Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Weoverme

Weoverme artwork

There is no such thing as a value-neutral tech investment

Apr 9, 20261 hr 12 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this podcast, I interview Nate Fischer, founder of venture firm New Founding and American Reformer, an opinion journal. I opened with a reference to the Bible verse 1 Corinthians 2:9 “What eye has not seen, ear has not heard, mind has not conceived, the things God has prepared for those who love him.” This verse reminds us that when God is truly at the center of our lives, our hearts and minds are opened in ways that transcend our own plans, ambitions, and even our cultural assumptions. When God precedes our decisions - whether personal, professional, civic, social, political, economic - we are capable of perceiving realities that often remain hidden to those who rely solely on human wisdom. Yet as a society, we have rarely approached our collective life with this kind of devotion-considering his will before we make our choices, including the ones that shape what we build, finance and invest in. Many of us have been seduced by a different premise: that reason serve as our North Star. We have assumed being sufficiently civil, culturally relevant, rational, conversant in the language of modern sensibility, and value-neutral were enough to discern the good, the true, and the beautiful. Even within the church, there has been a temptation to present Christianity as accommodating, progressive, or culturally agreeable - a faith that offers reassurance more than repentance, affirmation more than transformation. The consequences of this bargain we made however is now before us for we allowed a watered-down moral framework to seep into the very foundations of civilization. Many of the institutions that structure American life-education, healthcare, energy, the courts, governance, media-are still animated with a moral lens that is unrecognizable. Supporters of this value system even criticize it today, saying this morality was institutionalized during the last administration. Notwithstanding the sweeping changes in government, decisions continue to be made through a deeply value-laden lens, one shaped by a particular vision of the good, even when it presents itself as neutral. What is at stake, then, is not merely policy or change in management, but moral orientation, and as it pertains to my interview with Nate - it is a moral orientation that undergirds the products we build. There is a task incumbent upon all of us to reorder society and American civilization toward truth, responsibility and repentance. Nate and his firms are seeking to engage this moment with vision and intentionality. His venture firm seeks to harness the cultural realignment underway to “build an alternative vision for America.” A vision that consciously retreats from the assumptions of progressive liberalism that have long defined so many of our institutions. In our conversation, we talk about Nate’s faith, his “through-line” moment in 2016 when he lived in San Francisco; his journey that led to his outward political expression to how New Founding puts its principles to practice to the mission of American Reformer and today’s biggest cultural challenges. You can learn more about Nate on his venture firm website: https://www.newfounding.com/about Or read about New Founding’s strategy. Or you can visit American Reformer here. https://americanreformer.org/ Or follow Nate on X. https://x.com/NateAFischer Interview coverage 2:00 - Growing up in a Christian Reform church. 3:00 - How’s your Jesus time? 5:22 - Political expression. How evangelicals can engage in politics righty. 9:55 - The SF experience and feeling like denizens sought to put conservatives in the gulag. 12:25 - In 2016, Trump’s election shattered Silicon Valley’s techno-optimism and the Leftist force insidiously shaping the world with a radical ideology. 17:17 - The benefits of a border wall were uncritically addressed. 20:35 - Trump had a disregard for secular tradition, but many people disregarded the rule of law. 23:01 - Covid made clear the metanarrative that people saw the world differently. It was the beginning of New Founding and American Reformer. 27:22 - Capital allocation is never value neutral. 29:19 - A tech conference cannot be apolitical. It can only be apolitical if there’s a broad consensus of major values. 31:04 - How New Founding doesn’t fall into the trap that Stakeholder Capitalism did. Start with building on the right anthropology and it will be much more reflective of the America we want to live in. 37:06 - About the fund and startups invested in that manifest New Founding’s principles. 40:09 - The boundaries that determine which entrepreneurs to invest in. They don’t all have to say they’re Christian. 43:52 - The difference between Praxis and New Founding. 45:17 - The mission behind American Reformer. 53:00 - The biggest cultural challenges facing America - what is America’s identity? The relationship between the tech right and populist right and the right vision for tech. 56:00 - False ideologies corrupting Christianity and its institutions. Christian leaders abdicated their responsibility by handing over America to atone for its past sins. 59:22 - Tim Keller’s willingness to engage with culture was positive. Be he stopped at positive engagement vs prophetic critique. That’s where traditional Christians need to step in and become more assertive. 1:03:00 - Those pushing the Christian Nationalist narrative want Christians who have a privatized view of Christianity but secular progressive doctrines to shape the world. The term is being used to steer Christians from engaging in politics. Get full access to We Over Me at www.weoverme.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to CRT. I'm Bambi Francisco Roizen. Well, at CRT, we believe that when we innovate, we need to keep in mind our Christian values because it's our values, our beliefs that underpin everything we do. In fact, in my morning devotional, I came upon 1 Corinthians 2.9, no eye has seen No ear has heard, no mind has conceived what God has prepared for those who love him. So what is it that we can't see or hear or conceive without God

revealing it to us?

SPEAKER_02Well, someone I believe has a similar view is Nate Fisher. He started venture firm Newfounding, which believes the best builders will build products that aren't only useful and necessary, but also shape our culture and politics in a good way. Nate, welcome.

SPEAKER_00Good to be here. Thanks for having me.

SPEAKER_02Well, Nate, I want to start with first principles. You structured your company, New Founding, and your investment strategy such that it appears you're not just privileging competence or market opportunity, but the moral vision of the founders, one rooted in Protestant Christianity, as well as a conservative traditional view of how we should govern society. Your other platform, American Reformer, looks like a media consulting firm that essentially wants to

spread the gospel

SPEAKER_02inside institutions. Your faith is a big part of what you're doing professionally. I want to start there with your faith. You say that you're Protestant. There are about 9,000 to 45,000 different Protestant denominations. And then you've got the mainline evangelical. So when you say you're a Protestant, what is that?

SPEAKER_00So I am a member of the Presbyterian Church in America, the PCA, which is really the largest conservative Presbyterian denomination. I grew up in the Christian Reformed Church, which is in the Dutch Reformed tradition. It was also a fairly conservative, not quite as conservative, but fairly conservative tradition. So I've spent my entire life essentially in the Reformed tradition in relatively evangelical churches, and I've

SPEAKER_00In many ways, that is one of the most influential traditions, I think, across the history of our country, across a lot of Western Europe. And so I... I appreciate a wide range of aspects of really much of the Protestant world, both the evangelical world and both the more traditional denominations. I've always been in the Reformed tradition there.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Well, how does that faith get lived out daily? My brother would always ask me, how's your Jesus time? So, Nate, how's your Jesus time?

SPEAKER_00So I think that it's, and this is really, I think, a key element of the Reformed view, certainly traditionally, is it's, there's certainly the, there's the devotions, there's church on Sunday. I do, I do, I aim for a daily, daily devotion, which includes some Bible reading and listening, often listen. I attend church weekly and, Make sure that really the family is raised in ways that reflect that.

SPEAKER_00But really, I think it also reflects an approach to all of life. Ultimately, my understanding of the world is deeply shaped by... by that Christian understanding. And to me, that meaningfully shapes everything from the values applied to business, but also really the recognition of reality. I mean, as Christians, I believe that we understand the world in a way that oftentimes

other people don't

SPEAKER_00understand correctly. We understand human nature. We understand other aspects of creation. We were The Bible begins with Genesis, which talks about the creation of the world. And so that really plays out across everything that I'm doing in all aspects of business. And so it's very much not something that I sort of segment to particular time so much as both a lens through which the world can be viewed and an anchor for the

SPEAKER_00mission that I pursue and that I wake up every day and try to advance.

SPEAKER_02I like that. I was speaking to the, I think GoFundMe, but Gibson Go, which is a Christian version. And she said, yes, I know you don't really take the time to just sit down and pray, but it's part of your entire life. It's every, every walking minute or, you know, you're at least thinking about it. You're thinking about, especially when you, when people say, oh, well, I'll pray for you. And I, You know, I'm sure you're not sitting down and praying for that person, but you're thinking about that person. You're thinking about them through a biblical lens.

I want to talk about newfounding and American reformer are explicitly engaged in

SPEAKER_02the political conversation. For instance, American reformer, there was an essay written in 2024, I bet you wrote it. Evangelicals ought to engage in politics rightly. So I'm curious, were you always inclined toward being sort of overtly expressive about your politics, about your faith, or was this more of a latent interest that just emerged because of the changing shift in the culture and politics?

SPEAKER_00So in many ways, the answer is both. So I was always interested in this. I was interested in this since childhood. I grew up in a Christian family, homeschooled. I was always drawn toward independent thought. I was always interested in sort of big ideas, questions, very interested in politics. Interestingly, in college, I majored in political science. I was interested in going to D.C., going to politics. After my sophomore summer or sophomore year, I spent a summer in D.C. and actually became convinced at the time that politics was a place where

non-consensus ideas would get you shunted to the side and really marginalized. And basically a Mitt Romney style careerist was the sort of person who would do well in D.C.

SPEAKER_00So I just remember a one week period where I just... decided that that's not for me. That is not a game that I want to play. I have no interest in that. I am not going to do politics. I am going to, I will be an investor because as an investor, if you have a non-consensus but correct bet, you can make a lot of money. And so I really sort of, Almost sort of hard pivoted away from, you know, focus. I was still interested. I was involved in clubs, but it was much more of a sort of it went to much more of a sort of hobby mindset or even a social thing.

SPEAKER_00I enjoyed hanging out with people who still share the values. I went to law school after that. My wife met a business partner in law school. I. But I went to law school with a very conscious plan to use that to go into investing, focus on bankruptcy law, go into distressed investing. I ended up not practicing law and going straight into distressed investing. What I remember is at law school, likewise, I would go to the Federalist Society, which is the conservative legal organization. But I really looked at it and it just wasn't that... That world was not that interesting to me.

SPEAKER_00I think there's people who are well suited to that approach. But for me, it was it was not a space where the sort of outside the box bets that that I found interesting would work. So really spent about six to seven years. That was 2010 when I graduated. Spent six, seven years entirely focused on business. really took some big outside the box bets that ended up doing very well, and didn't think much about politics. And then I kind of got back into it,

SPEAKER_00both through a year that I spent traveling around the world, talking to people in 65 different countries, which really reinforced the importance of governance as a significant driver of success in many, many different spaces. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You went to 65 countries as part of your... It was sort of a research.

SPEAKER_00So I completed the... In the initial business, it was a big real estate acquisition spree that bought a bunch of apartments from 2011 to about 2014. And really the sort of opportunistic trade was mature and was starting to think about what's next. I and the business partner with which I founded that and decided that the best way to get a broader perspective would actually be to go... visit countries and talk to people. And it's a chance in our life we can do it. I had a six-month-old kid. My wife loves traveling.

SPEAKER_00So we ended up traveling. She and my six-month-old over the next year grew to about 35 of those countries. And we just hit up people, mostly Harvard alumni. And we just hit up people in business, sometimes in politics, and sit down and have coffees, several, over 300 coffees. And really just asked them, what are the opportunities? What are the challenges? So it was a really... Interesting and unique way to gain a broader global perspective. And that started to really, I think two themes came out,

SPEAKER_00the importance of technology, very, very significant power of technology, in many ways to actually scale governance and the importance of governance. And then I came back and moved to San Francisco, knowing that I wanted to get into technology. And that was what? That was 2016. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01OK. And that was when it really hit me that politics matters in a way that I didn't think.

SPEAKER_00That was when I first met in San Francisco. I met people where I was convinced they would put me on a train to the gulag if they could. And in Tampa, I had sort of I could just not even think it was a luxury to not need to think about it in a world where the stakes didn't seem high. And San Francisco is very clear. There are some existential fights here and there are people who hate politics. people like me, and they hate everything about what we believe. And that's not something that you can shy away from. And simultaneously, it became clear that my previous theory about sort of Mitt Romney types running

SPEAKER_00politics was no longer true. Now, this was the era of Trump. And Trump was a non-consensus guy who was sort of pushing the Romneys to the side. So the outside the box ideas were actually something that were suddenly up for grabs again. So politics was interesting again in a way it hadn't been. And so I was still focused on business. I was still focused on technology, but I was much more aware that there was a political layer to this. And you actually saw this across Silicon Valley. The big platforms were framing their mission in very political ways. Like you look at Facebook's mission, it was framed as

SPEAKER_00to make the world a more open and connected place. Like that's not just some more widgets or even a computer on every desk like Microsoft. That is essentially a political vision, sort of the Aristotelian sort of broad sense of politics. Uber would talk about their mission in very sort of aspirational. We're building the future in ways that were framed with political overtones. Yeah. WeWork, et cetera. And so it was very clear to me that politics and technology were coming together in the sense that technology was about building the future.

And people were interested in visions of the future that weren't just material,

SPEAKER_00but also sort of addressed how we interacted, addressed big political questions. It's also clear. almost no one coming from a Christian or right-aligned perspective was in that world. And so for me, the huge opportunity and need was to do so, was essentially to put a competing vision of the future in a world where the future is up for grabs, where the digital layer of life is up for grabs, We need people who are putting forward a vision that is aligned with that Christian perspective, aligned with a right aligned political perspective.

And so that was really my sort of political awakening in the sense of this matters.

SPEAKER_00This matters deeply. And there's really almost no one in the game in one of the most significant places, domains where it matters.

SPEAKER_02Well, we're going to talk about your approach because you've learned a lot over the last, that's 10 years since you landed in San Francisco. I know you're not in San Francisco now, but 2016, a lot was happening. It was also an entirely different world. I love to get inside the mind of people and understand that evolution, what they were facing, because I know I was facing quite a bit. And I'm curious if you could tell me, you told me even before when we had a brief conversation offline,

SPEAKER_02you said you had some revelatory moments points in time where it seemed that, you know, you believe one thing people were saying something entirely different. The media was spinning things differently. Tell me a little bit about what was happening when you came to San Francisco. What were some of those moments that made you think that something's not right here?

SPEAKER_00Well, so I think an interesting sort of two themes there. So I came in April of 2016. And I would say the first half of that decade, Silicon Valley was defined by a very techno-optimist view. They were almost uniformly progressive. They sort of embraced the Obama revolution, the Obama movement, and had this idea that tech could be this force that could help make the world more open and connected right they can help essentially bring about global democracy or whatever and uh so

it was it was a combination of sort of pervasive just acceptance of you know let's call it a sort of mainstream progressivism combined with a an optimism i would say

SPEAKER_00trump's election shattered that as in many ways they realized that some of the algorithms that they built actually contributed to so previously they would talk about the arab spring and things like their algorithms are going to help bring freedom now their algorithms elected donald trump elected hitler basically in their mind and so i think it led to a lot of you know dark introspection in that world a lot of younger more left lean left leftly left radical employees became uh

SPEAKER_00much harsher in sort of demands for woke enforcement in the algorithms, DEI inside the companies, et cetera. So I think that Silicon Valley took a very pessimistic turn where it became much more sort of harshly political. I saw around that era, I saw things like conferences where they would speak at the conference, like it was just obvious to a room of 20,000 people that everyone here would be horrified by the idea of a Trump election. And I remember one where they expressed just they expressed a sort of

A desire for aggressive purging of anyone who would dissent from BLM and some of

SPEAKER_00those views, firing employees who would suggest otherwise, and doing that to standing ovations in rooms full of Silicon Valley builders and entrepreneurs. I looked at that and realized this is a... dark and aggressive ideology that is going to turn very censorious. I've obviously read, you know, I've read history, I've read how leftist movements tend to evolve and it, you know, it's not a, not a short journey from that to even more aggressive forms of censorship and suppression.

SPEAKER_00So I realized that this is a, I've, This is a force that is shaping the world. These are the people who dominate many of the most powerful institutions, de facto governments of the digital layer of life. And they are pushing for radical ideology and everything from sort of censorship policies, algorithmic control to government suppression. And that was a wake-up call that you... As I said, I was, it was not new to politics.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't like I, it was one of those things where it immediately resonated with things that I knew that I just hadn't thought about for about 10 years.

SPEAKER_02Did you, so it's interesting. It sounded like for me, you know, I had one moment was when my pastor came by, he was running by the house, he came by and this was 2016 and Trump was on TV and he sort of mockingly said, and incredulously just said, oh, yeah, nobody's going to vote for him. He's misogynist, et cetera. And I thought, wait, why would you say that? That was kind of one point. I didn't make the connection that this was bigger. It was just one point. And then when I started understanding the way you're understanding,

SPEAKER_02it's when everybody started laughing about the border wall. And I thought, well, why is a border wall like why is that a silly idea and it was though i looked like an idiot that i was so unsophisticated that i didn't see this more elevated nuanced view of a border wall as being a bad thing and when you know that's when i started putting it together that there was some concerted effort to really undermine every western value it

seems like you came to that pretty quickly oh yeah well that was a good example it's a border wall like I never I could never get a good answer for why that is not a common sense solution.

SPEAKER_00It just did not make sense. A lot of the claims in this movement did not make sense, except when you realize that they have a radical ideology. Right. So there are a lot of let's call them middle class, respectable types who just sort of took for granted the respected, respectable opinion. That was a bad idea. that never made sense to me. It made sense to me that leftists who hate America would oppose a border wall because they want to destroy our country. So the only explanations that made sense was that this is driven by radical ideologues.

SPEAKER_00And having read the history of radical ideologues, of course, they want to undermine these things. But I would say it was similar. It was seeing things like that and seeing how pervasively they were believed and how sort of uncritically they were, you know, sort of unquestioned they were. And that just, I had always, I guess I was always, I was always a, I liked contrarian thinking or independent thought. And so my immediate reaction was,

SPEAKER_00This seems like an area where the consensus is absurd. And I am going to be very interested in taking the other side of that. And coming from a business perspective, I was very interested in taking the other side of that and thinking about the implications in the business world or the investment world or the world of technology that is so profoundly shaping the world. So for me, it wasn't just something where I'm just going to do it on the side and think about it. But I started thinking, OK, this is This is a mainstream, broad consensus that is wrong.

SPEAKER_00What does taking the other side of this look like?

SPEAKER_02Well, what did you get pushback from people where you actually had to constantly take the other side? I mean, you were in San Francisco, so I'm assuming that you had a number of people trying to persuade you to think otherwise.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and actually what's interesting is my church also had people who, some of them went sort of radical woke during the 2020 era, during the BLM era. And sort of seeing their, at the time, they would just sort of ask the sort of, you know, sometimes they'd ask these sort of concern trolly questions where they ask a question that's framed in a way that is designed to sort of make it, you know, is this being driven by racism or whatever, something, and they would just ask it. So I'd see those kinds of things. I was always kind of skeptical of, I mean, legal background.

So I was always sort of not necessarily accepting their framing or anything.

SPEAKER_00And I would, I, I would say the fact that I was independent, I, Working with a business partner who largely agreed with me meant that I didn't face the same sort of pervasive exposure to this that I would if I were, let's say, working inside Uber or Google or whatever. But absolutely, I ran into people all the time, including Church, who disagreed with that and very comfortable position for me.

SPEAKER_02Can you recall a conversation? What was it that they were trying to persuade you of? And how were you? Were you reticent? Were you basically like, I want to be friends, I'm walking away? Or did you...

SPEAKER_00Oh, I would always engage. I never shy away from engaging that. I don't recall a specific conversation, but I remember this sort of pervasive, the common one is just this assumption that Trump is bad and dangerous. He's bad for democracy and Again, didn't really make sense to me because democracy is their idea of democracy was something that was sort of patently undemocratic and did not reflect the will of America. And so I saw that as a fairly hypocritical term.

I would say that I would say the most the strongest one was sort of regular arguments to get about the threat to institutions and the threat to the rule of

SPEAKER_00law. But which I was sympathetic to. I mean, coming from the Fed stock world, I was sympathetic to a conservative understanding that really respected the role of law. It was very concerned about, let's say, it was very concerned about, you know, apparent disregard or disrespect for it, which certainly Trump at times shows. But so I would take seriously some of those those criticisms. But at the same time, I saw very clear arguments that I so many institutions that continue to pay lip service to those,

those things have wantonly violated any number of principles of the constitution.

SPEAKER_00So at the same time, I think it was very, it was very easy to realize that we've departed, that ship sailed a long time ago and it sailed in ways that sort of steadily moved the country in one direction. So as much as it sort of, to potentially have to abandon some respect for institutions in certain ways. That's the only thing that has a hope of moving the country back. a country where we've already abandoned substantive respect for them and only

maintain in some sense sort of procedural respect for them as a country where we

SPEAKER_00don't really take seriously those institutions. And that was, I think that intuitively sort of clicked for me. I certainly appreciated both sides of the argument, but I think for many people, it almost became an article of religious faith where, I mean, those were the sort of people who just absolutely cracked over January 6th and totally lost it.

SPEAKER_02But some of them converted. Some of them shifted. Did you know any of them who moved to the right?

SPEAKER_00I knew a few. It wasn't necessarily a lot of the people in San Francisco. Well, in San Francisco, there were people who were sort of already leaning that direction. There were the dissident. What I think you saw is a lot of younger people who were already sort of low-key dissident thinkers from that. Yeah. I think at a place like Dallas. So I moved to Dallas in 2018. Part of it's just a much better place to raise a family. San Francisco is never going to be a long, long place to live. There's really a chance to live in a certain phase in our life. Dallas is interesting because, so I moved there and I really am.

SPEAKER_00red pill in this sense. I really see an opportunity. And really, I was partially, I would say I was like, I recognized there were issues, but I hadn't clarified my thought on that. That really developed over 2019. And then really 2020 was very, very clear with COVID. During COVID, it was sort of very clear we believed profoundly different things about the world, about reality itself in many ways. There was a sort of meta-narrative that was ridiculous. That was when I became much more politically focused, was when I stepped out of some day-to-day business interests to really think about

SPEAKER_00what's next and what is the major play. And what was interesting in Dallas is I think it's still a much more comfortable place. It's much more like where I'd come from in Tampa, where In many ways, people didn't deal with people who would send them on the train to the gulag on a daily basis. So there were a lot of people who I think just embraced a sort of comfortable conservative narrative and remained very concerned about things like Trump's rhetoric in certain ways. And I... Yes, I would say many of those people did wake up over time as they

saw various things,

SPEAKER_00as they saw the sort of extremism of the Democrats over the Biden era, as they saw how they handled COVID. COVID was a major wake up for a lot of people. So I would say in San Francisco, I was gone by that period where a lot of people probably would have moved. I'm not quite sure. I know there were people from San Francisco who very much were on the right. But in many cases, I think they had just sort of been low key like that for a long time and kept their head down. In Dallas, you saw people sort of wake up in a way that was very different,

SPEAKER_00not just Dallas, but I would say nationally. So I started building a Twitter profile, building Twitter. building a sort of public voice on a lot of these issues. And a lot of it was people who would come, they'd often send messages to us, often private messages, where they're a partner at a prominent law firm, for instance, and they have realized that this is a major, you know, a major fight, and they don't really know anyone else, they can't take a public stand here. We were public We were public partially because we set ourselves up to be able to be public about this. And people could come to us,

often in positions where they couldn't be public about it. And we could start having conversations about how could you make a move that could

SPEAKER_00be more aligned with your values, more aligned with what you see in the world.

SPEAKER_02When you're saying we were public, are you talking about your company?

SPEAKER_00That was New Bounty. That was really when I started. So I skipped ahead a little bit. But I started, as I saw this opportunity and saw this need at the intersection of technology and politics to really... put forward a different vision for where the country could go. I saw a hunger for a positive vision in the country. I saw technology and venture as a really strong vehicle to advance that, along with media as a sort of amplifier of that. And I started new founding a venture firm focused on American

revitalization. as a means of bringing together people who ultimately wanted to build and realize

SPEAKER_00that, that future. And so I, and a number of other people at new founding have often been public about this. So it really is a, it really is something where I've, I've been one of the major voices, but we've encouraged other people sort of, once you join new founding, you're, you're in the open about what you're fighting for. And, and I, And courage to have a public voice helping move people this direction. And so that really I started that in January of 2021, after sort of a year of really developing and sort of gaining,

SPEAKER_00you know, really strong conviction on what the opportunity and the need was over 2020 over the year of COVID. And then that's what I've been doing for the last five years.

SPEAKER_02It's interesting, as you know, because I think this is how we met, I was thinking about hosting a CRT startup revival, and it had to have the underpinnings of faith and politics in many ways, because yes, sort of the politics or governance, that's kind of guides. or lays the foundation of what we should be building. And some people say that we have to be somewhat neutral about that when we're thinking of investing.

SPEAKER_02But you say on your website, the myth of technological and institution neutrality is disappearing. Because it's become clear our society is shaped deeply by the companies and technologies that mediate our ability to speak, build and organize. So you're making the claim that even capital allocation is never value neutral because the decisions you're making always have some conception of moral good. That's your claim, right?

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes, and I would say that's certainly true in capital allocation. I mean, what is going to earn a return is also a factor, but I would say even more true in a lot of the way the digital world works. So you think of Google and you think of how, and this is really true of algorithms broadly that guide your behavior. You think of a Google search result and the Google search result is a ranked set of results and there's going to be a number one and number two result. And there's a lot of questions where you put something in there

SPEAKER_00the ranking is going to reflect, must reflect a set of values about what should be number one and what should be number two, whether it be values that go, it's choosing kids' books, right? What is a good kids' book? Well, there must be value.

SPEAKER_02Gender affirming care is- Exactly.

SPEAKER_00So, or if you type, is Jesus God into Google search results, the top result is either going to say, you know, the most boiled down version is either going to say yes or no.

SPEAKER_02Can a tech conference be apolitical?

SPEAKER_00No, I don't believe it can. I believe that you can have... You can obviously have sort of different... I would say what people often see as apolitical is actually what exists when you have a general consensus about some of the major questions. So if you have a broad consensus about certain major things... then you can have something that seems apolitical because you're not really focusing on political debates. I would say that in many ways just reflects a consensus, a group that shares an understanding of the good in critical ways. So then you can just talk about,

if you're in an investment conference and everyone agrees sort of critical

SPEAKER_00guidelines, they agree on certain doctrines, then you can just debate what earns the highest returns or you can present things and pitch why it earns the highest returns in a world where everyone sort of accepts it. That's the good that we're focused on. I would say you look at what's happening in AI right now and it's very clear that there's major, major differences, not just about the sort of nature of reality, like what are we building? Are we going to achieve AGI or are we going to and how quickly are we going to achieve it? But also what's good?

SPEAKER_00Is it good for us to achieve it and embrace that? Is it bad? Is it something that we need to regulate? Is it something that we should sort of we're not gonna achieve AGI, but we should pursue techno acceleration and solve a lot of problems. That is very clear in the AI discussions that this is something that is impossible in many ways not to quickly engage what would be widely recognized as major political questions. And I would say in many cases, even anthropological questions and religious questions.

SPEAKER_02For sure, for sure. I want to get back to more of the sort of logistics around how you work with new founding and how that works on a day-to-day basis. Because I like the idea, obviously, you're not just for profit, but you want to pursue what's morally good. And there is some similarities to stakeholder capitalism, which is not to be driven by profits, but consider your employees, consider your customers consider your environment.

SPEAKER_02The challenge with stakeholder capitalism and why it didn't work from my perspective is that it had goals to achieve because they wanted to measure whether people were actually sticking with stakeholder capitalism. And then hence you had sort of profit driven decisions based on the incentives. So the incentive structure to achieve these certain moral goods that Klaus Schwab determined and defined, that really took stakeholder capitalism the wrong way.

SPEAKER_02So for you, you're trying to be profit-driven, but you're also trying to have an outcome of a moral good, but how do you operationalize that without having these measurements that can skew the incentives and just end up with stakeholder capitalism, which isn't very good?

SPEAKER_00So I think a key part of that, absolutely right that I do not, I hate the double bottom line approach where you try to say average two goods or whatever. I think that first off, certain problems are suitable to pursue through a for-profit endeavor like this. in many cases where my hope is and my expectation is we can actually achieve outsized returns as well as advancing a country we care about. So our motto is build the America you want to live in. Now, if you think about that, there's actually a lot of areas where there's a lot of areas

where it's not just a different set of values and we have to layer on a different set of

SPEAKER_00values, which is often the premise of stakeholder capitalism. It's actually, we have a different belief about the world. And if you have a different belief about that, and this was very true during COVID, for instance, we have very different beliefs about the world than many people on the left. If you have different beliefs about the world, in many ways, what I say sort of venture and entrepreneurship is, is you envision a future that doesn't yet exist and you will it into existence. And there's a wide range of futures that can be willed into existence. First off, if if we have a better and more accurate understanding of reality,

there are going to be cases where there are profoundly important implications to

SPEAKER_00that, that make us a lot of money for right and actually give us an edge like we should actually if we understand anthropology better. when it comes to the application of AI, we are going to let's and let's say our view is less transhumanist. We believe we have a view of the human. That means we have a better understanding of how technology can complement the human rather than replace the human in certain cases. Well, we're going to be building applications of AI that are both more grounded in reality. So they're more likely to be successful. And they're also going to be

SPEAKER_00better in line with our values when they succeed. So if you think of, let's say, the transhuman view, you may try to replace humanity more. A, that's not going to work. And you think of sort of communism, right, in the 20th century as a good example. It doesn't work as well. And it's also... if you dump trillions of dollars in it, you might still be able to sort of force the world somewhat in that direction. And it's also gonna be a grim direction for the world. Whereas if you have the correct view of the world, not only do you end up with a much better ROI because you have

a more successful

SPEAKER_00business, but your business is also ultimately much, much better for the world and much, much more reflective of the America that we wanna move toward. So there's areas where, I think there's many areas where there's actually an opportunity for outsized venture investment. I would say second of all, a lot of times the best founders Let's say we focus on critical civilization problems. I would say a lot of the best founders want to work on something that really matters. Maybe you could say that's a double bottom line. I would say it's often a bigger, harder, more important problem.

So it's probably not the sort of material sort of utility maximized approach to

SPEAKER_00them in terms of sort of expected utility. It's much easier to make 10 million bucks through real estate than it is by building some company that solves some very hard problem and sort of your utility after $10 million probably diminishes in terms of lifestyle, right? So if they were just motivated by lifestyle, they would pursue something simpler. But the most ambitious people want more. They want to do something. And many of them are motivated by civilizational concerns. So how do you actually earn outsized returns in venture? You bet on the best people working on some of the hardest and

most important problems.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I would say those people are often making tremendous sacrifices to achieve that. But if they succeed, they're going to produce exactly the sort of returns that makes a venture fund succeed. So again, it's not people who are necessarily making decisions in a sort of short-term utility maximized approach, but it is something that if successful produces exactly the sort of returns that venture needs far more so than like a watered down double bottom line approach. And I think it's...

SPEAKER_00You think of politics, right? And traditionally, if you sort of push a paradigm shift in some domain, it's hard. It requires heroic effort. But if there's a major constituency that embraces that, if you win, you do have something that has reshaped the world in ways that is likely, that can be in certain domains, involve an extremely valuable business. So again, I reject that trade-off that the stakeholder capitalism approach takes. And I actually think that it's more of sort of the inherent nature of entrepreneurship is you're aiming for something and what you're

aiming for is often

SPEAKER_00going to be almost inherently values-laden in many ways.

SPEAKER_02Okay, well, I want to ask you about how you put that to work because, and that showing me or telling me who you're betting on will show viewers how you're putting that to work. But first, just tell me a little bit about your fund. It's an accelerator, early stage.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so we've been doing venture of various sorts, early stage venture for about two and a half years. We just did the first close on our first sort of full drawdown fund. This will be a target is a $20 million fund. fund with an accelerator focused strategy, which means that we will be taking making pre-seed investments in terms that are often the first check in terms that are relatively favorable to investors in a way that allows us to really lever a lot of our network and a lot of our resources to

SPEAKER_00help these portfolio companies. Newfounding has been successful, not just on venture investment, but we've also helped incubate a few other platforms. So we really helped. We started, we helped incubate a real estate development company that's doing elevated rural development and really brought to bear tremendous resources around our network for that. I also had some experience in real estate that was relevant. We helped incubate. a company that's now a Palantir implementation partner that does AI-enabled transformation in sectors like infrastructure construction and mining. We are actually incubating another platform right now that's

focused on doing that

SPEAKER_00kind of thing, but at the principal level in industries like well-field services. We've been successful as a platform to work with early stage founders and really bring to bear resources. And our fund is structured to basically allow us to do that at a larger scale. And we are... We are sort of early in that process in terms of deploying the fund, but we have a number of examples from the previous fund that

illustrate this well. I'll hold off on talking about the companies that we've invested out of the current fund.

SPEAKER_00But to give you kind of a few examples, we invested in a company called Primer, which is a micro school startup that... In a world of school choice, you have a tremendous increase in demand, but often supply is very inelastic. They are building something that allows the rapid launch of new micro schools. Obviously, lots and lots of different ways that micro schools could look. by building a startup that is effective and allows effective scaling of supply,

you're also going to shape what that supply looks like in significant ways.

SPEAKER_00We've invested in a low-cost drone manufacturer. So their real capability is their ability to produce at high volume. I think that the scarcity in America is often the ability to just produce physical things at relatively low cost and high volume, and they're very good at that. So it fits with sort of a lot of the sort of American dynamism, American national interest, national security themes. We invested in a... We invest in a company that's doing automated mining drilling

equipment or drilling

SPEAKER_00services, really. So a huge part of new mining is exploration, is drilling exploration holes. That's a major bottleneck. We need critical minerals in this country. So you think of all of these and they are companies where if they succeed, they're solving critical problems that We care about it in America. And that really particularly are concerns for people who are concerned about things like America's national security, America's national interest, people on the right. So those would be a few different examples of how startups can

solve problems and their problems that are sort of particular concern to our movement and their major

SPEAKER_00business opportunities. Where's the boundary, by the way, when you when you select an entrepreneur?

SPEAKER_02I mean, there's opportunities that you see, but there's also that moral vision that they need to have. How do you how do you determine? which founder to invest in if they may not embody the same values or they're just...

SPEAKER_00So I would say a lot of it is, I think a lot of, traditionally a lot of Christians have approached this as sort of an identity-based thing. We'll invest in Christians. We won't invest in non-Christians, whatever. I actually... I focus much more on the lens of what are they building and if they succeed in the mission of this company. I believe that that ultimately ends up, the previous one ends up actually meaning very little because ultimately the sort of economics of the industry end up being almost deterministic in many cases. But it's more like...

SPEAKER_00Startups will have a particular thesis or perspective that they work on. If they succeed in what they are trying to do fundamentally, will that move the country in a direction? Will that mean that we are building a country that we find a desirable direction for the country? And they may not even share all of my values and everything, but... clearly they are aiming towards something in the core of their business that is actually aligned. And I believe that's a more sort of robust way of advancing that vision,

SPEAKER_00because in some sense, they're all in on that vision. They would have to totally change their business. It's not just a matter of like, them holding back. I think if it's personal values and they're sometimes trying to sort of hold back a business where the incentives are actually against their personal values, that's a hard position to be in. But if you are dedicating your life to solving the problem of critical minerals exploration for something, Your values may or may not be, in this case, the guy is a Christian, but your values may or may not be fully aligned with mine.

SPEAKER_00But I want that business to succeed, and we are all going to be better off if that business succeeds. And his business incentives depend on solving those problems. Now, I would say most of the people, all the people who come to us generally, the reason that they are going to want to work with us is... They value our platform. And in many cases, that means that they actually share our values, our beliefs about things, and they really want a firm that they recognize as truly

aligned on the sort of

SPEAKER_00civilizational mission that motivates them for their startup. So they see us as... One of them in a way, partially because we came out so early when it was really unpopular on a lot of these issues, they see us as someone who's willing to take a risk, willing to put skin in the game on that. So in many cases, the founders are actually going to select the founders who are drawn to our vision, our values are going to select us. And the best founders have their selection. They can often take from top tier venture firms that have a more established brand name than we do.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, it seems like you're unique and you are unique. There's another VC firm that has just emerged, Praxis. And when you want to talk to founders, because you kind of have to appeal to founders, right, you have to take them away from potential competitors. I don't know if they're a competitor, but they seem to have this approach. They call it redemptive investing.

SPEAKER_00I think that they are much closer to the founder is a Christian mindset. And I would say that I'm not extremely familiar with what their portfolio companies are, but my impression is their focus, their lens is much more the founder's identities and the founder's values. And then he could be doing any number of things. He could be doing a SaaS company and doing whatever. And I don't know I don't know if that means that the business itself is doing anything different than what a non-Christian business would do.

SPEAKER_00Or if it is, I think that that world, and again, not speaking to practice per se, but I think that that approach often would maybe add a little bit of a double bottom line approach to things. So that would be the differences. I think ours is... Ours is more like we believe that there are projects that need solving that are important projects that need solving that are going to be very, very profitable, partially because of our sort of thesis about the world. And we are going to back founders who solve those.

SPEAKER_00And they're going to be founders who ultimately often sort of share a civilizational concern for America.

SPEAKER_02I want to switch gears here to talk about American Reformer, but also just touch on some of the big cultural challenges America faces. But I know that how much time do I have with you?

SPEAKER_00About 25 more minutes.

SPEAKER_02OK, let's talk about American Reformer. On your Web page, it says that you want you're on a mission. a mission to promote, quote, a vigorous Christian approach to the cultural challenges of our day rooted in the rich tradition of Protestant social and political thought. So when you want to transform or a mission to promote this in these institutions, what what does that mean? Actually, is this like a business?

SPEAKER_02Is this a A business that you do, you go in and you consult with institutions. Who are those institutions you're consulting with?

SPEAKER_00So really what American Informal looks like now is it has a journal, it has a fellowship program, and then we have a center. We have some various programs we've been involved in. We've been involved in activities to reform particular institutions to actually, we help stand up, we help sort of put together an organization that's focused on addressing some concerns in the SBC. But one of the major ones is we have a center that we stood up that's focused on Christian colleges and really providing a positive vision for

Christian colleges

SPEAKER_00that looks like really doubling down on their mission. In many ways, I think it's a very, very much in line of sort of Teal's view that if you try to compete, then you're actually going to lose. So Christian colleges succeed by doubling down on what makes them distinctive. And the more they follow mainstream trends, the more they lose, the only thing that would give anyone a reason to send their kid to a sort of more expensive private school that often has lower career choices. So we have a center that is really focused on putting forth positive vision, largely putting forward white papers and things that actually can guide Christian

SPEAKER_00colleges and how to succeed. But then really the sort of core of American Reformer itself is a journal that is somewhere between sort of a first things and American mind is a more political one, really just taking on a lot of critical issues from a Protestant Christian perspective. I've whether they're cultural, whether they're political, whether they're theological. And then a fellowship program called the Cotton Mather Fellows, where we work with a bunch of sort of rising people who are thoughtful people in

SPEAKER_00the space, sometimes coming from seminary, sometimes just working in business, but interested in these issues. So really, it's more at the core, it's more meant to be a hub of people and ideas thinking about these issues, more like a journal.

SPEAKER_02More like a journal, but also just having instead of being proactive with that journal, you have an impact. Can you talk a little bit where you've seen impact, where you've seen reform inside? Maybe let's just say those colleges. Have you seen some of your work actually manifest in some changes that they've made?

SPEAKER_00Yes. Well, so on the college side, I want to, I think that there's been a very, very strong reception because a lot of presidents, a lot of college presidents, a lot of leaders recognize, they recognize that Kyra is in a crisis spot. I don't want to name particular names here in terms of colleges, but there's a widespread recognition that it is facing a crisis, that they need answers. The guy who's leading our center is recognized as one of the most credible, probably the most credible intellectual. I, expert in Christian higher education,

SPEAKER_00really higher education, higher administration generally, and he has a particular expertise in Christian education. So there's been a very strong reception to the content we put out, the white papers we put out that provide guidance for these colleges in a way that is really suitable to what institutions like that need, like white papers that could be Shown to boards that include the supporting arguments for why this is a direction that makes sense. And so that's a good example of sort of the positive side.

SPEAKER_00I would say on the journal side, there's a wide swath of especially seminary students who know that, let's call it the sort of legacy, in many cases, sort of Keller approaches to the world, probably reflected by people like the pastor you mentioned, who I said, you know, just sort of took for granted that Trump was too divisive or something. And these pastors look at the world and they realize, you There's just a dominant sort of dogma that's been accepted sort of on top of the Christian doctrine that is just wrong.

SPEAKER_00And we are the place they can go for ideas that are different, ideas that actually sort of accept the importance and the reality of what's happening in many cases in sort of politics and cultural ways. culture and sort of analyze it and assess it through a Christian lens. So, you know, another one of the co-founders and a senior fellow is Aaron Wren. And Aaron Wren has really done this, started through the lens of sort of masculinity and the sort of red pill world, for instance. And why did these people have advice that was more practically

useful to young men

SPEAKER_00in many cases than pastors? And it wasn't always aimed in a godly direction, but they clearly were able to sort of recognize and understand problems in the world. And American Reformer is meant to be the place that you can go where we often recognize critiques that in many cases come out of secular circles, or at least not sort of primarily Christian circles, evaluate them through a Christian lens and apply them to problems with a vision that is really a positive vision in everything from sort of politics to culture. So I think the deepest sort of institutional collaboration has

happened at the

SPEAKER_00Christian college level, but the journal really tries to put forward positive ideas positive proposals sort of across the Christian world.

SPEAKER_02Do you think this becomes some sort of a heritage foundation?

SPEAKER_00I don't know if we go in a think tank direction. I think that the fellowships are something that we aim to grow. I think events are something that we aim to grow. I think more than anything, people are hungry for new ideas. The evangelical world is not good. By and large, the ideas are pretty, I would say, the legacy institutions produce sort of profoundly mediocre ideas in many cases. And they really haven't optimized for being, they haven't optimized for sort of interesting and thoughtful people.

SPEAKER_00So I think that we become a hub of we become a hub of people and ideas who are really restoring both an ambition that's often missing in the evangelical world and a sort of ability to think broadly. I don't know if that looks like a think tank or not. I actually think the think tank model is... Maybe more specific to DC, it could be a journal. I could see the journal just growing in influence. I think the curation and editorial curation will actually

matter more in an age of AI.

SPEAKER_00People will sort of, in a world where the inundated content, they'll care more about sort of thoughtful curation of that. But the format is a question that we ask, we discuss and debate many times. The idea that we become a hub for this sort of thought, for this sort of people and ideas is really building on where we've already been very successful.

SPEAKER_02That's great. Well, I like your stuff. I read your stuff. I've read your stuff. Now, curating those ideas, of course, will depend on what you think are the biggest ideas that need to be out there based on the biggest cultural challenges that we are facing. Is it what are the biggest cultural challenges? Do you think it's the the DEI and the ESG that continues to just be there for some reason that's still there? Or is it this relentless pursuit of gender ideology, racist ideology?

SPEAKER_02What do you think are the biggest challenges?

SPEAKER_00So I think I think the major questions I would say, I mean, one of the major questions is sort of American identity and political identity and sort of who our country and who our institutions actually sort of serve. In a world of transition, people desperately want powerful actors, in theory it would be their government or their leaders, protecting them, acting on their behalf. And I think that's totally up for grabs in America. And I think many people recognize that legacy institutions don't just not serve them,

SPEAKER_00but are often dedicated to actively undermining them. Going back to our discussion about dismissal of a border wall, for instance, So I think that's a critical one. I would say a critical one is the engagement with technology and the future of technology. And what is one that I'm really working on more broadly is relationship between. That's a longer conversation that we could have here, but I'll be writing and talking a lot about this, including a piece coming out of American Reformers soon on the relationship between the tech right and the populist right and what a positive

vision for technology can

SPEAKER_00look like. A lot of people are especially on the right, are scared of technology, partially because they recognize that so much of Silicon Valley currently is dominated by people who don't share their values and often actively hate their values. So can we advocate a positive vision there? And I think that that particularly draws on the Protestant tradition. The Protestant sort of American spirit has always been one that has it been particularly good at developing a positive vision for technology for sort of recognizing how that can fit into the dominion mandate and into

uh reflecting you know we are made in the image of god first thing god did is created and so our creativity is actually channeling that that image of uh god that that sort of one

SPEAKER_00of the highest aspects of human nature and uh What does that look like? And I think currently Christian, most Christian institutions and sort of evangelical publications don't really have much to say that's very positive, much to guide what that can look like. You see a lot of warnings about it. what it can mean for families or whatever, but you don't have much on the positive side. I think that's a huge need and a huge opportunity because if we don't fill that void,

SPEAKER_00other people will. And I believe that ultimately those who are going to be building in the shaping the future will gravitate toward one of the visions that's out there or or they'll shape it in the absence of sort of moral and theological guidance. And so I think that's that's an area that American reformer is really going to be moving in an issue that is going to be focusing on very heavily in coming years.

SPEAKER_02And you want people to be exposed to these ideologies. You want to be ahead of that. And these ideologies that you call false, especially the ones inside Christian institutions. And I believe you wrote that about that. Christian institutions have been corrupted by false ideologies and practices. Yes, what do you mean by false? So I would say I find I would say one interesting example is I think Joshua Mitchell has talked about the idea in his book America Awakening and more broadly

SPEAKER_00about how so much of woke is is effectively it is a perversion of. the Christian approach to guilt and guilt. It's really guilt without grace. And so you have this ideology where people are consumed with guilt over past sins and their response is essentially to... try to justify themselves. And one of the ways they try to justify themselves is they hand over any power, that they lose confidence in the legitimacy and the goodness of

their rule.

SPEAKER_00So, so much of DEI is actually people who are leaders of institutions voluntarily handing power over to diversity committees or whatever that demand sort of redistribution of the power and fundamentally that is an abdication of responsibility it's actually a laziness right it's a decadent laziness because it's hard to actually govern and govern in a complex situation with a complex history it's easier to just sort of look virtuous and abdicate your power to some extent you maintain a nice

cushy position but you're not actually doing the hard work of stewarding this institution so you have

SPEAKER_00christians christian leaders across the board, essentially abdicating the responsibility to actually steward their institutions and also encourage their congregants, encourage their followers in other institutions across life to steward our inheritance, steward our national and cultural inheritance through a really threatening, tumultuous time into the next generation. Instead, they actually embrace this perverted perverted religion effectively that focuses on historical guilt

without an appreciation of God's grace and an appreciation of how the right response to that

SPEAKER_00is to take what you've inherited and steward it well, not to abdicate and hand it over as a sort of half effort to atone for that guilt.

SPEAKER_02I guess there's some people. So Tim Keller was my pastor for a long time. And I mean, I know he passed away, but he would be he may fall into that into that bucket of some of the people. I think you even mentioned Keller into that bucket of some of these evangelical leaders who've abdicated their responsibility. Some would say that it's just being much more accommodating and maybe that's even not good enough you can't be accommodating they're trying to create connections they're trying to bring people in versus being

pushing them out by extremely being extremely you know evangelical or hard-lined I guess how would you talk to people about why it's important to not not be so accommodating maybe maybe it's a slippery slope when you become accommodating

SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's I think there's two aspects. I think there's prudential judgment. And then I think there's sort of false, essentially false religion. And I would say, look, I think Keller did some things well, actually. I think Keller actually was popular partially because he recovered aspects of mainline Christianity that had been abandoned by the evangelical church, like a willingness to actually engage the culture broadly. And traditionally, the main line sort of engaged broadly. And I would say evangelicals sort of defended against liberal corruption by focusing very much on sort of a personalized faith.

Keller sort of turned back, but I would say he sort of largely stopped it. I would say positive sort of engagement rather than much more of a sort of

SPEAKER_00prophetic critique, which I think Christianity actually offers in a profoundly corrupted culture. He may have thought that was a prudential judgment for how you reach people in New York City. I would probably question the wisdom of some of that. Ultimately, I think whatever the truth at the time, we're in an era that demands it. Whatever the truth was, let's say during his sort of heyday, the 2000s, we're in an era that today demands leaders who are much more assertive. And certainly many people who are influenced by Keller are even

more dogmatic about sort of a refusal to challenge uh refusal for an aversion to conflict uh it's it's

SPEAKER_00something that let's say the world right now is deeply hungry for, they're often disillusioned with the mainstream narrative, including the sort of moral theological narrative. Many, many people recognize that that is morally bankrupt. They recognize that does not offer a vision of life that they find attractive, that they find that resonates as true. They're looking for an alternative. Christianity can provide that alternative. I would say, if you think of sort of American reformer, that is aiming to provide that alternative positive vision

in the sort of uh you know particularly in issues associated with sort of the the protestant tradition the moral theological space new founding is trying to provide that positive vision through venture substantially through certain things so two two sides two really necessary complements to what that vision looks like but i think we offer a strong vision grounded in christianity that is going to resonate with a lot of people who are disillusioned with what the world is offering today

SPEAKER_00and they know that it they instinctively know that the alternative that Christians can put forth is true in important ways. And that can actually lead them to explore a lot more of Christianity.

SPEAKER_02Well, we need that strong vision because you've made the claim that there are powerful Christians out there with a corrupt view of Christianity, but the same view is being made on the left about the Christians on the right, but they have a name for it. It's called Christian nationalism. James Tallarico, whom I'm sure you're from Texas, you know, rising star there. He says that Christian nationalism is the, quote, worship of power in the name of Christ. But then CNN just had a series. I don't know if you saw the show that they put the report that

they had the rise of

SPEAKER_02Christian nationalism. They define Christian nationalism as, quote, an ideology rooted in the belief that the United States was founded as a Christian nation. and that its laws and institutions should reflect Christian values." That's not so bad. That's basically every Christian, but the way they portray Christians make it sound like we're trying to redefine America into this version versus bringing it back to its roots. What are your thoughts on Christian nationalism?

SPEAKER_00Well, so I knew, I mean, American reformer became known as sort of a hub of discussions around Christian nationalism. Interestingly, I've never embraced the label myself, nor has Josh Abattoi, the executive director, Aaron Wren, but we were open to engaging a lot of ideas there. And I have, I think it's a very, it's a very positive, it reflects the desire to develop a positive alternative. And one of those is Christian nationalism.

SPEAKER_00I think that the critics, by and large, are upset. They reject any substance. Ultimately, they're going to reflect any version of Christianity that actually tries to have implications in the real world. Fundamentally, they are They want a neutered Christianity. They want a Christianity that at best is something that affects what you do in the morning with your devotions, maybe what you choose to spend your Sunday doing and what you do in your home. But they would, it's not that they reject, they ultimately,

SPEAKER_00most of them, James Tallarico, James Tallarico is not a Christian. James Tallarico holds a deeply, deeply distorted ideology. view of Christianity and what his even truth claims are about it. He is going to ultimately define Christianity as something that is coterminous with leftist religion and actually embodies that guilt without grace model. I mean, you hear him talk about how he would embrace vegetarianism and

how we need to move

SPEAKER_00toward that. And it's like, more and more of these sort of denials of yourself, denials of things that are aspects of our culture to atone for the sort of sins that we commit by killing animals or the sins we've committed, committed historically and say it is a guilt laden, guilt laden religion of sort of atoning for his whiteness continually. And so he's going to totally reject any, any sort of substantive Christian view. And I, And I would say I think the common critique centers on this power issue.

SPEAKER_00Christians want power. Well, anyone who is involved in politics all wants power. If you're living like the Amish and you're just trying to sort of put your head down and do your own thing, I'll believe people when they say they don't want power. But anyone who's out there involved in public discourse is involved in public discourse to a large extent because they're trying to shape the country, they're trying to shape the world. So ultimately, the question is, what are you using that power for? Are you stewarding that power well or poorly? Think of the parable of the talents. And the guy given 10 talents was commended for using the power

that came with that

SPEAKER_00responsibility well. The guy who buried his talent was not. So I think that when people try to harangue Christians over their use of power, all that really reflects by and large is they don't want Christians to be the ones shaping the world. They want non-Christians to be shaping the world. They want Christians who have a purely privatized view of Christianity, but otherwise accept sort of secular progressive doctrines to be shaping the world. And so I thoroughly reject that view. And that would be what American Reformer thoroughly rejects is

SPEAKER_00Christians should be in a conversation. Christianity has a lot to say about how to use power. It ultimately does not mean that our ultimate hope is not in this world. It's not about seeking redemption through power, but there is throughout the Old Testament and the New Testament, there is guidance about how power should be used. I mean, I'll use Keller as an example. Keller would talk about justice regularly. Well, Justice is ultimately something that the magistrate advances

through the exercise of power.

SPEAKER_00So you can't tell Christians to seek justice, certainly in anything that even touches on government, and then tell them not to seek power. That's an inherent contradiction in terms. And yet I would say it's been used to essentially steer Christians away from substantive engagement with politics. So that would be my thorough rejection. Now, personally, I think that the more important questions, and this is where I don't necessarily think it... I think Christian nationalism is one solution put forward.

SPEAKER_00I'm not sure about the nationalism. I think that... I think that there's arguments that sort of a more civilizational framing might be one that's more in line with the American tradition, but that would absolutely be a Christian vision of civilization that would address a lot of, that would answer a lot of the same questions in a lot of the same ways. So it's not some, so I think that there's very important debates to be had about the specific positive vision that Christians advance, but there's no question that Christians should be putting forth

a positive vision

SPEAKER_00that It touches on questions around the exercise of power in politics, technology, business, as well as what you do in your personal life. Is it worth trying to change the definition of Christian nationalism and make it

SPEAKER_02sound better or just forget it? That's a good... Look, I think that there's people who would take both positions.

SPEAKER_00As I said, it's never been a label that I've embraced. I think that Aaron Wren has the note that nationalism itself has sort of never been... It's never been a prominent term in the American tradition. So I think we're often better off. We're better off focusing on language that is that is already sort of has a positive connotation in the American tradition. So that's how I focus on things. I. I do think that we should certainly reject the sort of,

SPEAKER_00you know, lies that are directed at Christian nationalism. I think there's a lot of people who are, there's a lot of great ideas that have been proposed under that label. And I think that many of the attacks on the label are actually just attacks on the substance that would be sort of redirected to anything there. So I have not personally focused on embracing the label partially because I think strategically it's just, I mean, Trump is very smart about branding, right?

SPEAKER_00Trump knows how to frame things in ways that resonate. I think a lot of Christians could do well to learn from the branding skill of people like Trump and understand how to advance things in a way that really resonates.

SPEAKER_02Okay, last question. You're looking out 15, maybe even 30 years. Tell me what success looks like, not just financially for you, but morally and from the civilizational aspect. What would you hope that somebody is going to say, your kids are going to say that my dad helped build this? I mean, in many ways, I think it's a restoration and a revitalization of our civilization.

SPEAKER_00So it's a renewal of, going back to the Christian side, it's a renewal of Christianity as the primary public ethic that guides our institutions and our elites, which means that even if they aren't personally Christians, they accept that Christian norms and ethics are the default that they should hold to in the way that right now many progressive norms are sort of just widely and pervasively accepted. So it's that restoration of the primacy of Christianity in a

way that was true for

SPEAKER_00much of American history. It is certainly a restoration of a, I think, a restoration of a high trust society, which means that we need to restore a lot of cultural norms, which can be associated with Christianity and others. And I think it's a technological dynamism. We need to be a free country. We need to be a country that has broad-based economic opportunity. We need to be a country where there's sort of people across the country have the opportunity to gain from this technology.

Technology has been applied in a way that was not some, say, giant centralizing force that... essentially centralized all the government in a couple of institutions in Silicon Valley or the Chinese model where it's sort of centralized in the government that

SPEAKER_00rules those. But actually, we retain in many ways the Republican character of America, which includes, I think, distributed economic opportunity and distributed self-government. I think that the Both the businesses, the technology platforms and the businesses that are critical, a critical layer of that are things that I hope to play a significant role in building. Getting back to the mindset from 250 years ago, but with all the technological advances. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_02Nate, this was a great conversation. And by the way, it's not just technology. We definitely need the people and the right philosophy to take us forward. So thank you so much for everything that you're doing.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_02I've been speaking with Nate Fisher. I'm Bambi Francisco Roizen. You've been watching CRT. Yeah.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Other Side Academy CEO Tim Stay on CRT

    Sep 8, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Tim Stay is CEO of The Other Side Academy (TOSA), a long-term treatment and residential program in Utah for people caught in cycles of addiction, incarceration and destructive behavior. Its 2½-year program requires...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The church restores identity beyond the diagnostic label

    Apr 3, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    If there’s a tragic indictment of the 20th century, it is this: institutions became addicted to subscription models. Big pharma and the psychiatric fields are major culprits, essentially capitalizing on natural human...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. AI is ushering in the modern Renaissance man

    Mar 19, 202654 minAudio

    I’m already not driving my son to school (in my Tesla self-driving mode). Now Tesla has introduced cars sans steering wheels, and with that wheel literally gone so goes the small but meaningful bit of responsibility for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Religion is the missing piece in mental health

    Mar 5, 202652 minAudio

    Dr Harold Koenig is founding co-director of The Center for Spirituality, Theology and Health at Duke University Medical School. The center was founded in 1998 to conduct research, and promote dialogue and discussions...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI CEOs seek moral clarity from the Vatican

    Feb 19, 202645 minAudio

    Father Philip Larrey is a Catholic priest and professor of philosophy at Boston College. He previously served as Dean of the Philosophy Department at the Pontifical Lateran University in the Vatican. He’s also the...

    Credit the people on this episode