Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

China tightens exports, transgender rights under scrunity, and 92,000 crore betting network

Nov 16, 202627 minAudio

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Ravi Dutta Mishra about China’s proposed export curbs, their potential impact on Indian industries, and the government’s efforts to manufacture 100 critical products domestically. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Amaal Sheikh about a Supreme Court petition challenging provisions of India’s transgender rights law, the debate over self-identified gender and biological sex, and what the case could mean for transgender people’s legal rights. (13:35) And in the end, we look at the Mahadev online betting case, where the Enforcement Directorate says the estimated proceeds of crime have reached around ₹92,000 crore, even as the network allegedly continues to operate. (24:00) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at a new Supreme Court challenge to India's transgender rights law and the debate over self-identified gender and biological sex. We also turn to Mahadev online betting case, where the enforcement directorate says the estimated proceeds of crime have now reached around Rs 92,000 crore. But first, we talk about the future of India-China trade relations as China prepares to introduce new export curbs. Hi,

Speaker 1I'm Ichha Sharma and you're listening to 3 Things, the Indian Express news show. Starting this month, China is set to introduce an export licensing regime for goods used in key sectors such as solar equipment and heavy machinery, including tunnel boring machines. In simple terms, this means that new regulations will be put in place to control and monitor the export of certain goods and products overseas. These restrictions

Speaker 1could affect India's imports from China and potentially disrupt supplies to key industries. Against this backdrop, The Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade, or DPIIT, has identified 100 products across sectors, including intermediate goods and capital goods, that India wants to manufacture domestically. So what impact could China's export curbs have on India? Which products is India looking to manufacture domestically? And could these restrictions further strain an

Speaker 1already turbulent India-China relationship? To answer these questions... My colleague Niharika Nanda speaks with the Indian Express's Ravi Dutta Mishra.

Speaker 2Ravi, we understand that China has proposed certain export curbs. So, what kind of products would these curbs impact and why is China planning to impose them?

Speaker 3So, You know, China has been involved in a trade war with the United States as well as, you know, with the countries in the European Union. And now we are seeing China becoming a little more aggressive and they have announced a lot of curbs on tech products. And it can be categorized under capital goods. And they are specifically targeting solar technology and infrastructure.

Speaker 4For instance, tunnel.

Speaker 3Boring machine is one of the key infrastructures which they have announced that they're going to bring under a licensing mechanism. which essentially means that you have to go to and fro, seek a license. There could be a longer waiting time and eventually they can have more control over what goes out of China. So broadly, they are imposing curbs on technology items, which feeds into very critical industry for India and the world.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2And talking about that, how do we see these curbs impacting India and its imports in particular?

Speaker 3So the primary impact has been on our solar production, solar power production. And this is one of Prime Minister Modi's key projects. And he has talked about all the schemes that have been introduced, renewable energy multiple times. And we have seen India grow very fast. But there is significant amount of import dependency on items that goes into solar production. For instance, the cells, the silicon wafer, all of it have a very strong dependence on China and

Speaker 3not just India. I mean, China produces 90 to 95 percent of the products in the entire renewables sector. So that is something that is immediate trouble. Other than that, they've also announced restrictions on critical minerals. Now, that is a different ballgame. When critical minerals are being restricted, it affects your automobile industry. For India, particularly, rare earth magnets are extensively used in automobiles. And what we are seeing is Indian companies are trying to find way around. They're

Speaker 3trying to import the entire part rather than just rare earth magnets. And that has become a long drawn process and it just frustrates the industry. And as soon as you try to import these things from any other country, say Japan or ASEAN nations, there's an immediate cost escalation of 20 to 30 percent.

Speaker 4So this is how it has begun to impact the Indian industry.

Speaker 3But I must clarify that all these restrictions that China has announced, they have said that they will come into effect from November 16th onwards. So exactly how it will play out is something that we don't know. But we have seen in the past that whenever China imposes a licensing mechanism, it is either a negotiating tactics or it ends.

Speaker 4Up imposing those restrictions. So in both the cases, we will be in a difficult spot.

Speaker 2So keeping this in mind, India is planning to indigenize the production of about 100 products and goods to make itself more self-reliant, right? And one such commodity is solar power. So can you tell us about that?

Speaker 3Yeah. So we are targeting, I mean, DPIT has made a list of 100 critical items. What is interesting about this list is that it feeds into a broader set of items that are manufactured. For instance, one of the products that we are aware of is PVC suspension resin. This is an element which is used for making pipes. And pipes are used not only in irrigation, it is used in infrastructure projects, housing projects, everywhere. So by ensuring

Speaker 3that we are not dependent on something as common as PVC resin on China, we have started taking some measures.

Speaker 4Now, this is one element.

Speaker 3There is also critical items that are used in solar power manufacturing. And then there are petrochemical items that are used into several, you know, pharma products and such.

Speaker 4It also goes into textile. So all of them are related.

Speaker 3So we are targeting those kind of elements that have a very high use case. And at the same time, we are very dependent on China, where, you know, if, for instance, a drug.

Speaker 4that.

Speaker 3Comes from China, APIs, which we commonly know. If China imposes a restriction on it tomorrow, a lot of sectors will be immediately impacted. So those are the list, those are the items that DPIT is trying to indigenize or at least give incentive to the companies to indigenize. And we hear that this list could also feature in the union budget. Only time will tell, but we know that discussions have happened with DPIT line ministries and the proposal is being prepared.

Speaker 2And Ravi, something that you mentioned in your report is that India currently is not being able to fulfill its potential as far as the production of solar energy is concerned.

Speaker 1So can you tell us why that is?

Speaker 3Okay, so when we talk about solar power manufacturing, there are various components, cell, silicon wafer, batteries, there are multiple components that play a role.

Speaker 4So we have.

Speaker 3Launched several schemes and in some components we have achieved success.

Speaker 4Indigenization.

Speaker 3So which only goes to show that we have the potential, we have tried to produce things at scale. But when it comes to the most key element, for instance, sales, we're still 90% dependent on sales. When it comes to silicon wafer, we are still dependent on 80 to 90% on Chinese wafers. So there's one important element to it, which is cost. China produces everything at scale so even if Indian government comes out with a PLI scheme and it pumps money if as long as importing a whole

Speaker 3solar panel is cheaper from China that is what the players will do they will import parts from China and they may value add and then they may export it to other countries they can do all of those things but scale is the biggest challenge over here And because China has achieved scale, they are able to produce anything related to solar power much cheaper. And these things are flooding Indian markets. We have imposed anti-dumping duties. We have imposed a lot of anti-dumping investigations. But that will only work when we have maybe a new technology, when we

Speaker 3are able to scale it to a level which China has.

Speaker 4So that is where things are not really taking off for us.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 2And another commodity that India depends on other countries for are petrochemicals. So does India have a plan to domestically produce them as well?

Speaker 4Yes.

Speaker 3So when the West Asia crisis had happened, to alleviate the challenge the industry was facing, India had removed duty on at least 30 to 40 petrochemical items. Now, at that time, DPIT had reached out to the industry asking for inputs, asking for ways in.

Speaker 4Which we can indigenize them.

Speaker 3This was a lesson that we learned, that we are so dependent on China, so dependent on even West Asian countries, that if a crisis of that scale happens, a lot of our industry will be impacted. And petrochemicals goes into textile, it goes into pharma, it goes into.

Speaker 4Even fertilizers.

Speaker 3So this is one sector which perhaps there were efforts to bring in a large manufacturing plant in India to incentivize those plants. But after the West Asia crisis, this sector has become very important for us, especially now that we are also thinking about a.

Speaker 4PLI scheme on select chemicals. So it is going to take some time.

Speaker 3That is what even the government officers also believe that if we target particular chemicals, it will take some time, but it is necessary. So even if there is a short term cost increase, that is something that the industry will have to bear and the government will have to incentivize.

Speaker 4So that is where things are at the moment.

Speaker 2And what are some other commodities whose production India wants to indigenize?

Speaker 3So there's a lot of chatter on tunnel boring machine. You might have seen tunnel boring machine is also part of the restriction that China has announced last month. And they say that a licensing mechanism will be imposed on November 16th. Now, our commerce minister, Goyal, he had very sharp reaction to it. He had said that, you know, India will not go, quote unquote, go with a begging bowl to China if they restrict our tunnel boring machine. We'll find a way to manufacture it in our own country.

Speaker 3So it is a key capital good, which, you know, is used in urban projects.

Speaker 4Gone are the times.

Speaker 3When we used to use tunnels. dynamites and blasting away to make tunnels. Now, these sophisticated machines are sought after not just in India, but across the world. And even in first bullet train from Mumbai to Ahmedabad, tunnel boring machine is used. So that is something that we have said that we are going to manufacture, indigenize in India, but it takes a long time to do that.

Speaker 4I mean, China used.

Speaker 3To import tunnel boring machine or parts of it till 2018 2020 and it had started focusing on manufacturing these machines in 2000 so even china took about 20 years to indigenize tunnel boring machine and become a major exporter so One can say that, okay, we're going to indigenize, but it's a little difficult.

Speaker 4For us to achieve that.

Speaker 3But what we gather from the industry and from the officials is that initially we will import some of it from Japan. Of course, there will be an increase in cost of importing it, but this is all under a national security lens.

Speaker 4So those steps are being planned.

Speaker 2And Ravi, how have things been between India and China trade-wise in the recent past? And how do we see these curbs impacting this relationship?

Speaker 3So, you know, there was a huge restriction that China had imposed on critical minerals. And it seemed to be a negotiating position initially two years back.

Speaker 4But when Xi Jinping and a.

Speaker 3Lot of other Chinese officials had come to India, India had raised money. these concerns and they had sought a resolution of restrictions on critical minerals, but they remain in effect. So as far as our industrial dependence on China is concerned, we are acutely dependent. And our relationship, of course, due to the border issues, of course, due to the huge surge in imports from China, it has not been in the best of terms. But now we have seen that earlier this year, India had made a major change in

Speaker 3its investment regulation, Press Note 3. And that gave a signal that India is ready to welcome more Chinese investments in India, even in critical sectors.

Speaker 4So it's been very.

Speaker 3off and on you know removal of these restrictions press note these gave us signals that maybe things are coming back to normal but then what we hear in arunachal pradesh again kind of reflects in what our commerce minister has also been talking about you know use of these very sharp language we will not go to china with a begging bowl we will try to indigenize this is a very sharp kind of language which i have not seen him use against china very often And we all know the history. In 2019, India had pulled out of

Speaker 3RCEP negotiations, which was a China-led trade pact. And since then, we have been looking west. We've signed trade deals with the European Union, with UK, with Australia, a lot of bunch of other countries. And we are also negotiating a deal with US. But since then, we have not thought about joining RCEP, which remains a sticking point between the two countries.

Speaker 1And next, we turn to the Supreme Court, where a new petition challenging provisions of India's transgender rights law has reopened a fundamental debate. Should a person's gender be legally recognised on the basis of their identity or their biological characteristics? For more than a decade, this question has been central to the legal battle for transgender rights in India. In 2014, The Supreme Court delivered a landmark judgment in a case known as NALSA v. Union of India, recognizing that transgender

Speaker 1people have the right to determine their own gender identity. The court made an important distinction between biological sex. and gender identity, ruling that a person's gender cannot be determined solely by physical characteristics. The judgment was widely regarded as a major step towards securing dignity and legal recognition for transgender people in India. But now, a petition filed by the Indian chapter of a UK-based organisation called Women's Declaration

Speaker 1International has sought to challenge provisions of the Transgender Persons Protection of Rights Act of 2019 and the rules governing changes to official gender certificates. So to understand what exactly is being challenged and what could the case mean for the legal rights and everyday lives of transgender people in India, We're joined by The Indian Express's Amal Sheikh. Amal, to begin with, could you start by helping us understand what exactly has been challenged in the Supreme Court?

Speaker 5So an organization has filed a plea challenging one provision of the Transgender Act, which allowed a transgender person to change their gender identity through via obtaining a certificate. Now, the petitioners are saying that recognizing gender in this way could affect the rights and protections that are meant in law that was specifically created in law for biological women so this is what is challenged in the court recently

Speaker 5and the supreme court has just taken it up.

Speaker 1Right and before we get into the legal arguments of this plea how do we read the distinction between biological sex and gender identity Right.

Speaker 5So biological sex refers to physical characteristics such as reproductive characteristics, reproductive autonomy, chromosomes and hormones. That is something that is assigned at birth. Gender identity is something that a person identifies with. So it's basically a person's own understanding of what kind of gender they belong to, whether they identify as a man or a woman.

Speaker 1Or otherwise.

Speaker 5And that's a distinction that the Supreme Court also created in 2014 in the NALSA judgment where they recognized transgender as a third gender. They said that a person's gender can't just be determined by their biological sex and that their own understanding of their identity must be given importance. And this distinction concept, this understanding was placed under Article 19 and Article 21, where the court said that transgenders should have their own freedom of expression to express themselves

Speaker 5with whatever gender they associate with, and under Article 21, in order to preserve their dignity and personal liberty.

Speaker 1And Amal, the NALSA judgment placed emphasis on an individual's own understanding of their gender. So when the Supreme Court recognized the right to self-identify one's gender, What did that mean in practical terms?

Speaker 5Gender identification basically means that a person gets to decide their own gender. So, for example, if someone was born and assigned male at birth, but they identify as a woman, they get to change their gender later on. It's basically what a person understands their own gender and their own gender as. And the court has said that their identification or their understanding of themselves should be protected or recognized under a law.

Speaker 1And Amal, circling back to this latest plea, could you tell our listeners a bit about who are the petitioners and what is the central legal argument they're making?

Speaker 5So the plea is filed by an organization that is primarily based in the UK, but they have an Indian chapter called the Women's Declaration International, which basically advocates for women's rights based on the biological sex. So there is a section in Transgender Act, Section 7, which says that Transgender persons can obtain official documents recognising their gender identity. Now, the plea challenges this, saying that recognising gender identity which

Speaker 5is different from the sex that's assigned at birth could affect protections that are specifically placed for women in law. And they have cited examples where a biological male who may have been identified as a woman was permitted to compete in a woman's category in contact sports and also went ahead to win a state level championship. another example that was cited in the plea where they said that a biological male was appointed as a female nursing assistant

Speaker 5in a government hospital. The plea is also saying that even for biological women who identify with a different gender, they are also excluding themselves from the special provisions that are made for women in law. So essentially what they are trying to say is they want the court to reconsider how law distinguishes between sex and gender, because that distinction could affect how these protections are laid out for women, especially in spaces like women hostels or prisons and sports

Speaker 5like we just discussed.

Speaker 1Right, and you highlight how the petition frames women's rights and transgender rights as being placed in opposition. So how do we read that? Because critics argue that it could undermine the rights of transgender women. Right.

Speaker 5So what they're basically arguing about is who gets to be recognized as a woman under the law. And if some of the safeguards that we have in law, should they be based on sex or should they be based on gender? And some of the rights and protections that are solely for just women, if trans persons are also included in it, could it affect access to personal spaces like hostels or prisons? The court will basically have to advocate on if law can protect the right of a woman. while also recognising the constitutional rights protecting recognition of transgender persons.

Speaker 1And among this petition comes at a time when there's a wider debate over changes to India's transgender rights legislation in 2026. So how does this year's amendment fit into the debate?

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 5So just rolling back a bit to the law that was enacted in 2019, transgender persons could go to a district magistrate for an identity certificate. And what they had to submit was an affidavit declaring their gender identity. I think it had to be supported with proof of residence. This was enacted so that transgender persons wouldn't have to go through surgery or any medical examination to prove it. An amendment earlier this year was tabled in Lok Sabha, which brought changes to this framework. And now the amendment

Speaker 5said that a transgender person needs to go through a medical board. So that medical board will have to be headed by a chief medical officer and a district magistrate who issue a certificate based on the recommendation of the medical board. So essentially, previously, it was like the person's own declaration was enough. But now the medical authorities have come into the picture and they have a role in deciding whether or not a person qualifies for a change in their gender.

Speaker 1And Amal, what could this case mean for a transgender person trying to just get an identity document or just access public services?

Speaker 5Honestly, pleas like these, they affect how transgender persons are also viewed in the society, right? So this has just been filed in the Supreme Court and the court has just tagged with the larger set of matters, the clutch of petitions that already are pending. The court has not really observed anything on the merits of the case or on the arguments. So that's still pending from the court side, but experts and advocates that we had spoken to, they say that this plea essentially focuses on excluding trans women

Speaker 5from being recognized as a woman.

Speaker 1Itself, right?

Speaker 5And that means that a trans person would not be entitled to equal rights and equal protection. And because the community, they already face discrimination in accessing healthcare, in accessing education and employment, in acquiring a proper residential accommodation. So these kind of challenges, they could only make their experience worse, but they could also change or harden public attitudes even before court reaches a decision. Or even if court sides with the transgender or dismisses this plea whatever the court's

Speaker 5position may be such kind of challenges do affect where transgender persons are viewed in the society and it would become more difficult for trans people who come from marginalized backgrounds who already have difficulty in accessing even basic legal protection so it would be quite difficult for them to challenge any discrimination that they may end up facing Right, and speaking of.

Speaker 1The plea, what is the next step for this petition? Like, has the Supreme Court indicated whether it will examine these arguments?

Speaker 5The plea has been filed and what the court has done at this point in time is it has tagged it with the clutch of petitions that are already pending before the Supreme Court on the challenging the 2026 amendment that brings the medical board in the picture and determining whether a person can change their gender identity or whether the person can acquire a certificate changing their gender identity. So the court has just tagged this petition with the larger clutch of petitions and They have not given any observations as of yet, so we still have to see

Speaker 5how that unfolds once it comes up for hearing.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about the Mahadev online betting case, where the Enforcement Directorate has told a special court that the estimated proceeds of crime have now reached around Rs 92,000 crore rupees. even as the betting network allegedly continues to operate. The enforcement directorate made the claim while seeking seven days' custody of Saurabh Chandrakar, who investigators

Speaker 1describe as one of the key figures behind the betting syndicate. The agency says the estimated proceeds have risen from around Rs 11,000 crore in 2023 to Rs 92,000 crore now. As reported by The Indian Express's Jay Prakash S. Naidu, The 92,000 crore rupees figure is spread across multiple platforms. According to the ED, the Mahadev online booking application itself accounts for an estimated 75,000 to 80,000 crore rupees, while

Speaker 1sister platforms SkyExchange.com and Lotus365. com account for thousands of crores more. The agency has so far filed five supplementary prosecution complaints against more than 100 accused and attached assets in India and abroad worth around 9,000 crore rupees. Chandrakar was extradited from Oman earlier this month. The CBI had previously sought his custody to identify police officers, government officials and politicians

Speaker 1who allegedly accepted bribes to allow the syndicate to operate. Investigators say Chandrakar and another accused, Ravi Opal, left India in 2022, set up operations in Dubai and brought more than 100 young people from Chhattisgarh to help run what they describe as a franchise-based illegal betting network across India. Bets were allegedly taken not only on sports but also on elections. The alleged money laundering mechanism was extensive. The syndicate is accused of using bank accounts opened in the

Speaker 1names of poor or unsuspecting people, moving funds through multiple layers of accounts and then sending the money abroad, including through Hawala operators in Mumbai and Gujarat. Investigators also allege... that the games were rigged so operators retained 70-75% of the money, while the network estimated to earn around Rs 450 crore every month. And so what makes the case striking is not simply its scale as such, but the EDs claim that despite years of investigation, arrests and asset seizures,

Speaker 1the betting network has continued to generate enormous sums. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast

Speaker 1or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode