Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

CCTVs at medical stores, Kamathipura’s redevelopment, and protests at IIT Bombay

Sep 22, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Anonna Dutt about the Union Health Ministry’s proposal to make CCTV cameras mandatory in medical stores, whether surveillance can curb the misuse of prescription drugs, and why chemists are raising concerns about cost and privacy. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Apoorva Agashe about the redevelopment of Mumbai’s Kamathipura, how the historic red-light district has already changed, and why sex workers without formal ownership or tenancy rights risk being excluded from rehabilitation. (12:15) And in the end, we examine the death by suicide of IIT Bombay student Sahil Wakode, the allegations of caste-based discrimination made by his family, the institute’s handling of the case, and the demands raised by protesting students. (18:40) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava, Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1As industries adopt digital tools and artificial intelligence, professionals are increasingly required to learn, adapt and update their skills. The rapid pace of technological change means what is relevant today may not necessarily be enough tomorrow. This makes continuous learning increasingly important. As part of our ongoing collaboration with Xavier School of Management, Jamshedpur, we bring to you our third episode, where we discuss how professionals can learn fast enough to stay relevant. The episode will air on 23rd of September

Speaker 1at 10am. Do not forget to tune in. It will be available on our website indianexpress.com and everywhere you get your podcasts. Now, on with the show.

Speaker 2Hi, I'm Itchha Sharma, and you're listening to Three Things, the Indian Express news show. In today's episode, we look at Mumbai's Kamathipura, where a major redevelopment plan could transform the city's oldest red-light district, while raising questions about the future of sex workers who live and work there. We also take a look at IIT Bombay, where the death of a student has triggered protests, allegations of caste-based discrimination,

Speaker 2and scrutiny of the institute's handling of the case. But first, we turn to a new proposal from the Union Health Ministry that has drawn opposition from chemists across the country. The Union Health Ministry has proposed making CCTV surveillance mandatory for at medical stores as part of an effort to curb the misuse of prescription drugs. Under the draft notification, pharmacies would have to install cameras and retain the video recordings for three months. The proposal is aimed at strengthening

Speaker 2the monitoring of prescription medicines, particularly habit-forming drugs. In fact, this idea was proposed in 2021 as part of efforts to prevent drug abuse among children. But chemists have raised concerns that about both the cost of implementing the requirement and the implications for customer privacy. To learn more about the proposal, what all it entails and why chemists are against it, my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks to the Indian Express's Anona Dutt in this segment.

Speaker 1Anona, to begin with, tell us more about why this measure was first proposed in 2021.

Speaker 3So this was actually a measure to prevent drug addiction, which is a prescription drug addiction amongst children. And this was a campaign that the health ministry was working with the Women and Child Development Ministry. And this was actually one of the two measures that was agreed upon by the expert committee as well. One was, you know, the medical stores all providing their data on doctor's prescriptions that were given for the purchase of various medicines, which are

Speaker 3in Schedule H, H1 and X. So these are all the prescription drugs in the country with Schedule X naming several psychotropic drugs which can be habit forming. So all of this detail could be uploaded to this mobile app. and a CCTV camera being put in place at the point of sale to ensure that, you know, no child without any prescription gets any medicine at the store. So

Speaker 3that was the initial thinking behind this measure. And of course, this, the government says, we'll tightens surveillance and control over the sale of these prescription drugs, which even now sometimes happen without prescriptions, even in the national capital.

Speaker 1You mentioned Schedule H. For our listeners who may not know, can you explain what is Schedule H, H1 and X as far as drugs are concerned?

Speaker 3So when I say Schedule H, H1 and X, that encompasses almost all prescription medicines that are given in the country. OK, so Schedule H is the most commonly used, you know, prescription drugs. This could include, say, something like a steroid, which is commonly used. Then Schedule H1 is where there is a stricter record keeping. So Schedule H medicines can be dispensed on the prescription. But for Schedule H1, the pharmacist at the point of sale has to keep records

Speaker 3of who gave the prescription. So they have to note down these details and maintain it for some time. And this will include, you know, drugs like strong antibiotics, drugs for tuberculosis, all of these things. Then comes Schedule X and this is the most strictly regulated list of medicines in the country. And for this, actually, technically, the pharmacists are supposed to keep the prescription copy and also stamp the prescription so that it shows when the prescription has

Speaker 3been dispensed so that the same prescription is not used by the person at multiple stores. And Schedule X includes a lot of the psychotropic drugs, for example, strong sleeping pills, anti-anxiety medicines. All of these medicines would be listed as part of Schedule X. And some of these medicines can be habit forming, which is why this is so strictly controlled.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 1But how common is prescription drug related addiction, especially among children?

Speaker 3So yes, when it comes to children, especially, so opioid use as the, you know, umbrella term is the second most common form of addiction among children. But this also includes, you know, other opioids such as heroin and opium, along with pharmaceutical opioids, which are actually found in the strong painkillers, the painkillers that are given to cancer patients. So opioid use is the second most common form of addiction in children, which affects nearly 1.8% of them. And other than that,

Speaker 3of course, cannabis use, alcohol, inhalant use, these are common among children. This is based on a study done by Ames in 2019, which was essentially one of the most comprehensive studies to look at the estimation of substance abuse in India. It also said that about 2.3 crore people And this I'm saying both children and adults are actually opioid users in the country of which 25 lakh are dependent on pharmaceutical opioids.

Speaker 1And Anona, how is CCTV surveillance expected to help regulate the sale of these prescription medicines?

Speaker 3So see, when you put up a camera at the point of sale, it's not going to really record whether you know what is written on the prescription and whether that matches what the person is dispensing. So you cannot really do that. And it would also be very hard for a drug regulator to actually go through hours and hours of footage just looking at that however this measure was proposed because any child coming to purchase a medicine would be very clearly visible at the point of sale

Speaker 3so the drug regulators can look through the footage just to find children and then see whether they have given some prescription for the medicines that were dispensed to them. And secondly, of course, this footage can be used to corroborate certain complaints that the drug regulator might receive. However, in routine complaints, this is not going to be too helpful.

Speaker 4That is what the experts said.

Speaker 3Because while you can spot children easily, if adults, you know, do something like this, it would be very hard to actually track even with the CCTV footage. And also the number of drug inspectors in each state is very few as compared to the number of stores that each state has. So it is very hard for the drug regulators to actually go through these hours of footage just to find, you know, one instance or something. It would be very difficult to do that. So it is likely to be

Speaker 3only used in cases where there is a complaint and you go back to the time and whatever has been said in the complaint and you can verify that against the footage.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1And now coming to the chemists. What does the All India Organization of Chemists and Drugists have to say about this?

Speaker 4What are their concerns?

Speaker 3So actually, they have raised several concerns with this move. One is that, and that is a big issue that OCD has pointed out, is the money that would be required for pharmaceutical stores to actually ensure that there is a CCTV camera running and a recording is being done. And the draft regulation actually states that This recording has to be maintained for a period of three months. So what I was told is that this would be extremely expensive while some of the stores say actually most of

Speaker 3the stores in say Delhi would have a CCTV camera in place. In rural India, that is not the case. And usually these are smaller stores which would have like, you know, sale of say 5000, 10000 rupees. So for them to invest in setting up the CCTV cameras and additionally getting the high storage DVRs. So high storage DVRs actually cost a lot of money around say rupees 30,000 for one. and which is not enough to store footage

Speaker 3for 24-7 for the entire duration of three months. So they would need multiple DVRs. And then, you know, the cost of setting this up, cost of maintaining the CCTV cameras, this could be a huge financial burden for the smaller pharmaceutical companies. The second issue that they pointed out is that in rural areas, connectivity could.

Speaker 4Be a challenge.

Speaker 3And, you know, what happens if the CCTV camera doesn't function properly, stops working or there is no network and the recording stops? Because right now, wherever the CCTV cameras are installed, it's a voluntary process. However, with this regulation, they would mandatorily have to keep the data for three months. So if there is missing data, the action can be initiated against the store owners and their licenses may be cancelled. Another and I think this is a very important concern

Speaker 3that they raised was violating the privacy of the patient. So, for example, if a person comes to a medicine store and they, you know, have to buy medicine for a condition such as TB, which has a lot of stigma attached to it, nobody would want other people in the neighborhood to know that they are taking those medicines. Or for example, a person goes to a chemist store and wants to buy contraceptives, wants to buy a condom. They do not want to get recorded on the camera purchasing

Speaker 3these items. So it actually violates patient privacy and can lead to more problems which the pharmaceutical stores would face.

Speaker 1So then what is the solution here? And how do we see this going forward?

Speaker 3So right now, the government has released a draft notification saying And the stakeholders actually have a time for 30 day period to give in their suggestions and which I am sure a lot of the pharmacy owners and chemist stores, they are, I'm sure, putting in those comments right now. After 30 days, it would be evaluated by the government and they would decide whether they can take it forward. If this does go forward, there would be some challenges, especially the financial aspect of it. I think people would

Speaker 3raise that point even later. But as I mentioned earlier, what the expert says, it may not be extremely helpful. So maybe there needs to be a look into whether the cost actually gives you a real value.

Speaker 4For the cost.

Speaker 2And next, we talk about Mumbai's oldest red light district that is preparing to make way for a new neighbourhood. For decades, Mumbai's red light trade had a fixed address. It was concentrated in the narrow lanes and cramped rooms of Kamathipura, a neighbourhood where sex work was visible, identifiable and tied to a long-standing urban geography. That geography is now being dismantled. A 34-acre redevelopment plan, revealed last week,

Speaker 2proposes to remake Kamathipura with high-rises and large-scale rehabilitation.

Speaker 4So Kamathipura has a chawl system.

Speaker 2That's the Indian Express's Apoorva Agase, who reported on the story for the paper.

Speaker 5There are small crunch places where sex workers work and even the commoners stay over there.

Speaker 4This is going to be changed very soon.

Speaker 5Some developers have shown keen interest to develop Kamathipura and it could mostly be a residential plot and some plots would be commercial also.

Speaker 2She tells us that the plan proposes rehabilitation for more than 8,000 residential and commercial premises. with homes of about 500 sq ft compared with the roughly 120 sq ft homes many residents occupy now. And during construction, residents and landlords are going to receive a minimum monthly rent of Rs 25,000. In fact, two years of this rent will be paid in advance and another year will be paid by cheque. Now, talking about the neighbourhood, Apurva says that

Speaker 2Kamathipura was not always.

Speaker 4Defined by sex work.

Speaker 2The neighbourhood takes its name from Telugu-speaking construction labourers from the Hyderabad region who came to Bombay. And its association with sex work developed during the colonial period.

Speaker 5So many Kamgars used to live over in Kamatipura and it's near the docks, so it's near the sea.

Speaker 4So it had easy access to the Britishers and others.

Speaker 5So that's how it became a very popular red light district in Mumbai.

Speaker 2And so for decades after that, Kamathipura remained a concentrated ecosystem, where women, customers, middlemen and brothel keepers operated within a recognisable set of lanes and buildings. Now, while the buildings that once housed Mumbai's oldest red light district prepare to make way for a new neighbourhood, it's worth noting here that the sex trade itself is not disappearing.

Speaker 5So, brothels are it? disappearing from Kamathipura. So they are shifting their bases to Mumbai metropolitan region. But there are no designated brothels in that area. They are working in spas. They are working in hotels.

Speaker 2And for sex workers, the issue is slightly more complicated than just rehabilitation. Apurva says that many of them are not owners. They are tenants, informal occupants, or women whose work and housing have been tied to small rented rooms inside a system that has never actually fully recognized them. Now, that of course makes them especially vulnerable in a redevelopment process.

Speaker 5So exactly what happens with the sex workers is still unknown.

Speaker 4What the government is doing is still unknown to the women also.

Speaker 5From what I have gathered, sex workers weren't consulted before the rehabilitation or the redevelopment plan.

Speaker 2And community workers told Apoorva that Fourteen Lal Bazaars, once known as the area's sex streets, have now shrunk to five or six. The number of brothels has fallen and as a result, women working there are now dispersed across Navi Mumbai, Thane and Palghar, making it harder for organisations to track the sector and provide support to sex workers.

Speaker 4I have spoken to an NGO known as Prerna.

Speaker 5They are working in that area for quite a long.

Speaker 4They are saying that help reaches late.

Speaker 5Or they are not able to detect other women who are not in touch with them. Because Kamathipura was a designated area, women who were exploited would be found in that area. But now that they are dispersed, they have no way to reach out to the women who are exploited in sex trade. See, Kamatipura was a designated area or still is a designated area. But when we go outside of Mumbai, there is no designated area like Kamatipura. So we don't know how local authorities would locate women

Speaker 5and save them from human trafficking, sex trade.

Speaker 2And so for NGOs, as Apoorva mentioned, this fragmentation has created a new problem, locating the women. many of whom do not want to leave the neighbourhood.

Speaker 5If they want to shift the base, then they want alternative occupations also. So they want the government to have a clear plan where they would be shifted. If they are shifted, then what kind of occupation they can do. And if they are staying in the same space, then.

Speaker 4They need the land.

Speaker 2And there's another challenge. Kamathipura, for all its exploitation and hardship, also had a support structure. Women and their children could access civic schools, municipal hospitals, counsellors and organisations familiar with the community.

Speaker 5Kamathipura at least has three BMC-run schools.

Speaker 4So if women are shifting in a different area... they.

Speaker 5Might not have civic run schools. What the major problem the children are facing is that now they have to go to a private school, which is much more expensive. So it is likely that students or children might not be able to continue the education if the mothers are going out of the area.

Speaker 2And in the end, We talk about IIT Bombay, where the death by suicide of 20-year-old B.Tech student Sahil Wakode has triggered days of protests, allegations of caste-based discrimination and the removal of Professor Suryanarayan Dulla from his administrative position as dean. Now, this all started when Professor Dulla was invigilating the examination Sahil had taken shortly before his death

Speaker 2and has since been named in an FIR filed by Mumbai Police. following a complaint from Sahil's parents. They have alleged that their son faced caste-based harassment and discrimination from the professor. Now, one of the most contentious parts of the case concerns what happened during that examination. As reported by the Indian Express's Pallavi Smarth, a fellow student has claimed that Sahil was found uploading the question paper to chat GPT to seek answers. IIT Bombay later said that

Speaker 2no disciplinary action had been initiated against him, that he received counselling and that head of the department had assured him the episode would not damage his academic career. Sahil was found dead in his hotel room. room later that day. But the institute's decision to publicly mention the alleged use of an AI platform triggered further anger among students, who argued that details from an unresolved disciplinary process should have remained confidential. IIT Bombay has now apologised, saying that the

Speaker 2circumstances preceding Sahil's death remain under investigation and that it was inappropriate to characterize those events before they had been formally established. More than 400 students gathered on campus after Sahil's death, and protesters submitted a list of 18 demands, including Dulla's immediate suspension. The institute has so far removed him from the deanship, but he remains a professor, something protesters continue to oppose. IIT Bombay's faculty forum, meanwhile, has

Speaker 2publicly backed Dulla and said he has been subjected to what it described as false and misleading reporting. You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Bavar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write

Speaker 2to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode