INDIA bloc at Ramlila Maidan, sports funding cut, and Dia Mirza faces BJP's backlash
26 minAudio
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Asad Rehman about the INDIA bloc’s rally demanding Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation, its “public impeachment” campaign, and the BJP’s counter-mobilisation in Delhi. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Mihir Vasavda about PV Sindhu and Lakshya Sen’s title-winning performances at the Hylo Open, the withdrawal of government funding for India’s European badminton campaign, and its impact on players. (10:00) And in the end, we look at the BMC’s removal of a Diwali pollution-awareness video featuring Dia Mirza following objections from BJP leaders, even as similar campaign videos featuring other celebrities remained online. (22:50) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at Indian badminton, where PV Sindhu and Lakshasen won international titles despite the government withdrawing funding for their European tournament campaign. We also take a look at the BMC's decision to remove a Diwali pollution awareness video featuring actor Dia Mirza after objections from BJP leaders. But we begin today by discussing the India Bloc's mega rally that was held at the Ram Leela Maidan over the weekend. Hi, I'm Ichha Sharma, and you're listening to
Speaker 1Three Things, the Indian Express news show. On November 1st, the India bloc, led by the Congress, held a rally at the Ram Leela ground against the Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over alleged irregularities in the ongoing SIR process, following a report by the Indian Express. And the bloc's demand is clear, that given these irregularities... Gyanesh Kumar should resign.
Speaker 2So all India bloc parties which are formally in the bloc and which are part of the opposition bloc that is called the India bloc were present at the rally?
Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Asad Rahman, who reported on the rally for the newspaper.
Speaker 2It was basically a show of strength for the opposition on the issue of what they call vote chori and against the special intensive revision being undertaken by the Election Commission of India. And these wave of protests, if you see over the last month, month and a half, have been after the Indian Express investigation came out, showing that everything was not okay within the three election commissioners and that in 10 months, there were 14 times when they disagreed on certain decisions. And the latest rally that happened
Speaker 2is a part of the larger campaign of the opposition India bloc against the SIR and against the Election Commission of India, headed by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The demand of the opposition is that Mr. Gyanesh Kumar should resign in wake of what has been found over the last month and a half. And that was the main reason for this rally.
Speaker 1Now to learn more about how things unfolded on the ground and how the BJP has responded to it, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to Asad in the segment.
Speaker 3Asad, before we talk about the rally, can you tell us about the other thing that the opposition did, which was to conduct a quote-unquote public impeachment of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar?
Speaker 1Can you tell us what was that about?
Speaker 2So the public impeachment, as the India bloc has been calling it, was... sort of, you can call it a mock parliament, where in Mr. Malika Arjun Khargay's lawns, these elaborate arrangements were made. The seating was done in a way that it sort of emulates the way seats are there in the.
Speaker 4Lok Sabha and in parliament.
Speaker 2Former Speaker of the Lok Sabha, Meera Kumar, was presiding over these proceedings. The initiation of the proceedings was done by Mr. Khadge, who's the leader of opposition in the Rajya Sabha, where he brought out a resolution which had six charges against Mr. Gyanesh Kumar, alleging that he has been biased and he has not followed procedure and the SIR is an exercise which is against India. The main contention at that public impeachment was that Mr. Gyanesh Kumar
Speaker 2has to go and what he has done is treason. Speeches were given by the leaders of all the India Bloc parties. There were also some people, the opposition said, whose names had been deleted in the SIR and they also spoke about their struggles. And there were some student leaders, including Neha Bora. There were some civil society members like Mr. Yogendra Yadav and some lawyers who had spoken there. So it was basically a show because the opposition says that we've we've submitted motions in the Lok Sabha and the
Speaker 2Rajya Sabha for impeachment of Mr. Gyanesh Kumar. But that's not been accepted by the speaker. So they say that they were left with no choice but to go forward with this public impeachment program at Mr.
Speaker 4Khargay's house. And it became quite a spectacle at the end of it. Mr.
Speaker 2Rahul Gandhi also said that it is quite unusual for so many MPs to be sitting in a setting like the lawns and garden of Mr. Khargay's house. And that it was because the doors of all the institutions in this country are shut that they had to do this public impeachment of Mr.
Speaker 4Gyanesh Kumar.
Speaker 3Right, now coming to the rally, talk about how that went and what were the things that were highlighted by Rahul Gandhi in his address?
Speaker 4See, Mr.
Speaker 2Gandhi, if you look at his speeches over the last two years, he's been consistent. He's been even before the investigation by Indian Express came out and this issue became was highlighted again. I think even before that, he's been saying that there are irregularities within the Election Commission of India, that the Election Commission of India is biased and that it's not doing its job as a neutral body.
Speaker 4Under Mr.
Speaker 2Gyanesh Kumar, he repeated those allegations. He made some new remarks also that day.
Speaker 4One was that where it started from Mr.
Speaker 2Khargay saying in Bihar to some supporters, saying something to him that Modi ka baap bhi jaayega.
Speaker 1Modi ka baap bhi jaayega.
Speaker 5Modi ka baap bhi jaayega.
Speaker 2Which basically means that even Modi's father is, with Mr. Khargay's language barrier, Hindi not being his mother tongue, what he meant is that even Modi will go and even his ideological parent body, RSS, it was a dig at the RSS, will also go. So from there, it went to the BJP doing a counter that Modi kahin nahi ja rahe hain. And at Sunday's rally, Mr. Rahul Gandhi said that he named Mr. Amit Shah and said that Modi ab kahin jayenge bhi nahi kyunki hum unko jane nahi denge because he has to face.
Speaker 4The law for what Mr. Gandhi describes as vote chori.
Speaker 2Then he was very clear, his speech was very clear that They're not going to rest till Gyanesh Kumar is made to resign and that all three of them, Mr.
Speaker 4Shah, Mr. Modi and Mr.
Speaker 2Gyanesh Kumar are going to face legal action once the time comes.
Speaker 3And Asad, would you say we are witnessing a wave of anti-incumbency given the events that have unfolded since July?
Speaker 2I think the way to measure anti-incumbency is to wait for results of elections. And we have UP coming up. We have Manipur coming up. We have Uttarakhand coming up. We have five states that are going to go to elections early next year. And to make any assessment of the anti-incumbency or issues within the government or within the people against the government, I think the best way to gauge that is to wait.
Speaker 4For election results.
Speaker 2But yes, I think as far as the narrative is concerned, there are also concerns within the BJP that the BJP and the government has lost the narrative and that they're doing a follow-up job now and reacting to what the Congress and the India block does. But as far as the anti-incumbency and electoral issues are concerned, I think we should wait for election results for these five states to come in, including Uttar Pradesh, which sends the highest number of Lok Sabha members, has the highest number of seats in its state assembly. So let's wait for the UP
Speaker 2elections and see what happens there and the other states as well.
Speaker 4Punjab also.
Speaker 3And we understand that the BJP also organized a counter rally in the capital, right? Can you tell us more about that and how the party has responded to the India blocs rally?
Speaker 2The counter rally the BJP had been saying that November 1 is the anniversary of the anti-Sikh riots of 1984 and that the Congress is disrespecting Sikhs by doing this rally on that specific date.
Speaker 4They also did some protests in the capital.
Speaker 2There were also press conferences from the BJP claiming that the crowds didn't reach Ramleela Maidan and the Congress rally.
Speaker 4Was a failure. And the Congress has countered those allegations. And we saw Mr.
Speaker 2Amit Shah, who's the union home minister, yesterday do a march in Hyderabad against anarchy, as they are calling it, of the opposition and the Congress. So that's one of the things that the BJP and the government is sort of now following the what the Congress is doing. And that is where I think the shift of the narrative is being suspected. I wouldn't say that it's happened because unless we see these things reflect in election results in the coming months, we shouldn't jump the gun on whether
Speaker 2the BJP has lost ground or not.
Speaker 3And Asad, keeping all of this in mind, what can we expect from the opposition in the upcoming days?
Speaker 2See, the Congress and the India bloc, hasn't decided on its next course of action.
Speaker 4There is also the festive season that's here.
Speaker 2I think the next one week or so is going to be somewhat of a break from these protests. And the Congress, I'm sure, and the India bloc will come out with something new. But the thing is that the Congress and the India bloc cannot go back now. Anything that they do has to go a step up. So there are street protests happened and the Ramleela Maidan happened and now they have to go up and go beyond that, make a bigger spectacle of things. So I think the Congress and the India Bloc allies are discussing how they can take it forward. But eventually what the Congress and
Speaker 2leader of opposition, Mr. Rahul Gandhi is convinced of is that this issue of the right to vote being compromised by what he calls a compromised election commission of India is going to become a mass movement in this country.
Speaker 4We're yet to see that.
Speaker 2But he and the Congress feels that it's going to become an issue of the people and that it's a political issue and that it's going to become something that the people are going to stand up against.
Speaker 1And next, we turn to Indian badminton, where two of the country's biggest stars, PV Sindhu and Lakshya Sen, have won international titles despite an unexpected setback, the withdrawal of government funding for their European tournament campaign. On Sunday, Sindhu and Sen won the women's and men's singles titles at the Hilo Open in Germany. For Sen, it ended a year-long wait for a title, while for Sindhu, it marked
Speaker 1her second major title of the year, something she had not achieved since 2017. But behind these victories was a funding controversy that had left several Indian badminton players struggling to cover the costs of competing abroad. An investigation by the Indian Express has revealed that the Sports Authority of India, or SAI, declined to fund the Indian contingent's participation in four consecutive tournaments in Finland, Denmark, France and Germany. And the players were reportedly informed of this decision just days
Speaker 1before the first tournament began. So to understand what exactly led to the withdrawal of funding and how did it affect India's badminton players during this campaign, we're joined by The Indian Express's Mihir Vasavda, who led the investigation for the paper. Mihir, before we get into the funding dispute itself, Could you help our listeners understand why this four-tournament European circuit was so important for India's badminton players? Like, what was at stake for them?
Speaker 6Yeah, so I mean, if you look at the bigger picture, these four tournaments might not seem that important. These are not your World Championships or Super 1000s or any of those events. But in their own way, they had a meaning for the shuttlers individually. So for example, Lakshasen has had a tough year. For him, it was important to get a good run of results, get a couple of big wins, maybe a tournament and a title and all those things. For him, it was important that sense. For
Speaker 6PV Sindhu, she's making a comeback after a quiet couple of years. And for her, a good run of results in these four events would mean she'd maybe push closer and closer to the year-end World Tour Finals, which is a prestigious event. And it would kind of get her back into top 10, top 5 of the world rankings. For some younger players, Ashmit Achali or Tanvi Sharma, they're still kind of you know learning the ropes at the international circuit so for them every ranking point matters so
Speaker 6for every player there were individual targets so even though the tournament by themselves might not have been prestigious although this is debatable something like a French Open is big enough it was meaningful and important in their own ways for individual players Right.
Speaker 1And competing internationally, of course, involves a lot of resources. So in that terms, how important does government funding become?
Speaker 6So let's start with an example. PV Sindhu, of course, she travels for all these tournaments. There's flight, food, stay, travel, everything included. She has her own coach, a foreign coach with her. So she has to or someone has to foot the bill for him as well. Since she is on a comeback trail and her body is recovering after, I mean, she had injury and she's coming back from that as well. So she has a sports science expert, Wayne Lombard, traveling with her in some tournaments. And the European Swing was one such thing. So that's an additional expense.
Speaker 6And then you have physios and everyone else. Roughly, for PV Sindhu, these four tournaments, which started in Finland, then moved to Denmark, proceeded to France and ended in Germany, this estimated around 20 lakh.
Speaker 5That's a big amount.
Speaker 6For younger players who might not be traveling with their own personal coaches or physios, the amount would be less, but still you have to pay for your flights, your travel from the airport to the hotel, to hotel to the venue.
Speaker 5There is entry fees. There are so many variables.
Speaker 6Here that you end up spending lakhs of rupees to play in these tournaments.
Speaker 1Right, and this is where your investigation comes in. We know that PV Sindhu and Lakshasen have just won titles in Germany. But you mentioned how they had been competing across Europe without any government funding. So what exactly happened here? And when did the players first learn that their financial support had been withdrawn?
Speaker 6So the first tournament of this four was in Finland. It was the Arctic Open, which began on October 6. And what we understand is around October 1 or something about that is the players got to know that they'll have to fund their own trips except for the hotels in Finland.
Speaker 5They were informed about it via WhatsApp message.
Speaker 6So whenever there is a competition, WhatsApp group is formed in which there are officials from the federation and all the players are there just to have proper logistical coordination and all those things. On that WhatsApp group, they were informed that they'll have to manage their own things.
Speaker 5So that happened.
Speaker 6We spoke to PV Sindhu, who has been on the circuit for more than a decade now. And she said she was shocked when something like this happened. It hadn't happened before. And when they were told that they'd have to fund their own travel, stay, food, everything, it came as a shock.
Speaker 5But she did not entertain the thought of withdrawing from this event.
Speaker 6Now, she funded partially herself and then Olympic Gold Quest, her backers also chipped in. The problem for some of the younger players who might not have a support system or the financial resources like Sindhu, the problem for those players ran deeper.
Speaker 5Maybe we'll get into it later.
Speaker 1And Mihir, you point at two very different explanations for why the funding was cut. So what exactly did the officials say?
Speaker 6Richa, what we have been told what happened is there are two sides to the story. There are some people involved in the running of badminton in India. They say that the sports authority of India was not happy with the performances at the Asian Games. Now, the Asian Games in Japan got over last month. And it was the first time since 2014 that India did not win a singles medal. So the SAI apparently was upset, according to some people. We posed this question to SAI and they
Speaker 6said that it isn't the case and the funding wasn't cleared because the proposal from the Badminton Association of India came in late. Now, when we say proposal, it means there is a detailed budget where you give the names of the players, the hotel where they'll be staying at, the entry fees for the competition, the flight details and everything. You make a proposal and Sai said that the proposal has to reach them 30 days before a tournament. And the Badminton Association of India missed that deadline. And hence,
Speaker 6the tournament funding wasn't cleared for any of the players.
Speaker 1And so, how did the funding withdrawal affect players' access to coaches?
Speaker 5It depatted, I would say, in mixed ways.
Speaker 6So, for example, what Sindhu said that just the last minute nature of the withdrawal meant that they had to arrange everything by themselves just three or four days before leaving for these competitions. So that was a hurdle which they had to face before leaving the country. Then there were other issues. So, for example, few players did not have coaches in their corners. I'll give you a couple of examples. At the French Open, Ashmita Chalia had a fellow player, Isha Rani Barua, in her corner when she
Speaker 6beat Akane Yamaguchi, one of the best players in the world. The reason for that is she did not have a dedicated coach because the players could not afford to pay for the coaches since they were already paying for themselves and the federation did not have the resources to fund everyone's trip. Like Ashmita Chalia, Tanvi Sharma, who reached the quarterfinals in Denmark, also had no coach to guide her during a match.
Speaker 5So that was one part of the challenges faced.
Speaker 6The other problem was the sustenance itself. Now, India had 26 players at the Arctic Open, which was the first of the four tournaments, and all 26 played there. Then when the Jamboree moved to Denmark, six players pulled out. When they traveled to Paris for the French Open, seven players withdrew at the last minute. And at the Hilo Open in Saarbrücken, Germany last week, nine players with you so progressively the number of withdrawals increased as the weeks passed and we don't know for sure if it was
Speaker 6because of the financial uncertainty but the coincidence is.
Speaker 1There and Mihir despite everything happening off the court Indian players have given some outstanding results culminating in Sindhu and Lakshasen winning the high low open so how significant is this Yeah.
Speaker 5Not just them.
Speaker 6We mentioned, you know, Ashmita Chalia's stunning win against world number three Akane Yamaguchi at the French Open. Anmol Karb, another young player, reached the semi-final of the Hilo Open. Tarvi Sharma made the quarters in Denmark. So, those were also remarkable performances. But then, the icing on the cake was the twin titles that India won last Sunday.
Speaker 5So, Lakshasen.
Speaker 6winning his first title this year in the singles and Sindhu winning her second title this year. So it was the first time since 2017 that she won two super 500.
Speaker 5Or higher titles in one year.
Speaker 6And like we discussed, it brought her back to world number six, which means that her prospects of qualifying for the year-end world two finals have brightened considerably.
Speaker 1Right. And you spoke with a senior official at SAI who has said that funding will resume for future tour But will the players be reimbursed for this tournament, especially with the remarkable performances they've given?
Speaker 5No, that's the interesting bit.
Speaker 6And what we've also learned today, that's the day after the original report was published, is our colleague Shivani Naik has found out that even for the World Junior Badminton Championships, the funding wasn't clear. Now, these championships were held from October 5 to 7 in Cairo, and the Indian junior team nearly did not attend. make it to Cairo for the similar reason because the Sports Authority of India said that the proposal for the tournament came in too late and it was the reason they could not release the funds. So,
Speaker 6not just these four tournaments but also the Junior World Championships that the players could not go to. We asked SAI pointedly two questions. A, whether the funding will be restored, to which they said yes. For the tournaments going forward, the proposals will be clear. And second, we asked if the players would be reimbursed, to which they said no. So whatever expenses players have incurred so far, they won't be getting it back.
Speaker 1And Mihir, is this an isolated incident? And what you highlighted about the speculation that how this decision might have been linked to India's Asian Games performance. Should sporting performance influence funding?
Speaker 6That is a question that would require us a longer, proper episode to discuss the merits of it.
Speaker 5What is essential is to have a uniform policy.
Speaker 6And if, you know, performances are linked to funding, then there has to be a thorough review, an objective review.
Speaker 5I mean, it is for.
Speaker 6Anybody to guess the reason what's happened because nobody has claimed officially on record the reasons why the funding was stopped so well sai is claiming one thing the officials on the other side are saying the other but yeah i mean it's tough to answer immediately whether performance and funding can be linked because it's a slippery slope then given that indians are not world beaters in every sport So if you go down that road, then where do you stop, right?
Speaker 5Whether there should be accountability? There should be.
Speaker 6It's something that PV Sindhu herself has said. But yeah, in a country where the starting point for a lot of athletes is tough, the first break is tough enough financially, and even in terms of something as basic as getting the right space to play, it doesn't. will be a very tough ask to link performance with funding. Most importantly, it should be done in a manner that the policy dictates and not arbitrarily. And no, so this hasn't happened before, according to Sindhu and another official we've spoken to from
Speaker 6the badminton fraternity. Sindhu has been around for more than a decade, as I've mentioned before. And she said this is the first time something like this had happened to her. And other people we spoke to in the badminton circuit too said that they haven't noticed anything like this happening, at least in the last two decades.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about how Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation is removed a Diwali pollution awareness video featuring actor Daya Mirza after objections from BJP leaders. Even as similar campaign videos featuring Madhuri Dixit and cricketer Ajinkya Rahane remained online. The BMC had asked Mirza to urge Mumbaikars to avoid bursting firecrackers during Diwali amid concerns over deteriorating air quality in the city. But soon after the video
Speaker 1was posted, Mumbai Mayor Ritu Tawde objected to Mirza being chosen for the campaign. As reported by the Indian Express's Pratip Acharya, Tawde said her objection was not to anti-pollution message itself, but to the actor. She argued that Mirza's earlier public positions, including criticism of the Narmada project, the Uniform Civil Code, and statements associated with the Prime Minister, made her an inappropriate choice for a civic campaign. Tawde went further, describing Mirza as anti-Hindu and saying she had
Speaker 1been blacklisted. Mumbai BJP chief Amit Satam also criticised the video, saying people did not need lessons from Mirza on how to celebrate Diwali. BJP minister Nitish Rane separately accused her of selectively commenting on Hindu festivals. Within hours of the criticism, the BMC deleted Mirza's video from its social media platforms. Mirza responded by saying she had not taken any money from the civic body for participating in the campaign. A BMC official said the administration removed the post following the
Speaker 1public backlash, but maintained that its position on restricting firecracker use remained unchanged and was in line with Bombay High Court directions. Interestingly, the BJP's ally Shiv Sena did not support the removal. Deputy Mayor Sanjay Gadhi said there was nothing inappropriate in Mirza's message and argued that the real issue was that elected representatives had not been consulted before celebrities were selected. You were listening to Three Things by
Speaker 1The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...