Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very vague terms, so we decided to do more of a deep dive about why it was so awful to live from about 1453-1800, not as a moral judgment of those people who lived at that time but instead because the birth of the modern world was an absolute horror show for the entire planet and you didn't even have modern medicine or air conditioning yet. this is when the Leviathan is born into the world cover image is a stock photo of an edition of Hobbes' Leviathan

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I'm excited because it is at the time of recording this. It's Friday the 6th here in London. And this evening I'm going to go see the George Michael Faith in concert.

Speaker 2Is that a cover band?

Speaker 1No, it's a movie of tour footage of the Faith tour. Oh, cool.

Speaker 2So that would have been like, what, 91?

Speaker 191. Yeah, something like that. So I'm pretty hype. Nice. Yeah. So I'm going to go over to Leicester Square and see it at the movies. Although I was really annoyed because like the British Film Institute was showing it today because it's like opening day. And I was like, hell yeah, brother. Like, I'll go see that. And it was like all of these insane times. It was like 545. And I'm like, like, you don't get to be a capitalist country and then be like, oh, yeah, it's 545 on a fucking Friday. It's like I'm working here.

Speaker 2You know, working or in or like in transit somewhere because it's 545 on a Friday.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Like, how the fuck am I going to make that? Like, I can't exactly call into work anyway. So, like, I'm working till half six tonight. Come on, man. So, yeah, but I found one at 730. So that'll be good. Nice. Yeah. Yeah. It's just I wanted a bigger screen. Then it's a big screen, you know, and it is enough to see George Michael's face large and beautiful, obviously. But, you know, I just wanted to see it larger. But that's all right. That's okay. So yeah, that's what's up over here. As always,

Speaker 1every day is a great day to treasure the memory of important communist George Michael.

Speaker 2That's right.

Speaker 1I think also, like, since also as of recording, Russell Brand was convicted of rape yesterday. It's also always an important time, I think, to remember that, like, the cool thing about George Michael is he's the opposite of all other celebrities. You know, like, all other celebrities are a piece of shit rapists who are awful. And then, like, George Michael was just constantly fucking consensually. And then he died and it turns out he was also, like, a huge philanthropist. And just also that everyone was allowed to

Speaker 1talk about the communism again because you were never allowed to talk about the communism while he was alive. Lest people be put off. But, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. Sick.

Speaker 1I'm just saying, some people... Russell Brand once propositioned a friend of mine on Hampstead Heath in a very creepy and skeezy manner, and it was, like, not very good. George Michael was propositioning men out on Hampstead Heath, hashtag consensually. He was... Like, he was absolutely getting after it up there, and it's a beautiful thing. It's a beautiful thing, so....

Speaker 2Yeah, it's... I like... Yeah. I like George Michaels. He's fun. He's one of the only men I've ever seen pull off the Farrah Fawcett layered feather hair thing. It's diabolical how nice his hair was.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's really wild. I'll tell you what, not to get the calipers out, but what are the Greeks doing? What's in the water over there? Why is their hair that good?

Speaker 2Yeah, what is it? The keratin or whatever's in your hair that makes your hair look lustrous and shiny. Yeah, well, you know, as always, you gotta have faith. You gotta have faith.

Speaker 1That's one of the earliest music videos I remember watching on MTV.

Speaker 2I remember that, and I was like, And I remember that and that was so burned into my mind because there's all these like gorgeous women around him. And then when I found out like a few years later that he was gay, I was like, wait, no. What about the women he was in? Because I was like younger and now it's like, yeah, you idiot.

Speaker 1The divas know. They do. The divas know. I do. I remember when the Freedom 90 video was out and I just remember seeing it. It was like one of the first times I kind of really understood music videos as art.

Speaker 2Yeah. You know, I was like.

Speaker 1Oh my, I see, you know, like, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think one of the first times I understood music videos as art was waking up and seeing Britney Spears' Hit Me Baby One More Time video when I was like 15 on MTV. You know, I understood them as art. Oh, good times. Yeah, so that's cool. I'm glad you get to do that. This is like a

Speaker 2brand new movie, I'm assuming?

Speaker 1Yeah, it's brand new. It's opening day here in the UK, so I shall go out. But it's just basically resurfaced footage that they've remastered. I mean, someone was filming it, so it's just going to be good. It's the closest I'm ever getting to a George Michael concert, so that's exciting.

Speaker 2That's awesome. Well, good. That's cool. I'm glad you get to go do that. Anyway, let's get on to the show and talk about periodization.

Speaker 1One of the worst times to be alive?

Speaker 2One of the worst times to be alive. Periodization. Hello

Speaker 2and welcome back to We're Not So Different. a podcast about how i uh confused uh faith and freedom uh when i was talking just earlier yeah um anyway uh this is episode 301 why the early modern period sucked uh we're gonna talk about that and find out why um but before we get there uh we do have a couple of questions uh First, from Laura and Pegasus,

Speaker 2who says, what happened to a monk slash nun who was kicked out of a monastery as punishment? Could they join a different order, go back to their family? Are there any records of what happened after?

Speaker 1So it's uncommon for this to happen. And usually what will happen is that, like, they'll just be kind of mean to you within the monastery or nunnery. Like, they'll kind of like. you'll get sent to your room like they'll put you in solitary that kind of a thing so that goes on and usually what they do is they actually send you to another one they send you to another like monastery or nunnery because it's often thought that like what you're attempting to do is like reenter the world right and so they're like what they're going

Speaker 1to do is like look at what happened with Abelard for example they're like yeah we're going to put you in a monastery where everyone wants to kill you yeah.

Speaker 2And you're not going to help yourself one iota.

Speaker 1No, not even fucking slightly.

Speaker 2He's got the Jan Hus Memorial Death Drive going. He's like, yeah, I fucking hate Sandini. Not real at all. He's a dumb bitch who wasn't ever alive. And they're like throwing, you know, like torches at him.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. So they often just kind of it's usually not that you're kicked out of the order is the answer. It's usually that you're sent to like a more deprived one or they make you work harder or they cut your rations, stuff like that. It's like because you took a vow, right? And there's like this vow of obedience. So it's usually– it's really unusual to actually be kicked out of an order is the answer. So, yeah, yeah. Like you might– people run off. You know, like Joanna

Speaker 1of Leeds quite memorably and that sort of thing. So people will often run off, but not usually that one can return. Now, you can sort of be returned if, for example, you're from a really high up family and they need you to be king of France or something suddenly. But like for the most part, they kind of like return you to your family, I guess, if these things do happen. It's like you go back to the fam and the fam can fucking deal with how embarrassed they are by you, you know.

Speaker 2Like how embarrassed they are that you got kicked out like a like a dumb ass uh yeah laura and pegasus thank you very much for the question uh next got one from sir gawain and the green tea who says my brother collects drinking glassware and we were wondering would it be a bigger flex for a medieval household to have a set of matching drinking glasses for guests or many different glasses of various styles but just one of each and well yeah did they have a lot of did peasants have a lot of like like normal

Speaker 2people have a lot of glassware.

Speaker 1Oh like a glassware i mean if you're if you're like a rich peasant sure but glassware is pretty expensive right like one of the only things that we have left uh of in terms of like physicality from eleanor of aquatain is the wedding present she gave louis and it's like a it's like a crystal vase yeah like so it's like this is a really big deal And the answer is he wouldn't necessarily even really have such a thing as matching glasses. Right. Anyway, because since they all have to be hand-blown. and made, like the glass

Speaker 1guys are just going to be wiling out making weird little guys, you know, that kind of a thing. It's a very difficult one to say, though, because glass survives to us so infrequently. It does.

Speaker 2It does.

Speaker 1Mm-hmm. But it's like we don't have a matching set of like whatever. But I would imagine I think that probably you might have like two matching glasses. I think that generally one way or another having glasses at all is a huge fucking flex. So it sort of doesn't matter. It's just going to be up to your taste and like whatever the glass guy has on offer also. Very expensive thing to have. Yeah.

Speaker 2Most of like poorer... like middle sort to poor peasants were going to probably have wooden everything or like crude, like a metal. And I don't mean crude isn't badly done. I mean, like, it's just not going to be ornate or whatever, you know, most likely because, uh, ornamentation costs money and, uh, they don't have a lot of money and, you know, uh, you, you will have like pottery and glassware industries, uh, And a lot of times in history,

Speaker 2especially like for prehistory in places, you'll have like archaeological complexes. Like you'll hear like the corded ware culture. And those were people who pressed their pottery with like cords and stuff. And they're done in the same style, but, you know, they're not the same style enough that you can tell. But they're not like exact, even from one person to the next, because, you know, for the most part. You

Speaker 2just don't have that precision in a lot of things yet. But yeah, Sir Gawain in the green tea, thank you very much for the question. If you want to ask us questions like these, please do subscribe to the Patreon. Patreon.com slash WNSDPod. It is five bucks a month. You get to ask us questions. You get access to the Discord. You get all the episodes ad-free and our bonus episodes as well. And if you just can't get enough of us, also check out Welcome to the Crusades dot com. We

Speaker 2just released season two on the second crusade and you can check that out. It is it's a lot of fun. It's 10 episodes. You can go get it. I think it's 15 now, 15 for for the season or 25 for seasons one and two. So check that out if you're interested. We did it with Danny and Derek from American Prestige. So, yeah, go have a listen to that

Speaker 2and go sign up if you want to check it out.

Speaker 1Yeah, please do. It's good. We worked hard on it. And also it will help you argue with annoying chuds more better. So that's true.

Speaker 2Yeah. Anyway. On to the main show. So a patron from the River to the Seaaboo asked us a question. It was a very prescient question and one that we could use because we had to record this on short notice. But it's one that there are a lot of examples. So, yeah. And they asked, is it on topic to do an episode about how much the early modern period affected Sucked.

Speaker 1Sucked.

Speaker 2It sucked.

Speaker 1It sucked.

Speaker 2It is on topic, actually, and something we allude to often but haven't really expounded upon at length. Why did the early modern period suck? Like, why do we constantly say that? I mean, haven't the hosts of this very podcast said, even in the title of the show, that we're really not so different from one another over vast spans of time? Well, yes. Isn't it also true that for the vast majority of people on Earth, rural peasant farmers, There wasn't a whole lot of functional difference in the lives of one who lived in 1400 and one who

Speaker 2lived in 1700. Again, yes. So then isn't this whole discourse more of an exercise in relitigating old grievances because Victorians had negative and ahistorical views on medieval people and prejudiced academic and popular conception against the Middle Ages for over 150 years? Aren't we just complaining about outdated views on the Dark Ages all over again? Okay, first off, how fucking dare you?

Speaker 1Fuck you. Wow.

Speaker 2Secondly, yes, we do have an axe to grind with the awful way that medieval people are portrayed. Those worthless Victorian bastards. I almost said Victorian. Victorian Greyjoy. Just, again, like Anakin Skywalker, a character I love because he's the dumbest guy in a universe of very dumb people. Anyway... But neither the Victorian bastards or Victorian Greyjoy are the primary reason we're here. To put it quite bluntly, there were real tangible differences that began to crop up over

Speaker 2the years as technology progressed, but political rights and consciousness lagged woefully behind for millions upon millions of people. This is not a value judgment, but a trend that is apparent in the historical and archaeological records. While a peasant farmer in Eurasia might be using the same methods and living in a very similar house to one who lived in that same part of Eurasia 300 years before. Things were getting worse before they ever started to get better. Technological advancement is a fact of life for humanity, and

Speaker 2it always has been, but just because it's a fact of life doesn't mean it's not incredibly painful. The birth of the modern world is a horror show for almost all involved. Nation-states began to centralize and solidify their control over lands and peoples. Borders began to harden. Gunpowder made life cheaper and easier to take. Exploration brought the world together and colonialism snuffed out countless lives and civilizations in the name of progress. It's the time when capitalism as

Speaker 2we understand it began to take its earliest steps and the process of primitive accumulation kicked into overdrive as common land's were enclosed, old ways were abandoned, communal relationships dissolved, but the oppressive obligations remained. The world was coming together, the printing press made it easier for people to disseminate their views to one another, and heady new political ideals were swirling all about, but the reality on the ground was a horror show. The divine right of kings, absolute monarchies,

Speaker 2chattel slavery, colonial administration, and a thousand other new innovations made oppression easier and cheaper than it had ever been before. but mass political consciousness was still in the offing. Sure, it showed up in fits and starts with rebellions and revolts scattered across the world, but those were almost uniformly put down and reactionary political ideology held sway across the globe. So it's not that people of the early modern were worse or anything like that. It's that the people in power held all the cars and mass politics was still a little ways off. Waiting until 1792 when the French

Speaker 2finally got really really goddamn mad for all the right reasons. But that's the end of the early modern period. Let's talk about the actual reasons it got worse. Um, there are, uh, many, uh, we're just going to talk through, uh, a few of them, but, um, you know, I think it's helpful to remember, um, you know, the, uh, we, when we talked about the land management series, I talked about, uh,

Speaker 2Fernand Braudel, who is a, um, Marxist, uh, historian who passed away in the seventies. Um, and he had this kind of rubric for like how, uh, how the, the trajectory of history has worked, which is that typically technology, technology and, um, if you think about these things as like two, uh, two, two lines running in parallel and, um, They're kind of racing each other. Technological progress and political power,

Speaker 2political ideology and formation at the very top are typically out ahead of the social progress that people are making and the political consciousness that they have. And for most of history, those two things are widely... varying however in the early modern period like they start to go they start to pull so far apart and technology and everything

Speaker 2is way out in front and this is the mechanism by which things get worse it's not like the people who lived on the the 99 percent of people who weren't in like that top strata they are the same as people of the as the as medieval people just Their ideas and possibly some of the technology they use has progressed a little bit more, much like we are the same people as our great-grandparents and so on. We just have more technology, yada, yada. But the medieval era

Speaker 2across the world is marked by these combined communal and binding relationships that are two-way streets. It doesn't mean there's not oppression involved in this. It doesn't mean that it's not a violent, awful process that involves the defiling of the planet and people, but... But there is a fundamental

Speaker 2difference between a lord-tenant relationship or a lord-serve relationship where there is a reciprocal and mutual rights going on to a landlord-tenant relationship where you are paying for the pleasure of being there. Oh, and also they control all the stuff above you. Those are functionally different. uh, different. And so this is the, this is the idea. And towards

Speaker 2the end of this, as we talked about in like 1792, and of course you can like, you can fudge these numbers how you want. I typically think of the early modern from like 1492 to 1792, you could do 1453 to 15 or to like 1800, like anything in that range is fine. But like, at the end of this is when political consciousness and, and, and the first early inklings of real, what we can see as class consciousness start to crop up. And that's when you start to

Speaker 2have like what you would call it, proto-socialist and people like that, like Gerard Winstanley and, you know, but yeah, so Eleanor, like, I mean, we joke about it and, and, you know, a lot of that stuff is like, Um, the Victorian, but like in historiographical terms, like I, like what, like what was the old idea of like why people in this early modern period were better, uh, than, than

Speaker 2people before, than medieval people before them? What, what was the idea there?

Speaker 1Yeah, so this is one of these things that we can really link to, in particular, the Enlightenment and their ideas about all of this. So, like, again, this is one that we can kind of lay squarely at the feet of Voltaire, enemy of the pod. So the idea here is that when Voltaire talks about it, what he talks about, how he characterizes the medieval period is he calls it the Age of Faith. And he contrasts this

Speaker 1in opposition to what we would call the early modern period and what he calls the age of reason. And so essentially what he's done.

Speaker 2We're such conceited fucking assholes. We really are.

Speaker 1I know. It's like, holy shit, man. I know, right?

Speaker 2Fuck you.

Speaker 1People love it.

Speaker 2Yeah, I know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because it makes them feel civilizationally, culturally, and intellectually advanced. Yeah.

Speaker 1Exactly, exactly. So, and that's basically the crux of the entire matter, right? And so there are some hangers on to this that are not necessarily Voltaire's feet that we can't, you know, lay at his feet. But for example, for example, yeah, for example, for example, it's just a cute little example. For example, Protestants like this, right? So, because one of the things that they will say is that, you know, the trouble with the medieval period is this hegemony of

Speaker 1the church, right? This idea that there is church cops and, like, the pope is breathing down your neck all the time. And it is this incredibly slavish devotion to a Catholicism which is inherently superstitious and awful, right? So, Protestants are really big into it because if you do have a kind of untroubled power of the Catholic Church in a large part of Europe, you know, like, let's not talk about orthodoxy because they can't handle all of that, right?

Speaker 1Then that is necessarily to them a bad time, right? Because, you know, bad is when there is Pope, essentially. There's also, like, the interesting snobbery surrounding the conception of the Renaissance. So there... The person that we can blame for the conception of the Renaissance is Viserys, who is essentially running an infomercial for Michelangelo. Okay, and he compiles this big book.

Speaker 2You said Viserys, and I was like, oh yes, Viserys I Targaryen. I'm like, you Fucking dummy. Stop it. Yes, yeah.

Speaker 1That's right. Blame him.

Speaker 2Michelangelo's hype guy. Yes, yes.

Speaker 1Yeah, Michelangelo's hype guy. He writes this book. It's like the lives of the painters and sculptors or something like that. And he, so he's essentially an art dealer, right? And so his whole thing is he's like, oh yeah, art is so much better now because we're using perspective, which is, I mean, sure, if you're particularly into realism or perspective, go for it. But It's kind of a really poor understanding of art and what it does, right? Like, that would be, it's a real chud kind of move. Like, right,

Speaker 1it's really reactionary, I guess, where it's like, oh, yeah, art is supposed to be about making what you see in front of you, right? Like, as opposed to, you know, like, necessarily if you subscribe to this, then you're saying that, like, for example, like, cubism is bad, right? Or, like, you know, I don't know, impressionism is bad. or, you know, like most contemporary art. Like, you know, you can't handle any of that because art is just supposed to be about like painting something that is recognizable, right? And so, but

Speaker 1on the other hand, that's like a really easy argument to make, right? And although like you don't get a great difference, for example, in terms of like topic with Renaissance art versus medieval, it's mostly just like, I hope you like Jesus because you're about to see him, right? Although, like, you have more, I suppose, classical images that go along with this. And I think also one of the big ones politically that we tend to see is, you know,

Speaker 1and this is the whole fucking dumbass Voltaire, a holy Roman Empire, neither holy nor Roman nor an empire fucking thing, which drives me insane. But essentially politically, what the argument is here is that the function of governance... ought to be conquest and domination.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Right? So the Roman Empire in the ancient period is good because it is a slaving empire and it is about bloody conquest and taking as many slaves as you possibly can. And the kingdoms in the medieval period don't really do that. You know, I'm not saying that there isn't... enslavement that happens in the medieval period obviously there is the vikings do a lot of it for example um that's that's a really big thing uh but you know especially in europe you basically just have like the same

Speaker 1five rich guys like hitting each other in the face over and over again and this is seen as kind of a waste of time when one ought to be in theory like marching an army over there and enslaving as many people as you possibly can um so that's kind of like the political one there There's also this really ahistoric thing built up with this too around like concepts of science, right? And the scientific. And so, for example,

Speaker 1much will be made, for example, of the Galileo trial. And they're like, oh, yeah, you know, like, do you see what the church does? and they silenced Galileo, and it's like, they silenced Galileo for being a fucking prick. They didn't do shit to Copernicus, right, who's like the actual one who came up with the heliocentric model of the universe, right? And so then what they do is they kind of do this retroactive thing, and they're like, oh, and if the church was doing that in, what I can't stress enough, was the early modern period, right, then

Speaker 1what it must have been doing in the medieval period was much, much worse. And that is also interesting because it's like, we don't really come up with, you know, the scientific methods such as it is until the enlightenment period. And there's still plenty of the early modern period where we don't know about germs, right? Like, and indeed through the, well, actually the entire early modern period, we don't fucking know about germs, right? Like these people still fucking believe in humoral theory, like most people did. But what ends up

Speaker 1happening kind of as a result of all of these, varying strands of chauvinism, I think is that what they want to do is they want to save the ancient period, right? They want to save the ancient period. And my historical argument about this has always been that it is specifically an argument about empire and an argument about slavery. And they want to make a case for that's good. Like, you know, a government is good when it's enslaving a bunch of people. And it is aggrandizing and pouring wealth

Speaker 1towards an infinitesimally small slice of leadership. And when you have less organized, smaller groups of individuals who are just kind of like seeing to whatever it is they're seeing to in the local area, that is bad, right? So, you know, obviously they are going to be arguing against a world in which landlords owe something to their tenants, right? Because they're fucking landlords. Like, obviously, they're going to be saying, well, it's bad when the Catholic Church. runs things if you're

Speaker 1a Protestant. Obviously, they're going to be, like, making all of these varying arguments because essentially what it does is it makes them feel smart and good. And all of this is only possible, right? A, if you never study medieval history. And B... you also kind of don't study early modern history. Yeah. Which people don't, which people, and they fucking don't, they don't, you know, so.

Speaker 2Yeah. It's, it's, it's a mess. I mean, like you, like the process of like first contact or, you know, like, like technical or not technical first contact between, between, between, Afro-Eurasia and the Americas, like within a couple of hundred years, 80 to 90% of the population of those continents was

Speaker 2killed off by war, enslavement, disease, new diseases being introduced or some combination of all of those ecological impact and all that stuff from all the burning and fighting. And, like, the birth of the modern era is, like, we are... Humans are doing orgiastic levels of violence at this point.

Speaker 2I make fun of, like, the Hobbesian idea of the Leviathan and that it is always... there uh because that's not true it's created by by by stuff that that we do and and the leviathan that he saw which was very real is not like a perpetual thing in humanity it's birthed by the stuff that's happening in the early modern period you're the development of like rate of

Speaker 2racism at like of of modern racism as a concept to justify the enslavement and, uh, exploitation and oppression of, um, uh, of, uh, two new continents. And then of course, Australia and Africa as well. Um, a little bit later, but like it's, um, it's, uh, these things are just, it's just blood. Like, everywhere trying

Speaker 2and like the cycles we go through that we talk about like in these benign political terms yeah like yes we can see like uh the scientific revolution and we can see the um you can see like the the prominence of gunpowder you know through the gunpowder empires and we can see the great divergence where europe starts to take off and and china starts to weaken comparatively and we'll talk about that a little bit later but like All of these things are happening, and all of the

Speaker 2people at the top are... The ideas that are coming about, that are swirling, are almost universally incredibly reactionary. They are totally reactionary, but they are for the most part because that's how most rulers are throughout history, including now. They're reactionaries to one degree or another. But, like, it's... When you have that and you have, like, people just completely bearing down and, like, crushing down a populace or, like,

Speaker 2multiple populaces and you're able to send people– you're able to send entire armies across the ocean, like, you know, and conquer all these various lands, it's– it just destroys– it destroys so much like all of this process, like the process of, of industrialization. And we're not even gonna like, this ends just as like industrialization really kicks into, to overdrive, especially in Europe. But like, um, it like, I mean,

Speaker 2until like on a wide scale, until you get the French revolution and until you get, um, And this is not Napoleon as a great man. This is Napoleon as, as a guy who took the reins of history, like at that time and, and ran with it. Um, and it happened.

Speaker 1Disruptor. Yeah.

Speaker 2He, he, he disrupts these things. He spreads all, he spreads all these things. And this is when like the old, uh, manorial slash feudal relationships in Europe are finally basically all dissolved except for Russia, which is a different thing. But like, this is when that starts to happen and you have to pull that apart. And in between those time, like you have like chattel slavery, you have the formation of

Speaker 2like the, the span, the like first global, uh, kind of hegemonic empire, the Spanish and then the Dutch briefly. And then of course the English, um, and like, you are just all of that, that formation, like the, the argument against capitalism is not that communism has never done anything wrong. It's that you blame communist nations for deaths

Speaker 2from things that happen from, from, Some things that they do but like including like everybody who died of a famine in Russia as being victims of communism when the famine swept across like basically all of like Asia. Like it's– you know, like that is– you're coloring your narrative.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2All of this part right here, all the stuff that we're talking about is the state form. It is like the modern state formation. And it is like when people are, when human beings are put through the grinder by, um, I mean, not just Europe, but a lot of, a lot of, by a lot of places.

Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. Just more generally.

Speaker 2Like, yeah, it's, It's a, it's, it's rough. Um, so yeah, so we're just going to go through a couple of these as we've talked about, like, um, uh, reactionary political ideologies. Um, one of them is the divine right of Kings, which is Eleanor. Uh, a lot of people often think that divine right of Kings means what we had in the middle ages. How are the, how are they different to one another? Like in political terms?

Speaker 1Yeah, so Divine Rite of Kings is something that has really developed very particularly in this era. And, you know, the engraving of Hobbes' Leviathan, which we should probably use as the episode art, I suppose, like that kind of like really encapsulates the thing. So there is this idea in the medieval period that there is a link between the divine and conceptions of like kingship right so it's like so for example when you were anointed king obviously

Speaker 1there's the whole holy oil thing right and this idea that like god is now like blessing your reign right um and and that 100 exists that's real right the difference here The difference is that with that, it's sort of like not the body of the king in and of itself up to that point. There's sort of like this relationship where it's like, okay, well, you got here, so God must kind of want you to be here. Right?

Speaker 1And that's the idea, right? So it's like you got to this point, so it must be God kind of signing off to you to a certain extent. Because like otherwise, what would you do? It's more like, I suppose, mandate of heaven-y. If that makes sense. Whereas the divine right of kings is that I'm here and I'm in charge of things because not because like God wants me to, but because like that is innately, innately like the thing

Speaker 1about kingship, right? That, you know, and the state in and of itself does not exist. The body of the king exists and it is tied to the state, right? And as a result of me being king, I can do whatever the fuck I want because I'm king, right? So that's the difference where it's like kings in the medieval period are very, very, very much restrained by religion, right?

Speaker 1With Christianity. So the idea is that, like, I mean, if you ask a pope why the Holy Roman Empire emperor exists he's going to tell you that the holy roman emperor exists because he's there to do the violence that the church wants right so it's an instrument of religiosity and that indeed if he fails to do that that his emperorness can be taken away at any moment right whereas for divine right of kings it's like i exist because i exist and i can do any fucking thing i want with my power because that's what makes me a king yeah so there's no intermentality there.

Speaker 2Yeah, and the absolute monarchy, the concept of absolute monarchy kind of, they don't go hand in hand because you can be an absolute monarchy without claiming divine right, but they uh they sure do they sure do work very well to you know uh two great taste two awful tastes together at last um yeah yeah absolute monarchy is the idea that crops up uh toward uh as the haps really as the hapsburgs start to like uh spread

Speaker 2uh uh spread their their wings across uh yeah across the hemispheres um you know and it's that like the king like the at the total and absolute authority of the king to do as they will and do what they want um and uh damn the consequences and damn the churches and and anyone who tells them no and Um, and so you get, uh, you get that too. And these, these are the things that are bubbling up at the

Speaker 2top while at the bottom, because, uh, the printing, because the printing industry is still in, in its relative infancy. And, um, and, uh, it, it, it's, we, we, we don't have the technological advancements to make, um, to, to make, uh, faster mass communication happen, you know, again, until for this entire period, no matter how long you do it, the fastest way to travel is still by water,

Speaker 2you know, until the 1850s or so when you get, uh, 1850s or maybe the sixties, um, when you get, uh, when you get trains coming in, like it's incredibly hard to travel. So, and you also, um, because the world population was still recovering in a lot of places from the upheaval of, um, the, uh, the crisis of the 14th century with the black death and the famines and the, all of that, plus the, um, the attendant horrors that

Speaker 2came along with the meeting of, uh, the old world and the new world. Um, you just had a horrific mix of like, awful politics. And I mean, one of the theories for why the Little Ice Age happened and why it got worse during the early modern period, much worse than it was in the Middle Ages, is that so many people in the Americas were killed that it created a carbon sink. And there is, you know, scientific

Speaker 2evidence to back that up. So it's just like, people at the top are pulling ahead. They have the technological, political, cultural, everything. They have all these advantages and the people down below do not have anything. And to be completely honest, this is what, this is what reactionary politics has been trying to get back to for, I mean, for the entire time that this has been going on since, since, yeah, since.

Speaker 1Yeah. To them, this is good.

Speaker 2Yeah, to them this is good. This is what return actually means. Return means putting you back in chains and doing this. And I mean, I think the reason that they return, one of the big reasons they do the return for the bucolic, they use the bucolic Middle Ages now as like a return fantasy is that like, that's the idea that you're selling, but the like, the repression

Speaker 2that you're going to get is going to have all of the modern technological horror that comes along with it. So, you know, in reality, you're going, you know, whatever you're going back to is, is akin to the worst serfdom or, you know, something alongside chattel slavery. So, you know, people say techno feudalism, it's like, no, it's going to, it will be far worse than, than feudalism, whatever your feudalism was, if they get their way, it's going to be so much worse.

Speaker 1I'm like, yeah, you know, we don't need to go into it here. I think probably everyone has already listened to me go off on the concept of techno-feudalism, but I was on Culture Power Politics with Jeremy Gilbert talking about why that's stupid, because it's like, don't fucking, like, looking at, you know, like, something happens capitalistically, is this feudalism? Is essentially, like, the fucking thing, where it's like, no, it isn't. And, like, this idea that feudalism is necessarily worse, for example, than capitalistic slavery is.

Speaker 2Right, yeah.

Speaker 1Is ridiculous. And that is one of the things that, like, all of this is kind of predicated on. And I suppose that, you know, we have to sort of bring up the conception of whiteness here.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Right? As a part of it. Because, like, what they're saying is.

Speaker 2This is when whiteness... Yeah, sorry. Yeah. No, exactly.

Speaker 1This is when whiteness comes up, right? And, like, when we invent whiteness, like, as a category... Because, you know, certainly we had kind of like xenophobia and also, you know, like medieval people will get weird with it. They'll talk about like Jewish blood and stuff like that where you're like, OK, dog, like I don't know what that means.

Speaker 2And dynastic rites are inherently bloodborne. So like, you know, like there is that to it. But this is an innovation beyond just that.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah, absolutely. And like very much there isn't there's no pressing conception of being white anymore.

Speaker 2Right?

Speaker 1In the Middle Ages, where it's like they don't fucking know what that means. Like, they're like, well, we're Christians. And we got that going for us, right? But one of the things that you are going to see as a result of all of this nonsense is you will see, like, within the early modern period, this idea that it's like, okay, well, somehow... In serfdom is a worse situation because it's something that–

Speaker 1it's a form of unfreedom that happens to white people, right?

Speaker 2Right, yeah.

Speaker 1Whereas slavery can't be as bad because it's happening to other people who are racialized in different ways, right? So when they are hitting you with all this fucking return bullshit, the thing that they're hitting you with is that it's like, oh, it sucks when white people have to experience slavery. unfreedom and you know and all the other things that happen are kind of like par for the course it's the same thing with like now when you see like people get all weird about trafficking like they think it's taken

Speaker 1and they're like and what they're actually talking about is kind of like the Victorian concept of white slavery where it's like oh it would be bad if like you know a pretty little white girl was trafficked when it's like usually it's just kind of like your boyfriend does it like no one's kidnapping anyone off the fucking street right So, but that is kind of, like, part and parcel with the entire project is this idea, like, you know, the reason why they're saying, like, you know, like, techno-feudalism when this is a capitalist thing is because there is

Speaker 1this fundamental misunderstanding and, like, lingering, like, let's be so fucking real, it's, like, this lingering chauvinism about, like, it's bad when, like, white people are unfreed.

Speaker 2Right?

Speaker 1And, like, I'm not saying that I want to be a serf. That's not my fucking point. But I am saying that, like, I think, actually, and apparently quite controversially, that it's worse when we are enslaving people, yeah?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Than when we are, like, you know, having some people who are unfree, right?

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, it's... These innovations are not good. And a lot of the modern things that we have, modern technology, modern medicine, all that stuff is very good. But the path from there to here was not great. Next up, we have colonialism, modern or early modern colonialism, which is different from the ancient and medieval colonialism. quasi or you

Speaker 2know somewhat colonial uh ventures like the crusades medieval greenland the way the greeks and the carthaginians uh populated the first city states uh their first city states in the mediterranean etc but um what eleanor the just what What a fucking disaster for everyone who is not, like, a European, like,

Speaker 2overlord or a slaver. Like, good God.

Speaker 1Yep, yep. And this, so, I mean, in the first place, there's, you know, just the obvious genocide. Yep. Like, I mean, like, tell a Carib, right, who, you know, the group of people who no longer fucking exist in the Caribbean, right, that the early modern period was better than the medieval period. I fucking dare you. You know, like, talk to any Native American person.

Speaker 2All the Taino in Haiti got wiped out. They're not there anymore.

Speaker 1Yeah. Like, they no longer fucking exist.

Speaker 2Right?

Speaker 1There's huge groups of people that no longer fucking exist. And that is just a fact. Yeah? Like, that's just a fact that I'm noticing, like, in the area, right? And it's very distressing... that people kind of don't, they don't want to talk about that, right? Like it's terribly inconvenient, right? Because the convenient thing and, like, the correct thing, TM, is that, like, oh, it's so much better because of, you know, logicality, rationality. And also, fundamentally, you know, this

Speaker 1is the birth of, you know, a lot of stuff that people like from kind of, like, the early modern period. Like, look at You know, my least favorite, I guess, well, I don't mind the architecture, but I mind the interior design. But if you look at the Baroque period, right, and what it has is this, like, this absolutely disgusting excess, right? So it's like, it looks like a fucking wedding cake exploded when you go into a Baroque building and everything is gold, right? Yeah. And it's just like, oh, yeah, well, like,

Speaker 1look at all these incredible buildings, right? that are made and they're covered in gold and they're, yeah, they're covered in gold that, that was like processed by like enslaved native people in South America.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1Which like, that's bad. And then in turn, this conception of colonialism, like, lest you be one of those people who just kind of thinks that the only people on earth are white people. Colonialism also has knock on effects in Europe because this is very, very linked to, you know, enclosure because they're sort of like, oh, well, yeah. And Hey, if that's what we're doing over in the new world, if what we're doing is we're privatizing all of these huge swaths of land in order to enrich certain families, well, why don't we fucking kick the people here off the

Speaker 1goddamn land and funnel them into, you know, factories and places that process these things. So what you see when people go, who are kind of like talking about this, think that like it isn't necessarily better. One of the things that they're sort of talking about is like luxury objects and luxury items, which become, yes, much more luxurious. You know, palaces are, that are built in the early modern period are much larger than medieval castles. You know, and they're much more opulent and, you know, they have much, much larger staffs and things like that. I mean, Versailles

Speaker 1is a great case in point here, right, as ever. And so what they're sort of responding to is this opulence. But then you have to ask yourself, well, yeah, and like who fucking paid for all this? Who's doing all the goddamn work around here, right? And so I think that there's the genocide. There's the enslavement. There's just like the deaths of millions upon millions of people. And there is like enclosure at home as a knock-on effect of this.

Speaker 1And the people who benefit really are the wealthy. And I'm sure you can say, yeah, and the average European now has access to sugar more reliably or cocoa or coffee, these things that we continue to enjoy today. But, I mean, is that better than, like, having your farm? Right?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1I don't fucking think that it is, really. You know? Like, call me old-fashioned, but, you know, I just kind of feel like having a community and ways of feeding yourself is probably better.

Speaker 2Right?

Speaker 1Like.

Speaker 2Yeah. It's... Yeah. Like, I mean. He talked about Napoleon earlier and he is going to be a great, uh, the great vindicator for a lot of this. He also, uh, attempted to reimpose slavery on Haiti, um, uh, after, uh, after he, he came into power because he was trying to get, uh, you know, access to those, um, to, to get that access to sugar back because it was so,

Speaker 2so lucrative. And that was, You know, it was hard to get it from anywhere else in the world because of the monopolies the British had. And, you know, it's like colonialism is the easy outlet for everything. And that, you know, that like one of the things about the Crusades, why we refer to them as like colonial type ventures is because like this that was one of the earliest instances of europe being like we have to get rid

Speaker 2of these idiot second sons that we have there are too many of them here and they keep uh they they cause too much trouble we have to get rid of them and um and of course that just keeps being like a problem and a problem and a problem and you keep looking for outlets for it and that's how you end up with you know your manifest destinies and your lebensraums and you know every uh all those, you know, things. And it's, yeah, colonialism, we've talked about

Speaker 2it a bunch. It's just awful. Another big one, especially in Europe, is the emergence of the Reformation. This is, for Europe, this is catastrophic, especially for like the old, the old, way of europe this like break is is terrible and you know as we see and you know

Speaker 2with with with the 30 years war and all that when you try to reimpose when you try when these things have already started to change and you try to reimpose them the only way that you can do that is actual genocide that's all you can do when when uh when the Habsburgs wanted to reimpose Catholicism on Bohemia and they did very successful, but in order to do that, they had to just lay down the heaviest hand possible

Speaker 2and they did so. And, and that is like, that's the only way to, to, to re-entrench that, um, That's the only way to re-entrench that. And I mean, part of this is the fact that as the actual nation states of Europe began to solidify and become powerful in and of themselves, the church would be marginalized further and further. And so like part of this is also the church is trying to reassert some of the authority that it

Speaker 2had so recently had. But like, yeah, this really just breaks down. you're like 15, seven, like 15, 17. Well, the Hussites before that, like, you know, because yeah, they're, yeah. The Eleanor, like what did, you know, the end at the late medieval with the Hussites. And then of course, you know, the reformation just God damn.

Speaker 1So like, you know, I think I'm team Hussite as we all fucking know, we don't have to get into this, but it's just, you know, and, and also I very much am of the opinion that, That, like, yeah, there were huge problems with the Catholic Church. And also, like, I think the Reformation is bad. I think the Counter-Reformation is bad, right? But here are the several things that happen as a result of the Reformation. It's not just like, oh, that's cute. Like, oh, personal relationship with God. Lovely, lovely. In the first place, you see things like the witch panics,

Speaker 1for example, which are directly tied to the conception of Protestantism. And a desire to crack down on the freedoms of women and also, you know, new ideas about religiosity and who is able to do what. So, you know, we have thousands upon thousands of people who are killed across Europe as a result of, like, these newfangled religious ideas. So that's cute. You also have, of course, like, the crackdowns against peasantry that we see as a result of, like, the peasants uprising because they're like, oh, hey, we're humans now.

Speaker 1And then everyone is like, nope. Nope, not yet. Martin Luther is like, I just want to make it clear that I never said you people were human, right?

Speaker 2God, no. I was talking about myself.

Speaker 1Yeah. And it's like, you know, a huge part of the Counter-Reformation, which is also, you know, evil, as you say, Luke, you know, when the Habsburgs are cracking down on the Hussites and that sort of thing. Because, of course, this is also all linked to the Thirty Years' War, which is the deadliest conflict that Europe will see until World Wars I and II, right? The population... of the German lands in Europe is reduced by a third. Yeah. As a result.

Speaker 2It's so bad.

Speaker 1Like, it is so fucking bad because these people have fucking canon, right? These people have guns. They have gunpowder. And they've also now dehumanized each other to a level that you do not have within the medieval period as a result of kind of like the conception of Catholicism, right? There are people who die in medieval warfare obviously but you know it is seen as more dynastic and territorial it is much more supposed to be about how you

Speaker 1are attempting to um you know kidnap people and get money out of it and that's not what's happening during the 30 years war at the minute you're trying to kill the heretics right like that's what they're attempting to do um and take over it and That will, I mean, like a third of the population in the Czech lands is also recorded as being lost. People die all over the fucking shop. And that is a direct response to inventing Protestants, right? And then, of course, you have all

Speaker 1the kind of like knock-on effects of that bullshit, which is like, look, you know, we can stray right out of the early modern period, but it's like the reason we fucking have evangelicals today is because of Martin Luther, right? You go around telling... Every shot in the world that, like, they can just read the Bible and they'll understand. And it turns out that's bad. and and that is actually.

Speaker 2Hey hey let's let's give some let's give some blame to henry the eighth here too come on.

Speaker 1Yeah true like henry the eighth who's also you know like the fucking implicated in all of this is like you know the and the the terror that is unleashed on people in this country as a result of protestantism is is terrible and you know like much is made people always like to call you know um Mary Tudor, Bloody Mary here. It's like Elizabeth and Henry killed way more people than she ever did. It's just like just the wave after wave after wave of religious violence that

Speaker 1happens as a result of Protestantism. And it is much, much, much, much, much fucking bloodier than anything that goes on in the Middle Ages. So, you know, there's this tendency to say that people are barbaric. in the medieval period, and that they're bloodthirsty and all these things, they have absolutely fucking nothing on.

Speaker 2Even if they are, the level of bloodthirst is so much higher, you know, it's... Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, like, and I think that you can also kind of throw the Spanish Inquisition into this as well, which is kind of like happening as a result of the same religious tendencies. I think that they're very tied, I would argue, to um, Protestantism as well. And, and although they start out beforehand, but yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. Um, you know, I, uh, as I often say, I don't, um, I don't think there's any way, uh, to avoid a reformation. Um, uh, it's going to happen. There's no, there's no functional way for, uh, the, for the church to remain, um, in power over that much of Europe with that much money flowing through it with, with, with the spread of ideas and all that sort of stuff. It's just not, it's not going to happen. But just

Speaker 2because the, an event like this is inevitable, it doesn't mean that it had to go down like this. And I mean, it didn't, the, the spasmodic violence and the, the, the counter violence that, that the counter reformation, let loose these things are just like you're you are when when these two things pull apart it's going when when church and state do start to pull apart and i mean that is part of the modern period and and definitely

Speaker 2the 30 years war is is a huge rupture there when those things pull apart it's going to be uh violent but um Even if the Protestants had just returned the violence that the Catholics who were trying to bring them back in the fold had done, that's one thing. But when you kill 200,000 to 300,000 German peasants in the span of two and a half years, where you're marching out people with matchlock guns versus literal peasants with pitchforks,

Speaker 2that's a... you do not have to do that for the reformation to continue. They can have their own thing and you can have your own thing, but that's not, that's not how it worked. And I mean, um, a couple of other things going on here as the scientific revolution kicks into overdrive, um, you know, as we start to get much closer to modern medicine and, um, modern medicine,

Speaker 2You know, like we get the heliocentric model of the solar system. We get, you know, all these astronomical advancements by Tycho Brahe and Johannes Kepler and all these guys. And as you get that, that tears at the social fabric that it reinforced, you know, Europe and, I mean, basically all of the world up to this point. And

Speaker 2this is when you do get religion versus science as a real thing. Because science, both consciously and unconsciously, wrenches itself away from religion because it has to. Because as the church becomes more and more uh repressive in response to the reformation it starts to clamp down on scientific

Speaker 2innovation uh because that doesn't comport with its models of the universe and the world and all that and that you know is when you start to get it and and galileo he he's the church doesn't treat him well but that was mostly his own thing but like the real religion versus science thing would come uh That's more like the 1700s because, like, as I often say, you know, fuck,

Speaker 2what's his name? Newton, you know, Newton, so autistic that he invented calculus. But he, Galileo, Copernicus, Brahe, Kepler, all these guys, they got their final unction just like every other good Catholic boy and girl and they, them. uh, in history, you know, or, you.

Speaker 1Know, most of them anyway.

Speaker 2Um, so yeah, uh, just a few more things here. We talked about gunpowder, uh, sweeping the middle ages, uh, but a big thing, uh, in the, in the early modern is it gets way more powerful in Europe invents like the matchlock, uh, gun, the, they start to, uh, innovate the, um, they start to innovate gunpowder to become far, uh, more potent and deadly than it had been. They innovate, uh, especially,

Speaker 2especially along with the gunpowder empires, which are the Ottomans, the Safavids and the Mughals. Um, they really innovate like the big cannons to make them far deadlier and faster and more efficient and everything like this. And, um, we, we talked a lot about that on the gunpowder, so we're not going to go into too much here. Just that the availability of gunpowder makes– you can clear more land, you can blow up more rocks, and you can kill people a whole hell of a lot faster than you

Speaker 2used to be able to and far more impersonally. And that was not good. That has not been– That's a bad thing. We're really still working it out now. But it does feed into something that was a big thing here, and that is the great divergence, which is when– China, which for basically all of history had been the most technologically advanced civilization on Earth by several orders of magnitude, is.

Speaker 1Suddenly caught by the rest of Asia, including.

Speaker 2The gunpowder empires as we talked about, and Japan, but far, far more so by Europe and is just, just goes into the stratosphere. So Eleanor, like the great divergence, what do we usually chalk this up to? And this is not like really an intentional thing. Like nobody was like,

Speaker 2you know, this is just, this happens and it's something we can see in hindsight.

Speaker 1Yeah. So there, the like current kind of going thing is something that we refer to as the high equilibrium trap. And the idea behind the high equilibrium trap is what ends up happening in China is shit's pretty good.

Speaker 2Thanks.

Speaker 1You know, and so as a result of it, they aren't like desperate enough to get on a boat and start enslaving people because they're like, why would I why would I go anywhere else? What's going to be over there? People who don't have chopsticks.

Speaker 2Yeah, they.

Speaker 1That's weird.

Speaker 2They also have two important innovations that help keep the people, the lower strata at least somewhat content or quiescent. And that is the bureaucracy through which they can some of a very tiny number of them can get better lives and can try to get some type of government representation done. And more importantly, the Mandate of Heaven, which, when lost, erupts in spasmodic hyperviolence. But it worked for them for

Speaker 2a long time until it didn't.

Speaker 1Until it didn't. Until it didn't, right? And I do think that this is, like, one of these things where also, you know, basically, like, rice production is very complex, but they've got it worked out pretty well. You know, and so they've got like a kind of more food. And so basically they just don't do all the same kind of scrapping technologically because they're like, well, we don't need to scrap either technologically or like, I mean, like, baby, we've got it all here already. Like, you know, it's

Speaker 1kind of like they have a nice enough life that they're not grubbing around in the dirt, right? Whereas in Europe, that simply doesn't exist. And so they're more ready to do weird violence in ways that China wouldn't be. And then as we get later on into the period when, you know, the colonial powers are really going for it, then they will also, you know, China will have, like,

Speaker 1forced opium addiction as a result of the proclivities of the British, right? You know, as kind of like a thing that happens.

Speaker 2Two opium wars, baby.

Speaker 1Woo! And so, basically, the thing that we have to kind of understand here is that things were going so well. Like, things were going so well for China that they just kind of, like, they're resting on their laurels, as it were. They just don't have to do... The same levels of weird shit that Europeans need to do in order to have a nice life. And certainly their fucking, like, aristocracy doesn't need to.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Like, they're like, I'm good, babe. Like, they were already enjoying all of the things that Europeans wished to, essentially. So they kind of didn't do anything about it.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. One of the reasons they turned back from their– the first colonization efforts that they were making outside of what they would call like China proper or whatever is– there's a lot of complicated internal factors that had to do with it. One of the reasons is that there is– you don't have to have the outlet because there is a ton of land in China and in

Speaker 2Southeast Asia and everything where people can be and they can go to. And, and like you can, I mean, you know, you, there are obviously the step tribes and everything like that. And, um, you don't have that in Europe, Europe, if Europe is going to continue to prosper at, uh, the end of the medieval era and the beginning of the early modern, uh, their only outlet is to either try and invade Africa, the Middle East, or try to

Speaker 2go to the new world. And Africa at the time, Northern Africa was like, they, they had gotten, they had gotten gunpowder too. They were getting the, the downstream consequences of all of that. And so, um, going to the new world and seeing these people who were less technologically advanced because they had not been forced to be technologically advanced by being in an interconnected three continental world like Africa, Europe,

Speaker 2and Asia had been for so long. And that was just easy pickings for them. Whereas when China like looked, when the Ming dynasty looked inward, uh, following the death of the Anle emperor in the 1430s and decided to recall the treasure fleet and, and burn all their, their double masted ships, um, they could do that and still remain incredibly wealthy and have these nice, uh, these, uh,

Speaker 2these nice lives, uh, Um, like comparatively and Europe couldn't do that.

Speaker 1Like we don't have to do all that. Like we just don't have to fucking do all that in order to have nice lives. So why the fuck would we? Right. And you know, like, and, and that does that, you know, obviously in hindsight is a big fucking issue clearly, but the fundamentals of it are, you don't know that shit until afterwards. Right. Like it only becomes clear after the fact to be entirely fair, you know? Yep.

Speaker 2Exactly. Yeah. And, um, you know, that the, the, the fall of China for, uh, 500 years is, is one of the like bigger, you know, historical moments because China had been like a weight of global power influence and, uh, culture and everything for since, uh, 1600 BCE like the whole.

Speaker 1Fucking time like it's like it is 100% the nat if there is such a thing as like a natural state of the world which of course there isn't and like I'm not saying that there is it is with like China being in control of things like that's just how stuff is quote unquote supposed to.

Speaker 2Work yeah that's all I'm saying you know Yeah. And you, you know, you, when that, when that counterweight falls off and everything moves and, and the like weight of the world moves drastically to the West all the way like into Europe, um, that, you know, that has just this corresponding downstream effect. And I mean, eventually that would culminate in, you know, the Qing dynasty would take power. Um, and then, you know, the opium wars, as Eleanor mentioned, and that's,

Speaker 2that's more like modern era, but like you get the opium wars, you get like, uh, the, the, the boxer rebellions and everything like that are put down and you have, you know, the, the troops of, of, you know, foreign nations walking muddy boots through the forbidden palace and all that sort of shit. And it's like the mandate of heaven is in the gutter, but those European and Western colonial powers are going to prop up China and keep propping them up for another like 50 or 60 years

Speaker 2until of course it all fell apart in 1912. Um, but, uh, but yeah, just a few, a couple more things. We've talked about it a couple of times, but the printing press, um, it is hard to overstate how important, uh, the printing press was to the rise of all of these ideas that we're talking about, but also, um, To the eventual, you know, resurgence of political consciousness at the bottom. And

Speaker 2I think the big thing here is overall, if you just look at it from like the medieval period to the early modern period, the biggest single thing you could say is the difference is the mortality rate fucking skyrockets. Skyrockets. We were talking about genocide on an unprecedented scale up to that point in human history, chattel slavery killing millions upon millions in the Caribbean and Africa and other places

Speaker 2as well.

Speaker 1Also in Europe, I think. Yeah, sorry, but it just bears also saying that in Europe, the mortality rate also really goes up as a result of disease. So, you know, bubonic plague is now endemic. You know, a lot of people tend to think of it as like a uniquely medieval thing. It's anything but. You will see over and over and over re-explosions of the plague. You also have smallpox coming up. You have a syphilis outbreak. um it

Speaker 1gets gets invented um you know you have all of these things so that um so even if even if we're just talking about like Italy you know if you want to be like oh the renaissance yay Italy um like the mortality rate skyrockets in Italy to the point where it's suddenly like you now have um much more of a like a life expectancy of like being in your 20s if you're a man yeah It's crazy.

Speaker 2No, it is. It's awful. And I mean, one of the things about urbanization, even before like the real ramp up of industrialization is the more people are in close contact with one another, the more disease is going to be able to just flow in and out of there. And so when you had urbanization without idea without modern medicine and without you know modern sanitation and everything like

Speaker 2that that was just you know that's just a burgeoning cesspool of disease yeah but it's a lot and again you know we're not trying to make the same mistake of you know saying this is a fault of early modern people, because, uh, clearly it's not the, the people in the new world who were slaughtered and the people in, in India who were, who were put under the yoke and everywhere else. Um, you know, they didn't, they didn't

Speaker 2have much of a say in that. Uh, and so it's just, um, it's the people at the top concentrating more power and having that, uh, information and political and power. uh, asymmetry, uh, over the, over the people at the bottom. Um, and you know, that's, uh, it's not the cheeriest episode, but I do think that there is something to take heart

Speaker 2from here. And that is since this has happened, um, we have been through fits and starts, and very slowly, very incrementally, and a lot slower than it should be, and everything, but we are pulling back, we're trying to pull things back from that, there's a counterweight for this stuff, and it's not just like, it's not just like, oh, you know, we're the good guys, like, you know, America

Speaker 2and Europe are pulling this back, it's like, no, like, like we're there, there are political movements in the world to try and write these past wrongs and fix these things. And, um, And, you know, we have all this modern technology that's great and we should keep making technological advancements and everything like that and not let the world fall back into this. You know, this is this is a cautionary tale of like, you know, imagine if we fall back into this and

Speaker 2they have the technological advancements they have now to like, you know, that's going to be that'll that'll somehow even be worse, you know, but like, you That's the thing that has to be avoided.

Speaker 1Yeah, and it's, I think, important to kind of make sure that we don't assume that history and the way that the world works is this constant march towards the better or improvement of rights or that, like, necessarily the creation of more tech leads to more rights. And I think that that is a very important thing to keep in mind, especially right now, because that's what we're living through, right? So it's not techno-feudalism. it's just capitalism with more tech,

Speaker 1you know? Yeah.

Speaker 2It's, it's post, it's post capital. It's a post capitalist wasteland. It's not, uh, it's just, um, it's just barbarism like that. Like it's, it's, uh, it's, it's all of the oppression of the past with none of the, like, um, with none of the corresponding, um, improvements and benefits of the modern and postmodern morals that, yeah, it's, um, you know, that's the thing, that's the thing we have to avoid. And, you know, that's, that's, you know, that, that's kind of

Speaker 2like why the early modern is just, it's just such a, it's such a bad time. It sounds, it just seems like such a bad time to be alive in so many ways. I'm just like, good God.

Speaker 1Like, I think that, you know, just, just, Keep this under your hat. Keep these particular facts to your, you know, I'm not trying to be a hater. I like some of the art from the period. I like, you know, I think that some of this stuff is neat. You know, obviously, I do think that the hegemony of the Catholic Church, especially as it was, should be challenged. None of that is what I'm saying. And indeed, I live in a multicultural society and I enjoy multicultural societies and think that it's good that we were mixing with each other more. But,

Speaker 1you know. I think it's just kind of important to keep an eye on. That's all.

Speaker 2The process of going from here to there or from there to here is– and the process of going from Sumeria to the Holy Roman Empire is, you know, again, like it's– that's a, that's a horror show of its own. And you know, that's kind of history. And one of the good things about living now is that you can look back on that and be like, yeah, we should not do that again. Or, you know, we should not, we should, we should get out of these cycles. These

Speaker 2are awful. Anyway, folks, thank you so much for listening. Uh, we're glad, or we hope you enjoyed it. Um, as we said at the top, check us out on Patreon, patreon.com slash WST pod. Uh, Check out Welcome to the Crusades for our second season on Sega Crusade. And Eleanor, what do you got? I saw earlier today that they released the Chapo bonus episode that you and Derek did.

Speaker 1Yeah, so check that out. We're there talking about Crusade stuff as usual. So if you haven't checked out Welcome to the Crusades 2 yet, we can tell you why you might wish to do that. what the fuck else has been going on I recorded Be Gay Do Crimes with the lovely ladies over there where we were talking about CADFEL so do go check that out I think that should be out as well oh a personal plug

Speaker 1that has nothing to do with this over at my work they've launched a YouTube channel for Gone Medieval and it would help me personally if you would follow it so that I can negotiate a pay increase or something. Do it. Do it. So, yeah, we've got a Gone Medieval YouTube channel, so you can check that out. I think those are the major things. Oh, yeah, and of course, then the other thing is that I was with Daniel

Speaker 1Bessner from American Prestige, I was also on his imperialism show talking about ghost fucking. We did a chat on that. So I think that if you check out that on his sub stack, you can see our conversation over there.

Speaker 2Yeah, check it out. Yeah, and I am Lucas Amazing on the socials. You can find my old show, People's History of the Old Republic, if you want to hear me yap about Star Wars. But anyway, thank you all very much for listening, and we will see you next time.

Speaker 1Keep it sloppy, but not so fucking sloppy that you do something like the Reformation, right? Don't do that.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 297 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.1 Jerusalem

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode