Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

3 Things

3 Things artwork

New census rules, India invites Pak for SCO, and Brij Bhushan in top panel

Oct 30, 202625 minAudio

First, we speak with The Indian Express' Deeptiman Tiwary about the ongoing Census, and the government's decision to amend the Census Rules to explicitly state that teachers from government schools, local authorities and unaided private educational institutions can be appointed as census enumerators. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about India's invitation to Pakistan’s National Heritage and Culture Minister Aurangzeb Khan Khichi for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation's Civilisational Dialogue Forum, which will take place in New Delhi and what it means for the ties between the two countries. (14:15) Lastly, we talk about Former BJP MP and Wrestling Federation of India’s ex-President Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh being included in the BJP’s Uttar Pradesh state executive committee. (21:36) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this episode, we talk about India inviting Pakistan for the upcoming Shanghai Cooperation Organization's Civilizational Dialogue Forum to be held in the capital. We also talk about former BJP MP and Wrestling Federation of India's ex-president, Brij Bhushan Charan Singh, being included in BJP's Uttar Pradesh State Executive Committee. But we begin today by talking about the ongoing census and whether the government can compel private school teachers to serve as census enumerators. Currently, India is undertaking the Herculean task

Speaker 1of counting its population and collecting data about its people.

Speaker 2This is a massive exercise.

Speaker 1That involves 30 lakh enumerators visiting households across the length and breadth of the country. Now, for this task, the government has traditionally relied on government school teachers and clerks. But earlier this month, it amended the census rules to explicitly state that teachers from government schools, local authorities and unaided private educational institutions can be appointed as census enumerators.

Speaker 2So why did the government make this change?

Speaker 1And does it actually have the power to acquire private school teachers to conduct the census? To find out, my colleague Shashank Bhargav speaks to the Indian Express's Deepti Man Tiwari.

Speaker 3Deeptiman, traditionally, you know, the government has always turned towards teachers when it has required people to conduct the census. Can you tell us why that is? Why teachers?

Speaker 4So, as it was imagined when, you know, Census Act was created and census was conducted, at that time, what did you need? You needed a workforce which was available first across the country. Two, it was educated. Three, the society should trust the enumerator. Otherwise, the society will not give the right information. So teachers fit the bill at the time. And even today, teachers fit the bill the best.

Speaker 2They are, you know, virtually everywhere.

Speaker 4In villages you go, there will be schools, government schools, teachers will be available there.

Speaker 2So they are universally distributed.

Speaker 4Across the country. Unlike, say, a bank employee. or say a hospital staff. So, you may have a hospital in the district headquarter and not probably, you know, in a remote village somewhere.

Speaker 2So, there again you will have a problem.

Speaker 4Banks may be in the district headquarters or in nearby towns and may not be there in the villages. So, this workforce is universally distributed. Two, they're educated because obviously they're teachers, so they can read and write. They know how to interact with people. Three, teachers have, you know, culturally in our country have had great respect in the society. And so they enjoy a certain level of trust among the people. So when they go and seek information from the people, the people are unlikely to.

Speaker 2Be hesitant in sharing the information. Those are precisely the reasons because.

Speaker 4Of which, you know, teachers were chosen even when the parliament passed that act of census act and the rules that were framed thereafter, you know, teachers were specifically.

Speaker 2Mentioned in it.

Speaker 4So, that has been the reason for that largely teachers are used for census enumeration.

Speaker 3Right. Teachers, as you said, are available everywhere. And for an exercise like this, you do require a lot of people.

Speaker 2Yes, yes, yes.

Speaker 4According to the Registrar General of India, for the census that is going on right now, the requirement.

Speaker 2Is 34 lakh enumerators.

Speaker 4And the last available data says that 31 lakh enumerators have been trained for this job.

Speaker 3And talk about the amendment that came into effect earlier this month, the amendment to the census rules. It says that besides teachers of government and local authority, even teachers of unaided private educational institutions may be appointed as census enumerators. So talk about this amendment. What was the impetus for this? And why did the government bring about this change? And is this something new?

Speaker 4Okay, let me begin by saying that the census rules 1990. which has been amended to add teachers from private schools and bank employees and etc., already had the list of people who can be drafted for census enumeration. And this included teachers, clerks or any official.

Speaker 2Or any person.

Speaker 4Now, when you say any person, any person is actually a very broad term. It can include anyone. Any person means you. me or all those who are listening to this podcast. So already the rules contained a far broader umbrella for the government to choose from, a far broader list for the government to choose from. What has happened is we have to understand in the context of certain litigation that the government has been.

Speaker 2Facing of late and has faced in the past as well.

Speaker 4So while the MHA says that okay we need you know more enumerators and so you know we are also added private school teachers to the list or bank employees to the list that is why we have brought this amendment although this is already there when you say any person even a bank employee or a private school teacher is included in that what has happened is that recently there are some court orders which have come where actually private unaided school teachers had actually gone to the court

Speaker 4and protested. I mean, basically made a petition to the court saying that they cannot be conscripted for enumeration duty. Basically, those schools had got these letters from the concerned district magistrate that you have to spare these many teachers for census enumeration. In turn, those schools went to the Bombay High Court. On May 22, the Bombay High Court gave an interim protection to this association, which, you know, represents more than 500 private unaided schools in Maharashtra. And it

Speaker 4said that Section 4A of the Census Act, though it imposes an obligation on local authorities that you have to spare staff for census enumeration, Section 6 and Section 7 of the Census Act does not, the court said in its preliminary review, does not confer authority to compulsorily requisition teaching and non-teaching staff of private unedited schools.

Speaker 3And during this hearing, what was the government's argument?

Speaker 4So there also the government argued that Rule 3 allows us to basically seek assistance of any person. And in that, you know, private school teachers are also included. But the court rejected this interpretation, at least at the interim stage. And it observed that if any person, you know, were given an unrestricted meaning, it could extend to private professionals such as doctors, advocates, chartered accountants. I mean, you could just, as I said, they could force you and me to do sensitivities. And then, you know, on October 8th, earlier

Speaker 4this month, you know, Punjab and Haryana High Court state Haryana government communication seeking details of private unaided school teachers for census duty.

Speaker 2And eight days after that, this amendment came.

Speaker 4So that is sort of, you know, litigation appears to be the backdrop of this entire exercise of amending Rule 3 of the census rules.

Speaker 3Okay, so what difference does amending the rules make? Because rules are just the operational guidelines and the procedure to carry out the act, right? So if you just amend the rules and not the act, like what changes say for private school teachers because the rules have been amended?

Speaker 2Actually nothing. It changes nothing.

Speaker 4Because the school teachers when they go to the court, they don't challenge the rules. They challenge the main act and its interpretation. I don't understand the objective of this amendment. Because what you are amending is essentially the rules. The rules in no measure can go beyond the act from which they draw the power. So if the main act does not give you that power, No amount of amendment in rules can actually give you that power. Now, if you have to amend the Act, you have to go to Parliament. Rules can be amended through an executive order,

Speaker 4through a Gazette notification. That is not the case with the Act. So, if the government actually intends to give these kind of coercive powers to the government, it will have to actually amend the Act and merely amending the rules will not make any difference.

Speaker 3And Deepti, when it comes to the enrolment of private school teachers or someone in an organisation, what exactly does the Census Act say regarding that?

Speaker 4So, this act actually says that the government has power to appoint persons as census officers and when so appointed, this person shall be bound to serve accordingly. Now, it says this where does the binding come? The binding powers of the act comes once you have been appointed. The government, however, argues that the binding comes at the appointment itself. So, I have the power to appoint just anybody as census officer. That has been the argument of the government in the courts. However,

Speaker 4courts have pushed back on this because now there are section 6 and 7, which also I mentioned earlier. So, what does section 6 and 7 say? Section 6 and 7 permit assistance to be sought from private establishments and their personnel. But this is not as far reaching as you would imagine from the wording because it further says that this assistance of private establishment has to be sought

Speaker 4for people who are working under their charge. So, for example, you are the manager of a factory. The DM can write to you and say that you will conduct the enumeration of all the workers in your factory. It can't say that, okay, you are the manager of this factory. Now, you will go to Dantewala in Chhattisgarh and you will conduct enumeration there. No, that is not the intent of the act. That is not being said in the act. It is only for that specific area. And because, you know,

Speaker 4as the manager, you will know all your employees, so it will be easier for you to do it, do that census rather than send somebody from outside. So, this kind of an arrangement has been made in the act.

Speaker 2Now, the courts have.

Speaker 4interpreted it accordingly and said government cannot read the act beyond its intent.

Speaker 2In fact, in 2010, Life.

Speaker 4Insurance Corporation, which is a PSU and so in a way a government body, it challenged an order requiring its Jalandhar office to provide at least 150 employees as enumerators and supervisors. And the Punjab and Haryana court quashed that order.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 3And similarly, there have been other cases as well involving bank employees, for instance. But, you know, here we are talking about enlisting people for the census. But can the government pull in people for other kinds of public work as well?

Speaker 4Yes, the constitution does intend it that way, but these are more intended in states of, say, emergency, like the country is at war or, you know, the country is facing riots or some kind of, you know, emergency situation. Say there is a pandemic, you know, so in those situations, there is something called, you know, compulsory service for public purposes. Article 23.2, you know, permits the state to impose compulsory service for public purposes. Now, let's remember what is Article 23.

Speaker 4Article 23 actually prohibits forced labour, but makes an exception in another provision of the same article that, you know, for certain situations, you know, compulsory service for public purposes could be allowed, provide the state does not discriminate on, you know, certain grounds have been given. On those grounds, there should be no discrimination. Then there are certain acts. laws which have been passed. Again, they correspond to sort of emergency situations. For example, the Police Act 1861, this

Speaker 4is a British Act which has been retained. This was basically to maintain public order. So, suppose there are communal riots and certain citizens are drafted as special police officers. You know, the police is totally stretched, does not have enough manpower, So you draft certain responsible citizens as special police officers, give them certain powers, and then they can sort of enforce the law. So that provision is there. Then there is something called a National Service Act 1972, under which specified qualified doctors and engineers could be called

Speaker 4up for national service. But again, this is for, say, you know, there is a war going on, you need doctors. I mean, in such a time when the country is facing a crisis, You know, people cannot say that, you know, we have individual rights and so we will not go. And when the country needs you. So, you know, there is something called the National Service Act, which, you know, the parliament approves. you know, passed, but it has also created an elaborate statutory.

Speaker 2Regime for this.

Speaker 4And the Act itself, you know, identifies the circumstances under which they will be drafted, who are the people who will be drafted for this kind of a service. So, it has been drafted in detail in the Act itself. This kind of elaborate arrangement is not available in.

Speaker 2The Census Act.

Speaker 4The Census Act rules, you can say, many different things, but the Act itself does not give that framework. And when the entire Census Act and its rules are taken together, there is an air of ambiguity around it, and that is why it keeps going to the court.

Speaker 2Over and over again.

Speaker 1And next, we talk about India's recent invitation to Pakistan. For the first time since Operation Sindur, which was carried out in May 2025 in response to the Pahalgam terror attack, India has invited a minister from Pakistan for an upcoming forum. The invitation has been extended to Pakistan's National Heritage Culture Minister Aurangzeb Khan Kitchi for the Shanghai Cooperation Organization's Civilizational Dialogue Forum, which will take place in New Delhi on November 20 and 21. Now, the last time India hosted

Speaker 1a senior Pakistani minister was in May 2023, when Pakistan's then Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended the SCO Council of Foreign.

Speaker 2Ministers meeting in Goa.

Speaker 1So, to understand the significance of this invitation, we speak to the Indian Express's Diplomatic Affairs Editor, Shubhjeet Roy. Shubhjeet, can you first tell us a bit about the SCO Civilizational Dialogue, which was first proposed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, right?

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 5So, you know, what happened was last year when SCO met in Tianjin, the leaders had met where Prime Minister Modi had traveled to China for the first time after almost six years, you know, and it was a sort of gathering of all the SCO leaders. There, he had proposed a Something called the SCO Civilizational Dialogue, which should be held at the level.

Speaker 2Of Shanghai Cooperation Organization member countries.

Speaker 5And that was sort of the idea that was approached and later it was accepted. So the idea is that the Indian civilization, the Chinese civilization, the Persian civilization, all of them have a confluence and they should sort of have a dialogue, you know, invoking the historical past and the legacy and how to talk about it and make it more contemporary on the values, on the sort of principles and ideologies from those times.

Speaker 2And it got accepted.

Speaker 5And then it was announced by Defence Minister Rajnath Singh just last week at the SCO Defence Minister's meeting. So this meeting will take place in November 20th to 21st, 22nd for two, three days in Delhi. and right now as we hear that it will be held in one of the iconic monuments of Delhi possibly Purana Killa which obviously is a historical monument also you know it has a legacy of India's you know from the mythological past

Speaker 5to the historical past so it provides a very befitting setting for this dialogue. So that's how this SCO civilizational dialogue will be taken, which will obviously be addressed by Prime Minister as well, possibly, if it takes place here.

Speaker 2And we understand that Pakistan has also been invited for this dialogue.

Speaker 1Now, can you remind our listeners, why has there been a breakdown of bilateral ties between the two countries, especially in the recent past?

Speaker 5Yeah, so as you know that India-Pakistan relationship has really hit rock bottom in the last decade or so, especially after the initial overtures by Prime Minister Modi by calling Prime Minister of Pakistan along with other Sark leaders for a swearing-in ceremony in 2014.

Speaker 2After that, there was dialogue.

Speaker 5But, you know, after 2015, there was a sort of a breakdown in the conversation following the terror attacks in Pathankot and again in Uri in 2016. And since then, it has sort of gone on a free fall. There were a series of terror attacks. Pulwama happened in 2019. Pahalgaon terror attack happened in 2025, which is last year, in April last year. And in May last year, there were these military confrontation between the two countries where, you know,

Speaker 5under Ops Indore. And according to the Indian government's sort of doctrine, the Ops Indore is still on.

Speaker 2And in between, the two countries.

Speaker 5Have also had sort of a face off over the abrogation of Article 370 from Jammu and Kashmir. So overall, the relationship has really touched a new low where the two countries expelled each other's high commissioners. They withdrew their diplomats. So it's almost at a skeletal strength now. And right now there are sort of no contact at all bilaterally. Also, the borders are closed and there are no flights, no buses, no connectivity, no trains that run between the two countries.

Speaker 5A trade is also almost negligible. Whatever little trade happens, it happens through third countries, maybe through Dubai, Abu Dhabi or some other country. But broadly, that has been the state of play in the relationship.

Speaker 2So keeping that in mind.

Speaker 1Tell us what has led India to invite Pakistan for this SCO dialogue?

Speaker 5So in this particular context, Pakistan getting an invite for this SCO Civilization Dialogue is part of India's obligation as a SCO member country, which is obligated to invite all the SCO member countries together. for any SCO related event. So India's position has been so far that it can engage with Pakistan at the multilateral level, but there will be no bilateral dialogue as long as environment, the atmospheric

Speaker 5is not free from terrorism. So essentially, it has put the onus of a terror-free environment on Pakistan and has said that terror and talks can't go together. So in this kind of context, an invitation to Pakistan for an event is interesting and noteworthy because this is for the first time after almost two, two and a half years that India would be hosting a Pakistan minister if the Pakistan minister chooses to come here. Last time India hosted

Speaker 5a Pakistan minister was in May 2023 when Pakistan Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari had come to Goa And Shubhjeet, talking about the civilizational dialogue, what is.

Speaker 2On the agenda for this meeting and what all can we expect?

Speaker 5Well, you know, so far talking about the historical past, the legacy and looking at how they can take it forward in future.

Speaker 2It's also noteworthy that, you know, India.

Speaker 5Is trying to appropriate the civilizational sort of legacy of the past. especially because Pakistan is there and sort of Pakistan is also a successor state of the same legacy. But India is trying to appropriate that. And that will be an interesting thing, how Pakistan responds to this during the dialogue. And obviously, the Chinese civilization, the Persian civilization, and obviously the Indus Valley civilization, these civilizations will be sort of discussed there at the meeting.

Speaker 2And we'll have to see how it plays out.

Speaker 1And in the end, we talk about former BJP MP and Wrestling Federation of India's ex-president, Brijbhushan Charan Singh, who has been named to the BJP's Uttar Pradesh State Executive Committee. The Indian Express's Lalmani Verma reported that almost three months after he was acquitted in a sexual harassment case lodged by a group of women wrestlers, the party has added Singh to the committee. This is the first time he has been included in the top panel. Uttar Pradesh BGP President Pankaj Chaudhary constituted the State Executive Committee on 26

Speaker 1October ahead of its meeting scheduled to be held today to draw up the roadmap for the 2027 Assembly elections. Union Home Minister Amit Shah will address the opening session of the day-long meeting to be held in Lucknow, while Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath will address the concluding session. Amid the political storm caused by the sexual harassment allegations, The BJP dropped Singh for the 2024 Lok Sabha elections and fielded his younger son, Karan Bhushan Singh, in the Kesarganj Lok Sabha seat, one of the constituencies Bridge Bhushan has

Speaker 1represented in the past. Bridge Bhushan did not campaign outside Kesarganj and Karan won his debut election. A senior BJP leader said that now that the court has acquitted him, he may actively participate in BJP programmes and could also get a BJP ticket for the 2029 Lok Sabha. But the party might still be a little hesitant to field him again. Brij Bhushan remains one of the most influential political figures in eastern UP. Uttar Pradesh BJP spokesperson Rakesh Tripathi said that the allegations against Singh were were a

Speaker 1part of a political conspiracy and the courts have acquitted him. On 3 August, a Delhi court acquitted the BJP leader more than three years after six women wrestlers accused him of sexual harassment, which sparked national outrage. However, the acquittal by the trial court has been challenged and a Delhi court on October 28 gave Brij Bhushan a week to respond to the appeal by four women wrestlers challenging it. Lalmani reported that previously the State Executive Committee had 184 members and as per the list available on the UPBGP website,

Speaker 1the new panel now has 712 members, including 134 special invitees and 30 permanent invitees. You were listening to Three Things by Indian Express.

Speaker 2Today's show was edited and mixed.

Speaker 1By Suresh Pawar and produced by Shashank Bhargav and me, Niharika Nanda. If you like the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone you think will like it. Share it with a friend or someone in a family. It's the best way for people to get to know about us. You can also tweet us at Express Audio and write to us at podcasts at indianexpress.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Quad Summit, making chess TV friendly, and a bulldozer death in UP

    Nov 20, 202628 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Diplomatic Affairs Editor Shubhajit Roy about the 2026 Quad Summit in Manila, India’s role within the grouping and what its expanding cooperation means for relations with China and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Catch Up: ‘Bulldozer’ move at Akhilesh Yadav rally (19 November)

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. All about women: Domestic gig work, open prisons, and workforce data

    Nov 19, 202635 minAudio

    First, we speak with The Indian Express' Sukrita Baruah about women who provide household services via applications like Pronto and Snabbit. She talks about their experience, their earnings, and how their lives have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Catch Up: Bombay HC raps civic body over garbage for Mumbaikars (18 November)

    Nov 18, 20264 minAudio

    The headlines of the day by The Indian Express

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mumbai-Goa highway delay, fight for clean air, and UP's voter roll row

    Nov 18, 202633 minAudio

    First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Dheeraj Mishra about why the Mumbai-Goa highway remains unfinished nearly two decades after construction began, the companies and political connections behind its most delayed...

    Credit the people on this episode