Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Weoverme

Weoverme artwork

How does God, evolution and science fit together?

Feb 5, 202650 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We are all grappling with the consequences of AI. How profoundly will it augment or diminish human intelligence when we use it as our executive assistant, researcher, muse, designer or programmer? How might its seemingly infinite patience, simulated love and boundless compassion shape the development of our character? Will it help us become fully realized, well-grounded individuals or will it undermine the very process of our journeys? To what extent will AI serve humanity or to what extent will we become enslaved? These are all unknowns. Yet this seems clear: AI will accelerate the dissemination of ideas, such as the Gospel, in ways that have been historically transformative, comparable to the Roman trade routes spreading of Christianity or the Gutenberg press catalyzing the Protestant Reformation and the Enlightenment. This is good news in and of itself. Others, however, such as Ilia Delio, believe just as those technologies turned mainstream thinking on its head, AI will usher in a new Gospel of sorts and a new perspective of Jesus Christ, salvation, and the very nature of God. Ilia is a Franciscan sister and founder of the Center for Christogenesis - an organization dedicated to deepening the integration of science and religion. Illia is a theologian at Villanova University and she’s an author of a couple dozen books. She specializes in the area of science and religion, having degrees in theology and pharmacology. She even planned to do research in Alzheimer's before joining a monastery. To Ilia, evolution due to technological advancements, such as AI, is not a deviation from the divine, but rather an expression of God’s creation. Science, then, is not a rival to faith, but humanity’s disciplined attempt to study that ongoing act of creation. While many see science and religion as antithetical to each other, this conflict dissolves under her view, which is a good thing. On the other hand, she does stir the waters elsewhere, especially amongst Christians with her heterodox views of the cross. In her thinking, our understanding of Christianity, such as the idea of penal substitution, will evolve. “We’re too sin-focused and we’re too narrow and anthropocentric,” she said to me (14:30). “Jesus was about a oneness with God… we’re all too much about substitution and we did this wrong.” You can listen to my defense of atonement around 12:00. I will say at the onset that we invited Ilia on the show because of her interest in the intersection of science and religion. But our views vastly diverge as my worldview has largely followed the orthodoxy of 13th century Italian philosopher and theologian Thomas Aquinas. She is a follower of 13th century Italian saint Francis of Assisi. Within the Franciscan tradition, the doctrine of atonement doesn’t constitute the core of the Christian story, but is instead situated as a secondary component in a much larger metaphysical framework. As a Franciscan, Ilia also does not see God as absolute and transcendent or separated from creation but rather entangled with the very foundation of our existence. She humbly recognizes that her views are far from prevailing yet she is well aware that truth does not depend on popularity. It’s why she was compelled to start her own organization - Christogenesis - dedicated to exploring the possibility that God in a sense evolves in tandem with technology and humanity. She also builds on the thinking of Teilhard de Chardin. A good summary of her unorthodox idea is in her essay: The church’s inadequate response to AI-Human evolution. “The Vatican's approach, while ethically sophisticated, seems to operate within what we might call a "static divine" framework - God as absolute and self-sufficient being whose creation must be protected from technological overreach. This contrasts sharply with a process-oriented "dynamic divine" framework where God achieves reality through the evolutionary process, including technological development. “The Vatican's new AI guidelines emphasize "anthropocentric design" and ensuring AI serves humanity rather than replaces it. From the perspective of Teilhard de Chardin, this might represent a failure to recognize that the next stage of evolution could involve genuine human-AI collaboration in the cosmic process of complexification and consciousness-raising.” The way we think about the Bible is a “lower level of awareness,” she explained. “Jesus says put on a new mind, which is a deeper awareness that the reign of God is within you.” She also says that Jesus may not be the Christ because Christ may not be one person. One may be tempted to paint Ilia a gnostic - one who believes that the key to salvation is by having gnosis - some secret knowledge that we are gods ourselves that need to be freed from the fallen material world. But traditional gnostics also believe the material world and its maker are evil, which is far from her beliefs. She believes creation is good and is evolving in a way that shapes our view of religion. “We’re on this new level and it’s giving rise to a new type of person because we’re thinking differently.” You can learn more about Ilia by visiting her website: www.christogenesis.org Interview coverage: 1:29 - The Franciscan view vs the Thomistic view. 5:00 - Franciscan’s view of love is humble and relational. Thomistic view is God is separate and perfect. 7:27 - The incarnation Franciscan vs Thomistic. Incarnation is the ultimate act of love and humility. Franciscan makes the penal substitution secondary. A: Both Bonaventure would say the incarnation is not plan B. Plan A went wrong then God had to send his son. The traditional view is because Adam had sin, God sent his son. Aquinas - a satisfaction. Scotus said God is love. Whether or not sin or not to exist, God would have come. Bonaventure - creation is out of love and for love. Love is the purpose and essence and meaning. 9:44 - Supporting penal substitution - Colossians 2:14 and John 19:30. 11:38 - The cross is a gift to help us move to a new level of gifting. It’s not because one person died for us. 12:35 - Dying out of love vs dying as a sacrifice to save. 16:26 - The dominance of the Thomistic worldview - Aquinas was declared the official theologian of the church in 1879. 18:26 - In 1 Corinthians, Paul says he teaches the cross. Is there confusion about what the cross represents? 21:01 - How technologies spread new ideas and how religion has increasingly become personalized and away from cosmic. Where does it go from here? 25:50 - People still believe that Christ is the son of God. A modest change or a complete change? 30:12 - Carl Jung’s view: Jesus as archetype and Jesus as savior. 31:33 - Purpose of Center for Christogenesis. 35:48 - God separate or a part of creation. 41:43 - The movement behind cosmic life, biogenesis and the noosphere. 45:30 - What are we rejecting about ourselves if we’re seeking a better human than ourselves? 47:20 - Biblical eschatology presupposes a static worldview. Get full access to We Over Me at www.weoverme.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to CRT. I'm Bambi Francisco Roizen. I'm speaking with Ilya Delio. She's a Franciscan sister and founder of the Center of Christogenesis, an organization dedicated to deepening the integration of science and religion. Ilya is a theologian at Villanova University, and she's an author of 26 books. She specializes in the area of science and religion, having degrees in theology and pharmacology, She even planned to do research in Alzheimer's before joining a monastery.

SPEAKER_01Ilya, welcome.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. Great to be here, actually.

SPEAKER_01What a fascinating background, actually. Oh, and Happy New Year.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Thank you. Happy. May be happy.

SPEAKER_01This podcast focuses a lot on technology and religion, so your interest in the intersection of those two, your work in the intersection of those two is why we're excited to have you on this program. But first, as I dug into your background and watched several of your interviews, I found out that you're a Franciscan sister, you have a Franciscan worldview, something I'm not that familiar with, or I've become a little familiar with, It's different from the Thomistic worldview, which comes from Thomas Aquinas.

So can you tell us about the difference between those traditions and what you found

SPEAKER_01the Franciscan view more compelling?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks. That's a great question. Well, basically, the Franciscan tradition follows Francis of Assisi, who was a very simple person who found God in the world, literally in the world of trees and bees and matter and rocks. And so Francis's idea is that we don't go to God, God has come to us. So the incarnation or God becoming flesh is at the center. of his spirituality. And that was really built on by theologians such as Bonaventure

and Duns Scotus, who made the incarnation part of the principle of what life is about here.

SPEAKER_00So in other words, there's no such thing as brute matter, like every particle of matter has an infinite divine dimension to it. You might say a God dimension, to put this in kind of simple terms. So we find God in all things and not apart from all things. Thomas Aquinas was a follower of Albert the Great. By the way, Thomas and Bonaventure went to the same university and were there around the same time, but they probably were in different colleges,

SPEAKER_00so they never really had lunch together. Thomas was more Aristotelian, so his emphasis was on God as pure absolute being. God's existence is God's beingness. And maybe the difference is that for Thomas, God was essential being, and for Bonaventure, God is essential love. And Thomas had this idea that God's being is the source of all our existence, beingness.

And Bonaventure had the idea that love is the source of all our existence.

SPEAKER_00So they're slightly different in their theological emphases. And both basically read a lot of the same text, but Bonaventure was inspired by Francis of Assisi, and basically we, in a sense, go to God in and through the world. Thomas would agree with that, but for him, there was a priority of the spiritual over the material, that God is pure essence or pure being, and so contemplation is this inner reflection on this God of

pure beingness.

SPEAKER_00And for Bonaventure, contemplation is seeing that draws us out of ourselves into the life of the other. So it's very unitive. And so Franciscan theology is very continent. It's sort of a form runner of process theology that we find in Alfred North Whitehead and others. And so in this theology, there is a more of a mutual relationship between God and world. For Thomas, there's a unilateral relationship. God creates, but God doesn't need the world.

The world needs God because we're created by God and therefore dependent on God.

SPEAKER_00For the Franciscans, God is love and love is mutual. And so there is a more mutual relationship. God gives freedom to creation and creation in a sense gives glory to God. that kind of process idea spills over then into the 20th century into the work of whitehead and certainly in the work of taylor desjardins where the god world is a mutual relationship god affects the world and the world affects

god okay i have

SPEAKER_01okay thank you very much for that i have um I have another difference, and help me understand if I get this correct, because I understand that the Franciscan view of love may also be a little bit different, which I think you touched on. And when I think of the Franciscans' tradition and view of love being humble, and relational, as you said, mutual, right? There's a mutual interaction,

SPEAKER_01whereas the Thomistic view is so sort of God is separate, perfect, immutable, untouchable thing. It makes me feel that thinking about like a husband and wife where the husband is more just and the wife is more merciful, typically, although that is just wrong in my house because I'm the much more just and my husband's more merciful, but you know, Those stereotypes aside, my point is that it seems that, say, there's a just and there's a merciful side,

SPEAKER_01two sides of the same coin.

SPEAKER_00That's interesting. Yeah, I think, I think we can say that, you know, I think, I think, you know, honestly, Thomas and Bonaventure did hold similar positions, it's where they place the emphasis. So for Bonaventure love, Bonaventure, actually, one more difference here is that Thomas emphasized the oneness of God, God is unity, God is one. For Bonaventure, God is Trinity. So God is relationship itself. yeah and so that kind of love is spilling over all the time you

know yeah did thomas not think of thomas aquinas not also believe in the trinity i didn't he absolutely yeah but he placed the trinity in a sense uh within that oneness of god

SPEAKER_00so god's oneness is primary and then that trinity is within that oneness got it on adventure god is trinity that the oneness is triune so there's no like uh the one and then trinity it is that the one is trinity so uh it's a relational god through and through for bonaventure yeah i i truly believe because i've been

SPEAKER_01speaking to a lot of theologians who talk about what is image of God and many believe that God is relational and we actually see the image of God in relationship only to God and relationship to others so I fully really believe that as a true image of God. I want to talk about the incarnation too because here there's also a different view, a little bit slight different view in terms of The Franciscan and the mystic view and the Franciscan view,

SPEAKER_01correct me if I'm wrong, sees the incarnation as the ultimate act of humility.

SPEAKER_00The ultimate act of love and humility. In other words, God bending low, but bending low in love. You know, God comes to be where we are.

SPEAKER_01Right. Right, to be human, to take on human flesh. But you also believe, or maybe not, but I think in the Franciscan sense, in terms, it sort of makes the penal substitution secondary. Is that true? Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so both Bonaventure and much more SCOTUS more explicitly would say the incarnation is not plan B. In other words, you know, plan A went wrong because of original sin and God had to send the son. So the idea that we hold, I mean, the official Catholic position is, you know, because Adam had sinned, Christ had to come to, in a sense, pay the debt of that sin, known as the satisfaction theory, which is the position that Thomas Aquinas held,

SPEAKER_00that the incarnation is, in a sense, a satisfaction, a remedy, or a paying of the debt of human sin. As Scotus said, God is love. And so from all eternity, God will to love, to share love in a creaturely way with a finite other. So whether or not sin ever existed, Christ would have come, which means that in order for Christ to come, there had to be a creation. So creation, both Bonaventure and Scotus would say his creation is out of love, for love, in love, for love.

And so love is, in a sense, the purpose, the essence, and the meaning of our life here.

SPEAKER_00So love isn't just a benevolence of God. It is what God is about. And that means that life itself is essentially about sharing life, you know, which means relationship is fundamental to who we are, and the sharing of our lives is fundamental to what we become. and that's very franciscan and it has nothing to do with original sin it has to do with original love right okay original love but so in colossians 2 13 14 it does

say he forgave us all our sins canceling the charge of our legal indebtedness um

SPEAKER_01which stood against us and condemned us. He has taken it away, nailing it to the cross. So, or, and then in John 19 30, it says it is paid in full. So the Bible does state that we had this legal indebtedness. I guess, how do you, how do, how does it, how do we reconcile the view of original love with this view that in the Bible that says we owe this debt to God?

SPEAKER_00I think that actually comes, those are later editions. Certainly Colossians is a, well, Colossians is written, they're both written way after the death of Jesus. So the Pauline texts on the whole are somewhat faithful to the gospels, but they also borrow from other traditions. The idea of penal substitution or original sin is not a Hebraic idea. You know, we don't find that really. Sin is, we do have a sense of sin in Judaism,

SPEAKER_00but it's not this idea that there's an original sin and substitution. It's just not there. And so Jesus himself didn't have that. notion you know that i'm here to repay a debt there's nothing like that um you know the whole of the whole of scripture is really um about um chesed about compassion about love about mercy and jesus in a sense goes to the cross out of love out of an obedience in love to the father so it's not really like oh my god these people have gone astray uh you know and i need to round them up and you know pay for their

debt of sins yeah so so i take that sin as brokenness in other words we have chosen against love we have fractured our relationships and jesus is exemplary i think in this way that love

SPEAKER_00heals and makes whole And that the highest love, agapic love, you know, self-giving love, love that is not dependent on compensation or that you love me. That kind of love heals because it leads us into a new level of, it's a gift, a gift of love that's given to us. to help us, in a sense, move to a new level of our own self-gifting, you know, that we ourselves now are to be part of that love of self-gift.

SPEAKER_00That's how the world heals. You know, it's not going to happen because one person died for us. That's never going to work. It works because Jesus is the model, in a sense, of what we're about.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Interesting you brought up the Hebraic, I think you said Hebraic notion of sin because they don't, think of it, of man as being sinful. They don't think of that, right? The way that I guess Pauline Christians would think of that. You know, I had this conversation with my husband and we're sitting down and I said, okay, let me see, you know, I think I was trying to really sit in this worldview of love, original love and dying for someone because of love,

SPEAKER_01because that's what Jesus did, right? He died. And I thought, And I thought, well, to my husband, I said, well, you would die for us, right? Because you love us so much. I know you would die for us. But then as I thought about it some more, I thought he wouldn't die for us unless our lives were at risk. He wouldn't just say, I'm going to die, right? Because I love you so much, because if he did that, I would say there's no reason for you to die unless, of course, you're saving us from ourselves or saving us from some outside

perpetrator,

SPEAKER_01which is when I think of the incarnation, I think that Jesus died. Um, to save us from our own sinful nature. So there was something there that Jesus was saving. I would expect my husband to die if he was saving us from something, but not just to die, just for death itself to show humility. Does that make sense?

SPEAKER_00it's actually much more than that. I mean, it's sort of like, you know, an analogy that I would see would be say, oh, Oscar, Oscar Romero, for example, or, you know, a modern day martyr. I'm thinking of the conventional friar Maximilian Kolbe, you know, he's in a prison camp, and they're about to execute an innocent man who has a wife and four children and Maximilian Kolbe steps out and says, take my life, you know, again.

SPEAKER_00So it's not just about sin. You know, we're too sin-focused and we're too narrow, we're too anthropocentric. I think Jesus was about a deep, deep, a oneness, a relationship with God insofar as that listening, that deep listening to God was a drivenness and a passion for what God is about. And this God seeks to, you know, emerge in this world in a more, you know, a more fruitful way, a more explicit way, a world, a world where we are brought into a new community together,

SPEAKER_00a world of shared resource together. You know, I have come that you might have life and have it to the full. And I think Jesus is about that passion, that vision. And it's a work and it's a dying out of love for that. In other words, he kind of sets, he, he, he shows us what it takes for a new world to emerge. Um, so sin is, you know, it's not really there per se. We're sin because basically we're unfinished. We're just, we're just creature creatures in formation and we get a lot of

things wrong.

SPEAKER_00We're just like partials seeking to become holes. But I think the person who has come home to themselves, like a Maximilian Kolbe or an Oscar Romero, they come into that unified awareness of God in their lives. And they are driven by what they see, what God sees and they want what God wants. And that drives them to give their lives at whatever cost it will be. We're always too much about substitution and what, you know, like we did this wrong and we need to make up for this. That's kind of a lower level of awareness.

SPEAKER_00And I think we're called into a higher, this is what Jesus is calling us to, put on a new mind, you know, a deeper awareness that God is within you. The reign of God is within you.

SPEAKER_01When you look across the world, across your university, across the country, just say, not the world, let's just do the country. And you think about the zeitgeist in terms of how people view Christianity. Obviously, there's a lot of splits in the different worldviews. Do you think the Thomistic worldview or the Franciscan worldview is more dominant?

SPEAKER_00I think the Thomistic worldview is more dominant, actually, because Thomas Aquinas was declared the official theologian of the church in 1879 and therefore across all universities across all seminaries only Thomas Aquinas was taught and so it's the same theology that as actually forms our doctrines in the in the church. So both Catholic and Protestant, by the way, you know, so those those theologies and metaphysics really have wired us

to think of a

SPEAKER_00perfect idea of perfection. And we're imperfect of a God who is, you know, who redeems us, you know, through by sending the sun idea and that we are redeemed or saved by this one person, Jesus Christ. And that theology is shot through all of Christianity. And it's very hard actually to move us into a new understanding because we're pretty sure this is what God's about. And I'm saying, well, no, not really. This is one interpretation of things,

but it's certainly not what God is about. Even Jesus himself, there's an openness there, that God is doing new things.

SPEAKER_00And so even the way Jesus acts, It's very spontaneous. It destabilizes, you know, to say that you can't pin down what God is, that God will show up in unexpected places and do unexpected things. So many of the people around Jesus, like, who is this guy? You know, I mean, we don't, we don't get him. And so that we need to shift our understanding and we are too fixed on Thomas's God. And it's interesting because you talk about the differences and I've been reading

SPEAKER_01first Corinthians and I don't, I'm not quite sure what you think of it because it's written by Paul, but he does say that, you know, you follow Cephas, you follow, even some follow Paul, and he teaches the cross. Is there, do you feel that we should just teach the cross or is there too much confusion, even what the cross represents?

SPEAKER_00No. i think you know i like to think about paul in his historical context because he was a jew you know who had an experience of god or experience of christ and therefore a change of mind and so paul is he has a two-fold mission one he's borrowing from surrounding philosophies and understand judaism and you know jewish scholars to kind of convey, you know, a message about Christianity that can get out of its little circle into the wider world.

SPEAKER_00And so he does, I think he does construct in some ways some paradigms for us to understand this, this cross of Jesus Christ and know christ the new adam and these type ideas but these ideas i don't find them um completely coherent with the new testament with the gospels they have they have an affiliation with them but paul is in a sense constructing his own theology there so i take you know what he's saying there i actually like uh corinthians and i like

colossians actually i like what paul has to say on the whole but i've begun to see

SPEAKER_00it in a wider context And I think that, you know, there's definitely some truth and some great insights for Paul, but I also want to read them against what the New Testament is telling us. What are the gospels saying? Because that's the best, you know, even though Paul is 55 and the gospels aren't written until about 65, you know, AD, it's these stories about Jesus that were remembered. That's basically it. I mean, scholarship around Jesus, by the way, is very, very complex,

SPEAKER_00you know, scholars are very widely ranged in their interpretation of, you know, was Jesus God, when did he become God, the place of the cross, maybe he never, you know, I mean, it goes from one extreme to the other, you know, but I don't, I wouldn't take Paul with, I wouldn't isolate Paul's writings and say, this is what, you know, Christianity is about, I think that would be, skewed of what the larger picture is about Jesus as a faithful

Jew who had a new

SPEAKER_00experience and awareness of God in his life.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, when, and this probably will segue us into sort of science and new technologies, but when Paul came to be, or at least when Jesus came to be, you AD, zero BC, I don't know which is zero AD, you know, there was new technology there. There were all the routes, the trade routes that were established. And this enabled Paul to spread the gospel, to spread the good news of Christ,

SPEAKER_01which turned sort of mythology on its head. And this happened 2000 years ago, and also about 500, 600 years ago, we had another technology, which was the printing press, the Gutenberg Press, which enabled another new thinking, let's just say the Protestant Reformation, it also enabled this new way of thinking to take over, you could also say the Enlightenment, but certainly sort of Luther taking Christianity in a different direction.

SPEAKER_01We're now at the cusp of a different type of technological revolution, the internet and certainly AI. There could be a new movement in terms of a change in ideology that turns everything on its head. How do you look at today? It just so happens I just finished writing a book called The Christian Mutation. Is that your 27th?

SPEAKER_00Yes, actually, it is. And it is actually on this question. So it actually begins, so religion is really a part and parcel of evolution. You know, if we look at the emergence of the human person within an evolutionary worldview, we can begin to see the emergence of religion, even proto-religion among lower species and then into human life. All this to say is that Christianity, like Judaism and Islam, are emergent religions.

SPEAKER_00Prior to them, we had archaic religions or indigenous religions. And why I'm pointing this out is because one of the factors in the shift from archaic or cosmic religion to monotheism or personal experience of God, one of the shifts was in writing, the invention of writing. And so the way writing or the written word gave rise to an interior self and the emergence of that self. And so we can begin to see the shift from the cosmos,

the stars and the moon, as where the gods are exist and they're governing life here on earth to this idea that the human person now has a sense of self and a sense of god who is other than self and that's what we call axial religion and in that how do you spell that axil

SPEAKER_00And we can begin to see how axial religions, you know, begin to form and then begin to, in a sense, spread, which is what we're talking about with Paul and all. But then you're right, as we move, so we have inherited axial religion right into the 20th century. But in the 20th century, we had another shift, right? You began with the printing press, and that's right. So the written word now became the printed word. And once we began to print individualism,

SPEAKER_00became more rampant because you didn't need to read a book in common. There was only one book for the whole community idea. Now each person could read their own book. And so that is, in a sense, a new type of individualism. And that written word functioned for a long period of time, from 16th to 20th century. In the 20th century, we developed the Internet of things, you know, beginning with computer technology as a thinking machine and then the emergence of

SPEAKER_00artificial intelligence. So all this to say when I put this together is we have moved from archaic religion to axial religion and we ourselves are in a new axis or a global shift in consciousness that I call second axial religion. And it is being, in a sense, enkindled by the internet and the development of the global brain, which means religion is shifting. Religion always shifts as the human shifts.

SPEAKER_00That's what we see clear across the spans of the human phenomenon. um so it never stays the same that's one thing and that's what's hard for us because we're pretty sure religion is like God has always been this way and Jesus has always been this way and you know and things are always been this way and it's like nope they haven't and nor will they remain this way so

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, if you think about sort of Christianity and even after the Reformation, they still believe that Jesus Christ existed and is son of God. I mean, it's just a difference in terms of whether you're saved by grace or saved by works or, you know, or maybe you have to do a few more works in the Catholic tradition versus in the Protestant tradition. But is it, you know, a modest, slight version of what we already know? Or do you see like a complete...

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it's not so much Jesus Christ in works versus not works. It's what the question is, who is Jesus as the Christ? So Christ is not Jesus's surname. The Christ is the title given to Jesus by the early church. So they recognize in Jesus something that was foretold in Judaism, the coming of the Messiah. You are the Christos. You are the Messiah. and so what does that mean he himself never said i am the messiah you know i am i am the christ he spoke about you know peter said you are the

christ and he said well you know upon you you're the rock i'm going to build my church type thing so there was you know there's sort of like an in inference of things of jesus you know he himself intuited there was something unique about his life but he never

SPEAKER_00explicitly said that so the question now becomes in our own time What is, who is Jesus the Christ in our own age? And that question has been taken up by a whole host of people. Raymond Panikkar, for example, a Hindu Catholic theologian in the 20th century said, Jesus is the Christ, but Christ is more than Jesus. Christ is that incarnate word of love present from the beginning of the world. So that word is spoken throughout all of creation.

SPEAKER_00In Ponticard's view, every person has a Christic dimension. Jesus explicitly fulfilled that dimension in a unique way, but every person is, in a sense, the Christ. So the Christ may not be one person. The Christ is the whole body, which is what Augustine actually taught. The totus Christus, the whole body is the Christ.

SPEAKER_01So they are the body of the church, right? We all make up the church individualistic. because we all have different gifts. I don't think that's inconsistent with what we believe today.

SPEAKER_00Right. So just to take this one step further, Carl Jung and Thayer Desjardins would say that we are not saved by one person alone. And this is difficult now, certainly from the Christian side of things, because we have a very strong belief of orthodox belief that Jesus saves us and that belief in Jesus will save us. And what Carl Jung said is Jesus,

SPEAKER_00in a sense, shows us the way of salvation by showing us how to become whole within ourselves, which means reconciling our unconsciousness and consciousness, the conflicted energies within us. I think this is very in tune with what Jesus himself was saying, you know, you know, look within, you know, and forgiveness, nonviolence, all those things are about ourselves changing. As we, in a sense, become more whole within ourselves,

SPEAKER_00we then act from a new wholeness outside ourselves. And that's, in a sense, what Jung and Teilhard were saying is what salvation is about. Salvation is making an option for the whole. We belong to a whole, a whole earth, a whole universe. We ourselves are called to become whole. And that's, I think, what we mean by holiness. It is that becoming whole within oneself. When you meet a holy person, they are holy at home. with who they are, that sense of God just radiates from them in no particular way,

SPEAKER_00but every way about them. And so when we place too much emphasis that Jesus has done this for me, we lessen our responsibility of this is what I need to do for myself. I think God doesn't do it for us. I think God does it with us. In other words, God gives us the opportunity to become whole, but we have to, we have to say yes to those opportunities. We have to, accept that responsibility i guess i guess it's interesting you said that carl jung said he shows jesus shows us salvation and save us and i guess

i would say that but i i can i think those are both the same if i say that jesus shows us what it means to be salvation you know to be saved if he didn't show us we would not be saved so

SPEAKER_01in in in a sense because he did show us he did end up saving us so it's not incorrect to say that jesus saved us if he is the one who showed us salvation right yes you can you can definitely make that comparison i think you can read young a little bit like that because he is saying that christ is the archetype you know this is the

SPEAKER_00model of what salvation is about And I think, you know, when we say Jesus saves us, I don't know how we're interpreting that. Are we thinking that Jesus is the archetype of what I need to do in my own life? Or are we throwing, in a sense, our hope that Jesus has done this for us?

SPEAKER_01And we don't have to do anything else. Thanks, Jesus. I'll just sit here.

SPEAKER_00Jesus, we're saved.

SPEAKER_01Sit here with my margarita and you could take over now. So let's talk about your Center for Christogenesis and the purpose of it. It sounds like it's getting bigger. You're in demand here. What's the purpose of your center? yeah so uh i began the center because as a franciscan where the incarnation is central to what god is about what we're about what the earth is about um i saw that

SPEAKER_00comparison with uh taylor desjardins who i think has the one of the most incredible visions of God, self, and world for our lives today. It's such a comprehensive vision that is, I think, both faithful to the tradition in its own way, and yet visionary. Teilhard takes what we have inherited, and he interprets it in light of modern science, and he invites us to see our lives in this unfolding universe in a new way, and I think rekindles a dynamic God of love at the heart of our lives.

SPEAKER_00I think this language of God is too abstract, sometimes it's too static, and I think it has not bode as well. And so Teilhard is saying that evolution, you know, is a process of unfolding life towards more conscious life, towards more being, and God is at the heart of that life. So As we develop, God develops, the world develops, and he puts this whole thing in the symbol of Omega. What we're moving into is a wholeness,

SPEAKER_00a creation, you might say, a universe, like a one world up ahead. And so I found that very compelling, and a lot of my work has been building on that. I started the Center for Christogenesis as a way, in a sense, to share this insight with others because I think there's a lot of seeking in the world. Where are we going? What are we about? People don't understand how science and religion are not at

odds with one another. They are actually two sides of the same reality of the one life that we live,

SPEAKER_00two ways of knowing this world. And so being trained as a scientist and a theologian, I have never found them in conflict. I have always found them in complementary relationships. So Teilhard brings that together very nicely. And he invites us to pay attention to what science is telling us. I find too much religious language leaves science out as if science is just suspended. Talking about God and grace and being saved and everything,

SPEAKER_00and it has nothing to do with, say, evolution and quantum physics and the fact that we live in a chaotic, Susan Nemitz- Open systems world, and so we have no idea what this means, so the Center for Christogenesis has been building a kind of a. Susan Nemitz- A new platform for understanding these things by bringing together modern science philosophical reflection on those insights. and which we do through our podcasts and a lot of dialogue, and then developing the doctrines we have inherited along new lines,

along these new insights to say that can we kind of reattach ourselves to the

SPEAKER_00universe in which we live, to this earth in which is our home. We're so disconnected from the earth. We're completely abstracted from the universe. We're a species sort of that's hovering on the brink of complete chaos because we're so disconnected. And so I think Teilhard's model is a way to invite us to bring us back to reconnect on every level of wholeness. It's all about what what what I call a primordial Catholicity,

SPEAKER_00you know, sort of a foundational wholeness that's at the heart of life. And it speaks to people, I think, because I think every person desires that wholeness. desire to be whole within ourselves among ourselves and certainly with the earth

SPEAKER_01well for someone whose professional career really got started in Silicon Valley where, you know, in the early aughts with the new atheist movement, where you certainly fought a lot with new atheist technologists who believe that there was a separation of church and science. So it's nice to be able to say that they're They work together and they come together because first,

SPEAKER_01you know, firstly, God, you know, created us to be creators and create the science. What's interesting, so I appreciate that. What's interesting is that I think this, you believe or Franciscans believe that God is part of creation or is that, that's sort of what I, God is, God isn't separate from creation. God is creating with us. And I can kind of understand that. At the same time, I guess, from what I read and read,

SPEAKER_01that God being not separate, and I think you said that earlier, that God, there's a difference between Thomistic and Franciscan view, where God is separate, absolutely separated from creation, whereas the Franciscans believe we're relational and we're working to create this new world together, which brings gods into science. And I'm wondering, do you think this lessens God's authority? I'm assuming you're going to say, no, this shows God's love.

SPEAKER_01God is definitely in authority, but he is showing how much he loves us and he is in relation and partnership with us.

SPEAKER_00I think part of the problem is how we conceive of the word God. So when we use that language of God, what exactly do we mean here? And I think we're talking different meanings. So Thomas's meaning would be a unified being itself, right? But when we use that language, no one thinks in terms of unified being, we think in terms of oneness. So God is this divine one, this divine power. And we're wondering, how can that God be in all things without losing God's power?

SPEAKER_00But another way to look at it and the way Teilhard might look at it, if we stick with the love tradition is, and I think the more biblical perspective, by the way, is God as presence, a living presence. So when God shows up in the burning bush with Moses, he says, I am, who sent me? It's like, I am, I am, I am here. So exists, which is actually the basis of Thomas's reflections. But presence is a dynamic, vital, you know, existence.

SPEAKER_00And by living presence, we're meaning that God is the depth of our lives. God is the infinite horizon of our lives. So we know this presence within us. It's not something outside us. We can only utter the name God because there's something within, whether or not we believe in God, by the way, you know, there's some, even if say someone says, well, I don't believe in God at all. I'm an atheist. But even to reject something, you have to appropriate something to reject. So what is it you're rejecting? Most people reject this kind of big,

big guy in the sky idea, you know, like, super dude um and that is there's something here so some people might acknowledge the hereness as you know my attunement with nature or you know i'm at home with myself um but god is always the transcendent lore they're always the moreness we're never satisfied to put it another way you know we're always looking yeah go ahead

SPEAKER_00you want to say something

SPEAKER_01Well, as the apologist in me, I'd love to understand when somebody says that to you, an atheist says to you, well, I don't believe in God. And you can say, well, what are you rejecting? I mean, that's great. Like I reject God or I reject this thing that doesn't exist. You're saying, well, it doesn't exist. Why are you rejecting it? So I'd love to understand how you put on your Christian apologetic hat and speak to fellow scientists to get them to start believing in this, you know,

SPEAKER_00I never actually speak from a point of appreciation of apology. I actually engage in science. So I'm very, very interested in what science is telling you. I don't care. I don't wanna defend anything. I wanna know because every time I talk about science, I'm talking about a depth an infinite horizon. There's no technology, there's no science, there's no experiment that can get to the final answer of everything. It's always opening up into the mystery. And I think what we see with science is, oh, guess what? We thought we had the answer and it's just opened up into new questions.

SPEAKER_00And which means that it's an endless mystery. That's what we mean by horizon, that we're being constantly drawn and that being drawn into that mystery is what we mean by God. So I don't have to talk about it. You know, I don't have to. I can just back there. I have some atheist scientists who's, you know, who actually like to tune into the center for Christogenesis because we're not about defending a faith. We're about living it. Right. So it's like at the heart of everything that exists is an infinite horizon in depth

SPEAKER_00and in an inexhaustible depth that cannot be grasped, that cannot be logically explained, but it exists. It's a presence. It draws us and we move toward it, whether it's by passionate, passionate in a passion for science, a passion for technology that we're going to develop the superhuman something or other, you know, and And part of what I'm trying to do is if we can understand what this word God means and then how the scriptures or writings from the different

religions open us to a

SPEAKER_00set of values at the heart of this meeting, we can help shape technology towards what it can do for planetary life.

SPEAKER_01So as we moving together in terms of evolving, as more people start understanding that religion and evolution, we all, it belongs together, which I agree. Then you say that we're destined to become, I think you said this, or some, you know, maybe I got this from your website. We become one single organism, or at least the newest sphere. There's this concept of the newest sphere. I don't, there's the third state of evolution. How does that fit into this?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right, right. So this is a Teilhardian, well Teilhard borrowed it from Vernensky, the Russian geologist. Basically what they're saying is that as evolution unfolds, we move from a level of cosmic life, cosmogenesis, to a level of biological life, of biogenesis. But as biological life unfolds, it's developing in terms of thought or consciousness or mental capacity. And so the new sphere is actually right now evident on the

level of mind, extended mind.

SPEAKER_00It's the thinking layer of evolution, so to speak. And that's what has been developing, especially through AI, you know, in the way computer technology now extends. And by mind, you know, I don't mean just simply brain. I mean sort of that field of processing information. that allows us to connect an exchange of information across fields, so to speak. So we're on this new level of the news sphere. And, you know, it's actually giving rise,

SPEAKER_00I think, to a new type of person only because we're thinking differently on this new level of the news sphere. And that's where I think religion, we see the shift in religion from maybe institutional religion to a new search for a sense of belonging and the sacredness of all things, a sense of divinity. um you know in a much wider and broader sense the inter-religious kind of you know uh dialogues that have been taking place so we're in a huge

huge paradigm shift huge um and the new sphere is in a sense our most recent level of evolution which will continue of course to evolve because that's what life keeps doing it keeps

SPEAKER_00developing in complexity, you know, and consciousness and keeps moving. I'm sure this new sphere started around the introduction of the internet as it was

SPEAKER_01commercialized, or is it more the 2020s when AI was really commercialized?

SPEAKER_00Actually, I take the internet sort of with the emergence of Homo sapiens sapiens, you know, with our species. that's sort of a very, very birth of it, so to speak, you know, the birth of thought. But then, you know, for the longest time, we never thought too much about it. I mean, here we are, we think, but I don't think we really ever placed too much emphasis on this until the 20th century, and the problems of the 20th century, and then the birth of the computer,

SPEAKER_00you know, which really did, I mean, it was so remarkable, quite honestly, you know, Alan Turing's famous Turing test and, you know, in 1950, just to ask that question, can a computer think like a person was really, it was a dramatic turn. Who would have ever thought that even raising that question, a machine was a machine was a machine. And so right there, there's a, there's a boundary crossing, you know, can a machine think like a person that's a boundary crossing.

And I do take that as the inception or the beginning of the new sphere that has

SPEAKER_00been accelerating and you're in the computer world. So, I mean, it's been accelerating ever since.

SPEAKER_01It's an interesting question you bring up. What can the machine think like a human? I think the question now is, can the machine become human? Meaning can it have, can embody the human nature? It may not be embody a human body, but it raises the question of what is man? What is the nature of man? I am in my very modest and less researched view than you, I'm sure, is that machines can never have human nature because they don't

have a conscience

SPEAKER_01and they don't have a Holy Spirit. Yeah, I, well, those would be some reasons, but I, I think several things.

SPEAKER_00One is I'm not sure we want why I can see extending ourselves. I can't see replacing ourselves, you know? And I do think on one hand that This, this search for reproducing a human on a humanoid level, there's something about us that's deeply, deeply disconnected, or we actually reject something within us. and we're looking for a more perfect something outside us. And this is where I think religion really needs to get on board

with what evolution

SPEAKER_00and technology are about, because I think what we're looking for is already within our wisdom traditions of religion. But we keep wanting to project something that's not here onto something that could possibly be there, whether it's, you know, humanoid that you know looks like us thinks like us there are aspects of the human by the way i have to go soon i have another web i have another podcast oh okay okay yeah that's true it's already 10 55 last question then last question with regards

to this newest fear does this you know how does this relate to biblical eschatology yeah well this is where i would see a distinction because i think biblical eschatology uh presupposed a static world view in other words that that was um you know conceived within a hebraic cosmos which was static and fixed very much like the ptolemaic cosmos and so it was bounded it was closed and so what you could see a bound to close universe would be have finite limits you know

and there would be a

SPEAKER_00time where everything will come to an end We don't live in that universe anymore. And we have to rethink what do we mean by eschatology? What do we hope for? And I think hope is a good word here. Teilhard himself looked at the universe as an ongoing complexifying process of life open to more life. And therefore, you know, maybe the longing for the up ahead is already already beginning in the now you know that this heaven and on

earth that we're looking for maybe that opens here you know instead of something there that's not here because that that kind of thinking drives a lot of transhumanist technology right look what we can form up ahead you know a more perfect life a more thinking

SPEAKER_00life a more wonderful life that's not here And I'm saying maybe what we have is here, you know, and maybe, you know, what we long for is already now. But if our attention is away from here and now, we're looking for something that's not here, that kind of eschatological, oh my gosh, I hope to get to heaven. You might be missing heaven in the present moment, you know, and so we're always looking for perfection, we're always looking for perfect ability. That this is always the imperfect moment and we're looking for

the perfect moment of life.

SPEAKER_00And that's where we have to reach, we have to change our thinking on things that maybe all that we're seeking is precisely in the imperfect life, you know, and what we think may be better life, which no perfections, no sufferings, you know, pure joy, maybe the most boring life for all eternity. And I don't think that's going to be, I don't think that's what God is about or Heaven's about at all. I think it's going to be ongoing creativity, ongoing longing.

SPEAKER_00I think it's going to be a much more dynamic life that eye has not seen, ear has not heard, nor has it entered our hearts, you know, what this could possibly mean. I like to think of the eschaton as the up ahead, just sheerly that, you know, the up ahead that pulls me in the present moment.

SPEAKER_01Well, it's pulled me in. You make it sound inviting. And you certainly helped me to be more present and humble. So thank you so much, Ilya.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I appreciate you talking. Great questions, by the way. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I've been speaking with Ilya Delio and Bambi Francisco Roizen. You've been listening to CRT.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Other Side Academy CEO Tim Stay on CRT

    Sep 8, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Tim Stay is CEO of The Other Side Academy (TOSA), a long-term treatment and residential program in Utah for people caught in cycles of addiction, incarceration and destructive behavior. Its 2½-year program requires...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. There is no such thing as a value-neutral tech investment

    Apr 9, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    In this podcast, I interview Nate Fischer, founder of venture firm New Founding and American Reformer, an opinion journal. I opened with a reference to the Bible verse 1 Corinthians 2:9 “What eye has not seen, ear has...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The church restores identity beyond the diagnostic label

    Apr 3, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    If there’s a tragic indictment of the 20th century, it is this: institutions became addicted to subscription models. Big pharma and the psychiatric fields are major culprits, essentially capitalizing on natural human...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. AI is ushering in the modern Renaissance man

    Mar 19, 202654 minAudio

    I’m already not driving my son to school (in my Tesla self-driving mode). Now Tesla has introduced cars sans steering wheels, and with that wheel literally gone so goes the small but meaningful bit of responsibility for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Religion is the missing piece in mental health

    Mar 5, 202652 minAudio

    Dr Harold Koenig is founding co-director of The Center for Spirituality, Theology and Health at Duke University Medical School. The center was founded in 1998 to conduct research, and promote dialogue and discussions...

    Credit the people on this episode