Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

Desalinating seawater, Tukaram Munde vs FSSAI, and selling hospital shifts

Nov 10, 202631 minAudio

First, we speak with The Indian Express' Nayonika Bose about how Mumbai's first seawater desalination plant has triggered protests from fishing communities who fear the project could threaten their livelihoods. She discusses the need to turn seawater into drinking water and how this will impact the fishing community. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Anonna Dutt about how Maharashtra’s Food Safety Commissioner Tukaram Munde, who has recently been in the spotlight for his strict action against food businesses violating safety norms, approached the Bombay High Court against the national food regulator, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI). (20:02) Lastly, we discuss a trend emerging in West Bengal where medical college interns buy and sell hospital shifts on WhatsApp. (27:55) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, Ichha Sharma and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about a petition by Maharashtra government's Food Safety Commissioner Tukaram Munde against the National Food.

Speaker 2Regulator, FSSAI.

Speaker 1We also talk about medical college interns in West Bengal buying and selling hospital shifts on WhatsApp.

Speaker 2But we begin with Mumbai, where plans to build the.

Speaker 1City's first seawater desalination plant have triggered protests from fishing communities who fear the project could threaten their livelihoods. Hi, I am Niharika Nanda and you are listening to Three Things, the Indian Express News Show. For years, Mumbai has struggled with a familiar problem. How to provide enough drinking water for a city of more than 2 crore people? Particularly

Speaker 1when monsoon fails to deliver adequate rainfall. The city currently faces a daily drinking water shortfall of around 550 million litres. And with Maharashtra experiencing drought conditions this year, concerns over Mumbai's dependence on rainfall have only grown. Now to address this, the Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation or BMC has revived a plan that has been discussed for nearly two decades, turning seawater into drinking water. And the proposed desalination plant is coming up in Manori.

Speaker 3So Manori is a small coastal village. It is situated in the western suburbs of Mumbai, along the west coast.

Speaker 1That's The Indian Express's Neonika Bose, who reported on the story for the paper.

Speaker 3It's very famous for its beaches. So tourists flock to this place very often. And alongside Manori, there are several other coastal villages which are lined on this belt.

Speaker 4So these include.

Speaker 3Gorai, Uttan, Pali, Dongri and another area called Chok. And all of these villages are settled along the sea coast. Naturally, then the population here in the Manori region, Gorai and Uttan belt, they are predominantly involved in fishing or other allied work. Which means that while most of the families are dependent on fishing as a direct means of livelihood, it also creates indirect employment in the way of transport of fish, sale of fish, export, storage solutions, cooking fish-based delicacies, etc.

Speaker 3And besides this, Manori and Gorai also have lush farmlands. So there's a very thriving farming community based in these areas.

Speaker 1Neonica tells us that its first phase is scheduled to be operational by December 2029, producing 200 million litres of drinking water every day, enough to meet the daily needs of up to 15 lakh people. But while the project promises to improve Mumbai's water security, it has also sparked opposition from the people who have depended on these coastal waters for generations. So to understand why is Mumbai turning to desalination to meet its water needs and what exactly are the fishing communities worried about, my colleague Echa Sharma.

Speaker 2Speaks with Nayonika in this segment.

Speaker 5Nayonika, before we get into the protests... Could you tell our listeners a bit about how serious is Mumbai's water shortage? And why has the BMC decided that turning seawater into drinking water is now necessary?

Speaker 3Yeah, you know, despite being a coastal city where we are surrounded by the sea and seawater in three directions, Mumbai is entirely dependent on rainwater for our current needs. portable water demands. Not only portable water, but even for industrial and agricultural water demands, we depend on rainwater. How it works is that we have seven major reservoirs in and outside of Mumbai district. And these reservoirs get filled during the four months of monsoon season. And then through

Speaker 3the dams, the water is transported across the city through a channel of tunnels and water pipelines throughout the year. So Mumbai is entirely rain-dependent. It is so rain-dependent that should there be a year with poor rain, the city could face a severe water crisis. And the chances of crisis are high because Mumbai already is under a water supply shortfall.

Speaker 4So currently, Mumbai is able to.

Speaker 3Supply approximately 4,100 MLD of water every day. But the actual demand of the city stands at 4,650 MLD. So there's a huge shortfall. And this demand is further projected to grow beyond 6,000 MLD by 2024. And now with an El Nino, a strong El Nino system in place, where drought has spread across the state, the BMC is, you know, sort of taking up the cudgels to further diversify the sources of water that we have here. So

Speaker 3instead of being entirely dependent on rain, the idea is to now treat seawater, which is abundantly available in the city, and convert it into drinking water. And This, according to the BMC officials, is expected to play a crucial role in even bridging the gap that we have currently between the demand and the supply. So, you know, to put into perspective, in the first phase alone, when the plant is expected to treat up to 200 ml of water, it is projected that this project will cater to up

Speaker 3to 15 lakh people in the western suburbs of Mumbai.

Speaker 5Right, and we understand that hundreds of fishermen and villagers are protesting against this project that is supposed to provide drinking water to Mumbai. So, could you help us in understanding what exactly is happening in Manori?

Speaker 3See, for now, I mean, Manori has been making the headlines of late because a land parcel of approximately 29 hectares in this area has been earmarked for the construction of Mumbai's first ever desalination project. And that is the project which is now drawing concerns and there have been protests by locals, fishermen and activists alike. This project is expected to come atop a small hillock, which used to traditionally serve as a grassland where the cattle grazed and

Speaker 3local fisher folk would dry their fish. And, you know, local children just spend their time playing. This site also has a very scenic view of the beach. So it was also a very popular tourist spot. Now, however, that area has been barricaded by the BMC and the agency has now started doing ground survey, soil assessment to be able to finalize.

Speaker 4Their plans for desalination project.

Speaker 3This project work is expected to be carried out over the next three years. And the deadline is set at December 2029.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 5And Mumbai has been considering desalination for nearly 20 years, right? So what has changed now that makes the BMC confident that this project can finally go ahead?

Speaker 4Yes.

Speaker 3So for 20 years, it didn't work out because there's always been concerns over the cost and land availability and even the technology because it's fairly new for India.

Speaker 4We have plants everywhere.

Speaker 3Desalination plants in Chennai, which were commissioned in 2010. And this mechanism is very common globally. But in India, it still remains a very new and up and coming project. And even so, in 2007, actually, so nearly two decades ago, the state government had appointed a committee which suggested that Mumbai should have desalination plants. And gradually in 2009, Mumbai.

Speaker 4Was facing an acute water crisis.

Speaker 3So the BMC then, you know, took up the cudgels to sort of do some feasibility studies for the construction of this plant. However, again, the concerns over high cost and land acquisition came to fore and then the BMC decided to cancel this proposal.

Speaker 4Three years after 2016.

Speaker 3And 2019, the erstwhile environment minister, Aditya Thackeray of SENA UBT, he showed interest in the project.

Speaker 4And then the plan was again revived.

Speaker 3Then after that, in 2021, you know, the BMC sort of signed MOUs. It had interactions with international companies, water technology companies based in Israel. to sort of further build on this idea of a desalination plant for Mumbai. You know, in 2023, after much deliberations, then the BMC finally floated a tender. It was a 3,500 crore tender, which sought to invite bidders to sort of, you know, build, develop

Speaker 3and maintain a desalination plant in Banori. However, that proposal kept drawing very feeble responses and then gradually it was cancelled. And I think the final mark came in 2025 when the BMC again floated a fresh global tender. And gradually by December of last year, in 2025, a contract was awarded to a joint.

Speaker 4Venture between an Indian and an Israeli company.

Speaker 5Now, for those who may not know already, this desalination plant will use reverse osmosis, essentially the same basic technology found in many of our household water purifiers, but of course, on a vastly larger scale. So basically, seawater will be drawn through an underwater intake system. It will then be screened and filtered and forced through a barrier under high pressure to remove salt. The treated water will then be remineralized and disinfected before distribution to homes and businesses. The

Speaker 5process will also generate concentrated saline wastewater that will be returned to the sea from the outtake pipes, and this has raised concerns among the villagers. So, Nayonika, just how worried are fishermen? And what does this mean for the marine ecosystem?

Speaker 4Yeah, so for fishermen, you know, they account for the largest chunk of the population in this belt. So desalination plant and how it works has naturally created a concern. The biggest concerns surround around the impact on the marine ecosystem, the fish breeding and eventually the catch of fish. You know, not only in Manori, but these concerns echo even in the nearby villages of that area. So speaking about the intake outlet, the concerns have largely been around the fact that,

Speaker 4you know, This water, this intake outlet, it will be like a tunnel. So it's going to draw water from the sea. And many of the generational fisher folk are concerned about the smaller baby fish, the eggs and the fish breed. They're worried that it's going to get sucked into the pipe due to the suction pull of the tunnel. When it comes to another concern, it largely centers around the fact that Many fish, even eels for that matter,

Speaker 4more expensive catch like lobsters, they all come to the coast or the rocky side for breeding. The fisher folk have highlighted that they prefer to breed in a quiet area, but they are worried that with the development of the plant, the entire quietitude, the tranquil of the area will be disturbed. Also, they are worried that the facility will increase.

Speaker 3The movement and the churn in the water. So, they are concerned about these factors. When it comes to the outlet part of it, the outfall area of the tunnel, they are concerned that the brine, which is concentrated seawater, it's going to eventually be discharged into the sea and increase the salinity of the water. So they are concerned that, you know, while this may not have an immediate impact on the population of the fish, they are worried that gradually fewer fish will come here to breed. And this

Speaker 3is going to have a direct impact on the you know, the livelihoods of people here.

Speaker 4Having said that, when we went there, when we.

Speaker 3Spoke to the locals, the biggest cause of anger was the fact that their concerns are currently not being addressed.

Speaker 4This has further fuelled worries along the coast.

Speaker 5Right, and Nayonika, as you mentioned earlier, fishing here is not just an occupation, but an entire local economy. So how many families depend on the sea? And what makes this fishing economy vulnerable?

Speaker 3Right, so according to the local estimates, the villages of Manori, Uttan and Gorai are home to over 20,000 fishing families, which directly depend on fishing. If they do not fish, then like I said earlier, they are engaged in some kind of allied work.

Speaker 4Since they are directly dependent on fishing.

Speaker 3As a livelihood, any change in the population of fish, the change in fish breeding patterns is going to impact their catch significantly. which is going to directly impact the source of income. So for them, it's not just a matter of, you know, raising protests. They've been constantly saying that it is for them a cause of their entire livelihood.

Speaker 5And one of the most interesting insights for me was how the villagers actually brought fishermen from Chennai to understand what happened around the desalination plant there. So could you tell us a bit about that?

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 3So when the locals in the area first found out that there's going to be a desalination plant, there was a lot of unawareness about the project. Because like we had discussed earlier, it's still a very new concept.

Speaker 4So they started doing their.

Speaker 3Own research and they also spoke to the local corporator in the area. Interestingly, the local corporator told them that, you know, there's already a plant in Chennai and people there are facing no problems. This is how they found out that there is some kind of facility, some kind of similar facility which is operational in Chennai. And the fisher folk here on the west coast in Manori somehow managed to.

Speaker 4Get in touch with the fisher folk there.

Speaker 3They also got in touch with the activists in Chennai where a desalination plant is already operational.

Speaker 4So they had this exchange of dialogue and then.

Speaker 3Eventually, there was so much worry amongst the locals in this area that they pooled in money and they flew in two people from Chennai, the fisher folk and an activist from Chennai who came to Bombay, who came to the village here in Manori and had a dialogue with them. And when they spoke to them, they realized how badly the livelihoods of the fisher folk in Chennai had been impacted. They realized that they were facing problems owing to soil erosion.

Speaker 4The catch of the fish was going down. There were multiple concerns.

Speaker 3And during this dialogue, the fishermen in Chennai also explained to them, I mean, explain to the locals in Manori as to how to sort of map the coordinates, how to understand what's happening when, how to apply for applications for, you know, information from the government.

Speaker 4And this exchange of dialogue led.

Speaker 3To awareness amongst the locals in Manori, Gorai and the Uttan belt.

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 5And it's not just fishermen who are worried. You highlight how farmers in the surrounding villages are also opposing the project. So what exactly are their concerns?

Speaker 4Right.

Speaker 3So being a coastal area, Manori and its nearby regions, they predominantly have coconut, paddy and mango yield. But when we went there, farmers also told us that they grow vegetables like chillies and brinjals, tomatoes, pumpkins, you name it. They have vast fields, you know. So according to the farmer community, the increase in the salinity of water and eventually increase in salinity in the air also will impact the growth of their native crops. So that primary concern

Speaker 3has led the Farmers Association to even write to the authorities in opposition to the project. They've also joined the fishermen now in the protests.

Speaker 5And Ayonika, how has the BMC responded? Because you mentioned earlier that the fishermen's concerns haven't been heard.

Speaker 3So the BMC had initially had a dialogue with the local community. And according to the locals, that was more about a sort of presentation from the BMC's end.

Speaker 4According to the locals, the concerns of the villagers were not heard.

Speaker 3Having said that, the BMC for its part, you know, it maintains that the project is not going to have any impact on the marine life. the concerns over brine, you know, the discharge from the plant, which has become a source of controversy.

Speaker 4The BMC says that it will have no impact on marine life.

Speaker 3According to civic records, the brine discharge is mainly concentrated seawater with high salinity. It does not include any toxic chemicals or heavy metals. So the BMC said that, you know, it's not going to cause any shock to the marine life.

Speaker 4And they've also maintained.

Speaker 3That they're going to use multiple diffusers, ambient salinity and also maintain strict chemical standards as per the MPCB norms to ensure that there's no harmful impact. Besides that, you know, they've also said that specific features have been incorporated in the plant which are not existent at the time when the Chennai plant was built in 2010.

Speaker 4So, they believe that the concerns.

Speaker 3Which have been flagged by citing the problems in Chennai will not be faced in Mumbai because the technology is much more advanced.

Speaker 4So, for instance, you know, this could get a little scientific.

Speaker 3But the official said that there are intake heads which are situated below the low tide levels.

Speaker 4They're also very much deep into the sea.

Speaker 3And They've also designed it in a way that allows velocity at a very reduced rate to prevent any organism from getting trapped in the intake screen, you know. Additionally, they've also said that unlike older desalination plants, which used to use the thermal technology, this particular plant is going to use reverse osmosis in which there is no heating of water. And even the brine will be within 1 degree Celsius of the ambient seawater. So the BMC for

Speaker 3its part maintains that, you know, there's no big cause for concern. There's no cause for concern when it comes to the livelihoods of people.

Speaker 5And I think we know that Mumbai is already considering another desalination plant at Versova. So, does this resistance in Manori kind of speak about the larger problem that persists with how the city plans its coastal infrastructure, particularly when the people who depend on the coastline may not be the primary beneficiaries as such?

Speaker 4Yes, of course.

Speaker 3In fact, the locals that we met now have already been speaking in contempt of the plant planned in Varsova. And the coastal, the fisher folk community in Mumbai have always been very vocal about their concerns and their voice holds a lot of import in the state. So the concerns are naturally going to come when it comes to the upcoming plant. The similar concerns will be flagged by locals, not only in the fishing communities of Versova, but also

Speaker 3in other fishing beds. For now, however, it remains to be seen how this project is going to unfold. Because for now, the locals have raised demands of a dietitian. while the BNC has said that they are open to discussion. So it still remains to be seen how this project will unfold and how it will set a kind of standard for the next upcoming plant of BNC.

Speaker 1And next, we talk about a petition by the Maharashtra government against the National Food Regulator, FSSAI. Earlier this month, Maharashtra's Food Safety Commissioner Tukaram Munde, who has recently been in the spotlight for his strict action against food businesses violating safety norms, approached the Bombay High Court against the National Food Regulator, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of.

Speaker 2India or FSSAI.

Speaker 1In his petition, he alleged that the National Regulator had created a parallel regulatory mechanism and encroached on the state's powers. And he also argued that the Centre had restricted the powers of the Commissioner and his officers. Now, the petition has brought into focus how food safety is regulated in India, how responsibilities are divided between the Centre and the states, and the limitations of the current system. So, to understand the concerns raised in the petition and what they mean for food safety regulation in India, we speak with the

Speaker 1Indian Express's Anona Dutt. Anona, can you first tell us what exactly Tokaram Munde is saying through this petition?

Speaker 6So what he's saying is that the central agency, through its various guidelines over the years, has actually encroached on the powers of the state food safety officers. And it has created sort of a parallel regulatory mechanism for certain companies, especially, you know, the big companies that are dealing with high-risk foods like, you know, perishable items such as meats, milk, which was anyway allowed in the Act, but it has also encroached upon other activities with bigger companies, which is

Speaker 6the contention, because the state commissioners cannot inspect on their own these facilities, which are granted a central license.

Speaker 1And coming to the food regulation, tell us what is the division of responsibilities between the centre and the state?

Speaker 2What all does the centre have under its control?

Speaker 7So the Food.

Speaker 6Safety Act actually says that the centre can grant licences, like I mentioned, to companies which have a very high turnover, especially when they are working in high-risk food sectors and perishable items.

Speaker 4But it also.

Speaker 6Encompasses companies which operate across state borders. So there is no problem of these companies having to seek multiple licenses from different states. However, the Act does not stipulate any, you know, creating any cadre of officers known as the Central Food Safety Officers. But the Centre has created such a cadre and the Central Authority and has been using these officers to inspect the, you know, premises which are

Speaker 6licensed under the Central License. And in these premises, the food safety officers from the state are not allowed to conduct individual inspections, except for in some extenuating circumstances, like if there is an emergency or there has been like a report of some outbreak and the action has to be taken immediately. Barring those cases, the state regulators cannot inspect the premises without the central team. So this was actually one of the major points of contention because it

Speaker 6takes away the power from the food safety officers who are actually the designated officers as per the Act. to carry out the inspections, seize, you know, samples, conduct the tests and then launch whatever prosecution, whether civil or criminal. That was all what the state authorities had to do. But now some of it is also done by the centre.

Speaker 1And now coming to the state, what all does it have under its ambit?

Speaker 6So the state can regulate all other food business operators.

Speaker 7So whether it's packaged food or.

Speaker 6Even restaurants or certain hawkers, all of that comes under state regulation. So they have to get a state license and the state food officers can conduct these inspections. But in any case where the company has a turnover of over 50 crores and has a central license, they can now only be inspected by the central authority, like I mentioned.

Speaker 1So now keeping this in mind, what has Maharashtra government's petition questioned?

Speaker 6So like I mentioned, one of the key things is having, you know, the central food safety officers, which the act technically does not mention because it says the commissioner can appoint a food safety officer, but only the heads of the state food regulatory authorities can are known as commissioners, whereas the head of the central regulatory body FSSAI is a CEO. So the petition challenges that why is CEO appointing these so-called central food safety officers. Secondly, of course,

Speaker 6like I mentioned, they have taken away through its order in May 2023, they have taken away certain powers from the state food safety regulators in that they are They cannot conduct inspections in these centrally licensed places on their own. And third, of course, another important point that has been raised is that the center has also started this online portal for the compliance system.

Speaker 7It does various things, including the licensing part. And that Mr. Munday has alleged that that is.

Speaker 6Also taking away more and more food businesses from these state inspections.

Speaker 1And we also understand that the petition says that the centre has brought more food businesses under its own authority, right?

Speaker 2So tell us how is that?

Speaker 4Yes.

Speaker 7So there are two things here. One is the allegation by not just Maharashtra.

Speaker 6FDA, but some of the food safety officers from the states that I spoke to is that increasingly more food businesses are being brought under the central license. For example, all e-commerce platforms, the five-star hotels are certain categories which have been brought under central license. And the second thing is the authority to conduct food inspections in these places. So with the 2023 order, these centrally licensed places cannot be inspected by the state food safety regulator. So earlier,

Speaker 6even though certain businesses, especially the products that were being imported, came under the central authority, the state regulators could still conduct inspections in these spaces. So this is what the Maharashtra government has alleged that the centre is taking away some of its role.

Speaker 2And with these changes, what challenges has the state been facing?

Speaker 5So there are.

Speaker 6Certain challenges that the states have started facing because of this new division of roles. One of which is, you know, cases slipping through the cracks. So first, the authority has made a demarcation that certain businesses would be inspected by it, while the others with the state licenses would be inspected by the state regulators. However, there have been instances pointed out by various food safety officers where the center has also conducted inspections in places which technically then should have

Speaker 6been inspected by the state authorities.

Speaker 7Which creates its own unique challenges.

Speaker 6So, for example, one food safety officer from Delhi told us that in certain cases where inspection is carried out by the central authority, when the state authority goes to court, the officer is asked to identify the person from whom The sample was collected and since the state food safety officer was not present at the time of inspection, they cannot do that. They cannot identify the proprietor or the person whose permission was taken while collecting the samples.

Speaker 7So that again results in the cases failing in court.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about a trend that has emerged in West Bengal, where interns in medical colleges negotiate, buy and sell hospital shifts on WhatsApp. The Indian Express's Sweety Kumari reported that in government medical colleges in Bengal, shift switches that started as informal peer arrangements among medical interns have turned into a cash-for-duty network, that operates across medical colleges in Kolkata and other parts of the state, allowing interns to trade mandatory rotatory shifts for amounts ranging

Speaker 1from Rs 200 to Rs 600 per hour. One such group, named Internship Replacement, contains more than 255 members who regularly broadcast shift availability and the money expected in return. Now to keep a check on the interns, the State Health Department has rolled out a biometric attendance system. Health Minister Sharadwath Makhopadhyay, who says he came across a dental college intern performing duties on behalf of an MBBS intern during a surprise inspection at Murshidabad Medical College, held a meeting this month with principals and vice-principals of medical colleges where

Speaker 1the issue was discussed. Sources said that principals of three medical colleges across the state had no idea about this network under their roofs. Mukhopadhyay told Sweety that the practice has been found to be widespread across almost all government hospitals. Officials said that on an average, a medical college and hospital in Bengal has around 250 interns who must put in minimum hours for an MBBS degree, performing duties such as taking down case histories of patients for a monthly stipend of Rs 40-50.

Speaker 2Rs 50,000.

Speaker 1Only on health grounds or an emergency is an intern allowed exemption from duty with the requirement that missed hours be completed later. One of the officers added that there is no attendance system as such in place. Mukhopadhyay said that the government intends to eradicate all malpractices from the system that started during the tenure of the previous government. On the other hand, medical interns have also shared concerns. that not everyone should face the consequences of something a few have been indulging in, and that the government also needs to address the unbearable work pressure and the appalling

Speaker 1basic conditions the interns have to face daily, from unsanitary washrooms to a lack of proper rest areas.

Speaker 2However, an intern.

Speaker 1Also told Sweety that the swapping of duties is an open secret given the number of hours that they have to work.

Speaker 2You were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express.

Speaker 1Today's episode was edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar and produced by Ichha Sharma and me.

Speaker 2Niharika Nanda.

Speaker 1If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in your family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Podcast and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode