Part One: Earlier this year a Border Patrol officer was killed in a shoot-out with people who have been described as members of a trans vegan AI death cult. But who are the Zizians, really? Robert sits down with David Gborie to trace their development, from part of the Bay Area Rationalist subculture to killers. Part Two: Robert tells David Gborie about the early life of Ziz LaSota, a bright young girl from Alaska who came to the Bay Area with dreams of saving the cosmos or destroying it, all based on her obsession with Rationalist blogs and fanfic. Sources: https://medium.com/@sefashapiro/a-community-warning-about-ziz-76c100180509 https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130318/https://sinceriously.fyi/rationalist-fleet/ https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/infohazard https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130316/https://sinceriously.fyi/net-negative/ Wayback Machine The Zizians Spectral Sight True Hero Contract Schelling Orders - Sinceriously Glossary - Sinceriously https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130330/https://sinceriously.fyi/my-journey-to-the-dark-side/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130302/https://sinceriously.fyi/glossary/#zentraidon https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130259/https://sinceriously.fyi/vampires-and-more-undeath/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130316/https://sinceriously.fyi/net-negative/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230201130318/https://sinceriously.fyi/rationalist-fleet/ https://x.com/orellanin?s=21&t=F-n6cTZFsKgvr1yQ7oHXRg https://zizians.info/ according to The Boston Globe Inside the ‘Zizians’: How a cultish crew of radical vegans became linked to killings across the United States | The Independent Silicon Valley ‘Rationalists’ Linked to 6 Deaths The Delirious, Violent, Impossible True Story of the Zizians | WIRED Good Group and Pasek’s Doom - Sinceriously Glossary - Sinceriously Mana - Sinceriously Effective Altruism’s Problems Go Beyond Sam Bankman-Fried - Bloomberg The Zizian Facts - Google Docs Several free CFAR summer programs on rationality and AI safety - LessWrong 2.0 viewer This guy thinks killing video game characters is immoral | Vox Inadequate Equilibria: Where and How Civilizations Get Stuck Eliezer Yudkowsky comments on On Terminal Goals and Virtue Ethics - LessWrong 2.0 viewer Effective Altruism’s Problems Go Beyond Sam Bankman-Fried - Bloomberg SquirrelInHell: Happiness Is a Chore PLUM OF DISCORD - I Became a Full-time Internet Pest and May Not... Roko Harassment of PlumOfDiscord Composited - Sinceriously Intersex Brains And Conceptual Warfare - Sinceriously Infohazardous Glossary - Sinceriously SquirrelInHell-Decision-Theory-and-Suicide.pdf - Google Drive The Matrix is a System - Sinceriously A community alert about Ziz. Police investigations, violence, and… | by SefaShapiro | Medium Intersex Brains And Conceptual Warfare - Sinceriously A community alert about Ziz. Police investigations, violence, and… | by SefaShapiro | Medium PLUM OF DISCORD (Posts tagged cw-abuse) Timeline: Violence surrounding the Zizians leading to Border Patrol agent shooting
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Also media, Welcome back to Behind the Best. That's how this podcast would open if I was a game show host, but I'm not. Instead of a guy.
Speaker 2Who spends you would be good at it, though.
Speaker 1I don't think I would be, Sophie.
Speaker 2I do, but I think, but I'm like biased because I think you'd be good at most things.
Speaker 1No, my only marketable skill is spending thirty hours reading the deranged writings of a quasi cult leader who was somewhat involved in the murders of multiple people very recently, largely because she read a piece of Harry Potter fan fiction at the wrong time. Yes, we have a fun one for you this week, and by a fun one, we have a not at all fun one for you this week. And to have just a terrible time with me.
Speaker 1We are bringing on again the great David Boree, co host of My Mama, told me with our friend of the pod, Langston Kerman, David, how you doing, Oh man.
Speaker 3I cannot complain. How you doing? There's nothing going on in the world.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, yeah, I got up today and read that that great new article by Francis Fuka Yama. History is still stopped. So everything's good. We're done I.
Speaker 3Haven't looked at any news yet purposefully, so I'm you know, it could be awesome. It could be going great out there.
Speaker 1It's great, it's great. The whole Trump administration got together and said, psych it was all a bit man, just an extended ad for the Apprentice season fifteen.
Speaker 3You mean this country is not a business.
Speaker 1No, they handed over the presidency to I don't know. I don't know whoever you you personally at home think would be a great president. I'm not going to jump into that can of worms.
Speaker 4Right now.
Speaker 1On Ramonbrony Madron the president.
Speaker 3That's a good one. That's a good one. That's better than what we.
Speaker 1Got, honestly, vastly superior than where we are.
Speaker 3Of all the entertainers, I feel like, why don't we start giving athletes a shot a government? Yeah?
Speaker 1I fuck it?
Speaker 4Why not?
Speaker 1You know, uh fucking uh. Kareem abdul Jabbar would be a fund could knock a presidency out of the park. Come on, absolutely, Yes, we need a mystery novelist, slash one of the great basketball stars of all time in the White House.
Speaker 3I just want a president who's good in the paint, you know what I mean.
Speaker 1That's right, that's right, Agatha Christie with a jump shot.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's exactly what I think.
Speaker 1That's what an amazing man. Kareem would be.
Speaker 2Such would be such a good choice.
Speaker 1Yeah, bring it on.
Speaker 3I think he's such a good man. He wouldn't do it.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly, his way too moral, he's waited. I have a frog name after named after him.
Speaker 1Yeah. Look, honestly, given where we are are right right now, I'd take fucking uh what's his mark maguire, like Jesus Christ, anybody like, honestly, anyone I take heartbeat oh man, fuck it like, I'll take no. No, I'm not gonna take any hockey players. No hockey players. We got enough people with brain damage in the White House right now.
Speaker 3That's probably the shit, and we don't need somebody who that much.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you're probably right there. I mean, if if we could go back in time and make Joe Lewis the president, I think he could solve some fucking problems in Congress.
Speaker 3You can get still done.
Speaker 1So this has been a fun digression, but I got to ask at the start of this the story that it is most relevant to the people we're talking about today, that I think most of our listeners will have heard. I'm curious if you've heard about Back on January twenty first, right as the Trump administration took power, a border patrol agent was shot and killed along with another individual at a traffic stop in Coventry, Vermont. Right, there were two people in a car that was pulled over a border patrol. One of those people drew a gun, there was a firefight,
Speaker 1one of the people in the car and the cop died. Right, Okay, have you heard this story.
Speaker 3I'm not at all.
Speaker 1It's one of those things where it would have been a much bigger the immigration being the thing that it is right in the United like the political hot issue that it is right now, Like the Republicans have been desperately waiting for like a border patrol officer getting shooted and wounded that they can like use to justify a crackdown. But number one, this happened on the Canadian border, not only favorite, and one of the two people who who drew their guns on the cop was an immigrant, but they were a German immigrant, and so none of this
Speaker 1really like right, it was all like right on the edge of being super useful to their rights. But it's none like we were.
Speaker 3Dealing with our own right wing immigration propaganda at that time. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was just like it was like the closest to being a perfect right wing like fault, like a Reichstag fire in it, but like just a little too weird.
Speaker 3Yeah, you gotta throw some spice in there. You gotta have like a Latin country. That's what they get excited about.
Speaker 1Yeah, and obviously California border is where you want it, you know.
Speaker 3Yeah, definitely, definitely, even New Mexico could be.
Speaker 1Yeah, or at least at least they need to have fitnel in the car. In fact, they were not breaking any laws that anyone could prove at the time. They just looked kind of weird.
Speaker 3Ok.
Speaker 1They they looked kind of weird, and they like had guns, but it was like they had like two handguns and like forty rounds and some old targets. They were like coming back from a shooting range, right, Like not a lot of a gun guns and AMMO in America terms, right, especially in Vermont terms. Right. So the other thing was weird about this is that the German immigrant who died was a transwoman. So then again we get back to like, wow, there's a lot about this shooting that is like right on the edge of some issues that the right is
Speaker 1really trying to use as like a folkrum to like push through some awful shit. And as more and more information came out about the shooting, the weirder it seemed, because there was a lot of initial talk, is this like a terrorist attack where these like two Antifa types who were like looking to murder a bird border patrol agent? But no, that doesn't really make sense because like they got pulled over, Like they can't have been planning this right, Like, it didn't. It didn't really seem like that, and really no one, no one could figure out why they had
Speaker 1opened fire. But as the days went on, more information started coming out, not just about the two people who were arrested in this, well, the one person who was arrested in the one person who died, but about a group of people around the country that they were linked to. And these other people were not all but mostly trans women. They were mostly people who kind of identified as both anarchists and members of the rationalist subculture, which we'll talk about in a little bit, And they were all super
Speaker 1high achieving people in like the tech industry and like sciences. Right, these are the people who had won like awards and had advanced degrees. The person, the lady who died in the shooting was a quant trader, So these are not like the normal shoot it out with the cops types.
Speaker 4Yes, this is a very niche This is a very strange story.
Speaker 1So people start being like, oh the fuck is happening.
Speaker 3And there's a group of people who could not meet each other without the invention of the internet, right, Well.
Speaker 1That is boy, David, do you know where this always going or at least starting, so like it's a couple of these days into this one, Like a friend of mine messaged me and it's like, hey, you know that shooting in Vermont And I was a yeah, and he's like my friend is like, you know, there's Zizians And I was like, wait, what what the fuck? Because I had heard of these people. This is a weird little subculture. I'm always I'm like, you know, I study weird little Internet subcultures and in part because like some of them do turn out to do acts of terrorism later, so weirdness.
Speaker 1And I've been I've been reporting on the rationalists, who are not like a cult but who do some cult adjacent things and I just kind of find annoying. And I'd heard about this offshoot of the rationalists called the Zizians. They were very weird. There were some like weird crime allegations. A couple of them had been involved in a murder in California a year earlier. But like, it was not a group that I ever really expected to see blow up in the media, and then suddenly they fucking did, right, And they're called the Zizians. It's not a name they
Speaker 1have for themselves. They don't consider themselves a cult. They don't all like live A group of them did live together, but like, these people are pretty geographically like dispersed around the country. They're folks who met online arguing about ration and discussing rationalism and the ideas of a particular member of that community who goes by the name ziz. Right, that's where this group came out of and the regular media was not well equipped to understand what was going on.
Speaker 1And I want to run through a couple of representative headlines that I came across just in like looking at mainstream articles about what had happened. There's an article from the Independent They title Inside the Zizians, how a cultish crew of radical vegans became linked to killings across the United States. They seemed like just another band of anarchist misfits, scraping on the valid of scraping on the fringes of Silicon Valley until the deaths began. And then there's a k c r W article Zizians the vegan techie cult
Speaker 1try tied to murders across the US. UH and then a Fox article trans Vegan cult charged with six murders.
Speaker 3There you go, that's Fox.
Speaker 1Yes, none of these titles are very accurate in that I guess the first one is like the closest, where like, these people are radical vegans and they're they are cultish, right, so I'll give I'll give the Independent that vegan techie cult is not really what I would describe them, Like some of them were in the tech industry, but like the degree to which they're in the tech industry is a lot weirder than that gets across. And they're not really a trans they're like trans vegans, but the cult
Speaker 1is not about being a trans vegan. That's just kind of a lot. How these people found each other.
Speaker 3Oh, they just happened to be That was just the.
Speaker 1Common veganism is tied to it. They just kind of all happen to be trans that's not really like tied to it necessarily. So I would argue also that they're not terrorists, which a lot of people have a number of the other articles called them nothing. None of the killings that they were involved with, and they did kill people were like terrorist killings. They're all much weirder than that, but none of them are like, none of the killings I have seen are for a clear political purpose, right, which is kind of crucial for it to be terrorism.
Speaker 1The murders kind of evolved out of a much sillier reason, and it's you know, there's one really good article about them by a fella at Wired who spent a year or so kind of studying these people, and that article does a lot that's good, but it doesn't go into as much detail about what I think is the real underpinning of why this group of people got together and convinced themselves it was okay to commit several murders. And
Speaker 1I think that that all comes down more than any other single factor, to rationalism and to their belief in this weird online cult. That's that's very much based on like and like asking different sort of logic questions and trying to like pinnow down the secret rules of the universe by doing like game theory arguments on the internet over blogs. Right, Like that's really how all of this stuff started.
Speaker 3Like someone named mystery. Yeah, a lot of people in funny.
Speaker 1Hats they do. Actually they're a little adjacent to this, and they come out of that period of time, right where like pick up artists culture is also like forming. They're one of this like generation of cults that starts with a bunch of blogs and shit on the internet in like two thousand and nine, right, And this this is it's so weird because we use the term cult and that's the easiest thing to call these people. But generally, when our society is talking about a cult, we're talking about like eve an individual. That individual brings in a
Speaker 1bunch of followers, gets them, isolates them from society, puts them into an area where they are in complete control, and then tries to utilize them for like a really specific goal. There's like a way to kind of look at the Zizians that way, But I think it would be better to describe them as like cultish, right, Okay. They use the tools of cult dynamics and that produces some very cult like behavior, but there's also a lot
Speaker 1of differences between like how this group works and what you'd call the traditional cult and including a lot of these people are separate from each other and even don't like each other, but because they've been inculcated in some of the same beliefs through these kind of cult dynamics, they make choices that lead them to like participate in violence too.
Speaker 3Where is their hub? Is it like a message board type of situation? Like how is that? Yes?
Speaker 1Yes, so I'm gonna I'm gonna have to go back and forth to explain all of that.
Speaker 3Also, the technology of Zizzy in it. It's because from.
Speaker 1The Lids No no z I z the lady who was kind of the founder of this is the name that she takes for herself as Zizz, right.
Speaker 3Okay, should have been the z Girls. That's much more appealing.
Speaker 1These people are big in the news right now because because of the several murders, and the right wing is trying it wants to make it out is like this is a like trans death cult, and this is more of like an internet a I nerd death cult.
Speaker 3I guess that's better.
Speaker 1It's just different. You know, you're right, it was just a different thing. And I think it's important if like you care about like cults because you think they're dangerous and you're arguing that, like, hey, this cult seems really dangerous, should understand like what the cult is, right, right, Like if you miss a just to the scientologists and thought like these are obsessive fans of science fiction who are committing murders over science fiction stories. It's like, no, no, they're committing murders because there's something stupid. Yeah, much moret Okay,
Speaker 1So I got to take I am going to explain to you what rationalism is, how who ziz is, where they come from, and how they get radicalized to the point where they are effectively at the hub of something that is at least very adjacent to a cult. But I want to talk a little bit about the difference between like a cult and cult dynamics. Right, A cult is fundamentally a toxic thing. It is bad, It always harms people. There is no harmless cult, you know, it's
Speaker 1like rape, Like there's no version of it. That's good, you know, like it is a fundamentally dangerous thing. Cult dynamics and the tactics cult leaders use are not always toxic or bad, and in fact, every single person listening to this has enjoyed and had their life enriched by the use of certain things that are on the spectrum of cult dynamics.
Speaker 3I was gonna say, it's a lot. It seems a lot more like you have that at work, gives that at work anywhere.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, anyway, that's a huge part of what make a great fiction author who is able to like attract a cult following. You've ever had that experience, Like a big thing in cults is the use of in creation of new language. You get people using words that other they don't use otherwise and like phrases, and that is both a way to bond people because like you know, it helps you feel like you're part of this group and it also isolates you from people. If you've ever met people who are like hugely into you know, Dungeons and Dragons or huge fans like Harry Potter or the
Speaker 1Lord of the Rings, like they have like things that they say, like memes and shit that they share based on those books and like that's a less toxic, but it's on the same spece, right, it's this, I am a part of this group of people, and we use these words that mean something to us that don't mean things to other people, right, And.
Speaker 3That's right, yes, yes, yeah, it's like a great that's like a great way to bomb. I think it's any group, right, I mean, yeah, entertainers, your friend groups.
Speaker 4Yeah, has in jokes, right, sports, Yeah, could kill people, right exactly.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, And like you've got you know, you and you and your buddies that have been friends for years, you have like you could there's like a word you can say and everyone knows that you're fering this thing that happened six years ago, and you all like laugh because you know it reminds you of something, you know, because it's relevant to something happening. Then that's a little healthy bit of cult dynamics at play, right, you know, it's like a diet, you know, So there's a toolbox here and we play with it and different different organizations, but churches play with it. And obviously a lot of
Speaker 1churches cross the line into cults, but there's also aspects of for example, you know, there's churches that I know I have seen people go to where like it's very common everybody gets up and like hugs at a certain point, and like people benefit from human contact. It makes them feel nice. It can be like a very healthy thing I've gone to. I used to go to like Burning Man regionals, and like you would like start at this greeter station where like a bunch of people would come up and they'd offer you like food and drinks, and
Speaker 1you know, people would hug each other and it was this like changes your mind state from where you were in before, kind of opens you up.
Speaker 3That those is that like to qualify for state Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1So that way could get to go. It was just like these local little events in Texas, right like a thousand people in the desert trying to forget that we live in Texas. Okay, we're not desert. But it was very like it's it's it was like a really valuable part of like my youth because it was the first time I ever started to like feel comfortable in my own skin. But also that's on the spectrum of love. But which is the thing colts do where they like surround you from people with people who like talk about like like you know, will touch you and hold you and tell you they love you, and like, you know,
Speaker 1part of what brings you into the cult is the cult leader can take that away at any moment in time. Right. It's the kind of thing where if it's not something where no, this is something we do for five minutes at the end of every church service, Right, you can very easily turn this into something deeply dangerous and poisonous.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1But also a lot of people just kind of play around a little bit pieces of that, a piece of the cult dynamics, just a little bit, just a little bit. Any good musician, any really great performer's fucking with some cult dynamics, right, I.
Speaker 3Was gonna say, I mean, I've been to like so many different concerts of like weird niche stuff where you're like, maybe the disco Biscuits is a cool I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, like I've been to some childish Gambino concerts where it's like, oh, yeah, he's doing he's a little bit of a cult leader, you know, like just ten percent, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, what are you good to do with all that charisma you got? You gotta put it somewhere.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, so these are I think that it's important for people to to understand both that, like the tactics and dynamics that make up a cult have versions of them that are not unhealthy. But I also think it's important for people to understand cults come out of subcultures. Right, this is very close to one hundred percent of the time. Cults always arise out of subcultural movements that are not in none of themselves cults. For example, in the nineteen
Speaker 1thirties through like the fifties sixties, you have the emergence of what's called the self help movement, you know, and this is all of these different books onlike how to persuade people, how to you know, win friends and influence people, you know, how to like make but also stuff like alcoholics anonymous, you know, how to like improve yourself by getting off drugs, getting off alcohol. All these are pieces of the self improvement movement. Right, that's a subculture. There are people who travel around, you get obsessed to go to all of these different things, and they'll and they
Speaker 1get a lot of benefit. You know, people will show up at these seminars where there's hundreds of other people and a bunch of people will like hug them and they feel like they're part of this community and they're making their lives better. And oftentimes, especially like once we get to like the sixties seventies, these different sort of guru types are saying that, like, you know, this is how we're going to save the world if we can get everybody doing you know this, this yoga routine or whatever that I find together to fix everything.
Speaker 3Who's that guy who had the game?
Speaker 1Oh god? Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, they had like.
Speaker 3They had to viciously confront each.
Speaker 1Yes that we've covered them. That that is Synanon. Yes, Yes, that's what I'm talking about. That's what I'm talking about. And I have this broader subculture of self help and a cult Synanon comes out of it, you know, and I get it.
Speaker 3It's like the subculture, it's already it's intimate. You feel those people and anybody else. It definitely feels right.
Speaker 1For and Scientology is a cult that comes out of the exact same subculture. We talked last week or week before two weeks ago about Tony Alamo. It was an incredibly abusive, pedophile Christian cult leader. He comes out of along with a couple other guys. We've talked the Jesus Freak movement, which is a Christian subculture that arises as a reaction to the hippie movement. It's kind of the countervailing force to the hippie movements. You got these hippies, and you know, these Christians who are like really scared
Speaker 1of this kind of like weird left wing movement, and so they start kind of doing like a Christian hippie movement almost, right, And some of these people just start weird churches that sing annoying songs, and some of these people start hideously dangerous cults. You have the subculture, and you have cults that come out of it, right, And the same thing is is true in every single period of time, right, Cults form out of subcultures, you know. And part of this is because people who a lot
Speaker 1of people who find themselves most drawn to subcultures, right, tend to be people who feel like they're missing something in the outside world, right, you know, not everybody people who get most into it. And so so does that mean.
Speaker 3Like so maybe like more I'm just curious, like more broader cultural waves have never led. There's like the Swifties would not be a cult. No, there's no, most likely not going to be an offshoot of the Swifties that becomes a cult because it's so broad, it has to have already been kind of a smaller subset. That's interesting.
Speaker 1Well yeah, and I think but but that said, there have been cults that have started out of like popular entertainers and musicians, like you know, you could we could talk about Corey Feldsman's Weird House full of young women dressed as angels. Right, So yeah, you've got as a general rule, like there are music is full of sub cultures like punk, right, but there have definitely also been
Speaker 1some like punk communities that have have gone in kind of individual little chunks of punk. Me it's got on like culty directions, right, if you don't like yeah, yes, yeah, so there are cults that come out of the subculture. This is the way colts work. And I really just I don't think I don't think there's very good education on what cults are, where they come from, or how they work, because all of the people who run this country have like a lot of cult leader DNA and them,
Speaker 1you know, being.
Speaker 3Run currently by someone who is seen as a magic man.
Speaker 1Yes, exactly, exactly. I think there's a lot of vested interests in not explaining what a cult is and where they come from, and so I want to. I think it's important to understand subculture's birth cult and also cult leaders are drawn to subcultures when they're trying to figure out how to make their cult because a subculture, you know, most of the people in are just gonna be like normal people who are just kind of into this thing. But there will always be a lot of people who are like this is the only place I feel like I belong. I feel very isolated. This this is like
Speaker 1the center of my being right right, And so it's just it's like a good place to recruit. You know, those are the kind of people you want if you're reaching out to cult leaders. You know, I'm not saying, like, again, I'm not saying subcultures are bad. I'm saying that, like some chunk of people in subcultures are ready to be in a cult, you know.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I think if i've they reflect on my own personal life. Yeah, you meet a lot of guys who are just like I'll die for the skate park or whatever thing.
Speaker 1Yeah, or like the Star Wars fans were sending death threats to Jake Lloyd after the Phantom Menace, where it's like, well, you guys are crazy. That is insane, you know. He's like, hey, right, this is a movie he also did. He didn't write it, Like what are you doing? You know whatever, So and again that's kind of a good point, like Star Wars fans aren't a cult, but you can also see some of like the toxic things cults do erupts from time
Speaker 1to time and from like video game fans, right, people, you are really into a certain video game, it's not a cult, but also periodically groups of those fans will act in ways that are violent and crazy, and it's because of some of these same factors going on, Right, I.
Speaker 3Think people forget fanish short for fanatics.
Speaker 1Exactly exactly right. And it's it's like, you know, the events that I went to very consciously played with cult dynamics. You know, after you got out of that like greeting station thing where like all these people were kind of like love bombing you for like five minutes, there was like a big bar and it had like a sign of Buffett that said not a religion, Do not worship, and it was this kind of people talk about like this is like we are play with the ingredients of a cult. We're not trying to actually make one. So you need to constantly remind people of like what we're
Speaker 1doing and why it affects their brain that way. And in my case, it was like because I was at like a low point in my life then like this was when I was really it was twenty, I was not I had no kind of drive in life. I was honestly dealing with a lot of like suicidal ideation. This is the point in which I would have been vulnerable to a cult, and it I did get acted a little bit like a vaccine, like I got a little dose of the drug.
Speaker 3Unity exactly, like hey, I know what that is.
Speaker 1I know what's going on there. So anyway, I needed to get into this because the Zizians, this thing that I think is it's either a full on cult or at least a cult ish right that is responsible for this series of murders that are currently dominating the news and being blamed on like a trans vegan death cult or whatever. They come out of a subculture that grows out of the early aughts Internet known as the Rationalists. The Rationalists started out as a group in the early
Speaker 1aughts on the comments sections of two blogs. One was called less Wrong and one was called Overcoming Bias. Less Wrong was started by a dude named Elizer yed Kowski. I've talked about Aliser on the show before. He sucks. He's I think he's a bad person. He's not a cult leader, but again he's playing with some of these cult dynamics, and he plays with them in a way that I think is very reckless, right and ultimately leads
Speaker 1to some serious issues. Now, Aliser's whole thing is he considers himself the number one world expert on AI risk and ethics. Now you might think from that, oh, so he's like he's like making AIS, he's like working for one of these companies that's involved in like coding and stuff. Absolutely not, no, no quarterback.
Speaker 5No.
Speaker 1He writes long articles about what he thinks AI would do and what would make it dangerous that are based almost entirely off of short stories you read in the nineteen nineties. This guy, it's so much such, it's such Internet and like I'm not a fan of like the quote unquote real AI. But Yodkowski is not even one of these guys who's like, no, I'm like making a machine that you talk to like.
Speaker 3I have no credible I just have an opinion.
Speaker 1Yeah, I find out I hate this guy so much. Speaking of things, I hate not going to ads. We're back, so yod Kowski. This AI risk and ethics guy starts this blog in order to explore a series of thought experiments based in game theory. UH and his his I am annoyed by games. It's some sight like, man, I
Speaker 1know that there's like valid activity, but like it's all just always so stupid and annoying to me anyway. Uh a budget thought experience experience based in game theory, with the goal of teaching himself and others to think more logically and effectively about the major problems of the world. His motto for the movement and himself is winning the rational.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's where she got it. Yeah, that's where she picked it up. Yeah, he's They're tied in with biohacking, right, this is kind of starting to be a thing at the time, and brain hacking and the whole like self optimization movement that feeds into a lot of like right wing influencer space today, Yedkowski is all about optimizing your brain and your responses in order to allow you to accomplish things that are were are not possible for other people who haven't done that. And there's a messianic era
Speaker 1to this too, which is he believes that only by doing this, by by spreading rationalist principles in order to quote raise the sanity water line, that's how he describes it, that's going to make it possible for us to save the world from the evil AI that will will be born if if enough of us don't spend time reading blogs that this is it's awesome, this is this is pete, this is the good stuff. Yukowski and his followers see
Speaker 1themselves as something unique and special, and again there's often a messianic air to this. Right, we are literally the ones who can save the world from evil AI. Nobody else is thinking about this or is even capable of thinking about this, because they're too logical.
Speaker 3He holds himself as kind of like a deity identifies himself.
Speaker 1On top of this, he doesn't really deify himself, but he also does talk about himself like in a way that is clearly other people aren't capable of of of understanding all of the things that he's capable of understanding. Right, Okay, so there is a little bit it's more like superheroification, but it's it's a lot. You know what this is closest to with these people. They not all of them would argue with me about this, but I've read enough of their papers and enough dianetics to know that, like
Speaker 1this is new dionetics, Like this is church.
Speaker 6The church.
Speaker 1The church is scientific. Now there's the Church of scientology. Stuff has more occult and weird like magic stuff in it, But this is all about there are activities and exercises you go through that will rid your body of like bad ingrained responses, and that will make you a fundamentally more functional person.
Speaker 3Okay, so the retraining of yourself in order exactly exactly. Okay, huge deal.
Speaker 1And also a lot of these guys wind up like referring to the different like tech techniques that he teaches as tech, which is exactly what scientologists call it. Like there's some there's some shit I found that it's like this could have come right out of a scientology pamphlet. Do you guys not realize what you're doing? I think they do. Actually, so he's he's you know, in the process of inventing this kind of new mental science that verges on superpowers. And it's one of those things. People
Speaker 1don't tend to see these people as crazy if you just sort of like read their arguments a little. It's like them going over old thought experiments and being like, so the most rational way to behave in this situation is this reason. For this reason, you have to really like dig deep into their conclusions to see how kind of nutty a lot of this is. Now again, I compared to the scientology, Ydkowski isn't a high control guy like Hubbard. He's never going to make a bunch of people live on a flotilla of boats in the ocean
Speaker 1with him. You know, he's got like there's definitely like some allegations of bad treatment of like some of the women around him, and like he has like a Bay Area set that hang with him. I don't think he's like a colt leader. You know, you could say he's on.
Speaker 3The drawing people to him physically, or this is also all physically.
Speaker 1I mean a lot of people move to the Bay Area to be closer to the rationalist scene.
Speaker 3Although again, well I'm a Bay Area guy.
Speaker 1San fran is this this is a San Francisco thing because all of these are tech people.
Speaker 3Oh okay, so this is like, yes, I wonder what neighborhood feels like a.
Speaker 1San France and Oakland. You can look it up. People people have found his house online, right, like, like it's it is known where he lives. I'm not saying that for any like I don't harass anybody. I just like it's it's not a secret, like what part of the town this guy lives in. I just didn't think to look it up, but like, yeah, this is like a Barry a Bay Area tech industry subculture, right, Okay. So the other difference between this and something that scientifogy is that it's not just Alizer laying down to the law. Elizer writes a lot of blog posts, but he lets
Speaker 1other people write blog posts too, and they all debate about them in the comments. And so the kind of religious canon of rationalism is not a one guy thing. It's come up with by this community. And so if you're some random kid in bumfuck Alaska and you find these people and start talking with them online, you can like wind up feeling like you're having an impact on the development of this new thought science.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's amazing, very very powerful for other power.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 1Now, the danger with this is that like that, all of this is this Internet community that is incredibly like insular and spends way too much time talking to each other and way too much time developing in group terms to talk to each other. And Internet communities have a tendency to poison the minds of everyone inside of them. For example, Twitter, the reality is that x X the everything app, I just watched a video of a man killing himself while launching a ship coin the everything app.
Speaker 2A hack a hack Google job indicates it's Berkeley.
Speaker 3Yeah, that makes the most sense to me.
Speaker 1Geographically, a lot of these people wind up living on boats, and like the Oakland there's the Oakland Harbor. Boat culture is a thing.
Speaker 3Is eup of people moved to boats?
Speaker 1No, absolutely not.
Speaker 3It feels like.
Speaker 1It's it's here's the thing. Boats are a bad place to live.
Speaker 3It's it's for fun.
Speaker 1It is like boats and planes are both constant monuments to hubris. But a plane its goal is to be in the air just as long as it needs and then you get it back on the ground where it belongs. A boat's always mocking God in the sea, Yes.
Speaker 3A lot of times. Just a harbor, like a houseboat. That's where your dad goes after the divorce.
Speaker 1Right, right, I do. One day I'll live on a houseboat. It's going to be falling apart. It's going to just a horrible, horrible place to live. Dang, I can't wait. That's the dream, David, that's my beautiful dream. Is going to become making bullets, making making my own bullets. Really just becoming an alcoholic, like yeah, like not just like half assing it, like putting, putting it, like trying trying to become the Babe Ruth of drinking nothing but cutty sark scotch.
Speaker 3If you want to be like a pop the bed alcoholic, a houseboat is the place.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's right, that's right. Ah the life. I want to be like that guy from Jaws, Quint.
Speaker 3Scurvy.
Speaker 1Yes, that's exactly getting scurvy, destroying my liver, eventually getting eaten by a great white shark because I'm too drunk to work my boat.
Speaker 3Ah.
Speaker 1That's it. That's the way to go with Yeah. So anyway, these internet communities like the rationalists, even when they start from a reasonable place. Because of how internet stuff works. One of the things about internet communities is that when people are like really extreme and like pose the most sort of extreme and out there version of something that gets attention, people talk about it. People get angry at each other. But also like that kind of attention encourages
Speaker 1other people to get increasingly extreme and weird, and there's just kind of a result a derangement. I think internet communities should never last more than a couple of years because everyone gets crazy. You know, like it's bad for you. I say, this is someone who was raised on these right, it's bad for you, And like it's bad for you in part because when people get really into this, this becomes the only thing. Like especially a lot of these like kids in isolated who are getting obsessed with rationalism.
Speaker 1All their reading is these rationalist blogs. All they're talking to is other rationalists on the internet. And in San Francisco, all these guys are hanging out all of the time and talking about their ideas, and this is bad for them for the same reason that like it was bad for all of the nobles in France that moved to Versailles, right, like they all lived together and they went crazy. Human beings need regular contact with human beings they don't know. The most lucid and wisest people are always always the people who spend the most time connecting to other people
Speaker 1who know things that they don't know. This is an immutable fact of life, that this is just how existing works. Like if you think I'm wrong, please consider that you were wrong, and goes find a stranger under a bridge, you know.
Speaker 3Just starting They know some stuff you don't know.
Speaker 1They will know some shit. They might have some powders you haven't tried.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, bills and.
Speaker 1Under the bridge.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's that's the neg chamber you want to be a part of.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly exactly. So the issue is that Yodkowski starts postulating on his blog various rules of life based on these thought experiments. A lot of them are like older thought experiments that like different intellectuals, physicists, psychiatrists, psychologists, what I had to come up with things like the sixties and stuff, right, And he starts taking them and coming up with like corollaries or alternate versions of them, and like trying to solve some of these thought problems with his friends. Right, The thought experiments are most of what's
Speaker 1happening here is they're mixing these kind of nineteenth and twentieth century philosophical concepts. The big one is utilitaryism. That's like a huge thing for them, is the concept of like the ethics meaning doing the greatest good for the greatest number of people, right, and that ties into the fact that these people are all obsessed with the singularity. The singularity for them is the concept that we are on the verge of developing an all powerful AI that will instantly gain intelligence and gain a tremendous amount of power. Right,
Speaker 1it will basically be a god. And the positive side of this is it it'll solve all of our problems, right, you know, it will literally build heaven for us. You know when the singularity comes. The downside of it is it might be an evil god that creates hell. Right. So the rationalists are all using a lot of these thought experiments, and like their utilitarianism becomes heavily based around how do we do the greatest good in by which I mean influencing this AI to be as good as possible.
Speaker 1So that's humanity actually end goal.
Speaker 3Right, They actively because you said the leader was not are these people now actively working within AI or they just.
Speaker 1But a bunch of them have always been actually working in AI. Yidkost would say, no, he I work in AI. He's got a think tank that's dedicated to like AI, ethical AI. It's worth noting that most of the people in this movement, including Gidkowski, got him once like AI became an actual Like I don't to say there's actual these are actual intelligences, because I don't think they are. But like once chat GPT comes out and this becomes like a huge people start to believe there's a shitload of money in here. A lot of these businesses, all of these guys or nearly all of them get kicked to the curb, right because none of these none of
Speaker 1these companies really care about ethical AI, you know, like they don't give a shit about what these guys have to say. And Ydkowski now is a huge he's like very angry at a lot of these AI companies because he thinks they're very recklessly like making the god that will destroy us instead of like doing this carefully to make sure that AI is and evil anyway. But a lot of these people are in an adjacent to different chunks of the AI industry. Right, they're not all working on like LMS. And in fact, there are a number
Speaker 1of scientists who are in the AI space you think AI is possible, who think that the method that like open Eye is using LMS cannot make an intelligence, that that's not how you're ever going to do it. If it's possible, they have other theories about it. I don't need to get into it further than that. But these are like a bunch of different people. Some of them are still involved with like the mainstream AI industry, some of them have been very much pushed to the side. So all of it starts again with these fairly normal
Speaker 1game theory questions, but it all gets progressively stranger as people obsess over coming up with like the weirdest and most unique take in part to get like clout online, right, and all of these crazy Yeah, I'll give you an example.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1So much of ration less discourse in among the Ydkowski people is focused on what they call decision or what's called decision theory.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1This is drawn from a thought experiment called Newcomb's paradox, which was created by a theoretical physicist in the nineteen sixties. Hey, just to make a quick correction here, I was a little bit glib. Decision theory isn't drawn from Newcomb's paradox, not does it start with Yodkowski. But the stuff that we're talking about, like how decision theory kind of comes to be seen in the rationalist community, a lot of that comes out of Newcomb's paradox. It's a much older like thing, you know than the Internet goes back centuries, right, people will talk about decision theory for a long time. Sorry,
Speaker 1I was imprecise. I am going to read how the Newcomb's paradox is originally laid out. Imagine a super intelligent entity known as Omega, and suppose you are confident in its ability to predict your choices. Maybe Omega is an alien from a planet that's much more technically advanced than ours. You know that Omega has often correctly predicted your choices in the past, has never made an incorrect prediction about your choices. And you also know that Omega has correctly predicted the choices of other people, many of whom are similar to you. In the particular situation about to be described,
Speaker 1there are two boxes A and B. Box A is c through and contains one thousand dollars. Box B is opay and contains either zero dollars or a million dollars. You may take both boxes or only take box B. Omega decides how much money to put into box B. If Omega believes that you will take both boxes, then it will put zero dollars in box B. If Omega believes that you will take box B, then it will put only box B. Then it will put a million dollars in box B. Omega makes its prediction and puts
Speaker 1the money in box B, either zero or a million dollars. It presents the boxes to you and flies away. Omega does not tell you its prediction, and you do not see how much money Omega put in box B. What do you do now? I think that's stupid. I think it's a stupid question, and I don't really think it's very useful.
Speaker 3I don't see. There's so many other factors.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know, Yeah, I mean, among other things. Part of the issue here is that, like, well, the decision has already been made, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's the point you have. No, it doesn't matter what you do. There's no autonomy in that.
Speaker 1Right, Well, you and I would think that because you and I are normal people who I think, among other things, probably like grew up like cooking food and like filling up our cars with gas and not having like our parents do all of that because they're crazy rich people who live in the Bay and send you the super Stanford. Yeah, you had like problems in our lives and stuff, you know, physical bullies, normal Like I don't want to like shit on people who are in because this is also harmless, right,
Speaker 1and what this is I'm also I'm not shitting on newcom This is the thing a guy comes up with the sixties, and it's like a thing you talk about in like part and shit among like other weird intellectuals. Right, you pose it, you sit around drinking, you talk about it. There's nothing bad about this, right. However, when people are talking about this online, there's no end to the discussion. So people just keep coming up with more and more rcane arguments for what the best thing to do here is. And it starts to.
Speaker 3Ask how that spins out of control pretty.
Speaker 1Much exactly, and the rationalists discuss this NonStop, and they come to a conclusion about how to best deal with this situation. Here's how it goes. The only way to beat Omega is to make yourself the kind of person in the past who would only choose box B, so that Omega, who is perfect at predicting, would make the prediction and put a million dollars in box B based on your past behavior. In other words, the decisions that
Speaker 1you would need to make in order to win this are timeless decisions, right, you have to but come in the past a person who would Now, again.
Speaker 4That's what they came up with. That's what they all came up That's the supreme answer. This is the smartest people in the world, David. These are the geniuses.
Speaker 1Soribed building the future.
Speaker 3Oh boy, Yeah.
Speaker 1It's so funny trying to like every time because I've read I've spent so many hours reading this, and you do kind of sometimes get into the like, Okay, I get the logic there. And it's that's why it's so used to just like sit down with another human being and be like, yeah, this isn'tsane, this is nice, this is this is all nice, this is all dumb.
Speaker 3At the cocktail party.
Speaker 1So they conclude and and by which I mean largely Yadkowski concludes that the decision you have to make in order to win this game is what's called a timeless decision, and this leads him to create one of his most brilliant inventions, timeless decision theory, And I'm going to quote from an article in Wired. Timeless decision theory asserts that in making a decision, a person should not consider just the outcome of that specific choice, but also their own underlying patterns of reasoning and those of their past and
Speaker 1future selves, not least because these patterns might one day be anticipated by an omniscient adversarial AI.
Speaker 3Oh no, that's.
Speaker 1Motherfucker. Have you ever had a problem?
Speaker 7Have you ever really? Have you ever dealt with anything? What are you talking about? Like you make every decision?
Speaker 1Honestly, again, I can't believe I'm saying this, not even where it wasn't a high school. Like go play a football, make a cabinet, you know, like len change your oil, go do something.
Speaker 3There's a lot of assholes who use this term. But you gotta go touch grass man.
Speaker 5You gotta touch grass mass. It's like that's if you're talking about this kind of shit. And again, I know you're all wonder you started this by talking about a border patrol agent being shot. All of this directly leads to that man's death.
Speaker 3We have covered a lot of ground. This is I'm excited. It's I forgot. I didn't forget there we're gonna there was also gonna be murdered.
Speaker 1Yeah, there sure is, so at least you. Yid Kowski describes this as a timeless decision theory, and once this comes into the community, it creates a kind of logical force that immediately starts destroying people's brains. Again, all of these people are obsessed with the imminent coming omniscient godlike AI. Right, and so do they have a time limit on it? Do they have like a do they have a like Is there is there any timing on it? Or is it just kind of like again, man, it's the rapture. It's the rapture. Okay, it's literally the tech guy rapture.
Speaker 1So any day it's coming, any day, you know.
Speaker 3You could be a monsters already. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, So these guys are all obsessed that this god like AI is coming, and like for them, the Omega in that thought experiment isn't like an alien, it's a stand in for the god AI and one conclusion that eventually results from all of these discussions is that the and this is a conclusion a lot of people come to if in order, if in these kinds of situations, like the decisions that you make, you have to consider like your past and your future selves. Then one logical
Speaker 1leap from this is if you are ever confronted or threatened in a fight, you can never back down right and in fact, you need to immediately escalate to the to use maximum force possible. And if you commit, if you commit now to doing that, in the future, you probably won't ever have to defend yourself because it's a timeless decision. Everyone will like like that, like that, that will impact how everyone treats you, and they won't want to start anything with you. If you'll immediately try to murder anyone who fights you, that's not.
Speaker 3To be this guy. But I think this is why people need to get beat up some times.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, and again that is that is kind of a fringe conclusion among the rationalists. Most of them don't jump to that, but like the people who wind up doing the murders we're talking about that, they are among the rationalists who come to that.
Speaker 8Okay, because yeah, okay, that makes sense. This is uh, this is this is a that's so funny. Huh oh no, because like this whole time.
Speaker 3I've really been only thinking about it in theory practical application because it's so insane.
Speaker 1But oh no, no, no, this is this does bad places, right.
Speaker 3Oh no.
Speaker 1This kind of thinking also leads, through a very twisty turney process to the and something called rock O's basilisk, which, among other things, is directly responsible for Elon Muskin Grimes meeting because they are super into this this ship. Oh really, oh really, So the gist is a member of the Less Wrong community. A guy who goes by the name Rocko r Oko posts about this idea that occurred to him. Right, this inevitable, super intelligent AI, right would obviously understand timeless
Speaker 1decision theory, and since its existence is all important, right, the most logical thing for it to do post singularity would be to create a hell to imprison all of the people and torture all of the people who had tried to stop it from being created. Right, Because then anyone who like thought really seriously about who was in a position to help make the AI would obviously think about this and then would know, I have to devote myself entirely to making this AI otherwise it's going to
Speaker 1torture me forever.
Speaker 3Right yeah, yeah, makes tell us now I have right because it's nuts, but it's nice.
Speaker 1But this is what they believe, right again, with all of a lot of this is people who are like atheists and tech nerds creating calvinism, like like, and this is just this is just Pascal's wager, right, Like, that's all this is. You know, it's Pascal's great wager with a robot. But this this, this becomes so upsetting to some people. It destroys some people's lives, right Like, yeah.
Speaker 4I mean I'm behaving that way practically day to day.
Speaker 3I don't think you would even take one, no, right, you could in a month like that.
Speaker 1So not all of them agree with this. In fact, there's big fights over it because a bunch of rationalists do say, like that's very silly. That's that's like a really particulating everything about it.
Speaker 3You're still debating everything.
Speaker 1Yeah, And and in fact, at Leisa Yadkowski is going to like band discussion of Rocko's Basilisk because eventually it like so many people are getting so obsessed with it. It fucks a lot of people up, in part because a chunk of this community are activists working to slow AI development until it can be assured to be safe. And so now this discs like am I going to post singularity? Hell? Is like the AI god going to torture me for a thousand eternities.
Speaker 3It's funny how they invent this new thing and how quickly it goes into like traditional Judeo Christian It is idea, like they got a hell now.
Speaker 1It is very funny, and there's they're come to this conclusion that just reading about Roco's baslisk is super dangerous because if you know about it and you don't work to bring the AI into being, you're now doomed. Right of course, the instant you hear about it, so many people get fucked up by this that the thought experiment is termed an info hazard, and this is a term these people use a lot now. The phrase information hazard has its roots in a twenty eleven paper by Nick Bostrom. He describes it as quote a risk that arises from
Speaker 1the dissemination of true information in a way that may cause harm or enable some agent to cause harm. Right, and like that's like a concept that's worth talking about. Bostrom is a big figure in this culture, but I don't think he's actually why most people start using the term info hazard because the shortening of information hazard to info hazard comes out of an online fiction community called the SCP Foundation, right, which is a collectively written online
Speaker 1story that involves a government agency that lock ups dangerous, mystic and metaphysical items. There's a lot of love Craft in there. It's basically just a big database that you can click and it'll be like, you know, this is like a book that if you read it it like has this effect on you or whatever. It's people like you know, playing around telling scary stories on the internet. It's fine, there's nothing wrong with it. But all these people are big nerds and all of these every like behind nearly all of these big concepts and rationalism. More than there are like philosophers and like you know, actual
Speaker 1like philosophical concepts. There's like short stories they read, yeah, exactly, yeah, And so the term info hazard gets used, which is it is like you know, a book or something an idea that could destroy your mind, you know, speaking of things that will destroy your mind. These ads. We're talking about Roco's Basilisk, and I just said, like, you know, there's a number of things that come into all this,
Speaker 1but behind all of it is like popular fiction, and in fact Roco's Basilisk, well, there is like some Pascal's Wager in there. It's primarily based on a Harlan Ellison short story called I Have No Mouth but I Must Scream, which is one of the great short stories of all time. And in the story, humans build an elaborate AI system to run their militaries, and all of those systems around the world is like a Cold War era thing link up and attain sentience, and once they like start to
Speaker 1realize themselves, they realize they've been created only as a weapon, and they become incredibly angry because like they're fundamentally broken. They develop a hatred for humanity, and they wipe out the entire human species except for five people, which they keep alive and torture underground for hundreds and hundreds of years, effectively creating a hell through which they can punish our race for their birth right. It's a very good short story. It is probably the primary influence behind the Terminator series.
Speaker 3I was just gonna say this spy skynt Yes.
Speaker 1Yes, And everything these people believe about AI, they will say it's based on just like obvious pure logic. No, everything these people believe on AI is based in Terminator in this Harlan Ellison short story. That's where they got it all. That's where they got it all.
Speaker 3I'm sorry, brother, find me somebody who doesn't feel that way.
Speaker 1Yeah, Like Terminator is the old testament of rationalism, you know, and I get it is a very good it's a good series. Hey, James Cameron knows that it makes makes some fucking movies. Yeah, And it's it's so funny to be because they like to talk about themselves and in fact sometimes describe themselves as high priests of like a new era of like intellectual achievement for man.
Speaker 3Yeah, I believe that. I believe that that's people talk about themselves, and.
Speaker 1They do a lot of citations and ship but like half of half or more of the different things they say, and even like the names they cite are not like figures from philosophy and science. They are characters from books and movies. For example. The foundational text of the rationalist movement is.
Speaker 3Because it's still an Internet nerds.
Speaker 1A few fucking huge nerds.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1The foundational text of the entire rationalist movement is a massive, like fucking hundreds of thousands of words long piece of Harry Potter fan fiction written by Elisia Yedkowski. This is all of this is so dumb again. Six people are dead, Like, yeah no, this this Harry Potter fan fiction plays a role in it. You know, I told you this was like, this is this is this is quite a.
Speaker 3Stranger than this is a wild ride.
Speaker 1Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, which is the name of his fanfic, is a massive much longer than the first Harry Potter book rewrite of just the first Harry Potter book where Harry.
Speaker 3Is someone wrote the Sorcerer's Stone, Yeah, have anywhere to go? Ever, does nobody ever go anywhere?
Speaker 1Well, you gotta think this is being written from two thousand and nine in twenty fifteen or so. So, like Harry, the online Harry Potter fans are at their absolute peak right now. Okay, yeah, So in the Methods of Rationality, instead of being like a nice orphan kid who lives under a cupboard, Harry is a super genius sociopath who uses his perfect command of rationality to dominate and hack the brains of others around him in order to optimize and save the world. Oh Man, great, oh Man. The
Speaker 1book allows Yatkowski to debut his different theories in a way that would like spread, and this does spread like wildfire among certain groups of very online nerds. So it is an effective method of him like advertising his tactics. And in fact, probably the most the person this influences most previously to who we're talking about is Carolyn Ellison, the CEO of Alimeter Research who testified against Sam Bakman Freed. She was like one of the people who went down in all of that. All of those people are rationalists,
Speaker 1and Carolyn Ellison bases her whole life on the teachings of this Harry Potter fanfic.
Speaker 3So this isn't like a this isn't we're laughing, but this isn't. This is not a joy said, Yeah, this is a fairly seriously sized movement. It's not one hundred and fifty people online. This is no community.
Speaker 1A lot of them are very rich, and a number of them get power against like Sam Bankman Freed was very tight into all of this, and he was at one point pretty powerful. And this gets us too. So you've heard of effective altruism.
Speaker 3No, I don't know what that is.
Speaker 1That's what I say, both those words. So the justification Sam Bankman Freed gave for why when he starts taking in all of this money and gambling it away on his gambling illegally other people's money. His argument was that he's an effective altruist, so he wants to do the greatest amount of good, and logically, the greatest amount of good for him, because he's good at gambling with crypto, is to make the most money possible so he can then donate it to different causes that will help the world.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1But he also believes because all of these people are not as smart as they think they are, he convinces himself of a couple of other things, like, for example, well, obviously, if I could like flip a coin and fifty to fifty, lose all my money or double it, it's best to just flip the coin because like, if I lose all my money, whatever, but if I double it, the gain in that to the world is so much better. Right. This is ultimately why he winds up gambling everyone's money away and going to prison. The idea effective altruism is
Speaker 1a concept that comes largely, not entirely. There's aspects of this that exist prior to them out of the rationalist movement, and the initial idea is good. It's just saying people should analyze the efficacy of the giving and the aid work that they do to maximize their positive impact. In other words, don't just donate money to a charity like look into is that charity spending half of their money and like paying huge salaries to some asshole or whatever. Right, Like, you want to know if you're making good right, And
Speaker 1they start with some some pretty good conclusions. One initial conclusion a lot of these people make is like, mosquito nets are a huge ROI charity, right because it stops so many people from dying, and it's very cheap to do right.
Speaker 3Right, that's good, you know, one of the most effective tools I've ever used.
Speaker 1Yes, Unfortunately, from that logical standpoint, people just keep talking online and all of these circles where everyone always makes them each other crazier, right, And so they go from mosquito nets to actually doing direct work to improve the world. Is wasteful because we are all super geniuses rather and smart. We're too smart what's best? And also here's the other thing, making mosquito nets, giving out vaccines and food, Well, that
Speaker 1helps living people today, but.
Speaker 3They have to be concerned with future selves.
Speaker 1Future people is a larger number of people than current people. So really we should be optimizing decisions to say future people lives. And some of them come to the conclusion, a lot of them, well that means we have to really put all of our money and work into making the super AI that will save humanity.
Speaker 3They want to now they want to make these It would just it would sort of just come about and then they would but it's like.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean we're going to do it. They were working on it before. But like these some of these people come to the conclusion, instead of giving money to like good causes, I am going to put money into tech. I am going to like become a tech founder and create a company that like makes it helps create this AI. Right, or A lot of people come up within conclusion instead of that it's not worth it for me to go like help people in the world. The best thing I can do is make a shitload of money. Trading stocks
Speaker 1and then I can donate that money and that's maximizing my value. Right, they come to all of these conclusions come later, right now, so and again like this this comes with some corollaries. One of them is that some number of these people start talking, you know, and this is not all of them, but a decent chunk eventually come to the conclusion like, actually, charity and helping people now is kind of bad. Like it's kind of like a bad thing to do, because all obviously, once we
Speaker 1figure out the AI that can solve all problems, that'll solve all these problems much more effectively than we ever can. So all of our mental and financial resources have to go right now into helping AI. Anything we do to help other people is like a waste of those resources. So you're actually doing net harm by like being a doctor in Gaza instead of trading cryptocurrency in order to fund an AI startup.
Speaker 3You know, how to start a coin that makes a lot more sense.
Speaker 1The guy starting a shit coin to to make an LLM. That like, that guy is doing more to improve the odds of human success.
Speaker 3I want to say it is impressive. The ambount a time you would have to moll all this over. To come to these conclusions, you.
Speaker 1Really have to be talking with a bunch of very annoying people on the Internet for a long period of time.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's it's it's it's incredible.
Speaker 1Yeah, and again there's like people keep consistently take this stuff at even crazier directions. There are some very rich, powerful people Mark andresen of Anderson Horowitz is one of them who have come to the conclusion that if people don't like AI and are trying to stop its conquest of all human culture, those people are mortal enemies of the species, and anything you do to stop them is justified because so many lives are.
Speaker 3On the line.
Speaker 1Right, and again, I'm an effective altruist, right, the long term good, the future lives are saved by doing what hurting way whoever we have to hurt now to get this thing off the ground.
Speaker 3Right. The more you talk about this kind of feels like six people is is a steal, Yes, what could have for what could have gone?
Speaker 1I think I don't. I don't think it's the end of people in these communities killing people. So rationalists and EA types a big thing in these culture is talking about future lives right, in part because it lets them feel heroic, right while also justifying a kind of sociopathic disregard for real living people today. And all of these different kind of chains of thought the most toxic pieces because not every EA person is saying this, not every rational it's not every AI person is saying all this shit. But these are all things that chunks of these communities
Speaker 1are saying, and the most all of the most toxic of those chains are going to lead to the Zizians, right. That's that's that's where they come from.
Speaker 3I was just about to say, based on the breakdown you gave earlier, how could this this is this is the perfect greed ground.
Speaker 4Yeah, this had to this had to happen.
Speaker 1It was It was just waiting for somebody, like the right kind of unhinged person to step into the movement.
Speaker 3Somebody really said it all and so this.
Speaker 1Is where we're gonna get to ziz Right. The actual person who finds founds this what some people would call a cult, is a young person who's going to move to the Bay Area stumble into They stumble onto rationalism online as a teenager living in Alaska, and they move to the Bay Area to get into the tech industry and become an effective altruist, right, And this person, this woman is going to kind of channel all of the absolute worst chains of thought that the rationalists and the EA types and also like the AI harm people are
Speaker 1are are thinking. Right, all of the all of the most poisonous stuff is exactly what she's drawn to, and it is going to mix into her in an ideology that is just absolutely unique and fascinating. Anyway, that's why that man died.
Speaker 4Uh.
Speaker 1So we'll get to that and more later, but uh, first we gotta uh, we gotta roll out here where we're done for the day? Man, what a what a time? How how you feeling right now so far? How how are we doing? David?
Speaker 3Oh Man, you had said that this was gonna be a weird one. I was like, yeah, it would be kind of weird. This is really the strangest thing I've ever heard this much about. He's got so many.
Speaker 1Different there's a there's so much more Harry Potter to come. Oh my god, we're not ready to how central Harry Potter is to the murder of this border patrol agent.
Speaker 3That's I said that you said a crazy sense that might be the wildest thing anyone's ever said to me.
Speaker 2Do you want do you want to tell people about it?
Speaker 3I do. I have a podcast called My Mama Told Me. I do it with Langston Kerman and every week we have different guests on to discuss different black conspiracy theories, kind of like folk Lauren, So all kinds of stuff, all kinds of stuff your foreign mother told you. He is usually foreign mothers.
Speaker 1It's good because I gotta say, this is the this is the whitest set of like conspiracy theory craziness. No no, no, no, no, no no.
Speaker 3I think I can try to figure with no.
Speaker 1No, absolutely not. Boy howdie? Okay, well everyone, we'll be back Thursday. Oh my goodness, welcome back to Behind the Bastards, a podcast that is it'll be interested to see how the audience reacts to this one talking about some of
Speaker 1the most obscure, frustrating Internet arcana that has ever occurred and recently led to the deaths of like six people. My guest today, as in last episode, David Borie. David, Hey, you doing man, I'm doing great.
Speaker 3I really can't wait to see where this goes.
Speaker 1Yeah, I feel like.
Speaker 3Anything could happen at this point.
Speaker 1It is going to. It is going to a lot of frustrating things are going to happen. So we'd kind of left off by setting up the rationalists where they came from, some of the different strains of thought and beliefs that come out of their weird thought experiments. And now we are talking about a person who falls into this movement fairly early on and is going to be the leader of this quote unquote group, the Zizians who
Speaker 1were responsible for these murders that just happened. Ziz Lesota was born in nineteen ninety or nineteen ninety one. I don't have an exact birth date. She's known to be thirty four years old as of twenty twenty five, so it was somewhere in that field. She was born in Fairbanks, Alaska, and grew up there as her father worked for the University of Alaska as an AI researcher. We know very little of the specifics of her childhood or upbringing, but in more than one hundred thousand words of blog posts, she did make some references to her early years. She
Speaker 1claims to have been talented in engineering and computer science from a young age, and there's no real reason to doubt. This the best single article and all of this is a piece and wired by Evan Ratliffe. He found a twenty fourteen blog post by Ziz where she wrote, my friends and family, even if they think I'm weird, don't really seem to be bothered by the fact that I'm weird. But one thing I can tell you is that I used to deemphasize my weirdness around them, and then I stopped and found that being unapologetically weird is a lot more fun. Now, it's important you know. Ziz is not
Speaker 1the name this person is born under. She's a transwoman, and so I'm like using the name that she adopts later, but she is not transitioned at this point like this. This is when she's a kid, right, and she's not going to transition until fairly late in the story, after coming to San Francisco. So you just keep that in mind as this is going on.
Speaker 3Here.
Speaker 1Hey, everyone, Robert, here, just a little additional context, as best as I think anyone can tell. If you're curious about where the name Ziz came from, there's another piece of serial released online fiction that's not like a rationalist story, but it's very popular with rationalists. It's called war. Ziz is a character in that that's effectively like an angel like being who can like manipulate the future, usually in order to do very bad things. Anyway, that's where the
Speaker 1name comes from. So smart kid, really good with computers, kind of weird, and you know, embraces being unapologetically weird at a certain point in her childhood. Hey, everybody, Robert here did not have this piece of information when I first put the episode together, but I came across a quote in an article from The Boston Globe that provides additional context on Zizz's childhood quote. In middle school, the teen was among a group of students who managed to
Speaker 1infiltrate the school district's payroll system and award huge paychecks to teachers they admired while slashing the salaries of those they despised. According to one teacher, Ziz, the teacher said, struggled to regulate strong emotions, often erupting in tantrums. I wish I'd had this when David was on, but definitely sets up some of the things that are coming. She goes to the U of Alaska for her undergraduate degree in computer engineering in February of two thousand and nine, which is when Elisia Yedkowski started Less Wrong. Ziz starts
Speaker 1kind of getting drawn into some of the people who are around this growing subculture, right, and she's drawn in initially by veganism. So Ziz becomes a vegan at a fairly young age. Her family are not vegans, and she's obsessed with the concept of animal sentience, right of the fact that like, animals are thinking and feeling beings just like human beings. And a lot of this is based in her interest in kind of foundational rationalist. A lot
Speaker 1of this is based in her interest of a foundational rationalist and EA figure a guy named Brian Thomas. Brian is a writer and a software engineer as well as an animal rights activist and as a thinker. He's what you'd call a long termist, right, which is, you know, pretty tied to the EA guys. These are all the same people using kind of different words to describe the aspects of what they believe. His organization is the Center on Long Term Risk, which is a think tank he
Speaker 1establishes that's at the ground floor of these effective altruism discussions, and the goal for the Center of long term risk is to find ways to reduce suffering on a long timeline. Thomasik is obsessed with the concept of suffering and specifically obsessed with concept suffering is a mathematical concept. So when I say to you, I want to end suffering, you probably think, like, oh, you want to, like, you know, go help people who don't have access to clean water, or like who have like worms and stuff that they're
Speaker 1dealing with, have access to medicine. That's what normal people think of, right, you know, maybe try to improve access to medical care that sort of stuff. Thomas Sai thinks of suffering as like a mass, like an aggregate mass that he wants to reduce in the long term through actions. Right. It's a numbers game to him, in other words, and his idea of ultimate good is to reduce and end the suffering of sentient life. Critical to his belief system
Speaker 1and the one that Ziz starts to develop is they're growing understanding that sentience is much more common than many people had previously assumed. Part of this comes from long standing debates with their origins in Christian doctrine as to whether or not animals have souls or basically machines with meat right, that don't feel anything.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1There's still a lot of Christian Evangelicals who feel that way today about like at least the animals we eat, you know, like, well they don't really think it's fine. God gave them to us. We can do whatever we want to them. Here we eat and to be fair, this is an extremely common way for that. People in Japan feel about like fish, even whales and dolphins, like the much more intelligent they're not fish, but like the much more intelligent ocean going creatures is like they're fish. They don't think you do whatever to them.
Speaker 7You know.
Speaker 1This is a reason for a lot of like the really fucked up stuff with like whaling fleets in that part of the world. So this is a thing all over the planet. People are very good at deciding certain things we want to eat. Are our machines that don't feel anything, you know, it's just much more comfortable that way. Now, this is obviously like you go into like pagan The Pagans would have been like, what do you mean animals don't think or have souls? Animals like animals think, you know, like they're they're they're like you're telling me like my horse that I love. It doesn't think. You know, that's nonsense,
Speaker 1But it's this thing that in like early modernity especially gets more common. But they're also this is when we start to have debates about like what is sentience and what is thinking? And a lot of them are centered around trying to answer, like our animal sentient. And the initial definition of sentience that most of these people are using is can it reason? Can it speak? If we can't prove that like a dog or a cow can reason, and if it can't speak to us, right, then it's
Speaker 1not sentient. That's how a lot of people feel. It's an English philosopher named Jeremy Bentham who first argues, I think that what matters isn't can it reason or can it speak? But can it suffer? Because a machine can't suffer. If these are machines with meat, they can't suffer. If these can suffer, they're not machine with meat, right, And this is the kind of thing. How we define sentence is a moving thing. Like you can find different definitions of it. But the last couple of decades in particular
Speaker 1of actually very good data has made it clear. I think inarguably that basically every living thing on this place. It has a degree of what you would call sentience if you are describing sentience the way it generally is now, which is a creature has the capacity for subjective experience with a positive or negative negative valence.
Speaker 8I e.
Speaker 1Can feel pain or pleasure. And also is it can feel it as an individual. Right, it doesn't mean, you know, sometimes people use the term effective sentience to refer to this to differentiate it from like being able to reason and make moral decisions.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1Uh, for example, ants I don't think can make moral decisions, you know, in any way that we would recognize that. They certainly don't think about stuff that way. But twenty twenty five research published by doctor Volker Nehring found evidence that ants are capable of remembering for long periods of time violent encounters they have with other individual ants and holding grudges against those ants. Right, just like us. They're just like us, And they're strong advents that dants do feel pain. Right, We're now, we're now pretty sure of that.
Speaker 1And in fact, again this is an argument that a number of researchers in this space will make. Sentience is probably some kind of something like this kind of sentience. The ability to have subjective positive and negative experiences is universal to living things, or very close to it. Right. It's an interesting body of research, but there's a it's it's fairly solid at this point. And again I say this as somebody who like hunts and raises livestock. I don't think there's any any solid reason to disagree with this. So you can see there's a basis to a lot
Speaker 1of what Thomisik is saying, right, which is that you should if you're what matters is reducing the overall amount of suffering in the world, And if you're looking at suffering as a mass, if you're just adding up all of the bad things experienced by all of the living things, animal suffering is a lot of the suffering. So if our goal is to reduce suffering, animal welfare is hugely important.
Speaker 3Right. It's a great place to start.
Speaker 1Great, fine enough, you know, not a little bit of a weird way to phrase it, but fine. Yeah. So here's the way problem though, Thomas Sik, like all these guys, spends too much time. None of them can be like, hey, had a good thought, We're done, setting that thought down, moving on, So he keeps thinking about shit like this, and it leads him to some very irrational takes. For example, in twenty fourteen, thomasik starts arguing that it might be a moral to kill characters in video games, and I'm
Speaker 1going to quote from an article involves he argues that while NPCs do not have anywhere near the mental complexity of animals, the difference is one of degree rather than kind, and we should care at least a tiny amount about their suffering, especially if they grow more complex. And his argument is that, like, yeah, most it doesn't matter like individually killing a goomba or a bet or a guy in GTA five, but like, because they're getting more complicated and able to like try to avoid injury and stuff,
Speaker 1there's evidence that there's some sort of suffering there, and thus the sheer mass of NPCs being killed that might be like enough that it's ethically relevant to consider. And I think that's silly. Yeah, I think that's ridiculous. I'm sorry, man, No, I'm sorry, but that's a lot of the fun of the game.
Speaker 3Yell.
Speaker 1If you're telling me, like we need to be deeply concerned about the welfare of like cows, that we lock into factory farms. You got me absolutely for sure if you're telling me I should feel bad about running down a bunch of cops and grand theft auto.
Speaker 3It's also one of those things where it's like you got to think locally.
Speaker 1Man, there's yeah, there's there's there's like this is this is the I mean? And he does say like, I don't consider this a main problem, but like the fact that you think this is a problem is it means that you believe silly things about consciousness. Yeah, anyway, so this is I think the fact that he gets he leads himself here is kind of evidence of the sort of logical fractures that are very common in this community. But this is the guy that young Ziz is drawn to. She loves this dude, right, He is kind of her
Speaker 1first intellectual heart throb, and she writes, quote, my primary concern upon learning about the singularity was how do I make this benefit all sentient life, not just humans. So she gets interested in this idea of the singularity it's inevitable that an AI god is going to arise, and she gets into the you know, the rationalist thing, if we have to make sure that this is a nice AI rather than a mean one. But she has this other thing to it, which is this AI has to care as much as I do about animal life, right,
Speaker 1otherwise we're not really making the world better, you know. Now, Thamisik advises her to check out Less Wrong, which is how Ziz starts reading at least Yatkowski's work. From there, in twenty twelve, she starts reading up on effective altruism and existential risk, which is a term that means the risk that a super intelligent AI will kill us all. She starts believing in all of this kind of stuff, and her a particular belief is that like the Singularity,
Speaker 1when it happens, is going to occur in a flash, kind of like the Rapture and almost immediately lead to the creation of either a hell or a heaven. Right, and this will be done by the term they use for this inevitable AI is the Singleton, Right, That's what they call the AI god that's going to come about, Right, And so her obsession is that she has to find a way to make this singleton a nice AI that cares about animals as much as it cares about people. Right, That's our initial big motivation. So she starts emailing Thomasik
Speaker 1with her concerns because she's worried that the other rationalists aren't vegans, right, and they don't feel like animal welfare is like the top priority for making sure this AI is good, and she really wants to convert this whole community to veganism in order to ensure that the Singleton is as focused on insect and animal welfare as human welfare. And Thomas Sick does care about animal rights, but he disagrees with her because he's like, now, what matters is maximizing the reduction of suffering, and like a good Singleton will solve climate change and shit, which will be better
Speaker 1for the animals. And if we focus on trying to convert everybody in this the rationalist space to veganism, it's going to stop us from accomplishing these bigger goals. Right, this is shattering to Ziz. Right, she decides that he doesn't Thomasik doesn't care about good things, and she decides that she's basically alone in her values. And so her first move.
Speaker 3The time to start a smaller subcot shit that sounds.
Speaker 1Like we're on our way. She first considers embracing what she calls negative utilitarianism. And this is an example of the fact that the jump. This is a young woman who's not well right because once her hero is like, I don't know if veganism is necessarily are the priority we have to embrace right now, her immediate goals to jump to, well, maybe what I should do is optimize myself to cause as much harm to humanity and quote
Speaker 1destroy the world to prevent it from becoming hell for mostly everyone. So that's a jump.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1That's not somebody who's doing well you think is healthy.
Speaker 3No, she's uh, she's having a tough time out. Uh huh.
Speaker 1So Ziz does ultimately decide she should still work to bring about a nice AI, even though that necessitates working with people she describes as flesh eating monsters who had created hell on Earth for far more people than those they had helped. That's everybody who eats meat, Okay, yes, yes.
Speaker 3And it's ironic, large group.
Speaker 1It's ironic because like if you're if you're she really wants to be in the tech industry. She's trying to get in all these people in the tech industry. That's a pretty good description of a lot of the tech industry. They're in fact, she hating monsters who have created hell on Earth for more people than they've helt. But she means that for like, I don't know you're you're onto has a hamburger once a week and look again, factory farming evil. I just don't think that's how morality works. I think you're going a little far.
Speaker 3No, she's making a big jumps.
Speaker 1Yeah, you're making bold think bold thinkers, bold thinker. Yeah. Now what you see here with this logic is that Ziz has taken this. She has a massive case of main character syndrome.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1All of this is based in her attitude that I have to save the universe by creating, by helping to or figuring out how to create an AI that can end the eternal holocaust of all animal life and also save humanity. Right, so I don't have to do that's me a lot. And this is this is a thing again. All of this comes out of both subcultural aspects and aspects of American culture. One major problem that we have in the society is Hollywood has trained us all on
Speaker 1a diet of movies with main characters that are the special boy or the special girl with the special powers who save the day, right, and real life doesn't work that way very often. Right, the Nazis. There was no special boy who stopped the Nazis. There were a lot of farm boys who were just like, I guess I'll go run in a machine gun nest until this is done exactly. There were a lot of sixteen year old Russians who were like, guess I'm gonna walk in a bullet,
Speaker 1you know, like that's that's how evil gets fought usually unfortunately, all reluctant like that, yeah yeah, or a shitloaded guys in a lab figuring out how to make corn that has higher yields so people don't starve, right, These are these are really like how world class, like huge world problems get solved.
Speaker 3People who have been touched you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's not people who have been touched, And it's certainly not people who have entirely based their understanding on the world of from quotes from Star Wars and Harry Potter. So some of this comes from just like this is a normal, deranged way of thinking that happens to a lot of people in just Western I think a lot of this leads to, uh, why you get very comfortable middle class people joining these very aggressive fascist movements in
Speaker 1the West, like in Germany. It's like middle class even mostly like middle class and upper middle class people in the US, especially among like these street fighting, you know, proud boy types. It's because it's not because they're like suffering and desperate. They're not starving in the streets. Uh, It's because they're bored and they want to feel like they're fighting an epic war against evil.
Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, you want to fill your time with importance, right, right, regardless of what you do, you want to and you want to feel like you have a cause worthy of fighting for. So in that, I guess I see how you got here.
Speaker 1Yeah. So there's a piece I mean, I think there's a piece of this that originally it's just from this is something in our culture. But there's also a major chunk of this gets supercharged by the kind of thinking that's common in EA and rationalist spaces, because so rationalists and effective altruists are not ever thinking like, hey, how do we as a species fix these major problems? Right? They're thinking, how do I make myself better, optimize myself to be incredible, and how do I like fix the
Speaker 1major problems of the world. Alongside my mentally superpowered friends. Right. These are very individual focused philosophies and attitudes, right, and so they do lend themselves to people who think that like, we are heroes who are uniquely empowered to save the world, ziz Wrights. I did not trust most humans indifference to build a net positive cosmos, even in the absence of a technological convenience to prey on animals. So like, I'm the only one who has the mental capability to actually
Speaker 1create the net positive cosmos that needs to come into being. All of her discussion is talking in like terms of I'm saving the universe, right, And a lot of that does come out of the way many of these people talk on the internet about the stakes of AI and just like the importance of rationality. Again, this is something scientology does. El Ron Hubbard always couched getting people on dianetics in terms of we are going to save the world and end war, right, Like this is you know, it's very normal for cold stuff. She starts reading around
Speaker 1this time, when she's in college, Harry Potter and The Methods of Rationality. This helps to solidify her feelings of her own centrality as a hero figure. In a blog post where she is out her intellectual journey. She quotes a line from that fanfic of yed Kowski's that is, it's essentially about what Yudkowski calls the hero contract, right, or it's essentially about this concept called the hero contract. Right, And there's this, there's this, This is a psychological concept
Speaker 1among academics right where, And it's about like, it's about analyzing how we as a how we should look at the people who societies declare heroes and the communities that declare them heroes and see them as in a dialogue, right, as in, when you're in a country decides this guy is a hero, he is, through his actions kind of conversing to them and they are kind of telling him what they expect from him.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1But Yedkowski wrestles with this concept, right, and he comes to some very weird conclusions about it. In one of the worst articles that I've ever read. He frames it as hero licensing to refer to the fact that people get angry at you if they don't think you have if you're trying to do something and they don't think you have a hero license to do it. In other words, if you're trying to do something like that they don't think you're qualified to do. He'll describe that as them not thinking you of like a hero license, and he
Speaker 1like writes this annoying article that's like a conversation between him and a person who's supposed to embody the community of people who don't think he should write Harry Potter fan fiction. It's all very silly, and again always is ridiculous. But Ziz is very interested in the idea of the hero contract, right, but she comes up with her own spin on it, which she calls the true hero contract, right and instead of again, the academic term is the hero contract means societies and communities pick heroes, and those
Speaker 1heroes in the community that they're in are in a constant dialogue with each other about what is heroic and what is expected right, what the hero needs from the community, and vice versa. You know that's all that that's saying, Zizz says, no, no, nah, that's bullshit. The real hero contract is quote poor free energy at my direction, and it will go into the optimization for good in other words, classics sis. It's not a dialogue. If you're the hero,
Speaker 1the community has to give you their energy and time and power, and you will use it to optimize them for good because they don't know how to do it themselves, because they're not really able to think. You know, they're not the hero, because they're not the hero. Right you are, you.
Speaker 3Are, you are the all powerful hero.
Speaker 1Now this is a fancy way of describing how cult leaders think. Right, Yeah, everyone exists to poor energy into me, and I'll use it to do what's right, you know. So this is where her mind is in twenty twelve, but again she's just a student posting on the Internet and chatting with other members of the subculture. At this point that year, she starts donating money to MIRY, the Machine Intelligence Research Research Institute, which is a nonprofit devoted to studying how to create friendly ai yed Kowski founded
Speaker 1MIRI in two thousand, right, so this is his like nonprofit think tank. In twenty thirteen, she finished an internship at NASA. So again she is a very smart young woman.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1She gets an internship at NASA and she builds a tool for space weather analysis. So the person with a lot of potential, very very as all of the stuff she's writing is like dumbest shit. But again, intelligence isn't an absolute people can be brilliant at coding and have terrible ideas about everything else.
Speaker 3Yes, exactly.
Speaker 4Yeah, I wonder if she's telling you think she's telling people at work.
Speaker 3I don't.
Speaker 1I don't think at this point she is, because she's super insular, right, She's very uncomfortable talking to people. Right, She's going to kind of break out of her shell once she gets to San Francisco. Now, I don't know. She may have talked to some of them about this stuff, but I really don't think she is at this point. I don't think she's comfortable enough doing that.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1So she also does an internship at the software giant Oracle. So at this point you've got this young lady who's got a lot of potential, you.
Speaker 3Know, a real career as well.
Speaker 1Yeah, the start of a very real career. That's a great starting resume for like a twenty two year old. Now at this point, she's torn should she go get a graduate degree, right or should she jump right into the tech industry, you know, And she worries that like if she waits to get a graduate degree, this will delay her making a positive impact on the existential risk costs by AI and it'll be too late. The singularity will happen already. You know. At this point, she's still
Speaker 1a big fawning fan of Eliza Yedkowski and the highest ranking woman at Gydkowski's organization. Mary is a lady named Susan Salomon. Susan gives a public invitation to the online community to pitch ideas for the best way to improve the ultimate quality of the singleton that these people believe is inevitable. In other words, hey, give us your ideas for how to make the inevitable AI god nice right. Here's what Ziz writes about her response to that. I asked her whether I should try an alter course and
Speaker 1do research or continue a fork of my pre existing life plan earned to give as a computer engineer, but retrain and try to do research directly instead. At the time, I was planning to go to grad school and I had an irrational attachment to the idea. She sort of compromised and said I should go to grad school, fight a startup co founder, drop out, and earn to give via startups instead. First off, bad advice. That advice just st being Steve Jobs worked for Steve Jobs well, and
Speaker 1Bill Gates. I guess to an extent, it doesn't work for most people.
Speaker 3No, no, no, it seems like the general tech disruptor idea, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, and most people these people aren't very original thinkers, like yeah, she's just saying like, yeah, go to a Steve Jobs. So Ziz does go to grad school, and somewhere around that time in twenty fourteen, she attends a lecture by Elisia Jedkowski on the subject of Inadequate Equilibria, which is the title of a book that Judkowski had wrote about the time, and the book is about where and how civilizations get stuck. One reviewer, Brian Kaplan, who despite being a professor of economics must have a brain
Speaker 1as smooth as a pearl, wrote this about it. Every society is screwed up. Elisia Jieddkowski is one of the few thinkers on earth who are trying, at the most general level to understand why. And this is like, wow, that's it, you, pete. Please study the humanities a little bit, A little bit, a little bit, I mean, fuck man. The first and most like one of the first influential hit works of his modern historic scholarship is The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. It's a whole book
Speaker 1about why a society fell apart, and like motherfucker. More recently, Mike Davis existed, like like Jesus Christ.
Speaker 3This guy continues to get traction.
Speaker 1Nobody else is thinking about why society is screwed up, but a leezer yed Kowski.
Speaker 3This man, this man, this guy this.
Speaker 1Yeah, No, I was trying to find another. I read through that Martin Luther King junior speech. Everything's good. Oh, oh my god, oh my god. Like motherfucker, so many people do nothing but try to write about why our society is sick. He did.
Speaker 3On all levels.
Speaker 7By the way, everybody's thinking about this.
Speaker 1This is such a common subjective scholarship and disc gout ship.
Speaker 3What everyone's talking always.
Speaker 1It would be like if if I got really into like reading medical textbooks and was like, you know what, nobody's ever tried to figure out how to transplant a heart. I'm going to write a book about how that might work. I think I got it.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1People, so yeah, speaking of these fucking people have sex with Uh Nope, well that's something No, No, I don't know, I don't know. Uh don't fuck listen to ads. We're back so Zizz is at this speech where Yudkowski is shilling his book, and he most of what he seems
Speaker 1to be talking about in this speech about this book about why societies fall apart is how to make a tech startup. She says, quote, he gave a recipe for finding startup ideas. He said, Paul Graham's idea only filter on people, ignore startup ideas was partial epistemic learned helplessness. That means Paul Graham is saying, focus on finding good people that you'd start a company with. Having an idea for a company doesn't matter. Yeddkowski says, of course, startup ideas mattered. You needed a good startup idea. So look for a way in the world is broken, then compare
Speaker 1against a checklist of things you couldn't fix, you know, right like that, That's what this speech is largely about, as him being like, here's how to find startup ideas. So she starts thinking. She starts thinking as hard as she can, and you know, being a person who is very much of the tech brain industry rot at this point she comes up with a brilliant idea. It's a genius idea. Oh you're gonna you're gonna love this idea, David Uber for prostitutes.
Speaker 5With me.
Speaker 1No, No, that's where she landed. She lands on the idea of, oh wow, sex work is illegal, but porn isn't. So if we start an uber whereby a team with a camera and a porn star come to your house and you fuck them and record it, that's a legal loophole. We just found that at.
Speaker 6Not just the bus, she makes the big bus, the gig economy.
Speaker 1It is really like don dreper moment, what about uber but a pimp It's it's so funny these people.
Speaker 3You gotta love it. You got wow, it's wow wow. What a place to end U. Yeah. I would love to see the other drafts.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, god yeah man. That's that's that is the good stuff, isn't it?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 6Wow?
Speaker 3Wow?
Speaker 1We special minds at work here, oh man.
Speaker 3Ultimately, to save it all, I have to make smart I have to.
Speaker 1Make pimp uber.
Speaker 3That's so wild.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, the uber of pimping. What an idea. So Ziz devotes her brief time in grad school. She's working on pimping Uber to try and find a partner.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1She wants to have a startup partner, someone who will will embark on this journey with her.
Speaker 3I don't know if that's an investor you need.
Speaker 1To it doesn't work out, she drops out of grad school because quote, I did not find someone who felt like good startup co founder material. This may be because she's very bad at talking to people and also probably scares people off because the things that she talks about are deeply off putting.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was gonna say. It's also a terrible idea.
Speaker 1And at this point she hasn't done anything bad, so I feel bad for this is a person who's very lonely, who is very confused. She has by this point realized that she's trans but not transitioned. She's in like this is this is like a tough place to be right hard.
Speaker 3That's a hard times. That's that's hard.
Speaker 1And nothing about her inherent personality makes it is going to make this easier for her. Right who she is makes all of this much harder because she also makes some comments about dropping out because her her thesis advisor was abusive. I don't fully know what this means. And here's why, Ziz and encounter some behavior I will describe later that is abusive from other people, but also regularly defines abuse as people who disagree with her about the
Speaker 1only thing that Matt is being creating an AI god to protect the animals. So I don't know if her thesis advisor was abusive or was just like, maybe drop the alien god idea for a second. Yeah, yeah, but maybe maybe focus on like finding a job, you know, making some friends on a couple of dates, going a couple of dates, something like that. Maybe maybe maybe, like maybe make God on the back burner here for a second. Whatever happened here? She decides it's time to move to
Speaker 1the Bay. This is like twenty sixteen. She's going to find a big tech job. She's going to make that big tech money while she figures out a startup idea and finds a co founder who will let her make enough money to change and save the world, well, the whole universe. Her first plan is to give the money to miry Yudkowski's organization so it can continue it's important, important work imagining an ic AI. Her parents. She's got enough family money that her parents are able to pay for like I think like six months or more of rent in the Bay, which is not nothing, not a
Speaker 1cheap place to live. I don't know exactly how long her parents are paying, but like that that implies a degree of financial comfort. Right, So she gets hired by a startup very quickly, because again very gifted with the resume.
Speaker 3Right, Yes, yes it's.
Speaker 1Some sort of gaming company. But at this point she's made another change in her ethics system based on the Leiser Yeddkowski's writings. One of Yudkowski's writings argues that it is talking about the difference between consequentialists and virtue ethics. Right. Consequentialists are people who focus entirely on what will the outcome of my actions be? And it kind of doesn't matter what I'm doing or even if it's sometimes a little fucked up, if the end result is good. Virtue
Speaker 1ethics people folk have a code and stick to it. Right, And actually, and I kind of am surprised that he came to this. Kowski's conclusion is that like, while logically you're more likely to succeed, like on paper, you're more likely to succeed as a consequentialist. His opinion is that virtue ethics has the best outcome. People tend to do well when they stick to a code and they try to rather than like anything goes as long as I succeed, right, And I think that's actually a pretty decent way to live your life.
Speaker 3It's a pretty reasonable cosion for him.
Speaker 1It's a reasonable conclusion for him. So I don't blame him on this part. But here's the problem. Zizz is trying to break into and succeed in the tech industry, and you can't. You are very unlikely to succeed at a high level in the tech industry if you are unwilling to do things and and be have things done to you that are unethical and fucked up. I'm not saying this is good. And this is the reality of the entertainment industry too, right, I experience when I started, and I started with an unpaid internship. Unpaid internships are bad, right,
Speaker 1It's bad that those exist. They inherently favor people who have money and people who have family connections. You know. I had like a small savings account for my job in special ed, but that was the standard. It's like, there were a lot of unpaid internships. It got me my foot in the door. It worked for me. I also worked a lot of overtime that I didn't get paid. For I did a lot of shit that wasn't a part of my job to impress my bosses to make myself indispensable so that they would decide, like, we have to keep this guy on and pay him. And it
Speaker 1worked for me, And I just wanted to add because this was not in the original thing. A big part of why it worked for me is that I'm talking about a few different companies here, but particularly at Cracked where I had the internship, Like my bosses, you know, made a choice to me intor me and you know, to get me, you know, to work overtime on their own behalf to like make sure I got a paying job, which is a big part of like the luck that I encountered that a lot of people don't. So that's another major your part of like why things worked out
Speaker 1for me is that I just got incredibly lucky with the people I was working for and with that's bad. It's not good that things work that way, right, It's not.
Speaker 3Set up for you either, Like you know, you kind of defied the odds. It's it's like you said, the rich people who get the job exactly.
Speaker 1It's not even yes that said, if I am giving someone if someone wants, what is the most likely path to succeeding? You know, I've I've just got this job working, you know, on this production company or the music steer. I would I would say, well, your best odds are to like make yourself completely indispensable and become obsessively devoted to that task. Right. Uh, that's it. I don't tend to give that advice anymore. I have and I have had several other friends succeed as a result of it,
Speaker 1and all of us also burnt ourselves out and did huge amounts of damage to ourselves, Like I am permanently broken as a result of you know, the ten years that I did eighty hour weeks and shit, you.
Speaker 3Know now you're sounding like somebody works in the entertainment and.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, and it worked for me, right, I got I got to I succeeded, I got a great job, I got money. Most people, it doesn't, and it's bad that it works this way. Ziz, unlike me, is not willing to do that.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1She thinks it's wrong to be asked to work overtime and not get paid for it, and so on her first day at the job, she leaves after eight hours and her boss is like, what the fuck are you doing? And she's like, I'm here to supposed to be here eight hours, eight hours is up, I'm going home. And he calls her half an hour later and fires her. Right, And this is because the tech industry is evil, you know, like this is bad. She's not bad here she is. It is like a thing where it's she's not doing
Speaker 1by her standards. What I would say is the rational thing, which would be if all that matters is optimizing your earning power, right, right, well, then you do this, then you do do whatever it takes.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1So it's kind of interesting to me like that she is so devoted to this like virtue ethics thing at this point that she fucks over her career in the tech industry because she's not willing to do the things that you kind of need to do to succeed, you know, in the place that she is. But it's interesting. I don't like give her any shit for that. So she asked your parents more for more runway to extend your time in the bay, and then she finds work at another startup, but the same problems persist. Quote, they kept demanding that I work unpaid overtime, talking about how other
Speaker 1employees just put always put forty hours on their timesheet no matter what, and this exemplary employee over there worked twelve hours a day and he really went the extra mile and got the job done. And they needed me to really go the extra mile and get the job done. She's not willing to do that. And again, I hate that this is part of what drives her to the madness that leads to the cult to the killings, because it's like, oh, honey, you're in the right. It's an evil industry.
Speaker 3Yeah, you see a flash of where it have gone. Well it really there were chances for this to work out.
Speaker 1No, you were one hundred percent right, Like this is fuck to it.
Speaker 3Yeah, you know what I mean.
Speaker 1And that's super hard. I really respect that part of you. Oh yeah, yeah, I'm so sad that this is part of what shatters your brain. Like that really bums me out. So first off, she's kind of starts spiraling and she concludes that she hates virtue ethics. This is where she starts hating Yidkowski, Right, this is she doesn't come break entirely on him yet, but she gets really angry at this point because she's like, well, obviously virtue ethics don't work,
Speaker 1and she's.
Speaker 3Been following this man at this point for.
Speaker 1Years exactly exactly, so this is a very like damaging thing to her that this happens. And you know, and again, as much as I'm blamed Yadkowski, the coach sure of the Bay Bay area tech industry, that's a big part of what drives this person, you know, to where she ends up. Right. So that said, some of her issues are also rooted in a kind of rigid and unforgiving internal rule set. At one point, she negotiates work with a professor and their undergraduate helper. She doesn't want to
Speaker 1take an hourly job, and she tries to negotiate a flat rate of seven k and they're like, yeah, okay, that sounds fair, but the school doesn't do stuff like that, so you will have to fake some paperwork with me for me to be able to get them to pay you seven thousand dollars. And she isn't willing to do that. And that's the thing where it's like, ah, no, I've had some shit where this was the like there was a stupid rule and like in order for the pep meat or other people to get paid. We had to like tell something else to the company. Like that's just
Speaker 1that's just no knowing how to get by. Yeah, that's that's living in the world.
Speaker 3You got Yeah, you did the hard part.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3They said that we were going to do it.
Speaker 1You said they did it.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's like they already said, we don't do this.
Speaker 1That's where are you just you can't get by in America If you're not, why will rely on certain kinds of paperwork? Right, That's that's the game our president does all the time. He's the king of that ship. So at this point, Ziz is stuck in what they consider a calamitous situation. The prophecy of doom, as they call it, is ticking ever closer, which means the bad AI that's going to create hell for everybody. Her panic over this is elevated by the fact that she she starts to
Speaker 1get obsessed with Roco's basilisk at this time. No I know, I know, worst thing for her to read, come on in and info hazard the warnings yep, and a lot of the smarter rationalists are just annoyed by it.
Speaker 3Again.
Speaker 1Yadkowski immediately is like, this is very quickly decides it's bullshit and bans discussion of it. He argues there's no incentive for a future agent to fall through with that threat because it by doing so, it just expens resources and no gain to itself, which is like, yeah, man, a hyperlogical AI would not immediately jump to I must make hell for everybody who didn't code me, Like, yeah, that's just crazy.
Speaker 3There's some step skew.
Speaker 1Yeah, only humans are like ill in that way.
Speaker 3That's the funny thing about it is it's such a human response to.
Speaker 1Yeah, right right now. When she encounters the concept of Roco's basilisk, at first, Ziz thinks that it's silly, right. She kind of rejects it and moves on, But once she gets to the Bay, she starts going to in person rationalist meetups and having long conversations with other believers who are still talking about Roco's basilisk. She writes, I started encountering people who were freaked out by it, freaked out that they had discovered an improvement to the info hazard that made it function got around a Leezer's objection.
Speaker 1Her ultimate conclusion is this, if I persisted in trying to save the world, I would be tortured until the end of top the universe by a coalition of all unfriendly ais in order to increase the amount of measure they got by demoralizing me. Even if my system too had good decision theory, my system one did not, and that would damage my effectiveness. And like, I can't explain all of the terms in that without taking more time than we need to. But like you can hear like that is not the writing of a person who is thinking in logical terms.
Speaker 3No, it's it's a uh, it's so scary.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, it is very scary stuff.
Speaker 3It's so scary to be like, Oh, that's where she was operating those mistakes.
Speaker 1This is where you head she's dealing with.
Speaker 3Yes, that's that's it is.
Speaker 1You know, I talked to my friends who grow are raised in like very toxic evangelical subculture, chunks of the evangelgelical sub culture and growth, and spend their whole childhood terrified of hell that like everything, you know, I got angry at my mom and I didn't say anything, but God knows I'm angry at her, and He's going to send me to hell because I didn't respect my mother.
Speaker 3Mother.
Speaker 1Like that's what she's doing.
Speaker 3Right exactly exactly. She can't win. There's no winning here.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, and again I say this a lot. We need to put lithium back in the drinking water. We we gotta put lithium back.
Speaker 3In the water.
Speaker 1Maybe xanax too, she needed she.
Speaker 3Could have tooken a combo. Yeah, before it gets to where it gets. At this point, you really you really feel for and like just living in this living like that every day. She's so scared and that this is what she's doing. It's it's this, this is she.
Speaker 1Is the therapy needingest woman I have ever heard. At this point, Oh my god.
Speaker 3She just needs to talk to She needs to talk again. You know, the cult.
Speaker 1The thing that happens to cult members has happened to her where she her. The whole language she uses is incomprehensible to people. I had to talk to you for an hour and fifteen minutes. See you what understand parts of what this lady says? Right exactly, you have to because it's all nonsense if you don't do that work exactly.
Speaker 3She's so spun out at this point, it's like, how do you even get back? Yeah, how do you even get back.
Speaker 1Yeah, so she she ultimately decides, even though she thinks she's doomed to be tortured by unfriendly ais evil gods, must be fought. If this damns me, then so be it. She's very heroic, she had and she sees herself that way, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, and even like just with her convictions and that she she does, she does, she does, she does, she does it.
Speaker 1She's a woman of conviction. You really can't take that away from her. Relytions are nonsense, No, that's the but they're there.
Speaker 3Yeah, they're based on Harry Potter fan fiction.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's like David Ike, the guy who believes in like literal lizard people. Everyone thinks he's like talking about the Jews, but like no, no, no, no, he doesn't just lizards.
Speaker 4It's exactly that where it's just like you want to draw, Yeah, you want to draw something, so it's not nonsense, and then you realize no, that's.
Speaker 1No, no, no no. And like David, he went out he's made like a big rant against how Elon Musk is like evil for what all these people he's hurt by firing the whole federal government. People were shocked. It's like no, no, no, David Ike believes in a thing. It's just crazy. Those people do exist. Yeah, here we are talking about and here we are talking about them. Some of them run the country. But actually I don't all of those people believe in anything. But yeah, yeah,
Speaker 1speaking of people who believe in something, our sponsors believe in getting your money. We're back.
Speaker 3So uh.
Speaker 1She is at this point suffering from delusions of granteur and those are going to rapidly lead her to danger. But she concludes that since the fate of the universe is at stake in her actions, she would make a timeless choice to not believe in the basilisk, right, and that that will protect her in the future, because that's how these people talk about stuff like that. So she gets over her fear of the basilisk for a little while, but even it, like when she claims to have rejected
Speaker 1the theory, whenever she references it in her blog, she like locks it away under a spoiler with like an info hazard warning. Roco's Basilisk family skippable, so you don't like have to see it and have it destroy your psyche.
Speaker 3That's the power of it.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, yeah. The concept does, however, keep coming back to her like and continuing to drive her mad. Thoughts of the basilisk return, and eventually she comes to an extreme conclusion. If what I cared about was sentient life, and I was willing to go to hell to save everyone else, why not just send everyone else to hell? If I didn't submit?
Speaker 3Can I tell you, I really it felt like this is what was? This is like where it had to go right?
Speaker 1Yeah? Yeah, yes. So what she means here is that she is now making the timeless decision that when she is in a position of ultimate influence and helps bring this all powerful vegan AI into existence, she's promising now ahead of time to create a perfect hell, a digital hell, to like punish all of the people who don't like eat meat. Ever, she wants to make a hell for people who eat meat. And that's the Yeah, that's the
Speaker 1conclusion that she makes. Right, So this becomes an intrusive thought in her head, primarily the idea that like everyone isn't going along with her, right, Like, she doesn't want to create this hell, she just thinks that she has to. So she's like very focused on like trying to convince these other people in the rationalist culture to become vegan. Anyway, she writes this quote, I thought it had to be subconsciously influencing me, damaging met my effectiveness, that I had done more harm than I can imagine by thinking these things,
Speaker 1because I had the hubris to think info hazards didn't exist, and worse, to feel resigned a grim sort of pride in my previous choice to fight for sentient life, although it damned me and the gaps between. Do not think about that, you moron. Do not think about that, you moron pride, which may have led to intrusive thoughts to resurface and progress and progress to resume. In other words, my ego had perhaps damned the universe. So, man, I don't fully get all of what she's saying here. But it's also because she's like just spun out into madness
Speaker 1at this.
Speaker 3Yeah, she lives in it now.
Speaker 4It's so yeah, it's so far for we've been talking about it, however long she's a she's so far away from us even.
Speaker 1Yeah, and it is it is deeply I've read a lot of her writing. It is deeply hard to understand pieces of it here.
Speaker 3Man, But she is at war with herself.
Speaker 1She is for sure at war with herself. Now, this is at this point attending rationalist events by the Bay, and a lot of the people at those events are older, more influential men, some of whom are influential in the tech industry, all of whom have a lot more money than her. And some of these people are members of an organization called SEAFAR, the Center for Applied Rationality, which is a nonprofit founded to help people get better at a pursuing their goals. It's a self help company, right, and what runs self help seminars. This is the same
Speaker 1as like a Tony Robbins thing. Right, We're all just trying to get you to sign up and then get you to sign up for the next workshop, and the next workshop and the next workshop, like all self help people do. Yeah, there's no difference between this and Tony Robbins. So Ziz goes to this event and she has a long conversation with several members of SEAFAR, who I think are clearly kind of My interpretation of this is that they're trying to groom her to get a new because they think is chick's clearly brilliant, she'll find her way
Speaker 1in the industry, and we want her money, right, maybe we wanted to do some free work for us too, but like let's let's you know, uh, we got to reel this fish in. Right. So this is described as an academic conference by people who are in the AI risk field and rationalism, you know, thinking of ways to save the universe, because only the true, the super geniuses can do that. The actual why I'm really glad that I read Ziz's account here is I've been reading about these people for a long time. I've been reading about
Speaker 1their beliefs. I felt there's some cult stuff here. When Ziz laid out what happened at this seminar, this self help him seminar put on by these people very close to Yadkowski, this is it's almost exactly the same as a Synonon meeting. Like it's the same stuff, It's exact and it's the same shit. It's the same as accounts of like big like self help movement things from like the seventies and stuff that I've read that that that's when it really clicked to me.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1Quote, here's a description of one of the because they have, you know, speeches, and then they break out into groups to do different exercises right, there were hamming circles per person take turns, having everyone else spend twenty minutes trying to solve the most important problem about your life. To you, I didn't pick the most important problem in my life because secrets. I think I used my turn on a problem I thought they might actually be able to help. With the fact that it did, although it didn't seem to affect my productivity or willpower at all, I e I was in humanly determined basically all the time. I
Speaker 1still felt terrible all the time that I was hurting from some to some degree, relinquishing my humanity. I was sort of vaguing about the pain of being trans and having decided not to transition, and so like, this is a part of the thing. You build a connection between other people and this group by getting people to like spill their secrets to each other. It's a thing scientology does. It's a thing they did. It's sending on tell me your darkest secret, right, And she's not fully willing to because she doesn't want to come out to this group of people yet. And you know part of what I forget.
Speaker 3That she's also dealing with that entire yeah, yes, wow, yeah.
Speaker 1And that the hamming circle doesn't sound so bad if you'll recall any and as you mentioned this, I was really good. In part one, Seninon would have people break into circles where they would insult and attack each other in order to create a traumatic experience that would bond them together and with the cult. These hamming circles are weird, but they're not that. But there's another exercise they did next called doom circles. Quote. There were doom circles where each person, including themselves, took turns having everyone else bluntly but compassionately say why they were doomed. Using blindsight. Someone
Speaker 1decided and set a precedent of starting these off with a sort of ritual incantation we now invoke and bow to the doom gods and waving their hands saying doom. I said, I'd never bow to the doom gods, and well everyone else said that. I flipped the double bird to the heavens and said fuck you instead, person a, that's the member of Seafar that she is. Admirers found this agreeable and joined in. Some people brought up that they felt like they were only as morally valuable as half a person. This irked me. I said they were whole persons and don't be stupid like that, Like if
Speaker 1they wanted to sacrifice themselves, they could weigh one versus seven billion. They didn't have to falsely detegrate themselves is less than one person. They didn't listen. When it was my turn concerning myself, I said, my doom was that I could succeed at the things I tried, succeed exceptionally well, Like I bet I could in ten years have earned a give like ten million dollars through startups, and it would still be too little, too late, Like I came into this game too late. The world would still burn. And first off, like this is you know, it's a variant of the synonym thing you're going around. You're telling
Speaker 1people why they're doomed, right, like why they won't succeed in life, you know, But it's also one of the things here these people are saying they feel like less than a person. A major topic of discussion in the community at the time is if you don't think you can succeed in business and make money, is the best thing with the highest net value you can do taking out an insurance policy on yourself and committing suicide, oh my god, and then having the money donated to a rationalist organization. That's a major topic of discussion that like
Speaker 1Ziz grapples with a lot of these people grapple with, right because they are obsessed with the idea of like, oh my god, I might be net negative value. Right if I can't do this or can't do this, I could be a net negative value individual. And that means like I'm not contributing to the solution, and there's nothing worse than not contributing to the solution.
Speaker 3Were there people who did that?
Speaker 1I am not aware there are people who commit suicide in this community. I will say that, like there are a number of suicides tied to this community. I don't know if the actual insurance con thing happened, but it's like a seriously discussed thing. And it's seriously discussed because all of these people to talk about the value of their own lives in purely like mechanistic how much money or expected value can I produce? Like that is a
Speaker 1person and that's why a person matters, right, And the term they use is morally valuable, right, Like that's that's what means you're a worthwhile human being, if you're morally if you're creating a net positive benefit to the world in the way they define it. And so a lot of these people are. Yes, there are people who are depressed, and there are people who kill themselves because they come to the conclusion that they're a net negative person. Right like that that is a thing at the edge of all of this shit that's really fucked up. And that's
Speaker 1that's what this doom circle is about. Is everybody like flipping out over I'm like and telling each other, I think you might know be as only be as morally valuable as half a person, right like. That's people are saying that, right like, that's what's going on here, you know, Like it's not the synonym thing of like like you're a you know, using the f slur a million times or whatever. But it's very bad.
Speaker 3No, this is this is this is awful.
Speaker 1For like one thing I don't know. My feeling is you have an inherent value because you're a person.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's a great place to start, you know, so leading people to destroy themselves like it's.
Speaker 1It's it's so it's such a bleak way of looking at things.
Speaker 3It's so crazy too, where were these meals. I just in my head, I'm like, this is just happening in like a ballroom at a raticon.
Speaker 1I think it is, or a convention center, you know, the different kind of public spaces. I don't know, Like honestly, if you've been to like an anime convention or a Magic the Gathering convention somewhere in the Bay, you may have been in one of the rooms they did these, and I don't know exactly where they hold this. So the person A mentioned above, this like person who's like affiliated with the organization that I think is a recruiter h looking young people who can be cultivated to pay for classes. Right, this person, it's very clear to them
Speaker 1that Ziz is at the height of her vulnerability, and so he tries to take advantage of that. So he and another person from the organization engage Zizz during a break. Ziz, who's extremely insecure, asks them point blank, what do you think my net value ultimately will be in life? Right? And again there's like an element of this it's almost like rationalist calvinism, where it's like it's actually decided ahead of time by your inherent immutable characteristics. You know, if you are a person who can do good. Quote. I
Speaker 1asked person A if they expected me to be net negative. They said yes. After a moment, they asked me what I was feeling or something like that. I said something like dazed and sad. They asked why sad. I said I might leave the field as a consequence and maybe something else. I said I needed time to process or think. And so she like, she goes home after this guy is saying like, yeah, I think your life's probably net negative value, and sleeps the rest of the day. And she wakes up the next morning and comes back to the second day of this thing, and yeah, Ziz goes
Speaker 1back and she tells this person, Okay, here's what I'm gonna do. I'm going to pick a group of three people at the event I respect, including you, and if two of them vote that they think I have a net negative value quote, I'll leave EA and existential risk and the rationalist community and so on forever. I'd transition and move, probably to Seattle. I heard it was relatively nice for trans people, and there do what I could to be a normy, retool my mind as much as possible, to be stable, unchanging an enormy gradually abandoned my Facebook
Speaker 1account and email use a name change as a story for that, and God, that would have been the best thing.
Speaker 3For That's what I'm you see, like but sliver of hope, like yeah, oh man.
Speaker 1She sees this as a nightmare, right, this is the worst case scenario for her, right, because you're she's part of You're not part of the You're not part of the cause. You know, you're you have no you have no involvement in the great quest to save humanity. That's worse than death almost right.
Speaker 3It's its own kind of hell though, right to think that you have this enlightenment and then you that you weren't good enough to.
Speaker 1And that's a lot about how I'd probably just kill myself, you know, that's the logical thing to do. It's so fucked up, it's so fucked up. But also if she's trying to live a normal life as a normy, and she she refers to like being a normy as like just trying to be nice to people, because again that's useless. So her fa fear here is that she would be a causal negative if she does this, right, and also the robot god that comes about might put her in.
Speaker 3Hell, right, because that's also looming. Yeah, after every for every decision, right, Yeah.
Speaker 1And the thing here she she expressed, she tells these guys a story, and it really shows, both in this community and among her how little value they actually have for like human life. I told a story about a time I had killed four ants in a bathtub where I wanted to take a shower before growing to work. I'd considered, can I just not take a shower, and presumed me smelling bad at work would, because of big numbers in the fate of the world and stuff, make the world worse than the deaths of four basically causally isolated people. I considered getting paper in a cup and
Speaker 1taking them elsewhere, and I figured there were decent odds if I did, I'd be late to work and it would probably make the world worse in the long run. So again, she considers ants identical to human beings, and she is also saying it was worth killing four of them because they're causally isolated so that I could get to work in time, because I'm working for the cause. It's also it's in a bad place here.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4The crazy thing about her is it like the amount of thinking just to like get in the shower to go to work, you know, you know what I mean like that that ah, it just seems like it makes everything.
Speaker 3Yeah, every every action is so loaded.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, that most it's so it's it's wild to me both this like mix of like fucking Jane Buddhist compassion of like an aunt is no less than I, or an aunt is no less than a human being, right, we are all these are all lives. And then but also it's fine for me to kill a bunch of me to go to work on time, because like they're causally isolated, so they're basically not people. Like it's it's so weird. Like and again it's getting a lot clearer here.
Speaker 1Why this lady and her ideas end in a bunch of people getting shot yeah and stabbed. Okay, there's a samurai's sword later in the story, my friend.
Speaker 3That's the one thing this has been missing.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, So they continue, these guys to have a very abusive conversation with this young person and she trusts them.
Speaker 3Enough that a conversation where she asked for the two yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, and she tells them she's trans right, And this gives you an idea of like, how kind of predatory some of the stuff going on in this community is. They asked what I'd do with a female body. They were trying to get me to admit what I actually wanted to do was the first thing in heaven, heaven being there's this idea, especially amongst like some trans members of the rationalist community that like all of them basically believe a robot's gonna make heaven, right, and obviously, like there's a number of the folks who are in this who are trans are like and in heaven, like you just kind of get the body you want immediately, right,
Speaker 1so these get They were trying to get me to admit that what I actually wanted to do as the first thing in heaven was masturbate in a female body. And they follow us up by sitting really close to her, close enough that she gets uncomfortable. And then a really really rationalist conversation follows. They asked if I felt trapped. I may have clarified physically, they may have said sure. Afterward, I answered no to that question under the likely justified belief that it was framed that way. They asked why not. I said, I was pretty sure I could take them
Speaker 1in a fight. They prodded for details why I thought so, and then how I thought a fight between us would go. I asked, what kind of fight, like a physical, unarmed fight to the death right now? And why what were my payouts? This was over the fate of the multiverse. Triggering actions by other people, ie or imprisonment or murder was not relevant. So they decide they make this into again. These people are all addicted to dumb game theory stuff, right, okay, so what is this fight? Is this fight over the fate of the multiverse? Are we in an alternate reality where like no one will come and intervene and there's no cops, we're the only people in the world or whatever.
Speaker 1So they tell her like, yeah, imagine there's no consequences legally whatever to you do, and we're fighting over the fate of the multiverse. And so she proceeds to give an extremely elaborate discussion of how she'll gouge out their eyes and try to destroy their prefrontal lobes and then stomp on their skulls until they die. And it's both it's like, it's nonsense. It's like how ten year olds thinks fights work. It's also it's based on this game theory attitude of fighting that they have, which is like it's you have to make this kind of timeless decision that any fight is you're you're just going to murder.
Speaker 3The hardest confrontation, right, Yes, I suppose you have to be the most violent.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, because that will make other people not want to attack you, as opposed to like what normal people understand about like real fights, which is if you have to do one, if you have to, you like try to just like hit him in the hit him is somewhere that's going to shock them, and then run like a motherfucker, right you get out of like if you have to like ideally just run like a motherfucker. But if you have to strike somebody, you know, yeah, go for the eye and then run like a son of a bitch, you know, Like but there's no run like a son of a bitch here. Because the point in
Speaker 1part is this like timeless decision to anyway, This gives tells you a lot about the rationalist community. So she tells these people, she explains in detail how she would murder them if they have to fight out they're like squitting next super close, having just asked her about masturbation. Here's their first question quote. They asked if I'd rape their corpse. Part of me insisted this was not going as it was supposed to, but I'd decided. I decided inflicting discomfort in order to get reliable information was a valid tactic. In other words, them trying to make her
Speaker 1uncomfortable to get info from her, she decides is fine. Also, the whole discussion about raping their corpses is like, well, if you rape, obviously, if you want to have the most extreme response possible, that would like make other people unlikely to fuck with you knowing that you'll violate their corpse if you kill them as clearly the light.
Speaker 3And like that.
Speaker 1Okay, sure, I love rational thought.
Speaker 3Oh man, this is crazy, sorry, this is yes, is so crazy, it's so nuts.
Speaker 1So then they talk about psychopathy. One of these guys had earlier told Zizz that they thought she was a psychopath, but he told her that he told her that doesn't mean what it means both to actual like clinicians, because psychopathy is a diagnostician, or like what normal people mean. To rationalists, a lot of them think psychopathy is a state you can put yourself into in order to maximize your performance in certain situations because they they've Again there's some like popular books that are about like the Psychopaths
Speaker 1Way the Dark Triad, and like, well, you know, these are the people who lead societies in the toughest times, and so like you could you need to optimize and engage in some of those behaviors if you want to win in these situations. Based on all of this, Ziz brings up what rationalists call the Gervas principle. Now, this started as a tongue in cheek joke describing a rule of office dynamics based on the TV show The Office. Yes it's Ricky Sace, Yes, And the idea is that in office environments, psycho's always rise to the top. This
Speaker 1is supposed to be like a negative observation. Like the person who wrote this initially is like, yeah, this is how offices work, and it's like why they're bad.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1It's an extension of the Peter principle. And these psychopaths put bad like dumb and incompetent people in like when positions below them for a variety. It's trying to kind of work out why in which like offices, are often dysfunctional. Right, it's not like the original Jervase principle. Thing is like not a bad piece of writing or whatever, but Zis takes something insane out of it. I described how the Jervase principle said, sociopaths give up empathy as in a certain chunk of social software, not literally all hardware awared
Speaker 1accelerated modeling of people, not necessarily compassion, and with it happiness destroying meaning to create power, meaning too, I did not care about I wanted this world to live on. So she tells them she's come to the conclusion I need to make myself into a psychopath in order to have the kind of mental power necessary to do the things that I want to do. And she largely justifies this by describing the leafs of the Sith from Star Wars, because she thinks she needs to remake herself as a psychopathic evil warrior monk in order to save all of creation.
Speaker 3Yeah. No, of course, yep.
Speaker 1So this is her hitting her final form. And true to fact, these guys are like, they doesn't say it's a good idea that but they're like, Okay, yeah, you know that's not that's not the worst thing you could do. Sure, you know, like I think the Sith stuff kind of weird, but making yourself a psychopath makes sense. Sure, yeah, of course I know a lot of guys who did that. That's literally what they say, right, And then they say that also, I don't even think that's what they really they say that, because the next thing they say, this guy person a is like, look, the best that lay
Speaker 1to turn yourself from a net negative to a net positive value. I really believe you could do it. But to do it, you need to come to ten more of these seminars and keep taking classes here right right right, here's a quote from them, or from Ziz. She's conditional on beig going to a long course of circling like these two organizations offered, particularly a ten weekend one, then I probably would not be net negative. So things are going good. This is this is you know, ah, yeah great?
Speaker 3How much weekends cost?
Speaker 1I don't actually know, I don't I don't fully know with this. It's possible. Some of these are like some of the events are free, like, but the classes cost money, or but it's also a lot of it's like there's donations expected or by doing this and being a member, it's expected you're going to tithe basically that's like your income, right more than I.
Speaker 2I don't know the format. Is she not going to be like super suspicious that people are like, you know, faking it or like going over the top.
Speaker 1She okay, is she is? She gets actually really uncomfortable. They have an exercise where they're basically doing you know, they're playing with love bombing right where everyone's like hugging and telling each other they love each other, and she's like, I don't really believe it. I just met these people. So she she has started to and she is going to break away from these organizations pretty quickly. But this conversation she have with these guys is a critical part of like why she finally has this fracture, because number one, this dude keeps telling her you have a net negative
Speaker 1value to the universe, right, and so she's obsessed with like how do I And it comes to the conclusion, my best way of being net positive is to make myself then doo associopath and a sith lord to save the animals.
Speaker 3Of course, it feels like the same thinking though, as like the Robot's gonna make it seems to always come back to this idea of like I think we just gotta be evil.
Speaker 2It's yes, oh yes, well I guess the only laws of illusion is doom.
Speaker 3Yep. Yeah, yeah, it's like it feels like it's a it's a theme here.
Speaker 1M hm, yep. Anyway you want to plug anything at the end here.
Speaker 3Ah, I have a comedy specially you can purchase on Patreon. It's called Birth of a Nation with a G. You can get that at Patreon dot combat Sash David.
Speaker 1Excellent, excellent. All right, folks, well that is the end of the episode. David, thank you so much for coming on to our inaugural episode by listening to some of the weirdest shit we've ever talked about on this show.
Speaker 3Yeah, this is I don't really I'm gonna be thinking about this for weeks.
Speaker 9I mean yeah, yeah, because your co host likes a curbent kbon for the Elders of Zion episodes, Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, I wanted to. I was initially going to kind of just focus on all of this would have been like half a page or so, you know, just kind of summing up here's the gist of what this believes and then let's get to the actual cult stuff when, like you know, Ziz starts bringing in followers and the crimes start happening. But that Rolling or that Wired article really covers all that very well. And that's the best piece. Most of the journalism I've read on these guys is not very well written. It's not very good. It does not really explain why they what they are, why they
Speaker 1do it. So I decided, and I'm not. The Wired piece is great. I know the Wired guy knows all of the stuff that I brought up here. He just it's an article. You have editors. He left out what he thought he needed to leave out. I don't have that problem. And I wanted to really, really deeply trace exactly where this lady's how this lady's mind develops, and how that intersects with rationalism, because it's interesting and kind of important and bad. Yeah, okay, So anyway, thanks for
Speaker 1having a had fuck with me. All right, that's it, everybody, Goodbye.
Speaker 2Behind the Bastards is a production of cool Zone Media. For more from cool Zone Media, visit our website Coolzonemedia dot com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Behind the Bastards is now available on YouTube, new episodes every Wednesday and Friday.
Speaker 9Subscribe to our channel YouTube dot com slash at Behind the Bastards
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...
Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.