In part 2, we follow Galton during his youthful rampage through the middle east and then Africa, and how his 'gap years' created the racism we all live with today.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Call zone media.
Speaker 2And we're back! Welcome back to Behind the Bastards, a podcast about the very worst people in all of history. And this week, we're starting our series on Francis Galton, the father of eugenics. And boy, what a wonderful day for an actual eugenicist, Milo Yiannopoulos, to have just gotten taken into custody by ICE for overstaying his immigration visa. And look, listen, folks, if someone... If you're one of the people who's been like, we shouldn't laugh in Milo Yiannopoulos being taken into custody by ICE, I want to
Speaker 2read you a post Milo made a couple of years ago. What is the etiquette if you're going about your business and find yourself observing an ICE raid? I want to show a little respect and decency. Are you allowed to masturbate where you stand in the street, or should you find some kind of awning or motor vehicle? No, it's really funny and good that he got taken into custody by the exact people who he enabled and cheered on his entire life. And now he's stuck in immigration jail looking like shit. You can see his fucking mugshot right now. We'll make sure we put that on the YouTube. Otherwise, just look it up. Fuck him.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Fuck this eugenicist.
Speaker 3You can laugh at leopards eating someone's face. That doesn't mean you like leopards eating everybody's faces, right? It's just.
Speaker 2We tried to stop the leopards from eating anybody's face, Milo. You were on Team Leopard, and now they're eating your face, and I just feel nothing for you. Nothing but joy. Yeah. Because, again, you're also a eugenicist, like Francis Galton, the subject of our episodes, but not like David Bell, the guest of our episodes. David, you're not a eugenicist, right? No.
Speaker 3I'm very moist right now, though.
Speaker 2You are moist. That's good.
Speaker 3That's good. It's because in the last episode, my cat was on the desk, and I got him off, and he spilled my Red Bull everywhere. I didn't realize until later. So I smell awesome. I smell radical. Like Red Bull. Yeah. I smell extreme.
Speaker 2Again, this is why Francis Galton was a eugenicist. If we had just applied more eugenics, you could have had a cat that doesn't knock things over. Probably. It has to exist. I actually don't think that does with the cats.
Speaker 3I think they have to not have legs.
Speaker 2I don't think you can breed that into cats. Yeah. I don't think there's any amount of the cat genome. I think every divisible chunk of the cat genome is... includes the knock shit off of a counter because it's fun gene like i just think that's that's integral to being a cat.
Speaker 3I get it like if you don't know what gravity is you why not still see it and you're like that's awesome.
Speaker 2Yeah exactly And speaking of beings without a conscience who are just doing shit to watch what happens, Francis Galton is touring the Middle East and North Africa, committing every kind of sin imaginable. He next visited Syria, where Ali slash Bob, the little coffee boy that they were traveling with, takes ill.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah, no.
Speaker 2He dies of what Francis describes as violent dysentery.
Speaker 3When you gave the kid a name, I was like, this can't end.
Speaker 2He's got to die a horrible death. Now, Galton pays for the tombstone, but writes that he doesn't attend the funeral because his presence as a Christian, quote, would have been seriously resented by the Muslims. And I know that it's common today. And first of all, I just need to say that's that's not true.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2It's not true that there's some sort of like wider prejudice among Muslims as a group against Christians or members of other faith attending funerals or other like a birthday or something like that of the like.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2Wedding. Similarly, it's been very common for a very long time in a lot of areas, at least for those to be interfaith events. If it's a mixed community that the people live in.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2That said.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I do think Ali's family probably didn't want him.
Speaker 2That's what happened, right? Okay. He's saying is like, Muslims just don't want Christians. Or I think it's that they don't want you.
Speaker 3And it wasn't his family. I can see him being like, oh, you're Muslim. You don't want Christians. And them going like, yeah, let's go with that. Yeah, let's go with that.
Speaker 2Let's say that. Let's say whatever keeps you away. And these are not his, Ali's family. These are just some random Muslims who know that a Muslim has died away from his home and that these white people aren't going to do anything to give him a proper burial. Right? That's what's happening here. I will say, in terms of looking into this, I did look into like, was it permissible in the past for members of other and like, as far as I can tell, yes, it certainly is today. Crescent Funerals, a Muslim funeral provider in Leicester, England, says it's fine on their website. I found a bunch of
Speaker 2like Muslim religious scholars saying stuff like, yeah, if like your mom isn't Muslim and she dies or like a friend, you can go to their funerals. It's like cool. God isn't angry about that. He judges people. It's not for us to do. That's the general attitude.
Speaker 3It seems like most religions has those things, right?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Who gives a shit, man?
Speaker 2Who gives a shit, man? You gotta live your life. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's what's going on. I think they didn't want him there because they knew he was a dick. And I think that's... I'm not being presumptive by saying... I don't think he was allowed at the funeral because he was too much of an asshole. In order to kind of make the case that he was probably being a gigantic asshole, I want to read you something he wrote in 1885 about his travels during this time. This is him as an older man looking back on his travels through the Middle East. And this is what came to his mind. Such a difference between the Berbers and
Speaker 2the Egyptians. You cannot strike a Berber, but may flog as many Egyptians and beat them with sticks as much as you like. They are thoroughly slavish. So when I say I think he wasn't allowed at the funeral because this is what he remembers about the time is the people you can and can't beat with a stick. That's what he remembers from his vacation. The Berbers don't let you beat them. The Egyptians do.
Speaker 3He would be at the funeral, like, using the boy as the chair for the funeral.
Speaker 2Yeah, he'd be fucking hitting people with.
Speaker 3The kid's corpse. Yeah, slapping the boy's corpse, just having a grand old time.
Speaker 2Like, that's what he took out of the whole country of Egypt, is you can really flog the shit out of these people. They don't do anything, huh?
Speaker 3I feel like there's got to be a lot of... like customs being used this way it's like the drinking age in canada right it's like they're not gonna bring it up unless you're an asshole right you can see a lot of that right a lot actually it's our custom that you get the hell away from us yeah.
Speaker 2Well our custom is you leave immediately that's our weird muslim thing is get the fuck out of my house yeah yeah um So Galton claimed to have sent Ali's property and due wages, the money that he'd earned so far, to his wife in Cairo after he died, along with a little present for herself and thought his duty fulfilled. This is clearly all I'll need to do. Alas, he writes, he'd, quote, his banker advised him to get out of the reach
Speaker 2of the law as soon as I conveniently could. And that's why he ends his trip in 1845. It's because he stiffs this dead kid's family and they're trying to pursue him for justice.
Speaker 3Right. He's, he frames that like he's being attacked, but he's like, and then in order to remedy this, I had to get away.
Speaker 2From the law. I had to flee the country.
Speaker 3Okay. Well, it sounds like a crime spree.
Speaker 2It's like you committed a lot of crimes, Francis. It's like, maybe you killed this kid. I don't know. Yeah.
Speaker 3I wouldn't put it past him if i was man if he was like i'm sending you a little gift i'd be like no i don't even want to know what you consider a gift.
Speaker 2Your husband's died here's a little present for yourself i got you some perfume.
Speaker 3Like what yeah i would not put that perfume on me no i don't know what it would be.
Speaker 2Yeah i don't know if it's what killed my husband now he sails home with two living tokens of his travels he takes open some home some like Living souvenirs, a pair of monkeys, and he's allowed to take them into England. They're supposed to go into quarantine, but he's a rich white man, so nobody makes him obey the law. However, upon his return to England, quote, He handed them with
Speaker 2many instructions to his landlady, who thought and perhaps said, Drat the beasts, and shut them up in the cold scullery, where they were found the next morning dead in one another's arms.
Speaker 3Jesus. Honestly. Yeah, that's bleak. That's like... Yeah. They died Titanic style.
Speaker 2Yeah. Hugging each other for warmth? Yeah.
Speaker 3My God.
Speaker 2Because you wouldn't put them in your room, and you're blaming it on his landlady? Like, they're your monkeys!
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3I expected that to go worse, to be honest. I knew the monkeys were going to die no matter what happened, but I thought maybe a few children were going to go too.
Speaker 2There's a sense of euphoria I think you do get when freezing to death that I've read about. Of the ways a pair of monkeys could die in London in the mid-1800s, probably one of the more merciful things that's quick.
Speaker 3It's funny because I guess this is True for many of your episodes, but it's it feels very true here where it's like when you bring a bad person on, a lot of the bad shit they do is often around like a specific theme of of things they believed in. This guy's just an asshole.
Speaker 2And that's like he's just.
Speaker 3A dumb asshole. You're right.
Speaker 2Like if you if you read the summaries of Galton's life, it'll always be he invented and it'll list all these different mathematical innovations in science because he invented a lot of important stuff. And then also eugenics, like he was a racist, but a scientific racist. And the way, again, the summaries make it feel is that like, well, he was an educated man of a different time who came to believe something bad. But there's people like that who are not. I mean, you can say they're a bad person because they do believe a terrible thing.
Speaker 3But they're not killing monkeys.
Speaker 2They're not like personally vile every moment of his life. As far as I can tell, Francis Galton was an obscene human being every moment of his adult life. Like just a thorough sinner, like a vile man to his core. as bad as it.
Speaker 3Could be special kind of asshole where like yeah everything he does is like adjacent to something awesome that somebody could do like i'm all for bringing some monkeys sure.
Speaker 2Take some monkeys to england that does sound like a good time.
Speaker 3Yeah and listen if the monkeys do a light rampage then so be it sure but like yeah then the fate of the monkeys is it's so scummy where it's so he didn't fucking lazy to the monkeys and they died.
Speaker 2Yeah Yeah, I was worried he would be like, I would have to do a lot of like arguing with him and proving the science wrong in order to make it clear what a bad man he was. And no, just his life makes that clear. He was a fucking monster. He was an abominable person. And I should note here, because Galton was a statistics nerd, he might have found it interesting because I counted. He spends 70 words discussing the deaths of two monkeys and 17 discussing the death of Ali, a human being.
Speaker 3Not surprising. Not surprising. Honestly, not surprising.
Speaker 2Not surprising at all.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3He named the child.
Speaker 2He got a child and he named it.
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2So Francis spins the neck. Well, I don't know if it was a child because he had a wife. I don't know what age. He says coffee boy, but they call a lot of adults who aren't white boy. I think that's what the boy meant, right?
Speaker 3I don't know if that's worse.
Speaker 2I'm guessing he was young, but he had a wife.
Speaker 3He could have been 45 for all we know.
Speaker 2Who knows, given the way these people talk, yeah. Yeah. Francis spent the next few years living the life of an English gentleman, shooting and fishing from Wales to Scotland, and learning the ABCs of life in the English countryside. He writes that, like, I didn't know how to be an English gentleman because I never had to be before my dad died, so he has to figure that out now. And when he describes what he had to learn, it's how to shoot things. That's all there is. Aside from dressing right and being polite in public, it's just shooting. That's all being an English gentleman is, is shooting different things.
Speaker 2Bulwer writes of this time, he was invited to shoot on a friend's grouse moor in Scotland and spent a summer in the Shetland seal shooting and bird nesting.
Speaker 3Amazing.
Speaker 2I should note here, I don't know. It does look like the Scottish seals are endangered right now, although I don't know if they were in his time. So that may not be on him. But the black grouse nearly went extinct in Scotland during this period of time because of guys like, because of Galton and guys like him. Anyway, after several restless years of shooting animals and reading books, Galton decided to undertake a proper expedition to Africa in 1850. And by this point, he's evolved enough as a person, I think he's pushing 30 at this point, he no longer wants to be a tourist, right? He wants to
Speaker 2be an explorer. Schumacher notes this in her dissertation, and this is what he wrote about his motivations in 1849. Blank spaces in the map of the world were both large and numerous, and the position of many towns, rivers, and notable districts were untrustworthy. The whole interior of South Africa, and much of that of North Africa, was quite unknown to civilized men. Right? So there's just not maps of this area that people do have been living in for forever, and that's what he wants to go over there, is to make, like, maps of these blank spaces. Could he not? No,
Speaker 2we talked Yeah.
Speaker 3Could he just not? Could he not? I just, everything, like, now I'm off to Africa, and it's like, don't, man, son of a bitch.
Speaker 2I'm not anti, obviously, like, it's good that scientific maps that are, like, universal around the world exist now. That's a positive change. Yes, no, it's him specifically. It didn't need to be him. It didn't need to be him.
Speaker 3It's like... it's like you ever have like that scumbag friend who's just like i'm gonna become a mall santa and you're like no oh please.
Speaker 2Really no are you're allowed to be around kids again i thought that was like a five-year okay yeah so i talked recently about percy faucet who's an explorer from like a generation or two after galton's heyday and that he was doing the same thing he was another monster who went to go make maps of places that didn't have maps Francis was right at, but not quite at the start of the quest to map the world. And like most things in life, in his life, he secured his initial in to the Royal Geographic Society via nepotism
Speaker 2because his cousin was a prominent member. He gets everything in his life through nepotism. Very important part of the Francis Galton story. He does not ever in his entire life earn a single thing just on his personal merit. Never once.
Speaker 3He doesn't try once.
Speaker 2Never once. He does try, but he tries with significant effort. It's like trying to be nine foot tall when you have a ladder. Right?
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2The society helps him plan his first expedition to map chunks of West South Africa. Over the next two years, he had repeated contact with three different groups of native people. The Nama were heavily employed as servants by the Dutch and thus were quite westernized. The Herero and Ovambo weren't. In her dissertation for the University of Canterbury, Susan Schumacher just summarizes his impressions of these different peoples. Galton was unimpressed with the Nama and felt superior to them as he outsmarted the current chief, Janker Afrikaner, and managed to secure both passage for himself and convince the chief to
Speaker 2sign up to a western-style legal code, which prescribed Janker's behavior particularly against the Herero. whom they were murdering and stealing cattle from at the time. Galton also disliked the Herrero. While he considered them to be aesthetically pleasing, magnificent models for sculptors, he was critical of their moral and intellectual attributes. Describing the Herrero, or Damaris as he called them, he writes, there is hardly a particle of romance or affection or poetry in their character or creed, but they are a greedy, heartless, and silly set of savages. The Damaras have a vast
Speaker 2number of small superstitions, but they are all stupid and often very gross, and there's not much that is characteristic in them. So again, he doesn't speak their language. He doesn't really know anything about their art or culture. He's meeting these people as part of a surveying mission and trying to get them to sign treaties to help the local colonials. This is the same as if someone had met Galton and his friends earlier. when they were murdering and whoring their way through North Africa and been like, ah, so this says everything. Europeans don't make art. All they
Speaker 2do is just molest people. And like, well.
Speaker 3Kill monkeys occasionally.
Speaker 2Yeah. There's more to the culture than just Francis Galton, right?
Speaker 3Yeah. He's lost all privileges here to judge anything.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. Given his fucking behavior. Oh, yeah. The only local peoples Galton liked were the Ovambo, which again are the people who were like, Commonly used as slaves and servants by white people in the area. And so they're very westernized. He referred to them and praising them as being very domestic. And he applauded the lack of pauperism in the country. That means everyone's working for white people. So there's not anyone unemployed because any black person who doesn't work for a white person is unemployed. Right. That's
Speaker 2his attitude. And even though he likes the Ovambo, he still talks at length about how ugly he finds them, and he talks a lot negatively about their women in particular. He really likes to comment negatively on how gross he thinks specific women are. He puts this in his scientific papers home about his investigations of this culture. Galton returns home to Europe after this journey, more racist than ever, and a hero for his groundbreaking exploration of South Africa. He receives a Society Gold Medal, and the year after
Speaker 2he got back, he wrote a book about his experiences that became a bestseller all across England. Critics at the time did note that he really seemed to have some very strong and very specific opinions about the native people. His scientific recollections are replete with descriptions of, in the case of the Ovambo, ugly, bony men. But he again saved specific graphic distaste for the Ovambo women, who he described as decidedly nice looking. Their faces were open and merry, but they had rather coarse features and shown all over
Speaker 2with butter and red pigment. They have like cosmetics that they apply to themselves that he gets like stains his nice linen clothing when he's trying to molest them. And that really upsets him. Galton also exhibited a fascination with measuring and quantifying the bodies of native peoples. He likes to measure them to like determine how long their arms are and their This is pre-eugenics. He's doing this before that. He's just fascinated in measuring people. He would later justify
Speaker 2this by his work in eugenics and his standing as a prominent race scientist. But his writing at the time, before he comes up with those things, proves that his initial interest in measuring people is not scientific. It's sexual. In his biography of Galton, Bulwer writes about the time Francis used his quote, sextant for an unusual purpose. And a sextant is like a tool that you use generally when you're on a boat and stuff, but it's for like determining like where you are, right? It's a navigational tool, but you can use it to determine like distance and stuff. So you could use it to like figure out measurements.
Speaker 2I don't, I'm not, I don't understand the math, right? But what happens is that while he's visiting the Herrero, Galton meets the wife of his interpreter. And this lady is really hot. He describes her as a Venus among the Hottentots, right? The Hottentots are the Herrero. and a Venus is a European, like Venus is the European god of like beauty, or not European, but the Greek god of beauty and love. And for, by this point in time, because they're not pagans, but the term a Venus is a term anyone in Europe would recognize as a hot lady, right? That's what he's saying, is she was hot, right? So
Speaker 2there's this hot lady who's the wife of his interpreter, and as soon as he looks at this woman, he describes himself as being perfectly aghast at her development. He's talking about like her measurements, right? She's got a large breasts, right? That's what he's talking about, right? So he inquires of his white friends. And they told him that she was, quote, the lady who ranks second among her people for the beautiful outline that her back affords. In other words, she's got the second best ass in the tribe, is what
Speaker 2the white people say of this woman. Which gives you an idea of how common it is to sexualize these people among the whites.
Speaker 3Is it? Yeah. I guess here's the question. yeah this does feel it's getting weird like 4chan incel speak you know.
Speaker 5What i mean yeah yeah and i know it's like probably how they talked back then this is the equivalent of him saying like she's got some sweet milkers or whatever but like it's it's feels.
Speaker 3Grosser it feels grosser yeah it's what he's doing too is like there's certain industries right where like Like the, you know, you ever hear, you always hear those stories about like a fertility doctor impregnating a bunch of women. And it's those occupations where I feel like when someone was like, I want to be a fertility doctor, the first question you have to ask them is, why?
Speaker 2Why?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, our episodes on fertility doctors are literally all fertility doctors are bastards because it keeps happening. Not to all of them, but a lot.
Speaker 3Right. It's one of those industries where it's like, listen, there are people who are like, I believe in this and I want to help families, but you're going to get some freaks. I feel like the medical industry is, has done a better job over the years of weeding out, you know, serial killers and rapists.
Speaker 2They're really working on it, yeah.
Speaker 3But this is the era where there's a lot of that.
Speaker 2No one's trying to.
Speaker 3Where it's like, no one's screening. So if someone's like, I want to be a serial killer. Oh, you know what I could just do? I could just go to medical school.
Speaker 2Just be a doctor.
Speaker 3I can cut whoever I want as much as I want. Right, using this like the- Or be this kind of scientist. Front of science, where it's like, it doesn't mean they can't contribute, but it does mean that it's like sadists getting an opportunity to be sadists.
Speaker 2Yes, or in his case, perverts getting an opportunity to be a pervert, because that's what this is about for him.
Speaker 3Yes, he's a pervert.
Speaker 2These white people about this hot lady, and they're like, oh, the only person with a better ass is the chief's wife, her mother. And then they say the latter, the chief's wife, however, was slightly passé, while as the former was in full en bon poids, right? Which I think I'm pronouncing that sort of right. It's like a French term for in good shape, right? So they're saying that, well, her mom has a better ass, but she's getting kind of old. And so this lady is really, like, she's really at the prime age, right? Now, I'm going to continue with Galton's writing about what he does because he sees this
Speaker 2hot woman, right? It's a horrifying scenario.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2And I really dared not ask my worthy missionary host to interpret for me because it's like his wife, basically. I therefore felt in a dilemma as I gazed at her form. The object of my admiration stood under a tree and was turning herself about to all points of the compass, as ladies who wish to be admired usually do. She couldn't, like, see me, and she was just, like, walking around. But she was, like, turning around so I could see her ass. I could tell that.
Speaker 3She didn't have to say it. I knew it.
Speaker 2She knew, right?
Speaker 3She liked it.
Speaker 2Of a sudden my eye fell upon my sextant. The bright thought struck me, and I took a series of observations upon her figure in every direction, up and down, crossways, diagonally, and so forth, and I registered them carefully upon an outline drawing for fear of any mistake. This being done, I boldly pulled out my measuring tape and measured the distance from where I was to the place she stood, and having thus obtained both base and angles, I worked out the results by trigonometry and logarithms. So because he wants to measure this lady's ass and tits and stuff,
Speaker 2but he can't ask her, he uses a sextant and his knowledge of geometry to get her measurements without her knowing.
Speaker 3Get real incel energy.
Speaker 2Also real metaglasses energy. This guy would have been the first in line to fucking buy metaglasses if they'd been around in his time.
Speaker 4Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3I was thinking like, oh, these days you just take a picture on the subway, I guess.
Speaker 2This is advanced technology. Yeah, very advanced pervert. He is, you gotta give him that.
Speaker 3Yeah, he's a pioneer of perverts.
Speaker 2It took a lot more effort to be that kind of pervert in the Victorian era.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3That's amazing.
Speaker 2It is, and also, I had not realized, I had always assumed, because I've known for a long time, we've talked on the show about scientific racism, and that all comes out of Galton's science. He's the father of all of that. And to realize that the origin of all of that, of all of eugenics, of all of this skull measuring- Is him trying, because he thinks this black lady's hot, but he can't say anything about it. So he's like secretly trying to get her measurements. That's, it's always been prurient. It's always been pornographic for these people. Up to today, the races today are no different, you know?
Speaker 1Oh yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3Again, I would argue most people are perverts in some way in this world.
Speaker 2You don't have to be unethical about it. Right.
Speaker 3The judgment, the test of your perversion is how you deal with the fact that you're a pervert.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 3You've got to contend with being a pervert. Yeah.
Speaker 2The ethical thing to do is find someone who either shares your perversions or is okay indulging yours consensually. Right? Right. He's not, he doesn't care. None of them care about that, especially.
Speaker 3In the 1800s, right?
Speaker 2It's just consent, right?
Speaker 3Pervert plus consent is generally going to be all right.
Speaker 2It is important you understand, though, that all of what comes later, all of eugenics is based in a prurient and often sexual obsessive interest in the bodies of non-white people, right? Yeah. That they have to justify because you're not supposed to, right? Because it's like that to race mix. So you have to find an excuse, you know? Yeah. And again, he's having sex with a lot of non-white people. Rape, usually. I can't tell. I mean, I assume sometimes there were people who had chosen to work in a brothel. That said, it's the 1800s. I don't know how relevant things like consent are when we're talking about a brothel in 1840. Anyway,
Speaker 2to say Galton's writing was popular would be a massive understatement. He is, in fact, one of the writers who invents the grammar of Victorian-era exploration and conquest.
Speaker 3You know?
Speaker 2Like, when we... Whenever you read basically any writing justifying colonialism, it owes something to Galton. He creates the language with which we talk about colonialism. His first book was such a hit that he got to write a second in 1855, and The Art of Travel became a bestseller and, in modified form, a textbook for the Royal Geographic Society. This is the book that teaches you how to run an expedition and how to meet native peoples and interact with them. Oh, good.
Speaker 3I'm glad he wrote a book about this.
Speaker 2I'm glad the guy who never learned any of the local languages, really, and was never interested in any of the cultures he came to, wrote the book on how to, like, be an archaeologist slash you know anthropologist in this this period of time that's good yeah that's helpful here's ads anyway and we're back and by the way we do not stand with that statement i mean quite frankly i i think that people from michigan are the same as the rest of us you know whatever our advertisers said about them that's not our stance on michiganders so We apologize,
Speaker 2but obviously, you.
Speaker 1Know, the people at Buc-ee's have strong opinions.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Look, Buc-ee's needs to apologize to your parents because those ads, which may have been deleted. Maybe you guys didn't hear the Buc-ee's ads that are really racist against Michiganders, but they've been airing them on our podcast. So reach out to Buc-ee's. Ask why they hate people from Michigan. You know, email Buc-ee's and talk to them about why they hate everyone in Michigan. I don't know why. That's not my choice. You know, that's Buc-ee's. Anyway. Fucking Circle K, I'll take over at goddamn Bucky's.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3Fucking Bucky's.
Speaker 2So he's a leading man.
Speaker 4I love that for you.
Speaker 2He's a leading man in his field now and in Victorian England. So he's also just like one of the most prominent men of his day because he's rich and he is now famous, right? So he is a celebrity after this point and very influential. Galton, thus, gets to join in on the great debates of the day. And the great intellectual debates of his day are increasingly centered on race and As Schumacher notes in her paper, there are a number of different theories as to where human beings came from in this era. And most people are either monogynists and thus believe that all humans share a
Speaker 2single common ancestral pair because the Bible said so. There's people who. believe basically that now, but for not Bible reasons, for reasons of maybe genetically, that's what happened, right? We don't 100% know, right? And the upside of this belief, though, if you do believe that all human beings descend from the same ancestral pair, it can make, other people take it different directions, but it can make a powerful argument for the equality of all peoples. The Christians who are abolitionists in the early and mid 1800s, In part, they're abolitionists because they believe that, like, we're all, like, God
Speaker 2made us all, right? Like, you know, we're all descended from Adam and Eve. We probably should have known each other, right? Again, monogamous were still often very racist. They came up with different explanations for why some people are less equal than the rest. But also, there were always among the monogamous some wide-eyed maniacs who would, like, read the Bible and go, well, how does this not mean we're all equal? And if you take that too far, pretty soon you got John Brown on your hands, right? Which is good, you know?
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. Polygenism was the other big theory. and this anticipated that the different races of the world were different species with divergent and separate histories. And people found biblical justifications for this too, but it was much more popular among men who had discarded their faith. And Galton is in the process of discarding his faith in this period. He doesn't, he's not religious. He's not really an atheist yet, but he's not religious. That said, he hasn't discarded his prejudice. And so if you're the kind of person who doesn't
Speaker 2really believe that much in Christianity, but you're still a bigot, you can see this as a justification for like why people who don't look like you aren't human. Now, right. in the modern era, I think the, the, by far the most supported stance is that like all human beings share common ancestors. There is debate as to when did we fully become like what we would call modern day humans? And is it possible that like people left Africa and evolved into Homo sapiens separately from other groups? There is
Speaker 2some debate about that. I don't, and I'm not qualified to weigh in on it. Obviously there's people on that side. I think most people who are like, well, but that doesn't mean they're less human. It just means that we took People took different– and as we come to understand more about– because there are– all of us have non-human DNA pretty much to some extent, whether it's Neanderthals or Denisovans or what they call like ghost DNA, which is DNA from a similar to human, enough to interbreed, but non-human species.
Speaker 3That would have contributed, right, to us. Not as cool as what I thought it was.
Speaker 2I'm sorry.
Speaker 3No, Robert, we all come from, didn't you know we come from lobsters? Have you heard of Jordan Peterson?
Speaker 2Yes, we do inherit much from the lobsters.
Speaker 3Lobster serotonin is why hierarchies are good.
Speaker 2I've always said that, yeah. So anyway, there's debate about this to this day, and I don't think that debate means that anyone's less human than the other. Also, if fucking Denisovans or Neanderthals were around today, I would support them having rights because they were clearly intelligent sapient beings.
Speaker 3I understand a bunch of people standing around and thinking, why the fuck are we all here? What are we doing here?
Speaker 2What do I look different? It's a thing to figure out at a point.
Speaker 3It's a thing to figure out and it might inform learning about basic human nature might inform some things about us today. Much like religion for some people, This is all going back to finding ways to justify your current behavior with these people, right? Is it like, I just want a way to justify feeling like I'm the main character in some way.
Speaker 2It's the difference between I need to understand the genetics of these people because like sickle cell anemia is more common among folks who are inherited, you know, or who descended from this line. And we want to cure that. So we need to understand certain things about genetics in order to try to treat sickle cell anemia. to being like, oh, well, because those people have this, that means they're less human than me, right?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2People can take kind of the same starting point, and if you're an asshole, you wind up with bigots, and if you're not an asshole, you wind up trying to solve illnesses, right?
Speaker 3It's why, like, I know the alpha male thing is stuff of wolf prison rules or whatever.
Speaker 2Right, yeah.
Speaker 3But it's that same principle, right? Or it's Jordan Peterson with the lobster, where it's that I'm going to use this, like, pseudoscience or even real science to justify why... unfair systems exist today yeah and therefore it's natural you know.
Speaker 2Yeah exactly so the the question is not who was like right because today we don't call this monogamous or whatever we call it like the out of africa hypothesis i forget what the other one is called but there are still there's still debate the debate just shouldn't be about like who's a person right the.
Speaker 3Answer is ultimately it's like who gives a shit right like yeah i.
Speaker 2Mean you should give a shit out but it shouldn't change how you treat people it's just like interesting as to like for example carrying about like i don't know which ancient peoples did which genocides to whom doesn't mean that like you support punishing people because their ancestors the assyrians did this thing.
Speaker 3Right exactly and of course the further we get from all of that it like not that it matters but it's like You know, again, the further we get from all that, the more people are going to have to sit around and go like, what the fuck? Why are we doing this podcast? What is this? How did this all start? Who's to blame for all of this? But it really shouldn't inform the way we treat anybody ever.
Speaker 2That's the problem.
Speaker 3That's the problem. Yeah.
Speaker 2So you've got your monogynists and you've got your polygenists. Right. And Galton is kind of he's a polygenist. Right. He believes that these other races are not really human beings. And that's part of kind of involved in his like growing atheism in this period of time. Now, these are not universal views. As I said, there's a lot of debate and there's debate about how you should treat people and how you should see these different native peoples. One of the first really popular explorers to counter the attitudes of men like Galton was David Livingston. If you've ever
Speaker 2heard like Professor Livingston, I presume, right? Like the guy who like, yeah, yeah. That's David Livingston.
Speaker 3I don't know what the fuck that's from.
Speaker 2He was a scientist and he was a missionary, right? Who winds up in like the middle of fucking Africa. and he gets awarded a medal in 1856 for African exploration. Here's how Schumacher's paper describes his views. He reported being kindly treated by the natives and that they were remarkably civil and generous. Livingston had faith in the educability and the industry of the native races. Richard Burton, also a contemporary of Galton's, held vastly different views, describing an African tribe, the Wanika, as a feudal race of barbarians, drunken and immoral,
Speaker 2cowardly and destructive, indolent, greedy, and thriftless. So if the views on race can be thought of on a continuum then, while not an outlier, Galton's views of African natives were generally at the negative end, and he had little concern about being outspoken in his writings about his beliefs. So guys like Livingston are like, well, no, these are like people. And they're actually really great. You get to know them. If you learn their language, they're pretty chill. Right.
Speaker 3It's the idea of describing Native Americans as they're so stoic and serious and angry. It's like, no, they're angry at you.
Speaker 2They're angry at you. You fucked some shit up for them, man. Right.
Speaker 3You're describing how they felt about you as if it's what makes up their people. It turns out if you're not a dickhead... they might actually be quite nice to you.
Speaker 2Yeah, it'd be like if I came back from Iraq and was like, there's something in Iraqi culture that makes them really like bottled water. And it's like, no, just because of a wide variety of political things, the water's not fucking trustworthy. Like, a lot of the time in war-strewn areas, so they need to use bottled water. Like, they don't prefer it. It's just the only option they have. But you're not, like, people like him aren't thinking about shit that way. People like Livingston are, though. So again, you should condemn Galton and Burton and the like for not thinking of shit like this, because guys like Livingston are perfectly capable of it, right? This is a choice
Speaker 2people are making to be bigots. Francis returned home to England in time to spend the Christmas of 1852 with his mother and sister. He met a girl during this visit, Louisa Butler, and the two were engaged to marry by April of 1853. They traveled some and rented a few places while he kept writing books and doing his research on the increasing obsession of his life, race. In 1857, he purchased a home in South Kensington and would spend the rest of his life there working as a scientist. He transitioned then from the life of an active explorer to that of a rich man sitting at a high
Speaker 2level at the RGS helping to plan out expeditions and then critiquing the failures and successes of the men who actually went out to explore. He wrote one to one younger explorer after, so there's this debate over the origins of the Nile and And there's this legendary explorer, John Henning Speck, who turns out to be right about where the Nile is, but he winds up in a disagreement with everyone else in the RGS, including, well, a lot of other people in the RGS, including Galton. And Galton... Eventually, this guy Speck dies, right? He accidentally shoots himself while
Speaker 2he's doing one of these hunting trips that these guys are always doing. And afterwards, Galton writes like a friend of this dude who is dead. What he could have done and what you can do is to state accurately what you saw, leaving the stay at home minute science to collate the data. In other words, like. Well, where Speck went wrong is he tried to have ideas of his own. You should leave that to the smart, rich guys who don't go out and explore anymore. Like, leave the smart stuff to us. Don't think about things. Just report, you know? He didn't act that way when he was
Speaker 2in the field, but that's what he wants other people to do, right? And so Galton's life went on. Periodically, he took the time to publish articles with his growing theories on race. In the 1859 publication of The Origin of Species by his older cousin, Charles Darwin, electrified and inspired him. And this is what seems to have made him into fully an atheist, right? He reads this book by Darwin and he was like, okay, that explains it. There's no God. And like a lot of people have that attitude, right? To be fair. Yeah.
Speaker 3I have killed God. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. Darwin got him. Fucking spirit his ass. Um, Darwin had opened, uh, his book by discussing the breeding of livestock for specific traits, because that's relevant when you're talking about natural selection. Galton was struck with an idea though, when he read that portion, an idea that hadn't occurred to Darwin, which is like, what if we do that to people? Right?
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2Well, if we could do that to livestock, why can't we breed people to have more traits that we want? Right? What's wrong with that? Right? Yeah.
Speaker 3I'm not a dark, this isn't like a dark.
Speaker 2This isn't going to go anywhere bad. So he, he, Yeah, he publishes his first writing on what would come to be called eugenics in 1865. This two-part article published in Macmillan's magazine was titled Hereditary Talent and Character, and it introduced practical elements of early race science to the educated public. He writes, quote, The power of man over animal life and producing whatever varieties of form he pleases is enormously
Speaker 2There actually already was going on in this period of time an experiment into what if you breed people together who have only the best traits? As far as what we rich Europeans consider the best traits, what if you only let those people breed with each other? And what happens is you get the Habsburg monarchy, like the Habsburg family, who are horribly interbred to the point that you've got people on the throne not far from this period who are unable to function because they're horribly inbred, right?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2It's not good.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3It's the thing, like, they're not... People aren't fucking Pokemon. You can't, like... I don't know.
Speaker 2It's not how intelligence works. He doesn't understand recessive traits, so he thinks if you've got a smart man, it'll make another smart kid, right?
Speaker 3Right, exactly. The problem is.
Speaker 2He doesn't understand nurture.
Speaker 3I mean, there's a lot of problems. But one of the problems is, like, what is a better person is an impossible question. And the idea of, like... someone's decision of what makes a better person is all wrapped up in culture and prejudice and all sorts of terrible things and not understanding what it means. And like, you know, capitalism and the system in place and like how a person functions within that. None of that means anything.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 3Ultimately.
Speaker 2If you let the people who have, like, the most influence over, like, what gets written and what rich people think is credible determine who gets to breed based on the characteristics they most value, you'll get a bunch of people, you'll get a country full of nothing but people with substacks, right? Right. And you won't have anyone who knows how to, like, make or do anything, because these people don't know how to make or do anything, right? Right. It's the idea that- Galton never did anything really on his own, like, No, it's.
Speaker 3Just why diversity is actually strength. That's not just a saying. No, the more diverse group of people you have putting their heads together and putting their cultures together and putting their experiences together means that they're better equipped for anything that might happen.
Speaker 2It's why, for example, if you look at the mathematicians who are going to come about 100 years after this, like Albert Einstein... Not a guy who was bred, a guy who came from what he would have considered, what Galton would consider inferior gene stock, right? And when I said Galton never did anything, yeah, he does have a lot. He makes a lot of advancements in statistics and like math because he's a rich guy everyone listens to. He's not the only guy who could have thought of those things. He was just the guy that wasn't starving to death with that kind of a mind because he was born rich, right? Right.
Speaker 2That's what I mean. Like.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I don't have that much respect for even the good things he did because it was all on fucking easy mode because he was born rich and in charge of the British fucking empire. Right. So the core of this piece that Galton has put together, this 1865 article, that's like a precursor. He hasn't invented the term genetics yet or eugenics yet, but he's starting to think about it. And the core of his argument was that men of good breedings.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2Like he kind of collects a bunch of stories of men of good breeding to see how many times these like men who are like significant have kids who go on to be also significant.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2So he's trying to prove that great men are likelier to have children who are great men, sons. He's not really concerned with the daughters, but great men are more likely to have sons who are imminent men. And that's right. And they have better genes.
Speaker 3You know what is great it's it's that idea yes we're.
Speaker 2Gonna talk about all this it's like if.
Speaker 3Someone's like a successful lawyer right and it's like well he must be a great man and it's like no he's just good at the fake.
Speaker 2Good at making money in this way yeah.
Speaker 3About this thing and he happens to have a lot of money and and he can afford nice things A big.
Speaker 2Part of Galton's calculus is going to be like, wow, a lot of great lawyers have sons who are great lawyers. It must be because genetically they're more inclined to be great lawyers. And it's like, is it that or his dad owned a law firm? And so he got a really huge leg.
Speaker 1Up, right?
Speaker 2It would be like being like, wow, there's something in the Quaid genetics that makes for great actors. And that's why Jack Quaid has been a success. No, as Jack Quaid would say, he had a real leg up, right? He's a great, good actor. I like Jack Quaid, but he's Meg Ryan's son. His last name's Quaid.
Speaker 3It helps. the irony here and like it's the thing if listen if you're rich that doesn't mean you're useless piece of shit necessarily however this line of thinking creates a situation right where like you're actually doing the opposite and by like encouraging like oh these rich people need to have tons of kids because they're a better stock it's like i if anything you're putting in more people who are don't have to like learn or fight their whole lives who live, they're actually doing the opposite by
Speaker 3this line of thinking.
