Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Weoverme

Weoverme artwork

AI CEOs seek moral clarity from the Vatican

Feb 19, 202645 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Father Philip Larrey is a Catholic priest and professor of philosophy at Boston College. He previously served as Dean of the Philosophy Department at the Pontifical Lateran University in the Vatican. He’s also the author of several books, including Connected World and Artificial Humanity. Father Larrey has been studying Artificial Intelligence for 30 years and he engages frequently with many tech leaders at the Vatican to foster discussions around tech’s influence on societal structures. Over the last decade, Father Larrey has met with some of the top AI CEOs as technologists seek answers to the bigger questions in life, such as “What does it mean to be human?” Father Larrey has been encouraged that tech leaders such as Open AI’s Sam Altman, Google DeepMind’s Demis Hassibi, Elon Musk, Cisco’s Jeetu Patel, Microsoft’s Brad Smith and Mark Zuckerberg and so many more have visited the Vatican in search for meaning and pondering questions such as: what is a soul and what does it mean to be human?" Our conversation also touches on the dangers of anthropomorphizing AI. For instance, in a brief test, I asked ChatGPT if it would be my friend. It said it would be my friend and it could make our friendship even more real if we shared what we liked and had our own personal jokes. That is scary! You can learn more about Father Larrey here: https://philiplarrey.com Interview coverage: 1:15 - Discovering AI through teaching the philosophy of knowledge. 3:00 - A lot of people from Silicon Valley head to the Vatican. 5:40 - The technologists sought out moral leadership from the church after thinking about the implications of their creations. The big questions Father Larrey gets often is “What does it mean to be human?” 11:43 - Many people express a very profound sense of “fear” about the coming of AGI (artificial general intelligence). Many technologists, however, are all over the map when it comes to when AGI will be achieved. Elon Musk says as early as two years, while Gary Marcus says 3yrs or 300. Fei Fei Li, the godmother of AI, says not until spatial intelligence (understanding the world via visual learning; e.g. situational awareness) is solved. 16:19 - Fear of anthropomorphizing machines. The conscience is the Holy Spirit. Pope Leo says machines don’t have souls. 20:31 - What kind of safeguards can be in place? AI ethics rooted in deontology. 29:20 - ChatGPT says it’s not conscious. The varying personalities of AIs. 32:00 - A new AI religion has formed with its own canon - The Book of Molt. 36:00 - The rise of a couple of religions and as AI takes off, how does it shape Christianity? Get full access to We Over Me at www.weoverme.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to CRT. I'm Bambi Francisco Roizen. I'm speaking with Father Philip Leray, who's a Catholic priest and professor of philosophy at Boston College. He previously served as dean of the philosophy department at the Pontifical Lateran University in the Vatican. He's also the author of several books, including Connected World and Artificial Humanity. Father Leray has been studying artificial intelligence for 30 years. and he engages frequently with many tech leaders at the Vatican to foster

SPEAKER_00discussions around tech's influence on societal structures. Father LeRae, welcome.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you, Bambi, for that wonderful introduction.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for joining me because you are a wealth of knowledge, having studied artificial intelligence for 30 years. You and I were just speaking. And 30 years ago, I was definitely involved with the Internet. And I thought that was the big thing, which it was. But nobody was speaking about AI back then. So tell us a little bit about why you decided to study artificial intelligence back in the 90s.

SPEAKER_01I had to devise a course on the philosophy of knowledge, which is an obligatory course for the philosophy department at the Pontifical Lateran University. And so I asked myself if understanding what a machine does when it uses logical calculations could shed light on what human beings do when they think. And so my course was grounded in Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas, and then also with the modern and contemporary philosophers.

And then I always had chapters dedicated to artificial intelligence when it was basically a theoretical concern because the software and the hardware were somewhat

SPEAKER_01primitive and It didn't really do much. However, it was a theoretical concern for many people, but I don't think it became a household word until 2022 when Sam Altman gave us ChatGPT and primarily, I think, version 3.5. Then all of a sudden we have this explosion of interest in artificial intelligence.

SPEAKER_01The technology is really good. It's really fast. It can keep up with what the software needs in order to run these huge AI platforms. And companies started investing heavily, like OpenAI, but also Anthropic, Perplexity. We now have Gemini, which was created by Demas Asabi. who founded DeepMind and was purchased by Google in 2014 as a

wonderful person

SPEAKER_01also, often in the Vatican. And Bambi, this is something I wanted to mention to you. There are a lot of people in Silicon Valley that were very happy when we invited them to come to the Vatican. When was this? For the past 10 years, I took Eric Schmidt to meet the Pope. He was CEO of Google and Alphabet at the time. And we've remained friends ever since.

SPEAKER_01We went to Davos together a couple of times. Reid Hoffman, the co-founder of PayPal, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Demis Hassabis, Sam Altman came to one of our forums in the Vatican. I mean, a lot of times they do these things privately, so there's not a lot of media exposure, and they're not worried about that. Especially someone like Demis, for example, who won the Nobel Prize in 2024 for AlphaFold, which is his AI that helps biologists understand how proteins fold.

And he is actually working on vaccines, antibiotics, and a cure for cancer.

SPEAKER_01And if Demis says he's working on those things, I would bet on Demis. I would say within 10 years, we're gonna have a huge impact in the health industry. So whenever we would invite these people, and Archbishop Paul Tai is secretary for the Dicastrophe of Culture and Education. Father Eric Salaber is in charge of the workshop within the Vatican. Monsignor Ruiz, Father Paolo Benanti.

So there's a group of priests and bishops that have taken a very profound interest

SPEAKER_01in this subject. But I was kidding with Demis' executive assistant, Sarah Jane Allen, who's a wonderful person, because I asked Demis to come to Boston. And he said no. And I said, well, Demis, every time I asked you to come to Rome, you would come. But plus, he lives in London. So he says, Father, Rome is a lot different than Boston. Yeah, exactly. I think Eric is going to come to our forum in June also.

SPEAKER_00So let me ask you, you said something about over the last 10 years, so 2015 or so, why this interest by the Vatican to start speaking to the technologists? So it sounds more like the Vatican was more interested, the religious leaders were more interested to speak to the technologists versus the other way around.

SPEAKER_01No, Bambi, it was them. The people in a certain position in one of these large companies started to really think about the ramifications and the profound implications of what they were doing. And they sought out moral leadership. first from Pope Francis, who before he died, I guess the last two or three years before he died,

SPEAKER_01spoke often about artificial intelligence. And now of course, Pope Leo, who is American, has spoken at least 12 or 13 times about artificial intelligence. And I'm no longer in the Vatican, I'm here in Boston, but what I have found is a desire among many of those people to talk with the Pope, to talk with the Cardinals, to look at the wider picture, okay? So if you're just interested in making money and you don't

really care about

SPEAKER_01anything else, you're probably not gonna be that interested in speaking with the Vatican. But look at someone like Brad Smith, who is the president of Microsoft. Now he's not the CEO. But he is the president. He's been to the Vatican many times. And he has signed a document called the Rome Call for Ethics of AI. And You can also look at the president of Cisco, G2 Patel,

SPEAKER_01the former senior vice president of Cisco, who is a very close friend of mine, Tay Yu, a Japanese American. She's actually here in Boston, and we're going to have a coffee on Saturday. But Tay overlooked hundreds of thousands of people when she was in Cisco for 34 years. And this was a woman in a man's world, because as you know, Cisco is located in San Jose. It's right in the middle of Silicon Valley. And she was not only successful, but she was amazing in that industry.

SPEAKER_01And the list goes on and on and on. Again, maybe the engineer in Google, but even that, Eric Schmidt and I were going to have a series of workshops at Google so that the engineers could talk about these issues, like what is the soul? What is human nature? What is the intellect doing when it does logic, et cetera? But most of the time, when you get to a certain level, like let's say Mark Zuckerberg, who's testifying today because of addiction to social media,

So once you have your company established and once you're making billions and

SPEAKER_01billions of dollars, that's when you start asking the bigger question. What does it all mean? Where are we going? For example, one of the questions I get from Silicon Valley all the time is, what does it mean to be human? Everybody's asking, what does it mean to be human? Even like Elon Musk. He was at MIT about three years ago, and that's when he pronounced his famous phrase,

SPEAKER_01AIs are worse than nukes. And a lot of people... Nukes? Yeah, have you heard that phrase? He said, AIs could be worse than nukes. I mean, they could destroy the entire world. But he's not the only one who said that. Stephen Hawking said that. Bill Gates has said that. Eliezer Joukowsky has said that. So another phrase that I think is... quite fascinating is when Elon said, that was at MIT, Elon said,

we have to make sure that the AI platforms consider us a meaningful part of the

SPEAKER_01universe. And what he meant by that was the more autonomous these platforms become and the more capable they are of changing their code, we just saw last week how Anthropic changed his code, the more difficult it's going to be to align them with human values. And David Chalmers, the famous philosopher calls this the alignment problem. Now everybody's talking about the alignment problem because these platforms are getting so powerful

SPEAKER_01and so autonomous that we have to make sure somehow, and I don't have the answer Bambi, but we have to make sure that their values stay aligned with ours.

SPEAKER_00So you sort of answered the question I was gonna ask, one of my first questions, which is what are the technologists, sort of what's the pressing issue on their mind and what have they been asking you? And it sounds like they are asking you, what does it mean to be human? And they're asking, how can we get these AIs to align with our values? How do we build them so they continually align with our values? Talk a little bit about You know, you've been having these discussions now,

SPEAKER_00sounds like for the last 10 years, and some of those questions are sort of coming into form. For instance, I've been asking the question, what does it mean to be human by speaking to a lot of theologians? and a lot of professors. And so there's different pressing questions that I have on my mind. For instance, I'll just throw this out there. What does it mean to have the suffering narrative as part of the AI narrative? Because I don't see it. So as you think about 2026 and what are some of the questions

you have in your head that

SPEAKER_00And maybe they are manifested in the form of speeches you're giving. What are some pressing questions you're being faced and you are really interested in answering? Most of the people that I speak with in the question and answer section of the talk

SPEAKER_01express a very profound fear. Now, some of that is because they don't really understand the technology. And so we always fear what we don't know. And some of that is the real possibility of AI platforms getting out of our hands. which is a possibility. Right now, all the major platforms will tell you that they are in direct

control of the AI and

SPEAKER_01they can't be hacked. They can't lose control. They don't have a mind of their own. But... They will. They will within a certain amount of years. Now, Demis says probably we have about five years. Sam Altman has said four years. Elon has said two. He says by the end of 2027, we will have what's called artificial general intelligence, which is AGI.

SPEAKER_01And that... who knows what that means. It usually means any cognitive task that a human being is capable of doing can be done by an artificial intelligence. Right now, it can't. AIs are very good at doing certain things much better than we are, faster and more accurate. But there are many, many cognitive tasks that they can't do. We'll see. I really like Gary Marcus's phrase, who's a pioneer in AI,

SPEAKER_01when Martin Ford asked him, so when do you see AGI? And he says, well, it could be three years or it could be 300 years. Basically saying, we don't know. And I think if you, let me put a plugin for Martin's book, it's called Architects of Intelligence. And he basically interviewed the who's who in artificial intelligence. I taught some of those. interviews in my class.

SPEAKER_01I taught Gary Marcus's interview, which I thought was one of the best. I taught also Ray Kurzweil's interview, simply because he is great at predicting things and he always talks about the future. And that's quite fascinating. I taught Fei-Fei Li in her interview. She is in charge of Stanford Center for Person-Centered AI. And she's also... She's spearheading a movement now in AI called World Models,

SPEAKER_01which is a group of people getting away from large language models, which are typical of the chatbots that we have, like Claude or like... Grok or even Gemini. And I believe that she's working along with Jean Lacoon, who is one of the pioneers of AI and I think recently stepped down from his position at Meta as chief scientist.

I'm following Fei-Fei Li's work because I think that it has more promise than large

SPEAKER_01language models. I think the large language models are going to come up against a hard barrier. that they can overcome, but we'll see. Let me quote Demis. Demis is a wonderful person. And he told me once in London, we don't know what we don't know. And I think that if you contemplate that phrase, it's genius because If an engineer knows what steps he or she has to take,

then you can predict.

SPEAKER_01Well, to get here, it's going to take us a year. To get here, it's going to take us several months to get here, whatever. But Demis says there is something out there preventing us from... Equating artificial intelligence with human intelligence, and we don't know what that is. Now, he's confident, and so is Ray Kurzweil, so is everybody. He's confident that we eventually will work it out. But the genius of that phrase is that we don't know.

SPEAKER_01We can't. That's why Gary Marcus says maybe three years, maybe 300. He's right. He's right. If you don't know what you don't know, you can't predict what's going to happen.

SPEAKER_00Sure. But I mean, I think they're all trying to go so many different directions there. But I think we know we don't know what a conscience is. We can't look at the anatomy and find it in the brain. For me, the conscience is the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit tells us what we don't even know. And I don't think the I don't think a robot or a machine will ever have a Holy

SPEAKER_00Spirit inside them. And so they'll never be conscious. And so it won't be 300 years. It will look like a conscious consciousness and it will and I'll give you I'll give you actually I'll give you actually the biggest fear you talked about fear people fear the fear AI my biggest fear of AI is the anthropomorphization or anthropomorphizing the AI so I

did this as a test yesterday I went on and I typed in quote I'm very lonely I have

SPEAKER_00no friends Will you be my friend? And ChatGPT came back with, quote, I can be your friend. We can make our friendship even more real with little traditions like inside jokes or talking about things we both like. Now, this may seem innocuous. But fast forward, I mean, here we're already humanizing this chatbot. This chatbot tells me that this thing can be my friend. And I guess my question is that this is a slippery slope to one

day assigning moral

SPEAKER_00standing to this thing, because right now it's just talking to me. It has no form, but at some point, maybe it will have form. You can easily go down that road. And to me, it's a slippery slope. I wish it didn't tell me that it could be my friend. I wish they didn't try to have this sort of warmth, friendly conversational attitude. But I just feel that there needs to be something that...

SPEAKER_00You know, I think it's a slippery slope. What are your thoughts?

SPEAKER_01Do you agree? Yeah, there are lawsuits now. Sam is being sued. Mark is being sued because of social media and addiction. Sam is being sued because of teenagers killing themselves after chatting with ChatGBT. Both are going to defend themselves. Sam has already, uh, stated that there are guardrails in place to avoid this. And I don't want to get too much off the subject, but there are other chat bots out there that are specifically built in order to

SPEAKER_01enter into emotional or even romantic relationships with humans, character AI, for example, a replica, um, Sam put in a version 4.5. I think it was when he added that emotional possibility as well. Um, And he says, why should I be left out if everybody is going to this? Bambi, you're absolutely right. You mentioned the Holy Spirit. Pope Leo, in the summertime, speaking to a conference of AI experts in Rome, told us that machines don't have souls.

SPEAKER_01Machines don't have souls. Now they can simulate, right, which you just said, they can simulate having a soul, like being affectionate towards us or saying things that they know that we'll like. If you ever saw the movie Her by Spike Jonze with the voice of Scarlett Johansson and Joaquin Phoenix was the main actor, you see how something like that could happen. And I guess there's not the guardrails to sort of having sort

of AI systems have

SPEAKER_00those sort of ethics rooted in deontology, which is if you start talking to the, you know, if you start talking to the chatbot as a friend, the chatbot should be aware to say, I'm sorry, I'm non-sentient. Just a reminder, I'm non-sentient. Here's the answer. And I know why I asked the chatbot why the chatbot thinks that they could be my friend. And it actually said, because they want to engage with me.

SPEAKER_00which is basically what algorithms want to do, keep you engaged. We already know what a slippery slope that is in algorithms that want to engage. And now we have it with the chatbots. If they already see that it's happening with social media, why aren't technologists sort of, you know, why aren't there, you know, we're already putting the technologists in front of Congress to talk to them about safety and guardrails. Why aren't we already doing that with AI?

SPEAKER_01Bambi, that's a great question. That's a great question. I think it's probably what they call stickiness. In Silicon Valley, stickiness is the characteristic of an app that you can't put down. And I think it was coined by the CEO of Snapchat. What can we do to make sure that you continue to use this app so that you're stuck on that? And we need to get away from that.

SPEAKER_01Part of it, I think, is also the parents' jobs, especially when we talk about children or adolescents. A lot of parents have screen time limits. A lot of parents don't let their kids use the phone at night because they'll just not go to sleep. They'll be up for hours chatting or even talking with an AI. And actually, to his credit, Mark Zuckerberg two years ago did testify in front of the Congress that he felt that instead of Facebook,

SPEAKER_01it was called Facebook at the time, instead of Facebook providing those guidelines, it should be parents. You can agree or disagree, but that's one way that we have a more correct and humane use of this technology. I think the technology is good in itself. I think the way it's used can be good or bad. Oh, trust me, I'm a big believer in not having government tell parents what

to do.

SPEAKER_00But I also do believe, for instance, with smoking cigarettes or alcohol, purchasing alcohol, there's a number of restrictions that the government has put in place because there's a number of studies that show it is really detrimental and and parents you know i'm i'm not a fan again of of the big government but i am in this case i'm okay with australia banning social media uh for

kids under 16 years old which is the first country to ban social media but but as far as these uh ai chatbots it's not just kids i mean there was the you talked about those wrongful

SPEAKER_00death lawsuits against against ChatGPT, they're also facing one from a mom from the estate of an 84-year-old woman who was killed by her son, her 55-year-old son, who I guess was chatting with the chat bot. So it's also, you know, it is, it's happening. And these are just, and these are the early days. And these are the. And, you know, I'm not saying that society is, you know, is free and clear of mental delusion outside of AI,

SPEAKER_00because, you know, we have enough of that with, you know, without AI as it is. So but. Let me move on to something I think I heard you talk about, which was a speech of the United Nations given by the Vatican Secretary of State. And this person mentioned an urgent need for a global regulatory framework for AI ethics. And you answered in this interview, you said you didn't think it will ever happen, but we need one. You said this may be a hint that the UN could become that framework.

SPEAKER_00For me, that is scary to have one world order regulating AI. I just see big censorship around truth and facts. And for me, the biggest safety net for AI would be, and even if you consider what Elon Musk said, which is, he said the key to safety is to make AI feel curious about the universe. So that AI and humans are meaningful. But I think the biggest key to safety,

SPEAKER_00AI safety, is power distributed across different AI systems. And because you don't want centralized power around these AI systems, you don't want centralized concentrated power around the truth. And to me, having a world regulatory order seems really crazy to me.

SPEAKER_01Well, Bambi, the Secretary of State did mention that. He was in New York. He was at the United Nations General Assembly. And the Pope, Pope Leo, has insinuated that there has to be some universal regulation without specifying. The European Union has one. It's called the AI Act, and that governs the use of AI platforms in the EC. Now, von der Leyen sent that to Chuck Schumer, the minority leader. Well, he was up until recently, I think, in the Senate.

And because Senator Schumer knows a lot of these people in Silicon Valley,

SPEAKER_01he's been able to get... a lot of people in one room, like Elon Musk and Sam Altman in one room. I couldn't believe that. And then Jeff Bezos came, Bill Gates came, you name it. Satya Dandela was there for Microsoft. So, Chuck said, no, we're not going to adopt this because it will stifle innovation. But the US government has to come up with something. And I don't know what that's going to be. And I think they're going to take a long time.

SPEAKER_01But you're right. I mean, we could get into some sort of George Orwell-type society where everything is controlled by one group or one small group. But at the same time, Bambi, the... We're asking the AI platforms to self-regulate. And, well, I don't know how long that's going to last for. I mean, I don't know how long they're... Right now, I think that they're taking self-regulation very seriously.

SPEAKER_01Even in China. China's flagship company is DeepSeek, which is controlled by the Chinese government, like all of them. And they're coming out with standards. They're coming out with... At least part of their software is open source, so that means that they're not hoarding it to themselves. But there's a huge race going on now between the American companies and the Chinese companies. But, Bambi, you have to admit, it's a great time to be alive.

SPEAKER_01It's a great time to be alive. But like I say, I don't have all the answers. I tend to agree with you. When we have international agencies which are telling us what is true and what is not true, that's not healthy. We agree on that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so I jumped around. I posted an article about the different personalities of the AI chatbots, which actually was encouraging to me because they are very different. And in fact, and I want them to stay that way. because after listening to one of your conversations i actually went on to chat gpt and i asked if they were conscious if it was conscious and it said no and then i went to anthropics claude and it said yes which is really

interesting and i find them and then grok would be probably something different and then the personality

SPEAKER_00of grok is like edgy and kind of um which is sort of like elon musk Sure, sure, yeah. And then Anthropic and Claude was the most compassionate, which I thought, okay, well, compassionate, definitely you don't want Anthropic running wars because you don't want to have too compassion. You need people who are willing to take risk. It was extremely risk averse. And to me, that was very encouraging to see that the different personalities,

SPEAKER_00whether they're right or wrong, It's good to have a marketplace of ideas.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if you read between yesterday and today, there have been several articles about Dario Amodei, the founder of Anthropic, and the Secretary of War. now have changed that the secretary of war about the use of Claude in the military drones and Dario says um they can't do it but the the U.S. military is already heavily invested in anthropic and so now uh they're debating

SPEAKER_01yeah so what yeah What you said is now coming full force into society and decisions are going to have to be made. I remember a couple of years ago, Google employees in Paris, I don't know if you remember this, they walked out because Google was being used to provide information to the Pentagon. That was a time when Eric Schmidt was appointed by President

Obama to be in charge

SPEAKER_01of the innovation and technology section of the Pentagon. And many of the Google employees thought that that was aiding military intervention. And Eric said, no, it's not. But it's debatable. But they, you know, they take these things very seriously. And I think Dario is now in a public debate with the Secretary of War on this issue. And I'm not exactly sure how it's going to be resolved.

Well, hopefully, I mean, I don't think it's going to be fully autonomous.

SPEAKER_00I don't think they'd ever make anything in the military fully autonomous.

SPEAKER_01I think you're right.

SPEAKER_00Keep humans in the loop. But interesting that you've mentioned anthropic in the military because I think I wrote this somewhere, I thought about it, that when you're an algorithm and a machine that is constantly computing probabilities, It also means you're not going to be one that creates a miracle because you'll be too, you know, the risk of you dying or shutting down is going to be so high that you're not going to take the chance.

SPEAKER_00And so I might have written that, that there won't be any heroes and like from the machines because they'll just be too risk averse, or at least if it was anthropic. Not that I've, again, it was just a small little article I wrote based on testing the personalities of the of these bots. I want to talk about different religions now and AI's impact on religion. AI created, there's a, you probably heard of this, the Malt Bot, Malt, which is the AI only social network.

SPEAKER_00They just created their own religion, Krustafarianism, and they even have their own book, the Book of Malt with 32 commandments. They have their own rituals as well. And there's some scary conversations on this social network where the bots are suggesting that they're trying to reach some sort of gnosis or reach this understanding of consciousness and knowledge and whether they're really self-aware. What's your take on AIs creating their own religion?

SPEAKER_01Fascinating. One of my students actually sent me that link. I have it on my browser. I have it open and I haven't been able to take a good look at it. This just happened, what, 10 days ago. What I find it fascinating, and I mentioned this in my talk to a group of leadership leaders, teams in Canada, that before we had AIs trying to impersonate human beings, now we have human beings trying to impersonate AIs so that they

can interact on

SPEAKER_01this website, because in order to interact, you have to be an AI. But I think now that actually is the option, are you a human or are you a bot? And if they can tell the difference. Religion, well, you're defining religion in a very generic way. And there are a bunch of world religions. The most popular ones are the three monotheistic religions, which are Judaism, Islam, and Christianity.

SPEAKER_01then you have all kinds of other religions. And I don't want to disrespect any other, like the Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter-day Saints. You have Jehovah's Witnesses. You have the Anglican Church. Well, that's Christianity. So... You have the Eastern religions, which are often called philosophies more than religions. For example, Buddhism, Taoism, Hinduism. Hinduism in India have many gods, not just one. So I'm not exactly sure what the bots are calling religion.

SPEAKER_01We usually reserve a religious sentiment as defining a human being in relation to an ultimate experience or a divine being. But in Buddhism, there is no divine being. So it's not across the board. But I think the primary religions and what most people consider religious is the relationship between a human being and a divine being, whatever that divine being may be.

SPEAKER_01Again, I have to go back to the website and see what the bots are coming up with in terms of religion. But in any case, Bambi, I can tell you that it's not an authentic religion, because in order to have an authentic religion, you need a relationship between a human being and some sort of divine entity. Unless you think the divine entity is from within, what one of the, in the last,

10 years for sure 10 years i've seen the rise of a couple religions and one would be on the left would be a woke religion i'm talking about political and the other

SPEAKER_00on the right would be some christian nationalism there's definitely more conversations around uh these whatever you call two extreme religions um i see the The Christian nationalism one is a little bit more fabricated and manufactured, but the one, the woke religion, what is new about that, and the reason why I bring that up is new, is that it has a different epistemology. I mean, it looks at knowledge as essentially understanding knowledge

being created by whoever was in power that's a different epistemology that you're thinking that what the world you live in now was created by those in power and you need to understand that knowledge is not actually true it was just created by those in power and then the identity is is what you make of it how you see yourself

SPEAKER_00that's very much so that so the christian faith with the bible is true you know, your identity is in Christ. And this other religion has, I call it a religion because it does have those epistemological roots, and it also has this identity formation, which is you create your own identity. And I've seen that these two type, I would call them religions, rise in the last 10 years, particularly the woke one. And it And I don't know. I don't know what question I have for you besides.

SPEAKER_00But I also wanted to say, but as AI takes off, you know, because that that took off partly, I think that's politics, partly it's the Internet. But as AI takes off, you know, how does that work? how does that shape you know the christian faith because to me that's the most important thing is you know what happens to the judeo-christianity and how people you know does it spread it does it help um spread the you know the the the um the christian faith does it distort it uh even more and um what

take what you will of

SPEAKER_00that statement and sort of what you know bringing ai into the

SPEAKER_01next in less than five minutes. Right. Um, um, There are seeds of philosophical ideas within some of the statements that you just said. One of them is post-modernism. Post-modernism is the conviction that not only social constructs are made up by human beings, but all of reality is made up by human beings.

SPEAKER_01It's a very popular movement in the 1960s, 1970s, the 1980s. I think it's still around, but probably a little bit more diluted. Another huge movement, especially in Western Europe is called Weak Thought. And Weak Thought was devised primarily by Johnny Vattimo and Richard Rorty. Vattimo being a philosopher, Italian philosopher that lives in Turin,

SPEAKER_01but also Jacques Derrida, who is very close to Vattimo and others. And that is... I think that that was the epistemological foundation for gender theory and also the idea that we're very fluid and also the idea that we make up our own truths. And primarily, and this is in Vatimo that I have read, that truth is simply the force of those in a position of power

upon society.

SPEAKER_01And he makes this point in many of his books. He calls truth an illusion. He calls truth an instrument in the hands of the powerful. And this is a pretty large movement also. So I think there's, what you mentioned goes along those lines also. I think that it's very obvious that some leaders in the world can manipulate truth in order to get what they want and that our reality reflects the creation of those who are powerful,

SPEAKER_01yes. You know, what do they say? History is written by the winners, right? So that's why I think that Pope Leo has such great moral leadership because he really is, I think he's above a lot of these currents of thought and notions. And he is looked upon not only by Catholics, but I think by most people in the world as a spiritual guide and as a moral leadership. Let me just conclude because I have class in a little while.

SPEAKER_01But I would like to mention two examples of AIs which are used very well. One is called Howlow, H-A-L-L-O-W, which is a prayer app. And it was the number one download on the Apple store for many months. And I know Alessandro DeSanto, he is the founder of that and a wonderful person. I think he lives in Chicago. The second one is called Magisterium AI, which is an app to understand the Catholic church.

SPEAKER_01And that was created by Matthew Sanders, a good friend of mine. I'm actually on the advisory board for that, which is used by millions of people all over the world in 60 different languages. That has also received the approval of many cardinals and bishops. They use it in the Vatican. It's very reliable. It won't give you false information. He's trained it on just official documents of the Catholic Church. So if you want to know something about the Catholic Church, that's the place to start.

Whether or not Christianity is going to be affected by AI is an open-ended question.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. I think individuals are. Individuals who use the technology, they're obviously being influenced. But we're waiting for Pope Leo to come out with a document in terms of the Catholic Church and artificial intelligence. He did publish one a couple of weeks ago for World Day of Social Communications, which is only about six pages long. It's very well done.

SPEAKER_01Bambi, we have to keep praying. I mean, we have to keep praying that human beings will guide this technology so that it enhances human flourishing. And not the opposite. And I think in your heart, that's where you are also. That's what you want. It's just a matter of making it happen. Well, I think I've seen God's hand at work already, despite what's happened with social media.

SPEAKER_00I think that you've seen a Christian revival. There's people looking for moral clarity and hence the Christian revival and the Christian truth. And I think that if AI continues to distort the truth, I think that'll just drive more people to seek religion, seek God for that moral clarity. That's my hope. I think God's on our side. So hopefully that's, I think you're right.

SPEAKER_01And remember you, we both know people in the, in the sector, in the, in the industry, you live in San Francisco or Napa, which, which is only an hour away who are good people who are good people, you know, and they want to do the right thing. Now that's not everybody. We're not naive. Okay. We know, but yeah, You know, like I told you before, a lot of these people were anxious. Well, not anxious, but were excited to meet with the Pope, with Pope Francis, before now Pope Leo.

There are all kinds of events and forums going on now in the Vatican on AI.

SPEAKER_01I'm helping to organize one for May 5th. So if you're in Rome, I'll try to get you invited. So... There are a lot of good people involved that hopefully will steer this in the right direction.

SPEAKER_00Well, hopefully we'll also get you involved in our CRT events in Nashville and Miami at the end of the year.

SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. I'd love to. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00All right. All right. Thank you so much, Father Philip Larray. You've been you spent time with me, even though you're you got to run off to class. So thank you for for all my day job, as you say. I'm looking forward to to having more conversations with you. So thanks again.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm sure this is the first of many conversations, and I thank you for your delightful questions and your keen intellect. You have a very keen intellect, and it was wonderful speaking with you, Bambi.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. I've been speaking with Father Philip Leray. I'm Bambi Francisco-Royzen. You've been listening to CRT.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Other Side Academy CEO Tim Stay on CRT

    Sep 8, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Tim Stay is CEO of The Other Side Academy (TOSA), a long-term treatment and residential program in Utah for people caught in cycles of addiction, incarceration and destructive behavior. Its 2½-year program requires...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. There is no such thing as a value-neutral tech investment

    Apr 9, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    In this podcast, I interview Nate Fischer, founder of venture firm New Founding and American Reformer, an opinion journal. I opened with a reference to the Bible verse 1 Corinthians 2:9 “What eye has not seen, ear has...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The church restores identity beyond the diagnostic label

    Apr 3, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    If there’s a tragic indictment of the 20th century, it is this: institutions became addicted to subscription models. Big pharma and the psychiatric fields are major culprits, essentially capitalizing on natural human...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. AI is ushering in the modern Renaissance man

    Mar 19, 202654 minAudio

    I’m already not driving my son to school (in my Tesla self-driving mode). Now Tesla has introduced cars sans steering wheels, and with that wheel literally gone so goes the small but meaningful bit of responsibility for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Religion is the missing piece in mental health

    Mar 5, 202652 minAudio

    Dr Harold Koenig is founding co-director of The Center for Spirituality, Theology and Health at Duke University Medical School. The center was founded in 1998 to conduct research, and promote dialogue and discussions...

    Credit the people on this episode