Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Maharashtra's new textbooks, cost of tourism, and a missing Indian

Nov 2, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Pallavi Smart about Maharashtra’s revised Class 6 textbooks, the greater emphasis on ancient Indian knowledge, and the removal or rewriting of passages dealing with caste and social inequality. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Nikhil Ghanekar about the environmental cost of rising tourism and large-scale development in Himachal Pradesh, and the measures recommended by a Supreme Court-appointed committee. (08:00) And in the end, we look at a Chhattisgarh family’s search for 21-year-old Vineet Kumar Dubey after a job offer took him to Russia, where he was reportedly detained amid fears that he could be drawn into the war in Ukraine. (24:05) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In today's episode, we take a look at Himachal Pradesh, where the Supreme Court is examining the environmental cost of tourism and large-scale development. We also talk about a family in Chhattisgarh searching for their 21-year-old son after a job offering in Russia turned into a disappearance and fears that he could be drawn into the war in Ukraine. But we begin today by talking about Maharashtra, where a major revision of school textbooks and has changed how Class 6

Speaker 1students are being introduced to subjects ranging from gravity to ancient Indian history. Over the past few years, we have repeatedly seen chapters rewritten, historical references altered, and even entire

Speaker 1sections removed, often triggering debates about what children should be taught and how India's past should be presented. In 2023, for instance, the NCRT's textbook Rationalization Exercise saw portions dealing with the Mughal Empire and the Delhi Sultanate reduced. a class 12 chapter on Mughal courts dropped and references to the 2002 Gujarat riots removed. Then in 2024, the NCRT's new class 6 social science textbook introduced the Harappan civilization

Speaker 1as the Sindhu-Saraswati civilization, brought in Ujjain as an ancient reference point for longitude and removed earlier discussions on caste discrimination and B.R.M.

Speaker 2Bedkar.

Speaker 1While these revisions were explained as efforts to reduce curriculum load or align teaching with the national education policy, they also raised questions about how history is selected and presented to students. And now, a similar set of changes has emerged in Maharashtra. An investigation by the Indian Express said, Comparing the old and new Class 6 textbooks published by Maharashtra's Balbharti Textbook Bureau has found significant revisions across history,

Speaker 1geography and science. When our colleague Ishita Singh spoke with the Indian Express's Pallavi Smarth, who led the investigation for the paper, here's what she told us.

Speaker 3Under the new education policy 2020, the entire school curriculum in Maharashtra is undergoing changes for which state curriculum framework has been prepared by the state government, which is based on recommendations of national education policy 2020. Class 1 saw the curriculum changes last year. This year, classes 2, 3, 4, 6 witnessed curriculum changes. Other classes are to follow in the coming years. The idea is to align the school

Speaker 3curriculum with the recommendations of National Education Policy 2020.

Speaker 1Take geography for instance. The earlier textbook introduced the prime meridian through Greenwich, the internationally recognized reference for longitude. The new textbook adds a historical account of a Jain, stating that ancient Indian astronomers regarded the city as a central reference point and developed the concept of base longitude. Another newly introduced section traces geographical knowledge to the Vedas, Puranas, Upanishads and the Surya Siddhant. It describes the earth through

Speaker 1the ancient concept of Saptadvip or seven islands. and attempts to connect these descriptions with modern geographical regions. The textbook also places the Vedic account of the universe's creation alongside the Big Bang theory. Meanwhile, in the new science textbook, Isaac Newton now shares the chapter on gravity with ancient Indian mathematician Bhaskaracharya II.

Speaker 4I'm not sure if we can call it Vedicization because this is for experts to decide. With absence of written proofs on ancient Indian knowledge system, unlike the modern concepts, this has always been a topic of debate and it has come under spotlight after greater emphasis on Indian knowledge system by the NEP 2020. It is evident not only in school education, but also in higher education courses.

Speaker 2We can surely.

Speaker 4Say that these concepts were not part of the older textbooks, the previous textbooks of class 6th. But now we can see these concepts are introduced in the class six textbooks. Also, as Balbhardi has stated that these changes are in line with the National Education Policy 2020 recommendations, which, as I already said, has greater emphasis on Indian knowledge system.

Speaker 1Pallavi also tells us that in history, Sushruta, described as the father of surgery, now gets a detailed account of his medical contributions, including techniques for reconstructing the nose. Chanakya, who previously received only a brief mention, has an expanded section covering the Arthashastra, governance, taxation, defence and his role in Chandragupta Maurya's rise. But it is these changes to the history textbook that raise a different set of questions.

Speaker 1The old Class VI book explained that the Varna system, initially associated with occupations, became hereditary, over time giving rise to caste divisions and social inequality. The revised book removes that explanation. Instead, it briefly states that Vedic society was divided into four Varnas– Brahmana, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Shudra.

Speaker 4Well, there is no particular reason given for this officially. From my interaction with several experts, I have gathered different sets of opinion. While there are some who are saying that this is clearly an ideological shift, there are others who have simply noted that this could be because certain nuances or details of the concept like caste are likely to be introduced in later stages, that.

Speaker 3Is, maybe in higher classes. According to curriculum experts, such changes in the.

Speaker 4Curriculum outcome or learning outcome of a certain class can change in the process of curriculum or syllabus changes.

Speaker 1But alongside these additions, several passages dealing with caste discrimination, priestly control over religious knowledge, and the relationship between social inequality and the emergence of Jainism and Buddhism have been removed or substantially rewritten. Like passage which described how the priestly class developed a monopoly over knowledge of religious rituals and how social status became determined by birth rather than achievement has also disappeared. There is also a change in

Speaker 1the explanation of the decline of the Harappan civilization. While the earlier text book, listed invasions by foreign tribes among the possible causes. The new version mentions changing river courses, natural calamities, and declining trade with Sumerian civilization, but omits the invasion explanation.

Speaker 3Again, there is no particular reason given for this one too.

Speaker 4As of now, what we know is based on our comparison of two textbooks, the previous one and the new textbook. While the previous one included foreign invasion as among the factors contributing to a decline of European civilization, the new textbook does not include it. It only focuses on factors such as drying up of rivers, earthquakes, decline in trade, etc.

Speaker 1And next, we take a look at the impact of increasing tourism and large-scale development on the fragile ecology of Himachal Pradesh. Over the years, Himachal Pradesh has witnessed a steady rise in tourist footfall, along with growing infrastructure development to accommodate this increase. However, this has also raised concerns about the mounting pressure on the state's natural landscape and resources. Now, last week, the Supreme Court took up a matter concerning

Speaker 1ecological and environmental issues in the state. In this case, the court accepted the first report of the Central Empowered Committee, a specialized environmental body, which in this case examined things like compensatory afforestation, tourism, road development, and hydroelectric projects in the state. And the report identified serious shortcomings in the state's environmental protection and recommended measures to address them.

Speaker 2So, this issue dates back to July last year.

Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Nikhil Ghanekar, who reports on the environment for the paper.

Speaker 2When a bench of Justice J.B. Pardewala and R. Mahadevan, they were actually examining a different matter which related to the construction of a hotel in a green area of Himachal Pradesh. And while hearing that, the bench actually expressed its views that The ecology and environment of Himachal Pradesh were in danger. In fact, they went to the extent of saying, and I quote, that the day is not far when the entire state of Himachal Pradesh may vanish. As it rang alarm bells on the deteriorating environmental situation

Speaker 2in the Himalayan state. And the reasons behind this was that it had noted that the state was constantly getting battered by one extreme weather event after another, followed by a natural disaster. So it flagged all these ecologically sensitive matters. Why? they recorded their views and observations so while you know saying these things they also took up this matter of the larger environmental protection of the state and instituted a public interest litigation suomoto that is where it all began.

Speaker 1Now a bench of the supreme court which is looking at this issue has given the Himachal Pradesh government two weeks' time to file its response to the recommendations which have been made by the Central Empowered Committee. So to learn more about the recommendations and the key environmental concerns flagged by the committee, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to Nikhil in this segment.

Speaker 5Nikhil, first tell us, what is the Central Empowered Committee and why was it formulated in the first place?

Speaker 2So, the Supreme Court Central Empowered Committee is a statutory authority which has been long there, almost over 20 years now, which was instituted originally in the landmark case on forest protection known as T.N. Godavarman case. And their job essentially is to be like a watchdog of the Supreme Court to monitor their orders, its compliances, orders related to the environmental protection, forest protection. So Supreme Court usually whenever they have to look at environmental issues at large or issues

Speaker 2of environmental degradation, it directs the Central Empowered Committee to look at such matters. Right, and what exactly was the CEC asked to study in Himachal Pradesh and what all did it take into consideration for its first report? So, the Supreme Court along with the CEC and Amicus Curiae, Mr. K. Parmeshwar,

Speaker 2they arrived at this nine thematic areas to look at while examining this issue. And these thematic areas were zoning, forest cover, mining, compensatory afforestation, the hydroelectric projects planned in the state, the road expansions that are happening, tourism and construction developments. These were largely the thematic areas. Now, the CEC has been given time to, you know, examine these matters, not only by obtaining information from the state government and

Speaker 2its departments, but also it has been given the freedom to go on the ground, verify these things firsthand, also rope in experts. What has happened so far is that in the first report that has been submitted to the Supreme Court, they have, you know, submitted a report on four thematic areas. This includes one, obviously, is tourism. The others are hydroelectric projects, road expansion that have been undertaken and compensatory afforestation. Right.

Speaker 5And Nikhil, now coming to the CEC's findings, it found out that tourism and especially religious tourism has grown quite a lot in the state, right?

Speaker 3So.

Speaker 5What did it say and what were its recommendations regarding what the state should be doing about it?

Speaker 2So as we all know, Himachal is endowed with great beauty and the Himalayan range attracts a lot of tourists. There are several hill stations, obviously Shimla being the most popular one. People go higher up to Lahore, Spiti and Kangra. So what has happened is that the hotel registrations and homestays registration has really shot up. in the last 10 years. That has been one of the biggest observations. And because of the increased footfall, and the data that the CEC

Speaker 2has collated is from 2016 to 2025. Now they have seen that because of the increased footfall, obviously, there is a lot of pressure on the natural resources, but the planning by the state has not really kept pace. And that is where the problem lies, that there aren't enough capacity building measures to manage the waste. Let's begin with the most basic one. Second, What about the cars that have come in? You know, the vehicular density is really shot up because so many people visit the hills to escape the harsh summers in the plains of northern India.

Speaker 2So the state hasn't been really able to keep up with this pressure. If we talk about specific granular data, then the report says that homestays have risen 670% almost in the last 10 years, whereas the hotels have increased by 90%. These are the registered hotels, by the way, registered hotels and registered homestays. As far as the capacity is concerned, none of the departments have actually conducted any carrying capacity studies. Now, what is a carrying capacity study? It basically means that they do not have an idea

Speaker 2of what is the threshold of tourists, let's say, or vehicles that should be allowed over a specific place. So CEC has recommended as far as tourism is concerned that in the immediate measure, these kind of carrying capacity studies should be undertaken. In fact, they have also gone on to say that if need be, there should be temporary restrictions in some of these major tourist destinations.

Speaker 5And keeping in mind this increase in footfall and the large scale development projects, talk about the deforestation that has taken place and has that also resulted in compensatory afforestation? Has that worked?

Speaker 2Yeah, so compensatory afforestation also is one of the major areas that they examined for this report. And the data is actually quite startling in terms of the compliance. What they have found is that out of 17,598 hectares of forest land that has diverted under the Forest Conservation Act, and of this forest land that was diverted... the compensatory afforestation that has to be carried out, you know, as per law, there is still 10% compliance that is yet to be carried out or it's still pending. So usually

Speaker 2what happens is that when a forest land is diverted in our country under the relevant laws, then that project proponent, they have to work along with the state government where this is being taken up and they have to find land where compensatory afforestation can happen on double the area of land that has been diverted for the said project. So that is essentially what is compensatory afforestation and usually some of money which is known as net present value is paid to develop these forests and regenerate them etc. So they found out that hydroelectric projects and road projects

Speaker 2were the two sectors which accounted the highest for the diversion of forests. But as far as compensatory afforestation is concerned, they noted that there was a substantial shortfall in the expenditure of the funds that were released. So in the period between 2021 and 2025-26, the Himachal government was allocated 865 crores by the government of India. But out of the allocated 865 crores, the amount that the state spent was 592 crores, which was an unspent amount of 31%

Speaker 2was left. So overall, they noted that the expenditure was lower from what was approved and also what was sanctioned. And this reflected poor planning and management on the part of the state, the committee said. They also went to certain sites of older hydroelectric projects, which were started in the 80s and the 90s to see whether the compensatory afforestation was done. In some cases, they positively noted that it was done, but in some cases, it still remained incomplete. In fact, they also made a note of how the survival in certain sites, compensatory afforestation sites was really poor.

Speaker 5And we understand that the road sector was also examined mainly for its ecological consequences in the Himalayan terrain. Tell us what was found out upon examination.

Speaker 2So as far as roads are concerned, even Himachal Pradesh is actually witnessing a lot of highway expansion projects, not only at the state level, but also at the level of the National Highways Authority of India, which is from the union government side. So what we know so far based on this report is that out of 1628 kilometers of the national highway, which has been assessed in the past, Almost 993 kilometers fall in the high vulnerability zone and 11 kilometers are in the extreme zone. Then, you know,

Speaker 2with regards to the state highway, almost 2200 kilometers of state highway is present of that 1112 kilometers fall in the high vulnerability zone. And as we all know, this is a Himalayan terrain and for any expansion to take place. What happens is that the cutting happens through the forest areas, through slopes. And worryingly, the CEC has noted that, in fact, in some places, there is a near vertical cutting, you know, disregarding the guidelines that are laid down by the International Road Congress. And then CEC also visited a lot of

Speaker 2road projects to review what is the scenario there. They also visited places where landslides have happened in the past. And some of the most important recommendations that they have mentioned is that there is a system of clearances in our country and at the state level and at the central level when it comes to in all kinds of projects. Now, when it comes to highway projects, they do not necessarily have to go to the central government for environmental clearance. There is no environmental impact assessment done usually for projects which are of certain length. Now, the CEC has recommended

Speaker 2that this should change and that Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change should actually review this whole process so that there are environmental impact assessments done for such large road expansion projects. Secondly, they have said that there are several spots in Himachal which are seeing repeated landslides. And in fact, the NHCI itself has approved 825 Crow for restoration and stabilization on the Kiratpur-Manali corridor. After geological investigations identified 44 critical landslide in erosion locations. So the problems

Speaker 2are of different orders and multifold. It is not one specific thing that is affecting. But at the root of it, what we can understand is that because it's a vulnerable environment, fragile terrain, any kind of major blasting or cutting typically either in Himachal or Uttarakhand or the northeast also, the entire terrain gives way pretty quickly if it is not done in an environmentally sound and scientifically sound manner.

Speaker 5And Nikhil, the CEC observed that a high concentration of hydro projects creates cumulative ecological pressures. Tell us about that. What kind of pressures are they talking about?

Speaker 2So, you know, as far as hydroelectric projects are concerned, when the expert committee, I mean, the empowered committee says that there are community effects. So, let's say at the very top of a river basin or a specific channel of a river, there is one large hydro project planned. It impacts the catchment area because there is going to be felling of trees and forests and the biodiversity loss will happen because of the construction of the project. And the most fundamental thing is obviously the environmental flow of

Speaker 2the river. Now, what does environmental flow exactly mean? I mean, it's essentially the kind of minimum water flow that is required or necessary when we are taking into account a river's water body's health. Especially in this matters for river valleys, I mean rivers that really originate from high valleys in the mountains. Because any kind of reduction in the water levels, building up of silt that typically happens when hydropower projects are operational. So they will create cascading impacts downstream. So

Speaker 2the downstream effect as they call is what the committee is talking about. And people often say that a large project is the one that usually creates damage. But when you have several hundreds of projects planned, they may also create issues. Obviously, not all of them are operational. Many of them are still in the planning stage. But the data that we have, it shows that projects below 10 megawatts account for 866 of the 1000 odd projects that have been kind of planned. And 136 of them have been already commissioned. 470 remain under clearance or investigation. Apart

Speaker 2from this, we would also like to inform that this is some of the other data that has been collated as far as hydroelectric projects are concerned. 31.9% or 5598 hectares was due to hydro projects. So that accounted for the highest share of forest diversion. Secondly, if you look at the basin-wise data, so of the 1000 projects that we mentioned that are being planned and are at separate different stages across Satlaj, Bihar, Chenab, Ravi and Yamuna rivers. So this is the scale of the hydropower projects planned

Speaker 2and that is why the CEC has warned that this is actually a good time to pause and take a view of what kind of impacts all these projects might have.

Speaker 5And Nikhil, when can we expect these recommendations to be implemented? And do they have the potential to mitigate disasters?

Speaker 2So, that's a good question. I mean, typically in cases like these where the Supreme Court is really going into the depth of the scale of development planned in any state, this is just the first of probably two or three reports that the CEC is going to file before the Supreme Court by examining all the nine thematic areas that we talked about earlier in the conversation. So, only four areas have been examined so far and There will be more examinations that will happen. There will be more investigations into what is the environmental degradation that has happened because

Speaker 2two of the main thematic areas that actually cause more severe degradation such as the status of the forest cover and mining is yet to be examined. So, we will understand the full picture of what is at stake when it comes to the state's ecology and environment only when all the reports combined are placed before the Supreme Court and As far as how soon, it actually depends on whether the Supreme Court feels compelled enough after reading the first report to pass any orders in the interim. So if they feel that certain immediate restrictions have to be

Speaker 2put into place, let's say vis-a-vis the expansion of certain road stretches, tourism footfall, then they might actually pass some interim instructions. But only time will tell whether the Supreme Court is compelled enough to do that. They will again hear this matter later in December and we'll get to know soon about what they feel of these initial findings.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a family in Chhattisgarh searching for their 21-year-old son. after what appeared to be a promising job offer in Russia, turned into a deeply disturbing disappearance involving fears that he could be drawn into the war in Ukraine. Vineet Kumar Dubey from Bilaspur was looking for work when he was offered a job in Russia as a food storage supervisor at a restaurant with a promised salary of around $ 1, 200 a month. As reported by the Indian Express's Jay Prakash S. Naidoo, The

Speaker 1company reportedly paid for his tourist visa and flight tickets, but Vineet was never given a formal job contract or even told which city he would be working in. He left India on 29 September and reached Russia on 1 October. After travelling to Volgograd, he spent several days alone in an apartment while staying in regular contact with his family. Then on 6th of October, the situation changed. Vineet called his sister sounding frightened and told her that the company had misled him and was forcing him to work as

Speaker 1a delivery worker instead. Later that night, he told his father that he was being taken somewhere and warned the family not to panic if his phone was switched off. That was effectively the last direct conversation they had with him. His sister subsequently contacted the Indian embassy and filed a complaint through the government's MADAD portal. According to her, she was informed that Vineeth had been placed in a detention centre after allegedly being found carrying an illegal substance and

Speaker 1that he had been provided a lawyer and translator. The family's fears deepened when another Indian man allegedly called them demanding 3.5 lakh rupees for legal help and claimed Vineeth could otherwise be trained and sent to fight in the war against Ukraine. Vineet later sent a voice message from detention apologising to his family and saying he feared he could remain trapped for years. The family has since received an unverified message claiming that Vineet died by suicide, but

Speaker 1authorities have not confirmed this yet. Local police and the Bilaspur administration say they have contacted the Indian Embassy and the Ministry of External Affairs. So for now, Vineet's fate remains unclear. And what began as an overseas job opportunity has become a desperate search for answers across borders. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's

Speaker 1show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode