First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Rural Affairs and Agriculture Editor Harish Damodaran about India’s emerging milk-fat shortage, why ghee and butter prices are rising, and whether consumers could face further increases. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Amitabh Sinha about COP31 in Turkey, the growing gap between global climate commitments and action, and why the Paris Agreement’s 1.5-degree target is slipping out of reach. (08:40) And in the end, we look at a Diwali-night argument over firecrackers in Uttar Pradesh that allegedly escalated into a shooting, leaving a Rashtrapati Bhavan security staffer seriously injured. (19:05) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at COP 31 in Turkey, where countries are once again confronting the growing gap between global climate promises and actual action. We also take a look at Uttar Pradesh, where a Diwali night argument over firecrackers allegedly escalated into a shooting that left a Rashtrapati Bhavan security staffer seriously injured. But we begin today by talking about why are dairy fat prices rising And could
Speaker 1consumers face further increases? Hi, I'm Ichha Sharma and you're listening to 3 Things, the Indian Express news show. India is the world's largest producer of milk, accounting for nearly a quarter of global production. And over the years, the dairy industry here has expanded considerably. supported by millions of farmers and an extensive network of corporatives. But despite that scale,
Speaker 1the country is now facing an unusual problem, a shortage of milk fat. And the impact is beginning to show up in the prices of some of the most commonly consumed dairy products, particularly ghee and butter. In fact, just earlier this month, Amul increased the price of its cow ghee by Rs 40 per litre. while the Karnataka Milk Federation raised the price of its Nandini Ghee by as much as Rs. 135 per litre. Now, these increases come
Speaker 1at a time when demand for high-fat dairy products is growing, even as the country's milk production is expanding at a slower pace. But what's interesting is that India is not necessarily facing a shortage of milk itself. The problem lies in what that milk contains.
Speaker 2See, generally what has happened is more and more of your milk production in India is now coming from cows rather than buffaloes.
Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's National Rural Affairs and Agriculture editor, Harish Damodaran.
Speaker 2Buffaloes generally have about, you know, it can be 6.5, 7%, it can even be about 8% fat. Whereas cow milk, generally the fat content is less, you know, so... As a higher proportion of India's milk production is coming from cows, so therefore there is that much less of fat which is being produced.
Speaker 1So essentially, we need to look at the two main components of milk solids. The first is milk fat, which is essentially for making products such as ghee, butter, cream and many traditional sweets. The second is what the dairy industry calls solids not fat, or SNF, which includes proteins, lactose and minerals, and is used in products such as skimmed milk powder. And while demand for fat-rich dairy products has been rising... Demand for the non-fat component has not
Speaker 1increased at the same pace. This difference is particularly visible in the prices dairy companies receive.
Speaker 2And especially, you know, what happened during the Tirupati laddu controversy, right? I mean, it was found that a lot of the laddu was being made using adulterated ghee. But generally, I think now the authorities, you know, FSSAI, you know, the Maharashtra food inspectors, you know, everybody, I mean, I think the awareness has increased, you know. So because of that, what is happening is that the adulteration also is coming down. So that is further reducing the total quantity of so-called ghee, you know. So the ghee and khoa, etc., which you're
Speaker 2getting are probably less adulterated than they were maybe two years back or three years back. So I would say both these. And generally, I think our consumption of fats is growing, you know. So your fat consumption is growing. So India has this problem, you know. We are producing probably a surplus of SNF and probably the demand for fat is not catching up. And that's why you see the prices of ghee now going up, you know. You won't get good ghee, you know, that is pure ghee for less than 800 rupees per litre. If someone is
Speaker 2giving it to you for 700 rupees, 650 rupees, you can be sure that it has been adulterated.
Speaker 1Additionally, Harish highlights that in September 2025, the government reduced GST on several dairy items. Tax on ghee, butter and cheese was brought down from 12% to 5%, while ice cream moved from 18% to 5%. Packaged paneer was made tax-free. So these reductions naturally made dairy products more affordable and, according to industry experts, helped stimulate consumption. And there is also the question of exports. Over the last two financial years,
Speaker 1India exported substantial quantities of ghee, butter and anhydrous milk fat, particularly when international prices were high.
Speaker 2So India was exporting a lot of ghee. So there was a time when I think the year before last, your global prices of ghee, of fat shot up. So because of that, a lot of fat got exported, you know, and probably I think the government will have to be very careful about exports. You know, you can allow exports in consumer packs, you know, like if it is branded consumer, you know, if it is going as a Amul ghee or something, it's fine. But I think we should be very careful about exporting fat in bulk, you know, especially if it is amidress, milk fat, etc. Because the fact is,
Speaker 2we have a structural problem today, you know, which is that the fat consumption is growing, whereas probably the SMP, that is the SNF portion is not growing that much, you know. So to that extent, India has to be a little balanced.
Speaker 1So what explains this growing imbalance? One important factor, Harish says, is a gradual change in the composition of India's dairy production. Traditionally, buffaloes accounted for a larger share of the country's milk supply. Now, buffalo milk generally contains between 6.5 and 8% fat, significantly more than cow milk. But over the years, farmers have increasingly preferred cross-bred cows, which tend to produce more milk and begin lactating earlier than buffaloes. As a result, the
Speaker 1share of buffalo milk in India's total production has declined from roughly 57% at the beginning of the century to around 45% today. That means India may be producing more milk overall, but the proportion of fat available from that milk is changing. And then there is the larger question of how quickly India's milk production can expand. According to estimates from the US Department of Agriculture, India's milk production growth is expected to slow to 2.5% in 2026 and
Speaker 12% in 2027, partly because of tightening feed and fodder supplies and concerns about animal productivity. And climate conditions could further complicate this.
Speaker 2So I don't expect El Nino's impact to be on milk production immediately because the past experience suggests that, you know, whenever there is a drought here, what happens is actually milk procurement by dairies goes up because milk is a source of daily liquidity. So what happens is when there is drought, farmers stop growing regular crops, you know, say wheat, say rice, say sugarcane. Because farmers prefer not to grow these crops. And instead, what they do is they prefer, you know, whatever little water is there, they try and,
Speaker 2you know, reserve it for the animals, you know, including growing fodder, etc. So what happens is in that very first year, your milk production will not fall. But what happens is that the farmers will tend to feed the animals in milk more, you know. So suppose there is a cow which is already giving milk, they will give more fodder to that cow, you know. And suppose earlier they were sending, say, a buffalo for slaughter, you know, they'll keep that buffalo for one more season. But what happens is that the pregnant cows, the calves, they all
Speaker 2don't get enough fodder because all the fodder is being used for the animals which are already yielding milk. So what happens? So you'll see the impact of drought, etc., fodder shortage, etc., Coming not now, but the effects will be next year. Because the calves that have been underfed, they won't grow to be cows which can... Their entire pregnancy and lactation cycle gets disrupted.
Speaker 1And next, we move our attention to Turkey, where world leaders, diplomats and climate negotiators have gathered for COP31. the annual United Nations Climate Summit, at a time when one of the world's most important climate goals appears to be slipping out of reach. Back in 2015, nearly every country in the world came together to adopt the Paris Agreement, committing to keep global warming well below 2 degrees Celsius above
Speaker 1pre-industrial levels, while pursuing efforts to limit the increase to 1.5 degrees. The idea was to prevent the worst consequences of climate change by reducing greenhouse gas emissions and gradually moving away from fossil fuels. But more than a decade later, the world is nowhere close to meeting that ambition.
Speaker 3Because, you know, we are expecting a little too much from the cops, actually.
Speaker 1That's The Indian Express's Amitabh Sinha, who reports on climate action for the paper.
Speaker 3The COPs have delivered what they had to deliver. They have set the climate targets, the temperature targets that we are all familiar with, 1.5 degrees Celsius. and 2 degrees Celsius targets. And they have also laid down the broad rules for international climate action. What now remains to be done is that individual countries have to take climate actions. And together, these climate actions should be able to do
Speaker 3enough to reverse or fight the problem of climate change. Now, that second part is not happening. And it's not COP's fault because, you know, there is no mechanism within the COPs to force the countries to do more. Now, that is one perspective. The other perspective, look at it from the country's perspective. Now, there is a valid argument to suggest that, look, the targets that were set in the
Speaker 3Paris Agreement, the 1.5 and 2 degrees target that we talk about, these targets were too difficult to start with. They were too ambitious. In fact, you know, the Paris Agreement sort of relies very heavily on the moral force and the good conscience of the countries to, you know, do good for the world as a whole, not look at their own interests, not forego, prioritize global interest over
Speaker 3their own economic interests, their own developmental needs. That is not something that happens. Now, that is an inherent weakness of the Paris Agreement. And the results of that, it's unfolding right now.
Speaker 1And this is the backdrop against which COP 31 began in the Turkish city of Antalya on Monday, and is expected to discuss ways to accelerate climate action and build on commitments made during previous summits. But there is little expectation of any major breakthrough.
Speaker 3The COP process still has some meaning, a lot of meaning. In fact, you know, climate change has dropped in the global priority list for global agenda. It has dropped down. You don't see climate discussed as vociferously as it was. It used to be just two to three years ago at different global stages. You know, earlier it used to be the main agenda, G20, G7, all regional forums in trade talks and everything. Now, it's not happening. I mean, climate is not the biggest agenda on these different forums,
Speaker 3but it is the main agenda on this climate meetings. The climate meetings have been constructed specifically to discuss climate change. And the problem of climate change hasn't gone away. There are other problems that have come up. There are wars that have come up. There is an energy security crisis that is staring us in the face and all sorts of things, more emergent things are requiring our attention. But the climate change hasn't disappeared. You have to deal with it. You have to, you know, find ways to come up
Speaker 3with actions, collaborate, cooperate with each other and deal with the climate change. And that's what we will see happening at these COPs. So, they are not irrelevant, but to expect them to come up with something that will miraculously prevent the 1.5 degree centigrade breach or 2 degrees breach, that is something that is, we are confusing what its role has to be.
Speaker 1Now, of course, over the years, COP meetings have produced several important agreements, most notably the Paris Agreement itself. But they have struggled to ensure that countries actually deliver on their commitments.
Speaker 3And, you know, a lot has been done. It would be a mistake to say nothing has happened. There are thousands of actions that are being taken across the world, both by states like governments and also by non-state actors like corporations, civil society organizations, even individuals. All sorts of actions are being taken. a lot of these actions also have a variety of co-benefits in terms of, say, poverty reduction, in terms of better livelihoods, in terms of food security,
Speaker 3in terms of energy security. Lots of co-benefits also come out of these actions. Now, again, we come back to the fact that even though lots of these climate actions are being taken, they are not adequate. They are not adequate to meet the 1.5 and 2 degrees targets. So then we come back to these targets, whether they were, you know, too ambitious to start with. And it's actually very clear, you know, even if we bring down the entire emissions, entire global emissions to zero right now, things
Speaker 3are not going to change for the next three, four decades.
Speaker 1Amitabh, you have covered quite a few of these conferences. So tell us, after 30 years of co-ops, are we reaching a fatigue point in the process? Or does the fact that countries still show up signal hope?
Speaker 3So not exactly a fatigue point. And I think countries not just show up, most of them show up quite enthusiastically and in a lot of hope. But more than fatigue, there is certainly an element of frustration. And that frustration emanates from the fact that the pace of climate action so far in the last 30 years that, you know, the world has been trying to fight climate change, the pace of climate action has not been commensurate to the
Speaker 3scale of the problem. Now, I'm sure a lot of our listeners would be aware that last year, 2024, the 1.5 degree temperature target was breached. So one year, the 1.5 degree target has already been breached. And going by the current trend, it's likely to become a normal affair in maybe 5 or 10 years that consistently the annual temperatures would be 1.5 degrees higher than the pre-industrial times. While
Speaker 3at the same time, the global emissions, emissions of greenhouse gases, which are the main reason for global warming, those emissions are still rising. So the frustration actually comes from this, that the pace of climate action, what needed to happen, basically, that has not happened till now. And therefore, we are likely to miss the 2030 targets as well. And, you know,
Speaker 3the 1.5 degree target, as I said, is almost out of reach already. And the next, you know, the fear is that even the 2 degree target is likely to go out of the window very soon. So the frustration emanates from that. But I think most countries, if you ask them, are still hopeful that something can be done. Right.
Speaker 1And Amitabh, besides this, and we've actually spoken about this earlier as well, that developing countries are clearly frustrated with the lack of adequate climate finance and technology transfers as well. So would you say the trust deficit between the global North and South has now become the biggest obstacle?
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3I mean, finance, technology certainly are issues that frustrate the developing countries. They are extremely disappointed with the fact that the developed countries have not even taken adequate measures to reduce their emissions, right? I mean, as our readers would also be aware that the United States has pulled out of the Paris Agreement. It happened immediately after Donald Trump became president. Now, the important thing here is the United States is still the largest historical emitter By historical emitter,
Speaker 3I mean, you know, since the start of the industrial age till now, cumulatively, the United States has produced more greenhouse gases than any other country. And therefore, under, you know, the polluters pay principle sort of a thing that the climate change architecture applies, the United States also has the biggest responsibility to do the cleanup action, meaning it has the biggest responsibility to, you know, one, mitigate its emissions, I mean, reduce its emissions. and to also provide finance
Speaker 3and technology. So the United States is a key player here, and it has just abdicated its responsibility by having moved out of the Paris Agreement. So the way the international climate architecture is designed, It puts a higher degree of responsibility on the developed countries to reduce their emissions, to provide money and to provide technology to the developing countries to help them fight climate change. And that has not been fulfilled. The developing countries have been angry, have been
Speaker 3very disappointed and extremely frustrated.
Speaker 1And in the end... We talk about a violent Diwali night dispute in Uttar Pradesh's Bhagpat, where a 26-year-old man, posted with Rashtrapati Bhavan security, was shot in the head after an argument over bursting firecrackers. Saurabh Tomar had returned to his village, Gopalpur Khadan, to celebrate Diwali with his family when the confrontation took place.
Speaker 3As reported by.
Speaker 1The Indian Express's Manish Sahu, Saurabh and members of his family were bursting firecrackers on the road when two neighbours, brothers Dhiraj and Monu, objected. The disagreement initially involved Saurabh's elder brother Vineeth, but police say it soon escalated. Dhiraj allegedly pulled out a countryman. pistol and opened fire. The bullet first struck a wall and then hit Saurabh in the head. The accused are also alleged to have assaulted Vineeth and threatened the family before fleeing. Saurabh was rushed
Speaker 1to hospital, where doctors performed surgery and removed the bullet. Police said his condition was stable at the time of the report. An FIR has now been registered against Dheeraj and Monu on charges of attempt to murder and police say efforts are underway to arrest them. Now, there may also be a longer history behind the confrontation. Saurabh's father, Janak Raj, has alleged that the two families had an old enmity and and said his sons were attacked after the accused arrived while they were bursting crackers. Police have
Speaker 1not independently established that claim. Saurabh, who has reportedly been posted at Rashtrapati Bhavan for the past seven years, got married around two years ago and has a nine-month-old child. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Itchha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family.
Speaker 1This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...