Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind the Bastards

Behind the Bastards artwork

Part Two: Peter Attia and the Cult of Longevity

Oct 15, 20261 hr 17 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In Part Two, Robert is again joined by Dr. Kaveh Hoda to discuss the rise and fall of the doctor at the center of the wellness podcast circuit: Dr. Peter Attia. From his stent as a McKinsey consult consultant to his pricey concierge longevity practice, a hit podcast, and a #1 bestseller. We break down "Medicine 3.0" and where the evidence holds up, where it doesn't, and how a smart, credible doctor can end up giving cover to the MAHA crowd. Finally, we get into his emails with Jeffrey Epstein, the fallout at CBS and his sponsors, and what it all says about doctors, fame, and wealthy patients. Content note: discusses Jeffrey Epstein and sexual abuse. Sources: Attia, Peter. Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity. March 28, 2023. Johansson, Minna, et al. "Continuous Glucose Monitoring for Persons With and Without Diabetes." JAMA, August 3, 2026. Khullar, Dhruv. "How to Die in Good Health." The New Yorker, April 15, 2024. Mann, Brian. "McKinsey & Company to Pay $650 Million for Role in Opioid Crisis." NPR, December 13, 2024. Martin, Kristen. "The Problem With Peter Attia: The Longevity Guru Turned Up in the Epstein Files. Should We Have Taken His Health Advice So Seriously in the First Place?" Slate, February 26, 2026. Ruetenik, Daniel, and Arden, Farhi. "Dr. Peter Attia, Longevity Expert, Apologizes for 'Indefensible' Emails to Jeffrey Epstein." CBS News, February 2, 2026. Tyrangiel, Josh. "The Epstein Spectrum." The Atlantic, April 3, 2026. Walker, Graham. "A Skeptic's Review of Peter Attia's Outlive." LinkedIn, January 13, 2024. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/skeptics-review-peter-attias-outlive-graham-walker-md-z6rsc Blum, Dani "Peter Attia's Ties to Epstein Spark Backlash From Doctors." The New York Times, February 10, 2026 Kaufman, Maya and Gardner, Laura. "I Think She Will Be Loyal: Jeffrey Epstein's Role in Peter Attia's Rise." Politico, March 16, 2026. Pollack, Neal. "The Plight of Peter Attia." The Spectator, July 15, 2025. Greene, Jenna. Epstein files up in lawsuit, over stock options by longevity expert, Peter Attia. March 20, 2026 Podcasts: The Peter Attia Drive. Episode 168, August 2021. The Peter Attia Drive. Episode 172, August 2021. The Peter Attia Drive. Episode 190, January 10, 2022. The Peter Attia Drive. Episode 298, April 15, 2024. The Joe Rogan Experience. Episode 1735, 1961 Jocko Podcast. Episodes 55, 56, and 392. The Tim Ferriss Show. Episode 398, "Peter Attia, MD: Fasting, Metformin, Athletic Performance, and More," November 27, 2019.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome back to Behind the Bastards, a podcast about the very worst people in all of history. And here to talk about, well, here to do a special reverse bastards episode where I don't have to research and write about a terrible person. My guest does is Dr. Kaveh Hoda, who has been very kindly teaching us about Dr.

Speaker 2Peter Attia. Yeah. Atiyah? I don't know, actually. It's a good question. Atiyah.

Speaker 3Atiyah.

Speaker 1Sorry.

Speaker 2Peter Atiyah. Peter, I apologize.

Speaker 4I know that.

Speaker 1You said that correctly. I got it wrong, because my brain does not hold pronunciations well.

Speaker 2I might be wrong. Listen, I don't know if I'm saying my own name right, so I can't be certain about anyone else. So sorry, Peter, if that's the case.

Speaker 1Who's to say?

Speaker 2Okay. You guys ready to get back into this?

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1Let's do it.

Speaker 3Okay.

Speaker 2When we left off, our hero, Peter Attia, had left the oppressive groupthink of medical training.

Speaker 1Finally.

Speaker 2It was finally. It was only a matter of time. He was pretty upset about not being appreciated for attempting to operate outside the Johns Hopkins protocols. Being a maverick. A renegade. Yeah. He doesn't play by the rules, but he gets results. Yeah. You want a rebel doctor.

Speaker 1That's what you want. That's right. I love it when my doctors are rebel.

Speaker 2That's really outside the box.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2Getting weird with medicine. Yeah.

Speaker 1That's what you want. A lot of people say smearing poop into an open wound is bad for you, but they're just sheep. I like to get away from the herd. I like to try new things.

Speaker 2Yeah. Get that in there real good. Can we stop this?

Speaker 5Yep.

Speaker 1Nothing's bolder than sepsis i i don't get.

Speaker 3I don't get paid enough for this shit can we that.

Speaker 2Yeah well i mean if you didn't stop me i might have gotten stuck in that yeah it is it is disturbing how easily my brain can just like in like get into that role of the manosphere dude and that is it's easy it's funny to work on the joke about yeah Yeah.

Speaker 1But back to Petar.

Speaker 2So let's get back to him. So he decides to join, leaving the residency, decides to join a consulting firm called McKinsey and Company. Oh, good.

Speaker 1Oh, I'm glad they're showing up. That's fun.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, I was going to ask. Real peak McKinsey years.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. Okay.

Speaker 1They're one of those like bloodless consultants. Sorry, you're going to talk about them. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, no, no.

Speaker 2Please, please, please.

Speaker 1They're one of those like consulting firms who you bring in to tell like, here's how many people you should fire to maximize shareholder value and the like, right?

Speaker 2That is correct. They are a global management consulting firm that advises major corporations, governments, both here and abroad, and institutions on strategy operations some.

Speaker 1People call them bloodless ghouls but right no i don't because i i support actually the bloodless ghoul community you are valid you are beautiful and i love you bloodless.

Speaker 2You are seen they are one of the most influential oldest and maybe controversial consulting firms in the world let's talk about them because he decided to go work for them and i think that says something about a person good sign So they're firm with the history of being criticized for a lot of things, including involvement with the opioid crisis. Have you heard of the opioid crisis?

Speaker 3I have.

Speaker 1Oh, man. Yeah. I've had a few myself.

Speaker 2Robert.

Speaker 3Robert.

Speaker 4It's a bit.

Speaker 1It's a bit.

Speaker 2It's a bit. Please say it's a bit.

Speaker 1It's a bit. I'm a medical doctor.

Speaker 2I'm a professional.

Speaker 1I only do opiates in Mexico. And now I don't do opiates in Mexico anymore because of fucking fentanyl. Man, it ruins so much. You used to be able to just buy opiates off of a pharmacy in Guatemala or something and know that they were just hydrocodone. You could pick it up at the grocery store. It was beautiful. Anyway, whatever.

Speaker 2So McKinsey- and company, both of them, were hired by Purdue Pharma to work on strategies to increase opioid sales because they just weren't selling enough.

Speaker 1Yeah, 2006 is like peak getting Americans addicted to painkillers years.

Speaker 2That's exactly what we're talking about here.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Oh, cool. They provided them service for over 15 years, specifically advising them on marketing and sales strategies to aggressively increase the revenue of of OxyContin, the opioid painkiller.

Speaker 1You want to aggressively increase people using Oxy, yeah.

Speaker 2That's what they did. So they advised Purdue, really focusing their sales representative visits on doctors who were already writing high volumes of prescriptions. And according to the New York Times in 2013, McKinsey designed a specific strategy to turbocharge OxyContin sales And they advised the Sackler family, the people who own Purdue, to push the higher dose pills. They did a lot of really fun stuff. Because of this,

Speaker 2they faced a lot of legal challenges and some setbacks for the company. They've had to cut back at least 10% of their global workforce. They had to pay nearly $ 600 million American dollars to settle investigations.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1A fucking pittance, honestly. But yeah.

Speaker 2Probably.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And by these investigations brought on by 49 different American states. I'm not sure which state didn't, actually. I wish I had looked that up because I'm betting it's Alaska, but I don't know. And the DOJ announced a settlement resolving civil and criminal probes with McKinsey accepting responsibility for a misdemeanor charge of conspiring to aid and abet the misbranding of prescription drugs. So they also had a senior partner, Martin Elling, who faced felony obstruction of justice charges for

Speaker 2intentionally deleting Purdue. And they had to pay also 125 million into the Purdue Pharmacy bankruptcy estate to fund treatment programs. But what I have here is I printed out, I went to the Department of Justice, the Office of Public Affairs. And I printed out there some interesting stuff that they posted. about these court hearings. So they leveled a couple of complaints against the Perdue family, and they leveled a number

Speaker 2against McKinsey.

Speaker 1The Sackler family, yeah.

Speaker 2Sackler family, sorry. And two of the ones they leveled, two of the charges they leveled were criminal misbranding and false claims to the FDA. So this is fun. So the DOJ, this is a quote from the Office of Public Affairs, the Department of Justice, Quote, the DOJ leveled a criminal misbranding charge against McKinsey for falsely marketing it as less addictive, less subject to abuse and diversion, and less likely to cause dependence and withdrawal than other pain medications.

Speaker 2This was specifically their recommendations that McKinsey made to Purdue. They were like, they worked on messaging. They're like, hey, we have to counter these emotional public health warnings. including these complaints that mothers had of teenagers that had overdosed. And so they had this whole marketing campaign to fight that. Among other strategies, intensifying marketing to high-value prescribers, including prescribers who were writing opioid prescriptions for uses that were unsafe, ineffective,

Speaker 2and medically unnecessary. So what McKinsey did, basically let me translate some of that, was like, hey. Yeah. These people who are writing the worst prescriptions, the most questionable prescriptions, let's really drill down on them and get them to write even more. Hit them up. That should be number one. Don't go to the person that you have to convince. Go to the person that's just doing it and just work on them the whole time.

Speaker 1Makes sense.

Speaker 2McKinsey consultants spoke with Purdue about the concerns and increasing reluctance of pharmacists and pharmacy chains to fill prescriptions for OxyContin as abuse of the drug rose. McKinsey consultants also went on several ride-alongs with Purdue sales representatives in the field as these sales representatives called on prescribers and pharmacists. In notes about one of the ride-alongs, a McKinsey consultant wrote, quote, pharmacist had a gun and was shaking abuse is definitely

Speaker 2a huge issue they just kept doing it they set them on ride-alongs to convince them to work harder.

Speaker 1It's insane that's nuts.

Speaker 2And then on top of that they also got uh leveled uh for claims against the fda and McKinsey U.S. knowingly misled the FDA by assigning consultants to concurrently work on both FDA projects and competitively sensitive Purdue projects. So basically what they did was they said to the FDA, hey, we're going to give you some of our consultants. They're going to help you with managing this opioid crisis. And it was the same consultants that were working on Purdue. Who had helped make it worse.

Speaker 1Yeah. These guys really know the opioid crisis because they helped cause it. But they're experts.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1It would be like bringing in a bunch of former SS guys as experts on denazification.

Speaker 5It's like, look, they know who the Nazis were, obviously. They know what they're talking about. They know what they're talking about. There's also criticism of their work with Enron, as well as their work with China and Saudi Arabia and their efforts to enable authoritarian regimes.

Speaker 2In those places. I'll leave that for James and Mia to discuss it. that's probably more their wheelhouse. But they've done worse things also in other places as well. Now, Atiyah's work did not seem to be related to anything medical. So I have to say, even though he was there during the opioid crisis, it doesn't seem like he was a part of it. He was focused on corporate risk, and he worked as a management consultant during this time.

Speaker 2He considers this his recalibration phase, where he's exposed to systems-level thinking. I don't know who he was working with, but clearly it signals he has an interest in working with affluent, optimization-oriented populations. Right. His core audience is high-income, like high-income health-maxing professionals. People with the ability to pay top dollar for the health. And I'm sure this is a big part of why he ended up there. So he's there for two years. And it kind of correlates

Speaker 2when the first major actions are taken against Perdue. So I don't know if that was a part of why he left or not. But he leaves after a couple years. I think that's common for people doing the consultant gigs.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Right? And for reasons I'm not clear about, he's drawn back to medicine. He gets very busy. He starts doing presentations, lots of media stuff, doing TED Talks. He talks about metabolic dysfunction a lot. He co-founds a startup called the Nutrition Science Initiative, or NUSAI.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Gives him a very public-facing scientific role, and one that he does without needing board certification.

Speaker 1Oh, that's handy.

Speaker 2That's great, right? His blog helps establish him as a bit of a contrarian and... but one that can actually discuss data. Sophie knows my thoughts about medical contrarians. It's not great. And this is where the Atea content machine really starts. These long form technical pieces framed as this is what your doctor won't tell you. Again, has that real, the one secret your doctors won't tell you energy. And the rise of these doctors, these contrarian doctors, is something

Speaker 2that is very much a sore spot for me. Yeah. And not that medicine's perfect, it's not. I'm not going to say that it is. But a lot of these folks, him included, did a lot of what is called, or I call, I don't know if this is a term, I'm sure it is, science washing. Like taking some of the more blatantly crazy quack people, making them seem more legitimate, and making the more blatantly anti-vax doctors seem a little bit more legitimate, really paves the way for for the

Speaker 2Maha movement and where we are currently, again, in our golden age of diarrhea. Now, eventually, in 2014, he starts his own private longevity clinic, Early Medicine. And this is really the scaffolding on which his whole shtick is built.

Speaker 1On moving forward. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2It allows him to operationalize the Med 3.0 framework that he loves talking about.

Speaker 1I feel like you can see a hint of this in the fact that he got so into nutrition, because obviously nutrition is massively important for health, but also when you're in the business of nutrition, because of the way supplements and stuff are regulated, it means that you can, I'm not saying he was, but you can be in the business of just selling people nonsense and claiming it's basically medicine, as long as you avoid certain phrasing, right? That's exactly right. Anytime I hear nutrition, my warning bells start going off, like when it's in the context of

Speaker 1a medical professional.

Speaker 2Absolutely true. It's really the Wild West, because being a nutritionist could mean you have like two to three PhDs in the matter or can mean you're a wellness influencer online. And there's really a wide breadth of the conversation between the two. So yeah, absolutely true. So during this time, as he's creating this clinic, things he's doing are things like continuous glucose monitors for non-diabetic patients, which you may

Speaker 2have already gathered from the way I said it is not appropriate. repeated advanced lipid testing, VO2 max labs, routine MRI scans, DEXA scans, is giving people expensive wearables, using off-label drugs, doing after-hours consults. His clienteles are elite. They want high-touch care. They aren't taking new clients, by the way, I checked. It's a years-long wait list to get in. And although it's not disclosed exactly how much, From the

Speaker 2accounts I've seen, he charges anywhere from $ 100, 000 to $ 500, 000 annually for this care in this clinic.

Speaker 1Nice work if you can get it.

Speaker 2Jesus. I mean, if I could find three people to do that. Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1I'll give you nutrition advice for half a million dollars a year. Anyone listening, you know, wire the money ahead of time, and I'll give you all the advice you fucking want.

Speaker 2Will you be on call, though? Will you be on call all the time? Sure.

Speaker 1You can call me.

Speaker 2I may not answer.

Speaker 1Eat more fiber. I don't know, man. Fuck it.

Speaker 2Hey, you're hired. You're in. Well done, buddy.

Speaker 1Could be worse.

Speaker 2If I start a concierge clinic, I am going to hire you in a minute. Anyways, I could see why it's so appealing. I will say this, though, as an aside, I can only imagine as a doctor how annoying it would be to be a regular doctor of one of these patients once they leave this concierge clinic, and you have to see them. Like the stuff they would expect, it would just be wild. And I would not be giving them. But like, they'd be like, my last doctor,

Speaker 2he did this and this, and he ordered this and this and this, and he did this for me. And I'd be like, no, I'm sorry. That's just, none of that's appropriate or reasonable to do. And it would be so painful. And of course, none of this is accessible to the average patient, or I'm sure you can guess, covered by insurance.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2People like Atiyah or tech weirdo, Brian Johnson, other longevity enthusiasts. They're famous. That guy, that's the guy with the sons is blood boy for you listeners out there. Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1And tracks his erections. Don't forget about that. Really loves bragging about his four hour erections at night when he's sleeping.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Cool, man.

Speaker 2Great episode on him. And it was troubling. Um, lots of weird tweets about his, um, girlfriend's vagina um yeah and his and his son's erection just real weird real weird stuff.

Speaker 3Really uh tmi my guy.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah and i'm not a person who says that like i don't think i've ever said tmi before but i think if i were to use it it would be in this case tmi so uh these people the reason i bring them up both him and natia would would have you believe that this is all proof of concept stuff And that, yeah, only rich people have it for now, but eventually everyone's going to have it. But, I mean, that's just not true. It's not scalable. These longevity wellness people are essentially creating a two-tiered medical system

Speaker 2with a different level for the wealthy. I mean, you could argue we already kind of have one, but that gap will only grow. Right. Of course, like all bad people, he starts a podcast. It's called The Drive in 2018. They cover a range of topics built around his practice and early medicine framework. He's really starting to build this parasocial relationship with a high-value audience during this time. He's making appearances on Oprah at least three times on the

Speaker 2Joe Rogan Experience. He's hanging out with Bill Ackman, Hugh Jackman. Oh, boy. Yeah.

Speaker 1A lot of Ackmans in there.

Speaker 2A lot of Ackman and Jackmans.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And Gwyneth Paltrow and other New York elites. Sure. His book, Outlive, comes out in 2023 and shortly afterwards becomes a number one bestseller.

Speaker 1Yeah, they love titles like that. I can see why that one sold.

Speaker 2Really a good one, right?

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Over 3 million copies and spent 131 weeks on the New York Times non-fiction bestseller list. It's crazy.

Speaker 1That's bleak.

Speaker 2It's not great. He becomes a major figure in the health and wellness scene. Millions of people tuning in to what he has to say or write. And I am a little, I don't want to get too far into the medical minutia here, but I think it's kind of important to do. And your audience is very smart. And I'm not just saying that because I'm pandering, although I'm clearly pandering. They are very intelligent. I think they can hang with this. So I'm going to dig in a little bit to the medical advice he's endorsing and why it matters. Okay. He's moving past the lifespan stuff. He's

Speaker 2now about healthspan, the good years. Again, we are mind and body sharp. I'm into that. I like that. And this medicine 3.0, which his clients are paying top dollar for, and he would describe as preventive, personalized, and data-driven approaches to healthcare that focuses on avoiding disease rather than treating it, treating disease. And what's, you know, by the way, um, I get called a shill a lot for being part of big pharma. And it's a lot of the same

Speaker 2people who are like, you only want these diseases. to happen so you can be paid by pharma to treat them. And I'm like, what do you think he's doing in these situations? You think that these medicines he's giving you are free? Anyway, sorry. A key part of his justification for aggressive preventative treatments and aggressive pharmacology is this assertion that he has that 90% of the U.S. population has at least one of five markers of metabolic syndrome. Have

Speaker 2you guys heard of metabolic syndrome?

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Is that real? It's real.

Speaker 4Okay, that's good.

Speaker 2It's real, but it is vague, so you are right to be like, yeah, is it real?

Speaker 1I hear a lot of things called signs of metabolic syndrome that just sound... Okay, so Cheryl, listen to you.

Speaker 3It's like, you know, a number of things that make you at risk for other things. Am I in the right space?

Speaker 1It just crops up a lot in grifty kind of medical spaces.

Speaker 3Like, all these things means you might have a stroke, or all these things means you might get type 2 diabetes, or all these... Am I in the right... Is that correct, my friend? You guys.

Speaker 2You guys are so smart. I'm not just saying that. Honestly.

Speaker 1I mean, I had a lot less specifics than she did, but sure.

Speaker 2Yeah, that was good. But I meant you guys. I meant her. This is really smart. I just don't want you to feel bad. That is correct. Metabolic syndrome is a real thing, although you're right to be kind of questioning it because it's used by people both professionally who know what they're talking about and by grifters to sell you an enema made out of coffee. So you're right to be concerned about it. Now, what it is, let's go through it here, okay? Metabolic syndrome is important, and we should touch base on what these five markers of

Speaker 2metabolic syndrome are. One, central or abdominal obesity, basically a waist circumference greater than or equal to 102 centimeters in men, 88 centimeters in women, just a big gut. You get adipose tissue in your gut. It changes the way your body acts with insulin. Another marker, elevated triglycerides, greater than or equal to 150. Low HDL, which is quote-unquote good cholesterol. Right. Lower than 40 for men, lower than 50 for women.

Speaker 2Hypertension or high blood pressure with a systolic of 130 or greater. And a diastolic, that's the bottom number. Systolic is the top number. You see it's like 130 over 85. That's top number systolic, bottom number is diastolic. Probably more information than you need, sorry.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2And the last of these markers is elevated fasting glucose, if it's over 100. Now, Sophie is 100% right. If you have metabolic syndrome, it puts you at risk for diabetes, coronary artery disease, heart problems, and stroke. And his assertion that 90% of people have at least one of these markers is actually not far off. The CDC runs this research program called the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, or NHANES. And there was an NHANES study from 2009

Speaker 2to 2016, and it showed that about 12 only, I should say, only 12% of US adults were considered, quote unquote, metabolically healthy, or basically optimal on all five of those markers I mentioned without medication. That implies that roughly 88% of Americans have at least one abnormal test. I'm assuming that's where he gets this 90% number that he talks about. And that part is, I think, true.

Speaker 4Hey, everyone, this is Kaveh, you know, from the future after this recording. And I just wanted to jump in here real quick to say that what I said was totally correct. No, nothing factually wrong. I just hear Robert doing this every now and then. And, you know, it sounded fun to me. So I wanted to give it a try. But yeah, everything I said was right. So anyways, back to the podcast.

Speaker 2But the thing is, That's not how you define metabolic syndrome. To have metabolic syndrome, you have to have three or more of those markers. Having just one isolated marker is probably very, very common, but it's also clinically far less meaningful. For metabolic syndrome, you have to have at least three of those, and it kind of just drops it to one to start treatment. Okay. Does that make sense? Let me stop right there. Does that make sense?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3Sure.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2These things are important to note. And I want people to be thinking about all these things. But this concept of saying, like, he's changing the goalpost here about definitions that would justify treating people aggressively. And we'll talk about why you don't want to treat everyone aggressively. But I don't believe this justifies it. It's certainly not justifying in a uniform approach like he applies to his patients. We always say lifestyle modification should be the first thing you discuss. rather than reflexively treating people with medication. I'm the one

Speaker 2that gets accused of being a shill for pharma, and I'm the one that's usually saying, hey, let's hold off on this medicine that's unproven. I don't get it.

Speaker 3You do say that to me often.

Speaker 2Yeah, I get it a lot. I'm like, what do you think of this thing?

Speaker 3And you're like, no, no.

Speaker 2Yeah. And writing medicine is like my bag. I'm an internal medicine doctor at heart. That's what we do. Anyways. You should think of interventions, I feel, as a staircase and not a switch. And the first step should always be lifestyle modifications, if you can help it. Now, metabolic syndrome is a risk indicator, not an absolute risk. It doesn't account for everything, age, sex, smoking, LDL, other factors. Aggressive lab testing that he does is a big part of his practice and recommendations. But in these cases, it's

Speaker 2highly questionable about what kind of use that serves. He focuses on these aggressive tests for blood markers that could potentially represent heart disease. His core panel includes something called APOB, LP little a, CRP. And then he also recommends imaging the coronary artery calcium or the CAC scoring.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2As well as a coronary CT. I don't think other people refer to it as CAC, but I think it's funnier to refer to coronary artery calcium as CAC scoring.

Speaker 1CAC scoring.

Speaker 2I'm not opposed to... early focused cardiac intervention. Of all the stuff he does, I'm the most open to hearing about this. But a lot of what he is recommending, a lot of this testing outruns the evidence that we have to support its use. Some of it hasn't even been shown to be something we could change. So for example, these CAC scoring tests that he does, they're expensive. They expose you to radiation and downstream test events. And there's no trial so far that shows that doing that actually

Speaker 2helps you in any way or decreases cardiac events. And whenever you do a test, you should always ask, will the results of this test change our management? That should always be a question you ask. And if there's nothing different you can do, if there's nothing different it will give you, then you have to have serious conversations. It doesn't mean you can't do it, but it means you can't be applying that to everybody. He also is a proponent for early screening tests for things like colonoscopy. Which

Speaker 2he sees as being proactive, but I see, as a gastroenterologist who does them, as being a bit reckless. This is my wheelhouse, of course. And we could talk at length about when to start colonoscopy. But for someone without risk factors, it's 45. That's our recommended time for screening for colon cancer. And that's lower than 50 where it used to be. He pushes for 40.

Speaker 1I mean, there's a lot more younger colon cancer cases, right? So I don't know.

Speaker 2Is that wrong? I could talk to you about that. This is a fascinating topic to me. In fact, I just released an episode about early-onset colorectal cancer, and you are correct. There are increasing rates. Overall, the absolute risk is still low, but there is increasing rates of why that is. But that's why we drop it to 45. Now, people online constantly get mad when I talk about this. Because they'll be like, hey, I want a colonoscopy and you doctors are not giving it to me. And I'll be like, how old are you? And they'll be like, 30. And I'll be like, do you have any risk factors

Speaker 2like family with colon cancer or family with advanced polyps or history of inflammatory bowel disease? Or do you have any? signs or symptoms that are concerning? And the answer is no, they just want it. I'm like, that's not what we want you to do. I don't want you getting colonoscopies. I'm a guy who does colonoscopy. I get paid to do colonoscopies, but I don't want you to get it unless you need it.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's not like free for everyone, not just out of money standpoint, but like doctors don't have unlimited time. Yeah, I get that.

Speaker 2Yes, that's a big part of it. And there's more. We'll discuss that a little more. We'll come back to it. But what I think he is tapping into here is is a very real dissatisfaction, disillusionment with mainstream medicine. And I feel that. People feel like doctors, for one reason or another, are always gatekeeping healthcare. And to be clear, I am 100% for preventative care. This idea is not new. We've had primary cares for this exact reason. Why he

Speaker 2went into surgery, I don't know. He would have been better off had he gone to endocrinology, but, you know, not a lot of money there. So maybe that's, I don't want to assume that's why he did it. But there are other things you can do to get preventative care. And I'm, as I said, I'm a simple country doctor. Four years of medical school, three years of internal medicine training, a year of chief residency, three years of gastroenterology, and a year of liver transplant fellowship under my belt. simple country doc stuff. And I feel so much less confident

Speaker 2taking the giant swings he does on all these medical issues. He has no formal training in cardiovascular disease, neurodegenerative disease, endocrinology, or even nutritional science, yet these are the pillars of his practice. Again, Very smart, incredible potential as a doctor. But what he's describing as research into these fields seems more like maybe read a couple studies and having relationships with people that are his friends that do know more about than him. There's something you have to consider when

Speaker 2you're doing all these tests, all these advanced genetic testing, CT angiograms, these colonoscopies. There's real harms, real risks associated with them. And we have to weigh the benefits of them. I'm assuming you probably want to take a commercial break before we do that.

Speaker 1Yeah, why not?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Speaking of that, ads?

Speaker 2Why not?

Speaker 1Ads. And we're back.

Speaker 2Yes, we are back. Now, there was a JAMA study I want to talk about because I think this is really funny. And funny may not be the right word. It came out of UC Davis in 2012. It's an old study. And what it did was this. It showed how happy a patient was with the care they received and how that related to their outcomes. That study showed that the most satisfied patients had not only higher healthcare spending, but more hospital admissions, and most strikingly, a 26% higher

Speaker 2risk of death compared to the least satisfied patients cool the satisfied patients were doing worse yeah what what thoughts do you have about why why may that be we don't know for sure by the way the test this study was empowered.

Speaker 1I guess because people like are are satisfied because they like their doctor and they feel listened to but that doesn't necessarily correlate to actually improving their health care outcomes at all it's just like how people can be really satisfied with a doctor who's selling them like snake oil that doesn't actually cure their cancer until they fucking die. They don't notice something's wrong. I don't know. That would be my guess.

Speaker 2No, that's right. So the more satisfied patients are probably getting more than they asked for. More tests, more side effects, more complications. Doctors who always say yes score very well. And sometimes saying no in medicine is really hard. But sometimes, and not always, declining a test or medicine or antibiotic or refusing to do a low-value scan or imaging study may actually serve patients better. Now, this is a big, nuanced,

Speaker 2and difficult conversation because you have to weigh those considerations with listening to your patients and advocating for them. And it is not an excuse to not listen to your patients and take their complaints seriously. I'm fully aware that our country has a very serious problem taking patients seriously, particularly if they are Black and or female. This is a real problem that we have in this country. But it's always important to keep in mind that sometimes do no harm is the right step. Not doing the thing

Speaker 2is the better approach. To be totally transparent also, there have been follow-up studies to that 2012 studies. Some have supported, some have detracted. I feel the weight of time has sort of borne this out, though, and it does seem to be true. There was a 2019 Cochrane meta-analysis that showed real dangers to over-diagnosis and treatment. It can lead to unnecessary interventions. One test leads to another test leads to another test, and these things have risks. Sometimes they're necessary,

Speaker 2sometimes they are not. And these things carry not only real harm, but also psychological burden as well.

Speaker 3So.

Speaker 2I think largely his reason for doing this is not bad or malicious. I think he does want to help before a problem exists. And like I said, a lot of his advice is reasonable stuff. And I actually kind of like some of it. Eat less processed food, exercise, sleep well.

Speaker 1Great.

Speaker 2But it's also paired with this really over-the-top monitoring with intense and very pricey strategies that lack evidence. And some of the relationships he has to these things are not ideal at For example, he, as I mentioned, promotes continuous glucose monitoring for people without diabetes or signs of insulin resistance.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Not necessary. Yes. In your medical professional experience, you would also agree with me, and you are correct. But it's become a big hit with the MAHA crowd, these tests. And there's no evidence that's of any use to non-diabetic patients. And it can lead to unnecessary dietary restrictions, anxiety, even disordered eating. And the information, the data you get from these continuous glucose monitorings, it's often difficult to interpret. And getting one with an ongoing data plan is hundreds of

Speaker 2dollars per month.

Speaker 3It's expensive.

Speaker 2A lot of.

Speaker 3People that have diabetes that need these sorts of devices- are either unable to get it or the prices are increasing because of things like this. And I know a specific device that you're going.

Speaker 2To talk about.

Speaker 3And I know that it is extremely difficult to at times get that device. And I can't imagine this helps.

Speaker 2No, you're exactly right. That's what happens. You, the resources are limited. Our problem in this country is not so much that we don't have the things to help patients. It's that we don't have access for them to get to it.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And also grounding out what Sophie was alluding to there. He was a paid advertiser for a company called Dexcom that sells these devices. That's not ideal. It's not ideal. Um, He has been criticized for not disclosing that very well. I have seen him mention it, but I don't think he did it every time. So I think it's a valid criticism.

Speaker 4Sure.

Speaker 2By the way, that company has since said his advisory role ended in 2021. But when this topic comes up of concerns, hey, aren't we just creating a new tier of medical care for just those with extreme wealth? And that it's preventative medicine for people who are already privileged and probably doing better. He'll downplay the cost of these things he's ordering by correctly pointing out that the end-of-life care is also very expensive. And that is true. A

Speaker 2disproportionate amount of healthcare in this country spending is at the end of a patient's life. The cost of all the machines and the labor and medicine in those critically ill hospitalized patients, that adds up quickly. But both things can be true. And nobody's saying we shouldn't practice preventative care. But the thing is this, even if his measures do work, which is a big if, it's still just pushing the end-of-life care and all the money that goes into it further down the road. So you're not saving money this way.

Speaker 2You're spending money on both ends. A lot of it, a lot of health care dollars are going to go into this on both ends. And for that reason, actually, real quick before we move on from end-of-life care– It's an important reason that doctors recommend having those goals of care discussion and what you would want done if you were to become critically ill and not be able to weigh in. Unfortunately, when this is reasonably discussed, Republicans refer to it as death panels, and we never get to have this.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1I remember the death panel days.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1And then we had real death panels under a Republican. Anyway, whatever.

Speaker 2We've had real death panels. But having end-of-life care discussions is, is not only important for saving money, it's also just really important for knowing really what your loved ones want. So I think it's... Anyways, have that discussion, folks, even if you are healthy. You should at least be having those discussions along the way. Now, all this, I think, are things that you kind of learn in the actual practice of medicine, something he missed, this do no harm.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2The colonoscopy part, I think, is... A great example of this. So our current guidelines have dropped to 45. He wants it to go down even further to 40. And again, despite how strange it might seem to some people, there are people who want these tests done as early as possible. But as Robert said, one part of it is we just don't have the people to do it. I mean, I could... do colonoscopies every day, all day for the end of time, and I will not have scratched the surface of the colonoscopies that need to get done. So

Speaker 2we're taking it away from people who need it. But on top of that, there's risk to doing these tests. There's actual physical risks. Bad things can happen. It's rare, thankfully. You should get colon cancer screening. But colonoscopy does have some risk, and it's not cheap. And again, I'm telling you this as someone who stands to make a lot of money off of you getting colonoscopies.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2So take my word for this one. You're like, it's something we have to be more mindful about.

Speaker 1Yeah, for sure.

Speaker 2He talks about some other stuff with his patients that's overall less fun for me. He emphasizes zone two training as optimal for mitochondrial capacity and longevity. This does contradict some substantial evidence behind higher intensity training. Again, kind of what he's doing here is he's cherry-picking studies that look at observational data in elite endurance athletes. I'm not sure how that translates. But that cherry-picking study stuff is something that RFK Jr. does as well. And what they all do in this sort of world.

Speaker 1It's a vote these days, yeah.

Speaker 2It's the modus operandi of our current administration. So RFK Jr. One thing that they will all do is they will take a little bit of data and then extrapolate it far beyond what that data was meant to do. Something he does this with is one of his quote-unquote horsemen. He talks about the four horsemen of the apocalypse, and one of them is cancer. Sorry.

Speaker 3That was like an audible groan.

Speaker 4Okay.

Speaker 2Sorry, I'm back. I felt that way. Again, I actually liked parts of his book. Parts of it were, I thought, very reasonable. But, for example, when he talks about cancer, he points out that cancer cells require more glucose than normal human cells. And that is true. And you'll hear a lot of wellness people take that little bit of information.

Speaker 1Yeah, starve your cancer by avoiding sugar or whatever. I've seen that a lot.

Speaker 2Right. They take a little bit of truth and they make giant leaps from there regarding the nature of cancer's formation and sugar's role in it. And it's honestly, it's still not clear what that means, you know. Is it the cause of the cancer, the sugar, or is it just some interesting feature of the cancer?

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2To make jumps from a simple lab-tested fact to saying dietary manipulations could help the growth of cancer is shaky at best. And diet is important. I'm a huge proponent of a healthy diet that is high in fiber. Again, fiber, folks. I'm deep in the pocket of big fiber. But while there is solid evidence that healthy dietary patterns can lower your risk for things, right now... There isn't the risk of these things he's recommending, like ketogenic diets, prolonged fasts, caloric restrictions. There's no evidence that those things work. When

Speaker 2we want people to learn, when I want people to learn about what they're eating and how it affects them, I want it to be broad and sustainable patterns. Mostly plants, limited red meat, limited processed meats. And I don't disagree with limiting sugar either. I agree. For the purpose of maximizing your cardio metabolic risks, That's well proven. I don't find it to be a good argument in the case of cancer. The data just isn't there yet. Or if you're cool, you call it data. Let's talk a little bit more about the medications. Because, again, I'm the one

Speaker 2that gets accused of being a pharma shill. But if a right-wing doctor tells you to buy a year's supply of ivermectin, you do it out there. So I'll never understand that. Not that he's recommended ivermectin.

Speaker 3For the non-pharmacist. Netflix watchers, I just rolled my eyes very, very, very, very, very dramatically.

Speaker 2Yeah, you're going to strain something. You got to be careful. So he's a big fan of aggressive pharmacologic intervention using medications.

Speaker 4Sure he is.

Speaker 2Off-label. Now, I'll give one example. I could give a lot, but there's one, and I think it's a fun one. And there's a little nerd in me that wants to share this story with you guys. And I think your listeners will enjoy it. It's about a medicine that he prescribes. for his patients called rapamycin. You might have seen it, serolimus. And he prescribes it for longevity-enhancing purposes. And, yeah, there is a little bit of promising preclinical data to suggest

Speaker 2some longevity benefits. It's still very much a hypothesis, and there's no phase three trials to prove it. As an interesting aside, this rapamycin is actually an antifungal And this is fun, how it was discovered. It was discovered in the dirt of an Easter Island volcanic crater in the 60s in Rapa Nui. Okay.

Speaker 1Which I hope I'm saying right. How did they find it?

Speaker 2Great question. What in the world is going on here?

Speaker 1Were they just looking at random, just sucking up different things that they found on the island? Does this have medical? I don't know. How did they find it?

Speaker 2Great, great question. So there was this microbiologist. who was collecting soil because they wanted to take samples, and they wanted to figure out why the islanders who lived there never got tetanus despite walking around with no shoes.

Speaker 1Cool as that. Actually, that's a really cool thing to do. Yeah, that makes sense.

Speaker 2But you can imagine some Republican talking about this in the day being like, hey, we're wasting money testing the dirt in Rapa Nui.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 2You know, that's how it is. Yeah, that makes sense. You never know where research is going to lead you. And it leads you to some really amazing places. Anyways, since discovering it, people have studied its use for all kinds of different things. It was actually found to have some immunosuppressive effects. So because of that, it's used for transplant patients to alter their immune system. So if you get a transplanted kidney, you take this medication usually to help prevent your body from rejecting it. Now, as I mentioned,

Speaker 2there is some early data that suggests it can affect lifespan of mice. Human trials have been very limited, though. Maybe it might help improve the flu vaccine response. It's not quite clear. People thought it could be potentially used for weight loss, but that really didn't pan out. And it's not shown the metabolic stuff that they expect it to, but it's a really small example of of something that the anti-vaccine community and something that RFK Jr. do. Extrapolating

Speaker 2a small truth in a small study or an animal study to a large truth in humans, something it's not powered, meant, or designed to do.

Speaker 1Right, yeah, I see a lot of this.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's a big stretch.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And I mean, it's great clickbait stuff, right? You see an article that says like, this secret medicine discovered in the Easter Island crater is, will expand your life. And you're like, that's awesome. And you read it. And sometimes if you're lucky, they'll explain that it's not that, but it's really fun. Clickbaity stuff. It's really, it sits with people and it's exciting. So yeah, he's.

Speaker 3Also a guy that like is a soundbite guy. So you're, you know, you're going to get, you know, two minutes of him talking on some other guy. We hates podcast talking about how great said thing is. And it just spreads like wildfire and, and is actually just not scientifically sound, and you're just spreading scientific misinformation and causing harm.

Speaker 2That's exactly right. Yeah. Thank you. Now, because it's off-label, there's no regulating the dose. There's no guidelines on dosing or monitoring. Maybe there's some protective effects against aging, but these same exact pathways... drive immunosuppression. So you can't take these things lightly. You don't want to be immunosuppressed if you don't need to. No. Because as the title suggests, your immune system is being suppressed. And your immune system is a good thing.

Speaker 1Yeah, I wouldn't want to take immunosuppressants as a longevity treatment because your immune system sometimes helps you stop dying. Like I get why it helps your longevity if you've got like a transplant. That makes sense.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 2And people haven't studied its use in situations like this. It's long-term risk of use for people who don't have a transplant, for example. And, you know, there's some real risk with it that we do know about. There's some increased risk to infection, as I mentioned, the development of lymphoma, and some metabolic problems that the whole field of longevity is really supposedly aimed to prevent. So it's this kind of fast and loose relationship to science and medicine that's

Speaker 2made him a pop culture scientist and star. He sounds really convincing, intelligent when he talks about the stuff, especially if it's in these short bursts. He knows how to talk about data in a way that's even more convincing, I feel, than Andrew Huberman. He's good at it.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2And he's influencing people. He's getting the attention of everyone in the manosphere. His approach to medicine is great for people like RFK Jr. and anti-vaxxers. He can speak intelligently about the data and sound authoritative, but And it can help science wash them a little bit. He's got a real credibility behind him. It's like when Brian Cox shows up in Super Troopers. He gives them this whole sense of gravitas.

Speaker 3Great.

Speaker 1I often think about Super Troopers when I'm considering the validity of different medical opinions. Yeah.

Speaker 2He doesn't even need to vocally support RFK Jr. He doesn't vocally support him. He's pretty careful about what he says about him. But all he has to do is give them the plausibility by not refuting them And coexisting in the same world with them and going out of his way to not trouble them. For example, when he's asked about RFK Jr. 's accusation that Tylenol causes autism, something that every doctor I know of, even ones who don't have the same political links as me, they look at that, they've seen it, they know anything about it,

Speaker 2they're like, that's kind of nonsense.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2When he's asked about it, he describes it sort of as a low probability event and kind of tries to move on from that discussion.

Speaker 3Okay.

Speaker 2A low probability. Is it Pete? From all the available data, it's a no probability event. That's the kind of thing you have to be able to stand up. You have to be able to take a side. And I know people will say doctors shouldn't be political, but this isn't even political. This is not political.

Speaker 3This is just due diligence.

Speaker 1This is just.

Speaker 2Yeah. Say the truth. Say the medical truth. Say the scientific truth.

Speaker 3This is just the sky is blue bullshit. Yeah.

Speaker 2It absolutely is. So when it comes to his bastard-ish, bastardocity, is he a medical bastard? Obviously not on the level of Marion Sims, who we discussed before.

Speaker 1Right, or on RFK Jr. even. Or Dr.

Speaker 2Oz either, who I really don't like either.

Speaker 5Sure.

Speaker 2He's not as creepy. He's not as creepy as some of the other longevity gurus.

Speaker 3I pre-laughed at that. Sorry.

Speaker 1No, no.

Speaker 2He's not as creepy.

Speaker 3You're not wrong.

Speaker 1He's not as creepy.

Speaker 2He's not as creepy as some of the other longevity guys like Brian Johnson who deserves his own episode. Have you done Brian Johnson? No. No.

Speaker 3I mean, he comes up every now and again.

Speaker 1Nah, he's not, because he's not really a bad, he's a, we might do him because he's funny. Yeah. But he's not, like, the thing about him that I actually do respect a little bit is that, like, of all of the super crazy rich maniacs out there, most of them are spending all of their money on, like, horrible shit or really boring, bland shit, like, I've got a bigger yacht, no, I've got a bigger yacht, he's spending a lot of his money on, like, dangerous self-experimentation. And that kind of mania that I actually do respect a little bit, like, well, you're genuinely kind of unhinged, but you're committed to being unhinged. And, like,

Speaker 1I kind of respect that more than, like, the way Bezos spends his fucking money.

Speaker 2Yeah, no, he walks the walk. Yeah, that's a very good point.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Very good point. It's the same way that, like, I mean... I'll never totally understand deeply religious people because it's just not, I don't have that part of me. But when somebody believes it enough to proselytize, as annoying as that is and how little I want to see it, there's a part of me that's like, okay, well, they seem to really believe it or they wouldn't care to proselytize. Like the proselytizing, they really believe these people are going to hell, so they want to change their minds about it because they really believe it. So I kind of see that. Anyways,

Speaker 2so he's not that bad. And actually, compared to ghouls like that, he actually kind of seems reasonable. He did go to medical school. He didn't finish his residency, but he did some of it. If you saw him profiled on 60 Minutes last fall or read some of his stuff in Scientific American, he actually comes across as a pretty sound thinker. But this whole shtick is based on critiques of what he calls Medicine 2.0. And all of this is based on limited experience actually practicing Medicine 2.0.

Speaker 2A key point he makes in his book, which he illustrates, is that the mortality rate per 100,000 people declined relatively little over the course of the 20th century, if you subtract out the deaths from the eight top infectious diseases, implying that contemporary medicine has made scant progress against the horsemen of things like cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. Yeah, very frustrating. Well, first of all, yeah, one, if you take out all

Speaker 2these deaths that we're avoiding with, you know, treating these infectious diseases, which is like, come on, that's pretty good. Let's be.

Speaker 1Yeah, the problem is that, like, there are individual cancers, like, up until recently, because there have been, there do seem to be some, like, breakthroughs maybe occurring in pancreatic treatment, but, like, there wasn't a massive amount of progress made on pancreatic cancer compared to some other cancers up until fairly recently, but, like, lung cancer, we've gotten... way better at dealing with.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1And like, yeah, there's still some sorts of, there's still varying sorts of like, you know, heart disease or whatever that we don't have, but we've gotten better at like a lot of other kinds. Like it's, it's just people are, I think a lot of it is like, yeah, you lose a loved one to like a disease that we just haven't gotten a good handle on. And it's easier to, for people in that situation to be like, Medical science still hasn't made any progress. And it's, well, I'm sorry you got hit by that fucking bullet, but that's not the only thing going on, you know?

Speaker 2No, you're exactly right. And it is medicine 2.0, as he would call it, that is providing those advances in things like pancreatic cancer, which, I mean, agreed, not as fast as it should be. And we should be pushing this forward. But I don't think that's what medicine 3.0 really is. this, this whole thing is really not only downplaying the role of antibiotics and vaccines, but these horsemen he's talking about in particular cancer and Alzheimer's are diseases of older people. The fact that he gets to write

Speaker 2books about how we're not treating them aggressively enough is because our public health system had improved enough to keep us alive long enough to get these diseases, these diseases that are largely of older people, not completely, but largely. Um, And this whole 3.0 thing doesn't even make sense internally. In his book, Outlive, he discusses how immunotherapy is amazing, and it is, but that's very much 2.0 medicine. That's conventional medicine and research working. At the end of the day,

Speaker 2who has the time and the money to do these things? We have a real problem in this country with access. It's not enough tests, as I said. It's enough access. And he's clearly chosen on purpose to surround himself with only the wealthiest Americans who have the time and the money for all the exercise he recommends, the ability to pay for all the things, the testing, the wearable devices, and the desire to live forever. And that's what brings us to the last part of our conversation. But first.

Speaker 1Speaking of the last.

Speaker 2Oh, yeah.

Speaker 1Toby's got it. But first.

Speaker 3And now, Jeffrey Epstein. There we go. I know it's here. I know it's here. I brought it up in the beginning.

Speaker 2Carly Rae Jepstein himself. So that's right. Where does all this lead us to? All this Medicine 3.0, all the costs. Who can do it? Only the wealthiest people. And that is how our hero, Dr. Peter Attia, gets connected with one person. Jeffrey Birmingham Epstein. I'm just kidding. I don't think that's his middle name.

Speaker 1No, that was it.

Speaker 2Earlier this year, you might have heard CBS News announced a whole new slate of 19 contributors as part of the efforts. They are trying to go with Barry Weiss to revamp the network's public image. One of the contributors that they had hired, along with, again, Andrew Huberman, which we could do another two-parter on, conservative Mel Ferguson- was Dr. Peter Attia. Three days after that, the DOJ released a chunk of Epstein files, which included over 1,700 mentions of

Speaker 2the name Peter Attia, and a lot of very embarrassing and very douche-chill-inducing emails between Attia and J.E., as he calls him, J.E., And also with Epstein's handlers, live emails with Atiyah Epstein's handlers. Because of this, Atiyah was forced to step down from his role at CBS. Because it turns out, before he became this wellness influencer that he was destined to become, with millions of followers, a very

Speaker 2influential book, he relied on Jeffrey Epstein's advice to help get his concierge medical practice going. So let's get into the Epstein files here.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Here we go.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2Yeah. So from Atiyah's own report, he met J.E. in 2014.

Speaker 3I hate every time you say that.

Speaker 4I know.

Speaker 2But like, it's just, well, it gets worse. Wait, hold on.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2So he met Joffrey while he was raising funds for scientific research. And interestingly, he makes a point to note that it was facilitated, the meeting, by a female healthcare leader, Dr. Eva Anderson Dubin. Interesting person. She was a former model, became a doctor and philanthropist. That makes sense. Epstein clearly kept ties across academia. They remained in contact over the years, exchanging emails. They exchanged advice. Eventually, Atiyah lets Epstein know

Speaker 2that he's looking for someone to help run his office. I have this office, it's concierge practice, but I need a patient care coordinator, someone to like walk them through the whole thing, someone that's going to make the experience really enjoyable for them. And he's asking for his help in finding him or her. Epstein invited Atiyah to his Upper East Side mansion and introduced him to a foreign-born model Okay. Yeah. You might see where this is starting to head.

Speaker 1Oh, this is 2014, right?

Speaker 2Yes, 2014.

Speaker 1Okay, so he had been convicted and everybody knew.

Speaker 2Oh, yeah. That was 2008, if I remember correctly.

Speaker 1Just always really want to highlight when somebody befriends Jeffrey after that. Yeah.

Speaker 2Yes. Oh, yeah. We're going to get to whether or not he had a sense of what was going on or not here, too. I think there's some telltale signs in his emails. So, Atiyah, is introduced to this foreign-born model. They exchange emails. And in other emails, it's clear that Atiyah has invited her to a hangout with some other potential candidates, other people at Swanky Bar in Midtown. I think she will be loyal, Epstein writes to Atiyah in

Speaker 2an email. Turns out this woman was also a victim. Her name is redacted, but she was one of Epstein's victims. And from Atiyah's spokesperson, they say that this person never ended up working for them. After all, they said... that for some other reason, they went with somebody else. That wasn't even the reason he was at Jeffrey Epstein's apartment. But Politico reports that it was visa issues that were the problem. And you can see this in the emails. The emails are like, hey, she's great, but there's this

Speaker 2visa issue, and I don't think we can be able to get past that. And this is the kind of thing you see a lot in these emails, Atiyah relying on Epstein for referrals and providing him with health advice and testing. He downplays their relationship. He admits to hanging out about 10 times after that until Jeffrey Epstein's arrest. He says the hangouts happened at Jeffrey Epstein's home, although from emails, he did have interest in going to the island. And there was even a plan to go to the New Mexico ranch that Epstein owned, but there was no

Speaker 2evidence that actually proves that.

Speaker 1He actually did that. The Zorro Ranch.

Speaker 2Is that what it's called?

Speaker 1Yeah, the Zorro Ranch.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Oh, my God.

Speaker 2So he definitely did stay at one of Epstein's apartments in New York for some time period. Cool.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2He used Epstein to help fill out his clientele as well. That's really where I think Epstein came on big.

Speaker 4Great.

Speaker 1Yeah, because he can connect him to other rich guys who are interested in longevity stuff.

Speaker 2That's exactly right. And it looks like he's giving him medication. He's probably giving him metformin, which is another diabetes medication, which I don't.

Speaker 1Think Epstein had. It's very popular for life extension folks.

Speaker 2Right, yeah. In return, he provides medical care and advice. And to quote Atiyah later, he says, to be clear, I never witnessed illegal behavior and never saw anyone who appeared underage in his presence. But, To also be clear.

Speaker 1Appeared doing a lot of work. That is a very, very strong piece of verbiage there. There's a lot weighted on that.

Speaker 2Yes, exactly right.

Speaker 1Disgusting.

Speaker 2It's not ideal. No, no, no. No, men are terrible. I don't think you're going to find Robert and I defending men in general. No.

Speaker 1I'm being very specific about who I'm attacking here.

Speaker 2Okay. Also... To be clear, it was not a mystery at this point who Epstein was. As you mentioned, he already had a record and a reputation well known, and you can even tell from these emails that Atiyah knows his friend is infamous. I reviewed as many of these emails as I could tolerate, and there's a couple lines I want to read through some of these for you guys that I think stand out. 2015, an email thread from Atiyah with a redacted photo. and the subject line,

Speaker 2got a fresh shipment. Not clear what Atiyah was referring to there. Hold on. It's not clear what Atiyah's referring to there. He said later it was the medication metformin, but that kind of weird. But Epstein responds with an email that says, me too, with an attached photo, but the attached photo is redacted.

Speaker 1I got some theories.

Speaker 2Well, Atiyah's response, let me tell you first before you tell me your theories, Atiyah's response was, Please tell me you found that picture online. Dot, dot, dot. Bastard. Cool. Yeah. Yeah. Fuckers.

Speaker 1Not a lot. We're not exactly. We're not exactly connecting. Like, this isn't like a crazy board situation where we have to, like, draw pictures with, like, twine. It's pretty obvious what's happening here. Yeah.

Speaker 2Epstein's response was, afraid not. He just. He's so ghoulish, even in his emails.

Speaker 1What always takes me is not Epstein's ghoulishness, because he's Epstein. It's the degree to which you can tell there's so many of these guys that all cool is to them is having access to frighteningly young women. Like, that's cool. That's what makes you have, like, an enviable life is the young girls around you.

Speaker 2Cool. And to be clear, Atiyah's not the only doctor in these files. providing medical care or doing something for, for, for Epstein. And that bums me out so much. There's like one normal Norman Finkelstein to every like 20 other dudes trying to like get in on Epstein in Epstein's world. You know, Norman Finkelstein was invited to go to his, uh, he's the Columbia professor. I don't know if you know who he is. Cool dude. Um, Anyways, he was invited

Speaker 2by another academic colleague, and he was like, no, and if I ever see you bringing your daughter to hang out with Epstein, I'll throttle you. There are some cool dudes out there. But for the most part, it's just dudes like this who just want to be close to power. They want to be close to it. They want to suckle at the teat of these rich and powerful people. And doctors are no exception, and that really... bums me out. And not just because we took a stupid oath, but because, like, it's not our job. And it leads to more... We'll

Speaker 2get to that. I got something to deal with. Anyways, okay. So anyways, Epstein said, afraid not. So, you know, in defense of Etia, he said it was a picture of an adult woman. Now, I don't think that makes a lot of sense, because if it was a picture of an adult woman... why would he say, please tell me you found that picture online, dot, dot, dot, bastard? Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, I guess because he's like, theoretically, maybe just some hot adult lady that he's like, oh, please tell me that's not someone you're in front of right now because it's so cool that you get to fuck her, right? Like, that would be the defensive thing, knowing what we know about Jeffrey. My assumption isn't that she's of age.

Speaker 2I don't think so either. And I also doesn't, I mean, if my buddy was like, hey, this is this hot chick that I'm hooking up with, and she's of age, and it seems like normal. I don't think I'd be.

Speaker 1If he just sends me a picture of her sight unseen, that's also upsetting.

Speaker 2That's pretty weird.

Speaker 1But also, I mean, here's what I'll say. There were guys, and I kind of suspect Bill Clinton was one of them, who Jeffrey would have played them with women, but would have played them with adult women, because he didn't just automatically send someone underage. That's not what every creepy guy prefers. There's some creepy men who prefer to have sex with, like, 20-year-olds, right?

Speaker 2Right. Like.

Speaker 1that are provided to them by a service or whatever. So that's not impossible. But even if, even if the, he's playing you with adult women, you know what Jeffrey, you know, he got arrested for trafficking children. You know what he's doing to other guys, just because your taste is like not a felony. Doesn't mean that you're not enabling and supporting a guy who's trafficking children as a pen, right?

Speaker 2Even if you never saw it, You know what was happening. You know.

Speaker 1And I don't believe that never saw it.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1I think I think Jeffrey brought out a smorgasbord, you know, for the rich, powerful men. And some of them were adults. Some of them weren't. But the guys, they know what's happening and they often see what's happening, even if their tastes are not in that direction.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2So another email from 2016, Atiyah tells Epstein that he would, quote, love to add five years or more to your life, even if the only reason to do so is to have more sex. It's so gross.

Speaker 1Cool stuff, Peter.

Speaker 2It's so gross. Nice.

Speaker 1Yeah, disgusting.

Speaker 2I'm going to read this next one also, but I want you to take a drink of your water while you do it.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2Okay. In a related exchange, he asked J.E., have you decided if you're interested in living longer? Solely for the ladies, of course. Spit take.

Speaker 1I was going to do a spit take, but I don't want to actually like.

Speaker 2I don't want to have to then clean up after that.

Speaker 1I've got like vegetable powder in my water.

Speaker 2I don't want you to ask me about eating vegetable powder. Okay, another email. And this one's a big one. The biggest problem with becoming friends with you, the life you lead is so outrageous, and yet I can't tell a soul. Why not, Pete? Why can't you tell a soul, Pete?

Speaker 1Yeah, because of the felonies. Because of the felonies.

Speaker 2Listen, he knew the guy was a dirtbag, but I'll say this. I've become friends from doing this podcast with a couple of famous people. I tell everyone about it because they're not ghouls, Pete. They're not ghouls. If you hang out with people that aren't terrible, you can tell people.

Speaker 1Yeah. It's this idea that like what cool is and like the real, like the only kind of life that's really worth bragging about is one in which you just have constant, very young women or girls around you all the time. And it's all about like, it's, it's a very, wasn't cool enough in a high school and never got over it attitude as opposed to like, I don't know. Like when I think of the people I know who are like really cool and who I like tell people about, cause their lifestyle is so amazing. It's folks who like, have hobbies and do stuff like, you know, they participate

Speaker 1in like fucking incredible races or they like build things. They make like weird custom cars or motorcycles, uh, or they, they engage in like incredible feats of athleticism. You know, they build things, they into 3d printing or like they have skills and they make stuff and they, I don't know, that all takes money, but it's, it's actually impressive as opposed to just like, Oh yeah, you're just hanging out a bunch of around a bunch of like really young women who you're probably applying with money.

Speaker 2Cool yeah okay um another email that struck me it was him pleading with epstein's handlers to basically help arrange a play date with him i go into je withdrawals when i don't see him uh famously there is the email from a tia to epstein discussing the issue of cunnilingus that i brought up in the very beginning of the first podcast and i apologize i'm sorry Pussy is indeed low carb. Still awaiting results on gluten, though. Okay. Now I'm going to say something that's very, very controversial here.

Speaker 1Okay?

Speaker 2And I apologize in advance. Feel free to cut. But in a vacuum, this conversation I don't think is completely terrible for a couple reasons. One, It would at least suggest they're attempting to provide some pleasure. But that is something that I encourage men to do in general with their partners because I think there's a potential health benefit in terms of probiotics for men to get. And more men should be doing it if their partners want it. But I don't know if there are benefits because nobody will ever fund that study. But the point is, if

Speaker 2one of the two people in this conversation weren't the worst people in history, this could be a genuinely interesting scientific question. The nerd in me has curiosity.

Speaker 1If, if Jeffrey, if someone's talking about like giving a massage to like a partner, that's perfectly fine. If it's Jeffrey Epstein, it's not because that partner is probably not an adult, right? Like that's the thing.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1That's the issue. I think is that you just have no idea.

Speaker 2It's very gross. I agree. It's very, but I mean, as a scientist, there's a part of me that has, has questions. Um, but let's, let's move past that. Um, There's one other thing that his emails shed light on. It's something that was dug up afterwards. I'm not sure if it got enough attention. In his book, he shares that in July of 2017, while he was in New York, his one-month-old son back in California almost died. Has to be resuscitated by his wife, who's a nurse. And for

Speaker 2four days, his wife is begging him to come back home. She had to perform the resuscitation herself. The child is in the ICU. She needs him back home. And he didn't because he felt his work was too important. That's his own admission. Now, he will say that this was a mistake. He frames it as having deep disgust with himself for doing that. He's like, I thought my work was so important, I had to stay to do my work. But here's the thing. In his book, he shares the date being July 11th. And when you go through the files,

Speaker 2the Epstein files, he has an email exchange on July 13th to Epstein, where basically he's planning to meet him. And he's like, yeah, I'll meet you wherever you want. Like, so during this time while this kid is in the ICU, he is still there doing important work, quote unquote, but really it's to try and hang out with Epstein. And that is rough out of all the things. That's a really, that's a tough one. And I will say this. I think if anything gives him shame, it is that. That's

Speaker 2the only good news is that he probably does feel terrible about that.

Speaker 5No.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Along with the CBS fallout, he also parted ways with protein bar company David and powdered supplement maker AG1 or Athletic Greens. And he's currently in a lawsuit with wearable medical tracker Aura, the Aura ring, after they distanced themselves from him. They sound kind of like a sketchy company themselves.

Speaker 1But I don't know.

Speaker 2The thing about this, this is really a cautionary tale, I think, for all doctors. It's the cautions of interacting with people with fame and power. Doctors, as I mentioned, are people pleasers at heart. And just like anyone else, we can be drawn to the appeals of the rich and famous. And doctors can find themselves doing things to and for these people that they wouldn't do for other patients. And like that 2012 study, this is not always a service to people. Nope. Patient satisfaction doesn't always correlate with good outcomes. They want to be liked by these individuals.

Speaker 2They want to be seen as useful patients. And that can land the doctor, and more importantly, the patient, in serious trouble. Look at Michael Jackson's doctor, Matthew Perry's, Joan Rivers. These are all examples of when doctors probably overstepped the bounds of what they should have done, in part at least because they were dealing with a famous and rich person. So, my closing thoughts. Again, there's a lot of what he does that is not bad.

Speaker 1Uh-uh.

Speaker 2I'm well aware, as I said, that he is not the worst person, one of the least bad people we've ever done on the show. And I still hold out.

Speaker 1I don't know.

Speaker 3Hung out with Epstein.

Speaker 1The Epstein stuff really changes my opinion on that a bit.

Speaker 2Yeah. I still hold out hope for redemption arc as I do for everyone. I don't know why I do that, but I can't help but do that. But. What it does, it says a lot about the practice of medicine in this country and how it is moving towards becoming something even more economically inaccessible and unequal. It says something about the common pitfalls doctors make once they become public figures and what can happen when influence outweighs the actual science, becomes more important than the actual science. I think he's

Speaker 2sort of the missing link between the dangerous maha pseudoscience practitioners and the more mainstream, but kind of also problematic healthcare leaders like recent FDA commissioner, Marty Macari, who he claims is his close personal friend. He's not a bastard because he's malicious. He's because it's consequential. He's part of this push that's making medicine. I think he's a bastard.

Speaker 3I'm just going to.

Speaker 2Say it. I will say this. Like, I feel comfortable when he talks about certain things. He talks about strength training. Fine. Do it. Um, And I do want people listening to these things and learning about metabolic syndrome and learning what it is. I also don't want them being so hyper-focused on it. I think... We face bigger problems when he faces into areas where he doesn't have expertise. For example, we talked about colon cancer and I know what's right there. Then it sounds really silly to me. And I'm like, you just can't be an expert in all things, which is something that we have to address and grapple with

Speaker 2as medical podcasters. And this is something I have to wrestle with all the time, which is how do we do what we do and not fall into these common mistakes? And I try hard, but I don't know, maybe I'm not perfect either about this. I don't consider myself a medical influencer like he is, but it's always concerning to me if I'm overstepping my expertise or my bounds. So having the air of authority but without the same responsibility and guardrails of real medical practice is a concern for

Speaker 2all physician podcasters, myself included, and is a concern here with him. It's something we should all be aware of.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2But the long and short of it is I think he is a part of this push that is making medicine less scientific and it's making medicine less accessible. And it really worries me and concerns me. And that is my shtick on Dr. Peter Attia.

Speaker 1Well, thank you.

Speaker 2Thanks, Kaveh.

Speaker 1Yeah, bastard ends of things. You want to plug things before we roll out here?

Speaker 2I certainly do. I want to plug my podcast, The House of Pod. It is a fun-ish medical podcast. We look at science. We look at wellness grifters and make fun of them. And we talk about what RFK Jr. is doing to our terrible country. But even more than that, I want you to listen to my brand new podcast that I'm very excited about called Persian of Interest. It's about Persian contributions to art, music, philosophy, science, a lot of the fun stories that we've been written out of or minimized in. And we're going to cover a lot of great topics with a lot of great guests. It's

Speaker 2going to be a really fun time. Please check it out. Bye. Bye.

Speaker 1Bye.

Speaker 3Behind the Bastards is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com. Or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Full video episodes of Behind the Bastards are now streaming on Netflix, dropping every Tuesday and Thursday. Hit Remind Me on Netflix so you don't miss an episode. For clips and our older episode catalog, continue to subscribe to our YouTube channel, youtube.com slash at Behind the Bastards. We love about 40% of you, statistically speaking.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. It Could Happen Here Weekly 259

    Nov 21, 20263 hr 56 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Part Two: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Robert concludes the story of Pastor Mackenzie's starvation apocalypse church with a really shocking mass murder.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    This week Robert takes us to Kenya, and the deadliest cult since the days of Jonestown. Prepare to meet Pastor Paul Mackenzi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. It Could Happen Here Weekly 258

    Nov 14, 20264 hr 13 minAudio

    All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Part Two: Don Simpson: The Producer of Top Gun Also Ruined Hollywood

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.

    Credit the people on this episode