EC's U-turn, pollution from Pak, and all Agniveers to be inducted
30 minAudio
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Ritika Chopra about the impact of The Indian Express investigation on the Election Commission of India, the reversals that it led to and the changes in Form 6. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Sophiya Mathew about the deteriorating air quality in Delhi NCR and the sharp rise in the AQI. She also discusses the implementation of GRAP stage II in the region and how Pakistan is worsening Delhi's pollution levels. (15:10) Lastly, we discuss the Union Cabinet's decision to allow all Agniveers a chance to join the armed forces as regular soldiers. (27:30) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about Delhi NCR's deteriorating air quality and how some of the pollution appears to be coming from across the border from Pakistan's Punjab province. We also discuss a new decision which will allow all Agniweers a chance to join the armed forces as regular soldiers. But we begin today by talking about the Election Commission's latest U-turn post the Indian Express investigation. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you are listening to Three Things, the
Speaker 1Indian Express News Show. On 23 September, the Indian Express reported that two of the three election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had formally objected on record at least 14 times over the preceding 10 months to decisions taken by the election commission. Many of these decisions, they argued, were unauthorised and illegal. These included changes to Form 6, which is used to enroll new voters, as well as
Speaker 1decisions on who could and could not fully access the Commission's ECINet portal. Since then, the Commission has effectively reversed almost every.
Speaker 2Decision that had been objected to.
Speaker 1The Commission has also said that there will be greater oversight of the way it functions, along with an audit of ECINet. And now in its latest decision, the commission has removed the Special Intensive Revision or SIR declaration from the online version of Form 6.
Speaker 2So what does this latest change mean?
Speaker 1And what does it tell us about the series of reversals within the election commission? To understand this, my colleague Shashank Bhargav speaks to the Indian Express's Ritika Chopra, who led the newspaper's investigation into the election commission.
Speaker 3So Ritika, we know that one of the objections that both Sandhu and Joshi had made was that changes had been made to Form 6, which the Election Commission can't do. Only the central government has the power to do that. And one has to make an amendment for that to be possible. But despite that, a change was made. An extra question was added to Form 6. It asked new voters whether they or their parents or grandparents exist in the electoral role of the last SIR. So talk about
Speaker 3the significance of that change before we talk about what the commission has done now.
Speaker 4So.
Speaker 5Look, Form 6 essentially is a statutory form. So when a proposal to the effect, in the sense of proposal to amend Form 6 to introduce a declaration in that form, a declaration essentially where the applicant would declare whether he or his parents or his grandparents were part of the last electoral roll drafted under the last SIR exercise, which happened across the country in different years, but mainly in the early 2000s. So when that proposal came in May,
Speaker 5Vivek Joshi had said on file that he didn't object to the proposal. I would want to make that clear. Although he did say that we can't amend it, you have to send this across to the government. So why don't you bring back this proposal? You know, again, this is how officers speak on file that, you know, if they don't agree with something, they will write, let's put up the file again, you know, with sort of the fresh proposal under which we would actually root this through the central government. And his colleague Subir Singh Sandhu agreed on file. And now, of course, we haven't been able to speak to either of them. The presumption here is
Speaker 5that's where the matter did rest. What happened in July was that in the online version of the form, Form 6, so there is, of course, a physical Form 6. There is an online version on ECI Net Portal. In that form, a question similar to the declaration proposal of May was introduced between two sections, sections J and K. And this essentially, again, asked you to declare whether your name.
Speaker 4Whatever, your parents, your grandparents were there part of the electoral roll.
Speaker 5What was very interesting is that as part of our investigation, what came forth was that when.
Speaker 4This actually happened, this happened without the knowledge of the two election commissioners.
Speaker 5And one election commissioner actually then writes on file that he has found out about this from a report in the Indian Express. And this was a break that our colleague Damini Nath had, if I'm not wrong, on the 12th of July. And that file noting actually makes a reference to Damini's story, saying that, you know, he's finding out about this from newspapers. When did this happen? Because we did discuss this. This is just exactly opposite of what we've discussed.
Speaker 4And.
Speaker 5You know, he basically, and I'm not quoting here, but says something to the effect that, you know, this is going to lead to harassment of young and new voters and that this change is unauthorized and illegal and should be removed immediately.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 3And this part was significant because it showed us that these two election commissioners were essentially being kept in the dark about the final decisions that the commission was taking.
Speaker 5Yeah, because again, I would like to qualify that I'm presuming here, but it's quite evident from the files that you can see that there is a discussion that happens. They're clearly under some form of impression that of that same proposal will come back in a new form, hopefully with the clause that let's send this to the government. And lo and behold, two months later, they find out from the media that change has already been made to the form. So clearly two of them were in the dark about this.
Speaker 3Okay, so this change was made. Talk about what did the commission say after the investigation was published? What did it have to say about the Form 6 and the objections?
Speaker 5So that's actually the interesting part. The investigation appears on the 23rd of September. On that day, a press note comes out where, frankly, none of the objections is addressed individually, but the commission insists that all its decisions were taken in accordance with the law.
Speaker 4But it doesn't deny the.
Speaker 5Objections, but there's sort of this oblique reference statement to it saying that you know any commissioners note are essentially let's consider them these as inputs into a larger consultative process so that's how the press note labeled these objections but three days later even more interestingly they come out with a list of nine decisions which kind of more or less address all but two or three of these objections. In that, when I say all except two or three, to my mind, Form 6 was partially addressed because in
Speaker 5that they first say that the SIR declaration to Form 6 actually has been upheld by the Supreme Court. And given that the SIR exercise is over in large number of states, so this form will not apply to those states, the non-SIR states. and would remain part of the SIR exercise in the remaining states. So to my mind, it was like, but then even if, for instance, it's in force for states which are currently, you know, getting their roles revised intensively, this doesn't address the question that Sudhir
Speaker 5Singh Sandhu had flagged, which was that, how is it that we've.
Speaker 4Introduced this question in the online form?
Speaker 5Like, if it is not okay for all states of the country, how could it be okay for about 15, 16 states of the country?
Speaker 4So which is why to my mind, and this is something that we had.
Speaker 5Actually reported on the 27th of September based on their second press note, that this is something that kind of still remains unaddressed.
Speaker 3And what was also interesting was what the Supreme Court said about the Form 6 on the 12th of October.
Speaker 5Yeah, so there was a petition filed on the strength of our investigation, basically questioning the inner workings of the commission.
Speaker 4And just while hearing that, the court did make an observation.
Speaker 5I would like to call it was just an observation, but it did kind of interject and say that we want to clarify that we have neither approved nor disapproved of any change to Form 6. So that was a court stand that you know, which to our minds at that point was interesting because it came against the backdrop of the commission's 26th press note, which said that.
Speaker 4This was upheld by the Supreme Court.
Speaker 5Anyway, so when the election commission filed its affidavit before the Supreme Court on the 26th of October, aside from the fact that it denied most of, at least it insisted all its decisions were, again, there was nothing wrong with those decisions.
Speaker 4There are a couple of revelatory things.
Speaker 5One of them, of course, was that it said on the 21st of October, a meeting was held by the.
Speaker 4Electoral roll division.
Speaker 5It was decided to pull out the SIR declaration from the online version of Form 6. And this will now be a separate form. Of course, we reported that back then also, what the ECI's affidavit had said. But our story today essentially is that that assurance, I wouldn't say assurance, but sort of that information that the commission had put before the Supreme Court has now been officially implemented. So now when you log in onto the ECI net portal, you select your.
Speaker 4State, whichever state you're based in.
Speaker 5Earlier, for instance, if you'd selected a state where SIR was already over, to give you an example, let's say Uttarakhand, that declaration would not pop up between sections J and K.
Speaker 4But for instance, in.
Speaker 5Maharashtra, if you selected Maharashtra, that declaration would pop up. That's not happening anymore. So on the ECI and at corporal, you see form 6 and you see the declaration separately. So that again, which again, I had mentioned earlier, to our mind, it was partially addressed. This does in a way completely address that issue that was flagged by one of the two election commissioners.
Speaker 3And earlier, the Election Commission, as part of its justification, had said that they had done this for convenience, right? Adding that question to the online version of Form 6.
Speaker 5Yeah, if you log in and you fill one form, then you have to fill one OTP.
Speaker 4So you fill another form, another OTP. I don't know, we're a country of OTPs. Almost everything seems to be running on that.
Speaker 5But okay, that was the commission's defense before the court that this was done for the convenience of the applicants. Having said that, in the same breath, in that affidavit, and I should have mentioned it, it does acknowledge that there were some concerns.
Speaker 4Again, a very.
Speaker 5Oblique reference to what Joshi ji and Sandhu ji had flagged on the file that there were some concerns that the way these changes were made to the online version, it may be construed as an amendment to Form 6. Interestingly, like I mentioned earlier, neither the affidavit nor the two press releases of 23rd and 26th of September deny any of those 14 objections. Of course, it tries really hard to at times dub them, you know, as inputs or, you know, part of consultation, consultative process.
Speaker 4And the bottom line for.
Speaker 5The commission in court was that all our decisions have the approval of the three commissioners.
Speaker 3And Ritika, talk about some of the other changes that the commission has made pertaining to the issues that were raised by Sandhu and Joshi and that your investigation also talked about.
Speaker 5So since the 23rd, if you carefully look at it, so with Form 6, essentially, this completes a full reversal of everything that the two commissioners had a problem with and it's now been reversed. So that process actually started with the press note of 26th of September, where they did announce about seven or eight decisions. you know some of them as small as and which is why I mean that also as small as now from henceforth there
Speaker 5will be minutes in agendas of the commission meeting which actually is a huge comment on the fact that you didn't even have that and the two commissioners were fighting to get something that basic done to now you know from here on if Officers of the commission have to travel abroad. They will seek our permission. Again, something which one would assume is standard process in every government department or even constitutional authority was not being done here. To them saying that, OK, fine, let's audit ECI Net Portal to see that it's sort of operating.
Speaker 4In accordance with the law.
Speaker 5Although it never mentions it and it's part of our investigation, this exact same proposal was made by Joshi on file. it didn't really go anywhere to a point that maybe a couple of weeks later on file, Mr. Sandhu records that what happened to that proposal doesn't seem to have gone anywhere. So after the investigation appears, you know, that idea or proposal is accepted and then an audit is proposed. And other than that, again, to my mind, the most important were two developments.
Speaker 4One that election commission announced a special.
Speaker 5Drive to enroll all voters, which it felt had been, quote unquote, left out of the SIR process. So you kind of had a second chance to come back onto the electoral roll. And secondly, that, you know, on the ECINet portal, the election commission finally was listening to officers on the ground and it started relenting on many issues. demands that were being made by the officers on the ground. And frankly, these demands were not unwarranted. They were essentially just saying that allow us to do what the law wants us to do.
Speaker 2Give us our powers back.
Speaker 5So essentially, I think the correct description would be that the commission started restoring the power of its officers on this portal.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 3And one of the main things that your investigation talked about was that EROs were not being able to access ECI net properly. It was not allowing some EROs to add and delete names from voter lists. For example, in Goa, there were these 97 voters which were eligible to be part of voter rolls, but EROs were not being able to add them. And that pointed to a potential centralization of this entire exercise and that raised larger concerns.
Speaker 5Yeah, the problem was that once I am in the portal, I didn't have enough buttons or options to exercise my discretion to either bring back a voter or to kind of, you know, delete them. So the whole process in a way had become very exclusionary, which is just it goes against the spirit of what the Election Commission has been trying to achieve since independence, which is that no voter should be left behind. Let me try my best, leave no stone unturned to bring or at least enroll as many people as voters.
Speaker 3And Ritika, considering the changes it has made now, the complete U-turn the commission has taken, tell us what does it signal to you?
Speaker 5That the commission had become a one-man show. I mean, this is essentially a confirmation of that. So while this was never said on file, but yes, out of the 14 objections, five were marked.
Speaker 2With the CEC.
Speaker 5If the CEC was also always in the loop or other, you know, I mean, why would they mark these objections to the chief election commissioner, right? And it's honestly too much of a coincidence that most of these decisions, I would still say all of these decisions kind of match with all the findings of our investigation. So clearly, the commission's house was not in order. Two of the three commissioners were kept in the dark, which to my mind and several past election commissioners have also said this is unprecedented. And while this is not evident on file, it seemed
Speaker 5like the election commission had eventually become a one man show. And that to me was very interesting that by law, if the two commissioners wanted, they could have just overturned his decisions. But I guess what would you overturn if you can't overturn stuff that you don't know, right?
Speaker 4I mean, for them, they're mostly expressing surprise on these files.
Speaker 5They're Oh, this has happened. Oh, OK, that's happened as well. Why isn't anyone telling us? No one's talking to us. So they seem to have spent most of those 10 months, at least the 10 months that we've covered. Maybe the objections went much further back. But mostly it was them trying to come to terms with the fact that they were just completely kept in the dark and not in the loop. And the commission clearly did not have its house in order. There was no consensus between the three commissioners and the commission had kind of become a one man show.
Speaker 1And next, we turn our attention to the national capital, where as winter approaches, air pollution levels have already begun to rise. Earlier this week, Delhi's air quality slipped into the very poor category, with the AQI crossing 300. In response, the Commission for Air Quality Management invoked Stage 2 of the Graded Response Action Plan, or GRAP, across Delhi NCR. Now, farm fires and vehicular emissions have traditionally been among the major.
Speaker 2Contributors to the pollution.
Speaker 1But this year, even as farm fire incidents in Haryana and Uttar Pradesh have declined, pollution levels have remained high. Turns out that this time, some of the pollution appears to be coming from across the border, from Pakistan's Punjab province. So how is Pakistan contributing to the rise in pollution levels in Delhi? And what measures have been introduced under Grab Stage 2 to tackle the worsening air quality? To understand this, we speak to the Indian Express's Sophia Mathieu, who has been reporting on the issue for the paper.
Speaker 2Sophia, like every.
Speaker 1Year, this year again, the Delhi NCR region is seeing a major deterioration in its air quality. And we discuss these reasons every year. But tell us, how is Pakistan making things worse this time?
Speaker 6Yes, unfortunately, we are right back in the thick of it. Delhi's overall air quality has crossed an average of 350. In fact, as we are speaking, the AQI in Delhi is 379. It is the worst air quality recorded in the city in 287 days at least. And since you asked what are the causes for this, there are two primary triggers for the pollution to worsen during this time of the year. One is an increase in farm fire
Speaker 6activity in the neighboring regions. Second are unfavorable meteorological conditions. If we look at the latest satellite data which is provided from Indian Agricultural Research Institute, we can see that 798 farm fires were reported across six states including Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Punjab and Uttarakhand on November 3rd alone. Now, Punjab alone accounted for 584 of these farm fires. So
Speaker 6we see that there has been a reduction in farm fire activity in the two major states of Uttar Pradesh and Haryana. It has been an all-time low but there is an increase in farm fire activities on the other hand in certain regions including Punjab. On top of that, we also analyzed NASA's satellite imagery and we found that there has been a sustained activity of most likely farm fires in this west of international border in Punjab's Pakistan
Speaker 6province because there is a dense band of active fires that is visible in NASA's satellite imagery. for quite some time now but it has especially intensified in the last week now when you combine this smoke from these fires that gets transported all the way to ncr because when the wind direction is northwest which is commonly the case all this you know smoke gets transported and it gets trapped here and.
Speaker 2Can you tell us why is that why does it get trapped here.
Speaker 6It gets trapped in the NCR region because of its geographical structure. It is placed like a bowl. This region is landlocked, right? It's landlocked and it's also having a bowl-like structure. There is ravallis on one side. So all of that... ensures that more and more wind smoke from, you know, across the border gets transported and reaches this wider NCR region and it gets trapped here because of
Speaker 6the stagnant wind conditions and the low temperatures.
Speaker 1And vehicular pollution also significantly contributes to this problem, right?
Speaker 2Absolutely.
Speaker 6While farm fires get a lot of attention, it is in fact vehicular emissions that contribute most. This is what data shows. So there is something called the decision support system that we have in place, which is prepared by Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, a scientist from this particular body. They give us data on what are the sources that are actually contributing to delhi's pm 2.5 load apart from
Speaker 6this they also give us the forecast So when we analyzed this DSS data from the IITM, we found that transport emissions are the highest and these alone contribute to more than 20% during this time of the year. Now when you add this to the pre-festival traffic congestion, so we know that vehicular emissions are bound to increase and this would remain trapped in the lower atmosphere.
Speaker 1And what about the weather conditions? Are they impacting the air quality as well? Like last week, it rained in Delhi. Did that improve the AQI?
Speaker 6Yes, weather conditions play a crucial role for the worsening of air quality. The India Meteorological Department has been observing shallow fog in the morning hours over Delhi and they also say that winds are westerly and the speeds are roughly 10 to 15 kilometers per drop at night now any wind speed that is below 10 kilometers per hour is not favorable for these pollutants that get strapped in
Speaker 6the atmosphere for them to disperse so there has to be there have to be you know proper strong wind conditions for the pollutants to disperse So, which is why we can say that meteorological conditions play a very crucial role. For instance, just a week ago when it rained in Delhi, you know, AQI immediately improved and it was among the cleanest October air recorded in years. Now, so it is
Speaker 6really dependent, the air quality conditions are very much dependent on meteorological conditions, one can say.
Speaker 1And Sophia, now keeping all of this in mind, GRAP2 has been invoked in Delhi.
Speaker 2So what kind of measures does it involve? Yes, you're right, Niharika.
Speaker 6GRAP 2 has been invoked in Delhi by this AQM. Not only in Delhi, but in the larger NCR region as well. Now, what does this mean? These are pollution restrictions that kick in stage-wise as the air quality worsens and it is forecast to worsen. For example, GRAP stage 1 is invoked when the AQI is expected to be in the poor quality. GRAP stage 2 is invoked when it is expected to remain in the very poor range.
Speaker 6Very poor range is AQI above 200 and when AQI is expected to be in the severe category that is when like that's 301 to 400 that is when CAQM the commission invokes GRAP Stage 3. And finally, the highest set of restrictions the Commission puts in place is GRAP Stage 4, which is invoked when AQI is above 400. Now, under GRAP 2, which is in place right now, the
Speaker 6most noticeable restrictions include a strict ban on the use of coal and firewood in hotels, restaurants, open eateries, Now apart from this, parking fees are also should be increased, doubled is what the commission says in this order. Simultaneously, the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation has announced 20 additional metro trips on the weekdays to boost public transit. So all of this has occurred because the commission has invoked Grab
Speaker 6Stage 2 as the public transportation has to also be augmented during this time. You will also see intensified mechanical road sweeping and water sprinkling activities across major corridors. Since this is what intensified dust mitigation measures is a requirement under this particular grab stage.
Speaker 1And Sophia, this has obviously become an annual thing for Delhi now, right?
Speaker 2So can you also tell us why does this happen during winters?
Speaker 6Yes, for the people living in this entire INSEAD region, this has become a very normalized annual phenomenon. Why? Because first of all, it is the geography. Delhi is landlocked, meaning it doesn't have any coastal advantage of, you know, sea breezes. to clear air like in mumbai or chennai or other parts of the country every october and november the withdrawal of monsoon coincides with the cariff harvest in
Speaker 6punjab and haryana it leaves farmers with a narrow window to clear millions of tons of paddy stubble before sowing wheat so they resort to a burning simultaneously winter sets in bringing temperature inversions effect the I had explained earlier where cold air sinks and it traps all this local transport industrial emissions construction emissions all these kind of emissions local emissions combined with this farm fire smoke that is
Speaker 6you know transported kilometers and kilometers.
Speaker 1Right now can we expect the air quality and the overall situation to improve what does the meteorological department.
Speaker 6Say Unfortunately, in Iharika, there is no immediate relief in sight. The focus by the Indian Meteorological Department for the coming days says that there would be mainly clear skies. But it has also said that there will be persistent morning mist with no strong winds or rain to wash it off. So, this means that the suspended particulate matter, all of that could still remain trapped in the lower atmospheric region. The
Speaker 6Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology, which gives us focus on the air quality, has also clearly projected that the air quality will remain in the very poor category, which is why we have GRAP2 in place right now. And this is expected to be the case until at least November 5. And the outlook for the later six days, it says, it's also bleak because it says it could fluctuate between very poor and poor AQI.
Speaker 1And Sophia, with Diwali around the corner, we see that despite a ban on crackers, people do end up bursting them.
Speaker 2So how much will that affect the air quality?
Speaker 6Yes, it is highly likely that during the festive season, Diwali is coming, that the air quality is expected to worsen. Now the cracker ban is notoriously difficult to enforce on ground. This is what previously enforcement department, they have constantly flagged. Given that our baseline AQI is already at a 287 day low of 350 and above, the airshed simply has no carrying capacity left. So when firecrackers are burst, heavy metals,
Speaker 6chemical aerosols are released and these just do not disperse given that the ventilation index, all these wind conditions, all of that is so poor. Historically, the Diwali night emissions push the AQI straight past 400 mark into severe plus category and the smoke can linger for days even, you know, after the festival is over.
Speaker 1And in the end, we discuss a significant decision by the Union Cabinet which could change how Agni Veers are inducted into the armed forces. The Indian Express's Amrita Nayak Dutta reported that the government has decided to offer an additional two-year engagement period to the 75% of Agni Veers who are not retained after their initial four-year tenure. At the end of these two additional years, They will get another opportunity to join the armed forces as regular soldiers, provided they are willing and meet the objective selection criteria.
Speaker 1Addressing the media, Chief of Defence Staff General Raja Subramani said that the decision follows a continuous evaluation of Agni Veers over the last four years and it will help the armed forces maintain a youthful profile as well as provide it with experienced and mature troops. He also added that Agni Veers who opt for the additional two-year engagement period will receive a higher salary and those who choose to leave after completing the two years will receive an enhanced Sevanidhi package. This comes at a time when the
Speaker 1first batch of Agniveers from the Indian Navy are completing their four-year tenure this month. Under the original Agnipath scheme announced in 2022, only 25% of Agniveers were to be retained in each of the three services, with the rest exiting the services after completing their four-year tenure. Amrita writes that the three services had been in discussions with the Department of Military about significantly increasing the retention rate and had sent multiple communications to this effect. You were listening
Speaker 1to Three Things by the Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Audio and write to us at podcasts at Indian Express.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...