Rubio on India-US ties, cost of keeping cities clean, and Gadkari under pressure
27 minAudio
First, we hear from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio in a special conversation with The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the proposed India-US trade deal, tensions over tariffs and immigration, and Washington’s evolving relationships with China and Pakistan. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Jayprakash S Naidu about a survey exposing the difficult working conditions of sanitation workers in Chhattisgarh, including inadequate safety equipment, missing identity documents and limited access to welfare schemes. (15:55) And in the end, we look at why RSS-linked organisations are preparing to protest outside Union Minister Nitin Gadkari’s residence over Pyare Khan’s appointment as chairman of the Maharashtra State Minorities Commission. (23:55) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at the working conditions of sanitation workers in Chhattisgarh, where a new survey has highlighted gaps ranging from basic safety equipment to access to welfare schemes. We also talk about Nagpur, where RSS-linked organisations are preparing to protest outside Union Minister Nitin Gadkari's residence over the appointment of Pyare Khan as Maharashtra's Minorities Commission Chairman. But we begin today With India-US relations, where after months of
Speaker 1difficult negotiations and growing tensions over trade, tariffs and immigration, the two countries may finally be close to reaching a trade agreement. Over the past 25 years, India and the United States have built an increasingly important strategic partnership, expanding
Speaker 1cooperation in areas ranging from defence, technology to trade and regional security. But that relationship has faced several challenges under the Trump administration. Washington's tariffs and its pressure on India over purchases of Russian oil have strained economic ties. At the same time, tighter visa restrictions, uncertainty around the H-1B program, and growing anti-immigrant rhetoric have raised concerns among Indian students, professionals, and families with connections to the United States. There have
Speaker 1also been questions about Washington's changing approach towards China and its closer engagement with Pakistan, particularly Pakistan's military leadership. So how close are India and the US to concluding their trade deal? How does Washington intend to manage its disagreements with New Delhi? And what does the Trump administration's evolving foreign policy mean for the future of this partnership? In this special conversation with the Indian Express's Diplomatic Affairs Editor, Subhijit Roy, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, discusses these
Speaker 1questions and more. Here's the conversation in its entirety.
Speaker 2It's been about two years since as you took charge as the U.S.
Speaker 3Secretary of State.
Speaker 2And I wanted to get a sense from you, how do you see the trajectory of India-U.S.
Speaker 3Relationship, the arc in the last two years?
Speaker 4Well, I think positive in many ways. Certainly, it's become a feature of our foreign policy. It's one that we're very focused on. In fact, what I was just saying in another interaction I was having a few moments ago, when I became Secretary of State, I got sworn in by the vice president the day after they took office, the day after inauguration. I went over to the State Department by tradition, and I spoke to the diplomatic corps that was there.
Speaker 5I stood on the steps.
Speaker 4And then my very first meeting, I went upstairs to the seventh floor to my office. My very first meeting was a meeting with the Quad that included, of course, India. And since then, I've had multiple interactions with them. I must have been over a dozen with my counterpart here in every forum. This is my second visit here. And I think you've also seen at high levels of our government. where you've seen multiple of our agencies come here and visit as well. And of course, we had the bilateral visit by the prime minister to the United States. So we're going to continue to build on that. I think now, look,
Speaker 4we have some challenges because this is not a small country. This is a big and important country. It has a large economy. It has an enormous business class. So trade has been an irritant that we're working through on the trade relationship, and that needs to be solved. But I also think that even as that process continues to work its way out, We have so many areas of cooperation, the Quad being an example, an area of very strong cooperation that is beginning to actually turn ideas into action. We're starting to see like actionable items begin to happen as a result of the Quad. It's a very, very positive relationship. And that would not be possible without there
Speaker 4being a strong U.S.-India relationship.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3I'm glad you mentioned about trade.
Speaker 2And, you know, the issue of trade and tariffs have some challenges to the relationship. although President Trump has just issued a waiver on the India buying Russian oil. But there is a certain concern that it might be imposed at some point.
Speaker 3Does it put some kind of stress on economic ties? Do you think that?
Speaker 5I mean, it can.
Speaker 4There's no doubt about it. And that's why it has to be managed. It has to be managed very carefully. And that's why the relationship we have is so critical. We certainly don't want to do things. None of these tariffs are done to punish or to harm India. They are part of a broader foreign policy that unfortunately involves a war going on between Russia and Ukraine that we'd like to see come to an end. And I'm sure you saw that in our own media and in our own political system, when the president issued those waivers and did not impose the tariffs that are required under this law passed by our Congress, he got criticism for doing it. But one of the reasons why he didn't impose them
Speaker 4is because he understands that it would have a very detrimental impact on a very important relationship with India. So it's part of balancing foreign policy. And it's a difficult part of it, because on the one hand, you do want to make sure you can pressure the warring parties to the table to negotiate an outcome in that war.
Speaker 5I think we would all like to see that.
Speaker 4On the other hand, sometimes by imposing pressure through tariffs, you're creating stress on other important relationships.
Speaker 5So that all has to be balanced.
Speaker 4I think the president is trying very hard to balance that in a very positive way.
Speaker 5But it'll be a challenge. And it's one we're going to have to manage.
Speaker 2Right. Just to take this conversation forward, the two countries have been negotiating a trade deal for almost a year and a half now. And, you know, we've come closer, but it's still not there. Both sides have indicated that they're trying to find a landing ground, landing point. How far are we and what are the sticking points that are preventing us from concluding this.
Speaker 4Well, I don't want to get into the details of the sticking points. I can simply tell you that it's there. I won't call them technicalities, but it's language related. It's basically down to what certain words mean and what certain phrases mean, because it's important for both sides to have full agreement. Both sides have to 100% agree on what a deal means. If they don't, then in the future, it can unravel it in certain ways. And we don't want to see that happen. So I think we're incredibly close. The way I would say is we are weeks, not months away, I think, finalizing it. I think 99% of the work is done The remaining factor, you have to
Speaker 4have 100% done, but I feel very positive about the trajectory that it's on.
Speaker 2You said that in your first day, the squad foreign ministers meeting took place and there was a sort of momentum and you've been an early champion of the squad framework. But there's a sense that when it comes to the Trump administration's view of China, it has changed since 2014.
Speaker 3The first term to the second term. It's seen as soft. How do you sort of respond to that?
Speaker 4I don't think soft is the right terminology. I think the right terminology is that China is a, and you know this well, because India also has relationships with China. But China is a large economy. It's a powerful country. It's a country we have to have relations with. And it's a country that our relationship with them needs to be balanced. We are most certainly going to have disagreements with them.
Speaker 5We have them now.
Speaker 4Even as I speak to you now, there are things they are doing that we don't agree with and that we consider to be harmful to the interests of the United States. And so even now you see where there are actions that are being taken, whether it's export controls or different measures that are going into place that cause irritants. So I think the attitude of this administration has been to try to find a level of strategic stability in our relationship with them, understanding that if things go bad, if the United States and China get into a trade war, or into any other conflict for that matter, it would be incredibly detrimental to the world. But it won't be
Speaker 4easy because you have these two very large, powerful countries, large, powerful economies, large, powerful militaries. And it is important for us to have a relationship that is stable despite disagreements. And so we're going to continue to press on those items that we think are against our national interest that they are doing, but at the same time, try to manage the relationship in a way that doesn't escalate into something far more dangerous or detrimental, not just for us, but for the world. A U.S.-China trade war would be devastating to the global economy. It would impact India. It would impact virtually every country in the world. So we
Speaker 4seek to avoid that sort of outcome. But as I said, it's a challenge this administration has taken on in a way that I think has been reasonable and balanced.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 2The people-to-people relationship between India and U.S.
Speaker 3Is very, very strong. You know, a huge Indian diaspora. A lot of students travel there to study. But in recent.
Speaker 2Months and years, you know, this H-1B debate and the restrictions on visas and also this, you know, rhetoric, anti-immigrant rhetoric that is somehow translating into, you know, antagonism towards India. We saw this plot that was foiled last week targeting a temple. How do you assuage the concerns of millions of families who have you know, who have invested in a U.S. education or who want to invest in the
Speaker 2best and brightest, choose U.S.
Speaker 3As the preferred destination. So these concerns, how do you? Yeah.
Speaker 4So the first thing I would say is every country in the world has to have immigration laws. If they're not, they're not a sovereign country. And so all we ask is that our country, and I'm not saying this is unique to India. This is not about India. This applies globally because I could be doing this interview in any country in Latin America and I would be asked the exact same question. maybe a different visa, maybe a different immigration program or visa program, but they would ask about it nonetheless. And what has happened in the United States, unfortunately, is for a number of years, but especially under the four years of Joe Biden, we have 20 million people
Speaker 4enter the country unlawfully.
Speaker 5We just did. We also have.
Speaker 4seen abuses. Frankly, we've seen abuses in many of these programs. Again, not unique to Indians or India.
Speaker 5It is tied more broadly to the world.
Speaker 4We've seen a rise in birth tourism that has nothing to do with India, but with other countries, things of this nature. So we are trying to fix 20 years of neglect of an immigration system that was simply not being enforced.
Speaker 5And that's not targeted at India.
Speaker 4Now, obviously, because of the developments, because of the ties between our countries, because of how developed your economy is, there are certain categories of visas that have a large number of Indians who are using it to apply. But it's not targeted at India. We are simply trying to fix our immigration system so that we can arrive at one in which we were always going to welcome immigrants and visitors to the United States. We want people to visit the United States. We want people to study in the United States. There are certain people that we want that want to come work for a time in the United States. We want people to invest in the United States.
Speaker 4And we're always going to have people immigrate to the United States.
Speaker 5But we want it done.
Speaker 4To a system of laws that are followed and complied with. And that wasn't being done. And we've identified loopholes and ways that those laws were being abused that needed to be closed. The biggest threat to legal immigration is illegal immigration. The biggest threat to legal immigration is mass migration, which, again, is not an Indian phenomenon. That's more unique to other parts of the world. But we were confronting all of that. And that's what we're trying to solve. And while I know from your perspective here in India, it may seem targeted in India, it's not. There's virtually no country on
Speaker 4earth that I go to that I don't get a complaint about some visa or some process because we're fixing it globally. But once it's fixed, it'll be far more sustainable. I actually think it'll be better for the people that are using those programs. And I think it'll be right and good for the United States.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2The Trump administration's ties with Pakistan... the closer proximity, especially with the Pakistan general, it has, you know, not perceived very well here in India. And so I want to get a sense from you that, you know, India, some in India would see it as a return to the Nixon-Kasingera when the US administration was siding with the, was backing the Pakistan's military rulers.
Speaker 3How do you pacify these worries that A closer.
Speaker 2U.S.-Pakistan relationship impacts the India-U.S.
Speaker 5Relationship.
Speaker 4Well, I would not use the 1970s as an example because the world looks nothing like it did back then. Back then, we had the Cold War and all sorts of other dynamics that no longer exist. Number two, I would say that our relationship with no country in the world at any way comes at the expense of our relationship with India. I hope my visits here, our commitment to doing the trade deal, all of the engagements that we've done, all the work that we do together is evidence of that. In no way is our relationship with any other country, whatever come at the expense of our relationship with India. Pakistan is a country we have relationship
Speaker 4with and we need to have a relationship with. And I think in some ways could be a positive thing. If we could help to discourage actions that could potentially lead to conflict, if we could perhaps use our influence, in ways that are positive.
Speaker 5I think that could be good. But I think what everyone should.
Speaker 4Be assured of in India is that our relationship, not just with Pakistan, but with any country in the world, will never come at the expense of our relationship. We don't view it that way, our relationship with India.
Speaker 2Your visit also includes a visit to Jamnagar and this. I want you to talk about the energy cooperation agenda, especially the Texas refinery.
Speaker 3And also your meeting with the Ambanis. How does this sort of come?
Speaker 2A week after Elon Musk, he accused Ambanis of blocking the entry of Starlink to India.
Speaker 4Yeah, well, Elon Musk is a private citizen. So, you know, he obviously has a right to express himself and say whatever he wants. Our country has free speech and he's an important private citizen. He owns important businesses, but he's a private citizen. So I can't speak to that. What I can speak to is why it's important that we have this meeting. And that is one of the things that we are very interested in, the whole world is interested in, is diversifying technology.
Speaker 5How we get energy.
Speaker 4I don't think we want to live in a world in which an overwhelming amount of the global energy comes from one part of the world that's prone to conflict. I think this is a company and this is a country that has refining capacity. And we have, for example, Venezuela that's going to be rapidly increasing the production of oil and crude, heavy crude, which can only be refined in certain parts of the world. One of those places is the Gulf Coast of the United States. But another of those places, one of the other few other places in the world that can actually refine Venezuelan heavy crude is is in India and its reliance. So I think
Speaker 4that's important because it helps utilize and unleash the energy that's being developed in the Western hemisphere, but also they've invested in the United States. I think it's one of the first new refining expansions in the United States we've seen in recent times.
Speaker 5That's a very important investment.
Speaker 4So I think it's an opportunity to see how they operate, but also to identify opportunities to achieve our mutual goal of diversifying our energy resources so that they're not dependent on one part of the world in ways that leave us vulnerable.
Speaker 2India has initiated a proposal on the Black Sea ceasefire. How do you see India's involvement now?
Speaker 5It can be very positive. Unfortunately, as I said, it's a conflict.
Speaker 4The problem with the Black Sea ceasefire has been that those strikes that are occurring there have strategic value to the combatants. And so I think that's what's made it so difficult. But we applaud the very positive work. I reviewed a text that's about a week and a half ago that the Indian side had put together.
Speaker 5I think they've played.
Speaker 4A very positive role in a very difficult conflict to try to solve. But that is just an effort to sort of save the world from the implications that it's having on energy. And we welcome India's involvement. I think they have a very professional diplomatic corps and have done an excellent job of trying to bring the parties together.
Speaker 5It's just been difficult.
Speaker 1And next, we talk about the working conditions of sanitation workers who play a crucial role in keeping our cities clean, often at the cost.
Speaker 5Of their own health and safety.
Speaker 1From handling waste to taking on hazardous tasks like cleaning septic tanks, sanitation workers are constantly faced by tough working conditions. In Chhattisgarh's Raipur, The city's sanitation workers lack necessities like toilet at home, Aadhaar cards or even basic protective gear. These gaps emerged from a survey conducted by the Chhattisgarh State Human Rights Commission or the SHRC to get a better understanding of the issues faced by sanitation workers. Now,
Speaker 1despite the essential services they provide, their working conditions and welfare often remain overlooked. To learn more about this survey, what it revealed, and what are the conditions in which these sanitation workers are working, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to the Indian Express's Jaiprakash S.
Speaker 2Naidu.
Speaker 7Jaiprakash, your story highlights several problems faced by sanitation workers in Chhattisgarh. What prompted you to look into this issue and what did you find?
Speaker 6Yeah, so I came across this issue when I attended a press conference taken by the State Human Rights Commission here in Chhattisgarh's Raipur. So at the press conference, they were talking about several issues. But this one particular issue struck me, you know, because the plight of the sanitation workers is not highlighted much. And it was a unique initiative by the HRC. And I was thinking that, you know, it could be replicated in other states as well. So last time I remember we reported about sanitation workers was in the month of March when three sanitation workers died while cleaning a septic tank in Raipur. So I thought
Speaker 6it was an important issue to touch upon.
Speaker 7And for our listeners, can you talk a bit about the kind of conditions these sanitation workers have to work in?
Speaker 6So, you know, because they are poorly educated and they do not have much skills, they have to, you know, work in difficult conditions and with low incomes and little social security. So, I will talk about one case which I reported in March this year. So, it was about these three contractual sanitation workers, Prashant Kumar, 26, Govind Sendre, 35 and Anmol Makhand, 32. So, these three, they died while cleaning a septic tank which was nearly 20 feet deep. it was in a big hospital and they did this
Speaker 6work without any adequate safety equipment provided to them by their contractors all of them they earned roughly 7500 a month and you know financial pressures pushed them to take up this risky work So Prashant's family, they depended on the daily wages that he earned. Anmol had recently lost his job and he had loans to pay of around Rs. 70,000 and Govind was the sole blood winner for his wife and two daughters. So yeah, the situation is quite difficult for them and hence they have to take up these jobs.
Speaker 7And now coming to the SHRC survey, tell us why it was conducted in the first place and what all did it study?
Speaker 6Yeah, so the survey, as I said, was conducted by the State Human Rights Commission here in Raipur. And it was conducted to understand the problems faced by the sanitation workers in Raipur and Bilaspur, which is another big city. So it began last winter and it continued for nine months until July this year. And very interestingly, the survey was conducted with the help of more than 500 law interns. They went around the houses of around 8,000 sanitation workers as per the SHRC in Raipur and Bilaspur. And they were working in batches and they were accompanied by police officers.
Speaker 6So the idea was to understand the problems of the sanitation workers at work as well as at home. And the survey looked at the access that they had to toilets, identity documents, safety equipment, pensions, insurance benefits and also drug abuse. It also examined the financial exploitation by the contractors. The final report has been sent to the district authorities in Raipur and Bilaspur for further action.
Speaker 3And Jayaprakash, tell us about the findings of this survey.
Speaker 7What did it reveal about the problems that these workers have to deal with?
Speaker 6Yeah, so the findings revealed several gaps in the basic facilities and welfare benefits available to sanitation workers. Of the workers surveyed, about 336 did not have toilets at home. 749 of them, they were working without proper safety equipment. And about 1,907 of them, they lacked important identity documents like Aadhaar, voter ID and ration cards. The survey also found out that about 2,387 workers had not received benefits under two government-backed insurance schemes. So, these findings showed that
Speaker 6the problems were way beyond the basic facilities and it's also a point of concern that they were being financially exploited and did not have access to government welfare schemes.
Speaker 7You also write that a massive number of workers had their ATM cards confiscated. Why was that and why did they let that happen?
Speaker 6According to the SHRC, contractors confiscated ATM cards and passbooks to deduct commissions and pay workers less than what they were entitled to. As for why workers allowed this to happen, the officials said many were helpless and urgently needed money, so they quietly accepted these conditions imposed by the contractors. I think so. It's an issue of power imbalance. When workers depend on contractors for their livelihood, they may find it difficult to challenge them. You know, having the ATM cards taken away also means losing control over their own earnings. This raises serious questions about wage payments, transparency and also
Speaker 6the monitoring of contractors.
Speaker 7And Jayaprakash, an interesting thing about this survey, like you mentioned in the beginning, was that it was conducted by interns. So how did that happen?
Speaker 6Yeah, so as I said, this was an innovative and a unique idea by the then chairperson Giridhar Naik of the commission. He felt that sanitation workers, you know, who play a crucial role, like who played a crucial role during the COVID-19 pandemic, often remained invisible despite the work they did. So the commission also regularly received law students for their college field projects. So it was his decision to involve them in the survey, you know, giving them practical experience while documenting the problems faced by these workers. So there were essentially two objectives to this initiative. One was these workers' issue would be brought to focus and
Speaker 6then the law students first-hand, they will get exposure of the human rights concerns which are beyond their classroom.
Speaker 7And now coming back to the gaps highlighted in the survey, what can be done to improve the situation and find a solution to the problems these sanitation workers have been facing?
Speaker 6Yeah, so as I mentioned, they sent the survey report to the Raipur Collector and also to Bijapur Collector. So I spoke with Raipur Collector Gaurav Singh to take a feedback on what happened to the survey. So he said that within a week's time, they are starting a campaign for sanitation workers. It's called Safai Mitra, where the authorities will look into the issues faced by the sanitation workers and they will ensure that the issues get resolved and they will also start receiving the benefits under the government schemes. So this is one. bilaspur collector i mean the person concerned in bilaspur i could not get a comment from him on this but then i spoke with nilesh langote
Speaker 6he is the state president of all india sanitation workers trade union so he said that the first thing that the sanitation workers need is the right to live with dignity and he also raised the issue of contractors that they are not giving them proper wages and holidays so this is one major issue and the second thing that he raised was that The sanitation workers, you know, they have been living in these colonies and one after the other, the generation does the same work. So he was saying that they should get property rights. And second thing is that they should get this PM Awaz Yojana, where, you know, the government helps you to build your own home. And lastly,
Speaker 6one more thing that I would like to add is the transparency that needs to be between, you know, the contractors and the sanitation workers. The government needs to ensure that, you know, there is no illegal deductions done by the contractor and there should be greater accountability of contractors.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about an unusual political confrontation in Nagpur, where RSS-linked organizations including Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrang Dal are preparing to protest outside Union Minister Nitin Gadkari's residence over the appointment of businessman Pyare Khan as chairman of the Maharashtra State Minorities Commission. The groups are demanding Khan's removal and allege that his rise to the post was enabled by political patronage, including support from Gadkari. Now,
Speaker 1Khan is not a conventional political figure. As reported by The Indian Express's Ankita Deshkar, the Nagpur-based transport businessman became widely known during the second Covid wave when he spent more than Rs 85 lakh transporting over 400 metric tonnes of liquid oxygen to hospitals in and around Nagpur.
Speaker 3He declined reimbursement, describing.
Speaker 1The effort as a humanitarian duty, and eventually became known as the Oxygen Man. His association with political leaders continued after that. Khan campaigned for Gadkari during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections and was appointed chairman of the Maharashtra State Minorities Commission. in July 2024 for a five-year term. But sections of the Sangh Parivaar have objected both to his appointment and to what they see as the political backing behind it. VHP leaders have also questioned why a Muslim
Speaker 1was appointed to head the commission. The controversy intensified further after Khan visited Nashik Central Prison, where gangster Abu Salim is serving a life sentence. The VHP alleged that Khan had met Salim, and spoken in favour of his release. Khan denied this and said he would resign immediately if the authority that appointed him asked him to step down. The latest protest is now aimed directly at Gadkari, with BHP leaders arguing that his support helped establish Khan's political standing. Interestingly,
Speaker 1the RSS itself has distanced itself from that position. An RSS functionary said, its Vijayadashami event was open to people of all religions and that the VHP's opposition should not be interpreted as the Sangh's official view. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika
Speaker 1Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...