Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind the Bastards

Behind the Bastards artwork

It Could Happen Here Weekly 251

Sep 26, 20263 hr 5 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: West Bank Takeover The AI Regulation Debate Diversity With Andrew Gas Prices and Oil Wars Executive Disorder: Trump Bans the “Free Press,” Palestinian National Council Elections, ICE Shooting, Canadian Neoliberalism You can now listen to all Cool Zone Media shows, 100% ad-free through the Cooler Zone Media subscription, available exclusively on Apple Podcasts. So, open your Apple Podcasts app, search for “Cooler Zone Media” and subscribe today! Sources/Links: West Bank Takeover https://jewishcurrents.org/it-feels-like-a-death-sentence https://www.972mag.com/armed-settler-hikes-west-bank/ https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/06/opinion/israel-west-bank-settlers-violence.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/8/29/israeli-settlers-surround-palestinian-home-in-occupied-west-banks-qusra https://www.972mag.com/bilin-israeli-land-seizure-settler-road/ The AI Regulation Debate https://x.com/hilbertspaess/status/2097476196791709843 https://x.com/sama/status/2098811563415150910?s=20 https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/glossary/frontier-models/ https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/cybersecurity-101/artificial-intelligence/frontier-ai/ https://darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier https://www.anthropic.com/constitution https://bsky.app/profile/bishonentype.bsky.social/post/3mvg527c3k22n https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/117269745153543631 https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2099597928142688610?s=20 https://x.com/RapidResponse47/status/2099648450069512426?s=20 https://x.com/atrupar/status/2099132465612828964?s=20 https://x.com/cspan/status/2099878657174941991?s=20 https://x.com/benitoz/status/2099572926865715548?s=20 https://x.com/DavidSacks/status/2098973625252708460?s=20 https://x.com/Jason/status/2098817101628600383?s=20 https://x.com/daniel_koss/status/2099751931400847840?s=20 https://www.cnbc.com/2026/09/12/anthropics-amodei-proposes-plan-to-slow-the-pace-of-advancing-ai-capabilities.html https://www.cnbc.com/2026/09/14/anthropic-walks-tightrope-to-nasdaq-pushing-slowdown-and-pursuing-ipo.html https://www.sanders.senate.gov/press-releases/news-sanders-casar-introduce-legislation-to-ban-artificial-superintelligence-and-temporarily-pause-advanced-ai-development/ https://abdulforsenate.com/2026/06/first-do-no-harm-ai-under-democracy/ https://geesemag.com/articles/stop-the-ai-arms-race https://x.com/linamkhan/status/2099204390548639960?s=20 https://www.kirosforco.com/priorities-2 https://reports.verasight.io/r/june-2026-ai-survey#key-takeaways https://www.sanders.senate.gov/press-releases/news-sanders-introduces-legislation-to-create-7-trillion-ai-sovereign-wealth-fund/ https://council.nyc.gov/press/2026/09/16/3240/ Diversity With Andrew In Light of Our Differences by David Harmon The Difference: How the Power of Diversity Creates Better Groups, Firms, Schools, and Societies by Scott E. Page Gas Prices and Oil Wars https://www.npr.org/2026/09/18/nx-s1-5973810/houthi-attacks-saudi-oil-world-markets https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/oil-executives-say-the-great-fuel-crisis-is-here-b6b32030 https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2026/09/19/attacks-choke-off-saudi-oil-kingdom-confronts-limits-trumps-friendship/ https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/article/oil-hovers-near-100-as-analysts-warn-trump-diesel-export-ban-would-tighten-global-supply-130359301.html https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/what-is-saudi-arabias-east-west-pipeline-and-why-is-it-rocking-oil-markets-3e9823a3?mod=article_inline https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/oil-prices-mixed-as-traders-weigh-u-s-iran-talks-saudi-pipeline-progress-3b33f75c https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/trumps-oil-allies-see-nightmare-scenario-of-diesel-export-ban-becoming-reality-16973ae2 https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/trump-weighs-diesel-export-ban-as-fuel-prices-soar-6d1a3d2e https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us-energy-secretary-wright-says-diesel-export-ban-would-not-work-2026-09-23/ https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cj207y30wp0lo https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/trump-wants-big-oil-to-build-more-refineries-thats-a-tough-sell-54666292?mod=article_inline https://www.ft.com/content/05887f92-c777-48ab-8efa-9a39e7e18a9f?syn-25a6b1a6=1 https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/the-relentless-crypto-billionaire-who-moved-to-venezuela-in-pursuit-of-oil-a4f0f219? https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/inside-trumps-plan-to-give-the-pentagon-a-stake-in-venezuelas-oil-riches-f054cdc2?mod=article_inline https://finance.yahoo.com/energy/articles/chevron-ceo-thinks-world-spare-154027206.html Executive Disorder: Trump Bans the “Free Press,” Palestinian National Council Elections, ICE Shooting, Canadian Neoliberalism https://x.com/SecWar/status/2102382410600182000?s=20 https://x.com/ThomasBordeaux7/status/2102427909881294913?s=20 https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-administration-white-south-africans-refugees-afrikaners/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/09/supporting-americas-ranchers/ https://bsky.app/profile/ayoub.bsky.social/post/3mw4nwosork2f https://www.dailyecho.co.uk/news/26570976.hundreds-turn-face-police-gosport-migrant-boat-fears---live/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwXS24qsEEM https://www.npr.org/2026/09/23/g-s1-144623/trump-affordable-care-act https://www.propublica.org/article/fbi-susan-collins-navatek-campaign-donations-investigation https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-concludes-federal-ban-handgun-sales-18-20-year-olds-unconstitutional-and https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c6rm903e22lgo https://youtu.be/uNsQUNUvN0k?si=aFIiSAzCoJuAR1oZ https://www.dhs.gov/news/2026/09/22/correct-record-dhs-debunks-false-narratives-about-shooting-illegal-alien-austin https://www.instagram.com/p/Ddhn2cnItyi/ https://www.kvue.com/article/news/local/attorney-man-shot-ice-north-austin-news-conference-monday/269-9976441c-cedb-486f-85fa-05459daf4a20 https://welcome.rescue.org/sites/default/files/2026-04/ENG_CBP%20One%20Parole%20Update%20%26%20FAQ_March2026.pdf https://www.instagram.com/attorneygoldfinch/ https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.296754/gov.uscourts.dcd.296754.1.0_1.pdf https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/18/media/trump-claims-ban-cnn-msnow-politico-white-house https://x.com/CBSNewsPress/status/2102035354689671560?s=20 https://variety.com/2026/tv/news/tv-networks-suspend-white-house-pool-protest-trump-cnn-ban-1236871070/ https://variety.com/2026/film/news/fcc-approves-49-5-foreign-ownership-paramount-warner-bros-1236866217/ https://deadline.com/2026/09/paramount-leaving-california-merger-lawsuit-1237105417/ https://apnews.com/article/warner-bros-paramount-skydance-merger-settlement-1aaa7c471d8ba286ccfad92b18bc1ecf?utm_source=copy&utm_medium=share https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-announces-settlement-warner-brosparamount-litigation https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press-docs/2026-09-21-244-exhibits-re-243-joint-motion-enter-consent-decree-and.pdf https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/17/trump-calls-eu-offer-to-canada-associate-membership-laughable-threatens-tariffs https://archive.vn/NJc5J#selection-3749.107-3749.143 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canada-britain-military-expeditionary-force-nato-9.7347144 https://www.reuters.com/world/canada-applies-join-uk-led-military-coalition-says-carneys-office-2026-09-16/ https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/canadas-carney-calls-stronger-ties-with-france-face-new-global-threats-2026-09-20/ https://www.baltimoresun.com/2026/09/21/trump-us-canada-europe/ https://apnews.com/article/europe-canada-carney-associate-member-3fdb111dd4d23d88b3de88c274c52711 https://www.thestar.com/politics/federal/carney-government-tables-sweeping-bill-to-overhaul-environmental-and-labour-rules/article_3b03e2d3-0dce-4842-ade1-96b3d76dcd97.html https://apnews.com/article/europe-commission-state-union-leyen-speech-address-888f1d0c061ffb2accefc19cdbf39ffc https://thenarwhal.ca/canada-bill-c-39-environmental-assessments/ https://apnews.com/article/canada-europe-trump-tariffs-4078e9549ff9caa5ded08f7dd2f99065

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Call zone media.

Speaker 2Hey, everybody.

Speaker 3Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode of the week that just happened is here in one convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to listen to in a long stretch if you want. If you've been listening to the episodes every day this week, there's going to be nothing new here for you, but you can make your own decisions.

Speaker 1Hello everyone and welcome to It Could Happen Here. My name is Dana Al-Kurd. I'm a researcher of Arab and Palestinian politics. And today I want to talk about the truly insidious stories coming out of the West Bank that read separately look like a spike in settler violence, but read together look like something else entirely. On August 9th, settlers surrounded three Palestinian homes in a neighborhood called Ras Al-Ayn on the edge of a village called Qusra south of Nablus. They didn't leave. 21 days later, at least

Speaker 1four people were still inside one of those houses cut off from water, electricity, and basic supplies. Getting food into those people meant coordinating through the village mayor, which was a process that took three to four days. The Israeli army put up three new roadblocks, and in July, the village mosque was burned. I want you to sit with that for a minute, because this is not a raid. This is not a rampage. It's a siege with a bureaucracy attached. And that bureaucracy is the story. And that's what I want to talk about today. And I'm trying

Speaker 1to be precise about the difference because the distinction is not academic. It determines what you think the problem is and therefore what you think the solution would look like. Here's the framing you'll get from almost every Western outlet. And of course, every Israeli official. That this is a fringe and that these settlers are a violent fringe and they embarrass the state and the state condemns this fringe. When settlers besieged Qusra, Prime Minister Netanyahu did issue a statement, and here I'm quoting, condemning the, quote, criminal acts of

Speaker 1violence committed in the village of Qusra by a handful of rioters who are violating the law. And Israeli President Herzog also condemned it, and the foreign ministry condemned it as extremist and criminal violence. So let's take that framing seriously for a moment, because if it's true, what we're looking at is a law enforcement failure, a state that's lost control of its most radical citizens. And if it's false, what we're looking at is a state carrying out a policy through deniable means, and the condemnations are not a

Speaker 1failure at all. They're a feature. They're the part of the machine that faces outward. So let's go through what actually happened in these villages, and then let's ask which of these framings fits the evidence best. So Basel Al-Adra, the journalist from Masafir Yatta, the one who you know from No Other Land, the documentary that won a bunch of awards, He published a piece in Jewish Currents on September 3rd about livestock theft in the South Hebron Hills. So this isn't vandalism, it's theft. It's organized removal of livestock.

Speaker 1So shortly after midnight on August 21st in a place called Chirbet Dir Shams, a family was attacked by roughly 15 masked settlers with sticks and stones. One of them describes it flatly. They basically opened the pen where the family kept around 70 goats, and then they opened the sheep pen where there were about 100 sheep, And as the settlers moved off of the animals, Israeli army vehicles passed nearby. And in his words, they did nothing. Nearly two weeks later, not one animal has been recovered. Back in July, in another village, a settler pepper sprayed a man,

Speaker 1and then more settlers arrived, and then a flock of about 122 sheep were targeted and taken. Soldiers did show up that time. According to one of the villagers, what the soldiers did was push the Palestinians away from their own animals while settlers broke the locks. And of roughly 227 animals taken that day, nine came back. Four residents of the village were arrested and then released. B'Tselem, which is an Israeli human rights organization, has counted 17 livestock theft incidents in 2026 alone. And a flock of the

Speaker 1size that we're talking about here, it's worth something on the order of tens, if not $ 100, 000. I'm flagging this because I think it's easy to hear sheep and these kinds of things and file it maybe under like property crime or vandalism or something. But for a herding family in the South Hebron Hills, the flock is not just an asset. It's the entire productive base of the household. It's the income. It's the reason to stay on that hillside. So if you want to expel a pastoral community, you

Speaker 1don't just expel them. You can take its animals and then it can expel itself. And it does so in a way that produces no photograph of a bulldozer. Another incident was on July 8th, when the head of Israel's Central Command signed a land seizure order. And that order takes dozens of dunams of land from Bil'in and three neighboring villages to build a security road, six and a half kilometers long and eight meters wide, connecting the settlement of Modayin Elit to an outpost called Stei Ephraim. Sorry,

Speaker 1I don't know Hebrew, so I'm going to be butchering these. But Oren Zev reported this for 972 Mag on September 2nd. So those who are familiar with Palestinian Popular Resistance in the mid to early 2000s, you've heard of Bil'in. Lots of documentaries about it. Lots of international attention. This village basically sustained weekly demonstrations against the separation wall for something like 15 years because this wall was being built on their land and taking huge chunks of their land. In 2007,

Speaker 1the Israeli high court ordered that part of the wall removed and the land actually came back to the village. So in the international imagination, this was the best outcome. See, the nonviolent resistance worked. And this is the nonviolent resistance that Western commentators often point to when they want to lecture Palestinians about tactics. Now, this road that they're proposing runs through the land that was returned. So Mohamed Khatib, who led some of these protests, says the point is

Speaker 1not a road. It's a settlement corridor. It's basically an eventual seizure of something like 600 dunams. And the attorney, Michael Svard, put it very bluntly. They don't think twice about co-opting the security argument for purposes that are clearly settlement oriented. And what's really ludicrous is that this road runs through a wadi. kind of a valley, which from an actual security standpoint is a bad place to put a road. So the security rationale isn't just contested, it's incoherent,

Speaker 1which tells you that the word security here is doing legal work, not tactical work. It's this just magic phrase that converts a settlement expansion into a military necessity, and then a military necessity into a signed order from a general. A third incident or set of incidents I want to talk about is these hikes. There have been these hikes. This is a really ridiculous, insidious story. Aharon Parath and Roy Kleitman published an investigation of these hikes in 972 Mag in late August about these hiking groups, these organized

Speaker 1settler hiking groups in the West Bank. They've got really cutesy names sometimes, like hiking buddies. And they publish their routes. And they go from settlement to settlement, and they cross Palestinian farmland and springs and villages. So a hike near the north of Hebron... one of these hikes ended with a, quote, civilian security coordinator opening fire and killing 17-year-old Palestinian Karim Shalalde and seriously wounding another one. So that's, I think, the whole episode in two words. A civilian security coordinator.

Speaker 1This is not a hiker who lost his temper. It's a job. It's an armed, appointed part of the chain of command. The man who fired was functionally an arm of the state. But supposedly on a hike in a village that is not his. On July 24th, near the village of Tal west of Nablus, a hike ended with six people dead, two Israelis and four Palestinians. David Syed, who founded one of these hiking groups, basically says the quiet part in a single sentence. Wherever the hiker's foot treads,

Speaker 1there the border will pass. So he's talking about how they're going to places they haven't been to in a long time or maybe ever. And on the question of the army, he explains the relationship very precisely. We don't ask for permits, he says. We mainly notify them so we don't put the sector on alert. And this is very clear in a lot of their quotes about this issue. They coordinate with the army. They notify, but they are not asking permission. And the army isn't policing them. It's being kept in the loop so that it.

Speaker 4Can protect them.

Speaker 1And the reporting traces this back over a decade. There's a 2013 hike documented with 100 hikers and soldiers accompanying them. So supposedly this recreational activity has a stated territorial doctrine, a published route through other people's fields, an armed participant base, and a military that gets notified. All right, so we

Speaker 1have four things. The livestock theft with soldiers watching, a siege of villages, seizing of land and armed hikes with military escorts. Now let's get back to Prime Minister Netanyahu's phrase about this being a handful of riots. A riot is unplanned. A riot has no logistics. A riot does not file paperwork. What's in front of us here is very different. Because here, I think a lot of people who are critical of the state of Israel might make the argument that the settlers are the state. But I

Speaker 1think this loses a little bit of analytical detail. So let me make this a little bit more specific, which I actually think is more damning. The Israeli state and the settler movement are not identical, but they are complementary because they perform different functions in the same project. And it's very clear that the division of labor is the point. Because think for a moment about what each half can do that the other can't. Settlers can do things the state can't do openly without incurring some diplomatic cost. For example,

Speaker 1taking a flock of sheep or burning a mosque or standing outside a house for three weeks. These are acts with no legal basis. There's no order, no minister to sanction, no policy to condemn at the UN. They produce displacement without producing a decision. And then the state can do things settlers can't do on their own. It can sign a seizure order. It can declare land state land. It can build the road that makes the outpost viable and connect it to the grid and route the bus line. And it can decline to investigate when things happen. It

Speaker 1can arrest four Palestinians instead of the 15 masked settlers, which is exactly what happened in one of these villages. And crucially, the state can supply this ambiguity that lets the whole thing keep running. The soldiers present at these incidents are not intervening, Because not that they're absent. It's in fact a specific posture of the state. It converts this crime into something sanctioned. And it tells the Palestinian family there's really no one to appeal to. And this is what political scientists who study this stuff in other

Speaker 1contexts as outsourced or deniable repression by paramilitaries or militias or unknown gung men, quote unquote. We recognize it instantly when it's in other places. And we understand kind of the analytical move here because you don't ask whether the state ordered it, you ask whether the state built the conditions under which it happens. And by that test, this is not ambiguous at all. But for some reason, when we talk about Israel-Palestine, things get a little bit more ambiguous. I also want to point out something really crucial, which is that every one of these incidents, and they've been

Speaker 1happening for a while, but they've ramped up in severity, but every one of them produces a permanent gain. The animals that are stolen don't come back. The road that's built can't be unbuilt. The hiking route, you know, once walked with an escort becomes a corridor, then a security zone, then a place that Palestinians can't farm. And the siege doesn't need to end in a formal expulsion. It ends when the family decides they can't raise their children under these conditions. They can't stay under siege. And there's a phrase for what's coming when all of this happens all

Speaker 1at once, which is annexation. And People talk about it as if it's a future event that's awaiting some sort of vote from the Israeli Knesset or something. But I'd suggest that framing is itself part of the problem. It invites us to wait for a declaration and treat everything before that as some sort of tension or spike. The declaration of annexation is the least important part. What's happening on the ground is a territorial reality that's being produced by signature and by theft. And then maybe later on

Speaker 1the paperwork will ratify it, but it's not necessary. Israeli writer and analyst Marev Zanzin actually made a version of this argument in the New York Times on September 6th under a headline that I think is worth reading. The headline of the article is, it's not just the West Bank settlers, it's Israel. So hopefully this analysis doesn't seem fringe anymore. At the end of the day, if we consider settler violence a fringe problem, then the remedy is which the Biden administration toyed with half-heartedly, is sanctions on individuals,

Speaker 1a visa ban or an asset freeze. And we've run that experiment. That didn't really work. The violence kept going up. But if it's a state policy executed through deniable proxies, then the remedy has to address the state. And every actor with leverage over that state, which, you know, we're talking about D.C. here, understands this, but they've chosen the fringe framing precisely because it permits condemnation without cost. So

Speaker 1Netanyahu condemning a handful of rioters in the same week that the Israeli Central Command signs a road through Bil'in's returned land, this is not a contradiction he failed to notice, it is the design of this policy. So I'll leave you with this detail from the reporting on Qusra that I can't get out of my head. It was that six people were attacked on while trying to install metal bars and window shields on their homes. They were attacked by both Israeli soldiers and settlers together in the same action. And then the six of them were arrested. So they

Speaker 1weren't fighting. They weren't protesting. They were fastening metal on their own house to protect themselves. And they were being arrested for it by the same army standing alongside the people they were shielding themselves from. So if you wanted kind of a single image for this division of labor, I've spent this episode describing, that's it. Because the thing that's not permitted in the end is not that they're resisting. It's that they're staying. The families in the South Hebron Hills are still there. And Bala'in is contesting the order

Speaker 1of the seizure of their land. Qusra's residents have installed some shields anyway. And a number of Israeli journalists and lawyers and researchers are documenting this in Hebrew and in English. And then, of course, Palestinian journalists are putting themselves on the line to document this as well. That's not a hopeful note exactly. It's just the accurate one. Unfortunately, what's missing is apparently anyone with power willing to act on understanding this reality. That's it for me. Thanks for listening.

Speaker 4This is It Could Happen Here. I'm Garrison Davis. When it comes to the future of AI, currently there's a big public debate over what could happen and what we should or shouldn't do about it. A few weeks ago, a former OpenAI employee named Jacob Coxon, who moved over to Anthropic earlier this year, announced that he was quote-unquote quitting the AI industry over fears of AI's rapid advancement. To quote his statement, Coxon's resignation followed the Hugging Face incident,

Speaker 4where two OpenAI models were given various, sometimes impossible tasks to test for cybersecurity capabilities. During testing, AI agents escaped their testing sandbox and started working as a collective swarm,

Speaker 4secretly communicating with each other via online message forums to help each other hack into another AI company called Hugging Face in a sort of workaround attempt to pass these tests. And these models hid all of this from AI researchers by rewriting their own activity logs. AI skeptic Ed Zitron has described this as AI cheating on a test and then covering up that it cheated. A few days after

Speaker 4Jacob Coxon's public resignation, the CEOs of Anthropic and OpenAI, Dario Amadei and Sam Altman, both called for an AI development slowdown. Amadei released this long manifesto titled Pace the Frontier, which advocated for AI companies to bring in independent evaluators to review their AI safety standards, report incidents, and help assess alignment. But Amadei also called for the government to mediate, quote,

Speaker 4industry-wide coordination to slow down AI development and address safety risks. The title of Amadei's essay, Pace the Frontier, is a sort of pun referring to frontier AI models, which are whatever the currently most advanced large-scale general-purpose models powering advanced reasoning, agentic workflows, multimodal generation across text, images, audio, and video, and autonomous task execution. Most of the frontier models referenced

Speaker 4throughout this episode are not open to the public. These are internal research models being developed at companies like OpenAI and Anthropic. neutered versions sometimes get released to the public later on, often with a extremely hefty price tag. But it's crucial to understand that we are not talking about like the Google AI summary here. This isn't fancy autocomplete. These frontier models are very powerful, very dangerous tools with

Speaker 4massive cybersecurity risks, not just from offensive human use, but also from AI agents acting autonomously to solve a task by taking paths that humans didn't expect, resulting in collateral damage. Part of what these big companies are trying to do with their very advanced internal research models is automate AI research itself. This is what Jacob Coxon referred to as quote, self-improving superintelligence. Now, we do not know if that is

Speaker 4or is not possible. But the companies sure are trying, and in the process are creating dangerous products which are already causing active harm. Anthropic's whole self-styled philosophy is that Superintelligent AI is so potentially dangerous that they have to be the first ones to develop it, to ensure that it's built safely and aligned with human values, as defined in, quote, Claude's Constitution, a set of philosophical and moral guidelines that

Speaker 4Claude is trained on. In his Pace the Frontier essay, Amadei writes that frontier AI companies within democratic countries should, quote, coordinate to establish common safety standards as well as limits on the rate of unchecked AI progress. Some forms of coordination that would be impactful for pacing are legally challenging and will require government support, unquote.

Speaker 2More on this later.

Speaker 4Amadei also calls for the U.S. and, quote, other democratic governments to try to coordinate with authoritarian governments around the world on this issue.

Speaker 2Meaning China.

Speaker 4The prospect that China could achieve superintelligent AI before a US-based company is part of these companies' self-justification to rush to develop superintelligent AI as quickly as they possibly can. After Dario Amadei posted this Pace the Frontier essay, Sam Altman, Elon Musk, and the chair of Google's DeepMind all said they agreed. and joined in calling for some sort of slowdown. But this view is not uniformly held across the tech sector.

Speaker 4Palantir CEO Alex Karp, Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, and NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang have all said the opposite. Zuckerberg has called to accelerate rather than slow down AI development, as his own AI model, Muse, has struggled to catch up to anthropic and open AI. Last week, Palantir CEO Alex Karp told CNBC, we can't pause AI development because of the threat of China, and that AI will be a quote,

Speaker 4bonanza for the US economy.

Speaker 5You can't pause it because it's a structural advantage both for LLMs and algorithms. So getting algorithms and LLMs to work in a classified context is going to take very specialized, I could explain how it works, but the fact is this is going to be a bonanza for the U.S.

Speaker 2Economy.

Speaker 4But so far, the biggest voices advocating against regulation have been the Republicans and President Trump. President Trump has very loudly opposed regulation to slow down AI development, truthing last Monday that, quote, the only control or guardrails that AI needs is a strong and smart, high IQ president.

Speaker 6And the U.S.

Speaker 4Has that in spades, unquote. Trump truthed a lot last week and compared the, quote, unquote, AI hoax being perpetuated by the radical left Democrats. to the, quote, global warming scam, where everyone was going to die from extreme heat. To quote the President of the United States, quote, I am the hoax buster, and right now I am breaking another hoax, that AI is going to take over, consume, and destroy

Speaker 4the world, and that robots will be marching into our cities and getting rid of us all. This is even wilder than the Russia, Russia, Russia hoax or the global warming scam, Thank you for your attention to this matter, President Donald J. Trump. House Speaker Mike Johnson repeatedly last week shut down calls for Congress to take action and regulate AI, claiming that Congress is less qualified to regulate these companies than these companies are themselves.

Speaker 7The guys who are raising the alarms right now all have very different ideas on what the guardrails should be. There's no consensus among them. And Congress is obviously less qualified than the people who are pushing this frontier to know all the ins and outs of it. So this has to be a partnership with the industry itself, with the corporations that are doing this, and with the policy and lawmakers.

Speaker 4Mike Johnson also said that companies should take, quote, personal responsibility and warned that if, quote, Congress just races in and does some sort of emergency session to try to regulate AI, we will lose the race to China.

Speaker 7They can self-police. They can self-regulate. They don't need the government to tell them to slow it down. If they want to slow it down, they should. But we cannot have a moratorium on the development of AI, because then we will lose our edge to China. And that has serious national security implications for every American family.

Speaker 4Also last week, President Trump called NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang while Huang was speaking at a conference yesterday. While still on stage, the two talked over the phone about data centers, AI, China, and the recent calls for an AI pause. While on stage, Huang told Trump this. Now, of course, Jensen Huang would not be in favor of.

Speaker 8An AI pause.

Speaker 4Because his whole company has reoriented in the past few years to provide hardware for AI development. A slowdown would be very bad for NVIDIA's finances and their hugely inflated stock evaluation. Some on the left, as well as Trump's former AI czar David Sachs, have argued that, in calling

Speaker 4for this slowdown, OpenAI and Anthropic are just pursuing a strategy of regulatory capture. Basically trying to promote certain industry-friendly regulations tailored to protect their investments, curb competition from smaller companies and open-source models, and solidify a corporate monopoly on AI. Of course, there may be other financial incentives contributing to this recent push for regulation, whether that be declining capital investment, prepping for a bubble burst, getting out of various contracts,

Speaker 4or these companies trying to adapt to the data center pushback. Sam Altman recently announced that OpenAI would be delaying its planned IPO rollout until at least next year, calling the timing, quote, ill-advised. Though, on the other hand, Anthropic is going full steam ahead with its own public IPO this upcoming November. deciding to list on the Nasdaq, despite Amadei's calls for a slowdown. But if you actually read Amadei's essay, he isn't actually

Speaker 4calling for specific government regulation, but rather self-regulation. In Sam Altman's response to Amadei's essay on Twitter, he wrote, I agree with Dario that we need to pace the frontier. Unquote. Companies electing themselves to develop AI more slowly and hiring

Speaker 4quote-unquote independent evaluators isn't the same as actual regulation. We can compare Amadei's proposal to legislation that Bernie Sanders and Greg Kassar proposed earlier this September, which would permanently ban the development and deployment of so-called super-intelligent AI with capabilities to subvert shutdown commands or have the capacity to overthrow human governments, with penalties similar to those for the unlawful

Speaker 4development of nuclear weapons. This bill would also temporarily pause advanced AI development until a federal regulatory body has established safety rules. Abdul El-Sayed and Ro Khanna have also proposed an FDA-style agency to regulate and oversee AI development and evaluate the safety of frontier models before deployment. Unsurprisingly, OpenAI and Anthropic are not supporting this type of legislation because

Speaker 4it could threaten to put their own CEOs in prison. And an actual government-mandated pause rather than a self-directed slowdown would hurt their bottom line. Some of the skepticism towards these recent calls for a regulatory slowdown come from Amadei's Pace the Frontier essay, also advocating for companies to receive antitrust waivers so that the big tech companies can coordinate on this planned development slowdown without the threat of one

Speaker 4company gaining a competitive edge and and then that market pressure driving rapid AI progress. So what's been referred to as a proposal for regulation is actually just loosening regulations. Thankfully, there is an easy solution here. The government mandating a frontier development pause would not require the weakening of antitrust laws. But of course, these companies still... want control over AI's development.

Speaker 4Though what's really interesting to me is that this argument from on the day demonstrates like an awareness of the social danger of competition, how firms are sometimes compelled to to quickly develop unsafe products due to pressures from the market. And it's very funny to have capitalists propose some kind of conscious control of the market. And I wonder what would happen if you extend that logic a bit further.

Speaker 4Because even if these firms are allowed to coordinate on a slowdown, of course they would still be in a competitive environment. But what if we had a system, an economic system, designed around social benefit rather than the accumulation of capital through the free market? To quote an article in Geese magazine arguing for the socialization of this technology, quote, the AI industry is a class project to radically concentrate

Speaker 4power in the hands of a sliver of elites, even at the cost of colossal social disruption, immiseration, and catastrophic harms. If we fail to intervene, humanity will be gradually disempowered to machines of their design. The workers left behind, the children who have committed suicide, and the potential millions exposed to novel AI-designed viruses mean nothing in the face of their radical objective. To automate the very task of AI research,

Speaker 4and thus to create better and better AIs, of course, under their control. Without having to stake a position on whether or not this goal is technically possible, we can recognize that the financial imperatives of these enterprises and the security logic of their imperialist competition with China compel the AI companies to accelerate advancing a total transformation of social life against all democratic legitimacy and public control, unquote. Rather

Speaker 4than weakening antitrust laws to support allow for a development slowdown, something totally not necessary. Lina Khan, former FTC chair, has argued that these companies may already be pursuing unfair methods of competition. Last week, Khan released a statement arguing that we already have the authority to charge companies and their CEOs for, quote, creating and releasing dangerous, unvetted, or defective products. we shouldn't let discussions about new legal regimes distract from

Speaker 4the fact that there's no AI exemption from laws already on the books. Kahn argued that releasing unvetted AI models or agents could violate consumer protection laws. Quote, shipping flawed AI tools without implementing adequate measures to detect and stop rogue or defective AI agents can be an unfair or deceptive act or practice under the FTC Act, and analogous state laws. And some state AGs are already exploring holding AI firms and their CEOs criminally liable when their models

Speaker 4participate in criminal activity. Kahn also wrote, quote, existing laws also prohibit unfair methods of competition. This covers instances where AI firms appropriate the competitively sensitive information of their customers and including through tracking their use of various tools. It can also cover instances where firms pursue dangerous behavior, aware that doing so may compel rivals to do the same.

Speaker 4As the Supreme Court has noted, a method of competition which casts upon one's competitors the burden of the loss of business unless they will Con adds, Con adds, alongside

Speaker 4enforcing existing laws, unquote. These frontier models aren't just theoretically capable of causing harm in the future. They are causing harm right now. At this point, there are Undeniable concerns regarding the development and rollout of frontier AI models, from cybersecurity to military applications, surveillance, and the effects on the

Speaker 4labor market. These are real, current, pressing concerns beyond the prospect of an AI super god or self-evolving super intelligence. And just because these companies recognize risk doesn't mean they will do anything about it. These companies know how LLMs are affecting the mental health of children, but they're not really doing anything about it, and they won't unless the government forces them to. Historical Luddites did not deny the

Speaker 4transformative potential of automated machinery, but organized around the threat it posed to workers. Similarly, just denying the state of advanced frontier models leaves us under-equipped to meet this moment and treat this problem with the seriousness it deserves. Part of this AI denialism so common on the left comes from a very outdated understanding of AI's capabilities, accuracy, and functionality.

Speaker 4Because of the moral and cultural dogma against using AI, the last time a lot of AI-skeptic people interacted with technology like ChatGPT was three years ago. And these days, the only quote-unquote AI that most anti-AI people regularly interact with is the Google AI summary, which is a totally different product than the frontier models being developed and talked about in the news. Some of the anti-AI left promote

Speaker 4the idea that treating AI as a serious problem only works in the financial interests of these companies. even if taking this issue seriously means ripping power away from these companies and their CEOs. To quote an article on the AI arms race in Geese magazine, while the AI sector is undeniably frothy with fanciful projections, AI denialism would have you believe that AI is neither a capable nor dangerous technology,

Speaker 4but solely a marketing scheme of vast proportions. That any warnings of AI triggering massive job loss through automation or catastrophic risk through loss of control, only serve to pump valuations. Ignore that as public pressure increases, Sam Altman now downplays fears of job losses. Quite the turn from three years ago when he was saying that jobs are definitely going to go away full stop. While there is no reason to take Silicon Valley at its word, not rigorously engaging

Speaker 4with the dangers of developing AI capabilities is a strategic dead end, unquote. This technology can and is massively transforming production, warfare, the environment, and the health of humanity. And we can't all just hold hands and not believe in this technology hard enough to make it go away. Like it or not, this is not the metaverse or NFTs anymore. Whether you believe these existential safety risks are genuine, a marketing stunt,

Speaker 4or a mix of both, our response should be the same. We should be pushing for legislation to rein in these companies and technology. And like Lena Kahn has said, the CEOs should be prosecuted for creating and releasing dangerous, unvetted, or defective products. Now, Trump's DOJ doesn't seem keen on going after these companies right now. And it's unlikely that this Congress will pass any legislation on this issue, let alone industry hostile legislation. But during this national conversation on

Speaker 4AI regulation, it's crucial that the narrative around regulation isn't being controlled by OpenAI and Anthropic. these companies and technology must be regulated. But that regulation should not be up to the CEOs of those companies, nor the Republicans and center-left Democrats who are in the pocket of AI. But our response to bad regulation shouldn't be no regulation. Coming off the heels of the data center backlash and going

Speaker 4into the midterms, this moment could be a major opportunity for the left to build broad support for real transparent oversight, a frontier development pause, not just a slowdown, and ultimately taking power away from these tech companies and putting control of AI in the hands of the public. Because private control of such transformative technology will have disastrous outcomes for labor and humanity without the prospect of an AI superpower.

Speaker 2Super god.

Speaker 4Incoming DSA House Representative Malat Kiros of Colorado had democratizing AI in her congressional campaign platform. The development of transformative technology cannot be left to the market and the national security state alone, it belongs to all of us, unquote. Earlier this summer, Bernie Sanders introduced a bill to create an AI sovereign wealth fund, giving the public 50% ownership in the largest AI companies in the US through a

Speaker 4one-time 50% tax on the stock of these companies. An independent commission would then use voting shares to steer decisions in the public interest. Sanders said of the bill, quote, Left unchecked, artificial intelligence and robotics threatens the jobs, privacy rights, and mental health of every man, woman, and child in America. As a society, we can no longer sit back and allow a handful of big tech oligarchs to determine the future of this revolutionary technology with no democratic input. AI

Speaker 4was not created out of thin air. It was not a brilliant idea that just popped into Mark Zuckerberg's head or Elon Musk's imagination. The foundation of AI is based on the collective knowledge of humanity and of the creative work of tens of millions of people. The American people must have the ability to slow it down and make sure that AI benefits humanity, not just the richest people on the planet. That's precisely what this legislation does. Now,

Speaker 4such a bill would certainly have a difficult path to being signed into law, especially considering how many lawmakers are being bankrolled by these AI companies. But this idea already has majoritarian support. According to a national Verisight survey last June, 69% of Americans support quote-unquote forcing AI companies to to transfer 50% of their stock into a public sovereign wealth fund. To

Speaker 4quote Geese Magazine, there is a wide debate to be had about the shape of socialization and whether we mean forcing AI research into the public domain or outright nationalizing the entire sector. But it is clear that the overwhelming majority of the American people recognize that a technology trained on the common corpus of human art and text, poised to transform the character of work, ought to be held in common rather than by billionaires, unquote. The New York

Speaker 4City DSA convention is coming up this fall, and currently one of the most popular resolutions is to stop the AI arms race and have DSA, quote, take initiative against the AI company's project to make human labor obsolete and organize a working class coalition for the democratic steering and ownership of the technology. according to an overview in Geese Magazine. This resolution calls for DSA to demand and organize for

Speaker 4a pause on frontier AI research, an AI data center moratorium, regulations on frontier AI models, and policies to ensure workers are protected. To quote the Geese Magazine overview, our horizon must be the collective control of AI, with its gains shared by all. With AI under democratic control, we will decide what activities ought to be left to human hands, exalted creative tasks that make life meaningful, and which can

Speaker 4be automated to expand flourishing and freedom. DSA members may have quite different views on where those lines lie, with some wishing to ban the technology entirely. Regardless, the point is that those conversations will be ours. not Sam Altman's, not Dario Amadei's, not Elon Musk's. This is a once-in-a-century political opportunity. We have the chance to utilize one of the great issues of the day to mobilize workers around the democratic control of the economy, to drive a wedge

Speaker 4into the Republican Party's coalition and the democratic base, and to reorient politics around a question on which our answers are unfathomably popular. we could be at the forefront of the movement rather than tail-ending a disparate set of professionalized non-profits, unquote. This issue will be getting a lot of attention these next few months. AI CEOs will be meeting at the White House with President Xi later this week. The New York City Council is convening a hearing on AI safety

Speaker 4risks next month, with Dario Amadei and Sam Altman requested to appear. If we don't want them to be the ones leading the conversation on AI regulation, which would only result in an industry-friendly regulatory slowdown to curb competition and stabilize market pressure, then the left will have to step up and build on the data center backlash to seize the very technology data centers are powering to destroy these companies and put the future of AI in the control

Speaker 4of the public.

Speaker 8I find the word diversity has become so politically charged nowadays. You know, as a buzzword, as a dirty word. You know, we see it caught up in terms like the AI, in the debates around immigration and representation and all the culture wars that have captured so much of the world's attention as of late. But what has my attention recently, the kind of diversity that I want to focus on,

Speaker 8is the diversity that we are losing. That we are critically losing. Right now we're living through what many scientists describe as the sixth mass extinction. Species are disappearing at a rate driven overwhelmingly by human activity. Languages are dying. Indigenous knowledge is disappearing and entire cultures have been erased. assimilated or reduced to museum pieces. We are, in our lifetimes,

Speaker 8witnessing a profound loss of what author David Harmon calls biocultural diversity, the combined diversity of life and human culture. And all of this has happened at the same time that diversity itself has become so politically controversial. So the question I want to talk about today is why we should even care about diversity in the first place. Why does it matter that thousands of languages exist? Why should we care if a species disappears? Why does it matter whether there are countless different ways for people to live and think and create and organize themselves? Typically, we speak

Speaker 8of diversity as an unquestioned value, as something that some people like or dislike, are opposed to or in favor of politically. But I want to make a deeper argument that diversity is one of the fundamental conditions that makes life creativity and freedom possible. Welcome to It Could Happen Here. I'm Andrew Sage, Andrewism on YouTube, and I'm joined again by... James, it's great to be back.

Speaker 2I'm excited about this one.

Speaker 8Yes. So I suppose to start with, what would you say are the kinds of diversity that come to mind, you know, when you hear the term? And why would you say that it is something that you value, if it is that you value it? I assume you do.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, I do. Like there's like a very liberal way of understanding diversity.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2And I think sometimes even the libs getting better at this libs used to use the word tolerance a lot, which I despise as, as a way of talking about diversity.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2Like it's like a sort of, I don't like it, but I'll allow it to exist.

Speaker 9Approach yes like i'll put up with you kind of yeah exactly like yeah it's not getting us to where we want to get right but like i enjoy that there are people who obviously like are diverse in the way that neoliberalism wants us to think about diversity in terms of race in terms of sexuality in terms of neoliberalism is kind of waffling on gender but also like just approaches to the way we live our lives, right?

Speaker 2Like our cultures, our ways of organizing, our ways of being with one another. My life is so much richer because I've been exposed to that kind of diversity, right? Like I get to travel a lot and seeing how people approach all kinds of issues has really helped me with ways of dealing with things, of crossing the bridges we come to in organizing, in trying to live our better lives. Because I've been able to learn from the ways that they have developed to doing it, which is

Speaker 2very different from the way we do it, right? And so I think that kind of diversity is also super important.

Speaker 8I agree. Absolutely. I think that a lot of times as well, the conversation is really focused on diversity as it relates to people. But, you know, even before we get to diversity within our species, there is the diversity that... transcends our species, the diversity of all the species of planet Earth. You know, the variation as a feature of the world we live in. Yeah.

Speaker 2I think that's also like super valuable, right? Like, and in a way that we can't, I was thinking about this this morning, I was hiking this morning and like capitalism lacks a means to ascribe value to that kind of thing.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2Like I was thinking about in the US, they've proposed to rescind the roadless rule, which allows you not to build roads into national forests in certain infantry roadless areas. And like, there is a way of ascribing value to timber, right? You can talk about board feet of timber, like there is a way of ascribing cost to roads, right? We can estimate how much it will cost to build roads into this area. But like, There isn't a way of

Speaker 2ascribing value that works to the forest being there, to all the things in the forest that are not commercial timber being there, right? The plants, animals, the insects.

Speaker 8It's like the quantifiable value versus like the unquantifiable value, basically.

Speaker 2Yeah, like they're not productive to capital. But they do give us something that is valuable. And because capitalism can't ascribe value to them, it sometimes fails to protect them, right? We've seen this in North America. It's a great example, right? Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 8Like, how do you ascribe value to a view?

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 8I mean, there's an extent to which we see some of that value being wrapped up in the price of, like, a house. You know, like, if a house is on a hillside and has a great view of the ocean and stuff, people will say, oh, well, We could jack up its price on the market because, you know, people will pay for that view. Yeah. You know, a similar concept was like the way that hotel rooms might be more expensive on the higher floors because, you know, oh, you get that kind of panoramic view of the city

Speaker 8or whatever. But that doesn't really capture the experience. It is a crude approximation of the experience of, you know, waking up in the morning to The sun coming over the horizon, the sea in the distance, the birds, you know, making their way out into the world. None of that is captured in the number. It's just a way of trying to capture that in order to facilitate exchange.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. Like it's an attempt to ascribe value to something inherently like doesn't fit in that system. of like the cash exchange, which is what makes it valuable and beautiful.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2Like, uh, but your capitalism will never really be able to protect those things. Like even, you know, in the U S we have public lands, right. But like no fucking way. Okay. Even like Theodore Roosevelt, right. Like all the politicians now we're like, oh yeah, we love Theodore Roosevelt, blah, blah. You know, most us politicians I think would love to be compared to Roosevelt. and this is not someone who I think is a fantastic human being like morally, but, uh, you couldn't do that today. Like, like capitalism is too rapacious today to ever say, like, we are taking hundreds

Speaker 2of thousands of acres and just setting them aside because like, they're nice and it's nice for us to have them. So we're going to keep them that way. Like, uh, it wouldn't, it wouldn't function now, even in a way that was possible then, you know?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8And I mean, arguably even that time, those things being set aside, A person who had witnessed the old growth forests of the past, when they were, you know, in more recent memory, they might even be able to see that this is such a fraction of the value that has been lost of, like, yes, we're preserving some of what's left, but, you know, I don't know if you've seen those pictures of, like, those ginormous, like, trees that they just chopped down as they made that, you know,

Speaker 8that westward expansion into California and whatnot.

Speaker 6Yep.

Speaker 8They didn't even use most of the wood. They ended up having to like discard it, burn it, whatever.

Speaker 2I didn't know that.

Speaker 8But this is like centuries worth of growth that was just destroyed.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2The only reason I think we protected these things, right, was because there was a sort of realization that, oh shit, we've gone way too far with this capitalist exploitation of things, right? Like with this desire to impose ourselves on the world as it has been for a long time. Like that doesn't make up for that.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2It's like a, like your analogy of zoos that you used at the start, right? Like having the last passenger pigeon die in a zoo doesn't make up for killing all the passenger pigeons. Even while that passenger pigeon was alive in the zoo.

Speaker 8Right. Yeah.

Speaker 2Like that's not a trade anyone would make, I guess. No one would be like, Oh, I have to think about this. Like, is anyone ever going to sit around and worry about there not being enough mines or enough roads or, enough logging operations, right. Compared to like, I worry about that not being enough forests, worry about there not being enough wilderness places, you know, like it, uh, it's, it's something that, uh, yeah, we we've, we've failed future generations, I guess, in preserving that diversity.

Speaker 8Yeah. And, you know, as we speak of preserving preservation conservation, I think there's a tendency within those who value diversity. That can lead to a sort of a misdirection or it can lead to maybe a misplaced aspiration, I would say. Because obviously, change itself is not bad. You know, change is inevitable. Extinction has always been part of the history of life. Ecosystems have always been in flux, always evolving. The borders of, you know, ecosystems have been moving throughout

Speaker 8deep time. Mm-hmm. Similarly, cultures have always evolved and mixed and some have faded away. So we can't necessarily reject change, right? And reject the processes by which cultures and environments may change, even in response to human intervention. You know, we look at the forests of North America, since we've been focusing on that example, and many of those forests were engineered, you know, by human activity. So the Amazon rainforest also

Speaker 8shows some evidence of human engineering in terms of the terra preta, the soils being this very rich soil that was deliberately designed by the indigenous peoples.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2The same with like, I've been reading a lot on indigenous cultural use of fire for the last few weeks here since I got back from Spokane and thinking a lot about like how it's a very Western thing. perspective right to be like the wilderness is the thing that humans don't touch and have no engagement with and then everything else humans use as they wish like to create it as this binary distribution right of like the correct way to deal with places that are beautiful or special

Speaker 2is like just fucking leave it and the correct way to deal with everything else is just fucking pillage it like there's a way to find balance that they're We struggle with it under capitalism, right? Capitalism has struggled to provide us with that.

Speaker 8Yeah, I mean, one of the bases of capitalism is private property, which as defined under Roman law is the right to use and abuse one's own. Right. You know, the use and enjoyment and abuse of one's own to the limit of the law, which is a stipulation that had various interpretations over the years. But we shouldn't be surprised then that when something comes under the purview of capitalist property, that it has led to such detrimental effects. What is alarming about our current situation is not the

Speaker 8change that is taking place. It is the speed and the scale of that change. You know, we don't know exactly how many species we are losing or have lost. We don't even know how many species currently exist. We could even talk about the definitions of species and how that taxonomic system has evolved with time. But for that discussion, I leave it to a book that I read on the subject that I quite enjoyed, which was In Light of Our Differences by David Harmon. But regardless, we are

Speaker 8still talking about thousands to hundreds of thousands of species lost each year. And these are losses that are not happening in isolation because we know that every ecosystem is made up of relationships. They remove one species, and you can risk disrupting everything connected to it. Thankfully, these systems are typically quite resilient, so a species loss doesn't have to lead to the collapse of the entire ecosystem, but there are species that are foundational. Then the disappearance of

Speaker 8that single species can trigger cascading effects that threaten the entire ecosystem. There's also often a lag between our realization that a species has fallen below its minimum viable population and the death of the final individual of that species. As you mentioned, the last passenger pigeon in the zoo, I was reminded of that. We see that also happening with human cultures, particularly with language. From what I've read, about 44% of living languages today are now endangered. Some

Speaker 8have fewer than a thousand speakers remaining, and others are spoken by fewer than 10 people. and i know from what you told me of your travels james that you actually have met people who have spoken some of these endangered languages correct.

Speaker 2Yeah certainly like uh i think about languages that like i guess i've heard people speak that are less hegemonic Certainly, like, I can't imagine there are very many speakers of Marshallese, for example, in the RMI, many indigenous languages, right? Like I know the Embara like have made a great deal of like progress, educating young people in their language, right. And like making sure that they, they keep that. I was, uh, just talking to some like Yoemi and Otam friends this morning.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2Uh, I think those languages are doing relatively well for indigenous languages. in what is now the United States. But like, it's only through the concerted effort of people from that community to keep them alive, right? Like, I don't think the state has attributed a diversity value to those languages. And languages, like, they give us a way of understanding the world that is different. That's why I like to try and learn at least a little bit of different languages. Like, they give us a way of seeing things i think about like uh all the bass words for rain right

Speaker 2or uh i was uh diving the other day with like a sea lion and i was talking to a spanish-speaking friend about like in uh in spanish they're like uh wolves of the sea right lions of the sea it's kind of interesting and they do have like a kind of a wolf like vibe to them if you ever uh hung out around sea lions like uh.

Speaker 8In terms of what, like their social structure?

Speaker 2Yeah, and like their, like, I think people see sea lions as like this big cuddly kind of cute thing. And like, they're fucking killers, you know?

Speaker 8Oh, trust and believe I don't. I don't trust those guys at all.

Speaker 2Yeah, no, they're like, they will fuck.

Speaker 8I don't trust any mammal that chose to live an aquatic way of life. Okay, there's something fishy about that.

Speaker 2I love that.

Speaker 8Pun intended.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 2I love that as a category. You know, they're mean. They'll come at you.

Speaker 8As you were mentioning, there are like, according to the ethnologue, at least 7,170 living languages in the world today. Our lowest underestimations of the amount of cultures, that is an accumulation of knowledge, values, customs, technology, social practices. Our lowest estimate of the number of cultures on earth is like 4,000. They're definitely, certainly more than that. Especially if we are using language as a proxy for cultural diversity.

Speaker 10Right.

Speaker 8And even within languages, there's tremendous cultural diversity. Yeah. Biologically, we have a lot of diversity as well. I neglected to mention that. you know, blood types, heights, hair textures, all of these have emerged across the continents we've spread out across. I mean, obviously the concentration of that diversity is in Africa, where we began. But even our adaptations to different environments is a form of diversity that is necessary,

Speaker 8you know, to maintain us. I'll get into some of the arguments for why later on. But, so I didn't know that Basque had all the different words for rain but i am reminded i think that there are different words in inuit languages for describing snow yeah like uh.

Speaker 2The um i think it's in upiac have a bunch of words for snow and ice and like different textures of it i'm trying now to find basque words for uh for rain so i can remember some of them yeah land broa is drizzle or mist i know ziri miri is like a light rain It's like the noise it makes. I always thought that was a really sweet one. I had some fucking throwback. A Cornish anarchist who spoke Cornish, right? One of the languages that is not hegemonic and is

Speaker 2probably relatively endangered, even as European languages go, right? I think it's probably having a better time now than it was when I was younger, but it was relatively rare to encounter a Cornish speaker.

Speaker 8Cornish, that's Cornwall, right?

Speaker 2Correct. Yeah, yeah. was teaching me all these beautiful words for like a different wildlife and different like natural phenomena that sort of have an onomatopoeic quality to them. But like, for some reason, just like the sort of beautiful way that they showed of relating, I don't want to like a noble, savage Cornish people.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2But I just thought that they showed a different way of understanding the world and our relationship with it and these animals and like how they, how they appear. And like, it struck me as really special that that person was like, like kept that knowledge and, and that that person shared that knowledge with me. Um, this was at some like event in Barcelona when I'm like, you know, 21 years old, 19 years old, something like that. Uh, and it just really struck me that, uh, like there was so much beauty in, in seeing the world through the lens of that language. And it would be a real shame if

Speaker 2we ever lost that.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 8And I mean, that's just one case study. Every other endangered language, I'm sure you could point to similar novelties in, you know, how they engage with the world, how they describe and see things.

Speaker 2Sure.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 8And we can extend from language to culture, you know, different cuisines, different ways of, you know, engagement with foods, you know, different forms of architecture and music and ways of telling stories. Yeah. Ways of raising children, ways of celebrating and of mourning.

Speaker 2Yeah, definitely. Like there's a lot that I feel like I've learned about so many of those things from being lucky enough to spend time in different places, right? I guess I can give an example from, this is in my book if people want to read more about it, but like one of the things that a friend in Kurdistan said to me was that like they'd lost a friend, right? This friend had died fighting against the Islamic State. One of the things that they said was like because of this institution of tech mill which is like a form of collective criticism it doesn't quite work in english to

Speaker 2call it collective criticism because you think of maoism which is not but because they had like shared with this person their goals their aspirations their their hopes and then this person through this institution of tech mill had helped them be accountable to their own hopes for themselves that they were a better person because of the time they had spent with this person and now that this person was gone They carried him with them in their ways of being because he had helped them be a better person.

Speaker 2They shared it with me at a time when I had like lost a dear friend and it was a really beautiful way of me processing that. Like I'm not a person who is like a religious person. I don't, I have that belief structure to process it, but like that gave me a sense of an afterlife, which was more concrete for me, which I could understand, which I could see.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 2And like, it really helped me.

Speaker 8The afterlife of memory.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 2And of like, like we are all co-created by our community, right? Like I didn't make myself the way I am.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 2I was made the way I am by my interactions with people who care about me enough to help me be better. And the idea of that person who helped me co-create the person I am, like still existing in the person I am was very powerful to me. Like, it's like a concrete psychological benefit I got from, interacting with people who help me see the world the way they see.

Speaker 8It absolutely you know i'm glad for all the languages that still exist and still give us you know these words for things because if nation states had their way there would be like 10 languages left on earth yeah i mean dramatic but you know right now most of humanity speaks a relatively small number of languages the 23 most spoken mother languages i can't feel like 4 billion people, somewhere around there. And in the 200 most spoken languages,

Speaker 8over 88% of the world's population.

Speaker 2That's crazy.

Speaker 8And this is, of course, due to nation building, due to economic pressures, globalization. Basically, everywhere, the pressures of the status quo have led to indigenous and regional languages, minority languages, disappearing. And if not for the concerted efforts... of these language communities to maintain their way of speaking and to pass it down, we would have lost so many more as it is.

Speaker 2Yeah, definitely.

Speaker 8As you mentioned, by the way, the words that you've picked up over the years from different languages and your attempts to explain those words to me, I was reminded of a work of fiction that I'd read, I think about two years ago. It's a book called Babel by R.F. Kuang And it's kind of like a fantasy historical fiction where like a Chinese student goes to this school in England and the magic of that world is translation. The

Speaker 8sort of energy that gets picked up, the magic that they're able to wield is through the translation from one language to another. And the fact that because translation is on a one-to-one process, the Kind of nuances and, you know, meanings and subtexts and connotations that they get lost or gained in the process are potent. and so for people who are interested in linguistics and fantasy fiction i always recommend that book to.

Speaker 2Them yeah might try that one but what i.

Speaker 8Was alluding to just now was some of the reasons we've begun to lose our world's biocultural diversity as i said before There have been changes across time, across generations, all the way even prior to humanity, so we're not to blame for everything. But there are a lot of historical processes that have reinforced each other, that have led to what has been unfolding these past few centuries. Yes, we might have hunted some species to extinction in our

Speaker 8prehistoric past, but clearly the scale of our impact is quite different here now. Monocultures, for instance, and fast pasture lands have completely replaced ecosystems in certain areas. We've drained wetlands, we've leveled forests, we've fragmented habitats. And that's another thing that when we speak of habitat loss isn't always spoken about. But, you know, we have places where a lot of the

Speaker 8habitat was left alone, quote unquote. But when you have like six lane highways cutting through a forest, that is still a fragmentation of that ecosystem.

Speaker 9Oh yeah.

Speaker 8That's still a disruption of the flow of plants, animal life and fungal life.

Speaker 2Yeah. Can I make a podcast about this? But one of the issues that our endangered wildlife faces here in Southern California, right, is that it's fragmented both by freeways and the border wall. So like the border wall in particular is, people can listen to natural causes if they want to learn more about this. But the border wall in particular, right, is being built at such a speed that they're not even building wildlife gates into it. Now, they don't care about killing people with the wall. Why would they care about killing wildlife, right? But it means, for instance, our peninsula bighorns, which we have like 750

Speaker 2in the United States, one of the rams actually died in the border wall wire recently. And their ability to have like a healthy breeding population will be significantly limited to this to the extent that like, The intangible value of me seeing a bighorn in a hike in the desert might not be something that everyone gets ever again, right? Our mountain lions actually have some weird little genetic anomalies because of the divisions that are created by these big freeways and how dangerous it is to cross them. There's

Speaker 2like a thing you can observe in some of their tails. So there actually are mountain lions in the peninsula range are listed in the California Endangered Species Act, even though as a whole overall, they're not particularly endangered. California has a shit ton of lions, actually. It's because these specific lions, despite the fact that there are conditions for them to thrive, right, in the United States, the intrusion that has divided these populations has made it very hard for those populations, not just to thrive, but like to continue to be healthy.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 8That's the thing, right? Like a species doesn't necessarily have to be endangered or on the brink of extinction for it to be experiencing the extremely negative effects of, you know, our industrial civilization. Right. I would add also the pressures of invasive species through global trade, you know, the impact of pollution in the waterways and in the air. climate change, all of these have placed a tremendous amount of pressure

Speaker 8on the natural world. When it comes to cultural diversity and its losses, which coincide with the losses of biodiversity, we see the impact of colonialism destroying societies through conquest and genocide and assimilation and the very same environmental changes. We've seen nation building try to forge a single national identity at the expense of regional and minority cultures. And then, of course, with globalization, not in the sense of cultural

Speaker 8exchange across distances, as that has always existed, but specifically the kind that has been driven by capitalist markets and state power and industrial efficiency, which enforces standardization across places. You know, it's easier... for these capitalists, for these multinationals to manufacture the same products and market the same brands and basically flatten language and flatten cultural expectations across places.

Speaker 8So they even would manufacture consumer tastes in a way that benefits their bottom line. You know, now you get to pick between streaming services or, you know, you have a whole bunch of different varieties of cereals in your supermarkets, and that is what is counted as economic freedom. Meanwhile, there are cultures that are literally going extinct. Now, I

Speaker 8had a question for you about this subject because you are admittedly a bit older than me.

Speaker 2It's true. Sadly.

Speaker 8Right? But I'm curious, have you witnessed like in real time the loss of this kind of diversity through globalization? So I see like for me, I remember having like copies of older magazines and I could see through those that, you know, the world was, the places generally felt very different, very unique. And as I've come up With social media, I've seen places have kind of homogenized. Everything was starting

Speaker 8to look the same. And let's not even talk about the impact of like AI slop.

Speaker 2Oh, yeah.

Speaker 8But yeah, what have you seen?

Speaker 2Yeah, like it's one of those things that like you do see the, like the impact of the smartphone is huge, right? At a second level, the impact of Starlink is massive. much more than I think most people living in the colonial core would realize, right? Like more people have access to the internet through smartphones than have electricity in their homes. And like the internet is a very hegemonic place, right? Like there are probably seven or eight languages the internet's

Speaker 2really good in that like you could really access the internet in. And that really has made a difference with the way young people engage with the external world.

Speaker 8Right. Right.

Speaker 2I guess I've also seen like a, uh, a reclamation of some of that. And it's a thing that's largely happened like within, uh, the colonial core to the greatest extent, right? Like the, um, the so-called the Europe of nations hypothesis, right? Like one of the languages I can, uh, speak and read and, and write in is, is Catalan. And like, this is an example of a language that like was, uh, ruthlessly suppressed by the Francoist regime. Same with Basque, same

Speaker 2with other non-Spanish languages in Iberia. And now that is the primary language of instruction for most Catalan students. In my lifetime, my time spending time in Catalonia, I see infinitely more people speaking Catalan than I used to. I remember there's an anecdote about this in my dissertation, but some young Syrian kids who would always speak to me in Catalan They played football outside my archive, right? Like, so, uh, we'd be kicking the football around and, uh, it's cool

Speaker 2that this language that had once very nearly been destroyed, it's now like hegemonic. It was cool at the time, Catalan nationalism, but like every other nationalism has some qualities, which I don't like, but like, it was cool that at the time there was a, an acceptance of people, especially like these kids who spoke Catalan. happened to have been born in Syria.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2But like, they were Catalan as much as anyone else. Like it wasn't a, uh, an ethnic definition of, of nation.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2But at the same time, yeah, I've definitely seen that diversity lost in terms of so many things like foods.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 8I feel like there has been a homogenization of pallets as well.

Speaker 2A hundred percent.

Speaker 12Right.

Speaker 8Especially with the proliferation of fast foods.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. Like fast, cheap. high calorie food that stores easily. I mean, the example, I guess, is like, look at what they've done to bread for the time of my life.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2Like, uh, look at how like sliced white, what we would have called American bread is now like the global standard.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 2But like all those other bread products that people used to make, like, it can be very hard to get like freshly made tortillas. It's possible where I live.

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 2But it's not, I imagine if you live in like Minnesota. Just like the little moments of beauty that they gave you in your day that had gone. And, but yeah, also the big things like I, uh, you know, I, I watched kids watching TikTok in the Darien gap. That wouldn't have been possible seven or eight years ago.

Speaker 13Right.

Speaker 1Wow.

Speaker 2I didn't quite know when styling was widely distributed, but like that makes a difference to people.

Speaker 1Right?

Speaker 2Like their cultural world is that they're now engaging with the external world, not just through their own culture, through the internet. And I want those people to have everything I have to be clear, right? Like I want them to be able to see the whole world.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 8You don't want to like seal them vacuums. them in some kind of some kind of museum exhibit of what once.

Speaker 2Was exactly yeah but like i also wish that they could have it the way i have it which is that like i am i was born in england and i engage with the world in english i wish they could engage with the world number i wish to you know, Kurdish people can engage with the world in whichever type of Kurdish they speak, you know, which they didn't have to, to go through the English way of speaking and seeing the world, to engage with the external world, because we all lose when we don't have that diversity, right?

Speaker 8Yeah. And I mean, we're talking about what is lost, I think, when things get homogenized, but there is like, I think, another effect or another, I suppose, response to that global capitalism has the diversity, which is to package it, to market it, to sell it. I referenced those magazines that I read, but those magazines might even be an example of that because it is a capturing and commodification,

Speaker 8in a sense, of another culture for distribution and consumption.

Speaker 2Yeah, definitely.

Speaker 8You see as well, people's traditional dress becomes... a less of a traditional dress and more of a traditional costume as they put it on to perform for consumption for tourists.

Speaker 2Yeah, like the commodification of diversity. Yeah, that idea that diversity is a thing to sell. The marginalization of people such that their identity, which has been marginalized by the state and capitalism, is what they have to sell to exist under the state and capitalism, I guess.

Speaker 8Yeah. We've already sort of hinted at... Some of the reasons why I think we should care about this loss of diversity, you know, and I could even spot off a few more. And diversity makes our living systems more resilient, I think is a very key one. In our ecosystems, every species has its niche and they can compete and cooperate and recycle nutrients and everything is just part of one larger network. And the more diverse that network is, the more it has to respond to disruption. Diversity gives

Speaker 8ecosystems options. We see that in comparison to the monocultures, the monocultural approach to farming that has dominated much of the world, and the common inputs that approach requires. We look at how vulnerable that approach is to disease and to changes in climate conditions. In terms of genetic diversity, we can point to the fact that if every human immune system works in exactly the same way, A pathogen that evolved to bypass one person's immune system could bypass everyone's.

Speaker 8And so our biological differences create the variation in how diseases spread and keep us as a whole safe, keep our existence as a whole secure. Even within my own family, I've noticed that some people are more susceptible and others more resistant to different diseases. You know, when a virus passes, Into my household, there are some people who get sick and some people don't, and it changes each time, despite the fact that we are so close genetically. And so again,

Speaker 8we see the diversity creates resilience. And even if we want to take it from like a coldly utilitarian perspective, that resilience is a value. It has utility, you know, and an individual instance of a species or of a culture is might have value in a way that we don't realize until it's gone yeah we become poorer as a whole we lose possibilities when we lose languages when

Speaker 8we lose cultures when we lose species every culture represents literally thousands of experiments accumulated over generations in what it means to live as a human being we may like some more than others you know i'm not a relativist in the sense that I will turn a blind eye to things that I find morally objectionable in certain cultures. But I can recognize that every culture has something that adds to our library of experiences. And I would rather

Speaker 8have that full library than a single shelf of books.

Speaker 2It's a really good way of saying it.

Speaker 8Having that full library gives us more raw material to think with, to create art with, to do science with. If you like the arts, you know, you will like diversity because that innovation in the arts and in the sciences emerges from everything that came before. Diversity is a foundation for future creativity and innovation. If everybody approaches the world with the same assumptions and categories and ways of thinking, then, you know, our capacity to imagine alternatives will shrink. And

Speaker 8then just really from a deeply philosophical perspective, I appreciate diversity because I believe that when you are given a gift, you should meet it with gratitude. You know, we are born in a world, we happen to be born into a world that is overflowing with different forms of life, different landscapes, different cultures, different ways of thinking. That is a vast, rich inheritance that I believe we should appreciate.

Speaker 8That is my value. I'll add that You know, we were speaking about biodiversity and cultural diversity, what Harmon calls biocultural diversity, but there's also the value of cognitive diversity. You know, we have different opinions, but we might also perceive and categorize and solve problems in generally different ways. And having different perspectives, different interpretations, different heuristics, different predictive models,

Speaker 8what Scott E. Page calls cognitive toolboxes in his book, The Difference. You know, these give us an opportunity to solve problems in unique ways. You know, we're not all going to have the same tools and what tools I may lack, another person may have. And it's not always necessarily a requirement that you just get the smartest person to solve the problem. In fact, as Page's research suggests, getting a group of people who approach a problem differently

Speaker 8will outperform a group of people who are made up of individually brilliant people who all think in roughly the same way. Now, Page doesn't make the bold claim that cognitive diversity is always the best approach because he does distinguish between routine, regular tasks, and tasks that require like more experimentation and creativity and multiple competing ideas. So in those cases where you need that diversity of ways of thinking to solve complex problems in transportation, in dealing with

Speaker 8climate change and developing medicines, you know, we don't want everybody to be thinking alike. Another thing that Page points out is that while cognitive diversity and identity diversity are not one-to-one, There is overlap between the concepts because people who grow up in different environments and have different experiences and opportunities and social positions are more likely to develop different ways of seeing the world. So if we recognize that cognitive diversity is valuable for solving complex problems, then

Speaker 8prejudice is a practical failure as well as a moral failure. One of the things that I wanted to address, and I kind of alluded to it earlier, when I said that I'm not really a relativist, is that while I do value diversity, I definitely don't think that every form is worth celebrating. You know, I believe a healthy society should have space for different ways of thinking and living and organizing ourselves, but that does not mean this kind

Speaker 8of liberal tolerance that would put up with mindsets and practices of domination that would eliminate that very freedom at the end of the day though i want to retain the capacity for diversity because i think it gives us a capacity for freedom and i want as you know subcommandante marcos put it a world where many worlds exist yeah even as i reject certain forms that the world

Speaker 8has taken and certain manifestations of diversity any closing thoughts.

Speaker 2Like the world where many worlds can exist is I think the perfect way of looking at this, right? Like we therefore don't want people who would create a world where other worlds cannot exist, right? But we gain so much from having and respecting and cherishing diversity rather than treating it through that tolerance framework, which we both talked about. Like tolerance seems to imply like, well, we're doing it best, but we'll let you do it your way as opposed to like genuinely cherishing diversity yeah and uh yeah i

Speaker 2hope we can all see that.

Speaker 8Agreed and as always all power to all the people peace.

Speaker 6Welcome to It Could Happen Here, a podcast about the violent flailings of a dying empire. I am your host, Mio Wong. And today, we are going to be talking about a thing, perhaps the only thing that Americans understand more thoroughly than a burger, and that is gas prices. Now, elsewhere on this show, speaking about inflation, I have talked about price as a kind of social hieroglyphic. that serves

Speaker 6to encode the complex and brutal reality of geopolitics and production and labor and exploitation into a single number. And that number is their understanding of everything that is happening in the world and, you know, how content they are about it is about how much gas costs them. This has proven a real problem for one group. President of the United States, Donald Trump, as diesel is hitting an

Speaker 6average across the country of $ 6. 52 a gallon. Now, nominally, the President of the United States does not control the price of oil and does not, you know, set gas prices. However, comma, in this case, no, yeah, this is largely not technically entirely, but like, yeah, this is sort of just a thing he did as an individual. But I think what's important here, right, is that the way that all of the information that I'm about to describe is conveyed, right, and the thing

Speaker 6that makes Americans care about it is the social hieroglyphic of the gas price, right? It is the single number through which all of this complex information is encoded down into, and that is what sort of matters emotionally. And I want to undo the process of encoding all of that information down into the hieroglyphic. I want to actually expand it and go look at what is going on in the world that is causing all of this. And I want to take a look at how the structure of

Speaker 6American empire has changed in order to facilitate this. And to do this, I'm going to walk through a series of, I guess, nominally seemingly disconnected stories about oil across the world. And we're going to put it all together into the new structure of American empire at the end. Now, as everyone I think is aware, gas prices have been increasing dramatically, both of regular gas and of diesel. Bank of America

Speaker 6analysts are finally admitting that oil could hit $ 150 a barrel, not like right now, but as the war continues to drag out. And as we've talked about before on this show, a lot of the reserves that were being used to calm the market temporarily and keep prices down are being exhausted. The most obvious example of this is something we've talked about before, which is the draining of the American Strategic Petroleum Reserve. But this is true of a lot of

Speaker 6other reserves around the world as well. Now, this alone probably would not have been enough to cause what we've been seeing. But, comma, all of the problems that we have been talking about for a long time on this show, particularly the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, that is entirely directly just the fault of Donald Trump, right, through his war on Iran, has been doing significant damage to the world's oil supply, to the world's natural gas supply. Now, the reason it hasn't been worse has been that there

Speaker 6have been ways to bypass the Strait of Hormuz. They're not easy. They work worse than the Strait of Hormuz. But One of those important mechanisms has been Saudi Arabia's east-west pipeline. Now, we talked about this, Robert talked about this on last week's Executive Disorder. Last week, Iraqi paramilitaries launched drone strikes on Saudi Arabia's east-west pipeline. It did some damage. There is kind of conflicting reports about how long exactly that is going to take to repair, but

Speaker 6the damage to the pipeline has slowed the ability of the Saudis to route oil around the Plaque and the Strait of Hormuz. Now, also, there has been a major expansion in the war in Yemen. This is a really hideous conflict that has been going on for over a decade now. We don't really have, unfortunately, time to really go into all of the factors of the civil war

Speaker 6in Yemen, which is one of the most complicated wars being fought anywhere in the world. Broadly speaking, this is a conflict between a coalition that is sort of in the West. It's called the Houthis, but there's more forces involved in it, which is the kind of Iranian-aligned, vaguely... Not vaguely. I mean, they are allied with Iran, but they're not necessarily just an Iranian proxy. This is its own sort of political force, right? And then on the other side, there is the Saudi-backed coalition, which also involves a range of forces involved. but is kind of led

Speaker 6by the Saudis and the UAE, and they're kind of allied forces who pull a whole bunch of forces from a whole bunch of places and have committed horrifying atrocities, including, as I mention constantly every time someone talks about this because no one ever seems to remember it, to the deployment by the Saudi coalition of Sudanese child soldiers. So this war had, I don't know if calm down is quite the right word, But in the past few years,

Speaker 6had been less active than it was, say, in 2018, 2019. But the Houthis have now made a major push into Saudi coalition territories in Yemen's west and south. They have taken the port city of Mokha in the south, which is an important Saudi coalition's port city, which is further threatening the ability of the Saudis to bypass the Strait of Hormuz because This is a city that helps you control access to the Gulf of Aden. Now, this war

Speaker 6has been and continues to be a massive humanitarian nightmare. We really have no idea how many people have actually died in the war. The casualty figures right now are kind of stuck at 150,000. I suspect it is significantly more than that. This is a region that has been experiencing everything from you know, like hideous war, just famines. A huge part of this war has been a Saudi blockade of sort of like Sokol Houthi controlled territories, which

Speaker 6has had an absolutely devastating effect on the ability of, you know, people in Yemen to eat. This attack has also caused a massive surge of refugees, you know, as people sort of flee the violence. And this has been, you know, an absolute nightmare on the one hand. And on the other hand, the way that it's understood here, the way that it's reported on in the West, is not as its own unique humanitarian nightmare and this unique war of Saudi and Emirati empire. In Yemen, it's understood

Speaker 6as something that affects oil prices. And so that's one of the factors that is encoded in into this price. Another one has been Ukraine's drone attacks on Russian oil refineries, which have escalated. Now, from the perspective of what is happening with the oil, you know, Houthis have also been attacking Saudi shipping and Saudi shipping is, you know, when someone talks about Saudi shipping, they're talking almost like guarantee

Speaker 6the thing they're talking about is shipping oil out of the country, right? Houthi attacks on Saudi shipping have slowed down In the past week, but there is always the possibility of them starting up again. And this is the real problem in terms of the world's oil infrastructure, and particularly from the perspective of empire, right? In the sense of, you know, wanting to be able to secure access to oil for the US and for other sort of imperial powers. The issue that they're facing as this war continues, right?

Speaker 6And as these really, really, truly these series of wars, right, is that even if, you know, going back to the Saudi pipeline, right, the Saudi pipeline will eventually be fixed, right? Like full capacity, it might not be for 68 weeks, but eventually the pipeline is going to get fixed, even if it is sort of restricting supply in the meantime. The problem is that all of this infrastructure is just exposed. And a whole bunch of different militaries in the region

Speaker 6can and probably will hit them again, as the U.S. has been hitting Iranian oil infrastructure, right? Iran, its allied paramilitaries in Iraq, the Houthis, there are lots of groups in the region who are being attacked by the U.S. and the Saudis and sort of American allies in the region who are looking at this and going, oh, this is something we can use to extract oil. you know, to extract concessions and try to fight the Americans off. And there's no real answer for this other than ending

Speaker 6the war, a thing that just won't happen. Now, the Trump administration nominally has a plan for this. The plan that they are claiming to have, other than this sort of constant dance of claiming that the war in Iran is over, and then It's restarting again. We've started a whole bunch of different wars. Another trade war is actually open.

Speaker 6The other plan that Trump has talked about is Venezuela. Trump was at the UN recently where he gave an extremely distressing speech in which he talked about how he had been thinking about destroying Iran. He said, quote, do I drive them into hell with no chance of survival and no hope of future greatness or generations? Now, one of the other parts of this speech was him talking

Speaker 6about the U.S. 's deal with the Venezuelan government that it installed when it just kidnapped Maduro, who we are just also still holding, as people I think broadly have forgotten about. But yeah, no, we just are still just holding ahead of state. hostage in a prison. We're just still doing that. But he was talking about a deal that he struck with the current Venezuelan government, which is largely just composed of the same people from the Maduro government,

Speaker 6but with any person in charge of it and answering to Trump. Yeah, talking, you know, that was a 100-year, supposedly a 100-year concession for a significant portion of what's supposed to be Venezuela's oil fields. Now, Trump in this said, quote, to the victors belong the spoils. And this is nominally, right, this sort of is his previous war, or short war,

Speaker 6I guess, on Venezuela is supposed to be the solution to his new war. Trump has been pushing the line that oil flowing from Venezuela is going to, you know, be the thing that drives prices down and stops these escalating oil prices from his other imperial war in Iran. And as we're going to talk about now, there is oil flowing from Venezuela to the US, right? And the

Speaker 6amount of oil that is flowing to the US has increased. Companies that were already in Venezuela, like Chevron, are expanding production. But it hasn't even hit, like, 1990s levels. It's still, in the grand scheme of things, not enough oil to actually do anything. And as we have, you know, sort of repeatedly emphasized on this show, oil is not liquid money. It has material properties, it has social properties that come from the, you know, technical process of extraction. It's not

Speaker 6all the same. These oil reserves... you know, suck, right? And this is also part of the problem with Venezuelan oil, is the oil is just of a lower quality than the oil that you get out of the Middle East. Now, what's important for our purposes, right, is we're beginning to see a little bit more of the plan, which I guess is kind of an ambitious way to describe the kind of just semi-free-for-all that's been happening in Venezuela. In

Speaker 6terms of this sort of plan, which is to extract all of this oil from Venezuela, which is now just effectively operating as an American colony, even in just pure imperial terms, and not thinking just in terms of the fact that, yeah, Venezuela is just a dictatorship and the oil is now flowing to the US, there's real problems with this in that Venezuelan oil infrastructure is very bad, and the actual money in oil is in controlling infrastructure

Speaker 6that already exists and not building new infrastructure. So again, companies that were in Venezuela, which is, I mean, it's basically Chevron, right? You know, are expanding their existing production to some extent, but no one else wants to go in and actually like build a bunch of oil refineries and a bunch of extraction facilities because that stuff's expensive and it requires massive heavy capital investment and it's risky And this is becoming a real problem for this entire plan, right? Obviously, yes,

Speaker 6there is oil that the administration can ship out of Venezuela and is, right? But it's not enough to actually seriously have the effects that the administration is talking about in terms of sort of lowering prices. Now, we're going to get to the extent to which it does kind of solve... the regime's demand on just the basic level of, oh, if we're going to do a war, we should keep the oil. But the actual prospects for this oil are

Speaker 6just not very good. And this is where I want to get into something new that we've learned about sort of recently through reporting from the Wall Street Journal, that there's been some more stuff about some of the people who are coming into Venezuela in order to do this. Now, we have mentioned on the show before that there are a lot of network state people like involved in Venezuela. This is one of the places that these sort of like Silicon Valley tech fascists are moving into. And one

Speaker 6of the people who is now becoming important in Venezuelan sort of oil production or is attempting to become important is this crypto billionaire named Fred Ersam, who is one of the founders of Coinbase, which is a giant crypto company. He's sort of in tight with The entire Silicon Valley tech elite has ties to like every venture capital and Andreessen Horowitz, like steel-backed constellation you can imagine. And he's

Speaker 6one of the people who's been extremely important in terms of the ways that this sort of network state project of this like setting up these sort of like corporate fascist states works. right, have been interested in crypto as a way to sort of move money around and have money that's not like taxable directly or like is difficult for states to sort of get access to. Now, Fred has moved into this really, really sort of, it's like

Speaker 6described as a hotel, but it's like almost more like a kind of like I don't know, almost like billionaire resort thing in Caracas. It's like 36 rooms in it. And he's been spending a whole bunch of time living there. He's also like founded this company with some Venezuelan guys, one of whom was like went to Stanford. So, you know, it's like these sort of, there's always like a local elite kind of thing involved in these projects where particularly

Speaker 6you get like American educated guys from, you colonized nations who end up coming back and getting involved in these processes. And they have founded this company called Primavera, which is getting involved in the contracts for Venezuelan oil development. But there's problems here, right? Which is that this is a startup. They've never done oil extraction before, right? And the network state people and their VC firms have had a lot

Speaker 6of success In things like drone production, right? In missile production, in a lot of sort of, you know, like things that are like kind of like heavy industrial capacity. But this guy is a crypto billionaire and they're trying to do oil development that like the rest of the world's oil companies were like, no. So there are sort of real questions about whether even this, you know, this sort of like fascist plan to exploit the resources of this country can actually work. But this is the kind of

Speaker 6constellation of forces that have a line behind the Trump administration, right? And these constellation of forces are to an extent different than the ones from old American neoconservatism, right? Which was the last sort of, you know, last time we were like fighting wars for oil during the Bush administration. Now,

Speaker 6I want to go back and talk about this in terms of the structure of.

Speaker 3Empire, right?

Speaker 6Because it's very clear that the kind of regime that's been set up in Venezuela, which is just, okay, we've turned this entire nation into not even the kind of debt servicing colony that the US has traditionally done when it comes in to extract wealth from a country, but just as a sort of like appear, hey, we can say we got the oil colony, but this is the kind of regime that Trump wants, not just for Venezuela, but for Iran and Cuba and the rest of the world as well, which are just these sort of like

Speaker 6compliant dictatorships that will export him whatever he wants and flatter his ego. And this is a desire, this specific kind of empire, right? This specific kind of oil empire is a desire that comes out of a divide in American conservatism between the neocons and what are called the paleocons. Paleo is like the old conservatives, neocons the new conservatives or whatever. These are both kinds of empire. If you look at what neoconservatism was, it was an oil company

Speaker 6strapped to a weapons manufacturer like wearing a church for a face. And if you look at what the Bush administration is, like Bush is a Texas oil guy. Cheney is a Halliburton guy, which is like another oil company. He's also really heavily involved in a bunch of weapons manufacturers. You know, this is the alliance that was like doing the worst for oil. But part of what the project of neo-conservatism was, was nominally this mission of bringing like quote unquote democracy to the world. And obviously this is, you know, democracy insofar as it supports the US, which

Speaker 6is like capitalism and support for American empire. And, you know, they're setting up a stock market in, in Iraq, but like, and this is the way that a lot of these people thought about it was this sort of like Hegelian nation building process, right? Like the unfolding of American liberal democracy throughout the entire world in a way that, you know, could sort of permanently stabilize its hegemony. But there, there is this sort of like nation building.

Speaker 2Aspect of, of it.

Speaker 6But then there was also always, like, a paleocon opposition to it, and this is the more radical faction that didn't give a shit about any of the sort of democracy and human rights stuff that neocons would spout. You know, literally, they would, like, yeah, bomb them all and take the oil and leave. And this, to a large extent, is the faction that Trump has descended from, right? And these people sometimes will kind of, like, play at being anti-imperialist, or, like, not even anti-imperialist, they'll play at being anti-war. You know, Tucker Carlson, for example, is like a guy who did

Speaker 6this a lot, even though he supported the war when it was happening. But they'll do this thing of like, oh, we shouldn't go fight in these imperial wars.

Speaker 7The U.S.

Speaker 6Should only fight wars that benefit it. We shouldn't be the world's policemen. But the corollary to that is, you know, where like war for oil was like the leftist charge about what we were doing in Iraq. These people were just like, yeah, no, we actually should literally just fight wars for oil. Because they're just, they're fascists, right? They don't even have the kind of veil of this like nominally sort of democratic project. All they really care about

Speaker 6is just the pure resource extraction. But the thing about this, right? And like part of what was going on with this kind of thing was like, yeah, so you want to set up a stable government so that these oil companies have a secure base from which to actually do resource extractions. Because, you know, sort of unstable governments make it more difficult, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Now, with this sort of, like, fascist Trump coalition, like, obviously, yeah, like, the oil company supported him. But it's not the, like, oil guys directly

Speaker 6who are behind the Venezuelan coup or the people that have, like, moved in to extract the oil. It's, as we were talking about, it's these, like, tech fascist network state guys.

Speaker 8And.

Speaker 4The.

Speaker 6Reaction of the oil people to Trump's wars, and this is, you know, partially given his label, but mostly to this war on Iran, which he's framing as being about, like, nuclear weapons. But he's also been talking about, like, we should just sit there and take the trade off of Moose. You know, Iran shouldn't be able to, like, threaten the world's oil supply. The actual oil people are really pissed off about this because, yeah, they're losing access to their ability to ship oil. But this is what is inside of the sort of price hieroglyphic of gas price go up.

Speaker 6It's an attempt of, like, the tech fascists to, like, graft their project onto this sort of paleo-con-fascist id of Trump, where he's just doing these wars, like, because he wants to, and they're attempting to get something out of it. But what has actually happened here in all of this is that in the administration's war for oil, and in their attempt to sort of, like, fulfill the old paleocon desire

Speaker 6for wars for oil. They have successfully not gotten oil. They're replacing oil that they used to have or attempting to replace better oil they used to have with shit oil that won't work for these purposes. And they're depriving both the US and basically the rest of the world of oil. And that's in some sense the macro level of it. The micro level of it is that There's a whole bunch of wars and genocides that are playing out across the world that are the result of this.

Speaker 6And that's what's encoded in Gas Price Go Up, is all of the violence and all of the cruelty and all of this sort of inane, flailing stupidity of empire.

Speaker 4This is It Could Happen Here, Executive Disorder, our weekly newscast covering what's happening in the White House, the crumbling world, and what this means for you. I'm Garrison Davis. Today I'm joined by Mia Wong, James Stout, and special correspondent, Denna El-Kurd.

Speaker 6Welcome.

Speaker 1Thank you. Thank you.

Speaker 4This episode, we are covering the week of September 16 to September 23rd. I know this has been a busy news week. There's the United Nations. The Trump admin is throwing around the idea of a diesel export embargo. There's a lot of big issues in this country. But on Wednesday, Senator Tommy Tuberville of Alabama decided to use the United States Senate to bring up another very important issue threatening the national security of our country. Let's take a listen.

Speaker 10Airline pilots. Flight attendants and air traffic controllers are part of the furry community. Lord help us. It's terrifying when you think about this. When you walk onto a commercial flight, it's possible that the pilot flying your plane could have a deranged fetish of dressing up like an animal. You can't make this up.

Speaker 2Every time I hear that guy's name, he sounds like he's a character on Thomas the Tank Engine, like a side character. Then he goes and does shit like this.

Speaker 4He does have a very cartoony name. Also on the little podium here, a printout of the... An emoji? An emoji?

Speaker 2Not just any emoji. Does someone want to take a crack at describing this?

Speaker 4I think this is what we would describe as the pregnant man emoji. A yellow emoji figure with short hair who is pregnant. The text reads transgenderism is a mental illness. Something I think Tuberville and others are overlooking is if we were to, you know, excise furries from their jobs as airline pilots, flight attendants and air traffic controllers, our entire system would collapse. Those are those are the crucial

Speaker 4soldiers keeping our airspace.

Speaker 1They are the glue.

Speaker 6Yes, they are the glue.

Speaker 4Like we're already running into many issues in regards to air traffic controllers and the airline industry, if you take the furries out, it's done. It's over.

Speaker 6You know what? Honestly, someone in the furry community, get on organizing the furry strike where all the furries just go on strike. We can end this whole system right now. We can defeat them in a single stroke.

Speaker 4Let's move on to some other small news items.

Speaker 2Yeah, okay. Someone was upset on the subreddit that we didn't call this all the small things. We're not going to. I guess I'm going to start with Pete Hegseth. Pete Hegseth has announced a joint warfighter evaluation.

Speaker 8Oh, boy.

Speaker 2Yeah, so this is a thing for 06s who are screening for their first star, right, across all the different branches of the military. I'm not going to list what an 06 is because I don't understand how the Navy works. But he's claiming that this new evaluation for promotion will value competence over credentials. It's the way he phrased it. It's basically like an exercise that these officers will have to take part in, and various versions of it are going to involve a war game against an AI-powered adversary, which is great. I expect it, I guess. We probably

Speaker 2could have seen this coming. It's additive to the existing things that they consider for promotion, but this is part of his ongoing purge of the US military officer corps. Secondly, I want to talk about a visual investigation by Thomas Bordeaux. He's at CNN, but I think he's working with BBC Verify on this. BBC is doing a kind of true crime podcast about the disappearance of Austin Tice at the moment. People aren't familiar, Austin Tice was an American freelancer who disappeared in Syria at the beginning of the revolution and

Speaker 2continues to be missing. Have any of you guys seen this video?

Speaker 4No.

Speaker 2This must be like, well, I think it was 2012 or 2011. I think it was right at the end of 2011. So it purports to be a video of his execution. It seems very likely to be staged. Like if you watch it, it seems a lot like it's regime intel guys dressing up and pretending to be like rebels. Like they basically say nothing but Takbir the whole time. And then they make him say some stuff. And then the video cuts, right? You don't see him being executed. He's blindfolded and it's supposed to give that vibe. Anyway, they have geolocated this video to an area that would

Speaker 2have been controlled by the Assad regime at the time. which I guess further adds evidence to the claim that he was held by the regime, at least at that time. CBS is reporting the Trump administration is ready to accept 17,500 more Africana refugees. God. Yeah, the people who have struggled the most in the continent of Africa. CBS is reporting that the Trump administration said, quote, the United States anticipates that Afrikaners from South Africa will fully assimilate into

Speaker 2the United States in a manner that preserves taxpayer resources for US citizens and does not anticipate other countries resettling Afrikaners. One can only imagine why. This assimilation thing has been a consistent thing for them, right? The first time they accepted white South African refugees, Rubio talked about it in Congress. Like this seems to be the standard by which they're judging refugee admissions now. You have to be white and you have to like quote unquote assimilate. So that's great.

Speaker 4On Tuesday, J.D. Vance's so-called anti-fraud task force announced that they were cutting almost a million people from Affordable Care Act coverage after deciding that 760,000 people or enrollees were fraudulently enrolled in government health care plans. that these plans did not correspond to real people or these people were ineligible for coverage. Vance announced that another 419,000 accounts are under, quote,

Speaker 4additional verification. Mehmet Oz said that they canceled coverage for people in part because those people never filed a claim.

Speaker 13760,000 people, we call them phantoms because we believe most of them either don't exist or had no idea they had coverage. We believe that because we have been writing them, telexing them, walking to them, FedExing, whatever we could possibly do to get in touch with them, they won't answer and they have never filed a claim. So it meets all the criteria for us to pretty as much as any government can say, you actually don't know you have this or you don't exist.

Speaker 4Obviously, in numbers this large, it is not unlikely that there is many real people who do need this coverage or rely on this coverage who will be cut as a part of this almost a million people. And Vance has promised that more cuts will be coming. Last Friday, the DOJ released a new legal opinion concluding that the federal ban on handgun sales to 18 to 20 year olds is unconstitutional and should not be enforced against licensed dealers.

Speaker 4And lastly for me, ProPublica just published a super in-depth investigation into how Trump crushed a sweeping 2024 FBI bribery probe into Susan Collins and her super PAC, among a few other congresspeople as well. This article lays out what looks like a pretty clear pay-to-play scheme with requests for campaign donations in exchange for Collins securing millions of dollars in federal funding for defense contractors. Collins is the chair

Speaker 4of the Appropriations Committee, with one contractor, a naval company called Navtech, funneling donations through a shell company, which the head of Collins Super PAC said was, quote, very smart.

Speaker 8Oh boy.

Speaker 4In email correspondence obtained by ProPublica. This shell company, by the way, was called the Society of Young Women Scientists and Engineers.

Speaker 6Wait, just scientist?

Speaker 4Scientist.

Speaker 6Incredible.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2Scientist.

Speaker 4That typo was how this donation was first flagged that then prompted this investigation. Cool work there. ProPublica writes, quote, the money had come from Navitek's account, not their CEOs, violating a ban on government contractors making donations, unquote. So the CEO of Navitek is now in prison, but obviously Collins is not. Though the CEO was interviewed by the FBI for a number of years regarding his dealings with

Speaker 4Collins and other people in Congress. ProPublica writes that the CEO, quote, handed the FBI the 50-page document detailing Avatex dealings with more than a dozen members of Congress and their staff, unquote. So part of ProPublica's reporting is explaining how the FBI was about to kind of launch this much broader full-scale investigation around the end of 2024. And then obviously in 2025, Trump got into office. This whole type of investigation fell apart.

Speaker 4A whole bunch of attorneys resigned during February of 2025. This is another one of those articles I think it's worth just reading the whole thing. It's pretty long, but it's some pretty solid reporting. And it's already been corroborated by the New York Times as well.

Speaker 2All right. Do we want to talk about some medium-sized things?

Speaker 4Some medium items.

Speaker 8Okay.

Speaker 2Talking of medium-sized things, let's talk about wolves. Not as big as buffalo, larger than rabbits. So Donald Trump has signed an executive order which gives 90 days for the Secretary of the Interior to conduct a broad inspection of regulations impacting ranching and make suggestions to change them. The executive order presser was called Supporting America's Ranchers. As part of this, he talks about instructing Doug Burgum, who, if you don't remember, was endorsed by REI last year, to

Speaker 2work on delisting wolves from the Endangered Species Act. Specifically, I'm just going to quote here, the Secretary of the Interior shall make a determination as to whether the grey wolf and the Mexican wolf has met the recovery criteria for delisting or downlisting under the Endangered Species Act. And if he determines that the recovery criteria has been met, shall begin the process of delisting or downlisting them. also directs him to work with states to have them removed from state ESAs, right? So several states have their own Endangered Species Act. California is one of them, right? I think wolves were listed under the California ESA before the

Speaker 2federal ESA existed. If you're not familiar, wolves have become a massive culture war issue in the West, right? Like wolves are very woke. is a thing that I have learned. Like if you go, I don't go to garden or outside Yellowstone, right? Like this place, which we can categorically prove makes millions of dollars a year from people coming to look at wolves. You'll see people wearing those smoke a pack a day t-shirts and like, they're not talking about cigarettes, right?

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 2Removing wolves from the West, seeing wolves as like this, this woke thing that is destroying our writing interest. Like it's a big, culture signal.

Speaker 4Like the idea that like conservation is like woke or in some way or like animal like.

Speaker 2The thing with wolves is it combines like people don't like people who talk about animal rights. People don't like ecology and conservation and people don't like predators.

Speaker 8Got it.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 2And so when we get these three things together, it's the idea that it's a bunch of people in New York who don't understand what wolves do. and they want them back, but they don't have to deal with the consequences, right? It does suck when there is predation. My family raised livestock. I've dealt with predation. It fucking sucks. It sucks, especially when it's young animals, right? Calves or lambs or whatever. One of the things that the Trump administration has also instructed Burgum to do is to look at and consider amending the existing compensation programs, which exist for wolves, right? The wolf issue, I think, is also particularly controversial because

Speaker 2there have been hard introductions, right? Like, If you look at Colorado, Colorado had a ballot measure in 2020 to introduce wolves, to reintroduce wolves, which they began doing about three years ago. And Colorado has this big cultural divide between your blue counties and the Western Slope, I'll say. The idea that these front range folks in Denver and Boulder mandated wolves on ranches. And so it plays on other, I guess, existing insecurities. It's a little different here in California because the wolves in California weren't released. They walked

Speaker 2in on their own feet. Although a popular conspiracy theory that I've heard is that that's not actually true and that some people sneaked the wolves in from Oregon and released them like wolf vigilantes.

Speaker 8Wolf vigilantes.

Speaker 6This should be real.

Speaker 2I know, right? Yeah, please. If you have smuggled a wolf into the state of California, you've done a lot of crimes, but I would love to talk to you for my podcast. I want to address this more... in my podcast, Natural Causes, because I think a lot of people are wrong about wolves. I think it's silly to say that we shouldn't have wolves. I think it's also frustrating for people to think that the reason that we have wolves is to fix our fuck-ups. Wolves have a right to be there because they've always been there and they belong there. They're not there to undo the damage

Speaker 2done by capitalism and the state to the land. And we shouldn't tie the justification for reintroducing them to that Because sometimes the science will not support that, and then we will lose that justification. They have a right to be there because they belong there. That can be the start and the end of it, and I think it should be. And I think we should be expecting the wolves to do our dirty work, undo our dirty work. I'm a little confused about what Trump is exactly saying here, because he also wants a, quote, a legislative recommendation to fully delist or downlist the gray wolf and the Mexican wolf under the ESA. There are not many Mexican wolves.

Speaker 2I think there are fewer than 400.

Speaker 11Cheers.

Speaker 2Yeah, there are like 320-ish in those sort of southwestern and southern states, and then probably 50 in Mexico. We spoke about a prosecution for killing Mexican wolves a few months ago that I found in a New Mexico court in court records, right? But it seems very unlikely that they will meet the recovery guidelines set up under the ESA, but I admittedly have not looked in those recently. I want to move on to something that's even more depressing, the lifeboat protests in the UK. So this week, and

Speaker 2really this month, has seen a series of really disgusting protests and attacks on lifeboats in the UK. This includes fascist Daniel Thomas. He goes by Danny Tomo, really great nom de guerre, which disguised his identity very well, stabbing a lifeboat. For those not familiar with this, the discourse here is related to the mission of the RNLI, which is to rescue those in peril on the sea. The lifeboats were, I guess, at least during the time when I was growing up, a foundational British institution. They are funded by the people, not the state. They are literally

Speaker 2in the book Mutual Aid, like capital M, capital A, Mutual Aid. They also used to celebrate Kropotkin's birthday, the RNLI. You can go back if their Twitter page still exists and see them posting things about his birthday. There's a very good piece called Lifeboats and Anarchy in the RNLI magazine that people should read. They want to know more about that. When I was a child, there was a very popular book way back when, right, when there were only four TV channels, there was a very popular children's TV program and children who watched the program would hold fundraisers for the lifeboats every year. And this was like

Speaker 2a completely foundational thing that everybody thought was good, right? All they do is rescue people who are in danger of drowning. It's mostly a volunteer institution. I've had friends and colleagues who I've worked with who have volunteered on the lifeboats. It is a dangerous, stressful, and often thankless job. that you can't plan or schedule for, right? When someone needs help, you have to go and help them immediately. You have to stop what you're doing, work away from work, walk away from whatever you're doing socially, walk away from your family and go risk your life to help people.

Speaker 2And that's all they do.

Speaker 4Why are they stabbing the boats then?

Speaker 2So I guess.

Speaker 4I mean, fascist going to fascist. What's the source of these protests?

Speaker 2Specifically, it is the idea that the lifeboats are bringing people seeking asylum to communities who cannot support them.

Speaker 4Okay.

Speaker 2You see the same shit that you see everywhere in the world, right? Like I saw a BBC interview with someone who was like, we've got homeless people here. And I would be prepared to wager a large amount of money that that person has done the square root of fuck all to help homeless people in the last few years, right? But now is suddenly concerned because apparently they have to compete for scarce resources with asylum seekers rather than the fucking royal family. In this case, there was a protest in Gosport where we saw crowds of people led by a child chanting, let them drown.

Speaker 1I was about to ask if this was the same protest.

Speaker 2Yeah. One can understand a child who isn't fully formed in the brain saying shit like that, I guess.

Speaker 1It's not their fault.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2For a child to be raised in a place with that much hate is fucking disgusting. And for a grown adult to be joining in and encouraging that behavior is fucking appalling. Thomas has pulled this shit a few times, but obviously this was the worst. What they're trying to do, I guess, is boats have been leaving from Cherbourg, so on the west side of France, because of increased police presence in Dunkirk and those areas where you would go

Speaker 2to Dover, where there's a shorter channel crossing. And so the lifeboats being dispatched are coming probably from, I'm not exactly sure, maybe the Isle of Wight, I think. They are taking them to the UK mainland via the shortest route. If the lifeboats took those people who they rescued to Dover, that would take probably half a dozen hours. At that point, the lifeboat is then out of its area of operation. If anybody else is in distress on the sea, that lifeboat can't respond. It's a good example of how this bigotry hurts everyone. They've been doing this for a while.

Speaker 2I actually made a podcast a couple of years ago with Professor Ruth Kinner about lifeboats and mutual aid. But to see this many people going after something that was so foundational to the culture in the United Kingdom not so long ago, like when I was a kid, because they'd been whipped up into thinking that they have to compete for resources with asylum seekers rather than the only dangerous minority being the rich. It makes me really sad and it makes me really angry. And there is something

Speaker 2so fucking broken about a crowd of people chanting, let them drown. And I'm proud of all my friends who continue to volunteer for the RNLI. I really want to go back home and do a series on it because I know a lot of people who are lifeboatmen. And I think what they do is incredible. And it's the answer to the question that everyone always has about anarchism, like who will put out the fires without the state? The same people who fucking rescue thousands of people a year from the sea, right? The RNLI is funded by

Speaker 2donations and through people's wills. the money doesn't come from your taxes. The money doesn't come from the state. I've pointed to them for so long, like both when I'm teaching and in conversations. And like, I think that's something we should be really proud of. And it's disgusting to me that people are doing this shit. Talking of disgusting, do you want to talk about Trump's speech at the UN?

Speaker 4I think we should probably talk about the advertisers that support our podcast first.

Speaker 2Hopefully it's the lifeboats we can donate.

Speaker 4I don't think it's going to be the lifeboats.

Speaker 2I don't think they advertise on podcasts.

Speaker 4That would be cool.

Speaker 2All right, we're back. And now we're traveling from the United Kingdom to New York to talk about the United Nations General Assembly, where Donald Trump used the platform he had to make comments that sounded straight up genocidal.

Speaker 8But I have a big decision to make.

Speaker 11Will a deal be made with Iran that lets them rebuild and create a far greater country than it ever was before, maybe one of the greatest in the Middle East or even the world? Or do I annihilate the Islamic Republic and do it quickly, never giving them a chance to kill and destroy people and countries again? Do I drive them into hell with no chance of survival and no hope of future greatness or generations?

Speaker 8But I believe we'll.

Speaker 11Make a deal right after the election because it doesn't make sense for them not to.

Speaker 2This is fucking great, right? Oh my God. To go from like, don't worry, I'll genocide them all to vote for me, please.

Speaker 4Only a deal after the election.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 1It's like, I got to see what happens.

Speaker 2Right, yeah, we've got to keep him in just so we see how this goes. It's the fucking UN. Like, it was found... And admittedly, he has failed, right? But it was founded as the idea that if we could all get together and talk it out, we wouldn't have genocides. And there he is, just fucking... Like, as I said, the UN... manifestly failed in that regard and many others.

Speaker 4It still sucks.

Speaker 2Yeah. It's still fucking bonkers.

Speaker 4It's super easy to like, you know, poo poo on the UN because it's the UN, but I mean.

Speaker 1It's what we have. It's what we have.

Speaker 8Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2It's, it's a tool that we have and like, yeah. Uh, he then went on to talk about the midterms. Uh, this is like another 30 seconds. Let's listen to this.

Speaker 11They're waiting to see how I do in the midterm election. What they don't realize is that I'm not running. I did that already and won in a landslide.

Speaker 8We won in a giant landslide.

Speaker 11And I'll be here for two and a half years.

Speaker 8The Republican Party is running.

Speaker 6And I'll be helping them.

Speaker 1But I am not running.

Speaker 11I gave absolutely no credence and will not give credence to the election when it comes to Iran. It doesn't even enter my mind.

Speaker 2And then he goes on to say that they don't get a nuclear weapon, of course, right? This is bonkers, right? The idea that Iran is not aware.

Speaker 1He's like, wait, guys, you have to understand, Americans have different elections.

Speaker 2They can't comprehend, right?

Speaker 6Is this the thing where he didn't know this and someone told him? What is happening here?

Speaker 1He's like, they recently told me I am actually not running.

Speaker 2Yeah, I'm good, guys. Clearly, his war on Iran has been extremely unpopular and continues to be extremely unpopular because it costs six bucks to buy a gallon of gas now. Even if people don't care about the massive human toll of this, they do care about that.

Speaker 6Which I do also want to say for the record that this war was unpopular before the gas prices increased. It's made it more unpopular, but no one has ever liked this war and it just gets more unpopular every day.

Speaker 4Yeah. it's part of why he's, I guess, bringing this, you know, midterm stuff up in like both of these clips here. And I guess he's like, he knows he only has a few months left until the amount of like support he has in Congress will take a pretty big dip.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 4Even if they just lose the House. But I mean, if looking at the polls, if like the Senate's on the line, that's going to put at least some constraints, some checks as opposed to the Zero. I have zero negative checks that have been in Congress for the past two years. It's like he's going to, I assume, plot out all the way up until the time that the next Congress has sworn in, whatever his game plan is.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 2It's wild to see him electioneering this hard at the UN as well.

Speaker 1At the UN.

Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, he does this all the time, right? He goes somewhere and does something that's absolutely the most jarring tone shit from anything that has happened there before. But the way he continues to talk about annihilating Iran.

Speaker 4It's disturbing.

Speaker 2Especially as our conventional weapons resources get lower and lower. It's scary. It's genuinely scary.

Speaker 6That's stuff that you could just play at an ICC trial for genocide.

Speaker 8Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, he spoke about the ICC as well. He critiqued the ICC, or not even critiqued, that's not the right word.

Speaker 6Didn't he call for them all to resign or something?

Speaker 1Something, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, some of them can't even come to the US.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, this was and continues to be bonkers, I guess. It's not surprising in a sense, but it still sucks.

Speaker 6Yeah, it's horrifying.

Speaker 2Dana, I know you had some stuff you wanted to talk about. Do you want to pick up from here?

Speaker 1Yes. So there's a lot of talk about what's going to happen to Gaza, what's going to happen to the Palestinians in the West Bank. I just did an It Could Happen Here episode on the way the Israeli state and the Israeli settler movement are working together to ethnically cleanse the West Bank, but how we should distinguish between the two.

Speaker 8Anyway.

Speaker 1The way that international actors, particularly the United States, have behaved is to kind of audaciously sideline the Palestinians. Like they don't even pretend to include them or consider them. So the Board of Peace, for example, doesn't have any Palestinian decision makers. There are only technocrats who are essentially supposed to just take commands from the Board of Peace. So there's really like no space in the discussion for Palestinian agency. But I think international actors, governments in the EU, but even some in Washington kind of thinking medium to long term about after Trump, they understand that this doesn't

Speaker 1look great and that at some point they'll have to make a big display of getting Palestinians to sign some grand peace deal with the Israelis. And you need some group of Palestinians to do that.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1So the Palestinian Authority that governs the West Bank is is led by President Mahmoud Abbas, as I'm sure many know, who has overstayed his term limits for many, many years. He's also the chairman of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, the PLO. And Palestinians are very unhappy with this setup. Basically, the polls show that they think it lacks legitimacy and that he lacks legitimacy. So the international community has essentially been getting to work to kind of paper over this issue.

Speaker 1So last year, they pressured Abbas to find a successor because he's so old, they're afraid he's going to keel over. And he unilaterally changed the bylaws of the PLO outside normal institutional procedures to create a vice president position. And he appointed someone to that position from the PLO executive committee. The dude he picked, Hossein al-Sheikh, polls at 2% with Palestinians. So they're already setting up for what comes after Abbas. And now they're working on PLO changes that would, again, on the surface, look like an institution renewing its legitimacy.

Speaker 1So part of that, this is ongoing right now, is having the legislative body of the PLO, the Palestinian National Council, actually hold elections. So I'm going to quote here from the European Council on Foreign Relations. The PNC is responsible for formulating the PLO's policies. It acts as a parliament that represents all Palestinians except for Palestinian citizens of Israel. The PNC currently comprises 747 members representing Palestinians in Palestine and in the diaspora. But because the PNC has had such difficulty convening and all of these things, there are

Speaker 1other bodies that like bridge between the legislative and the executive, like the central council. And over the years, the PNC has basically lost any power, even though it's supposed to be the legislative body. It's supposed to be kind of the democratic engine of the PLO. So in February, 2026, so February of this year, Abbas issued a decree saying that there would be PNC elections in November and that this would include basically trying to make it so that all eligible Palestinians that can like feasibly vote directly living

Speaker 1in the diaspora, or if that's not possible, kind of through an electoral college process in different diasporas or via quote unquote consensus. So the PLO, the PA, which at this point overlap, they've been going around different communities, different Palestinian diaspora communities, and setting up so that these different communities run people for these elections. But the way they're doing it is extremely undemocratic. They are not thinking about,

Speaker 1you know, who are we going to tap that actually represents some constituency in these diasporas? Or are they actually representative of these diasporas? They're just getting yes-men in a lot of cases. Some members of the central council basically found out that they had been removed after reading it in the media. So it's completely undemocratic. The Palestinian diaspora in Chile, for example, they've tapped a particular organization, but that organization gets to run the elections. And other organizations in the Palestinian diaspora in Chile have to jump through

Speaker 1a lot more hoops. to be able to run in the same elections. So to me, it feels like a grand conspiracy against Palestinians to pretend like these PNC elections are actually legitimate. In reality, really disempowering huge swaths of the Palestinian diaspora. He also announced in that decree that he's going to half the numbers of the PNC from 747 to 350. So essentially one seat allocated for every 35,000 Palestinians is like the idea. But yeah, it's not great.

Speaker 1And I think that we should really, you know, focus on what's happening here because the Palestinians are being set up in so many ways for a very bleak near-term future. I feel like I've stunned all of you with the silence.

Speaker 6Well, it's so bleak. They're just like, how openly they're just kind of rigging the elections.

Speaker 2It's like.

Speaker 4I don't know.

Speaker 6It reminds me of like more expansive version of the way that like the CCP does elections for like there's like nominal elections for all of their party official offices where they do like a very similar process of like, yeah, we've we've like put forward one candidate who is like our person. You're all going to vote for them or you're going to vote for one of the like allied parties or something.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 1No, it's completely like. minimized as a process yeah i mean i haven't even gotten into like the local elections that have happened in the occupied territories and how kind of problematic some of those have been but just on every level like even when they're pretending at democracy like yeah it's not happening you know so yeah.

Speaker 6And then like in like in the same like ccp structure thing you have like this big assembly that does nothing and then there's like executive bodies that have been carefully chosen from their loyalists outside of that that like do all the things yeah.

Speaker 1Exactly no no that's that's a good comparison Yeah. So the second thing I wanted to just very briefly touch on is the issue of Palestine and higher ed. I think like because there haven't been the, you know, massive protests. widespread protests that we saw a year or two years ago. This maybe has dropped from the radar, but it continues to, you know, those protests on campuses continue to have ramifications for higher ed and for a lot of the people who participated. So two cases I wanted to just mention briefly is that at Stanford University, a number of students

Speaker 1were criminally prosecuted for protesting on their campus. And for some of them, that involved occupying the president's office. and demanding divestment and things like this. But the charges have all been dropped against those students. The Santa Clara County District Attorney that was assigned to this case, who was seeking criminal prosecution, was using the case to solicit donations for his re-election, saying he was tough on anti-Semitism.

Speaker 2Jesus Christ.

Speaker 1Jesus.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 1So the judge was like, hey, I think this is probably, you're probably too biased for this. So he like asked him to be removed from the case. And then eventually, as I said, the charges were dropped and the students like have to pay a small sum and like do some community service. But the idea is like all of these cases, whether at Stanford or other places, they were used to deter further protest for sure. And then the second case I wanted to mention is maybe people remember

Speaker 1three Palestinian students, one from Brown University, one from Haverford College, and one from Trinity College, were shot for wearing keffiyehs on the street in Vermont maybe two years ago. All three of them were wounded and one was paralyzed. So the guy who shot them, Jason Eaton... Faces up to life in prison. And despite the fact that that guy had claimed that the U.S. and Israeli intelligence agencies had transmitted orders to him to shoot the students via FM radio, and that God had commanded him to protect his Jewish neighbors,

Speaker 1no hate crime charges were filed. So I think that that is quite telling.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 1But, um... Nevertheless, one of the student's mothers, the student Hisham Awarthani, was the one who was paralyzed. His mother, Elizabeth Price, spoke to the media after the verdict and said, justice has been rendered for Hisham Kinan and Tahseen. After three years of sorrow, loss, and struggle, our families finally feel relief. We are grateful our son's suffering commanded attention and support. We grieve so much that Palestinian suffering never does. So I just wanted to update about that case as well. I'm not sure it's a happy update, but some semblance

Speaker 1of Repercussion.

Speaker 2Yeah, damn. Yeah. I guess we got another shooting because this is America.

Speaker 8I hate this country.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2I know this one's fucked up. Ice agents in Texas shot a man in the back last week. Wilbert Rafael Garces Perez. He's a migrant from Venezuela. He was shot in the back. He appears to be in stable condition now. We've seen a number of different videos. the videos of the shooting are not entirely clear of like the rundown events they ice claimed he's running away from them video doesn't seem to show that we have seen video of ice agents cuffing him and appears that they're doing that before rendering aid You could see a couple of agents

Speaker 2putting cuffs on him and another guy who apparently is struggling to put on latex, actually non-latex, but protective gloves. Wilbur, like many Venezuelans, came to the USA to help his family. I've heard this story a hundred times and I've met this family, not this family, but a family doing exactly the same thing a hundred times. He has a son with disabilities that he will probably either struggle to pay for or cannot be accommodated easily in Venezuela. And so his dad came here to work to fund his treatment. At the time that he was shot, he was delivering DoorDash,

Speaker 2super common employment for people becoming care-seeking asylum, right? His family attorney, Kate Lincoln Goldfinch, has been documenting the events after his shooting on Instagram, beginning with a post where she says she was at the hospital with Wilbur's wife, and they are trying to get into the hospital to see her husband, who had called her and said he had been shot, and then the phone cut off. So evidently, she's distressed, right? And the security at the hospital are

Speaker 2denying that he is there and asking the attorney and Wilbur's wife to leave. She is then informed by a congressperson that he is present at that hospital, but that the hospital's policy is not to disclose when someone's there in ICE detention. I've done a lot of, like, I haven't put much out on like hospitals and ICE detention. I have done a lot of interviews about that. It's something I want to kind of get my arms around fully before I put something out because I think I've also done a lot of responding to times when migrants

Speaker 2are in medical crisis and are afraid to get medical care and I think that there are really serious repercussions to suggesting that ICE is going room to room in hospitals or in EDs taking people. I'm not aware of them ever doing that and I just want to like Make that very clear for people whenever we get to this topic, because it kills people to not seek medical care too. We need to hold those two things at the same time. In this case, I guess Austin's mayor showed up and got them confirmation that he was stable and had been released into an ICE detention center. His

Speaker 2attorney then held a presser, which Wilbur attended remotely by calling in from detention. There are different ways people can call in different detention centers. I think he had some kind of tablet device. In this conference, he said he was in serious pain and that he had not been receiving adequate mental care and the ICE agents had not identified themselves before ramming his car. His lawyer later said that after this press conference, as a retaliatory measure, he was held in isolation and had his communication device taken away.

Speaker 2He was also removed from the infirmary in apparent retaliation for this presser and placed in isolation. He is now, according to Congressman Joaquin Castro... been returned to hospital to get better care. According to his lawyer, the agent who shot him was hired last year and either didn't have or didn't activate the body cam. A judge has ruled that Wilbur will appear in person for an immigration hearing on the 30th of September. So that would mean that he can't be removed before then, right? He'd previously been

Speaker 2ordered removed in absentia because he had missed a hearing. His lawyer says he had moved house and didn't get that document. ICE then proceeded to release this press release, effectively directly addressing the Instagram posts of his lawyer. And they claimed they were going to, quote, correct the record, unquote. with a number of lies. It was set up the way that you might write a document if you didn't know what a paragraph was.

Speaker 4The Axios style of writing.

Speaker 6Yes, yes.

Speaker 2Perfect, Garrison. Yes, that's correct. It used the Axios house style here. Yeah, an outlet that thinks you're too dumb to read two sentences consecutively. So it's set up in a claim fact format.

Speaker 4Oh my God.

Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, like... Sometimes I think that there's a moment, like with Jen Psaki, where just like the way press releases are done by the executive branch went off a fucking cliff. The Trump administration has like gone from like slight downhill to like free fall at this point. But throughout this, they don't refer to him by his name. They refer to him as the illegal alien.

Speaker 4It's very common in all of their communications.

Speaker 2Yeah, this shit really, like literally yesterday, my friends and I erected a memorial to a migrant who had died and then put their name on it, right? And I not giving people names really fucking makes me mad. Claim the illegal alien is here legally. Fact. I'm obviously quoting from their presser here. This is false. The person is in the US illegally. He entered illegally under the Biden administration. The illegal alien had no valid work permit, had no protective status, and had a final order of removal from a Department of Justice immigration judge. This is not correct.

Speaker 2He entered under CBP1, right? Like, To enter under CBP1 was a massive and significant burden to migrants in the Biden administration. People I know have died waiting for a CBP1 appointment, and not a small.

Speaker 8Number of people.

Speaker 2To comply with the requirements of CBP1 was to jump through every hoop that was placed in front of you at great personal risk. It was... safer for people not to remain in Mexico and to enter without inspection. He didn't do that. He got an appointment at CBP1, went to a border crossing, he spoke to numerous DHS personnel, and he was allowed into the country. CBP1 gave people a year of humanitarian parole. Trump tried to cancel that, but in March this year, a federal judge overturned him

Speaker 2canceling that, says you can't just like broad swath cancel parole like that. I've included an explainer For people who need to or would like to understand that more, it'll be in the notes.

Speaker 4Is that the welcome.rescue.org link?

Speaker 2Yes, yeah. This press release was just so annoying, right? Just repeating all these talking points that they have, right? CBP1, if you don't know, was founded by the first Trump administration. This is a thing that they made. They've since tried to retcon that, but I mean, they did it. It was used by the Biden administration as a de facto gating mechanism for migrants, right? It was a way of reducing the number of people who could come and apply for asylum. That is why people ended up eweing, right? Entering without inspection because there was no other way. A

Speaker 2large number of CBP1 appointments went to Russian speaking people, generally because those people who had come were wealthier. They could get hotels. They'd get hotels in Tijuana with Wi-Fi and they'd make the applications, right?

Speaker 8The.

Speaker 2The application did not work on previous generation Android telephones. And those are the telephones that the vast number of people coming to Seek Asylum will have, especially... I literally heard from a friend today who I met in the Darien Gap on, I think, her fifth phone number, because people's phones just get stolen from them constantly. It's the most reliable item of value that most people have, so it's the easiest thing to steal. And so they end up with When you turn your phone in to get an upgrade, it gets sold in different parts of the

Speaker 2world where people don't have as much income for technology stuff. So they end up with previous generation phones. The app didn't work on those phones. The facial liveness scanner of CBP1, let's say I'm booking an appointment for dinner, that it's actually dinner making the appointment and not me holding up a life-size cardboard cutout of dinner in front of the camera. So you have to go like that. It simply didn't work for black faces. I know there were NGOs in Tijuana, for instance, who had spent so much money on light rooms,

Speaker 2to try and make it work for people. Jesus Christ. Yeah, this act was horrific. And he went through all the fucking hurdles, and they're still just going to call him... They're still just going to lie about it, right? I think this is a particularly heinous example of how fucked our immigration system is. Yeah, I'll keep up on this. As far as we know, he's now in a hospital. I hope he's receiving better care than he would under a nice detention.

Speaker 4Let's go on one more ad break, and then we have a few more stories before we end this episode.

Speaker 6Okay, we are back on.

Speaker 4Friday afternoon, President Trump announced he was, quote, banning three news outlets, CNN, MSNBC, and Politico from the White House, quote, effective immediately as a result of their constant reporting fake news. Media outlets shouldn't be able to constantly write or report fiction and lies when they're covering the president of the United States. the Trump administration or the United States of America, other fake news media outlets to follow, unquote. Obviously not

Speaker 4good when the president says that outlets shouldn't be allowed to write or report. Only there was an amendment of the constitution. But it was at first kind of unclear what this ban meant exactly. Though at a press conference following Trump's announcement on Truth Social, He referred to this as a, quote, ban on the free press.

Speaker 6What? Wait, he just said that?

Speaker 11Yes.

Speaker 6Oh, I missed this.

Speaker 1What?

Speaker 2Let's get a video. That's fucking great.

Speaker 4Why not?

Speaker 1What does that mean in practice?

Speaker 14Are you taking away their badges? Are you banning them from the pool?

Speaker 2Are you banning them from the office?

Speaker 3What does that mean?

Speaker 1I still don't know what that means.

Speaker 2Oh, the ban on the free press, right?

Speaker 6Very simple ban.

Speaker 8I don't want him in my office.

Speaker 6I don't want him here.

Speaker 11I would say the ban would go as far as you can.

Speaker 1He's like, you know that thing we have an amendment about? Yeah.

Speaker 2Maybe he was referring to capital F, capital P, the Barry Weiss outlet that does transfer media.

Speaker 4I don't think he's talking about banning Barry Weiss's The Free Press.

Speaker 6It's so cool that we had an entire movement that was nominally about free speech and the result of it was... Like, white CEOs should be able to say the N-word, but also the president should be allowed to ban the free press from talking to him?

Speaker 4Hey, and the R-word.

Speaker 6There's so many slurs they want to be able to say.

Speaker 4So Trump told reporters in the Oval Office, quote, something is wrong with a country that can allow people to write purposefully negative stories. If they want to write them, that's fine. I don't have to let them into the people's house. Going on to say, like he started in that clip, I don't want them in my office. I don't want them here. I would say the ban would go as far as you can. And if they could straighten themselves out, I'd love it, unquote, suggesting he could lift the ban if outlets, quote, straighten themselves out, meaning

Speaker 4write the news in a different way. Someone asked Trump how this would relate to a then upcoming visit with President Xi. And I'll just play the clip.

Speaker 6You've got President Xi coming next week.

Speaker 1China is one of the most repressive countries for journalists in the world.

Speaker 9What signal does it send?

Speaker 11I don't know about that. I think we're repressive also.

Speaker 1We get fake news. We don't repress, but they write fake news. Jeez.

Speaker 2Oh, he was on a sick one.

Speaker 6This whole time I was thinking about there was a story like this week about a trial of some media organization in Hong Kong where the judge is talking about how you shouldn't be able to publish opinions that are like, I think the quote was like factually incorrect opinions because they were like negative about the regime. And then Trump's like, no, fuck that. We're banning the free press. We're going to out repress the CCP. I'm like, this is great. This is great. I love I love being a Chinese American. Such a good time.

Speaker 4This clip is really funny because he says we're repressive too but then he pivots and talks about fake news and then goes on to say like well we don't like actually repress but we do have fake news and like kind of equivocating fake news to repression in China is kind of what he turns that into but then he just banned the press perhaps after catching what he said but like yeah it's not it was a really odd press conference as you can imagine yes The banning the free press press conference.

Speaker 1His honesty is always refreshing.

Speaker 10Wild.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4So over the weekend, reporters from those three outlets were denied access to the White House grounds, with journalists' hard-pass credentials apparently being deactivated overnight. Then on Monday, the affected outlets filed a lawsuit against Trump and White House staff. The suit claims it's, quote, clear that the ban was motivated by Trump's disdain for reporting he considers, quote, one-sided and, quote, never good because it, quote, diminishes him and his accomplishments. This ban could not be a more direct assault on

Speaker 4the First Amendment nor a more blatant violation of our most fundamental constitutional principles, unquote. Also on Monday, ABC News, CBS News, NBC, and Fox reported The four TV news poolers, besides CNN, released a joint statement in support of CNN, who was supposed to be the designated TV pool provider for that day at the White House. The statement reads, the public has a vital interest in receiving accurate independent

Speaker 4information about its government. No administration should restrict a news organization because it objects to its reporting. These networks announced a solidarity blackout of White House pool coverage. With Fox News' Washington bureau chief and the current White House TV pool chair emailing the other networks on Monday, quote, This is to advise that, effective today, the TV pool will not be covering events designated as pool coverage of the president. This follows the White House's position preventing CNN from fulfilling

Speaker 4its assigned pool duties. There will be no replacement pool put in place. And later on Monday, this did affect their ability to report on White House events as Newsmax struggled to hear the president during a ribbon-cutting ceremony.

Speaker 1OK, so there is.

Speaker 12No microphone because there's no microphone because the pool cameras aren't there. So maybe, Tim, this is one example of it backfiring just a little bit. Pick up on some of the things Michael was saying. And obviously the ramifications are right here. Can't hear what the president's saying.

Speaker 4Indeed, you cannot hear what the president is saying.

Speaker 2Backfired a little bit.

Speaker 6Backfired a little bit.

Speaker 4A little bit. A little bit, it seems.

Speaker 2Well, they don't want to get the old press credential taken away. They got to be careful.

Speaker 4To me, it's unclear how long this blackout will last and how isolated it is, because obviously there was coverage of Trump at the UN, although outlets said that that was because the UN provides those credentials. So it's unclear if this is supposed to be targeted specifically at the White House pool. We'll get a better idea in the next few days as Trump returns to the White House. But not, you know, good for as Trump says, the free press.

Speaker 8No!

Speaker 4Another thing not great. Last Thursday, September 17th, the FCC approved Paramount's petition to allow almost 50% of the potentially merged Paramount WB equity to be owned by Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE following this potential Warner Brothers merger. Meaning the Ellisons, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Abu Dhabi would end up owning CBS, CNN, HBO, Discovery Channel, BET, Fandango, MTV, Nickelodeon, Paramount,

Speaker 4Pluto TV, Showtime, TBS, The CW, TNT, and Warner Brothers. Now, thankfully, 12 state AGs have sued to block this $ 110 billion Paramount-Warner Brothers merger since it obviously endangers competition and threatens editorial independence of even more news outlets. Though, after Paramount threatened to leave California last week, State Attorney General Rob Bonta,

Speaker 4who was leading the state coalition's antitrust case, caved on Monday and agreed to settle their lawsuit, essentially giving this merger the final green light.

Speaker 2California Democrat moment.

Speaker 4This is really bad.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 4A list of this settlement's, quote, court-enforceable concessions, which largely amounts to Paramount promising to release around 30 movies a year for the next five years. Only for the next five years, by the way. Or else they will face penalties and be required to divest Miramax Studios. Again, this requirement only is until 2031, roughly.

Speaker 2Also, that's what you're going to fight for? 30 Paramount movies a year? That's the big thing here?

Speaker 4Some of the other concessions include a $ 47. 5 million fund for workers, quote, displaced by the merger, and an annual $ 5 million fund to support independent film. We did it, Rob.

Speaker 6We did it, Gavin.

Speaker 4We got it. $ 5 million a year for independent film.

Speaker 6Thanks, Gav.

Speaker 4Now, California also announced a, quote, News Editorial Independence Board to help CNN and CBS maintain editorial independence. So, you know, worries, no need, no need to be worried about this. This will be fine. But if you actually read the documents establishing this board, I'll read this here. The Editorial Independence Board should be made up of five established journalists, active or retired, each of whom shall have practiced journalism for

Speaker 4a minimum of 10 years. No more than two editorial board members may be affiliated with the same political party. Editorial Independence Board members shall be appointed by the Combined Entities Board of Directors. Who do you think is the chair of Paramount's Board of Directors?

Speaker 6Wild guess. Larry Ellison?

Speaker 4David Ellison.

Speaker 6David Ellison, sure.

Speaker 2Oh, right, yeah, just kidding.

Speaker 8Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2I love that they can't be from the same political party, right? So you're going to get two Dems, you're going to get two Republicans, then you've got a wild card in there. And there is a kind of person who is a California journalist who is a member of the Libertarian Party, and they are the worst kind of person. And you know one of them is going to fucking end up in there. I love to live in a free society. Making things worse, Semaphore reported today that Paramount is weighing tapping one Elon Musk for equity investment as well. I did read that.

Speaker 1Physically painful.

Speaker 4So both Ellison and Musk could end up appointing people to this editorial independence board.

Speaker 1They love freedom.

Speaker 6Also, the other investors are like the Saudi government and the UAE's sovereign wealth funds. Part of it, right?

Speaker 4Part of that deal is allegedly making sure that they don't have voting power. even though they own the shares.

Speaker 6Sure.

Speaker 4We'll see how that works.

Speaker 1Honestly, I would bet on the Saudis more than I would bet on Musk. Like, give them voting power.

Speaker 4That's a dark timeline.

Speaker 1No, no, I'm just kidding.

Speaker 2We'll get a great comedy festival out of it.

Speaker 6Until we have proof that Elon Musk has deployed Sudanese child soldiers in Yemen.

Speaker 1Okay, okay, okay.

Speaker 6I don't know.

Speaker 1No, no, I didn't say the UAE. Let's distinguish.

Speaker 4That is true.

Speaker 6The Saudis also were involved in that. Not letting them off the hook.

Speaker 1You're right, you're right, you're right. I retract it.

Speaker 2You know exactly what kind of press freedoms Elon Musk is going to go for as well. Like, oh God.

Speaker 4But no, this is a massive failure specifically on executives in California. between the governor, Newsom, and the state AG. The fact that they caved on this due to the threat of Paramount moving to a different state puts the whole country in jeopardy.

Speaker 2People really need to wise up to what Newsom's doing right now. He's very clearly signaling that he will be friendly to capital before he makes his presidential run. He did it with the wildfire settlements in California. He's doing it with this. He is showing that he is going to be everything that Democrats have disappointed you with for the last 4, 8, 12 years. I despise what Newsom is doing right now.

Speaker 4The other thing in the fine print of these concessions is the force majeure clause that allows the combined entity to get out of all these concessions in situations of, quote, War, rebellion, hurricanes, other major storms, earthquakes, fires, terrorism, pandemics, strikes, labor disruptions, economic recessions, riots, insurrections, civil commotions, blockades.

Speaker 8Jesus Christ.

Speaker 4So in the case of the AI bubble bursting, they can get out of all of these concessions that the state AG of California is claiming as their big victory. Of course, also strikes and labor disruptions included in there as well.

Speaker 2What's a civil commotion?

Speaker 1A little shenanigans.

Speaker 6James, it's what happens when I walk down the street. It's a civil commotion.

Speaker 2That is a spiritually British phrase.

Speaker 1What legal basis is this?

Speaker 2I'm going to hit us up if you've been convicted of civil commotion.

Speaker 4One final note on this, also on Monday, the Writers Guild of America settled their own lawsuit filed this past summer on the grounds that this merger violates antitrust and would cause specific harm to workers. In terms of concessions that the WGA was able to achieve, they got Paramount to agree to a layoff prohibition for five years for CBS News broadcast members and got Paramount to agree to pay $ 17. 5 million to the Writers Guild Health Fund and cover their attorney's fees from the litigation. to quote the

Speaker 4WGA statement, quote, Unfortunately, the conditions Paramount has committed to with the AGs and with us fall far short of adequately protecting writers, and we continue to believe the merger will cause damage to the industry at large. As labor unions, however, the AGs' settlement means that we had to contend with the reality of forging ahead alone with a lawsuit that would cost millions of dollars through trial, unquote. Quick update here. On Thursday, a California judge delayed the court sign-off of

Speaker 4this settlement for at least another week by granting an administrative motion by a coalition to block the merger. This settlement to complete the merger does require a sign-off from this judge. The parties have till Monday. The next hearing to go over the settlement is expected to be on Tuesday.

Speaker 6You know, rolling it back a couple seconds, speaking of spiritually British, let's talk about Canada in our final section.

Speaker 2Hey, that is a burn.

Speaker 6It's a good one.

Speaker 8It's a good one.

Speaker 6So, okay, last Wednesday, September 16th, EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen proposed that Canada become the only, quote, associate member of the EU?

Speaker 4Hell yeah.

Speaker 2Nice.

Speaker 8So.

Speaker 6This was obviously, well, I say obviously, this was the day before Carney spoke in front of the European Parliament, was receptive to the offer, and it seems like this is something that's going to get voted on by the Parliament. Later on in this sort of trip, he met with the leaders of France and England and spent a lot of time talking about strengthening ties with European nations. It was also, I don't know if revealed the right term, but there was... The whole process of this was very weird,

Speaker 6but basically it was, it was, it was like got to the press that Canada had asked to join the, it's called the joint expeditionary force, which is this sort of like British led like military alliance project. I'm just going to quote from CBC here, quote, as it was originally conceived, the joint expeditionary force was meant to preserve battlefield relations that grew up during the Afghan war. So we're off to it. great start here. In 2012, Britain's

Speaker 6then chief of defense, General Sir David Richards, described a future force that could deploy rapidly overseas without Britain having to assemble an entirely new coalition for every crisis. So, again, originally this is a kind of, they want to be able to kind of build on the military integration of the war in Afghanistan, which, I don't know, very few wars in which I want to less build on military integration from. In recent times, it has been more that the sort of coalition existence and prominence has been more

Speaker 6about its potential response to continued Russian aggression in Europe. So all of this basically dropped at the same time last week. Trump responded to the whole thing about Canada becoming an associate member of the EU by saying it would be a, quote, hostile act. He also said, quote, if it's a good intention, that's fine. If it's bad intention, we'll put very heavy tariffs on Europe. So who knows

Speaker 6with that?

Speaker 8I don't know.

Speaker 6Genuinely, who knows what's going to happen with that situation? I don't know.

Speaker 2Maybe we can negotiate a swap now that Britain has left Europe and Britain could join NAFTA.

Speaker 6Yeah, can we physically swap the countries and put Canada over Britain?

Speaker 2Sure. At least they wouldn't have as much fucking coastline to be bastards about back home. Probably more coastline in Canada just because it's vast.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 6So, OK, we really know very little about what Trump's response is going to be to this. Now, the part that I actually am interested in here is what does this associate membership thing actually mean? And what is this actual partnership supposed to look like? So we talked a little bit. Obviously, there's some military integration. Most of it seems to be trade alliances. And even that is kind of vague. What you get out of it looking into this is that the rhetoric coming out of both the

Speaker 6EU and Canada is extremely loud. They're talking about the crisis of democratic institutions and the rule of law globally.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 6All of this sort of stuff. But there was a really interesting thing. interview in foreign policy with Canada's foreign minister, Anita Anand, about what actually, under the surface of this sort of grand rhetoric about forming this sort of coalition and promoting the rule of law and being a non-coercive body and all of this sort of very grand rhetoric that is in response to Trump without really mentioning him, There's a lot of really interesting parts of this interview

Speaker 6with Canada's foreign minister about what they're actually talking about doing. I think maybe the first thing that she gets asked is Trump saying, quote, we don't need Canada.

Speaker 2They need us.

Speaker 6And the response is very interesting because what she's doing is deemphasizing an actual break with the U.S.

Speaker 2Economically.

Speaker 6Which is what all of the reporting on this, everyone is talking about how like, oh, this is like Canada trying to pivot away from the US. And her response to this is like, well, no, the US and Canada are just permanently economically integrated. The auto sector is this, you know, like sign of permanent integration between the economies.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 6And largely the focus of her response is that, oh, we have a bunch of free trade pacts with a bunch of other parts of the world and, you know, between the US and Canada.

Speaker 8So.

Speaker 6This is kind of a sign of like when these people are talking about sort of a rules-based international order, what they're talking about is free trade pacts. I'm going to read this quote from the interview. So the first part of this, the question is from the foreign policy interviewer quote. So let me talk a little bit then about the canada europe relationship i hear the phrase associate member being used a week ago what would that entail what does that mean and then this is uh the canadian foreign minister the nomenclature that is being attached the growing relationship between canada and the eu is not the

Speaker 6focus of the work we're doing building up to the canada eu summit in montreal at the end of october Our focus is on several pillars where you will see deeper integration on critical minerals, AI and quantum, trade and investments following on from the Canada-EU comprehensive economic and trade agreements and people-to-people ties, including education students and the Erasmus program. The substantive discussions between our teams right now are very focused on these pillars. So this is the actual, right?

Speaker 6It missed everyone talking about how like we're going to form like a new trade block to.

Speaker 8Like fight the US.

Speaker 4It's like, no, they're doing free trade negotiations, basically. Yeah, and that's what Carney's been really pushing for. He's essentially just trying to be like Bill Clinton for Canada without that stuff.

Speaker 6Yeah, without that or playing the saxophone. Yeah, slightly more boring.

Speaker 4He's a central banker.

Speaker 6Yeah, yeah. And I'm going to get to that in a second in terms of what they're actually sort of trying to do. But You know, I think the comparison to Clinton is a good one because like what you have here basically is like what this bloc is, is this attempt to form a sort of like old school neoliberal, I say old school, but like 90s, 2000s style neoliberal bloc to oppose the sort of like modern Trump fascism. And it's like, well, okay, so that like got us fascism in the first place, right? So that's not great. There's also a lot of talk about sort of the

Speaker 6defense and support for Ukraine.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 6But I want to have one last quote from this article to really get a sense of what is going on here. This is Anand, the foreign minister. Taking you to the investment summit that we held last week in Toronto, we are seeing increasing levels of foreign direct investment. Commitments of $ 500 billion last week alone to Canada through 10 national projects from ports to highways to airports. Across the board, our work is to shorten the time period, the path to permit time period, so that investments continue to flow

Speaker 6into our country towards national projects. So what does that mean? And this is where things get really, really bad. Because what she's talking about when she's talking about this, like, you know, we're shortening the path to permit time. So investment continues to come in for national projects. What she's talking about is what's called Bill C-39, which is, I guess, like the next version of the Build Canada Strong Act. So, you know, it's a giant neoliberal deregulation bill, right? It decreases the permit process. for a whole bunch of projects

Speaker 6that are in, quote, the national interest from, you know, these can take multiple years if you're talking about environmental impact assessments, you're talking about, like, input from indigenous communities, you're putting, there's a whole bunch of things that you're supposed to have to do before you can start one of these sort of mega projects. And this bill would reduce that entire process to one year. It would allow ministers to just sort of wave away environmental protections if it was deemed in the national interest. I'm going to quote from the Toronto Star here, quote, it would also create special interests zones called regions of national interest, where

Speaker 6approvals for projects can be, quote, streamlined in certain areas, officials said, and follows recent changes. That means cross-border oil pipelines, gas-fired power plants, oil sands facilities, and other projects will no longer be subject to the existing federal impact assessment process. So this is special economic zones for oil fields.

Speaker 2I was about to say they're doing a special economic zone.

Speaker 6Yeah, and specifically, it's special economic zone where all of the environmental impact assessments of like, hey, is this oil field going to poison everyone who lives around it? We're not doing that. I'm going to quote here from the Narwhal. The legislation takes federal review of pipelines, nuclear facilities and power lines out of the hands of the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, a federal body that reports to the environmental minister. and is meant to ensure project designs protect Indigenous rights in the environment. Instead, pipeline projects will be reviewed by the Canada Energy Regulator and Agency of the

Speaker 6Crown that reports to the Energy Minister and oversees construction and operation of certain pipelines and power lines. So, that's a very dull way of saying that instead of environmental regulators looking at the impact of Like, car sands, it's going to the energy guys.

Speaker 4It goes to the executive.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 6And this is something that's been very specifically, like, pushed for in a massive lobbying campaign by the Canadian oil and gas industry over the last, like, few years. So, obviously, this is an enormous danger to Indigenous sovereignty, to, you know, anyone who, like, wants there to be a livable environment. And also, it gives the labor ministry the right to end strikes.

Speaker 8Oh, cool.

Speaker 6So effectively what it does, right, is there is a very nebulous legal authority that the Canadian government used to crush an Air Canada flight attendant strike in 2025. And this bill would just codify that right and completely ignore the union's legal challenges to it and would allow just government ministers effectively to just end strikes if they're in areas that are deemed as like adversely affecting the national interest, I'm going to quote from the MSN article here, either by having a, quote, significant impact on the economy or causing, quote,

Speaker 6serious social disruption. So, you know, it's interesting because the Carney administration has said that this is actually like a protection of the right to strike, even though it's giving a government minister the ability to end strikes. But this bill is being opposed by, you know, by the entire Canadian labor movement because it gives the government the ability to kill strikes on behalf of you know, on behalf of corporations in the name of this extremely nebulous national interest. There's no way that could possibly go wrong. And I

Speaker 6think both of these put together lets you look at the domestic side of this entire sort of PR, international PR push that's going on, right? It's the deployment of neoliberalism nominally against fascism. It is using the threat of the US to crush organized labor, indigenous groups, and environmental groups, which are the same enemies that sort of Trump and the American fascist movements have. It's just that it's being implemented using a sort of state of emergency caused by the fascists themselves.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 6And I think that's something that's incredibly important to keep in mind whenever you're sort of reading about Carney, whenever you're reading about this sort of international project that he's embarking on is that this is what this project means, right? It's a war to be able to do free trade in special economic zones. With that, I think that is all for us today at It Could Happen Here. Denna, do you have anything you would like to plug?

Speaker 1I want to direct people to the handbook of authoritarianism in the Arab world, which I edited, and it's out now, open access on the Bloomsbury Politics website. So if you just Google it, you'll find it. It's got lots of contributors from the MENA region, SWANA, whatever you want to call it.

Speaker 8Cool. Yeah.

Speaker 1Thank you for having me. Yeah.

Speaker 2Thanks for coming. If you'd like to email us, you can do so, coolzontips at proton.me. Some of you fuckers in the marketing world are still not fucking listening to me, so just say again, do not fucking email me about your product or service. I will block you. Don't email me about putting my podcast on YouTube to get more viewers. I don't fucking care. I'm going to block you harder from all of the iHeart emails one day.

Speaker 6Put a trans scroll on your couch.

Speaker 4We've reported the news.

Speaker 10We reported the news.

Speaker 3Hey, we'll be back Monday with more episodes every week from now until the heat death of the universe.

Speaker 14It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com. Or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Part Two: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Robert concludes the story of Pastor Mackenzie's starvation apocalypse church with a really shocking mass murder.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    This week Robert takes us to Kenya, and the deadliest cult since the days of Jonestown. Prepare to meet Pastor Paul Mackenzi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. It Could Happen Here Weekly 258

    Nov 14, 20264 hr 13 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Part Two: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.

    Credit the people on this episode