Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Weekend Reader’s Substack Podcast

Weekend Reader’s Substack Podcast artwork

EP 3: Romance Formula & Worldbuilding

Aug 4, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where Katrina Jackson and I bring our offline romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an invitation to continue the conversation well after the mic is off. In this episode, we tackle how romance gets a bad rep for being “formulaic”. In my humble opinion, the only formula is that it must have a HEA or HFN. For the naysers, having a destination isn’t the same as knowing how they got there. The journey looks different. Romance authors have a chance to build fascinating worlds, create complex characters, and, as Katrina mentioned, experiment. Can we convince you the convention doesn’t mean predictable? And a contemporary does not mean there is no worldbuilding. This episode might truly be a hear me out conversation. Thanks for reading Weekend Reader’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit weekendreaderx.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01But if you're writing or you hope to write, say, like a Harlequin category romance, you do not have room for that per their guidelines, right? So learning how to write, because I think their limitations, Cheryl Green has talked about this because she started her career with Harlequin and Kimani. And she talked about how when she moved indie, she had so perfectly gotten down. I think the Harlequin cap was like 50,000 words. She had so perfectly gotten her romances paced for that,

SPEAKER_01that she had to sort of break that sort of conditioning apart, right? Or things that people complain about. I don't know how much they complain about it now, but a lot of people say they don't like romances and deal with the same couple over and over again. Oh, eat that up. Same. And there used to be series where that was the case, right? Where like a singular book did not mean that like this is the end of their story. You could see them- Again and again and again. And it's their story as opposed to like a sort of cameo.

SPEAKER_01And so romances actually don't. I think people assume and then try and impose that all romances have to look the same in form. And they really don't. But I do think that sometimes that more complicated work becomes a better fit for women's fiction because of sometimes the expectation For how a romance should unfold. But you can play with that. You should play with that if you want to.

SPEAKER_00And I think you made a good point about you have to find your reader, right? Because I talk about like, yeah, I'm a romance reader, but I don't like this and I don't like that. And then I find an author who did that thing that I just said I didn't like. And now I'm like, okay, well, now I can't say that anymore. But you brought up a good point. Because I've been reading romance from, like, back in the day, I love a good check-in. I love a good... Because I don't assume that they're, you know, together forever.

SPEAKER_00Something could happen. Like, life happens. And as a reader, if I'm going to fall in love with a couple, I want to know. You could give me... 30 books on Sal and Shay. She's going to be pregnant every book. I know that to be true. But the stakes are going to continue to get higher. And we've talked about this too, where romance gets a bad rap for not having world building.

SPEAKER_00But I think, again, because I've been reading for so long where there used to be series, that's where I could easily see, yeah, no, Part of the shortcut, right, is that you are in current times, you kind of know what's going on, but culturally that could look different, right? Oh, absolutely. And so there is some world building. I mean, the world building is believing that love or the romantic relationship could happen, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I agree. I think that people discount worldbuilding and contemporary romance because they don't actually know what to look for. Because, I mean, I think we're really used to looking at, like, right, I know that conversation about worldbuilding has come up as a critique of, like, modern romanticcy.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01I don't read it, so I really don't know, like, what to say. But I did used to read a lot of fantasy with romantic elements and, you know, fantasy romance, which is slightly different. I love paranormal romance.

SPEAKER_00I love paranormal.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So those genres or subgenres tend to have a lot of worldbuilding. Like, my best example of that, I think, is, at least in terms of what I personally love, is Kit Rosh's Beyond series. It has an incredible amount of worldbuilding. But after the first couple of books, you don't need that much, right? So they set such a great foundation. But in contemporary romance, for instance, like Christina C. Jones, I think, does really fantastic worldbuilding. But the worldbuilding is like the communities, like the building, right?

SPEAKER_01The friend groups, you know, she'll create like... Historically black colleges, right? Like Nicole does something similar, or Nicole Falls does something similar when she's, a lot of her books are set in Chicago. And so like the world building around that is like letting you know, like here is a Chicago that her characters are inhabiting, right? I think that most people sort of, Downworld building and contemporary romance because they expect it to look the way that it does in fantasy or paranormal.

SPEAKER_01It doesn't have to. And yeah, you do have a shortcut in that, like, we are all living in a world where there are cell phones and email, et cetera. But, you know, a working class character in the South, for instance, is going to have a different contemporary world than a wealthy Japanese businessman who is, you know, In the U.S. to find his life. I don't know, right? Or even if you read romance class,

SPEAKER_01contemporary Filipino romance is and should feel very different, the contemporary world they're living in, than, say, the world that I would be creating in a contemporary

SPEAKER_00romance. And all of that is contingent on the author being able to describe the setting, right? Don't understand the family dynamics, which would be an example of world building, or the external conflict, or even the internal conflict. All of those things impact the world building on whether or not they're together.

SPEAKER_00I think part of that, though, is the imagination. It's easier to see if you're talking about a magic system or hierarchy in a pack or something along those lines where the author has to explain something in great detail. Whereas if it's set in Chicago, you might not pick up on this is an important cue about this How it's functioning

SPEAKER_00in this place because you're like, oh, this is Chicago. And I sometimes think about it too, like when authors are writing particularly niche jobs for their characters, that is part of world building. And it's always really funny when someone who works in that field and is like, well, that's not how it works. And well, technically in this world, it does.

SPEAKER_01And sometimes that matters and sometimes it doesn't, right? But yeah, yeah, exactly. Like that niche job, like when I write academics, like I'm writing academics from, you know, not just the standpoint of like, this is what academia looks like, but this is what academia looks like for people of color, right? Which can be a very different academia than what it looks like for white people or, you know, white people versus queer people.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Or people from the mainland U.S.,

SPEAKER_01Yeah, international faculty

SPEAKER_00like in the U.S.

SPEAKER_01have a very different experience. Yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and all of this, the end goal is the HEA. It's the HFN. But then when we remove that it has to be love and it focused on the satisfactory ending, that feels so much more subjective. So being That's why some readers are like, well, if they end up together, then that's it. But we've talked about offline where it's like, yeah, they shouldn't have ended up together.

SPEAKER_00The conflict didn't have enough time to resolve to feel satisfactory. I love when you usually point out what has changed from the beginning of the book to now. For the characters to stay together. And sometimes I'm like, the fact is that he still loves her. Or he still wants to be with her. That is the indicator, right?

SPEAKER_01Which... Sure. I think that I think most romances have a happy for now ending. Like if we're still using that old parlance. Like instead of it happily ever after. I feel like that's a heavy weight. I have said, until then people die. This is not an H.E.A. for me. It just cannot be, right? Because, like, after means a thing, right? Happy for now, I think, is a much less, and I don't know when the R.W.A. added that as an option. And I think it does actually,

SPEAKER_01I think of a satisfactory ending as sort of leaning towards the H.F.N., right? Because I think it sort of lessens the weight of some of the other things that have happened, right? If you have written a third act breakup, You will never in your life convince me that's an HEA. That automatically for me has to be an HFN because words are cheap, right? And you won't really know if you have really sort of laid the foundation for whatever that conflict was until maybe six months, a year, two years, five years later, right?

SPEAKER_01But have you gotten to a point where these two characters are at the space where they are willing to tough it out? I think you can show that, right? That's different than They were together for the rest of it. I think also some people think they were together for the rest of their lives and nothing ever happened. And I'm like, I just don't think that's realistic. Even if you're just thinking like, and I think that also too, some of this hinges on like How real or not you want your romances to be.

SPEAKER_01So if you want to be totally delude, like, yes, two weeks ago, he did tell her that, like, he loved his ex and he wants to go back and give it a try. And even though 16 hours later, he realized that he had made a mistake and he came back, yes, they are going to be together forever. No. Like, for me, personally, no. But if that's for you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I don't love the third act breakup. I love a first act or a second act, but something about that third act, I'm like, there is not enough time. But something about that third doesn't give enough time, unless you play with time in the third act, right? Where it's like, okay, now they've been away from each other for some time, because then that feels like there's room to really unpack the conflict.

SPEAKER_00But that doesn't often happen. If it's the third act, you have two to three, maybe five chapters to make it work and get them back together. But that again is like a indicator to me where it's not about necessarily about love, it's about them being together in the end. And that to me feels almost like there's no Santa Claus anymore. I don't know why, but it just does. And it doesn't change my enjoyment of romance,

SPEAKER_00but it does help me kind of bring down my expectations a little bit because we talked about The HFN, most romances being there. And I'm like, I wonder if that's why I was about to save someone's book. And I don't want to do that because I don't want to put anyone on blast. But it is in one of my recent posts where I was like, they shouldn't have ended up together or they would not have made it.

SPEAKER_01Oh, it was my book. You could have said it. That's not my book. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't. You know the book I'm talking about. We've talked about it. Because, you know, there is that wish fulfillment of needing to hear or read it on page that they are together, that openness feels, I don't know, maybe anxiety-ridden, why I think some authors are feeling like, yes, you have to say that they're together.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I wonder too, like the time thing, if that's why people started, or, and I don't know when this happened, so this is a guess, but people started writing the epilogues in the way they do, where you get the significant time jump. So it's like, okay, this is two weeks, you know, that last chapter, or the last couple chapters, or like a couple weeks later, then the epilogue has a significant time jump so that you know, same with the epilogue baby, like not just that they like maybe got married and are together, but that they had a baby, they're building a family, and you get that sort of like settled feeling After the epilogue in a way

SPEAKER_01that there's maybe not quite time to do in the actual body of the book. Which to me is like... I love an epilogue. I love an epilogue, but I don't like a significant time job. Okay. I love a...

SPEAKER_00Go ahead.

SPEAKER_01I was going to say, I love a two days later and he's, you know, or they're still fucking their brains out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, to me though... Then just make that a chapter.

SPEAKER_01No, because sometimes—well, never mind. Because I do this constantly, so I was really just going to defend myself. It does not matter.

SPEAKER_00I mean, don't get me wrong. There are a couple of—there's one book that I read, and I keep thinking about it because I cannot put my finger if it's an HFN or an HEA because at the end of the book, they are not together. But in the epilogue, they are. We'll talk about

SPEAKER_01that offline.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I love the book. I love the pacing of the relationship because it was a poly-established couple and a third. And they actually, on page, aren't... We'll talk about it all.

SPEAKER_01But see, my thing is, even though I said, no, write the epilogue, you won. My thing is, if they end the book not together, Write a second book so that epilogue makes sense. I don't know why. We'll talk about it. I think that sometimes people force an HEA where an HFN would give them a little bit more leeway.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So the book ended on an HFN, right? Because the couple, the main couple are together and they leave it open for the third to come back.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I see. Oh, then I absolutely want the second book because how the fuck you get this person back?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think you have to feel comfortable playing with romance forms. And I think a lot of authors aren't comfortable with that. And I think a lot of readers are not comfortable when people play with form as well.

SPEAKER_00Mm hmm. That makes sense because this author is fairly new. I mean, so I could see in a room or in a space where she's just like, no, this needs to end because I do not believe any of her books are interconnected. They're like standalone, one and done. But there are at least two books where I'm like, no, this should be

SPEAKER_01a series.

SPEAKER_00You've introduced too many good Subplots here. I mean, clearly I'm feral for a good story. And I think that's the beauty of finding an author fairly at the beginning of their career, because then you can see if they're really good at the beginning, what that will look like over time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nonfiction November Thoughts

    Nov 16, 202624 minAudio

    I wanted to try a different format to work through my thoughts on Nonfiction November's The New Dark Ages by James Marriott. Overall, I thought the book provided a baseline to discuss literacy but left me with more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Hear Me Out BWB Part 2

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    Hear Me Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hear Me Out Podcast EP 5 -BWB Part 1

    Oct 26, 202658 minAudio

    Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EP 5: Hear Me Out Podcast

    Sep 10, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EP 4: Hear Me Out Podcast

    Sep 7, 202633 minAudio

    Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...

    Credit the people on this episode