Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

MPSC paper leak protests, Garba's commercial boom, and Kolkata's deadly stampede

Oct 19, 202635 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Alok Deshpande about the 11-day protest by Maharashtra government-job aspirants, the allegations of examination irregularities that triggered it, and how political intervention led to an inquiry and the MPSC chairman going on leave. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Ritu Sharma about Garba’s evolution from a traditional Gujarati folk dance into a multi-crore cultural enterprise, and the role played by Bollywood, social media, migration and government promotion. (13:50) And in the end, we look at the stampede at Kolkata’s Chorbagan Durga Puja pandal that killed 19 people, the combination of rain, overcrowding and confusing announcements that may have triggered it, and the questions raised over crowd management and safety. (31:50) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Niharika Nanda and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In today's episode, we look at how Garba has evolved from a traditional Gujarati folk dance into a multi-crore cultural and commercial phenomenon. We also turn to Kolkata, where a deadly stampede at a Durga Puja Pandal killed 19 people and raised serious questions about crowd management and safety.

Speaker 2But first.

Speaker 1We talk about Maharashtra, where an 11-day protest by government job aspirants in Pune has ended with the state government ordering an inquiry into alleged examination irregularities.

Speaker 3For thousands of young people in Maharashtra, Competitive examinations conducted by the Maharashtra Public Service Commission, or MPSC, represent a pathway to secure government employment.

Speaker 1Many spend years preparing for these exams, often with considerable financial sacrifices by their families. But now, allegations of question paper leaks and irregularities in the recruitment process have raised serious concerns among aspirants about whether these examinations are being conducted fairly. And this comes at a time when students across the country have been questioning the fairness and credibility of competitive examinations. From protests in Jharkhand over alleged JPSC

Speaker 1examination irregularities to the massive demonstrations we saw at Delhi's Jantar Mantar following the neat.

Speaker 4UG paper leak.

Speaker 1Now in Maharashtra, The immediate controversy centred on the alleged leak of a Food and Drug Administration recruitment examination.

Speaker 4Paper held in March.

Speaker 1This prompted students to take to the streets in Pune, demanding accountability and the resignation of MPSC chairman Vivek Bhivanwar.

Speaker 4And for 11.

Speaker 1Days, aspirants gathered at the SM Joshi Bridge, refusing to call off their agitation until their demands were addressed. The protests have also drawn significant political attention. To know more about what exactly triggered the MPSC protests and what role

Speaker 1did opposition leaders play in shaping the outcome, we are joined by The Indian Express's Alok Deshpande, who reported on the story for the newspaper. Alok, to begin with, what exactly happened in Pune? Like, how did an 11-day agitation lead to the commission's chairman going on leave?

Speaker 5So the entire thing started over the examination conducted for food and drug administrative officers. The examination was conducted in March. The result was announced in June. And by July, there was this allegation that the examination papers were leaked of this exam. So the Maharashtra Public Service Commission, which conducted the examination, initially denied.

Speaker 6That any such incident had happened.

Speaker 5But ultimately, when the people came out and, you know, the probe took place, everything happened. Some people were arrested and then ultimately they had to accept that, you know, the leak did take place. Now, after this incident, the students started protesting. First demand was to cancel this exam. which was subsequently accepted. But that was just the trigger. The MPSC students have been protesting for many years now, especially there was a protest in 2025 as well. There

Speaker 5were protests in the previous years as well. They have multiple demands. One of them was, you know, the leak of online examination papers. There have been incidents in the past as well, be it agriculture officer examination or some other department examinations. And the protest was about bringing transparency into the entire system, as well as there were some concerns about the format of the examination.

Speaker 6For example, the demand is large.

Speaker 5Not to have descriptive, but to have objective examination papers. Then there was this demand to clean the entire MPSC system as well from the students. So the FDF, Food and Drug Administrative Officers Examination, became the trigger and the entire protest just became a big protest. Then as the protest continued, the demand was to remove MPSC Chairman Vivek.

Speaker 6Bhimanwar, who was at that position at that time.

Speaker 1Right, and during your reportage when you spoke with Bhimanwar, he maintained that the examination leak actually occurred before he became chairman. So why did the protesters insist that he should resign?

Speaker 5Yeah, Bimanwar has been saying that it was not under his tenure that the leak of FDA examination has happened. And on the contrary, his claim is that he has been trying to clean the system and he has accepted all the demands raised by students and he's ready to speak with them, negotiate with them, listen to them and do what they are saying. But one of the demands is to remove him. It is because initially he had rejected that any such thing had happened. Initially, the MPSC

Speaker 5had refused to accept that the FDA leak took place.

Speaker 6Also, Bimanwar, when he was.

Speaker 5Appointed as MPSC chairman, there are allegations from several protesters that he was appointed at that position only because he's a very close aide of Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis. So that's his only qualification to be there. There were allegations about his tenure as the Transport Commissioner of Maharashtra, from which he is now retired. But there were allegations about his conduct and several decisions that he had taken. So The students were saying that we don't want a person who has a very dubious kind of track record in

Speaker 5his previous services as our MPSC chairman. And that is why the students were demanding that students as well as the political leaders who are leading this to protest were demanding that he shouldn't be at this position.

Speaker 1And Alok, we understand that the government has now constituted a panel to look into the alleged examination leaks and the weaknesses in the recruitment process. And you spoke to Bhimianwar after the government announced the inquiry. And he insisted that his decision to go on a leave was entirely voluntary and guided by his moral conscience.

Speaker 4So how do we read that?

Speaker 5So what happened was the Maharashtra government has appointed a five-member panel and that panel is going to be.

Speaker 6Chaired by a retired judge, Dili Bosele.

Speaker 5The task in front of that panel will be to examine alleged irregularities.

Speaker 6In MPSC exam, including paper leaks.

Speaker 5The panel has been given 60 days in total to submit its report. So that panel is not limited to one particular exam. It will cover, you know, at least it is expected to cover multiple exams. There have been past exams of Group B services or then there are police sub-inspector exams, agriculture, exercise department, previous all the examinations. So it essentially means that this panel will be covering entire functioning of the Maharashtra Public Service Commission. The secretary

Speaker 5of this panel is current FDA Commissioner Tukaram Munde. Now, that was one of the demands of students that he should be appointed because at present, he's considered as one of the honest officers in the Maharashtra's bureaucracy. And on this background, at a time when a panel is going to examine the entity, Our MPSC system, it was inappropriate for any chairman to be there at this position. And just to ensure that there are no new allegations of conflict of interest, I think Mr. Bhimanoor decided that he

Speaker 5will step down from the post. Now, are we going to say that there is no political pressure on him? Obviously, he won't accept that even if there was a political pressure on him. But what he has said on record is that there is no political pressure on him to resign. It was his moral conscience that based on which he decided that he will step down.

Speaker 1And there's another high profile committee that you write about, which has been formed parallelly, right?

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 5Apart from this inquiry panel, Maharashtra government has also appointed another committee of senior serving IS officers led by Maharashtra's additional chief secretary, V. Radha, that Committee also includes Maharashtra's DGP Sadanandate.

Speaker 6It's a very high profile committee.

Speaker 5That committee has been traveling to all administrative headquarters of Maharashtra and they are interacting with various stakeholders of MPSC from students to workers to activists to teachers, the coaching classes. Everybody is welcome and they are asking their submissions. their recommendations, their inputs to better the entire system. So that committee is also expected to submit its reports and recommendations.

Speaker 1And Alok, we also see Rohit Pawar kind of emerging as the main political intermediary between protesters and the government. Talk about how has this agitation given him a significant political opening? Like how did he become such a central figure in the protests?

Speaker 5Rohit Pawar has been very aggressively active as an opposition leader in Maharashtra for several months now.

Speaker 6As you know, Maharashtra does not.

Speaker 5Have a leader of opposition because the reason that we have been given is, you know, they don't have enough strength to have LOP in Vidhan Sabha or Vidhan Parishad. So that is the reason that we don't have a leader of opposition. Now Rohit Pawar is from the Nationalist Congress Party led by Sharad Pawar, which is in opposition right now. And he has been touring the entire state aggressively, raising various issues as an opposition leader. He was one of the first leaders who had raised the issue of

Speaker 5leak of FDA examination. When he had raised the issue, there came the denial. from MPSC. But he continuously raised this issue and ultimately MPSC had to accept that there were leaks and everything. He also became political face of the entire agitation when he led the students protest march in Pune. It was attended in large numbers by students in Pune because we have to understand that Pune is a center of, you know, where students across the state

Speaker 5come and study for MPSC examination. And these students, majority of them come from Marathwada area of the state. And typically, these are from farming families. You know, they come here with their aspirations that they become government officers and they're ready to serve the state as a government officer. So they are a very large number. And that protest march of students was a huge one. Also, he ensured that all political leaders, including Rahul Gandhi, extend their support to

Speaker 5the agitation of MPSC students. All opposition political leaders attended the protest. They addressed the students.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 1And alongside Pawar, you highlight how Congress MLA Vishwajit Kadam also played an important role.

Speaker 4So how significant was his contribution?

Speaker 5Yeah, Congress MLA Vishwajit Kadam, who was there as a backup to, you know, the entire protest, who ensured all the students are getting facilities, food while protest is going on and everything. So these two leaders, you know, successfully handled the entire agitation. And that is why there was this political attack. on him as well from the BJP, which is ruling in Maharashtra, that the entire agitation is sponsored by NCPSP.

Speaker 6But despite all the attacks and all.

Speaker 5The allegations and everything, I think these two leaders, Rawit Par, Ishwajit Kadam, then Shivraj More, Maharashtra Youth Congress President, they all continued with the protest and ultimately Bhimranath had to go on a leave.

Speaker 1And Alok, how has the government responded? Because initially, we understand the government resisted removing Bhimanwar.

Speaker 4So how did that evolve?

Speaker 5BJP government did not want to look weak and they had said that they cannot sack Bhimanwar because it's a constitutional position and only the president has the power to remove him from that position. So initially the government was reluctant but as the protest continued, you know, what happened was there were political attacks on one side.

Speaker 6Then apart from this particular agitation.

Speaker 5There was other group of students which was agitating at a different location in Pune itself. Now that protest was attended by various leaders of the BJP. So it was very evident that BJP was clearly setting up another protest just to divert the attention. There was a meeting of MPSC students along with BJP MLA with Chief Minister Devendra Padnavis. And in that meeting, Chief Minister Devendra Padnavis announced that he is ready to accept majority of demands of the students.

Speaker 5And even the government is going to have a massive recruitment drive soon. So there was a clear attempt. The government was at one time it was negotiating. It was politically attacking. There were two protests taking place apart from this original one. So all these kind of methods were used by the government to ensure that this protest either breaks up or, you know, gets weakened.

Speaker 1And next, we talk about Garba, which has evolved from a traditional Gujarati dance form into a multi-crore enterprise. Every year, as October approaches, states across India begin preparing for the nine-day.

Speaker 2Festival of Navratri.

Speaker 1While the festival is celebrated through different traditions across the country, the fervour remains the same. Now, in our previous episode, we looked at how Durga Pooja celebrations are intertwined with the politics of Bengal and the extent to which the festivities this year are changing under the new BJP government in the state. But today, we head west to Gujarat, where people celebrate the festival with Garba and Dandiya. We look at how Garba has evolved over the years, growing from a traditional folk dance into a major commercial enterprise.

Speaker 4Bani lilai, badi lilai, lila naakar, bai naakar.

Speaker 1Now, while many festive traditions remain largely rooted in the regions they originated in, Garba has travelled well beyond Gujarat, gaining popularity both nationally and globally. What was once a traditional Gujarati folk dance performed in colourful chanya churlis has grown into a multi-crore enterprise, with cities like Delhi and Mumbai developing vibrant Garba scenes of their own. To understand Garba as an art form, how it has evolved over the years, and the business that has grown around it,

Speaker 1my colleague Niharika Nanda speaks with the Indian Express's Ritu Sharma, who reported on this for the paper.

Speaker 4Ritu, let's start with the origins of Garba.

Speaker 8How did the dance form emerge and what did its early forms look like?

Speaker 7So Garba is the ritualistic and devotional dance form that was once performed only by women in their homes and in temple courtyards during these nine nights of Navratri. So the Indian Express spoke to some of the experts who have documented its journey, one of them being Professor Parul Shah. She is a former dean and HOD of Faculty of Performing.

Speaker 2Arts, MSU in Vadodara. So what she told me was that the.

Speaker 7Word Garba or Garbo originated from Sanskrit word Garbdeep and it symbolizes an earthen pot with circular holes, popularly known as Garbo. So this earthen pot is a symbol of human body and the lamp inside, it signifies a divine soul. So what Professor Shah told in an express that the Garbha is not dated, but it has connections with the dynasties that had ruled Gujarat and also the peasantry and the agricultural classes. It also has variations with Dandiya, Dandiya Ras,

Speaker 7which is done using those sticks. So then with the establishment of Shaktipit Ambaji Temple in Banaskanta district around 700 years ago, people started worshipping through the Garbha of Mataji. And the festival is dedicated to the worship of the feminine energy or the Shakti. And as each village would have a Mataji temple, so women would do Sthapna or the installation of Mataji in the Chonk, which is popularly known as Chacha Chonk, and do Aarti and dance and

Speaker 7sing Garba.

Speaker 2And with the.

Speaker 7Development, it travelled to poles or loosely, that would mean kind of Mahallas and streets.

Speaker 2And local residents still.

Speaker 7Recall that during that time, it would take more than an hour for a garbo, which is the earthen.

Speaker 2Pot, to return to its starting point.

Speaker 7So people would gather in such huge numbers that time also. And people would sing and dance without any sound or lighting system at that time.

Speaker 2Yeah, so this is how garba started in Gujarat.

Speaker 8And over the years, from a dance form that was practiced in courtyards and temples, how has Garba grown within Gujarat?

Speaker 7In December 2023, Garba in Gujarat received the inscription on the representative list of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity by UNESCO. And I would say from villages and small towns in the desert area of Kach and North Gujarat, to the villages and towns along its long coastline, from the larger cities like Ahmedabad, Surat, Vadodara, or to the smaller ones like Bhavnagar and Jamnagar. So Garba is celebrated every year, everywhere, with equal joy and devotion. And earlier,

Speaker 7as only women would sing and perform Garba, the men, there were a few men though, they were criticized for doing so. But today, men are equally participating in the Garba. The Garba events have moved forward. from the poles to large party plots and grounds, especially along the highways and even to remote.

Speaker 2Outskirts of the cities.

Speaker 7And over the past few decades, I would say it crossed geographical and even in cultural boundaries and is celebrated across India and the world with equal zeal where the Gujarati diaspora resides, inviting everyone to the festivities. From celebrations in villages to celebrations in large public spaces with elaborate orchestral support, high-fetched singers, latest sound and light systems, even theme-based side decorations. So Garba is a festival where people

Speaker 7from all walks of life are enthusiastically involved in conceptualizing, planning, organizing, and even participating in the event. So this performative and... Visual celebration of Garbha takes place within homes and temple courtyards, public spaces in villages, urban squares, streets, large open grounds. So thus Garbha becomes an all-encompassing participatory community, event-inducing. And Ritu, we understand that there are different forms of Garbha, right? So can you tell us about some of them? Yeah, there are different forms. So the Garbha, which is the visual expressions of the feminine energy. expressed through the garba

Speaker 7dance that has an earthenware pot lit with a lamp, which is the gargri or an image of Mata Ji, Amba Mata Ji, Mother Goddess, placed in the centre around which the participants dance. So the dancers move around the pot in an anti-clockwise circle using simple feet movements while singing and clapping, hands in unison. And the traditional and most common garbha from form is accompanied by dhol and other musical instruments. The movements start and end with the

Speaker 7dancers facing the inside of circle while dancing each dancer circles around their own axis. So without any physical contact with others while continuing to maintain the larger circle. So starting with slow circular movements and gentle clapping, the tempo slowly builds up to a frenzied whirling and there are different styles of executing dandiya steps like the dodio simple five or simple seven or triconio where the hand movement forms an imagery triangle or three claps or butterfly two

Speaker 7claps and so these are the different forms of garba and ras so there are also some unusual forms i would like to mention like for particularly in amdabal where Men are dressing as women to perform Garba. This is a tradition which is known as the Sadhu Ma Garbo, which is done on the eighth night of Navratri for one day only.

Speaker 8And Garba is a dynamic dance form that has evolved over the years. And even the music associated with it has grown and changed.

Speaker 4So how did that happen?

Speaker 7Yeah, so as in the early 20th century, people collected the garbas. Garba here, I mean the songs, the devotional songs, which were passed on from the mothers to their daughters and this went on for generations. So it is said that the first garbas, which is said to be the Ananda Garba, it has 118 paras and it was written by Vallabh and Dhola brothers. And it's said that it's even sung today. So people would memorize these Garbha, the

Speaker 7devotional songs, as there was no recording at that time. And Satsang mandalis for Garbha, they were performed as early as 1949. And one such being was formed by Sri Jeetubhagat. The mandali was Sri Jeetubhagat Satsang Mandali in Ahmedabad. And particularly talking about this Garbha as a dynamic dance form, the practitioners and singers of Garbha, they share that The folk dance has changed drastically and over time and stating or calling it as a part of the cycle of life.

Speaker 2So Professor Shah, she.

Speaker 7Says that Garba has been redefined by every generation through the adoption of new performative styles, contemporary lyrics. and changing fashion trends while keeping the circle of feminine energy or Shakti intact.

Speaker 2So it remains a living tradition.

Speaker 7But I would say, however, some old-timers who see Garbha as essentially an expression of devotion, they are put off by the modern commercial dimensions this celebration has acquired in recent years. Then there is an increasingly visible presence of communal elements also lately. So who have in recent years sought to associate themselves with Navratri, claiming to keep a check, on the participants. However, the increasing inclination, I would say, towards the traditional garba forms is seen lately among the youth.

Speaker 7And I would say, which is a reason the forms like Sheri Garba, which is a street garba or the Mandali Garba, where only the music instruments are used. They are becoming more popular lately. And over the years, we can see more events based on these Sheri and Mandali Garbas.

Speaker 8Also, do you think Bollywood has also contributed to some extent to how garba has evolved?

Speaker 4Especially the music.

Speaker 2Yeah, I would say that.

Speaker 7But that would be a case in other festivals also, like Holi. During Holi, we have Bollywood songs which are based particularly on Holi and that become popular during the festival Holi. So I would say, yes, Bollywood has its impression on Garba. But we have our own.

Speaker 2Gujarati singers, very popular singers.

Speaker 7Who are more in demand. And people follow these songs which are written and sung by these. And even as I just mentioned, the oldest Anand Garbo, which is still sung today. So there is a mix of people who still prefer those old traditional Garbas, which are the songs, devotional songs.

Speaker 8And now in the last few years, we have noticed that Garba has moved beyond Gujarat. and is celebrated across the country. So much so that it has become a multi-crore celebration. Even Delhi, for that matter, has a pretty vibrant Garba scene every Navratri.

Speaker 4So, can you tell us how did that happen?

Speaker 7Yeah, so that's good to hear that cities like Delhi and other states, they are celebrating Garbha with equal fervour and enthusiasm as Gujarat.

Speaker 2But yes, that's correct.

Speaker 7Establishing itself as a multi-crore economy, Navratri and Gujarat takes new form every season. I would say be the resurgence of the traditional form, as I just mentioned, Mandli and Sheri Garbha, or from open grounds to even to enclosed areas. humongous air conditioned domes looking at because few years back there was a depending upon the unpredictability of the season there were rains during some navratri season then also these days it's very hot even today i would say amdabad has a temperature of 33 at this time it's 33

Speaker 7degree celsius So now they have moved from open grounds to enclosed air-conditioned domes. So then there are theme-based Navratri nights, like sustainable and eco-friendly. And you would be surprised that there are separate Garba events which are dedicated for dogs and cats and their pet parents. So the Navratri Garba celebrations, they are a massive economy enterprise right from the owners of the party plots, the planners of the event, the choreographers, and providers of sound and light systems, even to those

Speaker 7who are involved in the food industry, the artisanal community of potters, blacksmiths, carpenters, the decorators, and then there's this cloth and jewellery industry and even the accessories which are like very popular different kinds of accessories they have there's a different market industry for that and also many schools and universities they are offering professional courses in dance and music costume and ornament design and landscape planning sound and

Speaker 7light design so which all contribute to garba creations And also like part of this huge multi-clore economy. And I'm told US and Canada, they have been following, if not more, the equal forward enthusiasm in these countries also.

Speaker 8And Ritu, as a Delhiite, my first introduction to the concept of Garba as an art form, as a dance form, was Tariq Mehta Ka Uta Chashma. So do you think TV serials exploring the Gujarati culture, and of course, along with that social media, have also led to Garba's popularity to some extent?

Speaker 7I would say to some extent, but I would say there are other factors also. Since the Gujaratis are this huge diaspora in other countries, and as I just mentioned, US, and they have been there not since last one decade or two decades, they have been there since decades now. So with them, they have taken the culture, the dance form. And yes, I would say social media can be one of the reasons, but It would be not for the expansion of Garba or making it popular, but to some extent to the kind of trends which are catching up.

Speaker 2I would say be it in.

Speaker 7Fashion or the style or these treatments. So I would say social media has contributed to this more than the popularity of Garba, making Garba more popular. But to some extent, making certain trends more popular through the social media or the kind of the catch up or the race, like even everybody wants to follow a certain kind of trend, which is popular on social media, a certain kind of fashion trend, accessories trend. So that would be more rather than the popularity of Garba per se.

Speaker 8And we understand that the state of Gujarat and the government there also contributes towards this growing trend, right?

Speaker 2Yeah, that's correct.

Speaker 7Beyond the nine days of Navratri festival, so Garba in Gujarat is also performed at social and cultural events like weddings, childbirth or other occasions. And the wider diaspora of Gujarat community residing in other parts of India and even overseas, they continue to participate in Garba or Navratri in every celebratory occasions. And social groups like Yuvak Mandals and Garba

Speaker 7is then being followed, being done in apartment complexes. Even planners and clubs in cities, they organize Garba nights, accompanying musicians ranging from.

Speaker 2An individual dholi, who is a drummer.

Speaker 7To large musical groups and along with poets and writers of traditional and contemporary Garba songs. They're all also part of practitioners and bearers of Garba.

Speaker 2So they all contribute towards this growing trend.

Speaker 7The Gujarat government, they started organizing this vibrant Navratri festival in somewhere in 2003. And in all these years, they have been organizing this in amdabad there's this ground called gmdc ground so they have been organizing this festival every way every year in amdabad but this time what they did was it was new this time this year that they have started ticketing it Though they're not calling it tickets, they are calling it a registration fee, which is of nominal, the government is calling it as a token fee of

Speaker 7rupees 100. And the reason they are stating for putting a fee, registration fee on this event for the first time is to check the number of participants and also to kind of maintain a discipline during all these nights, nine nights. So the government has been funding, has been organizing this event every year in Ahmedabad.

Speaker 8And Ritu, you mentioned in your story that cosmetic treatments tend to see a rise during Navratri.

Speaker 4Can you talk a bit about that?

Speaker 7So there has been always been a relationship between these two. And now I would say today, the elements of fashion, style, decoration, trends, choreography. So they have accentuated and with the presence of social media. So they have taken over Garba, which originally it had no importance of fashion and looks, but only expression of devotion. And.

Speaker 2With the latest cosmetic technologies.

Speaker 7There has been a surge in the demand, which the usual spas and now they have been taken over by the dermatologists. So there was a demand during Navratri. There has been a demand. But this time, what was noted is that the latest cosmetic technologies So the usual facials and body scrubs, they have been taken over by the latest therapies like glutathione or HIFU or carbon peeling and others for this instant glow, which has been the latest trend.

Speaker 2Equally among boys and girls.

Speaker 7And so the derma experts in town, they shared that these therapies are lately getting popular for some time now, but their demand has increased many fold during the Navratri and especially among the younger generations.

Speaker 2Yeah, so there has been an increase in demand in cosmetic treatments.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a deadly stampede at one of Kolkata's prominent Durga Pooja Pandals, where 19 people were killed and at least 25 injured after rain, overcrowding and a confusing announcement appear to have combined into a disastrous crowd surge. Now, the incident took place at the Chor Bagan Durga Pooja Pandal on Saturday evening. when a large crowd had gathered in narrow lanes leading to the venue. In some stretches, only three or four people

Speaker 1could walk side by side. Investigators are still establishing exactly what triggered the panic. As reported by the Indian Express's Ravik Bhattacharya, Autri Mitra and Sweety Kumari, officials and eyewitnesses say heavy rain prompted people to rush towards the Pandal for shelter. Around the same time, An announcement was allegedly made suggesting that the structure could collapse if the crowd was not brought under control. Police have also said an announcement by private security personnel accompanied by whistles may have

Speaker 1triggered the sudden movement. Locals have additionally raised questions about crowd management. They allege that there were too few trained volunteers, that emergency arrangements were inadequate, and that an ambulance did not appear to have been stationed nearby. There is also scrutiny over whether a rope being used to separate or regulate the crowd was removed when the rain began, allowing people to surge together. Authorities say this is one of the several possibilities under investigation. Kolkata police have now arrested

Speaker 1seven people, including office bearers of the Pujo Committee, crowd control personnel, a Pandal construction worker and private security officials. They are being questioned over alleged failures in crowd management, safety protocols and structural arrangements.

Speaker 4Meanwhile, the West Bengal.

Speaker 1Government has announced 25 lakh rupees and a government job for the family of each person killed, while safety inspections have been ordered at major pandals across the state.

Speaker 2You were listening to Three Things by The Indian Express.

Speaker 1Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Niharika Nanda and me, Ichha Sharma. If you like the show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You can also recommend it to someone you think may like it, with a friend or in your family. This is the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast or write to us at podcast at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode