Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Your Next Chapter

Your Next Chapter artwork

Not All Feedback Is Good Feedback

Nov 3, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever received feedback on something you've created and suddenly started questioning the whole thing? Whether you're writing a novel, making art, or working on something that matters to you, criticism can be hard to hear. And even well-intentioned advice isn't always good advice. In this episode of Your Next Chapter, I'm talking about how to receive feedback without losing confidence in your own creative voice. I explore how to separate genuinely useful insights from advice that just doesn't fit your work. I'm also sharing two ways to process difficult feedback, plus why we should be cautious about receiving praise, too. The goal is to see that feedback can help you grow while recognizing that it shouldn't get the final say in what you create. Want more between episodes? Get my twice-ish monthly newsletter + free book club guides here: https://rebeccahasulak.substack.com/subscribe. Find more from me at rebeccahasulak.com.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to your next chapter, the podcast for women who read, write, and live creatively. I'm your host, Rebecca Hasulak. And today, before we get started, I wanted to tell you guys something a little bit fun. I have had a newsletter for a while, but I will be honest, I've been slacking a little bit with it. And lately I have just been really eager to write more. And I want to invite you guys to come check it out is Rebecca Hasulak.substack.com. And the newsletter is called I Digress.

SPEAKER_00And you can also find the link to subscribe in the show notes. So come visit me over there and we'll have more things to talk about outside of the show. As for today, we are talking about how to receive feedback without losing your voice. Now, if you've been with me a while, in season one, episode eight, we had an episode that was called Who Gets a Say When You're Creating? And this is along those same lines, except that episode was more focused on who you're actually letting into the creative process and when you might want to trust someone to give you feedback.

SPEAKER_00Today's episode is more about what happens when we get feedback. Sometimes we're asking for it, sometimes we're not, sometimes we have to take it. And how do we actually do that in a way where we're honoring what someone is telling us, we're giving it the weight that it deserves, but we're also not losing our own voice in the process. And we're also not just becoming completely demoralized in the process. And yes, not just talking about negative feedback, there's positive feedback too. But let's just get into all of it, you guys. This is a big topic. I have a lot of things to say. So here we go.

SPEAKER_00So, first, why do we give or receive feedback? The main reason, especially as creatives, is because we want to improve our work. We want to gauge how what we're creating might be received by somebody else. You know, we might love it. Our mom might love it, which is amazing. But how is someone in a bookstore going to receive it? How is someone online going to receive it? What would the market say about this? So we want to get an unbiased opinion of the quality of our work and we want to make it better. We also want to discover our own blind spots because let's be honest, we all have them.

SPEAKER_00When I read a novel that I've written, I have the context of the entire novel in my head. I have all of the work I've done on it. I have these characters who have been living in my head for months, if not years. I am reading the book from a very different place than a reader would, just a regular reader who doesn't have all that context and who wasn't the author. So am I going to have blind spots? Obviously. Someone might say, Oh, I'm so confused by what happens on page 36. And to me, I'm like, well, clearly what happened was this person went there and this happened.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, I know exactly what happened because I wrote it. And so whether it's on the page and being clearly delivered or not is another question. So that's why it really is important to get feedback and to get unbiased opinions about your work. But there's always a but, you guys, feedback isn't automatically helpful. That's not like a super big wow moment, but it is worth considering because sometimes, you know, I'll listen to writing podcasts and an agent might say, Well, to an aspiring writer, well, did you get beta readers?

SPEAKER_00Did you have a critique partner? Did you get feedback? And it feels like a binary. It feels like either yes, I got feedback, and therefore I am a good little writer pro protege, and I am doing what I'm supposed to be doing and checking all the boxes, or no, I didn't get feedback, and therefore my work is going to suffer because of it. But you don't just want to yes to that question. The quality of the feedback you get matters tremendously. So it isn't just a binary, you guys. And this is because art is subjective. We've talked about that. Did have an episode on subjectivity in art.

SPEAKER_00I don't remember the exact number, episode number it was. So forgive me for that, but that was a good one because it's true. And because art is subjective, feedback is also subjective, even from experts. You could have someone who is a songwriter who has won Grammys, for goodness sakes, and they might hear a new song from a new songwriter, and it might just kind of be meh to them. Their response might literally be meh. And then someone else notices their talent and they become this huge success.

SPEAKER_00I mean, you hear about this kind of stuff all the time. People pass on books, on screenplays, on songs, on artists. I mean, it does happen. And that's because even people who are very well trained in a specific field still have their own tastes, preferences, thought processes, you know, they still have their own criteria and they still are subject to subjectivity. So another example would be: let's say I had a beta reader for one of my books and I write upmarket women's fiction.

SPEAKER_00Let's say my beta reader does sometimes read upmarket women's fiction. So they thought they were a good fit, but maybe 80% of the books they read are sci-fi. Well, you guys, sci-fi has completely different genre expectations than upmarket women's fiction. So if they are used to reading a book that is perhaps 500 pages long versus my 300, it's going to feel really different. If they're used to a lot of world building, mine is set in a contemporary, mostly realistic place, it's going to feel really different.

SPEAKER_00And if they are used to some elements of sort of magic realism or fantasy, they're definitely not grounded in the world as we know it. And my books are all grounded in the world as we know it. You're not going to read one of my books and find something that's like defies the laws of, you know, our world. So all this to say they might be a very, very good reader. They might have the best of intentions. They might read broadly, but if the main genre they're used to is sci-fi, they're probably not going to like my book that much.

SPEAKER_00And as a result, they might make recommendations that don't suit me in the genre that I'm actually writing in, right? So they might say, oh, your pacing felt a little too quick. I wanted more detail. Well, you might want more detail because you're used to books being 500 pages long. But my book is going to be within the normal expectations for a women's fiction book, you know, which is generally between 80,000 and 100,000 words. So these are things that can make feedback a little bit tricky. And that's why it's important that you know who you're getting your feedback from and you really take everything with a grain of salt.

SPEAKER_00I do want to mention a little bit of research on this subject because I just find research fascinating. Research that was discussed in the Harvard Business Review examined 11,471 days of creative work across seven companies. They found that not only was feedback kind of uncommon, but receiving it also tended to leave people with negative emotions. So the study suggests that creative feedback can be particularly sensitive because people identify closely with what they make.

SPEAKER_00I don't think any of us are shocked by this, right? We don't love getting feedback. And the interesting thing is they didn't even say negative feedback. They didn't say negative feedback left people with negative emotions. The study found that feedback, period, often left people with negative emotions. So that's a pretty interesting point. No matter what you're saying, having someone critique your work is likely to leave you with kind of unpleasant emotions. And that makes sense because you've poured so much into it. And having it picked a part, even just to hear what was good about it, can be kind of painful.

SPEAKER_00Additionally, another study, it was a major review in 2007. So quite a while ago. Wow, you guys, almost 20 years ago. But anyway, still relevant by John Hattie and Helen Timperly examined different forms of feedback in educational research. In their synthesis, praise had a relatively small average effect size compared with stronger effects for several kinds of task-related feedback. So it just kind of tells you that, you know, even when when you get praised or when feedback is positive and someone says, I loved it, or something like that, that can feel really good.

SPEAKER_00But does it actually help you understand what worked or what to do next? No, not exactly. But I would still say it's nice to hear. And then a couple more research findings that I found interesting. Research suggests that detailed guidance can improve immediate practice performance while discouraging exploration. The example given for this is like if you're a writer and you're working with an editor, sometimes being told exactly what to fix might prevent you from discovering a better solution yourself. So that I mean, that's hard because writers will work with editors, and editors are amazing.

SPEAKER_00I've worked with editors and I've been an editor for people's work, and you're always doing your best. And sometimes it can be this awesome collaboration, but I can definitely see how if an editor kind of prescribes a solution or narrowly provides feedback, that it might sort of pen you in and keep you from figuring things out for yourself. So when it comes to feedback, you know, I would say most of the time when people are trying to offer it to us, it is given with the intent to be helpful, right? There aren't a lot of people who are taking the time to look at someone else's work and then offering thoughtful feedback who are genuinely just doing it to be a jerk or to waste their own time and to waste your time.

SPEAKER_00Like that's not typically how people operate. Of course, yes, there are trolls on the internet and there are people who might do that just because they have nothing better to do. But by and large, someone delivering feedback usually thinks they're helping. Now, whether they are or not, is always a different story. So the first question, if you're getting feedback, is did you ask for the feedback? Is this something you solicited or is it unsolicited? If it's unsolicited, you don't have any obligation to even give it another thought. You want to be polite, obviously.

SPEAKER_00You want to maybe even thank the person if it's clear that they are trying to be caring. But you do not have to sit with it a moment longer if it doesn't resonate with you and if you didn't ask for it. So that's number one. If it's feedback that you actually want, there are a few ways to receive it. I love these visuals or these ways of thinking about feedback. And I've used them with my kids a couple of times. So the first one is thinking of yourself as having an inner coach and an inner critic. We all have both, and we can choose where comments are going to land.

SPEAKER_00So let's say that I'm in a dance class and a teacher says, you have to go to the back row, you're not hoining your feet enough. So if my inner critic took that comment, the story I'm gonna tell myself about it is I'm a really bad dancer. I'm being put in the back because I'm not good enough, my feet are bad, and this teacher doesn't like me, right? That's often how our brains work. We take, we take the comment, and then our inner critic is like, let's make this as bad as possible. Whereas our inner coach can look at that same comment and be like, huh, what can I learn from this?

SPEAKER_00Well, the teacher did say my feet weren't pointed. I can point my feet, right? And then you're looking at something constructive from the feedback. Even if the feedback wasn't given in a very nice way or in a very constructive way, there was still something that your inner coach was able to find that was constructive about it. So you can do that with anything. I mean, it doesn't even have to be related to the arts. If someone says something to you, you can try to see if the inner coach can do something with it. And that's not always going to be possible. There are some people and some teachers who are just going to say things that are rude and hurtful, and maybe they think they're making you better for it, but it still is rude and hurtful.

SPEAKER_00And sometimes we just have to realize that. And that is why there's a second thing that I like to do. And I used to use this with my daughter quite a bit. So we have the inner coach and the inner critic, which is great, but we also have something that we can turn to. And I do not remember where I heard of this. This is not my own idea. I would love to give credit where credit's due, but I don't remember. It's called trash, truth, or treasure. Say that five times fast. Trash, truth, treasure. Okay, so when someone makes a comment, whether it's feedback, whether it's just a general comment, you can actually think about it and almost envision three different bins.

SPEAKER_00So let's take that comment again about you need to go in the back, your feet aren't pointed. So let's see. What is maybe true about that comment? Maybe the feet aren't pointed, right? That might be true. All right, you're gonna go in the truth bin, and then I can do something with you. You need to go stand in the back. Honestly, that sounds kind of like trash to me. That just sounds kind of rude. It's not giving me anything I can really work with. I'm gonna put that in the trash bin. Take that out. I don't need to see it anymore. It's gone from my life, right? So we have something in the trash bin, something in the truth truth bin.

SPEAKER_00And then there's nothing from that comment for the treasure bin. But sometimes there will be. So when you do get feedback, you know, someone might be like, wow, I love your writing style. I personally couldn't stand character B. But I do think if you developed their backstory a little more, I might empathize with them more. So something like that, okay, very easy. I loved your writing. Treasure. Put that as a win. Hold on to that, revisit that often. Somebody loves your writing.

SPEAKER_00That is so great. You should treasure that. I didn't like character B. Well, that's an opinion. It's also not really helpful to you. So we can just go ahead and throw that in the trash. But if you develop their backstory a little more, that goes in to the truth one, right? It's their truth, so still subjective, but it is giving you something that they believe that you can actually work with. So these are just some interesting ways of dealing with feedback. Obviously, when you're getting feedback in real time, it's very hard to kind of sit there and go, hello, inner coach, are you there?

SPEAKER_00Can you please help me parse through this feedback and do something constructive with it? Like that's not really how things work. But if you are reflecting on feedback later, you can think of it this way. And you can try to break things down into a way where you're keeping the pieces that are actually constructive. If there are any, there might not be. Some feedback just gets chucked in the trash bin, never to be seen again, and that's great. Go to the landfill. Bye. But most is gonna have at least one or two little nuggets that you can do something with. So pay attention to that.

SPEAKER_00And then the other thing is, you guys, when something does get said to you that hurts, ugh, you gotta just let it hurt. There's no point pretending it doesn't. We're not going to try to put a little silver lining polish on everything. Like sometimes someone's gonna say something and it might even be true, and it still really sucks to hear. And so you're just gonna have to let that sting for a minute and then remind yourself, okay, that's their opinion, back to the work. And that's all you can do sometimes. All right. Also remember when you're getting feedback to separate the person's experience from their proposed solution.

SPEAKER_00Because you might have someone who, again, I always use novels, but they're my, they're my thing that I know how to talk about. But you could apply this to so many different forms of art. But if you have a reader who says that they got really, really confused at a certain part, that's good information. Like maybe their suggestion is you have eight characters in this chapter and I got lost. I think you should combine these three characters into one character and it'll just be so much easier, and you're not gonna lose anything, and that's what you should do. Well, they're not the artist.

SPEAKER_00That's nice that they have a proposed solution for you, but that might not feel right to you. So remember that they're confused. That's important. You need to go back and address something there so that other readers aren't confused. But you don't necessarily have to take their proposed solution. So you are constantly, as the artist, as the creator, you are like a sieve. You are letting certain things flow through you. I know there's so many analogies, right? Letting things flow through you, and then holding on to other ones that you can actually do something with and that you that you think something should be done with.

SPEAKER_00Because not everything someone says is going to be something you need to act upon. And that is part of getting better at your craft is figuring out your own voice, figuring out what matters to you, holding on to your vision, and then allowing feedback that supports it and that helps you grow rather than detracting from it. And then a quick note on praise, we're getting short on time here, but also this goes back to something that we talked about in my episode with the wonderful Kristen Arnett when we talked about confidence. She talked about the story of You Are Special by Max Lucato.

SPEAKER_00And in it, there is a Wemmick who is a wooden person. If you haven't read it, please read it and also go back and listen to that episode. But the Wemmick, all the Wemmics got stars and dots, and the stars were praise and the dots were negative things. And there was only one Wemmick who had all the stars and all the dots fall off of her. And that's because basically she knew that her worth was in who she was and in who her maker created her to be. She not only got the dots to fall off, she also had the stars fall off. And that's a part that a lot of us don't remember because compliments feel good and praise feels good.

SPEAKER_00And I'm just as guilty of this. I love to be praised for stuff. I love to get compliments if I'm being totally honest. So it's very hard for me to be like, that doesn't matter. I have worth in myself. But I'm working on that. So just remember to take compliments with a grain of salt, too. If you put stock in every single positive thing people say, it's gonna be very hard for you not to put stock in every single negative thing someone says as well. So that's why it's important to remember who you are and stay grounded. And as an example, and also remember, people just don't see the full story always.

SPEAKER_00Like as an example, someone might compliment you for how you look, thinking that maybe you've been really hitting the gym and like getting your fitness on. And in reality, maybe you've been super stressed and you just kind of haven't been feeling that great and you're really at a low point. But what they see, they're interpreting a certain way, and then they're complimenting you for it. And really you're like, no, you have it all wrong. So that's just an example of how even when someone's praising us, it doesn't mean that they're that they're accurate. It doesn't mean that, you know, whatever they're saying is still being said subjectively.

SPEAKER_00So it's just something important to keep in mind. And lastly, I will say when it comes to the subject of feedback, this is not a one-way street. Ideally, don't give feedback unless someone asks you, because they probably don't want it if they haven't asked, unless you really feel strongly, in which case you can do so in a kind way. But I would say mostly wait for an artist to ask you. And second of all, remember how it feels to receive feedback if you are giving it. Your intent matters, but so does how the feedback lands. You can say, oh, I meant to make them better while you unleashed this entire monologue about how terrible their art is, but that doesn't accomplish anything, right?

SPEAKER_00That's that's still hurting them. That's not making them more productive or helping them grow. So be kind and honest. Use specificity without cruelty, speak to the work rather than judging the creator and make sure they know that you understand you're leaving all of it in their hands and you know that they're going to do with it what they will because you trust them to create according to their own vision. So when you get feedback, one of the most important things to hold on to is your own voice. Maybe your work is quirky.

SPEAKER_00Maybe your songwriting style is unusual. Maybe your art is kind of an acquired taste. Not all friction is a flaw to Sand Away. Feedback can reveal blind spots without becoming the author of your own work. You are the author, keep your own voice and stay true to you. And I will leave you with a quick quote from Margaret, which says, What fascinates A will bore the pants off B. And that was from her rules for writers, which was in The Guardian in 2010. So the point is, even sincere audience reactions differ, right?

SPEAKER_00What fascinates A will bore the pants off B. We're not all gonna like the same things. And keep that in mind when people are giving you feedback. And hold true to your voice. And remember to check me out on Substack, rebekahasselak.substack.com, R-E-B-E-C-C-A-H-A-S-U-L-A-K.Substack.com for the latest edition of I Digress, my newsletter. And I hope to see you there. And as always, I hope you will keep creating and keep turning the page.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Brain Fog, Hormones & Sleep: What Every Woman Should Know with Dr. Kris Wallace

    Nov 17, 202631 minAudio

    Want more between episodes? Get my twice-ish monthly newsletter + free book club guides here: https://rebeccahasulak.substack.com/subscribe. Find more from me at rebeccahasulak.com.

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Art of Hosting: How to Make Gatherings Memorable

    Nov 10, 202615 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 5 Hosting can be its own form of everyday creativity. A gathering has mood, pacing, sensory details, constraints and dozens of small choices that shape how people experience their time together. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Is Your Creative Life Too Cluttered?

    Oct 27, 202618 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 3 Creative people collect things: ideas, drafts, supplies, research, screenshots, half-finished projects and plans for things we might make someday. Some of that is generative. Some of it quietly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Do You Really Have to Pick One Calling?

    Oct 20, 202616 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 2 We’re often encouraged to find our "thing:" the career, calling, passion or identity that defines us. But real life tends to be more expansive. In this episode, I dig into what it means to have...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Inspiration, Idolatry & Plagiarism: Where are the Lines?

    Oct 13, 202619 minAudio

    Season 5, Episode 1 Where is the line between being inspired by someone else’s work and allowing it to shape too much of your own? To open Season 5, I'm exploring inspiration, creative fixation, idolatry and plagiarism....

    Credit the people on this episode