Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Your Next Chapter

Your Next Chapter artwork

Protecting Creativity in the Age of AI

Jul 14, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Season 3, Episode 12 In the final episode of Season 3, I'm digging into one of the biggest and most complicated conversations facing creatives today: AI and creativity. This episode is not about fear-mongering or rejecting technology altogether. Instead, it’s an honest, nuanced conversation about intentionality, brain health, critical thinking, originality, and what it means to remain deeply human in an increasingly AI-driven world. I also share reflections and excerpts inspired by Susan Cain and poet Joseph Fasano on art, humanity, and the irreplaceable nature of human creativity. Whether you’re excited about AI, wary of it, dependent on it, or simply trying to figure out your own boundaries, this episode invites you to think more intentionally about your relationship with technology and creativity. Want more between episodes? Get my twice-ish monthly newsletter + free book club guides here: https://rebeccahasulak.substack.com/subscribe. Find more from me at rebeccahasulak.com.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Rebecca HasulakWelcome back to your next chapter, the podcast for women who read, write, and live creatively. I'm your host, Rebecca Hasulak, and I want to welcome you to our very last episode in season three. I can't even believe that. Thank you for joining me for this wonderful ride. I am so excited about all the episodes I've already been able to share with you and looking forward to even more coming up soon in season four. So today we're talking about something that I have avoided talking about so far, not because I don't think it's important, but because I actually think it is very important.

Rebecca HasulakAnd it is such a big topic. And I quite frankly wasn't sure how to handle it and how to bring you my thoughts in a coherent way, in an honest way, and in a useful way. So I'm going to attempt to do that for you today, but I ask that you bear with me. I will be sharing some of my own thoughts, some questions for you to think about, and some thoughts of other people in the creative world who I highly respect. And of course, the topic, if you haven't guessed, is AI and creativity.

Rebecca HasulakSo let's dig in here. Artificial intelligence has always been something that humans have been a little bit wary of. It has been a storyline in countless science fiction novels and movies and different things through the years where people are worried about robots taking over the world. And it can be a very scary thing to think about because of the unimaginable level of quote-unquote intelligence that machines can in theory possess, the speed with which they can process information, and really the unknown nature of their ultimate capabilities.

Rebecca HasulakSo I'm with you that a lot of this is really scary. I'm also not someone who wants to be a fear-mongerer. Technology has been advancing throughout time. And usually with any wave of technology, there is a lot of fear. There are a lot of unknowns, and there's a lot of talk about what is going to be replaced. You know, if you remember back to video killed the radio star, right? We're always worried about what's happening next, where this is going to go. And I think, of course, the difference is that with AI, the potential is just so much greater than technology that we've seen before.

Rebecca HasulakBut I still am not bringing you this message as one of fear or dread or anything like that. I just want to be honest and talk about this as always through the lens of what does it mean for us as creative people and also what does it mean for us as humans? So I think the ultimate question is not is AI evil? I don't think it's inherently evil or inherently not evil. I think it's technology. And I think the bigger question is, what kind of relationship are we building it with? Are we building with it?

Rebecca HasulakAnd I'm even careful to use the word relationship because I'm very mindful of personifying technology. We are not going to have an actual relationship with it, but what I mean by this is what sort of interactions are we building with it? How are we using it in our lives? How is it changing our lives? And that sort of thing. I also want to talk about what happens to human creativity, what happens to cognition and attention and originality if we outsource too much of our inner lives. So the goal isn't fear. The goal is to just be intentional here and talk about something that honestly I would be a little bit remiss in not talking about on a podcast that is all about creativity.

Rebecca HasulakWhen I think about AI, I kind of go back and forth about my own thoughts on it. When it first started to become popular, and you know, mostly I'm talking about ChatGPT because that was that's the main AI that I hear about, although I know AI is present in so many different applications and companies. But when ChatGPT started to become commonly used, I saw a lot of adoption quickly. I am in the PR world and business people, I especially have worked with a lot of technology clients.

Rebecca HasulakAnd a lot of my clients have used AI in their own products for years. I mean, before it was really mainstream. But of course, it's become more sophisticated over the years. But I saw more adoption because, especially with content creation, which unfortunately or unfortunately is something that I've always done. And that was, you know, my writing professionally has always been my bread and butter. That has been my job. And all of a sudden, there was this machine that could do it faster. Some would argue better. And it was scary. It still is scary.

Rebecca HasulakI mean, I have seen a direct decline in client work for content as AI has become more prevalent. Now, of course, there is a little bit of back and forth there because as more AI created content has been pushed out into the world, a lot of people are really feeling the repercussions of that and wanting truly human content. And so there is still a need. I believe there always will be a need. But yes, are a lot of people using AI to write content? Yes.

Rebecca HasulakAre a lot of people using it in the business world? Yes. It is mind-boggling. I think I have no idea what the actual numbers are, but probably something like 90% of the content we see is AI written now. I mean, maybe that's a little high, but I wouldn't doubt it if it's really, really, really a large percentage, because it allows people to save time. And time is the one thing in our lives that is finite. So if you can save time doing a task and put that time towards something you would either rather be doing or something that is more useful to you, to improving your health, to improving your life, you can see why that's appealing.

Rebecca HasulakI mean, we can all see why. But I think that you can have very strong feelings about AI and not be anti-technology. I'm not anti-technology. I think technology has made our lives all a lot easier. I think we just always have to acknowledge the pros and the cons that come along with it, you know, even cars. That is ultimately technology. And before that, we didn't have efficient ways to get around. We couldn't travel as far. We have all decided to use cars, even though there is a lot of risk involved with using cars, right? There's always going to be trade-offs.

Rebecca HasulakThere will always be pros and cons. And that's what we have to really look at when we're talking about AI. So I do use AI in some of my areas of my work in my life. I will just be honest with you. I generally adopt technology fairly quickly. I like it in certain aspects, but I'm also very mindful of my use. So there, I actually have some clients who want me to use AI, which I will do if that's what they want. And I also write myself without it all the time. And my creative writing will always be written by me, myself, and I, and only me.

Rebecca HasulakAnd I think that's really important. That is something that is important to me. It's important to me from an integrity standpoint. And frankly, I love writing. So why would I not want to write? It just doesn't make sense. So yes, I do use it. I use it sometimes to help me organize things. I use it to help me plan things. I use it on the personal front to help me put together menu, menus for the week and help me figure out what items in my kitchen I can use up creatively and you know, how to save money, how to like I do. I use it on those fronts because it really does save a lot of time and it can help me save money and things like that.

Rebecca HasulakBut at the same time, I think it's really important that we we hang on to and preserve our ability to think creatively, deeply, and independently. It is just too easy now to have a question and instead of sitting there and wrestling with the question yourself, to go ahead and type it into Chat GPT or whatever your AI of choice is and get a very comprehensive answer within seconds. And that sounds cool, and in theory it's cool, but what happens to all that time spent just that we would have spent thinking? We're not thinking anymore. And there are some pretty crazy research studies.

Rebecca HasulakI'm not going to get too deep into that because quite honestly, I didn't want to make this too science-y, I should say scientific, but um, there are some kind of shocking studies coming out about how losing so much critical thinking is really impacting our brains. And it is a little bit, that is the part that truly terrifies me, especially for the younger generations and future generations, is like we need to be able to think critically as a society and as individuals, or what do we have? So that is something I would like to say to you.

Rebecca HasulakI think that the main reason that AI has become so widely used is because it removes friction. And who doesn't want less friction in their lives? We want things to be easier, faster, all that good stuff. I do too. But friction is often where creativity actually develops. When you wrestle with ideas, when you're uncertain, when you're bored, when you have to experiment or fail or revise or reflect, all of those things are really the basis for creativity. That's where originality lives.

Rebecca HasulakAnd honestly, some creative breakthroughs only happen because we stay with difficulty long enough. There's also a proverb that says, necessity is the mother of invention. And the the basic idea is just that the primary driving force for most inventions is a need. If you have so much refriction removed from your daily life and from all the things that you're doing that there's no friction, what is there going to be to invent? And of course, there will always be things to invent. So I'm not saying that super literally, but I'm just saying you we need friction.

Rebecca HasulakWe need to struggle a little bit. The struggle is often where the growth happens. And there really is a lot of danger in outsourcing your thinking. There's just an over-reliance on technology. It creates intellectual passivity. And some of the potential consequences are just reduced critical thinking, reduced creativity, weakened creative confidence, and a lack of trust. I talked about this with trying to remember what episode it was, with when we get too much advice and too many resources and we start to lose touch with our own instincts and we start to not really trust ourselves because we've had so many other voices in our heads.

Rebecca HasulakBut this happens too when you're not flexing your creativity muscles and you're outsourcing your thinking, you lose trust in your own thoughts, which is kind of mind-boggling and scary. So I said I'm not going to do fear-mongering, and I feel like I have talked about things being terrifying multiple times now. So I apologize for that. I'm not trying to spread fear. I'm mostly trying to kind of talk this through with you like we would if you were sitting here with me right now. So when it comes to AI, my big concern is aside from, you know, people trying to use it to replace the work of actual creatives, you know, we've seen a huge rise in people quote unquote writing books.

Rebecca HasulakYou're not, you didn't write a book if you used AI to write a book. You used AI to write a book. And people want to be authors, and I get that, but I don't want to just be an author. I want to actually write the book. I actually love writing the book. And it's a little disheartening to me to think that someone can be out there saying, I want to write a book, and then they just plug a few prompts into AI and then they call it their book. I think there needs to be some sort of disclaimer that it was created by AI. There's if you want to do that, fine, but you need to make that public knowledge.

Rebecca HasulakAnd as a consumer, I would be very keen to buy art from people who have actually created it themselves. And I think that's somehow we're going to need to make that distinction so that consumers can have a little more power and can choose to buy art from people who are actually doing the work themselves. So as we know about the brain, the brain strengthens what it repeatedly practices. If we constantly practice just doing things quickly with speed and shortcuts, what's going to happen to our imaginations, to our patience, our synthesis, our intuition, and our deep focus?

Rebecca HasulakSo here's what I propose. I propose that you think about this subject yourself. And I'm going to give you a few more, a few more uh nuggets to consider. But I propose that you create your own code of ethics. Yes, as a society, we're having to put guardrails in place. We're having to sort of think about this collectively. But for you as an individual, I encourage you to think about AI and think about your own values. There's not one universal answer, but think attentionally about your own boundaries.

Rebecca HasulakAnd on that note, I'm I want you to ask yourself a few questions. So if you're driving, just think about the answers. If you're somewhere where you can pull out a notebook safely, then you could even jot down your own answers. But here are some questions to think about. What role do I want AI to play in my life? What do I never want to outsource? What strengthens my thinking? What weakens it? Where does AI support me? Where does it attempt to replace me? And also remember as you're thinking about your answers and your own code of ethics, like maybe you're okay with using AI to draft emails because that's the bulk of what you do and they're very formulaic and you really don't need to think about them a lot.

Rebecca HasulakAnd maybe you're fine with that. But maybe you commit to yourself to never using AI to write in a personal email. That could be kind of where you draw the line for yourself. Some people may want to eschew AI completely. Some may think it's okay to use at work, but not at home. Or, you know, everyone is going to have their own view based on their values. But if you're connecting it to your values and you're thinking about this through the lens of integrity, I think you will end up in a place where you can feel confident about your own usage or lack thereof.

Rebecca HasulakAnd just remember, too, that your relationship to technology can evolve over time. Even if you've become very AI dependent, you can still fight for your brain and you can still take steps to reduce your dependencies and to reevaluate what role it's playing in your life and how dependent you are on it and make different choices. You absolutely can do that. And I would encourage you to do that if how your usage is right now is not sitting well with you for one reason or another. So before I kind of wrap up a couple other points here, I want to read a few things for you.

Rebecca HasulakSusan Kane is the author of The Quiet Life, and that's one of my favorite books. And as I always do, I will encourage you to go ahead and buy that, get a copy at your library. She is phenomenal. And on her Substack, she posted something about AI, and she posted about how it's changing your creative life and how to resist. And I just want to read you a little bit of that. So this is by Susan Kane. She said, Yesterday, a fellow author asked me to share my favorite writers on the subject of melancholy. So of course, I passed on my favorite C.S.

Rebecca HasulakLewis passage, the one I spotlighted in Bittersweet. And then she goes on to share that passage. And basically it says, I'll just read a little piece of it. The books or the music in which we thought the beauty was located will betray us if we trust to them. It was not in them. It only came through them. And what came through them was longing. And then it kind of goes on to talk about those things, the beauty, the memory, our good images of what we really desire. But if they are mistaken for the thing itself, they turn into dumb idols, breaking the hearts of their worshippers.

Rebecca HasulakFor they are not the thing itself. They are only the scent of a flower we have not found, the echo of a tune we have not heard, news from a country we have never yet visited. And that's the passage I ended up reading the whole thing, too, basically. So then Susan King continues. And then I realized we're not supposed to write sentences like that anymore, because writing in rhythms of three, as Lewis does in that sentence, is now considered to sound too much like AI.

Rebecca HasulakExcept, of course, that AI was trained on our best writers, like Lewis. So of course it echoes those writers' rhythms. So where does that leave us writers now? Should we abjure such rhythms for fear of sounding like a machine? Just to ask this question is painful, given that Lewis wrote not like a machine, but like an angel. The question is obviously not just for writers, but for anyone who cares about art, excellence, and expression. It's also a question for students who have to worry about the appearance that their papers were written by AI. And I think the answer is equally obvious.

Rebecca HasulakWe shouldn't cede an inch of ground to these new norms. And then she goes on to talk about this being a matter of principle. And she says, the real reason to read, write, and engage in any form of self-expression and communication is for one human consciousness to truly explain itself, to bear itself to another. No one but C.S. Lewis could have written those words because they came from his particular consciousness, his particular life experiences, and his particular spiritual longing. And then she adds, and yes, I just used an M-dash and a rhythm of three in that final sentence.

Rebecca HasulakAnd M-dashes and rhythm of three are things that we're being told are telltale signs of AI writing, and we're not allowed to use them. And in my work in PR, I hear this all the time and it's changing every week. It's like, oh, this week you can't use the word actually because AI is using actually, you can't use the word tapestry, which I find kind of funny. Like it's not a word that people use a lot anyway. But you get the point. I mean, I love M-dashes, and I literally am not able to use M-dashes in my PR writing because clients think that it's written by AI.

Rebecca HasulakSo this is constantly changing for us who are professional writers, and it's creating a very difficult writing environment, a very unnatural writing environment, which is really unfortunate. But I love Susan Kane's point is that, you know, we don't need to see. I mean, in my work, unfortunately, I do have to adhere to what the clients want. But in our creative worlds, we don't have to cede an inch of ground to these new norms. We should continue writing, creating like we always have. And before I close out, I also want to share a couple things from a poet and teacher who I have just more recently started following, but whose ideas I just love.

Rebecca HasulakHis name is Joseph Fasano. What's with an F? F is in Frank. So he wrote, he does posts a lot. One of his posts said, I do not want an AI summary of an email or a book or a life. I do not want an AI summary of a winter sky or my father's hands or the hope in my child's eyes. I do not want an AI summary of the human heart or the first little shiver of lust or the long good work of love. And I love that. And then he also created a poem, and the title was For a Student Who Used AI to write a paper.

Rebecca HasulakNow I let it fall back in the grasses. I hear you. I know this life is hard now. I know your days are precious on this earth. But what are you trying to be free of? The living? The miraculous task of it? Love is for the ones who love the work. So I loved that also. And then he had a much longer post that was an email he had sent in response to a young person who was feeling hopeless about her dream of becoming a writer in the age of AI. And he sent her a very long message, so I won't read the whole thing, but a couple things he said.

Rebecca HasulakPerhaps AI has secretly done not only harm but good, in that it has brought us all into these reckonings, which serve to really awaken us to what is unique, irreplaceable, and sacred about being humans. I promise you this, you have every reason to hope. AI may indeed replace or challenge certain aspects of our existence. It may do so many things we cannot anticipate. But I promise you, I promise you, it will never replace poetry, it will never replace art. The reason is simple. As long as there are human hearts, they will thirst for the encounter with what has been created in another human heart, with art that has been wrought from other human struggles.

Rebecca HasulakThis is essential. We find a painting or a poem or a symphony beautiful largely because we know it was made out of the profound struggle within another human life. AI may be able to write the computer code that sends us email, and it may be able to assemble and design and market a car, but we don't look to those things for proof that we are not alone in the universe. We do look to art for that proof. And my God, do we find it there? So he went on, and it was a really beautiful post, and I encourage you to follow him on Instagram or whatever social media you're on. But the point is this kind of similar idea to Susan Kane.

Rebecca HasulakWhy do we create and why do we appreciate art? It's because it is born out of the depths of another human being's soul. And that is something that I AI never can replicate, even though it's going to try, but even its best attempts are modeled after humans. And it's a really weird, weird world out there that this is something we're having to grapple with. But ultimately, creativity is not just productivity. It's expression, it's meaning making, it's emotional processing, it's humanity, you guys.

Rebecca HasulakSo let's keep the humanity, let's acknowledge that yes, AI can reduce busy work and improve accessibility. It can make some of our jobs easier, it will replace some of our jobs, but the technology is not disappearing. And we need to figure out a way to create our own personal code of ethics that we feel good about to protect and preserve our brains because the brain strengthens what it repeatedly practices. Don't give up on your brain, don't outsource all of your thinking to a machine. I really, really beg of you, hold on to your brain health, hold on to your critical thinking.

Rebecca HasulakIt is more important than ever. So just remember this: the goal is not to reject technology. It's just to protect the parts of ourselves that we don't want to lose, which in my opinion are our attention, our imaginations, our ability to think deeply, our creative instincts, our humanity, our empathy. None of us have all the answers yet. I certainly don't. We're all figuring this out in real time. I would love to hear if you have a different perspective on AI. But I do hope that this has helped you kind of figure out a little bit more about how you want to engage with technology and protect yourself.

Rebecca HasulakSo we are going to wrap up season three here. Thank you so much for listening, for sharing episodes, and for engaging with meaningful conversations. I'd love to hear if you have any feedback, if there are topics you want to hear about in the future. And if you have updates on your own creative journeys, I'd love to celebrate you. You can connect with me at my website, www.rebeccahasilac.com, and that's R-E-B-E-C-C-A-H-A-S-U-L-A-K. Or on Instagram, either at your next chapter club or at Rebecca DoesWords.

Rebecca HasulakEither one of those will work. And I will give you a quick quote to close out, which is attention is the beginning of devotion. And that was said by Mary Oliver. So I want you to keep in mind what are you giving your attention to? Whatever you are spending your attention on, that is the beginning of devotion. So be careful with your attention, protect it, and be intentional. And until next time, guys, keep creative, keep turning the page.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Brain Fog, Hormones & Sleep: What Every Woman Should Know with Dr. Kris Wallace

    Nov 17, 202631 minAudio

    Want more between episodes? Get my twice-ish monthly newsletter + free book club guides here: https://rebeccahasulak.substack.com/subscribe. Find more from me at rebeccahasulak.com.

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Art of Hosting: How to Make Gatherings Memorable

    Nov 10, 202615 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 5 Hosting can be its own form of everyday creativity. A gathering has mood, pacing, sensory details, constraints and dozens of small choices that shape how people experience their time together. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Not All Feedback Is Good Feedback

    Nov 3, 202621 minAudio

    Have you ever received feedback on something you've created and suddenly started questioning the whole thing? Whether you're writing a novel, making art, or working on something that matters to you, criticism can be...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is Your Creative Life Too Cluttered?

    Oct 27, 202618 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 3 Creative people collect things: ideas, drafts, supplies, research, screenshots, half-finished projects and plans for things we might make someday. Some of that is generative. Some of it quietly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Do You Really Have to Pick One Calling?

    Oct 20, 202616 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 2 We’re often encouraged to find our "thing:" the career, calling, passion or identity that defines us. But real life tends to be more expansive. In this episode, I dig into what it means to have...

    Credit the people on this episode