Afghans under scrutiny, a bird changes its call, and avalanche in Nepal
24 minAudio
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Shubham Tigga about how Jharkhand’s voter-roll revision has left a small Afghan-origin community in Jamshedpur fearful, and the difficult questions it raises about residence, documentation and citizenship. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Vidheesha Kuntamalla about how human-made noise is changing the calls of the Himalayan monal, why this behavioural adaptation matters, and how development and climate change are affecting the bird’s habitat. (08:30) And in the end, we look at the major avalanche on Nepal’s Himlung Himal, where at least two people have died and 14 remain missing as rescue efforts continue amid hazardous weather conditions. (21:30) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at how human-made noise is changing the calls of the Himalayan Monal, the state bird of Uttarakhand, raising concerns about the impact of noise pollution on wildlife. We also take a look at Nepal, where a major avalanche has left two people dead and 14 missing. But first, we begin with Jamshedpur, where a voter roll verification exercise has left members of a small Afghan-origin community anxious and silent. Hi, I'm Itchha Sharma and you're listening
Speaker 1to Three Things, the Indian Express news show. In Jamshedpur, a voter roll verification exercise has opened up a far larger question about citizenship and fear among a small Afghan origin community that has lived in the city for decades.
Speaker 2So it's a relatively small population which has been here for decades. And some families say that they have been here even since the British period.
Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Shubham Tiga, who reported on the story for the paper.
Speaker 2From my reporting, I found that many of these families came to different parts of India for business and eventually settled in Jamshedpur. So traditionally, some were involved in selling dry fruits. Some are still involved in selling dry fruits, blankets and other clothes. And some of the members of this community were also involved in money lending jobs. So I met people who told me that their families have been in Jamshedpur for two or three generations.
Speaker 3For instance, a 29-year-old man I spoke to.
Speaker 2So he said his great-grandfather father served in the British Air Indian Army and his grandfather worked at steel company. So the important thing is that when we say Afghan origin, many of these people are actually families who have been living in India for generations, not just in Jamshedpur, but also in India.
Speaker 1Shubham tells us that the immediate case involves three related men, Asil Khan, Muhammad Aslam and Muhammad Ibrahim. who were booked during checks linked to Jharkhand's ongoing special intensive revision, or SIR, of electoral rolls. Officials say the three may well have lived in India for decades, like others in the community, but the central contention was that they never actually formally took Indian citizenship. Now, one of them, Ibrahim, has been arrested, while the other two are allegedly on the run.
Speaker 2So according to the reports, they were already part of the voter roll process and they tried to apply for inclusion of their names during this SIR process. So they received notices because their names could not be mapped to the previous electoral roll from 2003. So if your name doesn't come in 2003 electoral roll, so you will get a notice from the election commission or the officials and your name would not be mapped. So the same thing happened in this case also. So now what they had
Speaker 2to do is they have to submit their documents to establish their identity and eligibility. So now, according to the election officials, they submitted photocopies of the documents including the passport so initially the document passed the first level of scrutiny but when the passports were sent for further verification officials found that Ibrahim's one of those three so Ibrahim's passport had previously been suspended on grounds that he could be an Afghan national So the process to cancel the other two passports are still underway on similar ground. And
Speaker 2then eventually the district administration was directed to register the FIR against the two also.
Speaker 3So they have registered the FIR, but they are still on the run.
Speaker 1Shubham highlights that the impact of that case is now being felt beyond the three men. And the scale of the SIR exercise is itself significant. For instance... In East Singbam district, of which Jamshedpur is a part, there were around 19 lakh electors before the revision. At the draft stage, around 3.38 lakh names were deleted, leaving a draft roll of 15.11 lakh voters, with notices served to around 4.5
Speaker 1lakh people. And so against that backdrop, the case of these three Afghan-origin men is has become a point of anxiety for others whose lives in Jamshedpur stretch back decades, but whose legal status as such may now be questioned through documentary checks.
Speaker 2So when I went to the areas where Afghan origin families have traditionally lived, in Jamshedpur, if you'll see, there are three to four areas, and there I found that people who were normally visible in the neighbourhood had now stopped appearing.
Speaker 3And the business are also shut now.
Speaker 2Like whatever the business they were doing about the clothes and the selling dry fruits or whatever business they were doing, now they have been shut. And even the people who are still there to whom we met, they are reluctant to speak to us. And some specifically asked that their names or details not to be mentioned because they are very afraid that they could also face the police action. So in short, these people are now living in fear and do not want to come in front and show their identity. And as we know that these families have
Speaker 2been living in Jamshed for decades and many generations. So suddenly when there is a question about the identity and the nationality, then obviously this will create anxiety among the community. So I think that is a reason why the Kan origin community is afraid now.
Speaker 1At the same time, officials are separating residents from citizenship. Shubham says that when he spoke with the electoral registration officer, Arnav Mishra, he said that the three men had submitted photocopies of passports, but that it was unclear how they had acquired them. Mishra also acknowledged that checks showed the three had been living at the same address for around 26 years and that information about their settlement there dates back to at least 2005. But he said, The problem
Speaker 1remained that they had not officially taken Indian citizenship. He also pointed out that while the Citizenship Amendment Act eased citizenship provisions for refugees from Afghanistan and other neighbouring countries, that provision does not cover Muslims.
Speaker 2At this point, I think there are actually two separate questions. What about the three men and what about the whole community? So for the three men, the immediate issue is the FIR and the investigation into the documents they have submitted. So now the investigation will have to establish how their documents were obtained, like whatever documents they have submitted. And police also, police official also told the Indian Express that they have made their documents like Aadhaar card, PAN card, license and the documents required for the gas agency and
Speaker 2then their citizenship status is also under surveillance and what are the offense they have committed so these are the questions that have to be raised from for the three men from the community and for the wider community it is less clear because according to the sources To whom I spoke, they said they were not aware of other Afghan origin residents facing similar action because of the SIR. But the community is clearly worried. We can see that when we went to the other people from the community, they were not willing to speak and they were reluctant.
Speaker 2So before talking to the Afghan origin people, I spoke to the neighbors and everyone. They told me that they often used to meet publicly and they had gatherings regularly. in some shops, in some places. But now everything has stopped. They have stopped meeting publicly and most of them have left the areas where they used to live or gather. So the SIR itself is still ongoing. So in Jharkhand, I think the deadline for claims and objections has now been extended to September 30. So for now, the next
Speaker 2step is the verification, the investigation from both the side, police verification, and they have filed the criminal case also.
Speaker 3And the investigation from the election officials also.
Speaker 1And next, we turn our attention to something that many of us have now taken for granted. Something we've become so accustomed to that we barely notice it anymore and have come to think of as natural. Think for a second about what our cities sound like. What do we hear as we move through the city? Every day, we
Speaker 1are surrounded by the honking of cars, the roar of bikes, and at times the sound of sirens and music, signals of emergencies and celebrations. Music And while these sounds are
Speaker 1often tolerable and fleeting, if you happen to live near an active construction site, the constant noise can take its own toll. And this noise, of course, doesn't just affect our us humans. Think about that crow you just heard. Do you think it had to call a little louder or change its call because of the construction noise around it?
Speaker 1Do other birds have to do the same because of how much noise we make? Well, it turns out that this is already happening with at least one bird. The Himalayan Monal, the state bird of Uttarakhand. This is a striking bird found across the Himalayan region, including Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand and Sikkim. Now, if you're in a
Speaker 1quiet place, you can hear this call from quite far away. But increasingly, as human-made noise makes its way into the monel's habitat, Studies suggest that its call is changing. So to understand what these studies have found out and what factors are affecting the Himalayan Monal, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to The Indian Express's Vidisha Kuntamala, who reported on the story for the newspaper. Vidisha, in your.
Speaker 4Story, you mention studies that talk about how the Himalayan Monal's call is changing. So tell us, what do these studies have to say about that?
Speaker 5So there are actually two interesting studies here, and both look at how human activity and environmental changes could affect the Himalayan monel, which is the state bird of Uttarakhand. So both studies were done by researchers from Hemvati Nandan Bahuguna Garhwal University here in Uttarakhand, and they were carried out over about five years. So the first study looked at sound specifically, whether the monel is changing the way it calls in places, where there is a lot of
Speaker 5human activity and noise. And they compared Monals in two parts of the Kedarnath, a musk deer sanctuary in Manmaheshwar Valley, which is relatively quiet and has very little human activity, and the Chopta Valley, which has roads and it has a lot of movement of tourists and pilgrims and a much heavier footfall compared to the Kedarnath musk deer sanctuary. The second study looked at climate change. So the researchers wanted to understand how changing temperatures and rainfall patterns could
Speaker 5alter the areas where the Himalayan monel can live in the future, including under different climate scenarios up until the year 2100. So essentially, one study is about noise and the bird's behavior, and the other is about climate change and how it's going to affect the bird's habitat.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4And how did the researchers figure this out? Like, how did they realize that the Himalayan monol is changing its sound?
Speaker 5What they did was compare the calls of the monels in these two different types of environments. They used what are called passive acoustic monitoring devices, basically recording equipment that can be left in the habitat and can continuously pick up sounds. So that's particularly useful in these high altitude areas because researchers can't physically stay there throughout the year. Because you have snowfall and rain and fog and it's
Speaker 5a very difficult terrain. So they recorded hundreds of monel calls across different seasons and they compared the characteristics of these calls. And that's where they noticed this difference. So the monels in Chopta Valley, which is the noisier and the more heavily visited area, were calling at a higher frequency and with greater amplitude compared to the monels in the relatively quiet Maheshwar Valley. So the researchers aren't saying the bird has suddenly developed a completely new call. What
Speaker 5they're seeing is a change in the characteristic of the call, particularly at the higher frequency end. And that sort of suggests the birds have some ability to adjust their vocal behavior depending on the environment they're in.
Speaker 4And Vidisha, what do the researchers say about why this is significant? What's the big deal about a bird changing its calls?
Speaker 5So for a bird like the Himalayan Monel, it's significant because sound isn't just a way of communicating. Its calls are important also for mating and social behavior. One of the researchers that we spoke to for the study explained that the male makes a mating call and the female responds to that call. So imagine that communication happening in a relatively quiet forest. Now, when you put a road through that landscape or a vehicle or a tourist and
Speaker 5pilgrims and a lot of human activity, suddenly there's much more background noise. So the concern is that the bird's call could get masked by that noise. And these researchers are saying that if the male's mating call isn't traveling far enough or isn't being heard by the female, that could potentially interfere with communication.
Speaker 1So, yeah.
Speaker 4So is it just because of loud human-made sounds or could there be other reasons too?
Speaker 5So the researchers link this difference particularly to the difference in human-made noise between the two.
Speaker 3Locations, right, as we spoke earlier.
Speaker 5So the strongest difference between these two sites is the amount of anthropogenic or human generated noise. But it's also important not to say that we've proved noise is the only factor affecting the bird's call because the studies also show a strong difference between birds living in these two environments. And the researchers interpret that human made noise is an important reason for it. There could potentially be other environment factors involved as well, which is why they say that
Speaker 5more research is needed and the research is still continuing in these areas. But the takeaway is not as simple as just the fact that tourists are making the monels change their calls. It's that in noisier, human-dominated environments, the monels are calling differently. And now we need to understand what that means for them biologically.
Speaker 4And the other study that you mentioned, what were its findings and how does climate change impact the monel?
Speaker 5So the second study is really about where the Himalayan monel will be able to live as the climate is changing over the years. So the monel naturally moves up and down the mountains with seasons. In summer, it moves to higher elevations for breeding. And in winter, particularly when there's heavy snowfall, it moves down to lower elevations. So the researchers took climate data and existing records of where Himalayan monels have been found and used those to model what their suitable habitat could look like under different climatic
Speaker 5scenarios going all the way up to the year 2100. So what they found is that some areas that are suitable for the monel today could become unsuitable in the future. And at the same time, new suitable areas could also emerge elsewhere because we do not have access to the entire Himalayan range. So there could also be areas where which could be suitable for this bird. But just because a new area becomes suitable, it does not mean that the bird can necessarily get there. The monel moves along
Speaker 5mountain landscapes and if those landscapes become fragmented because of roads, construction or a heavy human activity, the bird may not be able to move between suitable habitats. So that's how climate change is particularly going to affect these patches of forest by becoming warmer or colder.
Speaker 4And Vidisha, could these factors lead to a situation where the Himalayan Monol could get endangered?
Speaker 5So at the moment, the Himalayan Monol is classified as a least concern globally on the IUCN red list. So these studies are not saying that the species is currently endangered. But one concern the researchers raised is that we actually don't have enough reliable information about its population at the local level.
Speaker 1And that's important.
Speaker 5Because a species can have a relatively stable population globally, while particular populations in particular landscapes might be declining. So the researchers are essentially saying we shouldn't wait until a species reaches an endangered status because before we start looking at what's happening to its habitat. For the monel, the concerns they're highlighting are things like increasing human disturbance and interference, into the areas and fragmentation of its habitat.
Speaker 4And so then what changes can be made to improve the situation?
Speaker 5So the researchers aren't particularly saying that tourism needs to stop altogether. And I think that's an important point because particularly in Uttarakhand, where tourism and pilgrimage are such a big part of the economy, what they're talking about is better management of human activity. For the noise issue, that could mean managing vehicle movement and noise levels in particular sensitive wildlife habitats, especially in areas that see very heavy tourist or pilgrimage footfall. And on the climate side, the
Speaker 5researchers are emphasizing habitat connectivity. So if a bird's suitable habitat is moving higher up the mountain as temperatures change, it needs to be able to actually move through the landscape to get there. So that means protecting not just individuals, forests or habitats, but also the connection between them. So we need to know what is actually happening to monel populations in different parts of Uttarakhand. So the broader message, of course, from these studies is that conservation can't just
Speaker 5mean protecting a species on paper as a policy. It also means looking at how we are using these landscapes, how much noise we are creating, where we are building roads and infrastructure and whether we are leaving enough connected habitat for wildlife to move through.
Speaker 4And Vidisha, what does this say about overcrowding and more development around the hills and the Himalayas impacting the wildlife in the region?
Speaker 5So I think the Himalayan monel is a very visible example of something that can happen when human activity increasingly enters wildlife habitats. And we are not necessarily only talking about one big construction project. It can be the cumulative effect of roads, vehicles, tourism, pilgrimage, construction, and the sheer number of people basically moving through these landscapes. I think
Speaker 5the larger takeaway is that development and conservation don't necessarily have to be opposing ideas, but development in the Himalayas has to account for the fact that these are living ecosystems and they're not spaces available for unlimited human use. And I think that's why these findings are worth paying attention to now, rather than just waiting for much more visible decline in the species.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a major avalanche in Nepal, where at least two bodies have been recovered and 14 people remain missing after snow swept through Himlung Himal, a 7,126-metre mountain in the country's Manang district. The avalanche struck the Himlung Himal peak in the remote Narphu region. Those reported missing include both mountaineers and support personnel who were part of climbing expeditions in the area. The incident
Speaker 1has been confirmed by Rishi Bhandari, General Secretary of the Expedition Operators Association Nepal. According to Bhandari, two of the missing individuals were associated with Imagine Nepal, while eight others were affiliated with Himalayan Holidays Nepal. Authorities are still gathering information about those affected. Now, the incident comes amid worsening weather conditions across Nepal's high-altitude mountain districts. Since 22 September, authorities have been issuing warnings about the possibility of avalanches
Speaker 1and flash floods following heavy snowfall and persistent rainfall. These conditions have raised concerns about the safety of climbing expeditions and people working in remote mountainous regions. Nepal's Department of Tourism has said it is closely monitoring the situation and coordinating efforts to locate the missing climbers and support staff. Ramkrishnalamichne, the department's director general, said authorities were actively collecting additional information while search and rescue operations continued. The latest avalanche
Speaker 1comes just weeks after another devastating avalanche reportedly triggered flash flooding in Nepal's Rasuwa region, highlighting the country's continuing exposure to extreme mountain weather. And the immediate concern remains the fate of those still missing on Himlung Himal. With heavy snowfall and persistent rain already prompting warnings from authorities, the ongoing rescue operation is taking place against a backdrop of hazardous weather conditions. For now, two deaths have been reported, 14 people remain unaccounted for, and Nepalese authorities are working
Speaker 1to establish the full circumstances of the avalanche and locate those still missing. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...