Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Western Civ

Western Civ artwork

Episode 565: The Far Theaters

Nov 10, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

While Operation Overlord and D-Day get all the press in 1944, there were other battles being fought in the Pacific Theater, by the Soviet Union in the east, and, of course, in Italy. Today we cover all that to bring us up to June 1944 in all our theaters of war. Western Civ 2.0

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hello, and welcome to Western Civ, episode 565, The Far Theaters. On June 6th, 1944, The world's attention pivots, as ours has in the last episode, to a beach in Normandy, to a sunrise amphibious assault that oftentimes defines, I think, how we remember World War II. But we have to remember, on that same morning, with dawn breaking across Europe, the war was raging in places most newsreels never quite covered

Speaker 1on that day. The Soviets were building their greatest offensive, The Americans were climbing through Pacific coral islands toward Japan. In Italy, soldiers were still dying in mountains that had already killed tens of thousands. And over Germany itself, the machinery of destruction, the bombers that would reshape not just battlefields but cities, was turning. Now, today, we're not going to talk about Normandy. We're not going to talk about Operation Overlord or D-Day. We're going to cover the same

Speaker 1time period as the last episode, but we're going to talk about everything else. About the scale of a war so vast that even its greatest invasion is only one thread of a catastrophe of simultaneous conflicts. It's the story of June 1944, this time through the lens of other theaters and other fronts. And why, actually... The Allies could afford to pour men and ships into Overlord at the precise moment that they did. So let's start with the

Speaker 1Eastern Front. On the day that American paratroopers were landing in Normandy, the Soviet general, Aleksandr Veselesky, one of Stalin's most trusted strategists, was orchestrating something on the Eastern Front that would dwarf in sheer shale and casualties anything happening in the West. Operation Bagration was about to begin, and it was, by some measures, the largest military operation in human history. By June 1944, the Soviets had learned. After

Speaker 1three years of catastrophic defeats, they had built an army. They had learned combined arms. They had learned deception at scale that would have seemed impossible in 1941. And they had learned how to move. The Germans, for their part, were facing a crisis that they understood all too acutely. They could not defend everywhere. They couldn't reinforce the east and defend Normandy. This wasn't a choice Stalin made for them. This was a strategic reality that was just the result

Speaker 1of four years of attrition. By June, the Wehrmacht was spread across a continent, and the Soviets, massing three fronts— the term the Red Army used for what we'd call an army group, were ready to exploit that. In May, the Soviets had actually paused. This was deliberate. They halted their advance, gathered supplies, built depots, moved artillery pieces across devastated landscape. German intelligence watched and waited for the blow

Speaker 1that they knew was coming. The Germans had, even by some accounts, predicted late June would be the time of the attack. But predictions and preparations just aren't the same thing. The German command in the East knew what was coming. They knew it would be catastrophic, and they were right. Operation Vigration opened on June 23rd. But the preparation, the concentration, the vast machinery of Soviet logistics, all of that was visible in June 1944 to anyone paying attention. The Red

Speaker 1Army was visibly preparing to end the war on its front, and that meant that the Germans couldn't move much from the east to support Normandy. This is arithmetic that made Overlord possible. Soviets were tying down somewhere in the range of three to four million troops, not in a holding pattern, but in positions that were actually about to be crushed. By the time that Operation Begration already began on June

Speaker 1the 23rd, the Normandy beachhead was already a week old. And in that week, German reserves that might have pushed the Allies back into the sea were instead being held in place by the Spectre at Soviet columns massing in modern-day Belarus. Now, if you were an American soldier in June 1944 and you weren't in a landing craft heading toward Normandy, Odds are you were somewhere over between the islands of the Central Pacific, and you were fighting in

Speaker 1what strategists called island hopping, a campaign that by June had evolved into a grinding, brutal expansion across American-held territory toward Japan itself. The previous November, American Marines and soldiers had landed at Tarawa. The battle had lasted 76 hours and cost over 3,000 casualties, mostly Americans. All for an atoll barely three miles long. It was a shock. Americans had read about it. They understood for the first time

Speaker 1what it meant to assault a fortified island in the Central Pacific. And since then, the campaign had moved north and west. Finally, in June 1944, American forces were preparing for Saipan. Saipan was to be a turning point, though not in the way the Allies planned. On June 15th, 27,000 American troops landed on the beaches of Saipan. The island was defended by just over 30,000 Japanese. The fighting would take three weeks, and when it ended, the Americans had

Speaker 1lost nearly 3,500 men. But Saipan was taken. But more importantly, Saipan changed the war in the Pacific. Once the Americans held Saipan, they could base B-29 bombers, the new long-range heavy bombers that the U.S. Strategic Air Force had been developing in secret, within striking distance of Japan itself. This was the dream that had haunted Japanese military planners all the way back since 1942. This was the moment, I suppose,

Speaker 1in many ways, Japan's strategic defeat became visible. Now, the Japanese were moving to counter. On June the 20th, the day after the landings on Saipan, the Japanese 1st Mobile Fleet under Admiral Azawa attempted to defeat the American assault and reinforce Saipan. The result was the Battle of the Philippine Sea. In naval history, it's sometimes called the Great Marinera's Turkey Chute. American pilots shot down hundreds of Japanese aircraft.

Speaker 1The Japanese lost two carriers. They lost the cream of what remained, basically whatever they'd managed to rebuild since Midway. And so on the same day that Operation Migration was being prepared on the Eastern Front, June 20, 1944, the Japanese were suffering a naval defeat that would echo for the rest of the war. This is the scale of 1944 in June. Overlord, yes, of course, we've talked about that. We spent a long time last time speaking about it. But also, there was an offensive in the Soviet Union

Speaker 1that dwarfed in it the casualties and its strategic outcome. And in the Pacific, a naval battle and amphibious assault that closed one chapter of the island campaigns and opened the final terrible chapter, the approach to Japan. Italy by June 1944 was a sideshow, and that mattered. After the Allies had invaded Sicily in July of 1943, just under a year before the Normandy landings, they'd moved across the Straits of Messina into mainland Italy, and they'd been fighting

Speaker 1there in the mountains and on the coasts and in the small towns with names that no one in America really wanted to pronounce for nearly a year. By June 1944, the Allies had fought through the winter line. They'd taken Naples, they'd crossed their way inch by inch up the Italian peninsula, and every step had cost lives. On June 4, 1944, two days before the Normandy invasion, Rome fell to American forces.

Speaker 1It was the first Axis capital to fall, and it mattered symbolically to morale. The Allies announced it in the news, bulletins, soldiers heard about it, and it proved that the Axis could be beaten. But Rome's fall, in military terms, was almost a side note to what was happening on the beaches of Normandy. The Italian campaign had become, in American strategic planning, a secondary effort. Troops were being withdrawn from Italy to prepare for overlord. Supplies were being shipped west.

Speaker 1The Italians, defeated and divided, with Mussolini still commanding a puppet state in the north and the legitimate Italian government in the south, were fragments of power that had once rivaled Germany for dominance of an entire continent. By June 1944, Italy was where men were still dying, where battles were still being fought, where the war was real and present, but it was not any longer where the war would be decided. Now, of course, there was another theater actually

Speaker 1in June 1944, one that historians sometimes overlook when they focus on all the map and the troop movement. It was above Germany. By 1944, the strategic bombing campaign against Germany had evolved from an experiment into an industrial-sized catastrophe. The Allies had bombed aircraft factories, they'd bombed rail yards, they'd bombed shipbuilding facilities, they'd bombed cities, ostensibly to disrupt war production, but in fact destroying homes and killing civilians

Speaker 1with a directness that some historians have struggled to justify even now, nearly 80 years later. By June 1944, German air defense was really deteriorating. The Luftwaffe, the German air force, had been bled nearly white while trying to defend German airspace against American bombing raids. German pilots were becoming inexperienced. The skilled ones had been killed or wounded. New pilots were being rushed into service after minimal training. And they

Speaker 1were flying against American fighter pilots who, by 1944, were about the best in the entire world. In June 1944, as the Allies were landing in Normandy and fighting into the Norman bookage, the bombing campaign was reaching a crescendo. American B-17s and B-29s were striking deeper into German territory. Factories were burning, cities were burning, the German economy was stretched to produce everything for multiple simultaneous wars, was starting

Speaker 1to crack and break. This is worth underlining. While American and British soldiers were assaulting Normandy, American bombers were assaulting Germany from the air. German fighter cover over the beaches was limited because German fighter strength was being expended. And above all, trying to defend German cities and factories from this endless onslaught. They just couldn't be in two places at once. This is that two-front warfare that Germany, you know, really since the days of Autobahn Wismarck, had been trying

Speaker 1to avoid. It ended the First World War for Germany, and it's about to end the second. Now, the bombing campaign was horrifically imprecise. Estimates of civilian casualties vary, but by the end of the war, well over a million German civilians had died in bombing raids. sometimes the estimates are higher it's a number that historians have wrestled with because it's not simple these weren't all passive civilians germany was a totalitarian state mobilized for war german industrial production

Speaker 1was possible because the german society had been reorganized for total war and yet the bomb that falls on the tenement building kills families children it you know it could be the same as the bomb that falls on the munitions factory in a lot of ways In June 1944, this moral complexity was not a concern of the bombardiers crossing the channel. The bombers were part of the strategy. Wear down German air power, disrupt its supply lines, and reduce its industrial capacity. And guess what? They were succeeding.

Speaker 1Here's the truth that emerges when you look at June 1944 beyond Normandy. The Allies were waging multiple wars simultaneously on a scale that strained every resource, and they were winning, or at least they were not losing, on multiple fronts at once. The Soviets were destroying the German army in the east, not overrunning it yet. Vibration had not yet been launched, but they were visibly preparing to. The Americans were advancing in the Pacific at a cost that was

Speaker 1terrifying to American planners, but it was advancing nonetheless. Italy was secondary, yes, but with Rome taken, the peninsula was being pushed up. And over Germany, the bombers were flying every day they could fly, grinding down the capacity of Germany simply to wage war. Normandy, by this calculus, was not the most military significant event of June 1944. Normandy was politically and symbolically decisive. It was the second front that Stalin had demanded, that the Soviets needed, that would

Speaker 1divide German military strength when it was already divided. It was the commitment by Roosevelt and Churchill to the final invasion of Western Europe, and it was the beachhead from which eventually Germany would be defeated from the West. But the war in June 1944 was being won multiple places at once, and that was almost the whole strategic story. The war, as it stood in June 1944... was entering its final stages. Not its final victories, those would take

Speaker 1another year, but its final arithmetic. Germany was being squeezed. It was being compressed. The Soviets were preparing an offensive that would be the largest of the war, or at least maybe among the largest of the war. The Allies had established at an enormous cost a foothold in France. And in the Pacific, the Americans were bleeding their way toward Japan with an inexorability that even Japan could not now reverse. Now, In the next episode, we're going to follow Operation Begration. We'll see how the Soviets executed what

Speaker 1may well have been the most perfectly planned major offensive of the entire war. We'll see what happens when three Soviet fronts, each as large as an entire nation's army, crash into German positions in Belarus. And we'll see the consequences for the Red Army, for Germany, and for the rest of post-war Europe itself. Look, the far shore, the beaches of Normandy, that's what we remember about 1944. But the beaches were possible because every other front was moving.

Speaker 1The invasion was the opening move in the endgame, and the endgame had already begun. The Endgame

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 568: Victory In Europe

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 38 minAudio

    1945 will mark the end of World War Two. Today, in our penultimate episode, I am devoting the whole episode to Europe. We will cover the massive Russian offensive, the American and British race to Berlin, and the death...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 567: Operation Valkyrie

    Nov 17, 202628 minAudio

    Operation Valkyrie saw the closest that anyone would come to killing and overthrowing Adolf Hitler. The plot failed. Barely. And, in its failure, sentenced millions more people in Europe to die. Western Civ 2.0

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 566: The Hammer and the Hedgerows

    Nov 13, 202638 minAudio

    Now, all at once, the war seems to turn. Operation Bagration sees Soviet troops storming through Poland and into East Prussia. The Allies advance through France and turn back Germany at the Battle of the Bulge. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 564: The Longest Day

    Nov 6, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    Operation Overlord was not one day. It took months to prepare for D-Day and, even then, D-Day fits within the context of the continuing, larger war, which was still very much going on. But D-Day remains a crucial hinge...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Kennedy's Only Hero

    Nov 3, 202651 minAudio

    Today I sit down with author and historian, Joel Nelson, to discuss his book Kennedy's Only Hero: How JFK's Obsession with Winston Churchill Defined His Presidency. It is rare to get a biographical piece that features...

    Credit the people on this episode