian drone ops in Myanmar, there are Russian drones in Myanmar, there's Russian tech, there's Russian trainers.

Speaker 5Can you speak to why they are supporting the junta more?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's part of this like multipolar world sort of strategy, right? This desire to have a foothold in Asia because Russia and China do not align. The idea that they could have a foothold in this part of the world in a place that borders China.

Speaker 7Okay.

Speaker 2It's not unlike why they were willing, and they're also extracting a great deal of materials from Syria. And there are, of course, a great deal of materials that they could extract from Myanmar, chiefly rare earth metals, right? In the way that the United States has pursued... informal empire around the world in part to secure its supply chain and influence, Russia is doing a similar thing, I guess I would say.

Speaker 5So it's similar to their interventions in Libya and places like that?

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2I saw a group that monitors conflicts in Africa has been monitoring the deaths of Russian mercenaries in Africa. Hundreds of Russians have died in Africa in the last few months. They are doing this all over the world. It doesn't get covered In part, because the US has struggled to cover anything in Africa in a way that recognizes Africa as lots of countries and a continent, not one country. That's part of why it doesn't get covered, I guess. The same with Myanmar. The US media has been very poor at covering the conflict there. I guess talking about

Speaker 2the US angle, judges at the ICJ are increasingly concerned with the very real possibility that the Trump administration is will place sanctions on them following the judgment. The Trump administration has been suggesting that some kind of bar lowering for genocide is occurring and that the goal is to fight against Israel and the South Africa versus Israel case, right? Israel has cleared every bar that it needed to clear for genocide. No one needed to drop a bar for

Speaker 2Israel to enthusiastically vault over it when it comes to what genocide is. United States itself has previously concluded that what happened in Rakhine State was genocide. Of course, people are confused because they're thinking, well, didn't the US sanction the ICC? Yes, the ICJ is for states. The ICC is for people. So this would be a continuation of what it did against the ICC. This case, unfortunately, however

Speaker 2it resolves, is between states, right? It's between the Gambia and Myanmar. It would therefore only, first of all, the junta doesn't really give a flying fuck about international law at this point, right? Like it continues to murder civilians deliberately every day. But it wouldn't also bind the Arakan army. And the Arakan army are now the people who control much of Rakhine state. They have shown both intent and action, Sudhaa,

Speaker 2very similar to those the junta took in 2017. There's been a perverse shift in the junta's policy towards the Rohingya. The Arakan army has sought to construct a case that the Rohingya people don't belong in Rakhine state, that they are migrants, they should therefore be removed, that they are not residents, they're not from there, that they are undocumented, something that the junta was doing not so long ago. They have also in multiple incidents killed Rohingya civilians. I speak to Rohingya people who are in camps in Cox's

Speaker 2Bazaar on a relatively frequent basis and have heard terrible things. The Tatmadaw, the Burmese military in response, has used this to force Rohingya youth into its own military. I did a show on this with Aung Kyaw Mo. Aung Kyaw Mo is a minister in the National Unity Government, which is the opposition government in Myanmar that represents the people removed by the coup, the legislators removed by the coup. It is one of the opposition forces in Myanmar, by no means the only one. I have spoken with him

Speaker 2about what is happening with Rohingya people, which is that they are being forced into conscription by the junta, forced to fight for the very same entity that is being tried here for genociding their people. We also have this issue of the RSO and ARSA, both of which are militias that are in theory defending Rohingya people. In practice, they act as gangs. in camps in Bangladesh. They will occasionally fight the AA as well. All of this leaves Rohingya civilians trapped in the middle. As we spoke about

Speaker 2just last week, things are getting harder for them in the places where they've had to flee. The Burmese state was very hostile for them for a long period of time before 2017. But after 2017, we saw this huge exodus. And unfortunately, conditions in Cox's Bazaar and elsewhere have been horrific for Rohingya people and are getting worse and they're being criminalized when they try to organize against those things. This decision isn't going to change that. And there still needs to be a great deal of support. Obviously, it

Speaker 2makes me so happy to see people have so much solidarity for Palestine, but I would love to see that same solidarity for Rohingya people as well. Because they've had a really fucking horrific decade and for the most part like they've been used as a rhetorical device in the u.s to talk about how bad facebook is but like actual solidarity for them has really been lacking and uh yeah that makes me sad i'll try and do an interview with some people in the camps we sent them some microphones and shit it's just very hard for them to get connectivity that would allow us to have that

Speaker 2conversation but uh keep trying Hey, it's James with a pickup. So I'm recording this on the morning of the 19th of November, when we learned that the International Court of Justice has delivered a judgment. It has ruled that the Union of Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya people in Rakhine State in 2017. This is a major first, right? It's the first time a state has ever been found by the ICJ to have committed genocide as opposed to have

Speaker 2committed genocidal acts, because there was the court decided a genocidal intent in Myanmar to destroy the Rohingya people, right? The court also took into consideration things like the large and widespread destruction of people's houses, the use of sexual assault as a weapon. It's a judgment that really matters to Rohingya people. I was speaking to a friend in Cox's Bazaar this morning, Cox's Bazaar being the refugee camp where the largest proportion of Rohingya people still are. There are more than a million Rohingya refugees still outside Myanmar,

Speaker 2and he said he was over the moon with what he'd heard. I think for a lot of these people, it just feels like they are being seen because for so long, the world has ignored the terrible, terrible things that happened to them. The ruling obliges Myanmar, it says compensation will be decided at a later date, but to allow people to return with safety and dignity, that's a big swing, right? Like the junta does not control most of Rakhine State, the AAN, has said things which are

Speaker 2equally bad about the Rohingya people and has burned many of their homes too. So this doesn't solve the problem, but it is nonetheless an important step. I will link to a press release from the court so you can read more about all the individual charges brought by the Gambia and where the court landed.

Speaker 1Up on each of them.

Speaker 2But I wanted to update you to let you know that the court had found that Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya people nine years ago in Rakhine State.

Speaker 5So speaking of, I guess, a more positive kind of conflict in Bangladesh, I can't believe I'm saying more positive over a segment that I'm starting with a line from Daniel Kahn and the Painted Birds, The Butcher's Share, which is every pair of pants and grain of rice contains a horror story at its price. The story of the power people wield, the story about factories and fields of which you'll never have to be aware. just as long as the butcher gets his share. And today, one of

Speaker 5those butchers operating in Bangladesh is the large number of clothing companies that are operating in Bangladesh, where it is probably too strong of a statement to say on whose behalf the police are once again attacking protesting workers in a resurgence of the protests we have been documenting in that country. But that is in effect what is happening today. There has been another intensification of these protests as the government's wage board, which is supposed to be the board that sets sectoral minimum wages for the garment sector, which is, again,

Speaker 54 million people, most of whom are women, most of whom are migrant workers, was supposed to meet last week but failed to. Reportedly, this is due to one of the representatives of the workers feeling sick. I don't know whether that's true or not. That's the report that has been coming out. Workers are deeply unhappy about this, and there were massive protests. I think about 20,000 people were protesting outside of the building of the wage board after the meeting was cancelled. The board is set to meet

Speaker 5again November 23rd, but in the meantime, workers are incredibly pissed off because they do not believe that the wage board is going to actually meet their demands for Again, $ 240 a month as a minimum wage, which is just horrifying. They're also pissed off because management has been using a, basically like a, I don't know if quirk is the right word, but a couple of things that are in

Speaker 5Bangladeshi labor law that allow them to just impose lockouts at will. So owners are also shutting down factories and refusing to let workers work. So that has also been fueling the protests, which had looked like they were dying down. So this has led to yet another round of clashes in multiple cities. And I think this is an important thing to keep track of because, I mean, not just

Speaker 5fast fashion, but all clothes that are produced in the world are produced in conditions that are significantly worse than they used to be In the peak of the labor movement, a significant portion of the peak of the historical labor movement was about making sure that the largely women who make clothes aren't being treated like this. And those gains have been reversed. And this is the consequence.

Speaker 6Of that.

Speaker 5The fashion industry is built on the almost unfathomable human suffering of people at the other end of the supply chain who structurally we are never like supposed to see. And this is a fight over whether or not the conditions that they've been forced to work in, which is, again, like $ 125 a month, are the conditions that are going to prevail in this industry. And I think people have a tendency to look at these wages and start calculating

Speaker 5out what the purchasing power is. And I think that if you believe that people in other countries don't deserve the same wages as people in the And it pisses me off and sucks, but this is one of the most direct expressions of class conflict that we're seeing anywhere in the world right now.

Speaker 4Do you have an update on the scale of the protests? Is there a faction of Labour that actually is more organizing, or is it more of a general public protest?

Speaker 5Basically, what has been happening is that these have largely been wildcat protests. There haven't really been unions involved in this because of intense union-breaking things. And also, One of the interesting things that's been happening here, somewhat similar to the way that this has been happening in Vietnam for a while now in somewhat similar conditions, is that because there aren't unions and there aren't people to negotiate with, it's made it somewhat harder for the government to crack down on the protests because normally you could just go and arrest the union leaders. But there aren't any, and you get these conditions where no one even knows who

Speaker 5the first person to walk off the line was. So that's been leading to this really direct form of confrontation here. but it's been messy i think the latest reports on factory shutdowns was 500 although i've been seeing that number for a couple of weeks now and it's unclear to me whether people are repeating the same number or not the major protest that broke out in front of the wage board was about 20 000 okay uh 20 000 workers um like at that one there have been other ones i think the numbers seem to be down from

Speaker 5their peaks uh a few weeks ago but because of the wage board stuff yeah Yeah, and also because of the lockouts. Is the demand for $ 240 a month, is that a relatively unified demand from this massive 20,000 people, despite this being a wildcat strike? Yeah, that's been the demand from the broad strike in general. There's a couple of other ones. That's the main one. That's been the demand of everyone who's walked out and everyone who's been fighting. And that's the thing they originally walked out over, was this demand for $ 240 a month.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 4Thank you for the update on that. We should probably hear more after the wage board meets or does not meet this next week.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 4Let's go on one more ad break and then we will return for tariffs and some policing news. We finally have tariff news again.

Speaker 2Hit the music, hit.

Speaker 16The music. Hell yeah.

Speaker 15Oh man.

Speaker 3God, that feels good every time. It feels so much better than learning about tariffs.

Speaker 7Truly.

Speaker 3Which is going to, I'm sure, depress me.

Speaker 5So, we're going to get to the tariffs in a second, but the beginning of the story is as the U.S. sort of visibly falls apart around us, Trump is in Asia this week conducting a series of meetings with the regional leaders. As we're recording this on the 18th, he's been in China meeting with Xi Jinping. This is after wrapping up a visit to the Philippines. In the Philippines, he met with President Bongbong Marcos and spent some time with the Marcos family, which some of you may be like, wait,

Speaker 5hold on, that Marcos family. Some of you may be going, wait, who are the Marcoses? Bongbong Marcos is the son of Juan Ferdinand Marcos, who some of you may remember as the U.S.-backed and also weirdly Cesar Chavez-backed former dictator of the Philippines, who was overthrown by popular revolution after torturing literally tens of thousands of people. Bongbong Marcos amazingly is not– he is not legally allowed in the US without diplomatic immunity because a court in Hawaii ruled that his family

Speaker 5owed like $ 2 billion to the survivors of his persecution. However, because of incredible cowardice and an unwillingness to violate diplomatic immunity, the Biden administration, running dogs of the bourgeoisie, allowed Marcos into the country. But this is the kind of guy, yeah, like, I don't know, the Philippines having their own mess.

Speaker 1Of.

Speaker 3It is crazy that he's not the worst president of the Philippines in the last, like, 20 years.

Speaker 4Yes.

Speaker 15It's astonishing.

Speaker 2It's remarkable stuff.

Speaker 15Yeah.

Speaker 5But then also, you know, Trump is also meeting with like the extended Marcos family. And so he's meeting with like Ferdinand Marcos' wife, who's I think the famous one.

Speaker 6Oh, yeah.

Speaker 5Of these people in the US, who's like 97 years old. And, you know, they're just they're yakking it up. There's all these like one of the things that pisses me off is all these like cute stories basically about Trump and Bongbong.

Speaker 6Great.

Speaker 5We're like Bongbong's like ordering fast food fried chicken for Trump at night. And Trump is complimenting his interior design.

Speaker 2That's how you do it. That's how you get them on your side.

Speaker 5I don't know. It's just so sickening to me that it's like, yeah, okay, we have this grand meeting of two of history's great right-wing mass torturers, and the press reporting out of it is like, ah, from the AP, Bongbong ordered fried chicken from a fast food place for Trump when he was hungry at night.

Speaker 7I'm like, I hate this.

Speaker 4Yeah, but did you see the video of Trump waving the flags?

Speaker 7Oh, God.

Speaker 2Huh?

Speaker 1Huh? God.

Speaker 5Truth to power forever, guys. Jesus Christ. So, now, this has not all gone completely cleanly. Trump claimed to have reached a massive trade agreement with the Philippines. Which the government in the Philippines was immediately like, no, we didn't. We agreed on like economic coordination. We did not agree on a trade deal. This is the second time that Trump has claimed that he has reached a massive trade deal with the Philippines and then has not.

Speaker 4So I can't believe the fried chicken move didn't didn't didn't work out.

Speaker 2I didn't look it down.

Speaker 5They're like, damn it. We were planning to fry chicken for months.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 5So, you know, American trade negotiations being handled in an extremely normal way. Now, I want to move for a second to what's been happening with the last round or two rounds, three rounds ago. Something like four rounds of tariffs ago where we finally got the Supreme Court ruling that overturned them and the government's been being forced to pay tariffs. that money back. Tariff refunds.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 5We've now gotten some wonderful reporting by ProPublica about what those refunds are being used for.

Speaker 11Oh, cool.

Speaker 5Executive bonuses, baby.

Speaker 15Let's go.

Speaker 5Not back to the consumer.

Speaker 4What? No.

Speaker 15No.

Speaker 4Wow.

Speaker 2I was expecting the corporations to come in on our side on this one, Mir. I've got to say, I'm pretty disappointed in them.

Speaker 7It's really astounding.

Speaker 5So According to this ProPublica investigation, companies like TJ Maxx and Titlist, which is a golf brand, I'm not pronouncing that correctly. Titlist, I think is how that's... Yeah, I don't respect golf brands, so I'm not going to pronounce your name correctly.

Speaker 2Yeah, fuck it.

Speaker 5Yeah, have been funneling their refunds basically directly into executive compensation.

Speaker 9Now.

Speaker 5These refunds have obviously been going up kind of slowly. And yeah, of course, as we all expected, no, these are not going back to consumers. These corporations, of course, have already passed on the price increases. So there's largely two ways that corporations dealt with the sort of price shocks from this. One was by forcing their suppliers to either basically take cuts and eat shit. And some of those people have gotten reimbursed because out of a sort of desire to maintain good relationships with your suppliers and your contractors, some of those people have been getting tariff

Speaker 5refunds from these companies. But, you know, OK, so the estimates roughly are 30 to 40 percent of the cost of the tariffs were passed on directly to the consumers. The rest of it was largely eaten by these companies sort of down the supply chain. So what has happened is you have paid the companies that increased rate.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 5And then the government has handed all of the money back to the companies directly, including money that they were able to get from extracting stuff from their suppliers. So we have just paid them twice.

Speaker 9Right. Right?

Speaker 5We have paid them for the goods, and then the US government has also given them the money back. So the incredible stuff happening here, and also it's worth noting that these prices aren't coming back down, right? One of the things, this is a talking point under Biden, this has been happening under Trump, is that prices are relatively sticky, or they're sort of unchanged as long as consumer expectations don't change. And once you can tell consumers you have to increase prices because of tariffs, you can raise the prices again without the sort of like loss of consumer demand,

Speaker 5and you can leave them there. And so the conclusion of all this tariffs is to once again steal the old 2008 slogan is that they got bailed out, you got sold out, and the cycle of capital continues as ever.

Speaker 4I can't believe Amazon's not giving me my.

Speaker 5$ 4 for my toothbrush.

Speaker 2You know, hopefully this is what it takes to finally get the US population on board with abolishing golf.

Speaker 5Oh, from your mouth to God's ears, James.

Speaker 2And more importantly, to the Javelinas who are going to do the abolishing.

Speaker 3See, I think we should make it mandatory, James. Replace all cars with golf carts. That's where I come from, you know?

Speaker 5That's actually not a bad idea.

Speaker 3It's a good idea because if you're also always golfing, you can drink while driving them.

Speaker 2That's true, yeah.

Speaker 6That's the law.

Speaker 2It would kill a lot less people.

Speaker 1I'm not concerned with that.

Speaker 4If we shrink those streets down just for golf carts.

Speaker 5Oh, yeah, you.

Speaker 2You ever been to Catalina Garrison?

Speaker 5Oh, I would love to. I would love to go.

Speaker 2That's the way to live. It's a golf cart city. That's the way to live. There's also the Suzuki Jimny, I guess fits in the footprint of a golf cart. So people have been keeping those alive for a while out there.

Speaker 3If we transition to a golf cart based driving society, then the people who want giant cars can just get like Priuses and they'll still feel like the.

Speaker 2Kind of people. Get some rims on that bad boy. Sounds just a minute.

Speaker 4All of those huge truck guys in the Midwest are now driving Priuses.

Speaker 2But they've lifted them anyway. Yeah, they've lifted Priuses. Got a two-foot bed on that bad boy.

Speaker 1I'm sold. This is my politics now.

Speaker 4This is the future that Democrats want for America.

Speaker 5No, that's way too positive.

Speaker 10Oh, yeah.

Speaker 2I'm going to make... I'm getting like... Six Javelina, and I'm doing like a, you know what people do with Huskies? But I'm doing that with Javelina, and we're going to fuck up the golf courses so you can only drive your golf carts on the street.

Speaker 4Let's finish up with New York City. On Monday, Mehramdani announced that he is officially disbanding the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, or the SRG, which was formed in 2015 as a specialized rapid response unit tasked with both counterterrorism and protest response duties. The SRG has been at the center of brutal police crackdowns on protests the past 10 years, from Black Lives Matter to the Palestine College encampments.

Speaker 17During our campaign for mayor, I promised to disband the NYPD's strategic response group, known as the SRG. Today, we are keeping that promise. I am disbanding the SRG. SRG was tasked with both counterterrorism enforcement and protest response. Those are not the same, and they should be separate.

Speaker 4Over the next year, Mamdani will establish a, quote, first of its kind, civilian led community dialogue and de-escalation division or CDDD.

Speaker 5All right.

Speaker 4Within the mayor's office of community safety to, quote, prepare for and respond to protests through dialogue and engagement. These will not be uniformed police officers. This division will be made up of, quote, civilians without weapons or arrest power, to quote the mayor. As they build out this new civilian division under the mayor's office of community safety, a new, quote, specialized dialogue team called the First Amendment Support Team, or FAST.

Speaker 2That's a better acronym.

Speaker 5Much better acronym.

Speaker 2At least they fucking tried. Also, cops are civilians. I cannot say that enough. Cops would love to not be civilians. They are civilians.

Speaker 7Sure.

Speaker 2Yeah, sure.

Speaker 4That is, that is on, uh, uh, pushes glasses up, uh, technical correction.

Speaker 16Yes.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 4Uh, but FAST will be within the NYPD's community affairs bureau, and they will also engage in dialogue and de-escalation of protests and will consist of 30 uniformed officers, quote, trained in communication and de-escalation. And this seems to be based on a similar unit in Columbus, Ohio. People from the mayor's office visited Columbus earlier this year to look into their new dialogue and de-escalation division, and FAST appears to be based on that unit, whereas the so-called civilian-led community

Speaker 4dialogue division is more of a novel idea that Mamdani is trying out.

Speaker 2Is the Columbus unit called the de-escalation division? Because that would be an unfortunate acronym.

Speaker 4I'm not sure what the Columbus unit is called.

Speaker 2Okay, sorry, I'm stuck on acronyms. I can't stop.

Speaker 4To quote Mamdani... FAST will remain as a liaison team while CDDD takes the lead in engaging with New Yorkers. Trade officers can be called upon to come make arrests, including for those engaging in civil disobedience, unquote. Now, part of this change in disbanding SRG, crowd management duties will be transferred out of NYPD's special operations to, quote unquote, vetted patrol officers in a new division of the Patrol Services Bureau. officers who spend most of their time on

Speaker 4regular patrol-related duties, but can be called in to make arrests at protests in the case of violence, property damage, or disruptions caused by civil disobedience, like sitting in the street to block a roadway. The Legal Aid Society released a statement following this announcement, quote, Legal Aid commends Mehramdani for fulfilling his campaign promise to disband the SRG one of the NYPD's most notorious units, known for its violence and mass arrests of protesters, particularly during the 2020 George Floyd demonstrations, and for endorsing the Curb Act.

Speaker 1More on this later.

Speaker 4Both measures represent important progress toward protecting New Yorkers' First Amendment rights. The restructuring, however, will require vigilant oversight to ensure that SRG's tactics are not repeated. We urge the mayor to closely monitor the NYPD's use of force, surveillance, and arrests, both at demonstrations and and in the low-income communities we serve, unquote. The NYPD police union responded to the mayor's announcement. As well, I'll quote President Patrick Hendry, quote,

Speaker 4Today is not a good day for New Yorkers who just want a safe and orderly city. Mayor Ramdani is showing his true colors. He's willing to put your safety and police officers' safety at risk to appease his radical base. So next time your life is disrupted by demonstrators who are blocking bridges and roadways or causing chaos on our streets, remember, Mayor Mamdani is on their side, not yours.

Speaker 7Unquote.

Speaker 5Very scary.

Speaker 4Now, many people and activist groups have welcomed this change from Mamdani, but some have questioned if this move constitutes a substantial reform to the way New York City does protest response or is just a rebrand of the SRG. One of the core reasons Mamdani has cited for disbanding SRG is the need to separate protest and counterterrorism responses, which this change achieves full stop. SRG's counterterrorism functions will be consolidated within the NYPD's Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. Police

Speaker 4Commissioner Jessica Tisch has said that many of the 500 SRG officers will be reassigned to the Counterterrorism Bureau and that this change will, quote, strengthen our counterterrorism efforts. But some have still voiced concerns about patrol officers in this new, quote, patrol support division just moving over from SRG and kind of doing the same shit under a different name. As for the patrol unit and the officers in it, patrol officers will have to apply to join this new patrol unit.

Speaker 4We'll have to pass, quote, strict eligibility requirements and receive, quote, specialized training to, quote, conduct arrests at protests in rare instances if necessary, unquote. What these requirements are and what this training will exactly constitute of is not clear at this point in the announcement. Some people have also highlighted the specific reference to arresting people engaging in civil disobedience. My take on that is getting arrested is a part of this sort of civil disobedience protests that Mamdani is

Speaker 4referencing in that announcement, like sitting down to block the roadway in front of the U.N., Getting arrested is a core part of that type of civil disobedience, and that's what him and Chiose are referencing in that video. Whether you agree with that as a tactic, that's totally up to you. But in terms of, like, policing tactics, in addition to disbanding SRG, Mamdani also announced a suite of, quote, significant new restrictions on the tactics and weapons all officers can use during First Amendment activities, including a formal prohibition

Speaker 4on kettling, long guns, and tear gas. And also adding that, quote, pepper spray will not be used as a crowd management tool. Some of these things like like kettling and tear gas have not been allowed for the past like four years following a lawsuit. But this change is now a formal prohibition on these tactics within the department. And this pepper spray restriction is also new. Now, furthermore, in Mamdani's video announcement, he was joined by city council member Chi Osei to

Speaker 4endorse Osei's curb act. which would prohibit the SRG or any successor group from responding to protests and would also restrict NYPD from using certain crowd control tactics altogether and codify those restrictions into law so that a new mayor or a new commissioner can't just put in a new policy. The curb act or communities united to reject brutality doesn't just go after SRG. This seeks to regulate the aggressive tactics the unit has used to brutally suppress protests these past 10 years, and ensure that those tactics aren't just

Speaker 4redeployed by other NYPD units and officers. It would legally ban the NYPD from kettling, from using tear gas, pepper spray, and LRADs against protesters. And it would also prohibit officers from using bicycles as weapons, as done by the SRG and other protest units across the country, like Seattle, Portland has these sorts of units.

Speaker 5Did they mention horses at all?

Speaker 4I'm not sure if horses is mentioned in Curb. SRG doesn't use horses. Well, I don't think the SRG would use horses, but there are others. Horses are not really used at protests here anymore. And mounted police are within special operations.

Speaker 2In large part, bikes replaced. I wrote about this for Crosscut. Jason Wilson has a great piece for The Guardian called The New Horseman, which is about bike police.

Speaker 5Which my media thought was they're going to go back to horses. I know some cities do still use horses.

Speaker 4Horses are not used. And also, Mamdani just ended the horse-drawn carriage industry. Just been a long fight in the city because it's really bad for the horses.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 4So a lot of the reforms that Mamdani is pushing through here could make it easier to pass the curb act because a lot of that is what the curb act is also trying to do. But having city council pass the curb act would, again, put these policies into law with some additional public reporting requirements and oversight. In terms of the timeline for these things, SRG will be formally disbanded in early 2027, 90 days after the announcement. That's also when FAST, the new community affairs team of 30 officers, will go live as a unit. The quote-unquote

Speaker 4civilian-led unit in the community safety office will be up and running in a little over a year, sometime in 2028, and will be co-developed with FAST. with the idea that this quote-unquote civilian-led unit will over time take over more of those responsibilities. Commissioner Tisch has said that nothing would change about the way NYPD responds to crowd control conditions, like, for example, the celebration following the Knicks' epic championship, unquote.

Speaker 4It's important to keep in mind that Mamdani's plan for protest response with this civilian-led unit, NFAST, isn't for every type of crowd management situation, right? Like crowd control doesn't just relate to big protests, but other major events that aren't protests, but parades or sports events. But even for those types of events, NYPD is still moving crowd management duties from NYPD strategic operations to the patrol bureau. But

Speaker 4I think Tish is trying to reassure the elites here that crowd management duties at those big events like parades isn't going to look much different. Zooming out, obviously this type of reformism has limits. Twitter communists in Portugal or whatever are going to be mad that police are still allowed to respond to protests in New York. And like, I don't know what they were expecting. But if Mamdani's plan is implemented, how it's laid out with this new

Speaker 4non-police civilian-led unit, FAST with the Community Affairs Bureau, moving crowd control out of special operations, strengthening restrictions on aggressive tactics, and support for the curb act, this together would not be a simple rebrand of SRG. I want to read a quote here from Alex S. Vitale, a professor and chair of sociology at Brooklyn College and the CUNY Grand Center and the author of The End of Policing. He released a statement, quote, New York City is embarking on a major rethinking about how protest activity is managed. New

Speaker 4York is posed to be the first city in the country to civilianize a significant amount of its response to protest activity. It is also committing to reducing the militarism and intolerance of NYPD response. While the police will still have a role in dealing with protests that involve significant threats to public safety, they will have to do that without relying on highly intolerant, abusive, and militaristic strategies. There will always be pressure on the NYPD to be less tolerant and more aggressive in their response because protests can cause disruptions to everyday life. The mayor's plan acknowledges this

Speaker 4trade-off and attempts to shift the balance towards the toleration of some amount of disruption as a necessary part of a functioning democracy. It will be necessary for civil libertarians to monitor the rollout of this new approach to ensure the maximization of civilian response and the restraint on the part of the NYPD units that do get assigned to certain protest activities. We will also continue to press for the passage of the CURB Act to ensure this long-term change in strategic direction. It is gratifying that the Mayor,

Speaker 4Police Commissioner, and the Deputy Mayor for Community Safety were able to come together to develop and implement this plan, and I hope it opens the door to additional coordination needed to phase the use of the criminal group database and the creation of a more robust and comprehensive civilian mental health response capacity. That relates to some of Alex's writing on things the Mamdani administration could do in the future to move more aspects of public safety out of the NYPD. Does anyone have any comments on this before we close?

Speaker 5Yeah, I think we're going to have to wait and see as to like. Are they going to move to the old Chicago model, which is we don't use chemical weapons, we don't use long guns, we just beat people by hand?

Speaker 1Like the old days.

Speaker 5Yeah, I think it's one of these things where we'll have to see how a number of these protests play out before we can have any sort of real analysis.

Speaker 2Of how this is going.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 5But. Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I am in favor of less police violence at protests, and hopefully this achieves that.

Speaker 1It's worth a shot.

Speaker 4It will be interesting to see non-police units be the first city representative to respond to a protest with this quote-unquote civilian-led unit in the future. The SRG is so bad, it feels like almost anything is going to be better than the SRG.

Speaker 5The fact that.

Speaker 4Regular patrol officers will now be tasked with stuff as opposed to the sort of craziness that is in SRG training. Like, I could do a whole episode on, like, the stuff that SRG is trained on is, like, is wild. And, you know, they do see themselves as sort of, like, military unit. This counterterrorism aspect is a huge part of the SRG kind of.

Speaker 5Like, mindset.

Speaker 4And having protest crowd control move from that terrorism, militaristic mindset to patrol officers.

Speaker 5is a good step.

Speaker 4Of course, these changes don't, you know, solve the problem of modern policing. There will always be something to critique. The Community Affairs Bureau is by no means perfect. It was a community affairs officer that pushed Daria Lisa to the ground a few weeks ago at a protest.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 4But SRG is a special beast.

Speaker 5Yeah, like also like, you know, like from a CPD perspective, the difference between like one of these specialized groups that the specialized groups will drive past a housing project, blaring the N word out of their microphones. Whereas like the, the regular patrol cops will only call you the N word inside of the police car. Like it's, you know, we're, we're dealing with, with degrees here in terms of how shit these cops are, but hopefully, hopefully it's less, it's less bad because yeah, New York has had some of the worst, most effective from the perspective of we want to injure protesters and make people not protest of any

Speaker 5city in the U S.

Speaker 6So hopefully it gets better.

Speaker 5It will be nice to see the SRG go.

Speaker 2Yeah, fuck them.

Speaker 6Eat shit.

Speaker 4And not deal with pepper spray at whatever protest I go to in the future.

Speaker 5Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's good to see. That was one of those things that I had in my little reminder to check on, like, one year of Mamdani, you know, that was a big promise.

Speaker 9Yeah.

Speaker 2As you pointed out from the COP union, like, significant institutional resistance.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2So, yeah, good to keep.

Speaker 3An eye on.

Speaker 7A little.

Speaker 2Little, I don't know, fucking I've got something to say. If you're using the email line, that is for tips. Things that are not being covered, you might have seen a special insight into that you would like us to cover that you think would be well placed to cover. What isn't is a request line, especially when 17 other outlets that are much better placed than us to cover something have already covered it. That's sick. I hope you enjoy their coverage of that topic. We don't need to do it too. But if you have a tip that

Speaker 2is a tip, not a request, you can send that to us. CoolZoneTips at Proton.me.

Speaker 5We reported the news.

Speaker 1We reported the news.

Speaker 3Hey, we'll be back Monday with more episodes every week from now until the heat death of the universe.

Speaker 18It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions.

Speaker 1Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Part Two: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    1 hr 8 minAudio

    Robert concludes the story of Pastor Mackenzie's starvation apocalypse church with a really shocking mass murder.

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    1 hr 3 minAudio

    This week Robert takes us to Kenya, and the deadliest cult since the days of Jonestown. Prepare to meet Pastor Paul Mackenzi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. It Could Happen Here Weekly 258

    4 hr 13 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Part Two: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    1 hr 25 minAudio

    Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Part One: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    1 hr 10 minAudio

    In this week's harrowing episode, Robert and Soren Bowie explore the life and times of Don Simpson: the man who produced Top Gun and most of the other big hits of the 1980s while being a coked-up devil behind the scenes.

    Credit the people on this episode