Robert sits down with the magnanimous Katy Stoll to discuss the predecessor of Phyllis Schlafly, Candace Owens and Alex Jones: Elizabeth Dilling
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Cool Media.
Speaker 2Welcome back to Behind the Bastards. This is not the first episode of the podcast we've done this year during the official summer, but it's basically the official legal Christian summer, right, guys, team, isn't it? It feels hot as hell outside today.
Speaker 1It's gonna it's but but but it only for the next couple of days, and then it's gonna be in the sixties.
Speaker 2Oh is it?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 1And then and then and then mother Mother Nature will water my garden and I'm thrilled.
Speaker 2Great, I'm glad that my will burn down yet.
Speaker 3Yes, Oh yeah, Katie Stoles here legend.
Speaker 2Hey, everybody, how hot and or on fire? Is it where you are?
Speaker 3Oh? Yeah, both of those things? I am in the mountains. But it is an unpleasant Well, it's eighty five. It's eighty five, not too bad.
Speaker 4We had some ninety degree days last week. But I moved to the mountains thinking it would be cooler, and boy was I wrong.
Speaker 2Yeah, it gets hot. It gets hot.
Speaker 3Lots of burnable brush all around me as well, So.
Speaker 2Yeah, everything catches on fire out there. That's the beauty of living out in the country.
Speaker 4And they defunded one of my They close one of our fire stations anyway.
Speaker 1Oh that's always oh good.
Speaker 2It's not like California needs a lot of those wild I'm only bringing up the summer because I had my first. Every every year when it gets hot again, I remember, Okay, I gotta put out sunscreen before I go run this time. And then fifteen or so minutes into that first run of the year with sunscreen, I remember, oh yeah, when you sweat with sunscreen, it burns your eyes like a son of a bitch. So if my eyes look like red and buffy, it's because I just finished a run in a shower and my entire face was on fire from sunscreen.
Speaker 3I actually thought it was because you were crying. No, no, like, well, you've been touched.
Speaker 2I would tell you if I was crying. But this is simply self inflicted friendly fire.
Speaker 4Self inflicted friendly fire. Another piece of why are you're wearing a sweater?
Speaker 2Man?
Speaker 4It's it's cold, yeah, and we're talking about summer and you're all bundled up.
Speaker 2I am wearing my my hoodie or my sweater.
Speaker 3Yes. Meanwhile, Katie and I are Lucy Gucy.
Speaker 1Yeah, oh yeah, I got my Laker's Luka Dontrid shirt on.
Speaker 3Shout out to my haters. Okay, anyways, Robert did the job.
Speaker 1Should we do it?
Speaker 2Yeah? Shall we do the job? Katie Stole? How are you doing today podcasting wise?
Speaker 3Pretty good. I'm sitting here with my old pals, whom I've missed. Miss I have.
Speaker 2Missed you too, and I have missed talking to you about shitty people. So I wanted to give you a special shitty person today. You know, we talk a lot about old timey far right influencers on this podcast, you know, the first the guys around the twenties and thirties and forties, the og American fascists, but we haven't talked a lot about like the history of women in the early history of women in the American fascist movement, and the crucial role different like female influencers have played aid in the American far right. And so today we're going to talk
Speaker 2about a woman you could call the first Candace Owens or the first Laura Lumer. You can make a case she's got bits of both of those, both Candace and Laura. Oh a little bit to this lady we're going to talk about this week, Elizabeth Dilling. Have you heard that name?
Speaker 3Elizabeth Dilling. Do you see why I was like, we need Katie for this episode. Yeah, okay, I'm excited. I do not know anything about Elizabeth Dillon.
Speaker 2She's not super She is the B side who are more famous fascist and I think you will recognize from later on. But like again, because I guess of misogyny, she never quite got as famous as her her male fascist counterpart.
Speaker 3It's it's really the patriarchy on Netflix. Yeah, you.
Speaker 2Know, if you've watched it, they don't give a ship. They barely know what's on their own network. Thanks Netflix, thanks for the money. Elizabeth Elois Kirkpatrick was born on April nineteenth, eighteen ninety four, in Chicago. Now, if eighteen ninety four in Chicago sound familiar to you, that's because that is the same year in city as the Pullman Strike, which is a legendary moment in labor history. Began as
Speaker 2a local Chicago strike that became a national boycott and changed US labor law forever in the process, and that strike itself was heavily inspired by the trials of the eighteen ninety three economic panic that fractured the US economy and helped fuel Eugene V. Debs's creation of the American Railway Union. Right, so, Chicago at the time Elizabeth is born is real hotbed for labor, for this burgeoning and really exploding American left, which is growing into what some might argue and probably still to this day, would count
Speaker 2as its most influential period in American histories, kind of coming up as a result of the things that are sort of happening right around the time Elizabeth is born. So it's kind of going to be important a little that she's she's never going to adopt any of these kind of politics, but they are happening around her and very much in the environment that she's growing up in. Her family is against a lot of these changes, but she's going to grow up hearing about them because they're right outside her door.
Speaker 3You know, sure, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2So little Elizabeth comes into the world in a time and a place that was hugely significant in the history of American labor and the struggles of the workingman against his bosses, and so it's appropriate for the person she would become that even as an infant, she was entirely separate and protected from the normal world of working class people. This is happening outside her mansion gates. Basically, her father, doctor Leete Kirkpatrick, was a famous surgeon and her mother, Elizabeth Harding, was a homemaker. But both came from very prominent families, right, so both of their families have some
Speaker 2degree of like financial comfort. And her dad, at least initially is this like famous doctor the Kirkpatrick's. Her dad's family had been wealthy landowners in Ireland, but had fled near the end of the eighteen hundreds and settled in Virginia. Liz would Laters describe her father as coming from Scott's Irish stock, and some googling around has given me coust to think that her her family Basically, if you've ever heard of like the Irish Land Wars, this period of time in which like there's a lot of conflict in Ireland over like who gets to own what land, there's
Speaker 2a lot of conflict as a result of these like absentee landlords that piss off a lot of people. Well, her her ancestors are some of the absentee lands. Yeah, yeah, yeah, okay, because they're like a Scottish family who winds up owning a lot of land in Ireland, you know, yeah, And I don't know that the Kirkpatricks had to flee their family estate because they were brutal landlords, but my research does make that seem likely, and it's always a good yeah. Yeah. We don't talk enough about Ireland's land wars.
