All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data
35 minAudio
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have changed since they started their journey as gig workers. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Sadaf Modak about open prisons and open prison colonies that are being planned for female prisoners in Maharashtra. She discusses what these are, how they operate and how they give prisoners an opportunity to live with their families. (19:06) Lastly, we discuss why increasing female workforce participation is crucial to India's ambition of becoming a developed nation by 2047, and what factors prevent women from entering paid employment. (31:34) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In this episode, women are at the centre of all three of our stories. We look at why Maharashtra may soon have an open prison colony exclusively for women and what this could mean for them and their families. We also discuss why and how the government is looking to find what's keeping more women from joining India's workforce. But we begin today by talking about what on-demand domestic work on apps like Pronto and Snabbit actually means for women who do it. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you
Speaker 1are listening to 3 Things, the Indian Express News Show. Just like ordering food from your favourite restaurant or getting your daily groceries, hiring someone to do your household chores has now become incredibly easy.
Speaker 2All you need to do is.
Speaker 1Download an app and you can have someone at your doorstep within minutes. Whether you need your dishes cleaned, your floors swept or your clothes washed, companies like Pronto and Instahelp let you connect with women who offer these services. For many customers, this has brought a great deal of convenience, particularly those who are unable to employ regular domestic workers. But for others, it has raised ethical concerns and made them uncomfortable with.
Speaker 2The idea of hiring someone through an app.
Speaker 1But what has this app-based on-demand gig work meant for the women taking up these jobs?
Speaker 2And how has it changed their lives?
Speaker 1To find out, The Indian Express's Sukrata Barwa spoke to and spent time with several women working in this space. Sukrata now joins my colleague Shashank Bhargav to talk about what she found.
Speaker 3Sukrata, do we have a sense of how many women are working as domestic workers in the gig economy?
Speaker 4So this sector has been around for the last couple of years, but it has particularly boomed this year, from what I understand, because according to what Pronto told us, they had 1,440 workers.
Speaker 5They don't call them workers, they call them experts.
Speaker 4In January this year, and by September this year, it had.
Speaker 5Increased to 15,000.
Speaker 4And the other, which is Snabbit, when I spoke to the CEO in around September, October this year, they said that they have around 35,000 women.
Speaker 5Who are engaged with them. There's a lot of entry and it's very fluid.
Speaker 4But what he said, he estimated that there are around 10,000 new women who enter every month. So, of course, there's no formal data that is available. We also didn't get responses from Instahelp. But this is kind of the sense that we have numerically.
Speaker 3Yeah, and these services have become very popular, especially in places with high rises, you know. Delhi, Bengaluru, and even Mumbai. And you know, traditionally, you would find domestic workers through referrals, right? Your colony guard or a neighbor would recommend someone. How has the gig economy changed this space?
Speaker 4First of all, when we think about domestic work, right? Or, you know, as it's called in households across the country, maids. You know, it's such a quintessentially South Asian thing, right? I mean, of course, there are domestic workers in other countries and economies as well.
Speaker 5But this idea of, you know, having.
Speaker 4outsourcing your housework, you know, which people again, NRI say, oh, you know, it was so much better in India when we had that kind of help on hand. So it's something that's been around for so long. It's also something that I think, you know, it's not just the domain of the rich. So that is one reason that I was very curious about, you know, the entry of gig workforce here. Now, you know, we've had generations after generations of women working in other.
Speaker 5People's homes, right, in our country.
Speaker 4What I found very interesting when I started spending time with a lot of these women, having long, detailed conversations, was that quite a few of the women I spoke to have never worked as domestic workers before. For example, I met a woman who worked in a phone charger assembly unit in Noida. You know, she was an assembly line worker. She moved here because, well, when she was working at the unit, she was earning, she said, like, approximately 9,000 rupees a month was what she was taking back home.
Speaker 3For a 12-hour shift?
Speaker 5For a 12-hour shift.
Speaker 4And, you know, it was very interesting because she said, you know, I never thought that I would ever be a maid. She hid it from her family for several months because she was pretty sure that they would disapprove of her doing this work, which has some kind of social stigma around it.
Speaker 5So she hid it.
Speaker 4For a while, but she says that it is the money which she finds very empowering.
Speaker 3Is she earning more now?
Speaker 5Much more.
Speaker 4She said that there are months where she earns as much as 35,000 rupees a month.
Speaker 5So the shift has been a lot.
Speaker 4You know, they're given a uniform, which again, she was uncomfortable about because she's only ever worn salwar suits.
Speaker 5And now, you know, she's wearing shirt pant.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 3And with a uniform, it gives you a sense that, you know, you're doing something professional.
Speaker 5Yeah, it's the trappings of professionalism.
Speaker 4She says ki maini socha tha ki maini hamesha gaon mein rehti. You know, she basically came to Noida to look after an ailing brother.
Speaker 5And then to make ends meet, she joined the factory. Now she's working here.
Speaker 4And she says, you know, I have a job. I work in a company. Okay, I'm not a maid. I work in a company. It's just another job. And I'm earning well, you know, much better than I ever thought I would. And yeah, and most of the people I meet are She says that she's had positive experiences in her interactions with people. And I bring up this case because, you know, a lot of these women were like this, you know, in the sense that they never thought that they would do, they.
Speaker 5Never envisioned themselves as domestic workers.
Speaker 4But here they are, you know, and I met this girl, she was just 20 years old, and she's completed her school education, okay, she's completed her 12th, but family circumstances, she wasn't able to study further, so she was also working at a assembly unit, or a, you know, a manufacturing unit in Noida, and again, you know, low pay, which is why she's joined this, I met her on her first day, and she was very uncomfortable, you know, she said that, I've never did housework in my own house. And but you know, where are the jobs? You know, like, where would I work as a woman, say, who's not
Speaker 4trained in how to use a computer? You know, where would I work? So the money, I mean, I've been promised decent money.
Speaker 5So I'm here.
Speaker 4She is working so that she can finance a computer course. Like she says computer course, like upskill herself a little more and then look for a office job.
Speaker 5You You know, that's what she's aspiring for. And this is kind of an.
Speaker 4Intermediate kind of a step for her to transition to that.
Speaker 3Right. So you have a lot of women who otherwise perhaps would not have done domestic work. They're coming into this space. And of course, you have those who have worked as domestic workers. They're now coming to these apps and doing this on demand work, some for money, some for other reasons. But you know, when we are talking about money, can you talk about how does the payment structure work and what a typical shift looks like?
Speaker 4So you clock into your shift and you get paid for your shift. They will get paid for the duration of their shift, whether or not there.
Speaker 5Is any booking. So even if they say sitting.
Speaker 4And waiting all day for a booking, but they will still earn for every hour that they are on duty in the shift. So each of the workers are allotted what is called a work hub. So it's a place for them to log in and be present in through the duration of the shift.
Speaker 5And then they will get bookings from nearby.
Speaker 4Households and they have to go and report to those households for duty.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3And these work hubs are generally near residential areas and housing complexes.
Speaker 4Yeah, so when they log in for the day, they will report to their hub. They log into their app. In this lady's case, she had a work WhatsApp group where her supervisor was. So they have to take their selfies, you know, I'm present today and send it and then wait. Either or there might be a pre-assign. Suppose, you know, suppose a customer pre-booked the previous day for a slot, say 9 a.m. So then she'll get pinged and then she is to either accept or decline. They will are definitely encouraged to accept. So after accepting, She will go for duty. Now the duty can be 30 minutes.
Speaker 5It can be an hour.
Speaker 4I mean, those of our listeners who use these apps will know you can book it for up to three hours. So she will go and report for her duty. Now this is over and above the shift, right? I mean, she's already present for the shift. She's going to get paid for her shift. Now she will earn incentives for the bookings that she completes. And she can also say get extra points for things like she showed up early or, you know, she got a good rating. So she's going to get, you know, so there are little incentives that are there, but there are also disincentives. So, for example,
Speaker 4she turns up late. There'll be a docking of the pay. And you, of course, understand what is the bigger priority according to what the biggest penalties are. Amongst the biggest penalties that I've seen is being absent on a weekend.
Speaker 5It is compulsory.
Speaker 4Basically, the disincentive is so high that it's pretty obvious that it is compulsory to be present on the weekend because that's when there are most bookings, right?
Speaker 5People are in their home.
Speaker 3And I'm guessing if you cancel a booking, there would be a penalty for that as well.
Speaker 4So I think there's a cap also of how many you can cancel. Then you start getting penalized. That's why I say that there are variables now. So there's the baseline salary. So it is likely to increase from that because then you'll complete your bookings.
Speaker 5You'll earn some points or you'll upgrade. I mean, there are levels. It's like a real maze.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3If you're doing this for the first time, all these things must be very difficult to keep track of.
Speaker 4Yeah now for example pronto they have two paid leaves in a month so for two days if you don't clock in that's okay now for every day then that you don't clock in you will not get paid for that shift because you get paid for every shift that you work for so this is roughly how the model works. So yeah, so it's not a fixed monthly income per se, but there's a ballpark.
Speaker 3And talk about the kind of jobs they end up doing.
Speaker 4Sweeping, pocha, washing utensils. One thing is that, you know, bathroom cleaning is included. So a lot of say, you know, women who work in households, they don't, because you know, all of this.
Speaker 5Work is so caste coded, first of all.
Speaker 4So you know, there was this girl I met, she's working, and she hasn't told her family that she's working as a domestic worker on these apps. Again, like she says, it's just a job and it's in a company. But She says that, oh, I'm a thakur. And in my caste, people don't work in these houses. So, you know, my dad will be very, very infuriated. But, you know, bathroom cleaning, sanitation work is considered even, you know, it's very caste coded. So a lot of women who work in households normally also for cleaning, they don't clean bathrooms. And there are
Speaker 4different lower caste workers who clean bathrooms. But in these apps, it's all covered. So these women are doing all these jobs. Some things are off limits. They don't cook. They're not allowed to cook, but they can meal prep. So they can chop vegetables or they can, you know, knead the dough and get it ready for, but no.
Speaker 5Switching on the stove. Okay. It's like safety standards.
Speaker 4Also, I think a lot of these platforms are also going to introduce another category of.
Speaker 5Services for this. So, and again, no personal favors.
Speaker 4Like one girl said that, you know, one lady asked her to like press her shoulder and she said, no, we're not supposed to be doing that. So there are boundaries. But apart from that, anything, operating washing machines, doing the laundries.
Speaker 3And talking about washing machines, there's also an entire training process, right? Where they teach you how to use different appliances, right?
Speaker 4Yeah, so I actually got to visit a training center that Snabbit has in Gurgaon.
Speaker 5So they have a two-day training process.
Speaker 4So, you know, through publicity, word of mouth, once the women get to know, they come and they go through a two-day training process. And that includes, you know, orientation videos. They're made to understand how to navigate the app.
Speaker 5And then they taught about the different features. Then about how they're supposed to present themselves, say grooming, you know, how they should.
Speaker 4Wear their hair, their uniform. Then a very stern word against stealing, like... don't steal, you know, like there will be investigations if there's any complaint. So that kind of orientation is there. And then there's what they call in quotes, technical training. So this training center was, it was kind of done up like a mock apartment. So there was a bathroom with a toilet, a sink. There was a washing machine, there was a sink with dirty dishes in a mock kitchen and an ironing board and all of that. So when I was there, there were these women wearing
Speaker 4these uniforms, kind of performing these tasks. So they kind of evaluated and also looked at, say, how after you clean the sink, how you clean up the post work cleanup and all of that.
Speaker 5So they actually assessed if they're ready to join.
Speaker 4And if somebody is found to be not in quotes up to the mark, then they could be called back for a third day.
Speaker 3Oh, so can you fail that training?
Speaker 5You can fail the training. Yeah, you can. So there's just two days.
Speaker 4And like, I mean, at least a lot of people know how to use phones now, but still navigating that app for work is new. So they also have a mock app on which the women practice. But again, it's a learning curve. I mean, once the women join, but this kind of training.
Speaker 5Is also there.
Speaker 3And is money the main draw?
Speaker 4Money in some cases in some cases it's when you know you don't have any other work so which is something that even say i spoke to people who've done a lot of research on the gig economy and who work with domestic workers who kind of appreciated this aspect of it that it creates flexibility for these women to find work when there is none to be found And an interesting thing is that in these apps, it's an all women workforce. Again, like not only is domestic work caste coded, it's gender coded, right?
Speaker 5So this is an all women workforce.
Speaker 4So it kind of gives flexibility and opportunity at a time when it is scarce.
Speaker 3And you know, besides this, one of the things that you've written about is something that a lot of these women have a problem with. And that's the fact that a lot of these work hubs are located outside of residential complexes. And so a lot of the times they have to wait on the road or on the footpath. Yeah.
Speaker 4So for example, where I met a lot of these women is outside a particular high-rise society in Noida. So there's a divider outside the society's gates and they all kind of are over there.
Speaker 5So between bookings, they're.
Speaker 4Lying around, they're chatting, they're eating their lunch or they're just scrolling on their phones. Inside the society, and this I think is across societies, they're not quote unquote allowed to sit on the society lawns inside. So they log in, they go for duty inside a flattened society, and then they come out and then they wait. So in a lot of cases, they're out in the open, in the heat of summer. Currently, we're in peak pollution season, in the pollution. In winter, it's going to be biting cold. So that's a vulnerability, right? And that, I mean, some
Speaker 4women are used to it. Some don't like it. The union leader and the researcher I spoke to, they kind of flagged this as a thing.
Speaker 5So this is there.
Speaker 3And so, Krita, you know, these are women entering strangers' homes to work, right? What kind of risks do they face while doing this?
Speaker 5So in that sense, the apps do have.
Speaker 4These safety features, I mean, I can't comment on how effective they are, but all of these apps have SOS buttons, a red color SOS button that is prominently on the screen. So for example, like I said, I had spoken to the Snabbit CEO. So I asked him what happens, you know, if someone... presses on the SOS button. So for example, if they're being physically threatened or, you know, they're in an unsafe situation. So he said that when they press it, one, there's an SOS team which will reach out to the worker and like kind of ask her, you know, can
Speaker 4also be accidental. I mean, she might have pressed it accidentally or to understand what is the situation. Simultaneously, a customer care member will call the customer and try and get a sense of what the situation is. And then he said that there's also a field operation team who will start moving towards that location. And if by the time they reach the location, the SOS team hasn't resolved the situation over phone, then he said that they enter and try to.
Speaker 5Physically establish contact with the worker. So this is a SOS button.
Speaker 4So if they like shouted at or they're being verbally abused or whatever, they can click on that. The other thing is, I mean, I don't know about all the apps, but like because I'd gone for Snabbits training, they have something called the block feature. So for example, if they had an unpleasant experience with a particular customer, because.
Speaker 5You know, they work in that hub. So they very frequently get rebooked by same people, right?
Speaker 4So if they had an unpleasant situation with someone, they can block that customer. So they won't get assigned to any bookings by those customers. The rider is that they can't block more than five people at a time. So say, for example, now they want to block another person, they have to unblock one of the earlier people.
Speaker 5So these are the kind of features.
Speaker 4When I asked about these women going to multiple unknown homes in a day, What the Snabbit CEO Ayush Agarwal said that domestic work is such an unregulated space anyway.
Speaker 5The existence of mediation through.
Speaker 4This platform kind of gives it some kind of regulation, which is otherwise completely absent in the world of domestic workers. I mean, that is his version. But like domestic work is inherently a very vulnerable, a very fraught space, actually. And the women are always vulnerable. This has other kinds of vulnerabilities. They also have tried to build some kind of safeguards.
Speaker 3By the way, anything that surprised you about this work when you spoke to these women?
Speaker 4See, I was away from Delhi NCR for like three years.
Speaker 5So when I lived here last, this wasn't around at all.
Speaker 4And then I saw, you know, this online buzz, you know, and there's some kind of moral outrage, right? About a system where you can get somebody to come and work for you for 10 minutes and just.
Speaker 5Clean up your house.
Speaker 4I mean, because I've had long conversations with a lot of these women, I've tried to understand.
Speaker 5Why they do this work.
Speaker 4And like I gave some examples, there are some women for whom just the choice to work and to earn in that way itself is like it has its own agency and it can be empowering I think what my understanding was then that is like I said like in my conversation with the union leader and the researchers this came out is that at least you know for a lot of these women there is a choice Not necessarily an obvious choice. Like I said, they wouldn't have wanted to be domestic workers, but where pay is assured if
Speaker 4you show up in time and where even if you don't get work for the day, you get paid at a time when you can be at your most vulnerable without a job. Yeah, so that, you know, that there's definitely that flexibility and the little freedoms that come with that.
Speaker 1And next, we turn our attention to women we don't often think about. Women who have found themselves on the wrong side of the law and now in prison. Now, when we think of prisons, we typically picture dark, dingy spaces with rows of cells where hundreds of people remain confined behind four walls, sometimes for years. And while some prisons may fit this image.
Speaker 2India's.
Speaker 1Prison system has different categories of facilities, depending on factors such as the nature of a person's offence and their conduct while serving their sentence. These range from regular prisons to semi-open prisons and open prisons.
Speaker 2In open prisons, inmates enjoy.
Speaker 1Considerably greater freedom of movement with some even allowed to live with their families.
Speaker 6In some open prisons, most of them are part of the same prison institution where the prisoners live on their own, just their confinement hours are a little more relaxed.
Speaker 2That's the Indian Express's Sadaf Modak.
Speaker 6But then there are also open colonies and other open institutions where families of the convicts are permitted to live with them. Like their spouses or parents or children are permitted to live with them. So those are a different kind of an open institution. When we say open prisons, both those exist. Like the regular prisons where prisoners are kept but have more hours outside of confinement. And separate open colonies where families of convicts are also permitted to live with them.
Speaker 1Now, Sadaf tells us that there are 103 open prisons across the country, out of which 19 are located in Maharashtra. And the reason we're talking about open prisons today is that Maharashtra plans to set up its first open prison colony exclusively for women, where they will be able to serve their sentences while living with their families. To understand why the state wants to do that and what it means for women inmates, we speak to Sadaf in this segment. Sadaf, could you talk a.
Speaker 2Bit more about how an open prison is different from a regular one?
Speaker 6Yes. So, the concept of an open prison is basically, as per the Model Prisons and Correctional Services Act, it's a place which also is defined as an open correctional institution, which is a place for confinement of prisoners who meet certain eligibility, certain conditions. In Maharashtra, for example, there are open prisons which work in a way that they are part of the main prison itself. that the prisoners who are in the open prison category also stay in the same prisons as the others, but they have more hours in the day where they are free. What this means is basically prison rules are very strict when it comes
Speaker 6to the timings of when people are sent back to the barracks. So usually what happens is the way a prison schedule works is that prisoners are made to wake up around 5 a.m., 6 a.m., And then they spend some time in breakfast and other chores. And if they're convicts, then they're sent to work in factories within the prison or any other work that the prison may have. And once that is done, that afternoon, they're sent back to the barracks where they then spend another two, three hours inside the barracks and then they're again let out around
Speaker 6three four o'clock and again then sent back to the barracks around five where they then when the barracks are opened the next morning open prisons work in a way that the prisoners do not have to go back into the barracks into confinement in the daytime usually once they're set out after breakfast once they are out of the barrack they usually return only in the evening So in that sense, their confinement hours are more relaxed. And one more thing that a lot of open prisons in Maharashtra especially have is that they can also go out of the prison premises to work. They are of course made to still wear their prison uniform, but there is no
Speaker 6hard security around. Then there are also prisons which are open prisons in a few other states where what happens is that there are separate colonies or separate buildings altogether for prisoners. Those chosen for spending time in open prisons live separately. And they also have a lot more freedom in terms of roaming around, in terms of what they do. And all their families can come stay with them.
Speaker 1And now Maharashtra might see its first open prison colony exclusively for women.
Speaker 2Can you tell us how did this idea come about?
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 6So what happened is in February this year, the Supreme Court was looking into the issue of prisons. And one of the things that they spoke about is the need to establish new open and semi-open correction facilities. And the need for this also came about from, if you see the numbers, there is a lot of overcrowding in prisons across big cities in the country. And at the same time, the open correction institutions that states have are usually underutilized. And for that reason, the Supreme Court said that, you know, there must be a statewide inspection of these facilities and
Speaker 6to see whether they could be, you know, increased in number or any vacancies in existing facilities prison or in existing open institutions where maybe there is less staff or some other issues, they can then maybe have more open and semi-open correctional facilities. And they also said that, you know, we need to look at maybe transferring more prisoners from the regular prison to open prisons. And for all of that, they directed that each state have a committee, which then will look into these aspects. So in Maharashtra, this committee was formed in June. And currently, it is headed by
Speaker 6a Bombay High Court Judge, Justice Bharti Dangre, and Additional Chief Secretary of Home, Radhika Rastogi, who is an IS officer, and the DG Prisons of the Correctional Services, who are Mr. Suhas Varkey, is a member secretary. So the three-member committee has been, since June, looking at open prison institutions in Maharashtra. Maharashtra already currently has about 19 open prisons, and two of these are for women. So what the officials told us is that once the committee met, they realized that there is a possibility that Women prisoners may be more receptive.
Speaker 6It might be more practical to have an open colony for them first. And given the Supreme Court orders now, they've identified two spots, one in Sambhaji Nagar and one in Nashik, where they're looking at setting up the facilities for a women-only prison colony. How this will work is that there will be obviously some criteria that they set. And women convicts who have spent, say, a certain period of time and whose prison conduct, etc., will be taken into consideration and then they will be chosen to go to these open colonies.
Speaker 1But Sadaf, why are these open correctional facilities being created specifically for women?
Speaker 2And why do they think it would be more practical for them?
Speaker 6So from what we gathered from speaking to the officials is that Maharashtra already does have an open colony. It's in Atpadi, close to Sangli district. They said that although there's a lot more freedom and it's a facility for male prisoners and there is a lot more freedom for prisoners there, a lot of them don't choose to stay there. Also because for men, there is a lot of concern in terms of whether the family members would move in with them. whether you know if someone's going to school in a faraway district say for example someone who's in nagpur may not necessarily move say 300 400 kilometers only
Speaker 6to access this facility in sangli there might be school going children who may not want to move only to be staying with a male convict in the open colony so what they got a sense was from if you see the profile of a lot of women prisoners in maharashtra especially they are not habitual offenders They're not part of organized crime syndicates. A lot of them are inside because of, say, some domestic issue which turned into an offense. For example, the murders of a husband or a family member. In those cases, what happens is they also face immediate abandonment by the family. And in India, as per rules,
Speaker 6a child is allowed to stay with a woman till six years of age. And if there is nobody else to look after the child outside, then the child is sent to a children's institution till the mother is in prison. So they identified that a lot of people whose children are already outside in children's institutions might be more open to staying with their mothers in these kind of facilities. So they thought that maybe as a practice, you know, if you're setting up a pilot initiative, it might help to have a more practical solution where women whose families have abandoned them or whose family members would be more open to staying with the women, they might be better
Speaker 6equipped to stay in a facility like this. And like the male prisoners who, in at least one case, they are saying that it is not working as successfully as they expect it to. And one more aspect is that, you know, That from the feedback they got, a lot of convicts said that they may not be comfortable bringing in their families to stay with other convicts. And they said, you know, women prisoners, fortunately, unfortunately, are not looked at as sort of very dangerous when it comes to like offenses. And their families might be more comfortable living with each other.
Speaker 2And a similar.
Speaker 1Facility like this is also there in Sanganeer in Rajasthan and that houses more than 400 prisoners, including women, who are allowed to live with their families. They also work, engage with the community and even pay their bills. So tell us more about this model and will it be replicated in Maharashtra?
Speaker 6Yes, so the Sangane open jail that you're talking about, that has been in place since 1963 and it is one of the most sought-after models when it comes to open prisons. And the Supreme Court also did look at that as an ideal space for other prisons to emulate. But even in Maharashtra, they are looking at that as an example based on which they will set up their own open prisons for women, because it has worked successfully in terms of how inmates pay for their own water, electricity, they venture out for jobs. So in Maharashtra, officials told us that they are looking at how, you know, similar
Speaker 6kind of jobs can be created for women prisoners. Again, they said when it comes to women prisoners, it might be much easier for them to go into the, you know, the area and live, there might be less fear, less apprehension amongst the local community. So that is one of the things that they are looking at. So ideally, they are trying to sort of look at that model for implementation in Maharashtra as well. But Yeah, they are saying that there might be difficulties in terms of finding jobs for them, finding local communities which might be more comfortable. So they said that, of course, it might take a little while till that kind of place is reached where
Speaker 6so much sort of interaction between the local communities and the prisoners can happen. So that's, but indeed, that is the ideal sort of open jail that they are looking at.
Speaker 1But Sadaf, when it comes to prisoners who have been convicted by a court, Do facilities like this take away from the punishment that they are meant to serve? Or do they simply make the experience of incarceration more humane?
Speaker 6So when it comes to the criminal justice system, there are multiple ways in which one looks at convicts. So there is, of course, one which is punitive, where you think that, okay, someone is being punished for the offences that they've done. But there's also a whole other aspect, which is a more rehabilitative, a more restorative kind of justice that we also need to look at. So in these cases, a lot of people might feel that, oh, but why should they be given the freedom to live in such spaces? What I to look at how that there is a strict eligibility. You know, people who are repeat offenders, people who are convicted in heinous offences. They
Speaker 6may or may not be selected. Jail puts in a lot of sort of conditions when it comes to choosing these prisoners. One aspect that they look at also is that prisoners who are sent to open prisons, even currently, are those who are very close to finishing their jail term. those are the ones who would be selected to be spending the rest of their time in open prisons. So there is a larger possibility that they will not run, they will not escape because they know that they will lose all the benefits that they have earned over more than a decade. And secondly, we also have to consider that when it comes to prisoners who are going to
Speaker 6be eventually released, The fact that they are going to come back into society and should be enabled to come back into society and live a regular life after they have spent the punishment, the punitive part of their sentence is an aspect that needs to be considered. So, for example, if a woman who has spent, say, about 12 years in prison we need to keep in mind that she will be coming back into society. And the gap that has happened, you know, of being completely away from society, they will come back to society and find themselves in a very difficult situation when it comes to finding a job.
Speaker 6The stigma of being an ex-prisoner will still remain. And also the aspect of just being able to live a normal life. Those are things that an open prison kind of also looks at as an aspect, where what you do is you find... a way to make that process a little smoother. So somebody who is in an open prison is not free. The person is not completely out. The liberty of that person is still curtailed. Only thing that it'll do is that once they come back out of the prison in the next four, five years, they'll at least be a little more accustomed to regular society, to regular life. And it may not make their turn
Speaker 6that difficult. The restorative part of it also is a very, very important aspect of the criminal justice system. And these kind of initiatives just enhance that.
Speaker 1And finally, we talk about why getting more women into the workforce is crucial to India's ambition of becoming a developed nation by 2047 and what is keeping them out of paid employment. Now, the World Bank says that raising women's labour force participation rate to 50% could be one of the best ways for India to bring its GDP growth closer to 8% needed to become a high-income country. But in September, the female labour force participation rate stood at 34.6%.
Speaker 2So why aren't more women working?
Speaker 1As The Indian Express's Siddharth Opasani points out in a recent report, one important factor is unpaid domestic and care work. Though experts point out there isn't enough data to establish exactly how these responsibilities affect women's participation in the workforce. So to address this gap, the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation is proposing changes to two of its surveys. The Periodic Labour Force Survey or the PLFS and the Annual Survey of Unincorporated Sector Enterprises. The proposed changes to
Speaker 1the PLFS include more detailed questions about unpaid household work, such as cooking, looking after children and caring for the elderly. The survey will also ask people whether they want paid work, whether they have actively looked for it and why they may not have done so. Families and household responsibilities will be one of the possible reasons. Currently, the PLFS already asks women who aren't looking for work why they aren't doing so. In 2025, 44.4% of women cited childcare or personal commitments in homemaking as the main reason. But experts
Speaker 1say that this question is too generic and doesn't tell us whether women take on unpaid work out of choice or because they feel it is their responsibility. The government also wants to understand how much unpaid work is undertaken by people who are already employed and how many unemployed people are unable to take up jobs because of these responsibilities. Siddharth also writes that through its survey of unincorporated enterprises, the government wants to understand how restrictions on mobility, limited time and caregiving responsibilities affect women entrepreneurs. Experts told him
Speaker 1that in Tamil Nadu, for example, some of these barriers have been addressed. The state employs four out of every ten directly employed female factory workers in India, partly through the use of dormitories that provide women with accommodation close to their workplaces. But as economist Mitali Nikor told him, getting women back into paid employment requires several things to fall into place– suitable pay, a safe commute, an accessible workplace and adequate childcare and eldercare support.
Speaker 2You were listening to Three Things by Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed.
Speaker 1By Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in a family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Audio and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...