folks, we're back and diving into the patron mailbag once again. this time, we answer questions about a host of topics, including: height differences, Aurora Borealis, best Medieval turlet, Traditional Chinese Medicine, battlefield name changes, othering, and spectacular Medieval wizard battles! check it out! cover image is of Aurora Borealis, taken from space.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Yes, they're calling it the most in progress recording of all time. We can say that. I think I think we could say that.
Speaker 2Yeah, they're calling it. It's a it's a bit of a podcast. If you've heard of them, I don't know if you. I can't. I can't all the way.
Speaker 1Okay, let me do a cure Stummer. I encourage the recording in progress, but I encourage her to go further and actually do the podcast. That's good.
Speaker 2Oh man, he's so.
Speaker 1He sounds like that. Bro, he sounds like that.
Speaker 2Starmar is so weird because like, how do you why do you sound like that? Like, what is the what is.
Speaker 1Exactly how he was embarrasster. I don't know because you were in court sounding like that and people were like, yeah, dog, this is real shit.
Speaker 2Apparently I got no clue. Yeah, I just man, like if I sounded like that, I would voice train myself to death to not right, Like, I.
Speaker 1Mean, like, it's just something that you can actually work on, and he refuses to do it. It's although, on the other hand, I guess that like refusing to do shit is kind of like his I've decided that it's actually really funny that he's still the Prime minister. I think that at this point, it's just like a fucking camp, Like I don't know, one of the homies over here made like a you know, to share zone and it was like just stay, it's probably fine.
Speaker 2Like yeah, no, that's absolutely right. What are they gonna do?
Speaker 1Like, they're not gonna do shit like I mean.
Speaker 2Everybody else around she was ultra toxic and you don't really care, like from his from his perspective, why would he, like unless he is suffering something like because if he's been in my mind, if you've been in it for this long and you're doing this, like you don't really care about the indignity of this. It's not it's not a it's not something that concerns you. You care about you know, I don't know other things you know that
Speaker 2whatever those might be. But he is he just seems like a guy who's like, uh like, yeah, I don't shit on me, I don't care, like I.
Speaker 1Like, like it's it's I mean, I think I was to be prime minister. And so it's like he's not gonna go because like then what like yeah, you know so, and.
Speaker 2I mean from his perspective, like my guess is that he feels like he feels like he is fulfilling some kind of historical role in this because he's like holding back probably some gradiose idea he has. He's holding back like the right and the left simultaneously or something like that. And so like you, I mean like, yeah, you can see like how how people who are this narcissistic about stuff to get it to do what you have to
Speaker 2do now to get into these positions of power. Yeah yeah, I mean like I could easily see him like telling himself that every day, like what, what the fuck does he care?
Speaker 1He's looking in the mirror saying that every morning. He's like, that's fine, it's important. But I am here so that reform doesn't got to be the only ones who are racist.
Speaker 3I am a great man of history. Okay, whatever to get out of get out of bed into morning.
Speaker 1I mean, I'm not prime minister. So what I'll tell you what Like, after you know, these big elections, Uh, one of my fucking friends, like one of the actual homies is now the man of Southern mayor Southern, like I mate Claire is now the mayor. And it's like hell yeah, brother, And it makes me laugh so hard because I think one of the things they didn't realize when they like kicked all the hardcore leftists out of Labor down here is that we're actually quite organized. And
Speaker 1I mean Claire was always a green. I think she wasn't ever in labor, but like me and the homies, we're all, you know, corbonites, and they're like, you've all got to go because we are doing important centrist things. And uh now, and now who's the fucking mayor, bitch? Guess what? Like, I don't worry, babe, I'll knock on doors like it's yeah, it's quite funny, like so we got that going on. It's pretty good. It's pretty good. Yeah, Like, uh,
Speaker 1the hommies are giving it the big one. I can say that for sure. Nice Yeah yeah, uh so you know, yeah, it's it's fun. I mean, it's not gonna really do very much currently, but you know that's all right at the moment. It's like that at the moment I'm taking my enemies are mad, yeah, because I'm a grown up, you know, I'm like, yeah.
Speaker 2So yeah, well, everybody's gotta we all have to suffer more if if people are gonna get it, like whatever, that the West has to suffer more if people are actually gonna get it, and that is unfortunate.
Speaker 1Listen, I'm gonna be smoke looking on those have you seen online They've got those pe and E brand cigarettes that they're Chinese cigarettes, and they got a holographic container with Carl Marx on the front. I'm just gonna be fucking out. I'm gonna be I'm gonna take up smoking bra I'm gonna be hitting with the Karl Marx figs me like just hitting the baiju and cigarettes. I'm escaping the American century of humiliation. It's fine, It'll be fine. Good.
Speaker 2Yeah, God damn it. What is in my throat?
Speaker 1Pollen? Had a guess, tell you what. It's like the time of year year where all the pollen is attacking me. So I just like wake up with my eyes swollen shut. It's pretty it's pretty dope.
Speaker 2I'm just I'm avoiding every I'm doing my best to avoid everything. Like I'm like I'm juking in the backfield. I'm I'm I'm I'm putting on the moves, I'm hitting the spin button on everything, because like I'm dealing with like a kid who's in camps now, which means like she just in like camp with like kids from all over, which is great and cool. It's just that they have their own germ like micro bio things at their schools, and so now it's just like and I'm dealing with that.
Speaker 2And I was in airports and I was just like and I was just like ah ah, you know, and so I'm just I'm just I'm just trying to stay healthy here, and I'm like I'm right on the edge of it, and my wife's out of town, and like I'm just like, no.
Speaker 1Bro, okay, stop it. On the plane back from Krokov, the guy who was sitting behind me had I think it was the cold I had a couple of weeks ago, at least, this is what I keep telling myself. But Homie was like coughing on me, like I was in the window bit and like the coughing was sort of like hitting my arm. I was like, bra, like, I think it's really cool that we've learn nothing from COVID and people just be getting on planes coffin like that. No mask.
Speaker 2It's like hell yeah, brother, yeahs yeah.
Speaker 1And it's just like coming off of several days where I was getting up at the equivalent of like four thirty to four fifteen.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know.
Speaker 1So it's pretty pretty high. I'm fine. I wouldn't worry about it, you know.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, And oh it was fine. The flights were fine.
Speaker 1The flights are fine. And also Krackoff Airport fucking whips. Dude, you just like get right through security. They got that shit. You don't have to take anything else, and then you can buy perogi on the other side. It's great. They had just like a whole fucking thing in like one of like the equivalent of Hudson News is in there where that was like, oh, hey, did you need some booze to like just pound in the airport right now? And I was like not to day Krakoff Airport, but like, thanks for suggesting I might need a bunch of zubroka pretty dopey, pretty dope, like.
Speaker 2Man, Yeah, no, I was. I was in the Denver International Airport and so you know, I got to uh, I got to hang out with my homies from the Illuminati, the Deep State. Was there, Capital d Capital s uh you know. Yeah, so yeah, the the Denver if if you're not from here, the Denver International Airport is a host to a great many conspiracy theories, uh most horses.
Speaker 2You know, Well, okay, hold on that one. That one's the interesting one because that's not really a theory. But but like that, there's like all of this like different stuff, and like some of it is just like the way it was built, and then while they were building it, they had like a complete change of layout. It's complicated, but like so they're like train uh areas like plane train areas that look like that that that don't have
Speaker 2anything on them and look like they go to nowhere, So it looks like underground tunnels are running through there. And then you're like, yeah, but if they did that, why wouldn't they just cover it up? Like because I mean, realistically, the only thing you would need to like stop people from looking at it is a thick enough tarp like it's not you know anyway. And there's like some other stuff. But the one thing that is interesting about the Denver International Airport is there is a big blue horse with red eyes, with red eyes that like gleam and at night,
Speaker 2like you they they you could see them. They look like tail lights. And uh, the thing about what everyone there calls Blucifer is uh that Blucifer is the only thing at the Denver International Airport that is actually interesting because, uh, it did actually kill its creator, the guy who sculpted it. While he was doing it, the when they were putting
Speaker 2the head piece onto it, uh so he could make final adjustments to it, the crane or whatever slipped a strap broke and it fell and crushed the guy. So whoa, yeah, you know, right, man versus art, you know, postmodernism. It finally, it finally happened.
Speaker 1Okay, yeah, listen, now we're now we're cooking, all right.
Speaker 2Anyway, Yeah, that's Blucifer. He's out there hanging out. Great. He has uh, he is gilded, but he does have extremely extremely articulated testicles.
Speaker 1Extremely He's like, put the fucking balls on it.
Speaker 2Bro I don't know, no, dick, but man, those balls there was there was some effort put into those veins.
Speaker 1It's that's beautiful. I love that. You know, that's really listen. It's it's so important to make sure that it's like it's vainy. It's really important to make sure that people like really really understand how vassal congestion may occur. You know, yeah, exactly. I feel I feel this in my soul.
Speaker 2Yeah, all right, yeah, anyway, I'm miss Denver. But yeah, we should probably do.
Speaker 1Other I suppose we should probably do our job.
Speaker 2Yeahs other things. They could do a slideshow about my and it's just gonna do all those boring ass slideshows of my of my vacation be like this is when we went to you know.
Speaker 1All right, all right aunt Selma, that's right. Fuck yeah, I love it, all right, h.
Speaker 2Hello, and welcome back to We're Not So Different podcast about how I'm always going to point out the article, the heavily articulated horse testicles. Yeah, the statue, and like he's like, no, it's gotta be more veiny. He's like slamming the table, bring me pictures of rainy horse. Like, what all right you make Jamison?
Speaker 1Fucking are that horse statue? I asked you for sure thing, boss, real fucking ba.
Speaker 2Real fucking girthy, just like you asked. Oh I am uh and the and and the boss in this case is like great.
Speaker 1Perfect, perfect, thank you.
Speaker 2Hey uh it's mail time again, folks. We are back and ready to dig into some patroon questions for another mail bag. This month, we are going to answer questions on everything from the best medieval turlets uh to Chinese equivalents, to humoral theory, deep family lore, how medieval masters performed othering height changes, and where we'd most like to engage in spectacular medieval wizard combat. Enjoy and subscribe to the Patreon at patreon dot com slash w anstypod to ask
Speaker 2us questions like these burst up from Ali can't is there any truth to the urban legend of people, including medieval people of course, being statistically smaller than the average person of contemporary times. And how do we know that? Uh, yes, that's not an urban legend at all.
Speaker 1That is uh yeah, it's like literally it's us. We got them skeletons. Broh. Yeah, it's like so it's not it isn't an urgent urban legend, And it's just down to caloric intake, like of your parents and as a child, and like that is literally it. Do you have ready access to good calories? And the answer is medieval people do not have as ready access to good calories as we do, or even bad calories or any fucking calories, right,
Speaker 1so they definitely are shorter. And you also know stuff where It's like, for example, like they will like freak the fuck out if someone is six feet tall. Yeah, so like, uh, what is it? Henry Longshanks he was six feet tall.
Speaker 2That's why they called him like they were and like they'd be like Luke long Shinks and'd be like what, Like okay, I'm like they told me when I was a kid, I was going to be six four. Like you know, don't get me wrong, I'm happy to be six foot but like it, like I'm just like, uh yeah, sure, long Shinks. Like what can you they can you imagine what they would have said about you, Like.
Speaker 1Oh no, they like they would have been like, yeah, it would be interesting.
Speaker 2A million Bobby fetishes Spring Fourth.
Speaker 1Yeah right, like like somewhere unbidden. It's just like yeah, like I don't like it's it's difficult to to get your head around. Like interesting.
Speaker 2I was.
Speaker 1I was at the Krakoff Underground Museum and they had this interesting display with kind of like the average heights of people in the varying centuries in Crackham. But I was like fucking done and I was just like Frame Moggan like the average women and it was like, yeah, they're all like around five to one, five two, and I'm just like, yeah, you there.
Speaker 2Yeah, So for the best we could tell, like we talked about it before, from the best, but the best we can tell. Whenever hunter gatherer groups changed over to sedentism during the Neolithic Revolution, they typically lost four inches on average for both men and women. And it is uh and that as as a liter this is for a lot of reasons. Most of them had to do that,
Speaker 2like had to do with the fact that you get slightly less caloric intake when you settle down, unless you're set like now, you like now, you could just go to a place and just settle down and be fine because you go to a grocery store, but you're settling down to farm a place where farming has never happened. You're gonna get less calorie, You're going to be more prone to diseases because you're in contact with more people and you're you're in constant or at least relatively constant
Speaker 2contact with them, and things like that. And so humans lost and average of like four four to in some cases like six inches, and since then that has been going back. Now, height is also predicated on other things like genetics, though we can see, of course that the material conditions a person has, especially malnutrition when you're younger,
Speaker 2is a far greater indicator of height than genetics will be. Because even if your parents are both six five, if you know, if you are born and you know there is a tremendous time of bad health, or your family lives on the street for a while or something like that, you know, homeless or something thing, you're almost certainly going to be shorter than you normally them. Genetics would would dictate that you would be because of how human growth
Speaker 2patterns form growth plates in our body, hormone deficiencies, things. You know. It's a lot of complicated stuff, but the long and the short of it is, yes, we are due to better health, or more caloric intake, more varied caloric intake, better access to vitamins and minerals that help us grow and help keep us strong, and modern medicine, we're taller than we ever have been. And now that
Speaker 2varies from place to place, I believe the Dutch are famously the tallest or close to the tallest on average. Ye this, you know, and then the Scandinavian people's as well, very often very tall. Whereas you know, as we've talked about for the Mongols, and we could see this from skeletons. The medieval Mongols were notoriously short. Even for the Middle Ages, like other medieval people thought that they were, they were very short, so you know, it's yeah, it's not an
Speaker 2urban legend. That's definitely real. We are taller, we eat better, yeah, you know, yeah on average. Of course, there are people who do not, and you know, people who starve and that's bad, but on average, yeah, we are.
Speaker 1Well, there's been some interesting public health stuff around this lately as well, because you know, like the the you know, the kind of I suppose stereotype that Asian people are shorter. There's recently been some health interventions around this because, especially in East Asia, you know, like one of the traditional foods that you give babies is like rice pablum, and it turns out that doesn't do anything except for like make the baby hungry anymore. So there's been this huge intervention,
Speaker 1like from the World Health Organization to be like, don't don't do that anymore, and like make sure that the kids are getting I don't know, breast milk formula or something like that, you know, so that they're getting enough protein and we are seeing like a concomitten like huge jump in height. That's great any any stage as well. And it's just like one of these things where it's like oh, okay, word like you know, so, yeah, it's really cool. It's it's actually interesting thing that the World Health Organization is done. So yeah, you know, so it must be like Illuminati.
Speaker 2Yeah that's awesome. Yeah, it's uh yeah, it's it's an interesting thing. And you know it's, uh, we're not we're not you know, we're not better than them. We're not necessarily smarter than them. On average. We have access to more knowledge and things like that. And one of the benefits of living later, at least so far is technological advantages. Uh,
Speaker 2they ameliorate some of these things. And this is one of those cases where you know, like I've talked about before ninety nine point whatever percent of all people who are over like six' four have lived since like eighteen. Fifty like it's people just weren't this. Tall like we look at like we look At victor Women, yama like he's seven foot, six he has like like seven eleven. WINGSPAN i think something like, That LIKE.
Speaker 1I do look at What Victor, webaniana AND i just, thought Thank, god Thank god is. Here that's WHAT I.
Speaker 2But like he but like that would be like someone who's like six four to, them like you, know like six two six, Three you just like wait What like it's just, yeah it's that's just how it. Goes it's, uh if you have better, calies if you have, calories you have better nutrition when you're a. Baby and this goes on for a long enough, time heights rays and we get back to the, point past the point now
Speaker 2where we were before we took up. Sententism yay for six seven thousand years. Later we did.
Speaker 1It we did, It, john we did.
Speaker 2It we did. It ancestors and you know, what they're looking down and they're, like, man he gets to have like four he could have four different kinds of. Vegetables that's, insane fucking. Crazy, Anyway, Yeah, ollie thank you for the. Question next we got one from the final, vow who, says are there any other Biblical are there any biblical concepts that would seem obvious to A christian now but wouldn't have been recognized in the medieval. Era i'm Not, christian AND i only recognize those things if they IF i were to happen to know the art history or
Speaker 2history history behind, Them, UH i don't know how many things they would, recognize to be, honest even going like Strict, catholic even coming to like to a modern day like Strict catholic, CHURCH i don't know how many.
Speaker 1THINGS i, mean it's like it so it really, DEPENDS i, guess because it's like here In, europe they'd be, fine right because a lot of the time you just have still the same, stuff. RIGHT i suppose that the thing is they are like they're more trained in just like knowing what to. Do and it also depends on what you're you're. SHOWING i think one of the things they would be most confused by in any of our churches is they would be, like where's all the? Stuff, yes
Speaker 1they'd be, like where are all the pictures of? Saints BECAUSE i don't see shit in? Here? Right like where are all the? Statues where are all the? Paintings what the fuck is all of? This? Right SO i think the major thing there be like is like what the fuck?
Speaker 2Dude but hearing a mass that wasn't In, latin they'd be like wait? What like, literally they would be like, uh, heresy heresy of the highest. Order.
Speaker 1Yeah and also they wouldn't know what the fucker's saying because they wouldn't speak like whatever, language, Right BUT i think it's quite. Interesting LIKE i was in Uh krauckoff AND i was in The Saint Mary's basilica, there and they've got this really cool fifteenth century altar which is just like absolutely, banging and it's got like scenes from the life of The Virgin mary and you, know and Also. Jesus so it's, like, oh The nativity and the adoration
Speaker 1of The magi and stuff like, that and then the middle of it is the dor mission of The virgin and then she's being taken up into. Heaven and it's, like to, me this is completely, legible, Right but it's completely legible because A i went to a bunch Of catholic school AND bi studied medieval. History, yeah so so LIKE i learned some stuff along the, way, certainly you, know BUT i think that like also they've got they have a form of literacy with images that we just do not possess because they live in a world where more is communicated via. Images. Yep you, know like for,
Speaker 1them this is like the equivalent of, memes, right and so they would just get, it And i'm usually, FINE i usually know what's going, on unless you have too many guys with a bishop's tr, on and Then i'm like, mmmm and so there it's usually LIKE i don't. Know you then have to know like what century it, is and so like what bishop these bitches are talking, about and like they would probably know based on. Whatever but if you have too many guys and bishops, hats that's WHEN i got. Confused but there are always a little cheap, codes, Right.
Speaker 2Yeah, YEAH i MEAN i, THINK i, MEAN i. DO i think the broad strokes are the same, vaguely BUT i think like a lot of the smaller stuff would be uh just genuinely like uh baffling to to them in In ye're.
Speaker 1Gonna wonder where all the rude screens.
Speaker 2Went, yeah they're Gonna they're gonna wonder stuff like. That they are probably going to wonder why people are uh even if you, understand even if you can explain to them the difference between like nicely dressed and shabbily, Dressed they're going to wonder why so many people are shabbily, dressed uh and not wearing you know as it were Their sunday. FINEST i, think, UH i MEAN i think a lot OF i think a lot of the stuff about it would be uh shocking to, them not not
Speaker 2because uh you, know not because they're Not christians or people nowadays Aren't, christians but just because of how of like the for the different forms and way use things. Change AND i mean The Catholic church, now even like even if you take the most like, gracious woke view of The church now is vastly different in how they construct things than the Medieval church. Was like if you go to if you look at like Official catholic stuff, now they will cite, book chapter and verse in The
Speaker 2bible for a lot of, things and like that is a that that's a that's an outcome of the Counter. Reformation so they could so they didn't have to be, like, oh you're the you, know because The protestants just, say, look we'll just we'll just point to The. Bible and that was always much to the chagrin Of, catholics and so like they responded by doing this. Stuff and so they'd probably be, like why DON'T i don't give a shit that that's in Verse kings or. Whatever like, okay, Cool like, yeah it's it's. FINE i mean.
Speaker 1YEAH i think that one of the things that you see a difference in terms of citations is that like medieval people will just will just, say like preachers or, whoever when they're going to cite something of The, bible they'll, say you, know As david, said As joshua, said and and you're, like you're just supposed to have such an. Encyclopedia it's a Colloquial. Yeah, yeah it's like they know whatever happened and, wherever but they're not going to give you the. Verse they're just gonna be, like, hey remember when you know Fucking peter said to The, Corinthians but
Speaker 1they're not going to give you like, whatever and so like, yeah that that's definitely a. CHANGE i, think, uh they would be probably confused that everyone was taking.
Speaker 2Communion, yes, yes.
Speaker 1They would be hype mind. You they would be like they would be, like oh my, god like what do you mean we get to like have both bread and wine and everyone can just fucking do.
Speaker 2It.
Speaker 1That they would be like so over the moon about. That they would think that was really. INCREDIBLE i think.
Speaker 2If they came from, uh like The high or early medieval. Area it'd be, like where the fuck are my mystery? Plays how AM i supposed to know what's happening? Here where's the gay? Priests where does he bring them?
Speaker 1Out and they'll be, like oh, wait it's all of? Them okay still?
Speaker 2Here, yeah, okay all.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Yeah but also like the way that we talk About god is, different like it because we understand cosmology. Differently any reference to the, heavens like to to to space is going to be like they would be like wait what like like but, yeah it's not like it's not like set bounds that like humans could never transcend or anything like, wait what we have? Satellites like outside of.
Speaker 1It's in in church, though.
Speaker 2The way that people talk About god, now, YEAH i mean the way that LIKE i, THINK i, MEAN i don't, know LIKE I i just think that the way that people talk About god in the world now is so vastly different that it that it kind of changes some of this. Stuff not that it's not that it's bad or, good but it's just like The Catholic church teaching on What god is now and how old the world is is one thousand percent different than it was in say
Speaker 2one thousand when they were still trying to figure out whether The earth was six thousand years old or six, thousand two hundred years old or.
Speaker 1Whatever, YEAH i think that they ALTHOUGH i want to be clear here that they are not as stupid as like modern, no that those modern congregations who are like no, whatever it's like they're they did understand Like genesis as a.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah but they. Did but they also did think that the world was very short because.
Speaker 1Yeah well because well because we trying to fucking explain the concept of a trillion to a medieval peasant like, okay, Cool LIKE i MEAN i can't really even fucking get my head around.
Speaker 2It trying to explain a million to my eight year old and she's like what does that? Mean And i'm, like all, right let's think of something that you know what a thousand of looks? Like And i'm, like what do you know that?
Speaker 1Is?
Speaker 2What, okay what do you know that a hundred of looks?
Speaker 1Like all, right like let's just start with. That. Yeah so it's LIKE i think it's THAT i think would be a. Trick although whether or not it's like coming up in during maths of, one one doesn't exactly. Know BUT i would say also like just in terms of like liturgy and how they kind of feel about, THAT i think it would be it's going to be interesting to.
Speaker 1Them LIKE i think they're gonna be hype on, Pews like a lot of time you stand in, there like most of the time you're just kind of like stand in a lot of the, time they'll think that's pretty. Cool uh, yeah you, KNOW i think it's. There there are like a lot of all these like little, things you, know, uh that THAT i think are going to make a. Difference BUT i you, know if you've got like altered
Speaker 1girls up, there they're going to be like what uh that that would? Be that would be a lot for.
Speaker 2Them well that is a that is a highly effeminate altar boy like no, no, no, no.
Speaker 1No, no.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah that sort of STUFF i think would be a lot for.
Speaker 2Them, yeah oh go.
Speaker 1Ahead uh you, know they'd be kind of shocked about the church's current position on. ABORTION i think probably what what but how AM i supposed?
Speaker 2To? Yeah, yeah final, Val thank you very much for the. Question next question actually might shed a little more like on this, too from A colligue who, SAYS i have a question about How Catholic mass went in medieval. Times i'm a small group leader for teens preparing for. Confirmation over the weekend my group got. CONFIRMED i was a lictor At. Mass BUT i assume normal folks wouldn't have wouldn't have been reading scripture aloud During mass back in the, day particularly not women such as. Myself would a priest
Speaker 2or deacon or somebody have done all the scripture readings or would have been assigned an assigned educated person doing? That did they do the same number of readings in the same? Order anything Else i'd find different going To mass then Versus mass, now.
Speaker 1Uh, Yeah so the priest is doing it? All is, oh is like one of the big. Things so, yeah and absolutely not because most people can't read bout SO i mean like a, big a big, thing like in your parish. Church it's gonna be like one of the things that is happening is that your priest is the guy who can. Read, yeah so like at, school not that other people, can't like certainly they, can but like you, know out in the, countryside, right like you, know it's one thing to be out in the. Countryside AND i
Speaker 1don't Know northumberland and it's another thing to be, like you, know in one of the like parish churches somewhere or Near, paris, right, like probably more people are going to be able to read, there but it is more. Difficult an interesting thing is that we also think that people in The Middle ages basically only read. Aloud we don't know that they really could read silently or that you, know it occurred to them to do. So so that's an interesting, thing just
Speaker 1that that is neither here nor. There but, yeah so basically the priest does the whole. Shebang if you've got a lot of, priests like if you're in a cathedral or like a really big, basilica you might have another priest to do. It but, no there are not electors who are going to be putting coming. Up and, INDEED i think that is like a Post vatican two, thing like you can double check that. One but certainly no women would be, involved absolutely.
Speaker 2Not.
Speaker 1And so that that would be. Different and they. Are one of the things is they are reading In, latin which everyone's actually got a pretty good grasp. Of people now are, like, oh but that was just like some shit That Martin luther was, on who's, like no one Understands. Latin it's, like, yes they. Do we fucking dumb, ass like they've been hearing it since they were fucking, children, right like they were going to pick it up somewhere along the fucking, way. Right so certainly that is the. Case and THEN i think, though one thing that is
Speaker 1important to point out is that the sermon would then be in the vernacular for, them so they would be like a, word, like the whole thing's in. Vernacular that's, weird, Right but, definitely definitely it would just be like the priests doing the whole.
Speaker 2Thing it would be so funny if the priest had done the whole thing in last because if that was the, CASE i had one hundred percent me On Martin luther's side on that, Respect i'd be, like, no, no, No like if if if like the the person just standing there and like the priests is just doing the whole fucking thing in, life like, yeah what are you? Doing? Man, No, yeah they didn't do.
Speaker 1That they did not do. That that would be they Weren't.
Speaker 2They weren't that short sighted in that.
Speaker 1Regard, no it's a very important part of what we call pastoral.
Speaker 2Care, yeah, right very.
Speaker 1Important, indeed they everybody wants to make sure that everyone's getting they.
Speaker 2Sermons SO i also believe that one of the complaints about absentee bishops and things like that is they uh and, preachers is that they didn't hear biblical reassurances and uh theological researchs in in their own tongue like they they were they were looking for that type of, preaching you, know it just at that point only came like one specific approved.
Speaker 1Venue, Yeah like we definitely a thing that we see In prague is a lot of complaints about. That that'll be like you gave us A german priest and Weird czech. Speakers you gave us The czech priest and We're german, speakers you, know kind of thing that it's like.
Speaker 2Oopsie, yeah you.
Speaker 1Know so there's like a lot of like trying to get that right and sort that out. Right. Yeah so, yeah and like you can sometimes get switched, about you, know they'll move priests around all the, time that kind of, thing depending on like who needs to go, where whose son needs a, job et. Cetera they're trying to get rid. Of is anyone particularly Troublesome you're getting sent To, hungary you, know kind of a.
Speaker 2Thing so oh, man, yes send him To. Siberia, yeah, YEAH i think a lot of it was, different but as you can see a lot of, it you, know a lot of it would be the. Same they're gonna you, know they're gonna be taking from the same biblical, ideas the same, uh the same, thing the, same the same. Concepts and, YEAH i, think, uh you, KNOW i think there is, uh you, know it can't stay the. Same and the idea that it, can't that it even did
Speaker 2stay the same over The Middle. Ages it's silly because it. Didn't it changed. Constantly but you, KNOW i do think that there is something to be said for finding, meaning for people finding meaning in those, rituals you. Know and congratulations on.
Speaker 1Your uh, confirmation on your kids.
Speaker 2Confirmation, yeah, yeah, Anyway, collie thank you for the. Question Uh, now we got one from vast and Trunkless, tozies who, says, So i'm trapped in a room that just has a time machine that can go so that can only go somewhere. Medieval, ALSO i need to. Ship when where SHOULD i go for the nicest? Toilet not in any.
Speaker 1City i'd say That i'm not. Going i'm not going to a. CITY i guess the nicest one it's it's gonna be kind of, like, oh you know what's pretty good, monasteries so a lot of the time they have a lot of the time they have like actual plumbing and. Things Revlow abbey has like a system where they have like a piped this thing and they have a stream that like washes it. Away So Revlow, abbey that's.
Speaker 2Amazing. Yeah, literally, yeah any plumbing or pipework from before like eighteen hundred And i'm, like my, god they, YEAH.
Speaker 1I know one pretty good toilet AND i was, like, damn that's a nice ass, toilet, Right, yeah so, YEAH i would. HEAD i was head straight To Reblow. Abbey you're going To, yorkshire. Baby it's a really and also it would be worth it BECAUSE i would really like to see. It it's a really incredibly beautiful but it would be nice to see it when it wasn't in, Ruins so it would be pretty cool, Anyway like it's a nice destination one way or, another but definitely definitely for.
Speaker 2DROPPING i don't know where the nicest one would, be but mine is THAT i want to take a ship out of one of those castle.
Speaker 1The long drop.
Speaker 2Ones, yeah the long drop. Ones, yeah, yeah you, know it just seems, like, oh that's, living that's that's good. Shipping, Yeah, no just seems like. Fun uh. Yeah if you have to take a, ship, yeah and you've got a time, MACHINE i would travel to your own, house like your own, place like an hour.
Speaker 1BEFORE i mean surely somewhere in you, know the place where the time machine is has a, bathroom you probably would rather use.
Speaker 2That but if you have to go somewhere, medieval, yeah you go To revlo or go shit out of a long, dropper WHICH i just came up with the name for just. Now, Anyway Vassin truglestosey's thank you for the. Question next we got one from Dog. God who are the servants and medieval? Castles were they generally locals who are hired and fired based on, performance or were they tied to the castle like serfs to the.
Speaker 1Land so, like basically it's a pretty sweet gig working in the, Castle so you tend to have families that continue to serve, it you, know and you'll get kind of like taught to do these things from a young. Age, however if you are particularly good at whatever in the local, area word might get, around in which case you might find yourself with a. Job if you are, hot you are more likely to get a job in the castle because they're going to try to LIKE i don't, know
Speaker 1sexually assault you, slash you, know. Romance uh so like that that never. Hurts and also it kind of depends on like what what time period we're talking, about, right because one hundred, percent like earlier in The Middle, ages like a lot of people are just straight up and Slaved like the Early Middle. Ages it's like they bought you off a, viking, yeah you, know and like that's that's who's in, there like doing the rubbish, shops you, know the good, jobs those are going to be like more more involved like uh but, fundamentally like there needs
Speaker 1to be a lot of people in the kitchen and so like it's more likely that they've hired in kind of a fancy, cook where like someone who's been in the castle for years has been like a cook the whole, time, Right and then from there a thing that certainly will happen is they are going to like hire local hands from the, area you, know who they think are going to be. Good so they'll have scullery maids or whatever and it's like basically if they know your mom and they know they you could scrub floors and like they
Speaker 1can sparry it down on the farm or, whatever then you can come in that sort of. Thing so and then you can and you can work your way. Up that's certainly. True so it's kind of like a, mixture if that makes. Sense AND i mean yeah to an except like if you were one of the scullery, maids like you're, tied they're not gonna let you go, nowhere, Right like they're not gonna, eat like after you've been trained and. Everything it's it's sort of like you're still stuck. There and you, know especially if you've like come from one of the surf. Families but then if you're like
Speaker 1essential or, something that's that's a different. Story and that's kind of a big, job right m.
Speaker 2Hmm, Yeah, yeah the answer is, yeah seems like a better gig than most things in that day and, age although still. Backbreaking yeah, YEAH i mean sexual, assault, yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah like if you're a pretty girl in the, castle you.
Speaker 2Know not.
Speaker 1Great, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2Probably if you're a pretty guy, too also quite so. Suboptimal, yeah either, way not. Great, yeah it's uh it's a good gig if you can get, it as long as you're okay with certain. Things, yeah, quite or at least okay with them possibly happening. Anyway yeah, uh dog got thank you very much for the. Question. Uh, next we got one from Dog, spotter who, says was there any
Speaker 2kind of syncretism or exchange of ideas between practitioners of humoral theory and practitioners of Traditional chinese? Medicine for, example when new exotic ingredients have arrived over The, silka Did european Or arab doctors know anything about the supposed properties of those ingredients Back? EAST i think it Okay as regards a, Syncretism not, REALLY i can tell and it's.
Speaker 2NOT i don't think that's because they would have had issues with it, necessarily because both The muslim And christian worlds played off of each other the intellectual the intellectual rigors that they, had and one of the things they did, was you, know they would use they would Use muslim
Speaker 2findings for this And muslims Use christian findings for that and stuff like. That SO i don't really think they would have had an issue with it in terms of like it being something bad or. Weird it's JUST i think we underestimate how far it is From china even to The Middle, east to even to you, know The islamic, homelands if we want to call it, that and how much further it is from there to the hearts Of
Speaker 2christianity In constantinople and you, Know chrome Slash. Avignon AND i, mean you'll remember that when we've talked about the fall Of, constantinople one of the things that we are quick to point out is that when that, happened there was a rush of new scholarly info from In Western. Europe and what that was was it was a function of, academics
Speaker 2artisans and people and learned people's Fleeing constantinople before it got destroyed and then coming To Western europe or at least further Into Central europe and espousing those ideas and bringing their manuscripts and things like that with. Them so, like if the intelligent scholars Of Western, europe you, know think about A, dante a guy who's one of the most erudite and and learned men of his, time if
Speaker 2people of that amount of learning still weren't getting it From, constantinople then they're going to have a whole hell of a lot harder time getting it From mecca Or, baghdad and, way, way way worse of a time getting it From beijing or wherever In. China AND i think that is just something that we need to talk, about because we talk, about you, know Like, han The achaemenids and The romans
Speaker 2like linked all of the old world like they, did and they did that on a, map and they of course did have some contacts with each, other and and we talked about those a lot in Our iran, series how they both had contacts With china And uh And rome slash Slash. Europe but it's a long ass, way and when you have to carry everything either by word of mouth or by heavy manuscripts and stuff like that at the, time or, scrolls sharing and espousing those ideas
Speaker 2widely is much more. Difficult you, know the printing press being a revolutionary piece of equipment as it, is it's revolutionary for a reason like and that it's because before that it was very, difficult, timely time, consuming expensive, too to mix.
Speaker 1STUFF i think there's also a thing to kind of consider, here which is like who's moving around true and for and for and for why, Right so if you are a specialist trained, physician the place you move around to is courts, yep, Right like you're not going to be like, wow Like I've i've Trained, Salerno i've Like i've done all this work and now it's time to get onto road To. China like that's not a thing that you would.
Speaker 2Do that was for Ib batuta And Marco polo not?
Speaker 1Sure, yeah, yeah it's like traders, travel right like people people who are merchants are the ones that travel and occasionally like adventurers who are just in it for the, laughs right. Yea so even if you did bring back a, manuscript that's, like oh, here here's what's. Up it's IT'S, tcm let's. Go do you Speak? Mandarin? Right and not only, that do you Read? Mandarin like these moverrics don't read No? Mandarin, LIKE i, MEAN i don't think That Marco polo learned.
Speaker 1It you, know we we definitely know that there, are for, Example italian communities that have settled along The Silk. Road we know that there Are venetians In, china for, example and probably The venetians In china are taking advantage of Traditional chinese. MEDICINE i would imagine like you're not going to be able to ask for A western health, practitioner but you know they're they're settled over, there and and and it goes both, ways like the doctors In china aren't going to be, like, yeah let me go out. West, yeah can't wait to fucking traverse the gobie for like
Speaker 1whatever fucking, reason, Right, like it's it's a long fucking. Journey it's it's quite, arduous it's quite, difficult and people who have that kind of knowledge are at work in their respective, homelands, Right and so that that is just one of the things too that you that you've got to. Consider you are operating with the understanding that you've had this training in order to, Work so you're not just going to go trapesing. Off it's it's prohibitively expensive to do, so and like who knows if you'll ever fucking come.
Speaker 1Back people die all the, time.
Speaker 2Yeah, right think about, yeah, Sorry, no.
Speaker 1It's just basically like it's a different way of looking at, KNOWLEDGE i, Suppose, Yeah.
Speaker 2AND i mean think about the dissemination of. Knowledge, Now like how many times has there been something in a topic that interests, You like it's a big news piece or a big finding or something like, that and you learn about, it and you learn about it like eighteen months after it, happened or like two years or something after it, happened and you're, like how how COULD i have missed? This you know How LIKE i get emails from so and SO i you, KNOW i talk to
Speaker 2people in this, community we share, Info like how how DID i miss? This and the answer is that you can't keep up with it out and you can't even do that when you are getting email blasts and something you know from the you, know medieval historians in good standing society or you, know whatever it happens to me or like or you know some some group that publishes like history books and they're, like, here here are our new,
Speaker 2imprints you, know or, whatever and there's so much of, it and now remove it back to before you got email blasts about, that and all you had was word of mouth and what your local library has and what you or what they, had and what your school might have access. To it's like, okay and then back it out further to that and where things are even less, connected and you, know you're maybe back in like nineteen hundred or, something like. That and the most you're going to,
Speaker 2hear hopefully here about is like some retired distinguished guy coming around and he's going to give a talk on like his big theory that he published on twenty five years. Ago but you're only hearing about at that point because you, know you can't really send academic papers along telegram.
Speaker 1Quiet and it's, like you, know it's it's on, parchment you. KNOW i guess if it was going From, china it could be on. Paper that that, is that's certainly. TRUE i take that, back but, like you, know all this shit.
Speaker 2It's, on it's on something that could be easily destroyed over that long period of, time especially when it has to be either walked or carried on a.
Speaker 1Cart like it's, yeah like or like on a fucking ship or, cool like it's just gonna like get, wet you. Know, So and also the things that people are gonna bring along are going to be like stuff they know has resale. Value, Right they're, LIKE i have, porcelain, right you, know see our episode On chinese porcelain for more information the dissemination thereof, Right like that's what makes you, Money, LIKE i guess that's the other the end of the you, know end
Speaker 1of the tail right like. There it's also like who's going to be carrying what to what audience because who's got the money for? It so, yeah, yeah, yeah you.
Speaker 2Can, uh it's just hard to disseminate info like, that which is why schools have thought until very recently were so insular and myopically focused because of language barriers and things like. That and we're only, recently you, know probably since the nineteen sixties or, so like that's only become like globalized fully since that. Time so, yeah, yeah thank
Speaker 2you for the, question dog. Spotter next we got one from cryptos Zoologist, esquire longtime patron but new to the. DISCORD i have a question to. Submit my significant other found a book that claims her family name was changed from True love that's True Dash love To heirs By william the conqueror at The battle Of, hastings and they have a quote. Here Quote Duke william was flung from his horse and his helmet beaten into his, face Which
Speaker 2True love saw pulled off and horsed him. Again The duke told him that thou shalt hereafter uh From True love be called air or iron because thou hast given me the air to breathe in quote between zero percent and no way in? Hell what are the odds this is? True this is.
Speaker 1So fucking Wild who wrote this?
Speaker 2SHIP i don't whoever wrote? It good for, You good for. YOU i really appreciate. That thou shalt in there?
Speaker 1Really oh yeah at? Home, yeah thou.
Speaker 2Hast given me the AIR i Breathe.
Speaker 1Like this is almost certainly like Some victorian wilding. Out this is absolutely Some victorian wild in the funk.
Speaker 2Out.
Speaker 1Uh and also Like i'm sorry true love like wouldn't would it not be a normal? Right like would it not? Be LIKE i, MEAN i don't know what the norman for true love. Is it's almost certainly going to be like Vi amo or something like.
Speaker 2That am oh, god, yeah, UH i don't. Know there's zero percent chance this is. True but at the same, time like whoever put that, down like whoever put this down into a document.
Speaker 1Hats, Okay like, listen we don't even know, how we don't know how Fucking Harold godwinson died and and we're like people are going around being like oh, yeah and by the, way will Old willy yeah Or willy changed our? Name like, YEAH i, mean LIKE i think it would make more sense like uh like uh that if their name was true, love you, know like it would Be norman or, whatever but like amorverre like that squished that
Speaker 1down to.
Speaker 2Air, yeah that's.
Speaker 1True it makes more sense Than King william came off his horse like BUT i mean anything to make yourself look more, IMPORTANT i, guess but like it's.
Speaker 2CUTE i WILL i will say this if for some if there was some way that we could find out that this was. True this is the weird kind of shit that medieval people would do like, That LIKE I i do not doubt that at some, point like some would be king like dubbed some rando on the field with like a new, name and the guy like passed that Down like, YEAH i, mean, yeah that is that is definitely not the weirdest Thing i've ever heard of
Speaker 2a medieval person.
Speaker 1Doing the book is? THIS i need more? Information, yeah it's not gonna go look it up just to like understand it, better but, yeah like please please get back to us with more, INFO id bibliographic information so THAT i can be a more specific.
Speaker 2Hater thank, You, Crypto joel Just, Esquire thank you very, much for the.
Speaker 1QUESTION i, MEAN i love, This to be, CLEAR i fucking love. This But i'm just, like that's, great, Girl please be for real right, Now.
Speaker 2Oh next, week got one web For? Vietnam is a ho chiya.
Speaker 1Boo fuck out of. Here god damn. It every it's always sucking.
Speaker 2Something h dend them to the question about menopause answered In april's. Mailbag does that mean that grandparents were particularly involved in raising? Kids seems to encounter to the idea of a society where family ties are at the center of all. Levels and this is in a response to a question that we've asked about, menopause And eleanor talked about how a lot of women who went through menopause uh took uh took the veil or whatever you call
Speaker 2it when you become a nun or a an abbess or, whatever because, uh, yeah they maybe didn't want to spend the rest of their life lives on farms or.
Speaker 1Whatever so, yeah, yeah, like if you got enough, money you do. That BUT i, mean let's be so for. Real these are all concepts that are fairly you, know high, falutin and that's for the rich. People and if you like you're down on the. Farm grandma's absolutely looking after the fucking kids as and when because there's plowing to do and there are jobs and yeah, yeah and it's like so the things that they can do increasingly are not, physical so there is going to be more and more like looking not that looking after children isn't, physical but
Speaker 1it's not as bad as as doing the fucking, threshing, right, yeah.
Speaker 2Every every other job, there every other job on the farm requires typically requires you to get up and move or do physical activity in some, way watching the kids when they're little enough to be watched or old enough to listen and uh not do something too, stupid you, know of their own. Accord uh, yeah that's a thing that that that that an older person can.
Speaker 1Do and it's just basically what it means is you're less likely to be hired as a nurse in a, castle like because they're they're the ones who are gonna have, that AND i mean also probably because the guy in the castle wants to sexually harass the, nurses so you, know like mar, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah so, yeah, yeah you join a convent or a nunnery or, whatever.
Speaker 1Especially if you're, rich especially if you're.
Speaker 2Rich, yeah but LIKE i, mean if you're down on the, farm you they don't, yeah you, know they don't usually just take like anybody off the. Farm he's, like, well you, know it's not a retirement thing for.
Speaker 1Persons, no absolutely not like. Peasants peasants don't get to join nunneries one way or, another, Right like it's just that's not on the. Cards so, yeah it's like you basically this is all just kind of stuff that focuses on rich people anytime it's literary. Tradition like, granted there's gonna be like a trickle down. Effect i'm not saying that there, isn't but, yeah you're you're much less likely to have a problem with it as a result of, that because like normal people are just like oh, yeah word, whatever,
Speaker 1anyway back to, plowing you, know, Right like that's just what.
Speaker 2Happens, yeah, yeah we we've For vietnam is a. Huchibu thank you for the. Question next we get one From. Elsie you send along a YouTube video and it's about an hour, long but it begins with like this like fake commercial and it's like people advertising like WHAT i could basically only call is like a souped Up, bible
Speaker 2like it hits A bible with like extra like embellishments and stuff like extra margins for you to write in or like it has extra like, yeah, yeah it has extra like uh like tabs in it so you can know where you are and everything like. That AND i guess and it's like basically the video is by like ex evangelicals who are like they're they're making fun of
Speaker 2it And i'm, Sorry i'm, like this video is an hour. Long i'm. Trying i'm doing my best to describe, it but like they're making fun of, it but they're doing it in a way that, like, uh you have to be really involved in a lot of this stuff in order to like understand it enough to make fun of it like. This and it's like and uh, so like the whole thing is you, know like, oh you, know you pay like it's like you're it's like you're a medieval rich person and you're paying a monk to like make you like a nice medieval manuscript and these people
Speaker 2are making fun of, that and you, KNOW i guess the idea is that you, know the extravagant like if you're A, christian like you should just want The bible to be The bible and you, know leave all that extravagant bullshit for other. PEOPLE i guess is the idea that they are so.
Speaker 1Their franciscans is what you're telling.
Speaker 2Me, YEAH i guess, so and So elsie. SAYS i just don't get why paying monks to make a, nice eliminated manuscript for you or a loved one is a bad. Thing it's not that different from any other devotional. Object, no full. DISCLOSURE i am an ex evangelical who is more impassive than opposed To. Christianity the thing that weirds me out the most in the video is people writing In bibles with permanent.
Speaker 1Marker, Yeah i'm with. You, Yeah like like a damn that would suck to have a nice. THING i don't. KNOW i don't.
Speaker 2Like this is to me the thing LIKE i understand that there are people who report on, it and it is good to. KNOW i don't want to say that it's bad for any of, this but it is good to know what these, people what these insane idiots aren't. Doing it's just this to me seems like you've gone uh way deep on something and you're, like who cares
Speaker 2how they? Want like this is just.
Speaker 1Not anywhere near my top five complaints about, Evangelicals that's All i'm, Saying.
Speaker 2Like and, like why ISN'T i think THAT i think there Was LIKE i think there Were catholics in it, Too like SO i think it's Just christianity, Broadly but it doesn't, Matter LIKE i just it's one of those things that it's, like, YEAH i mean to like a certain way of, thinking like, yeah Plain bible is is is a good thing because like you like you're not supposed to try and adorn adorn it with all of these like uh special. Things it's just supposed to be
Speaker 2The word Of god and, therefore like it doesn't need all these bells and whistles and. Stuff but at the same, time LIKE i don't, know this has been this has Been this has been translated thirty five times by however many different. People like it's just, like you, know if we're going to read it the way it was quote unquote meant to be, read then like it needs to be on like an illuminated fucking manuscript in the first. Place when they start putting when they started putting them, together like put it on. Vellum what are we doing?
Speaker 1HERE i don't, Know, YEAH i MEAN i guess, that like my thing is like let's not clown, on you, know like one of the only good things that, LIKE i, mean it's a cool thing that the medieval church actually, was like illuminating. Bibles they're fucking. Beautiful they're gorgeous works of. Art that's that's. WONDERFUL i love to look at. THEM i can see their. Point but all, SO i just feel like it's straying into like the puritanical quite, literally like you, know Like franciscans are, like, yeah PROBABLY i wouldn't own, that, Right LIKE i probably wouldn't own. That
Speaker 1but on the other, hand like have. Fun i'm not condemning the concept. Thereof and if you've got enough money for, it then that's. FINE i, mean like you should probably also be giving money to charity, obviously and like or if like for, sure but if you've got some, leftover like why not enjoy this? Thing AND i, MEAN i guess it comes across to me like as like slightly self righteous in the other, direction like, again like not even my top five complaint about like organized religious groups
Speaker 1is like Fancy bible and, like don't get me, Wrong i'm as frustrated as anyone with like like probably more so with like the grifter churches that do things like being like oh like here's like also our shop on the way, out like you, KNOW i lived In sydney during the height Of, hillsong you, know which is where it's, from and like that shit was embarrassing and and genuinely gross just because like the way That but for me
Speaker 1it was like the weird sex guides that like the reverend's wife would write that squicked, me you, know and things like. That you, know it's, NORMAL i think to write notes in. Bibles that's what a gloss. Is.
Speaker 2Yeah but but my grand my say any grandmother whoever referred to a number of times WHO i never said heard say a word as bad as dang like she she do she wrote little things in Her, bible you, know like things that like little notes that meant stuff to her about certain passages and stuff like and like why would you choose bibles about, this like like if you're gonna, attack like if you want to attack Like christian religious institutions as like gaudy monstrosities that that spend
Speaker 2too much on uh on their outward image as opposed to like actually helping. People there are so many ugly ass cathedrals and strip mall churches and everything else that are like monuments to man's hubris and and affronts to goodness and decency that you could easily just point to and you're, like here's like this nice. Bible is three hundred dollars too much to pay for a? Bible in my? Opinion,
Speaker 2yes but like is that in the, Top LIKE i don't know two thousand of my complaints about Organized? Christianity, no, no not even. Close so, yeah that would be. Mine, yeah it's, just, UH i don't. Know it feels Like baby's first atheist complaint.
Speaker 1And, YEAH i guess that they're just how they're going through.
Speaker 2It, actually this Isn't baby's Force saty's, complaint because that's like why did they attack each? Other why did they attack Like constantinople and all that sort of. Stuff, Anyway, YEAH i don't. Know in my, OPINION i would attack it for other. Things but if these people want, to these people can run their YouTube channel how they. Want that's up to. Them, elsie thank you very much for the. Question we agree with you don't know what all the fuss is about in this regard we got three. More, first we got one From, gafzie who, says how did
Speaker 2medieval philosophers steeped In aristotelian worldview explain The aurora? Borealis AND i have gone to part five Of Aristotle's, meteorology which was written in about three hundred and FIFTY. Bce and this is translated from what's this guy's? NAME? E. W, Webster And i'll put a link to part five Of meteorology book. One sometimes on a fine night we see
Speaker 2a variety of appearances that form in the sky, chasms for, instance in trenches of blood red. Colors these two have the same, cause for we have seen that the upper air condenses into an inflammable, condition and that the combustion sometimes takes on the appearance of a burning, flame sometimes that of moving torches and. Stars so it is not surprising that this same, air when, condensing should assume a variety of. Colors for a weak light shining through a dense, air and the air when it interacts as a, mirror
Speaker 2will cause all kinds of colors to, appear but especially crimson and, purple for these colors generally appear when fire color and white are combined by. Superposition, thus on a hot day or through a smoky, medium the stars when they rise and set look. Crimson the light will also create colors for by reflection when the mirror is such as to reflect color only and not. Shape that is What aristotle. Thought but what what what historians and scholars
Speaker 2believe he thought about The aurora borealis which they would have been able to see increase at certain times of, year especially with the lack of light pollution eleanor how would that that you know, of how would that have been modified in any? Way?
Speaker 1Oh Basically, Nope, yeah you know That's.
Speaker 2God's god caused all of, that all of that air compression or whatever to.
Speaker 1Happen it'll just be LIKE i think that there's like a thing within that Where, yeah and then like underneath the crystalline, spheres that's where the the air compression. Happens you, know the crystaline spheres being the things that surround The earth in which the, sun moon and stars are embedded, varyingly and so, yeah it's you, know they believe in kind of like there's fire and water out there that the spheres are holding back and they like you think they're going to Contradict. Aristotle, no, home like they might modify and modify or they modify and they're, like Ad
Speaker 1god did. It they're Like aristotle is, right and that Was god's plan the.
Speaker 2End yeah, Right. Yeah, now to be to be, clear the Aurora's aurora borealis being only one of them is. Uh they're caused by solar winds hitting the, atmosphere and they do so at certain times and at certain uh certain times they get more intense and they hit. More, uh they they hit in a way that we can see them more. Often and, yeah it's it's not a fully, Understood,
Speaker 2uh it's not a fully understood. Phenomenon but, basically solar winds push particles into the atmosphere and they show up as these beautiful lights because of how it interacts with both the, uh the chemical makeup the, oxygen nitrogen and everything like, that and also the particles in the. Air BUT i do think in this you can see why, people uh why why people still uh do put a lot of faith in or at least a lot of
Speaker 2respect Into aristotle because this is, uh while his uh suggestion is not necessarily it's not technically. Correct, IT i, mean there is an attempt using something akin to using your senses to figure this out and not just Saying zeus or you, know Mare jupiter whoever you Know zeus did.
Speaker 1It or because The greek gods can't do, shit yeah, exactly other than like rape, people you, know, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2Rape people and occasionally turn into swans to rape people, anyway yeah. Exactly but, yeah like so you see why people why why people are like oh, yeah, okay that makes sense Because aristotle seems to like he seems to be combining you, know like how how flames play with with the eye and how you can see different colors coming off the top of like a flaming surface or whatever sometimes and, yeah, it's, uh it's a it's a precursor to you, know rational scientific. Inquiry and you can
Speaker 2see why people do. THAT i don't we rag on them a, lot but like you, know and, uh it's it's been used for a lot of bad. Things but like you can see where you're, like oh, okay LIKE i can see why you.
Speaker 1Are so logic to, It like it's not it's not completely, wild is the? Thing?
Speaker 2So and it and it. Doesn't and the reason it sounds better to us is because at no point in this is he, like you, know the sky fairy did it or whatever it.
Speaker 1Is, yeah but all medieval people are going to do is they're going to take The aristotle and they'll be, like this is correct and that Was god's. Idea like That's they're not like. That that's. It they don't they don't do much much more than. That.
Speaker 2Yep they're, like, yep compressed gases, Whatever god did. It. Yep, Cool thanks thanks, Arising, like isn't it?
Speaker 1Cool How god did?
Speaker 2That thanks. Buddy, yeah, yep uh, yeah that uh That's aurora borealis at this time of, day this time of yere localized entirely within this, question this part of the. Episode, yep, uh all, right and you were able to see, it and you were able to see it and hear. It all. Right we got a couple more first FROM i size, BABY i have a question about othering. People we know The christian version of this with anti semitism or race. Theory did something like this exist in other very different
Speaker 2cultures like Medieval china or Pre Columbus, inca, maya et. Cetera, basically did powerful empires inherently dehumanize outsiders forever until relatively, recently.
Speaker 1Baby we're still doing wait, wait, wait what do you, mean until relatively recently we still do this.
Speaker 2SHIT i would say that this is one of the problems of. Empire it is one of the problems that we point to at to, say when you say you're anti imperial is to point to things like this and say this othering of people is. Bad it's why like when you see communists who are homophobic or transphobic or, whatever and it's, like, no, Baby the point of this is that is that we don't do that. Shit we,
Speaker 2like we, understand like we try to understand these things rationally and scientifically and, logically and and then we try to build like a better society with all of these people instead of pretending that, like, actually you're subhuman if you are if you are a woman who likes women or whatever it happens to, be or because you're black Or asian or. Whatever AND i, mean, YEAH i think empires have always done. This the first, empire The, assyrians they,
Speaker 2uh they love to break up ethnic groups and do what we see as ethnic, cleansing, uh in forms of. Genocide and that has not stopped even to this. Day AND i do think that uh, yeah powerful empires or almost any, empire regardless of their power, level dehumanize outsiders by their nature because the nature of the empire is to say it is to defend the, empires to say
Speaker 2that it is better than things outside of. It it is better than the barbarians who un, culture who are uncultured and outside of our. Purview and that dog.
Speaker 1They literally all do. It they literally all fucking do. It please see you, know like the case system In india for for more, information the were like the kanji In chinese still for. Life the groups of people around them are, like Oh, vietnamese those are dog. People these are ant, people like in the different directions around. Them if you know Our Medieval china series we, did you know they would talk about cooked versus uncooked, barbarians so,
Speaker 1like you, know the barbarians that are cooked are like a little more like, people if not exactly so you, know the fucking hell the way Japanar.
Speaker 2Mongoles when we talked about The, mongols they had their their differences between the dirt scraping farmers who fed them and the noble nomadic peoples who rode their horses like it's.
Speaker 1The way The japanese talk about literally like THE i knew insane, shit like absolutely fucked. Up you, know even in like early early Modern russia when like The russians are expanding Into, siberia like the stuff that goes down in the way they talk about what they call The tartars is, insane you, Know, like so it's and it, certainly you, know we see this also among Varying islamic cultures as, well the way that we'll talk about like you,
Speaker 1know other. People, so, yeah this is one of the things about power and conquest and culture is that it happens. Everywhere and indeed it's still. Happening you, know we're getting, better we're getting. Better but like you, know, DOG i lived In. Japan, yeah you, know that's ALL i.
Speaker 2Mean it's, yeah and this IS i, mean this is the thing that that you recognize when you recognize the problem of. Borders like the border is not just a tool to stop human beings From it's not just an imaginary line that we that we draw and then we put port into reality and and and it it does, that it also stops, uh it has a way of
Speaker 2like numbing you to people who are outside of. It uh if you are not careful because it you because you, ah you think of them as as as lesser because they are. Outside even if you even if you, uh even if you have a tendency to to to to try and uh and stop thinking like, that you still you will still be tricked into it if you're not like careful and thinking you know about this at all.
Speaker 2Times because the border does, that the language barrier does. That and one of the reasons one of the things and one of the reasons THAT i think The internet is so great in spite of all the fucking problems it, has is that it breaks these things. Down it causes, that it causes you to see that all of these people are just like. Us the people who are who are victims of the genocidal empire that we. Inhabit they
Speaker 2are watching blue with their, kids like if they have access to, power they are playing, soccer they are arguing about sports teams or some fucking movie or something. Like they're doing that in their free time because that is what people. Do and it helps to break these ideas down like any like when you, know because if you see the border isn't it doesn't mean, anything and it's,
Speaker 2Useless and that's the reason it has to, go because it creates those ideas that there isn't us versus, them and there's Not the only us versus them that there should be is within class and political. Circumstances WHEN i, mean you, know we have an improt we have imperfects that produced fascism and and and and colonialism and. Imperialism AND i mean do we have a lot of this stuff? Now.
Speaker 2Yeah BUT i mean when that gets you, DOWN i would think to the fact that throughout all of human history there are people who have ignored that to shelter other people that they didn't, know people that they didn't have any any contact. With there were not a lot of, them but there were priests and bishops who came to The americas as part of This christianization genocidal project in the fifteen, hundreds and they were, like what the fuck
Speaker 2are we? Doing holy, shit we are? Evil what like? That those people, existed and there are people who who hid who Hid jews under their floorboard during The, holocaust and who Protected Japanese americans or tried to Protect Japanese americans from internment. Here and you, know there are people who did that in The Middle, ages just like there are people now like, otherwise every pogram that you hear, about every ethnic cleansing that you hear, about would have
Speaker 2been one hundred, percent it would have gone, farther it would have been. Worse and it's not like we, don't you, know even when you attempt to even conscious attempts at cultural, genocide as we saw with The iranian, identity and and what's happening now in all over the world is they don't, succeed you, know they sometimes they. Do sometimes they wipe
Speaker 2it out and the only thing we can find is archaeological stuff or we find like an echo in genomic. Sequencing but like other, times it's preserved by people who don't have any connection to the original culture or. Society it's just preserved because of human decency and, goodness.
Speaker 1Which exists, also you, know and it's it's the powerful that lack. It ordinary people have it in, spades you. Know so, YEAH i, mean this is a cultural tool of empire and you can find it literally anywhere that you can find an, empire and that's why they are bad and so our. Borders, anyway thank you for coming to our ted, talk you.
Speaker 2Know, YEAH i, mean, yeah were the different cultures like. That, Yeah remember we talked about The inca and AND i said that they uprooted people and they moved them to different, places and they did stuff like, that and and that did. Happen but a lot of times when these people would rise up and, fight some of the people who fought alongside them Were inca citizens who were tired of the way that The inca were doing, things just like some of the people who fought alongside The persians were Ethnic,
Speaker 2arabs Tribal arabs who had moved into who had moved into the area after the you, know after The muslim conquest of of Of Western. Asia it's, like you, know they don't the those things break down when material circumstances are are. Faced when when when material circumstances went, out people are, like, oh, YEAH i don't give a shit about. That oh that stuff doesn't mean anything to, me not all the. Time but they. Do and you. Shouldn't just
Speaker 2because empires other people and do this doesn't mean that it's, okay or that that has to be the way that we do things going, forward or that that's the nature of, people because it's not. Empires the nature of.
Speaker 1Empire, yeah and that's stupid. Things, yeah, yeah AND i think that that's you, know it's one of the you, know the reason WHY i work on WHAT i, do you, know like the reason Why i'm, LIKE i work on empire and propagandas you can't have one without the, other, Right so it's, like you, know every empire spends ra there are a lot of time trying to reinforce these ideas and you, know create a mythos of, like you know, whatever the idea that there is like an amalgamated group
Speaker 1that you are a part of that benefits from this and that you require it as a result of like the rapacious. Outsider. Right they all do, that and the reason that they all do that is because it's like necessary in order to ensure that they can continue to be allowed to do whatever the fuck it is they. Do so, yeah like you're not going to find one that that doesn't do. This they're not nice, things and that's why you got to keep your fucking eye on.
Speaker 2Them, Yeah Hobbes's leviathan that he feared so much was the market and the. Empire it's not humans don't create, That, like that's not a you know. Ye, true that's not a. Thing scarcity creates. That the inability to get food creates, That but it's not like a thing where humans are, like, YEAH i Think i'm just going to uh subserviate everyone around. Me that's not a typical thing that most people do, Anyways, baby thank you for the. Question last one for, today
Speaker 2we got one from A Pearl riverflow who Says i'm a wizard fighting a, chronomancer which is a person who can travel. Time, uh and we will have and we will have, going we will have going to be done a duel in the. Past what moment in medieval history is chaotic and weird enough to cover our pro brattle but still have a lot of awestruck survivors.
Speaker 1WITNESSES i probably show up to another battle mm By, yeah show up to another battle and then kind of everyone sees, it and then it's just like bra what the? Fuck uh so you're gonna want like a good one like bro show But, Chrissy yeah, right there's a lot of stuff happening At. Chrissy got a lot of, witnesses and, uh, yeah you can do. THAT i don't, know, baby that
Speaker 1was what was happening when Wat tyler met with The king On.
Speaker 2Smithfield, yeah you know watching they were watching a duel between the devil and an. Angel. Yeah, look if you're gonna, go you gotta go. Big i'm going to uh The siege Of, constantinople the final, one and we're fighting on the, walls and we're just gonna become like A we're gonna of COURSE i, Am and we're just going to become a a legend like something that people say they're. Like and and as the last cannonball, struck the wizard struck
Speaker 2down this other guy and it was so and everybody's, like, there weren't you a? Wizard what are you talking? About like the.
Speaker 1The and then they'll be, like, okay.
Speaker 2A lustful turk was love to do in his. Heart it was in reality and you were worried about a wizard and it's, like, yeah we did. It, No, yeah ALL i could think about WHENEVER i saw this question was just doing it at the fall content And ople.
Speaker 1Just like like constant thank you very, much either.
Speaker 2That or like, yeah WHEN i think it's a good, answer when When Tim eugen got head up for something and you're, like, yeah we could just fight, wherever it's. Fine they're not gonna be worried about us for. Days you just like.
Speaker 1You could just show up alongside The huns at any given. TIME i think it'll be all, Right, YEAH i. Think.
Speaker 2YEAH i think in the, past like you, could like you could do this and and like you would at most just end up as like some like drawing in Like marginalia somewhere that like to, us looks like something. Goofy but you know it's, like, oh there were two people fighting on the wall and one of them shot the other one with flames from his, hand and just like what and that's. Great we got to pick up the fucking. Corn we gotta shut the. Corn. Bro what are you talking, about, Man like, yeah, yeah oh. Yeah,
Speaker 2anyway my my suggestion is always just go to the Follow constantinople and look if if we're gonna do, it if we're gonna have, it, yeah or do? It, no hell do? It during uh do it during the twelve or Four siege Of, constantinople they were so, worried like they were so freaking out about the, uh the scene that was happening. There you could do whatever you. Want, yeah, yeah for, sure for, Sure like that scene In diehard with A, vengeance that movie we all remember and love when when the kid explains To john McClain what's going. On he's, like are you? Kidding all the cops are, gone so you could you could Steal City Hall and it's, like,
Speaker 2yeah it's It's. Christmas you. Could you could do whatever you, want as long as people are just looking at this one, thing just like over, here you're, like, yeah nobody's watching this incredible wizard duel we're.
Speaker 1Having, yeah yeah for sure.
Speaker 2And around, anyway. Folks, yeah thank you very. Much that's gonna do it for questions. Today thank y'all for. Listening that's all the questions For. June moving back next time with something. Else don't know what, yet but. Yeah if you want to ask us, questions please subscribe to The, Patreon, patreon dot, com sash w. Nsdpod we will be continuing our book club series On Between Two fires this. Month,
Speaker 2yeah oh, yeah check that. Out it's. Great other than, that eleanor what what's going on with? You?
Speaker 1Brah great question on The Australian Broadcasting CORPORATIONS thano podcast that is Called No One Saw It. COMING i was there talking about The Black. Death you can check that, out which is pretty. Cool, also if you're In, australia soon my appearance on stuff The British stole will be. Up so if you're if you're IN, oz if you're AN oz and you're enjoying The Australian Broadcast, CORPORATION i
Speaker 1can check that shit out. Out what else is my? Problem, Yeah i'm like in one of those periods Where i'm doing a bunch of stuff but it isn't out. Yet so, OH i Guess i'm. Online On june the, twelfth which is A, FRIDAY i am going to be speaking. Online there's an online thing for The London Jesuit center discussing the concept OF. Ai oh, cool And i'm gonna go in and be, LIKE i strongly feel this is an
Speaker 1insult to life. Itself so, yeah.
Speaker 2They want me to talk about like a bag of money and be, like, oh you, Know i've changed my. MIND i actually, yeah.
Speaker 1ACTUALLY i fucking LOVE. Ai but, YEAH i don't. Know they want me to talk About, apoca the apocalypticism And Peter thiel. Thing so, yeah if you're you, KNOW i think that's like seven pm on A friday. Night what a Cool friday. Night i'm about to have but, anyway.
Speaker 2Cool, yeah check that shut.
Speaker 1Out it's cool to. Me.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah you can find me, Online Lucas. Amazing you can check out my old Show People, Saystory Deal republic if you want to hear me yap About Star. Wars other than, that thank y'all very much for, listening and we'll see you next.
they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...
folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...
folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!
folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...
The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...