folks, we come to the final episode of our series on Medieval Land Management by discussing famine, the very thing that all these land management practices are trying to guard against. we talk famines, how and why they happen, famine evidence across the world, the Little Ice Age, the Great Famine of 1315-17, and, thankfully, the peasant revolts that often follow in the wake of famines. enjoy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I've got a new bit. Are you ready? I am, okay, I've come up with a new bit. I was just walking home from the store just now, and I decided my new bit is that, as a form of goodbye, I'm gonna start saying, keep it sloppy. That's gonna be my new personality trait. What do we think I'm trying to be, like, hey, keep it sloppy, keep it sloppy, big dog, et cetera. This is it's it's gonna be
Speaker 1my new that. This is gonna be my new personality trait for the next couple of months. We're trying it out. We're trying it.
Speaker 2I like it.
Speaker 1I think it's so important to come up with new bits. M hm mm hmmm. That's what's up. That's what's up. You know, a public intellectual, doctor ellinor Yanaga has something to say, and that's what we're saying. We're saying, keep it sloppy as a form of goodbye.
Speaker 2There we go. You have something funny to say? No, actually, actually I have something serious today.
Speaker 1That's right, I do. The people are saying it, uh, et cetera.
Speaker 2Yeah, there you go.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's you know this, this is what I spend my free time on I'm working out these bits for the world. Really, you know that that's what's happening. So yeah, how are you?
Speaker 2I'm good, just just here, just uh real talk YEP.
Speaker 1I realized this is we're having at the moment one of these differences between America and Europe, because in Europe we are embarking. This is the first day of a four day weekend. Mm because peak behind the curtains, everybody were pre recording this app because I'm away next week. But anyway, and it's good Friday, and we can all agree that Jesus has been killed by the hated Romans today. And in Europe that means you get the day off,
Speaker 1you get good Friday off, and you get Easter Monday off because you're gonna be hungover from Easter right at Like a lot of places, like Blair had yesterday off as well, he had like Mandy Thursday off, a Monday Thursday.
Speaker 2Oh, all of our employees got to get in their foot washing today, so that's right.
Speaker 1Like so it's like a big day for parties. I had like so much on us or I had to go to like a book launch and then I had Abby's birthday party. I was like running around like an idiot all day because and when everyone was like putting these things in the diary, I was like, why is there so much going on on a Thursday? And then I was like, oh shit, that's Mandy Thursday. Got it, Got I got I got I got it. But yeah, I scenes in front of the pubs yesterday, just like British people on the pavement, in this sliver of sunlight that had come through, nailing four to five pints before
Speaker 1getting on the train home. You know, it's a beautiful culture. It's very rich.
Speaker 2Mm hmmm mmm mm hmm. Yeah, yeah, I didn't don't don't get don't get any of that stuff. Well, actually the school school has closed daughters in camp today. But like, yeah, most most businesses here are are not giving that off. And I'll be honest, because I was raised here. If they did give it off, I would side eye them because I would. I would I would question, uh, you
Speaker 2know who who was running set establishment, because I doubt they would be giving it in the spirit of just giving uh employees a little more time off. And they're like, oh yeah, this is a weird Yeah, yep.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's I guess that's one of the big differences I guess about like having a country that is expressly founded by Puritans, right, is it's like, oh, we're still doing all the religion, but I want to make it so clear that you're still working. You better not have a fucking good.
Speaker 2Time, you know. I mean, I guess I think mine is. I think it's just to me, like I just have I have an instinctual disdain for anything that smacks of, like h religion in public life, and like Christmas doesn't do that because Christmas has become a secular holiday and I realized they try to do that with Easter, but like it moves every year and like really the whole point, like every everybody knows the whole point behind it, and
Speaker 2so it's yeah, it's just like when restaurants are closed on Sundays year and I'm like, oh, yeah, like you you're not being cute, You're you're you're not.
Speaker 1Like it's this isn't for the people. Yeah, yeah, Like okay. So big difference though, I think is that like obviously just if you don't live in a religious country, yeah, you know, then you're just like, oh, sweet four day weekend right, like like nobody here is religious.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, Like to be clear, if if it was like if if the place was like, we're giving you this time off because they get it up, because we want to give maximum time off. Great, like they're giving you get time off for that, you get you get a day off of Russia Shana, even though nobody in the company is jew you know, like because or take it off people, Yeah, like yeah, cool, that's great. I want people to do that. This is strictly a I
Speaker 2know what you're doing and I know why you're doing it. And the only reason I let Europe get a pass on it is because it has mostly become so secularized. Otherwise I'd side by that shit too. I'd be like, nah, now you guys now, but I did see where's where's my phone? I did see a poll yesterday. You know people are like, oh, young people are going back to uh to church or something in America and uh now
Speaker 2a dog belief in God amongst people eighteen to twenty four is down to thirty eight percent in this country. There you go, and look, you.
Speaker 3Guys in Europe are like, oh so suty, oh oh, we've sort of had enforced public agnosticism about these things for you know, hundreds of years. Like that's all well and good, but I grew up in the eighties and nineties in America, dog, and like the fact that only thirty eight percent of young people actually believing God is like, if you told me that in like nineteen ninety two,
Speaker 3I would have been like, there's no fucking way, Like that's well, I would have been nine too.
Speaker 1But I love to hear this. But also I find it really interesting that like hearing this in contrast to you know, all of this, Oh they're going back to church. It's like how you constantly hear like, oh, young men are supporting the far right in record numbers, and you look at it and it's like two percent of young men and they just mean like, oh, well, if anyone are doing it all, it at all, it's crazy. And it's like, Dog, two to ten percent is not like that's not worth you're trying to make this happen. Most
Speaker 1of them are like nine, right, And it's just like if they can find any young people doing conservative things, they go, oh, wow, it's a trend, and it's like, get out of here.
Speaker 2It's a it's funny. The uh the the highest I believe the highest uh percentage of voters of any cohort for Zoron Mamdani for the mayoral election was a white college educated men. Uh like that was his highest like personal support overall. And it's like, uh, you know, I'm not I'm not excusing men or anything like that, but
Speaker 2of of our mini mini sins. But uh, like, uh I don't necessarily think that. Uh, it's definitely not as bad as the news makes it out to be. Now that being said, if you know, we suddenly have spiking unemployment for like everyone of a certain age and young men start milling around in like city centers. Uh you know, well we might have to disperse that, but you know,
Speaker 2yeah they yeah, young people are doing better about that, especially here in I don't know, whatever the fuck we got going on? Equal parts delight and.
Speaker 1Uh it's the burst of times.
Speaker 2Well it's like every day it's like like like this is bad. But like the past two or three days, I've just been like chuckled, like just like warmly chuckling to myself because like Trump just keeps planting and stuff, and like I mean, like Iran is only you have to pay in the yu wan to pass through the strait of Cormeus in uh in over there, like that
Speaker 2is that would have been unthinkable. And now it's like that's there and that's like real, like actual destabilization of the dollar, like in real time that you can see right there. And then like his conservative Supreme Court is about to rule against him on like him wanting to remove birthright citizenship. And he did that speech last night or the other night, and people were so fucking mad about it, like or they were so like this is nothing.
Speaker 2That oil Future spiked while he was talking, and it's just like man, this, bros. Wow, also feels so nice. Yeah.
Speaker 1I love being a leftist actually, you know because at the very least I got like the you know, the warm satisfaction of being right about everything.
Speaker 2You know, yeah, pretty much.
Speaker 1You know. Look it's not much, but it's honest work.
Speaker 2So yeah, yeah, exactly. All right, Well let's talk about something that is depressing. All right, excuse me, hello, and
Speaker 2welcome back to We're Not So Different podcast about how We've always been idiots. Hey, folks, Today we are talking we are closing out our medieval land management series and we are going to talk about famine. But before we get there with you, yeah, rods, starvation, pestilence, Yeah yeah, multiple horsemen of the apocalypse. But before we get there,
Speaker 2we got a couple of questions from patrons. The first one is from Ali Kant, who says it's true that the Inca and similar South American civilizations never independently invented wheels like the rest of the world. And kind of it is kind of true. Uh, they did invent wheels for toys they had there. There are surviving cart type toys and and things like that that they could pull around. Uh,
Speaker 2but they did not invent it for large scale purposes because most like you, because they didn't I don't need it. They didn't need it. They like they could use they they used more if they were pulling stuff behind themselves. They used more like sled type stuff to like pull it like that, you know, and when you don't have
Speaker 2livestock and beast of burden to pull it along for you, the wheel, the wheel is not as essential Like al Paka and Lamas are not pulling.
Speaker 1Carts for They're not going to do that for you, dog.
Speaker 2They're just not They're they're not built. They're they're literally not built for that. They are, Uh they're very lovely creatures. Uh, they're they're very interesting, but uh like they can't pull like a horse or a donkey or an ox. Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's just not that's just not their thing. And so yeah, there was pro there was not really a a reason for them to invent it as such.
Speaker 2So yeah, they didn't, but it was more of like they knew what the concept of a wheel was. They had it and and and they had applied it to toys. It was just like there's.
Speaker 1No way to like apply it in general life that yeah, like it's not solving a problem they have.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's like think about it, like if you have a spaceship, a toy spaceship, and you pick it up and you're a little kid and you go bz boo oooh I'm coming in boop sap, b b boop, you know whatever, you make all the noises and everything like that. If you do that with a if you do that with like a little toy wagon or whatever, it's the same thing. But in real life, like you can't, you can't it just go and like uh uh turn like
Speaker 2random junk that you have into a functioning spaceship because there's nobody to pick it up with their big hand to go, and nobody to pull the cart. And if there's nobody to pull the cart, why the fuck would you make it in the first place. If there's nothing to do.
Speaker 1Yeah, like there's there's just no one to pull the cart. It's like doing it with humans would be inefficient. And also, like consider the terrain that we're talking about, Like, you know, it is actually just functionally easier to have packs if you're going up and down mountains than it is wheels because the force that is going to be exerted on a cart as it's going up and down those things is pretty substantial. So it's just like, yeah, they wouldn't have that, you know.
Speaker 2Yeah, And I mean at altitudes and with steep inclines like that, you any pulling of carts or anything like that has to be done by ox because they're the only ones who really can apply enough force to break essentially when gravity, if gravity becomes an issue, like I mean, it's always an issue, but if it becomes like a real issue acting yeah, going down a big mountain or whatever. Yeah, yeah,
Speaker 2So they did invent the wheel technically they were technically correct, the best kind correct, But yeah, they just didn't have it for life sized purposes because there wasn't anything to pull it, you know, like I mean, we don't think about it now. Carts like that are heavy, like you know, they even made of like you know, even just like a normal cart to maybe carry like a few things is like extremely heavy. So like one person pulling that
Speaker 2like with it on their shoulders, like I don't know, like how many of you have ever done like intensive like work out training where you pull like weighted sleds behind you, or maybe you did it for like a sport like football, soccer, you know whatever.
Speaker 1Are you a strong man?
Speaker 2Right? Are you a strong Yeah? Yeah, that stuff is cool, but like it's not it's not easy to pull that behind you, and it certainly wouldn't be easy when you live in the fucking like andyes, or in the Central American uh jungles or you know anything like that. So yeah, uh yeah, Ollie, thank you for the question. Next one we got is from Rita Patatina, who says, uh, you might have already talked about this, but was chicken more of a low status food in post Norman England?
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean like it's more of a low status food. You're not necessarily going to be serving that in and of itself at a feast. Although there is some talk about capons people do, like a stuck lid capon. But basically, you know, it's not a show stopper, let's put it that way.
Speaker 2Like, you know, you're not analogy not advanced to that point.
Speaker 1No, like they're not, they're not bringing that out. Well, there there is the showstopper recipe. I always talk about where you knock the chicken out by getting it drunk and then you kill it. Yeah, so like you could that's how you get a chicken to be impressive. But like if you look at, for example, images of feasts, what you're going to see is like whole calves, like ham, things of this nature. I mean, it came out, will probably be there, but it's like it's not considered a
Speaker 1fancy food. So yeah, it's like people do eat a fair amount of chicken. But the major thing that that medieval people are eating is fish. It's yeah, yeah, just like absolutely fuck tons of fish. So yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2Fish, normal people eating fish, normal people eating I don't know, whatever bird you could get away killing. Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, like absolutely, the minute your chicken stop laying you eat them.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, like yeah that yeah, yeah, it's like immediately chicken is a good good true, you know, like, yeah, chicken's a good source of protein. It really is. It is. It's a dense protein even even for you know, meat, animal meat. It it's still a denser protein just because of you know, how yeah, how food cooks. I'm not getting into all that here, but yeah, you know, yeah, Rita,
Speaker 2thank you very much for the question. Chicken was has been considered, as far as I know, a low statis food pretty much everywhere it has been. Modern fried chicken, as I understand, and here in America stems from poorer people in the Scottish Highlands making fried chicken eventually coming up with fried chicken their way, and then West African
Speaker 2people and the slaves that were unfortunately brought to the Americas making fried chicken their way, and the two of them kind of milded when they got here. And yeah, that's why we have delicious and amazing fried chicken with all the great seasonings in it and everything like that. But it's basically it's just a low statisfood for people because chickens are easy to keep, and no king was ever like the chicken is the king leaf, the royal
Speaker 2prerogative food.
Speaker 4You're like yeah, like yeah, it's like that you can't you can't keep chicken from because of how many people need, you know, eggs and things like that for the way our cuisines have come.
Speaker 1And like also like be so for real, dog that's a chicken.
Speaker 2Yeah, it would be like if they were like the pig is the kingly food, and then everybody in town would mysteriously have their pigs dying of random accidents because they're like, yeah, bro, I'm taking this bacon, you.
Speaker 1Cat, you can't have it.
Speaker 2This is this is my this is my comfort friend slash food anyway, Yeah, Rita, thank you for the question. Uh that were Those are a couple more that we're kind of tied to the land management stuff that I wanted to, uh to get to here. If you want to ask us questions like these, please do subscribe to Patreon, Patreon dot com, slash w nsd pod. It is just five dollars a month and you get access to bonus episodes,
Speaker 2ad free regular episodes, the discord and more. So check that out also check out Eleanor's limited series with Phoebe Roy on wolf Hall. You can buy it as a collection on the on our Patreon, and I will include a link in the show notes here. It is fifteen dollars for seven episodes. And if you like wolf Hall, if you like Eleanor and Phoebe, then you should check
Speaker 2it out because it's fun.
Speaker 1Have we got a show for you?
Speaker 2Have we have? We got the thing for you? All right? Anyway, here we go. So yeah, it's hard to find quotes about famine that don't turn into blaming or condescending to the people starving for trying to survive. But you know, I tried. I still tried most of them. I go like the quote from the ancient Greek scholar Yousebius, who
Speaker 2said he's not bad, but he's fairly judgmental. He says, quote of all evils, indeed, famine is the worst, and it destroys nothing so effectively as shame, for that which, under other circumstances is worthy of respect, in the midst of famine is despised. Thus women snatch the food from the very mouths of their husbands, and children from their fathers. And what was most pitiable of all mothers from their babies, and while their dearest ones were wasting away in their arms,
Speaker 2they were not ashamed to take away from the last drops that supported life. End quote. However, a better quote to sum it up, I think would be from Ralph Graves in a nineteen seventeen issue of National Geographic, where he took a stab at contextualizing historical famines from ancient Rome to ming China against the famines that were spreading across the world at that time as a result of World War One in the nineteen seventeen influenza outbreak. In summing up the horrors, Graves said, quote from this kaleidoscopic
Speaker 2picture of suffering undergone during some of the most direphral periods in world history, it is apparent that there is nothing grandiose or heroic about death from starvation. Neither is their glory to be gained, nor metal or honor or military crosses to be won in the battle for food. The casualties in this struggle are enormous, the compensation nil, no moments, no monuments are raised to the victims, no pensions provided for decrepit survivors. The suffering of those who
Speaker 2succumb is pitiful beyond description, and the individual's anguish inevitably is intensified by the necessity of witnessing the agony of his loved ones who perish with him. End quote.
Speaker 1Wow, so yeah, yeah, look.
Speaker 2Look we're got where the whole thing is not gonna be depressent. We're gonna have We're gonna have uh some fun at the end. But uh yeah, it's it's certainly something.
Speaker 1It is.
Speaker 2God, damn it. Where did he go? There? He goes? I lost that? Okay. At a very basic level, could be said that the basis of human civilization is a concerted effort to ward against famine. More than six thousand years, every agglomeration of people that formed itself into what we call society or a polity has been situated and mobilized to some extent to guard against famine. That's because we all know, at some instinctual level, all bets are off. The moment famine strikes people, whether there be thousands of
Speaker 2them in a Sumeri in an ancient Sumerian city state, or hundreds of millions of them in some countries today, will not suffer, starve and die in silence. Humans will suffer a great many indignities, far far more than we should in order to maintain the status quo on which our lives are situated, for better or worse. We are creatures of habit and moving outside of that comfortable center rut scares the shit out of us. But starvation has always been a red line, know the red line. Once hunger,
Speaker 2true agonizing, gnawing hunger that eats away a body and soul sets in amongst a sizable amount of the population, and the bodies pile up, the social contract that binds us together into polite society is thrown out the window. Oftentimes, such outpourings of rage are focused on the wrong parties, such as neighbors, fellow workers, or a capital o other in our midst people who are suffering and dying of hunger just the same as everyone else, but who are targeted nonetheless, as we humans are wont to lash out
Speaker 2at a close target rather than the true source of the problem. However, there are times when the better angels of our nature prevail and our righteous fury is directed upwards at the moneyed elites, aristocratic nobles, high ranking clergy and rulers. And those are the times when you come to understand the phrase there's more of us than there are of them, and what it really means. Famine induced revolts have caused centuries old dynasties to fall, been parties to the collapse of entire historiographical eras, and wiped away
Speaker 2modes of production. This is why society has been geared towards halting famine since civilization began. The powerful of any age don't want to be torn limb from limb, and so they try to keep things flowing, even the stupidest and cruelest amongst histories. Many many rulers, and that's saying a lot usually understand that people must have basic caloric intake if you want to keep your head on your shoulders. It's truism if there ever was one. The quote about
Speaker 2how any society is three missed meals away from chaos is often attributed to Linin, despite him never actually saying it. Oh, he wrote a lot about famines and their role in changing history, but that quote is not in evidence from his writings or speeches. The real quote, which that one is probably based upon, came from Alfred Henry Lewis in nineteen oh six, writing in Cosmopolitan magazine. Of all places, Lewis said that quote, there are only nine meals between mankind and anarchy end quote. I can't be sure whether
Speaker 2it's three missed meals or nine, but somewhere in that range is a point that radicalizes even the most complacent among us, and that's when revolutionary conditions begin, folks. Today we're closing out the Medieval Land Management series with episode nine on famine. Everything we've talked about in the series has in one way or another been a means of preventing famine, and yet we've never directly addressed it in the show. Though this may sound grim, it is one of the main reasons we do all this land management
Speaker 2in the first place, so we don't starve. So we're gonna talk about famines how and why they happened, how medieval society's dealt with them, and whether we've overcome them with modern technology. It's not all dooming gloom. Stick around at the end of the episode when we talk about famine as a driver of popular revolt. All right, So look, I mean we're realistic here. Every society that has ever existed has head starving people home, people who are unhoused
Speaker 2or who don't have enough whatever that be for the particular societies. But how how is what what is famine? Eleanor like from a very the like historical definition of famine, like what are what are what are you talking about there when when you say that in a paper?
Speaker 1Yeah, So basically famine what we mean by that is that there is a shortage that is widespread regionally. Right, It's got to be like more than just like this one valley hasn't produced food. It's got to be something that can't be alleviated on a scale within like a very large area. So like, particularly in the Middle Ages,
Speaker 1we're often talking about kingdoms here, right, So it's like if within the kingdom you can't come up with anything, you can't move resources from one place to another in order to alleviate hunger, then you've got yourself a famine. Often now, when we use it in a modern context, we often mean that famines are kind of like man made, they're sort of like induced. And I mean that also has to do obviously with post industrialized conditions. You know, where there's enough food for everyone on Earth, it's just
Speaker 1not getting to the right places, right, Whereas obviously in the medieval period there isn't enough food for everyone on Earth at any given time. And also you can't move around in the same way. You know, there's no airplanes, we don't have the preservation methods. You just can't do these things. So if, for example, you have quite a wet year and even though your crop has come in and say your barley goes off, then you're in trouble.
Speaker 2M Yeah, you know, like.
Speaker 1It's like the issue is going to be that whatever food stuff can't get out to the people.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, And so Eleanor mentioned regional. Now, typically when we talk about famines that we've heard about in history, we are talking about we're talking about your your national those that are national in scale or or even you know, multinational that that's spread out over you know, entire geographic regions and continents and stuff like that. Uh So, like
Speaker 2when we talk about that and you hear people say like famine occurred in X number of years, that typically means like say, if they say famine occurred in France in the Middle Ages for every and this I'm just making this number up. If they say every ten years, that would typically mean that a famine that was over, it was spread across you know, a sizable part of the entire population of the territory of the Kingdom of
Speaker 2France at the time. Now, within that you have local famines like all the time for for like cities or or regions or you know, territories or stuff like that. And we'll talk more about like causes of famines in a minute. But this is because you don't have the ability to move to store food as easily for as long a period of time. You don't have advanced preservation
Speaker 2methods and canning and things like that, and it's hard to move it. As I remember when we talked about how difficult it was and how expensive it was to move firewood even twenty kilometers in London in the High Middle Ages, it was too expensive for even the wealthiest families there. So like moving stuff like that is going to have to be done if it is done at all by like a ruler of sufficient wealth and power.
Speaker 2And if you're in a you know, a German if you're in an hr you know, one of the central German states, and it's not one of the extremely wealthy and for whatever reason, and a river in a dam burst in there, like that your region might have really bad have a really bad local famine for eight months or a year or something like that, and that could cause the population to dip severely. Even if the others around you are trying to help, they can't always do that.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I think so obviously we do tend to see more famines in sort of the places you'd expect, so like alpine regions, like you know the Swiss, who yeah, dog, you know, like that that's that's a hard road of ho you know, in the more desert areas when you have drought. But it's appost Also having said this, you know, one of the kind of things that we mean when we say famines, we also mean that it's longer term, right, Like we don't mean like there's been like a couple of lean months. It's got to be something that is
Speaker 1ongoing for quite some time. So there's going to be environmental factors involved in that. So, like, you know, you're a lot more likely if you are a Norse Greenlander to be facing conditions of famine than you are if you live in the Loire Valley, right, because it's just it's just easier to feed yourself in particular places right.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, and uh, of course, hold.
Speaker 1Up one thing, cut this out, but have you ever seen a hot cross bun? Because I just not live. Yeah, they're they're an Eastern treat.
Speaker 2I love it. Yeah, I mean they make they make buns here that you know that have that. But I don't think I've ever actually seen a real hot cross bun. Heh yeah, buddy's cool, bitch. Yeah, yeah's your recorder route? Yeah cross yeap? Oh lord, uh yeah. Famine Okay, sorry,
Speaker 2I'm log on on hot cross buns.
Speaker 1I mean the twenty first century brought so low in the ration.
Speaker 2Yeah, we're gonna we're gonna be hit like a like a ton of fucking bricks. So oh yeah, it's not a few months thing. It can be something that is that is like two very bad harvest can't create one, so you could have like you know, you're talking like six to eight months and something like that. It's expansive, you know. But the ones we typically hear about, you know, your Great Famine, the the the Chinese famines that happened
Speaker 2a lot, you know, those are four or five ten years. You know, like, wait, it's it's bad stuff. Yeah, So all right, let's just go ahead and talk about this, because it's something that always comes up. So Malthusianism in in academic circles, there is this idea and it's typically
Speaker 2called Malthusianism, and the basic idea of Malthusianism is broadly correct in that a certain part of the land can only sustain a certain number of people, and that varies with technology and stuff like that. Like, you cannot feed thirty five billion people with what we have on planet
Speaker 2Earth right now, that is not possible. And in the Middle Ages you could not feed You could feed far fewer people. And I mean it does seem like for a long time, the cap on that was like six hundred million, like worldwide, give or take, because these are old estimates, but like it would have been really hard to feed more people than that based on the amount of land that we had and the limited technology and stuff like that. Now, the problem with Maltheusenism is that
Speaker 2instead of people using this to say, Okay, how should we divide our food more effectively? How should we communally bring these things together to help everyone so that we have no starving people on this planet because we do produce enough food to feed everyone on this planet more than they need, and instead of that, they use Mauthausenism to be like, oh yeah, black and brown people shouldn't have children, only white people. And the reason that we
Speaker 2don't have and the reason that people in Africa starve is not because of the conditions that that that the Western world voice and thrust upon them at gunpoint, but because they you know, have too many kids and stuff like that. And so yeah, it's it's a fraud topic. But with the Middle Ages, with the lack of preservation off, it's you cannot transport enough food that far, and you
Speaker 2can't grow enough food in most places to sustain huge populations. I mean, nowadays, the estimates are that we could, we we can and have grown enough food to feed ten billion people on this planet. And we're sitting like right at eight I mean, like so we're you know, we're not doing Yeah, we're fine. And but in the Middle Ages, Eleanor, it was a different different story.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean to a certain extent, there's kind of like almost a natural inbuilt break here because well, first off, you know a lot of people fucking die, yes all the time, right, So I mean it just so so many people die before too, that it just is not that much of a surprise if you have eight kids in four live, right, Like, That's that is how it works, and it's awful and it's something that they really struggle with,
Speaker 1but it is also certainly true. You know, you also just have a lot of women who just straight up fucking die in childbirth, right like that, Like the maternal and infant death rate, if you kind of put them together, the range is somewhere between, like right, so like if you combine the two, so it's like there there's a lot of people just fucking dying.
Speaker 2Right. So, death rate from any disease, any infection, any like mildly serious injury like a broken bone are yeah, you're going like infinitely higher than they are nowadays.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean you know you get to stir up throat, you're gonna die, you know, Like, yeah, a badly broken bone, if it gets infected, yeah, you're you're in trouble, you know, because they're just they're just aren't antibiotics and like you know, obviously people clean things, but you know, who knows what might get in there, So you do you do have a higher mortality rate in general, and also if you're in conditions in which you yourself are starving, you are not able to get pregnant.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1It's like there's a certain level of caloric intake necessitated, uh to actually be ovulating. Right, so you know you're your uterus will just go on strike, uh if you're because because your body will just be like, oh words, looks like we can't feed a fucasty as.
Speaker 2Well it should at your yeah, like no, I'm I don't, I don't. I'm good, thank you, I don't.
Speaker 1Yeah, it turns out we'll die, uh and so will the kid. So yeah, that that kind of does take things down. Having said that, you know, if you have sick, relatively healthy kids, which isn't a weird thing to have, and suddenly the a famine kicks in, that's when you're in trouble. Right, So you're in trouble when you have you're having a kind of okay time and then suddenly and precipitively, these things fall off a cliff. And again we tend to see, you know, children die at greater
Speaker 1rates during famine, and certainly older people as well. You know, you know people who are in their seventies or eighties, they take it rather hard. So that does kind of drain a lot, you know, because you have to kind of go into your body fat reserves in these situations, and people who don't have those are the ones who are are going to be in rather a lot of trouble. So does it play a part, Yeah, absolutely, Like if you have to make one chicken go between eight people
Speaker 1versus one chicken go between four people, that's like a completely different concept. But also they don't possess any ideas of like family planning in the way that we do. This isn't to say that they don't like seek abortions, because they absolutely do and certainly also sometimes unfortunately they resort to infanticide as a result of being aware that they cannot feed their children, and so that's kind of what your options are. But you don't get the same
Speaker 1kind of like haranguing like oh, what are these what are these horrible pores doing? Right? Because I think also one of the big differences is there is this understanding of marriage as this very particular institution for creating children. Very particularly so if then you say, okay, but why are you creating children? Then that calls into question the entire institution can have that and then also we understand marriage as a way for people to have sex. You know,
Speaker 1there's much more matter of fact thinking about sex as something that's very difficult to not have, right, And so we've christianized it. We said this is what we're doing here. Yeah, and then like if you then say, okay, yeah, but knock that off, then like the church literally can't say that, right, The church cannot say that otherwise it's going to call into question the entire institution. So they actually probably have
Speaker 1a more nuanced opinion on family size than we do.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah in the now. No, don't get me wrong. And people disdained have disdained poor people for a long time. The extreme institutional and like like societal levels of disdain that you see owl that uh you know that that seemed to even like, uh hate charity for for poor people.