Speaker 4It sounds like we're setting up for a family that does not learn from those lessons. Perhaps perhaps they're here also resenting.
Speaker 3The different classes around them. I don't know, and has.
Speaker 2Like a long time grudge against anyone trying to fix things because they just see that as like you're fucking with my big you know, like that's the people that she comes from. So let's talk a little about the Irish land Wars because people don't often enough, and it's a fun bit of history. Only about five percent of the land in Ireland from the late seventeen hundreds to the end of the eighteen hundreds was owned by Irish Catholics, despite the fact that Irish Catholics were most of Ireland. People got very angry about this and it led to successive waves of protests and even violent insurgent direct action.
Speaker 2It is very possible then, that the Kirkpatricks had to flee because they wound up on either side of this dispute, but the fact that they had a family estate and came to the US with money makes me suspect that they weren't fighting for the freedom of poor men. Right, These are probably on one specific side of.
Speaker 3The land wars pretty solid gas.
Speaker 2Meanwhile, the Harding family, elizabeth'smother's people came from a long line of Anglican bishops, which also makes it like clear that her dad's people were foreign landlords at some point. Anyway, she grows up fairly well off. In a two thousand and two article for the Journal of American Studies, writer Christine Erickson describes her family as financially comfortable, upper middle class. Right, that's that's that's where they're coming from. Her parents have enough money that, even though these are pretty rough times, they're able to travel fairly regularly. But they're not able to send the kids abroad with them. So Liz grows
Speaker 2up not traveling much yourself. But her mom and her aunts are always visiting Europe spending their inheritance, and so she grows up hearing about that.
Speaker 4Sure, okay, yeah, I mean for the parents anyway.
Speaker 2Sounds fun. Probably wants to bring your kids.
Speaker 3Sorry, kids, you had to stay mom and tenn are off for a.
Speaker 2Bit, Mammadet are off for it. But also in this period of time, mammadett are off for a bit for like eight months because yeah, yeahs you're going to be raised by some lady we hired by. See you when you're.
Speaker 3Nine, Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2Be back in a year, baby, Yeah, be back in a year. Maybe her fat died when she was relatively young, and this was he dies a sudden and surprising death, and this leaves her mother in charge of the family. But it says a lot about their overall financial state that even though her father dies pretty early on, this never affects them financially as far as we can see, right, they remain comfortable, which means they're very well off. So she's going to grow up with extremely conservative values and politics. But she's also going to grow up because her mom
Speaker 2is the only one running things. After a while, she's going to run up very grow very used to seeing a woman call the shots right, and this is going to have a conflicting effect on her, right because she both comes to believe that like traditional values are best and also she's used to women being in charge in her own.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, that's that kind of tough to square at that point in time.
Speaker 1I guess I was gonna say, yeah, I was gonna say, as are you Robert.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. My mom reminded, it's very reminiscent of this, where like she was a very conservative person and also did not understand why men should be doing anything like Those were two ideas that co existed within her. As Amy Dye wrote of Elizabeth in her graduate thesis for East Tennessee University for East Tennessee State University, quote, if her father had not died, she would not have been exposed to such a strong, independent woman as her mother. Before doctor Lafayette Kirkpatrick's death, he strongly believed the woman belonged in the home and away from both politics and business.
Speaker 2In contrast, her brother, Lafayette was encouraged to pursue a business career and at the age of twenty three, had acquired financial security through land development in Hawaii. He subsequently traveled around the world for three years with Baron von Zepplin and continued to lead a privileged life until his death in nineteen forty eight. Again, for any of the family, of the money she comes from, her brother is best friends and traveling buddies with Baron von Zepplin. It doesn't get much older money than that. Then Baron von Zepplin having her road trip with the Zeppelin guy. So yeah,
Speaker 2they're doing fine even with dad out of the picture. Little Elizabeth would be described during her childhood as quote highly emotional and an eager girl with a dramatically sculptured face, enormous brown eyes and a quick giddy laugh. Somewhat lonely, and casting about in search of a career, which is also interesting. She's a very she will always espouse very traditional values. She's always looking for a job for herself. She never is interested in just being a homemade and not you know, no problem with that, but she is never interested in just sitting at home and raising kids.
Speaker 2She wants to do something out in the world that people are aware of.
Speaker 4It's actually a very fascinating dynamic for somebody. I mean we're seeing it still to this day. Yes, your mother, I guess was this way. But this is this big push in the Conservative party for traditional values, and yet they're going to be advocating for their own careers. It seems counterintuitive but interesting for this woman.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, it's the Philish Loveley thing right of like I don't think women should be doing any of this stuff. Also, as a woman, I really like to have a big career.
Speaker 3And also like modern times, that's very Erica Kirk. Yeah, it's very Erica Kirk. That is exactly what I was thinking.
Speaker 1But yeah, I mean if either of you have seen any of like the interview clips from tpusa's like first big like women's event that Erica Kirk led, it's all when people are interviewed, it's all like this where they're like all over the map on if they're like, well women can have it all, but they have to do this, but women could have it all, but not those women. It's really interesting coverage just to like get an insight into that ideological thinking.
Speaker 2It's fascinating anytime you have to be you have that much cognitive dissonance in your belief system that always winds up being fascinating on some level.
Speaker 1And like in a way that I just there's no way there would be an Erica Kirk without a Liz Dilling, without a philistathe without it.
Speaker 3You know, it's all.
Speaker 2She had to crawl so that Erica Kirk could.
Speaker 4That's right.
Speaker 2I don't know. I don't know who's doing it whatever.
Speaker 1So Erica Kirk could come out with a fire boom, yeah behind her.
Speaker 2So Elizabeth attends grammar school in a secondary school. She's going to nice schools. Her parents pay money to get her quality education. She studies the concert harp at a Catholic academy, and she graduates from a girls school and is noted as having an almost photographic memory. Her early interests were and this is not a normal like, her education's weird because I can't graph it directly onto a normal one. Because she is both doing like normal primary school, secondary school and also Catholic Academy women's preparatory finishing school.
Speaker 2Like she spends years in schools that are just to like teach you how to behave as a woman. Like that's part of part of her schooling because she's like an upper class lady. Right. It takes a lot. You gotta know where all the forks go and stuff. I imagine there's more to it than forks, but forks seem like they're pretty key.
Speaker 3Stand up straight? How does smile?
Speaker 2Stand up straight? That's right? How to ride side saddle? There's I know there's a sadder. There's a ry you're supposed to write as a lady. That's the polite way, So there's the rude way. Maybe side saddle is the rude way. I don't know much about it, hort.
Speaker 4I really feel like side saddle should be reserved for men anatomically speaking, but I digress.
Speaker 2Look the horse girls can can correct us, because I don't know much about riding horses. I know there's a way you're supposed to write, and there's a way that you're not supposed to ride as an old timey woman, but I don't know. I don't know which is which. Anyway, she goes to all these different weird schools. She learns how to be a lady and a good Catholic. She's interested primarily in both classical music and the French language. I don't actually know if she ever gets what you'd call a normal college degree, but during her time in Catholic school, she was made to study the Bible. And
Speaker 2so this is kind of like knowledge and faith are always weirdly wrapped up with her, but also knowledge and like the performance of societal roles, are always directly locked together. She never just gets an education that's an education on its own. It's always an education, partly in how to exist in a certain social hierarchy. If that makes sense.
Speaker 3It does make sense.
Speaker 2As Amy Die writes in nineteen seventeen, as the first US forces are getting their it's dirty in World War One, Elizabeth meets a man described as a young army officer from Arizona who quote introduced her to a completely new way of thinking. This is her first fascist boyfriend. So she meets this mystery army officer who starts saying, oh, you got to read these books, right, and so he starts giving her cocked and Nietzsche and Hegel and next quote, after introducing Elizabeth to these forward thinkers, he contradicted himself by saying women did not count as human beings. Oh
Speaker 2so he's like, he's you need to read this Nietzsche. But you're a woman, so you can't read it. You're not a person. But here you should have some Hegel.
Speaker 3But here read it. But you're not really a person a woman, and you're too dumb. You're not gonna get it. But here, God is dead.
Speaker 2I get the She doesn't say this, but I get the feeling. He's like, intermittently flirting with her and yelling at her like it's one of those kind of weird guys, and she's totally under it.
Speaker 4If you had ever been flirted with by a fascist soldier from Arizona, you would know.
Speaker 2That the game, that's part of the day, that's that what works.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, she.
Speaker 2Gets that beautiful experience and you can tell it completely awakens her. Right. This is where she becomes an ideological thinker for the first time. And the fact that her ideological awakening comes courtesy of a man who does not consider her human is very telling and very bleak. But what else are you gonna say.
Speaker 4I'm not saying I have empathy because I have a feeling she's not gonna be someone I like.
Speaker 3How well, it's just a holy shit, it's pretty fucked up.
Speaker 2Yeah, you guys can check out. Just imagine like trying to tell your like your other lady friends, like, Yeah, this wonderful guy, he introduced me all these great books. I'm really thinking in new ways about like what makes a person a person. I don't think I'm one. According to him anyway, he's nice, He's.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2At any rate, this does not last. I really wish I knew what happened with this guy. Maybe he was just too much finincell, or maybe he goes out and it dies out in world We hope he guy and dies in World War One. Yeah, I'm hoping the old dub dub uno does a solid on that one. At any rate, not long after whatever happens with this guy in she continues reading philosophy, and she starts thinking really hard about the underlying order of society. And as she's thinking about this, Elizabeth meets her future husband, Albert Walwick Dilling. Now,
Speaker 2I don't think Albert Walwick Dilling is the kind of guy who's gonna tell her she's not a person. He's the kind I get the feeling. He's very ideologically malleable. I think he's naturally more conservative, so he's comfortable with her ideology. But I also think he goes along with her a lot, you know, okay, And I think he gets One of the things he gets from her is that he gets to pretend and feel like and she will reinforce that he is in charge while also being in charge of a lot, and so he doesn't have to be in charge of as much feeling.
Speaker 3It's exactly what you mean you've seen these kinds of relationships, right, one hundred percent.
Speaker 4She's like, I defer to my man, But she's the one that's telling him, Yeah, I.
Speaker 2Defer to my man. God help him. If he has an idea of.
Speaker 4His own, I defer my man as long as it's he goes with what.
Speaker 2I said exactly. So at the time he was a lawyer, he had trained as an engineer. Originally, he had been born in Salt Lake City back in eighteen ninety two. By the time he was ready for college, and I don't think he was Mormon. I think it probably would have mentioned that she certainly is not, and I don't think she would have been cool with a practicing Mormon given her beliefs, but I'm not really sure. By the time he's ready for college, he migrated to the Chicago area and he took the Illinois bar in nineteen seventeen. Now, Elizabeth Harardi refused one marriage proposal by the time she met Albert, but for some reason, this guy sweeps her
Speaker 2off her feet and after nine months the two are married and the romantic city of Laporte, Indiana. This would have been made of nineteen eighteen. Yes, yes, the city of love itself, the city of unbridled fucking. That's what we call Laporte Indiana. That's the city motto. Actually, Laporte Indiana. It's a lee to buy condoms here, you know, Just so you know, Laporte. Everybody catch the fever and something else, because again, condoms are illegal. Yeah. After this point, Elizabeth Kirkpatrick, though,
Speaker 2is now Elizabeth Dilling. And this is the name that she's going to be famous under. Right, everyone knows her as Elizabeth Dilling. That's how she becomes Elizabeth Dillon. She marries this Albert Dilling guy. She's twenty four years old in nineteen eighteen, and after a brief honeymoon, she and Albert moved to a suburb of Chicago, Wilmot, where they borrow money and buy a home. Albert claims that when they got married, he had quote nothing to offer but a good education, bright prospects, good help, and some sizeable debts, but Liz had family money of her own. In just two years, Albert was made chief engineer of the Chicago
Speaker 2Sanitary District, and his career would continue to rise over the coming years. While he was making a career for himself as a high level engineer for one of the largest cities on Earth. He would eventually become the city engineer for Union Station Development and the Engineer Assistant to the Commission for Public Works. Liz was inheriting the money that would ensure she never needed to utilize public works herself. Her husband helps make sure that like the city's public like transit works, and Elizabeth inherits enough money that she doesn't have to use it.
Speaker 1Yeah, so only imagine they're the like twenty twenty six dating profiles.
Speaker 2Oh my god, these two and twenty twenty six are definitely the weird natalist freaks who wind up on the news every six months talking about like there're eleven kids that they're having to change the world with Elon Musk.
Speaker 1Yeah, Liz Dilling definitely like puts her credit scare on her dating profile.
Speaker 2Yeah. I can see her having an interview with Vanity Fair where she slaps her child and a fucking diner. Yeah. So she receives enormous inheritances from two aunts and then in the mid nineteen thirties from her mother. So she's very comfortably off even though her husband is not making a lot of money immediately, but her husband, you know, is making comfortable middle class incomes. You have inherits a lot of money and a good income. They're doing quite well, and they're doing well enough that in short order before either of them is, you know, particularly old, they're going
Speaker 2to have enough money to do what wealthy people do in this period of time in particular, which is go on really long and elaborate vacations all the time. So from nineteen twenty three to nineteen thirty nine, the Dillings travel oversea ten times, and these are all multi week or multi month excursions. We're talking like orient Express type shit, where you're on trains and in fancy boats, you've got sleeper car like that. These are not like casual vacations. You can't just jaunt somewhere quickly, right.
Speaker 4Yeah, no, this is this is yeah, like her mother months long also famously a bad.
Speaker 3Time for the world financially to not have needs to just travel like this exactly.
Speaker 2I mean they're mostly traveling, although they are through all the thirties too, you know. So yeah, like a lot of it is during a really rough time.
Speaker 4Yeah, it's not the main takeaway here, but I yeah, they're doing certainly fine. It says a lot about well, what they're doing while the rest that the world was burning.
Speaker 2Yeah, well while the rest of the world was falling to fascis, And they're going on like long elaborate vacations, right, They're doing very they're very comfortable. Their first trip overseas, they get to tour England, the Low Countries, France, and then Italy, at which point they enter the Vatican City and have a private audience with the Pope. So they have like, oh money, Like that's how comfortable she is. Amy Die writes that the Dillings had booked this trip in part to get a first hand account of the aftermath of the First World War, right, Like that's a big that's at least what Elizabeth wants her friends to
Speaker 2believe that, Like, we're not just doing this as a vacation. We're doing this to get an eye on how Europe's handled, you know, after the war, right, Like that's the way that she frames this.
Speaker 4Making my eyes roll back and it is Okay, here's we're just gonna go study.
Speaker 2We're gonna go check it out. And I can tell you from experience, if you're in like an active war zone, there are often a lot of people who are eager to talk about what's happening to them right now, in part because they hope that like maybe international attention will like help their situation, and like it's happening right now, and they want people to know about the horrible stuff. When you go to a place that has just been at war, like a couple of years ago, they don't usually want to talk about it. They're kind of trying to forget it. So this just for a vacation people
Speaker 2like nineteen nineteen, people wandering around like don't want to want to talk to a bunch of America's big Yeah, what was the war like here in dun You know, was it fun? Did you enjoy it? Like people wod not have a good time and don't want her shit.
Speaker 4Completely devastated trying to recover from uh yeah no bad timing bit.
Speaker 2Yeah, how did you do you think it was? Liz bad? And this seems to be what the Dillings encountered. People are not super eager to talk to them, As Dye's account says, quote, Dilling became frustrated by the anti American attitudes that she had encountered amongst the British and the French. The former Allies often gave the United States no credit for helping win the First World War and often complained that the United States had not entered the war sooner. So, yeah, I think people didn't really want to talk about the war, and like folks who'd lost all their money and like their kids didn't want to talk about how great America
Speaker 2was for eventually getting involved, like some fucking British family who lost everything. This is gonna be like, yeah, thanks guys, really glad you got here in nineteen seventeen, right on the dot.
Speaker 4Hh yeah, yeah, it's not surprising, not surprising.
Speaker 2She takes this personally. She takes this as an insult to herself. On the steamship home, an English traveler sees a member of her party who's wearing like a sailor outfit with US Navy printed on it, and he just like starts shit talking like that. But it's like, ah, your Navy's a joke, you Americans, And Liz responds, I don't know if it's such a joke. It's been able to lick Great Britain twice and I think it could do it again. And first off, Liz, the last time it beat Gray Britan was nineteen twelve like or eighteen twelve like, Yeah, I don't know. I don't know if
Speaker 2we should be bragging about that in nineteen eighteen. Just seems a little ahead of the eight ball. It's not been it's been a while since we fought the British Navy. I don't know, Liz the And also, it's just like, what a ridiculous reaction to someone saying that he's clearly like frustrated that you're walking around talking about what hot shit your military is when you just kind of sltered in the last minute of like a devastating war. I get why the Europeans are pissed at her.
Speaker 3Absolutely. This woman has no self awareness.
Speaker 2No, and this situation, this whole encounter with his rude person on the boat, causes her to make a vow then and there that if another war ever came to Europe, she will work herself to the bone to keep the United States out of it because of these ungrateful Europeans. I'll make sure we never enter another war to support Europe again. You know, that's Liz's encounter here, or it'll take it. It's really sad.
Speaker 4I'm not surprising I mean, no, I'm always whenever I'm here. It's impossible to not draw parallels to modern day I've already done it several times.
Speaker 3But it's like, it's so pathetic.
Speaker 4How easily some people get offended and vowed to make that their idea of an entire place for the rest of their life.
Speaker 3Anyway.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, like I think they didn't even have anything to do with honestly, But anyway, you know what else is sad? Not listening to ads?
Speaker 3Heartbreak? What You're right, it is such a heartbreak. I love ads.
Speaker 2We're back and we're talking about how we never skip the ads on podcasts. Never. What does that mean? Sometimes I listen to extra ads, you know. Sometimes I listen to ads that aren't even for podcasts. Sometimes they just fall asleep directly in front of a billboard, you know, so I can worship it.
Speaker 3Do you have an ad playlist too for bedtime?
Speaker 2Yes, it's only an ad playlist for bedtime to be fair. All right, So let's get back to Liz Dilly. So, yeah, Liz's just had this experience heading home from Europe where these ungrateful Europeans were not deferent enough to the US Navy so she decides to stop the US from ever helping Europe in a war again. I don't know if I believe that actually happened, in part because Liz is going to be like anti war during World War Two because she's a fascist. And I think maybe she invinced
Speaker 2this story because it's like a more palatable truth as opposed to like, I don't want you used to get involved in World War two because I like the Nazis. She could be like, no, they're so ungrateful after all the rudeness they showed us last time, Why would we risk our lives again for them? You know. I kind of think maybe she just makes this up after the fact, but it's possible that this actually happens. Like, I don't know one way or the other. Despite their frustrations with Europeans, the Dillings continue to book regular trips abroad throughout the twenties and the thirties, and at first this seems to have been mainly for the sake of hedonism, but I
Speaker 2think Elizabeth's strong Catholic upbringing makes her feel guilty for just traveling to have fun. I think this is why for most of these there's always a second purpose like, oh, we wanted to explore how World War One affected them, or we want to she's going to explore communist countries and at a certain point in the future. And I think part of it is that she feels bad about just spending her money on vacations because she's she's fundamentally a Catholic in her soul. I mean, she's an Episcopalian as an adult, but she was raised Catholic, and you never get over that shit. I think there's an element of that of like, this trip has to be more
Speaker 2than just a trip, otherwise I'm not being a good person, right, hmm. Whatever the reason not being a good person, She's not being a good person anyway, but she's this is important to her, so she starts convincing her husband to let her book trips like their yearly vacations to the communist countries, which have just started to be a thing. Right. The communist revolution, you know, has just swept over what had been Imperial Russia, and it's starting to take other places too, So this is like the first time in which you could have gone to a communist country, right, kind of in the nineteen thirties, nineteen twenties, and thirties, And so
Speaker 2she starts convincing her husband to start booking trips for these different for like Soviet Russia, right, because she wants to study the impact of communism and eventually write books about it. So in the summer of nineteen thirty one, her husband helps the books trips to Moscow and Leningrad. Now, Elizabeth is later going to write a book about what she saw in the Soviet Union, and she will express her horror at the nightmare she saw there at the quote atheism, sex, degeneracy, broken homes, and class hatred that she witnessed in the post revolutionary USSR. And indeed, the
Speaker 2Soviet Union at the start of the thirties was a nation that had recently endured great horrors, a horrific civil war, and was currently enduring horrors the horrors of the Stalinis era. Right, it would very soon endure even worse horrors, the horrors of the Nazi invasion. So you know, it's a tough time Russia in the thirties. There are plenty of things that Dylan could have seen in Russia in nineteen thirty one that are horrific, right, plenty of things that would have actually reflected badly on the Soviet government. However, it's important I let you know that her hatred of the Soviet Union is not based on any of those things
Speaker 2when you think about the actual bad things that were occurring in the US. Sorry in nineteen thirty one, Elizabeth isn't allowed to see any of them. She's on a vacation that she's booked through the Soviet government. They have minders. She's not traveling freely, she's only visiting the areas they're allowed to visit. And so she's not being horrified because she's like snuck through and seen some evidence of a fuck up that the government was covering up of Starvey. She's angry because she's seeing like churches that have been turned into like art museums, and she's.
Speaker 3Like she's angry at the beautiful, losing.
Speaker 2Her mind, she's losing her mind at it right, and she's pissed about like, oh, the people here aren't as well fed as Americans and like where they under the czar? Is that the Soviet Union's fault or is that just the fact that like it's Russia in nineteen thirty one, Like, again, I'm not going to minimize the faults of the Stalinists there, of the Soviet particularly, But you can't just be like, wow, people aren't as big in Russia in nineteen thirty one, that's just communism, Nah, Liz, that goes back further. I'm sorry,
Speaker 2hun like that, Yeah.
Speaker 4Like the laziest possible takeaway from what she Yazumov saw, But okay, yeah, yes.
Speaker 2And again, the Soviet Union is very well aware that Western countries are spying on them constantly. They are looking for people like Liz Dilling in these trips. So again, I don't think there's any chance Liz would have seen any actual, like bad things, right, She's just making this up based on like shit she sees that's like uncomfortable to her. And the primary things that she sees over there that are uncomfortable to her is that she doesn't know. There aren't rich people in the Soviet Union that she sees, right. She notices none of the people of my class are here, right,
Speaker 2there's no fancy places to go, there's no high end hotels, right, and the society is openly atheistic, and that's what she is reacting to. Christine Eriksson summarizes Dilling how Dilling would later describe her trip. She noted with concern the idle crowds and abandoned children roaming the streets, bordered by run down buildings and desperate need of repair. She described in vivid detail the poor, miserable workers' stores where the proletariat was forced to shop. What little food stocked the shelves was overpriced and fly infested, the site of Christian churches
Speaker 2being converted into anti religious museums, and the shock of seeing nude bathers swim in a river under the shadow of one Moscow church, an event Dilan captured on film clearly signaled to her that communism bred atheism and encouraged immorality. So whatever bad things are actually happening in the Soviet Union, remember when Dyling talks about the horrors of communism, She's talking about nude bathers right near a church. That's what's scares her.
Speaker 4That's what scares her, not anything else.
Speaker 2That's stalin, you.
Speaker 3Know, offended by poverty and atheism. Yeah, abandoned children.
Speaker 2They're naked.
Speaker 3She was at London.
Speaker 2I'm sure there are abandoned children in Moscow in nineteen thirty one, because they've just had a civil war that kills millions of people, millions and millions of people, that was vastly exacerbated by Western involvement. By the way, you know, like you can't again, you can you can't look at any of the stuff she's seeing and just be like, well, this is all the fault of communism. That's just silliness, right, and so ironically, while Liz is going to spend the rest of her life talking about the nightmare world that she saw, the things she's scared about are like any
Speaker 2effort to reduce inequality, in any effort to reduce the power of the church. That's what actually upsets her. She would also complain later in her writing that Soviet men seem to have no interest in her at all. They didn't find her hot the bedbuts in the Grand Hotel in Moscow were wild about me, the listless waiters not at all, which Ericson suggests is Elizabeth trying to display quote an unsettling image of Communism's power to emasculate. How could any man ignore dylling these men are even straight if they don't like me. Like again, her big issues with Stalinist Russia are nude bathers. I'm not hot.
Speaker 3Just honestly, it just does not sound like the place for you to vacation.
Speaker 2You know, I don't think I think you picked the wrong place to vacation. I don't think we take a thirty one was for you.
Speaker 3Yeah, again, your timing is all off.
Speaker 2Your timing's really bad. If you've gotten to Moscow in nineteen seventeen, things might have been a lot more interesting Liz been, at least from my perspective. So her call to action came during a tour of the Moscow Museum of the Revolution, where a party guide told her tour group that the World Revolution, which had started in Russia, had now expanded to China and would end in the United States. He then showed them an exhibit that featured a fictional map of the future world where a communist US had renamed all of its cities. And you know this is obvious propaganda, right, Like, this isn't an evidence
Speaker 2of the actual capabilities, as we all know of the Soviet Union's ability to infiltrate the United States. But this works perfectly on Liz. She and this is everything she needed too in terms of like a useful thing she could carry home for her propaganda so when she gets home, she is eager to preach the bad word. Elizabeth claims that when she tried to tell her friends, her suburbanite intellectual friends and my own episcopal minister about what she'd seen over there, they expressed bitter opposition to her telling the truth about Russia. Now, I don't know how much
Speaker 2I believe that. I can't imagine people who are better informed in her saying, Hey, Liz, like, there's obvious issues going on over there and with that government, but it doesn't seem like you actually know anything about those issues. It seems like you're just angry that there are any like luxury stores and they don't believe in God, and maybe that's dumb. Like I wonder if maybe that's what her friends were saying. It is like, listen, doesn't seem like you actually know anything about the problems over there. It seems like you're angry the hotels weren't nice.
Speaker 3Yeah, are you an elitist snob? But maybe I mean happening here?
Speaker 1Do you suck?
Speaker 2Yoh? Okay, is it possible you just suck?
Speaker 3Is it possible that you're kind of an asshole?
Speaker 2Wow?
Speaker 4I am imagining her friends always being relieved when she goes on one of the big journeys and then they're.
Speaker 2Like, oh my god, she's out for a couple months.
Speaker 3She's gonna bring out the photo albums.
Speaker 2Don't want to tell us about it. I don't know, Just pretend you're horrified or whatever. Like I do wonder how much of this is them having an issue just because they know she's felic. Shit, And I suspect even more. It's just like, oh shit, I don't want to see Liz's vacation pictures. You want to see that people swimming in Moscow. I don't really care, Like, who wants to watch this shit exact?
Speaker 1I went swimming, but then they didn't have Cavia for me afterwards.
Speaker 3It was a hard hell.
Speaker 2Hell, and Liz sees the fact that her friends do not find these stories entertaining evidence of their own suicidal, blinkered blindness, the kind that would lead her class to march to its own extermination if it wasn't careful. So she became a woman on a mission to ensure her fellow citizens understood the extent of the communist menace, and particularly the infiltration of leftist agents at every level of American society and government. In one of her early pieces, Elizabeth expressed her belief that good Christian women did not have the right to sit at home and avoid conflict
Speaker 2as a fire burns in the nation's basement and radical political subversives filled the platforms with their dirt and anti American ideas. So she's very pissed at her fellow rich friends for not, you know, doing more to stop this, to stop the spread of communism.
Speaker 4She sounds like a joy to have it in dinner PRIs.
Speaker 2It sounds like so much fun just to whot yeah again. You could if she'd had Twitter, she would be nonstitute of law, left all of her friends and family behind to tweet NonStop, like you know this person today. We've seen her.
Speaker 3One thousand we know several of them.
Speaker 2So initially Elizabeth wrote letters to newspapers and spoke up in local meetings, but she found little purchase for her ideas until she befriended Iris McCord. Iris is a teacher at the Moody Bible Institute in Chicago now MBI as it is also known as a private evangelical college that had been founded by a wealthy businessman turned evangelist named Dwight Moody in eighteen eighty six. Moody seems to actually mostly been an okay guy. He was sided with the Union during the Civil War, which you know, so he gets some ups there. His whole big thing was that
Speaker 2in the wake of the Civil War he decided that like evangelical Christianity needed to train what he called gap men, right, these were men who would stand between the laity and the ministers. So people who aren't like just normal civilians, but they aren't like professional men of faith either, who are trained to do like city mission work, who can like go and reach people in the cities and stuff. So that's Moody's idea, And that's where the Bible College comes from, right, And it's important you know, MBI starts as a college before Christianity is political in the United States.
Speaker 2That's not entirely accurate. There are left and right wing politicians who use Christianity, but no one would say Christianity is definitely more a left wing or a right wing thing. Okay, this area, you couldn't clearly say that.
Speaker 4Yet.
Speaker 2The religious right is not a thing in this point in time, right, Really.
Speaker 3That's a more modern thing, right.
Speaker 2But there aren't religious conservatives and religious hardliners right who are conservative, and Iris is one of them, and so is Elizabeth Dilling. And the fact that Iris taught there and loved Dilling's reactionary rants says something about where many of Moody's staff sat politically even in those days. So Iris used her connections to get Elizabeth invited to speak at numerous local churches about the communist threat to the American way of life. And this helps put Elizabeth's ideas in front of a bunch of different women, some of them are pretty influential who have like spots in the DAR you know, and these other groups, you know, the
Speaker 2Daughters of the American Revolution and the like. And so she for the next couple of years, she starts making an okay sight living, scaring her rich friends right, and she becomes she really is. She's actually really good. It's public speaking. She's got the gift of like entertaining and capturing an audience. She is an electrifying speaker in person. She's able to get a lot of these people to be just as scared and crazy about communism as she is, and her success earns her enough attention that she begins getting invitations all across the United States, not just from
Speaker 2churches but from civic organizations. Now, and the DAR starts inviting her to speak at a bunch of its local chapters. The American Legion starts inviting her to speak at different local events. And she's soon making enough money doing this to support her efforts and ensure she doesn't have to mooch off of her husband or her inheritance to have a career, a thing she didn't believe good women ought to have.
Speaker 4Anyway, must be really hard for her to square those things.
Speaker 3It's got to be filled with guilt.
Speaker 2Okay, to just to go from dilettant to a professional like media rabble rouser in a year or so, Yeah, a shameful must be hard for her. So yeah, they with which Elizabeth had gone from penning her little essays to addressing crowds around the country clearly went to her head. So she decided to write a book, The Red Revolution Do We Want It? Here? In this book, she railed against parlor pinks who were broad minded but didn't judge people based on their political tendency. These weak people, she argued,
Speaker 2let communist agents infiltrate society and corrupt children with their ideals. Right, it's these broad minded parlor pinks who aren't like hostile enough to socialism. That's how they sneak in. That's how they get your society.
Speaker 3Okay, okay, yeah.
Speaker 2And you know who's going to destroy our society?
Speaker 3I Donald Trump?
Speaker 2Maybe maybe, but perhaps it'll be the products and services that support this podcast. We can all hope, we can all hope. You know that's my dream.
Speaker 3Fingers crossed.
Speaker 2So we're back. The Daughters of the America Revolution in particular, loved her work. And if you're not an American or you just don't know, the dair is like one of the oldest groups of like rich ladies in America, rich white ladies.
Speaker 4Okay, if you've you're not an American, you just have to watch Gilmore Girls. That's exactly what I was. Gilmore Girls every time huge plum oils. Emily Gilmore is a daughter of the American Revolution.
Speaker 2It means your relatives date back as far as they can in the history of the United States while not being like indigenous obviously.
Speaker 1Remember they're that fantastic episode of Gilmore Girls, Katie Well, it's Rory's twenty first birthday, and she's become friends with all of her grandmother's friends from the DAR, and uh Luke goes up to them and they keep saying, oh, we know Rory from the DR, and he goes, what's the DAR and they all laugh in his face.
Speaker 1And for the listeners that also get that, you're really enjoying the story. If you're Robert and have no idea what you're talking what I'm talking about, you seem very baffled and confused.
Speaker 2I didn't watch The Gilmore Girls, but I you should also. Yeah, I don't think I will, but I will talk more about the DR. Robert.
Speaker 3You will love it. It was written for you, Okay.
Speaker 2I don't think that's accurate. So the DAR in particular loved Elizabeth's work, and they purchased ten thousand copies of The Red Revolution Do we Want It here? And distribute it to their local chapters. Elizabeth became a major name in the world of reactionary agitation, and she became increasingly well known among blue bloods like the Ladies of the DAAR. This was a scene she considered herself basically part of because this is these are the ladies she wants to be friends with. She really wants to be a DAR lady. But her family, again, they're pretty recent impocrants. I think
Speaker 2on both sides, it's death. It's death to her. She hates it.
Speaker 3She'll never be a joy, She'll never be that good.
Speaker 2They don't. They'll never gonna like you. Your family hasn't been here that long. And there's snooty assholes who don't have souls like they're dead already, but so are.
Speaker 4I'm gonna guess that that doesn't radicalize her to have empathy with people that have less than her.
Speaker 2She just desperately wants these rich ladies who are even richer than her to like her, right because she doesn't have any famous enough ancestors. For a time, getting asked to speak at DAR events and having them reprint her works seem like it was at least her getting her foot in the door. But Liz is always going to be an outsider to this crowd. However, she's now an outsider who's making a full time living trying to scare people about communists. She started telling anyone who would listen that her cause kept her working until midnight seven days a week. She's always talking about how hard she works,
Speaker 2so she's never she's a little bit Alex Jones there where she's constantly lying about it. I'm up to my neck and stacks of papers, documents that prove this extent of the communist menace. I never rest right. And although with her and might she might be telling the truth, because I do think she's like a compulsive workaholic.
Speaker 3Or at least obsessed with this, like looking for the right word, just feeling like she has to do this. Yeah, she has.
Speaker 2She's completely empty as a person. There's nothing else to her besides this. She's given up. She does that.
Speaker 4She also was bored when she became yes, and you know, caught up in this like she was.
Speaker 2She found this and this is the only thing that's ever made her feel full. Yeah yeah, yeah, it's healthy. So uh. She starts preparing for an even more influential book that she wants to publish, and I'm going to quote from Amy dies thesis again here. Dylan began collecting over one hundred file cards. Each note card contained the name of a person with pro communist affiliations. These file cards sparked her to purchase a large library of books about politics, history, law, philosophy, Jews, communism, organized labor, economics, revolution, and foreign policy. Hey it, Liz, I get why you're
Speaker 2interested in books of history and law and about like organized labor, and why are Jews live? Why are they in there? It? Li, we know?
Speaker 3Can you explain that a little bit more?
Speaker 2We know what Jews are in there? I think we do? We do?
Speaker 3We know why? Oh yeah, yeah, hmm okay.
Speaker 4I googled her and I saw an image that I won't reference right now because I will you where this is going.
Speaker 2Yeah, oh fun, I'm interested in what that image is. So Liz also did a lot of gumshoe work infiltrating local communist organizations in Chicago by convincing them she wanted to join and asking for exclusive inside information. Now, in reality, she was just getting essays and notices about upcoming meetings, but she always treated this as if she was receiving a highly dangerous military intel, because that makes her sound cooler. Her inspiration and a lot of this work was a guy named Harry Young, who was the director of the American Vigilant Federation. Now there's not a lot that remains
Speaker 2about Harry, but I found an entry for him on Fascippedia, which describes the Vigilant Intelligence Federation as quote an attempt to track radicalism among labor union members. After three days decades of monitoring radicals and their organizations America, it has been said his files exceeded a million names. Ciang is keeping track of anyone who's in the labor movement right He's keeping a death list ready, just in case anyone wants to go kill these people. Young is also one of the first Americans to distribute the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion in the United States, and it's
Speaker 2said that he received his copy from three white Russians fleeing their failed counter revolutions. So he is one of the first people to spread anti Semitic propaganda in an organized way in the United States. That's her direct inspiration. Perfect Yeah. Young is the guy who turns the Protocols into a movie for the first time, which helps to create a groundbreaking work of anti Semitic propaganda that's referenced by Nazis to this day. Elizabeth knew this about him when they met. In fact, it's why she was excited to work with Young. As Amy Die writes, Young agreed to help Dilling by letting her look at any of
Speaker 2his files that she deemed important to fight the communistic threat. Later, both Young's films and research came into the hands of the federal government. The Department of Justice deemed Young's work is Unamerican as it feature several racial prejudices that offend most American citizens. So that's her like model, that's the guy that she loves.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, okay, good work, Liz.
Speaker 2Good judgment, Liz, Yeah, you have great judgment in people. We can certainly say that about you. In the early nineteen thirties, Stilling also helped to found an organization, the Paul Revers, which she claimed was a patriotic organization to uphold Americanism in opposition to all other isms such as socialism and communism. Interesting, fascism isn't spelled out there. She lists severalisms, not fascists not Yeah.
Speaker 3She conveniently forgot that ism.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm sure if you pressed her, she said, oh, yeah, that too, of course, but she didn't want to bring it up unless you did. Now, the only restriction the Paul Revere's had for new members, you want to guess the only kind of person who couldn't join her organization, the Paul revers of Patriotic Americans. What kind of person would she exclude? Do you think Jews or black? It's Jews. It's Jews. No, it's actually not like black people weren't allowed. Actually, but that's welcomed. But they weren't explicitly banned the way Jewish people were. Although we have to assume they weren't welcome, right.
Speaker 3I do want to. I absolutely assume that.
Speaker 2Yeah, but I can also see them only stating outright that Jews are not allowed, in part because they maybe just wouldn't have assumed any black people would ever try to join. They may have just been like, really like you might have been joined, Paul as a black person. Is sort of a like like an air bud situation, where was like, well, no one put this in the rules, like we clearly not.
Speaker 3Even they might not even considered that.
Speaker 2They did not conceive of this as a possibility.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah, two.
Speaker 2Racists to have a race based entry requirement. Yeah. So in nineteen thirty four, Liz published what would have become her most influential book, The Red Network, Who's Who and Handbook of Radicalism for Patriots. This beautiful book which you'll be see on your screen now. It's gorgeous red cover embossed, you know, nice, very very basic font but effective, the Red Network of Who's Who and Handbook of Radicalism for Patriots. This collected all of Elizabeth's research, all of these note cards about these individual people that she's declared communists. This
Speaker 2is like almost part of it's like a almost like a like a phone book of leftist radicals. Again, it's kind of a kill list, right.
Speaker 3Like McCarthyism pre McCarthyism.
Speaker 2You've you've anticipated one of this books that yes, tailor Joe loves this fucking book. This will make it into the McCarthy hearings as it happens.
Speaker 3Yeah, oh wow.
Speaker 2Stuff. So we'll be hearing a lot more from this book and hearing a lot more from it about Liz. But that's all for part one, Katie. You got any pluggables to plug at the end here?
Speaker 3Yeah, oh sure, I got pluggables to plug.
Speaker 4You can find me over at some more News with Codyen. We got some more news. We've got even more news, both in the same channel.
Speaker 3We've got a Patreon excellent.
Speaker 2All right, everybody check their Patreon out, check their channel out, yeah, and check us out in like a day or so when we return with the rest of the story about Elizabeth Dylly.
Speaker 3I'll be in this spot for the next two days, right.
Speaker 2Perfect beauty, impatiently glorious.
Speaker 1Behind the Bastards is a production of cool Zone Media. For more from cool Zone Media, visit our website cool Zonemedia dot com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Full video episodes that Behind the Bastards are now streaming on Netflix, dropping every Tuesday and Thursday. Remind me on Netflix you don't miss an episode. For clips in our older episode catalog, continue to subscribe to our YouTube channel YouTube dot com slash at behind the Bastards. We love about forty percent of you, statistically speaking,
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: The Myth of Red Texas with David Griscom Biden and the War on Gaza Organizing Agricultural Workers Repression in Iran Executive...
All of this week's episodes of It Could Happen Here put together in one large file: Puerto Rico’s Water Crisis Isn’t Really Over Do Not Become Addicted to Water: Asheville After Helene Press Freedom and the Paramount...
Don Simpson rises to the top of Hollywood by co-opting gay culture and doing every drug imaginable. But then things take a turn on the set of a doomed Tom Cruise movie.