Behind the LPU protests, deep-tech funding, and Flydubai flight incident
31 minAudio
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Raakhi Jagga about the protests that took place at Punjab's Chitkara University and Lovely Professional University. She discusses the reasons behind the protests, the resulting violence, and how social media posts triggered both incidents. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Amitabh Sinha about the Research Development and Innovation Fund, the government's initiative to provide funds to companies engaged in research in sectors such as space, robotics and artificial intelligence. He shares how the process worked and why the invitation for funding will now close. (13:57) Lastly, we discuss an incident where an Indian pilot was credited with saving all the passengers on a Flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv that signalled an emergency landing at Tabuk Airport in Saudi Arabia. (28:15) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about the Research Development and Innovation Fund, a government initiative launched last year to support deep-tech research, which now appears to have hit a roadblock. We also talk about a FlyDubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv that faced a violent confrontation in the cockpit, forcing the aircraft to make an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia. But we begin today by talking about Punjab and the origins of two violent student-led protests that that took place.
Speaker 2Within a span of 27 hours.
Speaker 1On the 25th of September at Patiala's Chitkara University, hundreds of students gathered to protest after social media posts claimed that two female students were missing from the hostel. And then, less than 27 hours later, a similar chain of events unfolded at Lovely Professional University in Fagwada after a social media message claimed that a female student had been sexually assaulted by an outsider at the girls' hostel. Both these protests drew large crowds, witnessed clashes between students and the
Speaker 1police and ended in arson and major damage to property. The Punjab police is now examining the similarities between the two incidents, including the role that unverified messages and rumours played. To talk about these two incidents, my colleague Shashank Bhargav speaks to the Indian Express's Rakhi Jagga.
Speaker 3Rakhi, we can see that both these incidents have a lot of similarities, especially when we talk about the circulation of unverified social media posts. But begin by talking about what happened at the Chitkara University.
Speaker 4At Chitkara University, this is in Patiala district. I mean, it's 30 kilometers away from Chandigarh and it's at the end of the Patiala district border. So, I mean, although the major problem, whatever protest it happened in the intervening night of September 25 and 26, but whatever confusion led to that protest, it all started from September 23 onwards when the girls students, they heard some haunted voices. And
Speaker 4that too, using some speaker also in the girls' hostel.
Speaker 3And when you say haunted voices, what do you mean by that?
Speaker 4I mean, they said that these were ghost kind of voices. As we hear the voices in the Bollywood movies, like an evil spirit is shouting or screaming. So there was already a kind of a theory or already kind of a rumor going on amongst the students that there was a girl who had committed suicide in this hostel years ago.
Speaker 2They don't even know the year.
Speaker 4And her spirit haunts the students and the voices are heard every year or so.
Speaker 3Yeah, and I think almost every college or hostel has these kind of stories.
Speaker 4Yeah, for the hostelers, we can understand such pranks are quite common from decades. I mean, they are the genzies or so, but I've heard from my parents as well. When they were in college, such pranks used to be quite common in hostels. So on 23, there was a speaker used and haunted voices. They are saying the... They heard and everybody got scared. And then the girls, they said they asked the warden to do the checking. And there was another rumor going on that one of the hosteler in that hostel, she is into some black magic.
Speaker 4This is what was another set of thought which was going on between them. And then they said, do the checking and all. And the warden, she did all the checking and she didn't find anything increment. And then the thing settled. Everybody slept. And in the midnight, I mean, in the intervening night of 23 September and 24th at around 2.50 a.m., One ambulance arrived and then after some time it came back. So the rumor developed that one of the girl was doing black magic and another watched
Speaker 4her and both of them have died. This was another rumor which started cropping up and a few of them they said that both of them are gone missing.
Speaker 2The haunted spirit she has taken them away.
Speaker 4And then on the 24th, they kept on asking the management and all. It is believed that the management didn't reply to them. That's why the things, I mean, they escalated a lot on the 25th of night. And then 25th of September at around 3pm, one priest arrived in the girls' hostel in Chitkara University at around 3pm.
Speaker 3And did the students call this priest or the school authorities?
Speaker 2No, no.
Speaker 4He was father of one of the students. So he came to meet his daughter. This is what the management, they gave an explanation the next day. But the rumor, I mean, kept on growing between the girls that the priest has come. So maybe he has come to do some puja and all.
Speaker 3So they're connecting these different events to the rumors. Like the ambulance is here. That means students have died and a priest is here. So that means he's come to shoo away the spirits.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's what they kept on thinking.
Speaker 4And what we can understand, the management did not reply to the concerns or to the fears of the students. Had they replied to them well in time, so I don't think that they would have got restless. And by the night of 25th, by around 10.30pm, all of them, they got restless and they came out of their hostels and they didn't go inside their rooms. And they said, we want the video footage. And we want to know who are the girls who are playing this prank. If it is a prank, then who are these girls and
Speaker 4punish them. And why did the priest come and why did the ambulance come? And all these things they were asking, but they were too aggressive. Perhaps the management did not address to them at that time. They called the police and by 2 a.m. or we can say in the intervening night of 25 and 26.
Speaker 2I mean initially only one.
Speaker 4Or two cops they came and the students even manhandled with that cop. Apparently that cop he appeared to be under the influence of alcohol as per the videos. It appears that's why he could not retaliate much. And later on the police and the deputy superintendent of police, the SHO and few other staff members intervened. I mean, there were not more than 10 or 20 of them. They came in and two jeeps had come. But by that time, these students, there are around 15,000 students who are the hostelers.
Speaker 4So if not all, but maybe 5,000, 6,000, they all were out of the hostel and they had damaged both of the gypsies. They were kicking on the gypsies and they broke the window panes of the police jeeps. And at one point of time, the police staff, they literally came out of those vehicles and they stood at one corner and they were pushing those vehicles. And we could see the visuals that an empty vehicle is being pushed hard by the mob of all the boys. Students were there and a number of them, they had their faces covered.
Speaker 3Right. And it was only much later at around 5.30 in the morning that they finally returned to their hostel rooms. But by that time... All these videos of the protests and the allegations were already up on social media. And it was only a day later that the university issued a statement.
Speaker 4So 26th morning, the university issued a written statement as well and that to the media because everything was out and the media was reporting the news and then they had no escape but to give a statement. Then they said that there was a girl. I mean, they gave her name as well and the room number as well that she was sick and she was taken to the hospital. And after some time, after some first year or so, she came back. And then they said that the priest was not for some puja or so. He came to see his daughter and not to do anything, any puja
Speaker 4or so.
Speaker 2This is what they said.
Speaker 4And they said that the haunted voices or whatever, these are the pranks being played by the girls. And they said this is a matter of investigation to be done by the police that who are the girls or so.
Speaker 3Yeah, and after that, they decided to shut the university for a week. But by this time, protests had also erupted at the lovely professional university, which is about 140 kilometers from Chitkara. And while in Chitkara, the rumors were about a spirit and a ghost, which, you know, you can easily dismiss. But the rumor in case of LPU was much more serious. There, the allegation was that an outsider had sexually assaulted one of the female students. Can
Speaker 3you talk about what we know about the origin of this message? Because so far, there seems to be no basis for this allegation.
Speaker 4Yeah, this message, it originated from GH3 hostel of the girls and a text message which originated from that hostel was raped by a male worker in girls hostel of LPU. This message, it went viral and even there as well after 27 hours in the intervening night of 26 and 27 because that thing also happened in the midnight only. Even here as well, in Chitkara as well, by 2 a.m. they went violent and by 5 a.m. the things doused. And even in LPU also, this message popped up in
Speaker 4the night around 10 or 11 or so and it started travelling like wildfire and gradually students started coming out of the hostels. They came on the gate of the university in LPU because this is right on the.
Speaker 2National Highway 44.
Speaker 4And in the past as well, whenever students have any issues related to the university, they have multiple times blocked the NH44 because the university is right on the highway only.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3And in LPU, things turned far more violent. They were, like you said, blocking the National highway. They were damaging property. There is a mall inside the campus. Shops were destroyed there. Items were stolen. And there were also stones pelted at the police force there.
Speaker 4Yeah, this is what we have heard that the stone pelting started from the student's side and some bottles were thrown or some stones were thrown. It triggers the violence and then police had to use some force as well to control them. And then in retaliation, they had set the police vehicles on fire. They even damaged the ATM inside the college campus. I mean, whatever came in their hand, they damaged that. And ultimately, the university declared 10 days off.
Speaker 2Even here as well.
Speaker 4But in LPU, they have constituted a special investigation team who will investigate the entire matter. And there are likely that, I mean, the miscreants, they are likely to face some serious charges as well. And now students are claiming that outsiders came in and they vandalized. We were only peacefully protesting. So that is a matter of investigation from the police to find out. And there were a few walkie-talkies found from the location and now police has clarified that those were of the army officers. There are a few students
Speaker 4of the army officers who are studying on the campus and they said they had come here.
Speaker 2I mean, after they heard about the.
Speaker 4Situation, so out of concern, the officer came along with his staff to see the well-being of his ward and the walkie-talkies were of the staff of a serving major. And politically, BJP and Akali Dal, they are saying that this is a handiwork of the ruling party because on Wednesday, on September 30, Amit Shah is coming to Punjab to address the final rally of Nasha Mukhtiyatra, which BJP started on September 18th. And that venue is just six or
Speaker 4seven kilometers away from LPU.
Speaker 3And so are they saying that the Aam Aadmi Party sent people to the campus to cause all this agitation?
Speaker 4Yeah, they said that the way the mob had gone violent, they said it doesn't seem to be handiwork of the students, the undergrads who are studying here. And they said it seems to be the handiwork of some outsiders who were sent inside the campus just because the owner of this university is Ashok Mittal, who was earlier an Aam Aadmi Party Rajya Sabha member. And in April, when these Aam Aadmi Rajya Sabha members, seven of them had switched to BJP in a block. So he was also one of them.
Speaker 4They are saying that the AAP is trying to take a revenge from that MP. And also they are saying that as Amit Shah's rally is slated to be held on Wednesday in Jalandhar and that to seven kilometers away from the LPU University. So they are trying to create hurdles in organizing that rally.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3And also in this case, police were called from four different districts. But, you know, one aspect of this is the rumors spreading on social media. But how much of this is also students not trusting the college authorities and the authorities themselves not taking these rumors seriously and not communicating well with the students?
Speaker 4Yeah, actually, as I said, even in the past as well, there had been some concerns of the students with the management because in Chitkara, they were not addressed to well in time because if you see the sequence of the events starting from 23 onwards, so had they been addressed well in time, even the police observed that such a protest could have been avoided. Even the SSP Patiala, he himself said it on record. He said when there was a large-scale protest going on in the campus, The management
Speaker 4just casually informed us that there is a protest.
Speaker 2So please just come on to the campus.
Speaker 4And they said they did not even tell us properly the scale of the protest which was going on. That's why initially only one or two persons went. And that's why they got manhandled as well.
Speaker 1And next, we talk about a government initiative aimed at supporting deep tech research, which appears to have hit a roadblock. Last year, the government created a Rs. 1 lakh crore research, development and innovation fund for companies engaged in frontline research in critical sectors such as space, robotics and artificial intelligence. The objective was to help these companies raise funds for technologies considered crucial to the growth and strategic independence of the country's economy. The Department of Science and Technology, or DST,
Speaker 1was supposed to disperse this money to third-party agencies who would then provide funding to eligible companies that applied for it. But over the last year, only one third-party agency, the Technology Development Board, or TDB, was able to carry out the selection process for companies eligible to receive these loans. And this week, it issued a notice on its official website saying that invitations for funding would be closed after this month due to administrative reasons. So to understand why the application process has been closed and how many companies
Speaker 1have actually received funding, we speak to the Indian Express's Amitabh Sinha. Amitabh, can you first tell us about the process? Like, how does a company exactly get the funding and who these third-party agencies are.
Speaker 2Supposed to be?
Speaker 5So the way the RDI fund works is the government, you know, put in rupees one lakh crore. They created this fund and they housed this fund in the Department of Science and Technology. And then the fund was supposed to be disbursed through third party agencies, which are known as second level fund managers, SLFMs. And as of now, you know, these third party agencies, only two of them
Speaker 5have been nominated to act as SLFMs. One is the Technology Development Board, which is also a statutory body, a separate body, functional under the DST itself, Department of Science and Technology. And the other one is called BIRAC. So this is Section 8 company, which operates under the Department of Biotechnology. Now, both these companies, BIRAC, as well as TDB,
Speaker 5are government entities, fully owned by the government. And these have prior experience in funding private companies associated, you know, who have been working in related fields, you know, science and biotechnology related fields.
Speaker 1Okay, so only TDB and BIRAC are appointed to select companies and disburse these funds. But like we mentioned earlier, only TDB had been working on it so far. But tell us, why has it stopped accepting invitations? And what can we make out from the message on its website?
Speaker 5So on Wednesday, that is on 29th of September, TDB or Technology Development Board put out a notice saying it would not accept any fresh applications after this month, which means it has just closed, stopped receiving applications for accessing RDI funds from potential companies. Now, TDB said that it is halting the applications, it is stopping its work because
Speaker 5of administrative reasons. Now, we have been told that by sources that the actual reason why TDB has stopped receiving further applications is the fact that it itself has not received money from the DST, Department of Science and Technology, which it can commit to the companies coming in for loans. So if it doesn't have money itself, how is it going to make a commitment to the companies? So that has been the main reason why it has stopped the work. Now,
Speaker 5there is no lack of money as of now. So, as we discussed earlier, the fund itself is worth 1 lakh crore. That's a huge amount of money. And the DST, which is where the RDI fund has been housed, DST has already been allocated at least Rs 23,000 crore till now. Rs 3,000 crore were given to it last year and Rs 20,000 crore were allocated to it this year in
Speaker 5this year's budget. So DST already has Rs 23,000 crore which it can use for the RDI fund. Now out of this Rs 23,000 crore, The only money that has gone out as of now is rupees 2000 crore, which was given to TDB earlier this year. And TDB exhausted that entire money, 2000 crore, in making commitments to the companies that it selected in the first round in April 2020.
Speaker 5Now it was looking for fresh money to come in from DST so that it can offer to companies that were getting selected in further rounds. So it did the second round of selections in August. And it selected another 13 companies. So in the first round, 22 companies were selected. In the second round, 13 companies were selected. But this time, TDB did not have any money to commit. Now, all this are procedural processes. It's not that the fund has
Speaker 5stopped working. It's not that the money will not eventually go to TDB. There are procedural delays that have happened because of which these bottlenecks have arrived on the scene. Right.
Speaker 1So, Amitabh, what does the funding pause mean for the companies that have applied, particularly those shortlisted in the second round?
Speaker 5Yes, the companies that have been shortlisted in the second round are awaiting funding, but the funding doesn't come automatically also. So, the RDI fund, because it's public money that is being given to these companies, there are lots of checks and balances. So supposing a company has a project which is worth, let's say, 100 crore rupees, it doesn't get the entire project cost funded from the RDI fund. It is eligible
Speaker 5to get only 50% of its total project cost. So once these companies get shortlisted, These companies then have to raise an equivalent amount from the market and then come back to the government saying, look, we have raised this amount and now release our money. And only once they are able to raise that amount from non-government sources, does the money that has been promised to them from the RDI fund gets released. So the companies that have been
Speaker 5shortlisted in the second round, they are awaiting those promissory notes or the letter of intent from the government, which will help them in raising money from the market. So that gets delayed. And we understand that the appointment of additional second fund managers, the third party agencies, has also been delayed. Can you tell us about that? So, Considering
Speaker 5the amount that is available in RDI fund, 1 lakh crore, that's a huge amount of money. It is very clear that one or two agencies would not be able to disburse the entire amount to eligible companies over a six year period. So obviously, more such agencies were needed, more SLFMs were needed. Now, In January itself, applications were invited from these kind of entities to be appointed as second
Speaker 5level fund managers. And by May, that process was complete. And a committee, a selection committee had recommended the potential names. But the appointments have still not been made. So no additional SLFM has been appointed.
Speaker 1And now coming to BIRAC. What has prevented it from starting its own selection and funding process under the RDI fund?
Speaker 5So BIREC, as we discussed earlier, is another agency that was nominated. BIREC is Biotechnology Industry Research Assistance Council. It's a Section 8 non-profit company operating under the Department of Biotechnology. Again, fully owned by the government. Just like TDB, it's a government agency. Now, unlike TDB, unlike Technology Development Board, which is a statutory body. It has been created through an
Speaker 5act of parliament. BIRAC is a Section 8 non-profit company. So what happens is the second level fund managers in the RDI rules, when they offer loans to the companies, deep tech companies, there is this provision, there is this possibility that those loans can be created converted into equity later on, or loans can be offered in the form of equity also. Now, that would have tax implications. So,
Speaker 5BIRAC has been trying to get some clarity on how those issues will be handled if such issues arise in the future. And it has sought, you know, clarifications from the finance ministry because of which it has not been able to start its own process of selecting companies and providing them loans from the RDI funds.
Speaker 1And Amitabh, in the past, there were also concerns raised over links between the selection panel members and some recipient companies. So, how does that affect the implementation and credibility of the fund?
Speaker 5So, in August this year, the Indian Express had reported that in the first round of selections that were done by the TDB, of the 22 companies that had been selected, 15 of them had links with the members of the selection committee itself. So, there seemed to be some sort of conflict of interest. However, the thing was that, you know, this kind of situation was very well anticipated right from
Speaker 5the start. And the members who had links with the applicants, they were supposed to recuse themselves. from the appraisal process of those companies. And all these members did so. So they followed the process that was enlisted for them. However, considering that a large number of the companies that were selected had links with people, even even though they recused themselves completely from the process. There were some red flags
Speaker 5that were seen on the process that such a large number of projects that are getting selected should not have had links with selection committee members themselves. But to a large extent, in the second round, we did not see that kind of situation coming back again. Only one of the 13 companies selected in the second round had any link with one selection committee member.
Speaker 1And Amitabh, could you talk a bit about the kind of significance that this initiative holds for India's deep tech research and its self-sufficiency?
Speaker 5See, the RDI fund is a very, very ambitious program. It's also a very important program for the growth of India's deep tech ecosystem. A lot of these young companies, and we are talking about mostly startup companies, doing very risky job. Many of these companies are actually two, three-year-old startups, and they are just about building their first products. And a lot of work that they are doing in research
Speaker 5and development related to deep tech, these are risky sort of ventures. But these are also technologies that are very, very important for the economy of the country, for society, requirements of the country and for the growth of science and technology sector itself, which hopefully would create an environment that would create many more jobs. So this is important from the country's perspective. And that's why the government decided
Speaker 5to fund some of these ventures itself. So that's why this fund is extremely important. And this large amount of money that was placed, it's never been done. This amount of money to be offered to the private sector, even if it is just loans, has never been done. So the functioning of this RDI fund and the smooth functioning of this RDI fund is extremely important for a lot
Speaker 5of reasons, as we said, for creating this technology ecosystem, for for getting these startups to succeed, for attracting more and more people to start these kind of companies and do high quality value added work in frontline technology sectors for which India right now is dependent on other countries.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about an incident where an Indian pilot has been credited with saving all the passengers on a fly Dubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv that had signalled an emergency landing at Tabuk airport in Saudi Arabia. The Indian Express's Sukalp Sharma reported that according to the Times of Israel, the emergency signals were reportedly triggered by an altercation between the pilots aboard the flight. An Indian national, Smith Macher, was the captain of the flight who was stabbed by his co-pilot during a violent
Speaker 1cockpit confrontation that forced the aircraft to make the emergency landing. According to some Israeli news outlets, the co-pilot was identified as an Omani national who attacked and stabbed the Indian captain in what is being reported as a bid to take over the aircraft's controls and crash it. Macher was taken to a hospital in Saudi Arabia after the aircraft landed. The condition of his health could not be immediately ascertained. AP reported that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Saudi Arabia had arrested the co-pilot who apparently tried to
Speaker 1crash the plane which had a number of Israeli nationals on board. While details about the altercation and the sequence of events remain sketchy, some Israeli news outlets reported that the pilot fought back the co-pilot to prevent the aircraft from crashing, with the crew and some passengers then helping in subduing the co-pilot. The aircraft was successfully secured by on-duty FlyDubai crew travelling on the flight, who diverted and landed the aircraft safely at Tabuk airport. A FlyDubai spokesperson said that all passengers and crew were safe and accounted for.
Speaker 1He also added that it was too early to understand the reasons and motives behind the attack and that will be ascertained through formal investigation. Before the Boeing 737 sounded emergency alerts, it rapidly lost altitude, which likely happened during the altercation in the cockpit. It is not clear yet what weapon was used in the attack and how did the attacker manage to bring it on board. Sukalp reported Machar joined FlyDubai in June 2022 as a captain after serving with SpiceJet for 11 years. You were listening to
Speaker 1Three Things by the Indian Express. Today's show was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Audio and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...