Agniveers look for jobs, Indian caught in war, and a nurse trapped abroad
27 minAudio
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Vidheesha Kuntamalla about Uttarakhand’s proposed Agniveer Cell, how it plans to help the first returning batches find civilian employment, and the challenges involved in matching their skills and aspirations with available opportunities. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Brendan Dabhi about Sahil Majothi, a young man from Gujarat who travelled to Russia as a student, joined its armed forces and later surrendered in Ukraine, where he remains in a prisoner-of-war facility as his family seeks his return. (11:50) And in the end, we look at the case of Ranchi-based nurse Monica Kachhap, who says she was promised a nursing job in Dubai but became trapped in an exploitative work arrangement and an alleged debt of more than ₹3 lakh. (23:55) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at the story of a young man from Gujarat who ended up in a Ukrainian prisoner of war facility after travelling to Russia and his family's efforts to bring him home. We also turn to Jharkhand where a nurse who travelled to Dubai for a better paying job says she became trapped in an exploitative arrangement and is now seeking help to return to India. But first, we talk about the return of the very first batch of Agnivis and the government's efforts to help
Speaker 1them find employment. Hi, I'm Itchha Sharma and you're listening to Three Things, the Indian Express news show. It was in 2022 that the government introduced the Agnipath Scheme, a recruitment program for young Indians who who wish to join the armed forces. Under the scheme, Agni Veers are inducted into the armed forces for a fixed tenure of four years.
Speaker 1And at the end of this period, up to 25% are retained for permanent service, while the remaining 75% return to civilian life. Now, the first batch of Agni Veers will soon be completing their four-year tenure with the armed forces. And Uttarakhand, where military service is common among families, is setting up an Agniveer cell to help them find employment, develop additional skills and explore self-employment opportunities. So to learn more about this program, how it will facilitate employment for
Speaker 1Agniweers and the challenges it may face, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks with the Indian Express's Vidisha Kuntamala, who has reported on the issue.
Speaker 2So Vidisha, firstly tell us about the Agniveer cell. What exactly is it supposed to do?
Speaker 3So I would describe it essentially as a transition mechanism for Agniwears who complete their four-year engagement and then are now set to return to their civilian life. The most important thing is that it is not meant to just be another employment cell because the MHA is already trying to do that for all.
Speaker 4The Agni Veers who are set to return back this year.
Speaker 3But the proposal for Uttarakhand specially is to have one institutional mechanism that understands who these Agni Veers are what skills they have acquired in the armed forces and what jobs are available and what additional training they might need if in case they need to upgrade their skills to make them a suitable candidate to jobs available.
Speaker 4In the state.
Speaker 3So on one side, you have the Agniweers, their educational qualifications, military trade, technical skills and experience. And on the other side, you have vacancies in government departments, PSUs and the private sector. So the cell is supposed to act as a bridge between facilitating the Agniweers and the opportunities which are available in the state. And so this also becomes particularly important for Uttarakhand because Military service is deeply embedded in the state's social and economic landscape for years. So the first
Speaker 3two sizable army batches for, I would say, one Navy and one army batch from Uttarakhand are expected to return around, the army is expected to return around December 2026. And the cell estimates that around 1200 Agnewis will be returning in the coming few months.
Speaker 2So like you mentioned, the MHA is also planning a similar initiative.
Speaker 1Then why is such a cell needed?
Speaker 2What sets it apart?
Speaker 3Because there is a very important translation problem between military skills and the civilian job market. An Agnivir may have spent four years working in logistics, communications, vehicle maintenance, engineering support or security or any other specialized military role. But they may have discipline, physical training and considerable practical experience. But as a civilian employer, they will not necessarily understand what that experience translates into the terms of a civilian job.
Speaker 4So the question, I mean, it is simply not about does this person have a skill?
Speaker 3It is also about how do we translate this skill into an employable civilian qualification?
Speaker 4And there is also another structural issue.
Speaker 3So under Agnipath, only up to 25% of a badge can be retained in the regular carder.
Speaker 4So the rest.
Speaker 3leave after four years with the SEVA and a skill certificate. So for the state, this isn't going to be a one-off issue involving a handful of people. Successive batches will keep returning with the same, you know, certificate.
Speaker 4So that is why the CEL is being conceived as.
Speaker 3A continuing institutional mechanism rather than just an ad hoc employment drive.
Speaker 2And Vidisha, what kind of challenges do you think the CEL can face in the process of providing Agni Beers with employment?
Speaker 3I think the biggest challenge is going to be execution rather than the creation of the cell itself. You can create a database of Agni Beers, but that database is only useful if you have an equally dynamic database of actual vacancies. The cell will have to know continuously, I mean, not only for this batch, but for every batch that is going to come out. as to who is hiring for what positions, what the eligibility criteria are, what salary is being offered and whether an Agniveer's military experience is
Speaker 3actually relevant to that job. So, I mean, of course, the biggest problem that they need to cater to is the timing. The first army batch, which is expected to return towards the end of 2026 or early 2027, that is December or January, So the state doesn't have an unlimited window to build this mechanism. If an Adniveer comes back and doesn't see meaningful opportunities quickly, they may simply take whatever employment is immediately available. And I think another challenge is that not every Adniveer will want the same thing.
Speaker 3Some may want government employment, some may look at PSUs, some may want a private sector job and some may.
Speaker 4Want to start their own business.
Speaker 3So the cell has to be flexible enough to deal with every different aspiration.
Speaker 2And talking about that, what kind of a process will be followed to figure out which job is suitable for them and what interests them?
Speaker 3The proposal of the cell is essentially to build a consolidated profile of every Uttarakhand domiciled Agniveer. That would include their education qualifications, the armed force and the unit they served in, their military trade and technical or vocational.
Speaker 4Skills when they were recruited.
Speaker 3And when they complete service, their employment status after leaving and whether they need employment or rehabilitation assistance.
Speaker 4Then on the other side of this equation is the vacancy.
Speaker 3So ideally, the system would say, you know, this Agniveer has this qualification, this military experience and these technical skills. So this particular employer is looking for these qualifications and skills and this salary and these conditions. So this is a much more sophisticated model than just simply saying that there is a vacancy. You just send an Agniveer. And I think that matching exercise is really core of whether the cell... would actually succeed or not.
Speaker 2And what happens if an Agni Veer does not have the exact skill set required for a particular civilian job?
Speaker 3So that is where the skills gap analysis and the bridge training comes in.
Speaker 4The idea is that the cell.
Speaker 3Should not simply look at an Agniveer's existing qualification and say, you don't qualify, so you can't apply. Instead, if there is a job where the Agniveer has most of the required skills, but is missing, say, a particular certification or a technical qualification, the cell can identify that gap and arrange job-specific or vocational training. For example, if an employer is looking for a particular certification that isn't part of an Agniveer's military training, a short refresher course or a certification course could potentially make that person eligible again. So essentially,
Speaker 3it's just that don't just map people to existing jobs. The motto of the cell is basically to identify what needs to be.
Speaker 4Added to make them employable for those jobs.
Speaker 2And Vidisha, we understand that Uttarakhand even has reservation for Agniveer's.
Speaker 1So how does that fit in here?
Speaker 3This is where it's important to distinguish between reservation and the Agni Vir cell because they are actually two different mechanisms. So Uttarakhand, like many other states, has already notified 10% horizontal reservation for demobilized Agni Virs.
Speaker 4That is the Agni Virs.
Speaker 3Which are not part of the 25% who get placed at the end of the four years in direct recruitment to specified uniform group C posts.
Speaker 4These include posts.
Speaker 3In areas such as police, fire, prison, forest, excise and secretariat security. So the reservation creates an opportunity within specified government recruitments.
Speaker 4The cell has a much broader mandate.
Speaker 3It is supposed to like help and navigate government employment, but also outside of these sectors where that 10% horizontal reservation is being provided. And there is an important distinction here because a reservation gives you access to a particular recruitment opportunity, but it does not by itself guarantee a job. So the cell is supposed to help with the larger transition from military service into civilian employment. There are also employment provisions at the centre level. For example, the centre,
Speaker 3I think in July, if I'm not wrong, July 2026, had announced that ex-Arniweers would have 50% reservation in constable riflemen recruitments in Assam Rifles, along with age-related concessions and other exemptions. So the Uttarakhand cell sits within a much larger.
Speaker 4Ecosystem of post-service opportunities.
Speaker 3It is not only helping the Agni Veers who are not placed find jobs at a central level, but also at a state level. They're going to look at vacancies both across the state and across the country.
Speaker 2And Vidisha, you mentioned that around 1,200 Agni Veers will be returning from the first two batches. So how Will the cell be able to make sure that each one of them gets employed?
Speaker 4So that is, I think, the biggest challenge.
Speaker 3I think this is where we have to be very careful about what the state is promising and what the mechanism can actually deliver.
Speaker 4It is a very ambitious promise.
Speaker 3The purpose of the cell is to facilitate employment. That is not the same thing as guaranteeing a job to every returning Agniveer. There are around 1,200 expected to return Agniveer.
Speaker 4In the first army and navy batches.
Speaker 3According to the cell, the state can create the database, identify vacancies, again, try to facilitate in government schemes. But ultimately, employment will also depend on the individual's qualifications. So I would say the real test of the cell will not simply be how many Agniweers it registers. It will be whether it can demonstrate that an Agniweer who finishes four years of military service can actually make that transition into civilian employment. without falling through the gap between military training
Speaker 3and the civilian job market. And because the first batches are now approaching the end of their tenure, that test.
Speaker 4I mean, is sort of arriving quite soon.
Speaker 3So yeah, the implementation in itself is a huge challenge and.
Speaker 4We will just have to wait and see.
Speaker 5And next.
Speaker 1We talk about a 24-year-old man whose parents have been trying to find out his exact whereabouts for over two years. This man is Sahil Majoti. And the last time he called his mother Hasina, he told her he was in a jail in Moscow. Then in October last year, a video released by the Ukrainian army surfaced online. And in it, Sahil was speaking in Russian, a language his mother did not know. All she could make out were a few words.
Speaker 1His name, India and Morbi, the town he is from in Gujarat. Now, Sahil had actually left India in 2024 to study engineering in Russia. He had initially looked at universities closer to home, but didn't find any that he liked.
Speaker 5So then he searched for courses and all online, and he finally found this ITMO university in Russia, in St.
Speaker 4Petersburg.
Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Brendan Darby, who reports on the state for the paper.
Speaker 5And he decided to apply there. He got through. He got admission there. He paid the fees. And then he finally left India in January 2024.
Speaker 1For a while, Brendan says, Sahil sent his mother photographs of snow, cathedrals and his new life in St. Petersburg. But three months later, he called her crying from Moscow, saying he had been arrested after police allegedly found drugs in a delivery packet he was carrying. After that, the line went dead. Yes.
Speaker 5So along with the studies, he was also wanted to get a job there. So he got a job on Telegram as a delivery person. And that is where the problem took place. Unbeknownst to him, he was allegedly used to deliver drugs and that is how he was caught by the Russian police. He claims innocence and he claims that he didn't know anything about what he was delivering. But by what their advocate have told us that he was sentenced to seven years imprisonment and then asked to
Speaker 5sign papers to join the Russian army in due of, you know, a reduced sentence and other perks as well.
Speaker 1Brendan tells us that what followed was a long period of uncertainty. Sahil's family wrote to the Union Home Minister, the Ministry of External Affairs, the Indian Embassy in Russia, politicians in Gujarat and the Prime Minister's grievance portal.
Speaker 4In fact, in a.
Speaker 1Letter to the MEA in 2024 June, Sahil's uncle wrote that the family had not been in touch with him for more than two months and had heard he might be in a rehabilitation centre somewhere in Russia. But it turns out, Sahil had joined the Russian army instead and became involved in Russia's ongoing war in Ukraine.
Speaker 5So what happened was that he was misled. He claims he was misled into joining the Russian army where he was given training. He was earlier even given the option of becoming a drone operator. As you know, drones have seen widespread use in this current war. However, they sent him for training and put him as a foot soldier in the war and sent him on the front lines. That was in about September, October 2025. And when he was sent on the front lines, what Sahil says he did was that he crossed over into the land held
Speaker 5by the Ukrainian armed forces and surrendered to them there.
Speaker 1Then came the video, posted by the Ukrainian army.
Speaker 5My name is Mahjotih Sahil Mohamud Hussain. I am from India.
Speaker 4I am from Gorod.
Speaker 5I am 22 years old.
Speaker 2I was a student at the university.
Speaker 5I was sent to Churma for drug trafficking.
Speaker 1Sahil, speaking in Russian, said he had been sentenced to seven years in prison in the drug case and signed a contract for what Russia calls the special military operation. And that during his time as a soldier, he had an argument with a Russian commander, after which he ran away. He eventually reached a Ukrainian dugout, put down his assault rifle and surrendered. And all he said was, I don't want war. I killed no one. If possible, send me
Speaker 1home to India.
Speaker 5And the last conversation Sahil had with his mother, Haseena, was from a prison in Moscow, around about in October 2024. That was with the help of a sympathetic guard. After that, they had no contact. And in the meantime, Sahil was sent for training to something called the Octagon, which is the training ground or something. They're in Russia. And then he was sent on the front lines to fight the war. Then in around September-October 2025, which is one year later, after a year of silence, Haseena finally got to see
Speaker 5her son who had become the subject of an international news because the Ukrainian armed forces, the 63rd Separate Mechanized Brigade, had put out a video on all their social media handles claiming that they had caught an Indian who was fighting for the Russian army. That was Sahil Majoti. And that is where he described... In Russian, of course, what had happened to him, what had transpired and how he came to surrender to the Ukrainian armed forces. And that is when they knew that Sahil had reached Ukraine. But they still didn't know about his situation and whether he
Speaker 5was safe and whether he would be sent back to Russia or what would happen to him. But that is where the fight to bring him back, now that his actual location was known, the fight to bring him back began in earnest.
Speaker 1Sahil is now lodged in a prisoner of war facility in Lviv. Invest in Ukraine.
Speaker 5There are several people from several nationalities who are held as prisoner of war. What we know is this particular POW facility in Lviv city. So there is not only Sahil appears to be the only Indian there. But there are people from other several other countries also held there. Because they were all either caught or they surrendered to the Ukrainian armed forces while fighting on behalf of Russia. So that is why they are held as POWs. And that is why I suppose it is taking time. to have him extradited back to India.
Speaker 1Brendan tells us that it was advocate Deepa Joseph who filed a right petition in the Delhi High Court seeking intervention to bring Sahil home.
Speaker 5Shortly after Sahil surrendered to the Ukrainian armed forces and his video came out and so on, in December 2025, Advocate Deepa Joseph, who had a hand in, you know, helping release an Indian nurse from Yemen. She was asked for help in Sahil's case by his mother, Asina Majote. So she delved into this case and she has been working on it since then with the help of a local advocate there in Morbi. So in December 2025, she went to Europe for some work and decided to go
Speaker 5on to Ukraine to possibly see Sahil and understand the situation. So that's what she did. So she went there in the midst of The war where there was a lot of problem. Well, she stayed in some of the western cities which is a bit far from the war. But she ultimately had to go to Kiev and other places which are actively embroiled in the fighting and where there are attacks. So she had gone there and then she went to Lviv where she met Sahil. That was the first contact Sahil had had with someone, you know, close to his family in over a year. And there she
Speaker 5interviewed him in the presence of an NGO that works with foreign prisoners of war over there. And that is when... They also had their first video call with his mother that was also in over a year and since then Sahil has been in constant contact with video calls being facilitated for him with his mother every one or two months. The last one was just on September 22nd, 2026 and that is how it is going on just now.
Speaker 1Now, Brendan says that the status of his repatriation remains uncertain. In March, this year, in a response to the Delhi High Court, the MEA said the Indian embassy in Kiev was in contact with the Ukrainian government, but communication from Ukraine's Foreign Affairs Ministry on Sahil's release and repatriation was still awaited. Later, MEA sources said consular access had been obtained and Embassy officials had met Sahil twice and India was pressing Ukraine for his early release.
Speaker 5So it tentatively appears that Ukraine could technically send Sahil back to India of their own volition, but depends on when they do it and how they do it. So I do believe the Ministry of External Affairs of the Government of India and other actors are working on it. There are also several orders regarding this after a petition was filed by Advocate Deepa Joseph in the Delhi High Court. So the court is also monitoring the progress and the advocate has also received a letter from the office of the President of Ukraine saying that Sahil's case is under consideration.
Speaker 1And this isn't just about one Indian student trapped in a foreign conflict. It is part of a wider pattern that Indian authorities themselves have acknowledged, that young Indians reaching Russia on student or work visas are being drawn into the Russian military system after the war in Ukraine began. Last month itself, Foreign Secretary Vikram Mishra said India had information about 227 Indian nationals recruited into the Russian armed forces.
Speaker 1139 had been discharged and 51 had died.
Speaker 5Yes, so obviously this is a very widespread reported phenomena and obviously there are a lot of Indians who are stuck in Russia and who are fighting for Russia it also seems and they are stranded there at the moment. But Sahil appears to be different. His case is different because he is the only one who is stuck in Ukraine that we know of at the moment. So I think Sahil does have a better chance of coming back home. But we obviously cannot say anything since this is a
Speaker 5matter of geopolitical considerations.
Speaker 1And this hope that his case may be different and he will come home is what has kept his mother Haseena holding on through the uncertainty.
Speaker 5So Sahil's mother Haseena Majoti has raised him as a single mother working as a seamstress for a uniform making company and also teaching stitching at a convent of the Sisters of Charity here. So she has raised him single-handedly. And what she says is that, you know, Sahil was very happy when he got admission in St. Petersburg and he wanted to go. But she also describes this as her biggest mistake, letting him go. Obviously, she was not aware that all of this would happen, but she still feels a lot of guilt. for allowing sahil to go
Speaker 5to russia asina lost a lot of weight you know when all of this was happening and she also had onset of breast cancer which is now in remission and she has had several health issues also in the midst of all this care she is constantly looking at the news she is constantly following the russia ukraine war And she's quite up to date on even what happened recently between the Russian and Ukrainian presidents and what is happening at the moment. And she's constantly tracking all of that
Speaker 5and she's waiting for her son to come home. She's buying gifts for him on one hand and on the other hand she's constantly keeping track of what is happening in the international affairs over there. So while it has been two and a half years now of her waiting for Sahil to come back home, And in these difficult circumstances where she is having to see her boy, which she raised with much love and care, being reduced to a skeleton because of the food and the harsh winters and the situation there. But now she is a bit relieved at least because she knows where he is and
Speaker 5she knows he is being taken care of in Ukraine. That she has, you know, been better for a while now. But however, she still yearns for him to come back home and that remains her hope.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a Ranchi-based nurse whose dream of securing a better-paying job in Dubai has turned into an alleged debt trap, with her family now seeking government help to bring her back to India. As reported by the Indian Express's Shubham Tiga, The 35-year-old Monica Khachap came across an Instagram page last year advertising jobs for women in the Gulf. At the time, she was working as a nurse in Ranchi and looking for better opportunities to help cover her mother's medical expenses. As reported
Speaker 1by the Indian Express's Shubham Tiga, an agent named Priyanka Arya promised to arrange a nursing job in Dubai. But after reaching the UAE in May, she says the situation changed completely. Monica alleges that her passport was taken from her soon after arrival and that she was later made to put her thumb impression on a document written in Arabic and English. She says she was told it was a standard two-year employment contract. Only later, according to her account, did she learn that the document instead recorded a debt
Speaker 1of 12,600 dirhams, which estimates to around 3.29 lakh rupees, which she supposedly owed the facilitators. She says she was eventually asked to repay 14,000 dirhams, including interest, and was warned that she could face jail if she failed to do so. And the nursing job she had been promised never materialised. Instead, Monica alleges that she was sent to different homes to perform household work. care for patients and
Speaker 1look after children. She says language barriers made the work difficult and that she repeatedly asked to return to India. According to Monica, she was told she could leave only after paying the money demanded from her. She also says her passport remains with those who arranged her travel. She has denied suffering physical or sexual abuse. Her father has now filed an FIR against the alleged recruiters, accusing them of luring her abroad with promises of employment, food and accommodation and then subjecting her to forced labour. Police in
Speaker 1Jharkhand have confirmed that a case has been registered and say authorities are in touch with the Indian embassy to coordinate her return. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or
Speaker 1in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...