Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

An expert on how air pollution harms us and what we can do about it

Nov 12, 202637 minAudio

What do AQI levels actually tell us? What are the short and long term effects of air pollution? Why doesn’t the WHO recommend masks for air pollution? Do air purifiers really help? And what steps can the government take to tackle this problem effectively? Today on the show, we are joined by Dr. G.C. Khilani to discuss everything you need to know about air pollution. Dr. Khilani is the chairman of Pulmonary, Critical Care & Sleep Medicine at PSRI Hospital in Delhi and a member of the WHO's Technical Advisory Group on Air Pollution and Health. (This episode was first published on the 2nd of December, 2024) Hosted and produced by Shashank Bhargava Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hi, I'm Shashank Bhargav and you're listening to Three Things, the Indian Express news show.

Speaker 2Dr.

Speaker 1Khilani, you have been in the city for a while now. Do you recall a time when the air quality in Delhi was actually good?

Speaker 3Of course, we all know that the air quality in Delhi was amazing during COVID times.

Speaker 2When there was.

Speaker 3No traffic on the road, there was no movement, there was no factories running, the schools were closed, and you could see the blue sky which you see in New York, San Francisco.

Speaker 2Or Europe.

Speaker 3That was the time, and I have a picture of it, which I keep showing, and I show the India Gate, which is so clearly visible.

Speaker 2Besides that, Delhi.

Speaker 3Always had a very bad air pollution, especially in winter season.

Speaker 1That's Dr.

Speaker 2G.C.

Speaker 1Khilani. He's the chairman of the Pulmonary Critical Care and Sleep Medicine at the PSRI Hospital in Delhi. And he's also a member of the Technical Advisory Group on Air Pollution and Health at WHO. And in today's episode, we are dedicating the conversation to speaking to him about everything related to air pollution. What AQI levels actually indicate, how air pollution affects our bodies, the steps individuals can take, and what the government can do to reduce a city's pollution by half. And while this conversation is centered around Delhi,

Speaker 1it has important lessons no matter where you are in the country. So here's Dr. Khilani telling us the reasons why the capital's pollution is so bad.

Speaker 3So Delhi's air quality is bad, one, because of the geography, because the low-lying area is a part of the gigantic region where the air pollution is high, but.

Speaker 2Delhi is highest. As you know, it is the.

Speaker 3worst polluted city in the world. And there are so many reasons. So one of the reasons is the transport, that is vehicles. The number of vehicles in Delhi are more than Calcutta, Chennai and Mumbai combined. So the numbers are too large. Although everything is there, that pollution check is there and certificates are there, but there are issues about engine quality in city of Delhi also.

Speaker 2So that is transport is one.

Speaker 1And is that the biggest contributor?

Speaker 2More or less, yes.

Speaker 3That is the biggest contributor on an average.

Speaker 2It depends upon season.

Speaker 3But if you take annual average, then transport is the number one cause of air pollution. Besides this, the road dust and the construction dust, that's a very big contributor which is less talked about. You would have seen that, you know, big trucks moving and if you are, you know, or buses for that matter, if you are driving behind, you can see actually dust coming up, and every fourth house is being reconstructed or constructed, and demolition is going on,

Speaker 3and the norms are not followed. So the construction and demolition is another cause of air pollution. Beside this, 3-5% of the air pollution comes from the burning of the waste, municipal waste, which is done by the government, not by the people, and which is actually preventable. And if you talk about tandoors, there are 9,000 tandoors in this city, you know, for making chicken tikka and paneer tikka, and

Speaker 3they all run on coal and wood. So they are also a big source of air pollution.

Speaker 1And besides this, what is also highlighted when it comes to Delhi are outside factors, right? Can you talk about how much they contribute to the city's air pollution?

Speaker 2So one important thing that we need to understand that Delhi pollution is not only from generated in Delhi. A large proportion comes from outside Delhi, even from Afghanistan and Pakistan, Punjab. And if we talk about, say, distance of 300 kilometers within Delhi, there are many electricity generating plants. And except one, all are using coal.

Speaker 3And this is a big source of air pollution as far as the Delhi and NCR is concerned. And this is exemplified if you know that 10 worst polluted cities in India are Delhi, Gurgaon, Faridabad. Noida, Harford, they are around this area only. So this coal burning for electricity generation is a big source of air pollution. Besides that, of course, stubble burning, which is a periodic thing. And as I said, even from Pakistan, Afghanistan. And I have

Speaker 3talked about sources, but one of the reasons that air pollution continues to be worst in Delhi is the wind speed. Delhi geographically is a very low-lying area.

Speaker 2So the only.

Speaker 3Thing which reduces the AQI, as you must have read in the newspaper, that wind blow was good, the wind speed was good. So therefore, the air quality improved.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1Whenever the wind speed is high or it's not cloudy, the air quality improves. But you mentioned stubble burning and that makes so many headlines. How much does stubble burning actually factor into Delhi's air pollution?

Speaker 3So, stubble burning, anything between 5 to 18%. This is a rough figure and these are estimates actually. It depends upon the quantum of stubble burning, the area of burning and also wind direction. All those things matter, but the maximum what I have come to know with my knowledge is about 16 to 18% of the pollution coming from.

Speaker 2But that is episodic.

Speaker 3But the AQI in Delhi 12 months is much, much above. any acceptable limit, and if you talk about WHO standard, you might be shocked that the WHO average of PM2. 5 standard is 5 micron per cubic meter, whereas we are living at 250, 300, and WHO daily maximum is 15 micron. The 5 is annual average. So we are in trouble, and it's not new. It has been there for decades, actually.

Speaker 1And does the air quality get particularly bad during the winters or it's just that we can see smog in the air?

Speaker 3So what is smog? Smog is a combination of fog and air pollutants. When the temperature is down, the humidity is high, the air pollutants get trapped and there's something called inversion. Inversion is that air pollutants, instead of being equally distributed in the sky, they In the morning time when it is cold, it comes down at a breathable surface level. With that, visibility goes down, but also the concentration of air pollutants is extremely high. Whereas in summer,

Speaker 3despite the same vehicles and same, they go up. So that is why the effect is much less because the fog is not there. When the fog is there, winter is there, air pollution is there, the smog occurs.

Speaker 1And you mentioned a couple of factors that contribute to air pollution. You mentioned vehicles, you mentioned construction, garbage burning, stubble burning. Are they emitting different kinds of pollutants? And if that's the case, then how do those pollutants affect us differently?

Speaker 2Yeah, so that's an amazing question. PM2.

Speaker 35 from the petrol engine would be different from PM2. 5 from the diesel engine. Because diesel engine will emit lot of what we call it polyaromatic hydrocarbons which are carcinogenic. Whereas the petrol emission would cause more of asthma. Similarly, the PM2. 0 from firecrackers would have arsenic, thallium, potassium, very toxic substances which gets deposited.

Speaker 1PM2.

Speaker 25 from the road dust would be different. PM2. 5 from the construction and demolition will contain lot of fungi like this. So, PM2. 5 It's only something that we can measure and say.

Speaker 1And for those who might not know already, can you tell us what exactly PM2. 5 is? Because that's all we hear about these days.

Speaker 3So, you should understand that why these figures are quoted all the time. Because this is called aerodynamic diameter. How they are formed? They are formed by complex chemical reaction of noxious gases and other particles in the air.

Speaker 2So, PM10.

Speaker 3Why don't we talk about PM 15 or PM 20?

Speaker 2You know, after all, they are also small particles.

Speaker 1And this is the size of the pollutant.

Speaker 3Size of the aerodynamic diameter of the particle. The particles which are more than 10 micron are filtered by our nose. The God has provided with that filter so that foreign particles do.

Speaker 2Not go in.

Speaker 3So they cause cough and sore throat and blah, blah, blah. But the particles which are smaller than 2.5 micron, that is called PM2. 5, they go to the lowest part of the lung where gas exchange takes place. And they cause short-term as well as long-term diseases in the lung. But I would also like you to know there is something that we don't talk about, is ultra-fine particulate matter. This is PM0. 1 particle which are smaller than 2.5. 0.1 micron.

Speaker 3These are the particles which penetrate the lung and go into the blood vessel.

Speaker 2What is lung?

Speaker 3Lung is a filter through which the oxygen goes into the blood and carbon dioxide comes out. And with that other things also come out. But the particles which are less than 0.1 micron, they pass through that, what we call as allulose, go into the bloodstream and go into every part of our system. Like it may be brain, it may be eyes, it may be heart, it may be blood vessels, it may be kidney, intestine and everything.

Speaker 2That is why... The air pollution.

Speaker 3Affects every organ of the body and it is affecting our longevity as well as the quality of life.

Speaker 1And so when we look up the air quality index, the AQI of a place, and it shows us 200 or 500, what exactly is that number telling us? What does that number mean?

Speaker 3So the AQI that you hear is actually not made of one parameter.

Speaker 2AQI was... Sort of formulated.

Speaker 3In year 2012, there was a committee under the chairmanship of Dr. Mukesh Sharma, who is a professor of civil engineering in IIT. There was a 10 or 11 member committee and I was part of that and we sat down and discussed the health effects. So AQI is made of six parameters. One is of course PM2. 5, other is nitric oxide, other is sulfur dioxide, ozone and lead. Lead is no more very serious issue because it has been

Speaker 3taken off. So each parameter is given certain strength in that calculation. The final thing which comes out is one parameter AQI. So AQI should not be equated to PM2. 5.

Speaker 2It is a.

Speaker 3Mixture of all the six air pollutants. But while PM2. 5 affects the lung, Nitric oxide, sulfur dioxide, carbon monoxide, these gases will easily pass through the lung and go into the blood and they also cause their own harms and there are various adverse effects.

Speaker 1And so right now, are we measuring all these different kinds of pollutants?

Speaker 3Yes, the Central Pollution and Control Board measuring all the components except ozone. Ozone is not easy to measure, but they are measuring it for research purposes. But on a daily basis, ozone is not published. The rest of the parameters regularly are monitored at various stations by Central Pollution Control Board.

Speaker 1And, you know, we all know that pollution is bad for us. And we hear all the time that breathing in bad air is like smoking cigarettes and it reduces life expectancy. And in fact, some people react to that by saying, you know, I'm fine losing five years of life. I don't care that much about air pollution. But can you stress on how air pollution affects our quality of life and what are its long and short term effects?

Speaker 3So I'll talk about first the short-term effects of air pollution on us. And if you talk to any Delhiite today, you tell him that, look, I have some very bad throat, you know, my throat is so scratchy, I have running nose, I have got headache, and I'm coughing. Sometime I have to cough through the night. You will never get a sympathy because everybody has it. So they will say, okay, you have it, I also have it. So it's what we in French phrase you call fait accompli. This has

Speaker 3to happen every year. But this is not the only thing. Besides this, your feeling of well-being is affected. You feel more tired in the evening. Your appetite may go down. Quite importantly, slight heaviness of head is there. And what is lesser talked about, our sleep gets affected. If you are in a cleaner environment, you are more likely to sleep peacefully. But even without cough, that sleep quality gets affected.

Speaker 1And as someone who sees patients regularly, can you talk about the kind of problems you come across on a daily basis?

Speaker 3So about a month back, when I was sitting in my OPD, the AQI was Still in the 200 round category, but the pollution had started setting in. I got five consecutive patients who were my old patients who were happily living their life on inhalers or whatever treatment.

Speaker 2Consecutively, five patients came.

Speaker 3That we have increased cough, we have increased breathlessness, and we are unable to sleep. We have to sit up through the night. And when I asked the ST, they said we have no fever whatsoever. I do their x-ray, that is normal. And then I do their one test called fraction of exhaled nitric oxide. That is one exhales into a machine and we measure the nitric oxide, which is the measure of airway inflammation. All these patients have a high level of exhaled nitric oxide, which told me

Speaker 3that they have airway inflammation. So that means that there was increased inflammation there. due to the air pollution which led to exacerbation of their asthma or bronchitis or other respiratory ailments, some of them also landed up into the ICU. And not only that, those patients who were admitted with respiratory ailments during the high level of air pollution, their.

Speaker 2Response to treatment was very poor.

Speaker 3Instead of improving, despite the treatment which we thought giving was appropriate, they were not responding. At least two of my chronic patients with respiratory diseases, they got admitted. They knew it was because of the air pollution, and one knew that it was because of firecrackers, and he was unwilling to go home. and his response to the treatment was extremely poor. And this we know that even a viral infection, which should be trivial, at the time of

Speaker 3air pollution, it may take a serious turn and person may land into the ICU. There I also would like to tell you that children, young children, less than 5 years of age, and the elderly more than 60 or 65 years of age, And those who are having heart diseases or previous lung diseases or those who are immunocompromised because of diseases or chemotherapy or cancers, they are the people who are worst affected during this time.

Speaker 1And you know, there are a lot of people who claim that, you know, they are not being affected by any of this. So are they just not noticing some of these symptoms or have they just sort of got used to it?

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 3Those people who have allergic tendencies, those who are what we call technically as bronchial hyperreactivity, they are more likely to be affected. After all, if you give insult to five people, they react differently. So this is an insult to our lung. And everybody's lung will react differently and with different severity. And there are so many people who are traveling abroad and... They tell me and I also keep going. When I go to the Western world, I

Speaker 3go for morning walk, same person, same age, me. I walk for hour together, I don't get tired. And whereas here, I don't have that much energies or whatever you call it. One gets used to it, you stop complaining because it has been the visibility for that matter. If you land in the developed worlds and come out of the aircraft, you feel their vision has improved. And I would also like to tell you what is the evidence from India,

Speaker 3scientific evidence, that there are short-term implications. About 30 years back, There was a study conducted at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, which I was part of that. That's a published study where we collected the emergency visits of patients with asthma, COPD, and heart attacks over a period of one year and correlated with the level of air pollution. What was the conclusion was that there was 22 to 25 percent increase in the.

Speaker 2Rate of heart attacks.

Speaker 3Bronchitis and asthma attacks in response to the air pollution in last 48 hours. And actually that was the study which led to the vulnerable code taking cognizance and that time the CNG came and all the industries were asked to go 50 kilometers away from and that's how the daily air quality somehow improved in late 90s.

Speaker 1Okay, so, so far we have been talking about how our body gets affected immediately. What are the long-term effects of air pollution?

Speaker 3So, first I will talk about the respiratory effects. And if you talk about asthma, and today every third child has asthma. And Every other house where young children have nebulization machine. Whereas the incidence, prevalence of asthma in Indian children is about 5% or 10%.

Speaker 2But the daily children have.

Speaker 3The lung capacity of daily children as done by a study at All India Institute of Medical Sciences is much less than the lung capacity of Tirupati.

Speaker 2This study also is a published study long time back.

Speaker 3The COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, commonly causes bronchitis. And when we were studying, it was 90% was caused by tobacco smoking. And in India today, that COPD, 50% is caused by outdoor and indoor air pollution. And COPD is third leading cause of death all over the world. Talking about lung cancer, lung cancer is number one cancer killer all over the world.

Speaker 2More than prostate, breast, colon.

Speaker 3So lung cancer in the western world, 90% is caused by tobacco smoking. Whereas in India, 40% it occurs in non-smokers. And it is attributed to indoor and outdoor air pollution. And of course, we have already talked about acute exacerbation of asthma and COPD, which is caused by air pollution. So, as I talked in the beginning, that air pollution does not confine itself to lung. It percolates from lung to

Speaker 3all parts of the body. Almost every cancer, starting from intestine to urinary system to even uterus, ovary, the Incidence of cancer is higher if you are living in a polluted environment. Besides that, heart disease also occurs more because of obvious reasons. And everything culminates into quality of life and quantity of life. So India got, at the time

Speaker 3of independence, their life expectancy at birth in India was 32 years. Now we are at about 72 years. And the Chicago study, which was published in October 2023, estimated that because of the air pollution, that average life expectancy of Indian at birth is reduced by 5.3 years and 11.9 years for Delhiites.

Speaker 2So, this is very important for all of us to know that it's not about Delhi.

Speaker 399% of the Indians are living in the area where their pollution is more than what WHO standards.

Speaker 1Yeah, but WHO standards are like 5 and 15. So, do we know how badly our bodies get affected at say 200 AQI versus 500 or 800? So, more the level of AQI versus the.

Speaker 3I don't have the quantification of this. I'm not aware of any study. But the longitudinal study is done. There's something called Boston City Study. And the best evidence of effect of air pollution was documented during COVID. Where in Italy, you would recollect that initially Italy was worst affected. There was very high mortality. And the mortality in the North

Speaker 3Italy was four times higher than Southern Italy because the air pollution in North Italy was much higher. Similarly, the mortality in Germany and other parts of Europe, it was found out that if the NO2 levels were more than 100, the mortality was much higher as compared to the, if it was between 50 and 100. And if they're less than 50, the mortality was much, Similarly, in the United States,

Speaker 3each microgram increase in PM2. 5 led to higher mortality with COVID. So any infection that only exemplifies that any infection, be it any viral infection, if the pollution is high, it becomes worse and the outcome also becomes worse.

Speaker 1And you were talking about vulnerable people earlier and I was thinking about pregnant women. Does air pollution affect the fetus?

Speaker 3Definitely. Excellent question. So, before the pregnancy, it affects the fertility also. Air pollution also affects fertility. It also affects sperm count. But the fetus, yes, there is more incidence of what we call as intrauterine growth retardation, IUJR, more incidence of miscarriage. Also, the child which grows in the womb when the mother is exposed to poor air quality, his onward growth, even after taking birth, their growth is affected.

Speaker 2It's quite serious actually.

Speaker 1And so considering this and considering you see patients who get admitted to the ICU because of this, do you recommend people moving out of the city? And I know very few people can actually do that, but have you recommended that to people?

Speaker 2All the time.

Speaker 3And actually it is happening that my patients who are chronically ill, Those who have chronic lung disease, severe asthma, those who are on oxygen or who get repeated attacks, or those who can afford to leave city for two months or three months or even one month for that matter, I advise them to leave city. And the young people, young technocrats who are based in developed world and want to come back to India and they have small children, Delhi is not a preferred place for them. They prefer

Speaker 3to go to other cities. Because of this, because they are aware that their children's health will be jeopardized if they come to Delhi.

Speaker 1And which place do you recommend they go?

Speaker 2So, everything is relative.

Speaker 3If there is a technocrat is there, even Bangalore or Hyderabad or Mumbai will also be better. But Mumbai, I will see, so their air pollution is better.

Speaker 2So, that is how it is.

Speaker 1And for perhaps the 99% who can't leave the city, what are the things that they can do? And maybe we can start talking about masks. Does wearing a mask help?

Speaker 3So during COVID time, there was not a channel, TV channel where I didn't go saying that please use simple mask, cloth mask, three-ply mask and protect yourself and protect others. Unfortunately, for air pollution, WHO doesn't agree that any kind of mask works.

Speaker 1So WHO is saying that masks will not protect you against air pollution.

Speaker 2Air pollution.

Speaker 3WHO said that. But my thinking is that since WHO has got studies which are done on AQI of 25, they haven't studied the AQI of 300, 400, 500. So certainly the cloth mask or simple mask or three-ply mask does not help.

Speaker 2If something helps.

Speaker 3is N95 or there is something called KN99 mask. So if somebody is susceptible and he has to go to crowded market or he has to move out in a crowded place or air quality is very poor on that particular day and he must go out, then he should use N95 mask and not a simple mask. That is about the mask. And of course, initially you do feel claustrophobic. You find the breathing out is Only one thing is

Speaker 3that COVID time we said don't use mask with a valve because you will be emitting virus into the system if you are infected. Because the breathing becomes better when you use a valve mask. But pollution you are infecting nobody. So you can use a mask with a valve if you feel more comfortable using that.

Speaker 1What about air purifiers? Do they help at all?

Speaker 3So what is air purifier? Air purifier has got two components. One is a filter which filters 2.5, PM 2.5.

Speaker 2Another is adsorbitant, AD.

Speaker 3Adsorbitant that adsorbs the gases like nitric oxide, sulfur dioxide, carbon monoxide. And the air which comes out is purer. And nowadays the air purifiers will demonstrate whether it's pink or, you know, blue or, you know, whether it's 30 or 200 or whatever. So, presumably, the air that you breathe is better. But one thing, that there is a way that you should use your air purifier. Number one is

Speaker 3that air purifier should be of the capacity which is commensurate with the volume of your room. It is not that you procure one air purifier and keep it in the Living room and thing that your house is purified, that is not there. Second is the room has to be completely closed. All windows and doors should be closed. Third thing is that the flow of air from the air purifier preferably should be an area where you are there. So if you are sleeping, then it should be in that direction. Fourth thing is that the filter should be

Speaker 3replaced as per the recommendation. It can become a source of fungal infections if the air filters are not. Windows and doors, if you keep opening for tea, coffee, food, somebody coming, coming out, it becomes useless. And lastly, the WHO doesn't agree that air purifier leads to improved health. But my thinking is that, because I was in Geneva in a meeting as a member of expert committee, and I sort of argued that your.

Speaker 2Studies are at 2.

Speaker 3AQI of 50 or PM 2.5 of 30 or 20, but we are breathing at PM 2.5 of 200. So same recommendation cannot apply. So they said we have no evidence that it helps in the health. But I think the air purifiers are good. And one thing which I must emphasize that it should not be used like air conditioner, that when you enter the room, you put on the AC.

Speaker 2It should be on all the time.

Speaker 1And you mentioned keeping doors and windows closed. But one thing we have heard often in the past regarding indoor airport is that there should be proper ventilation so what is a good time to actually ventilate your house no.

Speaker 3No but the thing is that that good windows is there if you are cooking in that room or you know you are doing some activity which which generates some fumes then the windows should be open otherwise it doesn't.

Speaker 1Matter And any other tips for people who want to step out? Any places that they should avoid? And also, what is the best time to exercise?

Speaker 3So, few tips I would like to give. Those people who are susceptible, and I've already said elderly and with diseases, they must not go to crowded markets. Because air pollution, when you say AQI is 300 or 400 or.

Speaker 2200, it's not uniform.

Speaker 3Like if you measure the air pollution at the intersection, a busy intersection, which may be ITO or Chirag Delhi or whatever, it will be very high. And if you go from there 20 meters, 50 meters, it will keep on reducing till the time a plateau comes. Similarly, if you go to the crowded market, and I need not recite those names, it's not good. Those kind of markets, you feel choked actually, where actually the air pollution is very high. So those things should be avoided. And of course,

Speaker 3when the AQI is bad, one should not think of exercising. Early morning exercise in city of Delhi during winter is big no-no. As I told at the beginning that because of the inversion, the air pollutants are at the breathable level. So we breathe about 500 milliliters of air with every breath. And when you exercise, then you breathe, especially when you jog, this quantum becomes five types. And inevitably your mouth will open and you will breathe more through the mouth than

Speaker 3your nose.

Speaker 2So that filter gets bypassed.

Speaker 3The whole air which you are breathing directly goes without filtration in the lungs. So the adverse effects of pollutants are much more in the morning. So therefore, big no-no for... early morning when the smog is there. However, if you have time when the sun is bright, which is uncommon in Delhi, that is a better time to go for a walk and stepping out and doing some exercises. And there is an evidence for that. I should not be talking without evidence. There was a very elegant study conducted

Speaker 3in London. What they did was people above 60 years of age They made them walk in the Oxford Street, where a lot of diesel buses run, and did their lung functions before and after the walk. And they documented that their lung functions diminished after the walk. And they also did some inflammatory markers, which are actually highly technical, before and after, in their blood. So there was a definite increase in their inflammation in the system in response

Speaker 3to walking on Oxford Street. Same people, then they made them walk in.

Speaker 2The Hyde Park.

Speaker 3Hyde Park is a large park in London, and their lung function improved. So, this is the best evidence that we have, that walking in the polytrate area reduces your lung function. There is more inflammation in your blood, which will affect all the systems of the body. So, therefore, reiterating that it is better to do indoor exercises than to go out.

Speaker 1And lastly, you mentioned that Delhi's air pollution is because of many factors. There is the weather, there are external factors, you have dust coming in from the Middle East. But the other major factors are vehicles and garbage burning and construction. How is it that the government, you know, after all these years still struggles to tackle these issues?

Speaker 3So this is a political question, but I would tell you the science. There was a very elegant study done by the same Dr. Mukesh Sharma and Dr. Divedi from IIT Kanpur. They did a study in India, in the city of Delhi. And they documented that if you do following things, your air pollution would be much less.

Speaker 2And I will just narrate briefly.

Speaker 3If you vacuum clean the roads four times in a month and wash them also, If you carpet the sides of the road with some kind of greenery, if you follow the demolition and construction activities with the norms which are well known, I need not narrate that. If you deshock and denox the electricity generation plant, and there are machines which can do that, that same electricity would be generated without emission of NO2 and SO2, which are the

Speaker 3main sources. Outcomes of this, if you stop the municipal burning completely, and if you convert all the 9,000 tandoors from coal to wood into the LPG or electrical, and if you do what you call as carpooling, if you do all this, there will be at least 50% reduction in the air pollution. And this is a published study in the year 2016. So that is where we are.

Speaker 1And are there any lessons we can take from other countries or cities that have managed to do this?

Speaker 3That's an excellent question. So as a documented Chicago study, so that same study also says that China in 2014 had Beijing, especially China, had similar air pollution that we have in Delhi. And they took it on war footing. And their life expectancy has improved by 2.2 years. So there is solid evidence that if you, long-term evidence, that if you improve your air quality, your health quality improves. So,

Speaker 3and if you talk about California, 100 years back, they had pollution something like what we have in Delhi. 100 years down the line, their number of cars have gone up by 10 times. And their air pollution has gone down by 10 times. It is only because of good practices including engine quality.

Speaker 2And fuel quality.

Speaker 3Evidence is there. We have to follow it. There should be will on the part of policymakers.

Speaker 2Share it with.

Speaker 1A friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can tweet us at Express Podcast and write to us at podcast at IndianExpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode