Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind the Bastards

Behind the Bastards artwork

Part One: Edward Bernays: The Founding Father of Lies

Jul 23, 20191 hr 22 minAudio

In episode 75, Robert is joined by Jamie Loftus to discuss How Edward Bernays Invented America (And Propaganda). Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1M what's involuntary my celibates. I'm Robert Evans, host Behind the Bastards, the show where we tell you everything you don't know about the very worst people in all of history. And one of those very worst people in all of history is the person who cut the hair of the dog of my guest today, Jamie Loftus. Jamie, if I'm if I'm not mistaken, your dog got a terrible haircut and is ugly. Now, yeah, I think we can all. I mean, you saw the picture. He looks like Lord Farquad.

Speaker 1He used to be one of the sexiest dogs in the game, really getting and it was like this was the first time that he was taken on a walk and received no compliments because he looks like ship. Now he's going to have to, you know, develop a personality. Yeah, he looks like, as you said, an in cell, which is why I picked the opening for the show that I opened Perfect Circle. Yeah, he is now going to start really yammering on about bone structure. Yeah, he's gonna rent a van and ram a. It's probably not something worth joking about. Yeah, the dog looks like shit. But

Speaker 1you know, Jamie, because of our our subject for this week, I've learned that if you want your dog to get compliments again, the answer is not to get him a better haircut. The answer is to just simply change all of America's standards towards dog beauty. And today we're going to talk about the man who can tell you how to do that. Are subject today is Edward Burne's. Yes, Yes, do you know who Edward Burne's was? No, I'm coming in colder than usual on this one. I'm I love it,

Speaker 1I love it. Well, let's let's talk about Eddie b ed burn Uh, Sophie. We'll pull up a picture of him and I'll cue Sophie and on when to show it to you? And you can you can? You can give me that judgment. I'm gonna I'm gonna read my little intro first, though. So in common parlance, the term founding fathers is applied to the men who literally founded this country, either at the end of a rifle or a pen, and from a literal standpoint, that does make sense, whatever else you want to say about them. Dudes like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, Ben Franklin did start this

Speaker 1thing we call the United States, but the country they found it only bears a passing resemblance to the one we live in today. So for my money, we should expand our ideas of the founders to include the people who are most responsible for making America into the place it is right now, at this moment in time, for all of the people who live here. And by that measure of the term, it's possible that no single man deserves to be called a founding father of this nation more than Edward Burnet's. Eddie liked to be known as the father of public relations, which is only part true. He and another guy named Ivy Lee both have a

Speaker 1pretty solid claim on that title, But calling what Berness did PR gives an incomplete picture of the man's accomplishment. Edward Burnet's invented mass manipulation of the American populace to achieve specific ends, and in doing so, he invented modern America. So this is the guy we're talking about today. The first PR man I mean, isn't just saying you're the father of PR, even though you're not just good PR. It's fucking fantastic PR. Yeah, that's just good spin Berne's that's just good evidence. Otherwise, and I'm not going to

Speaker 1look it up. I am. He lived to be a hundred and three years old. Yeah, he he never died until he finally did. Like he should have died so much earlier because he was a real piece of ship, but he just kept being alive. Yeah, it really does. Yeah, like the like the toxicity of a person can really preserve you well. And he's one of these terrible people who like made really good healthcare decisions for himself and was always a very healthy person, which are like the worst terrible people, like the health nuts who were monsters. Yeah. Like when Steve Jobs is like slashing his green jee

Speaker 1You're like, get over yourself. Yeah, it's like because I need to live forever. Yeah, But unlike Jobs, Berne's picked health stuff that actually worked. Apparently, sick roast Robert, take that job, Steve Jobs, and you're dead ass alright. Edward Louis Berne's was born in Vienna, Austria, in ninety one. His father, Eli and mother Anna Freud. Berne's came from a middle class Jewish background. On his mother's side, they were perhaps a little bit above middle class due to

Speaker 1a very famous relative, her brother Sigmund As in Sigmund Freud, the guy who thinks we all want to funk our moms. Sigmund Freud is his uncle. Yeah, whoa are they closed? Oh yeah, yeah they were fucking tight. Yeah they hung out. There was Actually he helped Freud like get along when he was like older and like he was having trouble making money, like Berne's helped sell Freud's books and stuff over in the US and get him speaking deals and ships. So like they were like, like, fucking tight, I'm doing that.

Speaker 1You can't see the gesture over the audio, but I'm doing that. That gesture everyone knows, the tight gesture your fingers. Yeah, that is already deeply fucked. Okay, so your uncle is Freud. He's peddling all these this weird stuff that I sort of agree with, but mostly think it's more of a hymn thing. Freud is always like like the first twenty of everything he says is right, and then he just goes off the rails, right, and then he starts talking about how he wants to fuck his mom, and you're like, yeah, okay,

Speaker 1that's fine, but don't stop projecting on the rest of us. Yeah, he's like a guy who's really good at like building roads, but doesn't know where to build the roads too, so he just he just randomly starts making roads in the middle of nowhere and they lead to cliffs and stuff. That's that's that's Sigmund Freud, father of psychiatry. Also a coke addict, and I guess coke addicts like blazing random true. Oh yeah, he was way into cocaine. Um yeah, super

Speaker 1huge into cocaine. The first book he wrote was called On Cocaine, which was about doing cocaine. That's where psychiatry comes from. That's hardcore and I appreciate him more than I did one minute. Oh yeah, yeah, he's my favorite coke addict. That isn't a Hollywood producer. That's a cool like that's if some like a contemporary like thought leader wrote a book called like Jeweling for a long time like that. Man. All right, I'm a born so he's he's the nephew of the world's most famous coke addict

Speaker 1slash scientist. Now, Austria in the eighteen nineties was not exactly the best place and time to be Jewish. When Eddie was one, his parents moved the family to New York City, where his father went on to become a moderately successful grain merchant. Growing up, Edwards family was not rich, and there were some moments of financial strain when times were tough, but for the most part they managed an upper middle class existence. Now. His father, Eli Bernes, was not abusive or violent to his children, but he was a very German father, and that meant he was seen as more of a force of nature by his kids

Speaker 1than like a loving and supportive parent. Years later, Edward would write quote the household during the day, it around mother. In the evenings and on holidays and Sundays, my father dominated everything and everyone, intimidating all of us with his unpredictable temperament. My earliest recollection of him is that of a heavy set man leaving the house every weekday and Saturday morning for a place called downtown to make money. My mother was constantly on the alert to prevent explosions of father's temper. Cooking odors were anathema. He would sniff the air like a lion when he stepped into the vestibule of the house each evening if someone had forgotten

Speaker 1to close the dumb waiter, and odors sifted up from the kitchen through the house. He would call out and allowed stern voice open the windows. My mother would rush to the windows and throw them open, regardless of outside weather. I never knew why my father was so obsessed with details. So that's that's his dad, That's how he relied. And it's worth noting he capitalizes the M and mother, but does not capitalize the F and father. Another another sick burn there, I don't I mean, yeah, it's his dad. Just sounds like God, yeah, the force of nature thing.

Speaker 1It's so weird. I cannot really at all is someone with a very meek father. But it seems like okay, so so his dad needs attention and his mom is terrified of him, and I'm sure that bodes very well for their personal life. Yeah. Yeah, And it's one of those things that voted like this is actually a very German thing, Like the way his family worked was pretty normal for German families. A couple of years ago, I interviewed an old guy who had been in the Hitler youth as a kid and was like fourteen when World War Two ended, and when he talked about his childhood,

Speaker 1he made a point of noting that, like you didn't speak to your father directly unless he asked you a question. Like on Sundays when the family had a single egg, his dad would eat the egg and they would all watch, Like you didn't start eating food until your dad started eating, Like dad was like the dictator of the family. And this guy was like that was pretty normal in Germany at the time. It was like a way, like especially turn of the century Germany. And I really hate that egg things. Yeah, it's funked up, right, I ever heard that.

Speaker 1It's super fun up and it just like it feels like weirdly symbolic, even if they don't mean it to be. They're like, oh, yeah, no, we have to watch daddy eat an egg. Well, and it's this guy who again like grew up in the Hitler youth, connected uh, the way that like families were structured in Germany to how fascism was able to get such a hold on the country. He was like, we were already kindly used to this idea because of how we grew up with our fathers like that. Anyway, that's the connection this guy made when I read about Bun daddy eat an egg. Never watch

Speaker 1your father eat an egg. I never do it. My dad and I used to do this weird egg thing. But it was it wasn't like that. It was like my dad and I used to do this weird egg thing. Is a sentence that can go a lot of waste. What if I just what if I chose to just like not getting more specifically, anyways, I used to do this weird egg thing. We used to do this this We used to eat and we would each have an over easy egg and then we would time we would both swallow yolks hole but at the same time, and

Speaker 1then we'd high five. That's horrible, German. That's the worst story ever. I'm I'm making the rule right now that if anyone listening to this ever sees their father eat an egg, start pelting him with rocks. No more fathers are allowed to eat eggs. You're enabling fascism if you watch daddy eating, stop your parents. You're just your dad from eating eggs. I guess it's fine for your mom, unless that gets creepy. Yeah, anyway, I'm going to read

Speaker 1another quote Burns wrote about his dad. My sisters and I stood in awe of our father. We observed silence in his presence until we were addressed When he left the house in the morning, he called goodbye to us from the hall. We then ran from wherever we were and pecked a farewell on his bearded cheek. After dark he returned. I saw him for a few moments after supper, before I was sent to bed. He occasionally raised his voice to us in commanding tones, which had the shock effect of a New York traffic cop on a timid motorist. His awesome personality made corporal punishment unnecessary, so he doesn't

Speaker 1get hit at all by his dad. There's no no abuse. But it's like this is the strictness of the family. He grows up and Edward hates it, Like he really doesn't like his parents relationship. He doesn't seem to like the way his dad does things, and he grows up wanting to live a life as different from the life as parents lived as possible. That's like an early motivator for him. Yeah, I wonder what, I wonder what old Sigmunds making of this marriage. Yeah, I don't, I don't know. I don't think I have. I I didn't come across any evidence of Sigmunds psychoanalyzing his own nephew. Um he

Speaker 1seems mostly worried about money. Yeah, probably just something about fucking. Should have fucked your mom, kid, This wouldn't have happened. Classic Sigmund Freud, always telling kids to funk their mom. So. Uh. Eli wanted his son Eddie to get into agriculture and pick a career that was in line with the family business of selling grain. But Eddie had zero desire to do anything even vaguely related to agricultural work. He graduated from the Agricultural College at Cornell University in nineteen twelve.

Speaker 1Uh So he was this is something that everyone listening should be able to identify with. He was like yet another middle class kid with a degree in a field that he didn't want to work in. Uh like half of my friends. Uh. He worked for a brief time decoding cables about the grain trade and living off of dad's money in New York until one day in December nineteen twelve, when he wound up meeting his old friend Fred Robinson on the morning trolley. Now he and Fred had worked on the school paper back when they were in high school, and now Fred's dad had handed his son control of two academic journals. He happened to own

Speaker 1the Medical Review of Reviews and the Dietectic and Hygienic Gazette. Fred asked his old friend Eddie for help in running both papers. Next, according to the Father of Spin by Larry Tye quote, they used the Medical Review to argue against women wearing corsets with stays and to encourage shower baths. They published expert opinions on health controversies, a regular, relatively novel approach, and they write something even newer to promote the journal and its advertisers, distributing free copies to most of the hundred and thirty seven thousand licensed physicians in the United States. So Eddie gets like a chance to

Speaker 1break into publishing and immediately is this guy with new fresh ideas that nobody had thought of before. This is generally positive so far. Yeah, nothing, nothing bad. Putting women in cages and let them take a shower every once in a while. Yeah he is, Eddie. Eddie Burnet's is a feminist icon. By the way. Wow, interesting, Yeah he is. He's a weird feminist icon and a problematic one. But credit where it's due. He was like an early guy being like these these these these chest prisons we put

Speaker 1women in our are seemed like a bad idea. Perhaps he'll get angry, maybe they're uncomfortable. Well that's that's I mean, I guess that's the least you can do with a with a medical journal. They're just like, hey, stop putting your wife in prison. Yeah, don't imprison her lungs in a cage. Now I'm on. I'm on team Eddie so far. Yeah, yeah, we're all on team Eddie so far. Uh So. About two months into his new job, Eddie Burnet's came across a review written by a doctor about a play that

Speaker 1was just now starting to take off in New York, or that had just been written. It hadn't even performed yet, and the play was called Damaged Goods. It was about a man with syphilis who gets married and spawns a syphilitic child. Now, this is about the most risque subject you can imagine. At the time, people in nineteen twelve did not talk about STDs, and like any context, like doctors didn't like talking about them. Um. So the play both dealt with the subject frankly and dealt with the common remedies people attempted to use to deal with the illness.

Speaker 1So it was like like a groundbreaking thing that you would like discuss STDs at all in a popular play the rent of its time. Yeah, it was the rent of its time exactly. It really is like kind of in line with that. Yeah. So Eddie and Fred published that review, but decided that just like publicizing the play itself wasn't enough. So Burne's reached out to a guy named Richard Bennett, who was a popular actor who had expressed an interest in taking part in Damaged Goods. And he told Bennett, quote, the editors of the Medical Review of Reviews support your praiseworthy intention to fight sex pruriency

Speaker 1in the United States by producing bruise play Damaged Goods, you can count on our help. So, because of his really traditional upbringing and like how how kind of cloistered his family life had been, Eddie grew up wanting to like break as many taboos as humanly possible, and Damaged Goods gave him a perfect opportunity to do this. So he attached himself and the Medical Review of Reviews to the project as a sort of proto pr firm. His plan was to essentially gain funding to produce the play um and to get people to go to it and

Speaker 1make it a financial success success by turning the play into a cause celeb where basically like he was, he was staging as like, if you go to this play, you're fighting the cause of prurians. See, you're like fighting prudishness. Yeah. Yeah, it's literally Rent, so where people are like, yeah, I helped I've seen Rent before. Yeah, I helped raise awareness of AIDS by watching this play. That's exactly the same thing Bern's is having people do, but in nineteen freaking twelve. Yeah, damaged goods unrelated is just a great name for anything.

Speaker 1I would see any damaged goods. I would see anything called damaged goods. Yeah, even if it was it kind of sounds like a hair band, I would still see it, though. I would see it if it was a movie starring Jeremy Renner. H And I'm I'm not a Renner a Ritter fan, but you're not a Jeremy Renner fan. I'm not I'm not a Renter stand Yeah. Oh god, didn't he like try stand up or something. He's like tried stand up and he hates women. Love that. I don't know, but he is. I saw one picture of him from the New Avengers movie. And I thought that guy looks

Speaker 1like damaged Goods when he when he had the giant Samurai tattoo on his arm. That's some damaged Goods, right, I think. So that's the phase of Damaged good Jeremy Renner with a giant Samurai tattoo. There is a brief amount of time where both Jeremy Renner and and Hate were like hitting up bar shows that it was just like can you get out of here? Like go get get, get especially canceled. I don't know. I think Jeremy Renner was born canceled, and that's what gives him his great power.

Speaker 1Born to be canceled will be the name of my next play. That's his other arm tattoo, his second sleeve. So Edward Burnet's for the Medical Review of Reviews Sociological Fund Committee at age twenty one uh and like the Sociological Fund Committee was essentially like the organization he made to fund the play Damaged good So he raised money from people like John Rockefeller and the Vanderbilts in order to put on the show. His plan was wildly successful, and the Sociological Fund Committee raised huge amounts of money.

Speaker 1Damaged Goods was a hit, and it inspired Berne's to launch a series of other plays aimed at exposing other utra aspects of society, drugs, white slavery, anything that stirred controversy. After tasting success for the first time in his life, Eddie took the opportunity to travel to Austria and visit his famous uncle, Sigmund. They talked and walked and traded ideas about the functioning of the human mind. When Eddie got back to New York in late nineteen thirteen, he'd become obsessed with his uncle's idea about how unconscious drives from childhood impact the way people behave as adults. Burns

Speaker 1realized that if you could figure out what unconscious drives motivated people, he could manipulate those people on a massive scale. So he starts with like, I'm gonna get people to see this play about syphilis by convincing them that it's like an act of like a humanitarian act to watch this this piece of entertainment that's successful. So he starts doing it with other things drugs and white slavery and stuff, and he's really just titillating people, but he makes them feel like they're accomplishing something, and he realizes that like he's tapped into some sort of drive people have to

Speaker 1do better. So then goes to Austria talks to his uncle sneaky things. They're just like, you're super woke, but what you don't know is that I'm taking all of the money. Like okay, well exactly. Well so his first project after getting back was a comedic play called Daddy Long Legs, which basically seems you're back on now come for a second. The descriptions of it make it seem like it's just like almost a shot for shot rip

Speaker 1off of Little or fan Anny. Like the plot is literally that a poor girl comes up from the street and gets adopted into wealth and privilege. Um so, obviously I don't know, probably for some weird aspect of nineteen twelve, like thirteen vernacular. Um now, you may notice that the idea of a rip off of Little or Fannnny that's not at all risque. It's not like syphilis or white slavery or anything like that. Uh So, how is Eddie going to make people feel like going to this show

Speaker 1is activism? If if it's just about some some poor kid getting adopted by a rich guy. I know, all right, well he found a way. Yeah, he found a way, uh a little bit. Basically, he he uses as an excuse to launch like a charity campaign aimed at encouraging adoption. So like this is like He's like, okay, this play itself. There's nothing risque about it. So I can make people

Speaker 1feel good by making them feel like buying tickets to this is supporting the cause of getting poor kids adopted by rich kids or rich parents and stuff. Um. So he forms groups on college campuses and high schools to raise money that's aimed specifically at getting like private middle class and upper middle class families to take in orphans. Um. One of the colleges he goes to is Vassar, and he arranges a meeting with some influential undergraduates and gets like a writing in the front page of a upland newspapers. Um.

Speaker 1But they only donate about fifteen cents of money, which is fine. He's not actually trying to raise money for anything. There's no actual charity here. He just wants to be able to say Vasser supports this charity campaign, which they yeah, yeah, exactly, And Vasser gets really pissed at him, but the stories are already on the front page. There's no there's no turning it back. So like this is the tactic this guy invents um, which is you may recognize as familiar with the way things work today sort of. Um, so yeah, he's he's, he's he's he's a trend setter. Uh, he's

Speaker 1he's established, like the way pr out of work, where it's like I wanna make it seem like these fancy institutions support what I'm doing. So I'm just going to take a picture with a couple of people there, and folks will read between the lines and assume the college supports what we're doing and assume there's a real charity, even though there's not at all a real charity and no kids are getting matched up with rich parents. So he's a he's a genius. Now, Yeah, cool guy. At age twenty three, Edward took on his biggest client yet, the Russian Ballet. Now this was a particularly tough task,

Speaker 1since macho American men had little inclination to watch a bunch of Europeans and fancy tights bound around on stage like a bunch of fairies. Ballet was seen as effeminate. In order to fight that expression of toxic masculinity, Burnet has used another expression of toxic masculinity and published articles in prominent newspapers with titles like our American men ashamed to be graceful again. He's really smart. I like him. That's that's good. I mean, it's just like you just

Speaker 1have to make that's such a weird angle to come just like, oh, sorry, bro, are you like afraid to like enjoy a gorgeous ballet? I'm sorry you can't enjoy the beautiful shape, like the beautiful expression of a man's glorious glute muscles bounding in perfect symmetry on the stage. You don't like watching his quads bounce? I like, just like the image of an angry bro outside of like a ballet theater. Just they're just being like, dude, like what, oh,

Speaker 1I can't just go out and see fucking Romeo and Juliette with my friends? What then are you talking about? You're saying it's not manly to enjoy a manage tightly wrapped package as it as it bounds up and down on the stage, Like I can't watch that? Are you are you? Are you scared of grace. I'm still not there too. I'm just like, why want my boyfriend go to the Family of the Opera with me? Why? Why? Well, because watch musicals that slap. That's the that's the update.

Speaker 1Does Does Fantom of the Opera slap? Yes, it's well, you know you know what else slaps, Jamie loftus, you know what, you know what slaps even harder than Fantom of Coming And I hate it. The products and services that support this show, inder program, these slaps, these slap like the Phantom of the Opera, but unlike the Phantom of the Opera, you don't know where this story is going from a lifetime growing up in American pop culture. So this will another hater, not a not a hater,

Speaker 1but I'm saying, like the Phantom of the Opera, we all know how the Phantom of the Opera goes. No one knows what these ads are going to be. They could be for a belt company, they could be for coke industries, they could be for the Church of Scientology, they could be for Blackwater. Like, anything could happen when ads come on. It could be anything. Yeah, So let's spin the roulette wheel of capitalism and see whereupon it lands.

Speaker 1We're back. Oh my god, what a ride those ads were. I you know what, I didn't expect it to be a Raytheon ad um, But now that it's run, I've been thinking I really need some new missile guidance systems because I have I have a lot of Yemen to shoot at. Suggestion is very strong. Yeah, you don't realize how many ways there are to kill until you listen to the advertisements. Exactly, I'm gonna bomb so many uh

Speaker 1school buses in foreign countries. Thanks to these beautiful Raytheon products and and their sponsorship money really keeps the show will floats. So thank you to Raytheon. Yeah, it's really cool to get to finally see pictures of your large mansion that you live in. Yes, yes, built with Raytheon money. Yeah. Oddly enough, the main demographic for Behind the Bastards is the Saudi royal family, so they this is really a good place for Raytheon to advertise. Yeah. Alright, let's get

Speaker 1back to Edward Burnet's who is related to this because he invented advertising in context. Yeah, revolutionize bullshit. He revolutionized bullshit. So Berne's had realized with his his campaign for the Russian ballet. Uh, that he could sort of change American opinions about things like European men wearing tights by pushing think pieces into popular publications like Vanity Fair and creating the illusion of a national discussion. As long as that's

Speaker 1done to this day, Yeah, yeah, like he was. He's the first person to figure it out, and it's completely destroyed our our civil society. And remember that article that was like, why aren't millennials buying diamonds? Just like starting a conversation that no one was in the middle of. Meanwhile, the question with all of my fellow millennials is more along the lines of like, why can't I afford to buy my insulin? Why did Why did I go to a dentist who accept group on? That's why are people

Speaker 1able to afford a dentist? How do I? How do I in my vanity bones without getting a new credit card? Yeah? Did you know that there are a group on? Dentist? Robert? I am not surprised by that. It's a hard industry for dentists. I went to one. She sneezed in my mouth, but I think she did a good dental work. The last time I went to a dentist. That that's horrifying. It took me a second to catch up with that. She sneezed into my mouth. She wasn't wearing a mask. Is that? What is that? Was? She like those painless

Speaker 1dentists were like what she brags about it, I'm a maskless dentist. Didn't need to get happen. Yeah, mask off. She I'm thirty cheaper than the other dentists, but I will get my fluids inside of you. Yeah. The crazy thing is, I'm pretty sure that the gum procedure itself went just fine. But she she was like talking about Game of Thrones and she sneezed in my mouth. That's awesome. That's some solid dentistry. Yeah. I mean, hey, if I had, you know, had I gotten health insurance, had I had it been an option in my life, I wouldn't have this gorgeous anecdote to share are with you on this

Speaker 1this podcast, So really, you know, what is dystop you? I don't know. The last time I went to a dentist was when I had health insurance, and it was to get my wisdom teeth removed. And I understood then that that was the last dentist trip where I was likely to get hydro code down. So I just have not been back because why would you? Why would you go after that? There? I guess that's fair. I just my mouth kept bleeding. My mouth kept bleeding. Mouths are meant to bleed, Jamie, there is. I was just I was starting to get nervous about how my mouth would

Speaker 1bleed in any situation. If I started to feel any feeling, my mouth would respond by bleeding. Now, if your mouth stops bleeding, that's when you have a health issue. You want your mouth to bleed all the time. It's well, that's fair, it's but if you see enough pictures of yourself doing stand up with your mouth actively bleeding, people start to think it's a bit and not just how your mouth is well play. It is a bit either way. If your if your mouth is bleeding, it means you're drinking plan of blood, which means you have high iron levels, which is what we need if you can't afford to

Speaker 1go to the doctor. I love this spin. You're going full Burnet's thank you. I'm I I really have learned a lot from him. So as the nineteen teens rolled on, Edward Burnet's was making very good money on the cutting edge of the field that hadn't really existed before he got into it, public relations. Tragically, his success did not at all impress his father. Burne's later wrote, quote, my father's attitude toward my activities remain less than lukewarm. He was disappointed that his son had turned press agent. He enjoyed good theater in concerts. To occupy an orchestra sea

Speaker 1a performance was one thing, But for his only son to make a career of the theater, in daily contact with actors and managers with something else. I opened the window. Get this actor's stink out of here. Yeah, he thought his dad thought actors were gross, and he thought it was gross that his son had become basically a press agent for the theater. I mean, wouldn't you feel the same way. Yes, I hate the theater and all people who were involved with it. Yeah. I think that's a reasonable way to feel. Get get getting TV like every

Speaker 1self respecting actor board trotting. Yeah, where's your is he and Sag? I'm not fucking interested? Yeah he's he is older than Sag. I suspect. Now. When World War One kicked off in August of nineteen fourteen. It was, you know, probably the greatest calamity in human history. The whole nations in the continent of Europe were utterly ruined by war on a scale never before imagined. Luckily, for America and for Edward Burnet's it also meant an opportunity to get into some new business. For America. That new business was mass arms sales. For Edward, that new business was convincing

Speaker 1Americans that getting involved in a European war was a good idea. Now, this is gonna be hard to get your mind around, Jamie, but there was a time when Americans thought going to war in foreign countries was a bad idea. Oh see, that's not something I feel like we can relate with in our lifetimes. No, no, no, it was not. Okay, Daddy little legs, how's it has been a do it? How is Daddy longlegs going to do this? Well? His first big idea was to get out an article in the magazine Musical America urging musicians to help America get on board with the war by

Speaker 1having singers performed songs about the U. S. Military whenever they performed at clubs. So that was you know that can't all be great home runs. That is, that is one thing that seemed to us to work in this country that I truly can't understand, like hearing even like post nine eleven and like this this, you know, it actually did work in nine eleven. I grew up in a conservative household, and I heard that, fucking well, I'm proud to be an American where at least done, No,

Speaker 1I'm free. I heard that fucking every week of my life in the run up to like the Iraq War. Yeah that was. That was like the theme song of We're going to the track if we support this horrible war. Yeah, yeah, that was. And my parents were very moved by it, especially after and eleven thought it was the most profound song they'd ever heard. It was. So yeah, I guess maybe that wasn't a dumb idea. It probably worked really fucking well back then, and it worked really fucking well in two thousand three. Yeah. Yeah, he was a trend setter.

Speaker 1So eventually Bern's work earned an interview with the Foreign Press Bureau, who were the United States is proto propaganda agency for the US military at that point in history. Um, they were worried about hiring Burnet's because he came from Austria and they thought that might make him not loyal to the United States. But eventually they grew convinced that Berne's, you know, was really a company man, and they gave him a chance to serve the war effort directly. No. No, no, he's a relentless capitalist. Yeah, he has he's he is on board with capitalism. We're good, We're good. Yeah, I'm

Speaker 1gonna quote again from the father of Spen quote. Finally, given his chance to serve, Eddie recruited Ford International Harvester and scores of other American firms to distribute literature on US wars to foreign contexts and post US propaganda in the windows of six and fifty American offices overseas. He distributed postcards to Italian soldiers at the front so they could boost morale at home, and he planted propaganda behind the German lines to so dissent. He organized rallies at Carnegie Hall featuring freedom fighters from Poland, Czechoslovakia in other states that were anxious to break free of the Austro

Speaker 1Hungarian Empire. In short, he helped win America over to an unpopular war, using precisely the techniques he'd used to promote Daddy Long Legs and the Russian ballet. Oh my god. Yeah, Okay, so he's moved on from ballet to the First World War. Well, he's gonna quite a jump there. I never overestimate the confidence of a random guy. Yeah, well I successfully promoted Daddy Long Legs better trying to like Mike fuck the

Speaker 1world up. Yeah, it's one of the I know, the thought went through his head at some point, like if I can put asses in seats on Broadway, I can put dough boys in trenches in the Western Front. Wow. I well, there's there's no bouncing back from this. And it worked. It was it worked. Yeah, yeah, yeah, he was. He was an integral part of winning the American people over to World War One. Um. I mean there's really appealing to the power of fomo. Is is powerful for anyone.

Speaker 1They're just like, are you serious? Like people are there ship happening over there. It's one kind of dumb to be a European in nineteen fourteen and think like, oh, this war is gonna be awesome. We gotta get into it, like everybody wants a little bit. It's gonna be over real quick, Like I want to have a partner it. I want to have a chance to be a hero. That's one kind of dumb, and it's an understandable kind of dumb if you know European history up to that point. It's a whole other kind of dumb to watch three years of unspeakable slaughter in the trenches of Western Europe and be like, yeah, we we should really get in that.

Speaker 1Like this seems like it's gonna be a great tea. Let's hop on this trade, guys. But it does. But it does work. It does work. Uh, Imperial Germany is defeated, thus ensuring peace in Europe forever more. Um, I haven't read in the European history past nineteen eighteen, but I think I think I think it went pretty well. It's kind of a happily ever after kind of deal. Yeah, seems like it seems like it. So there's an extent to which, like obviously American involvement in the First World

Speaker 1War is one of those things that set off a chain of events that you know, made the rise of Nazi Germany inevitable. And you can't blame Edward Burnet's for that. Um, he was, he was doing what he thought was best. Uh, what you can blame him for is his work in the tobacco industry, which ironically would go on to kill more people than his work selling America on World Wars. But first, it's so wild that, you know, like his dad could have just been like, I love you. Yeah.

Speaker 1His dad actually did say that a lot, because we have some letters between them. It seemed like his dad could only communicate emotionally with his son through letters that they wrote each other. But his dad was also like really insistent that his son get into agriculture, which I guess maybe he was right about it because it seems kind of that Eddy, that would be fun and I wish I'm going, Yeah, I was like, I mean, I guess the world might be better out of you than that.

Speaker 1I wish that fathers were still pushing their kids to do the same ship as them. That that's what a what a fun what a fun trend that was for most of human history. I mean I say that, like I make fun of that idea of like Dad's like like pushing their kids to the same thing they did. But I wound up completely accidentally in the same career field my dad was in without ever meaning to because he was a radio guy for thirty years. And now look at look at fucking me, Look at you. You're on your goddamn microphone and your ray theon mansion, and

Speaker 1I'm also reporting on the Boston Bruins for local paper. You can't, you can't, you can't escape it yet. Genetics is destiny, um, except for Edward Burns who, instead of farming tobacco just sold it to millions of Americans. We're going to talk about that in a little bit, Jamie, but first I feel like we should have a little detour and talk about Edward Burne's feminist icon. Wow. This is yeah, this is this is my content. Okay, great,

Speaker 1you're ready. You're ready. The judge of that Berne's was a long standing women's rights advocate and was well ahead of his time on just about every gender issue. He you know, supported women's suffrage before women could actually vote. He and his wife, Doris Fleischmann, got married in nineteen twenty two after a long lingering courtship. When Edward had opened his first independent company, which he called a publicity direction office, in nineteen nineteen, Doris was his first employee. They fell in love, but we're so focused on a voiding what they saw as the mistakes of their parents that they kept their relationship hidden for years. Eddie's sister

Speaker 1actually had her husband adopt the Burnet's name when they married so the family line could go on, because she was that convinced that her brother would never marry. He was like kind of like a hippie sort of dude, where he's like, we're not gonna get married, We're gonna do like, you know, a different sort of relationship that that nobody else in America is on board like doing yet. So he was like ahead ahead of his time on that um. Now, on paper, the union between Doris Fleischmann and Eddie Burnet's seemed like it was like the wokest one in history up to that point. They got married

Speaker 1without a wedding ring. They did not inform their parents. Uh and you know, back before the wedding, they both joined something called the Lucy Stone League, which was an advocacy group dedicated to fighting for women's right to maintain their maiden name and not change their maiden name after marriage. That is cool and true to their word. After their marriage, Doris kept her maiden name. When they signed into the hotel where they would spend their wedding night, she registered for the room instead of Eddie, and she registered under the name Doris Fleishman. This was the first time any

Speaker 1woman had ever done this in American history, and like to give you an idea of where gender relations were at the time, multiple major national newspapers reported on the story of a woman signing in for a hotel under her name. Wow. There were headlines like this bride registers under her maiden name and just independent with the exclamation point. Yeah. It's like, so that's where we are at this time. But you know, Eddie Burne's is and he and his

Speaker 1wife like our fucking trend setters here. Um oh wow, I mean talk about multitudes on Mr. His friends must have thought he was such a cock that's funny. Yeah, yeah, that's something that's not nothing. That's not nothing. And he was, you know, in the nineteen twenties, was an advocate of the idea that housewives deserved to be paid by their husbands because he believed they were doing yeah, yeah, real work and that they ought to be compensated for it. Um,

Speaker 1And because he and his wife were business partners. He split the revenue from his agency with his wife evenly, um, so they were equal partners on paper at least. So his wife, Yeah, is she hot? Sophie, there is she hot? Wait? We gotta look him up. Yeah, we gotta look him up. We gotta, we gotta reduce Joras Fleischmann, women's rights pioneer two. Is she hot? I should have said earlier. I don't think Edward Rene's is hot. His head looks like a cube. I would not call him hot. His his wife is beautiful. Okay, yeah,

Speaker 1you do what she says, cube head. So well, actually, see this is where it gets kind of sucked up. So Jamie, nice friends, It's uh, this is a complicated story because everything I've just told you is true, but it leaves out an important aspect of the story, which is what Doris herself actually wanted. So I'm gonna quote again from the book The Father of Spin quote. Doris

Speaker 1also was a pioneer for women's rights, but winning the right to use her maiden name wasn't one of her proudest achievements. Eddie admitted it was he who had insisted on their joining the Lucy Stone League, bringing a reluctant Doris with me, and it was he who pushed her to use her maiden name on their wedding night because I had an interfere that marriage, though I wanted it fiercely with Doris, would take away some of my liberties as an individual if there were a missus added to my name. So years later, Doris actually would adopt her husband's last name, as she'd apparently wanted to do all along.

Speaker 1She never it was. It was played as this big gesture of an independent woman making a strike for women's rights, but she actually really wanted to take bernonas name and he wouldn't let her. So yeah, it's it's it's it's fucking complicated, right, Like that's some extremely weird Yeah, that's it just does sort of ring as like yeah, whatever. His fears are compounded with the fact that this all

Speaker 1got them pressed every time they would do something that was a hashtag feminist win. Yeah, that is so oh, that's like so many levels of emotional fuccory where I don't know, I'm like, I'm just picturing these gas lighting sessions of like are you telling me and do something bad? It's like no, but like no one ever Doris. God, it's so complicated. The only wokeman is also a fucking dick. Yeah,

Speaker 1it's it is the twenties, So I imagine that I do yeah for fifty eight years? Yeah, I mean she she She expressed happiness in their relationship. Doris Fleischmann was a legitimate U pioneer of women's rights. She worked in journalism long before that was common, and she was a huge part of her husband's groundbreaking pr work. But in spite of his insistence is that there's was an equal partnership, Burnet's always focused on the Burnet's name in their work

Speaker 1and downplayed his wife's involvement in it during the decades where that was a hindrance rather than an asset. Doris was expected to maintain their home as well, like any housewife of that era, but because Eddie was so woke and uncomfortable with the idea of having his wife do housework for him, she spent most of her life rushing to and from their home ahead of him to ensure that the house was an order, and to also ensure that Eddie didn't see her putting the house in order and Burnet's, their daughter, later said he wanted her to be a feminist outside the house, but inside he wanted her to be a Victorian wife. That's yeah, that's still

Speaker 1that's still happened. That's like, yeah, I would say a solid of men who own uh, like the future is female shirts are like still pieces of ship and like expect too too much? Uh from well, good to know, Good to know. Yeah, he's the original be where the wokeman sort of stereotype. Yeah, Like the guy who brags about being woke is usually quite dangerous. He's like, who's

Speaker 1that guy from Who's that guy from Orange as the New Black who like wouldn't shut up about how woke he was for three years and then everyone just stopped casting him so he'd shut the funk up. He's like that guy someone I don't I don't know who that guy is. His name was Matt And I'll tell you be shirtless. I mean, I'll say from my own part, the only thing all brag about is accidentally drunkenly vomiting on people that that I'm I'm close to, because because I I Jamie am a true hero. Are you are

Speaker 1the true wokeman? Thank you? Thank you? And the woman the person who has a problem moderating his intake of intoxicants and has ruined many a shirt from his friends. Matt mcgory, that was that was Mr Woke. I was thinking, is that the guy? Yeah, the shirtless wokeman. Yeah? Okay, god so gross, well, shirt full wokeman Eddie Burne's old cube head. When Doris died in nineteen eighty, a professor

Speaker 1named Susan Henry was inspired by the obituary Edward Burns wrote about his wife and you know, inspired her to write a book about Doris Fleishman and several other female pioneers. The book is titled Anonymous in their Own Names, which is a solid fucking title. Uh. Professor Susan Henry reached out to Edward Burns because he was still alive about writing this book that would feature his wife heavily, and he was enthusiastic in his desire to help Susan and to talk up the accomplishments of his deceased wife. As Susan dug more and more. Though, and talked to the

Speaker 1Burnet's daughters, she came to very critical conclusions about Eddie and I'm gonna quote from her book now. After visiting him in March I finished writing a paper about Fleishman that was accepted for presentation at a national conference. I sent him a copy nervously, though, since the paper's theme was his dominance of her at home and in the office and her lack of professional recognition. Once again he surprised me. I have no criticisms whatsoever, he wrote to me after reading it, except possibly one slight point. I had overplayed her invisibility, he thought, and not been sufficiently

Speaker 1mindful of how their business would have suffered. Quote if we had publicized a woman giving advice to men. This was not a slight point at all, but he was willing to treat it as if it were and to invite me back. So again, that's Eddie's justification for why he didn't give his wife the credit and she deserved while they were actually doing the work, and waited until decades later when women's rights was in vogue. That's certainly spin. Yeah, he's the data spin Big Papa spins Jesus Now Edward continued to work with Susan on her book in spite of the fact that her work both revealed the great

Speaker 1role Doris had played in his innovations, which meant less credit for him. This might seem to be somewhat to Eddie's credit as a human being and evidence that he was a man capable of seeing his own past flaws and acknowledging them in the harsh light of the historical record. But it's worth noting that Edward's own daughter Anne did not take this charitable view of her father. Quote. When I asked Anne Burnet's why she thought her father was so helpful, even though by telling fleishman story, I was undermining the soul credit he had received for their work, she reminded me that one of his favorite phrases was reflected glory. I was showing his good sense in choosing

Speaker 1her mother as his partner, she explained, you're flattering him. I later realized that the timing of my research added to the flattery. In contrast to the anti feminism of the nineteen fifties that made it a problematic time for Fleishman to disclose much about her career in a wife, as many women so she barely mentioned it. The feminism of the nineteen eighties and nineteen nineties made this an excellent time for Bernet's to call attention to her career. He was willing to take less credit for their public relations accomplishments if he could take full credit for having been smart enough to marry and form a professional relationship

Speaker 1with this remarkable woman. So that's how Eddie Berne's daughter analyzes everything that went on, and I just find very interesting. I realize she's an author, isn't she his daughter? Because I recognize her and I think I had to read one of her books at some point. Well that, I mean, that sounds that sounds accurate in terms of just like I mean, those men are still out there, just like a fair you know, the fair weather supporter of like when it's I mean, this guy just sounds like yeah,

Speaker 1when it's when he when the world will give you positive attention for being a feminist, he's a feminist, and then when feminism is out, then cool, Well I hate yeah, and I hate him. He's kind of would describe him as like yeah, yeah, I mean he wasn't entirely a fair other feminist. I got to give him that. Like, there were things that he was very outspoken about before it was popular, like him insisting that housewives get paid was never a popular like that's still not a popular

Speaker 1and was just I mean just the general like even if it's we don't know how genuine it is. But like the fact that he said, like, you know, women shouldn't be forced to work. Of course, it's like, that's that's good. I like it. But then the fact that he wasn't actually listening to his wife kind of really puts a puts a bad taste in your mouth. Yeah about old cute. Yeah, it's fucking complicated, um and weird and uh, you know, it's a bad taste in my intentions, Robert. Why,

Speaker 1that's one of those things like when we talk about like his his reputation or his his record with feminism, there's a lot to criticize, there's a lot to praise. I wouldn't call him a bastard on that because I am a big believer and you have to judge people by the standards of the time, and even with all of the warts on his story, he's still better than the average man for that time on that issue. Well, that's yeah, I agree with like, And there is something to be said for just being an influential person, Uh, saying something that's not like popular, what no matter if

Speaker 1it's not even if it's done for pr like it can still be helpful to the world. Uh well, I mean yeah, he just kind of sounds like a like a kind of flip floppy but sort of progressive. I don't know, you know, at the end of the day, sold a lot of cigarettes, and I guess I just don't like it. And we are going to talk about the cigarettes next because that's where we really get into Edward Burnet's definitely a bastard. But before we talk about cigarettes, Jamie loftus, Yes, let's talk about the fine products and

Speaker 1services that Raytheon provides. Products and services like the Hellfire missile Guidance System, which, Jamie, let me tell you, if there's a wedding party in Afghanistan that you want to blow up with several dozen pounds of art X explosives, there is no missile guidance system better than the ones Raytheon makes. I love it. I'm looking at Raytheon merch on now and boy do they have some graphic design. Yeah. My favorite Raytheon shirt is I went to an afghan

Speaker 1wedding and all I got was peppered with shrapnel there. Like, I don't know why I decided on Raytheon ad plugs today. Yeah, I mean they really need I just like to say it like how it sounds. Yeah, I'm I'm a raytheon stand um for sure. Yeah. Products, we're back. We're talking Eddie B and burn Daddy long Legs, the original Daddy

Speaker 1long Legs. He has his names to intro him as like Pitball. Yeah yeah, and in fact he and pit Bull are very closely related. That's not true, but let's let's let's see if we can just get that light a take off. Edward Burns would approve of me? Would he could cooler? Would he be perceived as cooler or less cool? Does your profile raise if you're related to Mr three or five Mr Worldwide pit himself like Pitall? Yes,

Speaker 1I like pit Bull and that's my feminism pit Bull. Is there anything more feminist than liking pit Bull than Mr three or five Mr Worldwide? I don't know. I don't know. Yeah, No, not at all, not at all. It's that is the most feminist one can be. Exactly, when we go to war with Iran, We're going to air drop pit Bull into UH, into the country in order to UH to lead a women's uprising against the regime. That's that's how that's gonna work. It's going to be. Yeah,

Speaker 1the revolution will be scored to pit Bull, and the revolution will of course be sponsored and supported by the good people of Raytheon Pitbull x Raytheon is I mean after forever, it's a match made in heaven. We don't know, Yeah, Yonline, I believe it. Yeah, I believe because that's fucking Pitbull branded hell Fire drones. That's that's a great that's a great branding opportunity right there. So we're going to talk

Speaker 1about Edward Burns and the mother fucking tobacco industry and Jamie Spoilers. When I say motherfucking I mean because his work in tobacco fucked over a lot of mothers. I thought it was another fried thing. If you know an older woman who died from tobacco, it's probably Edward Burness. False had a grandma who dropped from lung cancer. Only Yeah, I mean, I didn't like my great aunts, so I

Speaker 1guess shout out. I mean, then you really can thank Edward Burnet's and Edward Burnet's ensured that there would be more sweet and low packets by taking her out of the game early. So you're welcome Jamie, Yeah, thank you so much so. World War One was, of course a huge boon for the concept of smoking cigarettes. Prior to the war, real men tended to prefer cigars or pipes, or, if they were baseball players, chewing tobacco cigarettes excelled in wartime due to how easily you could smoke them in

Speaker 1a trench. They became a standard part of military rations, and hundreds of thousands of American men returned from Europe with a fun new addiction in Edward and Doriss PR firm was contracted by George Washington Hill, the head of the American tobacco company. Hill's goal was to get women to start smoking the company's biggest brand, Lucky strikes. Hey, that works, can crack that market? That worked out? Yeah it did it did that? Were yes, spoilers. This plan works like fucking gangbusters. Now, at that point, only about

Speaker 1twelve percent of cigarettes were consumed by women, which representative huge surge in lady smoking from like the way things had been in the eighteen nineties, but wasn't nearly enough to make big tobacco happy. He'll hit upon a brilliant theory, since being skinny had just come into Vogue. If he could convince women that cigarettes would help them lose weight, he could get them super fucking addicted to tobacco. Hill came up with the slogan on his own. Yeah. Yeah, it really does. And Hill came up with the slogan reach for a lucky instead of a suite, which is

Speaker 1a solid slogan. Yeah, he's a feminist, he is not intersectional. Hill knew that he was going to need the talents of the world's greatest admin to make the slogan work. From the father of spend, yeah, I mean that's kind of who John Draper is, kind of based on Edwards without the whole square head thing. Yeah, except for much better looking, although they both do have giant heads. Does John Hamm have a big old head? Yeah, John, I've seen John Hamm and he has a very large head.

Speaker 1Very good looking guy, but huge head. Well that's isn't that? Like there's something about humans that are like they find big heads cute, and that's why the powerpuff Girls look that way. I'm not I'm not crazy here, I there's it's the same reason we find babies cute because their heads are big for their bodies and puppies too. Yeah, all right, well, yeah, I like a big head. So yeah, He'll had this idea for like an ad campaign, reach for Lucky instead of a sweet, and he contracted with

Speaker 1Edward Burne's to make the idea work. So I'm gonna quote again from the father of spin. Berne has launched the campaign against sweets with his trident true tactic of enlisting experts, in this case convincing Nicholas Murray, a photographer friend, to ask other photographers and auris to sing the praises of the thin. I have come to the conclusion. Murray wrote that the slender woman who combining suppleness with grace and grace with slenderness, who instead of over eating sweets and desserts, lights a cigarette as the advertisements say, has created a new standard of female loveliness. I'm interested in knowing if my own judgment concurs with that of others,

Speaker 1and should be most happy to have your opinion on the subject. Magazines and newspapers were also furnished with the latest findings on the get thin trend for fashion editors that meant photo after photo of slender Parisian models and how coultured dresses for news editors and meant testimonials like the one from the former chief of the British Association of Medical Officers of Health warning that sweets cause tooth decay and advising the correct way to finish a meal is with fruit, coffee, and a cigarette. The fruit Dr George F. Buchan continued, hardens the gums and cleans the teeth. The coffee stimulates the flow of saliva in the mouth

Speaker 1and acts as a mouthwash, while finally the cigarette disinfects the mouth and soothes the nerves. Cigarettes are dental there. I you learned a lot from the twenties by knowing people were told coffee is a mouthwash and cigarettes clean your teeth, and we're like, all right, there is a part of me that's like I would like to live in that world for like a day. It would be nice. It's like everyone was living in a Kesha song. Yeah,

Speaker 1it's so yeah, that's psychotic that I mean, it is crazy. How I mean making cigarettes look feminine is it's such like an advertising hack job that was so effective. But it's like that was still My mom smoked cigarettes for chicks basically, and my dad smoked boys cigarettes like my dad did like Winston's and my mom does Missy Menthal one twenties because they're thin and sexy and there's a rainbow in the carton and that, like it's it works.

Speaker 1I hate it. It works. It's super or works. It's the same reason why there's all these like like where they have male patterned baby wipes. Now, yeah, like it's and it's god, I mean it's like becoming a little bit like more controversial to still be like arbitrarily gendering stuff like that. But it is crazy how like how recently it was so egregious of just like this one's for and this is how you know, if you ever want a really fun trip down an advertising rabbit hole,

Speaker 1look at all of the different handguns that are like marketed towards women, like car and stuff like their lady gun ads are it's great guns for like anything for for the gals is just guns for gals. Guns for gals. We gotta protect ourselves, two ladies. But look at like this pink trigger like it's well it's it's it's lisp. I mean you do see some of that. Mostly it's like, gals, we know you all want to carry the biggest gun available, but you don't want to ruin the lining of your

Speaker 1yoga pants. So like, here's yoga pants that are built to carry a gun, or here's like a gun that's designed to like go with the contours of feminine like like fashion. It's really how could I pack a piece and still look hot and still looked demure? Yeah, there's great. There are these new things. I actually like these, but there they sell them at like wart Walmart and Targets and warget um. But they're these panic alarms to carry around in case someone tries to attack you in the night.

Speaker 1But they just look look like heart key chains and they're advertised with like, if you ever need to make a big scene, girls, this is the accessory to have. And it is basically a very small taser. Oh that's amazing, make a big scene. It's beautiful and it all comes descended from the mind of Eddie Burnet's so in his quest to get more women smoking, he went directly to hotels and restaurants and encourage them to add sick grits to their dessert offerings. He oversaw print ads like this

Speaker 1beautiful piece of propaganda. I'm going to have Sophie show you, uh it says on the top, Actually, Jamie, why don't you, why don't you describe that ad for our listeners? Okay, so in a in and a nice little Sarah font at the top says to keep a slender figure, no one can deny. And then it's a horny looking woman. And then it's reach for lucky instead of a suite, and then it says the thing that we all know from the Mad Men episode, which is it's toasted. It's

Speaker 1no throat irritation, no cough. Yeah, oh my god, there I mean, and they were right, we're right. This is such a weird Yeah, this and and we're these the first advertisements of their kind. Yeah, this is really the first guy to start pushing this in a big way. Like obviously they're in products advertised for women before, but not like this. No one had thought of taking something that was a mass product and then specifically gendering it in order to sell more of them to a specific gender. Um. Yeah,

Speaker 1like Burnet's is the fucking king of that. He's he's the real trailblazer there. He's using his feminism for evil, Yes, exactly. The Bernet's office sent out a series of suggested menus to restaurants arranged to save you from the dangers of overreading. Inevitably, the after dinner menus advised reach for a cigarette instead of dessert. Burns pushed articles that advised wives to hire cabinet makers to add in special cigarette holders next to the flower and sugar holders. He sat down with home ex textbook writers to stress the importance of cigarettes and homemaking.

Speaker 1Just as the young and inexperienced housewife it's caution not to let her supplies of sugar or salt, or tea or coffee run low, so should she be advised that the same holds true of cigarettes. I desperately want a house with a cigarette holder built into the cabinets. I will start smoking just to be able to use that. That sounds fucking awesome there, I mean, the way it's crazy to think of. It's like they're, yeah, like cigarette used used to be like kind of a given and like built into it's still kind of like built into cars and just like became. If you want to know

Speaker 1what it was like, if you want to know what it was like to grow up in the twenties in America, go take a vacation to Serbia. Because they all still like you'll you'll have waiters walk to your table with a plateful of food with a cigarette in their mouths like it's it's so fucking crazy. They still smoked that way over there and it's, uh, it's amazing, like it really yeah, it really takes you back. Um yeah, it's retro, Robert, it's retro and they have a nightmarish rates of cancer.

Speaker 1But I don't think anyone gives a ship. It's Serbia man, like they've been through worse. But that's the national slogan. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you noticed that the places where like, uh, ship has gotten real most recently are the places where no one cares that cigarettes are bad for you, Like everybody smokes in a rack and it's like, why am I going to give a shit about lung cancer? Have you seen what's going on here? Yeah? Um, now, Jamie, have you ever heard the phrase a moment on the lips and

Speaker 1in a lifetime on the hips? You know you've never heard that? I guess. Okay, So for a couple of articles I wrote years ago, I spent several weeks in pro anorexia chat rooms just like listening to the conversations pro anorexi if people would have with each other about how to be anorexic better, and you run into that quote all of the fucking time. It is very common off offline, which is that's good. Yeah, that's good. Yeah, I did the same. Yeah. I'm glad that I did

Speaker 1the same with my eating disorder. Otherwise it would have been a real problem, um, or more of a real problem than it was. Uh. Yeah, but a phrase, a moment on the lips, a lifetime of the hips. That anthem of anorexia originates from a quote cooked up by Edward Burnet's. His version, of course, was a moment in the mouth and ten years on the hips, um, which I guess is less extreme than with the way the quote. Yeah, a moment in the mouth and ten years on the hips. It's a good line. It's a good line. Uh. He

Speaker 1got that line published in pieces in the New Yorker Life and other magazines, right next to cigarette ads. Now at this moment, in the late nineteen twenties, most of the resistance to Berne's tactics came from the fact that he was hurting the candy industry, not that he was, you know, encouraging horrible rates of cancer. Representatives of the sugar industry in particular were livid, which prompted Burnet's to respond in a letter that quote, a battle carried on fairly in this manner can serve the public and presenting both sides of a discussable question, and in bringing the underlying democratic principle of free competition fairly to the front,

Speaker 1which really that says a lot about capitalism right there. That he's like, no, we need a fair discussion. Should you eat a shipload of sugar or should you smoke cigarettes every ten seconds? That's the question, not like are both of these things bad? Are you doing either? It's just like, which is the more profitable right now? Yeah, which poison will sell better? Is the is the question we need to have a free and open discussion about. I mean, it is crazy to me that he was able to convince people that cigarettes are more fun than eating garbage, because I just contently disagree. Yeah, it's incredible,

Speaker 1Like that is an achievement right there. I like how cigarettes were like they're like, oh no, this is how you make friends, Like, oh okay, yeah, this is how you get men to like you ladies smoke a lucky strike. But December of nine, the first year of Eddie's pro cigarette campaign, American Tobacco's revenue group by thirty two million dollars, which thirty two million dollars in nineteen eight money is equivalent to roughly every dollar in two thousand nineteen money. Most of that additional sales came, of course, from the

Speaker 1increase in sales for Lucky Strikes, so this is almost all attributable to berne ad campaign. And of course Edward Burns had no issue in capitalizing off of the woman's liberation movement to sell cigarettes, since cigarettes smoking came into vogue right around the same time women got the right to vote. Bernese tied the two together, running ads suggesting that emancipated women ought to smoke cigarettes. He took advantage of his famous uncle, hiring the psychoanalyst Dr. A. A. Brill, who had studied under Sigmund Freud, and paying him to consult on his ad campaign. Brill wrote quote, It's perfectly

Speaker 1normal for women to want to smoke cigarettes. The emancipation of women has suppressed many of their feminine desires. More women now do the same work as men do. Many women bear no children. Those who do bear children have fewer children. Feminine traits are masked cigarettes, which are equated with men become torches of freedom. Oh the I it makes total sense that this works. It makes total sense that women can do anything that men do, include accidentally killing them else include include poisoning themselves with tobacco. Yeah,

Speaker 1I get it. That's well, you know, you got me. That's why our great aunts are dead. That line from Dr Brill Torches of Freedom inspired Edward Burnet's to create what some people call the first modern pr campaign in history. That might be overselling a little bit, a little bit, but it was very influential. Berne's decided that American tobacco should pick out a handful of stylish young ladies with social cash at you might call influence. Influence. Yeah, yeah, he's that fucking guy. So he hires these ladies to

Speaker 1show up at the nineteen twenty nine Easter Sunday Parade in New York and walk around smoking their cigarettes flagrantly in public as a protest against women's inequality. He's like, we're smoking cigarettes. Yeah, we're smoking cigarettes out on the street. So his office put out a press release which they disguised as a message from one of the lady activists organizing the event, but was of course actually written by Edward Burnet's and his his colleagues. From the interest in

Speaker 1the interests of equality of the sexes and to fight another sex taboo, I and other young women will light another torture freedom by smoking cigarettes while strolling on Fifth Avenue Easter Sunday. We're doing this to combat the silly prejudice that the cigarette is suitable for the home, the restaurant, the taxicab, the theater, lovvy, but never, no, never, for the sidewalk. Women smokers and their escorts will stroll from stret Street on Fifth Avenue between eleven thirty and one o'clock. So motherfucker is dueling for like pro choice justice psycho. Okay, yeah,

Speaker 1I'm I'm I'm with you. I understand why this Yeah yeah Now. The event received massive newspaper coverage and was one of the biggest stories in the country for days, even though only ten women actually showed up to march. Here's an example of how a local New York paper covered the it quote, I'm gonna try to do my best New York old timey journalist accent here, so just as Miss Frederica Freyling, who housing conspicuous and a tailor outfit of Dot Gray, pushed her way through the jam. In front of St. Patrick Smith. Miss Bertha Hunt and

Speaker 1six colleagues struck another blow on behalf of the liberty of women. Down Fifth Avenue, they strolled puffing at cigarettes. Miss Hunt issued the following community from the smoke clouded battlefield. I hope that we have started something and that these torches of freedom, with no particular brand Favid will smash the discriminatory taboo on cigarettes for women, and that our sex will go on breaking down all discriminations. Wow good, Yes, it was beautiful. I'm also imagining all the women that are advertising this being forced to act like sexy babies in the way that women in an advertising were at

Speaker 1this time and still are, but in a different way where they're just like, who me smoke a cigarette? Like they're like the sexy, the freaky sexy baby trope that I love and wish I could do myself. I think this was more like the boundary breaking, provocative flapper girl sort of thing. Yeah, abies, well you can have sex with me. Thet I get the I get the idea that they were more uh, acting like um, you know,

Speaker 1like the stereotype of like the feminist college student in that earliest episode of The Simpsons where where Homer grabs the candy off that lady. I think they're acting more like that. Um. But that's just the impression I get from, like the quotes in the newspapers and stuff. I don't know what voice they said them in. They were all dressed. Yeah they're the flapper, I mean, yeah, the flapper and the cigarette are very intwined. So Eddie's secretary, Bertha was

Speaker 1one of the marchers and the Tortures of Freedom rally. She gave quotes to numerous newspapers and told the New York Evening World that she first got the idea for this campaign when a man with her in the street asked her to extinguish your cigarette, as it embarrassed him. I talked it over with my friends and we just it it was high time something was done about the situation. Bertha denied being associated with any ad firm or agency and interviews, which was of course patently false because she worked her directly for Edward Burnet's The Torches of Freedom campaign was an influential moment in pr history. Berne's would,

Speaker 1in true fashion, go on to massively oversell the impact it had on national smoking habits. Later academic work suggests that it alone was not responsible for making women feel okay with smoking cigarettes, But it's pretty much beyond debate to say that Berne's overall impact on the tobacco industry was enormous and groundbreaking. Before Edward Burnet's, woman who smoked were seen as horrors, trollops, and criminals. After Edward, fucking everybody smoked. Observing the change he had wrought. Later in life, Edward wrote, age old customs I learned could be broken down by a dramatic appeal disseminated by a network of

Speaker 1the media, which is true. Uh, it's hard to quantify the exact cost in public health of Berne's tobacco marketing innovation. I found a article in the British Medical Journal that credited Burnet's with a formative role in marketing tobacco with two women and noted quote. The World Health Organization estimates that the number of women smoking will trip almost triple over the next generation to more than five million. World Health Organization. Of these, more than two million will die prematurely from smoking related diseases, so sizeable body count that

Speaker 1he's a part of here. So how are you feeling about the feminist icon label at this point? Definitely a feminist icon, but I think we can agree that icon is not an inherently positive term. Definitely had an impact on the lives of women, that's my spin. Very impactful in women's history. I gotta say, to be fair, contributing to two hundred million smoking deaths via marketing would not necessarily make Bernet's a bastard, because you have to consider someone's actions based on what they and the medical community

Speaker 1knew about cigarettes at the time. Like if I sell my listeners belts and then twenty years later scientists realized that belts cause aggressive waste cancer, I can't be blamed for that. But if Sophie had handed me right before reading that ad pieces of a study that suggested that belts might cause aggressive waste cancer, and then I covered that study up, then I would be a bastard. So this leads me to the question, what precisely did Eddie Burns know about the health consequences of smoking in the

Speaker 1twenties and thirties. Well, for one thing, it's worth knoking, noting that, unlike Don Draper, Edward Burns did not smoke tobacco himself. He hated the taste and ironically preferred chocolates. Now, first off, this guy's yet not comfortable smoking himself. For another thing, Edward Burns had to bribe medical experts to brag about the supposed health benefits of smoking. It was obvious even to people in the twenties that cigarettes were bad for your throat. People got smokers coughs then, as they do now. To combat this obvious fact of reality,

Speaker 1Burne's created the Tobacco Society for Voice Culture, whose goal was to improve the cords of the throat through cigarette smoking, that the public will be able to express itself in songs of praise or more easily to swallow anything. Society's ultimate goal was to provide what they called a smoking teacher for every singer. Now, you could argue that Burns didn't have much data on the health effect of cigarettes, but again, it was obvious to people that you know, cigarettes had harmful effects on your throat, and Burnet spent a lot of his career finding ways to get people

Speaker 1to deny this evidence of their senses. One way he did this was by finding ways he could market specific products in a way that seemed to encourage public health. When he was hired by Cremo Cigars to improve their image, he suggested they launch an anti spitting campaign and basically focus on improving hygiene through stopping people from spitting to kind of cover up the fact that cigarettes are obviously bad for your health. Uh. By the early nineteen thirties, a scientific study revealed that a rabbit exposed to tobacco for three years had developed a carcinoma. The studies stated for the first time that tobacco had cancer producing properties. Now,

Speaker 1this is an in nineteen thirties, about sixty years before this information is common knowledge and the few people how long has he been pushing cigarettes or is this pre him pushing cigarettes? Oh, this is while he's pushing cigarettes in the middle of it. He starts pushing cigarettes in the late twenties. But this isn't like he becomes aware of this data in the middle of his time in the tobacco industry. And in May of nineteen thirty three, he attached an abstract of the study to a letter he's sent to one of American Tobacco's executives. He wrote, as you will see, certain of the material in these articles is unfavorable to tobacco. However, I do not feel

Speaker 1that there is anything immediate to be done. I do feel that serious attention should be given to the problem of having ready a strong offensive in case the press should give prominence to the recurring articles which I note from time to time on the relationship of smoking in carcinoma. I believe that the American Tobacco Company and the tobacco interests generally should be fully prepared with authentic information if, as when the need for such information occurs. So Edward Burnet's knows that cigarettes are associated with cancer, and his first step when he becomes aware of that is to send warning to the company hiring him that they should

Speaker 1have a counter offensive ready in case newspapers pick up the story. Okay, so he's fully yeah, he's he's fully a bastard. And further evidence of that is that he was deeply concerned about the health impact smoking would have on his wife, Doris. She was a pack a day smoker, and Eddie needled her about her habit until she quit. Their oldest daughter, Doris later recalled to author Larry Tye, he used to hide my mother's cigarettes and make us hide the cigarettes. He didn't think they were good for mother. His daughter Anne added, he'd pulled them all out and

Speaker 1just snap them like bones, just snap them in half and throw them in the toilet. He hated her smoking. So Edward Burne's while he is getting America hooked on cigarettes, is committed to stopping his wife from smoking because he knows they're going to kill her and he loves his wife. Okay, so yeah, this, I mean, this is like basic Game of Thrones logic of just like if the person is not willing to drink their own wine, do not purchase that wine, you goofs it's poison. M h, All right,

Speaker 1well he's bad. Just started watching Game of Thrones, didn't you, Jamie. I started watching the Throne game? You did? You did watch the Throne Games? And now I'm smart. It's true. Yep, yep, yep, yep. It's a good show. It's fine. I like, uh, I like the guy who says the things. Yeah anyway, so yeah, that's that's part one of our story. Oh yeah, the guy with the hair is hot as hell. Ye, I mean Jamie Lanister. Oh boy, let's let's just say I

Speaker 1would like that torture freedom. That doesn't really actually tie into the context of how that was used. But no, you'd you'd set him one fire. It's set him on fire. That's what I do. That's how I flirt fire. Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah yeah. So uh that's part one. I think we should all be clear on Eddie Burnet's is a bastard. Now, he had America hooked on cigarettes after he knew that they were killing people. So there we go. How do you feel after this, after this episode about our unheralded

Speaker 1founding father, Edward Burns, he seems more complicated than your average bastard. He is. He is. I hate when the bastard to do something good every once in a while. It makes my life harder. Yeah, rationalize, he's really complicated. He's not your hitler or your saddam um. Yeah, because he does do some good stuff he has He clearly has some good impulses behind him too. But also he also gets people hooked on cigarettes when you know it's going to call give him cancer classically cartoon villain. Yeah,

Speaker 1this is He's a challenging one. I'm I'm stressed out by this. Well, you're going to be even more stressed out in part two because in part two we're going to talk about how Edward Burnet's popularized bacon inspired the Nazis and helped launch a brutal forty years civil war in Guatemala. So okay, great, quite a career this fellow had. Why did he live so long? Why he lived for fucking ever? Yeah? He really would not die. It's like

Speaker 1your wife dies in nineteen eighty take the hint, Eddie, but no hints or not something Edward Burnet's takes. I wish he had smoked. Yeah, so do I. Well, Jamie, do you have any plug able to plug? Ah? Yeah, let me plug e uh, let's see. You can listen to the Bechdel Cast, my podcast with Caitlin Dronte every Thursday. You can. You can follow me on Twitter at Jamie Loft's Help, or if you live in the UK, I'll

Speaker 1be at Edinburgh Fringe Festival all August and you can find me on Twitter at I right. Okay. You can find this podcast on the internet find the best roots dot com. Well, we'll have all of these sources for this episode, including the what of the book The Father of Spin, which is a really good and balanced look at Rene's although he comes to a bit more positive of a conclusion on the guy than than we are in this episode. Um and you can find us on Twitter and Instagram at at Bastards Pod. You can buy t shirts at the public behind the Bastards. You can

Speaker 1also buy our branded Raytheon gear, including guidance systems for your own missiles. If you want to build the missile yourself, but have you know Raitheon equipment, launch it into say an apartment building. Um, we all do, We all do. That's why Raytheon is such a good sponsor of this podcast. So everybody have a good day, go out into the world and remember the Raytheon company motto of fuck it, we make money either way.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Jamie Loftus Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Part Two: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Robert concludes the story of Pastor Mackenzie's starvation apocalypse church with a really shocking mass murder.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    This week Robert takes us to Kenya, and the deadliest cult since the days of Jonestown. Prepare to meet Pastor Paul Mackenzi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. It Could Happen Here Weekly 258

    Nov 14, 20264 hr 13 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Part Two: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.

    Credit the people on this episode