Speaker 2That is like seventeen eighteen hundreds. Uh, that's a huge, like Victorian English thing. Why haven't you pulled yourselves up by your bootstraps kind of bullshit? Yeah, It like in the Middle Ages, if you it's very hard to do, even if you even if they had a real concept of family planning, it's very hard to do. That because
Speaker 2like they're a lot of there. From year to year there's stuff would would would vary, it would go up and down. It is like you know, some years, you you know, the crops are a little better because there's you know, a little moraine and the weather's a little nicer, and then some years it's worth you know, and it's it's the same. Uh, it's the same thing. And so they have a bit more of an issue with just making those same long term things because they just didn't compile or have the ability to compile data and look
Speaker 2at it the way that we do now. And so you get, yeah, you get you just get to you get people and they they they have kids and it's great. It's great when you have all the help around the farm, until it's not great and then yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, like I think another thing to keep in mind too is if you are I suppose the nobility here, right, you also don't want to say don't have children, because that's right, Like you're not going to say stop making the workforce because it's not just that they're working on their parents' farms, because obviously they are, but you know, these are the people who are helping out with the core v you know, they're in your crops as well too, So you you can't be introducing this idea that you
Speaker 1shouldn't be having children, because that's going to mean that there are not as many able bodied workers, and we need able bodied workers very very much.
Speaker 2So Yeah, so they would keep even even when the beginning with the beginning of the fourteenth century and the weather downturns and all the famines that followed after that, they would keep pushing that population higher, because that's just what that's what we do. That's I mean, that's like, that's that's as that's as natural of an evolutionary thing as you can get. Is that you are going to
Speaker 2a lot of people, not everyone, of course, but most people are going or want to approcreate, and especially in a society where it's like, hey, God told you to do this, Why have you not pro you know, why are you not being fruitful and multiplying? Hello?
Speaker 1Yeah, it's just a totally different social structure than we experience now. And like, I mean, the moralization and this idea of like conquering the body in that same way is a modern it's a modern construct. And also I suppose it requires industrialization. You know, it requires this idea that you know, there are machines that can do a lot of work. There are no fucking machines. Yeah right at the time, like it's just it's just people to do all this stuff.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, exactly. Uh yeah. So causes of famine. Uh look, I wish I could give you one, but it could be anything from too much rain to not enough rain, to volcano on the other side of the planet blew its lid, small scale war breaks out one hundred miles away, and no traders can get into your talent, your secluded
Speaker 2mountain area that really only has one entrance. Intentional destruction of crops, unintentional destruction of fraud, global climatic changes because the sun went through one of its normal like cooling periods that happen a couple of really bad harvests, disease, kills off too many peasants, mismanagement by rulers, negligence by rulers, mauth e since but like anything that could affect the
Speaker 2actual crops not not like uh oh, the crops just didn't give as much this year, which could do that, but that's more of an attenuated thing. But like we couldn't bring in the crops because a flood broke the the banks of the river and it flooded the entire field and all the crops just they're dead or it didn't rain at all, and nothing, you know, grew because we had an unseasonable drought for however many you know,
Speaker 2for for six months or something like that. And it can just be any of those things. And when you do not have logistics, uh, specialized transport, preservation of food, anything like that, it is going to cause fa Like it's not it's the nothing, of course is inevitable. But when you do not have the means of transport, you
Speaker 2do not have the means of storage to deal with this stuff, famine is going to follow. Like it's a math problem.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, absolutely. And I do think that it's difficult for people to kind of understand how much closer medieval people understand themselves to be to to to all of this, And I think that that is something that we kind of ignore it our own peril, right, is that you know, like locusts, that's a real fucking thing for these people, right,
Speaker 1Oh yeah.
Speaker 2Like yeah, plagues of locusts that like, yeah, that's real, that's in the Bible is because that was a persistent problem in that part of the world.
Speaker 1For Yeah, yeah, exactly. And so it's like you have, you have all of these incredibly tenuous fluctuations that happen, and you know, like, so now, for example, we're about to learn something, right, because we are so dependent on fertilizer that's made out of fossil fuels in order to stave off stuff like crop failures, right, and when you don't have that, turns out it's kind of tricky, right. Yeah.
Speaker 2Did you know that all modern, all modern commercial fertilizer is made from fossil fuels and that something like twenty to twenty five percent of it flows through the strait of hormus at any given time. Uh, just something, you know, just just a thought for future reference. Just just store that one away in the bag.
Speaker 1Yeah, I just you know, which is an interesting choice. You know, it's also weird to me where you're kind of like, why why would you have all this? You know, like I don't really understand, I don't really understand fundamentally why it is that we actually have fossil fuels as a former fertilizer as opposed to other things but I mean, I don't know. I'm not a scientist. I don't know this.
Speaker 2Okay, well, I'm not a biologist or a food scientist. But in reading for this, that is one of the things that fueled the most recent green revolution, the one that happened in the fifties and sixties where we were suddenly able to grow so much more food. And in this case, as I understand it now, if I'm wrong, that's fine, but this use of fossil fuels is not nearly as problematic for climate change and stuff like that.
Speaker 2Other things are. As I understand it now, somebody writes in and they're like, no, actually it contributes than fine. I will correct myself, but I don't think it is. However, regardless of any of that, it is now made from fossil fuels. And whether that's a good or bad idea is another thing, but it is. And yeah, a certain country who that will remain nameless? Uh U States know
Speaker 2that's obvious. How about United su Yeah? No, look, folks, the it flows through the straight upfour moves. And I'm making jokes.
Speaker 1But I it's only because we're terrified.
Speaker 2It's not gonna be great for any one it's I have a friend in New Zealand. Thing prices for food there are skyrocketing, of course, and I mean we we will probably be the last to feel it here other than other than maybe China, and by here, I mean in the United States. But like that is you know, cold comfort to anyone else, And I am sorry to every not that it means anything, but like, yeah, it's
Speaker 2it's fucking not great. But this is, this is this feeds into what we're talking about because outcomes famine does doesn't necessarily have to happen because of a singular event. Yes, you can have a you know, a year without winter because of a volcano. Yeah, that that is definitely true. However, you could just have a succession of you know, just small bad things. You know, there was a flash flood
Speaker 2and it knocked out fifty percent of the harvest, So you get some hunger. Every time you get hunger, every single time people start going hungry on mass they get. The body becomes susceptible to all manner of diseases that it isn't normally or would be able to fight against. Much better infections, deadly diseases, strains of things like influenza and it's theorized that that hunger on massive scales across
Speaker 2all of your asia was a big factor that helped spread the Black death even more effectively or a deadly whatever the case may be. People get sick. Animals are not tinted as vigilantly, which means they get sick and die. They develop something called murine, which is a disease they get. In turn, people who eat the flesh of those animals without knowing that they had murine, can contract murine themselves. And you see this is it's a compounding thing.
Speaker 1See how it is?
Speaker 2Yeah, see how it is. And you can't just go to the grocery store. You can't even in a market town. Even in Paris, London, Constantinople. They all suffered from famine, all of them did. Like Florence, there was like a three hundred I don't have it right here. There's a three hundred and like seventy year period in which Florence had one hundred and eleven years of at least regional famine within their area and only sixteen years years of
Speaker 2good harvest.
Speaker 1That's that, Like it's like I.
Speaker 2Don't know what you do with that, Like I don't and anyway, Yeah.
Speaker 1You put on the best goddamn pageant show this town's ever seen exactly. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, famines are not spread equally everywhere. You know, for a long time, and especially during the Medieval Warm period, Europe was not very prone to widespread famines during that period at all. It was it was pretty good. But of course, like the hardest hit places are China and India, your places that have such huge populations, and I mean
Speaker 2there are studies that show that going back looking at records for China from one oh eight BCE to nineteen eleven, that is nineteen eleven, so a little over one hundred years ago. That was a two thousand and nineteen year period, and in that time China was hit by a major famine of at least regional scale one thousand, eight hundred and twenty eight times. That is just over that is
Speaker 2like two hundred years out of over two thousand where they weren't having at least a regional issue somewhere that is.
Speaker 1In Yeah, it's just like, I mean, it's difficult for us to even really understand. Yeah, I think because we are we live just in a really different world, you know, so kind of like this level of instability. It's hard for us to kind of get our heads around it. And you know, so it's one of these things that's quite interesting. Oftentimes when you see people who don't work on history kind of talk about the past, one of the things that they will say is like, oh, these people are really like obsessed with death. Yeah, yeah, yeah,
Speaker 1probably because of all the dying all the time.
Speaker 2Right, if you have any ideas, how many times in your life, if you are in your thirties or forties, how many times in your life you have had like a minor thing that you just went to a doctor for and they gave you like an antibiotic or even they were just like, hey take some tile and off a little relieve that fever. Those things could very easily have killed you, because if you don't control a fever, you don't know how or something doesn't work that fries your brain like it just it kills your brainstorm. So
Speaker 2it's like, yeah, of course they were obsessed with yeah.
Speaker 1Like and it's like so like, yeah, like if you if the crops could all collapse and you've seen the crops collapse repeatedly, then yeah, dog, you're going to be a lot more like oh fuckd like we all may die at any moment, like that's that's how this works, right, And you can also understand why, you know, they're a lot more religious than as a result of that.
Speaker 2Yeah, and also why these things are so destabilizing. We're gonna talk about the Great Famine in Europe here in just a second, but yeah, the worst pre modern famine that we know of hit China between thirteen thirty seven thirteen thirty three thirteen thirty seven, towards the end of the Yuan dynasty, and they were falling apart pretty rapidly. According to records, six million people died and likely paved the way for the spread of the outbreaks of bubonik
Speaker 2play across the Silk Road in the coming decade after that. But yeah, we wanted to.
Speaker 1Got some real mandate of having lost what can I say it is?
Speaker 2They did they We're going to talk about it. Yeah, the I think it was the Red Turbine Rebellion in this case took them down because man, they did not yea six million people when the population of the planet is like maybe four hundred million. When you have something like that, that's a carbon sink, it really is. Yeah, and as we're going to talk about it's. Yeah, so look,
Speaker 2we could there are there are a lot of famines, and we don't want to get this. This is already pretty. This is depressing stuff. It's it's not pretty, but we did want to talk about it. And the Great Famine is a bit easier to talk about because it affected Western Europe, and Western Europe loves to uh navel gaze about. So thank you for writing this down, guys. Yeah, so,
Speaker 2in case you don't remember, the crisis of the fourteenth century pretty much begins with in thirteen fifteen with the Great Famine, and the Great Famine struck all the way from Ireland to the Slavic Lands, over in Central and beginning in East and begin the beginnings of Eastern Europe and all the way down to the Alps. It was absolutely devastating. We'll talk about it in the second but
Speaker 2one of the reasons it's really interesting is that you can almost see the weeks that the little i say, the effects of the Little Ice Age began to hit Europe. Now, a little ice age, as we've talked about, was eventually became this global climatic shift where everything got colder for extremely long periods of time until the eighteen hundreds, really until we started, you know, doing industrialized climate change on
Speaker 2our own. But yeay, but it really that really became a thing across most of the rest of the world after about fifteen hundred or so. However, because of how the Gulf Stream is and how the Atlantic Current is affected by temperature fluctuations, how it's affected so much by general temperature fluctuations, Europe felt it much earlier. And the reason, basically,
Speaker 2the largely agreed upon reason for this, is that the Sun went through a normal cooling period. It does this all the time. Nohing's wrong, It just does this. It literally could start happening again tomorrow. And I mean it wouldn't cancel out climate change clearly, but like it like it.
Speaker 1Might be nice.
Speaker 2Yeah, it would be Yeah, it would be nice. Like this is a thing that could happen. It does happen. It could get a bit warmer as happens as well. God I hope not, but fucking hell. Yeah. There was this long period called the Sporer minimum, which is it has to do with sun spots and solar activity. We're not getting into it, but it lasted for one hundred and fifty years and yeah, the sun's rays just got
Speaker 2they weren't as hot, they weren't as warm, and this caused the Atlantic Current and the weather patterns over western and central Europe to well, it didn't like it very much, let's just say. And beginning in mid to late April on the continent and the week of May eleventh, according to to one of the accounts, uh, that really does
Speaker 2it for me, it started raining, but not like regular rain, not like ah, like people in England being like it's raining today, Like yeah, no shit, you live in England.
Speaker 1Like class are biblical?
Speaker 2These are yeah, biblical. These are flood of the century type rains. But they didn't stop for weeks and months. Some accounts say it rained daily for two months, like it is. The weather got in thirteen fifteen. The weather got so cold that wars that were being fought on the continent were called off because soldiers could not progress
Speaker 2through the muddy. The mud was so deep they couldn't walk through it. And there was frost on the ground in the morning in June and July. There's I want to say again, there's frost on the ground June and July in the mornings like like men were like starting to come down with like hypothermia, like from sleeping from from ill ill preparation and sleeping in these like freezing mud holes. And it was bad. Like what can we say,
Speaker 2It's a dry run, This is a dry run for how they were going to react to the Black Death. And in this case, I will say that they did. They they tried. They couldn't do much because again we're not we're when this happens, everything fails. You cannot get crops, the crops are washed away. The fall harvest for the
Speaker 2year of thirteen fifteen was completely gone. It did not exist. In most of Western Europe. Things were so bad in the Dutch Lands and the lowlands. Cities like Antwerp were just decimated. The low lying depressions that we talked about that the people of the County of Holland had worked so hard to do together were just flooded. They were
Speaker 2just totally flooded. The dikes cease working, the sluice gates stopped functioning. It just anything about that they couldn't do anything. And I mean the governments. You know, look, I'm going to say one nice thing about them, and a lot of the governments did seem to try like it like, uh, I believe Edward the Second was the king of England at the time, and he they tried to do like price controls to stop prize gouging, and they did. They
Speaker 2tried to stop people because because piracy kicked up immediately after this happened, because of course it did, because people are starving and what the fuck are you gonna do? Like, what are you going to There's nothing to do. I just I look at it, and it's not there's nothing. There's no dace X makin ex machina that can save you. There's nothing that can be done about this.
Speaker 1Yeah, And I think that it's important to note it's interesting. I mean, Edward of the Second one of England's worst case Yes, yeah, yeah, we could certainly say that, but yeah, it's interesting because one of the things that we learn from this point of time, and they talk about in the sources that like he doesn't have.
Speaker 2Food either, correct, Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, So it's like it's not just like he's not in this situation being like fuck my subjects or whatever. It's like there literally just isn't any food. Dog, Like, there's nothing that anybody can do about this, and that is. That is particularly interesting because we do tend to find you know that royals skate through these things more easily because they can just strong arm their way into getting stuff. But you know, there's we have records of him being on progress and them saying, you know, the king couldn't get bread. Yeah, and that's that's when you know you're
Speaker 1in trouble, right.
Speaker 2They when when they can't When they can't get the king bread, that means that not only are the regular people not having wheat bread, and they might have to be relying on the less nutritious rye bread. There's no rye bread. The barley is is gone. Like we are talking about just huge, huge problems. And like for people who get a lot of their caloric intake from uh
Speaker 2from ale uh, that's gone because you need you need those things to make like yeah, it's they called off wars because of this. They attempted to enforce as I said, price uh, you know, they they cannibalism occurred. I do not I don't think it's a good thing, clearly, but I feel like making moral casting moral aspersions on people
Speaker 2who are like starving is a stupid and frankly counterproductive thing, but it happened everywhere, you know.
Speaker 1It's yeah, we do. It is one of these things too where you have to sometimes be careful with the sources when they say anibal dismiss ocurring, because they might be using it in a hyperbolic sense. But in this case, we do think that likely it did occur, especially like going into the second year of fat Man first year less so second year, I think that that is probably likely. And also I don't know, I always come down on the side of like, oh, are you going to die? Yeah? Eat people, you know, like I mean if you're already yeah,
Speaker 1they're already yead like you know, I'm a materialist.
Speaker 2Yeah, now if we're yeah, like if people are like, oh no, we actually we we were like that guy looks uh, he looks supple and he has enough marbled fat that he's going to taste great, Like, no, that's pretty fucked up. But if it's like that guy died and his body is yeah, oh okay, Like I'm not going into it further because people it'll grows people out.
Speaker 1But yeah, wait, I got a brief stretch for an Australian history story because Blair and I were watching the Terror you watch The Terror. Yeah, yeah, thanks for Reley Scott. That's a good one. I enjoyed it. But we were we were talking about cannibalism and Blair was like, oh, yeah, do you know the story about like it's like some Australian prisoner and like he had been put in a you know, like one of the colonies for like very bad, naughty prisoners or whatever, and I don't know. They they come and check on them and they're like, hey, hey, Helmiet,
Speaker 1where are all the other prisoners And he was like, oh, I killed them and ate them and they were like we, oh, well whatever, Like all those prisoners escaped and this guy's kind of crazy. Anyway, like they put him in like some other like uh you know, island prison or whatever, come back and check and like found him eating people. Oh no, like that was his deal, like and it wasn't like out of necessity, that was just his thing. Oh yeah, So there you go. There's Australia. Like I'm like, yeah, transport that motherfucker.
Speaker 2But anyway, yeah, yeah, yeah. They the famine, the Great Famine, it just it didn't it didn't spare anything or anyone. I will say in this case, the Church appeared to do a better showing than it would during the Black Death. They did processions there were England, but England and France
Speaker 2were like telling telling their priests to like and and and a lot of parishioners to go barefoot and you know, following these processions to try and and appease God, which I mean, you know is not going to relieve it. But that's better than what they did in the Black Death, where they're like.
Speaker 1Lo, this is your fault, guys, like, wow, God's so mad at you.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's grazy. What did you guys do to make him so mad? Anyway, I'm gonna sit here. This is yeah, you guys deal with that. Have fun. Yeah, it's you know. Yeah. There there's a thing called the poem on the Evil Times of Edward the Second. It's from thirteen twenty one. Famous quote. When God saw that the world was so over proud, he sent a dearth on earth and made it full hard. A bushel of wheat was a four shillings or more, of which men might have had a
Speaker 2quarter before. And then they turned pale. Who had laughed so loud and they became all docile? Who became who before were so proud a man's heart might bleed for to hear the cry of poor men who called out alas for hunger, I die. Yeah, it's it was really fucked up. It didn't it didn't help. It did uh start the sabled. It did start the destabilization of the
Speaker 2the late medieval social cohesion that had been so such a static thing throughout It started to kind of erodes a lot of or at least some faith in the church. And yeah, it was just a portent of chill, important of things to come, chilling, chilling vision of things to come. Welcome, our welcome, our new famine overlords. It could be used
Speaker 2to round them up sugar sugar mines.
Speaker 1But listen, I think also one of the things that we're kind of realizing now too as a result of this, and when we get into the Black Death later, one of the things we've kind of realized as is that the epigenetic results of this are also something that really softens people up for the Black Death later, because you know, when there are terrible famines happening in the world, that
Speaker 1means that like, even if you survive them, you are probably pretty fucked up by it. Like you know, you're not going to be like, oh this is uh, this is like the healthiest I've ever been, and so that damages people like you never get those like years of growth spurt back, you know, if you're a teenager, you never get like whatever, and so that has a knock on effect. And it's kind of like this generation's kids are the ones that face the black death and yeah, yeah it didn't. Yeah it's bad for them.
Speaker 2You know, it didn't. It didn't uh turn out very well. It's just it's the total it turned.
Speaker 1Out very well. Hell yeah, brother, Hell yeah.
Speaker 2I don't I don't know along. I don't know how to like, uh yeah, I don't. I really don't know how to like describe it. But like it's just the total, like there wasn't anyone to do anything. Like it's not like it's not like they it's not like they had wheat ripe for the threshing, and they just didn't have people to do it. Not only did they not have they didn't as people died, they didn't have enough people
Speaker 2to do that anyway. There wasn't any.
Speaker 1Fucking wheat all.
Speaker 2The animals were dead all like rivers it rained, like, uh, there was one study I looked at. I think it was from twenty twenty. It rained enough for like three years in a in like a six month span in thirteen fifteen. Like that is.
Speaker 1That that would cause us too much? Dog? Yeah, Like it's like this would like this entire situation would fuck us up now. And I thought that that's like something to keep in mind.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, and yeah that kind of brings us to, yeah, to what's going on and what's going on now, which is that since since the seventeen to eighteen hundreds, humanity has been in the process of creating greater caloric intake for people. It is going it is going up generally,
Speaker 2and now especially since the nineteen sixties, we have more nutritious and varied and plentiful diets for the most part, those of us in the Western world. I am sure there are people who listen to this who are who face hunger and and don't have great housing situations. And I am not saying that those don't happen, But by and large, we have security in these things here, and
Speaker 2that given the situation with the straight upfour moves, the situation with fertilizer, and how much of our how much of our global thing is based on like taking cheap stuff still from the global South, or from places that we think we could just you know, take it from without consequence. As that is, the ability to do that
Speaker 2continually goes down as it we obviously see it's happening right now for America and its allies and NATO and everyone like that. It is going to We're going to start seeing stuff like this and that is going to you be bad.
Speaker 1It's a technical They're very bad, very bad.
Speaker 2Yeah, not good at all. It's what I am I trying to.
Speaker 1Say, We're about to be not so different.
Speaker 2Yeah again, yeah, it's it's not it's not good.
Speaker 5You can't there's not a lot of a way to sugarcoat it. I suppose there's not a way to sugarcoat it now, and there's not a way like people in people in America have not faced widespread hunger like this since parts of it did during the dust Bowl issues in the early nineteen hundreds, and never never since the
Speaker 5colonial days they have had anyone face anything like that.
Speaker 2It's just not it's not going to be uh, it's not going to be good.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think also part of the reason why we're in the situation that we're in as a result of that. You know, it's part of the you know, the kind of postmodern malaise is that people don't understand how quickly things can get bad and why, you know, things have been ordered in the way that they have in order to ensure that that does not happen. Right, It's like, oh, no, that that's not real. It doesn't happen. Yes it does, and you know that's why you have
Speaker 1to be very careful all of the time. So yeah, I mean, I wish I had better news for everybody, but like, apparently we're doing this for some reason. I don't know.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean I think, I think the only uh, I think the I think the only thing we can do when we face things like this is we can look at it and we can try not to make the same mistakes that other people did while we while while it is on going, you know, not not blaming this on the other, not blaming this on on you know,
Speaker 2spurious cultural signifiers, and oh this is because they let trans people blah blah blah, this is because of gay marriage. This is like no, this no, this is because of intentional mismanagement, negligence, wanton, cruelty, stupidity and everything else. Wandered the technological brilliance of six thousand years And I mean,
Speaker 2I don't think we've squandered it forever, but it's not going to be good while this is on going, and it is.
Speaker 1This is a situation that we're in. Yeah, it's ongoing.
Speaker 2This is the situation. We have to help each other. We have to help yeah, we like, yeah.
Speaker 1And if you're not already involved in a local mutual aid organization, now's the time to do it, Just to just to be clear, Yeah, yeah, because there's going to be you know, we're all going to be needing a lot of help from each other in the in the coming months, So like have a think about that. I think that that is you know, I mean I also realize that's my answer to everything. But you know, and granted, of course, like yeah, we're we're communists, not anarchists, but like obviously we've been abandoned by the concept of the
Speaker 1state right now, and so we've got to create our own, right, So like let's like let's fucking go yeah, you know, yeah, it'd be uh be more mate. Let this make you more involved with your community as opposed to less. So I suppose is what I mean here?
Speaker 2Yeah, drawing inward now is the worst thing, uh that that you can do. It's yeah, it's not great. But look, folks, we're not going out on a down note because, uh, this stuff is is sad, it is horrifying. But look, if there is one thing that we know, it's that when people get hungry, uh, they eventually start getting re angry,
Speaker 2real upset, real mad about everything. And when they do that, it is go time, go time. So yeah, the first recorded famine history, known as the Seven Year Famine, it was supposed to have occurred forty six hundred years ago during the Egyptian Third Dynasty, resulted in political unrest and unsuccessful minor revolts against government officials. However, more successfully, I guess if you could call it that the Bronze Age collapse,
Speaker 2which was when the seventy percent of the Mediterranean societies around twelve hundred BCE collapsed in one hundred year period or so. It's attributed a lot of that demises attributed to the Sea peoples, which some of it can be some of it was from other factors, but it's now believed that the sea peoples were essentially climate refugees who
Speaker 2were fleeing famine in their homelands and banded together and just sort of went went marauding and so yeah, I mean that is people getting so fed up that they turned into into a roving band of pirates and.
Speaker 1Yeah, they went mad max with it. It's great.
Speaker 2Yeah, helped destroy the Mediterranean world.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2The Han China in I think it was two hundred CE, fell because of the Yellow Turban Rebellion. Moving into the Middle Ages, of course, the classic Maya civilization collapsed due to famine and political struggles. It not great within thirty after the Little Ice Age really kicked off within thirty one years from thirteen fifty one to thirteen eighty to four major peasants revolts rock Eurasia. The Red Turbine Rebellion
Speaker 2in China felled the Yuan dynasty as we talked about, they lost the Mandate of Heaven after their decades long droughts could not be assuaged. In France, the unsuccessful Jacquarie Rebellion in thirteen fifty eight broke out due to responses from the Hundred Years War or due to famine from the one hundred years war in the Black Death eleanor the a little guy named wat Tyler in thirteen they
Speaker 2they got tired of being hungry, They got tired of people being you know, of the kings, the king's advisors were being bad, and they decided to told the fuck off. And you know they didn't, they didn't succeed, But.
Speaker 1I still talk about him, you know, like you still still you gotta you gotta try. They gave it a good they gave it a good go. You know, we could learn a lot from them, I think, so, Yeah, yeah, for sure.
Speaker 2Right, yeah, yep. It's hard to succeed when you've got all that stuff winging against you. Then the next year the Harel Revolt hit France. That was thirteen eighty two. But look, moving into the modern era, famine and skyrocketing grain prices were some of the primary outrages that fueled the French Revolution. It has been it's been shown that
Speaker 2another downturn in temperatures took place in the late eighteenth century and that caused a lot of the issues in France which caused the revolution, which you know, changed the world. It was successful and then unsuccessful, and then you know there's Napoleon, and there's a whole lot wrapped up in that. But he definitely changed a lot of things. You know, you can't yeah, say that.
Speaker 1He can't say he did. And also, you know, one of the big things that he changed was really pressing for technologies to preserve food. Right, Like, we have tinned food because of Napoleon, and it's a really good thing that we do. Like that's it just is a very very excellent technology. And I love the French for that. You can also get like really interesting tinned things when you go to France now as a result of like this particular thing that they did, and I for one appreciate it.
Speaker 2So yeah. And then the Russian Revolution was a response to well, the Russian revolutions were a response to the nineteen oh five one was in response to imperial policies that caused hunger and famine. Of course, the February Revolution that swept out the imperials also did that. The later one wasn't really so much driven by famine as it was. I mean, there are people weren't doing well, but it
Speaker 2wasn't you know. But but regardless, the October Revolution wouldn't have happened without the other two. And I mean, you know, the first stirrings of the Chinese Communist Revolution began because of famines that happened after the fall of the Imperial system in nineteen nineteen twelve, nineteen eleven, whatever it was. And yeah, so look, these idiots are gonna make They've
Speaker 2they've made a lot of bad decisions they based on what they've done in the past. I don't think they're going to start making good ones anytime soon. But you know, we go go back to that quote at the very beginning I was talking about. You know, there there's no compensation. There are no memorials to to the to the the Hungary dead who died because of their governments in transigence and stupidity and everything. And we may not be able
Speaker 2to save all of them. In fact, we definitely can't, unfortunately, Uh but uh we can fucking avenge them. I can say that much. We can. Uh we can, uh we can, we can at least try to meet out some justice for it. Yeah, folks, that is that's the land management series. It is all that stuff just combined, and they're just trying to uh trying to keep going. But yeah, we wanted to give you a better sense of like how the land was used, how people just how how people
Speaker 2went about, you know, interacting with their world and farming and fishing and all that sort of stuff. And uh, yeah, we hope you liked it. We we covered uh, we covered the Americas, we covered all of uh, all of Eurasia. I wish we could have gotten to uh uh Australia, but man, the stuff about agriculture and pre modern stuff there is hard to parse for me.
Speaker 1Yeah, look, we just don't we just don't have the sources in the same way. So yeah, that's the thing. But yeah, but.
Speaker 2Yeah, we we hope you like it. We hope it gave you a better sense of the everyday lives for people from the poorest of the poor to you know, how the kings and administrators, how how they responded to these things and gave and how their policies informed these things. And yeah, we we hope you enjoyed it. We will be back next time, probably with mail bag episode, because we got a bunch of questions and yeah, you know.
Speaker 1Probably have a lot of interviews coming up, a backlog of people who want to come on as well, so that fun.
Speaker 2Ye got that stuff all coming up. Yeah. In the meantime, check out the wolf Hall series, check out the Patreona, Patreon Accomplist, w Nasty Pod, and eleanor What's going on with you?
Speaker 1Uh yeah after this. I mean, this is coming out next week, so I think it probably should be up by then. Not to talk about other people's production schedules, but I am going to be on politics, theory other discussing Christian nationalism and apocalyptic thought. So if you want to come hear me be very serious around other leftists, come check that out.
Speaker 2Yeah oh yeah, yeah, and you can find me as usual. Luca's amazing on the socials and people's sistory of the Old Republic if you want to hear me chat about Star Wars. Anyway, thank you all very much for listening and we will see you next time.
they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...
folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...
folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!
folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...
The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...