I wanted to try a different format to work through my thoughts on Nonfiction November's The New Dark Ages by James Marriott. Overall, I thought the book provided a baseline to discuss literacy but left me with more questions than answers. This is a critique I often have with nonfiction books: the author makes a compelling argument, but what am I supposed to do with the information? To be fair, I fully acknowledge that I might be asking the book to do something it was not intended to do: solve the literacy crisis, rather than explain how we got here. Marriott’s core argument is that mass production of the printing press enabled widespread literacy, which in turn supported the Enlightenment, scientific progress, and modern democracy. The ability to read, engage with complex ideas, and evaluate evidence became foundational to modern democratic societies' function. I’m paraphrasing here because aht aht… While I understand his argument, this framing relies specifically on Western ideologies of progress. Societies existed long before the printing press, and many cultures have sophisticated systems of governance, knowledge-sharing, and oral traditions that do not rely primarily or at all on printed word. So idk fam… I digress, Marriott argues that as “our” society moves away from written forms of knowledge, we will eventually lose critical thinking and reasoning skills. In his account, the decline started with the introduction of radio, then TV/film, and has been accelerated by the internet and social media. Marriott cites conversations with his professor friends who report students struggling to read and, overall, a tendency to prefer shorter, less complex content. He presents this observation as evidence of an attention gap, coupled with declining literacy rates in the US and UK. As a sidebar, the literacy rates in the United States and the United Kingdom are often discussed (in my opinion) as being uniquely in crisis. While I do believe something is afoot, these countries are comparable globally but may be lagging behind smaller countries (World Population Review). So I agree, the inability to engage with print material might create an environment where we can’t have reasoned arguments which then could lead to people being more susceptible to overly simplified reasoning. I see this often online in straw man arguments, where someone oversimplifies or misrepresents someone’s position to make it easier to attack. Here, I think Marriot is on to something. The point of reasoning isn’t just about being right; it’s providing supporting evidence, which is lost if you rely on unchecked sources. The danger here is that not all written text is factual. A point he also makes. Marriott doesn’t romanticize written text as inherently truthful. Misinformation exists. That's why reading alone isn't enough. Critical engagement with the source material is necessary, i.e., literacy. So what is the point? If declining literacy threatens democracy and critical thinking, what are people but more specifically, readers supposed to do? Marriott suggests that readers need a compelling argument to read beyond “it’s good for you,” and stops there. In my head, if literacy is so foundational, why stop at identifying the problem? Deep sigh. So here’s what I’m thinking… * We should have accessible discussions about the reading and literacy crisis. I think it’s very important that we can’t have this conversation without also considering the growing number of book bans and challenges, and the inequalities in access to books. * Using clearer language about reading and literacy. Reading and literacy are related but not interchangeable: * Reading is the process of decoding text and constructing meaning (yes, this includes audiobooks). * Literacy is a broader skill that includes reading, writing, speaking, listening, critical thinking, and social communication. Communicating what you’ve read. * Sharing alternative pathways to literacy. Reading remains important, but literacy can also be strengthened through discussion, writing, and digital analysis. * Book community solutions. I’d love to crowdsource ways readers encourage reading among to their non-reading friends and family. In the end, The New Dark Age wasn’t perfect, but I think we have to do something more than just pointing out that there’s a problem, there needs to be actionable solutions to support literacy (including political, digital, and social media literacy). Would I recommend this book? Sure, with the caveat I personally wanted more practical solutions, but it certainly gave me plenty to think about. Thanks for reading Weekend Reader’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit weekendreaderx.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi, friends. I wanted to try a different format to talk about the nonfiction November pick, The New Dark Era by James Marriott. And part of the reason why I want to try and do a video and a Substack post is because while I think the book did some really interesting things, I have some thoughts. Okay. So if you've been following me this year,
SPEAKER_00I've been focused a lot on literacy and reading, improving my reading specifically. And I've been using romance as my case study, if you will. And part of that is because it's a genre that I read and I believe it does the things that a lot of people say it doesn't do in terms of engaging Increasing your literacy, okay? So that's my bias and the hill I will die on.
SPEAKER_00So I picked up The New Dark Ages because it ties into that really neatly or nicely. And I read it last month in preparation for Nonfiction November, and I was hoping that it would have Some really interesting thoughts about the book and to have longer and more in-depth conversations about it. Pump the brakes. I have some thoughts. And overall, what I will say is my takeaway is that I think I wanted the book
SPEAKER_00to do something that it wasn't intended to do. So what it What it does do is provide some context about the direction we're headed in terms of if we never address the literacy crisis. And so let's start from the beginning. What is the book talking about? The title gives it away. From James Marriott's point of view, we are moving towards a dark age or a new version of the dark ages.
SPEAKER_00And in this post-literate society. And his core argument is the reduction of our reliance and use of printed material is why we are moving towards this new era. And so the title itself, right, is the framing and opinion of the author. And he does set it up
SPEAKER_00to share interesting points of history to, for a better lack of words, prove his point. If you believe that printed material or printed text is a form of knowledge. So he talks about the access to and mass production of printed material is where democratic societies were the most thriving.
SPEAKER_00That's where we saw thinkers and being able to see innovation. Now you will know, he points out that Printed materials prior to mass production existed, but a lot of that was related to people related to their work or for the elite class. So he, I think, made some really good comparison or draws a connection that prior to mass access to printed material,
SPEAKER_00That only a certain type of person would be able to engage in society in a way that would be of influence. And in that regard, as we continue to not rely on printed text and information, we might be moving back to a place where there's only a small group of people will have that ability to engage with printed material. And he spends a lot of time really framing it
SPEAKER_00in terms of without this form of literacy, we are going to lose the ability to reason and logic and struggle with source materials, right? Source of truth and being able to engage with texts. And in that regard, I understand history. And this is where I think I want the book to do something that it wasn't intended to do.
SPEAKER_00It excludes communities and cultures where written text has never been the source of truth. Ways of knowing has always been orally communicated or in symbols or some other form of Knowledge generation outside of text. He does acknowledge that, but it doesn't go into details. Now, as a reader or a writer, excuse me,
SPEAKER_00part of what you need to do is ground the reader in what the argument you're trying to make. And so the argument he's trying to make is written text is important. And these examples that he's going to share throughout the book is really rooted in proving or supporting that argument. So he is not intending to argue that oral traditions are not important. He makes a point to say that they are important and written text is not queen.
SPEAKER_00So let's put a point in that Critique I have of the book. He does acknowledge that written text, specifically using the US and the UK as his grounding or supporting documents or points of reference for his argument. So, which is really key here, right? Because the US and the UK are countries
SPEAKER_00that have For lack of argument, mass resources. So what is it in terms of not engaging with written texts? He uses examples of professors not being able to teach the classics. And students not really engaging or being prepared to read classics. And from his estimation, it's because the sentences, the prose are not something that they're used to.
SPEAKER_00And because of that, anything that seems difficult, they don't want to engage in. So professors are noting that we're seeing it in terms of writing levels have decreased over time. So these are the points that he's trying to make. Point of A connection here is that he does not really talk about access,
SPEAKER_00might be part of that in terms of do you have access to the classics to be able to read those and understand them and being in an environment where that's a priority and or you have tools to be able to navigate that. No one picks up a classic in Just gets it, right? You have to read and reread, okay? That's neither here nor there, but the point that he's trying to make is there is a pattern that professors
SPEAKER_00in his circle have identified as something of concern. And why is this important is that he is making a connection that We are no longer able to grapple with text that's difficult. It is easier to be able to essentially be controlled, right? This is where shorter sentences, catch phrases,
SPEAKER_00it's easier for you to repeat without really understanding what that means. And I think Here's where I think he could have done a better job of, he is citing stats and examples, but he does the thing that he's saying reduce literacy. So he cites lower literacy rates.
SPEAKER_00What does that actually mean though? As someone who cares about literacy and wants to know it, I had to go back and contextualize that with, for the US specifically, I believe the last thing that I saw was reading levels are at sixth grade. So that is the soundbite that typically people will use to describe the literacy crisis in the US.
SPEAKER_00Well, do you actually know what that means? How do you contextualize that? Especially as an adult, you don't remember what's going on in the sixth grade. Well, what that actually means is that a sixth grade level is that you are able to read, but longer text and logic is not the focus. What you are trying to do is read to understand what is happening on page, but you're not able at that reading level to maybe identify subtext,
SPEAKER_00or you might not be able to Identify metaphors or analogies, right? That's closer to a ninth grade and or college reading level. So this is where I think we fall in the trap of talking about a crisis and not contextualizing, well, what part of the crisis do we need to have a better grasp on, right? I think, too, that I fall in the trap of, oh, yeah, there's a literacy crisis,
SPEAKER_00but don't really know what that means, right? And how do we contextualize that in terms of banning books or books becoming expensive to actually print and then e-books not owning them? All of those things, right? Here's where I point to where I think I wanted the book to do something that it wasn't intended to do. So that's neither here nor there. But now having the baseline of understanding adults being at a sixth grade level,
SPEAKER_00it contextualizes or has me thinking about why online sometimes people are missing the points of books. Because if their reading levels are at a certain rate, then it is easy to miss some of the things that the author might be trying to do. So how do we move someone from a sixth grade reading level to, say, a college reading level or an appropriate reading level for their age? He doesn't cover that.
SPEAKER_00Other than to say that we, folks who care about the literacy crisis, have to have a better argument about why people should read to non-readers beyond the fact that And so I've been thinking a lot about that for myself. And one of the ways that I think that looks like is you have to learn how to read or you have to read to sign contracts here in Florida
SPEAKER_00because Amendment 3 just passed. I think if people understood and were able to contextualize that amendment, we wouldn't be here now trying to redo So it's really showing really concrete ways that if we don't address the reading and literacy crisis, there are actual adverse consequences. Again, Amendment 3 would be an example of that.
SPEAKER_00And so part of what I want to do as I continue to think about this book is to start Advocating and working through, well, how do I, as someone who's embedded in the bookish community, do a better job of not just pointing out a literacy crisis, but also helping inform without being condescending? Because I don't want to go down that route. To teach people how we got here.
SPEAKER_00And part of how I've been trying to fix that or address that is in my author interviews, I'm asking questions to help pinpoint things I think I'm picking up and having the author confirm that and talk about their process and talk about the context, right, of in which that they're hoping readers to do. So I think as A collective, which is the approach I prefer to take, right?
SPEAKER_00Because I culturally grew up in a collective environment where the decisions I make, I understand will impact other people. I want to make sure that if I'm learning and improving this skill, that I can also pass that along to other people. So was the book perfect for me? No, but what it did do is help me see things that I can actively do to ensure literacy because I'm going
SPEAKER_00to continue to use romance as a baseline to talk about and read and think about or read closely. Because there is a difference between critical reading and close reading, I think for me, I want to stay in the area of close reading. So big picture-wise, should you read the book? Yes. Do I have issues with the book? Also yes. Do I think it does a good job with starting the conversation? No. Yes.
SPEAKER_00And that is why I think I would recommend it more so that it is a source of truth, which I don't think any book should be a source of truth. You should be pulling together books to be able to make a stronger argument. So the takeaway here is that I will be doing a little bit of additional research. I say research, but It's really about trying to share collective environments and cultural pinpoints where written text is not necessarily a deterrent
SPEAKER_00to their literacy crisis. You can still use it and be in this environment and be literate. And here's how I think that looks in the bookish space as a thread in my head. We tend to do it already where you are looking for certain accounts to be able to help confirm your understanding of the book or to help you think about a book a different way. So you do it already in some ways where not one person talking about a book.
SPEAKER_00Is enough, you might source some different things. So I think being able to have that kind of wraparound ecosystem of understanding and reading books is a healthy way to approach in the improvement of your and my own literacy. The second thing is that I want, so I'm going to look for communities, And frameworks and not frameworks, but communities where their structure is really
SPEAKER_00to help people understand and ways of knowing that it takes a collective approach and try to apply that to the book community. So I'm going to try and make that connection at some point. And then I also want to work on a project where I'm asking readers to say, well, how are we talking and encouraging non-readers to read in order to combat the reading and literacy crisis? Because if we're going to just stay in acknowledging that there's a crisis
SPEAKER_00but not doing anything about it, are we not complicit? And so I want to be an advocate for maybe part of the reason why romance is a draw to a lot of people is perhaps the reading level, which I can't remember. I'll try and find the stat and put it somewhere on the screen. But I believe someone said that writing is typically at an eighth grade level reading.
SPEAKER_00Which to me is a point of access, right? So if we're saying that most adults are at sixth grade reading level and romance is at the eighth grade reading level, there's a gap that we can close and then also increase over time. So my approach to that is why not use the resources And where people are and then encourage them to go from there. And this is why when I started the project at the beginning of the year, I was like, hold on.
SPEAKER_00I think there's a lot of secret sauce happening that's not occurring online, right? So I want to take some time and really start thinking about and really pulling sources, resources from you all to say, well, how are we going to encourage non-readers to read? Beyond, which is one of the points that Marriott makes, is beyond, it's good for you, right? And one of the ways that I can immediately think about that is, again, Amendment 3, right?
SPEAKER_00So how can we help increase literacy and reading without the judgment, without the shame, We got to move away from the audiobooks. It's not reading rhetoric because it's not true. It's backed by science that reading with your eyes or listening to an audiobook, it lights up the same parts of your brain, so you do it. So stop it.
SPEAKER_00Really just stay rooted in not just saying the literacy crisis, but how do we move a reader, a non-reader, to be a reader or a reader who might have missed the context of a book to helping them get there? Now, that is a cross I'm not necessarily—I don't think we all have to bear because some people just want to be rooted in their not-knowing. But I do think for the people who want to get better or who want
SPEAKER_00to increase their literacy, what talking points can we do to help them along? So that is where I am. I'm going to clean this up, edit it, and then post with some specific passages from the book that I want to highlight, again, to talk through where I themed. It really does a good job of understanding and then loop back to places that I wanted a little bit more because using
SPEAKER_00the US and the UK as the source of your argument already is an interesting decision. However, that's lived experience and points of reference I understand why you would go there and do that, but it helps me as the reader understand that the points, the supporting points of the arguments are rooted in the idealism
SPEAKER_00of these countries being the benchmark for literacy. And I don't necessarily know if that is a fair assessment. However, I recognize that there is a crisis. There is something happening that we should address. Now, I believe the key skills of being able to see and acknowledge when things are not right is becoming difficult.
SPEAKER_00And we are using the umbrella term of critical thinking as the missing skill. And so, you know, I don't have a disagreement or a counterargument to that. So, you know, I want to acknowledge that there's something there. So what can we do to support literacy? And what can we do? Well, let's start with what can we do to encourage reading?
SPEAKER_00And what can we do to support literacy? Because again, those two things are different and you have to have one to have the other to move through things. So as you can tell by this video and my bouncing thoughts, why it might have been hard to actually just write this because it would have sounded like I was just poo-pooing on the book, which I don't want to do, but there are There are certain points
SPEAKER_00that are more important to me than the whole argument of the book. And so I want to leave it there and I want to open up some discussions. And if you have some ideas on how to encourage reading and support literacy, I definitely want to talk about that. I do want to say I will continue this... Filter of encouraging reading and literacy through the lens of romance, that's not going away, through next year.
SPEAKER_00And so I'm hoping to pull in and really revisit and bring back the nonfiction times romance project to help support my argument that let's meet people where they are and then support their literacy through pairings of Different types of literature. All right. So thank you for sitting with me and listening to me. And I hope to do this format a little bit more.
Hear Me Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where Katrina Jackson and I bring our offline romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why...