Speaker 2It's the difference between J.R.R. Tolkien, who writes the Lord of the Rings and is like, he fucking has to fight in World War I. He's not a guy who gets like being a great author handed to him on a platter versus Christopher Paolini, the arrogant kid whose parents own like a publishing house. And so like when he's a kid and he's probably not really ready, he gets like a book published and they're able to like really push it to be very popular. It's just less impressive than what Tolkien did because it was handed to this kid. Right.
Speaker 3And again, it doesn't mean that someone can't be talented. It just, it actually worsens their odds. It's like when a, It's like later directors where it's like no one's pushing back on the directors so they can make whatever they want.
Speaker 2Why aren't we as impressed by fucking Spielberg anymore, you know? Right.
Speaker 3Why does Megalopolis exist? Probably because no one was like, Coppola, no, you can't.
Speaker 2Do this, man. It's because you hit a certain point of wealth and fame in which you have no more adversity. And like art comes from adversity. And so does like achievement as a rule. It's just less impressive when there's no friction, right? Right. And there's never any friction in Galt's life. And he is as he's trying to prove that, like, good breeding is what really matters and what makes people great or not. He's just looking at other rich people who have lived frictionless existence. Well, look at how many of their sons wound up rich and famous, too. And that's that's really like most of what's going on with
Speaker 2his actual like science in this book. And it shouldn't be surprising that the inventor of eugenics was a rich kid who inherited his fortune and that he concluded that great men tend to have great children. He came to understand as a result of this research that breeding or nature was the main and most dominant factor in deciding men's mental capability. It's almost the only thing that matters. And therefore, it makes sense for the state to lavish resources in breeding support, not on the poor who are struggling, but on the rich and the already successful in order
Speaker 2to ensure that they have more kids, because that's what will make society better in the long run. Galton expressed fear that financial constraints and the desire to have a career often kept men of genius celibate during their prime breeding years, right? They're too busy trying to establish themselves in a career, and they don't have as many kids as they otherwise would. And so he suggests that society should take a role in encouraging and funding breeding between exceptional people. What an extraordinary effect might be produced on our race if its object was to unite in marriage
Speaker 2those who possess the finest and most suitable natures, mental, moral, and physical. At one point, he tried to calculate the frequency that men of ability are born in the general population, and he concluded only one in 3,000 people were naturally exceptional, which means that if you've got three or four exceptional men in the same family in just a couple generations, that's proof that they're thousands of times genetically superior than the common man, right? Completely ignoring wealth, completely ignoring influence, nepotism,
Speaker 2all of that stuff, right?
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2He calculated this. And the way he gets this number that one in 3,000 people are exceptional is also complete bullshit because he calculates this by using the number of college students educated in Europe over the last 400 years and comparing that to estimates of the general population.
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 2Because only all of the exceptional people naturally made it to college. There's no exceptional people who didn't get to go to college in 400 years.
Speaker 3Again, it's just like self-fulfilling. It's, you know, it's an echo chamber. It's just dipshit math.
Speaker 2It's like everything just compounds. Yeah. It's... fucking A. In the second part of that article, he suggested selective breeding for positive qualities in some groups and discouraged breeding entirely for other groups. And these other groups are nearly all non-white people that he had zero experience with. He never meets any of these people. He doesn't know them. He doesn't even talk to most of them. As Susan Schumacher writes, unlike his work with European populations, he makes no attempt to provide any evidence for his comments. He expounds at length about the American Indian, a race he has not
Speaker 2interacted with personally. And he makes no effort to indicate the source of his information. He maintains, however, that they are cold, melancholic, patient, and taciturn, but also patriotic, have strong local attachments, and a sense of personal dignity. As Michael Billing comments, the prejudices of the Victorian explorer were raised to the level of immutable biological facts.
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 2Like, and this is, he's not even seeing these people. He just heard a description of them and like, ah, the red man, cold and melancholic. And he's like, yeah, that's their characteristics. This has to be everything you need to know about them. Can't be anything else to learn. Right.
Speaker 3It's this guy removed from people that he's standing in front of often. Now, like removing himself even more from people and trying to make people.
Speaker 4Yeah these equations in his head and it is it's one of those things where it's like the idea that any of this thinking would be passed on it's in an educational setting is not good.
Speaker 2It is upsetting His scientific method is, of course, flawed across the board. But while he received some criticism at the time, it was usually less dire than modern scientist Ruth Schwartz Cohen's conclusion that, quote, rarely in history in the history of science has such an important generalization been made on the basis of so little concrete evidence. So badly put and so naively conceived. I do like that's her discussing his his work here. This 1865 article and a lot of his other stuff is that like, yeah. This is about the most ignorant bullshit that's ever been
Speaker 2turned into science.
Speaker 3It's baby shit.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 2Now, one positive thing you can say about Galton in this era is that he was not as bad as he would come to be because he doesn't yet think that interracial marriage should be banned categorically. And in general, he muted his real opinions on race for a while out of fear of public backlash. As he later acknowledged in his autobiography, Popular feeling was not then ripe to accept even the elementary truths of hereditary talent and character upon which the possibility of race improvement depends. Still less was it prepared to consider dispassionately any proposals for practical action.
Speaker 2So I laid the subject wholly to one side for many years.
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 2I hid my power level so that people wouldn't know I was a fucking proto-Nazi for a little while.
Speaker 3I can't believe you're like, he's not as bad as he will be. And it's like, he's already murdered several monkeys.
Speaker 2He's killed monkeys. He's a sex criminal.
Speaker 1Great.
Speaker 3Yeah, he's a sex criminal. He made a person his pet. Yeah, he sure did.
Speaker 2Yeah. In 1869, he published a book, Hereditary Genius, that took his initial list of successful men and their offspring and expanded it to collect data on many different kinds of successful people. This reinforced his belief that some people are inherently special, and he wrote that if the eminent men of any period had been changelings when babies, a fair proportion of those who survived and retained their health would have equally risen to prominence. You'll see this today, this attitude, like, well, if you were to take any billionaire and start them with nothing again at the bottom
Speaker 2of society, they'd wind up being rich and powerful again because they're just inherently better, right?
Speaker 3I assume you saw the- If Jeff Bezos, yes. No, you saw the interview of Elon Musk being asked if he had to start over with $ 1, 000 and he couldn't even understand the question.
Speaker 2No, no.
Speaker 3He doesn't know why.
Speaker 2He can't conceive it. Yeah.
Speaker 3He was like, well, I wouldn't have that. And it's like, yes, you idiot.
Speaker 2We're trying to- No, you fucking dipshit. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and these are comforting things to believe that like, oh, even if I was made to live as a poor person, I'd wind up successful again because I'm so inherently good. That's comforting if you're one of the most eminent men in your era, right?
Speaker 3Right, because I get it is like, If you become stupid rich, you got to tell yourself like, ah, it's because I'm so cool.
Speaker 2I deserve it. Right. And he went on to argue in his book, in this book, that just as men like him were superior to others in their society, his race, the white race, existed on top of a pyramidal hierarchy. And he wouldn't have said the white race, right? He would have said Anglo-Saxons because he doesn't believe, for example, like people in the Balkans, maybe even Italians aren't really white to him, right? Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3This is advanced racism.
Speaker 2This is advanced racism, right? But as people like him, as he is at the top of his own cultural hierarchy, people, his race is at the top of the global hierarchy of races. And at the bottom, of course, are black people and lowest of all, native Australians, right?
Speaker 3Again, it's very funny for a guy to be like, hey, everybody, I did the science. I spent a lot of time on the science. I determined that I'm the best of all of you. Yeah.
Speaker 2His arguments here are filled with flawed and faulty logic because, quote, no man. And this is how he argues that, like, people who are at the top now would always have been at the top. Quote. No man can achieve a very high reputation without being gifted with very high abilities, and thus, few who possess these very capabilities can fail, right? Because anyone who succeeds must have be talented, anyone who's talented will always be a success, right? Now, he does make occasional allowances to the fact that being born especially
Speaker 2richer to powerful parents might tip the scales a little, but these are never more than cursory gestures, and his actual research is universally dogshit. His favorite kind of eminent man, when he's talking about like men of eminence, the top kind is a judge because no mediocre man could ever become a judge, right? It's impossible for men who aren't impressive to be judges. All good judges. All judges are good. Ajag. So he saw the fact that many prominent families had multiple eminent members as proof of their inherent genetic superiority.
Speaker 2Per Bulwer, his biographer, He rejected the view that this was due to their having more opportunities of thrusting their relatives into eminence. He also stepped in to explain points where the facts deviated from his beliefs. Great military commanders, he found, rarely had sons who were equally successful. Now, this might be because that's not really a heritable. It's based on like your experiences, on like what you're at, how you grow up.
Speaker 3And right.
Speaker 2Like if you if you become an emperor. your kid probably doesn't have to fight his whole life to build an empire. And she's just not going to be as good at it as you, right? Probably. You get some exceptions like Alexander, right? But usually most great military leaders in history are not the sons of equally great military leaders. It actually happens fairly rarely. And he blames this on the fact that if married at all, they're mostly away from their wives on military service. Now, first off, this ignores all the rapes that these guys commit as they conquer cities around the world. But also even in this
Speaker 2period of time, I'm reading a book right now called incomparable, which is about like Napoleon Bonaparte's, the most elite like regiment in his entire army, the ninth infantry. And like, there's tons of stories about guys who've been in the French army for like decades and have like kids and stuff.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2It's actually like really common, even if you're constantly on deployment to have kids and just be away.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2That's actually certainly more normal for like officers and stuff than not. Um, Women, though, he felt clearly had some direct impact on their sons, but he was never able to give them as much credit as the men. Of course. Women had to be less responsible.
Speaker 1Oh, man.
Speaker 2That's so crazy to hear. That's a real idea, bro.
Speaker 3Oh, man.
Speaker 2The racist guy also hates women?
Speaker 1Oh, man.
Speaker 2Also doesn't like women?
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 2That's so crazy. He hates them. It's just that whenever he has an imminent man whose sons don't do anything cool, he's like, well, their mom must have watched. Oh, yeah. Yeah. It's great man genetics.
Speaker 3It's also so scientific to be like, surely the women had something to do.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3He is like so curious. Yeah.
Speaker 2Galton, as far as I can tell, is the first man. I mean, this belief exists. He's the first man to try to argue scientifically that women are less suited for science and math. And he does this. by citing the fact that great scientists credited their fathers in their biographies three times as often as they credited their mothers. So obviously, science genes can't be passed on by women, right?
Speaker 1Wow, what a guy.
Speaker 2Were their moms allowed to be scientists? Were they allowed to read? He said, fuck women. He said the great scientist who credits his early education to his sister? Hmm. Did she really have nothing to do with your inquiring mind, Francis?
Speaker 3Like, I don't know, man. Well, this is the thing about him is like this whole thing is about a guy who you've already brought me through the history of him being like the biggest jackass of his time.
Speaker 2Just the shittiest dick who ever sucked.
Speaker 3Yeah, this perfect storm of mediocre and like evil.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3And then him growing up to be like, I think some people are naturally better than others. I'm naturally better. And it's like your life is that that's not true.
Speaker 2You in fact are not.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2Now, Darwin sent a letter congratulating his cousin on the book, Hereditary Geniuses. Galton responded to his cousin with fawning praise, saying, I used to be wretched under the weight of the old-fashioned arguments from design, of which I felt, though I was unable to prove myself, the worthlessness.
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 2He's saying, like, I used to believe in, like, God had made all, and you freed me from that, Darwin. So I'm just so glad that you find something valuable in my arguments that, like, were better than everybody else. You know who else is better than everybody else?
Speaker 3Dave Bell.
Speaker 4Me.
Speaker 2Yeah, Dave. And the advertisers of this podcast, who might be Dave. I don't know. It seems unlikely, though. It does seem unlikely. And we're back. Galton's book became influential across a broad swath of English intellectual life. Darwin pronounced that the book had convinced him that education and environment could have only a small effect on the mind of anyone, as most of our qualities are innate. Galton had his critics, though,
Speaker 2particularly in the religious press. One of his more scientifically-minded reviewers, Herman Merivale, published a cogent critique of some of his methodology, as Bulwer describes. To illustrate his argument, Merivale pointed out that of the 250 clever relations of judges in Galton's list, more than 100 had been lawyers themselves, which seems strange unless we are to assume not only that talent is hereditary, but that the special breed of the lawyer is hereditary also. Okay, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Thank you for watching. of them. These Atkinses are credited
Speaker 2with seven or eight remarkable relatives, but of these there is only one who was not a lawyer, and he was a reader of Lincoln's Inn. This whole list has the unmistakable character of a snug little family of jobbers rather than a galaxy of genius. In other words, no one's heard of these judges. No one's heard of these lawyers. There's no evidence they're good at what they were doing. There's just evidence that because some of them were lawyers, they made others lawyers. It's nepotism. There's just evidence of nepotism. That's jobbers.
Speaker 3It's lawyers. We invented our own little language, and now we are the best at interpreting.
Speaker 2Now we're the smartest.
Speaker 3We're the smartest.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2This intellectual monument to self-congratulation is the foundation of eugenic science. This is what it's all based on, babe. Galton expanded on his established habit of throwing as many numbers at the reader as he could gather. This is a big part of even today, like the modern race science. Well, look at this statistic about IQ. Does IQ really tell you that much? Are the IQ tests good and consistent? Where are you getting your... Anyway, it doesn't matter. It's the thing where.
Speaker 3Any Ben Shapiro sentence takes a paragraph to break up. Honestly, yes.
Speaker 2You have to hit some people. And Galton should have been hit. Anyway, before this had been a mix of– like before this book, the numbers he threw out because statistics wasn't really all that figured out. They'd been a mix of his own primitive attempts at statistical analysis and measurements of people's bodies. But between 1865 and the publication of Hereditary Genius in 1869– Galton learned about Gaussian law and started applying modern statistical analysis to his findings. Often badly, but someone else at Vince, like, figures out and starts
Speaker 2writing about this way of doing statistics better. And that's what Galton is starting to add to his science in 1869. For example, he read about a demonstration by another scientist that showed that height, weight, and other measurements for a population fell in a bell-shaped distribution. He extrapolated from these results and observations about grades at Cambridge, and he developed an A to G classification of all men on Earth according to their natural gifts. Naturally, only white men were capable of reaching the highest categories, like F, and no
Speaker 2black people reached that.
Speaker 1Of course.
Speaker 2There's no black people who are that level, right? That just doesn't happen.
Speaker 3Science. It's science.
Speaker 2It's just science that I invented and figured out.
Speaker 3This is cocaine science. Yeah, this is cocaine science. Yes, this is meth science.
Speaker 2Yeah. As Schumacher writes, as with previous articles, these assessments appear to be based solely on his own experiences in Southern Africa, and he makes no attempt to produce a scientific or statistical explanations for his comments. One representative example of his logic would be his belief that the least impressive white travelers would automatically hold their own and mentally outfox any African chief, even.
Speaker 3In his home.
Speaker 2And this is based solely on the fact that Galton was pretty sure he'd once outsmarted an African chief.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2So any white guy could do it. Right.
Speaker 3Yeah. This is turning his like random inklings into science. He's like, I think I could take that guy. Therefore it's in the textbook.
Speaker 2Now, did he outsmart this guy by making him sign a shitty treaty? Or did the guy just know like, well, this guy's the representative of people with more guns than me.
Speaker 3This is, It's cult thinking, right? Like this is, if I started a cult, a lot of the stuff I'd write down would just be shit that I think.
Speaker 2That I believe already.
Speaker 3Yeah. Like about like, oh, I think my neighbor is a murderer. Okay. That's a new commandment. Like that's just, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. If I was doing my version of this scientist based on my own success, I'd be like, well, look, obviously if you want to be a success as a writer, you've got to lick heroin off of a guy's fingers in Russia.
Speaker 3Exactly.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Like it's the only way as far as I'm right. Based on my sample group of one.
Speaker 3Yeah, exactly. It works for you. Therefore, it works for everybody. They should teach it in like fifth grade.
Speaker 2It should be mandatory.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2The book Hereditary Genius was a hit, but it did inspire, as I've stated, more than a few detractors. Galton responded to some of the most prominent criticisms of Hereditary Genius, specifically the idea embodied in a review published by the Times of London that Universal knowledge of reading, writing, and ciphering in the absence of pauperism would raise the national grade or ability far greater than any and higher than any system of selected marriage, right? So the, again, the Times of London is like, look, if we just educate kids and make sure that they're not like starving, that will do more than making rich people easier for rich
Speaker 2people to breed, which is objectively true. And I have to note here that as I wrote this part of the episode, I was listening to music and the song Flagpole Sit Up by Harvey Danger shuffled on. And as I typed the words selected marriage, I heard these lyrics that in retrospect describe Francis Galton's intellectual journey in thousands fewer words than I've used. Been around the world and found that only stupid people are breeding, the cretins cloning and feeding, and I don't even own a TV. Right? That's Galton. That's Galton, baby. Yeah. That's what he believes
Speaker 2about the world.
Speaker 3Oh, man. I have to also note.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Hereditary genius.
Speaker 2Terrible.
Speaker 3Like that is it's a it's a it's a manifesto title or it's like it is.
Speaker 2This is the title of a kid who goes up and shoots up a fucking school. Yeah.
Speaker 3That are like a Pixies album.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3It's just it's. Yeah. It's, man, like the moment someone hands you a book that says, I wrote this, it's called Hereditary Genius. You don't read that. You burn that.
Speaker 2You might burn it, yeah.
Speaker 3You might. You throw it right in the fireplace.
Speaker 2Yep. In 1873, Galton wrote an article for Frazier's Magazine that the website ScienceAQ summarized as describing a future in which the genetic elite were incentivized by the state to procreate, while the genetically unfit would be barred from reproducing at all. In a contemporary letter to the Times of London, Galton suggested giving Africa to the Chinese, theorizing immense gain if Chinese people could outbreed and finally displace Africans, which is at least a unique kind of racial ethnic cleansing. I
Speaker 2haven't heard that specific idea before.
Speaker 3Wait, what did he say?
Speaker 2He wants to replace Africans with Chinese people in Africa because they're more industrious.
Speaker 3That's such a weirdly specific racism.
Speaker 2He's being racist about the Chinese, too.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, it really is. That year, Galton also first started to speculate about the categories his fellow Britons might fit into, analyzing and describing them with the same tools he developed to categorize native races. He disliked what he found. Too many sickly children were born to narrow-chested men and fragile, delicate women. Galton first came up with the infamous term.
Speaker 1Narrow-chested men!
Speaker 2I like that. Yes, yes, yes. Skinny fucks! Too many soy boys having babies! Galton first came up with the infamous term eugenics in the early 1880s. We don't know exactly when, but it's first published when he's working on a book called Inquiries into Human Faculty and Its Development. As Angela Siney writes in the book Superior... Galton coined the term in 1883 from the Greek prefix eu for well or good to describe the idea of using social control to improve the health and intelligence of future generations.
Speaker 2Schumacher gives a somewhat differing account of the origins of the word eugenics in her paper. She says he adapted the Greek word eugenies, which translated to mean good in stock and hereditarily endowed with noble qualities. Meanwhile, Anne Hanley, a lecturer in history of science and medicine and director of the MA program for medical humanities at Birkbeck, the University of London, gives a third explanation. He coined the term eugenics from the Greek meaning well-born to describe the betterment of the race through scientific interventions and social controls. So there's a little bit of disagreement, you know, on
Speaker 2the specifics here. But what everyone agrees is that he coins this term to define the bettering of the race through scientific and social interventions, right? Hanley notes that one of his direct inspirations was his cousin Darwin's documentation of breeding pigeons for specific characteristics. She adds, to facilitate his studies of human difference, Galton created the Anthropometric Laboratory, the archives of which are held in the University College London. He collected enormous quantities of data to prove that humans were subject to Darwinian natural selection in the same way
Speaker 2as plants and animals. Indeed, according to Galton and his followers, including Carl Pearson, who became the first chair of eugenics at University College London, the British race was degenerating, right? As he starts to turn these techniques, he's initially developed to analyze these people he's either seen or read about, and he turns them onto his own people. He starts to realize, oh my God, these poor people are outbreeding the rich people, and that means the British race is going to get weak. It's the idiocracy argument, right?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. In the 1870s, he had formalized the often perverted inclination he felt to measure the anatomies of people to determine their abilities and fitness for breeding, and his findings, he argued, proved that the streets of London were being flooded with subpar people. particularly Irish famine refugees who, having survived near extinction, took on what he described as a Negroid look, right? Wow, once these people starved to death, they look like the other starving people I've seen. That must mean that they're all genetically inferior, as opposed to again... Malnourished,
Speaker 2because they haven't had enough food. They're all malnourished because of people like you?
Speaker 3He's such a star. Simple guy.
Speaker 2Yeah, he's such a simple guy, right? And he wasn't just worried that these people are going to outbreed higher quality men and women. He's scared that they're going to destroy society. His work measuring human bodies led him to be the first scientist to discover and elucidate the principle of statistic correlation. And he'd noticed that the people who seemed to be breeding the most, the poor, also did the most gambling and fighting. And they didn't. Actually, it was incredibly common at the point of time that he
Speaker 2was alive for like rich children of rich families to waste their entire fortune gambling. That's how, like, all of the rich families of his era are going to lose their money. It's like their sons gambling it away, right? But he's like, he just sees the poor people gambling. That's different from rich people gambling, right? It's worse. And that's probably heritable. So we should probably do something about that. Maybe by stopping certain people from breeding.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2That's where Galton's going to land. And we'll talk more about that in part three. But we're done for now, Dave. How are you feeling?
Speaker 3I feel invigorated. Good. You know, by all this talk of just a terrible eugenicist. Just an awful man. An awful man. I'm going to build a cage and I'm going to find his bones. I'm going to dig him up. I'm going to dig him up. I'm just going to say I'm going to dig him up.
Speaker 2Yeah. Dig him up. And look, folks. Go out and find some bones of your own. Find someone else's bones. Someone you think is bad and dig them up. They're not using them. I just want to know, are you.
Speaker 1Guys both narrow-chested men? What's happening here? Because I'm an uncommonly good-looking female lunatic, and I just want to know, are you narrow-chested men?
Speaker 2There's only one way to find out, Sophie, and that's we've got to dig up as many bones as we can, and we've got to measure the shit out of them.
Speaker 3We've got to measure the bones!
Speaker 2Get your sextants out and start measuring, motherfuckers. You know?
Speaker 3We've got a plan.
Speaker 2We've got a plan.
Speaker 3Okay, everybody. Bye.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 2Bye.
Speaker 4Bye.
Speaker 1Behind the Bastards is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com. Or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Behind the Bastards is now available on YouTube. New episodes every Wednesday and Friday. Subscribe to our channel, youtube.com slash at Behind the Bastards.
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...
Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.