Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

US midterm results, AAP loses three MLAs, and 12 broken streetlights

Nov 9, 202629 minAudio

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the Democrats winning control of both chambers of the US Congress, what this means for Donald Trump’s presidency, and the potential impact on India-US ties, tariffs and immigration. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Raakhi Jagga about three AAP legislators joining the BJP, the different circumstances behind their departures and what the defections reveal about political tensions in Punjab ahead of the 2027 Assembly elections. (12:30) And in the end, we look at the suspension of a municipal official in Gujarat after 12 streetlights along a route used by Prime Minister Narendra Modi were found to be non-functional. (26:10) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at Punjab, where three ARP legislators have joined the BJP just months before the 2027 Assembly elections, exposing fresh tensions within the ruling party. We also talk about Gujarat, where a municipal official was suspended after 12 streetlights on a route used by Prime Minister Narendra Modi were found to be non-functional. But we begin today with the impact that the results of the US midterms will have on India. Hi, I'm Ichha Sharma and

Speaker 1you're listening to Three Things, the Indian Express News Show. Last week, the United States held its midterm election and the results dealt a major blow to President Donald Trump. The Democratic Party won back control of both chambers of Congress, the Senate and the House of Representatives, shifting the balance of power in Washington. Here's House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries addressing the media shortly after the results were announced.

Speaker 2The American people have chosen the economy over extremism. The American people have chosen hope over hatred. The American people have chosen common sense over corruption, chaos and cruelty. The American people have chosen House Democrats because they want to see a dramatic change in direction. And that's exactly what

Speaker 2House Democrats will deliver beginning on day one.

Speaker 1Now the result has implications that go well beyond American domestic politics. With the opposition now controlling Congress, Trump could face greater resistance to his legislative and policy agenda. And this also has implications for India, which has been navigating considerable uncertainty over US tariffs, trade negotiations, immigration restrictions, and the war in West Asia. So what do these results mean for Trump and the future of American politics?

Speaker 3And how could they shape India's relationship? with the United States.

Speaker 1To understand this, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to the Indian Express's Diplomatic Affairs Editor, Shubhjeet Roy.

Speaker 4Shubhjeet, could you first explain what the Democrats' winning control of both the Senate and the House of Representatives means for the US political system and.

Speaker 5How should we understand this in the Indian context?

Speaker 6So it's a sort of Democrats have won essentially the House of Representatives, which is the lower house and the Senate, which is the upper house. So it is something like if the opposition party in India, India is not a presidential form of government. So we cannot compare the two systems. But Just for the argument's sake, if, for example, if we had a prime minister who was a presidential form of government, who was a president and who was elected

Speaker 6by the people, but if both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha were dominated by the opposition party, then that kind of a situation is what has happened in the midterm elections which took place in the United States, where Democrats have now won both the House of Representatives, which is equivalent to Lok Sabha and the Senate, which is equivalent to the Rajya Sabha. So whereas the president,

Speaker 6which is here in this case, is President Donald Trump, he is a Republican president and he's still in office. So Donald Trump still has two more years as a president to go till 2029. But the two houses of the parliament are no more dominated by his own party. So that is the significance of the verdict. And which means essentially that for any law to be passed, now

Speaker 6Democrats will have the say and they will have the upper hand and the president will have to implement it sign it or have to has.

Speaker 7To veto it. So he'll have a veto power. So which he can exercise.

Speaker 6But in a sense, so after almost one and a half years, almost two years of being in office, when he had the support of the Congress, both houses of the parliament, US parliament, He will no more have that freedom and there will be checks and balance on his powers to pass a law or.

Speaker 7Sign a law and get things done.

Speaker 4And the US president also has executive powers, right?

Speaker 5So how will that work out?

Speaker 6The United States presidents also have what is called executive powers, which he has exercised in the last 19 months or so, 19, 20 months or so, quite extensively in, for example, issuing.

Speaker 7Tariffs or launching a war on Iran.

Speaker 6So he has used those powers to do these things. But now those powers will be sort of questioned and those moves will be questioned and those impulses will be kept in check, provided the Democrats sort of stay united and they are able to form a sort of a united front against the president. So this also would mean that the president will have to negotiate with the Democrats, with the opposition to get anything passed that he wants

Speaker 6to or to get anything done that he wants to in the next two years.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4And Shubhjeet, how do we see this result impacting the U.S. policies, especially towards other countries?

Speaker 7Well, you know, so the.

Speaker 6U.S., has in the last, especially the two years or so since Donald Trump won the elections in 2024, it has created uncertainty because of this unpredictable nature of President Trump and his administration and his policies. So there is a sense that this particular verdict will bring back some sort of predictability in the global order, in the way US functions.

Speaker 7For example, the US president, he used his.

Speaker 6Executive powers, which are his special powers used under wartime, which has now been challenged by the Supreme Court and has set aside. But he used those powers to predict impose tariffs on different countries.

Speaker 7So now with a.

Speaker 6Sort of opposition controlled United States Congress, the president won't be able to do what he has been able to do, that is impose tariffs at his women fancy.

Speaker 7And there would be a pushback.

Speaker 6Similarly, you know, its policies say towards immigration, how it deals with them. Also, its policy is the current war, the war in Iran, which has been on and off, on and off. in the last seven, eight months, how it plays out, what decision does he take. So those policies will also be impacted and they will also be sort of be seen by how the Trump administration now carries forward those policies. Apart from that, its outlook towards China, Russia,

Speaker 6especially in the context of with Russia, especially in the context of the war in Ukraine, those moves and policy stances would also be to be seen how they play out in the next couple of years.

Speaker 4And now coming to India and its relationship with the US, like if we talk about the tariffs levied by the US president, like you mentioned, how do we see that changing?

Speaker 6With regards to India, you know, as I said, the issue of tariffs is something that has bothered India a lot because of the off and on policies that have played out in the last two years, especially in the last year and a half. And so now with the trade deal being negotiated between India and US, the midterm outcome is expected to have an impact as Washington will be sort of seen to be in a weaker position because,

Speaker 6you know, it will have a hostile, the Trump administration will have a hostile US Congress. I mean, the Indian government will obviously now watch this new playing field and negotiate differently here on.

Speaker 4So can we expect changes as far as immigration and H-1B visas are concerned? Because these are two issues that have really impacted Indians in the recent past.

Speaker 6Well, you know, the last two years have seen a rise in anti-immigrant racism and restrictions, especially in H-1B visas or the student visas, OPT, which is optional practical training. So the pushback against anti-immigrant crackdown, you know, which is being led by the Trump administration and the pushback is being.

Speaker 7Led by the Democrats.

Speaker 6Now, this will sort of serve as a reminder to the U.S. administration that the immigrant communities have tremendous veto.

Speaker 7Power and so do the big business.

Speaker 6So these are the areas which will be of interest for India and the world. And this will also be a live issue as several African-Americans and Indian-Americans have got elected in the U.S.

Speaker 7Congress and from the states.

Speaker 6And as well as those from say Arab Americans or the Hispanic community. So the immigrant origin senators and U.S. congressmen will obviously be much more sympathetic towards the more favorable immigration policies. So that is another issue that India will keep a watch on. How does the Trump administration follow through hereafter after these midterm results?

Speaker 4And Shubhjeet, now that the Democrats control both chambers of Congress, what are the key issues India needs to watch out for and are there any particular concerns for New Delhi?

Speaker 6Well, you know, there are issues like how does the Trump administration look at China, which India has sort of seen in the last two years, how it has engaged with China.

Speaker 7And there's a rapprochement, there is.

Speaker 6Talk of G2 by President Trump himself.

Speaker 7So that is of concern for India.

Speaker 6The other issue is about the Trump administration's proximity and closeness to Pakistan and its generals.

Speaker 7How does that play out?

Speaker 6Because Trump family has sort of our business interests have cut these crypto deals and critical mineral deals with the Pakistan entities and Pakistani firms. Now, those deals would also be under question. So we'll have to see how these two elements play out. And in terms of the war in Ukraine, how does Trump sort of engage with Europe and Russia will be something to watch out for in

Speaker 6the coming days. India also sort of will be under scrutiny from the Democrat lawmakers in the US on India's human rights record, be it the handling of its protests or these SIR, which is going on, the voter registration that's going on. And We have seen those issues be raised by the Democrat congressmen and congresswomen, including Pramila Jayapal, who raised this issue to which the Indian government responded

Speaker 6as well, including the Indian ambassador to the U.S.

Speaker 7And so we'll have to see how that also.

Speaker 6Plays out in the next two years with a stronger democratic majority in both houses of the U.S.

Speaker 7Congress.

Speaker 1And next, we talk about Punjab, where three legislators from the ruling Aam Aadmi Party have joined the BJP, exposing divisions within the party just months before the state goes to assembly elections. Last week, Harmeet Singh Pathan Majra from Sannor, Chetan Singh Jodha Majra from Samna, and Kuver Vijay Pratap Singh from Amritsar North formally joined the BJP in New Delhi after breaking away from AAP. the development comes at a politically sensitive time for the Bhagwant Maan government as

Speaker 1parties begin preparing for the 2027 assembly elections. But while all three leaders have ended up in the BJP, the circumstances behind their departures are quite different.

Speaker 3Take Harmeet Singh Pathan Majra, for instance. He's actually related to Chief Minister Bhagwant Maan's wife.

Speaker 8And he is MLA from that Sanor constituency of Patiala district.

Speaker 1That's The Indian Express's Rakhi Jagga, who covers the state for the newspaper.

Speaker 8And he became the MLA in March 2022. And in August 2022, he was in a controversy regarding bigamy. And a woman had alleged that on the pretext of marrying her, he had a live-in relationship with her for the past many years. And an obscene video of his had also, I mean, that had also gone viral or that woman had made that video viral.

Speaker 5But despite that, there was.

Speaker 8No action taken against him by the Aam Aadmi Party. And the leadership at that time, they had said that it's his personal life and we should not mix the personal life with the political life. But it was in 2025, August, that all of a sudden he started speaking against the government on various issues like mining. And he was saying that my area is not being looked after. And despite I am giving so many suggestions, they are not being taken care of. And maybe he had started apprehending that

Speaker 8they are going to register a case against me.

Speaker 5So on September 1, 2025, you can.

Speaker 8Say that three years after that lady's complaint, they lodged a rape case against him. And on September 2025, another FIR was lodged against him in illegal mining case. And Pathan Majra had disappeared from his house and then, I mean, he.

Speaker 5Fled to Australia.

Speaker 8When we had asked him when he came back, he said, I had gone there via Burma. And police arrested him in March this year, 2026. Police arrested him from Gwalior and then he remained in jail. And gradually he was given bail in both the cases. He got a regular bail in that rape case and he got a bail in that mining case as well. On 31 May, he came out of jail in both the cases. Now he's out on bail in both the cases and he's actively pursuing his political life.

Speaker 5So after all.

Speaker 8This controversy, he was sure that he's not going to get a ticket from the party. So eventually he joined BJP.

Speaker 1So that's the story of Harmeet Singh Pathan Majra. The other person who has joined the BJP is Chetan Singh Jodha Majra, a former cabinet minister who was once among the prominent faces of the AAP government.

Speaker 8So he was given the cabinet portfolio in July 2022.

Speaker 5He was made the health minister.

Speaker 8But days after he became the minister, he landed in a controversy. He made the vice-chancellor of Baba Farid Health University. This is the only health university of Punjab. He made that vice-chancellor, Dr. Raj Bahadur, lie on a dirty mattress. When he went to that Faridkot government hospital, I mean, he went to the hospital to inspect that hospital and he found anomalies. And then he told the vice-chancellor, can you lie on this mattress?

Speaker 5And if not, then how can patients sleep on it?

Speaker 8After that, that vice-chancellor, he felt humiliated and he resigned. And in July 2023, after six months, he was divested of this portfolio. Rather, he was given much powerful portfolios after that, water resources, mining, public relations, horticulture, and few more departments as well. So he continued enjoying this cabinet portfolio till September 2024. And then there was a rejig in the cabinet and then he was dropped from the

Speaker 8Council of Ministers. But in May this year, May 2026, the real twist happened in this year only. When Chetan Singh Jodha Majra, when he became MLA, he had defeated Akali Dal candidate Surjeet Singh Rakhta. He's a senior Akali Dal candidate and he remained minister also in Akali BJP government.

Speaker 5So in May this year, Surjit Singh Rakha, whom.

Speaker 8He had defeated in 2022, he joined Aam Aadmi Party because Rakha.

Speaker 5Rakhda is also from Samana.

Speaker 8So he came as a competitor for Chetan Singh Jodha Majra. And after that, all the focus was on Surjit Singh Rakhda only. And Chetan Singh Jodha Majra was given a cold treatment by the Aam Aadmi Party after that. And Chetan Singh Jodha Majra had openly been praising the central government schemes on camera and on his Facebook pages after that. So he was giving enough indication that.

Speaker 5He's going to join.

Speaker 8BJP because he was praising the Prime Minister, Avaas Yojna and other schemes on camera.

Speaker 1Now the third leader, Kuver Vijay Pratap Singh, a former IPS officer, represents a different kind of dissent.

Speaker 8So, I mean, this officer is known for speaking his mind, irrespective of the fact which government he's part of. So he took voluntary retirement in April 2021. He was part of a special investigation team, which was investigating that Kotkapura case. firing case and Bargadi sacrilege case. I mean, that's an important case in Punjab where the sacrilege of Guru Granth Sahib had happened in 2015. So he was the member of special investigation team investigating those cases. But in April 2021,

Speaker 8the High Court had quashed that report of the SIT and rather the government was told to form another SIT without Kumar Vijay Pratap. And in June 2021, he joined Aam Aadmi Party and in the presence of Arvind Kejriwal. So at that time, Arvind Kejriwal, he promised that once the Aam Aadmi Party comes to power, they will give justice in Bargadi sacrilege case, Kotkapura firing cases, Bahebal Kala firing cases, all connected to that sacrilege case. And Kovar

Speaker 8Vijay Pratap, he was an officer investigating those cases and now he's part of the party. So he will be a key player in helping us out to get the culprits punished. So he was a poster boy of Aam Aadmi Party because this was a major promise given by the Aam Aadmi Party before contesting 2022 polls.

Speaker 5So Aam Aadmi Party.

Speaker 8They came to power and Govind Vijay Pratap, he won from Amritsar North. constituency but after that this sacrilege investigation cases they went at snail's pace and kubar vijay pratap claims that he was hardly consulted on any of the cases and few months he kept quiet and after that he started speaking his mind and he started saying he found that government was wrong or so And mid of the 2025, maybe I think July 2025, he was suspended

Speaker 8by Aam Aadmi Party for five years for anti-party activities.

Speaker 1And so Rakhi, from the BJP's perspective, what is the significance of inducting these three leaders? Like, is the party kind of looking to strengthen its organisation in these particular constituencies?

Speaker 8Yeah, of course, because as I mean, we all know that BJP was earlier in alliance with the Kalidhal and they used to contest only on 23 seats and the rest 94 seats Kalidhal used to contest. So in 2020, Kalidhal parted ways. So before that, BJP had no organizational structure in the 94 constituencies or they had a very weak organizational structure in the rest of the 94 constituencies because they were mainly focused only on the 23 constituencies

Speaker 8which were largely in Amritsar, Pathankot, Gurdaspur, a few of the constituencies in Jalandhar and around area and one each constituency in Fazilkar and Ferozpur.

Speaker 5So they had no base in these districts.

Speaker 8So although they now over the years they have started building up so but the I mean, now these sitting MLAs, if they are joining them, so it's a boost for them. So they'll get the candidates for their constituencies who are known faces and who have a support base.

Speaker 5So, I mean, it's kind of a boost for them.

Speaker 8And if we see Chetan Singh Jara Majra, so he was given a cold treatment. Otherwise, he's not in much of any controversy. And Kovar Vijay Pratap, again, he was not in any controversy.

Speaker 5He was simply.

Speaker 8speaking against the Aam Aadmi Party for all the things which he felt that they promised and they did not fulfil.

Speaker 1Right, and like you mentioned earlier that the AAP has dismissed these departures, saying that it had already distanced itself from.

Speaker 3The three leaders. So how do we read this? The AAP saying these departures do not matter.

Speaker 5Yeah, they are now saying that they are the leftovers.

Speaker 8I mean, soon after they joined, their party general secretary Baltej Pannu, he said that they are the leftovers and BJP is having nothing of their own and they are just taking leftovers of the other parties.

Speaker 5So because they are.

Speaker 8They have already made an alternative arrangement in all these constituencies because once Surjeet Singh Rakhda joined in Samana, he is a known face, two-time MLA from Samana and he remained a minister as well in Akali BJP government. So he is a known politician. He has contested many assembly elections. So they have a backup candidate in that area. And in Sanaur area, they had already appointed a constituency in charge, Ranjot Singh Hadana. So he's already campaigning there. When Pathan Majra,

Speaker 8I mean, he ran in September 2025. Soon after, I mean, they launched an FIR against him. Soon after, they had appointed Hadana as the constituency in charge. So they have a backup plan in Sanaur as well. And similarly, they have a backup plan in... Amritsar North as well. So that's why they are saying that they are not bothered. And Gover Vijay Pratap was also already unhappy with the party. And they had already there were many few leaders, local leaders active in that area. So the party have backup plans,

Speaker 8the backup candidates with them in those constituencies.

Speaker 5So that's why they are saying that, I mean, it hardly matters.

Speaker 1And Rakhi, we know that these politicians joined another party while they were elected on ARP tickets.

Speaker 3So, what happens to their assembly membership?

Speaker 8No, but now that once the tenure of the government is less than six months, so anti-defection law is no longer applicable on them.

Speaker 5So, I mean, there is no need.

Speaker 8For a re-poll because the next elections are going to happen in February. So if they have resigned and their resignation has accepted, so they'll continue to stay as MLAs, but not of the Aam Aadmi Party. or at the most they will be no longer MLAs and if they will no longer be MLAs so I mean for three months time period because in January so there will I mean code of conduct is likely to be implemented maybe in the last week of December or maybe in the first week of January so it's hardly two months left

Speaker 8now and so I mean it hardly matters now and that's why I mean they strategically choose this time because there's no point for a And Rakhi, as Punjab approaches the 2027 assembly elections, what do these three defections tell us about the political tensions? Like, are parties seeing more disagreements over ticket distribution? No, as of now, Amadmi Party,

Speaker 8they had hurriedly taken out the first list of the 40 candidates. Now, it apparently, it appears that, I mean, that was a hurried attempt because they may be aware that a number of our candidates are going to join.

Speaker 5The BJP because.

Speaker 8The BJP president, he said that had they not released that list, a number of them would have left the party. And of course, it causes a major setback to the ruling party, a party which has 94.

Speaker 5MLAs in majority. And in that party.

Speaker 8If defections are happening, so it's a cause of concern. And if we see the list of the 40 candidates... Punjab CM Bhagwant Maan has also been listed in that list. I mean, if there is a requirement to, I mean, name him in the first list, that also itself explains that how difficult it is for the ruling party to regain the ground because he's the tallest leader of the party and if he listed as a candidate, so maybe, I mean, the other candidates will stick on or hold

Speaker 8on to the party or so.

Speaker 5This is what the political analysts, they see.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about an unusual disciplinary action in Gujarat, where a municipal official was suspended after 12 streetlights along a route used by Prime Minister Narendra Modi were found to be non-functional. Mahesh Vasava, the clerk in charge of the lighting department at the Boid municipality in Vatodara district, was suspended for six days for alleged negligence in.

Speaker 3Maintaining the streetlights. Now, the timing is what makes the case particularly striking.

Speaker 1As reported by the Indian Express's Aditi Raja, on 31st October, Prime Minister Modi, Gujarat Chief Minister Bhupendra Patel and other dignitaries had attended National Unity Day celebrations at the Statue of Unity in Ekta Nagar. They were originally expected to travel to Vadodara airport by helicopter. But because dusk had already fallen, the delegation instead travelled roughly 90 kilometres by road.

Speaker 3That meant.

Speaker 1the route through and around Daboi suddenly became part of the VIP movement plan. The municipality had assigned specific responsibilities to different departments, including cleanliness, control of stray cattle and maintenance of streetlights. According to the suspension order, Vassava had been instructed to ensure that the lights were repaired in time. But along the stretch from Sinnor Crossroads through Bhogol and up to Sarita Bridge, 12 streetlights were found not working, while several others were reportedly flickering. The municipality subsequently invoked

Speaker 1Section 48 of the Gujarat Municipalities Act, which allows disciplinary penalties against municipal officers and employees for what the law describes as good and sufficient reasons. Vassava has been asked to appear before the competent authority and explain why the required repairs were not carried out.

Speaker 3There is, however, another layer to the story.

Speaker 1The suspension order also refers to previous complaints against Vassava and sources told the Indian Express that the action may also be connected to other ongoing inquiries into works handled by him. His additional responsibilities have now been withdrawn. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like

Speaker 1the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family.

Speaker 3This is the best way for people to get to know about us.

Speaker 1You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode