First, we speak with The Indian Express' Alok Deshpande about the drought situation in Maharashtra. Last week Maharashtra declared drought in 265 of its 358 tehsils, after prolonged rainfall deficits and dry spells damaged crops across large parts of the state. Alok shares the seriousness of the situation, what this means for the farmers and what can be expected in the upcoming days. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Amaal Sheikh about the high cost of life-saving medicines, and why access to essential healthcare remains a major challenge. She discusses the process for pricing medicines, why certain essential medicines are expensive and the Supreme Court's stance on this matter. (14:51)Lastly, we talk about a protest by nursing interns over alleged restrictions on wearing burqas inside the labour room at the Government Medical College and Hospital in Jammu and Kashmir’s Doda. (24:20) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, Iccha Sharma, and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about the high cost of life-saving medicines and why access to essential healthcare.
Speaker 2Continues to be a major challenge.
Speaker 1We also talk about a protest by nursing interns over alleged restrictions on wearing burqas inside the labour room at Government Medical College and.
Speaker 2Hospital in Jammu and Kashmir's Doda.
Speaker 1But we begin today with Maharashtra, where a failed monsoon has now forced the state government to declare drought across nearly 75% of the state. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you are listening to Three Things, the Indian Express News Show. Last week, Maharashtra declared drought in 265 of its 358 tehseels after prolonged rainfall deficits and dry spells
Speaker 1damaged crops across large parts of the state. Now, the decision came two days after Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis toured rain deficit areas and said that a drought notification.
Speaker 2Would be issued soon. For farmers, this means.
Speaker 1That what began as an uncertain rainy season has now officially become a drought crisis. The declaration will now start the process of assessing crop losses and some relief measures will also kick in. So how serious is the drought situation in Maharashtra and what does this official declaration mean for the farmers? To understand this, my colleague Ichha Sharma is joined by the Indian Express's Alok Deshpande.
Speaker 3Alok, could you help our listeners understand what exactly the Maharashtra government has announced? And what does it actually mean to declare drought across nearly 75% of the state?
Speaker 4Okay, so Maharashtra government on this Saturday announced that trigger one of the process in declaring the drought has been applied in 265 taisees of the state. The state has around 358 taisees. which essentially means that around two-thirds of Maharashtra is under drought. Now, the thing is, what does it mean when they say we have applied Trigger 1?
Speaker 5So, there are Trigger 1, Trigger 2 and Trigger 3.
Speaker 4This is the process that is prescribed by the government about, you know, before declaring a drought.
Speaker 5Now, what is Trigger 1? So, Trigger 1.
Speaker 4Is in these 265 tahsees, there has been a dry spell of around 21 or more days so as a result of that there was a huge growing demand from different political parties farmers farmer organizations and even within the government that some steps should be taken to give relief to farmers since this 2026 Kharif season is under tremendous stress due to lack of rain and therefore the government
Speaker 4announced that Trigger 1 will be applicable in these 265 desis. It is said that the reason is this is the effect of El Nino and as a result of that Maharashtra is facing this one of the.
Speaker 5Unprecedented kind of droughts.
Speaker 4Even Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis had recently said that the present condition is almost equal to what had happened in 1972.
Speaker 3Right, and for those who may not know, El Nino is a climate pattern that causes the unusual warming of surface waters, leading to dry conditions and lower monsoons. And Alok, interestingly, you highlight how drought-like conditions had existed in these areas since June.
Speaker 6So, why has the formal declaration come only now, in late September?
Speaker 4So, even as per the procedure, the government has to wait until they reach to the.
Speaker 5End of monsoon.
Speaker 4So, initially, during May 2026, the government had itself said that there will be effect of El Nino and there will be effect on this year's rainfall. So, the government was preoccupied But during the month of July, there was satisfactory rain and as a result of that, the government thought that the effect of El Nino will not be as severe as it was initially predicted. But post-July, the August and September, we saw that majority parts of Maharashtra
Speaker 4did not receive any rainfall.
Speaker 5So as a result of that, by the end of.
Speaker 4August, the demands were already being raised and now finally the government has decided decided to, you know, announce this trigger one.
Speaker 3And Alok, if, say, I'm a farmer in one of these 265 teh seals, what relief am I entitled to immediately following this announcement?
Speaker 6And also, what will I still have to wait for?
Speaker 4Okay, so the notification which was issued on Saturday has given around 12 reliefs. The opposition has said that these reliefs are... This is like a very vague notification. There are no pinpointed relief measures that the government has announced. But as per the government notifications, there will be no land revenue collection in these areas. Then the crop loan will be restructured. Then there will be complete stay on... recovery of crop loan or recovery of any loan related
Speaker 4to farming plus there will be no charge on the pumps that are being used in the agriculture anyways in maharashtra that issue is not valid because maharashtra farmers are getting free electricity Then there will be educational fee waiver for students in these areas. Plus a lot of works will be announced under NREGA to ensure that the farmers and agricultural laborers get some work and they get that money because the entire economy will be under distress because
Speaker 4of this drought. We have almost lost the entire Kharif season of 2026 and the animals will be taken care of, water conservation work will start.
Speaker 5So these kind of different measures will be taken in these.
Speaker 3Right, and speaking of the stay on loan recovery, many farmers may have borrowed from informal lenders. So what about these farmers who borrowed outside banks? Would any of the announced loan relief measures help them?
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 4In May 2025, Maharashtra had announced Punnish Lok Ahilya Devi Holkar Farm Loan Waiver Scheme. The government had initially claimed that it will be around Rs 36,000 crore. But as of now, only Rs 11,000 crore have been spent on farm loan waiver. And there are a lot of complaints from the farmers that they have not received the waiver benefits. Also, there were issues with the banks as well, especially not the cooperative banks, but especially with the nationalized banks, because the other banks come.
Speaker 5Directly under the RBI.
Speaker 4So the state government cannot direct these banks to do certain things the way they can do to cooperative banks.
Speaker 5So there are some certain issues.
Speaker 4But as far as the new notification regarding drought is concerned, the government has said that they will restructure the farm loans, but they haven't yet announced how they will be doing it. So we'll have to wait for the actual publication of, you know, step by step circular regarding the loan restructuring, because we already have this farm loan waiver scheme ongoing. So whether the government will combine both these things or whether there will be some other scheme. So we'll have to wait and see what the government is planning.
Speaker 3And Alok, as you mentioned earlier, that there has been a substantive crop loss. talk about which parts of Maharashtra have experienced the most serious agricultural damage and which crops have been particularly affected.
Speaker 4The areas are especially Marathwada area and the western Vidarbha part. They are largely affected by this drought. Marathwada is a drought-prone region in the state. Now, if you say in Marathwada region, there are the Chhatrapati, Sambhaji Nagar, Jalna, Beed, Latur, Dharashiv, Nanded, Parbhani and Hingoli. These are the districts in this Marathwada region. Out of these, except for Chhatrapati, Sambhaji Nagar and Nanded, all districts have been declared drought. So even in Chhatrapati,
Speaker 4Sambhaji Nagar and Nanded, only one or two tehsis have been left out. So in that sense, entire Marathwada region, we can say largely is under drought. Also in Amravati, that is Western Vidarbha region, the entire Western Vidarbha region has been declared drought affected. As well as in North Maharashtra, which is like bordering Gujarat, District Nandurbar, Andhuley, So even these North Maharashtra districts are completely under drought. Only three districts in the state, which are Thane, Palghar and Raigad, which come under the Konkan region, there is not a
Speaker 4single tehsil which has been declared in this notification. So we can say that these three districts are drought-proof. There is no drought-related problems in these three districts.
Speaker 5And if we talk.
Speaker 4About crops, then the major problem this year is for soybean and cotton. Soybean crop also as well as horticulture. But soybean and cotton will be majorly affected due to this.
Speaker 3Right, and we understand that this list of drought-prone tehsils has also become a political flashpoint.
Speaker 4Several politicians, right, not only from opposition, but even from the BJP are saying that their tehsils or their areas have not been included in this list. For example, BJP MLA from Varda district, Sumit Vankedi, he had written to CM demanding that his area should be included in this list. And the CM approved it as a special case. Then he put it on Facebook. And then after the uproar, because you can't have this special case in drought-like situation. So he removed that post from Facebook. Then there was
Speaker 4this BJP leader, Ashok Chavan. His audio clip went viral where he was talking to a few of his workers. And they were complaining that their areas are not part of the drought list.
Speaker 5So he was trying to calm them down. And obviously, the opposition has also raised questions.
Speaker 4There is also talk about our political influence because it's very strange that, you know, say, for example, in Pune division, there is a district called Satara. And in Satara, there's a hill station called Mahabaleshwar. It's a tehsil and it receives huge rainfall. But that is now part of this drought list. At the same time, in Sindhudur district, the districts like, you know, Dodamarg and Kankavali, which received tremendous rainfall, but they are part of this list. So there is a talk of political influence as well on this list of tehsils, which have been declared as drought affected.
Speaker 6Analog drought is still a recurring challenge in Maharashtra.
Speaker 3So what makes particular regions of the state especially vulnerable to prolonged dry spells?
Speaker 4See, in Maharashtra, Marathwada and Western Vidarbha, they have always faced this kind of situation. If you see that since 2002, there have been five droughts. And obviously, one of the reasons is apart from the natural reasons, the man-made reasons we cannot ignore and the climate change and the other factors. But at the same time, regions like Marathwada, they are drought-prone regions. The politicians have been talking about making Marathwada drought-free for many, many, many years. But actually, nothing has happened.
Speaker 4There were a lot of schemes that are announced, especially like lift irrigation schemes where water from rivers in western Maharashtra will be brought to Marathwada. And then there are river linking projects that are being discussed.
Speaker 5So a lot of.
Speaker 4Projects, big ticket projects are being discussed. Some are even under consideration. Some are like in the first initial stages. But there's been not an effective way to tackle drought in Maharashtra.
Speaker 5We have to say that. I mean, we have to accept that. And at the same time, the.
Speaker 4Maharashtra government since 2014, when the BJP government came up. Devendra Fundamentalist has launched a flagship Jal Yukta Shivar project where widening and deepening of riverbeds and inalas was undertaken. But even after say 11-12 years, the entire scheme was to face these kind of situations. But now it is important that we check the effectivity of the project or the scheme. And so many irrigation projects have been launched.
Speaker 4So now it is high time that Maharashtra takes a serious look at its water sector.
Speaker 3Despite this, Maharashtra is a ranking state in agricultural produce.
Speaker 6So could this drought affect food prices?
Speaker 4See, it won't have impact only on food prices. It will have impact on entire economy. For example, when we are talking about the loss of entire curry season of 2026. See, the rural economy works when farmer gets money after selling his produce. He goes to the market. He buys certain things from market. That just helps the market, the local market, the town market, the traders in that market.
Speaker 5It helps them. And the effect is on manufacturing.
Speaker 4Because the more people buy, the more will be produced and the entire cycle runs. So now here the farmers don't have money. They are not going to go to market and buy something. So that is going to bring a slowdown in the market. So ultimately, it will have impact on manufacturing from manufacturing to other sectors as well. So now this is like the entire cycle that is going to get disturbed. So it's a very, very severe and serious crisis. It is not limited to rising food prices. It is going to affect the entire economy of the state,
Speaker 4at least to say the least. It might have some effects on other states as well, but it will have impact on state's economy as well.
Speaker 3And Alok, if the government has already established that drought affects these many taiseels and the impact that you spoke of on the rural economy.
Speaker 6Why hasn't compensation been announced yet?
Speaker 4So, that is one of the criticisms that the opposition is making, that notification of drought issued is a very vague notification. Now, the opposition has demanded that every farmer be given rupees 1 lakh per hectare. Our NCPSP chief, Sharad Pawar, wrote a letter to Devendra Fadnavis and demanded that farmers should be given rupees 1 lakh per hectare and agricultural labourers should be given rupees 25,000, considering the losses. Because one of the reasons is, this is unprecedented calamity. The entire investment of farmers, right from buying seeds and fertilizers,
Speaker 4sowing them, giving them water, the labor charges, everything, everything is now wasted. So the calamity is unprecedented and therefore money should be given. But now the government will issue a separate notification is what they have said regarding the compensation for crop losses and everything. Chief Minister, he had used the word sarsakat in Marathi. Basically, we can translate it into as it is. So whatever the loss is, we'll pay you as it is. And the opposition has now said that since the CM has announced it, it
Speaker 4should be like that. But as far as we know how the government functions, it is very unlikely that the government will pay as it is to farmers for their losses. We will have to wait and see how the government announces its financial package.
Speaker 1And next, we turn our attention to a problem in the healthcare system that seems to have only gotten worse over the years. Medical research and technological advancements have made great strides in the past, but much of this progress still remains out of reach for people from economically weaker sections. And it's not just the cost of surgery and hospitalization that can be expensive, but also life-saving medicines.
Speaker 2In fact, recently, while.
Speaker 1Hearing petitions challenging the prices at which medicines are sold, the Supreme Court said that the pricing of medicines was akin to broad.
Speaker 2Daylight dacoity against patients.
Speaker 1And the court said this while comparing the price at which medicines reach retailers with the final price printed on the pack.
Speaker 7So there are two petitions primarily filed in the Supreme Court along with multiple intervener applications.
Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Amal Sheikh who reports on law for the paper.
Speaker 7The main concern is that the medicines in India are priced at A higher price and the patients, they end up paying an inflated price for these medicines. The petitioners are also saying that some medicines, retailers and the hospital pharmacies earn profits that are 10 to 16 percent margin, that 16 percent retailers margin that the law protects. They're also saying that only 20% of the medicines that are circulating in the market are governed by the price control
Speaker 7and the rest of the 80% of the medicines do not have any price cap at launch of those medicines.
Speaker 1And these petitions also claim that doctors often prescribe more expensive versions of medicines even though cheaper generic versions are available in the market.
Speaker 7So all of this essentially affects patients' right to health, which is a part of right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Speaker 1While hearing the petitions, the Supreme Court, for instance, referred to an essential cancer drug that is supplied to retailers for Rs 2,700 but has an MRP of nearly Rs 27,000. The bench said that this kind of price difference was an absolute rampage and extortion. So to understand why there is such a huge gap between the two prices, we speak to Amal in this segment, who begins by telling us how drugs are priced in India.
Speaker 7So there is an act called the Essential Commodities Act, which lets the central government control the prices of essential goods and services. Under this act, the government has a power to issue an order called the Drug Prices Control Order, which basically prescribes prices of medicines. And there is a body of the government called the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority, which basically implements everything that the drug pricing control order states.
Speaker 7It fixes maximum prices, it regulates the prices, ensures that the company is following the prescribed mechanism under the DPCO.
Speaker 2And Amal, are different medicines priced differently?
Speaker 1Because some medicines are life-saving and absolutely essential, right?
Speaker 2So does the pricing work differently for these medicines?
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 7So in the DPCO, it sorts medicines into two different categories, scheduled and non-scheduled medicines. Scheduled essentially are called the essential medicines, which is listed in the national list of essential medicines. Now, how this list comes about is the health ministry appoints a committee of experts, pharmacists, doctors who review medicines and prepare this list. They look at what the complications common disease is going around, whether the medicines are safe, whether they're effective, whether they're cheaper. All of these factors are
Speaker 7taken into consideration. And once that list is finalized, it is included and added into the DPCO, which contains something known as Schedule 1. So this Schedule 1 has all the list of medicines that are included in the National List of Essential Medicine. And this list contains a total of 384 medicines. And then once the medicines are added to this list, the NPPA, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority, comes into picture and sets prices for those medicines. Non-scheduled
Speaker 7medicines is everything else. So like I mentioned, in the Schedule 1 list, it contains a total of 384 medicines, I believe, which is a total of 20% of the medicines that are circulating the market. Non-scheduled medicines are around 80%. The National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority does not fix a price for these non-scheduled medicines. So what that means is the company decides the initial price at launch.
Speaker 1So tell us what are they saying and what is the rationale behind not controlling their launch pricing?
Speaker 6So the drug.
Speaker 7prices control order, they do not fix the launch price for a non-scheduled medicine. Basically, the government has said that these prices are set by the manufacturers, so it increases competition and supports export and so on and so forth. The petitioners say that if a manufacturer wants to launch a new medicine in the market, say it can launch it at a price it deems best. So it can either launch it at 10 rupees, at 100 rupees or 1000 rupees or 2000 rupees. There is no limit to
Speaker 7the price that they want to set. Once that medicine is launched, let's say it's priced at 1500 rupees.
Speaker 6That's when the law kicks in.
Speaker 7And that's when it says that this price cannot be increased by more than 10% every 12 months or every one year. So the petitioners are basically saying that if the first The initial launch price is already so high, a cap of 10% doesn't really bring it down. And it also alleges that what the chemists and hospital pharmacies do is they sell these medicines at a discounted rate to attract patients. But again, that discounted rate is much higher than the MRP that is set for these medicines.
Speaker 1And Amal, when we talk about scheduled drugs, can you tell us how their ceiling prices or the legally mandated maximum prices are decided?
Speaker 7So this is something that's done by the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority. What they do is they look at different versions of a medicine and they look at the branded versions of a medicine, generic versions of the medicine, and they basically see what companies are charging for these medicines. So take, for example, Pharma Paracetamol. A Paracetamol is a generic version, which means the composition name. So that medicine could either be sold under the name of Paracetamol or it could be sold under branded version of Dolo or Crocin and multiple other branded versions. So what the NPPA
Speaker 7does is they take an average of the prices of all these versions that are in the market and they add 16% retail margin to that price. Just to explain with an example is if different companies are selling a drug at let's say rupees 8, 10 and 12, this is what they're selling it to the retailer. So the NPPA calculates the average amount which is 10 rupees and to that 10 rupees they add 16% retail margin, which becomes Rs.
Speaker 511.6.
Speaker 7And this is a ceiling price that is set for the companies and they cannot charge more than this price. This excludes the GST and the taxes.
Speaker 1And hospital pharmacies also play a role in setting the prices for medicines, right?
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 7So, Hospital pharmacies, this is something that is basically mentioned in one of the petitions that the sale representatives of pharma companies have said that MRP that is printed on a particular drug is decided by the.
Speaker 6Inputs of these corporate hospitals.
Speaker 7They also say that around 30 to 40 percent of a patient's bill comes from the pharmacy itself. And the hospital usually sells it to the patient at the full MRP. So take, for example, if an antibiotic that's used over here, they are talking about cancer patients. But in general, also, if an antibiotic that's being sold inside the hospital at 5000 rupees, that same antibiotic is available at just 350 rupees outside the hospital. But these allegations are yet to be tested by the court.
Speaker 2And Amal, so what is the current status of the case? And how do we see this going forward?
Speaker 7So the matter has just come up before the Supreme Court. There has just been two hearings where the court did related to the inflated prices of these drugs. And the court has basically asked the central government why that 16% retailer margin can't be applied uniformly across all medicines and medical devices. So why does that percentage has to be applied only to essential medicines or scheduled medicines and not the rest? The centre is supposed to file an affidavit, which will be taken up sometime next week, explaining these
Speaker 7pricing mechanisms. And the court may take up that next hearing. So we have yet to see how that unfolds.
Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a protest by nursing interns over alleged restrictions on wearing burqas inside the Gaini department's labour room at Government Medical College and Hospital in Jammu and Kashmir's Doda. The Indian Express's Arun Sharma reported that it all started on last Wednesday when scores of nursing interns held a demonstration inside the hospital premises. against Dr Madhu Chib, head of gynecology department at Doda Medical College, alleging that she had objected to their wearing of burqas. Protesters boycotted work and gathered outside the hospital building.
Speaker 1One protester said that a day earlier, Dr Chib had moved a student out of the labour room because she was wearing a veil. The protest was called off after the hospital administration intervened and Dr Chib clarified that her objection to the burqa was confined to ensuring hygiene compliance in sensitive areas such as labour rooms and operation theatres. The hospital management also set up a panel to look into the circumstances leading to the protest. Dr Irfan Tasaduk, the in-charge medical superintendent of Doda GMC Hospital, confirmed the
Speaker 1development and attributed the protest to a miscommunication. He said that the doctor had asked them to tighten their loose gears and wear a gown over them as protocols need to be followed by doctors in such sensitive areas where infection risk is high for the patients. Arun writes that the protest has drawn political reactions. While Dota MLA Mehraj Malik took up the matter with Health Minister Sakina Ittu, ruling National Conference chief spokesperson Tanvir Sadik expressed concern, saying that the Constitution of India guarantees citizens the right to
Speaker 1freely practice their religion. This is not the first time that Dr. Chib has been involved in a public controversy. She had previously lodged a police complaint against Aam Aadmi Party MLA Malik in May last year, alleging that he had made abusive and gendered.
Speaker 2Remarks against her on social media.
Speaker 1Malik had denied the allegations and accused the doctor of engaging in private practice at a local nursing home during official duty hours. and produced by Ichha Sharma and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know
Speaker 1about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...
First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...
First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...