Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

April Mailbag 1: The Pope is Weak on Crime

Apr 15, 20261 hr 43 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

folks, it's once again time to dive into the mailbag of patron questions. this time, we answer queries about the recent fight between Trump and Pope Leo, menopause, fried chicken, books bound in human skin, historical misconceptions based on a single erroneous account, the Pope being weak on crime, and much more. image: Antichrist seated on the back of Leviathan from the Liber Floridus encyclopedia (c. 1120), taken from Wikipedia Commons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1How you going, And what's your favorite Trump blasphemy of the day.

Speaker 2You know, I, uh, look earlier, earlier today he did, have you have you heard the story about the there's a cabinet member or someone who what did he say? Uh? Uh the the the there's a FEMA official who keeps saying that he teleported to waffle house. Like he.

Speaker 3Tell you that, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay.

Speaker 2So he says this and people are like, okay, man, that's uh, you're you're ridiculous, and and he's like, oh yeah, well, uh, here are these examples from the Bible where God teleported people. So it's real waffle houses. Oh he didn't. Look God moves in mysterious ways, eleanor I'm tired of your I'm tired of you kink, shame and god like that.

Speaker 3But you know what, look, I wish I could get teleported to.

Speaker 2A waffle house exactly.

Speaker 3Yeah, that'll be great.

Speaker 2Okay. So but everyone's like, okay, man whatever. So finally someone asked Trump about it today. He said, he said, what does teleport mean? Was he kidding? It just sounds a little strange, But I know nothing about teleporting. And I was like, okay, you know that I believe that.

Speaker 3You know, he's got my ass there. He definitely does like that.

Speaker 2He's like wait what, wait, wait, what is that?

Speaker 3I don't I know nothing about.

Speaker 2It, Like it's one of the it's one of those things that even like he won't he's.

Speaker 1Just like, yeah, yeah, I got nothing. I mean, I think it is an interesting one because it's like since he's surrounded himself with like the biggest freaks and losers in the world, like but he kind of knows it though.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, yeah, he knows that they're basically all losers. Like he doesn't have like a Steve Mduchin there. He treats Mike Johnson like shit. He treats JD like the stupid little kid he is. He treats uh Marco like crap. He throws them all under the like he yeah, he just he doesn't have someone who he respects as like a business guy, like he seems to respect Zorn, Mam Donnie far more than he respects anyone in his cabinet.

Speaker 2Like as far as I can tell.

Speaker 3I think that the thing is that he likes winners or whatever.

Speaker 2Yeah, oh yeah, absolutely, and like.

Speaker 3They're all losers and he knows it. So it's sort of like, oh word.

Speaker 2He respects winners, uh, and he respects like business people who have made a lot of money, even if they made a lot of money in very stupid ways. He's like, yeah that whatever, like it doesn't matter.

Speaker 1Yeah, it doesn't matter how they make the money. Like yeah, so for real, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, but like yeah until until it becomes a rivalry thing with him, and then you know, and then he just you know, he hates them for whatever reason. I mean it's yeah, I mean yeah, he thinks these people are all idiots. And you know, he posted that picture of himself as Jesus.

Speaker 3And like, okay, so like that made me lose my entire mind. I was talking to Josh Borman about it.

Speaker 1Because I was like like, I just like I can't handle this, like, as you know, someone who works on fucking anti Christ, Like, what do you want me to do with this shit? You know, like that's like literally Antichrist?

Speaker 3One?

Speaker 1Oh one, sir? Did you just say you were Jesus? And I think it's interesting because it's like I guess, on the one hand, like for sure, he's like, you know, just an IDEO or whatever. And I think to a certain extent, he is also testing the waters like what can he get away with? But also I guess the thing is since he isn't a Christian, he doesn't understand that you can't do that absolutely, and that I find really fucking interesting.

Speaker 3Like that he's just kind of like, oh, you can't. Why can't you do that? And it's like, yeah, sir, that.

Speaker 1Means you're the anti christ. He's like, uh, I thought it was a doctor.

Speaker 2It's like, no, you didn't, so like, yeah, that's saving things. But I completely agree with you what I said this in a group chat yesterday. Like he had no clue that this was like a like he he didn't know. And that's not to exculpate him from anything, but like this is like even people who like grew up as Christians, this is not unless you've gone down like the The Left Behind series, Rabbit Hole, or you're really into you know,

Speaker 2apocalyptics and all that sort of stuff, you know, you might not be that familiar with it. But like he does this and he's like, uh, yeah, actually it was I was uh it was the I was a doctor.

Speaker 1You know.

Speaker 2It's like he's trying to say face. But the most interesting thing is that he just didn't get it. Yeah, he didn't understand.

Speaker 1Yeah, Like I mean, it's and that's fine, you know, like I actually don't expect uh not Christians to know about it.

Speaker 3But it's like it's the whole act and.

Speaker 1The weird way that Christians pretend he does, like like he is a Christian or whatever. And you know, I've definitely seen some Christians saying shit like, oh, well, you know, it kind of doesn't matter if he does blasphemy because like he's the most pro Christian president of all time.

Speaker 3And it's like.

Speaker 2I post confessional world, baby, yeah doesn't mean anything anymos.

Speaker 3I mean, I guess it does sort of. I mean to an extent.

Speaker 4You know.

Speaker 3It's like one of these things that.

Speaker 1Like I tend to say is it's like, to an extent, beliefs don't matter. What matters is actions. I do kind of agree with that, And I mean I think that one of the things that we can say is that in.

Speaker 3Theory, your beliefs are supposed to inform.

Speaker 1Your actions, right, Like that's that's supposed to be, you know whatever. And like I've definitely you know, made fun of liberals for this because they'll be like oh yeah, well leftists just have these they have.

Speaker 3These beliefs in these morals.

Speaker 1But what happens when you have to make real decisions that it's like, oh yeah, your beliefs and morals inform those decisions.

Speaker 3And what you're talking about is that you don't.

Speaker 1Have morals or beliefs, and like that's that's where you're coming from, right, And so I mean to a certain extent that is true, But I also think that you really just can't compare yourself.

Speaker 2To to No, you can't no. And I mean people are going to be h people are going to be offended by it, like incredible, and you saw some of his people being offended by it, which I mean, you know that is.

Speaker 1I'm always interested in that in people's lines. I'm like, that's your line, yeah, okay.

Speaker 2I mean like it's I don't, yeah, I don't. The lines that people draw on things are extremely like just arbitrary, like all the other stuff he said and done and everything, and it's just like, yeah, you know, it's that all that stuff is fine, like everything else, and it's like

Speaker 2one of those things where it's like you you really don't care that much about what the Bible has to say clearly because of all the because of the stuff that he is saying that he wants to do that contradicts the Bible. The plain reading of the Bible is stuff that you personally want. But then when he does something like this and it cuts across your the grain of your reading of the Bible, you have to decide whether, like this is something you actually care about or not. And I mean, like, I guess if I'm not giving

Speaker 2anyone credit or anything, but I guess if you're going to have a line, I mean, I guess, say like someone saying they are Jesus, Like sure, Like I mean, I guess I'm glad.

Speaker 3I'm glad.

Speaker 1Though I guess that's some people do have this as a lie because I'm like, yeah, I mean, that's pretty blatant. That's that's pretty that's pretty uh you know, like it's it's very like mister Burn's trying to get worshiped as special.

Speaker 3K you know or whatever. You know.

Speaker 1I like that, uh that some people have been like wait a minute, like this is expressly long wrong, and I'm like, you know, what, good for you for noticing, right, Like, I.

Speaker 3I do appreciate that.

Speaker 1I will say that so yeah, I mean, shout out, shout out to like the three people who did do. I find it a bit weird. I'm like, that's your line, not like the pederasty.

Speaker 2Okay, like not the pederasty, not the the the endless string of horror, yeah, every like.

Speaker 1Not like the kidnapping of your neighbors and like, uh, you know whatever, like for sure, okay, cool, like, but at least you've got one, You've got a line, like at least you're willing to notice. And I'm like, I wonder, you know, if that noticing will lead to other noticing.

Speaker 3I doubt it. I like it if it did.

Speaker 1But you know, we're just like, I'm like, fair enough at least that there's been like one thing noticed.

Speaker 3That's that's something.

Speaker 2But we didn't have you Yeah, yeah, I mean I I just think it's I think it's part and parcel with the whole. Like religion, way or once religious belief was a its own separate column in people's lives. It was its own thing, and it it affected other it it affected other things like you would you would base

Speaker 2your life around what you believe the Bible said or the Koran said, or or what what the Buddha taught or what ever. And uh, it was such a central pillar. But over time it has just uh become less and less and less. And now for a lot of people, and especially in public life. Uh, it's just religious. Religion is a an outward symbol of your It's just an

Speaker 2outward performative thing. It's a it's a symbol that you are, that that you are part of the wider western world, or you are a part of you know, this group of Christians that that do these things. And even if you don't believe all of that stuff necessarily and you go to church and like hume your way through it or whatever, you know, you you you get to signify that. And people and the people who who you want to

Speaker 2follow you or vote for you or whatever and just are hooting and and lapping it up. So I mean, yeah, I don't I think that is Uh, I think that is what it is with Yeah, I don't know where. We're at a real weird place with religion now as far as these things go.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's I guess it's It's an interesting one for me because you know, one of the things that I think is really.

Speaker 3Changed in my life is like, you know, the move to Europe, which where you know, people just aren't religious. You know, we're large.

Speaker 1I mean, like, don't get me wrong, there are exceptions so that there are places where where people kind of still are, but for the most part, we're pretty secularized.

Speaker 3Like everyone I know who.

Speaker 1Is CV is like trans and a deacon, right, you know, like they're they're they're they're like they're super they're super fucking involved, and they're queer, you know, and you know, like that that's kind of like who.

Speaker 3I'm aware of.

Speaker 1And like granted, you know, uh, there are still countries that are quite Catholic and things like that, but I don't know, like all the ones that I've ever lived in like really emphatically not, so you know, I don't really experience this kind of day to day concept of you know, people being quite religious, Like you know, in my neighborhood, the like largest group of people who's attending church are like Nigerian immigrants, you know, yeah, like yeah, that's that's like a totally different thing.

Speaker 2So I don't, Yeah, I don't really experience it down here like you I mean, you see stuff, but like I mean I don't go to you know, I don't go to church. And I mean, I guess if I like had a job where I had to go into an office all the time, I probably feel a bit differently about it. But I do think in America it has gone down precipitously, like it's just like it's just

Speaker 2not the same as it was even you know, a few even a few years ago. I just think it's it has been fully sublimated into politics here, like on the whole, I think, I don't that doesn't mean that people that there aren't serious believers and people who take it seriously and strive to do better and everything. That's of course the fact. But I think like almost all religion in America, probably all religion in America, has been

Speaker 2sublimated to politics. And I mean I think it has in a lot of places. And I think that, uh, you know, that's not it's part of the secularizing of the world. I don't know that it's necessarily a good thing, but I think that it's I mean, the world that we have now, it's the only way for it to function because like we can't go back, we can't go

Speaker 2back to to you know, the the pre you know, religious liberty days where we were always fighting specifically over like religious beliefs, because we would just fucking nuke the world. Now that just you can't do that anymore so, and it's good that America is getting its ass handed to it in uh Iran like this to show you that it's bad to try and resurrect their crusades again. Anyway,

Speaker 2should we do the show? I guess yeah, let's do the show, because yeah, we got to talk some more about this stuff. Anyway.

Speaker 3Ew yeah, let's get it into it.

Speaker 4Let's go.

Speaker 2Hello and welcome back to We're Not So Different, a podcast about how I don't know any I don't know anything about teleporting either. I can't. Me and Trump are on the same look, me and Trump are on the same wavelength threat there like for one thing, there's like one thing that we're like both. It's like that and breathing oxygen and that's it. But you know, yeah, hey, folks, we're gonna do a mailbag episode today, you know, before

Speaker 2we get into it. Eleanor has done a limited series with a friend of the show, Phoebe roy on the first season of The Wolf Hall Television Show, and you can check it out on our Patreon page, Patreon, dot com, slash w nsdpod. It is fifteen dollars and that gets you access to all seven episodes, so check that out. It's a lot of fun and they are they really

Speaker 2they really enjoyed doing it, and you guys should check it out because it's good.

Speaker 3Yeah, that's right. I think you can tell that we enjoyed doing it.

Speaker 1Basically, it's just two of the nicest bitches, you know, gossiping about tutors.

Speaker 3Actually, yeah, so yeah, you know, girls night, girls night, what can I say?

Speaker 2Girls there you go, yeah, yeah, And if you want to become a patron, you can also do that. It's just five dollars a month and that will allow you to ask us questions like we're about to talk about and get X to the discord all episodes AD free and access to the bonus episodes. We're starting a new book club series. First episode will be out on Friday. It's on Christopher Buelman's twenty twelve I Believe twenty twelve

Speaker 2novel Between Two Fires, which is a medievalist fantasy horror novel about it's an alternate retelling of the Black Death. So we are going to do that and if you want to hear it, you want to read along with us, or just see what we thought. You should check that out Patreon, dot com, slash w niste pod.

Speaker 3Thank you through that shit.

Speaker 2By the way, Yeah me too, it's my life.

Speaker 3I loving two fires. I've got a lot to say.

Speaker 2It's really good. Yeah, all right, onto the show. So, folks, we just had a great series on medieval land management, and we hope you learned a lot about how they dealt with land, water, crops, livestock, for ust, and so much more. Since the series was so long, we missed a couple of mailbags and we've got an even larger pile of patron questions than usual. So we're going to do two mailbag episodes in a row to do some catching up, and then we're going to start a new but shorter series on pre modern Iran, since the United

Speaker 2States is too stupid and beholden to Israel to simply make peace, leave and accept whatever demands Aron gives. This for starting in a legal world repression, we figure we should discuss classical and medieval Aaron and what it looked like. But we're getting our head ahead of ourselves, as we will be back to that in a couple of weeks. Time for now, let's open some mail and yeah, you know, check out the Patreon if you want to ask us questions like these. Today we've got questions about everything from menopause,

Speaker 2stereotypically bad jobs, polyamory, historical misconceptions based on a single author, and more. But first we must talk about the most important news of the week and answer a question about why the pope is week on crime. Our first question comes from b Bailey, who says, are we going to get a discussion of the Avignon papacy and it's relevance to the current situation between the Papacy and the Pentagon? Yes, you are all right, So a few I'm sorry, not

Speaker 2a few weeks ago. This, yeah, last Monday, it was sorry, I had to pull up my article that I was reading from last Monday. The Free Press reported that the US threatened the Vatican with a new Avignon papacy in which we were going to elect an anti pope and

Speaker 2he was going to take a seat in fucking I don't know, I guess Mara Lago or Miami or some shit like that. And uh, yeah, we were going to do that. Now, the Pentagon and and the the the Church have spent the past week really trying to like play this down like this didn't really happen. This is blown out of proportion. The free press is making up stuff blah blah blah, which may be entirely true. Is the free press sucks. However, uh, it was still said,

Speaker 2so Eleanor, I assume that we will, of course all as Americans be swearing filty to the new Avignon, the new Pope of marri A Lago, Marco Rubio.

Speaker 1I guess, okay, Like look, so I immediately got so angry because you know, the the greatest sin of the Trump government, as I said on Blue Sky, is they're very poor understanding of medieval history.

Speaker 3Obviously, everything else is fine.

Speaker 2Everything else is great, but these these misconceptions they can't stand.

Speaker 1But like literally literally, the Avegnuel papacy isn't the great Western.

Speaker 3Schism like the ab like the Avenel.

Speaker 1Papacy or the Babylonian captivity, whatever you want to call it. Like even if you want to like get all like you know, judge about it, that is the fucking seventy six year period when the popes were just in Avenue the popes were just an avenue. Like, it's not an anti pope situation, it's just the popes were like.

Speaker 3Uh, I don't know.

Speaker 1Rome seems to be on fire, and we're French and we own a bunch of land in Avignon. So by right, you get seven popes out there, You get your clem at the fifth, you get your Clime at the sixth, you got my favorite pope of all time, Urban the fifth.

Speaker 3It's a fixed bag.

Speaker 1Clement the Fifth's a real piece of shit, to be fair. Clement the sixth the one of our more profligate popes. But like, Urban the fifth was like a good guy, Like he was like really kind of trying. Like a lot of them are reformers because they like know how it looks. Yeah, they're like, I know this looks bad. I know, I know this looks bad.

Speaker 2Like this looks bad. But have you have you ever thought about how uh Rome sucks? And I don't want to live there? And they're so real, you know, and yeah they're being real for that. Yeah, so just real quick. Uh. The Avignon papacy was, as Eleanor said, it lasted from uh it was thirteen about thirteen nine thirteen seventy six or so, and that was when the that was when

Speaker 2the popes just resided in Avignon. Now, to be clear, this was very bad for the church. It would have colaus so ramifications in with with regular people because while right, while while Rome does prop did almost certainly really suck, regular people were like, that's great, man, get back into the fucking swamp.

Speaker 1Now gives a shit, Like, I mean, to be fair, like that's a that's a generally fine critique.

Speaker 3It's well, your your job isn't to enjoy yourself. Your job is to be a bishop of Rome, you know.

Speaker 1So it also my life sucks, so like why are you so special?

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, like that''s fun.

Speaker 2But that's yeah, that's Avenon. Now. The Western Schism, which is what they which is what they meant, was the time between thirteen seventy eight and fourteen seventeen when there was a split in the church and you had competing claims to being the true pope, with one in Rome and one in avenue On, and later after fourteen oh nine also won in Pisa, and then that was resolved in f teen seventeen after the Council of Constance. So yeah,

Speaker 2they're you know that those are the things. Now, they were both very destabilizing in bad long term for the Catholic Church. But the Avignon papacy at that specific historical time was just there was one pope. They just lived in France.

Speaker 3They live instead of yah.

Speaker 2Instead of uh the boot, instead of part of the boot. Yeah, so yeah, they uh can you imagine being like I'm going to do the you do the avenue on papacy and and the Pope's people are like, you're going to capture Leo and take him to like Miami, and he's like no, we're going to do another one. And they're like that's a different thing, you idiots.

Speaker 3Because it's like, I mean, I don't know.

Speaker 1I suppose there could be like like like I'm sorry, are you threatening Hope Leo with a Boniface the eighth? Like yeah, what type like you're gonna kidnap You're gonna kidnap Pope Leo and beat him up so that he dies and then forced the election of another pope.

Speaker 3This pope is already American.

Speaker 2Gee, I think if you kill this one, they're going to it. To be clear, I don't think that they suggested killing the pope. I think they're they're evil and they're assholes, but like, I don't I don't think that happened.

Speaker 3I think they they mean a schism.

Speaker 1I think they I just think that they're too stupid to know about that.

Speaker 2Oh no, that that is definitely true. So it's like, but I want to be clear, like I don't think that.

Speaker 3I don't think I actually.

Speaker 2Threatened the life of the pope. And I don't want anyone to be like whoa Like I don't think we don't like anyway, sorry.

Speaker 1We think they're stupid and venal, like we don't think they're actually like And also it's just kind of like funny because it's like, bro, like there's already American in America and whose pope, so like.

Speaker 2We already have And there are also anti popes. There was one in his name was uh fuck, I don't remember his name, but he lived in kidsas he died. He died during COVID like he like, there are a lot of anti.

Speaker 3Poe and like, I mean, I guess that.

Speaker 1Also it's quite a funny one because like you know, even at the time of the Western Schism, it's like people were really like on all sides are really not happy about the situation, and like everyone was kind of going full fucking hell like, and you can't just say, yeah, well everyone in America would follow your new pope, because they probably wouldn't. I mean, like not all French people like followed the Avenue Knese pope during the schism, right, you know, people were just sort of like, hmm, well, like I'm doing my best and I have no idea

Speaker 1what's going on. And so there's a lot of discussion that we see during the Western Schism, for example, about like, well fucking hell, like how do I know h that when I'm getting communion from someone, like if they are sinful or whatever, doesn't still count, right, because it's like no one really trusts their priest or whatever faction.

Speaker 3Is going on.

Speaker 1So you know, like you can't say that every Catholic in America would be like, oh yeah, sure, like we'll go for that, and in fact almost none would, Like I'm sure JD. Vance would be hype, but like, you know, he doesn't count. He fundamentally does not count.

Speaker 2So no one is going to do that. Not to mention that, like most Catholics in America are somewhere between lapsed and don't really attend services all the time. Like it's not like the people talk about this stuff and this does really bother me. People talk about this stuff like it is. People talk about this stuff like it's fourteen twenty or sometime before sixteen forty eight, and it's

Speaker 2just not you like you be Confessionalism is not moving, is not moving people like that. Now, even people who like even the Conservatives who want America to be a quote unquote Christian nation, they do not agree on what that actually means, like they're they're just like we that's why they say Christian as this wide overarching signifier. So like,

Speaker 2assuming you did it, nothing's going to happen, like yeah, because it's not that this is the kind of threat that Frederick Barbarossa was making to the pope because he wanted to get one of his nephews fucking appointed to some higher office like in nine whatever eighty something like it's it's two thy twenty six. We have nuclear weapons, like people in the like, we haven't had confessionalism like

Speaker 2that since I don't know, like the sixteen thirties. It died sometime in the Thirty Years War, and even after that like even other nations that maybe other religions that maybe would have wanted to wipe out Christen them, they stopped fighting like that. It wasn't the Turks versus It wasn't the Muslims versus the Christians anymore. It was the Ottomans versus the Byzantines versus then versus the hr that.

Speaker 2You know, it's yeah anyway, but I'll go ahead.

Speaker 1I just wanted to point out though, What is really funny is I saw this one post from Twitter, the referend Jordan Wells one of the best things I've ever seen. So in the first place, he's got like the siren emoji. Yeah, and then are you fucking ready for the headline? Why so many Protestants are done with the modern papacy.

Speaker 3I'm like, oh no, what.

Speaker 2You guys are supposed to hate the papacy anyway. That's like, this is the thing you're supposed if you are, if you are an Evangelical Christian, you are supposed to hate the papacy. Even even the non evangelical Protestants in this country are supposed to be wary of the pope. Like that's how the whole thing was set up and they're like, uh oh, they're done with the papacy, Like okay, I don't think he cares man.

Speaker 3Like I just think like it is.

Speaker 1It's like the entire thing is just incredibly funny because none of these people because because I guess you're exactly right though, it's because of this kind.

Speaker 3Of like mainlining of the term Christian.

Speaker 1Yeah, that it kind of allows them to do this when it makes no fucking sense.

Speaker 2Right, Like yeah, it's just yeah, we're we're we're applying old labels to stuff that does not that doesn't fit into that anymore. Because if you because if you're if you're a Catholic, are you a a like a regular are you are you an attending Catholic? Are you an Eastern Christmas Catholic? Are you a lapsed Catholic? Are you a lapse Catholic who hates the church? Are you opus day? Are you set of a cantidate? Like they're you know,

Speaker 2and don't even get me started on the five hundred million sects of Protestant bullshit, Like we're tarring people with this huge brush. And it's like like the people who are like borderline atheist lapsed Catholics, like are they going to like follow you to Meri Lago for like Pope fucking Pope Marco Rubio, Like like I.

Speaker 1Mean honestly, like is he positioning himself as the because it's like, you know, the thing is, Catholics do believe in the church hierarchy, right like yeah, you know, like I know because I'm related to a bunch of them. So it's like they're not going to do that, right, Like it's just so overly simplistic, you know.

Speaker 2Yeah, But so as I said, the Church and the Pentagon both worked over time last week to be like look that, please, no, no, we didn't, you know, like come on, you know, they're like this is not what we need right now, come on. But you know, Trump and his infinite wisdom on I believe it was Friday evening posted on truth Social. Pope Leo is weak on terrible for foreign policy. He talks about fear of the

Speaker 2Trump administration, but doesn't mention the fear that the Catholic Church and all other Christian organizations had during COVID when they were arresting priest ministers and everybody else for holding church services even when going outside and being ten and even twenty apart. I like his brother Louis much better than I like him because Louis is all maggot he gets it and Leo doesn't. I don't want blah blah blah blah blah.

Speaker 1Um like you like his brother better, Well, that's not how the papacy works, homeboy, Like, incredibly cool story. Thanks for that, Like I mean, like, what are you like, Like it's just so funny because that's quite medieval, Like you know when you get like so it's like a.

Speaker 3The the pope's brother Cardinal Dime.

Speaker 1Like at that point in time, I've really liked Millage and like helped him out of jams or people, like when he would get arrested in Rome and stuff, he'd be like.

Speaker 3Oh, that's all, He's just a little guy, you know. So like I I have.

Speaker 1Like a pope's brother that I prefer, which is kind of like amusing, but I'm not suggesting he can be the pope, right, Like it's yeah, the whole thing is just ridiculous, right, or like I've seen literal I've seen a weird maga people be alike, well, I'm a Catholic, but that's not my pope.

Speaker 3But it's like well then you're not a Catholic.

Speaker 2Then get a new then get an anti pope. That's how it works. You've got there is a system for this. The first antipope was was around within like seventy years of Jesus' death, Like there's a there's a way you do these things. You get him. Uh oh. And I was going to say earlier the number of current antipopes one, two, three, four, at least four or five, six, seven, And I mean,

Speaker 2like we are talking like that, these are there're at least nine of these people. And I mean we're talking about like just the weirdest, little, tiniest babyest offshoots that probably don't even have you know, a couple of hundred adherents. But like, there are anti popes. I don't think the papacy cares about them, yeah at all, because they don't control anything or bring people in Like yeah, I.

Speaker 1Mean, and like I wasn't aware of that until you said it, and it's my job to know about it. So it's like, I mean, you can do that if you want. No one's gonna care.

Speaker 2Like, yeah, there are a lot of them. Yeah, But I've been laughing the whole weekend at the Pope is week on crime because like because you can, like throughout throughout history, that just means so many different things. Is the Pope being uh? Is the Pope week on crime because he didn't help out the gwelps? Is he week on crime because he fathered a child? Is he weak on crime because he.

Speaker 1Like I mean I guess I was like, does that mean that he's like willing to forgive sins?

Speaker 3Like, because that's like.

Speaker 2That's the Jobe.

Speaker 3I don't know, like I mean, and that's the thing.

Speaker 1It's like I mean again, like he's not a Christian, so he doesn't understand any he does. I don't get what you mean, but like absolutely go for it, babe.

Speaker 3I love this. This is kind of like really nice drama for me.

Speaker 1Yeah, like I ordered it up special, so yeah, I really it's a really huge fan of whatever the fuck this is.

Speaker 2Yeah, watching a non Christian process all of this and talk about the pope and write about the Pope like he is like like some tankerous uh Holy Roman Emperor is like this is just delightful. Like I love love this stuff, and I mean, like the on crime thing is like.

Speaker 3Week on crime. Seriously, when you said when you said.

Speaker 1Me that I lost my ship for like quite some time, I was like, not the Pope is week on Crime.

Speaker 3I was like, what the fuck? Bro, Like, oh no, it's like it's so good.

Speaker 2Like are we talking like because I mean, they're the sentence of the Catholic Church are enumerates? Like are we talking about I mean those No, No, we're talking about the fact that he is, like, hey, stop like destroying the world to like try and prop up Israel. He's not saying it in those terms, even though he should. But and yeah, you just you have this fucking just.

Speaker 3Man anyway, so stupid. I love it. It's so good.

Speaker 2The Pope is week on Crime will probably be rattling when I like one of the one of the things that fires through my brain as I lay die will be like just insane ship that I've that has stuck in my head my entire life, and it's just going to say, poop leo.

Speaker 3He's weak, Okay, okay.

Speaker 2Oh my god. Anyway, as always, our stance on the church is it's funny when he does this stuff. But uh, if the Pope is serious about compating fascism, he needs to start at home and excommunicate Opa Stay and and all those people.

Speaker 1I want to see j Vance excommunicated and then we can talk.

Speaker 2Yeah, I want to see that, and then we could talk and then we can start leading up to the like all right, we got to rip the gold out of these ceilings. Big dogs to have anyway, Yeah, b Bailey, thank you for that. We we had a I don't think we wanted to do just a total full episode on this, but uh, it's fantastic.

Speaker 4You know.

Speaker 3Yeah, listen, we like it.

Speaker 2We do.

Speaker 1Like I'm are I guess the official h we're not so different stances.

Speaker 3We're pro. We're pro the the Vatican, White House beef.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, please please keep fighting, Please keep please keep sending.

Speaker 3The girls are fighting, the girls.

Speaker 2Are fighting and uh yeah yeah, you idiots deserve o. Man, oh we do. This is great critical support to pop LEO. As soon as he actually excommunicates those people.

Speaker 3Yeah, then we're talking.

Speaker 2Yeah, fucking come on, man, like, come on, I can I'm not I'm not going to get onto it, but like it really annoys me that people are like this is so great, he's fighting this. I'm like, just touch communicate.

Speaker 4It.

Speaker 1What is even the point of having a pope. If we're not gonna excommun.

Speaker 2Let's uh yeah, let's let's move along. It's just because it's it's it's this is better to be funny about instead of being instead of just being annoyed at anyway. Uh, thank you, Bailey, uh matteras. The next question is from Mataras Sino, who says, would the Islamic population of Palestine around the First Crusade have been majority Sunni or Shia. I know the Celjouks were Sunni and the Fatimid Caliphate were Shia, but I'm talking about the general population.

Speaker 1Yeah, so this is a good question. Pretty much what you would expect was some mixing. Yeah, but then obviously there's gonna be some differentiation with that in terms of who is at the top of the hierarchies because the people who are kind of like leaving government and stuff like that, you're gonna find way more because they're the cel Jokes.

Speaker 3You're gonna find Sunnys.

Speaker 1Right, and so you're going to find kind of like the embedded population that.

Speaker 3Has been there for quite some time are going.

Speaker 1To continue to be Shia. But everyone who holds a government position less.

Speaker 2So yeah, every record that I can recall about Jerusalem at the time of the Crusades is very they they all talk about it there that not only are there like Christians, Jews, and Muslims there, but there are like different sects of all of those groups. So there are Coptic there are Coptic Christians there, There are that there

Speaker 2would have been like the different sects of Judaism at the time that that were that were represented that there. Now this is talking of course about the the the population at the beginning of the conflict at the end. So if you'll recall from our Crusade series, if you listen to that with Derek and Danny from American Prestige, you'll recall that in ten ninety eight the Fatamids took

Speaker 2it upon themselves to attack the Seljuks and eject them from Jerusalem at the time because the Seljecs were already taking heavy losses, and they did that, and then when the Crusaders finally made it to Jerusalem in June of ten ninety nine, the Fatimids would have ejected all of the Sunnies and Seljuks out of the city as well as a lot of as well as like certain types

Speaker 2of Christians and people like that, because that's what you did in the Sege. You ejected people who you thought were going to undermine you. So that is what happened. And but yeah, they, Uh, Jerusalem seems like it was a melting pot of of of of in a lot of ways. And uh that was very unfortunate because the Crusaders didn't really understand that. Yeah if you yeah they or oh you're Orthodox, that sounds an awful lot like

Speaker 2sunny to me or something along those what's.

Speaker 3What's a Coptic? You know?

Speaker 1And you know if you said, you know, like Prester John, they'd be like what you know? So yeah, yeah, listen, they're not they're not sending their best skid.

Speaker 3Yeah, good people. All Crusaders are idiots. Yeah a there you go, there you go, Okay, we're cooking. Were good.

Speaker 2Yeah, let's yeah, that's the Uh, Jerusalem's kind of been like that because it's the it's the crux of like three major faiths. And I mean except in times of when you know, it is made off limits by people who occupy that land. Yeah, you know, mostly because people so many different people from so many different religions make pilgrimages there and at the time it was literally considered

Speaker 2the center of their world. So yeah, it's a very diverse place and it would be again even after the Crusaders, you know, mascred people, Yeah, mass arrests. Mattrassino, thank you very much for the question. Next time we got from Shiloh, who says, I've been working on a project involving putting together a timeline of medievalisms from Petrarch to now ish and I'm working with the Enlightenment right now, everybody, booval tear,

Speaker 2Is there a single one of these dweebs who isn't a Eurocentric racist.

Speaker 3Or listen personal?

Speaker 1Yeah, Like, like, first of all, I want to say thank you for your service. This is a good thing to be doing with your time. Thank you very much for that. But you know, fucking what could I say, tim drinking water in the in the river.

Speaker 3Side high or whatever?

Speaker 1Thing?

Speaker 3Not really you know.

Speaker 1Yeah, Like, look, I am afraid that all of these people are Eurocentric sweeps, and that is fundamentally part and parcel of the reason why they're so down on the medieval period because what they're doing expressly is they're arguing for a genocidal slave society and so that is why they like Rome, right, They like Rome because it's like it's good when Europeans dominate other cultures and they just

Speaker 1do enslavement all the time, like that, that's good actually, and I like it, right, And so you have to be like boo the Middle Ages when everyone's kind of doing their thing and Europe isn't dominating other people, right, so that like the two things are inextricably bound, as all historians love to say. So the historiography is just going to be people being loud, stupid, wrong and racist, and I wish I had better news for you because

Speaker 1you're just going to have to put up with a lot of that. But it's also one of the reasons why it is a very good thing to do, because you do get to feel good about making fun of these people who are fundamentally wrong because they're wrong because the racist that's yea, the deal is, you know.

Speaker 2Yeah, And I mean, I think it's interesting that you start with Petrarch because he is the genesis of the idea of the fall of Rome as like a as like a historiographical event and something that we kind of signpost in history. And I think when you do that and when you start focusing on Rome, you start you

Speaker 2start like myopically, you're narrowing your horizon for what you're talking about. And when you're trying to justify these things and so like when you get to people in the Enlightenment, the Renaissance and thing and the later Humanists and stuff like that, you are getting people who knowingly or unknowingly are working on a project of like a like a

Speaker 2an ideological project to justify why it is okay to send people over to this new world and and enslave and kill and steal from and rape and pillage these people. And when you do that, you have to start coming up with these narratives. And that begins first when you're talking about the Roman Empire, by forgetting the actual positive

Speaker 2things about Rome, which is that it was incredibly diverse. The imperial structure of it meant that it included Africans, it included every people from the levant Eastern Europe and obviously Central and Western Europe and basically even up into Britain. And that is like, that is a huge, extremely diverse panoply of people. But when you but this project involves

Speaker 2the like dwindling down of that, so Egypt, instead of becoming this rich, vibrant culture that's been around for so long, just becomes the bread basket. And you know the fact that Rome had, you know, pop had emperors who were of Levantine and African extraction is left in the dusk and they're all white because I'll see all the marble busts are white. So all these people must have been lily white like us when when they started inventing, you know,

Speaker 2modern racial categorization and theories like that. Now, of course, other ing people was always a problem in the Middle Ages. They did that, and there is evidence that people of different of of minority skin colors were were abused and killed for that, they were blamed for things. However, that is manifestly different than like a political project to try

Speaker 2and justify the rape of two new continents. And that's why it takes on the Eurocentric racism, as Eleanor said.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, it's like the whole thing is part and parcel. Unfortunately, I mean, like even the periodization thing, like you know, even like saying, you know, Ages like to be fairest part of that, and so that's something that we still really struggle with obviously, But.

Speaker 3You know, we're doing our.

Speaker 1Best out here, yeah, you know, in trying times.

Speaker 2But yeah, but I do think it's I mean, I do think it is necessary to do that and to not shy away from what these people were talking about are saying, because we take the corpus of work that they gave us, and while we don't. While a lot of the stuff that they said is bad, the corpus of work that they gave us is also the basis for a lot of how we think and act and talk to Dan. Yes, part of the project we do here,

Speaker 2and part of the broader academic and intellectual project now, is to extricate ourselves from like the worst impulses of Petrarch and Voltaire. Yeah, of course, and and John Locke and all you know, etcetera, etcetera, on down the line. But like and even like Tolkien and stuff, who was a great medievalist but had his own issues. You know, that's just part of what you do with history. And I think it's it's good to you know, even when they're saying these awful things, it's good to have that

Speaker 2so you can be like, yeah, that was very wrong. You know, let's talk about how that informed Voltaire's theory of X or Y or whatever.

Speaker 3Oh for sure.

Speaker 1Yeah, And I mean I think that it's all it's it's all part of a rich tapestry.

Speaker 3As Margins therapist, let's say, you know, and.

Speaker 1You know, and I suppose that the thing about doing history and doing historiography more generally is the fact that we can take this work and do other things with it, right, and and that is kind of, you know, the point of it. So, I mean, I think this is a really worthwhile project. Really excited to see how you get on. But yeah, it's an interesting one. I don't I don't think you're gonna have a way of getting around it, though, dog like sorry, yeah.

Speaker 3A look at my forefather's dog. There's no way. There's no way I'm getting out of it.

Speaker 2Like yeah, yeah, Charlotte, thank you very much for the question. Next, we have one from Joss the Texican is following up on something I said in I Believe the Livestock episode where I talked about fried chicken rankings and Jusa's question I will reproduce as best I can give me the fried chicken index. Right, all right, look, let's let's talk about this. So we kind of have to base it

Speaker 2off of chain restaurants. I absolutely know for a fact that there are better there's better fried chicken at the local spots everywhere. It's all like the best local spot, especially if you're in like a place that has like a lot of food fusion from different places around the world, that that local spot is almost certainly gonna have better fried chicken than like going to like KFC or Popeyes or whatever. However, yeah, you can't. Like, you know, if

Speaker 2I tell you there's a place in Atlanta called Agave that is a like Mexican fusion restaurant that does like this incredibly like spicy fried chicken, you'd be like, that's great. I live in Courtland or France or whatever anyway, So yeah, for me, fried chicken has to have two things. It has to be really crunchy and the chicken has to retain some moisture, unlike other things where I'm like, I

Speaker 2will try that at home. I do not fry. I do not deep fry anything at home. I do not have an industrial hood to take the smell out, and I don't want my house to smell like fried foods permanently because they do. Yeah, so there's a difference to me between fried chicken and the fried chicken sandwich. The fried chicken like you know, like with the bones and everything, like if it's crispy and crunchy and there. The breading

Speaker 2has to have flavor, because chicken does unless you brine it, unless you you marinate it or something like that. Chicken itself just doesn't have any flavor. It's a very it's a very flavorless meat. So it needs to be crispy, it needs to be crunchy, and it needs to be it needs to not lose that when you eat it. Now fried the fried chicken sandwich.

Speaker 3Like.

Speaker 2It's really really hard to fuck up a fried chicken sandwich, like it really is, Like it's so delicious. Yeah, as as as long as as long as you get like the as long as you just as long as the chicken is good, like the the actual frying and everything on it is good. It's really it's really hard. But yeah, so for like the regular chicken restaurants, Popeyes is number one. Popeyes is the best. They have good biscuits, they have

Speaker 2good sides, including oddly their fries are very good too. But they have you know, they have good slaw and baked beans and collar greens. I'm told I don't really like collar greens because yeah, I don't know the smell or something just really not do it for me. But yeah, Popeye's is the thing. However, if you go to a Popeyees, you have to understand one thing. They are going to

Speaker 2just talk to you straight up like they're not They don't do any of the like, you know, I'm gonna put on the biggest fucking smile I can or anything. If they're having a bad day, they're gonna be like, what do you want? And you're just gonna be like, I would like the fried chicken sandwich. I would like a you know, four piece or whatever, and they're you know, and they're gonna get it. And there is a ninety eight percent chance that your order will be wrong in some way. However, However, when I say wrong, that doesn't always mean worse, because sometimes you're like, oh that somebody

Speaker 2be like what you order. You'd be like, I got a two piece, you know, a breast and a thigh and you open it up and you got four pieces of chicken in there, and you're like, huh okay, cool and then now, but other times that means you're going to open it up, You're like, oh I got uh, I got chicken fingers. You open it up and it is fried shrimp. And to be clear, the fried shrimp they're very good too. But it does, uh it happens. Popeye's is a little spicy. Uh it is it just tastes like really it still tastes like like good, like

Speaker 2good uh home cooked fried chicken like it still does. It has its issues, but you know it's it's good. Uh. KFC, on the other hand, is absolute fucking dog shit. I hate KFC. I despise it.

Speaker 4Uh.

Speaker 2The like the extra crispy isn't even good, Like the stuff just like slides, it slides off the chicken. The batter they use is like it's basically just like salty. There's no other flaw. I hate. I hate KFC. I hate it. My wife, on the other hand, really likes KFC. And this is a long point in between us.

Speaker 3That's a house divided.

Speaker 2Yeah, oh yeah, totally yeah. I'm trying to think of other Oh, I guess if you count places like Zaxby's and Raising Canes, which are chicken finger restaurants.

Speaker 3I love America. What the fuck do you mean chicken finger restaurant, Hell.

Speaker 2Hell, and Guthries. They're all based on a place called Guthries, which I worked in college. I think I've told the story before about how I accidentally like deep fried my hand for like a quarter of a second. That happened in a Guthries when I was working there. Yeah, oh no, Yeah, it's uh. Those places are fine. I think Zaxby's is the best one, but if you are sensitive to sodium, stay away, stay far, far away. They're even worse than a normal place. As for the sandwiches, Popeyes, they they

Speaker 2kicked off that sandwich craze. There's is really good. Windy's used to have a really good one, but VC Venture Capital and all that bullshit has Uh, it's not any good. They're their plain one's fine, They're they're spicy chicken samich used to be really good, but now it's just whatever. It's sad.

Speaker 3Uh.

Speaker 2Chick fil A is fine if you're in the mood for it and you don't mind their bullshit. The one thing Chick fil A does that is good is they brine their chicken and pickle juice, which is good to me. But I don't eat there that much. Because their sandwich is really just kind of mid man where else like everywhere put it out of sandwich. McDonald's had a decent one for a while, but I think they've changed it since too. Basically, like, don't with a chicken sandwich, Like

Speaker 2all you have to do is just make sure like it tastes pretty good and you have some like pickles and some kind of sauce on there, and uh, yeah, it'd be fucking great. Don't uh don't it, yeah, don't don't fuck with it. Yeah, anyway, they like do not fucking KFC. Everybody's like, oh yeah, Kentucky for our chicken, and it's like, I no, it's terrible.

Speaker 3I want to shout out a London chain. Go please like London.

Speaker 1So, I mean, if if you're in London and you're looking for a Frederick, now this is South this is a South London answer, but it's also the correct London answer. I mean, listen, you're only going to get a South London answer out me because I guess I've been living here most of the time. So like, that's what's up. Now, Morley's shout out Morley's. Everyone in London is nodding their heads, right, now it's a specific South London thing. There's tons of them.

Speaker 3You can always you can always get a Morley's down here. I understand it might be spreading north of the River or whatever, which is cool, but that they are very good.

Speaker 1They're good for a four piece, they're good for a burger. Morley's is the one that you want. It is, you know, also kind of like much duplicated. So a big thing that we do here is that if there is a kind of famous chicken shop or whatever, and then people will kind of like try to dupe it. So sometimes you'll see places that are like mad Le's and things like that, like really funnily like in our neighborhood. So

Speaker 1we to have like a real down market chain, but chain no no less. That was called Favorite Fried Chicken. And then someone bought it and they didn't want to like change the sign too much because that costs money, so then they changed it to Favorable Fried Chicken.

Speaker 2As favorable as it was, it was giving like a passing Yeah.

Speaker 1But let me tell you one thing about Favorable Fried Chicken. I was not giving it a passing grade, although I was often going in there because it was like the chicken shop on my street. Yeah, that was like open when I was coming back from pub, which is one of the which is when you need them the most, you know. But anyway, Yeah, just Morley's very good, good on Sammy good on the whole situation. A London institution for a reason, so yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's you know, the thing with fried chicken is as long as the batter has good flavor to it, it doesn't have to be spicy. If you don't like spicy, that's fine. As long as it has flavor, then you could do You could do fried chicken, you could do chicken fingers, you could do chicken nuggets, you could do chicken sandwich anything. I'm starting to sound like a Bubba from Forrest Shrimp Shrimp at fe Shrimp. Yeah, I'm not going to do the voice. But you all know, if you're old enough, you know what I'm talking about. And

Speaker 2if you don't, well, I guess you can spend three hours of your life watching Weirdly Problematic.

Speaker 1I just wouldn't you know. I'm I'm with John Waters on this one.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's like you know, yeah, I got I got no special love for it.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah for sure.

Speaker 2Yeah, uh Jos, thank you very much for the question. Uh. Next, we got one from gaff See, who says, how is menopause understood in the medieval world? The practical element of no more babies, no more periods was presumably pretty obvious, but I'm curious about if there are any sort of religious or philosophical connotations that were attached to it.

Speaker 1Yeah, they think you're poisonous. Now that's cool, so I'm not even joking. So the like the medical idea here is that, okay, so what the reason why you have monarch and like the onset of the mensis in theory is because your body is becoming colder and wetter, you know, as as you age, like you're the hottest and driest when you're born, and then as you age and your

Speaker 1body becomes colder, so you no longer have the ability to burn off excess humors. Uh so the excess humor in this case, They're like, well, obviously you have excess blood, so you know you get rid of it by leaking. So the idea is that then when menopause happens, well, now you're not even able to burn off your excess blood, and so that means that you are becoming slightly or massively poisonous. And there are you know, rumors for example,

Speaker 1that especially old women can like kill people with their with like a glance or by touching them. Keep old women away from babies because like the like the poison from their back up menzis is good because like the idea is that like your menzies are then like backed up, like you're just full of blood that that should be got rid of.

Speaker 3Uh so yeah, like not good news.

Speaker 1Yeah yeah, uh huh I.

Speaker 2I struggle, I struggled. I've really I mean, poison is like because here's the thing, Like you're not even afforded the status of like a matron or like the you know, like you're not even afforded the respect and dignity of being like like the the matriarch of a house or a clan or something like that. At this misogyny is

Speaker 2so ingrained and so advanced that once you stop your primary purpose of being able to have children, you then just become a like slushing, inflated, poisoned, bloated me. Like I don't, like I don't. I'm not saying this to be like I'm I'm cool or whatever, but like I'm really fucking sorry for men, like I really am. I'm

Speaker 2just really goddamn sorry for for like like that is that is super advanced patriarchy.

Speaker 1That is like yeah, fucking christ, well, I mean, and it kind of also explains like why a lot of older women, and especially from you know, kind of the ruling classes, they're like all right, I'm on, get up out of here.

Speaker 3Uh you know when they they reached that.

Speaker 1And they're like, I'm going to join an unery or whatever, because it's like if that's how you're going to be treated, it's like fuck it.

Speaker 2You know, go to a nunnery where you can read in garden, like.

Speaker 1Yeah exactly, and they're like, stop wagging your dick at me.

Speaker 3Okay, you have fantastic.

Speaker 1I'm out, you know, so yeah, kind of depressing, you know, like I spent a lot of time justifying medieval people and being like they're not that stupid, and then they do shit like.

Speaker 3This to you, and you're like, okay, cool.

Speaker 2Well I think it's just I mean, they aren't stupid, but they but like we aren't stupid either, and yet we have like we we have these like insane like this like insane stuff that that goes on like we're we're not stupid, but like we haven't like we haven't done anything about climate change, not really like we know it's happening, but because we get like and I mean that is not the fault of any single person, you know, it's this ingrained system that we have, and it's different

Speaker 2now because we have like an advanced knowledge of it. So I think in a lot of ways that means we're actually like worse morally, if that's like if that's like a thing we're doing. But uh yeah, it's m yeah, I yeah, I don't know. I don't this is this is particularly like it's just so like man, I really like every every day, like I see something from from men and I'm just like, man.

Speaker 3Like okay, dude, Like man, like I get it.

Speaker 2I get I get I get why people. I get why people. I get why women are like fuck men just like fuck it like swearing it off like political lesbianism or whatever they call it. Like I get it. I completely fucking get it.

Speaker 1It's just like it's like you get like it's very difficult to work under these conditions.

Speaker 3You know, It's like what are you supposed to even fucking say sometimes you're just like okay, yeah.

Speaker 1Man, sure totally yeah, got it, got it cool?

Speaker 2Ye see, thank you very much for the question. Next, we got one from dog God. What are some of the less reputable jobs that existed in medieval societies? Did any professions have a stigma where, for example, you wouldn't want your daughter to marry a tanner, even if they made good money, because it was a smelly job.

Speaker 1Uh yeah, I mean executioner quite famously has rather a lot of stigma to it. It's like one of these ones where no one wants to do that because it's still quite bad.

Speaker 2You're killing people killing.

Speaker 1They're like, dog, I'm gonna I'm gonna level with you. You do kill people for money, and that's not great. So there is certainly that. Yeah, Like they they are kind of like there is snobbery like around tanning or butchery.

Speaker 3Yeah, that's that's another big one.

Speaker 1Again just in terms of like how it smells and and also we we tend to see, for example, that butchers often live very close together and that sort of a thing because like just socially, they don't want butchers all over town.

Speaker 3Yeah, because it's gross.

Speaker 1So they're like like, go to one place, get your butchery done, and and that's.

Speaker 3How we're gonna make it work.

Speaker 1So like those are two big ones, you know, Grave digger. You know, like there's a lot of there's a lot of stigma around death, uh and the and the things that kind of happened.

Speaker 3There in general.

Speaker 1Yeah, like basically anything that smells anything like minors to an extent just because it's like it's backbreaking work.

Speaker 2Like yeah, you're gonna love hanging out with your husband who is dead.

Speaker 1Yeah, like yeah, and you die really readily, uh in that in that particular profession. So yeah, a lot of that, but yeah, I mean you you've kind of like hit the nail on the head here. There's like a lot of understanding of it as being kind of linked to to smell and things like that, because you know, these are these are realities.

Speaker 3Of a lot of professions.

Speaker 1And also it's you know fundamentally kind of just like a smell of your time period where they're a little bit more matter of fact about that stuff, where they're like, yeah, that sucks and it smells.

Speaker 2Bad, you know yeah yeah yeah, yeah, uh yeah. Dog God, thank you very much for the question. Next one we got from at Ao Kennel, who says, I was just listening to the latest episode of Podcasting Is Practice, which you Eleanor guested on uh reading the article about celabus from Matthew Bussy, and I was excited to hear you mentioned that you were non monogamous, or specifically that you are not monogamous. Non monogamy still such a wild stigma

Speaker 2around it, so when I hear little clues of folks bringing it up, it reminds me of when I was a young, closeted teen so excited for clues about queerness. I was wondering if you've been on any podcast but non monogamy, polyamory, et cetera specifically, or if you've written anything about it, or if you have any recommendations of your favorite media about it.

Speaker 1Yeah, Like, no one ever asked me about the shit. Like one of the things that I think is quite funny about being I guess that it's like, as a general like what the fuck am I like a lot of the time I'll.

Speaker 3Just be like non monogamous because it's easier. I mean, I think.

Speaker 1Technically I'm like, I like Sam a relationship anarchist, because that is the way that I try to organize my relationships. I like to treat my friends as as important as, you know, my romantic relationships. What my romantic relationships boil down to is, you know, I'm the most wifed up bitch on the planet.

Speaker 3Like I'm not double wifed, you know. So yeah, I've got Blair my husband, and Justin my boyfriend.

Speaker 1But the thing about being this wifed up is it makes people really functionally uncomfortable because the way they want to understand polyamory or they want to understand non monogamy is that it's a form of cheating or that it's like messy, and that like it's always like a non binary person in Portland named sock right and now listen, SoC is valid. SoC is so valid. I want I do want to make that clear. But like the thing

Speaker 1about both of my relationships is that they're extremely long. I've been with my husband for going on it'll be twenty four years in August, and Justin and I have been.

Speaker 3Together for ten years.

Speaker 1So when you start like doing it for real, people are like, oh no, because it's like it's like, no, you're not supposed to do that. This is supposed to be a joke. And also it's really necessary that like your relationships be falling apart and that like you're you're kind of a monster, and you know, it's like one of the things that that that you know, nom monogamous people are always kind of like annoyed about.

Speaker 3Is that, Like it is true that like for some.

Speaker 1People, no monogamy is kind of like the last stop on the way to like breaking up with their partner because they're like, Okay, well, clearly something isn't working, like this isn't working, we need to try something else.

Speaker 3So then they'll go be like open relationship.

Speaker 1And that is kind of like the thing that most people experience if they've like know, if they know someone right who's kind of like gone through this and so they go, oh that like that's the thing that you just kind of do like when you're desperate or whatever, and then and then it all falls apart, and yeah, that is that is not not always like uh the case. And so yeah, and also like I don't know, bro, I'm just like a lot of it is is just like Google calendars. It's like incredibly unsexy. It's the answer.

Speaker 1But no, I haven't really written anything about it. Because like it's it's mostly just the way I organize my life. Do I have a lot of political things to say about this? Obviously, yes I do, but like I don't know, no, like no, no one ever wants to hear about my boring ass life, mostly because I'm boring, you know, and it's just like I don't know, man, like like I do you ever wonder what it be like to have two mothers in law? Because because I got too like like that kind of a thing.

Speaker 3So it's it just kind of is what it is.

Speaker 1If anybody is like running a show about this, happy to come on and discuss my my complex it's actually not that complex, but my not normative lifestyle.

Speaker 3I guess I don't know.

Speaker 1Yeah, Like I guess that I like there is stuff to say about nominogamy in the medieval period, which I kind of like try to hint at in my work, but yeah, I don't know. Otherwise, listen to Justin's podcast Culture Sex Relationships if you want to actually like get some good insight into kind of like the political ways that I think about this, because you know, he's the actual sex and relationships expert and I'm just like with him, so h yeah, like, I guess that's a shout out

Speaker 1to a good Sister podcast. And you know, I don't know. Yeah, I'm not that interesting. I'm I'm just a I'm just an old person who you know. The dudes in my life are pretty great, which is the thing. I'm like, what, like it's hard. I would simply form a multiple, long lasting, committed relationships.

Speaker 3That's what I would do. I don't know if you try that, you.

Speaker 2Know, yeah, sounds good to me. I got nothing. I got nothing. I've been in a committed monogamous relationship for We've been married for almost twenty years. It'll be twenty years in August, well, nineteen years in August. But yeah, no, good for y'all. I don't know, I got I wish people were less weird about about about all of it, like everything, like it's the jokes are fun, the Google calendar,

Speaker 2that's fun.

Speaker 1But like y one likes to make fun of polyamorous people more than polyamorous people. Yeah, like that, like that's our specialty, the number one, Like there's no one more annoyed with polyamorous people than polyamorous people.

Speaker 2So yeah, but I also don't like I don't even get the taboos about this one, because like polyamory is like fucking incredibly old and incredibly like, oh yeah, normalize like for for large parts of history. It doesn't matter anyway.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, the victorians did a number on us. All let's just say.

Speaker 2That's a good that's a good that's a good point. Yeah, at a O. Kennell, thank you very much for the question. We got one from Ali Kant, who says, what's the deal with Monk's skin being fashioned to cover book bindings? I'm assuming it was part of their last wishes before death? But why they're metal as fuck?

Speaker 3Oh?

Speaker 1They just fucking love books, mate, Yeah, love books them.

Speaker 3Yeah, Like I mean it's yeah, it's metal as fuck.

Speaker 1Yeah, but it's just kind of like that's what they've dedicated their lives to, and you know, books are incredibly precious objects.

Speaker 3So yeah, it's like it's kind of just like, hell, you have brother times. You know, they identify with their work. I think it's probably the way to put it. So they just want to yeah, like they just want to keep doing it.

Speaker 1It's like I suppose it's a way to like be directly involved with it.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah, yeah, they just yeah, you what what better way to leave a lasting impression on history than to be bound up? Then to be bound as like a as like a beautiful uh you know, beautiful manuscript or something like that. What's the.

Speaker 1And like I think I think that it's so cool because I mean then, like you know, when it's like brother Reginald's skin or whatever, right, like that's that is a lasting legacy.

Speaker 3Like when we do that, you know, we'll see that.

Speaker 2Everybody at the library is like they just keep talking about like, oh this look, how look how lovely this copy of whatever is and it's and you're in heaven.

Speaker 3You're in heaven just being like hell yeah, bra.

Speaker 1Like uh, And I you know, like I think it's cool because I like it when they like, you know, uh what I like. I'm just I've got a chapel roone in my fucking head now. I like what you like, et cetera. Just like me and monks, you know we see eyed eye on this, uh you know that and stuck and dick.

Speaker 3Good times. It's good times over here. We're rolling. It's uh.

Speaker 1I don't mean a monk, because I know most of your chaste do I kind of mean it.

Speaker 2I don't know, I can't. I can't. Thank you very much for the question. We got two more, ah, okay, okay, we got The next one is from vast and Trunkless Tozzies, who says loved learning more about the Fall of Rome from your podcast. But I was wondering why did and

Speaker 2China fracture into one hundred tiny states after the collapse of the Sui dynasty. And yeah, in case you were wondering, the Sui dynasty was just after them, I believe. Yeah, okay, So there was the the Tang dynasty and then the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, and that led into

Speaker 2the Song. Before the Tang were the Sui. Now, the Sui had fused what had been known as the Northern and Southern dynasties together when it was previously broken China. China has fractured a few times, but as the Middle Ages went on, it started happening less. There was the Sixteen Kingdoms during the rule of the Gin. There was the Three Kingdoms of course, which we know from the

Speaker 2romance of the Three Kingdoms after the fall of the Han dynasty, and as I mentioned, there was the Five Dynasties of ten Kingdoms but I think the reason that it didn't break apart was because the dynasties in China had been They had started in like the thirteen fourteen

Speaker 2hundred's BCE, and when the Jiao, when the Jiao became preeminent, they took over from the Shang, and I believe it was like ten forty something BCE. They began a real bureaucratic centralization that initially started with a bunch of them breaking apart, but then as they came together and they formed back together, they eventually during the Warring Kingdom's period, they eventually formed into the Chin dynasty, you know, Chin Chi Wonde, and that was the first, the first Empire,

Speaker 2the first Imperial China. And so they had all been working towards this common idea of what China meant for a long time. And I mean as time went on, that grew from like Inner China to the outer China to then including these these mountain clans and all these people and blah blah blah. But they were working around that, whereas Rome was not. Rome had already been split in

Speaker 2two because of just the geographical and historical concerns, and it couldn't when it went and it split. Constantinople couldn't hold it together. They tried and failed, and the people in the east in western Rome, they didn't want to be united like that anymore. I'm sure that you know, the Goths or the Visigoths or whoever could have like

Speaker 2tried to do that. But they sent what uh what was his name is Theodoric st st Romulus, Augustulus's purple cloak and his scepter and everything back to back to Constantinople and was like, we don't need it any more. Thanks, Like nobody took over to reunite it. Like I guess, I guess someone maybe could have, but I don't know. It seems pretty tenuous.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean I think that that, like you're kind of bang on here, and it's like we do tend to see like whenever we see dynasties fall in China, one of the big differences is that like you know, you see you know bits flake off right. So for example, it's like the lose control of Taiwan, or like they'll lose control of whoever they took over most recently. But there is more of a unified vision of the idea of a China that exists over there, and also it really benefits people. Yeah, like like a lot of them

Speaker 1are actually kind of like benefiting from this kind of concept of imperium, this way of organizing the world in a way that they just kind.

Speaker 3Of weren't for for Rome.

Speaker 1By the time you get you get to the fall, right, so it's sort of like, yeah, I mean, like that'd be nice, that'd be cute if we could make it work, but like let's be so for real, and you know, by the time like we have the quote unquote fall, it's like, well, the taxation structure is like gone. You know, a lot they the amount of violence that was required to keep Rome going was I would argue, probably greater

Speaker 1than what.

Speaker 3You tend to see on a day to day level in in Han China, you know, So.

Speaker 1That that is is kind of part of it. And also like you've got a different structure of like concepts of citizenship. So in Rome it's like, you know, you might be subject to Rome, but you're not a fucking citizen, right, And like China doesn't have the idea of citizenship in the same way. So it's also not kind of creating out groups in the same way.

Speaker 3So it makes it more. It makes it easier for people to.

Speaker 1Say, oh, okay, well you know this, this benefits me, right, whereas it might not benefit you.

Speaker 3In the same way if.

Speaker 1You are living in Rome and you are like not a fucking patrician, right. So yeah, I just think that it's like structurally different.

Speaker 3In terms of what we're talking about.

Speaker 1For for imperial purposes, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, And I mean by the time, so the Sui dynasty lasted from five to eighty one to six eighteen CE, and by the time in six eighteen the concept of the Mandate of Heaven and the Chinese Empire was over eight hundred years old at that point, and it was it was a very overriding mythos. There are far more people in this area of the world than there were

Speaker 2in the Roman Empire. They I mean, during the Warring States period, they had they had armies in the field that had sixty two, one hundred thousand troops each in them. That was something that was far greater than, you know, than anyone else was capable of putting out right at that point, and you had had all of these structures, and I mean you think about it, if you go all the way back to the to the Shang which

Speaker 2is you know, like fourteen fifteen hundred CE, I mean BCE, like you've been working toward a common goal of some kind towards. Then now the land has expanded, as we said, to cover like wider and wider sas of what we now understand is China, but it's still they still have this goal. And even after the Warring States when it was united under a Chinchi Wangdi, it's they've they've already

Speaker 2changed their system. The imperial system of China lasted from to twenty something I'm sorry, like to sixty something BCE until nineteen eleven, and only reverted out of and only really reverted outside of that system during the rule of Wang Mang and that was like fucking like twenty CE and that that was like a very very brief return

Speaker 2for like fifteen or twenty years, and then they went back and like it's they were all they all had this idea of what they wanted and they could do it because they had this fertile, really nice land. But you know, whereas Western Rome didn't, I mean, all those groups, there were plenty of warlords there that could have reunited it. Just like the warlords of China, you know, reunited into an empire whenever they after they split apart, but like

Speaker 2they didn't. They were like, no, we're going to be We're gonna have our own little land. They're going to be Franks and Goths and added out and outa da da dah.

Speaker 1You know yeah everyone else Yep, it's it's too much work, Like it just wasn't worth the admin to them. Nope, you know, so the you know, the things had already. I think I think things have kind of contracted enough already that it was just like, yeah, no, we're good dog. Yeah, yeah, we got a period at home.

Speaker 2Yeah exactly, Yeah, we don't. We don't need this vastin trunkles Tozi's thank you very much for the question. Lastly, we got one from it Ninja Maxing, who says currently taking classes on historical Ninja and Shinobi, writing a paper for the class. It turns out so much shoddy English language scholarship can be transport traced back to the subpar work of one dude. What is the equivalent of this in your field of interest slash research in the medieval period? Like,

Speaker 2are there popular misconceptions about something medieval that there are the fault of one dude.

Speaker 1Oh god, I mean that that this is a really good question and I was kind of like racking my brains about it, but like I've got a medieval answer for this.

Speaker 3Yeah, I've got this.

Speaker 1So I've got a personal beef. Here's it's Eleanor's personal beef corner. Okay, you know my guy, you know my man, my man there Millach. So he one of the main the main autobio autobiographies, the main biographies we have of his life.

Speaker 3There's one written by.

Speaker 1Like some fucking like Oh god, I hate him Balbein, who is a monk who works during the Counter Reformation, and he's like he's just trying to.

Speaker 3Be like, no, Chuck's always love the Church. No, and he sucks.

Speaker 1But the main one that we work with is the Narzia Milo, which is fun to say. It is written by this guy, Amatya Ivanov, who is a follower of Militch who kind of comes after him.

Speaker 3He claims to have been his student. Bro, he never studied with him, but.

Speaker 1He very similarly to Milic, is obsessed with the concept of anti Christ and he preaches about him a lot. Right, Unlike Milich, who is a kind of on the light right, the right side of what that means. He gets in a lot of trouble and gets told to stop preaching. So while he gets he's like in trouble and he's under interdict and he's supposed to stop preaching, he writes this big thing that is that is called like the Novi vetter is a regularly testamentum, and he's writing out his whole concept of theology, and he's talking about he

Speaker 1puts this life of Militch in there, and in this life of Milach he claims that one day Milach was giving a sermon and the Emperor Charles the fourth was in attendance, and and Militch then points at the Emperor Charles the fourth and says, if you want to know who the great anti Christ.

Speaker 3Is, it's him. And he points and he points at Charles the Fourth.

Speaker 1Everyone loves this story. They love it so much. They love it more than anything else in the entire fucking world. Because it doesn't matter if you're like pro Milach or you're pro Charles the Fourth.

Speaker 3I'm prob.

Speaker 1But on the one hand, it lets you tell story. If you if you like Charles the Fourth, it's like, oh, it, isn't he magnanimous? He like didn't even you know, arrest this guy or kill him when he called him anti Christ, right, And then if you're like pro militic, it's like, oh, yeah, he's not afraid to speak truth the power, like he'll like he'll fuck you up.

Speaker 3He'll just he just says it, says it like he sees it.

Speaker 1But the trouble is that one hundred percent didn't fucking happen.

Speaker 3Oh my god, Like there's no way that happened.

Speaker 1I wrote my whole fucking PhD about how there's no fucking way that happened. And these guys like really really work incredibly close together. Militch is like writing all these sermons being like I think that the that the emperor needs to be involved with the pope in reorganizing the church, Like he did not call that man anti Christ, right, because like, why is he saying that like that the emperor should be involved in a synod with the pope if that's what he thinks, Like absolutely, one hundred percent no, But that story gets repeated over and over And I proved this in my fucking PhD in twenty fucking fifteen,

Speaker 1and I have to like have this argument over it over again, because everyone likes this fucking story like this new, this new like it claims to be, it purports to be, like a new history of Prague, all of it.

Speaker 3It's written by a modernist. This woman repeats it, and I just and it drives me insane because it's like, well, you.

Speaker 1Don't know anything about Mileach except this story, right, but you like the story because it's like a big sexy story.

Speaker 3It's a big sexy story. It's like really really fun. But there's no fucking way that happened. Dog, there's no way that happened.

Speaker 1And now, like you can't even talk about my weird little preacher guy without people telling this goddamn story when it didn't fucking happen. Fuck you, Matthew Yadoff, I'll see what hell fucking liar like. He obviously wrote that freaking story so that people wouldn't be mad at him, because he'd be like.

Speaker 3Oh, you know how you know how you like Milliach. I'm kind of like him in the thing.

Speaker 1No you're not, but fucking tamu ass Milich, Yeah, I hate that man.

Speaker 2That's awesome, I would say, I found I had a couple of examples about this. First of all, anything Herodotus says about anyone, any non hell Hellenic state is either at best an inflation or more likely just whatever myth and legend they had hanging around at the time. He he did try to consult real sources where they existed. But I mean he like all the stuff he writes about,

Speaker 2like the Persians and what they said, and like all of these different things about, especially about the Greek and Persian War, which like I mean, formed the basis of how we understand that war from the time they were written until like I I mean, one of the most famous like examples of this is the movie three hundred and the terrible Frank Miller graphic novel three hundred about the Thermophylae and the Spartans and all this sort of stuff.

Speaker 2And it's like, you know, you have all this like the decaded, debauched Persian king who is clearly like a you know, is his dark skin and everything like that, and I mean that you know, they have monsters following them, and their their soldiers aren't aren't even a tenth of what a Greek or a Spartan or an Athenian would be or whatever. All that is herodotous. All of that is myth making, and uh, you know it's.

Speaker 1It's really powerful that it's very difficult to get rid of it.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's been around for twenty five hundred years, and I mean some of the stuff he does say is has been proven out, but it's only been proven out by we've discovered, like inscriptions, Persian monuments and things like that, but also archaeological work and that sort of stuff. Another example for the Crusades. In eleven ten, Albert of Ike's wrote his chronicle, and it is considered to be one

Speaker 2of the best. He interviewed close to, if not more than, one hundred people about this. He got as first hand account as he could find. He consulted stuff. But in the retelling of this he retold it from the idea that Peter the Hermit was the one who inspired Pope Urban the Second to actually do this, He was the brains behind the operation and everything like that, and that is categorically false in every way. Peter was, of course

Speaker 2very important to the First Crusade for various reasons, was probably just a church hanger on or a very very low level cleric to begin with and he was just he just became a fireburm preacher and that was that. But yeah, from the time that Albert wrote that, which was in eleven ten, until about the eighteen fifties, historical consensus was that Peter the Hermit was the brains behind the first Crusade. He was the one that gave Urban

Speaker 2the second this idea. And I mean it doesn't to us now. It's a funny footnote, but like said, that's seven hundred years of academic consensus that people did have to work to be like come.

Speaker 1On, oh yeah, like really you think so? Yeah, yeah, yeah, And your fun answer is, of course Dante and anyone he put into hell, because no matter what happens for the rest.

Speaker 2Of history, those people are in hell. To us, they are. Doesn't matter how much they actually helped him, or they didn't do any of that stuff, or they're not actually real people, doesn't matter fucking hell. Enjoy Yeah, Ninja Maxon, thank you very much for the question. That is going to do it for us today. A little bit longer of a mailbag, but we we had to talk about the pope being weak on crime. Crime. I'm tired of it. I'm tired I'm tired of these these these scofflaw popes.

Speaker 1I get these motherfucking popes off my motherfucking plane.

Speaker 3Okay, like they're a week.

Speaker 2On crime, he's a week on crime. But no, no, no, God damn it. I can't believe I didn't bring it up. But I guess people who are listening to this to the end will get this treat. So somebody pointed out that the rate of petty crime in Vatican City is actually like no, no, no, it's actually it's it's it's kind of weirdly high. It's like one point six to six petty crime. Yeah, exactly at the Vatican.

Speaker 3The Roman pickpockets never sleep, they stay all no.

Speaker 2So someone was like, someone was like, oh, no, it's much worse than we thought. Not only is the pope week on crime, but Trump was actually right. Anyway, folks, thank you all for listening. We hope you enjoyed it as much as we do, because, uh, it's very rare that you just get something like that teed up for like your medieval industry show. But he's like, here you go, avignon, Babacy, Western schism, Uh, Pope week on crime. Like all right, man,

Speaker 2thanks for thanks.

Speaker 3That is ass. Get he's fucking.

Speaker 2Ass Jesus Christ. As I said, next time, we'll be back with another mail back episode. But please do check out our episode on Between Two Fires, which is coming on Friday for patrons. Check out Eleanor and Phoebe's limited series on wolf Hall and uh yeah, just uh yeah, Eleanor, what what's going on with you?

Speaker 3Uh yeah? I think that's what it was.

Speaker 1So I was supposed to do, I said, the other week, check me out on politics theory other but then Alex got sick and I tried to remind him that he was a leftist and that we were going to like work while he was sick. So I think that's going to be coming out, like I should be recording it now on Friday. I'm trying to get him to expanded some medievalisms generally, so I can talk about the avenue on papacy thing. But I don't know, like he wants to do a lot of reading, so I'm not sure if that's gonna pan.

Speaker 3Out, So do go look for that? Yeah, I don't know.

Speaker 1Otherwise, you know where your girl's at on the socials. Yeah, that's that's what's going now.

Speaker 2Yep. You can find me, Lucas Amazing on this stuff. You can find my show People's History of the Old Republic where I talk about Star Wars. You can find that wherever you're listening to this. Yeah, otherwise, that is going to do it for us today. Thank you all very much for listening, and we'll see you next time.

Speaker 3Bye, Stay sloppy, I remembered

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode