Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where Katrina Jackson and I bring our offline romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an invitation to continue the conversation well after the mic is off. In this episode, we discussed how the HEA/HFN in romance and reader expectations might not always match. Remember the bit of a spiral or epiphany I had? You know, the idea that romance isn’t the same thing as love and that an HEA or HFN might simply mean the characters end up together, not necessarily that everything is resolved the way we expect it to be. That realization opened up a larger conversation about how subjective romance really is. What we each want from a story can look wildly different. Are you reading for character growth? Low angst? or for specific tropes or ones you avoid at all costs? Even our expectations for what an HEA or HFN could look like aren’t universal. I’m drawn to character work. Katrina points out that second-chance stories can be a place where that happens, and the ending is plausible for romantic love to exist. In further discussion, we zoomed out to acknowledge that romance hasn’t always looked the way it does now… romance has not always looked the way that it looks today. Even the way that it looks today is shaped by your particular algorithm, what you like to read, what you share with people. I’m left to wrestle with the possibility that my expectations may need a reset. So if you’re interested in hearing more, check it out, and let us know where you land. Reflection prompts: * How do your expectations for an HEA or HFN shape your satisfaction with a story? * What are you most often looking for when you read romance right now (e.g., character growth, emotional safety, high or low angst, specific tropes)? * How have those preferences changed over time or been influenced by the algorithm? Happy Listening! Thanks for reading Weekend Reader’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit weekendreaderx.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome, Katrina Jackson. This is going to be an exciting series. Hear us out. So for context, hi, Katrina. Welcome. I'm so happy to have you. For context, Katrina and I have been in each other's DMs for the better half of the year talking about all things romance, romance community, book community. And we have some invigorating conversations.
And so we thought, why not share that with the public in small bits and pieces? So we have a couple of topics that we're gonna go through that actually align with
SPEAKER_00my personal curriculum for the year. So first things first, because we're talking about romance, I want to start with, what do we think about the HEA and HFN in romance? For kicks and giggles, I had a moment of clarity, what would you say, two months ago, a month ago, where I was like, oh my gosh,
SPEAKER_00they don't have to be in love. The HEA, the point of the HEA is not that they're in love. It is that they're together. And you were like, yeah. I was like, oh, was it just me that took that long time to get there? Because in my head, when we talk about romance, I just insert romance equals love. So and you gently walk me through that. So let's talk about it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. I don't think romance books are actually about love at all.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Which is why I don't actually think the HEA requires love. I mean, there's actually also never been anything in any of the definitions I read that talked about love at all.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01So, yeah. So where did that come from then? That you thought that people had to be in love? I think that most people think that the whole point of an HEA is love. Mm-hmm. But what I have realized over the years is that, one, people have lots of different definitions of love. Which is also why they're so, two people can read the same book and think, I hope these people never talk to each other again. I hope they break up five minutes after this book ends. And someone who's like,
I'm going to tattoo this relationship on my heart, right?
SPEAKER_01Because people have different definitions. Balanché. Right. People have different definitions of love. But I also think that, I think the current definition now is a satisfying romantic ending. Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1
SPEAKER_01That has actually never been a requirement. And I think that's such a vastly different, that looks vastly different for like every person. And so I have all, not always, I have thought for the past like three or so years that romance novels are about watching people build a relationship that can become love. But I think most books end before it does.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And where a reader would infer, because they're together, love would exist at some point.
SPEAKER_01Right. Or they think that they were seeing them at the early stages of loving love or something like that, which I think is fair. And I think depending on the relationship as well, you could maybe argue that a second chance, you might be seeing the rekindling of love by the end of that book, or that's what the book is about. Love itself, I don't really... I think that relationship between love and romance novels is still unclear.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think because the bulk of where romance starts the relationships is the beginning, right? So it's oftentimes the honeymoon period of if the couple are in love, right? And you bring up a really good point about Second Chance. They've established that there have been conflicts that separated them and you would think it is love that would bring them back or the desire to try to establish
SPEAKER_00the love. But I will say from a reader perspective, a lot of romance readers do not like Second Chance because it's like, if you broke up, don't get back together. So then we have that friction there.
SPEAKER_01Can I jump in? I think that perfectly illustrates my point. You can break up with someone and still love them and that relationship is not for you. And I think second chance could be we never fell out of love, but we did not have the tools to make the relationship work. And so now maybe 5, 10, 20 years later, we have the tools to make a relationship work. But if you're using love as the barometer, as opposed to, say, a romantic relationship, then the stakes feel higher. And so maybe as a reader, then you're like, no, no, no, like this didn't work out. Why do that?
SPEAKER_01And it's like, sure. But a lot of people have been in relationships that didn't work out and they still love and trifling people for months, maybe years after the relationship ended.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, you just did something there where I think we often recognize when we're talking is that We might be using words interchangeably, but we mean different things, right? And you made a really good delineation. Romantic relationship and love, again, are two separate things. They could orbit each other and they could feel slightly similar depending on the
SPEAKER_00couple dynamic, but romantic love And love, because you can have familiar love, you can have kinship love, like all of those things. So we're specifically talking about romantic relationships and the desire to be together, which could be, the summation of that could be love. So even in Second Chance, I think the go-to when people hear that,
particularly when it's
SPEAKER_00Break up with that man or stay broken up. It is really a box, right? Like cheating, miscommunication. There are certain things that I think readers are like, why would you start this over? But A good example of A Second Chance is One More Valentine. They still loved your book, One More Valentine for Votes. They still loved each other and they continued to orbit each other.
That breakup was out of, without spoiling it, it was out of fear and one character
SPEAKER_00did not want to impose that fear on the other character, but they still were at each other for a good portion of the book. And you could feel their love. And I think part of the work of Second Chance Romance is helping the reader see that sometimes you have to try again, right? Like sometimes, like you said, you don't have the tools. There's usually a miscommunication or an event that You might have to break apart,
work on yourself separately, and then come back. Which brings me to a thought about how contemporary fiction and women's fiction can actually do a lot of the character development work that we want to see that
SPEAKER_00romance may shortcut, right? I'm jumping around in my head, but you get what I'm saying?
SPEAKER_01I agree, yeah. I think that I wonder how much I don't read as much women's fiction as I used to so this is like just a thought but like there is conversation happening online about like whether or not romances should be single POV or dual POV and some people feel very strongly about single POV but a lot of women's fiction is single POV right and so you get to spend a whole bunch of time in that main character's
SPEAKER_01You spend some of that space in other people's heads. And so I think that, yeah, I think sometimes women's fiction or contemporary fiction, because they are often single POV, like, get a little bit more depth in the character and their life outside of the romantic relationship, because the romantic relationship isn't plot A. It's, you know, plot B or C. Or it doesn't exist, right, in some women's fiction and contemporary fiction.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I wonder too if, because we're getting into the weeds of like how you would differentiate what the storyline is. Like so romance, the plot, the central plot is about the romantic relationship. And so there's like a lot of You know off page or on page really exploration of the individual separate from the relationship it starts to get a little murky because you your
focus should be on
SPEAKER_00technically how are you guys going to you be together and I think For me, because I think I've been reading romance since the early 2000s, so like a little bit. Romance has changed over time, right? And I don't actually know if I was always reading romance in hindsight. It could have been more women's fiction with romantic elements.
Neither Here Nor There because, you know, the Terry McMillans of the world.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's women's fiction and contemporary fiction.
SPEAKER_01I have to say too, especially if you also read Black literature, I did not read romance until I was in the late 2010s or mid 2010s, but I read a whole bunch of contemporary fiction, a whole bunch of women's fiction. What did they street lit? They called some of it. I love that shit. Also my barometer for romance, or at least the interior and exterior life of the characters, has always been shaped by that.
And I think now, as a romance reader... Ooh, is that... Oh, let me not do the math.
SPEAKER_00Let me not do that, because that's going to distract me.
SPEAKER_01Were you going to figure out how long you've been reading? Go ahead. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00but I think it is a really good indicator of how maybe culture, like pop culture and cultural significance things impact and moves the genre around, right? So then what your expectations of what's happening in the plot, like the big beats might change. And so what I'm seeing right now in terms of romance,
because I mostly read contemporary and paranormal romance and romantic suspense.
SPEAKER_01I was going to say.
SPEAKER_00I'm going to be doing a whole bit on mafia romance next month, which I'm so excited about, but don't get me to get off topic. What I've noticed is that what tends to happen is you can clearly see the romance beats in contemporary romance more clearly when the character is under 35. That feels more where they're centralizing the relationship and
then anything after
SPEAKER_00that it starts to feel like Maybe this is veering off into contemporary fiction. The thing, though, is that they still end up together. So the H-E-A still occurs. So I have a question for you as an author. How do you feel about the percentage of the book, the couple? They're not together, but they're orbiting each other. Working towards the relationship, but they are not together.
And then the last, say, third of the book, they're together and then they get up.
SPEAKER_01What does together mean, though? Like, are they dating? Are they... Girl, I don't know. Because I have a couple of books in my mind that I just recently read that I will
SPEAKER_00not put on blast because I think the character work makes sense.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if it was a romance though, right? Because they were together on page by proximity, but in terms of relationship, they were not together. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_01I mean, it does, but I'm like, well, then what the fuck were they doing?
SPEAKER_00They were arguing with each other.
SPEAKER_01Can I curse on this? My bad.
SPEAKER_00Listen. I must probably cuss too, so yes, feel free. They were reestablishing trust.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so building a friendship or a relationship. Sure, okay. Yeah, I think that's fine. I think that's fine. I do think that veers a little bit closer to women's fiction, but I think that there's always been overlap between women's fiction and romance, which some romance readers do not like to admit. But I think for me that sounds fine, right? I mean your second chance romances. So there is an established relationship there of some sort that they are building on.
I think that there are probably so many different romance generations of readers who have certain expectations that have been shaped by that early romance phase. Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1
SPEAKER_01Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader 1 Weekend Reader is to have the least complicated relationship possible. So they meet when they're maybe in their 20s and they have no real responsibilities, right? Or their responsibilities can come and go, right? It's like, I gotta go to class or like, you know, I just started my first big girl job and, you know. Or my life is falling apart. Right. And so like the things pulling them away from maybe focusing on a romance are minimal. And they have a meet-cute relatively early.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't have to be in the beginning. And then they move from there. And I love an insta-lust. Like, I love to write it. I love to read it. So it's like we are, as soon as they meet, we are going, right? But you could even slow that down if you happen to not love the gift that is insta-love or insta-lust, right? And so then you could see them. I think that's where that comes in, where they're building a friendship or some kind of relationship on which they'll then build their romantic relationship. But the minute you have,
SPEAKER_01I think, a slightly more complicated character, I do think that you start to veer away from some people's, especially like sort of classic romance readers, although people have been reading from like the 90s or so, that they often, they can fight against, not always, but they can fight against. Which, you know, if you have a woman who her career and her job are significantly part of the plot, where her relationship with her love interest, like, might not be for her all the time, like, front and center or the thing that matters most to her.
SPEAKER_01If one of the characters has kids, which has always been, and not always, but I know it's controversial for some readers, right? Like, if you always have kids, like, kids need things, right? Like, so unless you can shuttle them off to, like, boarding school or another parent or whatever, Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1 Weekend Reader1
SPEAKER_01Making them nervous or reticent in any way about a relationship. I think some romance readers like people who sort of throw themselves into a romance, which I agree is really nice to read. But, you know, if you're writing someone who has, you know, been cheated on or who has been widowed or who, you know, might be a sexual assault survivor. They are going to probably take a little bit more to get to a romance.
I think sometimes people are looking for a feeling of romance or they are dictating
SPEAKER_01what a romance should do, the pacing, etc. The pacing is based on, in my opinion, the least complicated story possible. So you just brought up a really good point because it feels like based off of what
SPEAKER_00you just described, authors then have to find a careful balance of not having too much external conflict that would distract from the relationship. So you're trying to find ways to shortcut And I'm wondering, because I've been seeing a lot more readers like romance shouldn't be 350 plus pages or romance shouldn't be 500 pages, right? And so you have to then make some really,
SPEAKER_00some strategic decisions about, well, how much stuff has to happen to get them to be together? What is the conflict going to be that might or might not separate them then to get to the HEA? So I feel like You're saying without saying, or maybe I'm interpreting, sometimes that's why you have to, as a writer and author, kind of have a linear, they meet, they talk,
SPEAKER_00maybe not. Maybe they rub bodily fluids on each other at some point. Maybe they just hold hands.
SPEAKER_01Saliva is our thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, heavy petting. They do something there.
SPEAKER_01They don't have to physically.
SPEAKER_00Moving on, moving on. There is a middle. There is a middle. There's something happening that, you know, makes you feel butterflies in your stomach. And then some conflict there together. The end. So I think what you're saying is if you want deep character work, Plus this, plus that, then the romantic relationship might be hard to be the central focus.
SPEAKER_01No, that's not actually what I'm saying. So I don't actually think any author has to do a thing. Like, that is up to them, themselves. Like, if they, you know, it doesn't matter, or their editor or whatever, you don't have to do a thing. You can have a longer, more complicated romance where there is a lot of back and forth. I think, um, uh, So I run a podcast, which we have been on hiatus for two years. Life is rough. Anyway, with Steve Amadown, we talk about Black romance as a history. And part of the reason I really like Steve is because he,
SPEAKER_01like, I am not a scholar of the romance genre. As an archivist, he has become one. And he knows a whole bunch about the history of romance. And one of the really important lessons, like, that he has taught me is that romance, and I think people forget this, romance has not always looked the way that it looks today. Even the way that it looks today is shaped by your particular algorithm, what you like to read, what you share with people. And so there are people writing far more complicated, longer,
SPEAKER_01I would say messier, and I mean that mostly in a good way, where relationships are not linear, there are people writing those things and they have and will find their audiences.
I wanted to try a different format to work through my thoughts on Nonfiction November's The New Dark Ages by James Marriott. Overall, I thought the book provided a baseline to discuss literacy but left me with more...
Hear Me Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode invites...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...
Hear Us Out… is a podcast series where I bring romance conversations into the public space. As longtime readers of the genre, we talk through what romance is doing, how it works, and why it matters. Each episode is an...