Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Bus drivers' strike, students protest using reels, and SIR notice to Delhi CM

Sep 21, 202625 minAudio

First, we speak with The Indian Express' Devansh Mittal about a strike by Delhi Transport Corporation bus drivers and conductors that has disrupted public transport across the city. He shares the reasons behind the strike, the demands made by the drivers and the conductors, and the response from the government. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Pallavi Smart about Maharashtra, where school students have taken up the responsibility to highlight civic infrastructure problems, using social media. She shares that in several districts across the state, students have been posting videos highlighting the problems they face on their daily commute to school, hoping the posts would reach the authorities and a solution would be found. (12:54) Lastly, we talk about top bureaucrats, Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta, and former Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal being issued notices for discrepancy and to prove their eligibility during the Special Intensive Revision. (22:14) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, Ichha Sharma, and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about Maharashtra, where school students have taken up the responsibility to highlight civic infrastructure problems using social media. We also talk about Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta, former Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, along with top bureaucrats being issued notices for discrepancy and to prove their eligibility during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls. But first, we talk about a strike by Delhi Transport Corporation bus drivers and conductors that has disrupted public transport across the city.

Speaker 1Last week at the Vazirpur bus depot in north-west Delhi, all 150 buses stood parked, while drivers sat outside on mattresses. It was the third day of the strike and workers said they were refusing to back down until their demand for better pay was addressed. Now, of course, at the

Speaker 1heart of the protest are wages. Drivers and conductors say that they are being paid Rs 862 per day and that this is not enough to manage their families, daily travel, food and other expenses. And what's worth noting here is that these aren't DTC employees as such.

Speaker 2Yeah, so just to clarify, these are not drivers technically directly employed by DTC. These are drivers who are employed by private operators who get contracts from DTC to operate buses on specific routes.

Speaker 1That's the Indian Express's Devansh Mittal, who reported on the issue for the paper.

Speaker 2So they can't be said to be technically employees of the Delhi Transport Corporation.

Speaker 3But yeah, they are the people who are driving those buses.

Speaker 1Meanwhile, the Transport Minister has said that private concessionaires managing DTC electric buses have been directed to resolve the issues immediately. But the union says no government representative has reached out to them so far. So what are Delhi bus drivers and conductors demanding and how is this affecting commuters across the capital? To answer these questions, my colleague Ichha Sharma is joined by Devansh.

Speaker 4Devansh, we know that the immediate demand, of course, is better compensation. But you highlight how the dispute encompasses much more. So talk about why more than 10,000 DTC bus drivers have gone on strike. Like, what are they asking for?

Speaker 2Yeah, so they've gone on strike demanding a couple of things. One is so currently they are earning rupees 862 every day that they work, which turns out to somewhere between 21-22,000 a month for working six days a week. And out of it, some provident fund is also cut. So basically they earn on average around 20,000 rupees a month. So they are asking that this be increased from 862 per

Speaker 2day to 2000 per day. So what they're saying is that they're supposed to get a basic increment, which is like an increase in their salary every five years. And the last increment happened in 2019. So the next one was supposed to happen in 2024, which has not happened. And what the union also tells me is that their dearness allowance, which is supposed to go up every six months, has not happened in the last 18 months since this.

Speaker 3Government took over. So that increase has also not happened.

Speaker 2A combination of these factors and the already existing low wage floor means that they're asking for an increased wage. That is the central pillar of their demands in this strike. Other things that they're asking for is medical insurance, some guarantee of a job in case a driver dies due to an unfortunate accident, some annual bonuses and better working conditions in general. They're also asking that they get paid extra to work on government holidays.

Speaker 4Devansh, as you mentioned earlier, that their employment arrangement is slightly more confusing. So, if the Delhi government contracts a private company to operate a public bus, who is ultimately responsible for the worker?

Speaker 3See, that's a tricky question.

Speaker 2So what the union, the DTC Karamchari Ekta Union says is that although it's technically up to the private companies, which are, you know, managing and operating these buses on specific routes. And even the government has repeatedly said this, that these drivers are not our employees. And we have told those private operators to talk to drivers and listen to their demands. But the union says that any one operator won't do it individually. It will have like if

Speaker 2the government directs those private companies is the only situation which this increase is going to happen. So technically, it is the private operators who can increase the salary of these drivers. But I think it will have to be a conversation between the government and the private operators who do it together across the board. It won't be that, you know, like, Just one private company who's operating these buses can individually raise their salaries.

Speaker 4And this wage hike that we are speaking about, how has the union come up with the 2000 rupees per day figure? Like, is it based on some comparable transport jobs or cost of living?

Speaker 2I think the union has not done any specific studies or research based on what I've told you like their basic increment which is supposed to which is in hike in their wages every five years has not happened since 2019. The next one was supposed to happen in 24 which did not take place as well as their dearness allowance DA which is supposed to go up every six months that has not gone up for the last 18 months so three times. So combined with these two things and what drivers tell me is that, you know, Delhi is

Speaker 2getting more and more congested day by day and driving these really massive vehicles in these really, really congested roads is a very stressful task. And I mean, they have to complete their number of allocated kilometers, the number of rounds that they have to take on particular routes, etc.

Speaker 3So what they tell me is that these are really.

Speaker 2Stressful jobs, which really deserve salaries, which are above sort of what they say are minimum wage salaries of, you know, daily wage laborers. They say that you need to be really skilled at these jobs. And these are basically very stressful jobs.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4And during your reportage, when you spoke to a few drivers, they mentioned how they have to do gig work on the journey home to kind of supplement their income. So on ground, how are their living conditions?

Speaker 2Yeah, so this was one driver that I had met at the GT Karnal DTC depot in northwest Delhi, who told me that, you know, like after he gets done with his day job, which is as a DTC bus driver, while going back home to Sonipat, he also... picks up customers through rapido and you know earns maybe 100 200 250 rupees extra on the site to just to support his household expenditure now i mean i don't know how

Speaker 2many dtc drivers do this sort of gig work on the site but from a large number of them and who i've talked to one big issue that all of them face is that many of them come from delhi's neighboring districts in Haryana, Sonipat, Rohtak, Jajjar and commuting itself takes a significant chunk out of their salary because even though they're DTC bus drivers they don't get free bus rides and they either come by the metro which is

Speaker 2itself expensive or they come on their own private two-wheelers which takes like 100 to 200 rupees of petrol every day commuting these really really long distances a lot of them tell me that this 20 000 that they're earning plus you know maybe some incentives that some of them earn here and there by completing all their stops and completing their route perfectly so this 20 25 000 salary in a world where things are so expensive It's not

Speaker 2really able to afford them the kind of life that they want. So some of them supplemented with gig work. Some of them have taken loans, which they now have to repay by taking more informal loans from families and friends.

Speaker 4And Devansh, even in a city with one of India's largest metro networks, how integral and indispensable are DTC buses in the capital's public transport ecosystem?

Speaker 2So basically DTC has around 6,840 buses. So the earlier DIMTs, the Delhi Integrated Multimodal Transit System to operate the cluster buses was also sort of taken over by DTC sometime earlier this year. So DTC now basically operates all close to 7,000 buses in Delhi. And DTC has an average daily ridership of around 40 lakh people. Now in recent

Speaker 2years this is the largest such strike which has been carried out by DTC drivers and even for the last one week I have personally seen passengers who didn't know there was a strike going on standing at bus stops for the last couple of hours waiting for their bus because You have to understand that metro is really expensive compared to DTC, especially for women for whom DTC is completely free. So this is a really, really significant part of the public transit system in Delhi. because of its cheapness,

Speaker 2because of its reliability. So, you know, Metro has deployed additional trains to manage the additional crowds from the strike.

Speaker 3And on Thursday or.

Speaker 2Friday, it recorded its highest ever ridership of almost 82 lakh people. Just for context, Metro's average ridership is around 65 lakh people in a day. It recorded a ridership of 82 lakh people because of this ongoing DTC strike. So this DTC forms a really significant part of the public transit system, especially for lower income people.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 4And speaking of the negotiations, interestingly, on one side, you have the transport minister saying that every demand except the wage hike, of course, has been accepted. Conversely, the union says none have been met. So how do we read that?

Speaker 2So basically, so if you go through the transport minister, Pankaj Kumar Singh's remarks, he says that all the demands except the wage hike have been increased and he has told the private companies to accept these demands. But we have not heard yet or the drivers have not heard yet from the private companies accepting those demands. And even if those demands about, you know, working on government holidays, and some kind of medical insurance, better working conditions are accepted. The central demand of a wage hike from rupees 862

Speaker 2to maybe 2000 or somewhere in between, I think.

Speaker 3That is the key demand which will stall.

Speaker 2the resolution of this strike, at least for the next couple of days. So the union guys I'm talking to tell me that even till now, even till Sunday, they haven't heard about whether their demands have been met or not, and certainly not about the wage hike demand and that their protest slash strike will continue.

Speaker 4And they weren't given that thousands of drivers and conductors are off duty. And we just spoke of how significant they are to the public transport ecosystem. What's next for the government to look at?

Speaker 2That is anyone's guess, but from what I've been hearing right now, so the Delhi government did arrange some additional drivers, you know, people who had been promoted, they've been telling them to go back to drive some buses, etc. So over the last, maybe starting from Friday, there have been, I mean, some buses have been operating. But there are still large scale disruptions to the DTC service. Bus services are still patchy and they're still not operating everywhere. I mean,

Speaker 2we expect more conversations to happen between the union, between driver representatives, between the government, between owners of these private companies which operate DTC buses. But we don't know right now what will happen and when the resolution of these demands and the strike will take place.

Speaker 1And next, we focus on Maharashtra, where school students have taken up the responsibility to highlight civic infrastructure problems using social media. In several districts across the state, students have been posting videos highlighting the problems they face on their daily commute to school.

Speaker 6You say that our children are the future of India. But is there no other way to educate our children?

Speaker 3Does the government think that our children should be taught only to read?

Speaker 6For many families in rural Maharashtra, getting their children to school means navigating pothole-ridden roads, railway tracks and muddy, difficult-to-cross paths.

Speaker 1These conditions often leave parents worried about their children's safety.

Speaker 3So the students, taking.

Speaker 1Matters into their own hands, have started creating mock news reports filmed on mobile phones and videos making direct appeals to political leaders, hoping that their posts will push authorities to act.

Speaker 5But have these social media posts actually led to any change?

Speaker 7And what do these videos tell us about the state of basic civic infrastructure.

Speaker 5In parts of Maharashtra?

Speaker 1To understand more, we are joined by the Indian Express's Pallavi Smart, who reported on the story for the paper. So Pallavi, what prompted school children across Maharashtra to start using social media to highlight problems with roads and other civic infrastructure?

Speaker 5So there is no particular answer to what exactly prompted these children, but it is certain that this is a generation of children that is increasingly comfortable questioning authority and documenting problems and demanding solutions.

Speaker 7And they know how to use the tools such as social media, which is at their disposal in order to get heard.

Speaker 5By the authorities.

Speaker 7We can't accurately say where it originated. But the video of three girls performing a mock ground report while holding umbrella as a boom mic, which went viral in July, became.

Speaker 5Like a talking point.

Speaker 7And then we could see many such videos coming up from different parts of Maharashtra, where school students in their uniforms are complaining about local civic and infrastructure issues on social media.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 1And talking about the case that you mentioned about the three girls, They were from Khanpe village in Raigarh district. So tell us about that post and have the authorities taken any action after the video was circulated?

Speaker 7That video featured three girls who are class 10 students in a school in Khanpe village in.

Speaker 5Raigarh district of Maharashtra.

Speaker 7It was merely a fun activity for them to do that mock news report just because one of their friends was carrying her mother's mobile phone on that particular day. And they realized the impact of their video only after 3-4 days when it went viral and also prompted repair work. The girls told the Indian Express that they were talking about the potholes on the road while walking. And that gave them an idea to do a ground report on

Speaker 7the poor conditions of the road. That is based on similar kind of mock interviews that they have done.

Speaker 5In their schools for extracurricular activities.

Speaker 7This is particularly among those videos where significant action is taken where the local MLA ordered immediate repair work of the road and the authorities have also assured complete reconstruction of the road post-monsoon.

Speaker 1Okay, so in this case, we did see authorities actually responding to the video and taking action. But what about the other places? Like we saw children from Bahirwadi make a mock news report about their difficult journey to school. So tell us about the problems they are dealing with and has the viral video led to any concrete action?

Speaker 7Unlike to the Kanpe village, they haven't had any resolution to their issue as yet. Basically, these children from Gohirewadi hamlet, it's in Trambakeshwar, taluka of Maharashtra's Nashik district. They have to go to Pegalwadi village to attend school. Taking the regular road would take them hours to reach Pegalwadi and since.

Speaker 5That is a highway, parents are reluctant to let their children walk along it.

Speaker 7The alternative for them is a shorter trail connecting Goherewadi hamlet to Pegalwadi village which is not a proper road as it is a trail connecting Goherewadi to Pegalwadi through farm fields in the village. It is extremely slippery, muddy and waterlogged especially during monsoon and all this is because an alternative road connecting the hamlet to the village remains stuck with no agency taking the initiative to construct it.

Speaker 7Their viral video definitely brought some prominent opposition leaders, political personalities to visit that hamlet.

Speaker 5But the children are.

Speaker 7Still waiting for a resolution for their daily hardship.

Speaker 1And Pallavi, can you tell us about Vadiv, which is an island in the Palghar district and it doesn't have a permanent road or a bridge connecting it to the mainland? So people there have been forced to walk along railway tracks to get to school or the market, which is another thing that children from the place have highlighted. Tell us how long has this been the case?

Speaker 7In Palghar, that is not particularly, you know, children's issue because it's an issue for all residents of Vardhiv, which is an island in Palghar. It does not have a permanent all-weather road bridge connecting it to the mainland. As a result, all Vardhiv residents, including the children, use pathways along railway bridges and the tracks, whether to travel to work, to go to markets or to reach school. The situation has been like this for decades. Adult residents have noted

Speaker 7that they have been pressing on that demand for road for many years. But now they have a proposal on paper to construct 700-meter permanent bridge between Wadhiv and Vaithi. But it is now pending for administrative approval. Right, and now coming to Satara, the report notes that Mansi Mane's videos have previously resulted in repairs. So, tell us more about that and why has the road to her college remained unresolved despite the repeated attention? The attention has led

Speaker 7to repair works at isolated spots but it is important to note that it is a roughly 8 km route from Musford which has multiple stretches which are damaged with potholes and other issues also. It has been in poor condition for 10-15 years. There is an official proposal for repairs now and work will begin once the proposal is approved.

Speaker 1And across these cases, how much difference has social media visibility actually made in getting authorities to respond to civic problems?

Speaker 7Niharika, although we have managed to cover four such instances in the recent past, multiple such videos have emerged from different parts of Maharashtra and in many cases, issues have been resolved. While Kanpe girls managed to get their road repaired with an assurance of reconstruction of the road after monsoon, in Palghar, a proposal is now ready to construct a permanent bridge. Among multiple similar videos from across Maharashtra, many have resolution to the issue in sight now. Whereas in

Speaker 7other cases, even if it is not completely resolved, at least the issue has come under the spotlight with authorities forced to take cognizance of it at least, especially after school children appealing on camera.

Speaker 1And Pallavi, what do these stories tell us about the larger state of basic infrastructure and access to schools in parts of rural Maharashtra?

Speaker 7These stories have once again highlighted the poor condition of public education, particularly in rural.

Speaker 5Parts of Maharashtra.

Speaker 7We need to understand when the issue at hand currently is As basic as how to reach the school, the condition of the school, the teaching quality and other matters become secondary.

Speaker 5Parents in rural areas are willing to send their children to schools.

Speaker 7But with issues like this, many have noted how safety of their children is more important to them than education. This can easily result into children dropping out of schools.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about top bureaucrats including Election Commissioner Dr.

Speaker 3S.S.

Speaker 1Sandhu and Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta being issued notices for discrepancy and to prove their eligibility during the special intensive revision of electoral rolls. The Indian Express's Hari Kishan Sharma reported that among the top bureaucrats against whom SIR notices have been issued for discrepancies and no mapping are Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri, SEBI Chairman Tuhin Kantapande, Principal Scientific Advisor to PM Ajay Kumar Sood, Health Secretary Punya Salela, Fishery Secretary Abhilaksh Likhi and his wife, Department of Ex-Servicemen's

Speaker 1Welfare Secretary Sukriti Likhi, Fertiliser Secretary Rajat Kumar Mishra and Land Resources Secretary Narendra Bhushan. They are among the people who remained unmapped with the last SIR. In all, 593 people have received notices at the New Delhi Moti Bagh polling booth under the Delhi-Kant Assembly constituency. And along with bureaucrats, Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta, former Chief Minister Arvind K. Trival, New Delhi MP Masudi Swaraj and former Delhi BJP Chief Virendra Kumar Sachdeva were among the 33 lakh electors in

Speaker 1the capital who have been named amid the SIR for the issuance of notices to prove their eligibility. The bureaucrats against whom SIR notices are being issued for name mismatches include Expenditure Secretary Vumlanmang Volnam and Comptroller and Auditor General K. Sanjay Murthy, has received a notice for parent name mismatch. The Indian Express's Devan Schmittal reported that notices will be issued and disposed of between August 31 and October 29. The final electoral roll will be published on November 4.

Speaker 1Delhi had 1.45 crore electors before the SIR began. Names of 97.5 lakh electors made the draft roll published on 31 August. For those born in India before July 1, 1987, the Election Commission requires a document proving date and or place of birth. For those born between July 1, 1987 and December 2, 2004, the Election Commission requires a document for the elector and one parent. And for those born after December 2, 2004, the Election Commission requires documents for

Speaker 1the elector and both parents. The categories follow the requirements under the Citizenship Act, 1955. You were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Ichha Sharma and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know

Speaker 1about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode