Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Drought's toll on women, India-Swiss ties, and illicit liquor crackdown

Oct 8, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sadaf Modak about the toll the drought in Maharashtra is taking on the women of the state. She talks about how women have to carry pots filled with water to their homes when borewells and household taps run dry. She also shares how this arduous task is just one part of their already hectic and physically demanding day and what activists are demanding regarding this. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about Swiss President Guy Parmelin's three day visit to India and the bilateral talks held between the two countries. The visit also came as India and the four member European Free Trade Association marked one year of their Trade and Economic Partnership Agreement, which includes Switzerland. (15:19) Lastly, we talk about a police crackdown on alleged illicit liquor trade in Bihar, which resulted in two deaths. (21:51) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about Swiss President Guy Parmelin's three-day visit to India, during which he held bilateral talks with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. We also talk about a police crackdown on alleged illicit liquor trade in Bihar, which led to two deaths. But we begin today by talking about the toll that the drought in Maharashtra is taking on women. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you are listening to Three Things, the Indian Express News Show. For decades,

Speaker 1one of the most familiar images from large parts of rural India has been that of women carrying pots of water on their heads. Often walking in groups and sometimes accompanied by their young daughters, women still have to travel for miles through forests, deserts and some of the country's driest regions to fetch water for their homes. Now, war wells and household taps have become more common. But once they run dry, walking to the next available source is often the only option. And over the past few months, women in Maharashtra have increasingly had to do just that,

Speaker 1as the state grapples with drought in 265 of its 358 talukas. Recently, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis described it as the worst such crisis the state has faced since 1972. And it is also important to understand that for many women farmers, Fetching water is only one part of what can be a long and physically demanding day, something that state's relief measures do not necessarily account for. Recently, the Indian Express's Sadaf Modak travelled to some of the worst-hit districts,

Speaker 1including Marathwada. She joins my colleague Shashank Bhargav to discuss the toll this drought has taken on the women living there.

Speaker 2Sadaf, even after decades of this taking place, it is mainly women that go out to fetch water, right? So, tell us what you saw on the ground in this regard and what toll does this take on women?

Speaker 3Yeah, actually, you're right when you're saying that, because we traveled across seven districts, including most parts of Marathwada. And everywhere on the road, we saw that, of course, there was water scarcity, but that most of the times women were the ones who were involved in sort of traveling far, traveling kilometers to carry water.

Speaker 4On their heads.

Speaker 3And We saw minor girls involved in that work. And of course, the pressure that it puts on the household, there are sort of roles that each member plays. And there are, one is not saying that the men were not doing any work, but invariably in the majority of the places that we traveled through, we saw women and girls still being the ones who were putting in the physical labor of filling water and the situation right now is quite grim in terms of how like one person we spoke to said that one of the two in a couple like either the man or the woman had

Speaker 3to stay back home to fill water considering how much of a task it has become to find a source stand in a queue or wait for the tanker to arrive and then eventually fill water for the house, especially in households where they are living in a rather large joint family or the main thing that we wrote about also to kind of feed water to cattle, to livestock. That became like a whole additional responsibility. And one member of the family would end up having to take that responsibility altogether. And most of those times, the person, the

Speaker 3member was a woman or young girls. And while we were researching for the story, we also found one report by the United Nations, which talks about the progress that has been done on sustainable development goals.

Speaker 4And it had a very interesting number.

Speaker 3It said that In 53 countries where they have been tracking the progress of the Sustainable Development Goals, women and girls spend 250 million hours per day on water collection. And the report said was over three times more than men and boys. So clearly, this seems like an international sort of occurrence.

Speaker 2And Sadaf, can you describe what a typical day looks like for a woman farmer? Because that will, you know, help us understand the kind of work women end up doing in farms.

Speaker 3So this is true of even when there is no drought, but we found this to be a lot more apparent during our conversations now with the water scarcity becoming a daily reality for most.

Speaker 4Of the villages in these regions. Most of the women we spoke to said that they wake up around 4 or 5 a.m.

Speaker 3And the first thing they have to do is figure out those filling up the stock for the day for the livestock for the cattle and for their families and either women girls of the family or all the members of the family would be involved in at least one or two hours in the beginning of the day to go to the spot where because most of the bore wells that people access or taps in their homes that they access have dried up so then to find a source in the village where they can collect water from could be wells could be a tankers.

Speaker 2And how much water does a family typically require, especially those with cattle?

Speaker 3So about one buffalo would maybe have like some 30 to 40 litres of water. Usually in these parts, most of the people would have more than one. Some depend completely on cattle for even their livelihood in terms of like milk and bulls for ploughing. For example, this one farmer we spoke to said that he needs about 1000 litres a day or like one overhead tank. for his entire household including I think some 10 cattle that he had a lot of those people women we spoke to said that they have to fill at least like one large tank and typically in smaller households they wouldn't even

Speaker 3have so many utensils so many tanks to store water so then they would do these trips multiple times in the day to fill up water once in the morning once in the evening probably so that's how it is.

Speaker 2And how far do they have to travel to get this water So this.

Speaker 3Really depends on the area that they come from. So in Dharashiv, which used to be Osmanabad, where we spoke to a few villages in there, women said that they maybe have to walk a kilometre or less than a kilometre to go to a school where they typically got water from. Whereas in Sakri, where in Dhule, in northern Maharashtra, there we spoke to women who said that they had to walk almost like more than, I think, nearly a kilometre and a half to collect water from a small pond. So between, say, like half a kilometre to two kilometres

Speaker 3is what is the situation right now. And they fear that it will get worse and they will have to maybe walk much farther to wells which are filled up once the water scarcity becomes more grim, more apparent.

Speaker 2Okay, so they start their day at four, they go to fetch water, they carry it on their heads, their backs. And, you know, they would take multiple trips for this. What are they doing after that? Right.

Speaker 3So usually for harvest, while they say if people who had large lands would hire labourers to work on their farms, this year, because of the low yield and.

Speaker 4The lack of profit, a lot of family members are.

Speaker 3Also now involving other women in the household to do the harvesting of whatever limited crop there is. or to come left completely sort of harvest even the crop which has not yielded anything which has sort of started burning in the sun so that they can maybe prepare for a rabi crop in case there's a possibility of rain later in november or october november so the women who are working as laborers on other people's fields they end up going to work around eight nine and then work till maybe like five six and then come back home if there is a requirement of more water then go

Speaker 3back to filling water or then cook for the day cook like dinner for the family and that's how that they would end.

Speaker 2And with this drought so much of the harvest has been impacted this year can you talk about the kind of financial stress it has put on families and the kind of stress it has put on.

Speaker 3Women So, of course, there is immense financial pressure on households to meet expenses. A, the crop has not yielded any input. Typically, when it comes to small land holdings, people are in the cycle where they get some money from the previous season, put all of that in the current crop.

Speaker 4Hoping that there'll be some profit.

Speaker 3The situation in some homes we saw was so grim that usually like typically marginalized farmers would have maybe like half an acre of plot.

Speaker 4And they do go for sugarcane harvesting usually anyway, even when there is no drought.

Speaker 3But they carry with themselves, say like bajra and some other household food items that can sustain them, say till they come back, which is around February, March. At this time, we met one family which said that their half acre crop did not even yield any bajra for them to carry with themselves for their own consumption.

Speaker 4So they had to go and buy it from the market.

Speaker 3And that currently because of this situation, the prices have also increased.

Speaker 4So that was an additional burden on the family that they had to buy basic food items like dal or bajra and few other pulses from the market before they went so the family that we spoke to told us how they had to take an advance from the contractor.

Speaker 3Just to buy these basic food grains which typically they would have grown on their own field had rainfall not caused such a havoc and also in a lot of cases where families depend entirely on farming They're also worried about the next season and how they probably will need to take a loan now, you know, to buy seeds to sow them in like the next November, December, if there's any hope for rain and for another season of harvest.

Speaker 2And in that sense, this becomes a vicious cycle, right? You already have financial stress, plus the weather has become unpredictable and the forecast is not good. And on top of that, you have to take a loan, which you probably just cannot afford to default on.

Speaker 3Yeah, so a lot of households, the loans from money lenders, loans through microfinance organizations, to even the budget gut, the self-help group that a lot of women are a part of, typically have women as the loan takers. And that has also put a lot of responsibility on women. So one woman, for example, who we spoke to said that typically she's paying at least 6000 rupees in installments of all these loans. And they end up being in this cycle where to pay one installment, they're taking loan from some other organization. And when it comes to government speaking announcements of, you know,

Speaker 3loan waivers, invariably, they're linked to the expenses in the field directly in the crop.

Speaker 4But what women said is that a lot of these domestic expenses are linked to agriculture, right?

Speaker 3Like, for example, the losses that have been caused because of this harvest season completely being wiped out is obviously going to put a lot of domestic pressure on them in terms of regular spending on food, on education, on health. So women said that, you know, when we take a loan from, say, a microfinance institution or from a self-help group, it invariably is for the household and it is linked to agriculture. But governments typically will not announce waivers of these institutions. So a lot of activists are demanding that now, once the panch namaz are done in Maharashtra and once

Speaker 3the government decides on the relief that it will announce to these drought areas, they should also consider this aspect of maybe stalling or delaying or waiving off some kind of amounts that loans that women have taken from self-help groups or these microfinance institutions, because it is putting a lot of financial pressure on the women. We were told that this has led to a lot of domestic violence in some cases. And it does typically make a household, women in a household that much more vulnerable, where they are bound by their.

Speaker 4Responsibility of paying off these loans.

Speaker 3At the same time, since they are the ones who have been named in these loans, they feel a lot more responsible to sort of paying off these loans at the same time also taking care of the household expenses, which in such situations would like wear them thin.

Speaker 2And you know, the other issue has been that for a farmer to access any kind of benefits or government schemes, the land holding traditionally needs to be in their name. And that's mostly the case with men. And so women don't end up availing a lot of these benefits, right? And it is only now that the government has tried to change that.

Speaker 3Yeah, so a lot of sort of schemes or welfare policies, loans, credit schemes, programs that the government has invariably would need some kind of a documentary proof that you are a farmer, right?

Speaker 4So in that case, the land.

Speaker 3Ownership title would probably be one of the main documents that you're submitting to access those schemes and credit schemes or those sort of any kind of welfare policies. One law enacted by the state of Maharashtra in July called the Maharashtra Women Farmers Empowerment Act. has tried to change that. And it says that irrespective of whether you own land, you will still have a woman farmer certificate, you will still be identified as a farmer, and there will hopefully more access to welfare policy schemes. So that way, it's a welcome change to kind of acknowledge that women are farmers,

Speaker 3even though they may not have land title in their name. Also, this looks at, say, for example, landless labourers, like I said, marginalised farmers may not have land in their own name, but they are farmers nonetheless. So that kind of looks at the new law probably will, when eventually it comes out with programs and schemes, they may kind of be able to fill this gap where for you to be called a farmer, it is not necessary that.

Speaker 4You have land in your name.

Speaker 3It also looks at women who are involved in a lot of allied activities. kind of activities farm related activities like animal husbandry poultry dairy farming livestock rearing so these are aspects which also which will recognize you as a farmer so you may not necessarily traditionally work as a as like a laborer in a farm but even these allied activities would lead for you to be issued a woman farmer certificate under the new law.

Speaker 2And can you also talk about the kind of relief measures the government has come out with so far and whether they address some of these issues that women end up facing The.

Speaker 4Current GR, which was passed after the drought, was announced on the 26th.

Speaker 3The immediate measures that it speaks of in the 265 talukas where drought has been declared is more to do with the.

Speaker 4Immediate crop failure.

Speaker 3So, for example, more like maybe waivers in the revenue tax that is paid or waivers in terms of the losses incurred when the crop has failed, waivers when it comes to electricity bills, waivers when it comes to maybe any other kind of cost that the farmers are paying. So it's obviously more focused towards the immediate need, which is the immediate cost that the farmers have paid. And it also talks about, say, examination fee that children or farmers, you know, when they're going to college and schools, the fees that they'll have to pay, they are weaving of that.

Speaker 3They are talking about water and they're talking about making water available through tankers. Currently, there isn't anything that sort of specifically talks about women. And the government reiterates that it has schemes already. It has the Ladki Baheen scheme through which monthly money is transferred to women beneficiaries. But it does not necessarily speak of the impact of drought on women and typically women farmers. So that is something that I hope that in the next relief that is announced, Activists have also given written requests to the government that

Speaker 3they should probably have a lot more holistic reliefs announced, which take care of this aspect of how the drought impacts women, including the unpaid labour when it comes to, of course, filling water and the household work, as well as this whole aspect of them being the main contributors towards the domestic household expenses through these loans and through microfinance self-help groups. So that is something that women activists are also hoping that will be looked into when the government announces its next relief measures.

Speaker 1And next, we turn our attention to the growing bilateral ties between India and Switzerland. Earlier this week, Swiss President Guy Parmelin was in India for a three-day visit, during which he held bilateral talks with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and met President Draupadi Murmu. The visit came as India and the four-member European Free Trade Association marked one year of their trade and economic partnership agreement, which includes Switzerland. Welcoming the president of a country known for its cheese, Modi gifted Parmalan three special Indian cheese varieties, which were

Speaker 1meant to showcase India's growing tradition of cheesemaking and regional craftsmanship. Now to learn about the key takeaways from this visit and what the two sides discussed, we are joined by The Indian Express's Diplomatic Affairs Editor, Shubhjeet Roy.

Speaker 4Shubhjeet, Switzerland is.

Speaker 1Not a country that people associate having very strong ties with India. So, can you begin by telling us what kind of a relationship has India shared with the country in the past?

Speaker 5Well, India and Switzerland have had a long relationship, especially after the Second World War. What happened was Switzerland, because of its sort of position of neutrality, it.

Speaker 4Was a go between the Indians.

Speaker 5And Pakistanis, especially after the 71 war. In fact, when India and Pakistan both closed their diplomatic missions, their embassies and high commission's each other's capitals. After the war of 71 between India and Pakistan for almost five years, the embassy of Switzerland was functioning as India's high commission to Pakistan and Pakistan's high commission to India. So it has been a very interesting sort of relationship. And now in

Speaker 5the contemporary times, in the The recent years, the economic relationship, the technological relationship has sort of taken the lead. And that is how there was an economic pact that came into force in October last year. And the two sides are celebrating the first anniversary together. of this economic pact, which is essentially an economic pact with a small grouping of countries, which includes some of the countries of that region.

Speaker 5And that's how the relationship is now expected to move forward.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1Now, during this visit, the two sides had talks regarding trade, technology and mobility. And the two countries also signed the Migration and Mobility Partnership Agreement and the Young Professionals Agreement. Can you tell us how this will help strengthen the ties between the countries?

Speaker 4Well, a lot of Indians travel to Switzerland.

Speaker 5You know, as you know, Switzerland became this destination being portrayed in Bollywood, in cinema, from Yash Chopra to kind of Shah Rukh Khan. Their movies were shot there. So there's a lot of tourism potential. And in recent years, education and job opportunities have also opened up in Switzerland. So in banking, in infotech, in high quality machinery, from watches to chocolates to wine, Switzerland has become this destination.

Speaker 5So for all of this, young professionals can now travel to, there'll be an exchange program of young professionals. And also because Indians now travel so frequently to Switzerland, there is a sort of easing of visa regime because to facilitate mobility for up to five years of multiple entry, visa will also be easily available. Of course, on the basis of the credentials of the person, the applicant who is

Speaker 5applying for visa to Switzerland. So I think mobility-wise, it will be an important step forward.

Speaker 1And like you mentioned, the pact allows multiple entry visas for up to five years. Who is likely to benefit from this provision and what changes for them?

Speaker 5So students, businessmen, professionals who want to work there or who travel for work there, all these categories of applicants of Indian nationals, it will be extremely beneficial for this category, this community of people who would like to explore Switzerland and Europe.

Speaker 1And Switzerland had also played an important role in the trade agreement that was signed between India and the European Free Trade Association. Can you tell us a bit about that and how would the agreement benefit the two countries?

Speaker 5Well, as I said earlier, Switzerland is known for its watches and the technology that the Indian business wants to attract is this high precision technology that is used in watches but can be used in other areas as well. Because the Swiss craftsmanship in watches is also visible and available, that capability is available in watches. machinery in very cutting

Speaker 5edge machinery as well. So that is one thing that really opened.

Speaker 4Up, is expected to open up.

Speaker 5And of course, chocolates and wine, these are obviously some of its best known exports. But Switzerland has as I said earlier, has been seen to be a very, very peaceful destination. And it has offered venues for a lot of bilateral and multilateral events and meetings across the world.

Speaker 4So Switzerland actually has.

Speaker 5Had a history of negotiations and diplomacy, especially at the multilateral level. And that's why, that's how It contributed to the negotiations of this particular free trade agreement.

Speaker 1And Shubhjeet, along with these agreements, what were some other topics of discussion between the two heads of state? And where can we expect cooperation in the upcoming months?

Speaker 5Well, apart from this, defense and nuclear areas were seen to be some of the important elements and areas of cooperation. And we'll have to see how that plays out. As I said, Switzerland is known for its high-tech machinery. So that is an area to watch out for both in defense and in nuclear energy.

Speaker 4And in the end, we.

Speaker 1Talk about a police crackdown on alleged illicit liquor trade in Bihar, which led to two deaths. The Indian Express's Himanshu Harsh reported that according to a police statement on October 1st, five alleged liquor traders were freed by local residents after a police team conducting an anti-liquor operation in Behravan, Chakya, Musahari was attacked. On the following Sunday, police came better prepared. Teams from four police stations along with armed police forces descended upon Behravan Chakya Musahari village, looking to arrest those

Speaker 1allegedly involved in the case. What the police didn't anticipate was that in order to evade arrest, around 50 to 60 people jumped into the Punpun river and the next day, two of the bodies were recovered. Locals claimed that some of the villagers were still missing. The incident took place under Pipra police station in Patna district. According to Musahari Sub-Divisional Police Officer 1 Raghav Dayal, on Sunday, a large-scale search operation was initiated during which the police team was again attacked and several vehicles were damaged. Police said 39 accused,

Speaker 1including women, were arrested while around 1,000 litres of illicit country-made liquor was seized, along with equipment allegedly used for liquor production. Along with that, about 6,100 litres of Mahua-based fermenting mixture was destroyed and a country-made pistol and three life cartridges were recovered from the house of one accused. However, the local residents allege that the police operation triggered panic in the village, due to which people jumped into the river while attempting to evade the police. They allege that stones and bricks were thrown during the confrontation and that

Speaker 1the police also hurled stones towards people in the river, making it difficult for some of them to reach the opposite bank. Residents further allege that police entered homes and took away several belongings. Himanshu reported that the two deceased were identified by the locals as Akash Manji and Ram Manji. The police said that after the bodies were recovered, local residents placed them on the Bhetasarmera road, blocking traffic and creating a law-and-order situation. Officers eventually persuaded the protesters to clear the road and sent the bodies for post-mortem examination.

Speaker 1Local residents said that the road remained blocked for hours as protesters demanded the release of those arrested, a compensation of Rs 4 lakh for each deceased person's family and a search for people they alleged were still missing. You were listening to Three Things by Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think

Speaker 1will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Audio and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode