Oprah Winfrey has been responsible for introducing several of the most toxic monsters of our era to society. But is she a bastard? Robert sits down with Bridgett Todd and Andrew Ti to investigate. (Six Part Series)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Also media.
Speaker 2I watched a man vomiting a casino pit last night. Was beautiful. Welcome back to Behind the Bastards, a podcast that's this week hosted from sunny Las Vegas, Nevada. We've got a real special one for you this week. We've got an episode about somebody who embodies everything that is meaningful about like where we are in America today, like both our complete divorce as a culture from any sort
Speaker 2of shared truth, our acceptance of all sorts of like weird, unhinged metaphysical realities. The guy who's probably going to be running Medicaid in the near future. We all owe them to our topic this week. Our subject this week someone you all have heard of, Oprah Winfrey. And because Oprah is such a big topic and honestly kind of a scary person to go after, this might be the most powerful bastard we've talked about. I brought in some very special guests. First off, let's say a warm welcome to
Speaker 2the great Bridget Todd Bridget, Welcome to the show.
Speaker 3I want to say it like Oprah Dove, thank you for having me. I actually has that thing.
Speaker 1I just knew, I just knew you were the right person for this job.
Speaker 3I don't even know Bridget I do.
Speaker 1I was gonna say, Bridget is the host of There Are No Girls on the Internet, and that's right, and also just one of my favorite people in the entire world.
Speaker 4That's right. That's right.
Speaker 5She is here.
Speaker 1And we are so lucky. Who is our second guest today? Because we couldn't have just one for.
Speaker 2Oh no, no, for Oprah. You got to bring out that. You got to have a double barrel, you know, if you're going if you're going for a grizzly bear. And our second round of buckshot this week is.
Speaker 3Andrew t.
Speaker 1Thanks for being carry Andrew. Andrew is the host.
Speaker 3Of you is this racist?
Speaker 4That's right? How's it going?
Speaker 2We're gonna need to ask that a lot in these episodes.
Speaker 3The answer is always gonna.
Speaker 4Be, yeah, boy, it is.
Speaker 2There's a lot of stuff to discuss there, Robert.
Speaker 1Robert and I have been talking about doing the Oprah episodes for what feels like a year and the subject of like who do we have on for this? Like how like guess who do we have on?
Speaker 4What do we do?
Speaker 1Because like no matter what, like I mean, I I read Oprah's bio in like middle school and like she yeah comes off with her like origin story as like heroic.
Speaker 2She's deeply sympathetic in many ways, and these first two episodes are going you're gonna be sympathetic to her more often than not because we are covering a lot of her childhood in these The things that she does that are awful, and the reason why she deserves to be on the show is not because she's personally odious right in like her personal interactions usually like I've run into a bunch of like reddits where people who worked on the show talking more often than not, people who worked on the Oprah Winfrey shows say like, we were paid well, it was a reasonably good gig. You know. You can
Speaker 2certainly find people being like a she was a dick to me when I was like a barista or whatever. There's stories like that, but I wouldn't hang an episode on it. It's more her level of influence is so titanic and the things that she has chosen, she's chosen to push a number of people who are We have done two part episodes on in the past, Doctor Oz Doctor Phil both owed their careers and the intense amounts of damage that they've done to society, to Oprah Winfrey. Neither of those guys are in anyone's radar if it's not for Oprah Winfrey. John of God, that Brazilian mystic
Speaker 2who raped and molested thousands of people, owes a huge amount of her career in prominence to Oprah Winfrey. There's a number of cases like that. She's tied in massively with a satanic panic. She's tied in massively with a number of different like myths like we're going to talk about, like rainbow parties and the like. So we've got a lot of fun stuff today. I do want to start by asking Bridget Andrew, what are y'all's histories with Oprah.
Speaker 1Oh, that's a good question.
Speaker 6Oh.
Speaker 3I mean, I have to say, I'm really glad that you framed the Oprah conversation the way that you did, because I almost have like a love hate with Oprah. Yeah, you can't. First of all, you can't be a black woman and not have some deep admiration for Oprah. And I would say it's only been recently that I have really had to have my come to Jesus moment of some of the bad actors. Charlatan's hucksters and just like bastards that she has made famous and now we're sort of stuck with. So it's sort of a love hate Oprah.
Speaker 3Like I did a report on her when I was in fifth grade where I had to dress like her.
Speaker 2Yeah, you're, weirdly enough, not the only friend of mine who did a report on Oprah for when they were in school.
Speaker 7Yeah. Well yeah, I think there's like an element of like it's a little bit like Obama.
Speaker 4You're like, it's good that there's a.
Speaker 7Different type of like like a like a black person being able to achieve the highest ranks of whatever.
Speaker 2The wealthiest. She's the wealthiest person in media period, like wealthiest purely media star, two billion, something like that.
Speaker 7But there's also like some version of like having to so you're like kind of grading on a curve. It's like for a billionaire, she's probably pretty good, you know, relatively speaking, I mean, but she has you know, she has all the trap. It's the same with Obama, where you're like, every president has committed crimes against humanity.
Speaker 4That's just the job.
Speaker 7But like so for a while, you're like it's sort of nice that he's like, you know, he is who he is. But then you're like, just she weren't doing all these terrible things.
Speaker 2As we'll talk about one of the complicated things about Oprah. There's a bunch of stuff that really is very sinister about her impact. And then when you whenever you're reading the books and stuff, the critical bios of her, the things they choose to go after her for are always like, well, actually, I don't think she did anything wrong. There, Like, there's a lot of very weird she's she has she has also had to You can't talk about the things she's done bad without also defending her because she has come under fire for so many insanely unreasonable things as well.
Speaker 5I also did an Oprah book report, probably in the fifth grade, And you know, she was on my television for my mom watched a lot of Oprah.
Speaker 1There was a lot of Oprah in my household growing up. And then like a few years ago, I was working on a project with Jamie Loftus and we went back and we were looking for like a specific Oprah episode to reference in something, and just the show episode titles were so triggering. Oh yeah, and then it's and then Robert and Bridget you were both at you were both of the DNC and Chicago, but I don't think you guys were both there for Oprah speech?
Speaker 7Were you.
Speaker 4Speech?
Speaker 3I was in the audience. I remember it very well.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1I was there for that, and it was like the most like like detached I felt from an audience in my life. I was like, I was like, oh, no.
Speaker 3Sophy, do you remember. I feel like she got I completely agree with you about the tenor and the vibe of the speech. However, maybe it was just my section. I feel like people were losing their fucking minds when she came out and started talking like yeah, I was like, are we hearing the same speech?
Speaker 1Like it truly I had what I'm saying. That's why. That's why I was like I was. I was like, I was like, really, we're still, We're still. And then again with there were several people that I was like, Oh, these are known horrible humans and people are going Pharaoh for them as well. But yeah, Oprah Oprah.
Speaker 2Cheers were It's hard to get across because there's really no one on earth like this, how cross at least first certain kind of for a certain like category of person, particularly like middle aged moms from the nineties through the through the aughts. It's amazing the degree to which Oprah completely cut across like political and cultural boundaries. You know, Like my mom was a very conservative white lady in Texas loved Oprah. Oprah was always on and like that was the case with every mom that I knew as
Speaker 2a kid, Like Oprah was just like an institution, you know, like it's it's it's really And I don't think she's even quite like that today, just because like things have gotten considerably more fragmented in the media ecosystem, and so one of the things that's interesting about her is like when we talk about her influence, there probably won't ever be a single person that influential again in the same way.
Speaker 1Yeah, Bridget at the DNC, when she came out, were you sitting or standing?
Speaker 4Ugh?
Speaker 3I wish I could say that I like turned my back, you know, I gave her a standing ovation even from my like big talk.
Speaker 1But you were you in the standing section.
Speaker 3Or this ex I was in the seated section. I was.
Speaker 4So here's my question.
Speaker 1When she came out, did you immediately look under your chair?
Speaker 3Like, yeah, like Oprah, did you leave me?
Speaker 2You get a car?
Speaker 3I wish Oprah.
Speaker 1Came out at an instinctly was like, is there a gift? There was, There was not.
Speaker 3Honestly though, if anybody could arrange that, it would be Oprah exactly.
Speaker 2I should let you know. I've bought you both cars. They're not They're not they're geoprisms. They are not like these are really like burdens for both of you.
Speaker 4Robert's books. It's really just like a.
Speaker 2Used to offload I'm underwater on a deal. In the spring of twenty twenty four, Oprah Winfrey participated in a three hour special sponsored by weight Watchers called Making the Shift, alongside several other celebrity panelists. She talked about the failures and shortcomings of America's toxic diet culture and took some degree of ownership for her role in perpetuating it, calling herself a major contributor and saying I've been a major
Speaker 2contributor to it. I cannot tell you how many weight loss shows and makeovers I've done, and they have been a staple since I've been working in television. And even this statement, which is fairly unequivocal, underplays the reality of the situation, because it's probably accurate to say that no one human being alive has had more of an impact on how Americans talk about dieting and weight loss than Oprah Winfrey. For the entirety of the time that everyone on this call has been alive, she has been the most public face of diet culture, and tens of thousands of Americans followed along as she gained and lost weight
Speaker 2in the public eye. One of the biggest regrets of her career came in nineteen ninety eight as a result of this, and I'm talking about the famous wagon of Fat incident, which was precisely what it sounds like. Winfrey launched a new season of her hit daytime talk show by pulling out a red wagon filled with sixty seven pounds a fat, which is how much she'd lost on her most recent diet. And because this is kind of what Oprah says is in her view, the lowest moment of her career, I do want to start with playing a clip from this because it represents the intersection of
Speaker 2a couple of very complicated things we're going to have to dissect in these episodes.
Speaker 3Oh my god, Now let me tell you.
Speaker 1I lost.
Speaker 6I have lost as of this morning. As of this morning, sixty seven pounds since July seventh, sixty seven pounds and thirty inches from my bust, my waist Emma hoops seven twelve eleven. I think it is. And this let me tell you those of you who are starting dieting or dining a little bit, this is what sixty seven pounds of fat looks like. I can't I can't lift it. Now when you talk about Jimmy, is this gross or what.
Speaker 4Okay to me?
Speaker 3That I can't lift it?
Speaker 6But I used to carry it around.
Speaker 3She's definitely lifting.
Speaker 4The radio flyer people. Do you think they were like that in there?
Speaker 3Oh god, I remember that clip like it was yesterday when you as soon as you set it up, I closed my eyes and I can like I remember it crystal clear, Like what a moment in culture.
Speaker 2Yeah, and she does look great in that video. No one can deny that. And it's interesting to me first off that this is this is such like a especially in like the critical reading on Oprah. This is such like an apocal moment, right, like how how toxic this was? What a bad you know moment this was in terms of like cause like inculcating toxic attitudes and American you know culture visa v weight loss and how like tame It seems honestly in a lot of ways considering like where we are now just in general with like the TV,
Speaker 2how much like worse ship there is every single day. But it's also interesting because like this is an easy moment to hang on as toxic. I actually don't I have trouble blaming Oprah the for this, even though she's definitely contributing to some really ugly aspects of diet culture. As we'll talk about, the way she gets attacked and like focused on in the media over her weight is probably unique. Like I don't know that anyone else has been kind of anyone else's personal weight has been obsessed
Speaker 2over to the same degree that Oprah's has. It certainly was in the late nineties. So yeah, as we'll talk about, I don't see this as like a low point for her, but this is probably what she would name as like the absolute worst thing in her career.
Speaker 7Wait, and maybe I'm missing something, so and she would say that, or she has said that because it's just like a crass stunt.
Speaker 2It's and she has started to talk about the degree to which she thinks that diet culture and the are obsession with that and weight loss is unhealthy, and that she was a big part of that, right like she started talking about it now, she started talking about that in participation with weight watchers. So I don't know, I don't know how much credit you want to give her, right like clearly done in good faith. Yeah, maybe not totally done in good maybe more of just a pivot.
Speaker 7But I will just say, as someone who is like a little more outside of the Oprah sphere, I think, compared to everyone else here, I feel like I didn't particularly perceive, like I hear what you're saying about, like she was like one of the faces of it, was so pervasive everywhere. Not to like completely let her off the hook, but it is a little just like that's what you did when you were like especially marketing to middle aged women.
Speaker 2But it's partly what you did because Oprah was so successful at it, Like she likes it's a road that was there because she bush whacked it, you know, right, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, I actually have a a similar take. I think that why she regrets this is not because of like participating in this harmful, toxic diet culture YadA YadA, YadA, which she was. I think it was sort of throwing red meat to the people Robert that you were just describing who obsessed about her weight Personally, I think that, Yeah, it's probably a low point because she was engaging in this like highly personal public conversation about her weight and like playing into that. I don't I would probably I don't know that she was would say like, oh, I
Speaker 3shouldn't have been participating in diet culture written large.
Speaker 2Yeah right, yeah, yeah, I think that that's that that might be a fair critique, but we'll talk about it. But first, for these for these couple of episodes, we're going to really be getting into like the parts of Oprah's crew that are mostly or life that are mostly like a lot more empathetic, although you know, there's there's there's some darkness there too, mainly in like the way in which she has kind of lied and judged up some aspects of her background because it makes a better story. Yeah, this will all be interesting to talk about. So in
Speaker 2twenty twenty one, one of my sources for this is a book that Oprah released about trauma, much of which she discussed through the lens of her own childhood trauma. She co authored What Happened to You with doctor Bruce Perry, an American psychiatrist who specializes in child trauma, and from what I can tell, is like one of the less toxic doctors that Oprah is famous for launching to start them, although again that doesn't necessarily mean a whole lot. In an interview about that book for today dot Com, Oprah
Speaker 2posited that her childihood trauma was responsible for her low moments like the wagon a fat incident. I think that certainly all of the feelings of not fitting in of my disease to please, or feeling like if I don't do what everyone wants me to do, I'm going to be rejected somehow what I was afraid of in every instance, I'm going to get a whipping. I'm afraid I'm going to get that whipping. Thankfully, She adds, the decades of time she spent processing her pain has given her sort of what she calls post traumatic wisdom that she thinks makes her a good spokesperson for every kind of suffering
Speaker 2in a mirror or for a lot many kinds of suffering in American society today, right like because of my trauma, That's why I've done some of the things that I regret. It's my disease to please. It's like my fear of not fitting in. But because I have that trauma, I'm also a perfect spokesperson for many of these kinds of like traumas in American society. And the fact that she thinks that way is a really important prism to understand what she does, because Oprah in a lot of ways, if you look at especially the first ten or fifteen years of her show, it's a mirror in some ways
Speaker 2of like the Jerry Springer Show. Like they're literally doing some of the same episodes, bringing like clansmen out, you know, to have like big arguments and fights on stage. There's a lot of like, you know, bringing out people in relationships who are having conflicts. It is that kind of like trash teed TV. And then in the late nineties she starts to pivot, and largely the thing that she pivots around is her taking her own childhood trauma, her own experiences of like physical and sexual abuse and whatnot, and using that as sort of a lens through which
Speaker 2to explore those things in American society. And there's both a degree to which there are some really important issues that started getting attention because Oprah used herself as a lens to kind of like highlight them. And also there's this sense of like almost profiteering from the same things, which which makes this very complicated to discuss it.
Speaker 7I feel like it's so weird too, because it's like at the time, as you're describing it, I probably wouldn't have perceived it as such, but like we're also in an era where like influencer and just like you like that is the product that everyone, you know, the children today are very casually selling. Yeah, it's almost like the concept of like selling out for like between the nineties and the two of it. It's like, you know, it's not something that you would bad any at everything you're describing right now.
Speaker 2No, no, no, But it was really unique at the time, right.
Speaker 3Yes, it does seem like she was like very ahead of the game on this, like oh yes, I think it's like the influencer bread and butter today, But back then, I mean I do think that it set her apart from like your Jerry Springer's, your Jenny Jones is to really put these kind of trauma like it was like authenticity before that was a thing we expected from TV show hosts.
Speaker 2Yep, that's exactly I think that's exactly it, Bridgid. And what's kind of undeniable is that she was able to kind of get access to a lot of stories of people's hurting by from her own background of suffering. Her old executive producer Diane Hudson once told people profiles quote, vulnerability is the key to Oprah's success. People appreciate when you can be honest. It lets them feel more comfortable about themselves. She's got this special kind of connective ability. I see happen over and over again. Everyone who meets her feels like, oh, now I know her. And that's
Speaker 2what you're talking about, that kind of authenticity being the buzzword that it is today. It all really starts with Oprah, and yeah, it is one. It's both. I think there is a lot of vulnerability that she's been willing to put out there. But at the same time, Oprah's not like Oprah is a conscious crafter of her own image and her own story.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2She knows what she's doing. She's not like a naive in this kind of situation, in this kind of scenario, and that muddles the waters too, because some of this authenticity is very carefully sculpted rather than something that's kind of come out purely just as a natural reaction, you know. And that's going to make talking about some of this very hard because we do have, like especially when we talk about the traumas of her childhood, you have different sources who disagree and who disagree with like some of
Speaker 2the things Oprah says about what happens to her. And as a spoiler, like, we're not going to know, like who's actually right here because I certainly wasn't there when Oprah was a little kid. I'm gonna guess neither of you were either. Two of the biggest sources for this episode are first that book that Oprah wrote with a doctor about her own trauma, and then there's two biographies. One was written kind of early on in Oprah's time is a world famous talk show host nineteen ninety Nine's Oprah Winfrey, written by Meryl Noden for People Profiles, and
Speaker 2if you want, even like, you know, that's kind of actually a surprisingly good for being a pop biography, look at Oprah's backstory and kind of the different takes on what happened to her as a kid. A more recent biography is Kitty Kelly's Oprah, which is another major source for this episode. Now I'm going to warn you Kitty's twenty ten book is a mean biography, and she is kind, It's the best kind. Is like she is recognized as a lover of gossip and like, you know, there's a
Speaker 2tabloid feel to this. She's also someone who does put in the work to dig up dirt on her subjects, but it tends to be like real dirt, you know. But this is a mean book, you know, Like, don't mistake this for a work of like objective biography. Like so, like all great media figures, including you know me, Oprah's hometown was a destitute, little slice of hell in the middle of nowhere. This is something I really identify with her with. Right. She comes up in Kuseiusko kus Usko, Mississippi,
Speaker 2which is seventy or so miles above Jackson. She once said of her hometown that place is so small you can spit and be out of town before your spit hits the ground, which I both I get that feeling, right that like this isn't even there's nothing here right, Like, this isn't even a town, which I like empathize with. That's that's how I felt as a kid about fucking Ida Belle. It's a little bit of an exaggeration. And there were about sixty seven hundred people in town when she grew up, which like isn't huge, but it's not
Speaker 2quite that tiny now. She was born in the home of her maternal grandparents, Hattie May and Earlist Lee, who was known as Earless by the family because he was super old and also deaf as hell. The town has that weird Polish name because it's named after a Polish Revolutionary War general who was also an ardent abolitionist, and as a result, it had a fairly law or not as a result, but like that it having that name is a result of the fact that it had a very large black population. It was extremely segregated and extremely poor.
Speaker 2So yeah, that's the town that she grows up in, and it's one of those places that had largely been built around a cotton mill which went bust in nineteen forty eight, and that's kind of when things start to fall apart in her hometown because people start fleeing for northern cities that might still have work. You know, this is what's happening in kris Usko is kind of a microcosm of like a much larger national trend at the time. Right like this, this is a thing that's happening elsewhere to a lot of places. Meryl Noden writes, quote. Oprah's
Speaker 2parents were among those who left military service had already given twenty year old Vernon Winfrey a ticket out. He was at home on a furlough from Fort Rucker, Alabama, on the springs day he met Vernita Lee, an eighteen year old high school student and part time domestic worker. The two barely knew each other when they had what their daughter has described as a one day fling under an oak tree. The encounter seems to have been a source of shame for the ambitious young man who would go on to become a deacon in his church. In a Nashville City councilman, I'm not proud of what happened with Oprah's mother and me, Winfrey has said. I tell people today that if something like that happens, the boy
Speaker 2should help take care of the child. So that's the Pham, Yeah, it's not his. He's not told until she's born, right, Yeah, And he does like send financial aid as soon as he's told, but like they don't, they don't really let him know until there's already a kid. And as another spoiler, he might not actually be her biological father. I don't know that that doesn't really make a huge deal in this story because they all think he is during this period of time, and he's like going to be very
Speaker 2much a responsible dad to the extent that he is like allowed to be. But it is kind of like a little unclear as to what actually, like who her actual like biological dad is. I don't think that there's like a solid answer on that. Every biography will give you a little bit of a different answer. But Vernon is the one that they think is the biological father, you know, for most of this period of time. And Oprah Gail Winfrey is born on January twenty ninth, nineteen fifty four, And the story behind her name is a
Speaker 2fun one. So does anyone know what Oprah's original name was supposed to be?
Speaker 7This is the one thing I think I know, Oh yeah, isn't it Wasn't it supposed to be Orpa?
Speaker 2It was supposed to be Orpa, Yeah, which was it's a biblical name. Ruth's like if you know, I think Ruth was like Moses's sister, or because she pretty, she was like tight with Moses if I remember the Bible right, and Orpo was one of her friends. And this is like, it really says a lot about like the people here Orpa is a Bible deep cut. This is the This is the Biblical equivalent of like a Star Wars fan who names his kid after Kitster Banai, who's one of Anakin Skywalker's little little friends from Tattooine. So he's gonna
Speaker 2pull up a picture of Kitster here, not for any real reason. I don't know why I thought this joke deserved to be presented.
Speaker 3Because there he is.
Speaker 2There's kits there looking at him.
Speaker 3Like something.
Speaker 2L I'm sure he has, like I'm sure someone out there has, like the has like the original model from when the Phantom Menace came out of this little child.
Speaker 1I love, I love I love that haircut, built in bangs.
Speaker 2I'm no more a Bible scholar than I am a fan of the Phantom Menace. I did have to look up that kid's name, although I remembered his face. It's one of those things that's burnt into.
Speaker 4My head from my childhood.
Speaker 2I gotta say, though, from what I can read, and maybe I'm missing something here, not being a Bible scholar, it feels like her aunt picking Orpa as a name might have been her throwing shade at the baby. Because in the Book of Ruth Orpa, the person Orpa has a chance to go with Ruth and someone named Naomi, who are like going down this more godly path, or return to her old pagan gods and like her, you know, her villager and whatever, and Orpa turns back and goes
Speaker 2back to like being a pagan right and rabbinic literature. According to Wikipedia, so again I'm I'm not a rabbinic literature ever. Orpa is identified with Harappa, the mother of Goliath, and three other Philistine giants. Also, Harappa had a lively social life, by which I mean like got around right. The Babylonian Talmud describes her as being threshed by as many men as a man would thresh wheat.
Speaker 3Not threshed thresh.
Speaker 4That's in the fucking Bible.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4The Bible. The Bible loves doing like we got threshed. How much her body.
Speaker 3Count was crazy.
Speaker 4Yeah, I'm saying threshed from now on.
Speaker 2I'm saying threshed too. Uh so all till Yeah, it seems like they're kind of shit talking this baby by naming it Orpa. I don't know why else you would go with Orpa, Like, it's not a it's not a super nice name to give a little kid, just based on how the Bible talks about this person. Maybe she just thought it sounded pretty in anyways.
Speaker 7Just as someone else in the congregation just named a kid Neba Canezer and you just had to like want to that's a name.
Speaker 4That's a name.
Speaker 2And it's also a size of wine bottle that's now legal in Florida. Wow, that just happened. It's massive. Sofa can pull up a picture of a Nebukenzer of wine.
Speaker 6I do.
Speaker 1I'm not just imagine a really big bottle of wine.
Speaker 2It's very big. It's like most of your height of wine. So this is the first time where Oprah gets really lucky. Obviously she's born, you know, into a difficult situation, but she gets an early solid in the fact that somebody fucks up on her birth certificate and the name. The midwife misspells her name as Oprah, and everyone just kind of decides good enough, right, And this little error might be one of the luckiest breaks that Oprah ever received. Because I have trouble imagining Orpa working as well as
Speaker 2a star's name.
Speaker 3The Ripo Winfrey Show, the Orba Winfrey Show, I just have trouble imagining it.
Speaker 2You know, Oprah just seems to flow a lot better. I don't know, Maybe I'm wrong, Maybe we would all be saying that if she had been named Orpa and they'd been like, we almost called her Operah. God, can you imagine? I don't know, but yeah, anyway, you know what doesn't have a name is the nameless horror I feel when I think about you all missing out on these ads. Wow, and we're back. So we're talking Oprah,
Speaker 2who has now come into the world. So once she is born, the job of caring for this new baby is almost immediately made the work of Hattie May Presley, her grandmother, and that Presley there is going to be the reason why Oprah will, for years, for big chunk of her life, claim that she is related to Elvis. This does not seem to be the case. I don't think anyone in her family ever believed that. But she will make statements like that for quite some time, and it's one of the things that members of her family
Speaker 2will be like, I don't know why she does that. We're not related to Elvis in any way. Does she still do that today?
Speaker 3You think?
Speaker 2I don't think she still does it, But maybe I'm wrong about that. All of the times I found, like all the quotes of her claiming that I found her from earlier in her career, that's.
Speaker 3Truly a wild thing to claim.
Speaker 2Like true, Yeah, I could see it if it was like a widespread family myth that we have, you know, Elvis's kin, but like, it doesn't seem to be because it's always in these books. It's always your family being like, yeah, we got nothing to do with Elvis.
Speaker 7I don't know what she's doing that without being too wildly cynical, the value of being related to Elvis has also diminished greatly in the last probably twenty years, So yeah, it's like no reason to keep it up.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, it's certainly like there's less Yeah, you get less credit from being related to Elvis.
Speaker 3Oh cool, like just having the same last, the same common last It's like me saying, like, my last name is Todd. It's like me saying, oh, Chuck Todd and I are related. It's like, y'all have a very common last name, and what cachet would you be trying to get from that?
Speaker 2Yeah, Or it's like me bringing about my relationship to Rick Santorum.
Speaker 7I mean, but also, like, without getting too gross about American history, the obvious thing is when a black person and a white person have the same last name, the ante seated tends to be a different thing than direct well or.
Speaker 4Whatever I mean, right, lots of awful ways.
Speaker 2But yeah, I mean one way. But in this case, there doesn't seem to be any like evidence of that, right, Like that it's because like Presley's not an uncommon last name, right, there's a shitload of fucking Presley's out there. So Hattie May was the granddaughter of slaves, So that is like how kind of you know, we're talking about like the fifties here, right, And she worked as the cook for the sheriff of KOs Usko and managed the household of a rich white family, the Leonards, and at this point,
Speaker 2we've got two pretty different We start to get two very different stories of Oprah's first six years alive. She once told reporters, quote, I never had a store bought dress or a pair of shoes, and I was six years old. The only toy I had was a corn cob doll with toothpicks. This is like pretty consistent in terms of how Oprah talks about her life. Kitty Kelly writes, quote, she recalled her early years as lonely, with no one to play with except the pigs that she rode bareback around her grandmother's yard. I only had barnyard animals to
Speaker 2talk to. I read them Bible stories. She regaled her audiences with stories of having to carry water from the well, milk cows and empty the slop jar. A childhood of cinders and ashes that was the stuff of fairy tales. Oprah morphed into Operella as she spun her tales about the switch wielding grandmother and cane thumping grandfather who raised her until she was six years old. Oh the whoopings I got, she said. And the degree to which this is mythmaking is up for debate. It is worth noting that a lot of a number of her family members
Speaker 2and friends of the family who knew Oprah during this period very much don't agree with this take on her childhood. And I want to read a quote from that People Profiles biography here. Among Oprah's many assets, maybe a gift for self dramatization. As Vernita once put it, Oprah toots it up a little. In one tale Oprah has often told, she has cast herself as a lonely child whose main comfort was talking to the farm animals. The nearest neighborhood was a blind neighbor was a blind man up the road. She once said, There weren't other kids, no playmates, no toys except for one corn cob doll. I played with
Speaker 2the animals, and I made speeches to the cows. Esther's which is who her aunt, has a different explanation for the loneliness Oprah remembers. Right across the road were Oprah's cousins, the Presley twins, who were her age. They played together when Oprah was allowed to come outside because Aunt hat was very protective of her. And it seems that there's at least a good amount of evidence that the real Oprah's story at least the story of her childhood that the majority of the people who were there for at Tell is not that she was like locked, you know,
Speaker 2is that she was isolated because this was some like middle of the nowhere dirt farm. It's because she had a grandmother who was something of a hell copter parent, right, And while the family certainly wasn't rich, they weren't dirt poor. And in fact, everyone seems to agree that Oprah had a lot of toys. The whole I only had a corn cob doll thing is definitely not true. But the reason she had a lot of nice toys is that they were all hand me downs from their rich white family that Haddie may worked for, which is a complicated thing, right when you're thinking about, like, why would somebody kind
Speaker 2of exaggerate the lack of stuff that they had as a kid when it's like, well, but also the stuff that you have comes to you as a result of this relationship that's kind of very fundamentally unequal and that you were probably somewhat aware of at the time. And Oprah in fact talks a lot about how she was aware of the fact that like, white girls were treated very differently in her town and wanted to be white as a little kid, So like this is all very messy.
Speaker 3Yeah, it goes back to what you were saying, Robert, about how a lot of her early story is quite sympathetic and it's very easy. Like it's on the one hand, it's easy to say, oh, well she was doing some myth making and saying she didn't have any toys, But it's also like more complicated and sort of truer to be like, well, she had toys, but they came from the white kids, and that she didn't maybe maybe was aware of the dynamic there. Like it's less satisfying and more complex, but it doesn't make it any less true.
Speaker 2Right, right, And it's also one of those things where like she talks a lot about being whipped and switched in how like she didn't feel like the same thing happened to the white kids. Now does that mean, like, I'm white kids in Alabama. I'm sure plenty of them got beat by their parents too, But what kind of matters more there is her feeling on it, right, that there were these kids that my grandma's job is to serve, and they clearly get these much nicer things than I am, and it's not surprising to me that that would color her her concept of her childhood much more than like
Speaker 2what her older aunts would have picked up on, which is like, well she always had the nice things, right, yeah, Like neither of them can be lying and there can still be a discrepancy between what they remember, if that makes sense.
Speaker 7But it feels like myth making is sort of a fair way to say it, like this is just kind of part of it. The exact shorthand especially in a like entertainment capacity, like.
Speaker 2The whole I only had the cows to talk to thing is definitely a bit of myth making because like everyone doesn't really No, she had more family around her than that. Yeah, that's that's a little that's a little bit playing it up right.
Speaker 3That's like straight out of the movie Pearl, Like yeah, yeah, the pigs, so yeah, Oprah.
Speaker 2One of the stories she tells that tells is that she was like forced to make friends with cockroaches, which is actually like a reoccurrent bit of hers in her early years. Quote, we were so poor we couldn't afford a catter a dog, so I made pat pets out of two cockroaches. I put him in a jar and named them Melinda and sand and Oprah's sister Patricia Lloyd, does not entirely agree with this take. Oprah exaggerated how bad we had it, I guess to get sympathy from her viewers and widen her audience. She never had cockroaches for pets. She always had a dog. She also had
Speaker 2a white cat an eel and an aquarium and a parakeet called bo Peep that she tried to teach to talk, and she.
Speaker 6Had a.
Speaker 7Hard you really blasted past the eyel point.
Speaker 2Well, here's the thing, though, because, like Patricia Lloyd is telling the truth, I think I'm sure that Oprah had those pets. But Patricia is younger than Oprah and doesn't meet Oprah until Oprah is not living with her grandmother anymore. Patricia and Oprah never get along. And a big chunk of this is I'm not going to throw out stories like this from family members who were like, yeah, it wasn't as bad as she says it was, because there's definitely a good amount of myth making going on here. But also there's a lot of people who are angry that Oprah got rich in that they didn't get as much of that money as they wanted to get, and
Speaker 2so that's also a factor in some of these like like Patricia doesn't know what was going on in that farmhouse because she wasn't alive then.
Speaker 3And she's probably just a hater she that's not.
Speaker 2Zero percent of why she's saying this, right. Yeah, Now that said, there's also some evidence that like Oprah really pushes aside how doting her family was to her, because that's not kind of the conception she She always has this sort of like I've always been alone attitude, and maybe that's how she felt. But her maternal aunt Susie said this to Kitty Kelly. We all just adored her. We just worshiped her in everything. My mother Hattie gave Oprah everything she wanted her to have and everything Oprah wanted, and so we were poor people, but we got it
Speaker 2for her. She claimed she had no dolls, but she had lots of dolls, all kinds of dolls. And I, you know, I don't think that's lying either. I don't think it's uncommon for a kid to be like, well, I felt alone, and for the people around that coid to be like but you weren't, you know, and again, neither of those people are necessarily lying. That just gets down to people taking very different things, and like childhood, you're not aware of the stuff that maybe adults see,
Speaker 2Yeah how old how old is she in this time period? One to six?
Speaker 4Oh my god?
Speaker 2Yeah, or birth to six? I should say, right, I.
Speaker 7Feel like that that's exactly the type of disagreement that you always have with you You don't really remember how nice everyone was to you when you were six.
Speaker 2Yeah, because I have a lot of like complaints about my own childhood like one to seven or eight, And I'm sure my mom would say like, well, we were all working our asses off to take care of you, and it's like, well, yeah, but also you weren't around a lot of the time, you know, like that's just a nobody is wrong there. As the parent, you're like, but you understand that what I was doing was trying to take care of you, And as the kid, you're like, yeah, but I was still really unhappy, you know, like that's just childhood, you know.
Speaker 4Yeah, yuh.
Speaker 2Anyway, Kitty makes an interesting note here, pulling from a two thousand and nine interview Oprah did with Barbara Streisand in which Barbara, who grew up in poverty, talked about the fact that her only doll was a hot water bottle. Oprah, who had previously claimed to only have a doll she made from a corn cob, replied, Wow, you were poorer than I was. So again myth making is going on here. She's not ever totally consistent. You know, how poor she was depends on who she's talking to. When she's talking to someone who was like really growing up also very poor,
Speaker 2Oprah maybe like, you know, eases up on the throttle a little bit.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3I remember that Barbara Walters Oprah crossover very well because it ends with a very good performance where yeah, painted from Jesus microphone white because she was Barbara Streithean painted her microphone's white because her thing is like, wait, are you talking about streisand or Walters.
Speaker 2I think I'm talking about Streisand let me double check in the US, so I don't have fussed this up.
Speaker 3If it's Straithan. That was like a very big moment in Oprah lore.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's I'm pretty sure it's Streisand it's just that she also talked, she talked to everyone. There's because we just talked about Barbara Walters in here, who she mentioned like wishing that she had been white as a little girl to Barbara Walters, Barbara Streisand I think is the interview about how poor they were.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, all the Barbara's.
Speaker 2All the barber's. Too many barbers in this story. If they were famous in the nineties or early two thousands, Oprah had a tearful conversation with them. So yeah. Kitty Kelly quotes from a Life article in nineteen ninety seven which includes this line, Oprah was the least powerful of girls born poor and illegitimate on the segregated south on a town in Kouzusko, Mississippi. She spent her first six years there abandoned to her maternal grandmother. And so you can see that like this spin on the story, which is parts of it I'm sure are emotionally true. Some
Speaker 2of it is certainly literally true, but also the idea that she was abandoned, I think it's more. I think that doesn't quite get at the truth, which is that her grandmother took her over because her mother was not a reliable parent, and this was she benefited a lot from the fact that she had her grandmother during this very similar actually to Clarence Thomas's story, right where you had this kid who was growing up in a very impoverished background but wound up being taken care of their grandparent who was the absolute most responsible person to raise
Speaker 2them in that period of time. And so it is this situation where that's both I'm sure very difficult for the child who's not being raised by their parents, but it's also not this situation of like like, this is an example of there being a strong safety net in her childhood that a number of a lot of other kids in the same situation wouldn't necessarily benefited from. And both of those things are i think critical to talk about, whether we're talking about Thomas or we're talking about Winfrey. And this is where you get kind of a lot of the discrepancies because the Winfrey family historian Catherine Esters,
Speaker 2who is i think technically a cousin but one of those cousins who Oprah grew up seeing as an aunt, has really taken a lot of issues with Oprah's description of her childhood. And she told Kitty Kelly this, all things considered, those years with Hattie May were the best thing that could have happened to a baby girl born to poor kin. Oprah grew up as an only child with the full and undivided attention of every one of us, her grandparents, her aunt's, uncles, and cousins, as well as her mother, who Oprah never mentions was with her every day for the first four and a half years of Oprah's life until she went north to Milwaukee to find
Speaker 2a better job. And when I read this, I was very surprised because all of the other things I'd read about her childhood said that her mom had left immediately, but Esther's claims like, no, her mom was there for four and a half years and then just bounced for like eighteen months to try and set up a life and does eventually bring her up to Milwaukee, which is a different version of her story, right, Like, again, there's a lot there's less abandonment here than at least certain versions of the story. And obviously I was isn't there so who was lying or not?
Speaker 7But yeah, I don't know, just that feels like exactly like perception though, like between zero and four if your mom leaves, how would you materially know the difference between four and one?
Speaker 2And that is kind of the difficulty of how formative that period is and then how like shitty our memory is of it, because like I always would like, especially when I do stuff like this and I read about like, well, if I were to write my own recollection of like my early childhood out and then talk to my relatives about it, how many of them would be like, no, that's not what happened. No, right, yeah, you're a small child. So again, I don't even know how much of this is myth making, and just that was her she felt abandoned, and so maybe then it is like, is that even
Speaker 2more accurate than the truth that her mom was actually there most of the time, if that's what she took out of that period of time.
Speaker 3I don't know if you know the answer to this, But no, are the family members that are speaking on this sort of correcting the record. Are they alleging that Oprah is sort of outright falsifying? Oh yet her childhood was.
Speaker 2Like Aunt Catherine definitely is she she is very much. She's talking a lot of shade about Oprah. I think she takes it very personally because she was one of the people helping to raise her, that she talks about her childhood this way. And there's always the question of, like how much does money and people being unhappy about money play into some of this. I can't answer that. There's been allegations of that too. You know, nobody's like
Speaker 2coming into this without an angle, but Aunt Catherine is definitely alleging Oprah lies a lot about her childhood. That is her is precisely how she frames it. Is that like she's she's telling a lot of tall tales, you know, yeah, complicated.
Speaker 7So it's just like when the successful person in your family is the most like the richest person in media. That's that's what it becomes. A thing that's sounds so standard to any sit talking family.
Speaker 3I have to say, right, I would be such a hater if my sibling became Oprah famous.
Speaker 2Any billion dollars.
Speaker 3Put a microphone on my face and I'll say whatever. I would be such a hater.
Speaker 2No, just just buy me a vineyard and I'll shut up. You'll never hear from me again. Go date Steadman. We're good.
Speaker 3So there's also.
Speaker 2Another aspect of this that that didn't really come out until more recently. I'll be Oprah was open a lot about physical abuse that she endured. Although I should say when I say physical abuse, it is accurate to cold abuse. It is also totally normal corporal punishment for the time, right, Like the stuff she is talking about, My grandma would make me go get a switch and then would beat me if I did things that were bad. That is extremely normal for this place in.
Speaker 4Time, right.
Speaker 3I have to say, like, that is how I was raised. I grew up in the South. That's I mean, that's just like I know a lot of people same, like I know a lot of people today for whom that is like a normal vibe.
Speaker 2Even though it is abuse, and it's one of those things people will critique her for like and be like, ah, she wasn't relieved, she wasn't beat more than anybody else that Like, you know, Hattie was not particularly violent for a parent in that era. But also, I don't think Oprah's wrong for being like, this is really fucked up, and you shouldn't hit kids with switches. So I think I give that point to Oprah on the whole.
Speaker 3Yeah, and especially making the kid go out and get their own switch if you want to do that, that's like a special kind of psychological torture.
Speaker 2A lot of it does sound very familiar. Yeah, just growing up in the South, Like I got smacked, you know, I don't think more than my fair share. And it's the kind of thing where like there's a part of me that wants to be if I were to hear someone else complaining about the kind of stuff that was done to me as a kid, I'd be like, oh, man, that she was just growing up as a kid in rural Oklahoma in the nineties. But it's also bad you should do that to kids, So maybe I'll just shut up about that.
Speaker 6You know.
Speaker 2It's that kind of like it's that attitude where like if you went through something and you never really thought of it as that bad, then you get kind of offended when other people speak up, even if they should be. You know, it's that's probably just a thing we have to get over as people.
Speaker 7Yeah, well, see I went through it, I paid off my student loans, I did at it, and it's like, well, yeah, why should have.
Speaker 2Been hitting me as a kid? I guess. Earlier I mentioned that twenty twenty one book with doctor Bruce Perry, who, by Oprah's standards, is a pretty good doctor, but also seems to think ADHD isn't real, So again, by Oprah standards, does a lot of heavy lifting there. Like I was reading through this guy's by and I was like, Okay, he seems like a real Oh he doesn't think ADHD is a thing. Huh Okay. We got some RFK vibes coming off of this fella. In that book, What Happened
Speaker 2to You? Conversations on trauma, resilience, and healing. Each chapter opens up with a brief vignette or essay by either Oprah or doctor Perry, and the rest of each chapter is literally just like a conversation transcript between the two, written out in Q and A format. It is a very lazy book in my opinion. Right, this is the easiest way to write a fucking book. Everyone does like ten pages of essays and then you just fucking record a conversation. Man, how do I get that job? Right? Like, that's beautiful grift, beautiful grift. That said, there's also some
Speaker 2like pretty poignant vignettes from Oprah here, which I think maybe fills it out a little bit more. That includes some stark claims from her childhood. Now we should remember this book came out just a couple of years ago. So this is a senior citizen reflecting half a century later on things that would have happened when she was six at the oldest. So the best case scenario here, there's no way, you know, even if we discount like some myth making, you're never going to be perfectly accurate in your recollections of stuff that happened in this time. But here's how Oprah writes about the way in which
Speaker 2discipline was done when she was a child. At the time, it was accepted practice for caregivers to use corporal punishment to discipline a child. My grandmother Hadi may embraced it, but even at three years old, I knew what I was experiencing was wrong. One of the worst beatings I can recall happened on a Sunday morning going to church played a major role in our lives. Just before we were to leave for service, I was sent to the well behind our house to pump water. The farmhouse where I lived with my grandparents did not have indoor plumbing. From the window, my grandmother caught a glimpse of me twirling my fingers in the water and became enraged. Though
Speaker 2I was only daydreaming innocently as any child might. She was angry because this was our drinking water and I had put my fingers in it. She then asked me if I had been playing in the water, and I said no. She bent me over and whipped me so violently my flesh welted. Afterward, I managed to put on my white Sunday best dress, blood began to seep through and stain the crisp fabric a deep crimson. Livid at the site, she chastised me for getting blood in my dress, then sent me to Sunday school in the rural South. This is how black children were raised. Yeah, and it's
Speaker 2one of those Esther's aunt Catherine takes a lot of issue with this. She was like, Hattie made it not beat Oprah every day of her life, And like, I'm sure it wasn't every day, but I don't think Oprah's probably that's a very specific story to have lied about.
Speaker 3And it's like so visceral that you if that happened to you while you were a little kid, no shit, it's going to be memorable, No shit, it's going to be something you can stick with you.
Speaker 2Yeah, Yeah, of course, that would stick with you. Yeah, And I think this might be again when we talk about because it'd be very easy, especially since this is a bastard's episode, to just lean on Esther's being like she lied about this, She led about that, but like, well, she was one of the people who was taking care of Oprah when Oprah was getting smacked around as a kid, and maybe did some of the smacking And maybe he doesn't want to think about that as having been a problem, right, cool stuff. I think Oprah does genuinely care about child abuse.
Speaker 2It's something she has devoted a lot of her life to trying to fight, although ways in ways that have been on perfect imperfect. There's like criticisms of some of the stuff that she's tried to do for this, but it is something that she's like put a lot of time and effort into and that kind of does make me think she's probably telling the truth all in all about like what she experienced as a kid. Now, what's interesting to me is that Oprah, while she's all you know, been mostly seems to have negative things to say about her grandma. She's also very clear that like Hattie May
Speaker 2is the first person who inculcated with her within her the behavior that made her a success later on, quote, I developed a keen sense of when trouble was brewing. I recognized the shift in my grandmother's voice or the look that meant I had displeased her. She was not a mean person. I believe she cared for me and wanted me to be a good girl. And I understood that hushing my mouth or silence was the only way to sure a quick end to punishment and pain. For the next forty years, that pattern of condition compliance, the result of deeply rooted trauma, would define every relationship, interaction,
Speaker 2and decision in my life. The long term impact of being whooped then forced to sh hush and even smile about it turned me into a world class people pleaser for most of my life. And I think there's an Oprah would suggest that like part of why she got to be so good at what we call myth making, at entertaining people, because what is entertainment but people pleasing, is that she spends so much of her early childhood trying to keep her grandmother happy.
Speaker 3Right, yeah, I I mean, I not to be sympathizing with our bastard, but I should. Yeah, I mean, like that is that is my childhood, right, Like I think that is like classic kid who grew up getting that kind of punishment in a household where even as an adult you become so perceptive to like the tiniest little changes in someone's demeanor and kind of had to be to survive in households like that, Like that is like that rings to me.
Speaker 2Yeah, my child I wouldn't say was as extreme as what Oprah has related, but I definitely vibe with the feeling of like there is someone in my house who gets angry at me easily, and I'm going to get very good at like people pleasing and it lying in order to avoid pissing them off.
Speaker 3And I have to ask Robert, like, as a podcast to podcaster, do you kind of feel like this is like why you are good at like storytelling and entertaining and keeping people happy and laughing and smiling with you, right, Like she's wrong.
Speaker 2I don't think she's wrong at all, and like it's it's all of that, and it's also why I've always been really good at talking to the cops and like lying to the cops and getting out of trouble with the police. Is that I know when somebody I like allegedly lying, Yeah, like you learned to protect.
Speaker 5Allegedly allegedly allegedly.
Speaker 2Yeah. A lot of successful entertainers have something like this in their background. Right. I actually had this written out, like you learn to please people, and that teaches you how to please crowds.
Speaker 1Right, speaking of please pleasing crowds.
Speaker 2Fuck the crowds. Let's please our advertisers.
Speaker 4The only crowd that matters.
Speaker 2Yeah, So on the whole, you know, I think Oprah lies a lot about the specific. I think there are specifics that get exaggerated and just specifics that are misremembered about her past. But I don't think that means her We should discount what she says, right, And I think particularly we should pay attention when she says, quote, the most pervasive feeling I remember from my own childhood is loneliness. And I can believe that at the same time as
Speaker 2I believe her Aunt Catherine when she tells Kitty Kelly quote, Oprah makes her first six years sound like the worst thing that ever befell, a child born to folks just trying to survive. I was there for most of the time, and I can tell you she was oiled and petted and indulged better than any little girl in these parts. Every parent knows that a child's first six years lays the foundation for life, and those for six years down here with Hetty, Meg gave Oprah the foundation for her self confidence, her speaking ability, and her desire to succeed. I don't actually think both of those things are in
Speaker 2conflict the way that they both think it does.
Speaker 4Yeah, I think that's exactly.
Speaker 7Like as as we've been saying, like, these are all the skills you gain, I do feel it's worth saying that though sometimes you gain these skills, also the majority of the time people are crushed and hurt by this type of.
Speaker 3Uh it can be you can be crushed but also a good entertainer.
Speaker 4Yeah, you can be. I mean like a magic spell.
Speaker 8No, no, I would not recommend entertainers, but in more cases, like if you're an entertainer, like this story still ends in a place like the fucking floor in front of the viper room, as opposed to having two billion dollars.
Speaker 2Rip River Phoenix. So there's another story Oprah tells in this book, which again I don't like this book overall, but this passage struck me and if it's if it is accurate, I think it's something that may hint of some darkness buried in the family history that it's historian Aunt Catherine may not be willing to see quote. Growing up in Mississippi, I always slept with my grandmother. My grandfather, who had dementia, slept in a side room. One night, I was suddenly awakened to see my grandfather standing over
Speaker 2the bed. Even before I opened my eyes, I could sense my grandmother's fear. I could feel her heightened awareness as she slowly repeated, earlist, get back to bed, earlist, get back to bed. He wouldn't go. He was trying to choke her, fighting to get his hands around her neck. When she finally managed to push him off of her and run to the door, she cried out for one of our neighbors, called cousin Henry, who lived down the road. Henry Henry. Henry Henry was blind, but without hesitation, he came in the middle of the night to help my grandmother put my grandfather back in his bedroom. My grandmother then wedged a chair into the doorknob to her bedroom
Speaker 2door and found some cans to put around the door. The next morning, she tied those cans together and hung them from the door. And every night for the rest of my days living with my grandmother, the cans were on the door and the chair was up under the knob. I would try to sleep while listening to make sure that the cans didn't move.
Speaker 4Fuck.
Speaker 2Yeah, so that's so scary. Yeah, it's interesting. She tells this anecdote in the book because it goes along with another story she's telling, which is that she's talking about like this school shooting right in nineteen eighty eight, when a girl, a woman named Lori Dan entered a second grade classroom classroom and Winetka and started shooting, killing an eight year old and wounding five other kids. And Oprah tells her own story because like, in the aftermath of this shooting, there had been like a discussion about whether
Speaker 2or not to like chain and lock the school doors and have them manned by security guards. And the principal refused to implement these changes because he was like, if there's a chain on the door, it sends a message to the kids that they're unsafe, and kind of Oprah brings up the story to be like, I really feel that because of this, these cans hung from the door that we're supposed to make us safer. That just reminded me that there was this constant danger, you know, from my grandfather. So yeah, anyway, interesting, I don't.
Speaker 7Have children, but it is so fucked up to me that it's like, I mean, we're not going to make them safe, but we don't want to make them feel unsafe, which they hire.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, and it's you know, uh, Aunt Catherine, I think would probably say again, would doubt that that had happened. One of the statements she made to Kittie Kelly was I've talked to her about this over the years. I've confronted her and asked, why do you tell such lies? Oprah told me that's what people want to hear. The truth is boring, Aunt Catherine. People don't want to be bored. They want stories with drama, and so it is like you can't help think to a little bit like, well did she did she make that up or add to
Speaker 2that in order to have something that was relevant to the story of a shooting from her own life, which is like a thing, you know, being able to like like, And it's like you can't know it is. It is kind of worth stating that, like a lot of the people who will argue that about Oprah, and these are arguments coming from members of her family, aunt Catherine ahead of them, are also people who probably have a deep emotional interest in remembering, you know, Grandma Hattie and her
Speaker 2husband as one kind of person and Oprah. The fact that Oprah doesn't remember them that way is probably deeply offensive to these people. And maybe, yeah, yeah, I don't know, there's like no way to know what actually happened, right, none of us were there, But the fact that this conflict is present is as much a part of the story as what actually happened, right.
Speaker 3I would also say, just growing up in like a southern black family, I do think there might be some aspect of like, you're not meant to talk about whatever happens in our house. Yeah, And so like her aunt being offended that she would even be talking about anything that went on, you know, behind closed doors in their house, that I could really see that, And like, again, I don't think it's all one or the other, that she's just like callously making this up because people need a story. Probably some of that, But that doesn't mean that her
Speaker 3family members would not be invested in these stories that paint them in not so great light. You know, not so great light be not something that's talked about on a national stage.
Speaker 2Right right, right, Yeah, And I think that's like that's a pretty important part of it as well.
Speaker 7I will say another thing that is kind of weird, and partially because I am relatively not versed in Oprah and the elements of her beast diardiness. You know, the ones that I know about mostly seem to be about elevating horrible men, right, which is almost sort of do you know I could see paths to that anyway. I guess what I mean is like none of these like trauma, well not even not the traumas, but none of these like lies or like questionable stories. It's like weird because
Speaker 7that doesn't seem like the dimension of which, like the type of bad person that does those things tends to be more of like just a general asshole or a liar in some way. And it's just interesting that I'm like, this doesn't seem to be the bad part.
Speaker 2I guess, no, no, Well, also, she's six up to this point in the story.
Speaker 7Yeah, even in the retellings. Sorry, Like even if they are exaggerations, Like it's so weird because it's like she could do all that stuff and still not promote doctor oz R.
Speaker 4She could be a.
Speaker 7Weird kind of like shady, you know, Hollywood person, which happens.
Speaker 2Most people who lie about their childhoods don't also start doctor Roz's career.
Speaker 4Yes, I think that's that's like maybe what I'm saying.
Speaker 2Yeah, so well, you know the attitude of her a number of members of her family, including her mom Brenita, and her aunt Katherine, is that And this is Aunt Catherine again, she always wanted to have the spotlight. If adults were talking and she couldn't get their attention, she'd walk over and hit them to make them pay attention to her. And I think that that's you know, that's probably true because I have seen other kids do that. You know, it's a thing you have to like stop when a kid is doing that. But like that's not an uncommon stage of development or like for kids to
Speaker 2scream and pout when they don't get attention, you know, like they're small children. They are still learning these sorts of things. That said, it's not inconsistent with what Oprah says about being lonely or about wanting to be a people please. This is also a kid that is obsessed with having people pay attention to her, and as a result, she is from a very early age a performer, which is really interesting to me. She like every black church in her hometown, she's given like speeches at, and like read poems at and and whatnot. By the time she
Speaker 2is six or seven, which is a continuing thing in her life. When she moves, you know, to the big city, she'll be doing the same thing, going at every single church she can find, and like doing these kind of live performances. She's doing that from the age of like four or five. And this appears to be something in which she is entirely self motivated to do. Like she is pushing for her family to take her to these churches so that she can do like live performances, right, Like, this is always a thing that she wants in her life,
Speaker 2which is you know, interesting to me and something that's going to be a bigger thing in part two of our episodes. But that concludes part one of the Oprah Winfrey story.
Speaker 4That's wild.
Speaker 7I didn't realize that the church circuit was basically like open mic night for being a top show host.
Speaker 2Oh my god, it's a specific kind of open night, Mike Knight, Yeah.
Speaker 3It's yeah, it definitely is. I have seen the folks who like, have you ever it makes sense, Yeah, like people who speak at a certain kind of cadence. You're like, oh, you're a church game, you were like raised given as a church Wow.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, and it makes it. It's really interesting to me that like she has because like this does kind of speak to some of the things her aunt was saying about, Like, you know, we were all really focused on her. There was so much attention that went her way because well, yeah, I mean it would probably be pretty hard for her to have gotten taken to all of these different like places, right to all of these different like churches and whatnot, if her family wasn't interested in her and like focused on her success. That said
Speaker 2it also, that's exactly the kind of thing a kid who was deeply lonely would really want to do, right, Like that's because those are the kind of kids who become entertainers and a lot of.
Speaker 4It is a pretty unique thing. I can't imagine.
Speaker 7I mean, I don't think I got comfortable speaking publicly till I was like twenty eight, so like, yeah, six year old was like, let me, I just need I just need some stage time this Sunday morning.
Speaker 2I loved it. I was a little church wasn't where I did it, but like, yeah, I was an attention.
Speaker 7I guess I was attention. But like, truly public speaking is I think different?
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2And what she's doing the fact that she is like she is. She has the confidence in her speaking abilities to want to get up at church, which is like a big thing in a lot of way, especially to a little kid, that's really interesting to me. Yeah, anyone surprised about anything so far?
Speaker 1I think it's surprising to see the like conflicting stories.
Speaker 4M hmm.
Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, I will say I don't think anyone's scrutiny of any of the tales they tell about being six or younger would hold up to anything that's been put through this. No, So like every every knock against Oprah in this capacity, I am wildly sympathetic too. I'm just like, I don't know you're talking about when you're six and you're doing it in front of presumably a bunch of like white producers and network executives. Mostly so it's like,
Speaker 7gotta do what you gotta do.
Speaker 3Sometimes I am surprised that I pretty much uncritically just every thing that Oprah ever said about her childhood. I believed I repeated it in my fifth grade report, Sophie. I don't know if you did too, but that like that, like the thing about the dolls and her first getting her first pair of shoes at six, I specifically put that in my report. And now I'm like, dang, should a fact check that?
Speaker 1Fifth grade US?
Speaker 4I know, terrible journalists.
Speaker 2Oh man, Yeah, it's uh. I'm always fascinated by like the vagaries of memory, you know, like the past is not just a foreign country. It's didn't happen. It's a fantasy. It's a fiction dementia. Right, it's a fiction novel that you've been writing your entire life without even knowing it. Anyway, go sleep on that, everybody. We'll be back in a couple of days. Oh wait, pluggables.
Speaker 4Yep from us.
Speaker 2Yeah, yes, yes, yes, plug I'll just go.
Speaker 4Jos is racist. That's my podcast.
Speaker 7We have the premium shows at Suboptimal pods dot com. I'm trying to think mostly just been talking about this amazing celery salad I had I made the other day. I've had it three times since I made it. Well, Celery, lemon shalat and dates. Okay, it's pretty. It's a crazy ass salad. I put blue cheese in it too, but yeah, and walnuts.
Speaker 4All right now, I'm good. That's my plug.
Speaker 3Bridgie definitely making that salad. Yeah. Listen to my podcast There Are No Girls on the Internet, about the exploration of the intersection of identity and social media and technology. And listen to my podcast that I do with Mozilla Foundation called ir. It explores who has the power in AI and ethics in AI. New season coming soon. Check it out.
Speaker 1I want to plug at the end here just a couple of organizations just because of the devastating fires in Los Angeles. If you are able to help, just check out water Drop LA and kton for All for reliable resources ab how to help people with mutual Aid. Behind the Bastards is a production of cool Zone Media. For more from cool Zone Media, visit our website Coolzonemedia dot com or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. Behind the Bastards
Speaker 1is now available on YouTube. New episodes every Wednesday and Friday. Subscribe to our channel YouTube dot com slash At Behind the Bastards
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...
Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.