Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Opposition takes on the EC, a dunki route, and Nilekani's paper leak fix

Oct 14, 202628 minAudio

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Asad Rehman about how protests demanding Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation developed into a wider confrontation between the Opposition and the BJP-led government, and why the campaign is now moving from the streets to the Supreme Court. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Brendan Dabhi about three cousins from Gujarat who were kidnapped in Ethiopia while allegedly attempting to reach the United States through the illegal “dunki” route, and how Gujarat Police helped secure their release. (14:35) And in the end, we look at Nandan Nilekani’s proposed solution to examination paper leaks: building a vast digital question bank and generating final papers shortly before examinations begin, leaving little time for them to be stolen or circulated. (25:10) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawa

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at Gujarat where three cousins were kidnapped in Ethiopia while allegedly trying to reach the United States through the illegal donkey route. We also talk about a new proposal to tackle exam paper leaks by generating question papers only shortly before a test begins. But we begin today with a protest that started with questions over the election commission. and has since evolved into a broader political confrontation between the opposition and the BJP-led government

Speaker 1at the centre. After heavy police deployment and mass detentions over the weekend in Delhi, When CJP and Ayesha-led protests demanding Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar's resignation were stopped from reaching Jantar Mantar, on Monday, opposition parties mobilised a larger movement.

Speaker 1Led by the Congress, the demonstrations brought thousands of workers and supporters onto the streets for a march towards the Supreme Court. Now, the immediate trigger was an Indian Express

Speaker 1investigation which reported that over 10 months, election commissioners had objected 14 times to decisions taken by the chief election commissioner.

Speaker 2So once that report, that investigation was published in the Indian Express, the opposition and other civil society groups started a sort of movement saying that, see, we were saying this for a while now.

Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Asad Rahman.

Speaker 2That we had been talking about vote chori and about SIR and pointing out that there's a problem with this. But now once the Indian Express investigation came out, they had more armor in their arsenal, you can say. So once that happened, we saw the Congress that day itself hold a series of press conferences. The next day, Lok Sabha leader of opposition Rahul Gandhi held a press conference and he was very clear that our demands are very simple.

Speaker 3Ki Sarkar Narendra Modi. She is protecting Gyanesh Kumar. On one hand, we are saying that we need a resignation. But actually, we want them to protect him. Because as much as they protect him, in the end, we will go to their controller.

Speaker 2So once that happened, we've seen multiple street protests by the opposition India block. It started off with a march to the Election Commission of India office, which was halted outside Akashwani Bhawan. Then there was a big showdown between the police and Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi. Then there was the protest to Jantar Mantar, which started after a lunch of India block at this restaurant called Sagar Ratna in Connaught Place. Then the next day, there was another lunch at this restaurant called Moet's, after which they went

Speaker 2to Rajghat.

Speaker 4Which is the memorial for Mahatma Gandhi.

Speaker 2Then there were two days when the opposition had no plans and there was an open call from the Cockroach Janta Party in Delhi that everyone should gather at Jantar Mantar. Now, we saw what happened on Saturday and Sunday. There was a heavy police crackdown. Barricades were put up everywhere. Civil society, student leaders, journalists, lawyers, many people were detained and sent to different places across the city.

Speaker 4There was a big crackdown.

Speaker 2It was traveling in central Delhi was like you're traveling in a fortress or in what one would imagine to be like a cantonment of a city because it was heavily barricaded. There was lots of boots on the ground.

Speaker 4There were policemen, CRPF.

Speaker 2All kinds of hands on the deck for the police and administration to curb any sort of gathering at Jantar Mantar, which became the central point for protests in Delhi during the movement demanding Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation.

Speaker 1And it was after this crackdown that the scale and tone of the opposition's next move changed. In fact, Rahul Gandhi appealed not only to India Bloc allies, but also to civil society groups, student leaders, and anyone, in his words, who believed in democracy to join the protest.

Speaker 2Now, this is what the chronology or the sequence of events that have happened that led to Monday's protests in Delhi, which saw a huge number of political workers, civil society members, student leaders gather in Delhi on the streets of Kannad place in central Delhi. And their demands are that CEC Gyanesh Kumar should resign. The SIR should be halted and that the country should return to paper ballots instead of electronic voting machines, EVMs. And if you look at yesterday's

Speaker 2protest and the earlier protest, there's a stark difference. Because as we saw yesterday, Rahul Gandhi was not just accompanied by his allies, but was also accompanied by several student leaders, including Neha Bora was there from ISA. Then we saw NSUI student leaders being there.

Speaker 4Vinesh Phogat was there. These are people who are not MPs because.

Speaker 2Before Monday, the march and the protests that were happening were restricted to the India block MPs which are around 250-300 in both houses of parliament. So this is how it panned out and yesterday's show of strength, I mean if you look at how things panned out yesterday, it did seem that the Congress had put in a lot of planning. What they did was they activated their youth organizations, their frontal organizations, their party leaders, their MPs, their MLAs, their ministers from different states.

Speaker 4So it was a show of strength for the Congress.

Speaker 2And this open appeal sort of resonated with student leaders, with student organizations, civil society members. We saw Yogendra Yadav in the same bus as Rahul Gandhi. Now, he's not an MP, but he sat in the same bus as Rahul Gandhi, Malika Arjun Khadge, Priyanka Gandhi, Badra. So the messaging from Rahul Gandhi and the Congress was very clear that this is not our protest, this is everybody's protest.

Speaker 1Asad says that the protest has also expanded politically. The Congress says it is targeting the Election Commission and the Chief Election Commissioner, but it has also repeatedly asked why the BJP is defending the poll body. And that is why the confrontation is no longer only about the Election Commission.

Speaker 2See, there's no doubt that this is a confrontation not against just against the Election Commission of India. The Congress has been constantly saying that why is the Election Commission and the Chief Election Commissioner being defended by the BJP? So even if the BJP likes it or not, it's becoming a confrontation between the opposition and the BJP government at the center. And the Congress's justification for this is that we are not targeting the BJP. We are targeting the Chief Election Commissioner. Now, when the BJP comes out and defends it, the Congress says that it's very clear that they are the ones who are getting this done.

Speaker 2And this has been an argument that the Congress leadership has been putting across for days now, that when we question the Election Commission of India, why does the BJP feel the need to defend? Let the The EC and the CEC defend themselves. So, yeah, it is becoming a confrontation. Also, if you look at what Rahul Gandhi has been saying in the last few days, he's not just been targeting the CEC. He's also targeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi, calling him a coward on multiple occasions. He's saying that he has unleashed these RSS goons during the flash protest that happened on Saturday and Sunday in Kannad place. We've seen allegations of people saying that there were goons who were

Speaker 2present there. We don't know who they were with, but there are allegations that they were pro-government and they were in defense of CEC Gyanesh Kumar. So he's also not just been challenging the EC, but he's also been challenging the government. If you look at what he said in his video yesterday, he gave an open challenge to the RSS goons.

Speaker 3I was wondering when I was on the bus there, where the cowards of the RSS who were beating.

Speaker 4The young children day before yesterday were. Where were those people? Because I didn't see them.

Speaker 3When we are standing there and when the people of India are standing there, why don't you come out?

Speaker 4Why don't you wear your little scarves and come out and see what happens?

Speaker 2Because Rahul Gandhi has made it very clear that it's not just about the CEC. It's also about the BJP and the prime minister. And he's been constantly saying these four or five people. He names Mohan Bhagwat. He names Ajit Doval, the NSA. Mohan Bhagwat is the RSS chief. Home Minister Amit Shah. He says these people are cowards. They're curbing protests because they're scared of the people of India.

Speaker 4So it's a bravado. Thank you for watching.

Speaker 2And this might become a rallying cry for the opposition in the next general elections or the elections that are coming up. And we have elections in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Manipur, different states, five states in early next year. So it's not just an issue concerning the Election Commission of India, but it's also a political issue. Because what people in Rahul Gandhi's team tell us is that he feels that this can become a mass movement. This can become something that can, what he calls, awaken the people of India that your right to vote is being threatened by the BJP and their system, as he calls them. These five,

Speaker 2six people who've captured institutions, who've captured the Election Commission of India, it's a fight against them for the Congress.

Speaker 4And the opposition.

Speaker 1And here, the Supreme Court is now the next institutional front in this campaign. The opposition warned to meet the Chief Justice of India, but the CGI declined, saying the SIR-related matters were already pending before the court and that the appropriate route was to file a petition.

Speaker 2See, now we have to look at it from a broader lens of how the opposition and the Congress is looking at it. It's not just that they're meeting the Chief Justice of India. They started it by saying that let us march to the Election Commission of India.

Speaker 4They say that was not allowed. We saw it was not allowed.

Speaker 2Everyone was detained. We had a huge showdown at Akashwani Bhawan. We saw what happened. And then they say, we went to go to Janthar Mantar. We were not allowed to go there. Then we went to Rajghat. They were allowed to go there and pay their respects. And it was in advance decided that the day they went to Rajghat, which was Thursday, it was preemptively decided that they will not confront the police that day. They will peacefully go and pay their respects to Mahatma Gandhi and come back. OK, now coming back to the point. So then after that, they went to the president. Then they wanted to go

Speaker 2to the judiciary. So basically what the opposition is doing is that we are going to go to all these institutions, raise our concern about the election commission functioning and about SIR and about what they call vote chori. And we are going to ask them for their intervention. They met the president. Then they say that it was the time to meet the chief justice of India. And if you look at the tone and tenor of the Congress leadership, Malik Arjun Khadge said that we will go to the Chief Justice of India with folded hands and request him to give us time and to hear us out. Rahul Gandhi yesterday also was very quite soft on the judiciary.

Speaker 2He didn't raise any questions on the judiciary. He said he respects the Chief Justice of India and he has been told that he should file a petition and he will do that.

Speaker 4So the judiciary has, on the other hand, if.

Speaker 2You look at what Chief Justice of India Suryakant has said is, that this is an administrative matter, the SIR cases are already pending before the Supreme Court. So the Chief Justice said that there's no question of meeting a delegation from the opposition and that they're free to file a petition, which eventually happened on Monday evening, once the march to the Supreme Court of India was sort of halted.

Speaker 1And this is when Rahul Gandhi moved a petition against the Election Commission. Assad tells us that for the opposition, this is a part of a larger strategy to take the issue to every major institution while also keeping pressure alive on the streets.

Speaker 2So I think it's just they're trying to go to each institution and send that message across to the people of India that we are not here to just protest.

Speaker 4We are going to knock at every door.

Speaker 2We are going to go to every possible institution and ask for their help on this issue. What they call we're seeking their intervention. We've gone to the president. We've gone to the chief justice. Now, whatever is left, they're going to exhaust those avenues as well. So it's very, very interesting to see how the Congress and the opposition, while doing street protests, also have a method to it. Because it's not just we are going to sit here and not leave until you get the resignation, which was something that we saw during the protests that demanded Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation. We are going to go to every institution

Speaker 2because at the end of the day, the Congress is not a pressure group or part of the civil society.

Speaker 4They're a political party.

Speaker 2And what they do and how they do it is also a message to the people of India. So on Monday, when we saw this huge march with like flags of all different parties, student groups, we saw left party flags there. We saw youth Congress flags there. We saw Congress flags there. We saw Samajwadi party flags there. We saw IUML flags there, which is a party which mostly has influence in Kerala. People from Kerala had traveled to Delhi. So it's not just that we will protest, but we will have a method to this protest. And that's what the opposition is

Speaker 2planning to do. And from what I've been told from people within the Congress, that it's Mr. Rahul Gandhi who's calling all the shots. Most of the important decisions are being made by him and his office. And then they're being conveyed to the allies like the TMC, the Samajwadi Party and the Congress is consistently coordinating with all the allies and talking to them consistently so that they don't feel left out. There have been instances when the Congress has sort of, you know, taken the big brotherly approach in the alliance. But at this point, it doesn't seem to be the case. They're reaching out to each and

Speaker 2every party. We saw RJD's Tejasvi Yadav yesterday at the protest. We saw Akhilesh Yadav. We saw Mamata Banerjee was there because she had to leave for Calcutta. Then we saw left leadership being all in presence. So it's not just that it's a Congress protest. It's a protest for everyone, as for the Congress, who believes that our vote isn't under threat and that our democratic institutions are being threatened.

Speaker 4So that's their strategy, it seems, at this point.

Speaker 2And next.

Speaker 1We turn to Gujarat, where three cousins returned home after being kidnapped in Ethiopia while allegedly trying to take the illegal donkey route to the United States. The three cousins, all from a farming family in Mehsana district, had hoped to migrate to the United States. But after one of their visa applications was rejected, the family allegedly decided to send all three through a circuitous illegal route.

Speaker 5A donkey route, in the simplest of terms, is an illegal method to gain entry into a country of one's choice.

Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Brendan Darby, who reported on the story for the newspaper.

Speaker 5In most cases, it means the United States of America, but it's also been used for other countries. It involves travelling through several different countries, including India. routes that go through the Middle East, through Africa, through certain European countries and to either the countries north or south of the US and then to gain illegal entry often by the land border into the United States. This is done through the means of illegal travel agents who charge large sums of money in order to essentially conduct the human trafficking

Speaker 5of people from India into the United States. And we have seen a lot of problems also therein. Several people have died while making this dangerous crossing. However, with stricter border restrictions in place in the US now, especially under President Donald Trump, we are seeing that many people are still opting for the donkey routes in spite of the risks.

Speaker 1In this case, the family had already paid 60 lakh rupees to a network, basically 20 lakh rupees per person. But Brendan tells us that the journey never reached America.

Speaker 5Yes, so there are these three cousins, one age 30 and the other two younger than her, who are all from a single extended family harkening back to Wadasma village of Messana in North Gujarat. So these people all wanted to go to the US, but their eldest cousin, who is 30 years old, Actually, she has someone already in the US on a valid visa, but she was refused a visa. And in fact, some sources say a couple of times actually. And that is why the family may have decided to send her through the donkey route. And

Speaker 5police sources say that since they were already sending her, they decided to send two of her cousins along with her so that they could also start new lives in the US. And so having made this determination, they found a travel agent who was going to make sure that they reach the US. At least he promised them that. And through this network, they sent them out and they flew out from two airports of India. And then via different routes going through the Middle East, they reached Ethiopia. And from there, they were supposed to go. At least

Speaker 5that's what they were told, that they were supposed to go to Canada. And from there, they would have crossed over. But they never reached that far. They stopped at Ethiopia itself. And that is where their torment began, actually.

Speaker 1Brendan says that their belongings were taken away, they were held for about a week, and a man who identified himself as Baba Khan demanded more than 1 crore rupees for their release.

Speaker 5So the cousins had told their family members that they would call them once they reached Canada. So when the family members got a call, the first call after they were abducted, they made the call from the airport in Addis Ababa in Ethiopia, where they had just landed and got together. There they had already been abducted and then coerced to make a call to their family and tell them, that they had already reached Canada. And to further tell their families that they would now call only after reaching the US. So the families back home thought they had already reached Canada and they would soon get the good

Speaker 5news that they had already reached the US. So they waited for some days, but still the call did not come. And the actual information that these people had been abducted came from somewhere else entirely.

Speaker 1And Brandon, perhaps the most interesting aspect is that police officers sitting in a small station here in Mehsana, were negotiating with a suspected kidnapper thousands of kilometers away. So, how did they establish contact with him? And also, what strategy did they use to, you know, negotiate the cousin's release?

Speaker 5So the Lagrang police in Maesana first came to know that these people had possibly been abducted through their sources, through their human intelligence. Because another young man named Vansh had just returned from Ethiopia and it appears that his family had paid a large ransom for him. So when this youth came back to India, he told his family and others that he believed that three people from Messana were abducted in Ethiopia in the same place. He had not seen them, but he had heard about them. So that is when the police began their preliminary inquiry and

Speaker 5went to the home of these three cousins and asked them whether they were in touch with them or not. And when the Family came forward and said that they hadn't been in touch with them for a couple of days. That is when the police invited them to file a missing persons report and then started the work on it.

Speaker 4Finding them.

Speaker 5They then called in one of the family members. They called in the guy who had put them in touch with the network and they sat there and waited for the call from the kidnappers which had already come to them by then. And then they began the negotiation process. This man named Baba Khan called the guy who was in touch with the family. and asked for a ransom of 1 crore rupees. However, the family didn't have so much money. They had already spent Rs. 60 lakh trying to send them to the US. So how could they afford another 1 crore rupees? While they are a farming

Speaker 5family and they have land and so on, they simply said that they could not pay this ransom. So what happened was that the police met the broker and made the family members sit in the police station. and speak to Baba Khan themselves and try to negotiate him down. And at the end of the negotiation, he did come down to about 15 lakh rupees. While on the other hand, these three cousins had been bound and blindfolded and kept in a dark room somewhere in Addis Ababa, apparently. But they were given food on time to eat and so on. So they were not mistreated after the first time.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1And so the kidnappers had demanded more than 1 crore rupees, right? Eventually, they reduced that to 15 lakh and then apparently released the cousins without receiving any ransom. So how did the investigators negotiate that?

Speaker 5So in the meantime, here in Gujarat, Baba Khan was insistent that he be paid at least a nominal amount of 15 lakh down from 1 crore. He had dropped his ransom by 85% and still the family said they could not pay the amount. And the police was constantly negotiating on their behalf, which is a novel idea in itself, because mostly we hear about, you know, diplomatic channels going through and then finding these people and helping bring them back. But here was a small rural police station in Gujarat

Speaker 5that was handling the negotiations themselves. When Babakhan finally understood that these people really had no more money to pay them, He just swore at them and kept the phone down. But fortunately, sometime later, the cousins called from the airport. They had borrowed someone's phone and they called their family and told them that Baba Khan had booked them flights back to India, but had taken all their luggage and phones and everything and just left them with their passports and given them the tickets. And that is how they reached India.

Speaker 1And Brendan, you highlight how villages in Mehsana have many locked homes because the Residents have migrated to America and there persists this aspiration to go to the US. So why is the desire to settle in the United States so strong in this particular region of Gujarat?

Speaker 5Well, I cannot speak to why there is such a desire to go to the US. But obviously, there is this aspiration. It has been well documented over the last several decades, where people have constantly, especially from North Gujarat, from Messana and upper Gandhinagar, and especially these regions, where if you go to some of these villages, which are well known for this immigration, both legal and illegal, you will see even up to half of the villages empty. You know, their houses are locked. Now, while some of them may be staying in major cities, a lot of them have migrated to the US and other countries over time.

Speaker 4So that's how it is.

Speaker 5However, the matter of concern here is that while legal immigration is in the benefit of everyone, This illegal immigration brings up problems of law enforcement and danger to the public and the loss of so much money when the effort totally goes to waste. And of course, there's the problem of illegal immigration, obviously. While these people who try to immigrate and who fail to immigrate or who are deported back, they are considered victims in India. Obviously, it

Speaker 5is a matter of grave concern as immigrants. And Brendan, the.

Speaker 1Alleged kidnapping took place in Ethiopia. But the journey was arranged through agents and contacts here in Gujarat. So can the agents operating from India be held accountable?

Speaker 5The people, if their intent can be established, of course, can be held accountable. I do believe they can be held accountable for trafficking and so on if they know the intent that these people want to illegally enter another country. But however, the matter of finding them and apprehending them is the first order of business. So it can only happen after they are caught.

Speaker 1So let us see. And lastly, Brendan, as we discussed that the family had already paid 60 lakh rupees to agents. And for a farming household, that is an enormous amount of money. So why is it that families are willing to invest so heavily in this uncertain and also potentially dangerous route to the US?

Speaker 5The return on investment is the possibility that they would reach the United States and start a new life there.

Speaker 4That is the hope.

Speaker 5That is the aspiration. Of course, it doesn't always come true. Of course, people may be abducted from the middle. People may be sent back from midway. They may be deported back from the U.S., which we have also seen happen last year. So, yes, a lot of things can happen. And in spite of that, people continue to use these donkey routes to reach the United States.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a proposed fix for India's recurring exam paper leaks. one that would essentially eliminate the traditional question paper until the very last moment. Infosys co-founder Nandan Neelkani, who is heading a high-powered task force on examination reforms, has suggested creating a massive bank of questions and generating the final paper only shortly before the examination begins. As reported by the Indian Express's Dheeraj Mishra and Gayatri Mani, the logic is fairly simple. Neelkani

Speaker 1argues that the moment there is a single, fixed question paper prepared in advance, it acquires value and therefore creates an incentive for someone to steal, sell or leak it. Instead, a large digital question bank could be used to assemble the paper at the last minute, drastically reducing the window in which a leak could occur. Now, this proposal is part of a broader rethink of how national examinations are conducted. The six-member task force was formed after the NEET-UG paper

Speaker 1leak controversy and the subsequent student protests. It was asked to submit its recommendations within three months. Neel Ghani has also pushed for a wider shift towards computer-based testing. He said India currently has around 1.5 lakh locations where students can take tests. But this network would have to be expanded significantly. That would also require stronger infrastructure, including secure centers, reliable internet, IT systems, and better monitoring. And AI could

Speaker 1potentially play a role as well. When asked whether artificial intelligence could eventually generate examination papers dynamically on the day of the test, Neelkani said that was possible. Interestingly, a recent parliamentary committee has made a similar recommendation. It suggested that the National Testing Agency build a large and continuously updated question bank with papers assembled digitally, close to the exam, and then vetted by experts. The task force has already held around 18 internal meetings and 40 consultations, receiving more

Speaker 1than 50,000 suggestions. Its final report is expected by the end of the month. So, the proposed solution is not simply tighter security around question papers. It has to redesign the examination system so that, until almost the last minute, there is effectively no fixed paper available to leak. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Itchha Sharma. If you like

Speaker 1the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode