First, we speak with The Indian Express' Himanshu Harsh who led an investigation into the Bihar drug crisis for the newspaper. He talks about the current situation in the state, its relation to the prohibition of alcohol and the government's response. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Amitabh Sinha about the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage created in 2022 to help developing countries deal with disasters. He shares how the fund works, Nepal's emergency request for financial assistance post the recent flash floods, and why it took so long to establish this fund. (18:08) Lastly, we talk about an incident from Kolkata, where three people were forced to strip at gunpoint, and paraded naked. (30:23) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, Ichha Sharma, and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage created to help developing countries deal with disasters. We also talk about an incident from Kolkata where three people were forced to strip at gunpoint and paraded naked. But we begin with Bihar, where nearly a decade after the state imposed a complete ban on alcohol, a new and potentially more dangerous crisis appears to be taking shape. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you are
Speaker 1listening to 3 Things, the Indian Express News Show. In April 2016, the Bihar government introduced alcohol prohibition with the aim of tackling alcoholism and its devastating effects on families.
Speaker 2Particularly women and children.
Speaker 1Since then, the state has carried out an extensive crackdown on illegal liquor. Over the past 10 years, police have seized more than 3 crore litres of alcohol and made over 7 lakh arrests.
Speaker 2But while the government.
Speaker 1Has concentrated on stopping the sale and consumption of alcohol, another market for intoxicants has been expanding. A three-month investigation by the Indian Express based on police records shows Official data and conversations with doctors, social workers and investigators has revealed a sharp increase in drug-related cases across Bihar. And so, to break down for us how serious has Bihar's drug problem become and what does this tell us about the
Speaker 1unintended consequences and limitations of prohibition, my colleague Itchha Sharma speaks to The Indian Express's Himanshu Harsh, who led the investigation for the paper.
Speaker 3Himanshu Bihar's alcohol ban in that way is widely discussed. But when it comes to the scale of its illicit narcotics market, it has received less attention. And this is exactly where your investigation comes in. So when you began looking at Bihar 10 years after prohibition, what did the police records and the people you interviewed reveal?
Speaker 4So as you mentioned that Bihar has been a dry state for 10 years. So over these 10 years, Bihar police have almost kept their pace with these bootleggers who have trafficked almost 3.17 lakh crores of illegal liquor into Bihar, which Bihar police have seized during the decade. But while looking for these illegal liquor, they have found that there's a parallel narcotics economy which has been rapidly increasing in
Speaker 4Bihar so when we spoke to officials doctors social workers they have found that the narcotic issue has been multiplying year after year in Bihar and even not just the numbers if you look the kind of narcotics being consumed it has also changed over the years like earlier most of the addicts used to be addicts of plant-based substances like afim or ganja but in the recent years when you speak to social workers or officers they will tell
Speaker 4you that the ratio of synthetic or semi-synthetic narcotic substances they are increasing in this pool like heroin is increasing in the seizures as well as among the addicts Right.
Speaker 3And speaking of synthetic drugs, your investigation talks about a drug called Kota, which many of our listeners may never have heard of.
Speaker 2So what exactly is it?
Speaker 3And also, how does it differ from, say, heroin or ganja people are more familiar with?
Speaker 4Right. So Bihar police last year, they found that there's this substance called Kota. So Kota is basically like it's a dose like in common terminology. Many addicts say their dose as Kota like this is Kota for the day or this Kota for this hour. So the name came from there like and this Kota police officers describe it as a raw heroin. It's kind of a raw heroin. It's mustard looking, kind of saffronish, we can say. And it comes from Myanmar. So Myanmar have a production capacity
Speaker 4of this kind of narcotic substances. So they pack around 10 to 12 grams of Kota in soap boxes. then people from Bihar they travel to Assam and after these quota packets they cross from international borders in Assam people from Bihar and other parts of country they collect it from there and they travel back to Bihar so what officers have found that many women are getting involved in this quota trade like female officers they have disclosed that
Speaker 4it's very easy for them to carry these because they could hide it in their clothes and Normal frisking could not reveal these kind of substances being carried. Another reason is that since the quantity is so small that it can be hidden anywhere and since there is no metal signature, you can't track it with any machine. Also, sniffer dogs can be used but due to Russian crowd in Bihar trains, there is limited possibility of using sniffer dogs. But sources
Speaker 4have told us that they are looking into using sniffer dogs in the future.
Speaker 3Right, and I'm sure you highlight how Bihar was historically more of a transit corridor for narcotics. So, when did the police begin noticing that drugs moving through the state were actually being sold and consumed within the state as well?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 4So if you see Bihar's geography, so Bihar shares its border with Nepal, like seven of its districts from West Champaran to Kishanganj. They are right next to Nepal border. And if you look at Kishanganj, it is in the northeast region of Bihar, which is called Simanchal. So its proximity to northeastern states is also very close. So What was happening that Nepal is an historical source of ganja. So ganja used to flow from Nepal and it used
Speaker 4to cross through Bihar to other parts of India. Similarly, as I mentioned that Myanmar, the region, the Golden Triangle, officials even say it has that triangle because of the narcotic substance production so heroin and yeba mdma these kind of narcotic substances they used to flow in from myanmar border through assam and very recently even they have found some new routes in arunachal pradesh and these substances used to come to mainland india and the main route used
Speaker 4to be bihar so what has happened due to prohibition bihar has been a dry state there's no legal liquor in here so it kind of created a void so i mean liquor was available but it's very expensive in black markets if you look at the prices like an indian whiskey brand which sells for like 650 750 for 750 ml if you are to buy the same bottle in Bihar you have to pay almost double the price 1500 1600 so it's quite expensive and the newer generation
Speaker 4which are getting into narcotic substance like social workers they claim that one of the reason of them getting into narcotics is also the price of black market liquor. So they can't afford 1500, 1600 a bottle.
Speaker 5So they choose.
Speaker 4For cheaper, either some narcotic substances or even country made liquor.
Speaker 3And so Himanshu, can we safely say that 10 years after prohibition, we are seeing an unintended consequence of the alcohol ban and potentially to a more dangerous market?
Speaker 5Yes, we can say that.
Speaker 4Officers have been claiming this, social workers have been claiming this, that it's a side effect of liquor ban. But they also say that there are some other factors like geography I have mentioned.
Speaker 5Another thing is demography.
Speaker 4If you understand Bihar's demography like Recent reports claim that almost 81% of Bihar districts, they have at least one fourth of population which falls under NEET category. So basically NEET is not in employment, education or training. So this is calculated between an age group of 15 to 29. So you can say like almost 81% of Bihar has a population of like one fourth population, which doesn't do anything. like they are not getting any education training or any
Speaker 4kind of employment so officers believe that many of the peddlers and even addicts are coming from this need category because they don't have to do anything so like the peddlers they want to make quick money so they are looking this as a gold mine like they could transport some narcotic substance like for example quota they could transport it for like 10-12 grams they could transport to Bihar and from that 10-12 gram they make around 400-500 vials. So for the raw material that 10-12 gram they have
Speaker 4to pay for like 50,000 but the vials they make each vial could cost anywhere around 400-500 rupees. So they are seeing it as a business model, a quick money. They don't worry much about its side effect or I mean societal effects.
Speaker 5So that's one thing.
Speaker 4Social workers believe that these are mainly people who have been facing some kind of issues with their lives, maybe anxiety, societal problems.
Speaker 5Pressure, competition.
Speaker 4So to escape their reality, they start consuming some narcotic substances and over the period of time, these consumption become severe in terms of drug uses.
Speaker 3Right, and earlier you spoke of how women are increasingly becoming a part of these networks. But in local distribution, what all do we know about the people involved in this trade? Like, are we dealing with large organized syndicates or rather small networks?
Speaker 4As for now, there are no like mafias or organized syndicates. For quota, officers have found that people from Vaishali, they have been migrating to northeastern states for labor work. So when they were there, they got exposed to these kind of drugs. They found that there's this certain kind of thing that we can sell and make quick money. So these laborers kind of started carrying, trafficking these narcotic substances into Bihar. And once it reaches into Bihar, it could be distributed from anywhere, even paan shops and cigarette shops.
Speaker 4Many a times, even cigarette shop owners give away free samples just to try. But the issue with these kinds of semi-synthetic or synthetic drugs is that just two or three trials and you kind of get hooked to the addiction.
Speaker 5So that's an issue.
Speaker 4Another thing officers say that apart from demography and geography, COVID is a big catalyst. Like they believe that narcotic substances were flowing after prohibition and being consumed in the state. But what has happened in COVID like Earlier COVID, most of the things consumed in Bihar were plant-based, mostly marijuana, weed. But what has happened that since Bihar has a large migrant population living outside, mostly in metros, BIT, Delhi NCR, Punjab, Mumbai, Gujarat,
Speaker 4So officers say that these cities already had some hotspot for narcotic substances. And when these people were there, they got affected. So when the reverse migration happened during lockdown, these people traveled back. And with them, their addiction and their knowledge also came to Bihar. So most of these migrants were from rural Bihar. Before COVID, rural Bihar was mostly addicted on plant-based substances. But since these people came back with their synthetic addiction knowledge, so synthetic addiction spread
Speaker 4very rapidly during pandemic period.
Speaker 5Like even if.
Speaker 4You talk to social workers, they will claim that even school children in remotest parts of Bihar, they are now being addicted to very severe kind of narcotic substances, brown sugar. Yeah, the situation is severe in even the remotest parts of Bihar.
Speaker 3And Amanchu, speaking of this shift from plant-based substances towards synthetic drugs, during your investigation, you also spoke with doctors. So what did they tell you about the severity of this kind of addiction and the risk of overdose?
Speaker 4First thing is that plant-based substances are kind of less addictive. Like, I mean, one can recover faster if you compare the addiction with synthetic drugs. Also, doctors and social workers, they believe that these new kind of synthetic drugs, be it injections, tablets, or even heroin, these impact mental health of people. And since the age group which has been affected by narcotic substances, It works very rapidly, like over.
Speaker 5Two dose, three dose, five dose.
Speaker 4One could get hooked and once they are hooked, the withdrawal symptoms are very severe. If even if someone wants to quit the addiction, it's a lengthy process. For now, like Bihar has around 15 centers in 11 districts. Patna has three centers and 10 other districts have like nine centers. And apart from that, there are two more centers in Ames, Patna and Sardar Hospital in Bhojpur. But the issue is that the beds are very limited in these centers. These
Speaker 4centers are funded by central government and most of the NGOs who are funded by the central government, they have like only 15 beds. And another issue is that They cannot keep the patient more than 30 days. We have spoken to some NGO owners and they said that since the new addiction like this synthetic addiction, the withdrawal symptoms are very severe and 30 days is not enough to fully take him out of that addiction. So before he could completely recover, he has to go back to the
Speaker 4same environment, same people doing nothing.
Speaker 5So relapse rate is very high.
Speaker 4Patients even who come for check-in appointments, they don't return frequently.
Speaker 5Like after two, three visits, they stop revisiting.
Speaker 2And could they identify any reason behind this behavior?
Speaker 4I mean, doctors believe that there are certain factors. There's stigma, there's police fear. There's also peer pressure, like someone who wants to get out of this addiction, but his peer group would not let him.
Speaker 5They will reintroduce him to the substance.
Speaker 4So even doctors are seeing it as a very severe condition.
Speaker 3And Imanju, how has the government responded?
Speaker 4I mean, we haven't got any official data on this, but in 2016, government had ordered like to open at least one rehab center in each of the southern hospitals in each district. But again, the bed and the facility is not that robust. especially right now at which pace this problem is increasing. So there has not been enough infrastructural support. But government has said that they have ramped up their preparations under Nasha Mukt Bharat Abhiyan. And they
Speaker 4say they are taking a two-pronged step. The first one would be to catch as much of narcotics as possible. And second, that they will be spreading more awareness upon narcotics Even social workers we have spoken with, they said that it won't be contained if we keep our infrastructural system in district level. We have to go in ward level, Mahalla level to tackle the situation at the speed it is spreading right now.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 3And of course, there has been dissent among the opposition leaders. So what are they saying?
Speaker 4Many of the opposition parties, they are directly pegging it to prohibition. But the ruling party, they believe that prohibition and narcotics are two different things. So narcotics need a separate kind of infrastructural system.
Speaker 5So they say that they will work on both of these.
Speaker 4And despite the uproar on prohibition, BJP has for now said that they won't be lifting the prohibition in the state and they will continue with it. But they too have acknowledged that the cases are rising and the situation is getting severe, as the opposition has been saying. So they say that they will now look into this as well.
Speaker 3And Himanshu, lastly, after investigating this crisis for the past few months, what is something that became clearer to you about how the state is tackling this crisis?
Speaker 4Like first of all the infrastructure as we are discussing the infrastructure is not that robust like as i mentioned that the narcotic substances have reached even the remotest part of bihar but the medical infrastructure or the awareness level have not reached there so until unless the awareness or the rehab center reaches the people who have been affected on those remote areas it will be quite difficult to deal with it another reason is that the students who have been affected like NGO workers they claim that at
Speaker 4least 10 to 12 percent of school going children are affected from narcotic substances so they believe that in the remote parts of Bihar since the parents are working late like they are working for some labor job or maybe doing some household chores So what has happened that there's not enough attention they could provide to the children where he's sitting, where he's roaming. So they find that this thing is also making the spread of narcotic substances as
Speaker 4people cannot monitor their children more. So they believe that apart from the children, I mean, not just the children, the affected people like the addicts, the government also have to sensitize the families of all these people just to.
Speaker 5Make sure how to deal with this kind of situation.
Speaker 1And next, we talk about a fund that was created to help developing countries deal with disasters. In August this year, devastating flash floods swept across Nepal, killing more than 1,300 people and leaving over 5,000 missing. The floods caused widespread destruction across multiple districts, damaging homes, roads, bridges and energy infrastructure. This disaster once again raised serious concerns about the growing risks that climate-related disasters pose to vulnerable developing countries.
Speaker 6This was the biggest disaster that Nepal has seen since the 2015 earthquake. That was a massive earthquake that happened in Nepal.
Speaker 1That's The Indian Express's Amitabh Sinha, who reports on climate for the paper.
Speaker 6It was a flash flood caused by rock and ice avalanche, essentially a large chunk of a glacier high up in the Himalayan mountains. it broke off and fell down, bringing along with it big rocks and sediments and trees and everything else that came in its way. And it all flowed into the Bhotekashi River. And that river then swelled up and downstream, it created a lot of havoc. So
Speaker 6that's what happened. And I'm sure our listeners would remember this event as well.
Speaker 1Now to recover from the extensive damage caused by flash floods, Nepal estimates that it will need about 2.5 from a fund that was created in 2022. This is the FRLD, which stands for Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage, which is meant to address a long-pending demand from developing nations,
Speaker 1particularly those small and vulnerable countries that face the maximum risk from climate events. To learn more about this new fund, how it will help Nepal, and what led to its creation, we speak to Amitabh in this segment. Amitabh, could you explain the significance of the fund for responding to loss and damage and how it is meant to help a country like Nepal?
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 6So loss and damage is the third pillar of climate action. So the two other pillars being mitigation and adaptation, which a lot of people know about. So this comes post a disaster. In the immediate timeframe, you cannot prevent a disaster from happening. You cannot immediately wish the climate change problem to go away. And we would have These kind of disasters and every year we see these kind of disasters happening. You know, somewhere there is a cyclone that
Speaker 6is coming in. There's large scale flooding that happens. These flash flood events have in the mountainous and the Himalayan regions have also become much more frequent in the last few years. So these disasters would happen and cannot be prevented. So what can we do post the disaster to deal with, you know, these kind of events? So that is the area which is called loss and damage. The idea was, I mean, the developing countries had been demanding that a
Speaker 6fund be set up, which can be accessed in the case of such disasters, right? So, after long negotiations and everything, and, you know, stonewalling by the developed countries for a very long time, eventually, you know, a fund of this kind was set up in 2022. And, you know, it was operationalized in 2023, a year later, with some countries putting in some money, they acknowledged that, you know, there was need of such fund, and that countries like Nepal and
Speaker 6other smaller countries, they have a legitimate case and they need support, financial support to recover from such disasters. So this was a fund that was created in 2023. Right.
Speaker 1And Amitabh, could you also talk about what makes developing countries more vulnerable to such disasters? And what exactly have they been saying and demanding in the context of climate change?
Speaker 6So for a very long time, you know, developing countries and especially these small countries, which are also most vulnerable countries, small countries that are also are stressed on resources. These countries have been arguing that, look, we have not contributed to the problem of climate change. There is nothing that we have done that has caused climate change, but we are the ones who suffer the impacts of these climate events the most. So Nepal, for example, it is in
Speaker 6the Himalayas, you know, it faces these kinds of risks. of flash floods and also, you know, flooding of different kinds. And there are lots of other countries. There are these small island nations, for example, that face the risk of submergence and complete extinction itself because of rising sea levels. So these kind of countries, they have been arguing for a very long time that look, for us, what is the most important part of dealing with climate change is climate.
Speaker 6addressing this loss and damage that once the disaster strikes us, how do we recover from that? We are small countries with limited resources, but these disasters cause a lot of economic and non-economic damage. And we don't have the capabilities to actually deal with the post-destruction scenario on our own. So therefore, we need assistance from other countries, mainly countries
Speaker 6that have contributed to this problem of climate change. So mainly the rich and developed countries, they owe us money to deal with the post-destruction phase.
Speaker 1And so talk about how exactly does this fund work and how can a country that requires financial assistance access it?
Speaker 6So from last year onwards, that is 2025, This fund actually put out the first call for applications from countries saying, look, we have some money with us now and you can start making applications. Countries that have been affected by disasters and you need financial help in recovering from those disasters. So we'll assess your applications and we'll provide whatever help that we can. So this is the FRLD or the Fund to Respond to Loss and Damage that was set up.
Speaker 6So this is the fund that Nepal actually sent a request to immediately after the disaster saying, look, such a disaster has happened in Nepal. Of course, you are aware of it. And our assessment is that we need so much of money, but we need an immediate sort of assistance from you. And please consider our case and provide us some financial help. So this is what Nepal did. And in response to that request, you know, the fund said, has decided to earmark $ 20 million for Nepal last week.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1But in Nepal's case, this was an emergency request for funding, which meant it did not have to go through the entire application process, right?
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 6So as we discussed, the fund had put out a call for applications in December last year, and there was a window of opportunity for applying till 15th of June. So all those applications that have been received, they'll be assessed. And then the final decision on which application has to be given, how much money or whatever, that decision is scheduled to be taken in December. But this event in Nepal happened in August. And Nepal then petitioned the fund
Speaker 6seeking an emergency consideration of an urgent consideration, out-of-turn consideration for its request. And there is a provision for that, an out-of-turn sort of consideration. So then... Based on that request, the board of the fund actually met for an emergency meeting and they decided to consider the request of Nepal and they earmarked that $ 20 million sum for Nepal. Now, this is the first financial assistance coming out from the fund.
Speaker 6So right now, the fund has only got applications. It has not decided on the applications. But Nepal's case is is already decided. So Nepal is the first beneficiary of this loss and damage fund that was created after a long struggle by the developing countries.
Speaker 1And Amitabh, undoubtedly this is a very positive step, especially for the developing countries. But We understand that the developed nations weren't always in favor of this fund, right?
Speaker 6Yes, developed countries have not been in favor of this fund. They have not been in favor of, you know, shelling out money as would be expected. So it's not something that is out of ordinary. The international climate architecture as governed by the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and the 2015 Paris Agreement, It mandates the developed countries to provide climate finance to developing countries. The mandate is very
Speaker 6clear that developed countries would mobilize financial resources to help the developing countries in dealing with climate change. Now, the developed countries, they have not delivered on their emission reduction targets. And similarly, they have not delivered on their financial obligations as well. We have seen that even when the loss and damage fund was created, the amounts that have come in into that fund have not been great. A total of about $ 822 million have so far been put into
Speaker 6this fund by the donor countries, mainly the rich and developed world. But already after the first round of call of applications closed, the total sum of money that these 176 applications have requested for already amounts to some, you know, more than $ 2 billion. So, I mean, there is a general reluctance from the developed countries to actually put in financial resources. Again, I mean, that reluctance is not out
Speaker 6of ordinary. They are being asked to shell out money, which they don't want to.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1Because even when we talk about the money that Nepal is set to receive, $ 20 million, It is far less than the actual required amount.
Speaker 6Yes, their assessment is that they would be needing $ 4. 75 billion. What they have got from the loss and damage fund right now is $ 20 million with a million with an M. Now, obviously, there's a huge gap. What they're have received is less than one percent of what they probably would need what they have assessed that they would need but at least it is a start and nepal can make fresh applications
Speaker 6for different projects for the same disaster i mean that will be dealt with later but at least The significant part of this decision is that this fund actually met at an emergency meeting and decided to respond immediately. Out of turn, they considered Nepal's request and immediately earmarked some amount of money so that there is some amount of quickness in the decision making, some promptness in the way
Speaker 6decision is made.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about an incident from Kolkata where an 18-year-old, his father and his friend were allegedly assaulted, forced to strip at gunpoint and paraded naked, reportedly after the teenager was caught kissing a 13-year-old girl. The Indian Express's Sweety Kumari reported that the police have now arrested three accused who are members of the girl's family, including her parents. Police officers said that the 18-year-old and his friend met the girl on Sunday. According to them, the girl's uncle saw the 18-year-old kissing her and alerted
Speaker 1her father and another relative, who then reached the spot and forcibly took the teenager and his friend to their house. They allegedly assaulted them and forced the 18-year-old to call his father there. According to sources, the boy and his parents told the investigators that the girl's relatives gave them three choices– First, they could be framed in a police case.
Speaker 2Second, they could be shot dead.
Speaker 1And third, if they wanted to save their lives, they must roam the streets naked while the incident was recorded on video.
Speaker 2Following this, the video was circulated on social media. After the 18-year-old's.
Speaker 1Father filed a complaint, police have registered a case under multiple sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Sweety reported that the day after this incident, the police made the arrested accused walk on streets in their underwear. The police have not yet issued an official statement about the parade. However, a senior police officer said that they were reconstructing the crime. Videos on social media purportedly showed three accused walking barefoot with ropes tied around their waist as police officers flanked them.
Speaker 1Following this incident, veteran TMC leader MP Saugata Roy described the incident as absolutely appalling and said that there is a complete breakdown of law and order. On the other hand, Bengal Minister and BJP leader Indranil Khan claimed that the accused are associated with TMC, which was voted out of power in May this year.
Speaker 2You were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express.
Speaker 1Today's episode was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Ichha Sharma and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...