Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Express Investigation: The unprecedented rift within the Election Commission

Sep 25, 202637 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, which began in Bihar last year, has resulted in more than 13 crore names being removed from draft rolls across 30 States and Union Territories, putting the Election Commission at the centre of an intense public debate. But questions about the exercise were also raised within the three-member Election Commission itself. An investigation by The Indian Express found that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi formally objected, at least 14 times over 10 months, to decisions taken and orders issued, they say, without their knowledge. In this episode, we discuss this unprecedented rift within the Election Commission with The Indian Express' Ritika Chopra, who investigated the story. Hosted and produced by Shashank Bhargava Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Ever since the special intensive revision began in Bihar last year, the exercise has resulted in more than 13 crore names being removed from the draft electoral rolls across 30 states and union territories. And this has placed the Election Commission, which is in charge of conducting free and fair elections, at the centre of an intense public debate over its role in determining who gets to vote and who doesn't. Several people have not only questioned the manner in which

Speaker 1this exercise is being conducted, but have also questioned its legality. Now, an investigation by the Indian Express published earlier this week reveals that some of these questions were also raised within the three-member election commission. And they were actually raised by two of the three election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. Both Sandhu and Joshi formally objected on record at least 14 times over the last 10 months to decisions taken by the EC, some of which they said

Speaker 1were unauthorized and illegal. And they also objected to orders they said had been issued without their knowledge. In fact, the two even wrote to the cabinet secretary complaining about these changes. So today, we are dedicating this episode to discussing this unprecedented rift within the EC with the Indian Express's Hrithika Chopra, who investigated the story for the paper. Hi, I'm Shashank Bhargav and you're listening to Three Things, the

Speaker 1Indian Express news show.

Speaker 2Okay, so for the benefit of the listeners here, just quickly. So the election commission is a body made of three members, a chief election commissioner and two election commissioners. Currently, the chief election commissioners Gyanesh Kumar, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi are the two election commissioners on the panel. So how they operate, at least according to the 2023 Act, according to law, the commission is supposed to operate... unanimously at least make decisions unanimously and wherever let's say there's some form of difference of opinion they decide by majority

Speaker 2now by majority what we mean is that if two out of the three members of the commission feel a certain way they prevail what's interesting is that say even if the chief election commissioner is the odd one out here and say the two election commissioners are on one side whatever they say the two election commissioner goes Okay, so.

Speaker 1It's not like his vote or his opinion matters more than the other two.

Speaker 2So I understand where that impression could come from purely because Gyanesh Kumar is the chief election commissioner. You have the word chief in his job title.

Speaker 1Yeah, that almost makes it seem like he's the boss of the two.

Speaker 2Yes, but the law is very clear that they are equals. They all enjoy the stature of a Supreme Court judge.

Speaker 1But.

Speaker 2The CEC is the first among equals. But in a meeting, when they are discussing issues, important issues, and let's say if it comes to, you know, the matter literally going to vote, any two of the three will prevail, irrespective of whether it's the CEC, the Chief Election Commissioner, who's amongst the two, or whether he is, say, the odd one out.

Speaker 1Right, and it's also unusual because they're colleagues. Like, surely before putting these objections down on record, They must have confronted him, right? Like, do we know anything about that?

Speaker 2So this is something I kind of do want to put on record. And again, hopefully, if it helps the listeners understand this better, that in the past, the practice has been, the law doesn't say much about this sort of a gray area, but the practice in the commission has been that it's kind of the owner's of taking everyone along is on the chief election commissioner. That's what we've seen in the past. It's very difficult to say whether they tried confronting him. I would presume if that happened, that would have happened, you know, when it was just

Speaker 2the three of them in the room. But what we do know and what was very evident to officers within the commission is that the three were not talking because there was no commission, full commission meeting for almost four months, which frankly is a lot of time. The commission, even during what they call as peacetime in Raj and Southern, that is when there are no elections, they still tend to have commission meetings. Maybe you don't transact a lot of business in that meetings, but that kind of happens unless people are traveling, whatever. But to not have commission meetings for four months and And especially at a time

Speaker 2when the SIR is going on, you know, it's not as if it wasn't technically peacetime for them because the election commission is undertaking this sort of very intensive revision of the electoral law on such a huge scale, more than two decades after more than 20 years. So during that process for the commission to not sit formally is actually a bit odd.

Speaker 1And before we started recording, you were telling me that both Sandhu and Joshi were telling deputy election commissioners, these senior civil servants who work in the commission, that look, there are these statements that the commission is putting out in the public, but we don't know anything about that.

Speaker 2To my mind, why this stands out is because and which is why I explained first that how decisions actually made in the commission. Honestly, it was quite interesting and curious for me to see that, you know, in this case, two of the three commissioners, sometimes individually and sometimes sort of acting in concert, they would write and they were mostly asking about what's happening. you know so when i say what's happening of course i'm paraphrasing it but say sometimes it would manifest in shape of a note written by vivek joshi saying that i see a lot of statements issued in the name of the commission but i

Speaker 2have no idea so what happened you know and and then not just that but for them to insist that make sure this doesn't happen make sure the law is followed and as we've discussed the law is that keep the commission in the loop all three in the loop and then you decide unanimously or by majority so pete singh sandhu wrote a similar note as well asking that we i see a lot of communications issued in the name of the commission when the commission was not apprised of any of this. So what is happening? And please make sure it doesn't happen again. So it kind of starts with such notes, at least the exchanges that we have seen. And it kind of progressively, at least the

Speaker 2language of these notes kind of tend to get, you can kind of, I would say the tension a bit is palpable when you're reading it and kind of progressively, at one point, you can see that the two seem to have, I don't know if I could say, but seem to have had enough where they're trying to assert something. themselves now asking that, you know, because you can see them right in these notes that we've discussed this. This has been discussed in the past. Of course, there's no written record of that. I'm presuming these are oral discussions that we've discussed in the past happening despite us telling

Speaker 2you not to do it. Why did this happen? Right.

Speaker 1And eventually, like we mentioned earlier, both Joshi and Sandhu wrote separately to the cabinet secretary raising these concerns. And the issue was that they were being kept in the dark and that a number of things that the commission was doing was not legal. So let's talk about what these things were. Now, one of them was about who counts as a new voter. And here we'll talk about the Form 6. Form 6 is the one that is used for enrolling new voters. And the new Form 6,

Speaker 1it asks a question that was never there earlier. And this question is whether they or their parents or grandparents exist in the electoral role of the last SIR. Can you talk about what the issue is here? Why did they object to this?

Speaker 2See, like you rightly mentioned, that usually... If you either want to come back onto the electoral rolls, for whatever reasons you were deleted, or you turn 18 and you want to become a voter now, you fill Form 6. Form 6 is a statutory form. What do we mean by that? This is essentially a form prescribed by law. It's actually in law, mentioned. office and the content of it actually is it emanates from a set of rules called the registration of electoral rules 1960 so anything that emanates from a law or rules you know obviously if

Speaker 2you want to change it you will have to ideally amend the and here of course the source being the rules or the law so because form 6 is one of the many statutory forms there's form 6 you know for instance There's form 8. If you've moved residences, you fill form 8. So these are set of forms, statutory forms prescribed by law. When a proposal came, and this is around the time when SIR was gathering pace in the sense. So when a proposal came that even as we ask existing electors, to prove whether they or their

Speaker 2relatives were there on the electoral row of the last SIR, maybe we should now start asking that same question of people who are now trying to come or become a voter for the first time, which is the people who are filling Form 6. When that proposal came, interestingly, I think this was sometime in May, if I'm not wrong, Vivek Joshi made a noting saying that Not exactly opposing the idea, but saying if you have to do it, the legally sustainable way, and I'm quoting him, would be to actually amend the rule, right? Which is what has

Speaker 2happened even in the past.

Speaker 1So even just to add one question in the form, you have to make an amendment.

Speaker 2You have to make an amendment to the rule. And of course, the election commission cannot. Election commission may amend its guidelines, orders, all of that. That's within its powers. But when it comes to an act or a rule, it's the government that can do it. If it's an act, you go to parliament. If it's a rule, then the law ministry can do it. So Vivek Joshi's and of course, I mean, it is sound advice that you want to change it. You go to the government, ask them to change it. and then maybe put up a proposal accordingly. And Subir Singh Sandhu, his colleague on the panel, agrees with him a few days later in May when this is discussed on file. Very interestingly, and this was a

Speaker 2break that my colleague Damni Nath had, was that in July, apparently the online version of Form 6 has that question. And even more interestingly, it seems like Subir Singh Sandhu discovers this from the Indian Express news report, because in file he records that as per the Indian Express report that appeared on the 12th of July and say he quotes another news report, it seems like we've changed form six and this happens despite, you know, the written advice of Vivek Joshi, which I have concurred with. So how did this happen?

Speaker 1So an election commissioner is getting to know about the changes in the form six through an Indian Express report.

Speaker 2Yes, which is what, of course, now is evident. And that's the very interesting thing. And, you know, this is kind of a pattern which they keep referring to. We're finding this out, you know, essentially not from within the commission, but from outside. Now, I can also imagine when all of this comes out, it can't be a great feeling. It would be embarrassing because, you know, you are three equals and it's quite obvious that, you know, they didn't know a lot. So at least for form six, you know, then Sandhu in a very strongly worded note. And this

Speaker 2is like I said, that, you know, you can see the language changing progressively in these notes, where initially it's more like, you know, let's be careful, let this not happen again. And then eventually, this is one of those very strongly worded notes where he says that, A, of course, flagging the fact that when we said that this is not how you should do it, not the fact that you shouldn't do it, but this is not how the process, this is not how you should do it. Somebody has gone ahead and done this anyway. And then he makes a reference to Joshi's note of May, the reasons why. And then, of course, he says that this change is

Speaker 2illegal and unauthorized. Now, that's very strong from a bureaucrat. He's all retired as officer to put on file and that this should be removed immediately and removed immediately again. You know, I'm quoting and that this was leading to harassment of young voters. Now, that to me is very telling, again, in the sense that you could sense, you know, their frustration from these notes that, you know, We've discussed this. Again, I would like to reiterate that it didn't seem like they were against the idea, but they were saying that the process is not being followed.

Speaker 1And when they're saying harassment of new voters, I think that also comes from the fact that for a really long time, one of EC's main goal was to get as many voters enrolled as possible. And this has now become a major hurdle for new voters.

Speaker 2So, yes, the election commission and this, of course, I mean, I'm not naming officers that I've spoken to in the past, but in our conversation while covering the election commission, the commission's attitude as far as preparation of the electoral roll has been inclusion, inclusion, inclusion. It's for that very same reason that even a homeless person. just, you know, somebody who doesn't have a permanent place of residence or even doesn't, you know, not living on rent, even that person is actually entitled to become a voter in our country. You know, there are certain conditions you need to fulfill, but the

Speaker 2fact that you are homeless, you don't have a permanent place of residence. So that gives you an idea of how, and I don't know if that's the right word to use, but how inclusionary the whole process is. And that's been the spirit of it. This is the first time that, where the commission kind of, I wouldn't say committed to the idea, but very aligned to the idea of exclusion, exclusion, exclusion. So that is very, very, very different.

Speaker 1Okay, so one objection was related to the Form 6. And the other was related to the Election Commission's portal, ECINET. And who gets to access electoral rolls? Now, each constituency's voter list is prepared and controlled by its electoral registration officer, ERO. This is a statutory authority on the ground. And they're the ones in charge of adding and deleting names. But it seems that lately, they have not been able to

Speaker 1do that. Not every time. Talk about what did these two election commissioners have to say about this?

Speaker 2So this to my mind, amongst all the objections that are flagged, this to my mind, and of course, it's my opinion, is amongst the most serious objections flagged. Because the beauty of India's election processes, and frankly, this is a defense that the commission has resorted to for decades, you know, election commission has been accused of having political allegations of voting being rigged by way of EVMs, or say political allegations of the electoral roll being rigged, you know. But the beauty of the election process is, even at the Indian Express, you know, we've always had this editorial

Speaker 2line that elections can't be rigged because of how decentralized the process is. No one person actually has control over all the EVMs, you know, that whole process. There are these several returning officers, you know, who are in charge of conducting the election. There are thousands of EROs who are responsible for preparing the electoral roll. So let's say, That, you know, yes, okay, someone sets out in the commission, even wants to, say, direct the process, very hypothetical. How are you going to do it? The system is so decentralized,

Speaker 2maybe you can corrupt one officer, but you can't swing elections. And that is something that, honestly, the commission has also tried to protect like a hawk. all these years because that has served it so well. And over a period of time, it's become a very well-oiled machinery because decentralized processes kind of can sometimes feel you're not actually in control of it.

Speaker 1Like to some, it can seem like, you know, there are too many cooks. Exactly.

Speaker 2But again, over a period of time, you know, like I said, it's turned into a very well-oiled machinery. Things kind of, you know, have a rhythm. They move according to it. And again, like I said, the whole idea of explaining this was that that's been the Election Commission's defense. Coming to now what the two election commissioners are now discussing, they start flagging something interesting. They are saying as far as the electoral role is concerned, it now sits on a software, actually the digitization or whatever the software. Let me just simplify this. The digitization of the software is nothing new. It actually started in 2017. Then there was

Speaker 2sort of a second iteration of that started in 2022-2023. And by 2026, they launched one software called ECINET. which kind of subsumes everything that they've been doing along many portals, many applications.

Speaker 1And they said that they're doing it for transparency, credibility and public trust.

Speaker 2That's exactly the CEC's statement on the 22nd of january when they launched eci net which seems to subsume all of their applications of the past including ero net on which the electoral rule used to sit that was specifically so ero net in a way is part of eci net i just hope i haven't complicated that too much but they're saying that ever you know what's increasingly happening is that you are centralizing the control of the electoral rule which means that the ero on the ground who by law is authorized to actually include names, exclude names, restore names. And all of this is based on there's

Speaker 2a process laid down in law where you hold hearings, whatever. And if the ERO is satisfied, you can make it back. And what's happening now is they're not being able to carry out that purely because whenever, let's say, they're done with their statutory thing and they arrive at a decision, in order to implement that decision, they need to be on ECI-Net. And somehow, the software doesn't allow them to, let's say, for example, restore a name. Say a name which was deleted, it doesn't allow them to bring that back unless... certain permissions from the IT division New Delhi are activated. They are constantly flagging this as a problem

Speaker 2that this is then, you know, kind of we're moving in the direction where you seem to be centralizing the control of the electoral roll. Now this is not to say it's been centralized, but it's interesting that they start flagging this because it's very evident from the exchanges between at least the two election commissioners are constantly flagging that this is the feedback they're getting from the ground. Where EROs are complaining, the CEOs are complaining, while we can access ECI net, there are certain functionalities we can't access and which is actually... really coming in the way of the SIR exercise. So Vivek Joshi actually flags that first

Speaker 2and he says, let's, you know, kind of have an audit so that we ensure that an audit actually, and he wanted external members as part of that committee who could then ensure that the law is being followed, which is, of course, the decentralized nature of the preparation of the electoral roll. Right.

Speaker 1And what they were warning about, we see that manifesting in Goa. And this involved 97 voters who were initially flagged for logical discrepancies, but were later supposed to be added to the roll. But that could not happen.

Speaker 2So yes, in Goa, when the EROs figured that okay, fine, out of say 600, 700 odd people who were flagged for logical discrepancies, after hearing they said, okay, fine, out of these 97 should be brought back onto the roll. For seven days, and to me was very surprising where the CEO writes consistently to the election commission saying, the Supreme Court said that we should give these guys a chance to present their case. People flied for logical discrepancies. We've done that process. Now, in order to implement the

Speaker 2decision of the Supreme Court, we need to bring back these 97 people back onto the roll. They write letters after letters after emails. These are beyond a point. They start sounding like desperate pleas also because with every day, the deadline to publish the electoral roll draws closer. And they know that these guys have the right to come back onto the roll and we're not being able to restore it. Now, we don't know what were the pressures on the ground. Maybe, you know, The voters were asking them. I don't know what was happening on the ground. But despite these pleas, something, frankly, they shouldn't even have to write to the election commission. And then when they write,

Speaker 2it just doesn't happen. They keep writing to the officer concerned, which was Gyanesh Bharti, the DEC who was in charge of Goa in the election commission. And they keep marking the IT division, which is headed by Seema Khanna. And of course, it's actually the IT divisions here. And surprisingly, 21st of February, the roll is published. whatever permissions that need to be, you know, kind of activated in Delhi didn't happen. And 97 people, I know it can sound like a really small number, but imagine this is a body... which can't even disenfranchise even one person. They take that

Speaker 2really seriously. Every vote matters. And here 97 people are no longer part of the roll because we've checked that list and they were not part of the roll published on the 21st. They're marked as deleted because someone sitting in Delhi did not heed the pleas of the EROs, the statutory authorities on the ground. So that actually is a manifestation of what this centralization can actually look like. What is the impact of such centralization? And eventually, late in August, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, again, amongst one of his stronger notes, says that the DGIT has no legal authority

Speaker 2to restrict the EROs from carrying out their statutory functions. So this is him telling them or rather pushing back on behalf of the ERO CEOs who would have reached out to him, saying that I'm just getting a lot of this feedback and, you know, this is the law. year I was in charge, why is someone sitting here in Delhi controlling the permissions of the software?

Speaker 1And you mentioned that 97 people, you know, may not sound like a lot, but it does go to show that someone in Delhi could hypothetically control the system and has the potential to disenfranchise people who are eligible voters.

Speaker 2So that's exactly the worrying thing that you turn 18, let's say, and you're eligible to vote. And let's say for whatever reason, not turn, you're an existing voter. And say for whatever reason, you get removed and you make your case. The officer agrees with you. He said, yes, you should be on the roll. And you're not. So that too, you know, it wasn't being on the electoral roll was never a struggle. There are many hoops now that you need to jump through. But the point is the fact that even when you jump through these hoops, there is now no guarantee that you will be on

Speaker 2the electoral roll. And that's the worrying thing. And that's the concerns that these two commissioners had. And that is what we see playing out, you know, on the ground in Goa.

Speaker 1OK, now, besides this, the other objections actually relate to the SIR process in Bengal. Now, in Bengal, the recent elections were very contentious and so was the SIR exercised. In these polls, we saw the BJP coming to power in the state. And after that, there were a lot of allegations that, you know, this happened because of the SIR. But we know that the victory margin was far greater than the SIR deletions. But one unusual thing that happened

Speaker 1in Bengal was that the Supreme Court appointed judicial officers to take decisions regarding lakhs of voters, voters whose names were were flagged for logical discrepancies. Now, finally, some 27 lakh electors were deleted by the EC and many of their appeals are still pending. And the issue that was raised by Sandhu was regarding appeals, but of a different kind. Tell us what that was.

Speaker 2So just quickly a chronology. Bengal is a little complicated and frankly the only complicated state because here the Supreme Court stepped in and then took the SIA process out of the hands of the election officers and sort of towards the last leg of it handed it over to judicial officers. They made some decisions and let's say if you were still aggrieved with those decisions because it was the judicial officers eventually who decided whether you made it to the final roll or not, not the draft roll. So if you still agree with those decisions, the Supreme Court was of the opinion that the Election officers can't

Speaker 2hear appeals against decisions made by judicial officers. So we will set up tribunals of former like retired high court judges. And those tribunals will then hear appeals against decisions of judicial officers. That is what happened essentially. So these judicial officers initially looked at 60 lakh cases flagged for logical discrepancies. And I'm sure I'm sort of throwing this term around a lot. What do you mean by logical discrepancies? There are a bunch of criteria based on which you could

Speaker 2be flagged as logical discrepancy. Just to give you one example, let's say the age gap between you and your parent is more than 50 years. So they would then flag you for logical discrepancy, saying that something seems off. And now the onus is on you to make your case for your eligibility. So that was the case of logical discrepancy. And these judicial officers, about, I think if I'm not wrong, 700 to 800 of them, in a very limited period of time, disposed of 60 lakh cases flagged for logical discrepancies. Of those 60 lakh, 27 lakh were eventually deleted and

Speaker 233 lakh remained on the roll. So when the court stepped in, they said, if someone is aggrieved by these decisions, you can file now appeals before the tribunals that we are setting up. At that point, and I just want to make this clear, you know, it's not as if, I guess what everyone assumed was that the appeals would be against decisions of deletions. That I'm amongst the 27 lakh, I was deleted, I want to appeal against this decision. Interestingly, what has happened is that it seems like now, Because

Speaker 2there's a huge number of appeals now before these tribunals. I think they run into 38, like 38.8 or something to that effect, and which is clearly more than the number of relationals. So now, apparently, there are appeals pending before the tribunal, even against the decision to include someone in the electoral roll. And what we understand is a big number of that has been filed by the election commission. So it's the EC appealing against the inclusion of a voter. And we've discussed this in the past that, you know, the attitude has always been inclusion, inclusion, inclusion. And, you know,

Speaker 2sort of you kind of see this playing out where they go to the tribunal saying that you included them or at least judicial officer included them. We feel they should still be out of the role for these following reasons.

Speaker 1Yeah, this is odd. And it was against this backdrop in August that the Supreme Court asked the Election Commission that, you know, give us a breakup of these appeals because there was a lot of opacity about this a lot of stuff that we did not.

Speaker 2Know so yes now what was very interesting is that while you and i may have thought that we are outside the commission and we don't know what's happening and you know so many of these people frankly but one would assume that people within nirvachan southern which is the headquarters would know and then during our investigation we discovered that apparently at least one of the election no actually both because vivek joshi or his office at least, asks for details just a few days before, coincidentally, a few days before the Supreme Court asks in August, asking that, can somebody tell us, you know, what's happening with these appeals?

Speaker 2What's the breakup? And then after the Supreme Court asks for this breakup, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu then writes a note saying that the court has asked, can somebody and I have been apparently he says something to the fact that we have been asking for this information quite some time can someone please tell us on what basis are these appeals being filed and then he lists out five questions and for me the most telling are the last three questions where he says did actually someone file appeals on behalf of the election commission and he's part of the commission if yes who authorized it you know And then once again, this is just a manifestation, you know, this is just them saying that we don't know what's happening

Speaker 2within the commission. And that, again, was quite interesting that clearly at least two out of the three election commissioners don't know if the election commission has gone into appeal against inclusion of voters. And if yes, who had authorized them to do that?

Speaker 1But these are all big revelations, right? The fact that election commissioners don't know whether EC has filed appeals or not. The fact that Form 6 has this new question, why can't EROs access their online portal? Tell us what happened when you reached out to the Election Commission about it. What did they have to say about why Sandhu and Joshi were kept in the dark?

Speaker 2So, of course, I mean, at the Indian Express, for any investigation we do, I mean, in the spirit of fairness and accuracy, we have to reach out. Of course, the documents are telling us a certain story. And for us, it was really important to know if all of these concerns that are being flagged, were they addressed? What we know from the investigation, no, they were not addressed. But let's say for whatever reason, if say we have missed it, it's only fair to allow the commission to respond. So of course, we wrote to the election commission, to the institution, to the spokesperson, and individually to the two election commissioners also,

Speaker 2because they were the ones who were repeatedly flagging these objections. And we, of course, wanted to know, aside from the fact that if the concerns were addressed, because it was only on the 9th of September, which is the first time in four months that they met. So we wanted to know maybe were there any discussions held. So interestingly, yes, we now have a response today after the investigation has appeared. But we did not get a response either from the two election commissioners or from the institution to any of our questions.

Speaker 1And what is the response now?

Speaker 2The response now is that they're saying, interestingly, no denial of the fact that there were objections. So it's not as if they are countering it that so-and-so, you know, there was, let's say, no objection as far as Form 6 is concerned or there were no concerns flagged as far as centralization of the electoral database is concerned. What they're saying is that all of this is part of the consultative process. You know, when you're trying to arrive at a conclusion, people will give quote unquote a lot of inputs and those inputs quote unquote help improve the electoral process. But in a way, the statementary tries to.

Speaker 2assure that all the decisions eventually made have the stamp of approval of all three election commissioners.

Speaker 1And this is in conflict with the fact that these two ECs are saying that they were in the dark about things.

Speaker 2So exactly. So why that? doesn't kind of sit right with what we know and frankly they don't address the fact nowhere does the statement say were at least these concerns addressed and if yes how and let's say even if you want to not get into that maybe it's too much of you know too much information what we do know is that while the statement claims that this has everyone's stamp of approval what explains the objections let's say for form 6 because in that case a decision is taken implemented after that an election commissioner asks, when

Speaker 2did this happen? So clearly, it didn't have one person's stamp of approval. And that same election commissioner says a couple of months, the other person had warned against this. He's clearly also not on board. So then now we know they didn't have two people's stamp of approval. So then whose approval does it really have? Is it just one person? Or for instance, when they are As you remember, the Manish Karg incident, this is the first time sort of in an unprecedented step, they go outside the commission, reach out to cabinet secretary and ask him to take action against Manish Karg. And the whole ground of that

Speaker 2move was that Manish Karg has issued an order without telling us. And this goes against the law. So clearly, it does not have their stamp of approval. Because if it did, why would they actually write individually to the cabinet secretary? Because that's a pretty extreme step to take. So the commission's response actually does not address this. It is a fairly detailed statement, but sort of there are broad strokes where they kind of try and assert that there are, you know, sort of in any consultative process,

Speaker 2they're bound to maybe some difference of opinion, but Be assured. And even for the ECI-Net, given that we have done one detailed story upon the centralization, they've said that, you know, we've been operating in accordance with the law. But again, no response to what happened in Goa because clearly what happened there was not in accordance with the law.

Speaker 1And do we have a sense of what other people in the commission make of all this?

Speaker 2It's actually very evident now. I mean, like I said, the commission meetings, yes, happen in a room. But when the commission doesn't sit for four months, it was very obvious to everyone in that building. There are quite a few people in that building. And frankly, all of these exchanges that are happening are not happening between three people. These are being marked to a lot of people. So over... Again, now I can say this or we can say this because... We've done the investigation, but it seems like it was sort of fairly public knowledge in that one building that the three are sort of, at least the two are

Speaker 2maybe not getting along. That was the sense. It was fairly, but again, it's for the three to kind of arrive at a consensus. But clearly two commissioners were being kept in the dark and everyone knew of it. But they're sort of fairly further down the food chain. It's not that it's on them to operate by consensus. It's for the CEC to at least try and take everyone into confidence.

Speaker 1And Ritika, what do you think these revelations do to people's trust in the EC and people's trust in the electoral process?

Speaker 2See, that's the thing that we are trying to flag, that on the face of it might, if you really want to, kind of a very reductive approach would be that these are just officers fighting amongst themselves. Or let's just say that consultative process, a couple of them disagree. But please understand that all of this affects or strikes right at the heart of the electoral process, which includes, for now at least, what we have proof for is the electoral roll, which is literally the foundation of the election process. And the whole objective of this investigation is

Speaker 2also to, we're not saying that elections are rigged right now, but let's say the centralization the two commissioners are warning about, you know, right now say it's just 97 voters who couldn't come back on a roll, but what if that is possible if it's possible to keep 97 people off a roll that's not the winning margin that would not have swung an election but then who is to know that that 97 would not turn into a few thousands you know or who's to know that that eventually doesn't turn into lags there's no guarantee right and frankly let's

Speaker 2see even if that's not happening it's let's say this is just an aberration 97 what does that really do to the commission's defense for decades now you know And again, and this is something a very senior election commissioner had once, I mean, a told us that it's not just that it has to be a free and fair election. The perception is really important. They cannot afford to lose the trust of the voter and the political party. The idea is to have the trust of all stakeholders, which means

Speaker 2the voters as well as the political parties, irrespective of whether it's a party in power. I mean, for them, it was equally important to even have the parties in opposition to have faith in that process.

Speaker 1And especially at a time when, you know, the opposition, particularly the Congress, has been alleging that the BJP controls the EC and it manipulates elections. These are allegations that it has been facing. So, at that time, to do this.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. So, when, of course, then that's not a good look for you, you know. To somebody, then they feel that this only corroborates that. And again, it's very important for... the election commission to retain that trust, to maintain that trust. Frankly, a lot of it just operates on faith, on good faith. And the commission has a lot of it. The commission has had the media on its side for a very long time, maybe not the parties for some time now. But that's purely because, like

Speaker 2I said, the structure, the decentralized structure of the election. But if you're going to change that, then frankly, there will be questions raised and those questions were raised within. I would still want to say that Some of these exchanges that we've seen are pretty recent. They are from last month. So what we can see is sort of the beginning of something, maybe something going slightly awry. So this is, again, not to suggest elections are rigged. All the parties that have come to power in the last one year, these have been elected. It's not to say that. But it's also very important for a newspaper to flag

Speaker 2that there seems to be something going wrong. And it's best to kind of fix that right in the beginning.

Speaker 1You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express. Today's show was written and produced by me, Shashank Bhargav, and was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it, share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can tweet us at Express Podcasts and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode